Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Evidence
Negative › Squo Solves – Space Assets

Squo solves – the SC commits to increased investments in space resilience building

NATO, 6-30-2022, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, the people from the topic, “2022 strategic concept” No Publication, https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/2022/6/pdf/290622-strategic-concept.pdf//DG

We will expedite our digital transformation, adapt the NATO Command Structure for the information age and enhance our cyber defences, networks and infrastructure. We will promote innovation and increase our investments in emerging and disruptive technologies to retain our interoperability and military edge. We will work together to adopt and integrate new technologies, cooperate with the private sector, protect our innovation ecosystems, shape standards and commit to principles of responsible use that reflect our democratic values and human rights. 25. Maintaining secure use of and unfettered access to space and cyberspace are key to effective deterrence and defence. We will enhance our ability to operate effectively in space and cyberspace to prevent, detect, counter and respond to the full spectrum of threats, using all available tools. A single or cumulative set of malicious cyber activities; or hostile operations to, from, or within space; could reach the level of armed attack and could lead the North Atlantic Council to invoke Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. We recognise the applicability of international law and will promote responsible behaviour in cyberspace and space. We will also boost the resilience of the space and cyber capabilities upon which we depend for our collective defence and security

2022 Michigan Evidence
Negative › Squo Solves – Space Assets

Solves space---operations, resilience

Jon Harper, 6-29-2022, "NATO unveils new Strategic Concept, pledges support for new ‘defense innovation accelerator'," FedScoop, https://www.fedscoop.com/nato-unveils-strategic-concept-pledges-support-for-new-defense-innovation-accelerator//DG

The new Strategic Concept — the first update in more than a decade — also focuses on space as a key technology area and warfighting domain. “We will enhance our ability to operate effectively in space and cyberspace to prevent, detect, counter and respond to the full spectrum of threats, using all available tools,” it said, noting that “a single or cumulative set of malicious cyber activities; or hostile operations to, from, or within space; could reach the level of armed attack and could lead the North Atlantic Council to invoke Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty” and trigger collective defense responses that could include armed conflict. The alliance also intends to boost the resilience of its space and cyber capabilities which are at risk of being attacked.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Negative › Squo Solves – Innovation

Squo solves – the SC commits to increased investments in EDTs

NATO, 6-30-2022, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, the people from the topic, “2022 strategic concept” No Publication, https://www.nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/2022/6/pdf/290622-strategic-concept.pdf//DG

We will expedite our digital transformation, adapt the NATO Command Structure for the information age and enhance our cyber defences, networks and infrastructure. We will promote innovation and increase our investments in emerging and disruptive technologies to retain our interoperability and military edge. We will work together to adopt and integrate new technologies, cooperate with the private sector, protect our innovation ecosystems, shape standards and commit to principles of responsible use that reflect our democratic values and human rights. 25. Maintaining secure use of and unfettered access to space and cyberspace are key to effective deterrence and defence. We will enhance our ability to operate effectively in space and cyberspace to prevent, detect, counter and respond to the full spectrum of threats, using all available tools. A single or cumulative set of malicious cyber activities; or hostile operations to, from, or within space; could reach the level of armed attack and could lead the North Atlantic Council to invoke Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. We recognise the applicability of international law and will promote responsible behaviour in cyberspace and space. We will also boost the resilience of the space and cyber capabilities upon which we depend for our collective defence and security

2022 Michigan Evidence
Negative › Squo Solves – Cyber Security

Concept solves cyber---increases capability, mitigates impact of attacks thru resilience, coordinates response

John Curran 6-30-2022, Executive Editor at Meritalk "NATO Toughens Cyber Stance, Sets Defense Innovation Accelerator," No Publication, https://www.meritalk.com/articles/nato-toughens-cyber-stance-sets-defense-innovation-accelerator//DG

