2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Spillover
Peter Howard, 4 (Peter Howard is the economics director at Policy Integrity, and a former economic fellow, May 2004, accessed on 7-2-2022, International Studies Perspectives, Vol. 5, No. 2, “The Growing Role of States in U.S. Foreign Policy: The Case of the State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac)
With its focus on decision making in Washington, foreign policy analysis has overlooked the important role state governments are now playing in U.S. foreign policy. Under the U.S. federal system, states have a significant policy role, but one largely limited to domestic and economic matters. Foreign and defense policy are assumed to remain the responsibility of the federal government. Yet, states are getting more and more involved in these matters, and their impact is growing. Aside from the now routine gubernatorial international trade mission, state governments have adopted outspoken positions on issues such as the conflict between India and Pakistan over Kashmir, human rights abuses in Nigeria and Burma, use of Holocaust-era bank accounts, and war with Iraq. State national guards have come to play an essential role in recent overseas military campaigns and homeland security operations. This growth of international activity by states remains underappreciated due to existing approaches to foreign policy analysis.
This article argues that states can and do play an important role in contemporary U.S. foreign policy. From both a federalism and decision-making perspective, states have a limited international role and minimal influence in shaping the policies of the U.S. federal government toward other nations. As a result, state involvement in international affairs is most often seen as economic activity. An implementation perspective, however, reveals a growing role for states in carrying out U.S. foreign policy, including the "high politics” of national security issues. This article will discuss the value of studying foreign policy implementation and the growing role of states through an investigation of the State Partnership Program (SPP). The SPP links State National Guard units to the militaries of other countries through U.S. military engagement programs. The state-level National Guard then becomes the primary site for implementing U.S. military engagement programs. An implementation perspective reveals that this program provides a growing role for states in shaping U.S. foreign policy.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Readiness/Cyber
Whitney Hughes, 6-1 (Sgt. 1st Class Whitney Hughes, National Guard Bureau, 6-2-2022, accessed on 7-1-2022, Air National Guard, “National Guard strengthens NATO readiness in Europe”, , HBisevac)
ARLINGTON, Va. – More than 20,000 service members from over 20 countries supporting NATO, including the National Guard, showcased their integrated military capabilities during large-scale exercises throughout Europe in April and May.
The world’s largest peacetime military alliance conducted activities ranging from cyber warfare to airborne operations across Baltic and Balkan regions, bordering the ongoing conflict in Ukraine.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---PNs Say Yes
CALL 18 (The Center for Army Lessons Learned, “Security Cooperation and the State Partnership Program,” https://usacac.army.mil/sites/default/files/publications/19-01%20State%20Partnership%20Program%20%28Lo%20Res%29.pdf)//BB
Another aspect of the SPP that distinguishes it from similar engagements by active component forces stems from the National Guard’s dual status as both a state and a federal organization. In its federal status, the National Guard is a reserve component of the Army and the Air Force and is trained, organized, and equipped to conduct a wide spectrum of military activities. However, the National Guard is also the organized militia of each state, and, in that capacity, routinely operates under the control of its state governor, typically to respond to disasters and civil disorders. National Guard personnel in a “Title 32 status” have also conducted counterdrug, border security, and airport security missions. The practical expertise the National Guard has acquired in these areas may be complemented by the skills that National Guard personnel develop in their civilian occupations. For example, a National Guard Soldier may serve as an infantryman in his Guard unit, but may be a state trooper, paramedic, or emergency dispatcher in his civilian job. The expertise that National Guard units have acquired in conducting these types of operations are often in demand among foreign militaries, which frequently play a major role in their nation’s disaster response plans, and may play significant roles in their nation’s border security, civil disorder, or counterdrug operations. Although active component forces have significant expertise in these areas, as evidenced, for example, by the role active component personnel played in responding to the earthquake in Haiti and the floods in Pakistan in 2010, it is typically not exercised with the frequency of National Guard forces and, in certain cases, is intentionally limited by law.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Logistics
Tracey Poirier, 17 (Lieutenant Colonel Tracey Poirier, Vermont Army National Guard, 1-4-2017, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army War College Strategy Research Project, “Increasing Interoperability and Preparedness through the State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac)
The National Guard State Partnership Program (SPP) has continually received rave reviews from Combatant Commanders. Major General Frederick S. Rudesheim, US Army South Commander, called the program “almost incalculable.”3 Admiral James Winnefeld, Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, called it “one of the best foreign policy bargains our nation has.”4 Perhaps the most ringing endorsement comes from Admiral James Stavridis, Former US European Command Commander, when he stated the SPP is, “a very powerful tool. It is unmatched. They are, bang for the buck, one of the best things going. Anything that enhances state partnership is money in the bank for the regional combatant commanders.” 5 In fact, it is difficult to find a criticism of the program from anyone who has experienced it on the ground. Given such reviews, why would the US government not expand its model to include more interactions that would improve interoperability with partner nations?
