Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
Hegemony is good! › General

Deterrence and promotion of the US-led LIO is key to contain Chinese expansionism

Beckley 22 – Jeane Kirkpatrick Visiting Scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, associate professor at Tufts University (Michael, March/April 2022, "Enemies of My Enemy," Foreign Affairs,

The second feature of the emerging order is a double military barrier to contain China. The inside layer consists of rivals bordering the East China and South China Seas. Many of them—including Indonesia, Japan, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Vietnam—are loading up on mobile missile launchers and mines. The goal is to turn themselves into prickly porcupines capable of denying China sea and air control near their shores. Those efforts are now being bolstered by an outside layer of democratic powers—mainly Australia, India, the United Kingdom, and the United States. These democracies are providing aid, arms, and intelligence to China’s neighbors; training together so they can conduct long-range missile strikes on Chinese forces and blockade China’s oil imports; and organizing multinational freedom-of-navigation exercises throughout the region, especially near Chinese-held rocks, reefs, and islands in disputed areas.

This security cooperation is becoming stronger and more institutionalized. Witness the reemergence of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, or Quad—a coalition made up of Australia, India, Japan, and the United States that had gone dormant shortly after its founding in 2007. Or look at the creation of new pacts, most notably AUKUS, an alliance linking Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States. The overarching goal of all this activity is to maintain the territorial status quo in East Asia. But a more explicit aim is to save Taiwan, the frontline democracy most at risk of Chinese conquest. Japan and the United States have developed a joint battle plan for defending the island, and in November 2021, Peter Dutton, Australia’s defense minister, said it was “inconceivable” that his country would not also join the fight. The European Parliament, for its part, has adopted a comprehensive plan to boost Taiwan’s economic resilience and international recognition.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › ---at: andrea smith bad

This authenticity politics reproduces the chief weapon of settler colonialism- convincing the world of the “vanishing Indian” myth is the primary settler mechanism to destroy Natives

Gilio-Whitaker, 15 -- Center for World Indigenous Studies research associate

[Dina, NDN in the Colville Confederated Tribes, "‘Real’ Indians, the Vanishing Native Myth, and the Blood Quantum Question," Indian Country, 8-30-15, indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2015/08/30/real-indians-vanishing-native-myth-and-blood-quantum-question, accessed 10-2-15]

Of all myths associated with American Indians no myth is as pervasive as the myth of the vanishing Indian. We are all familiar with many of the other myths that were invented over the last 500 years and thanks to the work of Native activists, writers, intellectuals, and their allies we have begun to dismantle some of them in meaningful ways. Take for example the myth of Columbus as the discoverer of America. Campaigns over the last couple of decades in the United States have led to changes at the level of local and state governments to repudiate the veneration of Columbus as a hero and instead recognize indigenous peoples on October 12. Despite the fact that it is still a national holiday it seems entirely possible that the day will come when it will be no longer. In another example, with each passing year we see more and more media coverage on the mythic nature of the conventional Thanksgiving narrative. Not all Americans may understand the nuances of what makes this story largely a myth, but with each passing year there seems to be a growing sense in the general public that there is little truth to the story they grew up with. The vanishing Indian myth, on the other hand, is far more intractable because it has so many different manifestations. The reason for this is because of the inherent nature of the settler state, which is to eliminate the Native. This it does in a huge variety of ways, and because it is woven throughout the social fabric of the settler state it is well concealed. Even before the United States was created European immigrants counted on the disappearance of the indigenous population because they wanted the land, and so they narrated the reality they wanted to see as soon as they got here. It’s recognizable through every era of post-contact North America and has been written into every aspect of American history. First Indians were disappearing due to mass epidemics. Then they were disappearing through slavery. They were disappearing by being pushed out of their territories. They were disappearing through massacres and other acts of violence. By the end of the nineteenth century when the vanishing Native myth reached its crescendo and most Indians had been contained on reservations, disappearance took the form of culturecide by assimilation. Thanks to the boarding school system which killed the Indian but saved the man, Indians throughout the twentieth century were disappearing through trauma and identity murder. Trauma—from shame induced by the boarding schools, for example—caused many Native people to deny their heritage in order to survive racism, contributing to what I call identity murder. Identity murder is one of the most common (and insidious) modes of Native disappearance today. It takes many forms within American culture, and is always based on definitions of the “real” Indian. Real Indians dress like Indians. Real Indians live on reservations. Real Indians have reservations. Real Indians are full blood. Real Indians are at least half blood. Real Indians are enrolled. Real Indians know their language. Real Indians practice their ceremonies. Real Indians have dark skin and long black hair. The list goes on, and it isn’t based on any sense of logic. These impossible criteria are markers of authenticity and those who fail to meet them are deemed inauthentic, either in the minds of individuals or in governmental institutions. They are effectively eliminated as Natives. Blood quantum is perhaps the biggest determinant of Indian authenticity, but even those who are full blood can be deemed not real based on some stereotypes or legal definitions of what real Indians are. All Indians are subject to being judged for their authenticity, and even despite high blood quantum or enrolled status they can be deemed inauthentic simply by virtue of the fact that they live in the modern world. Because after all, the real Indians were the ones who dressed in buckskins and hunted buffalo and deer for their living, and didn’t speak English. And they’ve been gone a long time. Non-natives, whether they know it or not, are conditioned to determine the authenticity of Native people whenever they encounter them, especially those that live in places where Indians are highly invisible, like large cities or in states with low Native populations. Because they have been indoctrinated with the idea of the vanishing Native their whole lives, the assumption that there is no such thing as real Natives anymore is like a software program constantly running in the background. So when they meet someone who claims to be Native, the unconscious impulse is to automatically determine the truth of the claim. They do this by asking how much Indian blood you have. And depending on your physical characteristics, they’ll either say that “you look it,” or that “gee, I don’t see it.” Your authenticity as a Native person is thus based on your appearance, not on who you actually are. For you non-Native readers, keep this in mind. Native people rarely ask each other about their blood degree because they know that being Native is not about an abstract mathematical equation that parses out their identity into measurable fractions. When you demand to know how much “Indian blood” someone has, whether you realize it or not you are presuming the untruth of their identity claims, which is why the question can be so offensive. But most Native people don’t mind talking about who they are, so instead ask what Native nation they are from. That opens the door for a broader dialogue without subtly accusing them of a fake identity.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › ---at: andrea smith bad

Presumption should go toward Smith- the politics of passing is different for Natives than other marginalized groups- the biggest danger from settler colonialism is eliminating Natives by denying them identity- which means you should always err against authenticity tests. AND Process over product- the push to interrogate Smith’s authenticity was founded in settler motivations- no matter your conclusions on Smith’s authenticity the chilling effect on young Native scholars outweighs- it marginalizes Native students who fear having their authenticity challenged

Jolivétte, 15 -- San Francisco State University American Indian Studies professor

[Andrew Jolivétte is a Creole whose cultural heritage includes Opelousa, Choctaw, Atakapa-Ishak, Cherokee, French, African and Spanish, "Rachel Dolezal and Andrea Smith: On the Politics of Racial Identity and “Passing” from a Critical Mixed-Race Studies Perspective," Against a Politics of Disposability, 7-5-15, https://againstpoliticsofdisposability.wordpress.com/2015/07/05/rachel-dolezal-and-andrea-smith-on-the-politics-of-racial-identity-and-passing-from-a-critical-mixed-race-studies-perspective-by-andrew-jolivette/, accessed 10-2-15]