Cybersecurity Steps Below those top lines, cybersecurity concerns and steps are woven throughout the new declaration. “We are confronted by cyber, space, and hybrid and other asymmetric threats, and by the malicious use of emerging and disruptive technologies,” NATO said. “We face systemic competition from those, including the People’s Republic of China, who challenge our interests, security, and values and seek to undermine the rules-based international order.” Among the cybersecurity topics in the new strategy document are: Bolstering Ukraine’s cyber defenses and resilience, and supporting the modernization of its defense sector to strengthen interoperability with NATO; Taking a “360-degree approach across the land, air, maritime, cyber, and space domains, and against all threats and challenges”; Boosting “our resilience to cyber and hybrid threats and strengthening our interoperability”; Building out and exercising “a virtual rapid response cyber capability to respond to significant malicious cyber activities”; Strengthening cyber defenses through “enhanced civil-military cooperation” and expanding partnerships with industry.A fact sheet issued by the White House on June 29 said that the alliance’s new strategic concept “will ensure NATO continues to develop appropriate tools and collective responses to transnational threats such as cyber attacks” and climate change. “As an operational domain for NATO, cyber will also be a key component of NATO’s strengthened deterrence and defense posture,” the White House said. Speaking of the NATO plan to rapid response cyber capabilities, the U.S. “will offer robust national capabilities as part of this support network,” the White House said. Defense Innovation On the innovation front, NATO said it will establish the new Defense Innovation Accelerator and launch a multinational Innovation Fund “to bring together governments, the private sector, and academia to bolster our technological edge.” The only specific project mentioned for those initiatives is endorsement of a strategy “which will ensure the seamless delivery of the next generation Airborne Warning & Control System (AWACS) and related capabilities.” According to the White House statement, the Innovation Accelerator “will support NATO’s efforts to boost interoperability and ensure that every Ally has access to cutting-edge technological solutions for military needs.” “The U.S. will contribute by facilitating access to U.S. entities, such as test centers and accelerator sites, drawn from across the extensive and diverse U.S. innovation sector,” the White House said.

The SC commits to enhanced cyber security – reserves ability to utilize all available tools

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › AT Russia Encirclement Turn

Concept commits to a 260k boost in force posture – eastern flank has never been more united

David M Herszenhorn, 6-30-2022, Correspondent for Politico "From Madrid summit, NATO steps into more dangerous era," POLITICO, https://www.politico.eu/article/ussr-allied-leaders-russia-conflict-dangerous-cold-war-nato//DG

“I was present at the NATO summit adopting the former strategic concept — I was foreign minister — and then we had the aspiration of a partnership,” Støre said. But citing “the daily destruction, the extraordinary brutal use of military force” in Ukraine, the Norwegian leader added, “In 2022, I think, you know, nobody doubts the seriousness of the situation.” Among the most crucial decisions taken by leaders at the summit were plans to strengthen NATO’s so-called force posture, including with ambitious plans to be able to mobilize as many as 300,000 troops within 30 days. There was some confusion and disagreement about when such a capability might be achieved, but the resolve among allies to bolster their presence on the eastern flank was not in the slightest doubt The new model is about “more assured availability” of forces from allies, said one senior NATO official. “More readiness, more exercising, more preparation for the locations that these forces might have to deploy to — particularly in defense of the alliance — so that is the heart of what is new. “It’s a work in progress,” the senior official added. “We will continue to work with allies over the next year or so to identify the forces that can be attached to this model and to populate the model. But we know the forces exist … So this is an exercise of pre-identifying forces, which can be linked to defense plans.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › AT SC Solves – Disinformation

Doesn’t solve a coherent response---declarations are different from action

Tomasz Chłon, 5-16-2022, Former ambassador of Poland, director of NATO information GLOBSEC, https://www.globsec.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/NATO-and-Countering-Disinformation-ver1-spreads.pdf

At the same time, the West has yet to prepare a coherent, comprehensive and coordinated response to Russian disinformation. It is up to nations to fully utilise NATO’s potential. A response practice has been developed and seen partial success within some states and Euro-Atlantic institutions, but it has not yet been translated into a real common policy or strategy. At national levels, political declarations and agreed action plans are still not fully implemented in too many instances. Western states approach disinformation in varied ways due to differences in history, regional security, wealth, education, media quality, political and legal culture and – most importantly – the current state of their relations with Russia. As a rule, some states prefer bilateral approaches that safeguard national prerogatives. This may change now following the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › AT SC Solves Deterrence

Concept is ambitious, not material---actual implementation is a work in progress

David M Herszenhorn, 6-30-2022, Correspondent for Politico "From Madrid summit, NATO steps into more dangerous era," POLITICO, https://www.politico.eu/article/ussr-allied-leaders-russia-conflict-dangerous-cold-war-nato//DG

