American decline redux Today the military, economic, institutional and ideational pillars that have supported the Pax Americana are being challenged by China. This raises two fundamental and intimately connected questions: if China surpasses, equals or even approximates the United States in these dimensions of power, can the Pax Americana endure? And, if it cannot, what will replace it? Posing these questions raises the contentious issue—contentious at least in the US—of whether American power is, in fact, declining. During his abortive 2012 run for the Republican presi- dential nomination, Jon Huntsman—President Obama’s Ambassador to China, and now President Trump’s Ambassador to Russia—succinctly expressed the prevailing view of the US foreign policy establishment when he said: ‘Decline is un-American.’ Leading US security studies experts agree. These primacists argue that the extent of China’s rise—and hence of America’s decline—are, like prema- ture reports of Mark Twain’s death, greatly exaggerated. Primacists believe the international system is still unipolar, and that US power will keep it that way for a long time to come. This claim is increasingly dubious. Indeed, the case made by the ‘declinists’ of the 1980s—notably Paul Kennedy, Robert Gilpin, David Calleo and Samuel P. Huntington—looks stronger every day.23 Contrary to the portrayal of their argument by many of their critics, the 1980s declinists did not claim either that America’s post-Second World War power advantages had already dissipated, or that the United States was on the brink of a rapid, catastrophic decline. Rather, they pointed to domestic and international economic drivers that, over time, would cause American economic power to diminish relatively, thereby shifting the balance of power. In essence, the declinists believed that the United States was experiencing a slow—‘termite-like’—decline caused by fundamental structural weaknesses in the American economy that were gradually nibbling at its founda- tions.24 Kennedy himself was explicitly looking ahead to the effects this termite decline would have on the US world role in the early twenty-first century. As he wrote: The task facing American statesmen over the next decades … is to recognize that broad trends are under way, and that there is a need to ‘manage’ affairs so that the relative erosion of the United States’ position takes place slowly and smoothly, and is not accelerated by policies which bring merely short-term advantage but longer-term disadvantage.25 The unwinding of the Pax Americana Decline may be ‘un-American’, but that does not mean it isn’t happening. Ameri- ca’s ‘unipolar moment’ has turned out to be rather—well, momentary.26 The Great Recession that began in 2007–2008 did not end America’s unipolar ascen- dancy. It did, however, focus attention on, and accelerate, the ebbing of American power—the evidence of which has cumulated rapidly over the ensuing ten years. This slippage of US dominance is chipping away at each of the four pillars on which the Pax Americana was erected: military power; economic power; institu- tions; and soft power. As these pillars erode, it becomes increasingly doubtful that the Pax Americana can endure. China’s challenge to American military power Until now the dominant view within the US foreign policy establishment has been that military strength is the one area in which America’s advantage is insur- mountable (at least within any meaningful time-frame). American military power is considered by US policy-makers and many security studies scholars to be the geopolitical trump card—no pun intended—that will ensure continuing American dominance even if China closes the economic and technological gaps separating it from the United States.27 However, some within the foreign policy establish- ment are beginning to question this viewpoint. Important recent studies of the Sino-American military balance suggest that some analysts are taking a fresh look at the question of how long it will take China to catch up with the US militarily. China and the United States face different grand strategic challenges. As self- styled global hegemon, America must be able project decisive military power to the three regions it considers vital to both its security and its prosperity: Europe, the Middle East and east Asia. In contrast, China’s strategic goals, at least for now, are more limited. China aims at dominating its own geographic backyard: that is, it seeks regional hegemony in east and south-east Asia, which have become the focal points of Sino-American geopolitical competition. Even if China is not at present able to mount a global challenge to the US, there is evidence that it is beginning to draw level with the United States in regional military power in east Asia. In a recent report on the Sino-American military balance, the RAND Corporation refers to the ‘receding frontier of US military dominance’ in east Asia.28 According to RAND, the trend lines in the Sino-American military rivalry in east Asia are not favourable for the United States: ‘Although China has not closed the gap with the United States, it has narrowed it—and it has done so quite rapidly. Even for many of the contributors to this report, who track military developments in Asia on an ongoing basis, the speed of change … was striking.’29 In a recent book, Roger Cliff, an east Asian security expert at RAND, says that by 2020 China’s military establishment will