The SPP model uses the power of American ideas and perpetuates them through personal relationships. Additionally, it can give the US the opportunity to improve infrastructure in various regions around the globe advancing our logistical readiness. However, the effectiveness of ideas and relationships are difficult to measure and too often, we choose not to. The Partnership Program is no exception. The program’s annual report shows measures of performance only and does not assess its effectiveness.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Logistics
Zach Sheely, 6-3 (Sgt. 1st Class Zach Sheely, National Guard Bureau, 6-3-2022, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army, “National Guard Leaders Emphasize Value of State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac)
This year alone, the National Guard has assisted U.S. Southern Command in accomplishing theater campaign objectives by conducting 30 engagements in eight countries, with another 12 scheduled this fiscal year. These exchanges include small-unit security, maritime search and rescue, noncommissioned officer leadership development, public affairs, small-unit patrolling, logistics and sustainment, and cyber protection.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Interoperability/Integration
Tracey Poirier, 17 (Lieutenant Colonel Tracey Poirier, Vermont Army National Guard, 1-4-2017, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army War College Strategy Research Project, “Increasing Interoperability and Preparedness through the State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac)
The National Guard State Partnership Program (SPP) has continually received rave reviews from Combatant Commanders. Major General Frederick S. Rudesheim, US Army South Commander, called the program “almost incalculable.”3 Admiral James Winnefeld, Vice Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, called it “one of the best foreign policy bargains our nation has.”4 Perhaps the most ringing endorsement comes from Admiral James Stavridis, Former US European Command Commander, when he stated the SPP is, “a very powerful tool. It is unmatched. They are, bang for the buck, one of the best things going. Anything that enhances state partnership is money in the bank for the regional combatant commanders.” 5 In fact, it is difficult to find a criticism of the program from anyone who has experienced it on the ground. Given such reviews, why would the US government not expand its model to include more interactions that would improve interoperability with partner nations?
The SPP model uses the power of American ideas and perpetuates them through personal relationships. Additionally, it can give the US the opportunity to improve infrastructure in various regions around the globe advancing our logistical readiness. However, the effectiveness of ideas and relationships are difficult to measure and too often, we choose not to. The Partnership Program is no exception. The program’s annual report shows measures of performance only and does not assess its effectiveness.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Cyber
Jeffrey Caton, 19 (Jeffrey Caton is president of Kepler Strategies LLC and an intermittent professor of program management with Defense Acquisition University and an associate professor of cyberspace operations and defense transformation chair, 1-31-2019, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army War College Press, “Examining the Roles of Army Reserve Component Forces in Military Cyberspace Operations”, , HBisevac) ARNG = Army National Guard
With the increased concern for Russian military cyberspace activity, the SPP programs with the Baltic nations have grown in prominence. Baltic Ghost started as a series of cyber defense workshops facilitated by U.S. European Command (USEUCOM) to build and sustain cyber partnerships amongst Estonia and the Maryland ARNG, Latvia and the Michigan ARNG, and Lithuania and the Pennsylvania ARNG.139 Baltic Ghost transitioned to become a training exercise in September 2015―held simultaneously in the capitals of Tallinn (Estonia), Riga (Latvia), and Vilnius (Lithuania)―and focused on the coordination of responses to cyberattacks on critical infrastructure.140 The exercise was most recently hosted by USEUCOM in June 2017, with participation by the ARNG state partners and assistance by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence. Baltic Ghost 2017 pursued an objective “to test cooperation between the three Baltic States and the United States in the event of an escalating cyber incident, the solution of which requires internationally coordinated joint action.”141 In August 2017, the Maryland ARNG also supported Estonia in the Baltic Jungle cyber exercise, which included opportunities to exchange experiences in the areas of cyber range development, education, and research.142 In September 2017, members of the Ohio and Serbian armed forces worked together in the second annual Cyber Tesla exercise, which examined cyber incident preparation and responses processes.143
