2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › LGBTQ – advantage
[Ali, “For LGBTQ People, Recent Anti Discrimination Advances Could Lessen Barriers to Economic Inclusion,” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, June 29, 2022 https://www.cbpp.org/research/poverty-and-inequality/for-lgbtq-people-recent-anti-discrimination-advances-could-lessen, 7/12/2023 GDI-CB]
June is Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) Pride Month, a time to celebrate LGBTQ individuals and families. It is also a time to honor leaders of the fight for LGBTQ rights and to commemorate those lost to anti-LGBTQ violence.Central to Pride Month, which started as a commemoration of the Stonewall Uprising against police brutality, is the ongoing movement for LGBTQ justice. While the nation has made significant gains toward full social inclusion for LGBTQ people in the past two decades, there is more work to be done until every member of the LGBTQ community — and the parents who raise LGBTQ children — can work, learn, and access food, housing, health care, and public benefits without facing discrimination, criminalization, or violence. LGBTQ people face higher rates of discrimination, poverty. Everyone, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity, should have economic stability and opportunity, but discrimination against LGBTQ people is a significant barrier to their full economic inclusion. Nearly 1 in 3 LGBTQ adults reported that discrimination negatively affected their financial well-being to a moderate or significant degree, according to a nationally representative 2020 Center for American Progress survey. Discrimination can make it difficult for LGBTQ people to find and keep work, rent an apartment, receive needed medical care, or meet other basic needs. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Census Bureau included questions about sexual orientation and gender identity for the first time in its Household Pulse Survey. According to Pulse data, LGBTQ adults were more likely to report loss of employment, not having enough to eat, and inability to pay expenses than non-LGBTQ adults. (See Figure 1.) These data align with previous research that LGBTQ people are more likely to have low incomes, and face economic instability at higher rates, than non-LGBTQ people. Pride Month is a time to embrace the diversity of LGBTQ people. There is no singular “LGBTQ experience.” Therefore, addressing LGBTQ poverty requires recognizing the different circumstances of people in different LGBTQ groups. LGBTQ people of color. Structural bias in the labor market and discriminatory governmental policies have led to higher rates of poverty for people of color, and anti-LGBTQ discrimination can put up further barriers to economic stability for LGBTQ people of color. In the 2020 Center for American Progress survey, nearly 4 in 10 Black LGBTQ adults reported that discrimination moderately or significantly affected their financial well-being. Similarly, analyzing Gallup survey data collected between 2012 and 2017, the Williams Institute found that nearly half of LGBTQ people of color reported living in a low-income household. For the approximately 1.3 million LGBTQ immigrants — most of whom are people of color — and their families, multiple barriers to obtaining public benefits that are available to others in times of need present another obstacle to economic inclusion. LGBTQ people with disabilities. LGBTQ people, especially trans and bisexual people, are more likely to have a disability than cisgender straight people. People with disabilities also can face significant barriers to economic inclusion, such as employment discrimination, lack of workplace accommodations, lower pay, higher disability-related costs, and insufficient workplace protections like sick days and paid medical leave. Discrimination is another such barrier; nearly 4 in 10 LGBTQ adults with disabilities reported that discrimination moderately or significantly affected their financial well-being, according to the 2020 Center for American Progress survey. Transgender and non-binary people. Transgender people face the highest rates of poverty and have needs distinct from those of cisgender LGBTQ people. Trans people reported high rates of discrimination when trying to find work, rent an apartment, or attend school in the latest U.S. Transgender Survey from 2015, all of which can limit their opportunities for economic stability and mobility. Moreover, there has been a recent uptick in state policies targeted against trans people and their families, seeking to deny them needed services and the ability to live their lives in accordance with their gender identity. For example, trans and non-binary people may experience discrimination or be denied access to needed benefits or services because their government-issued ID does not reflect their gender identity and chosen name. This is especially concerning given that only one-fifth of trans people in the 2015 survey reported having successfully changed all of their IDs and records to their correct gender identity and name. One-third of trans people in that survey reported not being able to change any of their IDs or records (such