“I was present at the NATO summit adopting the former strategic concept — I was foreign minister — and then we had the aspiration of a partnership,” Støre said. But citing “the daily destruction, the extraordinary brutal use of military force” in Ukraine, the Norwegian leader added, “In 2022, I think, you know, nobody doubts the seriousness of the situation.” Among the most crucial decisions taken by leaders at the summit were plans to strengthen NATO’s so-called force posture, including with ambitious plans to be able to mobilize as many as 300,000 troops within 30 days. There was some confusion and disagreement about when such a capability might be achieved, but the resolve among allies to bolster their presence on the eastern flank was not in the slightest doubt The new model is about “more assured availability” of forces from allies, said one senior NATO official. “More readiness, more exercising, more preparation for the locations that these forces might have to deploy to — particularly in defense of the alliance — so that is the heart of what is new. “It’s a work in progress,” the senior official added. “We will continue to work with allies over the next year or so to identify the forces that can be attached to this model and to populate the model. But we know the forces exist … So this is an exercise of pre-identifying forces, which can be linked to defense plans.”

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › AT SC Solves Deterrence

The concept doesn’t overwhelm ongoing failure to solidify an effective deterrent posture

Hans Petter Midttun, 6-30-2022, "NATO’s Strategic Concept-2022: names Russia as threat, deletes key commitment to act on this threat," Euromaidan Press, https://euromaidanpress.com/2022/06/30/natos-strategic-concept-2022-names-russia-as-threat-deletes-key-commitment-to-act-on-this-threat//DG

When NATO is no longer willing to employ military power to “escalate to de-escalate,” it might be failing as a military alliance. It is reflected in the new strategic concept as it steps away from its commitment to “stop ongoing conflicts where they affect Alliance security”;in its failure to act on Russian violations of international law since 2008; in its failure to respond to the Hybrid War Russia has conducted against NATO and EU members since 2014; and not least, in its failure to respond resolutely to the ongoing attempt to subjugate Ukraine through the use of both military and non-military force. NATO fails to counter the Russian “fait accompli” strategy, using the threat of nuclear escalation as a means to secure freedom to use military force as an integrated part of its increasingly more aggressive foreign policy. As a result, Russia is openly threatening Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, and Norway. And the Alliance takes another step backward. Today, Lithuania and Kaliningrad. Tomorrow, Norway and Svalbard. NATO has, however, recognized that the Euro-Atlantic area is not at peace. That’s a hugely important first step towards acknowledging the Russian strategic messaging of being at war.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › SC Thumps – Rapid Reaction Force

The DA is n/u – SC with NATO is at a record high – rapid reaction force increased eightfold

Stratfor 6/30

Stratfor Worldview, “Placing NATO’s New Strategic Concept in Context,”Jun 30, 2022 https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/placing-nato-s-new-strategic-concept-context