be almost on an equal footing with America’s with respect to doctrine, equipment, personnel and training (though still lagging behind in organizational structure, logistics and organizational culture). Consequently, he predicts that by 2020 American military dominance in east Asia will be significantly eroded.30 He predicts that the 2020s will witness a power transition in east Asia and that at this point China will be able to challenge the regional status quo.31 American economic decline and the impairment of US economic hegemony During the past decade, signs of waning US economic power—and China’s growing economic muscle—have become too numerous to ignore. Since the onset of the Great Recession, China has successively taken top position in the world in exports (passing Germany); in trade (passing the United States); and in manufacturing (claiming a title the United States had held for a century). In 2014 the World Bank made the stunning announcement that China had vaulted past the United States to become the world’s largest economy (measured by purchasing power parity (PPP);32 and in the early to mid-2020s China is predicted to overtake the United States in GDP measured by market exchange rate.33 These shifts in the relative economic power of China and the United States have enormous economic and geopolitical implications. Indeed, in July 2017 Christine Lagarde, managing director of the IMF, stated that in ten years’ time the organization’s headquar- ters—which are required by its by-laws to be located in its member country with the largest economy—could be in Beijing.34 Taken together, these indicators paint a clear picture of relative economic decline. American primacists have advanced a number of clever but unconvincing arguments in an attempt to downplay the significance of the ongoing economic power shift from America to China. For example, some primacists assert that per capita GDP is a better yardstick of national power than aggregate GDP; that newly developed metrics of national power have diminished the importance of GDP as a measure of a state’s economic power; that China is far behind the United States in advanced technology; and that China is incapable of doing innovation.35 This last claim is ubiquitous among primacists.36 It is, however, undermined by recent developments. For example, in September 2016 China began operating the world’s largest radio telescope, which is intended to project China’s ambitions deep into the universe, and bring back the kind of dramatic discoveries that win honours such as Nobel Prizes.37 In August 2016 China launched the world’s first quantum satellite, which could lead ‘to new, completely different methods for transmitting information’.38 In another example of how China is catching up with the United States in innovation and technology, in June 2016 a Chinese computer (using made-in-China microprocessors) topped the ranking of the world’s fastest supercomputers.39 In July 2017 China’s State Council announced an ambitious plan to sprint to the front of the pack in artificial intelligence (AI), including both military and civilian applications.40 Indeed, The Economist recently observed that already ‘China could be a close second to America—and perhaps even ahead of it—in some areas of AI’.41 And China is moving to the forefront in green technologies (solar panels and wind-generated power) and in electric cars.42 The waning of US economic dominance may not be obvious to primacists, but it is perfectly apparent to many observers in the real world.43 The weakening of US relative economic power, which became unmistakably clear during the Great Recession, has undercut the Pax Americana both by compromising the United States’ ability to manage the international economy and by shifting the Sino- American geopolitical balance in east Asia. During the Great Recession it became evident that in some (not all) respects the United States was unable to fulfil its responsibility as the international economy’s manager. After all, an economic hegemon is supposed to solve global economic crises, not cause them. But it was the freezing up of the US financial system triggered by the sub-prime mortgage crisis that plunged the global economy into hot water. The economic hegemon is supposed to be the lender of last resort in the international economy. The United States, however, has become the borrower of first resort—the world’s largest debtor. When the global economy falters, the economic hegemon is supposed to jump-start recovery by purchasing other nations’ goods. From the end of the Second World War until the Great Recession struck, it was America’s willingness to consume foreign goods that constituted the primary firewall against global economic downturns. When the Great Recession hit, however, the US economy proved too infirm to lead the global economy back to health. It fell to China to pull the global economy out of its nose-dive by stepping up to the plate with a massive stimulus programme. Barack Obama acknowledged the deeper implications of this when, at the April 2009 G20 meeting in London, he conceded that, in important respects, the United States’ days as the economic hegemon were numbered because it was too deeply in debt to continue as the world’s consumer of last resort. Instead, he said, the world would have to look to China (and other emerging market states, plus Germany) to be the motors of global recovery. ‘If there is going to be renewed growth,’ Obama stated, ‘it can’t just be the United States as the engine, everybody is going to have to pick up the pace.’ He added that in some ways the world has become accustomed to the United States being a voracious consumer market and the engine that drives a lot of economic growth worldwide. And I think that in the wake of the crisis, even as we’re doing stimulus, we have to take into account our own deficits.44 Another example of the slipping US grip on global economic leadership is Washington’s inability to prevail over Germany in the transatlantic ‘austerity versus stimulus’ debate that began in 2009. Reflecting their different historical experiences, the United States and Germany adopted divergent fiscal policies during the Great Recession. Economic policy-makers in the Obama administra- tion were guided by the Keynesian lessons learned from the Great Depression of the 1930s: in essence, that to dig out of a deep economic slump, the federal government should stimulate demand by pump-priming the economy through deficit spending, and the Federal Reserve should support this policy of stimulus with low interest rates and easy money. Obama administration policy-makers, and leading American economists, were haunted by the ‘1937 analogy’—the fear that, if stimulus is withdrawn prematurely, nascent recovery could be aborted. On the other hand, Germany—the EU’s economic engine—has long been haunted by the ‘1923 analogy’—the fear that inflation easily can become uncon- trollable, with potentially disastrous economic, social and political consequences.45 From the founding of West Germany after the Second World War until the advent of European monetary union, and eventually the euro, the primary missions of the West German central bank, the Bundesbank were to combat inflation, and to preserve the Deutschmark’s value. For the German government, assurance that the new European Central Bank would follow the Bundesbank’s sound money policy was a sine qua non for its decision to give up the Deutschmark in favour of the euro. The US–European divide on austerity versus stimulus manifested itself at the April 2009 London G20 summit. The US objective at this meeting was to achieve a rebalancing of the international economy by inducing the Europeans—which meant Germany—to lift the continent out of recession by emulating Washington’s use of deficit spending to spur economic revival. Washington wanted Germany to export less and import—and consume—more. Berlin flatly rejected US entreaties with respect to rebalancing. German Chancellor Angela Merkel argued that for states—especially ones already deeply in debt—to accumulate more debt in an effort to spend themselves out of recession would only set the stage for an even greater crisis down the road.46 Washington’s inability to persuade Berlin to adopt a policy of economic stimulus highlighted America’s flagging ability to act as the leader of the interna- tional economy. The then Treasury Secretary Jack Lew implicitly admitted this at the October 2015 IMF–World Bank biannual meetings when, echoing President Obama, he stated that the United States could not be the ‘sole engine’ of global growth. And the Trump administration, although it has complained loudly that Germany exports too much and imports too little, has like its predecessor been unable to push or persuade Berlin into reducing its trade surplus while simultane- ously increasing its consumption. Even as the US ability to manage the international economy is decreasing, China’s growing economic clout has profound implications for the Sino-American strategic balance. For example, the Obama administration’s ‘pivot’ to Asia was intended to reassure the nations of east and south-east Asia that the United States would use its military power to offset China’s growing economic influence in the region. As Jeffrey Bader, the Obama administration’s National Security Council director for Asia, put it: China’s emergence, China’s rise, is the focus of attention not only of the United States but among all countries in the region. None of them wants to have hostile or adversarial relations with China. At the same time, none wants to be dominated by China. The countries in the region welcome the US presence as, if you will, a kind of balance against China.47 However, the outlook for this ‘balancing’ strategy is clouded. Doubtless, Bader was correct: regional states do not want to be forced to choose between aligning either with China or with the United States. But economic trends suggest that they will be inexorably drawn into Beijing’s geopolitical orbit by the overpow- ering magnetic pull of the Chinese economy. The lessening of America’s regional economic influence, and the corresponding jump in that of China, have been dramatic. In 1993 China accounted for only 2 per cent of ASEAN’s trade in goods, and the United States accounted for 18 per cent. By 2013, however, the American share of ASEAN trade in goods had shrunk to 8.2 per cent while China’s had skyrocketed to 14 per cent.48 Growing economic dependence on China is reflected in geopolitical alignments. Since 2016, Malaysia, Cambodia, Myanmar and the Philippines have all tilted away from the United States and towards China. Even Australia, long a staunch US ally, is debating the merits of taking a more equidistant political stance between Washington and Beijing because of its economic dependence on China. In the coming years these trends are