Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Gas Affordable

Uptick in demand leads to an increase in various methods of production

U.S. Energy Information Administration, 4-27-2023 [U.S. Energy Information Administration, 27 April, U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Natural gas explained Where our natural gas comes from” https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/natural-gas/where-our-natural-gas-comes-from.php Accessed on 20 June 2023, NP]

The United States now produces nearly all of the natural gas that it uses

U.S. dry natural gas production in 2022 was about 35.81 trillion cubic feet (Tcf), an average of about 98.11 billion cubic feet per day and the highest annual amount recorded. Most of the production increases since 2005 are the result of horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing techniques, notably in shale, sandstone, carbonate, and other tight geologic formations. Natural gas is produced from onshore and offshore natural gas and oil wells and from coalbeds. In 2022, U.S. dry natural gas production was about 10.8% greater than total U.S. natural gas consumption. Although most of U.S. the natural gas consumption is met with domestic production, the United States imports some natural gas to help supply domestic demand.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Gas Affordable

Strong production will keep natural gas prices low --- additional capacity will ensure grid reliability and balance

Hyerczyk 5-25-23 – Senior Market Analyst (James, “Natural Gas Forecast: Prices Face Downward Pressure Amid Ample Supply, Milder Weather”, https://www.fxempire.com/forecasts/article/natural-gas-forecast-prices-face-downward-pressure-amid-ample-supply-milder-weather-1349407, FX Empire, NK)

The Natural Gas Supply Association (NGSA) stated that ample storage levels, milder weather, and increased production will likely lead to downward pressure on US natural gas prices this summer. Despite reaching record levels of customer demand, with an average of 97 billion cubic feet per day (bcfd), prices at the Henry Hub are expected to average below last year’s $7.10 per million British thermal units (mmBtu) from April through October.

Higher Production, Storage Impact Prices

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Gas Affordable

Natural gas industry is thriving – creating thousands of new jobs as it expands

Blankley 6-24-23 (Bethany, “Texas oil and gas industry reaches another record in May” https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/texas-oil-and-gas-industry-reaches-another-record-in-may, Washington Examiner, NK)

(The Center Square) – As Texas continued to lead the U.S. in job growth last month, the Texas upstream oil and natural gas industry added 6,900 jobs in May, the highest job growth reported in a single month in the 33 years the Texas Workforce Commission has reported the data.

The record jobs added in May brought the total upstream oil and natural gas job count in Texas to over 200,000 employed in the industry for the first time in over three years. Last month’s more than 206,000 upstream jobs was an increase of 22,700, or 12.4%, from May 2022, according to the data

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – Gas Affordable

Natural gas is abundant and affordable in the U.S. – we have enough gas to help Europe overcome losses from Russia – our evidence accounts for current levels of renewable energy

AT: renewables thumper --- natural gas biggest source of power despite existing renewable increases

Graeber 6-8-23 (Daniel “Renewables gaining ground, but gas dominates the U.S. energy grid” https://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2023/06/08/eia-renewables-natural-gas-electric-power/7301686235769/)

June 8 (UPI) -- Considerable gains in renewable energy are apparent in the energy sector, though natural gas remains the single largest source of power, the U.S. government said.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – US Gas Production High

Strong U.S. natural gas production is keeping prices affordable and a wave of LNG export terminals are coming online

Jones, 6/22/2023 - International Banker [Alexander, 22 June 2023, International Banker, “Why Natural-Gas Prices Have Crashed” internationalbanker.com/brokerage/why-natural-gas-prices-have-crashed/ Accessed 25 June 2023, NP]

In the United States, meanwhile, booming natural-gas production has been cited as one of the main factors responsible for the price decline. Already the world’s largest natural-gas producer, the US is now pumping out vast quantities of natural gas, with the country’s biggest shale field—the Permian Basin of Texas and New Mexico—producing record-high gas volumes for every month this year thus far, according to the U.S. EIA. Much of this supply uptick has come in concert with the rise in crude-oil production off the back of higher oil prices. “About a third of US gas production is associated gas—produced from oil wells,” Jacques Rousseau, a managing director at research firm ClearView Energy Partners, told Reuters in early April. “This production is unlikely to decline given current oil prices.” As such, the amount of gas sitting in storage in the US is around one-fifth higher than is normal for this time of year.

