Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › AT: Europe Won’t Shift

EU loosens gmo regs

Blenkinsop 21 [Philip Blenkinsop, Chief Correspondent specializing in EU affairs, 4-29-2021, “EU calls for rethink of GMO rules for gene-edited crops”, Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/eu-calls-rethink-gmo-rules-gene-edited-crops-2021-04-29/, 6-28-2022]

BRUSSELS, April 29 (Reuters) - The European Commission launched a review of EU rules on genetically modified organisms (GMOs) on Thursday, opening the door to a possible loosening of restrictions for plants resulting from gene-editing technology.

Prompted by a 2018 ruling from the European Union's top court that techniques to alter the genome of an organism should be governed by existing EU rules on GMOs, the Commission concluded that its 2001 legislation was "not fit for purpose".

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › AT: Europe Won’t Shift

Europe wants more GMOs

Linnekin 22 [Baylen Linnekin, Senior Fellow, food lawyer, scholar, and adjunct law professor, 5-21-2022, “Britain Finally Relaxes GMO Rules, but Advocates Want More Deregulation”, Reason, https://reason.com/2022/05/21/britain-finally-relaxes-gmo-rules-but-advocates-want-more-deregulation/, 6-28-2022]

The decision by the U.K. Parliament to relax rules around the planting of some genetically modified crops in Britain is being celebrated this week in an excellent Observer editorial published by sister publication The Guardian. (The papers share an owner.)

"In an overpopulated, overheated world that desperately needs secure food supplies and to limit emissions of carbon dioxide, [anti-GMO] barriers should no longer be allowed to restrict progress," the editors write. "We urgently need solutions and Britain, one of the world's leaders in animal and plant research, must be free to play a key role in this agricultural revolution. Blanket bans of genetically altered crops and animals can be countenanced no longer."

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 2NC - Link – Unsustainable/Bad

Impact on BIPOC farmers

Ray Cooper, 21, 7-9-2021, Farmers Trapped in Unsustainable Cycle by Biotechnology, Seed Consolidation, National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/farmers-trapped-in-unsustainable-cycle-by-biotechnology-seed-consolidation/, 6-28-2022

To many, the advent of the modern seed and biotechnology industry represents the pinnacle of benevolent ingenuity for our food system.

There are certainly conversations to have about the role genetically engineered crops play in increasing yields and boosting productivity of agricultural land per-acre through the reduction of crop loss. However, just as important but less present in mainstream conversations is a frank consideration about whether those gains can be justified given the adverse, long-term impacts that conventional farming has on people, animals, and the land.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 2NC - Link – Unsustainable/Bad

Unsustainable

Ray Cooper, 21, 7-9-2021, Farmers Trapped in Unsustainable Cycle by Biotechnology, Seed Consolidation, National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/farmers-trapped-in-unsustainable-cycle-by-biotechnology-seed-consolidation/, 6-28-2022

To remain profitable, multinational agribusiness companies must generate and maintain a constant state, or at least a general trend, of overproduction and depressed commodity prices. Input suppliers, including biotechnology and seed corporations, can sell their patented products to a client (farmers) always seeking to expand their operations. Meanwhile, on the other end of harvest season, a concentrated number of food processors are able to purchase commodities for a price driven down by excess supply.

To illustrate the relationship, the following chart demonstrates that corn yields increased rapidly during the decades that these corporations amassed profit and influence – multiplying almost 600 percent since the mid-century dawn of the age of industrial agriculture and consolidation.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 2NC – UQ/Link

GMOs are blocked now, but the plan is a boon for biotech – that is all of their modeling claims.

CEO 2021 - Corporate Europe Observatory has been tracking the industry’s lobby attempts to get new GM techniques deregulated since 2015 ["Derailing EU rules on new GMOs," Mar 29, https://corporateeurope.org/en/2021/03/derailing-eu-rules-new-gmos]

For many years the biotech industry has lobbied the European Commission not to regulate products made using new GMO techniques, including ‘genome editing’ techniques such as CRISPR-Cas. Sidenote However on 25 July 2018 the European Court of Justice ruled that such genome editing procedures are GM techniques and its products must be regulated as such. Since then, industry and researchers have been pushing hard to change the EU GMO law (2001/18) in order to get genome editing deregulated (ie with no risk assessment, monitoring, or labelling).

But there are two huge hurdles to overcome. First, each decision on GMOs in the EU is highly contested, therefore it will be hard to find enough support to overhaul the EU GMO regulations. Second, and connected to the first, public support also has to be won. Therefore, wild promises are being made about the alleged benefits of crops and animals which are made using genome editing techniques, to convince the public of their value. Similar promises were also made for GMOs in the past, but never proved true.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 1NC

Antibiotic resistant bacteria have the potential to destroy all life on earth

Garrett 2016 - senior fellow for global health at the Council on Foreign Relations Laurie, "Anti-biotic resistant bacteria and the world's peril," Sep 19, https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/antibiotic-resistant-bacteria-and-the-world-s-peril/