as Social Security and school records). Similarly, in the 2020 Center for American Progress survey, 51 percent of trans people reported that discrimination moderately or significantly impacted their ability to obtain accurate identification. Fortunately, there have been significant strides toward more trans-inclusive identification policies. For example, the federal government, as well as 22 states and Washington D.C., allow non-binary people to choose an “X” gender marker. On the other hand, 17 states and two U.S. Territories have policies making it more difficult for trans people to have their gender marker on their driver’s license or birth certificate align with the gender identity, such as requirements that they have undergone gender affirmation surgery. For trans people with criminal records, obtaining accurate ID can be even more challenging. At least 17 states either temporarily or permanently bar people with a criminal record from legally changing their name, and other states require additional scrutiny for those with criminal records. Trans people are disproportionately arrested and incarcerated, often because they had engaged in criminalized activities to earn income to meet their basic needs. Also, due to racial bias, people of color are overrepresented across many dimensions of the criminal legal system, including arrests and incarceration. Therefore, policies limiting the ability of people with criminal records to change their name likely have a disproportionate impact on trans people of color.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › *UBI – Gender empowerment
Iyahen et al , UN Women’s Headquarters, 21
[ Isiuwa, “Universal Basic Income as a means of Gender-Responsive Social Protection”, Joint SGD Fund, 9/22/2021, access info , date accessed 7/13/2023, GDI-AL]
With increasing labour market uncertainty, rising poverty and inequality, all of which have been exacerbated by the COVID-19 shock to economies, the idea of a UBI that is accessible by all has been gaining traction.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Green UBI + carbon tax
Paul, Assistant Professor of Economic and Environmental Studies at New College of Florida, 2021 [Mark, “Greening the basic income”, UNESCO, June 15, access info [https://en.unesco.org/inclusivepolicylab/analytics/greening-basic-income] Accessed 7/11/23 GDI- JY]
The world is in the midst of multiple ongoing crises: the global pandemic, the climate crisis, and a persistent economic inequality crisis that condemns far, far, too many to poverty. As the vaccines begin to roll off the production line, an end to the pandemic is in sight. But the other issues, including continued scarcity amidst abundance, abundance that is helping to fuel the climate crisis, are going to take much longer to address. In these times of runaway inequality and an ever-warming planet, policy makers are increasingly looking for ideas to mitigate emissions and redistribute resources at the same time. One of the biggest ideas gaining traction is a global green new deal.[1] As countries seek to rebuild after this devastating crisis, green investments should unquestionably be front and centre. But complementary bold ideas, including a universal basic income, are catching on too. The hiccup, per usual, is the pesky, and often misguided question of “how do you pay for it?” But what if I told you there was a straightforward policy that could finance a universal basic income and substantially curtail carbon emissions? It is called a carbon price-and-dividend. The policy is simple really: set an economy-wide price on carbon across the globe and rebate the revenue back to the people on an equal per-capita basis. It is true, a carbon price, in the form of a tax or cap, means higher prices, at least in the near future as the transition away from fossil fuels takes hold. But these higher prices will be more than offset for the vast majority of the world's population through the carbon dividend. The math here is rather straightforward: the rich and those living in high-income countries are responsible for the vast majority of greenhouse gas emissions, and thus will pay the bulk of the tax (Gore, 2020). But the money is redistributed to everyone, equally. Thus, low-income people will end up with far more money in their pockets at the end of the day. Such a policy could reduce the Gini coefficient by 3-6% and drastically slash the number of people living in poverty (Davies et al., 2011). This green basic income would be highly progressive while providing people not only with the benefits of cash but cleaner air too. All the while the pricing would curtail emissions as the global community runs out of time to meet the goal established under the Paris Agreement to “limit global warming to well below 2, and preferably 1.5ºC, compared to pre-industrial levels” (UNFCCC, 2015). To account for historic emissions, rich countries could agree to simply forgo their carbon dividends, leaving more money to be redistributed amongst low- and middle-income countries. Either way, the money from a carbon price will not be substantial enough to provide a true basic income for people in middle- and high-income countries, though it would