One also cannot ignore the outsized impact LNG (liquefied natural gas) is now having on the natural-gas market, with a wave of new export terminals coming online over the next few years likely to weigh heavily on prices. Indeed, with gas supplies from Russia to Europe being severely curtailed, something of a supply frenzy has emerged as LNG exporters step in to replace this shortfall. The US, for one, is set to expand its export capacity significantly, with several LNG projects on the US Gulf of Mexico coast that use Texas shale gas expected to launch soon.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › UNIQUENESS › U – US Gas Production High

LNG exports high now to support international demand

EIA, 7/12

The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) collects, analyzes, and disseminates energy information to promote sound policymaking, efficient markets, and public understanding of energy, 7-12-2023, "Natural Gas Weekly Update," No Publication, https://www.eia.gov/naturalgas/weekly/

Natural gas deliveries by pipeline to U.S. liquefied natural gas (LNG) export facilities (LNG feed gas) averaged 12.8 billion cubic feet per day (Bcf/d) in the first six months of 2023, following the Freeport LNG terminal’s return to service, according to data by S&P Global Commodity Insights. This average was 1.0 Bcf/d (8%) more than the 2022 annual average and 0.5 Bcf/d (4%) more than the same six-month period in 2022.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – CCUS Trick

CCUs are the only way to solve warming.

Fransen ‘20 Bas Fransen. “Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU).” EcoMatcher, 13 Feb. 2020, www.ecomatcher.com/carbon-capture-and-utilization-ccu/#:~:text=Carbon%20capture%20and%20utilization%2C%20or. Accessed 13 July 2023.

Carbon capture and utilization, or CCU, is the process of capturing carbon dioxide (CO2) to be used later for a specific use. This process can be a key player in reducing climate change issues since it can positively impact the total levels of greenhouse gases. CCU aims for the further use of CO2 in the creation of more economically appealing products while maintaining the overall carbon neutrality of the production process. 

CO2 accounts for around 77% of greenhouse gases. Industries across the world still rely heavily on the burning of fossil fuels in order to create energy. Other major contributors to CO2 emissions are transportation and the construction industry. Building materials like concrete and steel require massive amounts of energy in order to be produced. On the flip side, active deforestation of forests is removing natural and effective CO2 sinks which inadvertently adds to the total emissions.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – CCUS Trick

Strong gas industry leads to investment and development in CCU.

IEA ‘20 The Oil and Gas Industry in Energy Transitions, IEA, Paris https://www.iea.org/reports/the-oil-and-gas-industry-in-energy-transitions, License: CC BY 4.0

The oil and gas industry is already one of the global leaders in developing and deploying carbon capture and utilisation (CCUS) technologies. Of the 35 Mt CO2 captured today from industrial activities in large-scale CCUS facilities, nearly 80% is captured from oil and gas operations. CCUS is a critical technology to reach the emissions trajectory of the SDS, with deployment split almost equally between the power and industry sectors (including cement, iron and steel, and refineries). Total CO2 captured globally rises from 170 Mt CO2 in 2025 to nearly 2 400 Mt CO2 in 2040. In the power sector, CCUS in the SDS is concentrated in a handful of countries, most notably China (for coal) and the United States (for natural gas). The use of CCUS in industrial applications is widespread, as emissions from energy-intensive sectors are typically hard to abate, and CCUS constitutes one of the few currently available technology options to achieve deep levels of decarbonisation. As shown by the 45Q fiscal incentive in the United States, actions by governments will play an essential role in facilitating the growth in CCUS. This can be via targeted regulatory levers, market-based frameworks, public procurement, low-carbon product incentives, tax credits or grant funding. Governments can also play a role in facilitating the growth of multi-user transport and storage networks that industrial facilities can access, and in helping to manage risks associated with ensuring stored CO2 does not leak. If the incentives are in place to encourage investment in different components of the CCUS value chain, there are several ways to think about the role of the oil and gas industry in relation to CCUS. • As a source of some concentrated streams of CO2 that are relatively easy and cost-effective to capture (for example in gas processing or parts of the refining sector). Deployment of CCUS in these areas would contribute to reductions in scope 1 and 2 emissions intensities. • As a user of CO2, primarily for injection into reservoirs as a mechanism for EOR. Depending on the source of the CO2 and the volumes being injected, this could reduce the emissions intensity of the produced oil considerably (and even, theoretically, lead to carbon-negative oil). • As an industry that undertakes well-funded, high-level research, and that has the large-scale engineering, pipeline and subsurface, and project management capabilities to scale up CCUS. This could have positive spillover implications for many aspects of energy transitions, including for the large-scale production of low-carbon hydrogen and the decarbonisation of heavy industry. CCUS could also play a key role in helping to achieve “negative emissions” if bioenergy is used in conjunction with carbon capture and storage (BECCS). Negative emissions could help to offset emissions from hard-to-abate sectors, such as aviation or the manufacturing of iron, steel and cement. Further, most scenarios that aim to limit the temperature rise to 1.5°C (such as those assessed in the IPCC special report, Global Warming of 1.5°C) rely heavily on BECCS to do so. In the SDS, just under 100 Mt CO2 is absorbed from the atmosphere using BECCS in 2040.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – Clean Transition

LNG’s the real GND – environmentalists fail to recognize how it’s solved our emissions and is continuing to do so.

