2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency - Poverty
Jeffrey A. Miron, 11. Senior lecturer and director of undergraduate studies in the Department of Economics at Harvard University, and a senior fellow at the Cato Institute. “Rethinking Redistribution.” National Affairs, Winter 2011. https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/rethinking-redistribution
The ideal system of redistribution to benefit the poor in America, then, would involve mainly cash transfers. Possible exceptions might include vouchers for education and health insurance. Where possible, these exceptions should be managed at the state level; to the extent that the federal government is involved, it should supply funding to the states through block grants — which provide a set amount of money to the states, generally based on each state's population, and allow the states to make their own decisions about how to allocate the funds. This, in turn, allows more decisions about benefit allocation to be made by people closer to the ground — people who have a better understanding of the lives and needs of benefit recipients. It also gives the states more flexibility to experiment with different approaches. Indeed, the negative income-tax system as a whole might well work best at the state level — that is, if it replaced both federal and state redistribution efforts with 50 state-level negative income-tax systems. Advocates of redistribution fear that state-level negative income taxes would start a "race to the bottom," in which states slash benefits to avoid attracting poor populations. But in fact, numerous examples — including minimum-wage laws, TANF and Medicaid provision, and pre-1935 state-level Social Security programs — show that states can exhibit substantial altruism, so that state-level anti-poverty efforts would not be miserly. Concern over in-migration might nevertheless counter political pressures in favor of excessive expansion, yielding a better balance than a federal system could attain. And state experimentation would no doubt produce some innovations and improvements that a federal system would fail to discover. Of course, a transition from our current system to a negative income tax might be easier if it first involved a transition to one federal negative income tax. In an ideal world, however, such a system would eventually be turned over to the states.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency - Poverty
Economic Security Project, 22. The Economic Security Project (ESP) works to advance economic prosperity by providing research, supporting campaigns to get from pilot to policy, and working to change narratives about economic inequality and poverty. “States Lead the Way.” “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income.” April 13, 2022.
Economic Security Project, Shriver Center on Poverty Law. Report.
Economic Stability
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI “Sufficiency Framing”
Michael D. Tanner, 19. Former Senior Fellow, Cato Institute. “Universal Basic Income Might Fix Our Broken Welfare System — Give It the Serious, Scholarly Debate It Deserves.” CATO, March 23, 2019. https://www.cato.org/commentary/universal-basic-income-might-fix-our-broken-welfare-system-give-it-serious-scholarly
Federal, state and local governments spend roughly $1 trillion every year on anti‐poverty programs, yet cities like Newark are not thriving. Maybe it’s time to consider a different approach.
A UBI has several things to recommend it over traditional welfare.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI “Sufficiency Framing”
Brooks Rainwater, 18. Senior executive director of the Center for City Solutions and Applied Research at the National League of Cities. “Yes, Cities Can Pilot Universal Basic Income.” https://www.nlc.org/article/2018/11/09/yes-cities-can-pilot-universal-basic-income/
UBI could potentially satisfy those on the political left and right by providing a stronger social safety net and expanding individual liberty. The cash payment could be used by people to spend on anything from food and housing to seed money to start a business and anything else in between — the choice would be in the individuals’ hands. But ultimately, cities cannot do it on their own. A fully implemented national- or state-level UBI will need a large amount of support from all levels of government; in the meantime, cities are able to institute pilots to provide a track record of success and identify challenges to overcome.