likely to continue, and China will be able to leverage its economic power to enhance its geopolitical position in east and south-east Asia—and diminish that of the United States. The institutional challenge to the Pax Americana Not only is the Pax Americana being whittled away by constraints on Washing- ton’s ability to continue playing its role as the manager of the global economy, and by China’s ever-increasing economic dominance of its region; even more strikingly, the institutional framework is being challenged. An important indicator of the Pax Americana’s erosion is the weakening of its legacy institutions amid calls, magnified by the Great Recession, for a major overhaul of the international institutional order. Examples include demands that the IMF and World Bank be reformed to give China (and other key emerging market economies) greater voting power, and a (so far unsuccessful) push to expand the membership of the UN Security Council by adding, among others, Brazil and India. Another indicator of the shifting global balance occurred in November 2008 when the G8 global economic summit was transformed into the G20 by the addition of China and other emerging market states including India, Indonesia and South Africa. The G20’s creation as the new focal point for coordinating international economic policy was a response to the insistence of China, and the other major emerging market states, that they be given a greater voice in interna- tional economic affairs. Implicitly, the G20’s emergence confirmed three trends. First, the necessity of conceding power to the emerging market states—especially China—confirmed that America’s relative power is declining. Second, the G20’s empowerment underscored the shift in power from the Euro-Atlantic world to Asia. Whereas only one Asian nation ( Japan) had been a G8 member, the G20 has six members from the region: Australia, China, India, Indonesia, Japan and South Korea. Finally, the G20’s emergence as the central organ of international economic management demonstrated that—as a result of the Great Recession— the prestige and authority of the United States and Europe as stewards of the international economy had slipped dramatically.49 The past decade or so also has seen the creation of new institutions that potentially could constitute a parallel—‘shadow’—international order outside the framework of the Pax Americana. The most important of these may be the Beijing- backed Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB). Other examples include the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, the Collective Security Treaty Organiza- tion, the Eurasian Economic Union and the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa). The staying power and impact of these institutions are uncertain; but at the very least they are important symbolically. They underscore the decline of the American-designed post-Second World War international order, and the rise of new powers such as China and India—and the resurgence of old ones such as Russia—demanding recognition of their status and prestige, and a concomitant voice in the management of the international system. Soft power: the end of the US monopoly One of the major impacts of the Great Recession was its effect on perceptions of US soft power. As Martin Wolf argued at the nadir of the meltdown, the collapse of the American financial system marked a ‘humiliating end to the “unipolar moment”’.50 The meltdown has also damaged America’s status and ideational power. As Martin Jacques has suggested, the fact ‘that the American-run interna- tional economic system has been plunged into such turmoil as a result of a crisis which had its origins in the United States has served further to accentuate the loss of American power and prestige’.51 US claims that the so-called Washington Consensus—based on free markets, democracy and globalization—is the only viable path for economic and political development have been discredited. As former US Deputy Treasury Secretary Roger Altman said, the Great Recession ‘put the American model of free market capitalism under a cloud’.52 In the wake of the meltdown, China has broken the US monopoly on soft power.53 Beijing has become increasingly adept at developing its own brand of soft power based on its culture, its diplomacy and the attractiveness of its own system— ‘market authoritarianism’—as an alternative to the American model.54 Indeed, even before the crash, Kurt Campbell and Michele Flournoy—both of whom would go on to hold senior national security positions in the Obama administra- tion—acknowledged that China, despite not being a democracy, might already have leapt ahead of the United States in soft power. This was, they observed, ‘a troubling indictment of our current course’.55 China’s challenge to the Pax Americana: the AIIB, and ‘one belt, one road’ In May 2016 leaders of 29 nations, and representatives from some 80 others, descended on Beijing to discuss China’s ambitious ‘one belt one road’ (OBOR) development initiative—also referred to by some as the ‘new Silk Road’. This plan is the follow-on to China’s creation several years ago of the AIIB, conceived as a new major international institution to foster economic development in south-east, south-west and central Asia. OBOR—a signature policy of Chinese President Xi Jinping—calls for the investment of massive amounts of money (US$1 trillion, according to some reports) to promote trade and