Let me begin by stating that the recent comparisons between Rachel Dolezal and Andrea Smith are deeply problematic and troubling for a number of reasons. 1. Smith unlike Dolezal grew up being told she was Cherokee, she did not invent this identification as a child. 2. The politics of tribal enrollment and citizenship, especially within the Cherokee Nation are deeply politicized, racist, and in my view Eurocentric to say the least (see Sturm, Blood Politics). 3. Smith has not held official appointments in Native American Studies, unlike Dolezal who held positions in African American organizations. While Smith has held positions in Native organizations, this was not her source of employment. 4. Passing functions differently in Native and Black contexts and while both benefit from supposedly passing the issue of who is and who is not Indian is much more tied to state and federal laws both historic and contemporary that seek to limit the number of Indians while increasing the number of Blacks. In other words kill the Indian through a paper genocide so no one can be an Indian unless the U.S. Government approves and anyone with Black blood is black according to the U.S. Government so that they can be thoroughly disenfranchised. 5. When the Cherokee were removed in the 1830s not all Cherokee left many remained, unrecognized in their original homelands but we both native and non-native academics tend to favor the enrolled to the detriment of the unrecognized (I.e., California Indians especially in Northern California who are also “Not Indian” like Smith for the very same reasons). I’m not going to sugarcoat this. Smith like the Ohlone are Not recognized because of a government system that seeks to erase Indian people, especially mixed-race Indians. This happens throughout the United States and Latin America where blackness is in fact used to erase Indian blood, while whiteness in Indian country is rarely questioned. 6. The problem of the census and enrollment from a critical mixed race perspective—census takers did not enroll all Indians nor did they even record the blood quantum of siblings with the same parents in a consistent manner. In Louisiana, where my father is from the practice of categorizing mixed race people especially after 1890 focused on making as many multiracial people into African Americans as possible to disenfranchise them. This is not to say that these individuals were not Black, but they were also White/Latin and American Indian. 7. Oral versus written records. I’m not writing this piece to claim Andrea Smith is Indian, I am writing it to question the way we have come to overwhelmingly accept the ways that Europeans have defined Indianness based on written versus oral forms of “evidence”! For all we know Smith could descend from the Cherokee who never left during removal. I only raise this to say that culture, not biology should determine identity, but as is the case with mixed race identity in the black community, it is too tempting to read mixed-race as fake race. I did attend graduate school with Andrea Smith. I do NOT know her family or her ethnicity other than what she told me during the time we were in school together, but my point is why did the Cherokee nation in Oklahoma begin to question her identity in the first place? Was it because of the political questions she was asking? 8. Disappearing one of “their own”? Whether Smith is biologically Cherokee or not, I find it ironic how whiteness has so thoroughly taken hold of the Cherokee Nation in Oklahoma. Indeed they are a nation with a long-standing series of tribal chiefs who were partially and often predominantly white. Whiteness within the nation has been at the very least less offensive than blackness (Cherokee freedmen, who like Smith have been disappeared because supposedly they are NOT Cherokee by blood) but why disappear a mixed white person in this case when this has not been the consistent pattern of a nation with no minimum blood quantum? Did she ask one too many questions? Racial identity politics are tricky business to say the least but at the end of the day mixed race scholars argue that culture and cultural participation is what we should use to determine group membership. This case of questioning Smith opens up a set of other larger questions with enormous stakes for the future of American Indians—who should determine who is an Indian? Many say tribes have the sovereign right to grant citizenship, but what happens to tribes like the Ohlone who live without recognition? Are they Indians? What about nations like unlike the U.S government deny citizenship on the basis of race or inaccurate or distorted written records. In the end, how does Smith’s work further or take away from Indian struggles for justice? How do Dolezal’s claims serve as an act of anti-blackness in that she purposefully wanted to perform blackness, no where has Smith romanticized being an Indian to my knowledge. Let us ask ourselves are we who are grandmothers and mothers tell us we are or should we be what the government wants us to be? If it’s the latter I fear all the Indians will be gone and soon all the blacks will follow, albeit for different reasons. PART TWO: One more note to my earlier post today regarding Andrea Smith. While I believe we should use her case to raise bigger questions about the politics of recognition and problematic census rolls I would be remiss if I did not state that no one should ever, ever claim enrollment status if they know it is false. As some who comes from unrecognized people I would never claim enrollment and on this point I can agree that misrepresentation is an abuse when so many look up to a person who is by all rights “representing” a Native nation or Native issues period. It is a sad day in many ways and I appreciate and thank colleagues who are taking up the issue from many very honest and difficult vantage points. PART THREE: I’d like to further clarify my post yesterday about Andrea Smith. My comments were not meant as a defense of her knowingly claiming to be an enrolled member of the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma. My post was about what issues make it possible for someone to be denied or granted citizenship and how are current systems deeply flawed and how racial mixing has been used to deny citizenship and erase some people who are Native because no records exist. It’s really a simple question. Was every person of Cherokee/American Indian descent counted? If not could there be folks who claim Native identities based on oral traditions that have no written documentation? Could Andrea Smith be one of these people? I’m not saying whether she is or is not. I was raised not to question people’s identity. That is between them and their community(ies). My reference to policing is really a question about why we as academics are engaging in questioning the identity of another person and their integrity? As a legal issue hasn’t this already been decided? Do these discussions take away from the real entity that gets to decide—the tribe? At any rate as I’ve said it I’m not defending nor critiquing the choices she made. I don’t believe it’s my place to do so. I will say that collectively perhaps as a Native Academic community there is a responsibility to the communities we serve to ensure that indigenous peoples are not being represented in ways that are NOT of their own choosing. My point here was not to say without a doubt that Andy is mixed-race or even Native. My larger point was who gets to decide? The Cherokee Nation decides but are there problems with how people have been included and excluded from the nation on the basis of racial mixing? My point is we don’t know if she was raised Native/Cherokee or not and I was merely suggesting that there could be legitimate reasons why her family has no paper trail. The only two plausible reasons- she has no ancestry or the paper work for her family like many Indian people just isn’t in the records and we do know that this happened a lot even among tribes with great records. How many Natives reading this have relatives and ancestors who had an incorrect BQ or none listed at all? I used unrecognized tribes like the Ohlone to suggest a similar problem with written records not always under the control of the tribes themselves. All this language we are using is not from us, it comes from a Western, essentialist construct. But I do often feel as many of you do that academia is not necessarily the place where change really happens because in the end whether she is or isn’t Indian or mixed and whatever the reason for her actions—what will change other than she won’t be considered Indian anymore? That she will no longer be a “Native” academic. This is also an opportunity for all of us to ask ourselves what does it mean to be a Native academic and who/what are responsible for? All other Native academics? All tribes? Just our specific tribes? The tribes located in the regions where we work and live? This is not the first case and it probably isn’t the last and certainly not the last among “Cherokee” academics…there will be more (there have already been whispers about other prominent figures) so this is why I chose to focus on the larger, structural and systemic problems related to BQ and census records. How in all of this do we bring kinship, clan, cultural participation and family back into the conversation to also get more Native students, faculty, staff, and administrators in higher education if that’s what they/we want to do? And how will engaging with academia benefit our home communities, territories, and nations. We owe it to the coming generations of Native scholars to create spaces, where their multiple identities are not cause for concern that they too will be chased away. In the end it is up to our families and communities to determine our identities. I have heard from students all across the country since writing my statements and many have expressed both gratitude for the perspective and fear/concern for their own well-being as they pursue their own academic careers. So let us elevate our discussion to focus not on individuals, but rather on institutions and structural practices that continue to marginalize Native peoples.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › ---at: andrea smith bad

The attacks on Andrea Smith are founded in anonymous online blogs and elite Cherokee councils- NEITHER of which reflects the grass-roots Natives who claim and embrace Smith as an important and dedicated participant in social justice struggles

Little, 15 – Muscogee Creek/Seminole woman from the Skunk clan; ceremonial practitioner and a language revitalizationist; degree in Native Studies from the University of Oklahoma

[Tawna, "Statement from Tawna Barnett-Little" Against the Politics of Disposability, 7-2-15, https://againstpoliticsofdisposability.wordpress.com/2015/07/02/tawna-little-muscogee-creekseminole/, accessed 10-2-15]

[Dawes era note: The Dawes Act of 1887 authorized the President of the United States to survey American Indian tribal land and divide it into allotments for individual Indians.]

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › at: black/white binary bad

Their desire to go beyond the black white binary simply strengthens anti blackness. We must start with analysis of the slave to every have truly meaningful cross racial political analysis – the impact is anti blackness

Smith ‘6 [Andrea smith- activist/educator who was born in San Francisco and grew up in Southern California. She received her PhD in History of Consciousness from the University of California, Santa Cruz.- Heteropatriarchy and the three pillars of whaite supremacy- Color of Violence-Incite! The anthology- p. 69-70]

