Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Negative
K › Set Col › 2NC---Link---Set Col

Reformism is not emancipatory but instead contributes to the iterative perfection of colonial capitalism – the transformative potential of legal change is circumscribed by hegemonic power structures that are embedded in international political systems.

Vanni ’21 -- Dr. Vanni obtained both her PhD and LLM degrees in International Economic Law from the University of Warwick, where her doctoral thesis was awarded the 2018 SIEL–Hart Prize in International Economic Law. She has BA(Hons) in International Relations and Politics from Keele University, where was awarded the Vice-Chancellor Partial Scholarship (2004-2007). Dr. Vanni currently teaches the undergraduate and postgraduate modules in intellectual property law (Amaka Vanni, 3-23-2021, "On Intellectual Property Rights, Access to Medicines and Vaccine Imperialism," TWAILR, , accessed 8-24-2021) //nikki

These events – the corporate capture of the global pharmaceutical IP regime, state complicity and vaccine imperialism – are not new. Recall Article 7 of TRIPS, which states that the objective of the Agreement is the ‘protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights [to] contribute to the promotion of technological innovation and to the transfer and dissemination of technology’. In similar vein, Article 66(2) of TRIPS further calls on developed countries to ‘provide incentives to enterprises and institutions within their territories to promote and encourage technology transfer to least-developed country’. While the language of ‘transfer of technology’ might seem beneficial or benign, in actuality it is not. As I discussed in my book, and as Carmen Gonzalez has also shown, when development objectives are incorporated into international legal instruments and institutions, they become embedded in structures that may constrain their transformative potential and reproduce North-South power imbalances. This is because these development objectives are circumscribed by capitalist imperialist structures, adapted to justify colonial practices and mobilized through racial differences. These structures are the essence of international law and its institutions even in the twenty-first century. They continue to animate broader socio-economic engagement with the global economy even in the present as well as in the legal and regulatory codes that support them. Thus, it is not surprising that even in current global health crisis, calls for this same transfer of technology in the form of a TRIPS waiver to scale up global vaccine production is being thwarted by the hegemony of developed states inevitably influenced by their respective pharmaceutical companies. The ‘emancipatory potential’ of TRIPS cannot be achieved if it was not created to be emancipatory in the first place. It also makes obvious the ways international IP law is not only unsuited to promote structural reform to enable the self-sufficiency and self-determination of the countries in the global south, but also produces asymmetries that perpetuate inequalities. Concluding Remarks What this pandemic makes clear is that the development discourse often touted by developed nations to help countries in the Global South ‘catch up’ is empty when the essential medicines needed to stay alive are deliberately denied and weaponised. Like the free-market reforms designed to produce ‘development’, IP deployed to incentivise innovation is yet another tool in the service of private profits. As this pandemic has shown, the reality of contemporary capitalism – including the IP regime that underpins it – is competition among corporate giants driven by profit and not by human need. The needs of the poor weigh much less than the profits of big business and their home states. However, it is not all doom and gloom. Countries such as India, China and Russia have stepped up in the distribution of vaccines or what many call ‘vaccine diplomacy.’ Further, Cuba’s vaccine candidate Soberana 02, which is currently in final clinical trial stages and does not require extra refrigeration, promises to be a suitable option for many countries in the global South with infrastructural and logistical challenges. Importantly, Cuba’s history of medical diplomacy in other global South countries raises hope that the country will be willing to share the know-how with other manufactures in various non-western countries, which could help address artificial supply problems and control over distribution. In sum, this pandemic provides an opportune moment to overhaul this dysfunctional global IP system. We need not wait for the next crisis to learn the lessons from this crisis.

2022 Michigan Negative
K › Set Col › 2NC---Link---Set Col

Legal agreements are grounded in the construction of intellectual property regulations as enlightened safeguards against the primitive savagery of indigenous conceptualizations of property – international legal frameworks are an ethically bankrupt starting point for change.

Rahmatian ’10 -- Professor of Commercial Law at the University of Glasgow (Andreas Rahmatian, 6-23-2010, "Neo-Colonial Aspects of Global Intellectual Property Protection," The Journal of World Intellectual Property, Vol. 12, No. 1, pp. 40-74, 2010, , accessed 8-27-2021) //nikki --bracketed for ableist language

The problems that the establishment of an international legal framework for world trade could pose for developing countries had been noticed right from the beginning. In 1964, the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) was founded because it was felt by developing countries that the pattern of world trade disproportionately favoured the industrialised nations (Blakeney, 1996, p. 26; Zamora, 1995, pp. 512, 518). In the course of the negotiations leading to the Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organisation (WTO Agreement), a convergence in the positions of the industrialised and the developing countries has repeatedly been attempted, with some success (Blakeney, 1996, p. 6). When the Uruguay Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) ended with the Final Act on the results of the Uruguay Round and the Agreement establishing the WTO in Marrakesh on April 15, 1995, the creation of the WTO as a specialised agency of the UN realised the hope (reaching back to the time of the creation of the UN itself) of an international organisation with responsibility for world trade (Blakeney, 1996, pp. 29, 36; Zamora, 1995, pp. 503, 506; Jackson, 1998, pp. 24-9); thus in theory, the promotion of world trade should benefit each Member, developed or developing alike. The preamble to the WTO Agreement states expressly in the second paragraph that especially the least developed countries should be secured “a share in the growth of international trade commensurate with the needs of their economic development”. This overriding principle also applies to TRIPs (Appendix 1C to the WTO Agreement), and the preamble to TRIPs expressly recognises (in paragraph 6) the special needs of the least-developed countries as far as the required domestic implementation of laws and regulations is concerned, “in order to enable them to create a sound and viable technological base ...”. These aims indicate the intention to create the implementation of a benign system of universal common standards of intellectual property rights for the mutual benefit of all nations. However, it is well known that originally the principal objective of what was to become TRIPs was actually the fight against piracy of Western intellectual property rights in developing countries. In the 1970s, the realisation of the adverse effect which the increase of sales of counterfeited trade-marked goods had on trade income prompted industrialised countries to reach an “Agreement on Measures to Discourage the Importation of Counterfeit Goods”, whereby the United States took the lead.8 It was also the United States which pushed for a recognition of legislative measures for the protection of intellectual property rights as to be considered within the jurisdiction of GATT, and not of WIPO only, as developing countries, especially Brazil and India, had argued (Blakeney, 1996, pp. 2-3; Zamora, 1995, p. 529). This was the starting point for the present situation of TRIPs being within the WTO framework (Drahos with Braithwaite, 2002, p. 109).9 The “anti-counterfeit” origin of TRIPs does not appear in its final preamble (Blakeney, 1996, p. 9), but the preamble makes clear that the objective of TRIPs is “the provision of effective and appropriate means for the enforcement of trade-related intellectual property rights, taking into account differences in national legal systems”, which obviously encompasses measures against counterfeited goods. Thus TRIPs grew out of the endeavours by the Western industrialised world to safeguard and enforce their own Western intellectual property rights, based on Western concepts, in the non-Western, and typically developing, countries.10 Theoretically, this could have been achieved without any reciprocity, because what really matters to Western interests is that Western rights are respected in a nonWestern context and culture, especially by way of an effective combat against piracy. Thus bilateral agreements could have been reached ensuring that, say, a US patent will be duly protected and enforced in developing country X, without the requirement that a patent granted in X will be enforced in the US, or indeed, without X even being required to maintain a national patent law which could enable X to grant patents itself; hence there would be no (theoretically) enforceable right in a country outside X. Such a measure would be openly colonial in its approach, but politically unsustainable in the late twentieth century or today, because the developing countries have achieved sufficient political counterbalance against Western interests during the period of decolonialisation that allows them to counteract such strategies at a large scale.11 TRIPs wishes to represent a compromise, which may have been honestly conceived as such in that it leaves some flexibility for developing countries (Correa, 2002, p. 52), but, as it is modelled on Western intellectual property legislation, it is nevertheless in effect slanted in favour of Western interests (Drahos with Braithwaite, 2002, pp. 11-6, 143-6; Correa, 2000, p. 3; Robbani, 2005, pp. 565, 571). The “provision of effective and appropriate means for the enforcement of trade-related intellectual property rights” (preamble, pt. c) is obtained through an introduction of minimum standards of intellectual property protection (Article 1 (1) TRIPs). These minimum standards are determined by TRIPs itself, which is remarkably detailed for an international instrument in respect of the substantive law of the respective intellectual property rights,12 and by broad reference to the central international intellectual property conventions, especially the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property 1883 (Paris Convention) and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works 1886 (Berne Convention).13 The principle of minimum standards as a basis of mutual recognition and protection of intellectual property rights is reinforced by the national treatment rule (Article 3) which echoes the existing intellectual property conventions in this respect.14 As a result, non-Western countries are required to introduce comprehensively the Western regime of intellectual property rights, irrespective of whether this regime is necessarily compatible with, and useful to, their own cultures and economies,15 otherwise they would not be able to conform to the protection obligation of Western intellectual property rights in their own territory. Non-Western countries are also expected to undergo an industrialisation process according to the model of Western industrialised nations to create a context in which Western intellectual property rights would then become meaningful (Ngenda, 2005; Gana, 1996, p. 738). In return for the protection of their own rights, Western countries could generously agree to recognise Westerntype intellectual property rights originating from developing countries, because these rights were unlikely to arise often and would not pose a real competitive threat.16 This is a good example of the liberal ideal of two equal contracting parties that [ignores] the real imbalance created by political and economic realities. It could also be seen as a modern version of constructed savagery of the non-developed world which will be overcome by the gift of intellectual property rights from the developed and civilised nations.17 How Western in nature TRIPs effectively is, can be shown by the fact that Western national legal systems have had to adapt little to TRIPs,18 while, for example, Latin American and Carribean states had to make significant changes in their intellectual property laws to implement the minimum standards (Correa, 2000, pp. 101, 111).19 More recently, TRIPs also serves as a bottom line for further extension of IP protection which the developed world continues to push for in bilateral “TRIPsPlus” agreements with countries of the developing world (Drahos, 2001, p. 805). Such “friendly nudges” towards adaptation of international standards are obviously not a development of the postcolonial era. The national treatment provision of the Paris Convention in Article 2 intended to compel Paris Union members to provide mutually adequate industrial property laws. It contributed to Switzerland’s decision to introduce a patent law (which it did not have when it joined the Paris Union) in order to be able to give effect to this obligation towards nationals of the Paris Union (Oddi, 1987, p. 869). The Netherlands also enacted patent laws which it had abolished some time before (Bender, 2000, p. 54; Drahos with Braithwaite, 2002, p. 36). The Paris Convention, and later the Berne Convention, had the then industrialised Western countries of the 1880s as relevant potential members to the Paris/Berne Union in mind; the non-Western world (where it did not have the status of a colony anyway and was therefore part of the Paris/Berne Union, see Drahos, 2002a, pp. 766-7; Drahos with Braithwaite, 2002, p. 75) was not perceived as a significant candidate for such conventions, and conflicts with indigenous cultures as a result of this transplantation of rights were then unlikely to be noticed as a potential problem. Sensitivity in relation to one-sided technology transfer and possible lack of economic equality was also less developed in the nineteenth century, despite an otherwise generally far greater tendency to arrogant nationalism among the European nations. An example is the awkward British standard gauge of railways of 561 /2 inches (1,435 mm) that can be found in much of Continental Europe (which adopted the metric system far earlier) because George Stevenson’s first locomotives delivered from England were produced with this gauge. The legal protection of such technological innovations usually follows suit and that may help explaining why it was possible at all to agree on a modest legal standardisation through the Paris and Berne Conventions in the much more belligerent atmosphere of the nineteenth century.

