2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Growth Advantage
Mike Lee 22. Ranking Member, Joint Economic Committee Republicans, R-UT, JD and former United States attorney for the District of Utah, December 2022. “Entrepreneurship and the Decline of American Growth.” https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/aecd69fe-28e3-4fb7-9119-6ff15be1fa07/entrepreneurship.pdf
Economic growth has served as a powerful force for improving living standards throughout America’s history. However, in the last half- century, economic progress has slowed, holding back economic output. Had growth rates continued at their pre-1974 level of almost 4 percent, the economy would have been approximately 50 percent larger in 2022.
Slower growth undermines the prosperity of current and future generations. The benefits of past economic growth show up across various dimensions of well-being. Americans at all income levels have access to a greater quality and quantity of food than ever before, have more leisure time, and work fewer hours for higher incomes than at any other point in history.1 They live in higher quality homes with modern appliances and less overcrowding. Advances in medical technology have helped increase the average life expectancy from 47 years in 1900 to 77 years in 2020.2 Slower growth also undermines Americans’ ability to surmount future fiscal, environmental, and social challenges.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Growth Advantage
Dr. Lucien von Schomberg 22, PhD, Lecturer in Creativity and Innovation at the University of Greenwich Business School, “RAISING THE SAIL OF INNOVATION: Philosophical Explorations on Responsible Innovation”, ebook
I then realized two things. First, the concept of innovation defines our age. It fuels the global economy, promises a sustainable future, and stands at the heart of our interconnected society. Not only was the underground surrounded with all kinds of innovations, but we have even reached a point in history where people are reading about innovation and – as the commuter would later confess – dream of becoming innovators themselves, for public icons like Steve Jobs and Elon Musk are praised in the same way artists and scientists were in previous times. Second, the concept of innovation is widely presupposed in terms of the commercial value it generates. In this view, innovation is only considered valuable insofar customers are willing to pay for it. As claimed in the tradition of economic analysis, innovation is characterized by its competitive dynamics and is primarily directed at developing marketable products and services (Stoneman 1995).
At the same time, our geopolitical landscape faces an unprecedented crisis, overwhelmed with global issues such as climate change, overpopulation, water shortage, a loss of biodiversity, food security, and the more recent COVID-19 pandemic. The reality of these issues increasingly urge innovation to generate societal value beyond mainstream economic incentive. This is particularly the case in the context of the European Union (EU), which strives to represent high ethical standards on the world stage and thus prioritizes normative objectives on its political agenda. To this end, the EU policy discourse has paved the way for Responsible Innovation (RI). The core idea here is to steer innovation processes towards societally desirable outcomes, specifically in response to the so-called grand challenges of our time (European Commission 2015). A frequently cited and particularly influential definition of RI calls for “a transparent, interactive process by which societal actors and innovators become mutually responsive to each other with a view on the (ethical) acceptability, sustainability and societally desirability of the innovation process and its marketable products” (von Schomberg 2013, p. 63). Under the sway of science with and for society, the hypothesis is that innovation can only respond to the needs and ambitions of society by including all its actors throughout the process. As such, in 2011, RI made its entry by the name of Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) as a cross-cutting issue under the EU Framework Program for Research and Innovation ‘Horizon 2020’. More recently, RRI has been articulated in terms of six keys – ethics, societal engagement, gender equality, open science, science education, governance – through which the EU imposes a strong normative view of what constitutes responsibility in innovation processes (European Commission 2020).
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Daniel Baisier 22. Associate at the Boston Consulting Group and graduate of Vanderbilt University. "The War on Normal People: The Truth About America's Disappearing Jobs and Why Universal Basic Income Is Our Future." AmeriQuests 17, no. 1 (2022).
Large-scale economic upheavals often lead to redefinitions of the relationship between the American government and the people. The fallout from the Industrial Revolution—epitomized by tragic events such as the 1894 Pullman Strike and the 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire—bred the widespread public expectation that the government would act on behalf of workers to regulate companies’ behavior. Monopolies and child labor were outlawed, and unions went from organizations whose members were occasionally murdered by federal troops to legally protected institutions at the heart of the American economy. As President Theodore Roosevelt described it, the government became the guarantor of a “Square Deal” for American workers. Decades later, during the Great Depression, Roosevelt’s cousin Franklin D. Roosevelt’s “New Deal” normalized federal jobs programs and social security as a means of stimulating the economy and providing economic security for older citizens. Andrew Yang argues that America is experiencing another Industrial Revolution- or Great Depression-level event dubbed "the Great Displacement,” which merits a similar, fundamental reimagining of the relationship between the federal government and the American people. He warns of the need for a paradigm shift, and he offers solutions for how we can prevent catastrophe before it’s too late.