Weinstein ‘19

BERNARD L. WEINSTEIN, OPINION CONTRIBUTOR - Bernard L. Weinstein is associate director of the Maguire Energy Institute and an adjunct professor of business economics in the Cox School of Business at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. - 07/31/19; Natural gas is the ‘real’ green new deal; ; //[TMS—GK]

As proposed, the Green New Deal was naively impractical and prohibitively expensive. For example, according to a study by the Mises Institute, transition to a power sector with net zero emissions of greenhouse gases in 10 years would require a capital investment of $5.4 trillion by 2029. In addition, the annual operation, maintenance and capital-recovery costs would exceed $387 billion. Amid all the brouhaha over climate change, a major milestone has been ignored — namely, that America’s greenhouse gas emissions are 13 percent lower today than in 2005, even with an economy that is a third larger. This achievement isn’t the result of environmental regulations or the huge subsidies available to wind and solar investors; rather, it has been the increased use of natural gas that has helped reduce GHGs in the U.S. It is a well-known fact that natural gas burns a lot cleaner than coal or oil. At the same time, thanks to the “shale revolution,” natural gas is abundant, inexpensive and likely to remain so for the foreseeable future. Consequently, the power generation sector, which is responsible for about 25 percent of GHGs in the U.S., has moved quickly to adopt natural gas. Electric utilities have shuttered more than 250 coal plants since 2010 and a dozen more will be closed this year. A decade ago, coal-fired generation accounted for about 50 percent of the electrons coursing through the nation’s power grids but by last year, that percentage had dropped to 27. No utility in the nation has plans to build a new coal plant. Opponents of fossil fuels acknowledge that gas has a smaller carbon footprint than coal but nonetheless object to its use because of methane (CH4) releases associated with its production and transportation. Because the heat-trapping characteristics of methane are 20 times greater than carbon dioxide, environmentalists have good reason to be concerned. But here again they fail to acknowledge the tremendous progress that has been made in recent years to contain methane emissions. According to recent data from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Energy Information Administration, methane emissions from onshore oil and natural gas production fell 24 percent between 2011 and 2017, even as production increased by almost 50 percent and 730,000 miles of new transmission and distribution pipelines were added. What’s more, the Oil and Gas Climate Initiative (OGCI), a coalition of global energy companies, has committed to cutting average methane intensity by at least 20 percent and total GHG emission levels by one-third by 2025. Already, participants have conducted more than 156,000 leak-monitoring surveys across 78,000 production sites in the U.S. America’s natural gas boom also is helping to reduce greenhouse gas emissions abroad. From virtually zero a few years ago, liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports approached 800 billion cubic feet last year. With capacity expected to double by the end of this year, export volumes will continue to grow exponentially. Indeed, by 2024 the U.S. is projected to be the world’s second largest exporter of LNG, after Qatar. Countries such as China, India and Japan — which still rely heavily on coal for power generation — are among the largest purchasers of American LNG. To the degree they substitute our “clean gas” for their domestic or imported “dirty coal,” the air becomes cleaner while global greenhouse gas emissions are reduced. Cheap natural gas, made available by hydraulic fracturing of deep shale, is the “real” green new deal that has made the U.S. the world leader in reducing carbon emissions. Though President Trump took us out of the Paris Climate Treaty, we will surely exceed the carbon reduction targets in that agreement, and well ahead of schedule.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 2NC › 2nc – GND Bomb

Green New Deal GND’s a gift to Putin – transition’s too fast without a bridge fuel – locks in Russian energy dependence and European energy insecurity.

Barton ‘19

Michael James Barton is the founder of Hyatt Solutions and speaks around the country on energy and energy security matters. He previously served as the deputy director of Middle East policy at the Pentagon.; “Green New Deal Strengthens Putin But Weakens America,” 02/22/2019; ; //[TMS—GK]

