Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

The only way a job guarantee works without massive wage inflation is by suppressing labor power – plan is basically job training for a reserve army of scabs

Bruenig 18 [Matt, founder of the People’s Policy Project, “The Great Contradiction in Job Guarantee Advocacy,” People’s Policy Project, 10/18/18, ]

Old school JG pulls off such a feat by creating an open-ended minimum-wage public employment program. The program employs everyone not employed by regular employers, getting the country to 0 percent unemployment. And, by only paying the minimum wage, the JG would not actually be competitive with regular jobs, almost all of which pay more than the minimum wage. The idea that workers in regular jobs would be able to use the existence of the JG to force up their wages was thus described as preposterous: how do you force your employer to pay you more if your “bargaining chip” is that you can go get a minimum wage JG job that pays you even less than you are already making? In fact, JG advocates claimed, the JG program actually helps discipline the wage demands of regular workers. If a regular worker gets too uppity, employers could just fire them and replace them with a JG worker who would be thrilled to take a job that pays more than the fixed minimum wage they get in the JG program. Randall Wray is very explicit about this in his 1997 paper: However, just as workers have the alternative of [JG], so do employers have the opportunity of hiring from the [JG] pool. This is the primary “price stabilization” feature of the [JG] program. If the wage demands of workers in the private sector exceed by too great a margin the employer’s calculations of their productivity, the alternative is to obtain [JG] workers at a mark-up over the [minimum wage]. This will help to offset the wage pressures caused by elimination of the fear of unemployment. Another way to put this is to say that the JG does not eliminate the reserve army of unemployed people who help hold down the wage (and other) demands of workers. It’s just that, instead of the reserve army sitting around on unemployment benefits, they now work a minimum wage job that they are eager to leave as soon as they can get higher pay from a regular employer. Wray actually puts the point in exactly these “reserve army” terms: It must be remembered that the [JG] workers are not “lost” as a reserve army of potential employees; rather, they can always be obtained at a mark-up over [the minimum wage]. The old telling makes perfect sense of course. The whole challenge JG is trying to solve is getting to 0 percent unemployment without creating unsustainable wage-price inflation. If it somehow massively increased the bargaining power of regular workers, then it would create unsustainable wage-price inflation and be unworkable as a policy. The benefit of the JG over having a small percentage of the workforce on unemployment benefits is not that it tightens labor markets and runs up wages, but rather that it puts people to work, and jobs are better than welfare (the normative judgment at the heart of JG advocacy).

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

Capitalists would love a job guarantee – it is a deceptive form of workfare that creates a more predictable and safe trained workforce for businesses to tap

Bruenig 19 [Matt, founder of the People’s Policy Project, “Warren Mosler on the Job Guarantee,” 03/03/19, https://mattbruenig.medium.com/warren-mosler-on-the-job-guarantee-5c86afd25974]

The most fascinating thing in the Job Guarantee discourse is that the program is now being sold in a very different way than it used to be sold. In the 1990s, JG advocates like Randy Wray were saying that the program was a way of holding down private sector wage demands by making unemployment less palatable by pushing unemployed people into minimum-wage (the JG wage is necessarily the minimum wage) make-work jobs. These days, this language of workfare has been replaced by some kind of radical posturing that a JG “eliminates the reserve army of unemployed people” and is anti-capitalist or something. But the dream of the 1990s is still alive in Warren Mosler’s head. Mosler is the founder, funder, and tax exile extraordinaire of the JG and MMT movement. Last month, he gave a long interview about these concepts. In the interview, he gives a very clear description of the JG that has been unaffected by the recent rhetorical shifts adopted by its proponents. Here is a transcript of the relevant snippet: So right now, we have what we call the Phillips Curve where we watch unemployment. And we watch various measures of it. And what we run into is, particularly in Europe now where you have the NAIRU at 10% or something, employers don’t like to hire people who aren’t working. They just don’t like to do that. And there are studies that show that. They’d rather hire somebody already working who has some kind of employment history. So you can go to their boss or their supervisor and find out whether this person has good work habits and things like that. If they are just unemployed in the streets and they’ve been unemployed in their home and they haven’t been working, you don’t know. It’s high risk. They might be on drugs. They might not take a bath everyday. They might get into fights with their employees. Businesses don’t want to hire these people. […] How do we get those people that the government doesn’t want to hire — and we don’t want to just load up the public sector — how do we get them back into the private sector? How do they transition back? And one very effective way to do that is to give them what I call “transition jobs,” what the MMT proponents call the “job guarantee.” By offering a “transition job” — let me call it that rather than the “job guarantee” at some, and I call it a non-disruptive wage, and we can argue whether that’s $10 per hour or $15 but it’s just a numerator; it doesn’t matter in theory. Having these people come into this job makes them now a whole lot more employable and they will then transition into the private sector. We can then use fiscal expansion — lower taxes or higher public spending, but let’s start with lower taxes — to create more aggregate demand so that sales will go up and [companies] will start hiring these people out of the transition job where you can’t get a raise in pay into the private sector. And they’ll pay more than the transition job. There will be a spread. And that will transition these people out of the public sector and into the private sector. The problem I see with these MMT proponents is they say they want a job guarantee and the first question is: what are they all going to do? And when they start explaining the types of jobs they are going to do: wrong answer. What they are going to do is transition into the private sector over some period of time: six months, a year, two years. And that’s the whole point of getting them into this job guarantee is to transition them into the private sector. It’s not about what they are going to do. Mosler is very clear here. The idea is to make unemployed people more attractive to private employers by having them do any kind of make-work job at a non-disruptive minimum wage. The goal of this job is to prove to private employers that they are viable workers, increasing their odds of being hired. The goal is not to “load up the public sector” by permanently hiring folks into it. It’s a transition job. For real public sector work, you would presumably hire in the normal way we hire public sector workers like teachers. There is a lot of room to quibble with Mosler’s idea here. If employers are hesitant to hire unemployed people, then why wouldn’t they also be hesitant to hire people “employed” by the JG program? Will they not be smart enough to realize that the people in that program are the same kind of people they would otherwise be reluctant to hire? But the point of this post is not to argue the merits of Mosler’s idea. It is simply to raise awareness of what this idea actually is. There is widespread confusion about what the JG is and where it came from. It is workfare and always has been.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

Without first fundamentally altering the capitalist economic system, a jobs guarantee will inevitably fail just like the New Deal did – leading to catastrophic stagflation, overproduction and public debt

Booth 19 [Adam, PhD in Environmental Engineering from Cambridge University, Editor of Socialist Appeal, founder of the Cambridge Marxist Discussion Group, “Marxism vs Modern Monetary Theory,” 06/07/19, https://socialist.net/marxism-vs-modern-monetary-theory/]

What MMT proposes, therefore, is again nothing but the old Keynesian economics of demand-side management. But such Keynesianism has been tried before – and found wanting. This top-down attempt at economic management was in vogue across the advanced capitalist countries throughout the 1960s and 1970s, up until the point where its inflationary policies led to a global capitalist crisis of overproduction, stagflation, and the collapse of the Bretton Woods system that had underpinned the post-war boom. Today, the call for a Green New Deal (GND) has become popular on the left, advocated by AOC in the US and by left-wing Labour activists in the UK. A key element of the GND proposals put forward on both sides of the Atlantic is the idea of a ‘jobs guarantee’: the provision of a minimum-wage, public sector job to all those who are unemployed. In this way, left-wing MMTers argue, governments can maintain an ‘appropriate’ level of demand in the economy. Maintaining full employment becomes the primary target. As capitalism’s ‘reserve army of labour’ (as Marx described it) expands and contracts, so too does the government’s own army of labour to compensate. This of course is designed to emulate the original New Deal: President Roosevelt’s programme of public works that were intended to stimulate US economic growth during the Great Depression. The ideas of Keynes were clearly influential in shaping the New Deal. After all, in his General Theory, the English economist even suggested that the government could boost demand by burying money in the ground and getting workers to dig it back up. “There need be no more unemployment,” stated Keynes. “It would, indeed, be more sensible to build houses and the like,” he continued, “but if there are political and practical difficulties in the way of this, the above would be better than nothing.” The only problem that the advocates of a ‘jobs guarantee’ fail to mention, however, is that the New Deal did not work. The slump continued long after its implementation (in fact, it became worse with the rise of ‘beggar-thy-neighbour’ protectionism). Unemployment even went up. Only with the onset of the Second World War and the mopping up of workers into the army and the arms sector did unemployment fall. Even Keynes himself was forced to admit defeat. “It is, it seems, politically impossible for a capitalistic democracy to organise expenditure on the scale necessary to make the grand experiments which would prove my case — except in war conditions.” The same can be seen in China today, where the largest ever Keynesian programme of construction has been undertaken in the last decade, in an effort to escape the impact of the global capitalist crisis. But the result has been a massive increase in public debts, on one side, and the ludicrous contradiction of ghost cities alongside a huge housing crisis, on the other. This is the logical conclusion of Keynesian attempts to bureaucratically manage a capitalist, profit-driven economy. There is no reason to believe a new New Deal would fare any better today in America, Britain, or anywhere else. And so we arrive back at square one, asking ourselves what MMT really has to offer?

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

Job guarantee is a faux-solution that perpetuates capitalist gains

Standing- former Director of Socio-Economic Security in the ILO, 18

Guy Standing- Fellow of the UK Academy of Social Sciences, and Professorial Research Associate, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. Formerly Professor of Economic Security at the University of Bath, and Director of Socio-Economic Security in the International Labour Organisation. Open Democracy. Why a Job Guarantee is a bad joke for the precariat – and for freedom. . 7th September 2018. DOA: 06/17/2023. AR.