The updated Strategic Concept was announced during the June 29-30 NATO summit in Madrid. The Madrid summit was the first held since the alliance’s March 24 extraordinary meeting to coordinate a response to Russia’s Feb. 24 invasion of Ukraine. In response to these changing priorities and threat perceptions, NATO also announced changes in its force posture, including the expansion of its rapid reaction force and new U.S. deployments on Russia’s borders. NATO plans to increase the size of its rapid reaction force nearly eightfold by next year, from 40,000 to 300,000 troops, following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The United States, in particular, plans to significantly expand its military presence in Europe. On June 29, President Joe Biden announced Washington will establish a permanent headquarters in Poland for the U.S. 5th Army Corps, send 5,000 additional troops to Romania, and increase rotational deployments in the Baltic states (namely, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania). The United States will also send two additional squadrons of F-35 fighter aircraft to the United Kingdom, station additional air defense systems at bases in Italy and Germany, and increase the number of naval destroyers in Rota, Spain, from four to six. NATO’s so-called Response Force includes land, sea and air assets that are designed to be deployed quickly and wherever necessary in the event of an attack. The force numbered just 13,000 troops prior to Russia’s initial aggression against Ukraine in 2014. Despite identifying Russia as a “direct threat,” NATO declined even stronger action to deter and defend against Moscow. The updated Strategic Concept describes Russia as “the most significant and direct threat” to security and stability in the entire Euro-Atlantic area, as Moscow seeks to “establish spheres of influence and direct control through coercion, subversion, aggression and annexation,” using “conventional, cyber and hybrid means against NATO and [NATO’s] partners.” The only other “direct threat” identified in the document is terrorism. This harsh language represents a fundamental reversal from the document’s previous iteration in 2010, when NATO said it sought “a true strategic partnership” with Russia and would “act accordingly, with the expectation of reciprocity from Russia.” The updated Strategic Concept also removes any mention of the 1998 Russia-NATO Founding Act governing relations between the alliance and Russia, which the 2010 version reaffirmed. But in the 2022 document, NATO says it is willing to “keep open channels of communication with Moscow to manage and mitigate risks, prevent escalation and increase transparency,” which indicates a desire to maintain the spirit of and compliance with the 24-year-old pact. The new NATO troops that will soon be deployed to Poland and the Baltic states will also continue to rotate throughout the alliance’s Eastern European members to avoid running afoul of the Founding Act, in which NATO pledged not to permanently station combat troops on the Russian border. On June 29, U.S. Assistant Secretary of Defense Celeste Wallander said the U.S. 5th Army Corps’ permanent stationing in Poland will be staffed by headquarters officials, not combat troops, and would thus not violate the U.S. understanding of the NATO-Russia Founding Act. Officials in countries such as France and Germany have said the Founding Act should be preserved, while some, particularly in Eastern Europe and the United States, had called for the alliance to consider formally disavowing or suspending the agreement to remove restraints on NATO force posture. But the new strategy will still fuel Russia’s concerns about NATO’s expansion and prompt Moscow to increase its military presence in the Baltic region. NATO's impending troop movements do not contradict the alliance’s stated desire to maintain the possibility of dialogue with Moscow. They do, however, contradict Russia’s desire for a decreased NATO presence on its periphery, which Moscow expressed prior to invading Ukraine in February. Increased NATO forces in Poland and the Baltic states — not to mention Sweden and Finland’s impending admission to the alliance — will thus still push Russia to increase its nuclear and nuclear-capable weapons systems in the Baltic area and eventually base many more conventional forces there as well. The 2022 Strategic Concept also reaffirms the decision of the 2008 Bucharest Summit that said Ukraine and Georgia will one day be NATO members, adding that “decisions on membership are taken by NATO allies and no third party has a say in this process” in a clear jab at Russia. While this does not portend any concrete or imminent action regarding Georgia and Ukraine’s membership aspirations, it will still increase tensions with Russia, which could use the reaffirmation of the policy to help justify an escalation of the war in Ukraine and/or destabilization measures in Georgia or Moldova. China’s first-ever mention as a strategic “challenge” also reflects NATO’s new concerns with Beijing’s growing influence in Asia. The 2010 Strategic Concept did not once mention China nor the Indo-Pacific region, but the 2022 document devotes significant space to China, whose “stated ambitions and coercive policies challenge NATO interests, security and values”, and says “the Indo-Pacific is important for NATO, given that developments in that region can directly affect Euro-Atlantic security.” This represents a long-awaited change of tone toward China. The alliance’s statement in the 2022 document that it will “strengthen cooperation with new and existing partners in the Indo-Pacific to tackle cross-regional challenges and shared security interests” will likely raise eyebrows in Beijing. However, the updated Strategic Concept also makes clear that it “remains open to constructive engagement to build reciprocal transparency” with China. The 2022 Strategic Concept highlights new cybersecurity, climate change, authoritarian governance and other non-military threats as well. Climate change was mentioned only once in the 2010 Strategic Concept. But in the 2022 version, it is mentioned 11 times, including the ambitious statement that NATO should “become the leading international organization when it comes to understanding and adapting to the impact of climate change on security.” Additional attention is also given to cyberattacks. The alliance reaffirmed its longstanding policy that a “single or cumulative set of malicious cyber activities; or hostile operations to, from, or within space” could prompt NATO to trigger its Article 5 mutual defense clause — another measure directed first and foremost toward Russia and China and intended to deter cyberattacks causing physical damage, as otherwise the alliance would be skeptical of triggering Article 5 because of a cyberattack. Finally, the 2022 Strategic Concept on several occasions notes the challenge to the alliance’s interests and values posed by advancing authoritarianism — a threat not acknowledged directly in 2010.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › SC Thumps – AI/Cyber/Disinformation