In “Part One: What's Happening to Jobs,” Yang tells the economic history of the United States over the last few decades. He identifies improving technology, financialization, changing corporate norms, and globalization as the main culprits driving both increasing wealth inequality and what he calls “the Great Displacement” of millions of American workers who have departed the workforce. He then proceeds to define “normal” Americans as those who find themselves at the median on all metrics: an American with less than an associate’s degree making about $17 per hour (in 2017) and living in the suburbs. He then argues that advances in artificial intelligence and automation will displace millions more blue- and white-collar workers alike in the coming years. Despite all this displacement, he maintains that automation is an inevitable, net benefit to society that will result in better, cheaper goods and services. However, he argues that these changes will require us to think more deeply about what makes human beings inherently valuable. Finally, he responds to the usual objections to his level of concern about automation. Chiefly, he denies the common belief that—in light of similarly disruptive technological shifts through history—his level of concern about automation is an overreaction. Yang counters that “[t]he speed, breadth, impact, and nature of these changes are considerably more dramatic than anything that has come before” (70).
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Jonathan Perry 21. Global Dialogue for Social Development Branch, Division for Inclusive Social Development, UN DESA, 7-20-21. “Trust in public institutions: Trends and implications for economic security.” https://www.un.org/development/desa/dspd/2021/07/trust-public-institutions/
Trust is integral to the functioning of any society. Trust in each other, in our public institutions and in our leaders are all essential ingredients for social and economic progress, allowing people to cooperate with and express solidarity for one another. It allows public bodies to plan and execute policies and deliver services. Greater public trust has been found to improve compliance in regulations and tax collections, even respect for property rights. It also gives confidence to consumers and investors, crucial to creating jobs and the functioning of economies more broadly. Success in achieving each of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)—from eliminating poverty (SDG1), to combatting climate change (SDG13), to building peaceful and inclusive societies (SDG16)—will depend on citizens’ and businesses’ trust in public institutions and in each other.
Governments have also drawn on public trust to effectively address every stage of the COVID-19 pandemic response—from containment, to mitigation, to vaccinations. Early evidence has found that higher levels of confidence in national public institutions is associated with lower national COVID-19 mortality rates. This is consistent with evidence from previous health crises—including SARS, H1N1 and Ebola—where high public trust was found to be a crucial determinant for successful responses. Governments will need to count on, or in cases where government responses were largely found to be ineffective, to regain public trust as they plan and implement an inclusive recovery.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Francis M. Lappé 22, the Andrew W. Mellon Distinguished Fellow in Environmental Studies at Colby College in Maine, Associate Fellow at the Tellus Institute, recipient of 20 honorary doctorates from distinguished institutions, founder of the Small Planet Institute, and member of the World Future Council, “Democracy's Peril and Promise: Let the Ukraine Crisis Awaken Action”, https://www.smallplanet.org/single-post/democracy-s-peril-and-promise-let-the-ukraine-crisis-awaken-action
The attack on Ukraine focuses the mind on a most critical question for humanity: In our fast-changing world, what is democracy's future?
Certainly, a strong argument can be made that democratic governance is more important than ever as humanity faces at least two unprecedented challenges: the existential threats of the global climate crisis and a global pandemic. Attacks on civil and human rights continue as well—challenges that can only be met with democratic governance.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Max Stier 22. President and CEO of the Partnership for Public Service, a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization that strives for a more effective government for the American people, has worked in all three branches of the federal government, with Tom Freedman, 3-1-22. “Opinion | Why Democracy’s in Such Trouble: A Crisis in Public Trust of Government.” https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/03/01/democracy-public-crisis-trust-government-faith-00012565.
Amid all the reasons to worry about the health of American democracy, perhaps the most striking is a new poll that captures the astoundingly low level of public trust in the federal government.
The national poll, conducted on behalf of our two organizations by Impact Research, shows that only four in 10 Americans at least somewhat trust the federal government to do what is right. For all the concern about the rise of anti-democratic movements or unfair laws that could be used to steal an election, that disheartening statistic strikes at the heart of our nation’s primary democratic institution and its ability to deal with social, economic and foreign policy challenges. If you don’t trust your government, does it really matter what policies it pursues?
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Daniel Geitz 21. Freelance Health Writer and Registered Nurse, 7-13-2021. "The Government Needs to Rebuild Trust. Is UBI The Answer?," https://aninjusticemag.com/the-government-needs-to-rebuild-trust-is-ubi-the-answer-bb055edc0bfa.