Welcome to the Anthropocene, the era in which one species—human beings—so utterly dominates the planet that all of the driving forces of climate, oceans, geology, air and every other life form on Earth are controlled by the activities of humanity. Most of the damage is thoughtless. Humans don’t decide to pollute, they just do so. People don’t make a choice to lower the numbers of oxygen-producing trees on the planet, they just chop them down without thinking about it. Among the most dangerous of these thoughtless actions executed by our species is wild misuse of antibiotics. On September 21, the United Nations General Assembly is convening a special session to look at ways to curb use of precious medicinal drugs that are swiftly being outwitted by drug-resistant bacteria, making everything from a scraped knee to a bout of pneumonia far more dangerous and difficult to treat. But that focus, important as it is, remains limited to human use of chemicals and concern about their misuse to our species’ health. Genuine governance and stewardship in the Anthropocene requires a far broader look at what our activities mean for the planet, writ large. At the most basic levels of life every single system on Earth is controlled, or influenced, by microbes—microscopic creatures ranging from nano-sized viruses to enormous colonies of bacteria; from populations of microbes in the depths of the oceans to the inside of the human gut. A human being is made up of about 30 trillion cells and 39 trillion microbes, most of which are indispensable to our mental and physical health. If all the viruses and parasites swarming inside and on the skin of a human being are tallied the microbe-to-cell ratio is about ten-to-one. The microbes—collectively known as the Human Microbiome—digest our food, help us do battle with invading pathogens, clean our skin and provide us fuel. Life without microbes is no life at all. Antibiotics kill bacteria, and as anybody who has been on a long course of the drugs to treat an ailment knows, the medicine is indiscriminate, knocking off not only invaders like the bugs that cause pneumonia and ear infections, but also those that prevent stomach aches and constipation in response to ingestion of food. Human overuse or misuse of antibiotics has bred the emergence of Superbugs that are not only resistant to the drugs, but may be able to surge in numbers within a person’s gut, for example, leading to dangerous imbalances in bacterial populations that then cause diabetes, some types of heart disease, depression and an enormous range of common diseases. The Earth has its own microbiome, representing about a third of the weight of all biological material and life forms on the planet. And it is every bit as indispensable to the planet as your microbiome is to your personal health. Microbes living on the surface of the oceans, for example, aerosolize and end up in the atmosphere, where water droplets collect on their surfaces, forming clouds . Eliminating those microbes would directly affect rainfall. More oxygen that humans breathe is made by microbes than plants. And even the plants rely upon the microbiome of soil to transfer nutrients into their roots, allowing trees and forests to make more oxygen for humans to breathe. So it should be with some considerable alarm that we consider the killing potential manmade antibiotics have for Earth’s microbiome. When people, or our pets and livestock, take antibiotics, these substances and possible resistant bacteria are passed via sewage and septic tanks into water systems and the seas. Ton for ton, 80 percent of antibiotics are used to treat livestock, not to cure infections, but to make them fatter. Most of those chemicals, which are routinely loaded into animal feed and dumped into aquaculture systems, are chemical identical or closely similar to human treatments. As the human population increases and wealth grows, demand for animal protein is soaring. Researchers estimate that for every 2.2 pounds of cattle weight 45 milligrams of antibiotics were used as growth promoters; for chickens that’s 148 milligrams per 2.2 pounds and for pigs it’s a whopping 172. On a global scale that translates into about 63,000 tons of antibiotics used in agriculture in 2010, which researchers predict will soar to 106,000 tons over the next 14 years. Today the United States, alone, uses 25 million pounds of antibiotic products on livestock every year. Animal poop has always been a part of the environment, and played a big positive role in supplying bacteria, viruses and parasites for the Earth Microbiome. But the once-diverse range of large animals that roamed the planet has shrunk, with 92 percent of the poopers lost and the entire Earth Microbiome fertilized by just eight percent of the species that existed after the Ice Age, most of them used as livestock or pets by Homo sapiens. This means there are fewer checks-and-balances in nature to offset the monumental impact human and livestock poop are having on the Earth Microbiome. We are filling the world with livestock and human pathogens and bacteria, many of the microbes rendered ultra-virulent or drug resistant by the barrage of antibiotics we and our animals are subjected to. For example, a super-toxic form of E.coli bacteria has thrived in the antibiotic-saturated cattle industry, and turned up killing wild deer. Wildlife all over the world, from the depths of the seas to the Himalayas, are developing antibiotic-resistant bacterial diseases. Superbugs that are resistant to nearly every antibiotic on Earth are bred, for example, in pig farms in China, flow from sewage systems or river dumps into the oceans, infecting fish. Seagulls feeding on those fish carry highly drug resistant bacteria all over the world. Normal ocean microbes that convert sunlight into oxygen that humans breathe form microscopic vessels packed with their genes—including ones for drug resistance—that bob across the seas, to be absorbed by ocean life, even seals and whales. The dangerous organisms collect along any solid surfaces they come in contact with, forming drug resistant biofilms in which genes for resistance are swapped between microbes, even across species, making those biofilms giant lending libraries of genetic tools for devastation of the Earth Microbiome and, ultimately, human health. Proper wastewater treatment can greatly reduce the threat to the environment, eliminating most drug-resistant organisms. But most of the world’s waste goes untreated. Worse, cheap waste treatment – the type used in most of the world—basically mixes chlorine with poop, killing off bacteria. But new research shows chlorine treatment can actually promote a surge in antibiotic-resistant microbes, in a sense purifying the waste into a form that is even more dangerous to the environment. So at a recent meeting of the American Chemical Society scientists were told that, “Treated wastewater is one of the major sources of pharmaceuticals and antibiotics in the environment. Wastewater treatment facilities were not designed to remove these drugs. The molecules are typically very stable and do not easily get biodegraded. Instead, most just pass through the treatment facility and into the aquatic environment.” In China the overuse of antibiotics, especially in animals, and failure to remove them through standard wastewater treatment has gotten so bad that pure amoxicillin and other antibiotics come right out of the tap, into home drinking water. More than 60 different antibiotics has been found in random samples of the Yangtze and Pearl Rivers. Downstream from pharmaceutical plants in China antibiotics have been found in concentrations that are 10,000 times above normal human treatment doses. Extreme drug resistance genes have been found escaping wastewater treatment from northern China to the Rocky Mountain streams and the Hudson River alongside New York City. Antibiotic resistant bacteria hitchhike in dust plumes, and using human cargo and transport, spreading across the terrestrial world. Birds poop them, honeybees spread them and the impact on the Earth Microbiome is enormous. And so, as the United Nations General Assembly convenes on September 21 to debate measures aimed at preserving the utility of antibiotics to protect human health, I wish they would consider the well-being of the entire planet. We are tempting fate every time a person takes antibiotics mistakenly to treat a viral infection, a cow is fattened with pounds of “growth promoters,” a pool of salmon are dosed with antibiotics in aquaculture settings and the daily kilotons of human waste pour into the world’s rivers and seas. I wish the UN and the political leaders of the world would contemplate what killing off species of oxygen-producing microbes, of methane-eating bacteria or of human gut beneficial microbes will mean for the future of Earth.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 1NC