That triggers their perception links but doesn’t solve the aff – the SC is symbolic not operational

Ed Arnold 7-1-2022, Research Fellow for European Security at ISS "New Concepts but Old Problems: NATO’s New Strategic Concept," No Publication, https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/new-concepts-old-problems-natos-new-strategic-concept//DG

How Much Does the Strategic Concept Actually Matter? Politically, the Strategic Concept and the unity it represents are very important. However, militarily and operationally, it is less significant. The 2010 Strategic Concept had been moribund since at least 2014, following Russia’s annexation of Crimea, but of course NATO has still been operating effectively since. While a lot of effort has gone into building consensus for Madrid, in many ways the hard work starts now. There is a coherence issue. The Strategic Concept, as NATO’s strategy, comes after the two main plans – SACEUR’s Concept for the Deterrence and Defence of the Euro-Atlantic Area and the future NATO Warfighting Capstone Concept – have already matured. There was tacit acknowledgement at the Madrid summit that many underlying operational plans would have to be revised. However, with NATO’s strategy transforming, mere tweaks to plans do not seem sufficient, and their core assumptions should be revisited. For NATO’s Warfighting Capstone Concept – how it fights in the future – it is imperative that analysis of Russia’s military performance in Ukraine now becomes the backbone for its development. Moreover, despite the collective might of NATO, it cannot do everything, and the commitment at the 2015 Warsaw summit to a ‘360-degree approach’ to security – both thematically and geographically – risks overstretch. In a hardening world, the Alliance must take the opportunity to go back to its roots and seek support from other actors, such as the EU. It is still expected that a NATO–EU joint declaration will materialise before the end of the year.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Affirmative › Generic › SC Thumps – AI/Cyber/Disinformation

The SC commits member states to addressing cyber, AI and disinformation

Alex Kingsbury, 6-29-2022, Editorial Board member for the NYT "Opinion," No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/29/opinion/nato-expansion-putin.html//DG

The discussion at the summit about a larger, stronger NATO is playing out against the backdrop of a new strategic-concept document for the alliance — a vision for its trajectory for the next decade. As recently as a year ago, that document was poised to focus more broadly on China, climate change and cybersecurity — important priorities to be sure, yet superseded by events on the ground that create an opportunity for the alliance to concentrate on its core mission of safeguarding freedom and security in Europe by political and military means. The updated strategy also rightly addresses newer forms of warfare, from cyber and artificial intelligence to disinformation. The changes to NATO will help European member states focus their attention on the security threats the continent faces, and it should also underscore that all members should pay their fair share. For years, American presidents have leaned on Europe to spend more on its own defense. NATO nations have a target of spending 2 percent of their G.D.P. on defense. Yet few nations meet that moderate threshold, which leads to the widespread sense that Americans have been subsidizing European defense and freeing those governments to spend more money on things like generous welfare benefits. Donald Trump, mercurial statesman though he was, wasn’t wrong to chide NATO partners for not carrying their share of the defense burden.

2022 Michigan Topicality
AT: Kotila

That was because the definition of “the” did violence to common sense

Supreme Court of Kentucky 6. “Matheney v. Commonwealth”; 2002-SC-0920-MR; March 23, 2006; Lexis //BY

In , this Court held that the version of  then in effect required possession of all the chemicals or equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine. Essentially, this Court found that the statute's use of the word [**5]  "the" meant that a person could be convicted under  of the statute only for possession of all the chemicals or equipment (as opposed to "any" or "some" of the chemicals or equipment) for the manufacture of methamphetamine. The Kotila majority based this conclusion on grammatical construction and subsequent statutory enactments by the General Assembly. While attempting to discern the General Assembly's intent by analyzing subsequent legislation, the majority opinion conceded that the precise intent of the General Assembly was ambiguous.

The majority also rejected the applicability of criminal attempt under  unless all the chemicals or equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine were present. Justice Keller concurred in the Court's opinion relating to . However, he believed  [*603]  that  applied to "defendants who intend to manufacture methamphetamine and who undertake 'substantial steps' towards manufacturing methamphetamine by knowingly accumulating materials necessary to do so, but who are apprehended before they can complete the  Manufacturing Methamphetamine offense by knowingly possessing all of the chemicals or all of the equipment necessary to manufacture methamphetamine."  (Keller, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part).

