Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Patriarchy lead to war, prolif, environmental destruction, and eventually extinction

Warren and Cady ‘94—Warren is the Chair of the Philosophy Department at Macalester College and Cady is Professor of Philosophy at Hamline University (Karen and Duane, “Feminism and Peace: Seeing Connections”, p. 16, JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/pdfplus/3810167.pdf, JB)

Operationalized, the evidence of patriarchy as a dysfunctional system is found in the behaviors to which it gives rise, (c), and the unmanageability, (d), which results. For example, in the United States, current estimates are that one out of every three or four women will be raped by someone she knows; globally, rape, sexual harassment, spouse-beating, and sado-masochistic pornography are examples of behaviors practiced, sanctioned, or tolerated within patriarchy. In the realm of environmentally destructive behaviors, strip-mining, factory farming, and pollution of the air, water, and soil are instances of behaviors maintained and sanctioned within patriarchy. They, too, rest on the faulty beliefs that it is okay to "rape the earth," that it is "man's God-given right" to have dominion (that is, domination) over the earth, that nature has only instrumental value, that environmental destruction is the acceptable price we pay for "progress."And the presumption of warism, that war is a natural, righteous, and ordinary way to impose dominion on a people or nation, goes hand in hand with patriarchy and leads to dysfunctional behaviors of nations and ultimately to international unmanageability. Much of the current" unmanageability" of contemporary life in patriarchal societies, (d), is then viewed as a consequence of a patriarchal preoccupation with activities, events, and experiences that reflect historically male-gender identified beliefs, values, attitudes, and assumptions. Included among these real-life consequences are precisely those concerns with nuclear proliferation, war, environmental destruction, and violence toward women, which many feminists see as the logical outgrowth of patriarchal thinking. In fact, it is often only through observing these dysfunctional behaviors-the symptoms of dysfunctionality that one can truly see that and how patriarchy serves to maintain and perpetuate them. When patriarchy is understood as a dysfunctional system, this "unmanageability" can be seen for what it is-as a predictable and thus logical consequence of patriarchy.'1 The theme that global environmental crises, war, and violence generally are predictable and logical consequences of sexism and patriarchal culture is pervasive in ecofeminist literature (see Russell 1989, 2). Ecofeminist Charlene Spretnak, for instance, argues that "militarism and warfare are continual features of a patriarchal society because they reflect and instill patriarchal values and fulfill needs of such a system. Acknowledging the context of patriarchal conceptualizations that feed militarism is a first step toward reducing their impact and preserving life on Earth" (Spretnak 1989, 54). Stated in terms of the foregoing model of patriarchy as a dysfunctional social system, the claims by Spretnak and other feminists take on a clearer meaning: Patriarchal conceptual frameworks legitimate impaired thinking (about women, national and regional conflict, the environment) which is manifested in behaviors which, if continued, will make life on earth difficult, if not impossible. It is a stark message, but it is plausible. Its plausibility lies in understanding the conceptual roots of various woman-nature-peace connections in regional, national, and global contexts.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Current welfare policies Labels women as “Welfare Queens” for raising children – that locks in stigma and segregation in work places.

Danaher, 2014 - a lecturer at the National University of Ireland, [John July 14, Feminism and the Basic Income (Part One) TA]

The second argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because of its potential to reduce the sexual division of labour. The traditional division of labour is that of the male breadwinner and the female caregiver. If UBI has the potential to raise the status of non-waged work, then it could also, potentially, encourage more men to engage in that type of work. This might allow for some de-gendering of work roles. The mechanisms for this are likely to be indirect. The UBI wouldn’t actively reward unpaid work, it would simply make it a more viable option. I’ll be talking about this more in part two. The third argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because it could reduce existing labour market segregation. This is essentially just the flip-side of the previous argument. One of the problems with the sexual division of labour is that it impairs women’s access to paid employment. If women are forced, demanded or expected to engage in unpaid work within the home — and if men are not — then the opportunities for women to access paid employment are limited. So if the UBI can reduce the sexual division of labour, it could also increase the access to paid employment. This would also represent an improvement over existing welfare systems where entitlements are dependent on total household income. In support of this, Fitzpatrick gives the example of systems in which the benefits payable to an unemployed man are actually reduced if his spouse/partner is working. This can encourage women in low-pay work to give up that work. The fourth argument holds that feminists should embrace the UBI because it will reduce the burden placed upon women by the welfare state. The idea here is that women are often the chief “victims” of the bureaucracy of the traditional welfare system. Due to social panics about “welfare queens” and the like, women often experience intrusive means-testing and enquiries into their personal lives in order to prove eligibility for welfare. The unconditional nature of the basic income cuts out those intrusions.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Gendered norms in the labor market subordinate women by reinforcing the “breadwinner” model, where men work to support their families. This portrays women as dependent on their husbands and devalues domestic work, which reinforces the patriarchy

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, ]

The freedom not to be employed runs counter to the direction of much recent public policy and political rhetoric (especially in Anglo-American countries, though the policies are international), and this makes stakeholding more palatable than basic income in the current political climate. The effect of such policies and rhetoric is to draw even tighter the long-standing link between employment and citizenship, at the very time when a reassessment has been made possible by changing circumstances. The institution of employment is a barrier to democratic freedom and citizenship in two ways. First, economic enterprises have an undemocratic structure, a point that I shall not pursue here.23 Second, as feminist scholars have demonstrated, the relationship between the institutions of marriage, employment, and citizenship has meant that the standing of wives as citizens has always been, and remains, problematic. The Anglo-American social insurance system was constructed on the assumption that wives not only were their husbands’economic dependents but lesser citizens whose entitlement to benefits depended on their private status, not on their citizenship. Male “breadwinners,” who made a contribution from their earnings to “insure” that they received benefits in the event of unemployment or sickness, and in their old age, were the primary citizens. Their employment was treated as the contribution that a citizen could make to the well-being of the community. Ackerman and Alstott acknowledge this in their criticism of “workplace justice,”24 and their recognition that unconditional retirement pensions would be particularly important for the many older women whose benefits still largely derive from their husbands’ employment record.25 That is to say, only paid employment has been seen as “work,” as involving the tasks that are the mark of a productive citizen and contributor to the polity. Other contributions, notably all the work required to reproduce and maintain a healthy population and care for infants, the elderly, the sick, and infirm—the caring tasks, most of which are not paid for and are undertaken by women—have been seen as irrelevant to citizenship.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Domestic violence is a key form of Structural Violence – it is a form of torture. Prioritizing it makes it visible.