GMOs spread antibiotic resistance – lack of treatment capability, biosolid recycling, and selection advantage magnify the environmental impact

Hilding 19 – Director of Communicatons at Washington State University College of Engineering and Architecture [Tina. “Researchers find persistence of antibiotic-resistant GMO genes in sewage sludge.” WSU Insider. 10/18/19.]

Antibiotic-resistant genes that have been inserted into genetically modified food are able to withstand conventional wastewater treatments.

The findings, contained in a research paper published recently in the journal, Biotechnology and Bioengineering, might point to a previously unknown way that bacteria may become resistant to life-saving antibiotics. The work is based on graduate work done at Duke University by Courtney Gardner, now an assistant professor in WSU’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering. She, along with Professor Tim Ginn in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, have recently received a 3-year, USDA grant to continue the research.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › DA – GMOs › 1NC

No European GMOs now, but the plan is a trojan horse to break legal barriers.

CEO 2021 - Corporate Europe Observatory has been tracking the industry’s lobby attempts to get new GM techniques deregulated since 2015 ["Derailing EU rules on new GMOs," Mar 29, https://corporateeurope.org/en/2021/03/derailing-eu-rules-new-gmos]

The biotech industry is waging an ongoing battle to get its new generation of genetic modification techniques excluded from European GMO regulations. This would mean that plants, animals and micro-organisms, made using ‘genome editing’ techniques like CRISPR-Cas, would not be subject to safety checks, monitoring or consumer labelling. Corporate Europe Observatory has uncovered various new tactics used by the biotech industry to prepare the ground for such deregulation. Officials from national ministries were hand-picked for joint strategy meetings with lobbyists; a think-tank set up a new Taskforce with a large grant from the Gates Foundation to pave the way to GM deregulation via "climate narratives"; and a lobby platform built around a sign-on letter overstating its backing by research institutes. The European Commission is due to publish a study by the end of April about the new techniques which will provide a basis for further discussion among Member States. Civil society and farming groups call on the EU to prioritise environmental and health concerns, and keep GM safety checks in place.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – United Nations › 1NC - Internal

Effective ILaw prevents extinction– puts a cap on conflict

Pickering 14 (Heath Pickering, “Why Do States Mostly Obey International Law?, ” E-International Relations, February 4th 2014, )