2022 Michigan Negative
K › Set Col › 2NC---Link---Set Col

Intellectual property is rooted in the universal exportation of the Western liberal philosophical tradition that idealizes private property arrangements – patent law is an extension of cultural imperialism invested in the preservation of whiteness at the expense of the global South.

Roy ’16 -- Professor Alpana Roy is the Dean of Law at the University of Waikato, a legal academic and practitioner, and an accredited mediator. Her areas of research expertise include intellectual property and information technology (IT) law, internet and domain name law, traditional and Indigenous knowledge, and alternative dispute resolutionAlpana Roy, 6-29-2016, "Copyright: A Colonial Doctrine in a Postcolonial Age," COPYRIGHT REPORTER, Vol. 26, No. 4, December 2008: 112-134, , accessed 8-24-2021) //nikki

In this article, I am interested in exploring the legal doctrine of copyright from the standpoint of a postcolonial critic. According to Shelley Wright, there is a ‘deep and continuing grip of colonial thinking on all systems currently in place, from the personal and local to the global.’1 And the law of copyright is no exception. Like other areas of intellectual property, copyright as a Western philosophical idea, is deeply imbued with the values of the European Enlightenment, liberalism, and a society founded on a print-based culture. As Wright suggests, copyright continues to be one of ‘the quintessential representations of the modern, public world of bourgeois expansion, male dominance and European colonial infl uence in the creation of political and economic systems in Europe and the colonies.’2 Indeed, the Western history of copyright is inextricably tied to the Western history of colonialism. A major argument in this article is that copyright (like other forms of intellectual property) is not a natural right, but instead embodies a particular set of values and assumptions – such as the need to commodify ideas, and also the expression of those ideas. As a product of the European Enlightenment, the concept of copyright has been infused with the ideals of the liberal legal tradition, and these ideals – such as ‘private property’, ‘authorship’ and ‘possessive individualism’ – are not universal principles of property law, but instead are Western ones. Consequently, the supposedly universally-shared view of copyright law embodied in international agreements such as the Berne Convention and the TRIPS Agreement are not simply ‘agreements’, but rather are multifaceted projects (or dominant narratives) which are laden with values stemming from particular cultural traditions, and which have evolved from particular historical moments in Western history. However, while these values have been packaged and exported around the globe based on their apparent universality, it is signifi cant to note that copyright remains a foreign concept in many cultures. Indeed, a number of societies take a radically different view as to ‘what constitutes property or what may rightfully be the subject of private ownership.’3 Several cultures also consider ‘copying’ or sharing ideas within a community as a sign of respect and recognition – not as piracy, or a violation of private property rights.4 Before moving on to explore the concept of copyright law in more detail, I should outline my reasons for wishing to scrutinise the laws in this area using a postcolonial lens. Copyright is a multi-billion dollar global industry, which has increasingly become an enormous source of revenue for countries of the North.5 From a postcolonial perspective, the export of copyright products raises particular concerns as these items are not simply just another trade commodity, but emblematise the exporting cultures’ values and traditions. In other words, Disney movies and MTV songs are not simply just another product because they represent the cultural signs and symbols of the dominant narrative.6 Due to the enormous volume and dominant position of Western popular culture on a global scale, critics have labeled this essentially one-way traffi c as a form of ‘cultural imperialism’ in this postcolonial era. As Fredric Jameson suggests, the export of American culture around the globe has had a far deeper impact than earlier forms of colonisation, imperialism or simple tourism, as these cultural goods (along with agribusiness and weapons) constitute the principal economic exports for the US.7 Moreover, the current imbalance in global information fl ows is in many ways merely an extension of the exploitative colonial past. For this reason, Philip Altbach asserts that ‘[c]opyright must not be seen in isolation from issues of access to knowledge, the needs of Third World nations, and the broad history of colonialism and exploitation.’8 I also wish to examine the concept of copyright law in more detail in order to partially fi ll the gap in understanding of the negative impact of an overly prescriptive international copyright regime. This is important, as most of the opposition in the late 1990s to the international intellectual property regime primarily focused on the dire effects of patents for countries in the South.9 This article will begin by exploring the concept of copyright law as essentially a Western idea, and then move on to discuss copyright and the colonial process, the Berne Convention and the TRIPS Agreement as colonial (and postcolonial) constructs, and the role of international copyright law in continually othering the South in the global publishing and software industries. The Western liberal idea of intellectual property law has now been globalised through the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights or TRIPS.78 The TRIPS Agreement was established as part of the World Trade Organization (WTO) regime that came into operation on 1 January 1995. TRIPS is one of the number of agreements which make up the WTO, and links intellectual property rights to WTO obligations. This international legally binding agreement establishes minimum standards for intellectual property rights, which members of the WTO must implement through national legislation. Under TRIPS, the 151 members of the WTO (at 27 July 2007) are required to give effect to a set of basic minimum principles and rules covering copyright, trademarks, patents, layout-designs of integrated circuits, geographical indications, industrial designs, and protection of undisclosed information. There are also uniform remedies available for the enforcement of these rights. In many cases, nations are applying higher standards than were previously applied in their domestic law. For example, longer terms of protection, fewer exceptions to the scope of rights, and sometimes new rights. While the Agreement has only been in force for thirteen years, it has been heavily criticised by Southern nations as essentially a neocolonial instrument – privileging the colonial view over the postcolonial ambitions of the Other.79 Copyright protection is provided for in Articles 9–14 of the TRIPS Agreement. These provisions are discussed briefl y below.

2022 Michigan Negative
K › Set Col › 1NC---Link---Set Col

The global intellectual property regime functions to preserve imperial hegemony and accumulative neoliberalism and sanctions the systematic theft of essential medical resources from non-Western nations -- this necessitates structural violence on an international scale.

Vanni ’21 -- Dr. Vanni obtained both her PhD and LLM degrees in International Economic Law from the University of Warwick, where her doctoral thesis was awarded the 2018 SIEL–Hart Prize in International Economic Law. She has BA(Hons) in International Relations and Politics from Keele University, where was awarded the Vice-Chancellor Partial Scholarship (2004-2007). Dr. Vanni currently teaches the undergraduate and postgraduate modules in intellectual property law (Amaka Vanni, 3-23-2021, "On Intellectual Property Rights, Access to Medicines and Vaccine Imperialism," TWAILR, , accessed 8-24-2021) //nikki