Mazurana and McKay, 2001 - Research Director of Gender, Youth, and Community at Tufts Univ. and contributor to The Irish Times [Dyan and Susan “Women, Girls, and Structural Violence: A Global Analysis”, TA]

The male bias inherent in (patriarchal) democracy has led to forms of patriarchal structural violence that relegate “women’s issues” to the “private” realm where they become “private matters” that the state does not address. This bias is perhaps nowhere clearer than in the issue of domestic violence, where male bias greatly impairs the ability of police, judges, and lawmakers from recognizing the violent behavior in the family. “The view that ‘as a family matter’ battery is less important, is based on men’s, not women’s perceptions” (Murray & O’Regan, 1991, p. 45). The multiple forms of domestic violence that women suffer have profound physical and psychological effects (Herman, 1992; Kelly, 1993), prompting international calls for domestic violence to be recognized as a form of torture (Copelon, 1994). Governmental support of patriarchal structural violence through its inattention to “private” matters is apparent throughout the world. Until 1991, the murder of a wife in Brazil was legal—it was considered an honor killing and was done to preserve the family’s honor because of a woman’s transgression. In many areas of the world, men are free to rape their wives with no threat of legal repercussions (Mertus, 1995). Other examples of government-sponsored patriarchal structural violence include laws and systems that condone particular forms of violence against women, deny women control over their bodies, provide no assistance with child care and maternity leave, make no attempt to remedy child support defaults, and fail to provide unemployment protection to women who work within the “private” realm in domestic service or farm work (Waring, 1988; Murray & O’Regan, 1991). Because governments rarely address patriarchal structural violence or fight for women’s rights, progress for women is largely made by women working for the recognition and enforcement of women’s rights. As a result, in countries such as Australia, Brazil, Britain, Columbia, India, Sri Lanka, and the United States, violence against women in the home has been identified and some forms of it criminalized (Fineman & Mykitiuk, 1994).

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Specifically, domestic violence increasing now – covid put strain on the economy and led more women to be financially dependent on their abuser

Hallett 21 – [Hamish Hallett, “UBI and Domestic Violence,” UBI Lab Network, 02-06-2021, ] /jsam

Domestic violence is a global problem that persists across all levels of society. Despite attempts by governments and NGOs to address it through legislation and activism, abusive relationships and traumatic experiences continue. The same reasons why people cannot leave come up again and again. These include shame, denial, lack of self-confidence, and fear for safety. But the most common reason why victims of domestic abuse do not leave these relationships is because of their economic dependency on an abusive partner.

Victims of domestic abuse are often so tied up financially with their partner they’ll stay within a relationship to make sure necessities are covered. These necessities include clothing, food, and transportation. Some survivors cannot get treatment for their injuries as they do not have the necessary funds to go to a hospital.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Gendered violence is the defining feature of economic rationality – this perpetuates a paradigm of economic utility, environmental disaster, and inevitable extinction.

Westra ‘17 [Richard, Designated Professor in the Graduate School of Law, Nagoya University, Japan, “Varieties of Alternative Economic Systems Practical Utopias for an Age of Global Crisis and Austerity”, Routledge, p. 208-210, Accessed: 7/10/23] HZaidi

Next to questions of androcentric conceptualizations of value and the gendered division of labor, feminist economics has for a long time been struggling with the ideas on the “free” individual. In mainstream economics the free individual constitutes itself in the concept of the Homo oeconomicus. That economic agent is seen as an autonomous identity, a separate self, “fully sprung from the earth” (Hobbes 1966 [1651]) and not dependent on the care of others, not even a mother to give himself birth. In the Hobbesian metaphor, economic agents are envisioned as mushrooms; more recently, the economic agent is seen as an independent adventurer, a Robinson Crusoe, shipwrecked on a lonely island (see Grapard 1995). In this metaphor the Homo oeconomicus is envisioned as a rational individual (whose mind rules over his body); he is utility-maximizing, and fully informed by the signals of the market. Feminist economics is also deeply concerned with the consequences of establishing the “free” individual, the Homo oeconomicus as the economic subject, and with the placing the foremost value on the utilization of private property. Feminist economics clarifies that such a paradigm constitutes an economic system resting on invisibilized, un(der)valued, un(der)paid reproductive labor and the priceless exploitation of commons such as clean air and water. The dominant economic system “cannot respond to values it refuses to recognize. It is the cause of massive poverty, illness and the death of millions of women and children, and it is encouraging environmental disaster. This is an economic system that can eventually kill us all”1 . Feminists, (proto-)feminist utopian thinkers, and feminist economists ranging from Christine de Pizan ([1405], 1999), Mary Wollstonecraft (1792), Charlotte Perkins Gilman ([1911], 1971), Marge Piercy 1997 [1976], Marilyn Waring (1988, 1995 and 1999), Marianne Ferber and Julie Nelson (1993) and Nancy Folbre (1991 and 1995) to countless others have for a long time criticized those core ideas of the current economics paradigm. Not only their manifestation in accounting practices, the distribution of labor, and incomes and wealth, but also the destruction of livelihoods, the environment and the planet as a habitat. They have called for a reconsideration of the current conceptions of value, care, and labor which are the foundations of androcentric and anthropocentric economics (see Schönpflug 2008). Still, a shortcoming of feminist economics is that, while the dominant paradigms have been assessed and deconstructed at lengths, and while the category woman has been added to mainstream models and concepts such as GDP accounting and the evaluation of reproductive labor and welfare indexes have been expanded2 , truly alternative programs have – with some exceptions (see below) – largely been missing and/or have not been largely established (see Habermann 2010). Feminist economists are aware of this shortcoming. Marilyn Waring, one of the second wave’s more prominent feminist economists, originally argued for a (monetary) imputation of values generated by unpaid work or the environment. In her 1988 core book If Women Counted. A New Feminist Economics, she urged policy makers to bring to light “the invisibility of unpaid work and the ecosystem in the unidimensional growth paradigm” in national income accounting (Waring 1999, xx). Interestingly, in her book’s second edition called Counting for Nothing: What Men Value and What Women Are Worth, Waring reconsiders her strategy of the first edition. She explains that because she was striving to save ecosystems and prevent environmental destruction, she was originally “prepared to use whatever tools could immediately empower my argument in the short term. Since economics was all powerful, the way in which I would empower our ecosystem was to give it a monetary value, to quantify it, to make of it a commodity. I desperately had to prove that the natural environment […] had a value comparable with the alternative proposed exploitation. There was no time to battle the pathology of the economic mode” (Waring 1999, xx). Therefore Waring’s primary strategy was to align goods of a common nature or items of the nature-state (in the sense of Locke), which were not yet a private property, with commodities (e.g., objects exhibiting utility). But in 1999 Waring reflects on that strategy: “My underlying agenda was to disable the system. I saw a mechanism for this in taking economics on at its own game. […] I thought that the models would then be so overwhelmed, conceptually and statistically, that they would become inoperable, and even greater nonsense than they are. […] I underestimated the willingness of the ideologues and practitioners to construct even more abstractions, regardless of the model’s relationship to human experience. I underestimated their capacity for unreality” (Waring 1999, xxi). Waring had in that sense originally planned to implode economic models by adding monetary value to non-commodities such as women’s unpaid labor, environmental degradation and so forth, hoping the complexity would collapse the system. In this paper’s final section, we are proposing this exercise again but in an even more systematic and explicitly posthumanist way.