Our organizing can also reflect anti-Black racism. Recently, with the out- growth of "multiculturalism" there have been calls to "go beyond the black/white binary" and include other communities of color in our analysis, as presented in the third scenario. There are a number of flaws with this analysis. First, it replaces an analysis of white supremacy with a politics of multicultural representation; if we just include more people, then our practice will be less racist. Not true. This model does not address the nuanced structure of white supremacy, such as through these distinct logics of slavery, genocide, and Orientalism. Second, it obscures the centrality of the slavery logic in the system of white supremacy, which is based on a black/white binary. The black/white binary is not the only binary which characterizes white supremacy, but it is still a central one that we cannot "go beyond" in our racial justice organizing efforts. If we do not look at how the logic of slaveability inflects our society and our thinking, it will be evident in our work as well. For example, other communities of color often appropriate the cultural work and organizing strategies of African American civil rights or Black Power movements without corresponding assumptions that we should also be in solidarity with Black communities. We assume that this work is the common "property of all oppressed groups, and we can appropriate it without being accountable. Angela P. Harris and Juan Perea debate the usefulness of the black/white binary in the book, Critical Race Theory. Perea complains that the black/white binary fails to include the experiences of other people of color. However, he fails to identify alternative racializing logics to the black/white paradigm. Meanwhile, Angela P. Harris argues that "the story of 'race' itself is that of the construction of Blackness and whiteness. In this story, Indians, Asian Americans, and Latinos do exist. But their roles are subsidiary to the fundamental binary national drama. As a political claim, Black exceptionalism exposes the deep mistrust and tensions among American ethnic groups racialized as nonwhite."~ Let's examine these statements in conversation with each other. Simply saying we need to move beyond the black/white binary (or perhaps, the "black/non- black" binary) in US racism obfuscates the racializing logic of slavery, and prevents us from seeing that this binary constitutes Blackness as the bottom of a color hierarchy. However, this is not the only binary that fundamentally constitutes white supremacy. There is also an indigenous/settler binary, where Native genocide is central to the logic of white supremacy and other non-indigenous people of color also form "a subsidiary" role. We also face another Orientalist logic that fundamentally constitutes Asians, Arabs, and Latinos as foreign threats, requiring the United States to be at permanent war with these peoples. In this construction, Black and Narive peoples play subsidiary roles. Clearly the black/white binary is central to racial and political thought and practice in the United States, and any understanding of white supremacy must take it into consideration. However, if we look at only this binary, we may misread the dynamics of white supremacy in different contexts. For example, critical race theorist Cheryl Harris's analysis of whiteness as property reveals this weakness. In Critical Race Theory, Harris contends that whites have a property interest in the preservation of whiteness, and seek to deprive those who are "tainted" by Black or Indian blood from these same white property interests. Harris simply assumes that the positions of African Americans and American Indians are the same, failing to consider US policies of forced assimilation and forced whiteness on American Indians. These policies have become so entrenched that when Native peoples make political claims, they have been accused of being white. When Andrew Jackson removed the Cherokee along the Trail of Tears, he argued that those who did not want removal were really white.7 In contemporary times, when I was a non-violent witness for the Chippewa spearfishers in the late 1980s, one of the more frequent slurs whites hurled when the Chippewa attempted to exercise their treaty-protected right to fish was that they had white parents, or they were really white. Status differences between Blacks and Natives are informed by the different economic positions African Americans and American Indians have in US society. & African Americans have been traditionally valued for their labor, hence it is in the interest of the dominant society to have as many people marked "Black," as possible, thereby maintaining a cheap labor pool; by contrast, American Indians have been valued for the land base they occupy, so it is in the interest of dominant society to have as few people marked "Indian" as possible, facilitating access to Native lands. "Whiteness" operates differently under a logic of genocide than it does from logic of slavery. Another failure of US-based people of color in organizing is that we often fall back on a "US-centricism," believing that what is happening "over there" is less important than what is happening here. We fail to see how the United States maintains the system of oppression here precisely by tying our allegiances to the interests of US empire "over there." Heteropatriarchy and White Supremacy Heteropatriarchy is the building block of US empire. In fact, it is the building block of the nation-state form of governance. Christian Right authors make these links in their analysis of imperialism and empire. For example, Christian Right activist and founder of Prison Fellowship Charles Colson makes the connection between homosexuality and the nation-state in his analysis of the war on terror, explaining that one of the causes of terrorism is same-sex marriage: Marriage is the traditional building block of human society, intended both to unite couples and bring children into the world . . . There is a natural moral order for the family . . . the family, led by a married mother and father, is the best available structure for both child- rearing and cultural health. Marriage is not a private institution designed solely for the individual gratification of its participants. If we fail to enact a Federal Marriage Amendment, we can expect not just more family breakdown, but also more criminals behind bars and more chaos in our streets." Colson is linking the well-being of US empire to the well-being of the heteropatriarchal family. He continues: When radical Islamists see American women abusing Muslim men, as they did in the Abu Ghraib prison, and when they see news coverage of same-sex couples being "married" in US towns, we make this kind of freedom abhorrent-the kind they see as a blot on Allah's creation. We must preserve traditional marriage in order to protect the United States from those who would use our depravity to destroy us? As Ann Burlein argues in Lift High the Cross, it may be a mistake to argue that the goal of Christian Right politics is to create a theocracy in the United States. Rather, Christian Right politics work through the private family (which is coded as white, patriarchal, and middle class) to create a "Christian America." She notes that the investment in the private family makes it difficult for people to invest in more public forms of social connection. In addition, investment in the suburban private family serves to mask the public disinvestment in urban areas that makes the suburban lifestyle possible. The social decay in urban areas that results from this disinvestment is then construed as the result of deviance from the Christian family ideal rather than as the result of political and economic forces. As former head of the Christian Coalition, Ralph Reed, states: "'The only true solution to crime is to restore the family,"10 and "Family break-up causes poverty."" Concludes Burlein, "'The family' is no mere metaphor but a crucial technology by which modern power is produced and exercised."'* As I have argued elsewhere, in order to colonize peoples whose societies are nor based on social hierarchy, colonizers must first naturalize hierarchy through instituting patriarchy.13 In turn, patriarchy rests on a gender binary system in which only two genders exist, one dominating the other. Consequently, Charles Colson is correct when he says that the colonial world order depends on heteronormativity. Just as the patriarchs rule the family, the elites of the nation-state rule their citizens. Any liberation struggle that does not challenge heteronormativity cannot substantially challenge colonialism or white supremacy. Rather, as Cathy Cohen contends, such struggles will maintain colonialism based on a politics of secondary marginalization where the most elite class of these groups will further their aspirations on the backs of those most marginalized within the community. Through this process of secondary marginalization, the national or racial justice struggle takes on either implicitly or explicitly a nation-state model as the end point of its struggle-a model of governance in which the elites govern the rest through violence and domination, as well as exclude those who are not members of "the nation." Thus, national liberation politics become less vulnerable to being coopted by the Right when we base them on a model of liberation that fundamentally challenges right-wing conceptions of nation. We need a model based on community relationships and on mutual respect.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › at: asian diaspora

This turns the K and causes their intersectional analysis to fail –by failing to interrogate how their own self reinforces oppression they poison their own performance and perpetuate the harms of the 1NC – intersectional analyses must begin with “I”

Moore 11 [12/2011, Darnell L. Moore is a writer and activist whose work is informed by anti-racist, feminist, queer of color, and anti-colonial thought and advocacy. Darnell's essays, social commentary, poetry, and interviews have appeared in various national and international media venues, including the Feminist Wire, Ebony magazine, and The Huffington Post. “On Location: The “I” in the Intersection," ]

The most general statement of our politics at the present time would be that we are actively committed to struggling against racial, sexual, heterosexual, and class oppression and see as our particular task the development of integrated analysis and practice based upon the fact that the major systems of oppression are interlocking. The synthesis of these oppressions creates the conditions of our lives. As black women we see black feminism as the logical political movement to combat the manifold and simultaneous oppressions that all women of color face. -The Combahee River Collective in A Black Feminist Statement Many radical movement builders are well-versed in the theory of intersectionality. Feminists, queer theorists and activists, critical race scholars, progressive activists, and the like owe much to our Black feminist sisters, like The Combahee River Collective, who introduced us to the reality of simultaneity–as a framework for assessing the multitude of interlocking oppressions that impact the lives of women of color–in A Black Feminist Statement (1978). Their voices and politics presaged Kimberlé Crenshaw’s very useful theoretical contribution of “intersectionality” to the feminist toolkit of political interventions in 1989. Since its inception, many have referenced the term—sometimes without attribution to the black feminist intellectual genealogy from which it emerged—as a form of en vogue progressive parlance. In fact, it seems to be the case that it is often referenced in progressive circles as a counterfeit license (as in, “I understand the ways that race, sexuality, class, and gender coalesce. I get it. I really do.”) to enter resistance work even if the person who declares to have a deep “understanding” of the connectedness of systemic matrices of oppression, themselves, have yet to discern and address their own complicity in the maintenance of the very oppressions they seek to name and demolish. I am certain that I am not the only person who has heard a person use language embedded with race, class, gender, or ability privilege follow-up with a reference to “intersectionality.” My concern, then, has everything to do with the way that the fashioning of intersectionality as a political framework can lead toward the good work of analyzing ideological and material systems of oppression—as they function “out there”—and away from the great work of critical analyses of the ways in which we, ourselves, can function as actants in the narratives of counter-resistance that we rehearse. In other words, we might be missing the opportunity to read our complicities, our privileges, our accesses, our excesses, our excuses, our modes of oppressing—located “in here”—as they occupy each of us. Crenshaw’s theorization has provided us with a useful lens to assess the problematics of the interrelated, interlocking apparatuses of power and privilege and their resulting epiphenomena of powerlessness and subjugation. Many have focused on the external dimensions of oppression and their material results manifested in the lives of the marginalized, but might our times be asking of us to deeply consider our own “stuff” that might instigate such oppressions? What if we extended Crenshaw’s theory of intersectionality by invoking what we might name “intralocality”? Borrowing from sociologists, the term “social location,” which broadly speaks to one’s context, highlights one’s standpoint(s)—the social spaces where s/he is positioned (i.e. race, class, gender, geographical, etc.). Intralocality, then, is concerned with the social locations that foreground our knowing and experiencing of our world and our relationships to the systems and people within our world. Intralocality is a call to theorize the self in relation to power and privilege, powerlessness and subjugation. It is work that requires the locating of the “I” in the intersection. And while it could be argued that such work is highly individualistic, I contend that it is at the very level of self-in-relation-to-community where communal transformation is made possible.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › 1nc anti-blackness links

There is an impact to all of these links – obscuring the structural position of blackness causes their coalitional politics to fail – this explicitly indicts their method which is BASED upon intersectionality/coalitions – only the alt solves

Sexton ’10 [Jared Sexton, Associate professor of African American studies and film and media studies at the University of California, Irvine, 2010, “People-of-Color-Blindness; Notes on the Afterlife of Slavery,” ]