All states in the contemporary world, including great powers, are compelled to justify their behaviour according to legal rules and accepted norms. This essay will analyse the extent to which states comply and the reasons for their compliance. Essentially, the extent to which states follow their international obligations has developed over the past 400 years. From a historical perspective, international obligations and accepted norms were founded following two key developments in European history. In 1648, the Treaty of Westphalia ended the Thirty Years’ War by acknowledging the sovereign authority of various European princes.[1] This event marked the advent of traditional international law, based on principles of territoriality and state autonomy. Then in 1945, again following major wars initiated in Europe, states began to integrate on a global scale.[2] The UN Charter became the international framework for which norms of sovereignty and non-intervention were enshrined. Now, as a result of modern technology, communication, transport, and more, the evolving process of Globalisation, “The internationalization of the world”,[3] has provided an opportunity for international law and accepted norms to reach every corner of the globe. However, the development of international law and accepted norms has not compelled states to comply all the time. Instead, the trend over the past 400 years has shown that states have been mostly compelled to justify their behavior according to legal rules and accepted norms. The emphasis on mostly should be stressed. Even though the UN Charter does not permit violating sovereignty through the use of aggression, the extent to which states follow their international obligations varies. Louis Henkin’s book, How Nations Behave, articulates the extent of compliance.[4] He said, “Almost all nations observe almost all principles of international law and almost all of their obligations almost all the time”.[5] As such, the trend in contemporary international relations is that war remains possible, but it is much less acceptable now than it was a century or even half a century ago.[6] The benefit of the trend is that almost full compliance is said to lead states into a pattern of obedience and predictable behaviour.[7] Therefore, conflict only arises when countries fail to comply. States attempt to manage the friction with ongoing compliance through the principle of pacta sunt servanda – the adherence to agreements.[8] Over time, such agreements to norms and treaties have diminished sovereignty, increased international institutions, given rise to non-state actors, and rapidly developed the contemporary customary and treaty based rules system.[9] The evolution of the dispute-settlement procedures of the World Trade Organisation (WTO), the establishment of the International Criminal Court (ICC), and the establishment of numerous global treaties illustrate states agreeing voluntarily to give up a portion of their sovereignty.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – United Nations › 1NC - Internal

Effective ILaw key to combatting climate change

Hunter 21 (David Hunter, “International Environmental Law”, American Bar Association, January 5th 2021, , WC-NAS)

Profound environmental changes caused by the increasing scale of human activity have led many observers to conclude that the planet has entered the “Anthropocene”—a geologic era signified by human impact on the biosphere. International environmental law is the set of agreements and principles that reflect the world's collective effort to manage our transition to the Anthropocene by  resolving our most serious environmental problems, including climate change, ozone depletion and mass extinction of wildlife. More generally, international environmental law aims to achieve sustainable development—i.e., development that allows people to have a high quality of life today without sacrificing the quality of life of future generations. International environmental law is thus critical both for addressing specific environmental threats and for integrating long-term environmental protection into the global economy.

But not all environmental threats trigger international (as opposed to solely national or local) response. For countries to sacrifice their autonomy, some advantage must be gained in addressing the problem collectively. Typically, countries turn to international cooperation where (l) the environmental impacts are transboundary (such as pollution into the Great Lakes) or global (such as climate change); (2) some international activity contributes to environmental harm, for example, the international trade in elephant ivory or the killing of whales; or (3) international coordination of financial or technical support can catalyze action (for example, for the global conservation of biological diversity). In these circumstances, international cooperation—whether in the form of a binding treaty or a non-binding “soft law” agreement—is necessary for an effective response to the environmental challenge.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – United Nations › 1NC

UN action sets impartial norms that regulate the dual-use of biotech

Camacho 18 (Juan Jose Gomez Camacho, Permanent Representative of Mexico to the United Nations, “Keeping Pace with an Accelerated World: Bringing Rapid Technological Change to the United Nations Agenda”, United Nations Chronicle, December 2018, , WC-NAS)

Humanity is at a crossroads: we face both the opportunities and challenges of a range of powerful and emerging technologies that will drive radical shifts in the way we live. The accelerated pace at which technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI), biotechnology, robotics, automation, advanced materials and quantum computing are developing, is already transforming the systems that we take for granted today. From how we produce and transport goods and services to the way we communicate, collaborate or even elect our governments, rapid technological change—which often happens at an exponential pace—is reshaping how we experience the world around us.

The good news is that this period of rapid technological change is in its early stages and is still under our control. Standing at this crossroads means that we bear a huge responsibility, since new technologies can increase inequality among and within countries, replace obsolete labour forces, affect vulnerable groups, foster a concentration of critical knowledge and wealth, and pose significant ethical questions. However, such technologies can also be used positively to accelerate achievement of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and their 169 targets.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – Bioethics Commission › 1NC

Bioethics commissions create new regulatory frameworks for emerging threats – promotes consensus and norms

Wolf et al 2/28 -- Professor of Law, Medicine & Public Policy at the University of Minnesota, JD [Susan M., R. Alta Charo, JD, Alexander Morgan Capron, LLB, Rebecca Dresser, JD, MS, Helene D. Gayle, MD, MPH; Christine Grady, MSN, PhD; Marion Hourdequin, PhD; Isaac Kohane, MD, PhD. “Recommending a New Presidential Bioethics Commission.” National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine. 2/28/2022.]