At its unlikely best, a job guarantee would be paternalistic. It presumes the government knows what is best for individuals, who would be offered a necessarily limited range of jobs at its disposal. Suppose someone was pressed to take a guaranteed job on a construction site (‘infrastructure’, a favoured area for guaranteed jobs) and that person proved incompetent and was injured. Would the job guarantee agency be held responsible and pay compensation? It should, since it put the person in that position. How would that be factored into the costing of a job guarantee scheme? Similarly, if a person put into a ‘social care’ job was negligent and caused harm or distress to the care recipient, would the latter be able to sue the job guarantee agency for compensation? In addition, a job-guarantee scheme would spring a familiar trap – the phoney distinction between those who ‘can work’ and would thus be eligible for a guaranteed job and those ‘who cannot work’. In Britain, this has led to demeaning and stigmatising ‘capacity-to-work’ and ‘availability-for-work’ tests, resulting in discriminatory action against disabled and vulnerable people, and those with care responsibilities. Another failing of the job guarantee route is the mapping of a path to ‘workfare’. What would happen to somebody who declined to accept the guaranteed job? They would be labelled ‘lazy’ or ‘choosy’ and thus ‘ungrateful’ and ‘socially irresponsible’. Yet there are many reasons for refusing a job. Studies show that accepting a job below a person’s qualifications can lower their income and social status for the long term. As what is happening in the current UK benefit system attests, those not taking jobs allocated to them would face benefit sanctions, and be directed into jobs, whether they liked them or not. Jobs done in resentment or under duress are unlikely to be done well. A job guarantee would be a recipe for perpetuating low productivity. What would happen if a person in a guaranteed job performed poorly, perhaps because of limited ability or simply because they knew it was ‘guaranteed’? This was a fatal flaw of the Soviet system. If you are guaranteed a job, why bother to work hard? If you are an employer and are given a subsidy to pay employees guaranteed a job, why bother to try to use labour efficiently? If subsidised through tax credits or a wage subsidy, a worker would need to produce only a little more value than the cost to the employer to make it profitable to retain him or her. This would cheapen low-productivity jobs relative to others and inhibit the higher productivity arising from labour-displacing technological change. If a job of a certain type is guaranteed, what happens if an employer wishes to invest in technology that would remove the need for such jobs? Those calling for a job guarantee also ignore the fact that any market economy requires some unemployment, as people need time to search for jobs they are prepared to accept, and firms must sift applicants for jobs they want to have done. To adopt a job guarantee policy would risk putting the economy in gridlock. Job guarantee advocates, such as Larry Summers, President Clinton’s former Treasury Secretary, argue that people without jobs ‘are much more likely to be dissatisfied with their lives’ and are more likely to be drug addicts and abusive than those with even low-wage jobs. This is bogus. I suggest there would be no correlation between life satisfaction and having a job if the comparison was made between those in lousy jobs and those with no job but an adequate income on which to live. Somebody facing a choice between penury and a lousy job will prefer the job. But that does not mean they like or want it for itself. The polling company Gallup conducts regular State of the Global Workplace surveys in over 150 countries. In 2017, it found that globally only 15% of workers were engaged by their job, and in no country did the figure exceed 40%. One recent UK survey found that 37% of jobholders did not think their job made any significant contribution. Summers ends his article by equivocating – ‘the idea of a jobs guarantee should be taken seriously but not literally’. He seems to mean government should try to promote more employment, through ‘wage subsidies, targeted government spending, support for workers with dependants, and more training and job-matching programmes’. In other words, he reverts to the standard social democratic package that has not done very well in the past three decades. Besides being a recipe for labour inefficiency and labour market distortions, tending to displace workers employed in the ‘free’ labour market and to depress their wages, the job guarantee proposal fails to recognise that today’s crisis is structural and requires transformative policies. Tax credits, job guarantees and statutory minimum wages would barely touch the precariat’s existential insecurity that is at the heart of the social and economic crisis, let alone address the aspirations of the progressive and growing part of the precariat for an ecologically grounded Good Society. The emphasis on jobs is non-ecological, since it is tied to the constant pursuit of economic growth. There are many instances, with support for fracking and for the third runway at Heathrow airport being recent examples, where the promise of more jobs has trumped costs to health and the environment. And a job guarantee policy could have a strong appeal to the political right as a way to dismantle the welfare state. Why pay unemployment benefits if everybody has a guaranteed job? In the USA, one conservative commentator chortled that ‘over 100 federal welfare programs would be replaced with a single job guarantee program.’ Finally, there is what this writer regards as the policy’s worst feature. It would reinforce twentieth-century labourism, by failing to make the distinction between work and labour. Those who back guaranteed jobs typically ignore all forms of work that are not paid labour. A really progressive agenda would strengthen the values of work over the dictates of labour. It would seek to enable more people to develop their own sense of occupation. A job is a means to an end, not an end in itself. Economists tend to be schizophrenic in this respect. In the textbooks, labour has ‘disutility’; it is negative for the worker. Yet many economists who use or write these textbooks then advocate putting everybody in jobs. Why make a fetish of ‘jobs’? A job is doing ‘labour’ for others. What about all the forms of work that we do for those we love or for our community or for ourselves? Many forms of work that are not labour are more rewarding psychologically and socially. A regime of putting everybody into jobs, in unchosen activities, would be orchestrated alienation. Surely a progressive should want to minimise the time we spend in stultifying and subordinated jobs, so that we can increase the time and energy for forms of work and leisure that are self-chosen and oriented to personal and community development. There is one last point, to do with the claim that a job guarantee would be politically popular. Much is made of a US poll which asked people whether they would support a scheme to guarantee a job for anybody ‘who can’t find employment in the private sector’, if paid from a 5% tax on those earning over $200,000. The result was 52% in favour. Supporters thought this was ‘stunning’. With such a loaded question, one should be stunned by the bare-majority support. After all, most respondents were being told they would not have to pay, and that there were no alternative jobs available, an unlikely scenario. Rather than jobs per se, the primary challenge is to build a new income distribution system, recognising that the old one has broken down irretrievably. The rentiers are running away with all the revenue thrown up by rentier capitalism, and real wages will continue to lag. Putting people into static low-wage jobs is no response.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

GND job guarantee’s just increase private sector demand power

King, political post-doc at York University, 20

Adam D.K. King- Post-Doctoral Visitor in the Department of Politics at York University in Toronto. The Maple. UBI And Job Guarantees Aren’t The Leftist Solutions We Need. . May 28, 2020. DOA: 06/18/23. AR.

A Job Guarantee? A JG is sometimes included alongside, but usually counterposed, to UBI. As with basic income, job guarantee proposals vary. In the most popular JG plan, a federal job program would guarantee employment to anyone unable to secure other private or public sector work. JG jobs would pay the minimum wage and offer a minimum benefit package. Like UBI, a job guarantee generates support because of its straightforward pitch: everyone who wants a job should have one, regardless of whether it can be provided by the market. Additionally, job guarantee advocates often position the JG as a means through which to achieve other progressive political goals. A JG has been advanced as part of a framework to address climate change through a Green New Deal, as a mechanism to tackle racial injustice and inequality, as a means to improve labour standards throughout the economy and as a way to maintain or boost economic demand while narrowing wage and income inequality. The job guarantee, it seems, is many things to many people. And although writers on the left have criticized UBI extensively, there’s a surprising lack of critical evaluation of what a job guarantee might actually look like in practice. What Do We Really Want from a Job Guarantee? Like UBI, the job guarantee appears as a social and economic panacea in the writing of some of its advocates. However, JG writers most commonly claim a job guarantee can do three things: maintain full employment; strengthen workers’ overall bargaining power in the economy; help solve the climate crisis by creating green jobs. As neoliberal capitalism moved away from policies to generate full employment after the inflationary crises of the late 1970s, some left economists looked for ways to solve the full employment-inflation trade-off. This is the origin of the idea of guaranteeing paid work through a government “employer of last resort” program. The notion, put forward by economist Hyman Minsky, was that the government could simultaneously maintain full employment and stabilize the economy through a job program that grew and shrank according to the business cycle. But this is where the most glaring contradiction appears. Minsky and those who followed him insisted that the wages of JG jobs would be kept low enough to not produce wage-induced inflation in the private sector. If private sector workers demanded too much, employers could always hire low-wage workers from the JG program. However, somewhere along the line, contemporary JG advocates got the idea that a job guarantee could do the opposite: that it would improve the bargaining power of all workers by eliminating unemployment. Insofar as contemporary JG advocates believe a job guarantee that sets a higher minimum wage can avoid this problem, they are both mischaracterizing a central feature of the JG — that it won’t allow private sector workers to bargain up wages — and committing the same error as UBI proponents: thinking a policy fix can be an end-run around class struggle. As with UBI, the job guarantee is ultimately about addressing unemployment. But insofar as a JG program would simply pool the unemployed in a minimum wage make-work scheme, it would ‘employ’ these workers only in the most superficial sense. And if it functioned according to its original design, a job guarantee would contain, not enhance, the power of private sector workers to demand more. Although JG writers claim the program would not be another form of workfare, it’s hard to imagine a job guarantee program under present political conditions not functioning as a welfare-to-work scheme. Neoliberal attacks on social supports have been characterized equally by cuts to income supports and workfare. A job guarantee program runs the risk of continuing this trend. Though left JG enthusiasts argue that the program shouldn’t be used to coerce social assistance recipients into paid work, in the hands of neoliberal politicians it could very well operate in this way. The JG is no less amenable to neoliberalism than a UBI. What about the JG’s potential as a green jobs program? This is perhaps the most surprising claim of all. There’s no question that transitioning away from fossil fuels and averting the climate crisis will necessitate a massive expansion of public sector employment. But thinking this can be achieved through a minimum wage job guarantee program only confuses matters. Because the JG is fundamentally about guaranteeing employment, it must not include any skills requirements and must provide work to all those who apply. The green jobs necessary for a just transition, however, will involve considerable skill and training. These need to be secure, adequately paid public sector jobs. A job guarantee, according to its principal policy architects, is also by definition a temporary employment program. JG jobs, as economics professor L. Randall Wray argues, would grow and contract according to the performance of the private sector labour market. A green transition needs good public sector employment, not temporary minimum wage workfare. Some writers imagine JG workers also working in the caring economy. Canada desperately needs publicly funded eldercare and universal childcare, along with greater investment in health and education more broadly. Yet a job guarantee program could not be depended upon to staff these highly skilled caring jobs. Moreover, the claim that a JG program with no skills requirement could meet these needs reinforces the sexist and racist argument that such jobs aren’t skilled.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- job guarantee

The aff fails to interrogate the structuring power of the larger political system. Enacting a jobs guarantee within capitalism only reproduces status quo domination. Revolutionary praxis must be aimed at the modes of production, not at becoming a petitioner for table scraps.