Lack of trust in government needs to be addressed before almost any other issue in the United States.
In one of my recent posts, I discussed the lack of trust in our biggest institutions as one of the most significant factors affecting COVID vaccination rates. I’ve been thinking more about that lack of trust recently — specifically the lack of trust in government.
2023
ENDI
Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › 1AC---Automation Advantage
Aaron James 20. PhD from Harvard and is professor and chair of philosophy at the University of California, Irvine, September 2020. “Planning for Mass Unemployment: Precautionary Basic Income,” Ethics of Artificial Intelligence,
Rapid automation leads to unemployment on a mass scale—not as a temporary shock, but as a new normal. Such was once the stuff of dystopian fiction. Now it could be our future, especially given amazing recent advances in machine learning and robotics. Not this year or this decade, necessarily. But down the road. After all, it’s only dawn in the new machine age.
Keynes warned in 1930 of a “new disease” that he called “technological unemployment,” by which he meant “unemployment due to our discovery of means of economizing the use of labor outrunning the pace at which we can find new uses for labor.” Alas, his fears didn’t materialize in much of the twentieth century. But by the close of the millennium there were signs that it’s no iron law of economics that jobs destroyed will invariably bring new opportunities for human work. As Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAffee explain, citing trends in computing capacity, digitization, and the power in recombining older technologies, “Employment grew alongside productivity up until the end of the twentieth century. [But then] job growth decoupled from productivity in the late 1990s.” Even as productivity rose, employment fell off. The long trend didn’t hold. And so, in due course at least, artificial intelligence (AI) really might cause lasting structural unemployment on a mass scale.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Solvency › ---XT---UBI Fails---2NC/1NR
Alexandra K. Przegalinska 21. Associate Professor, Kozminski University, 8-1-2021. "AI: UBI Income Portfolio Adjustment to Technological Transformation," https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fhumd.2021.725516/full.
In addition, UBI will not ensure the end of poverty because nothing will prevent net recipients from consuming more instead of saving for future exigencies (Goolsbee, 2018). Moreover, if net recipients can borrow against future UBI payments, some may consume their future UBI payments today, rendering them in need of aid in the future (Fleischer and Hemel, 2020). If not allowed to borrow, however, net UBI recipients will find it more difficult to invest using leverage or to begin their own businesses. If employment has decreased or disappeared, subsistence will be the only practical income option available if UBI payments are insufficient to meet their life goals. Society therefore may remain filled with people who are non-poor in absolute terms but still at the bottom of the income distribution and hence unsatisfied with their lives and structurally prevented from improving their lot, or their income ranking (Boyce et al., 2010).
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Solvency › Solvency---1NC
Anna Coote 19. Principal Fellow at the New Economics Foundation, and Edanur Yazici, April 2019. “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A UNION PERSPECTIVE.” http://www.world-psi.org/sites/default/files/documents/research/en_ubi_full_report_2019.pdf
Some of the most trenchant criticisms of UBI focus on its costs and afforda- bility. The higher the level of payment, the greater the amount of additional funds needed to pay for it – and vice versa. This is neatly summed up by Martinelli who concludes from his own microsimulations (see above): “an af- fordable UBI is inadequate and an adequate UBI is unaffordable”.
There are inevitably winners and losers and the effects are not necessarily progressive. If means-tested benefits are abolished to help pay for UBI, then some of the most vulnerable people on low incomes are bound to suffer. If income taxes are raised across the board, workers on low pay are likely to lose out. In one scheme modelled by Martinelli, both child and working age poverty fell by around 14-15% and the Gini coefficient by 5.5%, yet there were still “unacceptably high proportions of households losing out amongst lower income deciles”27.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Solvency › Solvency---1NC
Melissa S. Kearney 19. Neil Moskowitz Professor of Economics at the University of Maryland, College Park and a research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research, with Magne Mogstad, 8-23-19. “Universal Basic Income (UBI) as a Policy Response to Current Challenges.” https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/UBI-ESG-Memo-082319.pdf
We view a UBI to be a sub-optimal, and possibly harmful, policy response to all three of these challenges. A UBI in its most basic form would be massively expensive yet do little to reduce inequality or advance opportunity. Devoting that level of spending to targeted benefits, focusing on the poorest and those hardest hit by ongoing economic forces, and polices dedicated to human capital development instead of mere redistribution would produce a much greater social return than a UBI.