The ARNG also supports the education and training of partner nations at U.S. facilities. In July 2015, the ARNG PEC welcomed the first group on international military students for a 6-week integrated information technology training course. Four students from Bulgaria, Poland, and the Slovak Republic attended, with two Illinois Guardsmen [soldiers] training in the same class with their Polish state partner.144
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Cyber
Zach Sheely, 6-3 (Sgt. 1st Class Zach Sheely, National Guard Bureau, 6-3-2022, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army, “National Guard Leaders Emphasize Value of State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac)
This year alone, the National Guard has assisted U.S. Southern Command in accomplishing theater campaign objectives by conducting 30 engagements in eight countries, with another 12 scheduled this fiscal year. These exchanges include small-unit security, maritime search and rescue, noncommissioned officer leadership development, public affairs, small-unit patrolling, logistics and sustainment, and cyber protection.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Commitment/Credibility
Robinson 7 – JD @ Yale (Nick, “Citizens Not Subjects: U.S. Foreign Relations Law and the Decentralization of Foreign Policy,” Akron Law Review, Lexis)//BB
State and local governments are arguably seen as representing the U.S. government abroad in a more official capacity than U.S. non-state actors. The governments of these localities are democratically elected and so it is more likely that they will be seen as acting on behalf of the American people. Additionally, the federal government generally has a greater ability to control the actions of these localities than non-state actors. Therefore, there is a greater chance that nonintervention by the federal government to stop offensive activity will be seen as federal endorsement of such activity. Such logic though should caution against court intervention in these cases rather than encourage it. If localities' actions damage U.S. foreign policy interests, the federal government can easily preempt the state or local policies in question. Further, with the world's increased interconnectedness, it is more likely that if a foreign government takes offense to a locality's policy it can discriminate between the policy of the locality and the policy of the federal government. n155
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Commitment/Credibility
Zach Sheely, 6-3 (Sgt. 1st Class Zach Sheely, National Guard Bureau, 6-3-2022, accessed on 7-1-2022, United States Army, “National Guard Leaders Emphasize Value of State Partnership Program”, , HBisevac) **edited for gendered language**
“Stability makes the National Guard uniquely suited to conduct these partnership missions,” he said. “Guardsmen [soldiers] typically remain in their states during their entire term of service, unlike our active-duty brethren who move every few years. This constancy creates trust through long-term associations that last decades.”
U.S. Airmen with the Indiana Air National Guard, and Slovak armed forces personnel participate in joint training Feb. 22, 2022, at the 122nd Fighter Wing, Fort Wayne, Indiana. The joint training was held to further build a robust State Partnership that Indiana and Slovakia have held for over 25 years. The State Partnership program demonstrates Indiana’s deep commitment to our NATO allies, as well as European security and stability.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Follow-on---Climate-Specific
Adrianna Pita, 7-1 (Adrianna Pita, Assistant Director of Events at The Brookings Institution, 7-1-2022, accessed on 7-2-2022, “What does the Supreme Court’s EPA ruling mean for climate regulation?”, , HBisevac)
PITA: On environmental issues, as on others where federal action has been stymied by a lot of this congressional dysfunction or inaction, the states have sometimes stepped in, and in some cases, as with the vehicle emission standards that you mentioned, sometimes, a large enough or influential enough state or groups of states can kind of set national standards for things, even though it’s not technically a national policy. Where is there any avenue for state action on these sorts of the power plant regulation issues?
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---Follow On
James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, , HBisevac)
Any new directives, regulations or statutory authorities would be most effective with a “bottom-up” approach, using input from the National Guard to the greatest extent possible. Given the vastness and diversity of the programs requirements, the coordinators at the National Guard Bureau level should be the “trusted advisors” to ensure that language incorporated into evolving guidance ensure the flexibility required to administer the program effectively “where the rubber meets the road.”