TRIPS Agreement and Access to Medicines Intellectual property rights (IPRs) are time-limited legal rights granted to inventors and creators. IPRs include copyrights, trademarks, patents, trade secrets, and geographical indications, while protected subject-matters include, but are not limited to, brands, inventions, designs, and biological materials. Importantly, IPRs overlap as a product may be covered by a series of rights. For example, a pharmaceutical medicine, defined by Britannica as a ‘substance used in the diagnosis, treatment, or prevention of disease’, is protected by patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. Patents are the most common form of IPR used for the protection of innovation in pharmaceuticals. Patents grant inventors limited market exclusivity for their inventions, and, in exchange, the inventor must disclose sufficient information such that competitors will be able to step into the market. This disclosure allows a competitor to make preparation to enter the market at the end of the monopoly period. Due to this legally-mandated exclusivity, patent owners – usually multinational corporations – have the right to prevent others from making, using, or selling a patented invention. The TRIPS Agreement, concluded as part of the Uruguay Round of multilateral trade negotiation and in force since 1995, provides a minimum of 20 years patent protection. The belief is that the duration allows corporations to recoup the expenses of developing, testing and upscaling an innovative pharmaceutical product. From the onset, the TRIPS IP regime created imbalance between innovation, market monopoly, and medicines access, because it failed to take into consideration the health burden, development needs and local conditions of the various countries that make up the WTO. This has led to several issues. First, the market monopoly of IP rights, which allows the corporation to set the market for drugs, has created a privileged societal class with access to lifesaving medication distinguishing them from those excluded from access to available medications. This phenomenon is vividly illustrated in the HIV/AIDS crisis of the 1990s and early 2000s. While HIV/AIDS patients in developed countries were able to afford antiretroviral (ARVs) treatments, which had been developed, approved and patented as early as 1987, many patients in Africa and other parts of the developing world could not afford the approximately USD 12,000 per annum treatment at that time. By 2001, approximately 2.4 million people in the region had died of AIDS. The South African government intervened to reduce the cost of ARVs by amending its domestic patent laws to allow the authorization of parallel imports of patented pharmaceuticals and to encourage the use of generic drugs, but it was sued by the US industry group Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA). Though the lawsuit was eventually dropped, it highlights the measures pharmaceutical corporations, backed by some national governments, are willing to take to protect their profits at the cost of human lives. Significantly, we see how law (or the threat of legal action) is used not only to protect and expand the profitability of a certain kind of property but, as Anjali Vats and Deidré Keller have taught us, also reveals IP law’s racial investments in whiteness and its continuing implications for racial (in)equality, particularly in the way it informs systems of ownership, circulation, and distribution of knowledge. Similarly, Natsu Saito takes up the analysis of IP, race and capitalism by theorizing some of the ways in which ‘value’ in IP law concentrated in the hands of large corporations is calculated in terms of its profitability rather than what it contributes to the well-being of society. However, the proverbial chickens have come home to roost as even rich countries are beginning to feel the bite of the dysfunctional IP system. The issue of excessive pricing for medicines is a growing problem in developed countries as well and has now become the single biggest category of healthcare spending in these states, particularly the US. An empirical report by I-MAK reveals how excessive pharmaceutical patenting is extending monopolies and driving up drug prices. The report, for example, notes that over half of the top twelve drugs in the US have more than 100 attempted patents per drug. Specifically, the report revealed that Humira® by AbbVie (used in the treatment of Crohn’s disease and the US’s highest grossing drug) has been issued 130 patents. The drug costs USD 44,000 annually and generated more than USD 19.2 billion for the company in 2019 alone. The Report also notes that the first patent filed for Herceptin® – used in the treatment for certain breast and stomach cancers – was in 1985 but currently has pending patent applications that could extend its market monopoly for 48 more years. Meanwhile, Celgene has over 105 patents for its oral cancer drug Revlimid® (used in the treatment of multiple myeloma) extending its monopoly until the end of 2036 – a patent lifespan of 40 years. In addition to excessive patenting and pricing, we have also come to understand the power of data in this context. Health inequity and inequalities in vaccine access are not unfortunate outcomes of the global IP regime; they are part of its central architecture. The system is functioning exactly as it is set up to do. Second, regulatory agencies worldwide require drugs to undergo safety and efficacy testing to ensure they are harmless before approval. These tests, known as clinical trials, involve human subjects and are costly because they can run up to three separate phases. The data collected during these clinical trials are the proprietary materials of the company conducting the tests. Because it is expensive and time-consuming, generic drug companies usually rely on the safety and efficacy data of brand name companies to seek regulatory approval as long as they can prove their generic version is chemically and biologically equivalent to the original. Relying on the test data of brand name companies reduces the production cost for generic medicines and allows for quicker market entry. However, recent years have seen a promotion of time-limited, legally mandated protection against the non-proprietary use of such data by generic companies. This is known as data exclusivity. Put differently, data exclusivity is a period when a generic company cannot use the clinical trial data of an innovator pharmaceutical company to receive regulatory approval for a generic medicine. In so doing, data exclusivity provides a layer of protection in addition to patent protection to further delay market entry of generic medicines. Data exclusivity periods vary depending on the jurisdiction. For example, it is twelve years in US and ten years in the EU. While the TRIPS Agreement does not create property rights over registration data, the US and the EU have continued to champion and export data exclusivity through free trade agreements, particularly for biologics. For example, the US Affordable Health Care for America Act in 2009 extended a 12-year exclusivity period for biologics. This US interpretation for registration data was also included in the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), which sought a 10-year data exclusivity for new biologics. However, after intense negotiations, the data exclusivity protection was reduced to 5 years for new pharmaceuticals. In this instance, we see a crystallising of Euro-American ideas of property and a willingness to promote those property interests through the law, both domestic and international. In fact, certain scholars assert that this pursuit of higher TRIPS standards is driven, in part, by the US desire to achieve levels of protection it anticipated from the TRIPS Agreement but failed to secure. Given the influence of the industry and its representative group, PhRMA, in seeking stronger protection on a global scale, it is not surprising that the US’s post-TRIPS policies continue to rachet up standards in ways that undermine access to affordable medicines, and perpetuate social hierarchy and subordination. Third, patent practices in recent decades have seen pharmaceutical companies engaging in trivial and cosmetic tweaking of a drug whilst still reaping the benefit of 20 years of patent protection. This tweaking sometimes involves making minor changes to patented drugs, such as changes in mode of administration, new dosages, extended release, or change in color of the drug. These changes normally do not offer any significant therapeutic advantage even though pharmaceutical companies argue they provide improved health outcomes to patients. These additional patents on small changes to existing drugs, known as evergreening or patent thickets, block the early entry of competitive, generic medicines that drive medicine prices down. For example, while not mandated by TRIPS, many US led TRIPS-plus free trade agreements have expanded the scope for evergreening. These include the US-Jordan FTA (2000), US-Australia FTA (2004) as well as the US-Korea FTA (2007), which allow for the patenting of new forms, uses, or methods of using existing products. The development discourse often touted by developed nations to help countries in the Global South ‘catch up’ is empty when the essential medicines needed to stay alive are deliberately denied and weaponised. The cancer drug Gleevec®, owned by Novartis, is another example of how pharmaceutical companies often secure patents on new, more convenient versions with marginal therapeutic benefit to patients whilst blocking the entry of generic medicines. In 2013, Novartis’ patent application for Gleevec®– the β crystalline form of the salt imatinib mesylate – was rejected by the Indian Supreme Court because it lacked novelty. However, the company has secured patents for this product in other jurisdictions such as the US and has maintained a high price of Gleevec there. But in India the price of Gleevec® was reduced from approximately USD 2,200 to USD 88 for one month’s treatment in the generic drugs market as a result of the 2013 Indian Supreme Court judgement. Novartis is not the only culprit. The depression drug Effexor® by Pfizer was granted an evergreen patent when the company introduced an extended-release version, Efexor-XR®, even though there was no additional benefit to patients. Eventually, the patent was declared invalid, but by then it had already cost an estimated USD 209 million to Australian taxpayers and kept generic competition off the market for two and a half years. In another instance, Pfizer went on to secure an additional patent for the Pristiq®, which contained identical chemical compound as Efexor-XR®,and again with no added therapeutic benefit. These evergreening practices, of course, have material effects. Apart from delaying the entry of generic versions, they give brand-name pharmaceutical companies free reign in the market, which allows them to set the market price. Recent years have seen monopoly prices rise exorbitantly causing significant financial strain to patients, domestic healthcare services and even insurance companies in developed countries. A notorious example is Martin Shkreli, who in 2015 bought the rights to an anti-malarial drug, then raised the price by 5,000 per cent from a cost of USD 13.50 to USD 750. Similarly, a white paper by I-MAK shows how excessive patenting and related strategies are driving families to overspend on lifesaving medicines. Celgene, the makers of Revlimid® raised the price of the drug by more than 50 per cent since 2012 to over USD 125,000 per year of treatment. Using the example of Solvadi® by Gilead, which costs USD 84,000 per treatment, Feldman notes the drug would cost the US Department of Defense more than USD 12 billion to treat all hepatitis-infected patients in US Veterans Affairs. But the US is not alone. In Europe, expensive drugs have prompted a growing backlash against pharmaceutical corporations. Reacting to these price hikes, Dutch pharmacies are bypassing these exorbitant prices by preparing medicines in-house for individual patients. The broken IP system ranging from an extraordinarily low standard for granting patents to permissions of patent thickets around a single molecule has not only severely distorted the system of innovation, but they have also skewed access to life-saving drugs. As a result, prices for new and existing medicines are constantly rising, making essential medicines inaccessible for millions of people around the world.

2022 Michigan Negative
K › Cap › 1NC---Link---Cap

IP is a crucial part of intellectual capitalism.

Granstand, 99 [Ove Granstrand works for the Dept. of Industrial Management and Economics at Chalmers University of Technology, 1999, accessed on 7-18-2022, Nordic Journal of Political Economy, "Intellectual Capitalism – An overview", https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.199.735&rep=rep1&type=pdf]/ISEE

What then is intellectual capitalism? Standard dictionary and textbook definitions of capitalism refer to an economic system characterized by private ownership of the means of production and by operation of a market with enterprises competing for private profits, etc.9 Hence a necessary condition for intellectual capitalism to be present is to have private ownership of intellectual capital. This is what the intellectual property rights system as an institution allows for. However, most intellectual property rights are temporary, and when patents and secrets expire, the corresponding information becomes public property.10 In that sense, there is a feature of “intellectual socialism” as well. Still, if the share of industrially useful knowledge generated in the private domain compared to the public domain is large, and if its growth rate is also large, then at some point privately held knowledge will dominate. For example, if technical knowledge is doubled every seventh year and all new knowledge is privatized through patents for twenty years before it becomes publicly owned, then close to 7/8 (= 87.5%) of the knowledge is under private ownership at any one point.11 The exact figures are not important here, of course, but what is important is the fact that if privately held knowledge grows faster than that which is publicly held, it will dominate in the not so distant future.12 In broad terms intellectual capitalism can be interpreted as a confluence of a capitalist economy and a knowledge or information economy. More specifically, intellectual capitalism is taken here to refer to an economic system with basic capitalist institutions (private property rights, private profit, competitive markets and free enterprise) in which productive assets and processes, as well as commercial transactions and products, are predominantly intellectual or immaterial rather than physical in nature.

2022 Michigan Negative
K › Afropess/Racial Cap › 1NC---Link---Afropess/Racial Cap

Intellectual Property protections are rooted in a white racial project.

Vats, 21 [Anjali Vats is an Associate Professor of Law, with a secondary appointment in Communication, at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law., 7-15-2021, accessed on 7-16-2022, Taylor & Francis, "The color of creatorship: intellectual property, race, and the making of Americans",

