Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

UBI better then EITC—4 key reasons

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pg. 20, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

In this paper, we compare two types of transfers: subsidies of low-wage work, like the existing Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), and unconditional transfers, such as the hypothetical Universal Basic Income (UBI). We discuss several arguments for unconditional transfers. 1. Negative marginal tax rates are bad for both efficiency and equity: a. When marginal tax rates are positive, we have to take more than $1 from someone rich to give $1 to someone less rich, reflecting a tradeoff between efficiency and equity (“leaky bucket”). b. When marginal tax rates are negative, as under the EITC, we have to take less than $1 from someone with income to give $1 to someone without any income, by eliminating the distortion to supply too much labor (“magic bucket”). c. Going from the EITC toward an equally generous UBI would therefore improve both efficiency and equity. 2. Subsidizing increased labor supply hurts other workers: a. Subsidizing low-wage labor supply depresses wages. The subsidy is, at least in part, a transfer to employers rather than to low-income earners. b. If there is unemployment, subsidizing low-wage work increases competition for a limited number of jobs and increases search times and search costs for all workers—rather than increasing employment. 3. Fairness, justice, liberty: a. A UBI contributes to a society in which everyone is entitled to a basic level of dignity, safety, and liberty, free from material fear and personal dependence on abusive partners, overbearing welfare bureaucrats, or exploitative bosses. b. A UBI provides remuneration for the numerous unpaid activities a functioning society relies on—including, for example, care for children and the elderly, political and community involvement, and artistic and cultural production. 4. UBI might enjoy more stable support than narrowly targeted transfers: a. Narrowly targeted transfers are often stigmatized and have a limited political constituency to support and defend them. b. By contrast, broad-based transfers (e.g., Social Security or Medicare in the U.S.) enjoy stable and broad popular support and experience less political volatility. If appropriately framed, the same might ultimately be true for a UBI.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

Replacing the EITC with a UBI is justified on both efficiency and equity grounds

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pgs. 9-11, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

In particular, this logic can be applied to the design of transfers and taxes at the bottom of the income distribution. The key point that we will argue here is that subsidizing earnings (negative marginal tax rates) is as distortionary as taxing earnings (positive marginal tax rates). Subsidizing earnings—as opposed to making payments to those with zero earnings—is bad for redistribution but also because it distorts incentives. To the extent that people without any earnings are in even greater need of income than those with low-wage jobs, an unconditional basic income is therefore better policy on both efficiency and equity grounds than a subsidy of low-wage work, as provided by the EITC.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

UBI safeguards dignity, empowers individuals, and values non-market contributions, surpassing EITC in addressing fairness and personal freedom.

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pgs. 7-8, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

The previous arguments drew on established economic theory and empirical research, but the political debate regarding cash transfers to the poor is, however, also rife with arguments about fairness, justice, and deservingness—in addition to arguments about tradeoffs and empirical responses. The third argument for a UBI is that it provides a baseline of safety and dignity for all and serves as a source of personal liberty. By providing a guaranteed outside option, a UBI reduces personal dependency on exploitative employers, overbearing welfare administrators, and domestic partners, and guarantees that no one is completely left behind and excluded from society. Being able to count on a UBI gives people the power to say no. A UBI also serves as a means for society to reward the activities that are socially valuable but do not generate market revenue, which are often done by those without paid employment. In particular, this socially valuable work includes care for children, the elderly and sick (care work still done predominantly by women), but also artistic and cultural contributions, political and community participation, and more.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

The Earned Income Tax Credit only increases low-wage work.