2023 CNDI Evidence
Feminist UBI Aff › 1AC › 1ac – Advantage

Status quo economic models and welfare programs reflect gender neutrality at best and masculinity at worst.

Marco Cedro et al 23 [Marco Cedro is researcher of Tax Law at LUMSA, authored Sect. 11.4, Sect. 11.2 is written by Eleonor Kristoffersson. Teresa Pontón Aricha wrote Sect. 11.1, Lidija Živković Sect. 11.3 and the conclusion is authored by Teresa Pontón Aricha and Lidija Živković, “Gender Equitable Taxation”, p. 393-394 of “Gender-Competent Legal Education”, Springer, Accessed: 7/17/23] HZaidi

Economic policies (both macroeconomic and microeconomic policies) are often thought of as gender neutral. Budgeting is generally considered a gender-neutral policy instrument. But that is a mistake: the budget is not gender neutral, but rather gender blind. Some examples of gender biases in taxation, both explicit and implicit, have been analysed in the previous section. Moreover, budgeting policies can hide gender biases too. Public accounting policies are not gender sensitive and have a negative impact on women compared to men. It must be understood that by maintaining gender inequality, these policies also have a negative impact from an economic point of view, making it difficult for all categories to access work or business. It is clear that governmental budgets reflect political priorities. If we neglect this distinct impact on people, we perpetuate economic disparities and disable the improvement of social roles various groups individuals hold. National or local budgets do not affect individuals directly, but the choices contained in the national or local budget, impacting the market demand or public services, influence employment, family life, healthcare, price level and so on. Individuals in general have different economic roles and, consequently, different economic and social power. In most cases, women and minorities are at a disadvantage. The apparent neutrality of the public budget hides the fact that, often, women and third-gender persons do not have the same variety of choices (political, social, economic) in relation to others. If we consider gender inequality as inefficient, both from the point of view of access to work and business, and as a lack of participation in political life, it becomes clear that the government (and parliament) can use the money raised through taxes to reduce inequality. By orienting public finances, it is possible to redistribute wealth and fight against women’s poverty and gender inequality. Public spending encompasses gender bias and produces gender-disparate effects on distribution of public services and wealth. Usually, government budget is considered as a monetary quantification of political objectives,86 but we must understand that the public budget is the result of political negotiations and it is influenced by political and social contests and values. Public budget is the reflection of the government’s interpretation of these values through the use of public expenditures. Very often public policies do not consider the unpaid work of women enough, especially during economic crises.87 Women become the last resort of families, compensating for insufficient public healthcare or social services. Public budgets do not recognise the role of women (nor individuals of third-gender and non-binary individuals) in the economy and society. To achieve equity and redistribution of wealth, considering the limited public resources, it is necessary to set the objectives of public finance taking into account these needs.88 Recently, UN statements (Millennium Development Goals and Sustainable Development Goals, especially action n. 5) reiterated the need to adopt and strengthen sound policies and enforceable legislation for the promotion of gender equality. Fiscal policies determine the composition of expenditure, and expenditures can consent investments and benefits to influence private behaviours in a gender responsive way. A high level of taxation and a similar level of public expenditures can contribute to an inclusive growth,89sustaining investments that reduce gender gap. Moreover, austerity measures after the financial crisis were executed without regard to gender bias. By cutting public expenditures or reducing taxation, governments cannot drive budget priorities towards improving the opportunities for minorities, boosting welcoming culture towards gender equality and avoiding the lack of integration into social life.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Weaponization

Solar geoengineering sparks geopolitical conflict that quickly escalates to war.

Birnbaum 2/27/23 [Michael Birnbaum is Education: Yale University and BA in History; Deep Springs College. He is a a national security reporter for The Washington Post, covering the State Department and diplomacy. He previously served in Europe for more than a decade as the The Post’s bureau chief in Brussels, Moscow and Berlin. He has reported for The Post from more than 40 countries, covering the conflict in Ukraine, the Egyptian revolution, the fall of Libyan leader Moammar Gaddafi and the Arab Spring elsewhere in the Middle East. He also covered climate and security from Washington. Birnbaum has a degree in German history from Yale University. He grew up in Chicago., 2-27-2023, "A ‘climate solution’ that spies worry could trigger war," Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2023/02/27/geoengineering-security-war/]//gbs-aarz

It sounds like something out of science fiction: A country suffering from heat, flooding or crop failures decides on its own to send out a fleet of aircraft to spray a fine, sun-blocking mist into the earth’s atmosphere, reducing temperatures and providing relief to parched populations. Other countries view it as a threat to their own citizens and ready a military response.