If the oppression of nonblack people of color in, and perhaps beyond, the United States seems conditional to the historic instance and functions at a more restricted empirical scope, antiblackness seems invariant and limitless (which does not mean that the former is somehow negligible and short-lived or that the latter is exhaustive and unchanging). If pursued with some consistency, the sort of comparative analysis outlined above would likely impact the formulation of political strategy and modify the demeanor of our political culture. In fact, it might denature the comparative instinct altogether in favor of a relational analysis more adequate to the task. Yet all of this is obviated by the silencing mechanism par excellence in Left political and intellectual circles today: “Don’t play Oppression Olympics!” The Oppression Olympics dogma levels a charge amounting to little more than a leftist version of “playing the race card.” To fuss with details of compara- tive (or relational) analysis is to play into the hands of divide-and-conquer tactics and to promote a callous immorality.72 However, as in its conserva- tive complement, one notes in this catchphrase the unwarranted transla- tion of an inquiring position of comparison into an insidious posture of competition, the translation of ethical critique into unethical attack. This point allows us to understand better the intimate relationship between the censure of black inquiry and the recurrent analogizing to black suffering mentioned above: they bear a common refusal to admit to significant dif- ferences of structural position born of discrepant histories between blacks and their political allies, actual or potential. We might, finally, name this refusal people-of-color-blindness, a form of colorblindness inherent to the concept of “people of color” to the precise extent that it misunderstands the specificity of antiblackness and presumes or insists upon the mono- lithic character of victimization under white supremacy73 — thinking (the afterlife of) slavery as a form of exploitation or colonization or a species of racial oppression among others.74

The upshot of this predicament is that obscuring the structural position of the category of blackness will inevitably undermine multiracial coalition building as a politics of radical opposition and, to that extent, force the question of black liberation back to the center of discussion. Every analysis that attempts to understand the complexities of racial rule and the machinations of the racial state without accounting for black existence within its framework—which does not mean simply listing it among a chain of equivalents or returning to it as an afterthought—is doomed to miss what is essential about the situation. Black existence does not represent the total reality of the racial formation — it is not the beginning and the end of the story—but it does relate to the totality; it indicates the (repressed) truth of the political and economic system. That is to say, the whole range of positions within the racial formation is most fully understood from this vantage point, not unlike the way in which the range of gender and sexual variance under patriarchal and heteronormative regimes is most fully understood through lenses that are feminist and queer.75 What is lost for the study of black existence in the proposal for a decentered, “postblack” paradigm is a proper analysis of the true scale and nature of black suffer- ing and of the struggles — political, aesthetic, intellectual, and so on — that have sought to transform and undo it. What is lost for the study of nonblack nonwhite existence is a proper analysis of the true scale and nature of its material and symbolic power relative to the category of blackness.76

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Anti-Blackness K › 1nc anti-blackness links

They parallel black suffering to Asian suffering – every attempt to position the black by the way of analogy is parasitic upon blackness

Wilderson 10 [Frank B. Wilderson, Associate Professor of African American Studies and Drama at the University of California & former member of the Umkhonto we Sizwe, Red, White and Black: Cinema and the Structure of US Antagonisms]

This is one of several moments in Black Skin, White Masks when Fanon splits the hair between social oppression and structural suffering, making it possible to theorize the impossibility of a Black ontology (thus allowing us to meditate on how the Black suffers) without being chained to the philosophical and rhetorical demands of analogy, demands which the evidentiary register of social oppression (i.e., how many Jews died in the ovens, how many Blacks were lost in the Middle Passage) normally imposes upon such meditations. The ruse of analogy erroneously locates the Black in the world—a place where s/he has not been since the dawning of Blackness. This attempt to position the Black in the world by way of analogy is not only a mystification, and often erasure, of Blackness’s grammar of suffering (accumulation and fungibility or the status of being non-Human) but simultaneously also a provision for civil society, promising an enabling modality for Human ethical dilemmas. It is a mystification and an erasure because, whereas Masters may share the same fantasies as Slaves, and Slaves can speak as though they have the same interests as Masters, their respective grammars of suffering are irreconcilable. In dragging his interlocutors kicking and screaming through “Fact of Blackness,” or what Ronald Judy has translated more pointedly as “The Lived Experience of the Black,” Fanon is not attempting to play “oppression Olympics” and thus draw conclusions that Blacks are at the top of every empirical hierarchy of social discrimination, though that case has also been made.xv Having established that, yes, the Jew is oppressed (and, yes, the Black is oppressed) Fanon refuses to let the lived experience of oppression dictate the terms of his meditations on suffering. He writes: [The Jew] belongs to the race of those [who] since the beginning of time have never known cannibalism. What an idea, to eat one’s father! Simple enough one has only not to be a nigger [emphasis mine]…[I]n my case everything takes on a new guise. I am the slave not of an idea others have of me but of my own appearance. (Black Skin, White Masks 115-16) Two tensions are at work here. One operates under the labor of ethical dilemmas-- “simple enough one has only not to be a nigger.”xvi This, I submit, is the essence of being for the White and non-Black position: ontology scaled down to a global common denominator. The other tension is found in the impossibility of ethical dilemmas for the Black: “I am,” Fanon writes, “a slave not of an idea others have of me but of my own appearance.” Being can thus be thought of, in the first ontological instance, as nonniggerness; and slavery then as niggerness. The visual field, “my own appearance,” is the cut, the mechanism that elaborates the division between the non-niggerness and slavery, the difference between the living and the dead. Whereas Humans exist on some plane of being and thus can become existentially present through some struggle for/of/through recognition, Blacks cannot attain the plane of recognition (West 82). Spillers, Fanon, and Hartman maintain that the violence that has positioned and repetitively re-positions the Black as a void of historical movement is without analog in the suffering dynamics of the ontologically alive. The violence that turns the African into a thing is without analog because it does not simply oppress the Black through tactile and empirical technologies of oppression, like the “little family quarrels” which for Fanon exemplify the Jewish Holocaust. Rather, the gratuitous violence of the Black’s first ontological instance, the Middle Passage, “wiped out [his/her] metaphysics…his [her] customs and sources on which they are based” (BSWM 110). Jews went into Auschwitz and came out as Jews. Africans went into the ships and came out as Blacks. The former is a Human holocaust; the latter is a Human and a metaphysical holocaust. That is why it makes little sense to attempt analogy: the Jews have the Dead (the Muselmenn) among them; the Dead have the Blacks among them. This violence which turns a body into flesh, ripped apart literally and imaginatively, destroys the possibility of ontology because it positions the Black within an infinite and indeterminately horrifying and open vulnerability, an object made available (which is to say fungible) for any subject. As such, “the black has no ontological resistance in the eyes of the white man” (110) or, more precisely, in the eyes of Humanity.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › FW › TVA—2NC

TVA is a prerequisite to the alt.

Ahn, et al, 21—executive director of Women Cross DMZ and coordinator of Korea Peace Now (Christine, with Terry Park, lecturer in the Asian American Studies Program at the University of Maryland, College Park, and Kathleen Richards, communications director of Women Cross DMZ, “Anti-Asian Violence in America Is Rooted in US Empire,” , dml)

Yet such hawkish rhetoric against China—which was initially spread by Donald Trump and other Republicans around the coronavirus—has directly contributed to rising anti-Asian violence across the country. In fact, it’s reflective of a long history of US foreign policy in Asia centered on domination and violence, fueled by racism. Belittling and dehumanizing Asians has helped justify endless wars and the expansion of US militarism. And this has deadly consequences for Asians and Asian Americans, especially women.

Anti-Asian violence through US foreign policy has manifested in the wars that have killed millions, torn families apart, and led to massive displacement; in the nuclear tests and chemical weapons storage that resulted in environmental contamination in Okinawa, Guam, and the Marshall Islands; in the widespread use of napalm and Agent Orange in Vietnam, Laos, and Korea; in the US military bases that have destroyed villages and entire communities; in the violence perpetrated by US soldiers on Asian women’s bodies; and in the imposition of sanctions that result in economic, social, and physical harms to everyday people.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › FW › Topic Solves—2NC

This is offense—excluding analysis of empire makes Asian identity into a monolith.

Jung and Nakagawa, 21—Senior Partners of ChangeLab (Soya and Scot, “A DIFFERENT ASIAN AMERICAN TIMELINE,” , dml)

Most Asian American timelines focus only on events related to people who arrived in the United States from Asia. However, that approach paints a misleading picture. It implies that Asian American experiences can be understood in the absence of a broader context of race and capitalism, that the history of a given population can somehow be placed outside the systems of power that organize society. It also assumes that Asian Americans share more in common with each other than with other groups of people, yet there is no single Asian or Asian American past, politics, or culture. Most people from ethnic and national subgroups considered to be Asian American don’t call themselves Asian Americans. Many harbor prejudiced notions of one another. This stems from histories of conflict, conquest, and colonization within the vast and ill-defined continent that Europeans labeled Asia many centuries ago. The boundaries of Asian American identity, like the boundaries of Asia itself, are always in flux, constructed by dynamics of power that demand to be studied: imperialism, racial domination, gender oppression, labor exploitation, war, and social movements.