Slininger 18 [Katy, socialist organizer of the Cargill Tenants Union, member of the DSA Communist Caucus, and practicing multimedia artist, “Sanders’ job guarantee is not radical,” 04/24/18, ]

A major defense of Sanders’ project is that a tight job market, and a federal works project indirectly establishing the floor for worker benefits and compensation*, would pressure private businesses to increase wages and improve working conditions. Supposedly this scenario would, on top of solving unemployment outright, curb underemployment. But such an expectation relies upon the assumption that the “free market” will behave rationally and predictably. If we look at recent news, it is clear that there is not necessarily a correlation between a tight labor market and rising wages. Earlier this year, an above-average increase rate for wages made the news, signaling a growing, healthy economy after a reduction in unemployment. The Wall Street Journal reported: Wage growth accelerated, with average hourly earnings for private-sector workers climbing 0.34% on the month and up 2.9% over the past year. That was the strongest year-over-year gain since June 2009, a sign the tightening labor market may be finally producing notably larger pay raises. Wow, that sounds great — just what you would expect to happen! But wait… Who took home the biggest increases? Managers. Wages for private-sector employees increased 2.9% in January from a year earlier, the strongest annual increase since June 2009, according to the Labor Department’s latest jobs report. Nonsupervisors, about 82% of the workforce, saw a smaller increase just modestly above the pace of inflation. Anti-capitalist organizing should not be based on objective or idealistic rationality in traditional (capitalist) economic terms, but based on an understanding of how the market exerts power in the interest of the bourgeoisie. Worker wages don’t necessarily rise in response to a shrinking labor market because capitalism attempts to adapt with long-term power as its priority. Business owners will underpay their work force and deny them benefits even if they end up understaffed — because it preserves an essential power dynamic. They would often rather close than capitulate to workers. If you understand market rationality only as immediate, corresponding responses to economic changes, you fundamentally misunderstand capitalism. The market is rational only in a macro-Marxist sense — it consistently acts with preservation of capitalism (and capitalists’ self-interest) as its motivation. Socialists should be confronting capital and the political systems that submit to and enable it. We shouldn’t spend time guaranteeing a job that may or may not increase private-sector job wages but, at the very least, tie the minimum wage to inflation and force the private sector to pay more — and even this is only an extremely tepid reform! We should not endorse a proposal that provides healthcare through a federal job, when we could instead continue the fight for healthcare completely de-linked from employment. And we — the workers — should build workplace power by increasing union activity to protect workers against the reduced hours and layoffs that inevitably follow rising wages. Waiting for the market to correct in favor of the worker is a foolish endeavor rooted in capitalist thinking, and further exposes a federal job guarantee as a reform based in capitulation, not transformation. There are plenty of reforms that genuinely build worker power as we build a path towards a complete restructuring — Sanders’ job guarantee, without a clear plan to decommodify services, is not one of them. Progressives and leftists have used Sanders’ proposal as an opportunity to debate the concept of a federal job guarantee, but fail to engage with the political context in which such a program would operate. There is a world of difference between a socialist job guarantee under a democratic government and a capitalist job guarantee under our existing (undemocratic, imperialist) state. It is important not mistake criticism specifically directed at a bourgeois job guarantee for a condemnation of an eventual planned economy featuring a similar program. That redirecting of discourse idealizes the oppressive, volatile state that currently exists and fails to adequately analyze the potential success of the reform. We have seen job guarantee programs in the past, which were introduced during capitalist crises. Progressives point to past, temporary successes in alleviating working-class suffering as proof of the program’s validity, but fail to question why we’re back in the midst of a capitalist crisis. These supposedly radical reforms are non-transformational! The positive effects are finite without changing power dynamics. We need people building our infrastructure, urgently, in the face of a changing climate. There is vital work to be done in many sectors. But we will ultimately fail at securing a sustainable future if those projects (and “jobs” — though in a socialist state it would not be wage labor) are contingent on the ever-volatile support of those in power. We’ve witnessed major policies attacked and dismantled after a change in administration, and most of us are tired of repeating the cycle. The proposed capitalist federal job guarantee does not change economic or political power dynamics — it keeps the working class in the position of petitioner. Wrestling power back from the bourgeois state, and dismantling the capitalist system, has to precede anything resembling true liberation. Socialists need to stop selling the working class on scraps by labeling them “radical,” and instead agitate it to the point of fundamental change.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc– link- social security

The historical record proves that social security has been about stabilization of capitalist industrial interests from the start – it has been the tool for exclusion of radical alternatives from policy debates

Brents 84 [Barbara, Prof of Sociology at UNLV, “Capitalism, Corporate Liberalism and Social Policy: The Origins of the Social Security Act of 1935,” Mid-American Review of Sociology, p.35-7]

The political history of the Social Security bill demonstrates clearly the carrying out of the corporate liberal link between business, academicians and government. Swope and Young actively advised Roosevelt up until he appointed the Committee on Economic Security to research and write the bill, and the Committee was careful to carry out Roosevelt's wishes (Witte, 1962). Key positions on this committee were held by Wisconsin group people and AALL members, and a majority of the participants were connected in some way to corporate liberal organizations. The advisory council to the committee consisted of labor representatives, "public" members and business leaders. The businessmen were clearly those who were connected to corporate liberal ideas. There was much debate within this committee, and in Congress on the specific details of the bill, but overall the Social Security Act was framed in corporate liberal terms. In fact, the bill changed little once it was in Congress. Indeed, there were only two radical alternatives put before Congress at that time: the Townsend Bill (advocating $200 per month for everyone over 60) and the Lundeen Bill (advocating benefits equal to average local wages to all workers and farmers over 18 who were unemployed through no fault of their own). But neither of these bills, nor working class movements, nor general non-corporate liberal business opposition could legitimately enter the policy making process once the basic outlines were formulated. The corporate liberal ideology had clear hegemony and dominated Congressional debates. A survey of Congressional hearings shows that stabilization of industry was the dominant theme and debates among those involved in government, the Committee on Economic Security, and liberal industry centered around the best method of stabilization. In justifying the act to Congress, administration spokespersons, including advisory council member Marion Folsom of Kodak and. other businessmen supporting the act, emphasized that unemployment insurance would stabilize the labor force as well as purchasing power, hence giving employers more predictable markets. Even old age insurance was viewed in terms of stabilization and efficiency. According to a report published by the Social Security Board (1937:199), old age insurance was created to enhance the elderly's sense of security and confidence, get old people out of the labor market and stabilize their consumption expenditures. Hence, old age insurance was viewed as helping to solve part of the unemployment problem, a problem viewed more in terms of the inefficiency of industry rather than the effects on the worker. According to Murray Latimer, who helped write the old age provisions of the Act: There are a number of industrial companies who's level of productive efficiency has been and is being reduced by the fact that they have a number of old men whom they would like to retire but cannot on account of public pressure, and at the same time they have not sufficient funds available to start a pension system (Latimer, Senate Finance Committee Hearings, 1935:749). After explaining how benefits would induce elders to leave the labor force, increase wages, absorb the young employed and also take the burden of support off their children, Latimer added, "nor should the advantages of the maintenance of a large and continuing stream of purchasing power directed almost entirely to consumer goods be overlooked" (Ways and Means Committee Hearings, 1935:223-4). The advantages for the stabilization of industry via production and consumption was the central theme of the debates on old age insurance. The development of corporate liberalism from the German Historical School through the research and policy planning organizations composed of capitalists and academics gradually altered views toward social insurance by encouraging businesses to believe it could help expand their industries as well as ensure social peace. Industrial and social rationalization and stabilization; and, the social benefits of a more efficient corporate system were the key values. The policy planning 'groups involved the same businessmen and academics who would later help formulate the Social Security Act. These groups and certain liberal businessmen began to participate in government studies on unemployment insurance and began to push for state legislation and private pension plans that would serve as exemplars for the Social Security Act. These exemplars specifically centered on rationalizing and stabilizing industry. Social justice for the worker was a subsidiary concern. The Social Security Act was a culmination of corporate liberal ideas on unemployment-the need to have predictable and efficient labor and consumer markets through payments to those previously tied to the labor market, and the need to smooth out business cycles. Old age insurance was likewise viewed as a means to remove inefficient older workers from the labor force and put more money in consumers' pockets. In addition, both unemployment and old age insurance were contingent on labor force participation and in fact excluded large numbers of the labor force that were not tied to mainstream industry (such as agricultural workers, domestic servants and seamen), reinforcing dependency on the labor market for subsistence. Hence the Act was formulated with the interests of industry foremost.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc– link- social security