be a substantial basic income for others. Additionally, the income flow will not last forever. One of the major goals of the policy is to facilitate a transition away from fossil fuels, thus the revenue will eventually run out. A carbon price-and-dividend is already in place in Canada and Switzerland, while dozens of other national and sub-national governments have implemented some form of carbon pricing to date. Similar policies, such as the Alaska Permanent Fund have also recognized that common environmental assets—in this case oil—can be leveraged to benefit the people through a form of basic income support. The fund has for decades paid out upwards of $2,000 per resident per year (Boyce, 2019). Carbon pricing is no panacea. Other complementary policies, including large-scale green investments and smart regulations are essential. But a green basic income is a straightforward way to deal with two of our most pressing issues at the same time.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Solvency – environment
Lohan, Tara Lohan is deputy editor of The Revelator and has worked for more than a decade as a digital editor and environmental journalist focused on the intersections of energy, water and climate. Her work has been published by The Nation, American Prospect, High Country News, Grist, Pacific Standard and others. She is the editor of two books on the global water crisis., 2020
[Tara, “Should Environmentalists Embrace Universal Basic Income?”, The Revelator, June 26, 2020, access info [https://therevelator.org/basic-income-climate/] accessed date 7-13-23 (KG)
How would UBI benefit the environment? There are many theories.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Solvency – degrowth
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
It is necessary for the world's nations to move toward a less material-based and more social-service-oriented economy. This model leads toward new societal goals, beyond GDP, and will improve both human and nature's well-being, as is proposed in the first IPBES–IPCC co-sponsored workshop report on biodiversity and climate change (IPBES–IPCC, 2021). There is a need to change the functioning of financial, political, academic, and social institutions. A better future can be achieved through a democratic and redistributive downscaling of the biophysical size of the global economy by means of sustainable degrowth (Kallis, 2011; Schneider et al, 2010), rather than economic decline leading to capitalist crises responsible for recessions and deterioration of social conditions. Such an equitable downscaling should be grounded in reversing the deterioration of the planetary resource base and the consequent environmental degradation. Mainstreamed in conservation policies and plans, a sustainable degrowth strategy would effectively halt biodiversity loss and enhance ecological conditions, while improving human well-being. Sustainable degrowth would also help humanity adapt to a future with fewer resources and more social conflicts. Limits to growth need to be taken into account on a planet with finite resources, as does limited ecological and social carrying capacity; pursuing efficiency gains is not enough. In addition to these general suggestions, we also argue for and provide in Table 1 specific guidelines for a sustainable, degrowth-based biodiversity conservation strategy (Table 1).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Answer to decoupling possible
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
*GHG = Green House Gas
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Answer to decoupling possible
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
There are many reasons ecologists reject an economy based on permanent growth, but chief among them is the fact that the decoupling between economic growth and the ecological impacts is not observed. In fact, a recent report observed that there [is] no empirical evidence supporting the existence of a decoupling of economic growth from en- vironmental pressures on anywhere near the scale needed to deal with environmental breakdown, but also, and perhaps more importantly, such decoupling appears unlikely to happen in the future (Parrique et al., 2019, p. 3; Cf. Hickel & Kallis, 2019).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Degrowth good – solves climate
[Page, “Can We Address the Climate Crisis by “Degrowing”?”, The Sierra Club, December 29, 2022 [https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/can-we-address-climate-crisis-degrowing] 7-12-23 (KG)]
Earlier this year, in the sixth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, two working groups specifically highlighted degrowth policies as a pathway to reducing the impacts of climate change. Lisa Schipper, a lead author for the IPCC, coordinated a team of researchers that assessed 34,000 papers on climate impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability. “Degrowth has reemerged over the last few years out of a frustration with other kinds of economic models,” Schipper told Sierra. “Global forces like consumerism are a big part of why we’re facing climate change, but making a systemic transition away from that is so necessary.”