We cannot fully understand Asian American history without asking why Asians arrived in the Americas, and what relationship their arrival had to the global conditions affecting people across racial and national boundaries at the time. For example, why did the British “coolie” trade accelerate after Britain outlawed slavery in 1833? A more traditional Asian American timeline might not make this correlation visible, yet enslaved African people and indentured “coolies” were closely related within British and U.S. systems of racialized labor control in the 19th Century. Viewing Asian migration to the Americas in this context starts to erode the myth of the United States as a benevolent land of immigrants, to reveal instead a nation effectively ruled by oligarchy in which the plights of various kinds of exploited workers and oppressed groups have been inextricably connected.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › FW › Topic Solves—2NC

Militarism explains Yellow Peril and anti-Asian violence.

Luo, 21—writer and organizer in movements for decarceration, economic justice, and Asian-American issues (Nina, “The American Victims of Washington’s Anti-China Hysteria,” , dml)

A month later, a shooting at a massage parlor in Atlanta killed six Asian women. In response, #StopAsianHate marches spread across the nation, including in my Chinatown neighborhood. Perhaps after four years of Trump, marches couched in the reductive language of individual “bias” are enough for some. But long before Trump took office, xenophobia, anti-Asian racism, and Yellow Peril–style propaganda served as useful tools to advance American domestic and foreign policy goals. They may yet again.

In recent decades, the defense industry has perfected this rhetoric to make the case for war on China. Republicans and Democrats—including both President Biden and even our most progressive members of Congress—amplify the warmongering and push for increased defense spending. There is no violence like the mass rape and murder of war, yet in this moment of outcry against anti-Asian violence, lawmakers in D.C. are bringing us to the brink of global conflict. Asian and Pacific Islander peoples around the world—who are, like my grandparents living in China, often loved ones of people here—will suffer that violence. And as in all wars, the enemy abroad becomes the enemy at home, making Asian Americans at home once again the target of state and community brutality.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › AT: JACL Bad

Their example of the Japanese-American Citizen’s League [in the Chambers-Letson card] goes neg—their advocacy of specific policy proposals enacted postmemory by refusing to let the government and public forget the injustices of internment—state engagement does not obscure that history!

Fukarai and Yang, 18—Professor of Sociology and Legal Studies AND Associate Professor of History, UC-Santa Cruz (Hiroshi and Alice, “The History of Japanese Racism, Japanese American Redress, and the Dangers Associated with Government Regulation of Hate Speech,” 45 Hastings Const. L.Q. 533 (2018), dml)

Activists in the 1960s and 1970s also dismantled claims that the camps were necessary for national security by publicizing studies that documented the racism behind mass exclusion and incarceration. To gain credibility outside the community, it was important that a growing list of books by non-Japanese-American researchers could be cited as evidence for the injustice of the incarceration. 128 Accounts by historian Roger Daniels and journalist Allan R. Bosworth denounced government euphemisms that called mass ",129 removal an "evacuation" and labeled the camps as "relocation centers. Instead, these authors argued that the camps should be called "concentration camps" because they had caused widespread suffering. Documenting the racist views of DeWitt and other architects of the incarceration, this scholarship helped Japanese Americans recognize the camps were not just a wartime "mistake," but reflected a long history of anti-Asian racism. 130 Researchers also began presenting evidence of suffering within the camps, including the fact that several prisoners were shot and killed by trigger happy guards, which helped activists persuade former prisoners that there was no shame in sharing their personal accounts of trauma they experienced during and after the war. Activists frequently quoted this scholarship to convince Americans who had no familiarity with the Japanese-American community that the damage mass incarceration inflicted on individuals, families and the community was significant and pervasive.131

To counter claims that Japanese Americans should "move on" and avoid dwelling on the past, activists Edison Uno and Raymond Okamura organized a grassroots campaign in 1967 to repeal Title II of the 1950 Internal Security Act to prevent other groups from being incarcerated without due process. 132 This act provided funding for detention sites, including the former Japanese-Amenican camp at Tule Lake, to imprison individuals labeled as subversives without hearings. While the act specifically targeted communist agitators, black power and antiwar protesters feared that they also might be placed in "concentration camps." After the campaign gained momentum within the ethnic community and increasing media coverage, more conservative JACL lobbyists, Senator Daniel Inouye, and Congressman Spark Matsunaga shepherded the legislation through Congress in 197 1.133

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 2NC Critical Legal Advocacy Good

Critical legal advocacy by Asian-American communities has engendered progress—only public pressure and legal advocacy can protect those gains and enable future challenges to succeed

Yamamoto, et al, 17—Fred Korematsu Professor of Law and Social Justice, William S. Richardson School of Law, University of Hawai’i (Erik, with Maria Amparo Vanaclocha Berti and Jaime Tokioka, ““Loaded Weapon” Revisited: The Trump Era Import of Justice Jackson’s Warning in Korematsu,” 24 Asian Am. L.J. 5 (2017), dml)

The Justice Department declined to further appeal the coram nobis decisions. So the Supreme Court did not confront an opportunity to belatedly reverse its World War II rulings. Nor in other subsequent security and liberty disputes has the Court overruled Korematsu. 149 While the case has been sorely discredited by judges150 and scholars,151 as well as by the coram nobis decisions, the Court’s original ruling formally still stands—if not for its now widely recognized wrongful validation of the forced removal and incarceration, then for its embrace of unconditional judicial deference to government claims of national security as justification for broad civil liberties restrictions. 152

Indeed, the late-Chief Justice William Rehnquist153 and influential Seventh Court of Appeals Judge Richard Posner, in important respects, treat Korematsu as “correctly decided.” 154 Underscoring Korematsu’s principle of judicial passivity, Judge Posner indicates that during times of hostility when faced with government national security claims of urgent need, as in Korematsu, the courts can say, “[W]e’re going to defer.” 155 As Justice Jackson predicted, “every repetition” of judicial deference to unsubstantiated government claims of exigency “embeds the principle more deeply in our law and thinking and expands it to new purposes.” 156

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Immigration DA

The impact is legal violence- deportability is a direct form of violence imposed by the immigration regime with drastic material consequences on the lives of students- focusing on immigration policy avoids rendering the student as the object of study while allowing for improved understanding to form their own relationship to structures of power

Jeffries 14 (Julian, Department of Reading and Literacy Education, CSU Fullerton. "Fear of Deportation in High School: Implications for Breaking the Cricle of Silence Surrounding MIgration Status" Journal of Latinos and Education, 13)

In the case of one particular immigration raid, both immigrants and the general public got a strong glimpse of the “spectacle of enforcement” (De Genova, 2004, p. 177) of immigration law: In 2007, a total of 361 workers, mostly mothers, were arrested in a factory in the town of New Bedford, leaving 113 children without parental care and producing significant hardship and stress for the people involved (Capps et al., 2007), their relatives, and the community. The television footage of children crying for their mothers and the desperation of family members in newspaper reports resonated in the minds of undocumented migrants, authorized migrants, and citizens alike and plays a major role in the creation of a sense of deportability. Thus, fear of deportation is a powerful presence in the everyday lives of not only adults but also youth and the school personnel serving them. In looking at how administrators treat the issue of migration status in school, it is important to account for the effects these deportation policies have on the daily routine of a school.

The policies that contribute to the fear of deportation are linked to the growing national and international sense of deportation as being the only response to undocumented or unauthorized migration: “It has come to stand in as the apparently single and presumably natural or proper retribution on the part of the state powers to this apparent ‘problem’” (De Genova & Peutz, 2010, p. 1); furthermore, it is normalized as “uneventful, familiar, and legal as individuals come to understand it as ‘the law’” (Menjivar & Abrego, 2012, p. 1414). The effect of immigration is to make visible what scholars have called the “spectacle of enforcement.” As De Genova (2002) described in the “Border Spectacle,” the intensification of military control at the U.S.-Mexico border (Dunn, 1996; Heyman, 1991; Jimenez, 1992) serves not to stop the so-called flow of migrants but to create the “theatre of an enforcement crisis” to render undocumented migrants as distinctive national and racialized “illegals” (p. 439). In a similar fashion, immigration raids in Massachusetts, such as the one in New Bedford, create a public image of an illegal subject and contribute to the distinction between legal and illegal, belonging to this country or not. This illegalization fulfills the intended goals of deportation policies not to physically exclude migrants from the nation state but to include them socially under “imposed conditions of enforced and protracted vulnerability” (De Genova, 2002, p. 249), “pushing them outside the boundaries of jurisdiction [while] simultaneously includ[ing] them by criminalizing their presence” (Menjivar & Abrego, 2012, p. 1403). This study highlights how the conditions of vulnerability and a fear of deportation affect the educational experiences of these youth in high school by honing into their relationships with teachers and administrators and the consequences for educational success.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Immigration DA

Asian Americans should engage legal architectures—it’s critical to challenge transnational structures of vioence---spills over to challenge immigration exclusion and deportation of undocumented people—coalitions are valuable

Gee, 17—attorney, previously served as an Attorney with the Office of the Federal Public Defender in Las Vegas and Pittsburgh, the Federal Defenders of the Middle District of Georgia, and the Office of the Colorado State Public Defender (Harvey, “Asian Americans and the Law: Sharing a Progressive Civil Rights Agenda During Uncertain Times,” 10 DePaul J. Soc. Just. 1, dml)

The November election of Donald J. Trump as the 45th U.S. President heightened ever-growing concerns about a retrenchment of civil rights for Americans, 2 limiting voting rights, invoking tougher criminal penalties, 3 keeping Guantanamo Bay prison open and returning to aggressive interrogation techniques, 4 mass deportations 5 and stricter immigration laws. 6 Immigration holds particular relevance for Asian Americans because the majority of Asian Americans are foreign-born,7 and they along with Latinos, are among the fastest growing immigrant groups in America.8 This immigration stream shows that immigration has never been a white/brown issue even though mainstream America tends to think of immigration as an issue only affecting Latino/a immigrants. 9 On the contrary, immigration law and historical exclusion have shaped the Asian American legal and political identity within the existing U.S. racial hierarchy: whites on top, African Americans on the bottom, and Asian Americans as somewhere in-between.