Social Security is a governmental technology of control designed to stabilize capitalism from its failures – coopting revolutionary class struggle and restoring confidence in capitalist organization

Brents 84 [Barbara, Prof of Sociology at UNLV, “Capitalism, Corporate Liberalism and Social Policy: The Origins of the Social Security Act of 1935,” Mid-American Review of Sociology, p.25-7]

Social insurance as we know it had its earliest intellectual roots in the late 19th century transformation of liberal thought from an individualist laissez faire ideology to the social responsibility, interventionist ideology of the 20th century. It was the view of this new corporate liberalism that provided justifications and methods for social insurance in America, along a course that was entirely consistent with the continuance of a capitalist system. Twentieth century corporate "liberalism, as James Weinstein (1968) defines it, involves an ideology which holds that social engineering, social efficiency and social responsibility are the means to stabilize, rationalize and expand the existing capitalist political economy, and avoid dangerous alternate forms of social organization, especially socialism. In the attempt to succeed in this endeavor, the economist arose as the technical expert who would develop government policy that could create and maintain a stable social order. As corporate liberalism developed, it succeeded in co-opting a potentially radical and often violent working class by incorporating labor representatives as junior partners in a business/government association designed to work out "rational" and "efficient" solutions to conflicts and maintain industrial peace'. Terms such as efficiency and stabilization replaced justice as the main expressed goal. However, corporate liberalism, as it shall be discussed throughout this paper, cannot be viewed as a static, autonomous concept. It was a dynamic set of ideas that originated in the minds of humans and was both shaped by and shaped interaction in a social environment. This ideology laid the intellectual groundwork, set the ideological boundaries, and devised the methods used in the formulation of the Social Security Act as "the" solution to the problems of old age and unemployment. Corporate liberal ideas originated in Germany in the late 187Os and were first brought to the United States by a group of prominent American economists trained in the German Historical School of Economics centered at the University of Heidelberg. Contrary to classical economics and its abstract reasoning and individualistic emphasis on natural rights and natural law, this group believed economic phenomena could best be understood by using statistical investigations and inductive methods to shape economic institutions to meet social goals through active state intervention. The members of this school formed the Union for Social Politics (Verein fiir Sozialpolitik) in Germany to gather economic information to meet "the acknowledged need ... of social reform in -opposition to social revolution on the one hand, and to rigid laissez faire on the other" (Dorfman, 1955 :21). These attempts to "meet the challenge of socialism resulted in an advanced program of social insurance, culminating in Bismark's program of sickness, accident, invalidity and old age insurance" (Dorfman, 1955 :21). The American economists from this school returned to the United States with these ideas during the late 1880s and 90s, years fraught with long and severe depressions and widespread labor unrest. Many, including some businessmen, were losing confidence in the ability of an unregulated economy to maintain social order, and these economists did much to change the scope of American economics. The work of Richard Ely in particular helped define and institutionalize emerging corporate 'liberal 'thought and subsequent notions of social insurance. Ely, impressed with the efficiency of the German government, believed the United States government could likewise efficiently shape economic life for the good of the public. He outlined programs of social reform that resembled those of the New Deal over 40 years later public housing, public work for the unemployed, child and female labor restrictions, and government insurance for protection against death, old age, sickness and accidents (Fine, 1956; Ely, 1894). His reforms had the expressed goals of avoiding socialist- violence and revolution, and maintaining the existing class structure by eliminating the waste and inefficiency of the present system (Fine, 1956; Ely, 1894). Ely published 25 books and 280 pamphlets and articles before his death in 1937. His students included a long list of New Dealers, reformists, economists, sociologists and others who became important in forming American social policy during the first half of the twentieth century

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- UBI

UBI is just lightly disguised free market ideology that will enable a wholesale attack on the working class

Booth 17 [Adam, PhD in Environmental Engineering from Cambridge University, Editor of Socialist Appeal, founder of the Cambridge Marxist Discussion Group, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” 02/10/17, ]

For those on the Left, the UBI is proposed as a progressive demand: a reinforced safety net, beyond the sticking plaster of the current welfare state, funded through increased taxation on big business and the rich. Raised in such a manner, it is clearly a demand – like any genuine reform – that should be supported and fought for. UBI, however, is not an inherently left-wing or progressive measure. The idea of a universal payment, in fact, has many advocates on the libertarian right. Indeed, even prominent bourgeois economists such as Milton Friedman have made similar proposals in the past, with his idea for a “negative income tax”. For these respectable ladies and gentlemen, the concept of a UBI has great appeal as an extremely streamlined version of – or, worse still, replacement for – the welfare state. In one fell swoop, these small government zealots suggest, one could “simplify” (read: slash) vast swathes of the taxation and benefits system, “eliminating bureaucracy” and “reducing market interference”. At the same time, one can clearly see the attraction of the UBI to the Schumpeterian liberals who preach the virtues of the invisible hand and the powerful transformative forces of “creative destruction”. Provide a primitive safety net, eradicate “barriers” to job creation such as the minimum wage, and give the anarchy of the market a free hand to destroy industries and jobs, without any planning or provision of education and retraining. It’s a libertarian’s dream – and a nightmare for the working class. Some free-market fanatics, meanwhile, have even advocated the idea of a relatively large UBI payment, but (and here’s the catch) only on the proviso that pesky public services – such as healthcare and education – are scrapped, i.e. privatised, and opened up to profit. Far from strengthening the conquests made by previous generations, therefore, one can see how the demand for a UBI can equally be raised by those looking to roll back and destroy such gains. Rather than increasing the welfare state in a progressive way by redistributing society’s colossal wealth, a UBI could instead become a deeply regressive fig leaf for a wholesale attack on – and privatisation of – public services, bolstering the capitalist market instead of weakening it.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- UBI

UBI papers over the contradictions of the system and rationalizes the underlying structure of the economic system

Lyon 21 [Rob, International Coordinator for Socialist Action/Ligue pour lÁction Socialiste, political organizer for the New Democratic Youth, “Canada: socialism or UBI?” 03/01/21, ]

It should also be understood that the only way such a UBI reform would ever actually be implemented in a meaningful way is if the capitalists felt threatened, i.e. if the capitalist system itself were at risk. History has shown that when the class struggle reaches such a level of intensity that the ruling elites will be prepared to offer reforms from above to prevent revolution from below. However, even in this case, our demand would not be for UBI, but for socialist revolution. In that situation, why would we support a last-ditch reform to save capitalism, when we could put forward a position for the overthrow of capitalism? This points to one of the main problems with reformist demands like UBI. The demand is rooted in classical reformism: through their policies and program, what the reformists are really saying is that the capitalist mode of production is fine, the private ownership of the means of production is sacrosanct and must be preserved, and that it is only the capitalist mode of distribution that is distorted and needs correcting, i.e. we just need to lessen the inequality a little bit to avoid the chaos of revolution. All these proposals and reforms, which amount basically to taxing the rich to pay for social services (or for UBI), only paper over the contradictions of capitalism, they do nothing to solve the fundamental problem. The reformist proponents of UBI fail to pose the question from a class perspective. They ignore an analysis of who actually owns and controls the wealth in society, and they ignore the question how this control of the wealth was obtained in the first place. CRB does benefit the workers, but it was implemented under capitalism by a capitalist party running a capitalist government. This means that CRB was ultimately implemented in the interests of the capitalist class. It would be the same with UBI. UBI implemented under capitalism would ultimately serve the interests of the ruling class. If a universal basic income were introduced, it would be subject to the same pressures and efforts other social services are under. It would come under the pressure of austerity. UBI is an attempt to save capitalism from its own contradictions, but ultimately preserves low-wage work in the private sector by having the state absorb unemployment and getting the working class to pay for the costs through taxation. A universal basic income would really be a wage subsidy for the bosses, who should be paying higher wages and providing benefits. These are what we should be fighting for in terms of reforms. On this basis, you could see UBI becoming a roadblock to struggles for decent pay, better working conditions, minimum wage increases, etc. We must fight for vast improvements in the benefits for the unemployed, the poor and the disabled, but rather than fight for UBI, we should fight for decent wages and for the expansion of public services like healthcare, housing, child care, education and public transit. Fighting for expanded social services is part of the class struggle, and in this sense is part and parcel of the struggle for the socialist transformation of society. Being based on the idea of wage top ups out of tax revenues, UBI essentially amounts to supporting the status quo. This means accepting low wages and precarious work. Social programmes and public services have been attacked and gutted for decades, and the reformists have come to the conclusion that we should compensate for this with a universal basic income rather than fighting against austerity, rather than fighting for increased social services, rather than fighting for the socialist transformation of society. UBI lets the bosses off the hook of the class struggle and in this regard it actually rationalizes and signals an acquiescence to austerity. UBI means accepting the class rule of the bourgeoisie. It means accepting austerity, low-wages, precarious employment. It fundamentally means accepting the status quo of capitalism in an attempt to paper over the contradictions of the system with a meagre cash payment.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- UBI

Even best case UBI gets coopted or circumvented through other economic means

Lyon 21 [Rob, International Coordinator for Socialist Action/Ligue pour lÁction Socialiste, political organizer for the New Democratic Youth, “Canada: socialism or UBI?” 03/01/21, ]