The Bureau can most effectively synthesize the discrete nuances across the program into a cohesive representation for the further development of directives and authorities. Without initial input from the program level, any top-driven attempts to develop guidance will ultimately fail to achieve the balance and flexibility required to effectively administer the program. The National Guard Bureau has had over twenty years experience with this program and is the only single agency that truly has the “big picture.” The Bureau is more than capable of fairly and honestly representing the needs of the partner nations consistent with the requirements of the Department of State, the Geographic Combatant Commanders and the American taxpayers.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---T/L
William Spence, 13 (Lieutenant Colonel William Spence, Idaho Army National Guard, 2013, accessed on 7-2-2022, United States Army War College, “National Guard State Partnership Program: Building Partnership Capacity”, , HBisevac)
Within these four goals, the SPP facilitates the development of a regional and global environment congruent with the U.S. national interests of security, prosperity, values, and international order. 21 In addition, these goals facilitate a stable global environment that influences U.S. partners and potentially adversaries away from negative and disruptive approaches.
The first goal, to deter adversaries and regional conflict is supplementary to the second goal to respond and recover from attacks and disasters. The focus of the two goals are developing defense management capacity, training personnel with the capabilities to deter internal and external adversaries, and utilizing appropriate action when events occur. Interagency and civil military cooperation is critical to the development, sustainment, and execution of the capability. 22 The National Guard core missions provide a unique capability and institutional knowledge to meet these two goals. At the federal, state, and local levels, the National Guard supports the land and air component missions, the homeland defense mission, and the support of civilian authorities and disaster relief missions. The National Guard capacity to mentor and train at the various levels with the partner is representative of the U.S. armed forces. Interagency integration is standard practice at the local, state, and federal levels within the National Guard. These two goals provide the partner a core capacity for developing force sustainment and growth in the last two goals
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---T/L
James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, , HBisevac)
As the nation confronts its current economic crisis, the Department of Defense faces budget reductions between four hundred billion and one trillion dollars over the next ten years. Yet in spite of constrained resources the United States must continue to meet National Security challenges in this “era of persistent conflict”. The strategy to meet these challenges and overcome diminished capacity will rely more heavily than ever on security cooperation, engagement and building partner capacities. Gaining security cooperation and aiding partner nations to develop their capabilities is a way to shape the environment, deter conflict and assure access and assistance in the event of conflict. For nearly two decades, the National Guard State Partnership Program has done all of this and more. Since long before the term “smart power” was coined, the State Partnership Program has evolved, almost imperceptibly, as a means to employ a “whole of society” approach to building partner capacity. This paper will demonstrate that the State Partnership Program is an effective and economical tool that facilitates a bridge between military engagement and civilian diplomacy in support of the National Security Policies of the United States.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---T/L
Dickerson 13, Lieutenant Colonel @ US National Guard (Jeffrey, “Shifting State Partnership Program Resources to the Asia-Pacific Region,”
SPP countries demonstrated success in reforming their defense sectors and enabling and facilitating enduring broad-spectrum security relationships. The outcomes have been dramatic, with partners supporting U.S. and international security objectives through training received and transformation performed through SPP. SPP partners made significant contributions to collective defense efforts in NATO by supporting peace and stability operations in the Balkans and uniting in a fight against violent extremism through support to operations in Iraq and Afghanistan from 2003. For example, Slovenia assisted the U.S. and NATO in its efforts to stabilize and bring peace 8 to the Balkans by providing troops in support of Stabilization Force (SFOR) in the 1990s. SPP countries’ support of the war effort in Iraq and Afghanistan clearly demonstrated the ability of partners to provide military forces to operations. After the U.S. invaded Iraq in 2003, thirty-eight other countries joined this “coalition of the willing” to help depose Saddam Hussein and topple his regime.21 Twenty-five of the troopcontributing states were SPP partners, which made up 65.7% of the troop contributing countries to Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF). 