Death Of The Energy Revolution? The Green New Deal would undo this energy revolution which America has worked so hard to achieve. In addition to massively subsidizing solar and wind power, it would place enormous restrictions on drilling and fracking. The 14-page document is light on details, but its ultimate goal is clear — effectively eliminate fossil fuels and generate "100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources." No word from a fan of this plan, presidential candidate Sen. Cory Booker, on how exactly this renewable energy production will avoid rolling blackouts in every city and town in America. Perhaps his imaginary drug dealer friend "T-Bone" relayed an invention to Sen. Booker that makes the plan possible. The Green New Deal would also put many oil and gas firms out of business. If America gives up its role as the global leader in oil and gas production, hostile foreign governments will gladly take our place and weaponize their energy resources. The bill would transport us back to the 1970s, when the Arab oil embargo brought the U.S. economy to a standstill and caused gas lines and fuel rationing. America produces more than 11 million barrels of oil a day. Removing that supply from global markets would give Putin and his ilk a stranglehold on the entire world economy. Perhaps plan supporter Sen. Bernie Sanders likes the idea of American workers wasting their time in a socialist line for basic products like fuel and bread. Not steaks though, as the plan's proponents also call for the end of cattle in the United States. Green New Deal: Just Hot Air Progressive activists dismiss such concerns, arguing that America will generate almost all its energy from renewable sources and thus be immune to oil market fluctuations. But that's fantasy. Leading researchers doubt it's possible to transition to renewable sources within three decades — much less the 10 years called for in the Green New Deal. In addition to hurting U.S. consumers, the Green New Deal would undermine the security of America's closest allies. Consider that the European Union gets more of its oil and gas from Russia than from any other country — an arrangement that stymies Europe's ability to check Russian power. Should Russia seek to expand its influence and control in the region, as it did when it annexed Crimea in 2014, Europe will be forced to choose between standing up for its values and protecting its energy imports. That's a precarious position. Supporters of this plan have been screaming from the rooftops about Russian influence in the 2016 election, but seem eager to hand over power to Russia in exchange for some vague promises of new things that haven't yet been invented. A Gift To Putin The United States is Europe's best hope of breaking its dependence on Russian energy. American firms have been ramping up their sales of liquefied natural gas to the continent. In October 2018, the United States traded more LNG with the EU than any month on record. The Green New Deal would make such trade impossible. Our rapid exit from the oil and gas sector would be a gift to the Putin regime. The Green New Deal would be a geopolitical disaster for America. Lawmakers shouldn't give it the time of day.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc

2. Failure in Ukraine triggers World War 3.

Farkas ‘22 (Evelyn N., former deputy assistant secretary of defense for Russia, Ukraine, Eurasia in the Obama administration and former senior advisor to the Supreme Allied Commander of NATO, "The US must prepare for war against Russia over Ukraine," Defense One, 1-11-22, ) DGW

The United States must do more than issue ultimatums about sanctions and economic penalties. U.S. leaders should be marshalling an international coalition of the willing, readying military forces to deter Putin and, if necessary, prepare for war.

If Russia prevails again, we will remain stuck in a crisis not just over Ukraine but about the future of the global order far beyond that country’s borders. Left unrestrained, Putin will move swiftly, grab some land, consolidate his gains, and set his sights on the next satellite state in his long game to restore all the pre-1991 borders: the sphere of geographical influence he deems was unjustly stripped from Great Russia.

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc

1. Maintaining natural gas exports is key to victory in Ukraine and stability in Asia.

- capabilities key to deterrence and upstream key to Asian supplies

Collins, et. al, 22 --- Baker Botts Fellow in Energy & Environmental Regulatory Affairs (August 4, 2022, Gabriel Collins, Anna Mikulska - Fellow in Energy Studies & Baker Institutes, Steven R. Miles - Fellow in Global Natural Gas & Baker Institute, “Winning the Long War in Ukraine Requires Gas Geoeconomics,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/winning-long-war-ukraine-requires-gas-geoeconomics)

Gas Geoeconomics in Europe Would Help Contain a Global Axis of Autocracy

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc

b. Link: Government mandated green energy crushes the US gas production platform.

- Investment flight and lost efficiency reduces our ability to export affordably to allies.

Pugliaresi ‘23 – President of Energy Policy Research Foundation [Lucian Energy Policy Research Foundation, 29 March United States Senate Committee on the Budget Hearing on "Left Holding the Bag: The Cost of Oil Dependence in a LowCarbon World” Mr. Lucian Pugliaresi - Testimony - Senate Budget Committee, https://www.budget.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Mr.%20Lucian%20Pugliaresi%20-%20Testimony%20-%20Senate%20Budget%20Committee1.pdf, EME]

Introduction

2023 CNDI Disadvantage
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23 › 1NC › 1nc

a. Uniqueness: U.S. natural gas industry is strong

– production is up to meet demand and there are profit incentives that causes increase reliance.

Slav, 4/20 [Irina Slav; Apr 20, 2023; Why U.S. Gas Production Is Growing So Fast; ; //TMS—GK]