Already, we have seen great success with the Alaska Permanent Fund, which while not a true UBI, shares similarities, including a universal payment from oil dividends for all permanent Alaska residents. This fund has proven incredibly popular and stories abound of people utilizing it to pay their bills, go to school or help someone in a pinch. But since this cash payment topped out at around $2,500 a year at its height, it is not meant to replace, but rather to supplement, people’s incomes.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - Federal UBI fails
Ryan Sears, 20. Writer at the Harvard Political Review. Graduated from Harvard with a double concentration in History & Literature and Government “COVID-19 Makes it Clear: We Need Universal Basic Income.” Harvard Political Review, March 7, 2020. https://harvardpolitics.com/covid-19-makes-it-clear-we-need-universal-basic-income/
Many economists also argue that a federal UBI program would be bureaucratically, fiscally and politically impossible to implement. As of the COVID-19 stimulus bill, that argument is void. We witnessed something revolutionary in the past two weeks: the graduation of a left-wing academic idea into the political mainstream. The fact that Rep. Alexandria Ocasio Cortez (D-NY), Senator Mitt Romney (R-UT), and President Donald Trump agreed upon a policy instrument is a terrifying sign of the times. It dishearteningly reveals that bipartisan agreement on fiscal policy can only be garnered during times of existential crisis. In a matter of days, the question of whether direct unconditional cash payments to individuals was sound policy quickly became “how much” and “to whom.” U.S. lawmakers agreed on a $2.2 trillion stimulus bill that would send a direct payment of up to $1,200 for an individual earning up to $75,000 a year with special provisions for married couples and families with children. Although this is an emergency stopgap program, no longer can anyone argue the technical impracticality of a universal basic income. Yes, an ongoing UBI would be massively expensive, but if Congress can conjure up trillion-dollar aid packages to bail out massive corporations, surely it can spend to protect American workers operating in an unpredictable labor economy.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - Federal UBI fails
Martha C. White, 18. Reporter & writer for NBC with 15+ years of experience as a freelancer. “Finland's experiment with giving away money shines a light on the idea of universal basic income.” NBC April 19, 2018. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/economy/finland-s-experiment-giving-away-money-shines-light-idea-universal-n869611
Other proposals have suggested raising the income tax on the wealthiest Americans, or funding a UBI system with taxes on a particular commercial activity like data collection or financial transactions — ideas that are appealing to liberals, but anathema to conservatives. “On the right, that’s a nonstarter. There’s no support for higher taxes,” Tanner said. Although this stalemate over funding could be an insurmountable impasse for policymakers seeking to implement a federal UBI, states and municipalities are putting their toes in the water with smaller-scale experiments. The San Francisco suburb of Stockton launched a pilot program this year to give $500 a month to some of its lowest-income residents, and a few Western states — California, Washington and Hawaii — have considered the idea. "It’s a broader question of what we value as a society. As a country, we’ve been prioritizing the interests of the wealthy few for many many years." Advocates are hopeful that these efforts could serve as prototypes for an eventual national model. “As we move forward, the scope of the problem will become so clear and so big, people across both sides of the aisle will recognize something has to change,” Foster said.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - Federal UBI fails
Miles Howard, 20. Contributor & freelance writer who covers culture, travel and transformational politics. “The Federal Check Won't Be Enough. Now's The Time For Mass. To Introduce A Universal Basic Income.” March 25, 2020. https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2020/03/25/universal-basic-income-congress-coronavirus-covid-19-miles-howard
Early Wednesday morning, Senate leaders and the White House finally reached an agreement on a coronavirus stimulus package that includes $1,200 payments to most American adults and $500 to most children. Still, senior leaders from both of America’s parties had found ways to screw up the UBI proposals that were before Congress. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and the GOP released a plan that would mail individuals the $1,200 check, but give lower-income households only $500. (Imagine thinking that any person in America can subsist on $500 to $1,200 for weeks — or more likely, months — of social distancing.) Better ideas had been put forth by Democrats like Rep. Maxine Waters, whose stimulus plan would have sent monthly checks of $2,000 to individuals, with additional money for dependents and a temporary suspension of most household bill payments. But House Speaker Nancy Pelosi threw cold water on Waters’ universal aid idea by insisting that any coronavirus aid package should be means-tested — which may sound sensible, except means testing makes it much harder for poor people to get the benefits they need right away. Watching this impasse from Massachusetts, one of the most expensive states to live in was infuriating. And it’s ironic that we should be at the mercy of the feds on UBI, because historically speaking, Massachusetts has been a leader on issues that have transformed life in America.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - Federal UBI fails
Brian Galle, 21. Professor of Law at Georgetown University. A.B., Harvard; J.D., Columbia; LL.M., Georgetown. "The American Rescue Plan and the Future of the Safety Net," Yale Law Journal Forum 131 (2021): 561-586.
Part II argues that the Checks were made necessary by our reliance on cooperative-federalism programs whose basic design makes them poorly suited to respond to recessions. While it was remarkable that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) was able to deliver checks to millions in a relatively short period of time' (all while its workforce was operating mostly remotely), it is neither desirable nor politically sustainable to expect the federal government to implement a wholly new federal poverty-relief program in every recession.