But members of the U.S. intelligence community and other national security officials were worried enough last year to plot how to avert a war triggered by this kind of climate engineering. In a role-playing exercise, they practiced managing the tensions that would be unleashed, according to people familiar with the exercise, a sign that they see it as a credible threat in need of a strategy.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Dangerous

Solar geoengineering is untested, dangerous, expensive, and risks thousands of human lives.

Cohen ‘22 [Ariel Cohen is a Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council and the Founding Principal of International Market Analysis, a Washington, D.C.-based global risk advisory boutique. He advises law firms and corporations, and once helped to get a famous Russian oligarch out of Putin’s jail. He is also a Senior Fellow with the International Tax and Investment Center (ITIC) where he directs their Energy, Growth, and Security Program (EGS)., 5-12-2022, "Geoengineering: Injecting Aerosols into the Atmosphere is Untested and Dangerous," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2022/05/12/geoengineering-injecting-aerosols-into-the-atmosphere-is-untested-and-dangerous/?sh=36d7f6a96665]//gbs-aarz

With global temperatures rising, policymakers are increasingly desperate for easy solutions to climate change. A report released by the Council on Foreign Relations validates a scientifically and politically controversial hypothesis— man-made solar geoengineering.

Also known as sunlight reflection, this is the process of reflecting sunlight away from Earth to reduce rising temperatures. Two approaches to climate alleviating geoengineering have garnered the most attention, Stratospheric Aerosol Injection (SAI) and Marine Cloud Brightening (MCB). SAI has attracted the most attention as it mimics a volcanic eruption by dispersing man-made aerosols into the atmosphere. It would be causing a cooling effect due to the aerosols’ reflective properties. While MCB reflects sunlight by spraying salt crystals from the ocean into low-lying clouds.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Oceans

CP can’t solve for ocean acidification or other effects of warming

Nicholson ‘12 - has spoken at MIT/Stanford VLAB, SXSW Interactive, the National Science Foundation, the National Research Council, the Space Studies Board and Brookhaven National Laboratory (Christie, “Blocking the sun to save the planet”, 1/23, http://www.smartplanet.com/blog/thinking-tech/blocking-the-sun-to-save-the-planet/10004)

To be sure, however, the models also predict that some areas might be harmed by the slightly darker days. Some experts also worry that such a drastic measure doesn’t solve the issue of ocean acidification, which is causing massive deterioration of coral reefs and basically impacting every corner of sea life. Plus there are plenty of political issues regarding high-flying planes traversing the Earth spewing aerosols. “The climate system is not well enough understood to exclude the risks of severe unanticipated climate changes, whether due to our fossil-fuel emissions or due to intentional intervention in the climate system,” said Julie Pongratz of Department of Global Ecology at the Carnegie Institution, in a press release. “Reducing greenhouse gas emissions is therefore likely a safer option than geoengineering to avert risks to global food security.”

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Fails

No solvency – impractical, expensive, negative effects

Govindswamy ‘9 Bala, climatologist at the Indian Institute of Science - Bangalore - McGill University, (“Problems with geoengineering schemes to combat climate change”, 9/22/08, http://indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/Problems%20with%20geoengineering%20schemes.pdf)//RN

The conclusion of the 1992 NAS report13 was that most geoengineering schemes, though feasible, are impractical, cumbersome to manage, or too expensive. It suggested some further study, but did not find it worthy of great effort. In support of this conclusion, Schneider29 suggested to reduce slowly our economic dependence on carbon fuels, rather than try to counter the side effects using risky options such as centuries of injecting sulphur into the atmosphere or iron into the oceans. While acknowledging that all geoengineering schemes have serious flaws, Keith10 judged that this century is likely to see serious debates about geoengineering. The serious debate indeed started when Nobel laureate Paul Crutzen8 published his influential editorial article on geoengineering. Since the attempts to curb fossil-fuel emissions have been unsuccessful, Crutzen suggested that the usefulness of artificially enhancing the planetary albedo to counteract the climate forcing of growing CO2 emissions might again be explored and debated. In a series of editorial comments8,30–33, broad recommendations were made to pursue scientific research on the effects of geoengineering schemes. However, Bengtsson34 expressed his reservations against geoengineering schemes for the following reasons. (1) There is a lack of accuracy in climate prediction. (2) There is large difference in the timescale between the effects of CO2 and the effects of aerosols, forcing us to commit to the artificial release of aerosols for several hundred years. (3) There are serious environmental problems such as ocean acidification, which are not mitigated by the albedoenhancing geoengineering schemes. To address the last two issues, Wigley advocated a combination of mitigation and geoengineering to prevent both climate change and ocean acidification. And thus the debate on combating climate change via geoengineering continues3

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Fails

Geoengineering fails – large technical and scientific uncertainties and doesn’t eliminate GHGs

Johnson et al. 10

Andrew Simms, policy director of New Economics Foundation, UK think tank, and head of NEF's Climate Change Programme, Dr. Victoria Johnson, researcher for the climate change and energy programme at NEF, MSc with distinction in Climate Change from the University of East Anglia and PhD in Atmospheric Physics at Imperial College, London and Peter Chowla, Policy and Advocacy Officer at the Bretton Woods Project. “Growth isn’t possible”. New Economics Foundation, January 25,2010. http://www.neweconomics.org/sites/neweconomics.org/files/Growth_Isnt_Possible.pdf

In most cases, geoengineering schemes are viewed as a stopgap between now and some point in the future where mitigation technology is cheaper and more widespread. There are, however, large technical and scientific uncertainties. For example Professor David Victor, Director of the Laboratory on International Law and Regulation at Stanford University argues: ‘…real-world geoengineering will be a lot more complex and expensive than currently thought because simple interventions—such as putting reflective particles in the stratosphere—will be combined with many other costlier interventions to offset nasty side effects.’327 The large majority of academics working in the field of geoengineering research have been clear that their research and technical propositions are not intended to distract from the efforts of reducing greenhouse gas emissions as the first priority for controlling climate change. However, many now argue that a technological intervention may be required parallel to current mitigation efforts.328