22 For example, Thailand, partnered with the state of Washington, and the Philippines, partnered with Hawaii, provided military support for reconstruction efforts in Iraq while other SPP countries provided combat brigades. When the country of Georgia deployed one of its brigades to Iraq in 2007, several Soldiers from the Georgia Army National Guard deployed along with them and served with them throughout their deployment.23 This Georgian brigade’s capability to deploy and fight stemmed from a concerted SPP effort to develop their sustainment capabilities during the year prior. After returning from a deployment to Iraq in 2006, a fortuitous visit by the Brigade Commander of the 48th Infantry Brigade Combat Team (IBCT) of the Georgia Army National Guard on a training visit to Tbilisi, Georgia, in early 2007 led to the development of a four month training program from April through July 2007 to improve the combat service support capabilities of the Georgian Army. In conjunction with the Georgia Security and Stability Operations Program (GSSOP II), the 48th IBCT deployed teams of National Guardsmen to Georgia to train the Georgians in supply and maintenance operations.24 In addition to the country of Georgia, Poland also provided 9 combat units to support the war effort in Iraq. In both instances, the brigades from these countries deployed along with embedded Soldiers from their partnered states in the form of Bilateral Embedded Support Teams (BEST). In these two cases, Illinois and Georgia each deployed Soldiers alongside their partnered countries.25 In several instances, the troop-contributing SPP countries would only provide troops if their SPP partners from the U.S. accompanied them.26 Opportunities like this enabled the U.S. military to be reinforced with troops from an unexpected source, and these sources were even more heavily relied upon during the war in Afghanistan. As of 2012, fifty separate countries contributed combat forces to the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in support of Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF) in Afghanistan,27 and SPP countries made up a significant percentage of the overall troop contributing nations to ISAF – twenty-three out of the forty eight troop contributing nations.28 Collectively, SPP countries provided over 8,200 troops to ISAF.29 For example, Poland, partnered with Illinois, provided an entire Battle Group that served and fought as a battle space owner in Afghanistan. Other countries participating in the SPP, such as Jordan, Macedonia, and Mongolia, also provided troops in support of ISAF for purposes such as force protection.30 Several other SPP countries provided troop support to ISAF in the form of Operational Mentor and Liaison Teams (OMLTs), which made up a large percentage of these SPP country troop contributions. The OMLTs were responsible for embedding with and training and mentoring the Afghan National Army (ANA).31 Latvia, the very first SPP country, along with its partnered state, Michigan, deployed the first BEST OMLT to Afghanistan in support of OEF in 2008.32 In all, twenty-four separate countries provided OMLTs to Afghanistan in support of ISAF 10 efforts to develop and train the ANA, and of those twenty four OMLT providing countries, ten are countries participating in the SPP. The contemporary historical examples of partnership extended beyond the war fighting role and also included examples of supporting partner capacity to build and recover, developing professional forces, and facilitating enduring relationships. These contemporary examples of SPP partnership activities and outcomes are much more representative of civilian diplomacy and the whole of government approach to partnering. These examples include port security, humanitarian assistance, defense support to civil authorities (DSCA), government and economic development, and combating transnational criminal activities in support of the four SPP goals. “The unique civil-military nature of the National Guard allows the SPP to engage in a wide range of Security Cooperation activities, such as: Disaster Preparedness, Humanitarian Assistance, Defense Support of Civil Authorities, Chemical, Biological, Radiological, and Nuclear, Cyber, Reserve Component Reform, Counterdrug, Border/Port Security, and Public/Private Partnerships.”33 Serbia provides an example. In 1999, the United States and NATO conducted offensive air operations against Serbian forces as a part of Operation Allied Force in order to deter Serbian aggression in Kosovo.34 Over a decade later, the relationship between Serbia and the United States evolved into a much more peaceful one. Serbia has since entered into an SPP agreement with the National Guard in the state of Ohio. In 2010, non-commissioned officers (NCOs) from the Serbian Army graduated from the Ohio National Guard NCO academy, and these partners’ military–to-military engagements recently included humanitarian missions to rehabilitate several schools 11 damaged during a powerful 5.3 magnitude earthquake in November 2010.35 This partnership, which began in 2006, is more than just a military to military partnership. Their goals are also to further develop the cultural bonds between the United States and Serbia through enhanced engagements between universities and youth programs. In September 2010, Ambassador Mary Burce Warlick, U.S. Ambassador to Serbia, praised the SPP for playing a critical role in improving U.S. and Serbian relations.36 SPP also facilitated private organizations and business engagements as well as government to government engagements as it developed enduring relationships. The SPP effectively built relationships at the local level and linked local U.S. leaders with