Need for a New Commission The United States has not had a federal bioethics commission since 2017. In the interceding five years, a global pandemic has raised profound ethical issues in public health research, clinical practice, and public policy–issues that require attention to the public good as well as individual autonomy. Those include how to formulate public policy in the face of uncertainty, how best to conduct rapid research on vaccines and treatments, how to reconcile population research with individual patient needs, how to allocate access to therapeutic interventions in times of scarcity, and how to address the devastating health disparities the pandemic has revealed. 3 As noted in Appendix A, the President’s Commission was followed by a failed effort to create a Biomedical Ethics Board in the legislative branch with six Senators and six Representatives equally divided between the two major parties. More specialized executive branch panels have included the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments (1994-95) established to investigate human radiation experiments and the intentional release of radiation between 1944 and 1974 and to recommend appropriate standards for evaluating the responsibility of individuals and institutions for those past acts. 4 The Brain Research Through Advancing Innovative Neurotechnologies® (BRAIN) Initiative. https://braininitiative.nih.gov/. 3 At the same time, our world faces a climate crisis that imperils the natural environment and human health. No prior bioethics commission has canvassed the ethical issues raised by research and interventions that can alter ecology, including genetic modification of insect populations to control transmission of certain deadly diseases, or using genome editing to rescue endangered species and perhaps even to revive some that are extinct. Nor has any commission addressed the health and equity implications of heat waves and heat stress, changes in the distribution of vector-borne diseases, flooding and displacement, and increased ozone pollution, to mention just a few effects of climate change. Yet ethical concerns—including our obligations to future generations—are central to understanding and solving these environmental problems. Another domain not previously addressed by a bioethics commission is the growing integration of artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and software algorithms into medical and public health practice. The ethical challenges are profound. If complex algorithms are based on inadequate or unrepresentative data, their use risks magnifying and cementing racial and other bias into research and clinical care, while undermining professional expertise and shared decision-making with patients. Regulators face daunting challenges, such as ensuring the quality of adaptive algorithms that evolve as they are used. Ethical issues raised by AI in health care and public health call for exactly the kind of path-breaking analysis and consensus building that a bioethics commission can offer. A bioethics commission could also advance analyses of existing technologies whose rapid development continues to raise unresolved issues. Genetic and genomic technologies, for example, offer an expanding range of predictive and screening tools – including direct-to-consumer tests -- with continuing debate over appropriate uses and safeguards. The growing use of such tools risks placing undue emphasis on genetics to the exclusion of social determinants of health. Genetic testing is also being used in areas such as immigration and law enforcement, raising privacy issues distinct from those raised by uses in health care. Meanwhile, emerging technologies that can alter the genetic makeup of animals and human beings challenge current oversight systems to protect responsible innovation while preventing abuse.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – Bioethics Commission › 1NC

Bioethics commissions solves global governance – influences social norms and professional standards

Childress 17 – professor of ethics at the University of Virginia, founder of the Institute for Practical Ethics and Public life, author of books and articles in bioethics, served on the National Bioethics Advisory Commission until 2001 [James F. “The Bioethical Approach: The President should establish a commission on bioethics.” UVA Miller Center for Public Policy. May 9, 2017]

Finally, the new president and his administration will have to consider the governance of gene editing, both domestically and globally. Of course, governance is not limited to governments and their policies. It encompasses various other social institutions as well, and its exercise is not limited to laws and regulations but involves professional standards and the like. Nevertheless, there is a central role for government, and the U.S. government needs to continue to play a pivotal, though nonexclusive, role in the still nascent complex global governance of gene editing, as discussed, for instance, in the 2015 International Summit on Human Gene Editing. The U.S. government’s laws and regulations, as well as its investment decisions, will be crucial both tangibly and symbolically.

Given the perennial problems in health care and in research involving human participants, the outbreaks of serious and even deadly infectious diseases, and the rapid pace of global scientific and technological change, the new president will surely confront and need to address several bioethical problems. How the president meets these challenges and helps our government, the scientific and biomedical communities, and the public deliberate about appropriate policies and practices in response will be one of the tests—and measures—of our nation’s new chief executive.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – Bioethics Commission › 1NC

A bioethics commission shapes governmental policy on biotech – solves a laundry list ethical problems – human testing, gene editing, public health

Childress 17 – professor of ethics at the University of Virginia, founder of the Institute for Practical Ethics and Public life, author of books and articles in bioethics, served on the National Bioethics Advisory Commission until 2001 [James F. “The Bioethical Approach: The President should establish a commission on bioethics.” UVA Miller Center for Public Policy. May 9, 2017]

After Dolly the cloned sheep was born, President Bill Clinton asked the National Bioethics Advisory Commission to prepare a report recommending federal policies on human reproductive cloning.

Each of these three institutional mechanisms can contribute significantly to presidential and other governmental bioethical policy making. Which one is best for a particular topic depends in part on process values such as transparency and efficiency. While not every bioethical topic needs to be addressed by a standing presidential bioethics commission, such a commission has the substantial advantage of being able to address a range of bioethical topics, sometimes interrelated, in public over time and the advantage also of being ready to address fairly quickly new issues when they emerge. For instance, following the announcement of the cloned sheep Dolly’s birth, President Bill Clinton gave his relatively young National Bioethics Advisory Commission 90 days to prepare a report recommending possible federal policies toward human reproductive cloning.