The majority of Asian Americans have been identified as immigrants or children of immigrants.1 0 Asian immigrants from Asian countries face the longest backlogs for visas.11 The perennial connection between race and immigration comes up often. historically and as seen and felt in last year's presidential election, race and immigration status have enhanced the unpopularity of immigrants who have become scapegoats for the nation's economic troubles.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Case

If they’re right that power is a structural constraint they can’t articulate new modes of relationality

Bayet 13, PhD, Catherine and Bruce Bastian Professor of Global and Transnational Studies at the Department of Sociology, University of Illinois, (Assef, Life as Politics: How Ordinary People Change the Middle East, Second Edition, Stanford University Press, pg. 41-46)

The dearth of conventional collective action—in particular, contentious protests among the subaltern groups (the poor, peasants, and women) in the developing countries, together with a disillusionment with dominant socialist parties, pushed many radical observers to "discover" and highlight different types of activism, however small-scale, local, or even individualistic. Such a quest, meanwhile, both contributed to and benefited from the upsurge of theoretical perspectives, during the 1980s, associated with poststructuralism that made micropolitics and "everyday resistance" a popular idea. James Scott's departure, during the 1980s, from a structuralist position in studying the behavior of the peasantry in Asia to a more ethnographic method of focusing on individual reactions of peasants contributed considerably to this paradigm shift.27 In the meantime, Foucault's "decentered" notion of power, together with a revival of neo-Gramscian politics of culture (hegemony), served as a key theoretical backing for micropolitics, and thus the "resistance" perspective. The notion of "resistance" came to stress that power and counterpower were not in binary opposition, but in a decoupled, complex, ambivalent, and perpetual "dance of control."28 It based itself on the Foucauldian idea that "wherever there is power there is resistance," although the latter consisted largely of small-scale, everyday, tiny activities that the agents could afford to articulate given their political constraints. Such a perception of resistance penetrated not only peasant studies, but a variety of fields, including labor studies, identity politics, ethnicity, women's studies, education, and studies of the urban subaltern. Thus, multiple researchers discussed how relating stories about miracles "gives voice to popular resistance";29 how disenfranchised women resisted patriarchy by relating folktales and songs or by pretending to be possessed or crazy;-"-1 how reviving extended family among the urban popular classes represented an "avenue of political participation."31 The relationships between the Filipino bar girls and Western men were discussed not simply in terms of total domination, but in a complex and contingent fashion;32 and the veiling of the Muslim working woman has been represented not in simple terms of submission, but in ambivalent terms of protest and co-optation—hence, an "accommodating protest."33 Indeed, on occasions, both veiling and unveiling were simultaneously considered as a symbol of resistance. Undoubtedly, such an attempt to grant agency to the subjects that until then were depicted as "passive poor," "submissive women," "apolitical peasant," and "oppressed worker" was a positive development. The resistance paradigm helps to uncover the complexity of power relations in society in general, and the politics of the subaltern in particular. It tells us that we may not expect a universalized form of struggle; that totalizing pictures often distort variations in people's perceptions about change; that local should be recognized as a significant site of struggle as well as a unit of analysis; that organized collective action may not be possible everywhere, and thus alternative forms of struggles must be discovered and acknowledged; that organized protest as such may not necessarily be privileged in the situations where suppression rules. The value of a more flexible, small-scale, and unbureaucratic activism should, therefore, be acknowledged.31 These are some of the issues that critiques of poststruc-turalist advocates of "resistance" ignore.3' Yet a number of conceptual and political problems also emerge from this paradigm. The immediate trouble is how to conceptualize resistance, and its relation to power, domination, and submission. James Scott seems to be clear about what he means by the term: Class resistance includes a«/act(s) by member(s) of a subordinate class that is or are intended either to mitigate or deny claims (tor example, rents, taxes, prestige) made on that class by superordinatc classes (for example, landlords, large farmers, the state) or to advance its own claims (for example, work, land, charity, respect) vis-a-vis these superordinate classes.36 (emphasis added) However, the phrase "any act" blocks delineating between qualitatively diverse forms of activities that Scott lists. Are we not to distinguish between large-scale collective action and individual acts, say, of tax dodging? Do reciting poetry in private, however subversive-sounding, and engaging in armed struggle have identical value? Should we not expect unequal affectivity and implications from such different acts? Scott was aware of this, and so agreed with those who had made distinctions between different types of resistance—for example, "real resistance" refers to "organized, systematic, preplanned or selfless practices with revolutionary consequences," and "token resistance" points to unorganized incidental acts without any revolutionary consequences, and which are accommodated in the power structure.37 Yet he insisted that the "token resistance" is no less real than the "real resistance." Scott's followers, however, continued to make further distinctions. Nathan Brown, in studying peasant politics in Egypt, for instance, identities three forms of politics: atomistic (politics of individuals and small groups with obscure content), communal (a group effort to disrupt the system, by slowing down production and the like), and revolt (just short of revolution to negate the system).38 Beyond this, many resistance writers tend to confuse an awareness about oppression with acts of resistance against it. The fact that poor women sing songs about their plight or ridicule men in their private gatherings indicates their understanding of gender dynamics. This does not mean, however, that they are involved in acts of resistance; neither are the miracle stories of the poor urbanites who imagine the saints to come and punish the strong. Such an understanding of "resistance" fails to capture the extremely complex interplay of conflict and consent, and ideas and action, operating within systems of power. Indeed, the link between consciousness and action remains a major sociological dilemma." Scott makes it clear that resistance is an intentional act. In Weberian tradition, he takes the meaning of action as a crucial clement. This intentional-ity, while significant in itself, obviously leaves out many types of individual and collective practices whose intended and unintended consequences do not correspond. In Cairo or Tehran, for example, many poor families illegally tap into electricity and running water from the municipality despite their awareness of their behavior's illegality. Yet they do not steal urban services in order to express their defiance vis-a-vis the authorities. Rather, they do it because they feel the necessity of those services for a decent life, because they find no other way to acquire them. But these very mundane acts when continued lead to significant changes in the urban structure, in social policy, and in the actors' own lives. Hence, the significance of the unintended consequences of agents' daily activities. In fact, many authors in the resistance paradigm have simply abandoned intent and meaning, focusing instead eclectically on both intended and unintended practices as manifestations of "resistance." There is still a further question. Docs resistance mean defending an already achieved gain (in Scott's terms, denying claims made by dominant groups over the subordinate ones) or making fresh demands (to "advance its own claims"), what 1 like to call "encroachment"? In much of the resistance literature, this distinction is missing. Although one might imagine moments of overlap, the two strategies, however, lead to different political consequences; this is so in particular when we view them in relation to the strategies of dominant power. The issue was so crucial that Lenin devoted his entire What Is to Be Done? to discussing the implications of these two strategics, albeit in different terms of "economism/trade unionism" vs. "social democratic/party politics." Whatever one may think about a Leninist/vanguardist paradigm, it was one that corresponded to a particular theory of the state and power (a capitalist state to be seized by a mass movement led by the working-class party); in addition, it was clear where this strategy wanted to take the working class (to establish a socialist state). Now, what is the perception of the state in the "resistance" paradigm? What is the strategic aim in this perspective? Where does the resistance paradigm want Lo lake its agents/subjects, beyond "preventing] the worst and promising] something better"?40 Much of the literature of resistance is based upon a notion of power that Foucault has articulated, that power is everywhere, that it "circulates" and is never "localized here and there, never in anybody's hands."'11 Such a formulation is surely instructive in transcending the myth of the powerlessness of the ordinary and in recognizing their agency. Yet this "decentered" notion of power, shared by many poststructuralist "resistance" writers, underestimates state power, notably its class dimension, since it fails to see that although power circulates, it does so unevenly—in some places it is far weightier, more concentrated, and "thicker," so to speak, than in others. In other words, as a system of power. It is, therefore, not accidental that a theory of the state and, therefore, an analysis of the possibility of co-optation, are absent in almost all accounts of "resistance." Consequently, the cherished acts of resistance float around aimlessly in an unknown, uncertain, and ambivalent universe of power relations, with the end result an unsettled, tense accommodation with the existing power arrangement. Lack of a clear concept of resistance, moreover, often leads writers in this genre to overestimate and read too much into the acts of the agents. The result is that almost any act of the subjects potentially becomes one of "resistance." Determined to discover the "inevitable" acts of resistance, many poststructuralist writers often come to "replace their subject."42 While they attempt to challenge the essentialism of such perspectives as "passive poor" "submissive Muslim women," and "inactive masses," they tend, however, to fall into the trap of essentialism in reverse—by reading too much into ordinary behaviors, interpreting them as necessarily conscious or contentious acts of defiance. This is so because they overlook the crucial fact that these practices occur mostly within the prevailing systems of power.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Case