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Aff › 2ac – Fails

Geoengineering fails – costly, risky, and can’t be sustained

Moriarty and Honnery ‘10

Patrick Moriarty, Ph.D. Department of Design, Monash University, and Damon Honnery, Ph.D. Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Monash University. “Why Technical Fixes Won’t Mitigate Climate Change”. Journal of Cosmology, 2010, Vol 8, 1921-1927. http://journalofcosmology.com/ClimateChange107.html

As discussed here, geoengineering is action intended to manipulate climate on a global, or at least regional, scale. Corner and Pidgeon (2010) have pointed out that our emissions of CO2 (which have raised atmospheric CO2 levels from the pre-industrial 280 ppm to the present 387 ppm) could also be considered geoengineering. If so, we are merely arguing about different forms of the practice. The potential use of geoengineering for climate mitigation received a boost with a paper by Nobel laureate Paul Crutzen (2006). Like the present authors, he argued that conventional methods of mitigation were not working—the CO2 atmospheric concentration continues to climb at about 2 ppm each year. His inspiration was the significant drop in global temperatures recorded in the year following the Mount Pinatubo volcanic eruption in the Philippines in June 1991. The cooling resulted from the emission of some 10 Mt of sulphate aerosols into the lower stratosphere in the tropics. Continuous deliberate placement of fine sulphate aerosols in the lower stratosphere would reflect some of the incoming short-wave solar radiation, increasing the Earth’s albedo, and counteracting the positive forcing from increased levels of GHGs. The options available for geoengineering can be either local in extent (such as altering the albedo of deserts, crops or urban areas) or global (such as the use of giant space-based mirrors). Only aerosol placement in the tropical stratosphere, albedo enhancement of marine stratiform clouds and reflective mirrors in space would have the potential to counteract a doubling or more of atmospheric CO2 ppm (Lenton and Vaughan 2009). Of these global approaches, the cheapest is likely to be aerosol placement. Except for space-based mirrors, the approaches appear both far cheaper and far faster to implement than more conventional mitigation methods. Because of the lack of progress in slowing emissions and the low cost and rapid cooling resulting from global measures, geoengineering is gaining acceptance. The U.K. Royal Society (2009) has endorsed it as a technique to be used alongside other mitigation methods. But implementing measures to reduce the planetary albedo run enormous risks. Global precipitation would on average be reduced—it is not possible to bring both global temperatures and precipitation to their previous levels (Bala 2009). Acidification of the oceans would continue, potentially destabilising ocean ecosystems (Doney et al. 2009). Also, because elevated levels of CO2 will persist for centuries, so too must geoengineering—the continuous placement of aerosols, for example. Any abrupt cessation because of dangerous side effects discovered would rapidly raise the forcing to levels corresponding to the GHG concentrations at that time, resulting in very rapid warming, with possibly catastrophic effects on ecosystems (Matthews and Caldeira 2007). Thus although the costs of aerosol placement may well be modest, the overall cost of countering the unwanted consequences could be very high. Recently, perhaps because of these serious drawbacks, some researchers have modelled the effects of more modest aerosol placement schemes. Rather than global year-round aerosol coverage, they have looked at techniques that might prevent melting of the Greenhouse ice cap or Arctic summer sea ice, or summer warming of the north Atlantic during the hurricane season (Caldeira and Wood 2008, MacCracken 2009). The aerosols might be locally applied, for part of the year, to address a very specific problem resulting from climate change. But to be effective, their effects would necessarily be felt globally (Caldeira and Wood 2008), and if several of these projects were to be implemented simultaneously, the combined gobal effects might be extremely uncertain.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Neg › 2nc – AT: Causes War

Geoengineering weaponization is impossible – tech is imprecise and easily countered.

Horton and Keith ‘21 [Joshua Horton is the research director of geoengineering at the Harvard Kennedy School. David Keith is a professor of public policy and engineering at Harvard University., 11-4-2020, "Can Solar Geoengineering Be Used as a Weapon?," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/blog/can-solar-geoengineering-be-used-weapon]//gbs-aarz