2022 Michigan Negative
Disad things › CP – Bioethics Commission › 1NC

A commission on bioethics solves dual use – guidelines, research, and framework for development

Childress 17 – professor of ethics at the University of Virginia, founder of the Insitute for Practical Ethics and Public life, author of books and articles in bioethics, served on the National Bioethics Advisory Commission until 2001 [James F. “The Bioethical Approach: The President should establish a commission on bioethics.” UVA Miller Center for Public Policy. May 9, 2017]

In his first year, President Donald Trump should develop a charter for, assign priorities to, and establish by executive order a new presidential commission on bioethics. Even though its membership should be diverse in background, experience, and expertise, it is reasonable for the president to set up a commission that is generally congenial to his administration’s values. The commission’s main function will be to provide advice and counsel to the president. It can also report directly to federal departments and agencies and to congressional committees. Further, its meetings and reports can contribute to public discourse and education about bioethics.

Doing so will build on the best practices of previous presidents, who have used such outside guidance to address complex ethical challenges in the biological sciences, medicine, and health care. The new president can choose from several options in how to design such a commission, and which topics to address. But having such a commission will ensure that thoughtful examination will guide emerging technologies.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
2AC---AT: Queer IR › perm

The perm allows for queer sensibility through more incorporation of queerness in IR

Amoureux 15 – Scholar postdoctoral fellow at Wake Forest University; received his PhD from Brown University in Political Science [Jack, 2015, “Queer Ethics of World Politics”, Academia.edu]

In summarizing some of these themes, controversies and tensions, I am unavoidably reading queer theory as an IR scholar steeped in a literature that, for the most part, has not accepted and has even been actively hostile to a ‘queer IR’ (Weber 2014b). Nevertheless, an intersection of queer and ‘dominant’ IR is potentially fruitful, but it is not a matter of ‘mixing and stirring’ since the queer has been relevant to IR and world politics all along, in its dominant narratives of discipline as they extend through the halls of power, products of media and culture, and the offices, conference rooms and journals of the field of International Relations (Weber 2013; 2014a, 2014b; Wilcox 2015). In other words, I am interrogating IR from a body of literature that has become known as ‘queer theory’ but this effort should not be read as a neglect of the ways in which a growing contingent of IR scholars have read world politics through a queer lens to make up a rich variety of critical and innovative approaches

2022 Michigan Counterplan
2AC---AT: Queer IR

Alt Fails — rethinking doesn’t change material conditions.

Cocks 16 — Joan Cocks, Emeritus Professor of Politics and Co-Founder of the Program in Critical Social Thought at Mount Holyoke College, holds a Ph.D. from the University of Massachusetts-Amherst, 2016 (“Queer International Relations (II),” The Disorder of Things—a scholarly blog, November 22nd, Available Online at , Accessed 02-06-2020)

Although he/she stands as an emblem of Cynthia’s hope for pluralizing the monolithic concept of sovereign man and for queering an integrated Europe, I’m going to gesture only briefly to the border-straddling Eurovision song contest winner Neuwirth/Wurst. I have to confess that I’ve never watched Eurovision and so must trust Cynthia’s reading of N/W entirely, but as she depicts him/her, unlike the normal homosexual, this bearded lady from Austria and Colombia managed to provoke wildly clashing reactions from leaders and peoples in different countries and of different political stripes by impaling him/herself on the border of masculine and feminine, the Global North and Global South, secularism and religion, white and brown racial identities, and national particularity and regional integration. Still, while Cynthia’s layered reading of N/W is as sophisticated an interpretation of identity deconstruction as any cultural theorist could hope for, a performance of ambiguities in identity on stage, and the parsing of those ambiguities in a queer IR theory text, can push the world forward (or, to the minds of N/W’s critics, backward) only so far.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
2AC---AT: Queer IR

Alt fails—Trump era cemented heteronormative views within politics, cooption inevitable

Weber 16 (Cynthia Weber, Professor of International Relations at the University of Sussex, “Sovereignty, Sexuality And The Will To Trump: A Queer IR Analysis And Response,” 11-27-2016, accessed 07-21-2022, https://thedisorderofthings.com/2016/11/27/sovereignty-sexuality-and-the-will-to-trump-a-queer-ir-analysis-and-response/)//sfs