Failure to connect critique of Asian violence to legal change is alchemy, not activism

SAITO 09 (Natsu Taylor, Professor Law at Georgia State University College of Law, “INTERNMENTS, THEN AND NOW: CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY IN POST-9/11 AMERICA” https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.com/&httpsredir=1&article=1011&context=dflsc)

The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee called for the removal of Civil Rights Commissioner Kirsanow following his defense of internment in 2002.210 He was not removed, although apparently he did apologize, insisting that his remarks had been taken out of context.211 In January 2006, while Congress was in recess, President Bush appointed Kirsanow to the National Labor Relations Board.212 Congressman Coble expressed his “regret” that “many Japanese and Arab Americans found my choice of words offensive,” but ignored calls for his resignation as chair of the subcommittee on terrorism.213

CIA Director “Leon Panetta announced at his confirmation hearing that CIA agents that engaged in torture, including waterboarding, in the early phases of the war against terrorism, would not be criminally prosecuted.”214 In fact, attorneys in the Obama administration have continued to rely “on the state secret doctrine and thus seem prepared to confer de facto immunity on the CIA for constitutional wrongs as gross as those entailed in extraordinary rendition.”215 According to Attorney General Eric Holder, “It would be unfair to prosecute dedicated men and women working to protect America for conduct that was sanctioned in advance by the Justice Department.”216

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Case

Systemic solution oriented policy is key to effective activism to counter anti-Asian violence – it solves material harms and helps build broader multi-racial coalitions that empower movements, but detail and theoretical nuance are key

Kohli & Belcore 21 [AARTI KOHLI Aarti Kohli is the executive director of Asian Americans Advancing Justice–Asian Law Caucus, the organization that convenes the Asian American Leaders Table. More by Aarti Kohli BECKY BELCORE Becky Belcore is executive director of the National Korean American Service and Education Consortium (NAKASEC), a progressive grassroots organization and a member of the Asian American Leaders Table. More by Becky Belcore "Coalitions and solidarity with others are vital to Asian American activism." https://prismreports.org/2021/06/10/coalitions-and-solidarity-with-others-are-vital-to-asian-american-activism/]

For many Asian Americans, it can feel as if we live surrounded by absolutism and extremes, with little room for nuance. But we often occupy “in-between” spaces and identities, and nuance is necessary in order to understand our work with Asian American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) communities. It’s also essential when it comes to understanding ourselves as immigrants from colonized nations, and as Indigenous people, multi-racial people, undocumented people, or trans-racial adoptees. It may be uncomfortable, but we must persist in the complex work of making progress toward racial solidarity so that we can create a more just future for our communities.

In the wake of increased violence targeting Asian Americans, a new network of 100+ organizations serving AAPI communities was convened. Its goal is to coalesce and leverage our power toward policy change, solidarity, and shifting the public narrative. The “Asian American Leaders Table” provides a ray of hope in the type of coalition building and mutual support that can buoy us during hard times.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – Techno-Orientalism – BFHR 7wk › Case › 1NC Case

The aff’s approach to politics fails – without the ability to compare proposals they have no method for designing policy other than a naïve faith that they’ll figure it out, and their refusal to engage the process of imaginative hypothesis generation proves they either leave things in the hands of useless elites or they spill up to a new society that’s more likely than not to fail

Wilkinson, 17—Vice President for Policy at the Niskanen Center (Will, October 24, “PUBLIC POLICY AFTER UTOPIA,” )