Solar geoengineering—the idea of using technology to reflect a small fraction of incoming sunlight away from Earth to partially offset climate change—poses many problems, including its potential to discourage emissions cuts, its uncertain distributive consequences, and the possibility that suddenly stopping implementation might result in dangerously rapid warming. And yet available evidence shows that moderate use of solar geoengineering may offer an opportunity to mitigate climate hazards beyond what is possible even if all emissions could be eliminated tomorrow. In our view, the prospect that solar geoengineering could significantly reduce risks for the world’s poorest, reducing income inequality, is a strong basis for pursuing research and international governance. Debate on solar geoengineering, however, is haunted by a concern that such technology might be weaponized. This concern stems from longstanding military interest in weather modification technologies, most notably the U.S. use of cloud-seeding during the Vietnam War, which led to adoption of the 1976 Environmental Modification Convention (ENMOD) restricting hostile use of environmental modification techniques. It also stems from suggestions that governance of nuclear weapons may serve as a useful analog for governance of solar geoengineering. Fears about the dual-use nature of solar geoengineering are sometimes stated explicitly (e.g., at 51:30 in this recent Rolling Stone debate), but more often implied in terms of vaguely defined security threats or speculation about “predatory geoengineering.” In a recent guest blog for the Internationalist, for example, Elizabeth Chalecki argues that “Just as nuclear fission can produce both weapons and energy, so too can geoengineering provide benefits if applied judiciously;” unsaid but insinuated is that solar geoengineering might also be used to wage war, which justifies placing it under international control in the same way the Baruch Plan of 1946 sought to internationalize atomic energy. (For other recent examples see here and here.) The premise that solar geoengineering is weaponizable, however, is either false or grossly overstated and inapplicable to those technologies that might plausibly be deployed. Precision is a defining attribute of weaponry; indeed, the so-called revolution in military affairs has made it the most prized attribute for many strategists, as exemplified by the dominant role now played by precision-guided munitions. One hallmark of solar geoengineering, however, would be its imprecision. Take stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI), which would disperse aerosols in the stratosphere to reflect sunlight and reduce some harmful aspects of climate change. SAI is the most prominent type of solar geoengineering and the one most associated with fears about weaponization. Yet injected materials cannot be contained along lines of latitude and would quickly encircle the globe. Some north-south control is possible, but only at a very crude level using just a few knobs like dispersing in equatorial versus polar regions or in northern versus southern hemispheres. Only climate effects—changes in average temperature and precipitation—could plausibly be induced; weather control at the level of individual storms or heat waves would be impossible to engineer. Moreover, there would be several steps between any induced climate change and the types of climate impacts—like changes in water availability or crop yields—that might affect states and societies in a somewhat predictable manner. There is simply no physical basis for believing that significant—large compared to natural variability—impacts could be targeted at the level of the nation-state. Thus, SAI would be much too imprecise to function as a useful weapon. To take just one scenario, suppose the United States wished to attack Venezuela. The most predictable damage the United States could inflict using SAI would be a reduction in precipitation caused by dispersing aerosols solely in the southern hemisphere; doing so would shift the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ), an equatorial band of tropical rainfall northward, leading to decreased rainfall over Caribbean South America. But since the ITCZ circles the globe, this action would disrupt (sub)tropical precipitation worldwide. Indiscriminate climate modification of this nature would surely not be welcomed by China (America’s principal rival), India (the linchpin of America’s Indo-Pacific strategy), or Mexico (America’s southern neighbor and third largest trading partner). Furthermore, the effect would be slow-moving within Venezuela, requiring perhaps years to determine whether reduced rainfall was responsible for observed impacts like droughts or food shortages. And it would be even harder to link this intervention to combat readiness, battlefield conditions, and other operational variables with clear implications for warfighting. Whatever strategic or tactical benefits might accrue to the United States, they would be dwarfed by the costs, risks, and uncertainties produced by worldwide rainfall disruptions affecting friends and enemies alike. SAI lacks the minimum level of precision—in space, time, and effect—implicit in the concept of a weapon. The other two solar geoengineering technologies regularly discussed—low-level marine cloud brightening (MCB) using seawater spray to block incoming sunlight, and high-altitude cirrus cloud thinning (CCT) via dissipative seeding to enable more outgoing heat to escape the atmosphere—could be deployed with far more precision in space and time, yet it would still be extraordinarily difficult to use them to produce strong local effects, and such effects would inevitably cause significant distant consequences. It is conceivable that if MCB or CCT were deployed at global scale then they could be fine-tuned using meteorological data to enable limited weather control. But this is unproven, and even if possible, the physical consequences might be too diffuse or easily countered to have significant military value.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Neg › 2nc – AT: Inequality

Geoengineering solves economic inequality

Temple ‘20 [James Temple is the senior editor for energy at MIT Technology Review. He is focused on renewable energy and the use of technology to combat climate change., 1-13-2020, "Why geoengineering may narrow global economic inequality," MIT Technology Review, https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/01/13/130918/why-geoengineering-may-narrow-global-economic-inequality/]//gbs-aarz

Some scientists believe that geoengineering, the idea that we could spray reflective particles into the atmosphere to reverse global warming, may especially reduce suffering in the hottest, poorest parts of the world.

A new paper in Nature Communications goes further, concluding that such measures could accelerate economic growth in nations most vulnerable to climate change. That would narrow global inequality, at least relative to what would happen if we simply allowed the world to heat up.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Neg › 2nc – Geoengineering Inev

Geoengineering is both inevitable and key to curbing global warming

Patrick 22 [Stewart M. Patrick is a Senior Fellow and director of the International Institutions and Global Governance Program at the Council on Foreign Relations., 7-17-2014, "To Reduce Growing Climate Dangers, the World Needs to Consider Sunlight Reflection," Council on Foreign Relations, https://www.cfr.org/blog/reduce-growing-climate-dangers-world-needs-consider-sunlight-reflection]//gbs-aarz

For too long, sunlight reflection has been the third rail of climate change politics, a relegation that has severely crippled its basic research and discussion in diplomatic circles. This situation, however, is starting to change as the devastating implications of a fast-warming planet become impossible to ignore. Today, the Council on Foreign Relations released a new Special Report on the topic: Reflecting Sunlight to Reduce Climate Risk: Priorities for Research and International Cooperation. It calls on the United States to launch a robust sunlight reflection research program and spearhead international negotiations to advance multilateral scientific assessments of and collective decision-making regarding these novel techniques and their potential future implementation.

Sunlight reflection, also known as solar climate intervention (SCI) or solar geoengineering, would entail reflecting a tiny percentage of sunlight back into space to reduce the heating effects of solar radiation on greenhouse gases, thus limiting—and conceivably even reducing—the rise in global temperatures that would otherwise occur. The two simplest and most cost-effective means of doing so would be either dispersing aerosols in the stratosphere or spraying salt crystals from ocean-based platforms to brighten low-lying marine clouds.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Neg › 2nc – Solvency

Geoengineering solves climate – growing scientific support.

Jacobo et al. 4/21/23 [Julia Jacobo is a multimedia reporter at ABC News. Daniel Manzo is a meteorologist and weather producer at ABC News. Ginger Zee is the chief meteorologist at ABC News, reporting on the nation’s weather on “Good Morning America” and across ABC News broadcasts and digital platforms., 4-21-2023, "These geoengineering technologies could help combat the climate crisis, scientists say," ABC News, https://abcnews.go.com/US/geoengineering-technologies-combat-climate-crisis-scientists/story?id=98476205]//gbs-aarz

Climate scientists have been warning for decades of global warming's devastating consequences.