What we need instead are recession-proof safety-net policies. Step one is figuring out what recession proofing looks like. Proponents of a universal basic income (UBI) point to the Checks as an example of the promise of simple, lightly means-tested, ordeal-less programs. Still, we need to better develop the capacity to issue checks quickly and reliably. A robust federal-option payments system can deliver the Checks, bank the unbanked, and even offer recession-period government lending.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - Federal UBI fails
Michael Tanner, 15. Tanner is a senior fellow with the Cato Institute and the author of numerous books, including The Poverty of Welfare: Helping Others in Civil Society (2003). “The Pros and Cons of a Guaranteed National Income.” CATO Institute Policy Analysis, May 12, 2015. Number 773. https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa773.pdf
Another issue that would arise in any national level implementation of a UBI is how to address the regional variation in the cost of living. The benefit might be more than sufficient in low cost states like South Dakota, but it might not be enough in high cost states like California and New York. A recent study by the Tax Foundation looked at the purchasing power of $100 in each state, with the relative value ranging from $84.60 in Washington D.C. to $115.74 in Mississippi. Our current system addresses this disparity to some extent, although some of the variation may be due to states increasing benefit generosity for reasons other than cost of living differences. In The Work versus Welfare Trade-off 2013, I found that the benefits package from the same seven programs ranged from $25,491 in Arkansas to $49,175 in Hawaii. The impact of the UBI would vary by location, and low-income people in high cost areas could be worse off. It is not hard to imagine a scenario where people advocate for some kind of benefit adjustment based on the cost of living in the area. While this could potentially be a better design, it would again add a layer of complexity to what initially seemed like a very simple program. And, since the populations of high-cost states such as New York and California are often larger, any such adjustment could again make the program far more expensive. In short, unless we are prepared to significantly increase taxes, a pure universal basic income is unaffordable. It would also very likely lead to political pressure for a more complex and still more expensive system, one that looks less and less like a universal basic income.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – General
Sarah Berger Richardson & Nadia Lambek, 18. *Sarah Berger Richardson is an Assistant Professor at the University of Ottawa Faculty of Law (Civil law section). *Lambek is an adjunct Professor at Vermont Law School. “Federalism and fragmentation: Addressing the possibilities of a food policy for Canada.” Canadian Food Studies, 5.3, pp. 28–48. SSRN download.
If the universal basic income pilots are successful, they will offer a transformative new model for addressing income insecurity at the heart of food insecurity in Canada. Similarly, many of the most innovative moves in food law and policy are currently happening at the local level through deep participatory processes. For example, in Quebec, both the provincial government and the municipality of Montreal launched new food strategies in the past year following extensive public consultations (Government of Quebec, 2018; SAM, 2017). The themes identified at the provincial and municipal level in Quebec are different from those identified by the federal government for a national food policy, and this may be a good thing. In some cases, regional variation is desirable because it reflects more accurately local preferences and preoccupations. A robust practice of democratic experimentalism will see these local initiatives as complementary and inspirational to the design of federal initiatives. Creating spaces for creativity, innovation, and experimentation is extremely important to achieving more democratic, just, equitable, and sustainable food systems. A national food policy can encourage further provincial and municipal experimentation – while also articulating overarching principles, values, and norms as well as a food systems framework to guide it.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – General
Kody Carmody, 17. Economics Writing Intern at the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Current software engineer at the UPenn Wharton School. “The Resurgence of Universal Basic Income.” 2017. https://www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/econ_focus/2017/q3/feature2