U.S. natural gas production is booming. The country is pumping so much of the commodity that prices have dropped to multi-year lows after last year, soaring to over $7 per mmBtu amid the European energy crunch. Now, U.S. benchmark gas is trading around $2 per mmBtu and likely to remain at this level for the observable future. Because of associated gas. Just four shale basins in the United States are currently producing some 36 billion cubic feet of associated gas daily. Those are the Permian, the Eagle Ford, the Niobrara, and the Bakken. And the reason they are producing so much is that oil production is also on the rise. Because of higher prices. "About a third of U.S. gas production is associated gas - produced from oil wells," Jacques Rousseau, a managing director at research firm ClearView Energy Partners, told Reuters earlier this month. "This production is unlikely to decline given current oil prices." Indeed, the Energy Information Administration recently forecast that associated gas production in the country will continue rising until the middle of the century. The EIA also estimated associated gas would account for a fifth of all U.S. natural gas production between 2023 and 2050. Now, this is great news for natural gas importers as various regulators within the U.S. itself clamp down on natural gas use, effectively stifling demand, or at least trying to. But even before these regulators set their sights on natural gas, domestic demand was flattish and unlikely to grow by any substantial amounts unless energy transition plans fail spectacularly. This means that gas prices in the U.S. won't be going anywhere higher anytime soon. Until they do, as demand for LNG from overseas ramps up. Unlike the domestic market, international demand for natural gas remains strong and likely to become even stronger as the transition push favors gas over coal for power generation—a big target for decarbonization efforts. As the biggest natural gas producer in the world, the United States is perfectly placed to take advantage of the opportunity this gas-favoring offers, as long as it can tackle its capacity-building problems. Last year, all reports about U.S. LNG and its future were upbeat. The U.S. was going to overtake Qatar as the world's largest exporter. The U.S. was adding new LNG capacity at breakneck speed. Until it hit a speed bump. Rising costs and intensifying competition are making life difficult for LNG developers and many projects currently in the pipeline may never see the light of day. This is what the Financial Times reported this month, citing industry executives as saying it had become more difficult to secure the long-term offtake commitments necessary for any LNG project. There are already several LNG export projects under construction or close to commissioning that will boost U.S. export capacity by 70 percent by 2027, and that's quite an increase. It will make the U.S. the largest LNG exporter in the world as soon as this year. Yet many other projects are getting delayed and may get canceled eventually because it's getting harder to secure funding for such massive facilities in countries whose governments are betting everything on the transition away from fossil fuels, including gas, despite its favorable place. Even without these projects, assuming all the ones under construction get finalized, the United States can claim the crown of the world's biggest LNG exporter and keep it for quite a while, thanks to that cheap associated gas. It is going to continue flowing because, with OPEC+ determined to keep control over global oil prices through supply constraints, prices are likely to remain at levels that make production growth attractive to U.S. drillers.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Cap K Links › L- GND

Attempts to create a greener capitalism not only fail to stop climate change, but continue capitalist imperialism

Escalante 19

Alyson, Marxist-Leninist, Materialist Feminist and Anti-Imperialist activist. “Communism and Climate Change: A Dual Power Approach.” Regeneration. 3/26/19. LS

One of the most pressing of the various crises which humanity faces today is climate change. Capitalist production has devastated the planet, and everyday we discover that the small window of time for avoiding its most disastrous effects is shorter than previously understood. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change predicts that we have twelve years to limit (not even prevent) the more catastrophic effects of climate change. The simple, and horrific, fact that we all must face is that climate change has reached a point where many of its effects are inevitable, and we are now in a post-brink world, where damage control is the primary concern. The question is not whether we can escape a future of climate change, but whether we can survive it. Socialist strategy must adapt accordingly. In the face of this crisis, the democratic socialists and social democrats in the United States have largely settled on market-based reforms. The Green New Deal, championed by Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the left-wing of the Democratic Party, remains a thoroughly capitalist solution to a capitalist problem. The proposal does nothing to challenge capitalism itself but rather seeks to subsidize market solutions to reorient the US energy infrastructure towards renewable energy production, to develop less energy consuming transportation, and the development of public investment towards these ends. The plan does nothing to call into question the profit incentives and endless resource consumption of capitalism which led us to this point. Rather, it seeks to reorient the relentless market forces of capitalism towards slightly less destructive technological developments. While the plan would lead to a massive investment in the manufacturing and deployment of solar energy infrastructure, National Geographic reports that “Fabricating [solar] panels requires caustic chemicals such as sodium hydroxide and hydrofluoric acid, and the process uses water as well as electricity, the production of which emits greenhouse gases.” Technology alone cannot sufficiently combat this crisis, as the production of such technology through capitalist manufacturing infrastructure only perpetuates environmental harm. Furthermore, subsidizing and incentivizing renewable energy stops far short of actually combating the fossil fuel industry driving the current climate crisis. The technocratic market solutions offered in the Green New Deal fail to adequately combat the driving factors of climate change. What is worse, they rely on a violent imperialist global system in order to produce their technological solutions. The development of high-tech energy infrastructure and the development of low or zero emission transportation requires the import of raw material and rare earth minerals which the US can only access because of the imperial division of the Global South. This imperial division of the world requires constant militarism from the imperial core nations, and as Lenin demonstrates in Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism, facilitates constant warfare as imperial states compete for spheres of influence in order to facilitate cheap resource extraction. The US military, one of many imperialist forces, is the single largest user of petroleum, and one of its main functions is to ensure oil access for the US. Without challenging this imperialist division of the world and the role of the US military in upholding it, the Green New Deal fails even further to challenge the underlying causes of climate change.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Cap K Links › L- GND

Control link—the aff’s attempt to make capitalism greener is just a new form of social control to continue looting the working class and the Global South