Now that the effects of climate change are being experienced around the globe -- droughts, rising sea levels and stronger storm systems -- scientists are exploring how geoengineering technology can help to alleviate the effects of rising temperatures.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
Geoengineering CP › Neg › 1nc

Solar geoengineering can reverse global warming – it’s cheap, fast, and flexible

Conca ‘19 [James Conca has been a PhD scientist in the field of the earth and environmental sciences for 35 years and is a Forbes contributor., 09-10-2019, "Why Solar Geoengineering May Be Our Only Hope To Reverse Global Warming," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2019/09/10/solar-geoengineering-we-better-do-it-or-well-burn/?sh=5f7cadb818ad]

Solar geoengineering is the process by which humans deliberately reduce the effect of heat-trapping greenhouses gases by reflecting a small fraction of sunlight back into space. It sounds strange, but it isn’t as odd, or as difficult, as it might seem. And we know that it works because it happens every time a huge volcano erupts. And we’ve been studying those for over 100 years. [image omitted] Some serious scientific mojo has been applied to this idea at universities around the world. Harvard’s Solar Geoengineering Research Program is a research initiative devoted entirely to the science, technology and public policy of solar geoengineering. But too few scientists, and too little funding, has been applied to this solution. Which is sad since it doesn’t need much. There are several technologies for this approach, including injection of aerosols (fine droplets or particulates as fine as powder) into the stratosphere, where they would scatter some sunlight back to space, thus cooling the planet by reducing the amount of heat that enters the lower atmosphere (see figure). Marine cloud brightening is another way to reflect solar radiation back into space. This would use automated ships to spray droplets of seawater into the atmosphere above the ocean where they evaporate to form an elevated concentration of sea-salt aerosols which seed higher concentrations of cloud droplets in clouds over the ocean, increasing their reflectivity (see figure). [image comitted] According to one the fields long-time researchers, Dr. David Keith at Harvard, solar geoengineering could limit global warming’s predicted side effects such as sea level rise and changes in precipitation and other weather patterns. Because these changes would have their most powerful impact on the world’s most vulnerable people, who lack the resources to move or adapt, Keith finds a strong ethical case for research into solar geoengineering. Besides, we’ve been geoengineering the atmosphere for over a century - in the wrong direction – by injecting huge amounts of CO2 and other greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere. Let’s face it. As a species, we just have not risen to the occasion of fighting the planetary crisis of global warming. And by all measures we’re not going to. Global emissions are continuing to rise. Oil and gas keep getting cheaper and easier to find, and coal is the easiest energy source to emplace in a poor country with little infrastructure. To bring this home, all you have to do is see how climate scientists are seeking psychiatric help for the depression, anxiety and PTSD that happens when you see a train wreck coming but no one seems to want to do anything about it - and you’re on the train. And America seems to have gone on a carbon binge. We’re producing more oil, gas and coal than any other country, and more than ever before. Along with trying to repeal over 80 environmental rules going back to the Nixon Administration, the Trump Administration has moved to eliminate federal curbs on methane emissions from oil and gas operations. Even the oil companies don’t want this. Prior to the United States pulling out of the Paris climate accords, there was growing skepticism that the world could, or would, decrease its total greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 enough to actually prevent the worst of global warming. All climate models show that the next 20 years is critical. The best we can do is keep warming to 3 to 4°F, and that only if we get global emissions to zero by 2040. If we don’t, temperatures rise by 6 to 8°F. That’s because CO2 has a half-life in the atmosphere between 30 and 300 years, depending on the various chemical mechanisms that naturally remove CO2 from the atmosphere. And that’s just the half-life. We have to start reducing emission now by almost 10% per year until 2040 when anthropogenic emissions will have to be zero. We are extremely unlikely to meet this target - global emissions are still growing and it looks like we will not even start declining for at least 10 more years. At that time we would have to reduce emissions by 20% per year. Let me state that clearly – there is no way to reduce carbon emissions in the next 20 years sufficient to mitigate the worst effects of climate change. This is sobering indeed. But don’t get too bummed because it’s not the end. Many scientists have wondered how to either remove GHGs from the atmosphere or mitigate the effects some other way. Indeed, an entire scientific discipline has evolved around this issue and some great work has been done. Removing GHGs is really difficult and really expensive. Much more expensive than preventing them from entering in the first place. So if we refuse to spend the amount of money and effort needed to reduce emissions, we certainly wouldn’t spend even more trying to get them back out. But we still need to try. [image omitted] The other strategy is to mitigate the effects of warming by directly cooling the planet. Cooling occurs naturally when millions of tons of particles such as soot from huge fires, particulates and gasses from large volcanic eruptions, or excessive amounts of ice crystals, enter the atmosphere and either block incoming solar rays or reflect them back into space. Enter Solar Geoengineering. Solar geoengineering should not replace reducing emissions (mitigation), coping with a changing climate (adaptation), or carbon dioxide removal and sequestration. Solar geoengineering does not change the CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere, it treats a symptom - heat. It’s like putting some serious sunblock on Planet Earth, giving us time to figure out how to lower our carbon emissions to near-zero. Changing the Earth’s albedo, or reflectivity, is what these strategies target. Lower albedos capture and hold solar radiation, higher albedos reflect it back. Speaking as a geologist, we have seen the cooling effects of big fires and big volcanoes in the geologic record going back many millions of years, so we know it works, and how it works. When the huge volcano Krakatoa erupted in 1883, the billions of tons of particulates thrown into the stratosphere dropped global temperatures about two degrees. But as the particulates came out of the atmosphere over the next few years, the effect went away. [image omitted] But these natural processes are uncontrolled and in many cases cause very big adverse environmental changes themselves. Of course, the particulates and gases coming out of a volcano are not the ones we would choose in solar geoengineering. And that’s the whole point of research, says Dr. Tom Ackerman at the University of Washington Department of Atmospheric Sciences. Because we have studied large volcanic eruptions like Krakatoa, Tambora and Pinatubo, there aren’t any real basic science unknowns. We know that stratospheric aerosols can achieve cooling that offsets half of the warming from a doubling of CO2 concentrations. It’s just figuring out how to do it effectively without causing other problems. By choosing where to release the aerosols, a uniform global aerosol layer could be created. Its thickness could be varied as needed - thicker at high latitudes or in one hemisphere or the other - in order to craft a desired outcome. Within certain limits. As Keith describes, solar geoengineering has three essential characteristics: it is cheap, fast and imperfect. Long-established estimates show that solar geoengineering is at least 100 times cheaper than cutting emissions in offsetting the expected global temperature rise through 2100. A few grams of particles in the stratosphere can offset the radiative forcing of a metric ton of atmospheric carbon dioxide. At about US$1,000 a metric ton for aerosol delivery, that adds up to maybe a billion dollars per year, not the trillions of dollars it will take to replace all fossil fuels with hydro, nuclear and renewables. And $50 to $100 million a year for about 10 years is all it would take to do the research needed to figure out how to do this right. That’s barely the cost of a single fighter jet, not much for saving the planet and half the species on it. Not to fund this research program is like being too cheap to buy sunblock, knowing skin cancer runs in your family. This research will answer a lot of things, even the ethics questions of whether we should do it at all. But if you don’t do the research in the next ten years, you may not be able to implement this correctly when you realize we need to do this fast. And others may do it anyway, without the care we might show. The Chinese have specifically said they will do exactly this if things get too out of hand with global warming. And they have a robust research program already underway. [image omitted] As Joseph Lassiter of Harvard calculates, “Assuming humanity continued to make a net addition of CO2 into the atmosphere every year for a decade, and some of the sulfate aerosol shield would dissipate every year, continuous injections of greater amounts of sulfates would be needed each year in order to maintain the concentration required to manage the earth’s temperature.” For example, in the first year it would take about 25,000 metric tons of sulfates dispensed by 1 or 2 aircraft to offset about 50% of that year’s increase in warming. In order to maintain the 50% reduction, in year two, about 50,000 tons of sulfates would need to be dispensed and so on each year into the future. After 10 years this number would reach over a million metric tons of sulfates dispensed by 100 aircraft. This is still not much. And we should finally start decreasing carbon emissions after 2030, decreasing over the next few decades until we no longer need solar geoengineering. Let’s be clear - solar geoengineering is not to be done, or even considered, as a replacement for cutting carbon emissions. It’s just to buy us the several decades we need to actually cut emissions to near zero without frying the planet. This is because solar geoengineering cannot eliminate all of the damages caused by green-house gas-driven warming, even if it tried to restore global average temperatures to pre-industrial levels. Compared to the warming caused by GHGs - which trap long wave radiation - climate variables such as temperature and precipitation respond differently to cooling caused by solar geoengineering which reflects short wave radiation. For example, if temperatures were restored to pre-industrial levels by solar geoengineering, the water cycle would be weaker than it was in the 1700s. An important point to remember about solar geoengineering is that it inherently self-limiting. You have to keep doing it continuously until we get a handle on emissions. If you stop, the effect goes away in a year or two as the aerosols come out of the atmosphere, just like happens a few years after every huge volcanic eruption. But this turns out to be a good thing. Solar geoengineering can be adjusted easily and relatively quickly, even reversed, if you don’t like the effects. We wouldn’t have to accept even a few degrees temperature increase, we could keep it the way we want it, even cool off a bit back to where we were 100 years ago. As Keith puts it, “Because the warming impact of carbon is more or less forever [on biological lifetimes], all that we can achieve this century by cutting emissions is to stop making the problem worse. Solar geoengineering allows a more optimistic outcome. In combination with technologies to remove carbon that is already in the atmosphere, it would allow humanity to aim to restore the preindustrial climate over two human lifetimes.”