What's Next? Several new UBI trials have just been launched around the world. One experiment, run by a nonprofit called GiveDirectly, will continue for at least 12 years and provide some villages in Kenya with a truly universal benefit. This might uncover some of the long-term and macro-level effects that the NIT experiments couldn't measure, but it is unclear how applicable any results would be to the United States. Closer to home, Y Combinator, a Silicon Valley startup accelerator, is giving 100 Oakland families a UBI for up to one year as part of a five-year study. These projects, however, are for the most part small and short term, revisiting the NIT experiments of the past, and focused on labor supply and other micro-level statistics. Marinescu argues that the next step should be to implement something larger, maybe at the state level, in the United States so that researchers can evaluate macro-level effects and interactions with other policies. A state-level UBI isn't totally without precedent: In 1976, Alaska used revenue from oil extraction on state-owned land to establish the Alaska Permanent Fund. This fund, popular with Alaskan voters, provides all residents of the state with $1,000 to $2,000 per year. Marinescu's own research has shown that the fund's payments have had no effect on the state's employment rate and only a minor decrease in hours worked; the income effect, Marinescu concludes, might have been cancelled out by stimulation of labor demand. But the amount of the payments is small compared to typical UBI proposals, so the effects of that program might not be a good predictor for a full-scale UBI.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – General
David A. Love, 20. Philadelphia-based writer, commentator, and journalism and media studies professor. Writes for CNN, Al Jazeera, Atlanta Black Star, theGrio, & other publications. “Governors who are banding together on pandemic response should adopt universal basic income.” May 1, 2020. https://theappeal.org/universal-basic-income-coronavirus-state-governors/
A Universal Basic Income would bring many potential benefits to the states that implement it, as states rely on economic activity to raise revenue and thrive. A UBI would result in economic growth by eliminating poverty and boosting the security of low-income workers—who are more likely to spend in the near term, as opposed to the rich, who are hoarding their mounting piles of money, hence the inequality. Such a policy shift would also bring permanent relief to gig workers with precarious income, those whose jobs are displaced by automation and globalization, and the massive ranks of the unemployed. Further, a UBI would empower people to choose jobs that they enjoy, allow them to spend more time with family, and make decisions that benefit themselves. In a nation where COVID-19 and economic devastation join forces and Washington is missing in action, a UBI would allow states to fortify their economic future and provide stability to their citizens during the pandemic and beyond.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – General
G. Jason Jolley, 22. Ph.D., Professor of Rural Economic Development, Master of Public Administration Director, Associate Dean for Public Strategy, and Innovation at Ohio University. "Basic income: a 50-state economic impact analysis," Journal of Financial Economic Policy 14.6 (2022): 768-777. https://doi.org/10.1108/JFEP-04-2022-0090
Design/methodology/approach Building on existing pilot studies of basic income in the USA, this paper presumes a $500 per month basic income for individuals earning less than $25,000 in annual income. Using impact analysis for planning (IMPLAN) input–output modeling software, estimated increase in gross state product and employment are provided on a state-by-state basis. Findings A $6,000 annual basic income ($500 per month) to adult persons earning less than $25,000 annually results in an increase in gross state product (e.g. gross “regional” product in IMPLAN terminology) ranging from 0.7% (District of Columbia) to 5.7% (Florida). Likewise, this increase in household spending will create demand for employment across these states, resulting in an increase in employment from 0.9% (District of Columbia) to 5.8% (Florida). Originality/value To date, to the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first state-by-state analysis of the economic impact of a basic income provision to lower-income individuals.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency - National follow on
Julian Glover, 22. Breaking news reporter and fill-in anchor at Fox 4 in Fort Myers and as an associate producer at the CBS owned & operated station in Miami, WFOR. “Does universal basic income work? Here's how it changed this SF family's life.” December 23, 2022. https://abc7news.com/ubi-universal-basic-income-california-sf-program/12607304/
ABC7 News followed Deisy and her family for the six months of the program. "One of the words (the families) used when they were describing how the funds impacted them was that it increased their calm... So the idea that families are so stressed out by their finances, or lack of finances, and that affects everything," said Kisch. There are currently more than 100 active Basic Income programs being tested in all 50 states - most of them following the huge success of a program started in Stockton by former Mayor Michael Tubbs. Tubbs now leads the group Mayors for a Guaranteed Income. The group is a network of dozens of mayors across the country that have pledged to test the idea of a guaranteed income in their cities. The locations range in size from major cities from San Francisco, Oakland, and Atlanta to smaller cities like Salisbury, Maryland. A newly released report by Mayors for a Guaranteed Income shows that families surveyed from 20 guaranteed income programs primarily used the funds on necessities. The