Ghilarducci & Farmand, professor of economics, re-lab research associate, ‘19 [Teresa & Aida, 06-28-2019, prospect.org, “What’s Not to Like About the EITC? Plenty, It Turns Out”] 06-28-2023, RM

The Earned Income Tax Credit is widely praised. A subsidy paid to low-wage workers depending on family size, the EITC expands labor force participation and increases income to families, which helps stabilize them. It helps working-poor women to become economically engaged, and improves the life chances of their children by keeping them in school, providing better food, and even increasing their vocabulary. It is one of the few policies on which Democrats and Republicans agree. Democrats like it because it puts more money in the pockets of the poor. Republicans like it because it rewards the so-called virtuous poor who work, and because government’s involvement is minimal. From a modest start in 1975, in 2018 some 25 million eligible workers and families received approximately $63 billion in EITC credits. The average federal EITC subsidy received nationwide was about $2,488, which is almost 17 percent of the annual salary of a full-time worker earning the federal minimum wage. In addition, 29 states and the District of Columbia have supplements to the federal EITC.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

EITC is riddled with errors and fraud

Edwards & Rugy, family chair and scholar CATO Institute, ‘15 [Chris & Veronique, 10-14-2015, CATO Institute, “Earned Income Tax Credit: Small Benefits, Large Costs”] 06-27-2023, RM

The EITC is a huge program. In 2015 it will provide an estimated $69 billion in benefits to 28 million recipients. The EITC is the largest federal cash transfer program for low-income households. Benefits are available to household with earnings from employment. While the EITC is administered through the tax code, it is primarily a spending program. The EITC is "refundable," meaning that individuals who pay no income taxes are nonetheless eligible to receive a payment from the U.S. Treasury. Of the $69 billion in benefits this year, about 88%, or $60 billion, is spending. Articles by liberal and conservative pundits regarding the EITC often make it seem as if there are few downsides to the program. The EITC is aimed at reducing poverty and encouraging work. Alas, there is no free lunch with subsidy programs. The EITC has a high error and fraud rate, and for most recipients it creates a disincentive to increase earnings. Also, the refundable part of the EITC imposes a $60 billion cost on other taxpayers, reducing their incentives to work, invest, and pursue other productive activities. We conclude that the costs of the EITC are likely higher than the benefits. As such, the program should be cut, not expanded. Policymakers could better aid low-income workers by removing government barriers to investment, job creation, and entrepreneurship.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

UBI strengthens job seekers, increasing wages, and avoiding negative impacts on workers, making it superior to EITC.

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pg 7,Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

The second argument for a universal basic income is that subsidizing increased labor supply hurts other workers. Workers compete with each other for jobs in the labor market, and wages are affected by this competition. As the EITC was expanded in the 1990s, low-wage workers’ labor supply increased. It appears that due to this increase in labor supply, the wages of other workers competing for the same jobs were depressed. As a result of depressed wages, employers’ profits increased. Because of this depression of wages, the EITC is, at least in part, a transfer not to low-wage workers but rather to the employers of these workers.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC EITC CP

UBI could be more economically efficient and equitable compared to subsidies for low-wage work, like the EITC

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pgs. 5-6, Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

The first argument for a UBI relative to subsidies of low-wage work is that transfers that increase with earnings cause inefficiency. The standard framework that economists use for analyzing income taxes can be summarized as follows. Redistributive taxation involves a tradeoff between the welfare of different people. Higher incomes are generally taxed at higher rates, because richer individuals have a higher ability to pay, and because there is a desire to compensate for the inequalities generated by society. Unfortunately for a policymaker who seeks to redistribute income, taxable earnings might fall when marginal tax rates are increased. Such a decline might be due to tax evasion or reduced work effort. As a consequence, reducing tax contributions for lowerincome individuals by $1 might require increasing the contributions of richer individuals by more than that. This is sometimes described with the metaphor of a “leaky bucket.” Optimal taxes trade off the desire to redistribute income against the efficiency costs due to this leaky bucket.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Elections DA – UBI helps dems

UBI has bipartisan support from the public

Miller, Former Wall Street Journal staff reporter, 19 [John W. Miller, October 2 2019, America: The Jesuit Review, “Universal basic income is having a moment. Can advocates convince a skeptical public?” , 6/25/2023, EJ]

Matt Bruenig, the founder of the People’s Policy Project, a Washington-based, left-wing think tank, estimates the United States controls $100 trillion of collective wealth, including land, resources like oil and copper, and intellectual property. “If we owned the country’s wealth collectively you could just pay everybody a dividend from that wealth out of a common fund,” he told me.