First, on inequality and redistribution, a UBI is by design not ideal for redistributive purposes. For example, a UBI that paid $10,000 to every U.S. adult would cost about $2.5 trillion per year, well more than half the current federal annual budget. Furthermore, by giving money to everyone, there would be far fewer resources available to redistribute money and/or invest in the human capital of those with the most need. In calculations presented below, we show the practical trade-off between giving more money to a more targeted group of low-income individuals and less money to a more diffuse group including less needy individuals. We cite work by Hoynes and Rothstein (2019) documenting the loss of progressivity that would come from replacing our current system of transfer programs with a UBI. We further argue that programs that are universal do not accomplish as much in terms of generating social benefits as those that are targeted, citing evidence from examples such as child care and early childhood education programs.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Solvency › Solvency---1NC
Anna Coote 19. Principal fellow at the New Economics Foundation and co-author of Universal Basic Income: A Union Perspective, 5-6-2019. "Universal basic income doesn’t work. Let’s boost the public realm instead," https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/may/06/universal-basic-income-public-realm-poverty-inequality.
A study published this week sheds doubt on ambitious claims made for universal basic income (UBI), the scheme that would give everyone regular, unconditional cash payments that are enough to live on. Its advocates claim it would help to reduce poverty, narrow inequalities and tackle the effects of automation on jobs and income. Research conducted for Public Services International, a global trade union federation, reviewed for the first time 16 practical projects that have tested different ways of distributing regular cash payments to individuals across a range of poor, middle-income and rich countries, as well as copious literature on the topic.
It could find no evidence to suggest that such a scheme could be sustained for all individuals in any country in the short, medium or longer term – or that this approach could achieve lasting improvements in wellbeing or equality. The research confirms the importance of generous, non-stigmatising income support, but everything turns on how much money is paid, under what conditions and with what consequences for the welfare system as a whole.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---Economy Uniqueness---Growth Now
Lucia Mutikani 5-26-23. Correspondent at Thomson Reuters. "Strong US consumer spending, inflation readings put Fed in tough spot," https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/us-consumer-spending-beats-expectations-april-inflation-picks-up-2023-05-26/.
The reports added to labor market resilience, a rebound in factory production and a pickup in business activity in suggesting the economy was experiencing a spring revival after hitting a speed bump in the first quarter. They also increased the chances that the U.S. central bank would hike rates in June.
Minutes of the Fed's May 2-3 policy meeting, which were published on Wednesday, showed policymakers "generally agreed" the need for further rate hikes "had become less certain."
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---Economy Turn Link---Inflation---2NC/1NR
Stirling Larkin 19. Chief Investment Officer at Australian Standfirst Asset Management, Australian Financial Review, 7-2-2019. "Why universal basic income is a bad idea," https://www.afr.com/wealth/personal-finance/why-universal-basic-income-is-a-bad-idea-20190628-p522ea.
UBI is economically flawed for one rudimentary reason: if some in any given society receive additional cash or income from whatever source, then yes, assistance or advantage can be gained by some; but when all in a society receive ubiquitous universal income, then market forces naturally accommodate and the price of everything moves accordingly, dollar for dollar.
Economically this is known as “price elasticity” – a measure used in economics to show the responsiveness of demand for goods and services when nothing but the price changes.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---Economy Turn Link---Taxes---2NC/1NR
Ryan A. Hughes 23. Founder of Bull Oak Capital, an investment advisory firm, 1-27-2023. "Universal Basic Income is a Bad Idea," . Modified for ableist language.
UBI is expensive. Very expensive. As an add on, without simultaneously trimming government programs, it would require a significant tax increase.
Following the Finnish study results, Kari Hamalainen, chief researcher at the VATT Institute for Economic Research, said implementing a universal basic income for all citizens “would be expensive. If we had a universal basic income, we’d have to incorporate taxation”, and based on these results, “it would be unsustainable.”
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---XT---Turn---UBI Kills Labor/Incentives to Work---2NC/1NR
Eduardo Porter 16. Economics reporter for the business section of The New York Times, 5-31-2016. "A Universal Basic Income Is a Poor Tool to Fight Poverty (Published 2016)," https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/01/business/economy/universal-basic-income-poverty.html.
Work, as Lawrence Katz of Harvard once pointed out, is not just what people do for a living. It is a source of status. It organizes people’s lives. It offers an opportunity for progress. None of this can be replaced by a check.