An added weakness of UBI is that even when it is proposed with the best of reformist intentions, the fact that it is also being put forward by the right wing means that it is open to co-option. A Liberal government fighting to survive may rhetorically adopt UBI to steal NDP votes, only to turn around and use it as a fig-leaf for cuts in social programs. An NDP government capitulating to capitalist pressure could do something similar, jettisoning the expansion of the welfare state and corporate taxes, leaving behind only a cash payment funded via deficits and inflation. The left-UBIers also cannot escape the problem of any proposal to tax the rich while they continue owning the means of production. Any plan that genuinely taxes the rich and redistributes wealth will not be accepted by the capitalists. If you tax the rich they will not invest. They will take their capital overseas, close factories and make millions unemployed. This is why the key question is not taxation and redistribution, but ownership. You cannot plan what you do not control and you cannot control what you do not own.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- UBI

UBI is simultaneously too utopian and not utopian enough. They imagine that the capitalist class will peacefully give over their wealth, but they cannot imagine the end of capitalism itself. UBI without class struggle is ideological mystification

Booth 17 [Adam, PhD in Environmental Engineering from Cambridge University, Editor of Socialist Appeal, founder of the Cambridge Marxist Discussion Group, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” 02/10/17, ]

Before continuing, let us make one thing crystal clear: the money clearly does exist to provide a decent UBI payment to all – and at levels far beyond $10,000. As has already been noted, according to the recent Oxfam report on global inequality, just eight billionaires own as much wealth as the poorest half of the world’s population. Meanwhile, big business in the USA sits on an idle cash pile of around $1.9 trillion dollars. The problem, however, is not economic, but political. To implement a genuinely progressive UBI would constitute the most ambitious and radical shake up of the redistributive taxation system since the cradle-to-grave welfare state was introduced in the post-war period. And yet, at a time when all these gains of the past are under attack from austerity, we see various well-meaning left-wingers calling for the UBI and proposing a titanic challenge to capital, with huge tax increases on the rich and corporations. Everywhere we look, social democracy and reformism is in retreat as a result of the crisis of capitalism. Elected “left” governments, such as Syriza in Greece and Hollande’s “Socialists” in France, far from carrying out progressive programmes of tax-and-spend, have been forced by the dictatorship of the banks to implement cuts and counter-reforms. But never mind all that: double or nothing! In this respect, the demand for a UBI is only the latest utopian proposal from a naïve layer of the left who imagine that austerity is ideological, and that we can – somehow, surely – persuade the rich and wealthy to kindly and quietly pass over the money for the good of society. This, at root, is what the advocates of UBI are relying on and hoping for: the benevolence and philanthropy of the capitalists and the establishment politicians who represent them. Whilst the occasional multi-billionaire such as Bill Gates might well part with a small portion of their vast fortune voluntarily for charitable causes (and even then, often only as a cynical PR stunt), the capitalist class as a whole – in the final analysis – are in business to make a profit. And they do not – and never have – appreciated having their private wealth forcibly taken from them to fund the rest of society; hence the almost farcical tax-dodging schemes that the world’s biggest businesses are scandalously embroiled in. As Warren Buffett, the renowned billionaire investor, stated emphatically after pointing out that he pays less tax than his receptionist: “there’s class warfare, all right – but it’s my class, the rich class, that’s making war, and we’re winning!” Again, we should stress that the wealth is most definitely there in society to fund a genuinely progressive UBI system. But the only way such a reform would ever actually be introduced in any meaningful way is if the capitalists felt threatened to the point that they feared losing everything; that is, if the class struggle reached such intense and heightened levels that the ruling elites offered reforms from above to prevent revolution from below. And even then, in such a situation, the demand would have to be not for UBI, but for socialist revolution! If the demand for UBI is to be posed and fought for by the Left, then it cannot be done so in a manner divorced from the question of class struggle. We cannot rely on the altruism of the rich and the compassion of the capitalist state, the essence of which – as Engels explained and Lenin underlined – consists of “special bodies of armed men” in defence of the property and interests of the ruling class. Particularly at a time when governments everywhere are prostrating themselves before the “invisible hand” of the market, therefore, it is pure utopianism to suggest that the capitalists will happily and calmly agree to hand over their wealth to fund a decent UBI, or that the bourgeois state would ever be willing to begin on undertaking such a task. The main limit of the call for a progressive UBI, as with all reformist demands, is that it fails to pose the question from a class perspective – that is, to analyse who actually owns and controls the wealth and technology in society, and, most importantly, how they have come to have such control in the first place. The problem with the UBI (and reformist policies in general), in other words, arises from its almost exclusive focus on the issue of distribution, rather than production. As Marx comments in his Critique of the Gotha Programme (a similarly reformist and utopian programme put forward by Marx’s socialist peers, the Lassalleans): “Quite apart from the analysis so far given, it was in general a mistake to make a fuss about so-called distribution and put the principal stress on it. “Any distribution whatever of the means of consumption is only a consequence of the distribution of the conditions of production themselves. The latter distribution, however, is a feature of the mode of production itself. The capitalist mode of production, for example, rests on the fact that the material conditions of production are in the hands of non-workers in the form of property in capital and land, while the masses are only owners of the personal condition of production, of labour power. If the elements of production are so distributed, then the present-day distribution of the means of consumption results automatically. If the material conditions of production are the co-operative property of the workers themselves, then there likewise results a distribution of the means of consumption different from the present one. “Vulgar socialism (and from it in turn a section of the democrats) has taken over from the bourgeois economists the consideration and treatment of distribution as independent of the mode of production and hence the presentation of socialism as turning principally on distribution. After the real relation has long been made clear, why retrogress again?” (our emphasis) These words ring even more true today. By focussing on the question of taxation and redistribution, the modern leaders of the labour movement actually end up aiming their fire at the wrong people, alienating the middle classes with talk of taxes on incomes and personal property, rather than attacking the super-rich of the capitalist class, whose wealth is tied up in profits and capital – often far beyond the reaches of the state’s tax collectors. The emphasis for socialists, therefore, as Marx stresses, should not be on redistributing the wealth that has already been created in society (through taxation and welfare, etc.), but rather on having collective and democratic control over the means by which new wealth is created – that is, the means of production. If such a rational plan of production was implemented, then questions of taxation, inheritance, redistribution, welfare, and so on, would quickly disappear. For Marxists, the question of inequality, whilst important, is secondary. At root, our criticism of capitalism lies primarily not with these symptoms of the senile system, but with its fundamental disease: the laws of capitalism itself; the barriers of private ownership, competition, and production for profit, which stand in the way of the development of the productive forces – of industry and science, technology and technique, and art and culture. As Leon Trotsky, the great Russian revolutionary and theoretician, commented in his Marxist masterpiece Revolution Betrayed, “The fundamental evil of the capitalist system is not the extravagance of the possessing classes, however disgusting that may be in itself, but the fact that in order to guarantee its right to extravagance the bourgeoisie maintains its private ownership of the means of production, thus condemning the economic system to anarchy and decay.” (Leon Trotsky, Revolution Betrayed, chapter 1) Today we see this “fundamental evil” of “anarchy and decay” vividly displayed by the contradiction of enormous cash piles in the hands of the big business alongside historically low levels of investment and stagnant productivity growth; by the absurdity of the potential for mass automation alongside fears of technological unemployment; by the concerns over forced idleness for millions, instead of the realisation of voluntary leisure for all. UBI, for all its attempts to paper over the cracks, does nothing to stop this anarchy of the market and resolve the crisis of overproduction that has led society to this impasse. Indeed, as Marxists have always emphasised, no amount of reforms can unravel these fundamental contradictions of capitalism. Only the revolutionary transformation of society can cut through this Gordian knot. “Wages for housework” Notably, there are also feminist advocates of UBI who support the demand on the grounds that a payment of this nature would challenge present notions about work, demonstrating the value of currently unpaid – but socially necessary – labour, such as housework. But the associated call of “wages for housework” is not a socialist demand. Marxists do not wish for women (or men) to be compensated monetarily for their domestic labour – that is, to create wage labourers in the home alongside wage labourers in the workplace. Instead, Marxists wish to do away with the concept of domestic work altogether: to take these currently privately performed tasks out of the hands of individual families – out of the walls of isolated homes – and to organise these socially necessary tasks in a social manner, as part of a rational plan of production. Only by socialising the question of childcare and domestic tasks, and removing this burden of labour off the shoulders of working class women, can we expect to achieve genuine gender equality in society. As Engels remarks in Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State: “The emancipation of woman will only be possible when woman can take part in production on a large, social scale, and domestic work no longer claims anything but an insignificant amount of her time. And only now has that become possible through modern large-scale industry, which does not merely permit of the employment of female labour over a wide range, but positively demands it, while it also tends towards ending private domestic labour by changing it more and more into a public industry.” (Frederick Engels, Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State, chapter 9) The only way to instigate real, permanent change in society, therefore, is not to pay women for their domestic work, but to take domestic, unwaged labour outside of the individual home altogether; to make this labour a social task that is the responsibility of society as a whole; and ultimately to invest in new machinery and technology that allows for us to abolish this work altogether. The invention of household machines such as the microwave, the dishwasher, and the washing machine have helped to massively reduce the time needed for domestic duties. The challenge now is to take this technology and put it under public and democratic control; to socialise these tasks as part of a socialist plan of production; and thus to liberate both working women and working men from the scourge of domestic labour. Wages, income, and the UBI Within modern capitalism, where the working class has managed to secure for itself – through struggle – publicly-funded services, such as the NHS, and a welfare state, the “income” a worker receives is effectively split into two parts: a wage paid by the employer in exchange for labour-power; and a “social wage” of publicly-provided benefits and services that are free at the point of use and provided on the basis of need, without any money being handed over. Under socialism, the ratio between these two components would shift dramatically towards the latter. The unseen “social wage” would vastly increase, whilst the wage paid in exchange for labour-power would be diminished (in relative terms – the total would of course increase as society’s wealth grows). Instead of just receiving healthcare without any monetary transaction required, transport, housing, electricity, food, clothes, etc.: all of these, and even things currently considered “luxury items”, could be provided without any exchange as part of a socialist plan of production. The concept of value would gradually become meaningless and the money system would wither away. With UBI, however, a third income variant is introduced: alongside the paid wage and “social wage”, we now have also the unconditional monetary payment of the UBI. For those on the libertarian right who are in favour of UBI, the introduction of this universal payment acts not to strengthen the socialist element of the “social wage”, but to weaken it, (as discussed earlier) by using the UBI as a pretext for opening up public services to privatisation. Similarly, the introduction of UBI might also be used to justify the elimination of important reforms such as the minimum wage, putting workers on the back foot in the battle against the bosses. Far from eroding the power of money and the market, then, the UBI could serve to consolidate and bolster these forces. Those on the Left who most enthusiastically and unthinkingly call for a UBI must therefore be careful what they wish for. Again, rather than embracing the ambiguous and dubious demand of UBI, the leaders of the labour movement should be pushing the call for nationalisation and workers’ control back to the fore. The greatest irony regarding UBI is that those on the Left calling for it openly recognise all the glaring contradictions present in capitalist society, but then choose to turn the problem on its head, suggesting everything but the solution itself. They see the irrationality of mass unemployment alongside overwork; of inequality increasing whilst technology advances; of automation that enslaves us rather than liberates us: and yet they accept these irrationalities as a given fact – admitting to capitalism’s failings, but refusing to recognise capitalism as the root of the problem. As with all reformist demands, the advocates of UBI are willing to propose the most extraordinary and utopian measures, as long as these do not challenge the one right that they consider to be the most inviolable and sacrosanct of all: that of private property. Indeed, it has even been suggested that UBI could be a “capitalist road to communism” – that is, to Marx’s maxim, “from each according to their ability; to each according to their needs.” For such venerable ladies and gentlemen, competition and the pursuit of profit may be responsible for the scourge of inequality, unemployment, and economic crisis that blights society – but to suggest abolishing the anarchy of the market is pure blasphemy. After all, as we revolutionaries are so frequently reminded – we must be realistic! Indeed, for some, as Thomas Paine – the English-American Enlightenment political philosopher and one of the Founding Father of the United States – argued, a form of UBI would be a tit-for-tat entitlement to all citizens conditional on them accepting the very existence of private property. As the Economist notes: “Thomas Paine would have relished such a prospect. His case for a basic income justified it as a quid pro quo for the existence of private property. Before the advent of private property, he believed, all men had been able to support themselves through hunting and forage. When that resort is taken from them, they should be compensated by means of a ‘natural inheritance’ of £15 to be paid to all men every year, financed from a ‘ground rent’ charged to property owners.” Instead of calling for a UBI, socialists should be using this question to expose the irrationalities, absurdities, and contradictions of capitalism. Our demand should not be for a UBI, where economic control remains in the hands of a tiny rich elite, and where money continues to flow into the pockets of parasitic capitalists. Our demand must be for nationalisation of the key levers of the economy and for workers’ power. Rather than demanding a basic income for those who are made obsolete by automation, we should be calling for necessary work to be shared out, with the hours of the working day reduced for all. But this is only possible on the basis of an economic system based on needs, not profits. Furthermore, we should highlight the potential for a genuine socialist society, where mankind and machine exist in harmony: a society of superabundance; of “fully automated luxury communism”, where the motto “from each according to their ability; to each according to their need” can finally be realised in practice.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- UBI