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW, the body of legal doctrine and practice that governs the ownership of information, is animated by a dichotomy of creatorship and infringement. In the most often repeated narratives of creatorship/infringement in the United States, the former produces a social and economic good while the latter works against the production of that social and economic good. Creators, those individuals whose work is deemed protectable under copyright, patent, trademark, trade secret, and unfair competition law, create valuable products that contribute to economic growth and public knowledge. Infringers, those individuals who use the work of creators without their permission, steal those valuable products and act as drains on economic growth and public knowledge. These narratives, while comforting, are frequently oversimplified in public cultural conversations, in ways that center and elevate Westernness and whiteness and obscure and replicate histories of race and (neo)colonialism. The Color of Creatorship is a book about the historical and continuing relationships between race and (neo)coloniality in intellectual property law. In it, I join a respected and growing group of scholars in contending that intellectual property law is a set of rhetorics about citizenship. However, unlike those who have previously written about the relationships between intellectual property and citizenship, I focus on the latter as a discourse through which race and coloniality continue to structure doctrinal practices in copyright, patent, and trademark law. Citizenship in the United States was and continues to be a raced concept. More specifically, it is a concept constructed by and through constantly evolving public cultural conceptions of Americanness, white masculinity, property, racial capitalism, and labor. I use the term “intellectual property citizenship” as an anchoring analytic for understanding how intellectual property and citizenship have evolved—and continue to evolve—in deeply intertwined and raced ways. Through a periodic analysis of American legal cases, political speeches, and cultural practices, this book shows that copyright, patent, and trademark regimes are imagined through always already racialized notions of citizenship that purport to be free of racial bias. Citizenship, while presumed to be race neutral, is frequently defined via shifting normative claims about race, gender, and class and implicit definitions of “good citizens.”1 This book is more specifically about the complex ways that whiteness and its attendant property interests structure intellectual property law, often in the guise of equality and race neutrality.2 Racial inequality is a continuing and persistent problem in intellectual property law, not because of legal happenstance, economic motive, or racial accident but because copyright, patent, and trademark doctrines are fundamentally prefigured through raced conceptions of citizenship. Intellectual property citizenship, then, is a “grid of intelligibility”3—a framework for understanding how power is organized— that reveals the racializing and colonizing principles around which familiar and repeated doctrinal standards in copyright, patent, and trademark law were and are structured. The codified racial discrimination that made intellectual property law the purview of whites in the 1800s did not disappear. It persisted through the continuing racialized entanglements of the principles of EuroAmerican citizenship with the principles of Euro-American creatorship. Because conceptions of Americanness were and are structured through a trenchant “racial episteme,”4 a frame that a priori constrains possibilities for treating people of color as full persons, let alone full creators, the discourse of citizenship operates as a container for importing race into intellectual property law, even when the law itself purports to be colorblind. The continuing practice of thinking about copyright, patent, and trademark law through romanticized imaginings of American citizenship constrains the manner in which knowledge production/protection can be understood, managed, and adjudicated with respect to race. I do not claim that such racial investments explain the outcome in all intellectual property cases. However, I contend that intellectual property law is organized through a racial episteme that consistently protects the (intellectual) property interests of white people and devalues the (intellectual) property interests of people of color. Tracing “racial scripts” is a tangible method for understanding America’s racial episteme and how it informs citizenship and creatorship/infringement as discursive formations. Racial scripts are historically grounded and flexible racist logics about racial groups that can be accessed at any time to exclude the original or other people of color.5 They operate as shorthand mechanisms for calling upon dominant American ideals of national identity, patriotism, political economy, and personhood without necessarily explicitly invoking racial categories or colonial logics. In this way, racial scripts can be baked into the seemingly colorblind ideals of American citizenship that, in turn, inform intellectual property law. Examining how intellectual property law operates as a space of racial formation in which the meaning of racial categories evolves over time is a prerequisite to undoing entrenched white privilege and democratizing knowledge production and ownership.6 Intellectual property law is also a “racial project,”7 that reproduces particular racial orders, in which people of color are coded as lacking the capacity to create. Unspoken longings, fears, anxieties, and prejudices wrapped in economic and legal language move us to prefer certain intellectual property narratives over others, predictably to the detriment of people of color. When anti-racist, anti-colonial activists grapple with the racial episteme that structures intellectual property law, they can advocate for strategies that resist the underlying drivers of unjust copyright, patent, and trademark policies. While such resistive strategies may ultimately still provide only precarious and fleeting relief, as Derrick Bell famously argues, they confront the fears and anxieties that sustain racial and colonial knowledge hierarchies.8 This book contributes to a growing body of scholarship at the intersections of race and intellectual property law through its historically situated consideration of the links among race, coloniality, and knowledge governance.9 It traces evolutions in the racial rhetorics around copyrights, patents, and trademarks that unfolded in parallel with the economic and political turns of the nation. Such an inquiry is useful in contextualizing the increasingly important legal regimes governing knowledge that mark some bodies as not only inherently incapable of creatorship but also inherently undeserving of citizenship. As the racial rhetorics of intellectual property law have changed over time, in ways that are consistent with post–civil rights era colorblindness, they have come to exclude people of color in new and different ways. Accordingly, addressing intellectual property law’s structural inequalities requires thinking about how these racial evolutions persist in a nation that claims to value all people equally. When marginalized groups are considered to be “aberrations from the ethnoclass of Man”10 contra a white ideal, as Alexander Weheliye writes, they cannot fully occupy the space of creatorship or (intellectual) property ownership until the nation attends to the contours of inequality and exclusion. While Weheliye is commenting on anti-Blackness, his statement is true for all those people of color who are considered outside of the ethnoclass of Man. In the so-called information economy, intellectual property justice is racial justice. Working through key moments in intellectual property history in the period between 1790 and 2016 reveals that even as American understandings of creatorship/infringement have seemingly evolved, they have actually remained remarkably racially conservative and consistent over time. This book will not provide an exhaustive account of race, coloniality, and intellectual property law during that period. Such a project is neither possible nor desirable. Instead, it focuses on reading some of the most important and notable historical touchstones in copyright, patent, and trademark law as examples of the continuity of racial scripts and colonial relations of domination in the context of knowledge production. I INTRODUCTION CREATING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, CREATING AMERICANS Race enters writing, the making of art, as a structure of feeling, as something that structures feelings, that lays down tracks of affection and repulsion, rage and hurt, desire and ache. These tracks don’t only occur in the making of art; they also occur (sometimes viciously, sometimes hazily) in the reception of creative work. Here we are again: we’ve made this thing and we’ve sent it out into the world for recognition—and because what we’ve made is in essence a field of human experience created for other humans, the field and its maker and its readers are thus subject all over again to race and its infiltrations. In that moment arise all sorts of possible hearings and mis-hearings, all kinds of address and redress. —CLAUDIA RANKINE and BETH LOFFREDA, “On Whiteness and the Racial Imaginary” But you're a good girl! The way you grab me Must wanna get nasty Go ahead, get at me —ROBIN THICKE, PHARRELL WILLIAMS, AND T.I., “Blurred Lines” NTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW, the body of legal doctrine and practice that governs the ownership of information, is animated by a dichotomy of creatorship and infringement. In the most often repeated narratives of creatorship/infringement in the United States, the former produces a social and economic good while the latter works against the production of that social and economic good. Creators, those individuals whose work is deemed protectable under copyright, patent, trademark, trade secret, and unfair competition law, create valuable products that contribute to economic growth and public knowledge. Infringers, those individuals who use the work of creators without their permission, steal those valuable products and act as drains on economic growth and public knowledge. These narratives, while comforting, are frequently oversimplified in public cultural conversations, in ways that center and elevate Westernness and whiteness and obscure and replicate histories of race and (neo)colonialism. The Color of Creatorship is a book about the historical and continuing relationships between race and (neo)coloniality in intellectual property law. In it, I join a respected and growing group of scholars in contending that intellectual property law is a set of rhetorics about citizenship. However, unlike those who have previously written about the relationships between intellectual property and citizenship, I focus on the latter as a discourse through which race and coloniality continue to structure doctrinal practices in copyright, patent, and trademark law. Citizenship in the United States was and continues to be a raced concept. More specifically, it is a concept constructed by and through constantly evolving public cultural conceptions of Americanness, white masculinity, property, racial capitalism, and labor. I use the term “intellectual property citizenship” as an anchoring analytic for understanding how intellectual property and citizenship have evolved—and continue to evolve—in deeply intertwined and raced ways. Through a periodic analysis of American legal cases, political speeches, and cultural practices, this book shows that copyright, patent, and trademark regimes are imagined through always already racialized notions of citizenship that purport to be free of racial bias. Citizenship, while presumed to be race neutral, is frequently defined via shifting normative claims about race, gender, and class and implicit definitions of “good citizens.”1 This book is more specifically about the complex ways that whiteness and its attendant property interests structure intellectual property law, often in the guise of equality and race neutrality.2 Racial inequality is a continuing and persistent problem in intellectual property law, not because of legal happenstance, economic motive, or racial accident but because copyright, patent, and trademark doctrines are fundamentally prefigured through raced conceptions of citizenship. Intellectual property citizenship, then, is a “grid of intelligibility”3—a framework for understanding how power is organized— that reveals the racializing and colonizing principles around which familiar and repeated doctrinal standards in copyright, patent, and trademark law were and are structured. The codified racial discrimination that made intellectual property law the purview of whites in the 1800s did not disappear. It persisted through the continuing racialized entanglements of the principles of EuroAmerican citizenship with the principles of Euro-American creatorship. Because conceptions of Americanness were and are structured through a trenchant “racial episteme,”4 a frame that a priori constrains possibilities for treating people of color as full persons, let alone full creators, the discourse of citizenship operates as a container for importing race into intellectual property law, even when the law itself purports to be colorblind. The continuing practice of thinking about copyright, patent, and trademark law through romanticized imaginings of American citizenship constrains the manner in which knowledge production/protection can be understood, managed, and adjudicated with respect to race. I do not claim that such racial investments explain the outcome in all intellectual property cases. However, I contend that intellectual property law is organized through a racial episteme that consistently protects the (intellectual) property interests of white people and devalues the (intellectual) property interests of people of color. Tracing “racial scripts” is a tangible method for understanding America’s racial episteme and how it informs citizenship and creatorship/infringement as discursive formations. Racial scripts are historically grounded and flexible racist logics about racial groups that can be accessed at any time to exclude the original or other people of color.5 They operate as shorthand mechanisms for calling upon dominant American ideals of national identity, patriotism, political economy, and personhood without necessarily explicitly invoking racial categories or colonial logics. In this way, racial scripts can be baked into the seemingly colorblind ideals of American citizenship that, in turn, inform intellectual property law. Examining how intellectual property law operates as a space of racial formation in which the meaning of racial categories evolves over time is a prerequisite to undoing entrenched white privilege and democratizing knowledge production and ownership.6 Intellectual property law is also a “racial project,”7 that reproduces particular racial orders, in which people of color are coded as lacking the capacity to create. Unspoken longings, fears, anxieties, and prejudices wrapped in economic and legal language move us to prefer certain intellectual property narratives over others, predictably to the detriment of people of color. When anti-racist, anti-colonial activists grapple with the racial episteme that structures intellectual property law, they can advocate for strategies that resist the underlying drivers of unjust copyright, patent, and trademark policies. While such resistive strategies may ultimately still provide only precarious and fleeting relief, as Derrick Bell famously argues, they confront the fears and anxieties that sustain racial and colonial knowledge hierarchies.8 This book contributes to a growing body of scholarship at the intersections of race and intellectual property law through its historically situated consideration of the links among race, coloniality, and knowledge governance.9 It traces evolutions in the racial rhetorics around copyrights, patents, and trademarks that unfolded in parallel with the economic and political turns of the nation. Such an inquiry is useful in contextualizing the increasingly important legal regimes governing knowledge that mark some bodies as not only inherently incapable of creatorship but also inherently undeserving of citizenship. As the racial rhetorics of intellectual property law have changed over time, in ways that are consistent with post–civil rights era colorblindness, they have come to exclude people of color in new and different ways. Accordingly, addressing intellectual property law’s structural inequalities requires thinking about how these racial evolutions persist in a nation that claims to value all people equally. When marginalized groups are considered to be “aberrations from the ethnoclass of Man”10 contra a white ideal, as Alexander Weheliye writes, they cannot fully occupy the space of creatorship or (intellectual) property ownership until the nation attends to the contours of inequality and exclusion. While Weheliye is commenting on anti-Blackness, his statement is true for all those people of color who are considered outside of the ethnoclass of Man. In the so-called information economy, intellectual property justice is racial justice. Working through key moments in intellectual property history in the period between 1790 and 2016 reveals that even as American understandings of creatorship/infringement have seemingly evolved, they have actually remained remarkably racially conservative and consistent over time. This book will not provide an exhaustive account of race, coloniality, and intellectual property law during that period. Such a project is neither possible nor desirable. Instead, it focuses on reading some of the most important and notable historical touchstones in copyright, patent, and trademark law as examples of the continuity of racial scripts and colonial relations of domination in the context of knowledge production.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA › Decoupling DA › 2NC---XT---Uniquness