Despite its appeal to Mr. Bruenig and others on the left, U.B.I. is also attractive to many conservative thinkers, a right-left synch that gives U.B.I. a fighting chance. Libertarians argue that it emphasizes freedom while redistributing wealth more efficiently and fairly. “U.B.I. is far less paternalistic than traditional welfare, which often treats the poor like 10-year-olds receiving an allowance,” Michael Tanner, a fellow at the Cato Institute, wrote this year.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Elections DA – UBI helps dems

Income-anxiety represents a major electoral issue for 3 out of 4 adults

Juliana Bidadanure – Faculty Director, Stanford Basic Income Lab and Assistant Professor in Philosophy, Stanford University, et al. ’18, Sean Kline – Director, San Francisco Office of Financial Empowerment; Camille Moore – Former Carnegie Mellon Heinz Fellow, Center for City Solutions, National League of Cities; Brooks Rainwater – Senior Executive and Director, Center for City Solutions, National League of Cities; Catherine Thomas – Graduate Fellow, Stanford Basic Income Lab and PhD candidate in Psychology, Stanford University, “Basic Income In Cities A guide to city experiments and pilot projects,” NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES, https://www.nlc.org/resource/universal-basic-income-whos-piloting-it/

Nearly three in four U.S. adults are dissatisfied with the current state of the country, and an overwhelming majority of Americans express anxiety about the near future.1 This fear stems at least in part from rapid advances in artificial intelligence, automation and the concomitant predicted disappearance of millions of jobs.2 As the gig economy and precarious work arrangements continue expanding, the future of work will generate growing concern.

By the numbers, the country is enjoying one of its most prosperous years to date. America is experiencing its highest-ever median incomes, all-time stock market highs and historically low unemployment rates. And yet, the reality for many residents is much more nuanced, leading to widespread dissatisfaction. Notably, the U.S. is seeing rising wealth and income inequality. Between 1979 and 2013, earnings have grown 192 percent for the top one percent of wealthiest Americans, but only 46 percent for the bottom 20 percent.3

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Elections DA – UBI helps dems

Trump benefits from wealth inequality and automation fear – UBI resolves pressure on citizens who vote republican out of desperation

MICHAEL HILTZIK, BUSINESS COLUMNIST, ’17. JUNE 23, 2017, “Column: Conservatives, liberals, techies, and social activists all love universal basic income: Has its time come?” LOS ANGELES TIMES, https://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-ubi-20170625-story.html

What’s driving interest in the U.S. is increasing disquiet about the dearth of ideas for stemming increasing wealth inequality in this land of plenty, along with disquiet about how automation could eliminate employment across the industrial sector.

“There’s a convergence of current anxiety about economic instability with an underlying fear of the future of work and jobs,” says Andrew Stern, the former president of the Service Employees International Union whose 2016 book “Raising the Floor” is a manifesto for a universal basic income. By some reckonings, these anxieties helped elect Donald Trump, whose inchoate promises of easy solutions to complicated problems appealed to voters feeling cast aside by globalization and technological change. Trump may not have had the answers, but he was at least articulating familiar questions.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Farm bill – food price defense

Food prices are too complex to solve domestically

Smith, Forbes Advisor Senior Consumer Finance Reporter, ‘22 [Kelly, 09-21-2022, forbes.com, “Why Are Food Prices Still Rising?”] 06-26-2023, R.M.

High prices are forcing some consumers to make difficult decisions, such as turning to food banks for the first time in their lives. Some say they’re not getting their full dietary needs, such as an adequate protein intake, because it’s simply too expensive. Unfortunately, what’s driving the soaring prices isn’t a simple problem or solution—and analysts say it will take time for consumers to see relief. The pandemic disrupted nearly every part of the food supply chain, including production, processing and retail. Those effects on the food supply chain are still being felt today. When lockdowns forced people to eat at home, producers catering to restaurants lost a key customer base, while grocery stores faced a massive increase in demand. Many food producers struggled in those early months to convert their operations to serve grocery consumers. Food production costs also increased due to labor turnover, investments to protect products from contamination, and additional worker-training costs. Even the cost of transportation of food to processors and grocery stores increased as retailers placed rush orders to keep shelves stocked.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Farm bill – food price defense

World food prices falling, but still globally unpredictable

Shine, Forum Agenda, ‘23 [Ian, 02-10-2023, weforum.com, “World food prices falling, and other economy stories you need to read this week”] 06-26-2023, R.M.