2023 CNDI Counterplan
AFF › AT: FIIB › No Solvency- Empirics

Infrastructure bank funding model is unsustainable- can’t provide long term fixes

Robert Krol 2017

Does a National Public Infrastructure Bank Make Sense?; Mercatus Center @ George Mason University; https://www.mercatus.org/economic-insights/expert-commentary/does-national-public-infrastructure-bank-make-sense

The bank could also be allowed to leverage the initial taxpayer capital by borrowing in financial markets. Leveraging initial taxpayer funds and lending at below market interest rates in order to make loans attractive would put the bank’s capital at risk, endangering its ability to fund future projects, even if all loans were repaid. If the infrastructure bank took this approach, it would also attract projects with lower returns. Large highway projects are inherently risky. Project costs and demand are difficult to forecast, resulting in defaults that would further reduce the bank’s capital. Unlike private banks, public lenders often fail to focus on the riskiness of a project. The biggest problem is that a national public infrastructure bank would cement politics into transportation funding decisions. We can expect this discretionary lending institution to be guided more by partisan politics than by hard economic facts. If the past is any indication, loans are likely to go to states with close elections or to reward past political support, rather than to areas of the country where it makes the most economic sense. And because a national bank would not be able to provide a sustainable source of highway funding on the scale envisioned by its supporters, it would most likely need additional taxpayer funding over time.

2023 CNDI Counterplan
AFF › AT: FIIB › No Solvency- Empirics

FIB won’t generate the financing needed- state banks prove

Robert Krol 2017

Does a National Public Infrastructure Bank Make Sense?; Mercatus Center @ George Mason University; https://www.mercatus.org/economic-insights/expert-commentary/does-national-public-infrastructure-bank-make-sense

This is a naïve view. State infrastructure banks offer valuable lessons as to why a federal bank is unlikely to become a long-term, sustainable source of funding. The 1995 National Highway System Designation Act established a state infrastructure bank pilot program. Since then 34 states set up public infrastructure banks. The initial capital came mostly from federal and some state tax dollars. According to tallies by Brookings Institution researchers Robert Puentes and Jennifer Thompson, these banks made 1,134 agreements worth $7.4 billion between 1995 and 2012, amounting to one-half-of-one percent of total state spending on infrastructure over the period. Seventy percent of the agreements were for highway construction. However, rather than making traditional loans, 28 percent of the agreements were issued interest free—defeating the goal of providing a sustainable source of infrastructure funding. Today, many of these banks are inactive or require addition taxpayer dollars. A national infrastructure bank would presumably allow firms to borrow at the Treasury bond interest rate, an attractive feature to private borrowers. But state and local governments—traditionally the main borrowers in this case—have historically been able to borrow at lower rates. Interest rates on infrastructure bank loans would have to be below the state and local rate in order to entice them to borrow from the bank. Again, this is a problem if the goal is a sustainable source of infrastructure investment funds.