UBI’s focus on distribution distracts from the modes of production – economic inequality is only a symptom of the system of private ownership and free market competition

Booth 17 [Adam, PhD in Environmental Engineering from Cambridge University, Editor of Socialist Appeal, founder of the Cambridge Marxist Discussion Group, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” 02/10/17, ]

The main limit of the call for a progressive UBI, as with all reformist demands, is that it fails to pose the question from a class perspective – that is, to analyse who actually owns and controls the wealth and technology in society, and, most importantly, how they have come to have such control in the first place. The problem with the UBI (and reformist policies in general), in other words, arises from its almost exclusive focus on the issue of distribution, rather than production. As Marx comments in his Critique of the Gotha Programme (a similarly reformist and utopian programme put forward by Marx’s socialist peers, the Lassalleans): “Quite apart from the analysis so far given, it was in general a mistake to make a fuss about so-called distribution and put the principal stress on it. “Any distribution whatever of the means of consumption is only a consequence of the distribution of the conditions of production themselves. The latter distribution, however, is a feature of the mode of production itself. The capitalist mode of production, for example, rests on the fact that the material conditions of production are in the hands of non-workers in the form of property in capital and land, while the masses are only owners of the personal condition of production, of labour power. If the elements of production are so distributed, then the present-day distribution of the means of consumption results automatically. If the material conditions of production are the co-operative property of the workers themselves, then there likewise results a distribution of the means of consumption different from the present one. “Vulgar socialism (and from it in turn a section of the democrats) has taken over from the bourgeois economists the consideration and treatment of distribution as independent of the mode of production and hence the presentation of socialism as turning principally on distribution. After the real relation has long been made clear, why retrogress again?” (our emphasis) These words ring even more true today. By focussing on the question of taxation and redistribution, the modern leaders of the labour movement actually end up aiming their fire at the wrong people, alienating the middle classes with talk of taxes on incomes and personal property, rather than attacking the super-rich of the capitalist class, whose wealth is tied up in profits and capital – often far beyond the reaches of the state’s tax collectors. The emphasis for socialists, therefore, as Marx stresses, should not be on redistributing the wealth that has already been created in society (through taxation and welfare, etc.), but rather on having collective and democratic control over the means by which new wealth is created – that is, the means of production. If such a rational plan of production was implemented, then questions of taxation, inheritance, redistribution, welfare, and so on, would quickly disappear. For Marxists, the question of inequality, whilst important, is secondary. At root, our criticism of capitalism lies primarily not with these symptoms of the senile system, but with its fundamental disease: the laws of capitalism itself; the barriers of private ownership, competition, and production for profit, which stand in the way of the development of the productive forces – of industry and science, technology and technique, and art and culture. As Leon Trotsky, the great Russian revolutionary and theoretician, commented in his Marxist masterpiece Revolution Betrayed, “The fundamental evil of the capitalist system is not the extravagance of the possessing classes, however disgusting that may be in itself, but the fact that in order to guarantee its right to extravagance the bourgeoisie maintains its private ownership of the means of production, thus condemning the economic system to anarchy and decay.” (Leon Trotsky, Revolution Betrayed, chapter 1) Today we see this “fundamental evil” of “anarchy and decay” vividly displayed by the contradiction of enormous cash piles in the hands of the big business alongside historically low levels of investment and stagnant productivity growth; by the absurdity of the potential for mass automation alongside fears of technological unemployment; by the concerns over forced idleness for millions, instead of the realisation of voluntary leisure for all. UBI, for all its attempts to paper over the cracks, does nothing to stop this anarchy of the market and resolve the crisis of overproduction that has led society to this impasse. Indeed, as Marxists have always emphasised, no amount of reforms can unravel these fundamental contradictions of capitalism. Only the revolutionary transformation of society can cut through this Gordian knot.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

Green capitalism is the primary driver of modern accumulation – the aff appropriates ecological crisis to serve the ideological framework of capital

Nikula 17 [Ilari, PhD Researcher in Social and Economic Geography at the University of Lapland; "Neoliberal Environmentalism," 08/06/17, ]

Mueller and Passadakis (2009; 2010) have argued that the ecological crisis has been placed at the heart of the growth strategy of the present neoliberal regime. They point that green capitalism is now the main driver of a new round of capitalist accumulation. This is seen, for example, in initiatives like The Green New Deal (GND) that was announced by the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) in 2008. It is a proposed set of policy proposals that aim to address global warming and financial crisis. They include schemes for reducing incentives to invest in ‘dirty’ over ‘clean’ industries, creating systematic measurements for ecosystem valuations, like consistent global carbon, emissions and water charges (UNEP 2011, 9, 14, 29). These proposals also strive for trade liberalization, safeguarding market access of individuals, credit availability and microcredit programmes (ibid., 9-10, 31, 34). Green parties that are pushing the GND policies are hailed as a “market-friendly engine of innovation” and the GND is described as a “stimulus package for the ecological technologies of the future” (Mueller and Passadakis 2009, 55). The director of UNEP summed it up when announcing UNEP’s two-year GND project in 2008: “The new, green economy would provide a new engine of growth, putting the world on the road to prosperity again” (quoted in Mueller and Passadakis 2010, 560). Indeed, UNEP (2011, 38) further defines that the so-called “trade-off” between economic progress and environmental sustainability is a myth. GND proposals have been criticized, especially in the developing countries, in that they undermine national sovereignty, set a green "normative straightjacket" for developing countries, and that they signal a "privatization and commodification of nature” (Vedeld 2011, 28). Critics also refer that these global prescriptions consider too little the local consequences of such solutions, saying that local solutions might have much more potential in terms of their sustainability (ibid., 16). Mueller and Passadakis (2010, 555) suggest that the ecological threat has given global institutions like World Bank, IMF, WTO and G8 a way to overcome the legitimation problem they have been having. If there ever was a real antagonism between environmental reason and neoliberal capitalism, it has now been internalized by both.2 In addition to the policies of global institutions, this has also happened in our everyday lives, inasmuch as “sustainability [has become] a political attitude of the multitude” (Parr 2009, 4). Slavoj Žižek (2009) notes that consuming has now become ecologically ethical. Consuming has become an act for the environment as ‘green’ and ‘socially responsible’ companies claim to sell an ethical framework as well as a product, thus freeing buyers from the distasteful role of being merely consumers. In products labeled e.g. “environmentally friendly” one doesn’t buy just a product, one buys, in the very consumerist act, a “redemption from being only a consumerist.” One act of egotist consumerism, but within it one pairs for being redeemed for it as the “act of egotist consumption already includes the price for its ethical opposite.” Save the planet by shopping.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