World food prices fell in January for a 10th consecutive month, and are now down 18% from the record high they hit last March following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the United Nations food agency says. However, there are warnings that dozens of countries are still experiencing double-digit food inflation, leading to rising food insecurity and undernourishment. The UN Food and Agriculture Organization's (FAO) price index, which tracks the most globally traded food commodities, averaged 131.2 points last month against 132.2 for December, putting it at its lowest since September 2021. Falls in the prices of vegetable oils, dairy and sugar helped pull down the index, while cereals and meat remained largely stable, the FAO said. The decline was helped in by an agreement in July to unblock Ukraine's grain exports, the UN says.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Politics DA

Basic income would be politically popular – broad and sustainable support

Kasy, Associate Professor, Department of Economics, Harvard University, 18’

[Maximilian, 8-5-2018, Pg. 8 Harvard Kennedy School Mossavar-rahmani Center for Business and Government, “Why a Universal Basic Income Is Better Than Subsidies of Low-Wage Work,” https://www.hks.harvard.edu/centers/mrcbg/programs/growthpolicy/why-universal-basic-income-better-subsidies-low-wage-work, 6/27, DG]

The fourth argument for a UBI is that universal benefits have greater potential for broad and sustained political support. Industrialized countries differ in the width of their social safety nets. Some countries traditionally provide narrowly targeted benefits (income transfers, housing, etc.) for the poor, without providing much in terms of transfers or public services to those slightly further up the income distribution. The consequence of such narrowly targeted programs is that only a small group of people benefits from the transfers and services. In general, those who benefit comprise a group of people with little political leverage, and benefit recipients are often socially stigmatized.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Politics DA

UBI spurs bipartisan cooperation by resolving fights over the current system

Worstall, writer at the Adam Smith Institute in London, 15’

[Tim, Sep 18, 2015, Forbes, “The Real Value Of A Universal Basic Income Is That It Raises The Reservation Wage,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/09/18/the-real-value-of-a-universal-basic-income-is-that-it-raises-the-reservation-wage/?sh=7d3434787ca1, 6-25,DG]

A UBI therefore meets one of the demands of the liberal right (ie, the economically liberal), that if we're going to have some form of a welfare state, which we obviously are, then let's have the most efficient one we can. With the fewest distortions, with low marginal tax rates, fewest disincentives to work and lifestyle choice and so on. A UBI also meets the demands of the liberal left (ie, the not so economically liberal in the modern parlance) and aids in overturning the power imbalances that they see in the current society.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Inflation DA

Struggling households need assistance or inflation will never stabilize

Schweitzer & Khattar, Biden Administration, Racial Equity, ’22. [Justin & Rose, 09-01-2022, americanprogress.com, “Wages and Employment Do Not Have To Decline To Bring Down Inflation”] https://www.americanprogress.org/article/wages-and-employment-do-not-have-to-decline-to-bring-down-inflation/ 06-26-2023, R.M.

The United States—much like the rest of the world—is currently experiencing high inflation, due to a range of factors including COVID-19-related supply disruptions and Russia’s war in Ukraine. As low- and middle-income households struggle with recent inflation on top of the decades long affordability crisis fueled by stagnant and low wages, policies to strengthen supply and shore up households’ financial stability should take precedence over a strategy that proposes sacrificing employment to lower inflation. Historically, countering inflation has been left to the remit of the interest rate policy of the Federal Reserve. In recent months, the Federal Reserve has been sharply increasing interest rates in an attempt to reduce demand, slow the economy, increase unemployment, and lower inflation.