national leaders from other countries, such as Senegal. After expressing a desire to develop their country’s ability to conduct crisis management and search and rescue operations, as well as improve the professionalism of their NCO corps and develop family support programs, Senegalese leaders entered into a SPP agreement with the State of Vermont in 2009.37 In September 2010, President Abdoulaye Wade, President of Senegal, visited Burlington, Vermont, and remarked that he will take back to Senegal a better understanding of the state’s economic model as well as a better understanding of the relationship and interaction between business, services, and tourism and their contributions to quality of life.38 SPP built partner capacity to deter, prevent, and prepare for threats to trade and commerce. Thailand and its partner state, Washington, conducted several port security exercises between 2003 and 2012. These exercises focused on responding to hazard material and WMD incidents, crisis management, port security, and disaster planning and included participants from the Royal Thai Army, Navy, and Marine Department, as 12 well as the Thai National Security Council and other civilian agencies along with members of the Washington Air and Army National Guard and other U.S. civilian participants.39 This partnership improved port security operations at the Port of Tacoma in Tacoma, Washington, which handles a significant amount of cargo exported from port at Leam Chabang in Thailand every year.40 These examples clearly demonstrate the SPP’s ability to achieve success in the goal of building partnership capacity to deter, prevent, and prepare for natural/manmade disasters with emphasis on civil-military and interagency cooperation while also building partnership capacity to respond and recover from attack and man-made disasters. It also clearly develops the ability to support partners’ defense reform and professional development, as well as enabling and facilitating enduring broad-spectrum security relationships in support of the DoS and other lead agencies. While each of these examples provides far more concrete evidence of the SPP’s effectiveness, military and civilian leadership testimony provides additional support to the effectiveness of the program. During a speech delivered on July 17, 2012, at a National Guard Symposium on Mutual Security Cooperation, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Martin Dempsey, stressed the imperative for major powers to develop partnerships that work within a “competitive fiscal and security environment” in order to confront the decentralized threats of the 21st century. He went on to praise the SPP for its ability to provide continuity in relationships among the leaders of the partnered states and countries. He also remarked, “the State Partnership Program has reaped benefits far 13 beyond what was initially conceived” and added that it was “a modest investment for a pretty substantial return.”41 During recent testimony regarding their GCC Defense Posture Statements before the Senate Armed Services Committee, several GCC Commanders testified regarding the effectiveness of the program. They praised the value of the SPP within their respective GCCs, and requested additional SPP support. For example, in 2009, General Brantz Craddock, Commander, USEUCOM, testified that the SPP “continues to be one of our most effective [build partner capacity] programs…the unique civil-military nature of the National Guard allows it to participate actively in a wide range of security cooperation activities and help bridge the gap between DoD and DoS responsibilities…”42 His successor, Admiral James Stavradis, also testified in 2012 that the program is “one of European Command’s most unique, cost effective, and essential international engagement tools…that support key Theater Security Cooperation objectives and preserve and develop these important strategic partnerships...”43 The Commander of USAFRICOM, General Carter F. Hamm testified in 2012 that the SPP was an “important component” of USAFRICOM’s “efforts to strengthen defense capabilities of African partners”.44 He further added that he had asked NGB to add two additional partnerships and consider further expansion of the program.45 U.S. civilian leadership also provide testament to the success of the SPP. “In a 2010 survey of Ambassadors to USEUCOM SPP nations: 6 said SPP is their most significant program; 14 said SPP is a significant program that adequately supports their objectives; and 1 said SPP adequately supports their objectives, but would like to see increased engagements.”46
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › SOLVENCY › 2NC---Solvency---T/L
James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, , HBisevac) **edited for gendered language**
Using the National Guard as a primary tool to develop relationships with potential allies is a diplomatic multiplier, and its utility across the various domains of diplomacy was recognized after only a few years of effort. In a 2002 article in the Washington Quarterly, former Colorado Governor Bill Owens touted the State Partnership Program as a proven approach for “strategic democracy building.” 23 Governor Owens was one of the first to document the SPP’s “quiet achievements” in facilitating the development of emerging democracies beyond the typical military-to-military exchanges. For perhaps the first time, under SPP state governments became involved in helping the federal government in achieving diplomatic goals abroad.