Some may think of “degrowth” as the latest buzzword—like others might have thought of “climate justice” years ago, or “sustainability” decades before that. But any lofty idea has the potential to ignite real change when defined and implemented locally. Local degrowth movements are cropping up around the world, and many of them are flat, decentralized, and just beginning to mobilize in earnest.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Degrowth good – K of your GDP DAs
[Page, “Can We Address the Climate Crisis by “Degrowing”?”, The Sierra Club, December 29, 2022 [https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/can-we-address-climate-crisis-degrowing] 7-12-23 (KG)]
The economic shift that degrowthers want starts with rethinking metrics that reinforce “business as usual”—namely, GDP. Looking for a way to gauge recovery after the Great Depression and World War II, economist Simon Kuznets first developed a in 1937. The World Bank and International Monetary Fund were eager to easily understand economic activity by individuals, companies, and governments with a single measure, so GDP fit the bill. Soon the metric became the standard tool for appraising a country’s economy and comparing development between nations.
But the metric had one fatal flaw: It measured only market transactions, completely ignoring social costs, environmental impacts, and income inequality. Therefore, Kuznets and his contemporary warned against equating GDP growth with societal welfare. “We must be highly skeptical of the view that long-term changes in the rate of growth of welfare can be gauged even roughly from changes in the rate of growth in output,” in 1959.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Impact - Inequality hurts environment
Green, Department of Political Science University College London and Healy, Geography and Sustainability Department Salem State University, ‘22
[Fergus and Noel. “How Inequality Fuels Climate Change: The Climate Case for a Green New Deal.” One Earth Volume 5 issue 6, Science Direct . GDI-FLC]
It is not only wealthy people’s own consumption that influences emissions. In a context of economic inequality, conspicuous consumption by the wealthy drives society-wide increases in consumption-related GHG emissions, by inducing status-based consumption competition and longer working hours among the rest of the population.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Impact - Inequality hurts environment
Green, Department of Political Science University College London and Healy, Geography and Sustainability Department Salem State University, ‘22
[Fergus and Noel. “How Inequality Fuels Climate Change: The Climate Case for a Green New Deal.” One Earth Volume 5 issue 6, Science Direct . GDI-FLC]
The first focuses on the role of consumption patterns at the top of the income distribution. People tend to consume more goods and services and more energy as their incomes rise, meaning that wealthy people’s consumption causes more emissions than poor people’s. In one study, the consumption-based emissions of the richest 10% of the world’s population were estimated to account for nearly half of global carbon dioxide emissions in 2015 (see ), while other studies put the figure at between 36% and 47% of emissions. Large inequalities in consumption emissions across income deciles have also been reported within countries, especially in high-income and, to a lesser extent, middle-income countries. Substantial cuts in emissions could thus be achieved by reducing income and wealth at the top of the distribution, or more steeply taxing or limiting carbon-intensive luxury consumption. To give an indication of the magnitude of emissions savings that such measures could yield, one study found that global CO2 emissions could be reduced by 30% in 2030 relative to a business-as-usual baseline if the emissions of the 1.1 billion highest emitters globally were capped at the level of their least-polluting member. (The cap envisaged in the study would need to be institutionalized globally; in reality, measures to curb top incomes, wealth, and consumption are likely to be more feasible at the national level than at the global level).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Impact - Inequality hurts environment
Langridge, Department of Social and Policy Sciences University of Bath, et al ’23 [Nicholas. “An ecological basic income? Examining the ecological credentials of basic income through a review of selected pilot interventions”, Basic Income Studies 2023 vol 18 (1) De Gruyter Accessed 7-12-2023. GDI-FLC]
Poverty and inequality create a vicious cycle of debt and insecurity (Kallis et al., 2020), which has multi-generational social impacts (Standing, 2017). Debt also has negative ecological consequences. Paying interest on government bonds requires economic growth, which often sees the slashing of supposed “barriers” to growth, including environmental protections (Hickel, 2020). Similarly, servicing private debt, and generating returns on investments, requires increasing production and consumption within the economy. Over the last 50 years, credit has been encouraged to facilitate economic growth (Kallis et al., 2020). The wider ecological consequences of growth are discussed further below.