Further decoupling is destabilizing

Edward Wong 7/5, a diplomatic correspondent for The New York Times who reports on foreign policy from Washington, D.C, “U.S. Aims to Expand Export Bans on China Over Security and Human Rights”, The New York Times, 7-5-2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/05/us/politics/us-china-export-controls.html)/maze

The Biden administration on Tuesday put five Chinese companies on an export blacklist for continuing to support Russia’s military-industrial sector. It was the first time the U.S. government had taken action against Chinese companies for aiding Russia since the war in Ukraine began in February, though U.S. officials say the Chinese government and most companies appear to be complying with the U.S.-led sanctions.

Even before those actions, the Biden administration had doubled down on a Trump administration policy of wielding export controls as a cudgel against Chinese companies.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA › Decoupling DA › 1NC---OFF

Decoupling causes inevitable war and miscalculation.

Kevin Rudd 21, President of the Asia Society, in New York, and previously served as Prime Minister of Australia., “Short of War: How to Keep U.S.-Chinese Confrontation From Ending in Calamity”, Foreign Affairs(Vol. 100, Issue 2), March-April 2021, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2021-02-05/kevin-rudd-usa-chinese-confrontation-short-of-war)/maze

Officials in Washington and Beijing don't agree on much these days, but there is one thing on which they see eye to eye: the contest between their two  will enter a decisive phase in the 2020s. This will be the decade of living dangerously. No matter what strategies the two sides pursue or what events unfold, the tension between the  and  will grow, and competition will intensify; it is inevitable. , however, is not. It remains possible for the two countries to put in place guardrails that would prevent a catastrophe: a joint framework for what I call "managed strategic competition" would reduce the risk of competition escalating into open conflict. The  is increasingly confident that by the decade's end, China's economy will finally surpass that of the United States as the world's largest in terms of GDP at market exchange rates. Western elites may dismiss the significance of that milestone; the CCP's Politburo does not. For China, size always matters. Taking the number one slot will turbocharge Beijing's confidence, assertiveness, and leverage in its dealings with Washington, and it will make China's central bank more likely to float the yuan, open its capital account, and challenge the U.S. dollar as the main global reserve currency. Meanwhile, China continues to advance on other fronts, as well. A new policy plan, announced last fall, aims to allow China to dominate in all new technology domains, including artificial intelligence, by 2035. And Beijing now intends to complete its military modernization program by 2027 (seven years ahead of the previous schedule), with the main goal of giving China a decisive edge in all conceivable scenarios for a conflict with the United States over Taiwan. A victory in such a conflict would allow President Xi Jinping to carry out a forced reunification with Taiwan before leaving power--an achievement that would put him on the same level within the CCP pantheon as .

Washington must decide how to respond to Beijing's assertive agenda--and quickly. If it were to opt for economic decoupling and open confrontation, every country in the world would be forced to take sides, and the risk of escalation would only grow. Among policymakers and experts, there is understandable skepticism as to whether Washington and Beijing can avoid such an outcome. Many doubt that U.S. and  leaders can find their way to a framework to manage their diplomatic relations, , and activities in cyberspace within agreed parameters that would maximize stability, avoid accidental escalation, and make room for both competitive and collaborative forces in the relationship. The two countries need to consider something akin to the procedures and mechanisms that the United States and the  put in place to govern their relations after the Cuban missile crisis--but in this case, without first going through the near-death experience of a barely avoided war.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA › Decoupling DA › 1NC---OFF

US regulatory policy causes Chinese tit for tat retaliation which causes divergence.

Angela Zhang 21 an associate professor at the Faculty of Law in the University of Hong Kong. An expert in Chinese law,, “Chapter 5: Weaponizing Antitrust During Sino-US Tech War”, Chinese Antitrust Exceptionalism: How The Rise of China Challenges Global Regulation Oxford Scholarship Online: July 2021, https://global.oup.com/academic/product/chinese-antitrust-exceptionalism-9780198826569?cc=us&lang=en&)/maze

In response to US hostility, China has chosen to retaliate tit- for- tat. Such a strategy simultaneously consists of a promise and a threat: if the United States does nothing, then neither will China; conversely, if the United States attacks, so will China. One of the most famous examples of this strategy is the ‘liveand- let- live’ system that emerged during the trench warfare in the First World War.46 There, it was observed that cooperation is possible even amongst antagonists. Soldiers on the frontline defied orders from their higher command and refrained from shooting at the enemy as long as their opponents reciprocated. To deter America’s aggressive strategy of stifling Chinese leading technology companies, China has a few regulatory tools at its disposal. One of them is the AML which has emerged as a powerful economic weapon allowing the Chinese authority to exercise extraterritorial jurisdiction over foreign multinationals. The coercive capacity of the AML is expected to increase, given that a pending amendment to its powers would enhance its punitive capacities.

2.1 The Folk Theorem To illustrate China’s tit- for- tat strategy, consider the following hypothetical game between the United States and China.47 In this game, the United States makes the first move, and it must decide whether it will maintain the status quo of accommodating the rise of China or take a more aggressive stance in order to deter China from acting in a way that would harm US interests. In this hypothetical game, if the United States keeps to the status quo, both countries will receive the same payoff score of 10. However, if the United States takes an aggressive approach, it will receive a score of 15 and China will obtain a score of 1. China must then decide whether to punish the United States, which will harm both itself and the United States. If China chooses to punish the United States, then both countries gain nothing. While the cooperative outcome yields the highest joint payoffs for the two countries, this equilibrium cannot be achieved in a one- shot game. If the game is only played once, then the United States’ dominant strategy will be one of aggression in which it will receive the largest advantage. In this scenario, United States will obtain the maximum payoff of 15. China will not be content but it is better off acquiescing and collecting a payoff of 1 instead of being left with zero gain. However, in reality, the United States and China are repeatedly and continuously interacting with each other in this relationship. Given that this game involves an infinite number of interactions, China will opt for a different strategy to fulfil its objectives. It will choose to punish the United States, in which case the United States will obtain nothing. In anticipation of being punished by China, the United States will modify its strategy to tolerate China’s rise, as a result of which China will acquiesce, achieving a payoff of 10 for both players. The key to maintaining this equilibrium is the implicit threat of punishment, and peace is only possible if China has the capacity to retaliate against any US aggression. This logic applied during the Cold War. In his Nobel Peace Prize lecture, Robert Aumann said: ‘In the long years of the cold war between the US and the Soviet Union, what prevented “hot” war was that bombers carrying nuclear weapons were in the air 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. Disarming would have led to a war.’48

2022 Michigan Negative
DA › Decoupling DA › 1NC---OFF

Decoupling is on the brink BUT a shift would be devastating

Michael Hirsh 6/22, senior correspondent at Foreign Policy, “The U.S. and China Haven’t Divorced Just Yet”, Foreign Policy 6-22-2022, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/06/22/united-states-china-decoupling-business-ties)/maze

U.S. businesses, meanwhile, continue to  in China, and they are growing more outspoken about their intention to continue doing so. In a  in Washington this month, Evan Greenberg, a former chair of the U.S.-China Business Council, called decoupling an “economic impossibility” and urged U.S. companies to redouble their efforts to enter the Chinese market. Decoupling, Greenberg said, will only “feed China’s worst instincts” and at the same time undercut U.S. global competitiveness.

“The less reliant China is on American-produced technology, the less leverage the United States will have to influence how China pursues its interests over time,” he said. According to a new survey by  of more than 300 American companies in China, 60 percent reported increased investment compared with 2020. 

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Dedev › 1NC---Dedev---Link

IPR is the “powerhouse” for economic growth.

ICC, ND [ICC (International Chamber of Commerce, No Date, accessed on 7-18-2022, ICC - International Chamber of Commerce, "Intellectual Property: Powerhouse for Innovation and Economic Growth - ICC - International Chamber of Commerce", https://iccwbo.org/publication/intellectual-property-powerhouse-for-innovation-and-economic-growth/]/ISEE

Private-sector companies and industries likewise are looking for ever-more competitive ways to succeed, by developing and incorporating creative and useful innovations into products and services that we all benefit from and enjoy in virtually every area of life. This paper explores and explains the benefits of intellectual property (IP) protection in helping to achieve these important goals. Intellectual property rights (IPR)—the copyrights, patents, trademarks and similar rights upon which the lion’s share of creative and innovative products and services rely—have a vital role in growing the economies of developed and developing countries all over the world, in spurring innovation, in giving large and small firms a range of tools to help drive their success, and in benefitting consumers and society through a continuous stream of innovative, competitive products and services and an expansion of society’s overall state of knowledge. This paper reviews how IPR works in five main areas: 1. Intellectual property protection benefits the economy. 2. Intellectual property protection promotes innovation. 3. Intellectual property protection helps firms monetize their innovations and grow. 4. Intellectual property protection helps small and medium enterprises. 5. Intellectual property protection benefits consumers and society. As the ‘knowledge economy’ advances, more and more of the value that firms and the overall economy achieve will come from high value-added intangibles—including IP in inventions, brands and works. In many companies even now, 80% or more of their market value is attributable to intangibles, including IP. In some small companies, the only value is the intellectual property they own in an exciting new innovation that they have developed. IPR has truly become an ‘intellectual currency’ helping to promote economic growth, company competitiveness and innovation world-wide.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---War

Space col creates two scenarios for galactic destroying wars.