Historically, countering inflation has been left to the remit of the interest rate policy of the Federal Reserve. In recent months, the Federal Reserve has been sharply increasing interest rates in an attempt to reduce demand, slow the economy, increase unemployment, and lower inflation. This risks sending the country into a recession. While low-income households often feel inflation the hardest, a Federal Reserve-induced recession would be far worse, as millions of the most economically vulnerable Americans could lose their incomes entirely.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC off-case*** › 2AC Inflation DA

UBI doesn’t cause inflation worse than usual government interventions – UBI echoes post-World War 2 strategy which was a success

Economic Times 2023

This article is syndicated by PTI from 360info.org, 3, 20, 2023, “Economic Times,“ , 6/24, DG

The idea that a Universal Basic Income fuels inflation makes no economic sense. We live in an age of crisis. The Global Financial Crisis, austerity measures, climate change, Covid-19 and war have all reduced people's standard of living, wellbeing and even predicted lifespan. It's a dire outlook, made worse by a fast-evolving cost of living crisis. One way to ease the burden on people would be a Universal Basic Income. In our last age of crisis, during WWII, Western governments took the momentous decision to tackle even more serious crises through massive state intervention. Governments rapidly committed themselves to costs with few precedents in creating social security systems, healthcare systems, nationalised industry and a range of other equality-promoting measures. At a time in which countries could, apparently, least afford those policies, policymakers saw no alternative than to spend big. The consequence was three decades of growth, increased standards of living, increased life expectancy and unprecedented technological development, ended only by war-induced increases in energy prices that sent inflation spiralling. As the Financial Times recently noted, the policies adopted over the past four decades have left countries such as Britain poor, but with some very rich people. Universal Basic Income has been presented as a means of addressing this crisis. Giving people largely unconditional, predictable forms of income to satisfy their basic needs has been identified as means of restoring social security, increasing equality and supporting growth in areas of countries that have been left behind by development and promoting public health overall. There is, however, widespread belief that any monetary intervention stimulates hyper-inflation of the form found in 1920s Germany, 1990s Argentina and 2000s Zimbabwe. This is because people believe that giving consumers more money to spend leads to businesses charging higher prices to take advantage of increased purchasing power, creating a cycle in which employees demand higher wages to buy commodities, increasing the cost of production, cancelling out any benefit from the monetary intervention and actually reducing the standard of living overall. There is little evidence to support this view. UBI is no more or less inflationary than anything else that raises incomes - its impact would depend on whether the economy is at full employment, whether taxes are raised to pay for the scheme and various other factors. Where hyperinflation has occurred, it has occurred because essential goods are scarce, raising their value overall, and debt has been held in foreign currencies and paid in currencies declining in value by virtue of countries' domestic production being disrupted or declining. Our current levels of inflation are caused by similar pressures as those in the 1970s: war leading to an increase in the cost of fossil fuels. If the logic behind objecting to a UBI on the basis of inflation were correct, then there ought to be absolutely no attempt to introduce new jobs or increase wages, since both increase purchasing power. If inflation is our sole concern, governments ought to slash wages and massively increase taxes. The point is that nobody wants either of those options because, even if they did reduce inflation, people would not want to have their wages reduced. UBI is a redistributive economic policy that can be funded by taxing those resources that contribute little to society: wealth and passive income from shares as well as income at the very top end of society. The resources of the rich are generally off-shored and contribute little to a country's financial wellbeing. Analysis of the distributive impacts of UBI in the UK suggest its introduction would shift resources to those people and areas that need the investment most. That may increase the cost of housing and other goods in parts of countries that have been left behind, but this is a central means of enhancing community wealth and 'Levelling Up'. It is also a means of developing entrepreneurship and production within areas that have been deindustrialised. This support for production is, again, an essential means of supporting a bulwark against hyperinflation. Given that we live in market societies, the fear that this will lead to unchecked inflation is counterintuitive, since competition is supported by rising purchasing power and serves to check price increases. The alternative is simply to leave all but the metropolitan centres to wither away and to be dependent on the whims of finance. As our recent RSA report indicated, if governments are committed to resolving our age of crisis, they need to do as their predecessors did in the wake of WWII: invest in transformative policies with expensive up front costs to achieve the most significant social outcomes. Nothing is more expensive than undoing climate change, dealing with pandemics and repairing the damage of social decay. In that context, there is evidence a UBI is economically feasible and voters regard UBI as a necessary means of promoting social security.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC T – UBI*** › T – UBI definitions