The ecological crises have also reached unprecedented levels (IPBES, 2019; IPCC, 2021). As of 2022, at least six of the nine planetary boundaries which define “the safe operating space for humanity with respect to the Earth system” (Rockström et al., 2009, p. 472) have been crossed (Wang-Erlandsson et al., 2022): Greenhouse gas (GHG) concentrations are at a three-million year high (Willeit et al., 2019) putting the world on course for 2.5 °C of warming above pre-industrial levels by the end of the century (UNFCCC, 2022), 25% of all animal and plant species are at risk of extinction within decades (IPBES, 2019), biogeochemical flows are at more than double safe levels (Steffen et al., 2015), and 75% of land is severely degraded (IPBES, 2019).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Impact/solvency – post growth models
*ev is a k of green growth when pursuing only expansion, answers green growth turns
Langridge, Department of Social and Policy Sciences University of Bath, et al ’23 [Nicholas. “An ecological basic income? Examining the ecological credentials of basic income through a review of selected pilot interventions”, Basic Income Studies 2023 vol 18 (1) De Gruyter Accessed 7-12-2023. GDI-FLC]
Environmentalism encapsulates mainstream responses to the crises which refrain from challenging the political and social consensus. Such responses embrace “means-based” development, the belief that the goal of development is simply to expand the total available means of production and consumption (Patnaik, 2010), and the continued expansion of the global economy through the pursuit of “green growth”. Green growth is a strategy for accruing long-term economic benefits through investment in natural capital, environmental protection and clean-up activities, and an industrial revolution to decarbonise the global economy (Gough, 2017). A primary focus of capitalist economies, green growth forms the foundation of the mainstream environmental movement (Dale et al., 2016) and underlies international policy agreements such as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the 2015 Paris Agreement (Spash, 2021).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Now key time – change economic model
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
The enduring social and global climate crises are challenging society to look for alternatives to existing economic models. Nevertheless, in order to move away from the existing situation of unsustainability (Barry, 2012) we face, old solutions will hardly be enough, as the Anthropocene is characterised by countries already living above their limits.1 This is strongly suggested by indicators such as the ecological footprint and the planetary boundaries. With the ecological footprint we conclude that according to the goods and services we use, human- ity currently needs the regenerative capacity of 1.6 Earths (WWF, 2016). The concept of planetary boundaries is particularly interesting. It consists of the definition of boundaries for nine Earth system processes that should not be passed in order for the planet to remain within “safe operating space”, with four of those systems having already passed beyond the limit (Rockström et al., 2009; Steffen et al., 2015).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Now key time – transition
Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 , GDI, TS]
UBI is only one of the many ideas currently pursued by academics studying the possibilities of degrowth. While optimistic, Kallis concedes that a transition to degrowth is unlikely to be easy or smooth. But it might still be our best option. The end of fossil fuel is coming, whether we want it or not. Under the current growth economy, this will lead to disaster. Implementing degrowth early enough could lead to a less dramatic outcome. In Kallis’s words, “it is unlikely that technology will allow the economy to grow while resources and energy use decrease to the level necessary. […] If this is right, then the future will by necessity be one of lower throughput — the question is whether it will be by design or by disaster. The spread of the degrowth imaginary creates the conditions needed to turn the disaster into a desired future.” He concludes his book with the following statement: “You may agree or disagree with the degrowth prognosis and diagnosis, but you cannot deny that they raise inconvenient questions that we can no longer afford to ignore.” And I would certainly agree with this last part. Busyness and the culture of overwork have been deeply entwined with a culture of growth, as the rhetoric of almost any early-stage startup shows. So the questions raised by the degrowth movement also directly touch on the issues of work and leisure.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Growth Unsustainable now