report shows 39% of the fund's recipients received was spent at discount superstores for clothes, food, household goods and hygiene products. Another 27% of funds were spent at grocery stores, 9% on transportation costs including gas and car repairs, and 7% on housing utilities. Other notable expenses included loan payments, medical expenses, and tuition. "If you're worried about food to feed your children, pay your rent, pay your utilities, buy milk - that's going to impact your mental health, that's going to impact your ability to parent... So just the idea that we could reduce that tension-that stress-and support the families' calm just feels like it's certainly a good use of $350 a month," she added. Along with the six monthly payments of unconditional cash, the 13 families enrolled in this pilot program received additional help including access to family counseling and money management classes, much-needed help when you're just one unexpected bill away from homelessness. "The situation that they are facing is they cannot pay their rent or they cannot buy groceries or they cannot pay other bills," said Gerardo Gonzalez, Compass Family Services family and community engagement coordinator. That's the exact situation Deisy and her family found themselves in when we checked in halfway through the program, some three months in. We caught up with Deisy over Zoom as the entire family recovered from COVID. She told us her husband was out of work for two weeks because he was still testing positive for COVID. Paid sick leave through Deisy and her husband's job kept the family afloat, but still sick, her husband couldn't work his part-time job so money was tight. Deisy said she's unsure how they would have purchased groceries without the extra cushion from the program. She's grateful for the assistance - and is already saving what she can. She's planning ahead for when her family will no longer have that added help and hopes the family can move into a less expensive apartment to save even more. Months later, we caught up with Deisy on a busy summer day as she picked up her youngest son from after-school care offered by Compass Family Services. She's grateful for this support along with the $350 of unconditional cash she's received for the last six months. With a sense of gratitude and emotion akin to guilt, Deisy told us she wishes even more families could receive this basic income on top of services like SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) her two boys already receive. Her wish is becoming reality as an increasing number of organizations and city governments across the Bay Area, and beyond, test out basic income programs. The City of Mountain View, which started sending out $500 payments to more than one hundred families just days ago, is the latest city to test out a basic income in the Bay. "We can definitely call the movement," said Sean Klein, associate director of the Stanford Basic Income Lab. "I don't think we ever thought we would be at this place even a few years ago. Stanford's Basic Income Lab was launched in 2017 to study the successes and roadblocks of basic income pilots across the country. Early findings from the lab suggest families spent the money on necessities like rent and food - not drugs and alcohol. Kline also noted the added assistance allowed adults to look for better-paying, full-time jobs and does not cause reliance on the program, a major argument by naysayers. "The evidence suggests that unconditional cash is efficient. It's swift. It's much more powerful than in-kind assistance: food, even housing, because it gives people the agency and the means to make the choices they know are right for their family," Kline added. Kline points to recent examples of the government doling out unconditional cash at large scales as an example of the power these programs could have if applied more broadly.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency - National follow on
Noah Smith, 21. Smith is an American blogger, journalist, and commentator on economics and current events. Smith obtained his doctorate in Economics from the University of Michigan in 2012 and was an assistant professor of Behavioral Finance at Stony Brook University “Will New Mexico prove a universal basic income can work?” August 14, 2021. https://www.tbsnews.net/analysis/will-new-mexico-prove-universal-basic-income-can-work-288169
If New Mexico ultimately decides not to go through with the plan, other states should try it. Then, if a universal basic income is shown to have unambiguously positive results at the state level, it can more easily be scaled up to a national program. This is too important of an idea to leave it untested yet again.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency - National follow on
Economic Security Project, 22. The Economic Security Project (ESP) works to advance economic prosperity by providing research, supporting campaigns to get from pilot to policy, and working to change narratives about economic inequality and poverty. “States Lead the Way,” “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income.”
Economic Security Project, Shriver Center on Poverty Law. Report. April 13, 2022. https://economicsecurityproject.org/resource/states-lead/
Why Should States Engage With Guaranteed Income?