By 1995, the program had expanded its scope to include “multifaceted engagement activities…in the social, economic and military spheres.” 24 In cooperation with state and municipal agencies, the program provided assistance and training in “emergency management, disaster relief operations, civil and criminal justice, judicial processes, and law enforcement.” 25 As a result of these engagements over time, more informal relationships developed. “Through SPP, many countries have established successful governmental, educational, and medical relationships with counterpart agencies from the partner states.” 26
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › COMPETITION/THEORY › 2NC---Theory---AT: 50 State Fiat Bad
Clint Peinhardt & Todd Sandler, 15 (Clint Peinhardt is a Professor in the Political Science department at UT, and Todd Sandler is a professor of economics at the University of Wyoming and has received a NATO postdoctoral fellowship in science and a National Defense Education Association fellowship, August 2015, accessed on 5-24-2022, Oxford Scholarship Online, “Principles of Collective Action and Game Theory”, https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199398607.001.0001/acprof-9780199398607-chapter-2, HBisevac)
A final distinction is between cooperative and noncooperative games. A noncooperative game has each player acting on his/her own. In contrast, cooperative game theory involves players acting in unison as a coalition to maximize some joint gain that is subsequently divided among coalition members. The devil is in the details because how to divide the collective gain is never clear and can be done in various ways. Even though this book is about transnational cooperation, we rely exclusively on noncooperative game theory for a number of reasons. First, all cooperative games can be expressed as a noncooperative game. Second, a noncooperative game can encompass cooperative or mutually beneficial outcomes along with mutually deficient outcomes. Third, by eschewing cooperative games, we do not have to impose a payoff division assumption that can always be subject to question. Fourth, countries cherish their sovereignty and rarely form tight, enforceable ties With Other countries that allow the collective to act as one, as required by cooperative game. For example, NATO allies must vote unanimously on key policies (for example, membership expansion or changes in military doctrine), thereby effectively preserving members' sovereignty. As such, NATO is a loose alliance because allies can block undesirable policy changes or decisions. Fifth, cooperative games require a good deal of algebra, which we can avoid by staying with a noncooperative game representation.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › COMPETITION/THEORY › 2NC---Perm---AT: Do CP
Thompson ’21 [Thompson School District; 2021; Public school district for Loveland, Colorado and surrounding area; Thompson Schools, “Structures of Government,” ]
Australia, Switzerland, Canada, Mexico, Germany, India, and some 20 other stats also have federal forms of government today. In the United States, the term ‘Federal Government’ is often used to refer to the National Government, but note that the 50 state governments are unitary in structure, not federal.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › COMPETITION/THEORY › 2NC---Perm---AT: Do CP
U.S. Legal ’16 [U.S. Legal; 2016; Organization offering legal assistance and attorney access; U.S. Legal, “United States Federal Government Law and Legal Definition,” ]
The United States Federal Government is established by the US Constitution. The Federal Government shares sovereignty over the United Sates with the individual governments of the States of US. The Federal government has three branches: i) the legislature, which is the US Congress, ii) Executive, comprised of the President and Vice president of the US and iii) Judiciary. The US Constitution prescribes a system of separation of powers and ‘checks and balances’ for the smooth functioning of all the three branches of the Federal Government. The US Constitution limits the powers of the Federal Government to the powers assigned to it; all powers not expressly assigned to the Federal Government are reserved to the States or to the people.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
STATE PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM CP › COMPETITION/THEORY › 2NC---Perm---AT: Do Both
James N. Williams, 12 (Lieutenant Colonel James N. Williams, Army National Guard, March 2012, accessed on 6-30-2022, United States Army War Project Strategy Research Project, “The National Guard State Partnership Program: Element of Smart Power”, , HBisevac)
Any new directives, regulations or statutory authorities would be most effective with a “bottom-up” approach, using input from the National Guard to the greatest extent possible. Given the vastness and diversity of the programs requirements, the coordinators at the National Guard Bureau level should be the “trusted advisors” to ensure that language incorporated into evolving guidance ensure the flexibility required to administer the program effectively “where the rubber meets the road.”
The Bureau can most effectively synthesize the discrete nuances across the program into a cohesive representation for the further development of directives and authorities. Without initial input from the program level, any top-driven attempts to develop guidance will ultimately fail to achieve the balance and flexibility required to effectively administer the program. The National Guard Bureau has had over twenty years experience with this program and is the only single agency that truly has the “big picture.” The Bureau is more than capable of fairly and honestly representing the needs of the partner nations consistent with the requirements of the Department of State, the Geographic Combatant Commanders and the American taxpayers.