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
The sustainable-development inherent idea that continued economic expansion is compatible with planetary limitations was formalized at the 2012 UN Conference through the concept of “green–blue economic growth” (GBEG) (Eikeset et al., 2018; Hickel & Kallis, 2020). The GBEG pursues climate-change mitigation and nature conservation and restoration through economic growth and profit. The GBEG is governed by conventional economics principles, striving to measure nature's monetary value and linking it to the mainstream concepts of natural capital, sustainable development, and ecosystem services (Gómez-Baggethun et al., 2010; Loiseau et al., 2016). The GBEG concept dominates the international sustainability agenda, including the European proposal for a “Green New Deal,” which advocates application of GBEG to cope with the social consequences of the 2008 financial crash and ecological breakdown (Schneider et al., 2010). However, current trends in biodiversity decline show that GBEG is, like sustainable development, another oxymoron that combines contradictory interests and strategies in the pursuit of legitimacy (Brand, 2012).
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Growth Unsustainable now
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
INTRODUCTION
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Environment › Growth Unsustainable now
Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 , GDI, TS]
In his book Degrowth, environmental scientist Giorgos Kallis describes the early movement as an “amalgam of research and action — a mixture of researchers, professors, activists and downshifters, who lived as they professed.” From there it has since grown into an active community of academics, with a research conference every two years. In 2014, over 4000 scholars from different fields attended the conference. At the core of degrowth is a “ruthless critique of the dogma of more — the dogma of economic growth.” The Growth Paradigm Our current economy is so deeply rooted in growth that any suggestion otherwise may be seen as crazy. Kallis calls this underlying assumption “‘the growth paradigm’: the idea that perpetual economic growth is natural, necessary and desirable.” But growth needs fuel, and this fuel comprises human and non-human resources. Both these will eventually run low. Our current population growth cannot be sustained forever (and has already started reversing in some countries). And natural resources get depleted. Our current renewable energy technologies have a very low energy return on investment (EROI): lots of energy needs to be invested in getting energy back out. Supporters of “green growth” believe that the EROI of renewables will eventually improve to a point where they can by themselves sustain growth, but, while not impossible, Kallis believes the green growth scenario to be implausible. At first, changing the infrastructure to renewables would come at a huge cost, dampening growth. And eventually, we would need more and more surface area covered with e.g., wind or solar farms. Unless we assume that we can constantly improve technology, sustained growth is physically impossible. The only way to achieve this would be if we discovered a third “Prometheus technology,” a fundamentally new energy technology like fire and steam engines before it. We cannot rule this out (fusion, for example), but relying on it is foolish. As Kallis notes, “by logical necessity economic growth must come to an end, independently of what one measures or how. Constant compound growth of anything quickly runs to infinity.”