The Green New Deal is a trap that diverts class struggle into the dead end of the Democratic Party – turns solvency and guarantees the link

Dyne & Grey 19 [Bryan, Barry, US national editor of the World Socialist Web Site, member of the national committee of the Socialist Equality Party, “The fallacies and evasions of the Green New Deal,” World Socialist Web Site, 03/05/19, ]

The entire social structure of the United States, and therefore its political system, is anchored in the vast concentration of wealth at the very top. Speaking of a return to “Gilded Age levels” of inequality, the economist Gabriel Zucman recently wrote: “What the data show is that wealth concentration in the United States has returned to the level of 1920. Forty percent of total household wealth belongs to the top 1 percent. About 20 percent belongs to the top 0.1 percent, which is about the same as the bottom 90 percent’s wealth share.” This is part of an international process. Earlier this year the British charity Oxfam reported that in 2018, just 26 people controlled as much wealth as the 3.8 billion people who comprise the bottom half of the world’s population. No genuine social reform can be enacted today outside of a direct assault on social inequality and the entrenched wealth and power of the corporate-financial oligarchy. That includes the political parties it controls. The other basic obstacle to resolving the climate crisis and all of the other social ills that plague humankind is the division of the increasingly integrated world economy between rival nation-states, which are the political forms through which the competing national cliques of capitalists fight for control of the world’s resources, markets and sources of cheap labor. Climate change is a global problem and can be solved only through the systematic and intelligent mobilization of the resources and scientific and technological know-how of the entire planet. The Green New Deal is not a program to address the urgent social needs of working people in the US. It is a hollow slogan and grab-bag of demands meant to divert the growing struggle of the working class into the dead end of the Democratic Party. The solution to climate change, along with social inequality, poverty and the growing threat of dictatorship and war, is the revolutionary overthrow of the capitalist system, both in the US and internationally. The financial oligarchs must be expropriated and their corporations and banks turned into public utilities under the democratic control of the working population. The social force capable of carrying out such a transformation is the working class. It must be mobilized and armed with a revolutionary socialist program to take political power and establish a workers’ state, as part of the world socialist revolution. The Socialist Equality Party must be built to lead this struggle.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

The Green New Deal is mobilized through an imperialist frame of national capitalist expansion – it is incapable of solving climate change or class struggle

Dyne & Grey 19 [Bryan, Barry, US national editor of the World Socialist Web Site, member of the national committee of the Socialist Equality Party, “The fallacies and evasions of the Green New Deal,” World Socialist Web Site, 03/05/19, ]

It is an established scientific fact that human-induced climate change has already cost billions of dollars and caused thousands of deaths, and is poised to inflict exponentially greater social misery if it is not immediately abated and reversed. Repeated studies have shown that it will require the coordination of the most advanced scientific and technical resources the world over in order to even begin to seriously reduce global warming. Such measures would require an international reorganization of the world’s energy industry. The Green New Deal resolution, however, neither calls for the cooperation of the nations of the world nor places any limits on the activities of the energy corporations. Quite the opposite, it insists on “making the United States the international leader on climate action” by calling for “investments to spur economic development [and] deepen and diversify industry and business in local and regional economies.” These investments would be allocated by means of “community grants, public banks, and other public financing.” In other words, more public funds will be handed over to the US energy monopolies and other corporate interests, the same institutions that are responsible for climate change in the first place. Any measures ostensibly aimed at reducing climate change will have to be acceptable to corporations and banks and their wealthy shareholders. Far from advancing an internationalist perspective, the Green New Deal resolution has a distinctly nationalist axis. It makes an unambiguous appeal to the national security agencies of the American state, first by citing as a model the “Federal Government-led mobilizations during World War II,” and, second, by arguing that climate change “constitutes a direct threat to the national security of the United States by impacting the economic, environmental and social stability of countries and communities around the world and acting as a threat multiplier.” The not-so-subtle suggestion here is that the adoption of the Green New Deal is an essential component of US imperialism’s preparations for war against its rivals for world domination and necessary for the stability of US capitalism. It should not be forgotten that the “Government-led mobilization during World War II” included the mass incarceration of Japanese-Americans and ended with the nuclear incineration of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. “National security,” a euphemism for the continued rule of the capitalist class and the pursuit of its global profit interests, is incompatible with any serious mobilization of resources to meet the social needs of working people, including a healthful and life-sustaining environment. Numerous national security think tank studies have stressed the need to drastically reduce so-called “entitlement” spending, i.e., funding for Social Security and Medicare, as well as spending for other social programs in order to carry out the military expansion and modernization necessary to prepare for war against the major rivals of American imperialism, in the first instance Russia and China.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

Appeals to green tech are a delaying tactic to maintain the status quo. Tech can only solve when organized and produced in a post-capitalist society

Black 21 [Emma, Co-convenor of the Melbourne School of Continental Philosophy, “Capitalism’s fake solutions to the climate crisis,” Red Flag, 05/23/21, ]

“Net zero by 2050” (or 2060 in China’s case) has become the new mainstream political mantra on climate change. However, this ambitious-sounding, yet still far from adequate, goal is premised on a series of new technologies that remain untested at best and completely hypothetical at worst. The name dropping of an array of these high-tech “solutions” to the climate crisis was a feature of US President Joe Biden’s Earth Day summit in April. Among those in which Biden has promised to invest US$35 billion as part of his proposed American Jobs Plan are carbon capture and storage, hydrogen, nuclear, floating offshore wind, biofuels and electric vehicles. While the disappearance of the outright climate denialism of the Trump era might seem cause for celebration, the new trend for spruiking the magical power of technology to solve the climate crisis is cause for serious concern. When you look beyond the headline-grabbing announcements of increased long-term ambition, the Earth Day summit amounted to little more than another case of government greenwashing of the business as usual of fossil-fuelled capitalism. Instead of detailing the changes to be made in the here and now to reduce emissions, Biden and other world leaders instead promoted faith in the capacity of science and technology to come to the rescue at an indeterminate point in the future. Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison was among them. While the media highlighted the supposed gulf between a progressive, “green” Biden and the conservative, fossil-fuel-loving Morrison, they both promoted the same faith in the powers of technology. Like Biden, Morrison has vowed to invest tens of billions of dollars in developing carbon capture and storage technologies, “clean” hydrogen, “blue” carbon and “green” steel—among other colourful innovations. In May’s federal budget, the Coalition allocated more than half a billion dollars to developing the first two of these technologies—$263.7 million for carbon capture and storage (CCS) and $275.5 million for “clean” hydrogen. CCS mostly involves capturing C02 emissions at their source—in mines, power stations and so on—and pumping them deep underground (so the theory goes) to be permanently stored in appropriately porous and stable rock formations. But despite politicians and business leaders spruiking CCS as an easy fix for the climate crisis for decades, it has never been shown to work on anything near the scale required. Australia already boasts the world’s largest, supposedly functional, CCS facility at Chevron’s Gorgon gas project in Western Australia. However, according to the Climate Council, “the Gorgon CCS trial has been a big, expensive failure ... capturing less than half the emissions needed to make CCS viable”. In what is only the latest in a series of problems since it became operational in 2019, Michael Mazengarb reported in Renew Economy earlier this year that pumping equipment required to clear water from the undersea formation into which the C02 is to be injected had become clogged with sand. However, while CCS may be useless for addressing climate change, it remains an extremely useful political tool for the government—providing it with green cover while it continues to funnel money to Coalition supporters in the coal and gas industries. And of course, it’s also useful for those companies on the receiving end of the government’s “green” largesse. Bernard Keane was right in his assessment of it as a scam in Crikey. “Fossil fuel interests”, he wrote in 2019, “sense the opportunity to extract some taxpayer funding from a government worried it might have to pretend it believes in climate change”. With this year’s budget, they hit the jackpot. But if CCS is a scam, what about “clean” hydrogen? In his speech to the Earth Day summit, Morrison vowed to rival US innovation by investing billions in high-tech “hydrogen valleys”. “In the United States you have the Silicon Valley”, he said. “Here in Australia we are creating our own ‘Hydrogen Valleys’, where we will transform our transport industries, our mining and resource sectors, our manufacturing, our fuel and energy production.” Hydrogen is potentially a clean energy source, but only if it’s produced using renewable energy. And to be produced at the scale required to transform the economy in the way Morrison is implying would require a lot of electricity. In his recent contribution to the Quarterly Essay, Australia’s former chief scientist, Alan Finkel, calculates that to produce the equivalent volume of hydrogen to what Australia currently exports in liquefied natural gas would require “approximately 2,200 terawatt-hours” of electricity. This, Finkel notes, “is about eight times Australia’s total electricity generation in 2019”. If Morrison genuinely believes the “hydrogen boom” he envisages will be based on production of renewable energy on that kind of scale, the government would have provided increased funding for renewables in the budget. None was forthcoming. The reality is that Morrison sees the talk of “hydrogen valleys” as a way of greenwashing the same old “gas-fired recovery” he was promoting last year. The government doesn’t envisage producing hydrogen with electricity from renewables, but rather from gas. The focus on CCS gives the game away. The “hydrogen valleys” of the future will be criss-crossed with pipelines and peppered with gas-fired power stations with (we’re supposed to believe) the magic of CCS ensuring that the whole operation can nevertheless be run green and guilt-free. “Clean” hydrogen then, just like CCS, turns out to be just another technological chimera designed to greenwash capitalism’s continuing addiction to fossil fuels. What then of the other technological solutions being touted? Perhaps the most headline grabbing of them has been Biden’s proposed US$174 billion investment in the infrastructure for electric vehicles and their production. On the surface, again, this might sound like a good idea. Who wouldn’t want to live in a world in which we can all drive around in sleek, silent, powerful and “green” electric vehicles like Teslas? Again, however, this is just another fake technological “fix” to the climate crisis that will help perpetuate the environmentally destructive status quo. A genuinely sustainable society won’t be built around the kind of car culture that exists today. What’s needed, among other things, is a massive investment in public transport and the transformation of cities to reduce the need for long commutes. The promotion of electric vehicles as part of a technological “green” utopia is designed to forestall this kind of change, to protect as much as possible the car makers and other big business interests that profit from the status quo. Elon Musk personifies this. In his authorised biography, Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future, Ashlee Vance revealed that Musk’s California “hyperloop” proposal was aimed at quashing plans for a high-speed rail link between Los Angeles and San Francisco. “Musk had dished out the Hyperloop proposal just to make the public and legislators rethink the high-speed train”, wrote Vance. “He didn’t intend to build the thing ... With any luck, the high-speed rail would be cancelled. Musk said as much to me during a series of emails and phone calls leading up to the announcement.” For those who can afford it (a base-level Tesla will set you back an eye-watering $73,900 in Australia today), driving an electric car might make you feel like you’re doing something to help save the planet. This is an illusion. Even if your car is charged from electricity produced by renewable energy, you also have to consider all the emissions produced in the construction and maintenance of the roads and freeways on which you drive. Then there’s the material of the car itself, and the lithium needed for the battery. Already, the skyrocketing demand is causing major environmental problems for major lithium producers like China, Chile and Bolivia. Tellingly, Musk has already devised the ultimate escape plan for himself—moving to Mars. This is not an option for most people. The long list of fake technological fixes to the climate crisis is nothing more than a delaying tactic, designed to create the impression of change to ensure the profits bonanza of the fossil fuel economy can continue for as long as possible. Only a total transformation of society, in which technological production is rationally designed and democratically organised and controlled, can ensure that we are able, in Marx’s words, “to bequeath the Earth in an improved state to succeeding generations”.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