Ajl 21

Max, associated researcher with the Tunisian Observatory for Food Sovereignty and the Environment and a postdoctoral fellow with the Rural Sociology Group at Wageningen University. “1 Great Transition – or Fortress Eco-Nationalism?” A People’s Green New Deal. Pp 21-23. LS

Concern about the climate crisis has become overwhelming in the Global North. It is no longer the isolated worry of climate scientists, forward-thinking investors, coastal real estate proprietors, or “environmental” activists. From financiers at Davos to McKinsey Consulting, it is everywhere, as the business press and mainstream media emit blizzards of policy papers, communiques, and financial forecasts.1 Why? In part, climate change is now unmissable. Eighteen-degree Celsius days in January in New England. Catastrophic floods and hellish heatwaves across the US Great Plains and Paris. Climate change is no longer in the future tense. It is today. The media is forced to pay attention as people understand more clearly what is happening and why it is happening. Yet most media outlets are owned by big corporations that are part of the capitalist system responsible for climate change.2 So the speed and simultaneity with which the ruling class has changed its tune, from decades of denialism to widely touted tabulations like that of the World Economic Forum “that $44 trillion of economic value generation…is moderately or highly dependent on nature and its services and is… exposed to nature loss,” ought to make anyone curious.3 For climate change does not dictate any specific political response. This chapter considers the rising chorus for “emergency change” from those with their hands on the pulleys and levers of the machine, in order to understand how top-down plans seek to maintain exclusion and exploitation in the world-system. Not the 1 percent but more like the .01 percent, who have seen incomes and net worth scrape the sky during the neoliberal age. They wish to preserve an imperial way of life and the planetary resource base upon which to live it. Their hands, pens, and plans are not idle. Amidst rising awareness of the capitalism–climate nexus, it is only natural that the ruling class would seek to avert a climate crisis which could imperil their power, to displace blame from fossil capitalism to a faceless and structureless humanity, and to make the poor pay the costs of transition. There is not a whit of concern here for the well-being of the working class, or more than a few grains of worry for non-human life. If that were the case, they would have taken action on climate change 30 years ago. Rather, a constellation of forward-looking right-wing and liberal forces plan for what the global sociologist Philip McMichael calls “managing the future.”4 These range from the Australian Breakthrough Institute – a doppelganger of the Ted Nordhaus think-tank with the same name based in California – the Energy Transitions Commission, and on to figures often associated with the progressive left. Such proposals share a number of leitmotifs: corporate– community and corporate–state/business–state partnerships, warmth to the national security sector, a Promethean enthusiasm for “new tech,” recasting models to integrate variables like climactic risk and enfolding them into investment horizons, and a greened US military. A large number are converging on what the economist Daniela Gabor calls the Wall Street Consensus, reorganizing “development interventions around selling development finance to the market…escort[ing] capital” into bonds, and melting and reforging Third World governments as the “de-risking state,” relegating risks onto states and their treasuries and budgets as sovereign representatives of the people and removing those risks from the mountains of capital which such plans seek to mobilize.5 GREEN SOCIAL CONTROL Green Social Control aims to preserve the essence of capitalism while shifting to a greener model in order to sidestep the worst consequences of the climate crisis. Because there is no capitalism that exists apart from the violent hand of the state, such plans emphasize the national security sector. Drawing borders around the people, denizens, or citizens of the nation means exclusion.6 Structural exclusion, from popular development. Ideological exclusion, from concern or care. Physical exclusion, through hardened steel, concrete, razor-wire and motion-sensor kitted-out borders and militarized maritime zones. And temporal exclusion, in the erasure of a past of colonial looting and atmospheric enclosure. Such plans are engineered by the best and the brightest, and we have to take them at their precise word. What they say or do not say about the Third World is what they mean. And because the US is an empire, sitting astride tremendous flows of energy and capital, silences speak. A decision to avoid reparations is a blueprint for world management in which imperial loot remains in the North. Part of the right’s Great Transition is to match up existing assets such as working-class pensions, or the public resources of the people in the form of the state budget, with new tech to harness and commodify the sun and the wind through solar power and wind energy. Greening the US military is central. Putting prices on “eco-system” services, including a potentially serf-like labor-intensive CO2 drawdown program, is a third pillar of their programs. And because the framework of threat is paramount in securing the consent of the core citizenry to their programs, the alarm bell of emergency blares daily (in this case accurately) to frighten people into accepting any plausible program to preserve a livable Earth.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Cap K Links › L- GND

The green new deal is a stopgap to keep capitalism on life support- it will rely on private investments and labor relationships that expand the power of capital

John McCollum|Dec 11, 2019

Assistant professor of Sociology, Minot State University; Limits of the Green New Deal; Marxist Sociology Blog; https://marxistsociology.org/2019/12/limits-of-the-green-new-deal/