Crucially, the Trump campaign didn’t just roll out its vision of this ‘US sovereign subject’ by employing either/or logics, even though much of the time this seemed to be the case. Yes, Trump pitted ‘trustworthy’ and ‘untrustworthy’ US citizens against one another. But he constantly flip flopped on who these trustworthy and untrustworthy citizens were, whether in the case of women, ‘the blacks’ or the first black President of the United States of America. The campaign also rolled out Mike Pence to deny many of the things Trump said. And Trump made a lot of inherently contradictory statements that suggested he was for and against some groups or policies at the same time. For example, Trump said, ‘There can be no discrimination against gays. I’m against gay marriage’ (although in his 60 Minutes interview, Trump said gay marriage was a legally settled issue). Trump also made inconsistent statements about the anti-trans* bathroom law in North Carolina. Comments like these were implicitly and explicitly made in the register of sex, gender and sexuality throughout the campaign, and they were more consistent with and/or logics and neither/nor logics than they were with either/or logics. These statements demonstrate how some of the paradoxical figures and logics found in queer discourses were coopted by the Trump campaign for its own purposes. All of this left many politicians, pundits, and ordinary US American citizens wondering if Trump was a clown who should be laughed off or an existential threat to the American democratic project. Trump positioned himself as either and both and even neither as it suited his ambitions. And he will likely continue to do so as the 45th President of the United States. What is to be done? As the US and the world face up to the realities of the impossible Presidency that the Trump campaign made possible, there is no shortage of recommendations circulating in critical camps about what is to be done. These include: Organizing new coalitions and devising experimental techniques to make them effective; Disarming the specific modalities of citizenship, governance and reason that make (un)reasonable identifications with a will to Trump possible; and Resisting all xenophobias, forms of racism, misogyny, homo/bi/trans*phobias, and other oppressive ideologies and social relations that violently order the world in whatever name – be it white supremacy, rightwing nationalism, conservatism, or neoliberalism. I am less hopeful than Joan Cocks might be that these new political alliances and institutions will be forged ‘without sovereign aspirations, delusions, or pretensions’, whatever their scale. And I may be more persuaded than Cocks is that the counter-Trump re-imaginings of the US that will support these political alliances and institutions are an essential part of what makes radical change possible, even if these re-imaginings fail to escape the ‘delusion of sovereignty’ and its corresponding delusions of things like sex, gender and sexuality. This, it seems to me, is something Trump’s radical re-imagining of the US as his platform for winning the White House underscores. As we all move forward and ready ourselves for some difficult conversations, this queer IR analysis suggests we keep the following two points in mind. First, connections between sovereignty, sex, gender and sexuality are neither academic nor trivial. Nor are they separable from racisms, xenophobias and other systems of power. How sovereignties are specifically sexualized, racialized, classed and otherwise configured to authorize the defense of particular nationalisms and internationalisms has real effects on real people. This is as true in relation to the hate speech and physical violence authorized in the name of Trump as it is for the policies that will emerge from a Trump administration. Second, exclusively anti-normative, always contrarian, somehow liberating understandings of ‘queer’, ‘queers’, and ‘queer logics’ can obscure the fact that ‘queer’ – just like any (dis)position, strategy, or tool – can be captured, mimicked, and mobilized to map the world in despicable ways. Alt-Right offers one important example of a white supremacist organization adopting techniques of the left for such purposes. How the Trump campaign mobilized what (otherwise) might appear to be queer logics of statecraft to de-normalize Clinton’s ‘neoliberal US sovereign subject’ on behalf of Trump’s (re)normalized ‘repressed, entitled, white US sovereign subject’ is another. There is no reason to believe that, as President, Trump will abandon the very logics and tactics that helped win him the Presidency. These are among the stakes a queer IR analysis of a will to Trump makes plain. For me, opposing a will to Trump starts by reminding myself that – like ‘queer’ – a ‘state’s sovereign subjectivity is…”[i]llusive, always on the move.” It is “at best like something, but it never is that something”’. Trump is of some ever-changing United States of America, but Trump is not the United States of America. The same can be said of the ‘US sovereign subject’ Trump’s campaign strategically figured to authorize Trump’s will to power. It is in these gaps and fissures where I will pitch my political tent and stage my practical political resistance to a will to Trump.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
2AC---AT: Queer IR

And, it doesn’t specify an alternative global system---that’s a precondition to any form of alt solvency---they say there are other ways to engage internationally but don’t specify what they are or how they are superior---“negation in every instance” is not an advocacy.

Dillon Tatum 18. Assistant professor in the Department of Political Science and Geography at Francis Marion University. “Toward a Radical IR.” Duck of Minerva. 11/28/2018.