Kovic, 21 [Marko Kovic is the co-founder president of the nonprofit think tank ZIPAR, February 2021, accessed on 7-18-2022, Futures, "Risks of space colonization", https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0016328720301270]/ISEE

Achieving 5. Conflict risks Conflict risks are risks that are created by the prospect of hostile actors or powers in the context of space colonization. Conflict risks are in principle not unlike conflicts that humankind has experienced throughout its Earth-based history, but they are much greater in scope and severity. The four conflict risks I focus on are depicted in Fig. 5. I identify two catastrophic and two existential conflict risks. 5.1. Secession and independence conflicts Human habitats beyond Earth are likely to remain modest in the near-term future. The International Space Station, humankind's most advanced habitat-like project so far, can accommodate six people and is dependent on supplies from Earth. More ambitious colonization projects such as SpaceX's plan for Mars colonies typically envision what amounts to very small and simple camps (Musk, 2017). Managing such simple colonization projects should be doable legally and politically. With more mature colonies, however, the picture changes. Imagine, for example, the large, self-sustaining habitat on Venus that consists of 2 billion people that I mentioned in a thought experiment before. That hypothetical habitat is truly self-sustainable, in the sense that survival on Venus is not contingent in any way on resources or other kinds of support from Earth. If prior human history is an indication, it is conceivable that the Venusians could at some point seek to change their political status. They might want to no longer be governed by Earth or Earth-based governments and instead have sovereignty to autonomously and freely shape Venus’ future. They might, in other words, seek to secede and become an independent political entity. Given prior human history of secession and independence movements, such a claim to independence in the context of space colonization could easily result in violent conflict, and given the scale of the conflict parties in this scenario, the bloodshed could be much greater than all the wars that happened in Earth's history so far. Of course, we do not know what the dominant political philosophy of the future will be. Perhaps popular sovereignty and the wish for autonomy will be fully respected and met with unconditional, enlightened understanding. But that prospect is, at best, uncertain, and the prospect of catastrophic violent conflicts seems at least possible. 5.2. Reactionary colonies Let us assume for the sake of argument that the risks surrounding secessionist claims of extraterrestrial colonies will eventually have been overcome and that there are colonies which have attained a country-like or world-like status. What should the political systems in and the moral foundations of those independent colonies look like? Ideally, they would be at least as democratic, liberal, and generally morally progressive as the most democratic, liberal, and morally progressive countries today. More specifically, independent future colonies should have socio-political systems that do not lower average wellbeing or create (disproportionately) more suffering compared to their pre-existing peers such as Earth-based countries (Or whatever the dominant polity on Earth in that future might be.). However, there is no guarantee that independent colonies will meet that socio-political and moral bar. It is possible that there will be colonies whose socio-political systems are regressive in one way or another, marked by a relative moral decay compared to the baseline of political systems and moral frameworks. I call such potential undesirable entities reactionary colonies. The emergence of reactionary colonies might seem implausible given that humankind has, very roughly speaking, so far morally improved over the course of its history.9 But reactionary colonies might actually be a fairly common future development. If humankind at some point achieves the technological means for creating colonies with relative ease, creating new colonies might be an attractive option for extremist groups and beliefs. Imagine, for example, a religious group that believes in the fundamental superiority of men over women. Such a religious group might find it difficult adhering to their flawed moral principles in a pluralistic society. Opting for colonial exodus might represent an attractive opportunity for that religious group to build a society from scratch which is based on their notions of female inferiority and subjugation. The specific risk posed by reactionary colonies is twofold. Reactionary colonies would by definition lower the average happiness and wellbeing of humankind and create unnecessary, preventable suffering. Reactionary colonies would also represent potential rogue actors that could greatly amplify the aberration risks described in Section 4. For example, a dictatorial regime that causes great suffering to its population might be tempted to expand its dictatorial ideology to other colonies. Or that dictatorial colony could be led by a psychopathic elite that enjoys letting sentient simulations suffer as much as possible. The potential catastrophic and even existential multiplicator effects of reactionary colonies are, unfortunately, numerous. 5.3. Inter-colonial conflict Let us, again for the sake of the argument, assume that the previous problem of reactionary colonies has somehow been solved or avoided. Humankind has continued its path of technological development, and it has established several large clusters of colonies beyond the Solar system. Assuming that the fundamental problem of faster-than-light communication has not been solved yet, communication between the clusters lags months or even years, and physical contact between the clusters is rare since travel takes even longer than communication. The inevitable consequence of such a splintering of human civilization is that the different clusters of colonies would over time develop distinct cultures, and with only scarce and delayed contact with other clusters, a form of intergroup bias (Hewstone, Rubin, & Willis, 2002), the moral preference of one's own in-group over the out-group, would likely start to manifest. Over time, that us-versus-them heuristic could help create distinct and solidified social identities within the colony clusters (Hewstone & Greenland, 2000), and the beliefs and preferences about the outgroup colonies could become more overtly negative. Given enough time and great enough idiosyncratic development within each colony cluster, the cultural and moral connections between the colony clusters could further erode, and in their place, a sense of dread and looming danger about the others’ goals and preferences could take hold. Over a long enough period of time and great enough separation, the perception that other colonies are a threat could grow; so much so that taking preventative action and attacking and suppressing them might seem like the most rational course of action (Torres, 2018). Given the scale and the likely technological sophistication of future weapons systems, a violent conflict between advanced colonies and colony clusters would create suffering on an astronomical scale. Of course, the prospect of inter-colonial conflict is somewhat speculative (Cirkovic, 2019). But given humankind's past experiences, violent conflict clearly seems within the realm of the possible. That does not mean that such an almost immeasurably terrible conflict is unavoidable. Even the slightest probability of such conflict, however, means immense potential expected disvalue. 5.4. Hostile extraterrestrial intelligence We do not currently know whether intelligence, biological or artificial, exists beyond Earth, but it is not implausible to assume so. Coming into contact with as well as refraining from seeking contact with extraterrestrial intelligence poses risks, as I discuss in Section 4. In addition to these risks, extraterrestrial intelligence also poses a conflict risk: If an extraterrestrial intelligence has moral values that are sufficiently different form humankind's, the intelligence could de facto react to humankind and other forms of intelligence with hostility. At first glance, the prospect of a hostile extraterrestrial intelligence, be it biological or artificial, might seem farfetched. Isn’t some baseline of altruistic moral behavior to be expected of any kind of intelligence? We might intuitively associate intelligence with prosocial behavior of one kind or the other, but from an evolutionary perspective, greater intelligence is not necessarily correlated with prosocial and altruistic behavior towards other species (Raybeck, 2014). Intelligence is the generalized capability for achieving goals, regardless of moral underpinnings and considerations. After all, that is why artificial intelligence as superintelligence is an existential risk today: Superintelligence is a threat precisely because it is much more intelligent than humans but lacks any inherent sense of human preferences and moral values. Hostile extraterrestrial intelligence is a serious risk even if such intelligence is exceedingly rare in the universe. The mere possibility of hostile intelligence could result in something like a “Dark Forest” (Yu, 2015) game theoretic configuration. If benevolent biological or artificial intelligence is aware of the possibility of hostile alien intelligence, the best course of action is silence (If there might be hostile alien intelligence, best not to be noticed.). In addition, preventative action could also be a rational choice: If an alien intelligence — such as our human civilization — is being observed gradually expanding beyond our home planet, a risk averse intelligence, even one that is benevolent in principle, might find it prudent to eliminate that civilization; be it because the civilization in question might become hostile or because it might, through folly or ineptitude, draw unwanted attention to oneself. The mere possibility of fundamentally hostile intelligence could, in that sense, be enough to fuel a silent astronomical war.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---Tradeoff

Climate Change is existential

Ng ’19 [Yew-Kwang; May 2019; Professor of Economics at Nanyang Technology University, Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia and Member of the Advisory Board at the Global Priorities Institute at Oxford University, Ph.D. in Economics from Sydney University; Global Policy, “Keynote: Global Extinction and Animal Welfare: Two Priorities for Effective Altruism,” vol. 10, no. 2, p. 258-266; RP]

Catastrophic climate change Though by no means certain, CCC causing global extinction is possible due to interrelated factors of non‐linearity, cascading effects, positive feedbacks, multiplicative factors, critical thresholds and tipping points (e.g. Barnosky and Hadly, ; Belaia et al., ; Buldyrev et al., ; Grainger, ; Hansen and Sato, ; IPCC ; Kareiva and Carranza, ; Osmond and Klausmeier, ; Rothman, ; Schuur et al., ; Sims and Finnoff, ; Van Aalst, ). A possibly imminent tipping point could be in the form of ‘an abrupt ice sheet collapse [that] could cause a rapid sea level rise’ (Baum et al., , p. 399). There are many avenues for positive feedback in global warming, including: the replacement of an ice sea by a liquid ocean surface from melting reduces the reflection and increases the absorption of sunlight, leading to faster warming; the drying of forests from warming increases forest fires and the release of more carbon; and higher ocean temperatures may lead to the release of methane trapped under the ocean floor, producing runaway global warming. Though there are also avenues for negative feedback, the scientific consensus is for an overall net positive feedback (Roe and Baker, ). Thus, the Global Challenges Foundation (, p. 25) concludes, ‘The world is currently completely unprepared to envisage, and even less deal with, the consequences of CCC’. The threat of sea‐level rising from global warming is well known, but there are also other likely and more imminent threats to the survivability of mankind and other living things. For example, Sherwood and Huber () emphasize the adaptability limit to climate change due to heat stress from high environmental wet‐bulb temperature. They show that ‘even modest global warming could … expose large fractions of the [world] population to unprecedented heat stress’ p. 9552 and that with substantial global warming, ‘the area of land rendered uninhabitable by heat stress would dwarf that affected by rising sea level’ p. 9555, making extinction much more likely and the relatively moderate damages estimated by most integrated assessment models unreliably low. While imminent extinction is very unlikely and may not come for a long time even under business as usual, the main point is that we cannot rule it out. Annan and Hargreaves (, pp. 434–435) may be right that there is ‘an upper 95 per cent probability limit for S [temperature increase] … to lie close to 4°C, and certainly well below 6°C’. However, probabilities of 5 per cent, 0.5 per cent, 0.05 per cent or even 0.005 per cent of excessive warming and the resulting extinction probabilities cannot be ruled out and are unacceptable. Even if there is only a 1 per cent probability that there is a time bomb in the airplane, you probably want to change your flight. Extinction of the whole world is more important to avoid by literally a trillion times.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---Tradeoff