UBI is a regular cash payment to individuals.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562

The idea of ‘income’ is the least contested. There is broad agreement that UBI should be ‘paid in cash’ (Van Parijs and Vanderborght, 2017: 12). It needs to be ‘money’ (Standing, 2017: 3) rather than exchangeable vouchers or access to set services or provisions. UBI is agreed by all proponents to focus on putting dollars in the accounts of the population. While not agreed by all, there is wide- spread agreement that UBI should consist of a ‘regular’ payment (Standing, 2017) rather than being a one-off grant, awarded at birth, or irregularly, for example, once every 10 years.6 In keeping with standard income practice across the wider capitalist workplace, UBI’s advocates typically suggest a monthly payment of accessible cash into the accounts of recipients.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC T – UBI*** › T – UBI definitions

The ‘Basic’ in UBI is controversial and can refer to either full or partial support.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562

The ‘Basic’ of UBI is more controversial. As Van Parijs (1992: 4) rightly states, arguing that people should have a ‘basic income’ is not the same as arguing that everyone should have their ‘basic needs met’. In principle, a basic income could be well short of what is required for survival, or well in excess. For Standing (2017), this remains a crucial area of contention (p. 3). This is fur- ther complicated by a central fissure within UBI proponents: whether the UBI payment is meant as a replacement for all existing welfare or as an accompaniment to existing state provision (see Kela, 2016). As Martinelli (2017: 7) notes, traditionally left-wing advocates of UBI favour the retention of existing state provision and an additional UBI payment, while right-wing advocates propose the removal of all existing state benefits and their replacement by a modest UBI. The relative calcula- tions involved, dependent on which approach was taken, can lead to the adoption of either ‘full’ or ‘partial’ UBI proposals, where ‘full’ are enough to live on and survive in lieu of other state support. In contrast, ‘partial’ UBI would be insufficient to survive off and would need to be accompanied by either state provision in the form of welfare or privately obtained or accrued wealth, or a com- bination thereof (Martinelli, 2017).

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC T – UBI*** › T – UBI definitions

consideration of person’s sex, gender, qualifications, and race.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562

The ‘Universal’ of UBI necessitates that there are not ‘any conditions attached’ to be eligible for the payment (Loft et al., 2020: 2). That is, the income will be provided without consideration of the person’s sex, gender, qualifications, ‘race’, past-behaviour, current wealth, current income, fore- cast future income or future plans. Whether one has already earned twenty million pounds, whether one has spent their last few decades in prison for murder or whether one loudly proclaims their desire to spend the rest of their life surfing and never doing a day’s work,4 in principle, everybody should be eligible for this universal payment. Thus, there would be ‘no means test involved’ (Van Parijs and Vanderborght, 2017: 17) and no surveillance on how the money is actually spent. Typically, only the most basic eligibility restrictions would apply: residency within the polity and being of legal age.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***2AC T – UBI*** › T – UBI definitions

UBI is a modest regular income grant given to all residents unconditionally.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University 23’

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562

The most commonly accepted definitions of UBI reinforce the centrality of each of the proposal’s three key terms: ‘Universal’, ‘Basic’, and ‘Income’ (Haagh, 2019: 1; Standing, 2017: 3; Van Parijs, 1992). For example, Haagh defines UBI as the desire to ‘give all residents a modest regular income grant that is not dependent on means-tests or work-requirements’ (Haagh, 2019: 1). Similarly, Standing (2017: 3) introduces UBI as ‘a modest amount of money paid unconditionally to indi- viduals on a regular basis’. It is worth exploring each of the three key terms further.