David Brook’s latest column in the New York Times, banging on the same themes about “the kids are just not right,” raises some questions about what it means to engage in radical politics in the Trump era. Brooks compares the younger generation’s belief “that the system itself is rotten and needs to be torn down” to accomodationist and gradualisms. He continues on to speculate about how these new attitudes might affect older, more “pragmatic,” liberals who desire to work within the system. Brooks, as usual, uses a conservative argument to position himself in the “middle.” I have been thinking a lot about this issue of “radicalism” contra arguments about working within systems that are unjust in thinking about liberal world order and its futures. It has led me to a question I am currently exploring in a work-in-progress about what the possibilities are of radicalism as a way of approaching international politics. Against arguments like Brooks’, and even more sophisticated arguments about agonistic democracy developed by thinkers like Chantal Mouffe, I think there is a place in IR for radical conceptions of transformation, order, and politics. What is radicalism? Brooks never fully fleshes out this concept. Philosophy and political theory have engaged with the issue of radicalism as a concept, though the results are often divergent. To quote Agnes Heller, in her treatise on radical philosophy, it “can give the world a norm, and it can will people to want to give a world to the norm.” Radicalism as an idea, and as a form of critique, mobilizes many different modes of thinking about the social and the political. The most comprehensive definition of radicalism is that provided by Paul McLaughlin, who defines radicalism “in terms of (i) a fundamental orientation (toward fundamental objects) (ii) in the political domain (iii) of an argumentative nature.” More than that, though, we can add that radicalism intervenes in the political domain with the goal of fundamental transformation. Additionally, though radicalism indeed proceeds in an argumentative nature, this methodology for argument is one that is aimed at critiquing, and seeking the destruction/replacement of existing institutions. A revised working definition of radicalism, therefore, is: a way of thinking about politics that focuses on totalities, praxis and political action, and the deployment of historicist methods with an eye toward “getting to the root of things.” Thus, radicalism is both a broad range of critical thought and practice, but also is specific in the realms of focus, action, and method. If Brooks is right that there is a major clash between a radical younger generation and a more pragmatic and moderate older generation in American politics, these differences are not well expressed in contemporary thinking about IR. Some of the biggest divisions are between what Robert Cox called “problem-solving theories” and theories that critique such approaches, but provide little argumentation aimed at tearing structures of injustice down altogether. In short: IR, even at its critical ends, is not radical (for an excellent exception see here and here). Why is this important? This morning, I taught a seminar on the question “Is Liberal World Order Finished?” I asked my students to think about what makes a liberal order “liberal,” and then asked: “Can we fix the liberal world order, or can we imagine a world without it?—and what would that look like?” The students were quick to point out the violences, inequities, and problems inherent in a liberal world order, but it took a good bit of pushing and prodding to get them to articulate whether/how we should/could take this order apart and rethink it. This was not just a difficult task for the students—it is something IR has not spent enough time meditating on.

There is a lot to be critical of these days. And, I disagree with Brooks’s pessimism about a younger radical generation. Politics is deeply intertwined with engagements with radicalism. What I think is missing when we consider global politics, though, is that many of our pressing questions about institutions, order, and state action proceed from the same sort of moderation, accomodationism, or—at the most—an immanently critical vein. If we want to intellectually and politically approach issues like: What do we make of the future(s) of liberal world order? IR needs to engage with radicalism.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
2AC---AT: Queer IR

Queer IR doesn’t explain international relations.

Currah 14 — Paisley Currah, Professor of Political Science and Gender Studies at Brooklyn College, 2014 (“The State,” TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 1-2, Accessible Online via e-Duke Journals Scholarly Collection, Accessed On 07-13-2016)

According to Gilles Deleuze, a concept ‘‘should express an event rather than an essence’’ (1995: 14). Molar, large-scale accounts of sex and the state have assumed a sameness to sex and a singular rationality to state actors, decisions, and projects. If the state is not unitary, coordinated, and hierarchically organized in an ultimately rational way—if, as Michel Foucault suggests, ‘‘the state is only a composite reality and a mythicized abstraction whose importance is much less than we think’’ (1991: 103)— then it should come as no surprise that state definitions of sex are also plural. A contradiction is something that does not make sense, a position that is logically inconsistent. To begin by letting go of the assumption that there is any ‘‘there there,’’ any whatness, to (legal) sex apart from what an agency says it is, the contradiction evaporates. The official sex designation—or, more precisely, the M or the F— stamped on documents or coded in records becomes the starting point. Then an analysis can focus not on what sex is, or what it should be, but on what it does, what it accomplishes, what it produces. Indeed, if the only thing we know for sure about sex is what any of these many state actors say it is in any particular instance, sex will turn out to be as messy and diffuse a concept as the state. Entering into the analysis without a firm sense of what sex is or what the state is—as a priori facts, as edifices—makes the processes through which they come into being more visible. It might be better to defer attempts to resolve— theoretically or politically— the messiness in order to understand what a particular system of sex designation does for a particular state project such as recognition or redistribution (Currah, forthcoming). Of course, states should not only or always be imagined as messy, scattered nodes of local and arbitrary power arrangements. The Leviathan state’s terrible concentrated authority to impose sanctions (death, imprisonment, fines) has been the subject of theories of sovereignty for centuries. For this purpose, the most apt definition of the state begins with the simple description from Max Weber: ‘‘A human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate physical violence within a particular given territory’’ (1991: 78). To create a truly compelling account of sovereign violence and the paradox of sovereignty, one must take Weber’s definition, put question marks around ‘‘legitimate,’’ and add the observation made by scholars such as Walter Benjamin, Carl Schmitt, Hannah Arendt, Jacques Derrida, and Giorgio Agamben that the force that creates the law and makes it legitimate cannot be justified by a law that does not yet exist. Still, much of what states do— regulating the health, safety, and public welfare through myriad regulations, rules, decisions, practices— does not reach the threshold of juridical violence, even if those actions are ultimately undergirded by its threat. Fetishizing a generalized idea of the state and its terrifying or redemptive power (depending on one’s perspective) can obscure what is actually happening in the local, micro, particular sites where most public authority is exercised. While it is crucial to theorize the singular finality of state violence, neglecting to examine the messiness of actually existing and potentially incommensurate policies, practices, rules, and norms risks substituting the conceptual for the concrete and gets in the way of understanding what might actually be going on (Latour 1995: 48).