The GND is consciously modeled on the New Deal of the 1930s. The New Deal saw an expansion of social programs benefiting wide swathes of the working class. Social Security was lifted wholesale from socialist programs. Farm aid encouraged both recovery from environmental problems like the Dust Bowl and debt relief for poor farmers. Infrastructural development raised wages and boosted further growth. In terms of arts and culture, working people were mobilized into new forms of cultural production celebrating working-class identity. The general agitation during this period by the broad left pushed these programs forward despite the opposition of powerful factions of the capitalist class in the United States. Despite this legacy, the New Deal preserved capitalism during one of its most dire crises to date; the GND may perform a similar regulatory function. One of the boosts the GND is likely to give to capital is through state investment through private partnerships. The GND does not propose the creation of state ownership of utilities, much less agriculture, housing, or medical care. Similarly, the bill has provisions for energy upgrades through refurbishing existing buildings, environmental cleanup, and an unusual provision to “ensure businesspersons are free from unfair competition.” Without further establishing state ownership over these sectors, many of these provisions are going to add value to existing private property or rely on contractors to do the work, paid for by large sums of public money. Although the GND provides decent employment and these emission reduction programs are desperately needed, much of this activity will generate further wealth in private hands if not performed by the state. The present electoral left may not be capable of enacting or want to deliver on this revolutionary goal. The Green New Deal could end up following a similar course of initial interest, growth, and collapse. However, a “Green” New Deal has other social and environmental goals which need to be considered. As environmental degradation continues, compromise measures that do not lead to drastic cuts in greenhouse gases, mining and processing of non-renewable energy sources, and losses of biodiversity will not suffice. However, such activities might provide some degree of environmental stability that will enable capital to continue its dominance.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Cap K Links › L- GND

GND expands the socioeconomics of capitalism- it expands environmental rifts, maintains an economy focused on production, and leaves workers as wage-dependent

John McCollum|Dec 11, 2019

Assistant professor of Sociology, Minot State University; Limits of the Green New Deal; Marxist Sociology Blog; https://marxistsociology.org/2019/12/limits-of-the-green-new-deal/

Despite this good news, there are some reasons for hesitation. There are some issues surrounding the Green New Deal that the left needs to broadly consider coming out of the eco-Marxist left, especially the scholarship and writing of John Bellamy Foster and the “treadmill of production” theorists, including Allan Schnaiberg, David Pellow, and Kenneth Gould. Second, we must consider the likelihood of the state becoming the main engine of this movement, rather than private capital, replacing our prevailing system of production with a “state-sponsored” green capitalism. I consider the GND’s limits in the most optimistic and open spirit, and I hope that this piece will help to write a more effective program. The political opportunities opened by such a plan are something to celebrate, but if the GND ultimately worsens the climate crisis, the Deal will hardly have been worth the political capital spent in passing it into law. For this reason, I hope leftists of all orientations will take a moment to consider these critiques. The dangers of expanded production and consumption One of the most prominent theories in environmental sociology is the “treadmill of production” theory pioneered by Allan Schnaiberg in his 1980 The Environment: From Surplus to Scarcity, and expanded upon with his frequent collaborators Kenneth Gould and David Pellow. This theory holds that demands by both capital and labor to expand economic production create new and greater forms of waste. Similarly, this pressure promotes more efficient use of resources. However, this efficiency incentivizes further net consumption. This “Jevon’s Paradox” was first demonstrated in 1865 by William Stanley Jevons in Britain’s improvements in steam engines resulting in faster consumption of the country’s coal supplies. A similar phenomenon prevails with small cars in the US today. Take, for instance, the gain in “miles per gallon” efficiencies in personal automobiles. Although the fuel efficiencies of most vehicles have risen dramatically since the 1970s, the addition of millions more automobiles and the increased distances Americans commute mean that Americans are consuming more gasoline than ever before. The treadmill of production idea becomes relevant in the context of the GND because of the gains in energy production efficiency, as well as the program’s proposed investments in the expansion of public transportation and “clean” manufacturing methods. The efficiency gains of a nation-wide energy efficiency program can be undone by a total increase in material inputs. Examining renewables in greater detail, wind turbines and solar panels produce a host of environmental externalities. Both technologies rely on the availability of rare earth metals. Their manufacturing and disposal generate other forms of toxic pollutants. Also, converting land from either “natural” usage to land for renewables will also have a variety of environmental externalities, exemplified by solar farms in California’s deserts, which have displaced native species like the desert tortoise. Another issue resulting from this practice will be a widening of the “metabolic rift” between global regions and between the natural metabolism of the earth and humanity’s production and consumption of natural resources. John Bellamy Foster’s work on the “metabolic rift” derives from Marx’s Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844 and Marx’s attendant interest in the widening gap between “town and country.” Marx studied the developments in agricultural science and soil chemistry during his era and noted the tendency of capitalism’s material demands to outstrip nature’s restorative capacities. As the natural fertility of soil declined, agricultural producers came to rely on distant sources of nitrogen-based fertilizers. This shift led to a “metabolic rift” in the spatial distribution of soil nutrients and a temporal rupture in the earth’s natural cycles of soil fertility. The GND threatens to reproduce this gap. To use a single example, though the US has some deposits, the rare earth metals used in solar panels and wind turbines will come from Global South states where mining and processing these minerals poses great risks to human health and the environment. The benefits of using these materials in renewable technologies will not be seen by the citizens of those countries where extraction occurs. The GND’s agricultural methods hold some promise of making major gains in de-carbonizing the US’s agricultural system, but the movement of soil fertility around the US as agricultural goods made in one region move to another still would widen the spatial and temporal elements of the metabolic rift. At present, it does not appear that the GND is dealing with the contradictions of the treadmill of production and a widening metabolic rift. The “treadmill of production” poses yet another problem though: the contradiction of continually expanding production to meet the systemic demands of capital to accumulate and workers’ attendant dependence on this cycle for wages. Production of “green” things may need to expand continually to generate employment and welfare benefits for workers. Workers in a new state sector could find themselves dependent on this expansion, just as they would have under private capital. Although “green”, this expanded production will recreate the environmental problems the GND is meant to end. Getting off this treadmill is going to require more than just vigorous investment by the state in green infrastructure. Next, I turn to the GND’s potential to create a state-sponsored green capitalism.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Infrastructure Bank CP › S – Green Jobs