Many political philosophers, and most adherents of radical political ideologies, tend to think that an ideal vision of the best social, economic, and political system serves a useful and necessary orienting function. The idea is that reformers need to know what to aim at if they are to make steady incremental progress toward the maximally good and just society. If you don’t know where you’re headed—if you don’t know what utopia looks like—how are you supposed to know which steps to take next? The idea that a vision of an ideal society can serve as a moral and strategic star to steer by is both intuitive and appealing. But it turns out to be wrong. This sort of political ideal actually can’t help us find our way through the thicket of real-world politics into the clearing of justice. I’ve discussed the problems with ideal theory at length, in the context Gerald Gaus’ tremendous book The Tyranny of the Ideal, in a Vox column. This piece will be easier to understand if you read that first. Jacob Levy’s paper, “There’s No Such Thing as Ideal Theory,” is an outstanding complement. And, on the more technical side, the work of UCSD’s David Wiens is state of the art, and adds texture to Gaus’ critique. A major paradigm shift in political theory is underway, and it’s all over but the shoutin’ for ideal theory. But it takes a while for the shoutin’ to peter out. New paradigms can take a generation or more to trickle down through the intellectual culture. So we’ve barely begun to grasp what it means to give up on ideal theory, especially in public policy. It’s a bit dramatic to say that the death of ideal theory changes everything, but it changes a lot. It definitely changes what it means to be an ideologically principled think tank. If you agree with Gaus, as I do, then you will think that there’s a pretty major intellectual mistake lurking within the ideal-theoretic version of libertarianism that the most prominent institutions of the “freedom movement” were built to promote. Again, this has nothing to do with libertarianism, per se. Gaus’ argument is general. It doesn’t matter which normative standard you use to rank possible social systems. It could be the orthodox libertarian conception of freedom as non-coercion, John Rawls’ two principles of justice, or a radically egalitarian conception of material equality. It doesn’t matter. In order to say that any particular system is the best in terms of your chosen normative standard, you’ve got to be able to rank rival systems against that standard. Doing that ranking in a principled, non-arbitrary way requires evidence of what the realization of your favorite possible social world would actually look like. Otherwise you can’t really say that it does better in terms of your chosen standard than competing systems. Utopia is a guess The fact that all our evidence about how social systems actually work comes from formerly or presently existing systems is a huge problem for anyone committed to a radically revisionary ideal of the morally best society. The further a possible system is from a historical system, and thus from our base of evidence about how social systems function, the more likely we are to be mistaken about how it would work if it were realized. And the more likely we are to be mistaken about how it would actually work, the more likely we are to be mistaken that it is more free, or more equal, or more socially just than other systems, possible or actual. Indeed, there’s basically no way to rationally justify the belief that, say, “anarcho-capitalism” ranks better in terms of libertarian freedom than “Canada 2017,” or the belief that “economic democracy” ranks better in terms of socialist equality than “Canada 2017.” You may think you can imagine how anarcho-capitalism or economic democracy would work, but you can’t. You’re really just guessing—extrapolating way beyond your evidence. You can’t just stipulate that it works the way you want it to work. Rationally speaking, you probably shouldn’t even suspect that your favorite system comes out better than an actual system. Rationally speaking, your favorite probably shouldn’t be your favorite. Utopia is a guess. Again, this is a general problem. But it does hit especially hard for those who appreciate the unpredictability of complex systems and the inevitability of unintended consequences. It’s no coincidence that Gaus is a Hayekian. As my colleague Jeffrey Friedman argues, expert predictions about the the likely effects of changing a single policy tend to be pretty bad. I’ll use myself as an example. I’ve followed the academic literature about the minimum wage for almost twenty years, and I’m an experienced, professional policy analyst, so I’ve got a weak claim to expertise in the subject. What do I have to show for that? Not much, really. I’ve got strong intuitions about the likely effects of raising minimum wages in various contexts. But all I really know is that the context matters a great deal, that a lot of interrelated factors affect the dynamics of low-wage labor markets, and that I can’t say in advance which margin will adjust when the wage floor is raised. Indeed, whether we should expect increases in the minimum wage to hurt or help low-wage workers is a question Nobel Prize-winning economists disagree about. Labor markets are complicated! Well, the comprehensive political economies of nation-states are vastly more complicated. And that means that our predictions about the outcome of radically changing the entire system are unlikely to be better than random. If your favorite system is quite a bit different from any system that has existed, then even if it were true that it would rank numero uno in terms of your favorite normative standard, you’re not in a position to rationally believe it. Clearly then, it’s not actually useful to aim toward a distant ideal when you don’t really have a good reason to believe that it’s better than actually existing systems in terms of liberty or equality or nationalist solidarity or whatever it is you care about. This is a hard lesson for ideologues to swallow. I still haven’t totally digested it. But a number of things have become much clearer after giving up on my sinful, ideal-theoretic ways. Analysis after ideal theory: measurement and comparison The death of ideal theory implies a non-ideological, empirical, comparative approach to political analysis. That doesn’t mean giving up on, say, the value of freedom. I think I’m more libertarian—more committed to value of liberty—than I’ve ever been. But that doesn’t mean being committed to an eschatology of liberty, a picture of an ideally free society, or a libertarian utopia. We’re not in a position to know what that looks like. The best we can do is to go ahead and try to rank social systems in terms of the values we care about, and then see what we can learn. The Cato Institute’s Human Freedom Index is one such useful measurement attempt. What do we see? Look: Every highlighted country is some version of the liberal-democratic capitalist welfare state. Evidently, this general regime type is good for freedom. Indeed, it is likely the best we have ever done in terms of freedom. Moreover, Denmark (#5), Finland (#9), and the Netherlands (#10) are among the world’s “biggest” governments, in terms of government spending as a percentage of GDP. The “economic freedom” side of the index, which embodies a distinctly libertarian conception of economic liberty, hurts their ratings pretty significantly. Still, according to a libertarian Human Freedom Index, some of the freest places in on Earth have some of the“biggest” governments. That’s unexpected. This is why we need to try to rank social systems in terms of our prized political values. Our guesses about which systems lead to which consequences are likely to be pretty bad. Suppose we were to poll a bunch of American libertarians, and ask them to tell us which country enjoys more freedom, according the Cato Institute’s metrics. The United States or Sweden? The United States or Germany? The United States or Canada? The United States or Lithuania? I’m pretty sure almost all of them would get it wrong in each of these pairwise comparisons. Why? Because typical libertarians carry an ideal-theoretic picture of the “the free society” around in their heads, and (for some reason!) a minimum of taxation and redistribution is among the most salient aspects of that picture. And that means that Denmark, say, doesn’t seem very free relative to that picture. But there’s a great deal more to freedom than fiscal policy. And we see that, as a matter of fact, the country with the biggest-spending government in the world is among the freest countries in the world, and ranks first in personal freedom. That is our basic data. It doesn’t necessarily imply that the United States ought to do more redistributive social spending. But when a freedom index, built from libertarian assumptions, shows that freedom thrives in many places with huge welfare states, it should lead us to downgrade our estimate of the probability that liberty and redistribution are antithetical, and upgrade our estimate of the probability that they are consistent, and possibly complementary. That’s the sort of consideration that mainly drives my current views, not ideal-theoretical qualms about neo-Lockean libertarian rights theories. Though libertarianism is of personal interest to me, I want to emphasize again that my larger point has nothing to do with libertarianism. The same lesson applies to alt-right ethno-nationalists dazzled by a fanciful picture of a homogenous, solidaristic ethno-state. The same lesson applies to progressives and socialists in the grip of utopian pictures of egalitarian social justice. Of course, nobody knows what an ideally equal society would look like. If we stick to the data we do have, and inspect the top ranks of the Social Progress Index, which is based on progressive assumptions about basic needs, the conditions for individual health, well-being, and opportunity, you’ll mostly find the same countries that populate the Freedom Index’s leaderboard. Here: The overlap is striking. And this highlights some of the pathologies of ideal theory: irrational polarization and the narcissism of small differences. Some pathologies of ideal theory, both personal and political Ideal theory can drive political conflict by concealing overlapping consensus. Pretty much any way you slice it, Denmark is an actually-existing utopia. But so is Switzerland. So is New Zealand. The effective difference between the Nordic and Anglo-colonial models, in terms of “human freedom” and “social progress” is surpassingly slight. Yet passionate moral commitment to purist ideals of justice can lead us to see past the fact that the liberal-democratic capitalist welfare state, in whatever iteration, is awesome, and worth defending, from the perspective of multiple, rival political values. We miss the fact that these values fit together more harmoniously than our theories lead us to imagine. I suspect this has something to do with the fact that utopia-dwellers around the world seem to be losing faith in liberal democracy, and the fact that “neoliberalism” can’t get no love, despite the fact that they measurably deliver the goods like crazy. Yet ideologues interpret this loss of faith as evidence of objective failure, which they diagnose as a lack of satisfactory progress toward their version of utopia, and push ever more passionately for an agenda they have no rational reason to believe would actually leave anyone better off. It is intellectually corrupt and corrupting to define liberty or equality or you-name-it in terms of an idealized, counter-factual social system that may or may not do especially well in delivering the goods. Commitment to a vision of the perfect society is more likely than not to lead you astray. Consider how unlikely it is for a typical libertarian to correctly predict more than a couple of the top-ten freest countries on the libertarian freedom index. The fact that ideological radicals are pretty unreliable at ranking existing social systems in terms of their favored values ought to make us skeptical of claims that highly counterfactual systems would rank first. And it ought to lead us to suspect that ideal-theoretical political theorizing leads us to see the actual world less clearly than we might, due to cherry-picking and confirmation bias. If you’ve already irrationally ranked a fanciful social system tops in terms your favored value, you’ve effectively committed to the idea that the world works in a certain way without sufficient evidence that it actually does. This is almost always a commitment of identity and group membership rather than a judgment of reason. And it leads you to cast about for evidence that the world does work the way it would need to work in order to vindicate your ranking. You end up lending a great deal of credibility to comforting evidence, while ignoring and dismissing evidence that the world doesn’t work that way you’d like it to work. The result is that your ideal-theoretic commitment ends up driving your model of the world. But if your ideal theory is likely to be wrong in the first place, using it as a filter for evaluating evidence is going to leave you with a disastrously distorted picture of the way the world actually works. And that means you’re going to make systematically terrible predictions about the likely consequences of this or that policy change. You may want to identify reforms most likely to promote liberty or equality, or whatever, but you’ll end up really bad at this because your distorted ideological model of the world will leave you unable to evaluate evidence objectively. Progress in policy requires idealistic moral passion without preconceived ideals For me, the death of ideal theory has meant adopting a non-speculative, non-utopian perspective on freedom-enhancing institutions. If you know that you can’t know in advance what the freest social system looks will look like, you’re unlikely to see evidence that suggests that policy A (social insurance, e.g.) is freedom-enhancing, or that policy B (heroin legalization, e.g.) isn’t, as threats to your identity as a freedom lover. Uncertainty about the details of the freest feasible social scheme opens you up to looking at evidence in a genuinely curious, non-biased way. And it frees you from the anxiety that genuine experts, people with merited epistemic authority, will say things you don’t want to hear. This in turn frees you from the urge to wage quixotic campaigns against the authority of legitimate experts. You can start acting like a rational person! You can simply defer to the consensus of experts on empirical questions, or accept that you bear an extraordinary burden of proof when you disagree. I think the reign of ideal theory in political philosophy turned lots of incredibly smart, principled, morally motivated people into unreliable, untrustworthy ideologues. This has left the field of rational policy analysis to utilitarian technocrats, who have their own serious problems. Long story short, we ended up with a sort of divide in public policy between morally passionate advocates trapped in epistemic bubbles and technicians capable of objective analysis but devoid of guiding vision. What we need are folks who are passionate about freedom, or social justice (or what have you) who actively seek solutions to domination and injustice, but who also don’t think they already know exactly what ideal liberation or social justice look like, and are therefore motivated to identify our real alternatives and to evaluate them objectively. The space of possibility is infinite, and it takes energy and enthusiasm to want to explore it. Imaginative hypothesis generation is the great intangible without which progress is impossible or maddeningly slow. The technicians, the quants, the lab rats tend to be awful at dreaming up hypotheses. Ideological moral passion is the perfect wild horse to harness; it could power the exploration of the near frontier of the feasible. But thanks to the tyranny of the ideal, it’s a source of intellectual energy more often wasted hooked up to a wagon train headed off the map to Shangri-La.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Misc › Too monolithic

There is no monolithic “Blackness” to “center.”

Kennedy, 2-4-21—Michael R. Klein Professor at Harvard Law School (Randall, “On the Authority of Experience in Black Thought,” , dml)

A distinguished roster of black activist thinkers have adopted an optimistic perspective regarding the possibility of attaining racial justice in America. Optimists include Mary McLeod Bethune, Walter White, A. Philip Randolph, Martin Luther King Jr, Ralph Ellison, John Lewis, and Barack Obama. An impressive cadre of black activist thinkers believe, by contrast, that attaining racial justice in America is a virtual impossibility. Agreeing with Thomas Jefferson and Alexis de Tocqueville, they contend that racial slavery fatally poisoned the possibility of racial harmony in America. They contend that we shall not overcome. Pessimists include Henry McNeal Turner, Elijah Muhammad, Malcolm X, Derrick Bell, and Randall Robinson.

Fervent debates about scores of subjects – indeed every imaginable subject — have roiled African Americans ideologically: accommodation versus protest; interracial socialism versus black nationalism; Gandhian non-violence versus “by any means necessary,” support for affirmative action versus detestation of “lowered standards,“ “integration” versus “black power,” “respectability politics” versus “I don’t give a fuck” authenticity politics. Black thinkers have even disagreed over the years about the preferred term by which they designate “Blacks,” “blacks,” “African Americans,” “Negroes,” “colored people,” and “people of color.”