Space col trades off with earth focus and damns climate change reversal

Singh, 22 [Samantha Singh, 2/3/22, accessed on 7-18-2022, No publication, "Billionaire Space Race Avoids Facing Consequences", www.blakespectrum.org/blog/2022/02/03/billionaire-space-race-avoids-facing-consequences/]/ISEE

On December 19th, 2021, the Falcon 9 rocket, a private vehicle owned by SpaceX, was launched, alleviating sustainability concerns regarding space exploration with the end goal of colonizing Mars. Suddenly, the idea of space exploration has become startlingly close, and less of a trope from a sci-fi movie. However, the romanticism surrounding the terraformation of Mars, and the space tourism industry as a whole, is not only idealistic–it’s incredibly dangerous. Space capitalists like Elon Musk, owner and founder of SpaceX, have released concerning statements that acknowledge Mars as having “no Earth-based government” that carries “authority or sovereignty over Martian activities” and that ‘“SpaceX will move to impose our own legal regime” to provide authority over Mars. This capitalist trick to curtail government involvement is particularly concerning, as the US government has no agency to instill any pre-existing labor or human rights protections on the planet. SpaceX is known for prioritizing profit over the well-being of their workers– many infamous lawsuits have detailed a toxic work culture rampant with sexual harassment and lack of workplace safety regulations, all swept under the rug by the company. There is no doubt that they will enforce similar exploitative labor practices on Mars. Mars colonization and similar endeavors are simply a way for the bourgeoisie to maximize profit while escaping government regulations needed to maintain healthy working conditions. The reality of space travel is ugly in more ways than one. For one, space exploration propagates Western colonization and imperialism. Institutions of oppression are inevitably bound to seep into space endeavors, specifically when it comes to claims over natural resources. The entitlement American private enterprises possess when it comes to exploring the frontier of space skirts dangerously into Manifest Destiny ideology, that we have the obligation to colonize space despite the ruthless exploitation of land and minority groups that will inevitably follow. This harmful ideology, a main motivating factor for space exploration, spins stories of ultra-nationalistic white men justifying exploitation to secure existence for the future generations, a notable white nationalistic dogwhistle. Manifest Destiny during early American history did guarantee existence for future generations, however they were exclusively white generations. To make matters worse, the rise in space tourism–an industry that sends civilians to space for leisurely reasons–holds deadly consequences for the environment. Wildfires, record heat waves, increased floods, among other rapid shifts in weather conditions, are just a few of the many climate disasters currently endangering all life on Earth. As flights to space double and triple in numbers in the next decade, in addition to the rockets, so too will carbon emissions and burning fuels, advancing the destruction of the ozone layer. The irony is not lost on anyone; billionaires push space-age Manifest Destiny and utopian daydreams on Mars as a way to escape the climate change that they largely accelerated, while continuing to fund the destruction of the atmosphere. However, many climate scientists acknowledge that it is not too late to rectify the situation on Earth. The facts are simple: Mars colonization is a form of utopianism, providing an escape for the bourgeoisie rather than a haven for all people. Conversely, climate change is a very real and devastating threat that requires immediate attention. Instead of shuttling money and precious resources into inhospitable planets like Mars, billionaires should reinvest in the Earth to ensure the safety of future generations. As countless climate activists and organizations have echoed throughout the years, there is no Planet B.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---Tradeoff

Climate change is on the brink of being unstoppable

Makowski, 21 [Michael Makowski works for the Progressive Media Project, 7-28-2021, accessed on 7-18-2022, Newsday, "Planet burns while billionaires soar", https://www.newsday.com/opinion/commentary/global-warming-billionaires-space-race-c74790]/ISEE

While record-breaking wildfires burned across the Western United States, Amazon executive chairman and billionaire Jeff Bezos stepped out of his space capsule to a crowd of cheering fans. His company Blue Origin’s first launch into space was a success. Bezos became the second billionaire to reach space and cement his stature as a leading private space industry figure. The three billionaires building the private space industry so far are: Richard Branson with Virgin Galactic, Elon Musk with SpaceX and Bezos with Blue Origin. Musk has yet to make the trip to space himself. "If we can do this," exclaimed Branson, who preceded Bezos’ space trip by about a week, "just imagine what you can do." With a billion dollars, he should have added. These billionaires see themselves as virtuous trailblazers of a new space age. While Branson has the more docile plan of business expansion and commercial space travel (think space tourism), Bezos envisions settlements on the moon. Musk, famously, locates humanity’s future in the colonization of Mars. Besides their money, eccentricities and desire to float in space, these three men share a dislike for paying taxes. Branson has moved billions between tax havens to avoid paying in his home country of England. For a number of years, Bezos and Musk, the two richest men in the world, paid no federal income taxes. Behind their space ambitions is a recognition of the more earthly challenges to our future: the depletion of resources, population growth and, most importantly, climate change. In his post-launch briefing, Bezos even spoke of the Earth’s fragility and the need to protect it. "As we move about the Earth, we damage it," he said. In a separate interview, he stressed the need to keep Earth "as this beautiful gem of a planet that it is." Admissions like this demonstrate a willful ignorance of the billionaires’ own complicity in these existential crises. Bezos’ Amazon is responsible for a carbon footprint that rivals that of some countries. At the same time, Bezos and his company fund a leading climate-change-denial think tank and reject grassroots employee demands for greater climate action. Amazon has created the Amazon Climate Pledge to reach net zero emission by 2040, and Bezos has pledged $10 billion toward the new Bezos Earth Fund. One year after creating the pledge, however, the company’s carbon emissions increased by 19%, and Bezos has only given a fraction of his pledge. Climate change is an immediate crisis that, at this point, we are in a stage of harm management and not prevention. Proponents of the Green New Deal argue that to salvage our planet and its inhabitants requires a warlike scale of mobilization. Estimates of the cost of reconstructing a new, green economy usually amount to trillions of dollars of government spending. In short, $10 billion isn’t going to cut it. Upon his return from the sky, Bezos made it a point to thank Amazon workers, who "paid for all this." This rhetorical thanks is a stark contrast to the working conditions in Amazon warehouses and the union-busting efforts pushed by Amazon around the country. It’s important to remember how these billionaires made their money and what their space race really means while so many issues persist at home. While they continue their privatized space race, the rest of humanity is imperiled. The planet will continue to burn, and inequality will worsen until massive action and investment is taken, which means billionaires finally paying their fair share. Billionaires would do best to put their space race on pause and focus more of their attention on this planet.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---New Tech

Space col generates new tech that is existential.

Kovic, 21 [Marko Kovic is the co-founder president of the nonprofit think tank ZIPAR, February 2021, accessed on 7-18-2022, Futures, "Risks of space colonization", https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0016328720301270]/ISEE

Achieving space colonization capabilities means obtaining sufficiently advanced technology for venturing beyond Earth and permanently sustaining human life there. In order to achieve that goal, maximizing the pace of technological development seems like an instrumentally desirable goal: The faster we technologically innovate and develop, the higher the probability of obtaining space colonization capabilities. However, the problem with such a technological push is that the increased pace of technological development might also result in an increased pace of existential risk creation. As I argue above in Section 2.1, anthropogenic existential risks correlate with human technological development. All non-natural existential risks are the result of our technological progress, and more technological progress is likely to beget more existential risks. Of course, this should not be misunderstood as a quasi-Luddite argument against all technological progress in general. Scientific and technological progress has made life enormously better and removed tremendous amounts of suffering from the world, to the benefit of current as well as all future generations. However, existential risks are an unprecedented challenge, and the more numerous and probable they are, the more difficult it is to mitigate them in time. In the context of space colonization, this issue is of elevated importance because, as I argue above in Section 3.1, delaying space colonization has an almost imperceptible impact on the long-term future of humankind, whereas existential risks and our attempts at mitigating them (or failing to do so) has an enormous impact.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---Contamination

Missions to colonize increase microbes. Extinction.

Smith-Strickland, 15 [Kiona Smith-Strickland is a freelance science and technology journalist, 6-22-2015, accessed on 7-18-2022, Gizmodo, "Why Scientists Have Been Scared of Space Germs for Almost 50 Years", https://gizmodo.com/why-scientists-have-been-scared-of-space-germs-for-almo-1712562498]/ISEE

If we find life on another world (assuming it’s not sentient and well-armed), we’re going to want to bring samples back to Earth. And we’re going to want to bring them back alive. So we’ve got to have a way of preventing back contamination, or the act of bringing extraterrestrial micro-organisms back to Earth, or into human colonies in space. Our typical ways of preventing contamination aren’t going to work — we can’t leave the life behind, and we can’t sterilize everything. So we’d opt for heavy-duty containment. When the Apollo missions returned with rock and dust samples from the Moon, back contamination was a major concern. At the time, scientists didn’t know whether there would be life on the Moon, but they felt it was better to be safe than sorry. To that end, according to NASA’s history of the quarantine program, “The existence of hazardous, replicating microorganisms on the moon would be assumed.” During the missions, the Apollo crews were careful not to track materials from the lunar surface into the Command Module which would return to Earth. That sounds like “wash your hands and wipe your feet,” but it’s more complicated when you’re wearing a bulky spacesuit in an environment that’s full of dust. Once they returned to Earth, the crews went into immediate quarantine. First they lived in a mobile isolation unit on the aircraft carrier that recovered the landing capsule, then in an aircraft set up for isolation, and finally in a special quarantine unit at the Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas. They stayed there for three weeks, while NASA doctors performed tests and watched for any signs of illness that might indicate an alien infection. Apollo 11 crew in quarantine. Image credit: NASA. Meanwhile, the lunar samples went to the Lunar Receiving Lab at Johnson Space Center, where they could be studied in careful quarantine. Once the samples were proven to be devoid of life, some were released to other research facilities. NASA’s plan for bringing Martian samples home is a bit more advanced. The agency’s Planetary Protection Subcommittee recently laid out its proposal for preventing back contamination. It includes a requirement that any samples brought back to Earth must be either sterilized or packed in a sealed container before being brought aboard the spacecraft. That containment system must also have a redundant failsafe as a backup. They’re not playing around. The proposal also says, “The mission and the spacecraft design must provide a method to ‘break the chain of contact’ with Mars. No uncontained hardware that contacted Mars, directly or indirectly, shall be returned to Earth.” Sorry, Curiosity Rover: you can never come home. Once on Earth, the samples would, according to NASA’s proposal, go straight to a Sample Return Facility, where they would be subjected to a battery of tests for potential biohazards. Once they’re deemed clean, they will be distributed to other research facilities. NASA’s proposed Sample Return Facility would include Biosafety Level 4 labs (the same types of facilities where viruses like Ebola are studied today), as well as cleanrooms to prevent the Martian samples from picking up any stray Earth germs. Unfortunately, “such an integrated facility is not currently available,” NASA notes. What Could Go Wrong? So, what happens in the unlikely event that those measures fail, and the first crewed mission to Mars sets alien microbes loose on Earth? We don’t know, and that’s what makes containment so important. The whole thing could play out like a microscopic version of H.G. Wells’ War of the Worlds, where terrifying Martian invaders are killed off by Earth viruses. If extraterrestrial microbes escape from containment, they might not last long out in the world, where they have to compete with Earth’s own battalions of bacteria and viruses. Of course we might see the opposite scenario. Extraterrestrial microbes might thrive in Earth’s environment, and they might out-compete many Earth microbes, just like today’s terrestrial invasive species — which are problematic enough without help from other worlds. Humans would have no natural immunity to Martian pathogens, and our whole species might be wiped out. So you might think of extraterrestrial microbes as the potential next version of Ebola, which explains the Biohazard Level 4 recommendation. But humans aren’t the only ones in danger. Extraterrestrial microbes could rapidly wipe out Earth’s other animal species, plants, and microbes. That might actually be a more horrific scenario: humanity survives, but all the animals and plants we depend on for sustenance die off, or all the microbes that play such a vital role in our environment are displaced by alien microbes that don’t fill the same roles. There’s probably an excellent post-apocalyptic novel waiting to be built around that scenario.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › Space Col Bad › 1NC---Space Col Bad---Contamination