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Employment/work incentives › UBI Solves Employment
Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021
[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]
Like housing, choice in employment is limited for people experiencing or at-risk of homelessness. There are various reasons for this, including limited time to address competing unmet needs (e.g., shelter, food, child care, employment, healthcare, and so on), fewer opportunities due to lower education attainment, and existing income support programs’ restrictive policies on employment. As previously noted, the latter issue can take different forms, from requiring those living with a disability to demonstrate an inability to work to qualify for funding, putting a cap on earned income after which point income supports may be terminated, or clawing back earnings from employment (Morley et al., 2019; Shåhl & MacEachen, 2021). Each of these policies disincentivize workforce returns, which may be the difference between housing and homelessness for people who are just scraping by on their income supports. UBI would bring an end to this systemic problem, as cash payments are unconditional, with no work or nonwork requirements. If a UBI were to have a phaseout (i.e., the point at which UBI cash payments are scaled back), this would not affect people with low incomes, as it would only take effect at a much higher income threshold. Hence, UBI would foster self-determination by removing barriers to returning to the workforce for people experiencing or at-risk of homelessness. The second employment-related benefit of UBI is its implications for workplace automation. UBI is often discussed as a policy approach for reducing the harms to job and income security associated with increasing automation (Morley et al., 2019). There are no known studies examining the relationship between homelessness and workforce automation; however, the risks are evident. In a study of OECD countries, risk of job automation was negatively correlated with workers’ income and level of education (Arntz et al., 2016). As low education and income levels are both overrepresented in the homeless population (Hwang et al., 2011; Poremski et al., 2015), it would be surmisable that the vocational prospects of many people with histories of homelessness are at higher risk of automation. A recent study by Tsai et al. (2021) of automation in another group vulnerable to homelessness drew a similar conclusion. A survey of vocational rehabilitation programs for veterans in the U.S. showed that the most common job placements had the highest probability of being automated (Tsai et al., 2021). Although more research is needed on the effects of workforce automation on homelessness, UBI could serve as a crucial buffer against future job losses that exacerbate or perpetuate homelessness risks.
2023
GDI
Affirmative
Case – advantages › Crime › UBI solves crime
Love, Senior Research Associate in Brookings Metro, ‘21
[Hanna, “Want to reduce violence? Invest in place”, Brookings Institution, November 16, 2021,, 7/12/23, GDI- ES]
Aside from the physical conditions of a neighborhood, a place’s economic health has a significant influence on violent crime. Numerous studies have found that neighborhoods with higher poverty and unemployment rates (often due tosystemic disinvestment and public and private sector abandonment) have higher rates of violent crime, and that income inequality within a neighborhood is associated with higher rates of violence.19 For example,Brookings research demonstrates that boys born into poverty are over 20 times more likely to be incarcerated than those born to wealthy families, and that economically isolated neighborhoods worsen these trends. In Los Angeles, for instance, the incarceration rate for people who grew up in in Westwood, Santa Monica, or Sierra Madre (wealthier neighborhoods) is essentially zero, whereas in neighborhoods in South L.A. or Compton (more economically and racially segregated neighborhoods), the rate is close to 7%.20 But the directionality between a place’s economy and rates of violence goes both ways; by enhancing economic opportunity and reducing inequality within neighborhoods, places can significantly reduce crime. For instance, evidence shows that youth workforce development and employment programs, including summer jobs programs, can reduce youth involvement in violence by as much as 35% or 45%.21 Universal basic income pilots have also been found to reduce crime and create numerous other community benefits.22 This indicates a strong role for city leaders and economic development stakeholders to increase resources (including leveragingthe influx of American Rescue Plan funding) in youth programming and workforce development efforts in those neighborhoods most impacted by crime. Some cities have already begun to see progress in reallocating criminal legal system funding to workforce development in high-crime neighborhoods. Indianapolis, for instance, revamped itscommunity safety grants to fund community organizations in its highest-crime neighborhoods, with funds for job training, mentoring, and housing programs. Philadelphia alsoexpanded its violence prevention efforts to fund employment and career support among other community-based investments.Building Blocks DC, which provides grants for community-based organizations to lead skill-building and neighborhood revitalization efforts in Washington, D.C. neighborhoods most impacted by gun violence, is another promising example. However, for communities to see truly transformative results, other sectors and city agencies—not just those that are explicitly violence-prevention-based—will need to come together to address the root causes of violence and poverty, not only through workforce development but also throughcoordinated efforts to enhance economic opportunity and connectivity within and between neighborhoods.