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – Other states follow on
Miles Howard, 20. Contributor & freelance writer who covers culture, travel and transformational politics. “The Federal Check Won't Be Enough. Now's The Time For Mass. To Introduce A Universal Basic Income.” March 25, 2020. https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2020/03/25/universal-basic-income-congress-coronavirus-covid-19-miles-howard
Localized UBI would go much further than the state-centric economic relief ideas that we’ve come up with thus far. The interest-free small business loans that Baker announced last week would still leave many of us indebted. The Boston Resiliency Fund, announced by Boston Mayor Marty Walsh, is a step in the correct direction (it would provide food and additional forms of material aid to kids, older adults and health care workers). But to address the full scale of the coronavirus economic fallout, we need the federal and state governments to come up with a livable and fair substitute for the economy that we’d otherwise be paying into as consumers, workers and business owners. Mailing out checks to everyone each month would move us a lot closer to that goal. Universal cash aid would not only prevent bankruptcies but also save lives. Instead of thinking of cash aid as "free money," think of it as paying people to stay home, social distance and do their duty to prevent hospitals from being swarmed with COVID-19 patients. Trump is already talking about sending people back to work by Easter (ignoring the recommendations of epidemiologists). Cash payments would help governors push back against Trump and urge their residents to stay home as long as public health officials recommend. Massachusetts could find a way to do this. We reaped a billion-dollar surplus last year, and while we’ve agreed on how to spend $541 million of it, that still leaves a hefty balance. We could even make Gouveia’s aid package universal, sending out checks to everyone now and finding a way to tax wealthier households retroactively. That would solve the means-testing, red-tape problem. But on a broader level, doing this would be an act of leadership and innovation in line with the history of Massachusetts. We love to rest on laurels when it comes to reliving the days of giving people health care and legalizing same-sex marriage. Now, as millions of Americans struggle to survive the pandemic without going bankrupt, Massachusetts could show other states how to compensate for the federal government’s inadequate response to the economic calamity.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – Other states follow on
G. Jason Jolley, 22. Jolley is a Professor of Rural Economic Development and director of the Master of Public Administration program at Ohio University's Voinovich School of Leadership and Public Affairs at Ohio University. “Basic income: a 50-state economic impact analysis.” Journal of Financial Economic Policy 14.6, 2022. pp. 768-777.
Purpose – This paper aims to estimate the economic impact of a basic income for each state in the USA. Design/methodology/approach – Building on existing pilot studies of basic income in the USA, this paper presumes a $500 per month basic income for individuals earning less than $25,000 in annual income. Using impact analysis for planning (IMPLAN) input–output modeling software, estimated increase in gross state product and employment are provided on a state-by-state basis. Findings – A $6,000 annual basic income ($500 per month) to adult persons earning less than $25,000 annually results in an increase in gross state product (e.g. gross “regional” product in IMPLAN terminology) ranging from 0.7% (District of Columbia) to 5.7% (Florida). Likewise, this increase in household spending will create demand for employment across these states, resulting in an increase in employment from 0.9% (District of Columbia) to 5.8% (Florida). Originality/value – To date, to the best of the author’s knowledge, this is the first state-by-state analysis of the economic impact of a basic income provision to lower-income individuals.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – Other states follow on
Josephine Fuller, 22. Fuller is a reporter for The US Sun covering all things regarding money and consumers. Prior to moving to finance, she was part of the news desk covering events. “HELPING HAND 29 cities and states sending payments between $200 and $1,200 monthly – full list of universal basic income in 2023.” Nov 26, 2022. https://www.the-sun.com/money/6761547/cities-states-universal-basic-income-2023/
AMERICANS all over the country are getting help making ends meet through universal basic income (UBI) programs. These guaranteed income programs provide monthly payments to eligible participants. These programs offer money to low-income residents with no strings attached. Usually, the programs are government-sponsored or run by not-for-profits. In most cases, there are no strings attached to how the cash can be used and it doesn't have to be paid back. While there is growing support or these programs, those who oppose them say they discourage people from finding work.
Here are some of the UBI programs across the country.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 1NC Shell - Interstate Compacts
Claire Carothers, 06. J.D. Georgia Law School, Assistant Professor of Law at Wayne State University. “Note: United We Stand: The Interstate Compact as a Tool for Affecting Climate Change.” Georgia Law Review, Fall 2006. 41.229. Lexis.
Before 1921, the thirty-six compacts enacted with the consent of Congress dealt mainly with the establishment of boundaries between adjacent states. n92 States continue to use boundary compacts to avoid litigation. n93 However, since the New Deal era, modern scholars and judges have adopted a more expansive view of interstate compacts as effective and underused mechanisms to solve regional and national problems without direct congressional action. n94 While the exact number of compacts is hard to calculate, one survey estimates over 140 agreements enacted after 1920. n95 An increasing percentage of these have established administrative agencies with jurisdiction over important regional issues. n96 In identifying and classifying new compacts enacted since the 1970s, Patricia S. Florestano reported a decrease in the number of border and boundary compacts, an increase in regional compacts, and a sharp increase in environmental and transportation compacts. N97