Space causes bacterial resistance to antibiotics which greatly increases infection and spread.

Minhas, 20 [Vikrant Minhas is a co-founder of the space research company ResearchSat,7/23/20, accessed on 7-18-2022, The Conversation , "As If Space Wasn't Dangerous Enough, Bacteria Become More Deadly in Microgravity", theconversation.com/as-if-space-wasnt-dangerous-enough-bacteria-become-more-deadly-in-microgravity-141053]/ISEE

Worryingly, research from space flight missions has shown bacteria become more deadly and resilient when exposed to microgravity (when only tiny gravitational forces are present). In space, bacteria seem to become more resistant to antibiotics and more lethal. They also stay this way for a short time after returning to Earth, compared with bacteria that never left Earth. Adding to that, bacteria also seem to mutate quicker in space. However, these mutations are predominately for the bacteria to adapt to the new environment – not to become super deadly. More research is needed to examine whether such adaptations do, in fact, allow the bacteria to cause more disease. Read more: Bacteria found to thrive better in space than on Earth Bacterial team work is bad news for space stations Research has shown space’s microgravity promotes biofilm formation of bacteria. Biofilms are densely-packed cell colonies that produce a matrix of polymeric substances allowing bacteria to stick to each other, and to stationary surfaces. Biofilms increase bacteria’s resistance to antibiotics, promote their survival and improve their ability to cause infection. We have seen biofilms grow and attach to equipment on space stations, causing it to biodegrade. For example, biofilms have affected the Mir space station’s navigation window, air conditioning, oxygen electrolysis block, water recycling unit and thermal control system. The prolonged exposure of such equipment to biofilms can lead to malfunction, which can have devastating effects. Microorganisms that form biofilms include bacteria, fungi and protists. Shutterstock Another affect of microgravity on bacteria involves their structural distortion. Certain bacteria have shown reductions in cell size and increases in cell numbers when grown in microgravity. In the case of the former, bacterial cells with smaller surface area have fewer molecule-cell interactions, and this reduces the effectiveness of antibiotics against them. Moreover, the absence of effects produced by gravity, such as sedimentation and buoyancy, could alter the way bacteria take in nutrients or drugs intended to attack them. This could result in the increased drug resistance and infectiousness of bacteria in space. All of this has serious implications, especially when it comes to long-haul space flights where gravity would not be present. Experiencing a bacterial infection that cannot be treated in these circumstances would be catastrophic. The benefits of performing research in space On the other hand, the effects of space also result in a unique environment that can be positive for life on Earth. For example, molecular crystals in space’s microgravity grow much larger and more symmetrically than on Earth. Having more uniform crystals allows the formulation of more effective drugs and treatments to combat various diseases including cancers and Parkinson’s disease. Also, the crystallisation of molecules helps determine their precise structures. Many molecules that cannot be crystallised on Earth can be in space. So, the structure of such molecules could be determined with the help of space research. This, too, would aid the development of higher quality drugs. Optical fibre cables can also be made to a much better standard in space, due to the optimal formation of crystals. This greatly increases data transmission capacity, making networking and telecommunications faster. As humans spend more time in space, an environment riddled with known and unknown dangers, further research will help us thoroughly examine the risks – and the potential benefits – of space’s unique environment.

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › IPR Bad › 1NC---IPR Bad---Monopolies

Imposing IPR hampers innovation and creates monopolies

Emrah Karakilic 19, holds a PhD in sociology from Goldsmiths, University of London and 20. He finished his PhD in 2016 with a thesis entitled The Limits of Cognitive Capitalism., “Rethinking intellectual property rights in the cognitive and digital age of capitalism: An autonomist Marxist reading”, Technological Forecasting and Social Change Volume 147, October 2019, Pages 1-9, 7-5-2019, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040162518316275)/maze

From this perspective, the enclosure of the common should be considered a structural fetter on the development and growth of human beings. In particular, intellectual property rights act as forms of structural restraints for the expansion and development of productive forces. They block the qualities and capabilities, that is, the very human potentiality of wage-workers. They precisely interrupt the Foucauldian circuit in which l’homme produit l’homme (man produces man). In this regard, it is fair to state that by imposing IPR, capital prepares its own social crisis in terms of established capitalist relations of production Furthermore, the enclosure through IPR hinders the opportunities for innovation, profit-making, and growth. From the perspective of neoclassical economics, Boldrin and Levine (2002, 2010) challenge the ‘common argument [that] the presence of strong intellectual property rights spurs innovation leading to higher economic growth and increasing benefits for all’ (2002: 209). By drawing on quantitative models, they analyse the difference between property rights applied to material and immaterial goods and show that IPR constitute a monopoly, ‘intellectual monopoly’, ultimately hindering free market, competition, growth, and wealth. Again, from the perspective of neoclassical economics, Lerner examines the impact of IPR policy shifts in 60 nations over the past 150 years and finds a ‘lack of a positive impact of strengthening of patent protection on innovation’ (2009: 347), which is key for profit making and economic growth. Martin (1998) inquiries into the relationship between IPR and innovation from a different perspective. By using real-life cases, he demonstrates how big companies purchase someone else’s idea to inhibit other companies from transforming this idea to an innovative product and selling it on the market as a competitor of their product. Along the same lines, Baker, Jayadev and Stiglitz’s comprehensive - policy- paper argue that ‘the current global regime of intellectual property rights is inadequate in serving the purpose of development and welfare … both in developed and developing countries’ (2017: 7). They state that ‘if the knowledge economy and the economy of ideas is to be a key part of the global economy and if static societies are to be transformed into ‘learning societies’ that are key for growth and development, there is a desperate need to rethink the current regime [of IPR]’ (2017: 7). The famous Manchester Manifesto, signed by fifty international scholars from various disciplines, underlines ‘the significant drawbacks’ of IPR in ‘its effects on economic efficiency’ (2009:2), especially in terms of ‘reducing competition and allowing large companies to dominate markets’ (2009: 4).

2022 Michigan Negative
Turns › IPR Bad › 1NC---IPR Bad---Warming

Warming causes extinction

Dr. Yew-Kwang Ng 19, Winsemius Professor of Economics at Nanyang Technological University, Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences in Australia and Member of Advisory Board at the Global Priorities Institute at Oxford University, PhD in Economics from Sydney University, “Keynote: Global Extinction and Animal Welfare: Two Priorities for Effective Altruism”, Global Policy, Volume 10, Number 2, May 2019, pp. 258–266

Catastrophic climate change Though by no means certain, CCC causing global extinction is possible due to interrelated factors of non-linearity, cascading effects, positive feedbacks, multiplicative factors, critical thresholds and tipping points (e.g. Barnosky and Hadly, 2016; Belaia et al., 2017; Buldyrev et al., 2010; Grainger, 2017; Hansen and Sato, 2012; IPCC 2014; Kareiva and Carranza, 2018; Osmond and Klausmeier, 2017; Rothman, 2017; Schuur et al., 2015; Sims and Finnoff, 2016; Van Aalst, 2006).7 A possibly imminent tipping point could be in the form of ‘an abrupt ice sheet collapse [that] could cause a rapid sea level rise’ (Baum et al., 2011, p. 399). There are many avenues for positive feedback in global warming, including: • the replacement of an ice sea by a liquid ocean surface from melting reduces the reflection and increases the absorption of sunlight, leading to faster warming; • the drying of forests from warming increases forest fires and the release of more carbon; and • higher ocean temperatures may lead to the release of methane trapped under the ocean floor, producing runaway global warming. Though there are also avenues for negative feedback, the scientific consensus is for an overall net positive feedback (Roe and Baker, 2007). Thus, the Global Challenges Foundation (2017, p. 25) concludes, ‘The world is currently completely unprepared to envisage, and even less deal with, the consequences of CCC’. The threat of sea-level rising from global warming is well known, but there are also other likely and more imminent threats to the survivability of mankind and other living things. For example, Sherwood and Huber (2010) emphasize the adaptability limit to climate change due to heat stress from high environmental wet-bulb temperature. They show that ‘even modest global warming could ... expose large fractions of the [world] population to unprecedented heat stress’ p. 9552 and that with substantial global warming, ‘the area of land rendered uninhabitable by heat stress would dwarf that affected by rising sea level’ p. 9555, making extinction much more likely and the relatively moderate damages estimated by most integrated assessment models unreliably low. While imminent extinction is very unlikely and may not come for a long time even under business as usual, the main point is that we cannot rule it out. Annan and Hargreaves (2011, pp. 434–435) may be right that there is ‘an upper 95 per cent probability limit for S [temperature increase] ... to lie close to 4°C, and certainly well below 6°C’. However, probabilities of 5 per cent, 0.5 per cent, 0.05 per cent or even 0.005 per cent of excessive warming and the resulting extinction probabilities cannot be ruled out and are unacceptable. Even if there is only a 1 per cent probability that there is a time bomb in the airplane, you probably want to change your flight. Extinction of the whole world is more important to avoid by literally a trillion times.