GND is symbolic green gesturing that locks in climate extinction

Abbott- philosophy professor at Federation University- 21.

MATHEW ABBOTT- lecturer in philosophy at Federation University Australia. STEVEN CHANG- n academic librarian at La Trobe University. Jacobin. The Victorian “Green New Deal” Is Really an Exercise in Greenwashing. . 02.04.2021. DOA: 06/17/23. AR.

Anti-Capitalist Realism This proliferation of symbolic green gesturing is a challenge for ecosocialists who must learn to distinguish between green branding and the radical changes that are really needed. If we buy into green illusions, it could detract from the urgency of mobilizing while leaving the power of capital over the environment unchecked. Indeed, ambiguities like this may have been a blind spot resulting from the broad politics and soaring rhetoric that are associated with the more radical, transformative GNDs. The market is a key driver of climate change and the only solution is rational, democratic planning — but this will cut into corporate profits. Even if it’s possible to make money from some green technologies, competition will drive ecological destruction elsewhere — and exploitation everywhere. We are not all on the same side, and we never were. To liberals, socialism seems like an unrealistic goal. But the real utopianism is to think that gradualist half-measures will be anywhere near sufficient to halt global heating at 1.5 or even 2°C. Realism means understanding that big polluters won’t give up unrealized stranded assets without conflict. Only a confrontational social movement, building on workers’ power at the point of production, can win such a fight. Ultimately, we will have to force a break with the extractive logic of commodity production and build a planned, socialist economy. But ecosocialists should also reject the fatalistic assumption that steps toward decarbonization are impossible within capitalism. Radical action is both possible and necessary in the 2020s. Instead of subsidizing “green” industry with public money, comprehensive decarbonization will require a direct confrontation with fossil fuel and extractive capital. In other words, a GND is only as good as its class politics. In Australia, the urgency of the environmental crisis is already being used as a pretext to ramp up job insecurity and unsafe working conditions. On a global scale, co-opted GNDs could easily dovetail with imperialism, as states guarantee corporations the ability to profitably extract rare earth metals from the global South. In a similar fashion, neoliberal environmental policies like carbon credits could have disastrous consequences for Indigenous peoples, as companies buy up land to claim offsets. An ecosocialist GND, on the other hand, could stand in solidarity with less developed countries while bolstering First Nations’ sovereignty by funding land management, regeneration, and rewilding programs, under Indigenous control. Rather than constituting a static set of policies, the GND should be viewed as a high-stakes site of contestation. As the Climate Justice Collective has argued, any successful GND must be founded on the “four Ds”: decolonization, decarbonization, decommodification, and democratization. Anything less may fail to halt climate change. Strengthening “green” capital will weaken our side politically, while intensifying the exploitation of the poor and vulnerable.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- link- GND

The Green New Deal is just progressive neoliberalism that reinvests into market mechanisms

Abbott- philosophy professor at Federation University- 21.

MATHEW ABBOTT- lecturer in philosophy at Federation University Australia. STEVEN CHANG- n academic librarian at La Trobe University. Jacobin. The Victorian “Green New Deal” Is Really an Exercise in Greenwashing. . 02.04.2021. DOA: 06/17/23. AR.

Progressive Neoliberalism The standard tactic used by Daniel Andrews is to feint left while maintaining the ALP’s decades-long commitment to privatization and market-based reforms on matters of substance. And when it comes to environmental policy, his approach has always been weak. Meanwhile, the eagerness of the Victorian Greens to compromise on their GND may indicate they are angling for a ministry or a power-sharing arrangement with the Victorian ALP after the next election. Stories like this are increasingly familiar and likely to become more so in the coming decade. It’s part of an emerging pattern in which center-left and even right-wing governments brand themselves as green while pursuing the same neoliberal economic policies. Consider British prime minister Boris Johnson’s recent announcement of a “green industrial revolution” — a plan that offers very little prospect for decarbonization and relies on unproven technologies such as carbon capture and storage, nuclear power, and hydrogen power. Despite the rhetoric, the Tory “green industrial revolution” is neither green nor revolutionary. Meanwhile, under Keir Starmer, the British Labour Party has borrowed GND terminology to sell a timid Green Economic Recovery. A significant retreat from the party’s ambitious £250 billion Corbyn-era package, it abandons previous 2030 decarbonization targets and omits any mention of public ownership or a just transition for workers. Similarly, the European Green Deal has been almost terminally compromised, with fossil fuel lobbyists diluting a green “solution” to a shade of grey. In the United States, Joe Biden has just announced a raft of new executive orders on climate, creating a new White House Office of Domestic Climate Policy and shifting to a “whole-of-government” approach. The announcement mixes GND-style language of “environmental justice” with noncommittal technocratic substance, including “rigorous reviews” of leasing practices and the need to “identify steps that can be taken” toward renewables. Biden has also appointed fossil fuel allies to senior government positions and is still refusing to ban fracking. And there’s good reason to be concerned about the announcement’s “national security” framing. Biden’s apparent shift away from Trump’s destructive environmental agenda may be welcome, but it isn’t yet time to celebrate. Rather, examples like these show the need for greater scrutiny of reforms and announcements that ape the rhetoric of the GND.

2023 GDI Kritik
Capitalism K › Links › 2nc- at- permutation

The K is a prior question. Specific policies can only be understood and evaluated within the social order that they’re being pursued. Even if the plan could exist in a noncapitalist world, the aff gives value to status quo structures by seeking inclusion within them

Azmanova 20 [Albena, Prof of Political and Social Science at the University of Kent, Capitalism on the Edge: How Fighting Precarity Can Achieve Radical Change without Crisis or Utopia, p.56-7]

The problem goes even further. Successful struggles against inequality and exclusion and the structures that enable them do not simply obscure systemic domination: they often enhance it. This happens because such struggles confer value on the system (and the attendant notions of a successful life and an accomplished person) within which we seek equality and inclusion. In this way, struggles against relational and structural domination risk deepening systemic domination. While feminists struggled against the oppressive structure of patriarchy and fought for equality with men in the labor market, women in fact increased the desirability and, ergo, the legitimacy of the competitive production of profit as a systemic dynamic of capitalism. Struggles against global capitalism such as “America First” and Brexit valorize capitalism at home. The welfare state consensus on inclusive growth and redistribution has elevated the value of prosperity into a right to be middle- class, with expectations for ever-improving living standards. This formula of prosperity- for- all remedied the relational injustice of inequality, but did so to a great extent by deepening the systemic injustice of environmental destruction. The protests of the Indignados against austerity policy expressed the paradox of emancipation perfectly in their famous slogan “We are not against the system; the system is against us.” They render the system more valuable through calls for being included in it. This is how the validation of the system often penetrates the language of protest and disables the radicalization of social protest: that is, it prevents the transition from fighting relational forms of injustice to fighting systemic ones. That is why it is imperative that when addressing inequality and exclusion, intellectual critique and political mobilization make sure to also target the very constitutive logic of the social order within which inclusion and equality are being pursued.