economic devel- opment by constructing transport links that will tie together east Asian manufac- turing hubs with markets and raw material suppliers in south-east Asia, central Asia, south-west Asia and Africa.56 These new transport routes will also connect China and the participating Asian nations with Europe—thereby creating new markets for the goods and services it produces. Some analysts regard the devel- opmental aspects of OBOR as a Chinese version of the post-1945 Marshall Plan (albeit on a much grander scale). OBOR is also seen as an instrument for extending China’s geopolitical influence—especially in central Asia. Indeed, it has been suggested that OBOR is part of a strategy of establishing Beijing’s dominance over the Eurasian ‘heartland’, to use the term favoured by the early twentieth- century British geopolitical theorist Sir Halford Mackinder, who argued that control of the heartland was the key to dominating the international system.57 Since the early 1940s, leading American policy-makers and academic strategists have—explicitly or implicitly—embraced Mackinder’s ideas about geopolitics.58 The AIIB and OBOR are both indicators of receding US power, and they challenge the Pax Americana—not just geopolitically, but also with respect to international economic leadership and international institutions. Beijing envisions the AIIB as a rival to the IMF and World Bank. In discussions of Sino-American rivalry, less attention is usually paid to these issues than to the military balance between the United States and China, or to the flashpoints—the South China Sea, the East China Sea, Taiwan, the Korean peninsula—that could spark a conflict. But the contest for international economic and financial leadership, and for the guiding hand in reconfiguring the twenty-first century’s international institutions, will also shape relations between Washington and Beijing, and help determine the fate of the Pax Americana. The diminution of US influence—itself a signal of the Pax Americana’s erosion—was underscored by Washington’s inability to derail China’s plans to create the AIIB. This failure was not for lack of effort. When Beijing rolled out its AIIB plans, the Obama administration kicked into high gear diplomatically in an attempt to quash the project. As the New York Times reported, Washington ‘lobbied against the [AIIB] with unexpected determination and engaged in a vigorous campaign to persuade important allies to shun the project’.59 Washington’s attempt to dissuade its allies from joining the AIIB failed. Or, to put it more bluntly, in the face of China’s growing power, the United States could not keep its allies onside. The dam burst when, in a decision taken fittingly on the Ides of March in 2015, Britain—ostensibly America’s closest ally—announced it was going to become a member of the AIIB (Et tu, Britain?). London’s action set off a stampede as other states that previously had been on the fence rushed to sign up for membership in the new institution. Those joining the AIIB included traditional US allies such as Australia, France, Germany, Italy and South Korea. Beijing’s diplomatic coup in attracting widespread support for its AIIB initiative was viewed—correctly— as a direct challenge to America’s global geopolitical and economic leadership. Writing in the Financial Times, former US Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers said that London’s AIIB decision and its aftermath ‘may be remembered as the moment the United States lost its role as the underwriter of the global economic system’.60 Beijing’s ability to persuade America’s allies to sign up to the AIIB also was a concrete demonstration of the lure of China’s financial and economic clout. China’s AIIB initiative is important because it represents a double-barrelled challenge simultaneously to US leadership of the global economy and to the Pax Americana’s institutional (and ideational) foundations. At the 1944 Bretton Woods Conference, the United States took the lead in constructing the struc- ture of the post-Second World War international economy by creating the IMF and the World Bank, which were intended to anchor the postwar international economic system. Both of these institutions were structured to ensure Washington would have veto power over their decisions. As China’s importance in the world economy grew, however, Beijing demanded that voting power in the two Bretton Woods institutions be recalibrated. In April 2010, the IMF and World Bank agreed to increase China’s voting weight. However, to become effective, this agreement required approval by the US Congress; and the Obama administration was unable to persuade Congress to enact the necessary legislation until January 2016. Beijing’s frustration with the stalemate on voting rights helped drive its decision to launch its AIIB initiative.61 With the AIIB, Beijing seeks to enhance China’s roles both in the management of the international economy and in international development. The AIIB was also intended to signal that China was serious in demanding an increase in its voting power in the IMF and World Bank commensurate with its current economic and financial clout. The AIIB is—and is intended to be—a direct challenge to the primacy of both of these Bretton Woods legacy institutions.62 At the same time its impact reaches beyond international economic affairs, because it signals that the Sino-American balance of power now is tilting towards Beijing.