The bank is the only viable way to green our infrastructure.

Sadek Wahba ’21 – senior fellow at the Development Research Institute of New York University.

“The US needs an infrastructure bank that models the World Bank,” 08/04/21, https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/566307-the-us-needs-an-infrastructure-bank-that-models-the-world-bank/

The infrastructure bill that reached the Senate floor on July 28 was missing a key provision — an infrastructure bank. But that omission may turn out to be a good thing — if it opens the way to the creation of an infrastructure bank in the form we actually need. The Infrastructure Financing Authority (IFA) that was included in the Bipartisan Infrastructure Framework but was removed from the final proposal, was close to being that — but unfortunately, no cigar. It was the right idea but the wrong execution. The IFA was certainly a welcome concept and had the support of both Democrats and Republicans. Ironically, its removal was more the result of political maneuvering than a decision on the merits — Democrats reportedly traded it for a wage provision they wanted to protect. This should not be the end of the story. An infrastructure bank should be reintroduced in an amendment as the final bill takes shape, but not as originally proposed. Instead, Congress should seize the opportunity to create an institution independent of government, separate from the appropriations cycle, and capable of bringing large-scale, permanent, long-term funding to bear. That is the way to jumpstart our infrastructure and launch a new era of American productivity. The Infrastructure Financing Authority could not have achieved these goals. As proposed, the IFA would have been a limited, government-dominated institution, with Congress directly controlling board membership, management structure and compensation. It would have had limited ability to raise and distribute funds — restricted to investment-grade projects, which the capital markets already fund — and would have had no permanent capital base. Instead, it would have been entirely dependent on congressional appropriations — a politically uncertain funding stream with a short-term perspective, mismatched to the long-term nature of infrastructure projects. In other words, the IFA would have been a structure- and scope-limited extension of the federal government — not a fully capable financial institution, not a center of innovation and not a magnet for diverse private-sector expertise and experience. Can we do better? We can and we must. To scrap the bank would be a terrible mistake. To build it the right way is critical for the long-term success of any infrastructure plan. Here is why a better solution is needed. Our infrastructure is in crisis because of chronic underinvestment. For decades, the U.S. has invested less than 2 percent of GDP in infrastructure — compared to China’s 8 percent. Republicans and Democrats want the U.S. to compete with China. The way to start is by investing in our domestic infrastructure for the long term, not just for the coming few years, however large the current bill may be. The funding shortfall is significant not just in contrast to China but on its own terms as well. The leading independent expert group — the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) — estimates that we are currently investing $2.59 trillion less than the amount needed just to bring our existing core infrastructure into an adequate state of repair – that is, without starting any new projects. And if we are serious about climate change, we will need to invest to make our infrastructure greener. That will add significantly to the cost. The way to close the funding gap is to bring private-sector investment to bear. That should be the infrastructure bank’s mission. And the mission should determine its structure.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off Case Args › Infrastructure Bank CP › S – Green Jobs

Green investment banks retool infrastructure to solve climate change. They make better decisions that government-run programs.

OECD ’15 (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, “Green Investment Banks,” Policy Perspectives, December 2015, )

This Policy Perspectives describes the relatively new phenomenon of publicly-capitalised green investment banks and examines why they are being created and how they are mobilising private investment. It draws on the forthcoming OECD report Green Investment Banks: Scaling up Private Investment in Low-carbon, Climate -resilient Infrastructure.

KEY MESSAGES