A universal basic income has many undesirable features, starting with its non-negligible disincentive to work. Almost a quarter of American households make less than $25,000. It would be hardly surprising if a $10,000 check each for mom and dad sapped their desire to work.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---XT---Turn---UBI Kills Labor/Incentives to Work---2NC/1NR
John F. Cogan 21. Leonard and Shirley Ely Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution, with Daniel L. Heil, 1-14-21. “The Economic Impact of a Universal Basic Income.” https://www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/prosperityproject_cogan_heil.pdf
UBI supporters acknowledge this departure and counter that a UBI will improve work incentives and redistribute income to achieve a more equitable income distribution. Our economic analysis has cast serious doubt on these claims. While a UBI can improve work incentives among recipients of the transfer programs it replaces, a UBI worsens work incentives among UBI recipients who are not beneficiaries of these programs. In our analysis of a UBI that has no phase- down provision, aggregate labor supply increases slightly. But such a plan dramatically worsens the distribution of income by redistributing government transfer payments from lower- to higher-income households. In our analysis of UBI plans that have phase-down provisions, work incentives are reduced and, as a result, these plans would all significantly reduce aggregate US labor supply and, thereby, US economic output. These plans show little improvement in the distribution of income.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---XT---Turn---UBI Kills Labor/Incentives to Work---2NC/1NR
Milton Ezrati 21. Chief Economist of Vested, a financial communications agency, 4-15-2021. "A New Try With UBI: As Wrongheaded As Before," https://www.forbes.com/sites/miltonezrati/2021/04/15/a-new-try-with-ubi-as-wrongheaded-as-before/?sh=7905c8c84d53.
If these considerations were not sufficient reason to question the wisdom of a UBI scheme, the evidence from various trials is not especially encouraging. A Bureau of Labor Statistics study of people on unemployment discovered, for instance, that they spent more time in front of the television and sleeping than upgrading their working skills, as some UBI proponents say it would do. A similar study on disability recipients revealed similar patterns. Statistics from earlier federal pilot programs on negative income tax, a variant of UBI, are equally discouraging. Between 1968 and 1980, Washington made four controlled trials of negative income tax, involving thousands of people across six states. Hours of work desired by all recipients fell some 9% below to those not in the program. They fell some 20% for married women and 25% among single women heads of household. Desired work among single men fell some 43% below non-recipients. If those receiving the negative income tax lost their job, the spell of unemployment lasted two months longer on average than with non-recipients and 12 months longer for married women.
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---XT---UBI Not Solve Innovation/Entrepreneurship---2NC/1NR
Dominic Chalmers et al., 20. Senior lecturer in entrepreneurship at the University of Glasgow's Adam Smith Business School, with Niall G. MacKenzie, and Sara Carter. “Artificial Intelligence and Entrepreneurship: Implications for Venture Creation in the Fourth Industrial Revolution.” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 2021, Vol. 45(5) 1028–1053. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/1042258720934581
The widespread introduction of UBI1 or another form of fiscal transfer to offset automation- based job losses would create an immediate social safety net for people without jobs to start new ventures (D’Mello, 2019; Levine, 2019) and would therefore reshape antecedents of venture creation relating to risk-taking and creativity (D’Mello, 2019; Eberhart et al., 2017). More utopian-leaning forecasts also suggest the economic restructuring brought about by AI could lead to a new breed of intrinsically driven entrepreneurs (Choi & Kang, 2019; D’Mello, 2019) who are not necessarily motivated by rapidly scaling ventures and then exiting.
This, however, is balanced against the possibility that AI-driven technology platforms become even more dominant to economic life (Shapiro, 2019), leading to entrepreneurial opportunities increasingly being mediated by private firms who control the parameters of trade and competi- tion (Zhu & Liu, 2018). This growing consolidation of “large tech” has already been linked to a long-term decline in business dynamism (Decker et al., 2016, 2017; Shapiro, 2019). Given that these same technology companies currently lead investment in developing AI technology, hold most patents (Hartmann & Henkel, in press) and are in a strong position to maintain their market position, there is potential for a prolonged period of stagnating entrepreneurial activity should antitrust legislation fail to improve allocative efficiency and productivity within the economy (Decker et al., 2017).
2023
ENDI
Negative
NEG › Answers to Growth Advantage › ---XT---UBI Not Solve Innovation/Entrepreneurship---2NC/1NR
Ryan A. Hughes 23. Founder of Bull Oak Capital, an investment advisory firm, 1-27-2023. "Universal Basic Income is a Bad Idea," .
The Finnish study is the most recent and thorough case study on the topic and, as such, should be relied upon as the go-to data.
Participants in this study received 560 euros ($600) per month from 2017 to 2018. Those included were part of a randomly selected group of 2,000 jobless people between the ages of 25 and 58. The funds they received included no strings attached.