2022 Michigan Topicality
“The”---T/L

“The” can determine specifics

Supreme Court of Michigan 21. “Ricks v. State”; July 8, 2021; Lexis //BY

In its review of the threshold-eligibility requirements in MCL 691.1755(1), the Court of Appeals aptly recognized that the Legislature repeatedly used the word [**440] "the" in front of "crimes," "charges," and "judgment of conviction" in MCL 691.1755(1)(a) to (c) in setting forth when a plaintiff is eligible for compensation under the WICA. On the other hand, the Legislature uses the word "another" before "criminal offense" in MCL 691.1755(1)(b) and [***27] "conviction" in MCL 691.1755(4)—other subsections of MCL 691.1755 that explain when a plaintiff is not eligible for compensation. We have previously defined "the" as a "definite article . . . (used, especially before a noun, with a specifying or particularizing effect, as opposed to the indefinite or generalizing force of the indefinite article a or an)."20Link to the text of the note As an adjective, "another" is defined as "different or distinct from the one first considered"; "some other"; or "being one more in addition to one or more of the same kind."21Link to the text of the note Accordingly, the Legislature's use of "the" before "crimes," "charges," and "judgment of conviction" throughout MCL 691.1755(1)(a) to (c) means those provisions refer to the specific crimes and charges leading to a plaintiff's wrongful conviction and imprisonment that gave rise to a WICA claim. The Legislature's use of "another" before "criminal offense" in MCL 691.1755(1)(b) and "conviction" in MCL 691.1755(4) [*413] means those provisions refer to some other offense or conviction that is different or distinct from the wrongful conviction and imprisonment, and which therefore does not warrant compensation under the WICA. Thus, MCL 691.1755 reflects the overall structure of the WICA in only providing compensation for the specific crimes, charges, or convictions [***28] that the plaintiff was wrongfully convicted of and imprisoned for, and which ultimately form the basis of the WICA claim—not "another" crime, charge, or conviction.

2022 Michigan Topicality
“The”---T/L

The most precise definition of “The” specifies particulars

Supreme Court of Minnesota 12. “State v. Hohenwald”; A10-1986; July 11, 2012; Lexis //BY

With regard to Minn. R. Crim. P. 20.01, the definite article "the" is a word of limitation that indicates a reference to a specific object. The definite article "the" particularizes the subject which it precedes. "The" is used before singular or plural nouns and noun phrases that denote particular, specified persons or things Applying the word "the" as a word of limitation, Rule 20.01 requires the suspension of the proceedings in the then-existing case in which the court orders the suspension, not in an unspecified or indefinite number of cases. The word "the" is a word of limitation, not a word of indefinite or generalizing force. If the drafters of the criminal rules intended to suspend all proceedings brought against a particular criminal defendant, including those not yet in existence, they could have easily used words to that effect by suspending "all criminal proceedings" or "any criminal proceedings." Thus, the most natural reading of Rule 20.01 is that it requires district courts to suspend the proceedings in only the particular case in which it orders the suspension, not in all prospective actions that could possibly arise during the period of suspension.

2022 Michigan Topicality
“The”---T/L

“The” means one or more.

Oxford ND – The OED is the definitive record of the English language, featuring 600000 words, 3 million quotations, and over 1000 years of English. ("THE English Definition and Meaning," Lexico, https://www.lexico.com/en/definition/the, Accessed 7-5-2022, LASA-SC)

[The] Denoting one or more people or things already mentioned or assumed to be common knowledge.

2022 Michigan Topicality
“The”---T/L

“The” isn’t all or nothing---it can refer to particulars

United States District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin 22. “United States v. Nash”; 21-CR-105-JPS; April 1, 2022; Lexis //BY

Magistrate Judge  analyzed Question 11.a's grammar and usage to determine whether it was fundamentally ambiguous. He wrote,

[t]he question did not ask, "Are you the actual transferee/buyer of a firearm(s) listed on this form...?" or "Are you an actual transferee/buyer of the firearm(s) listed on this form ...?" [Rather, it asked: Are you the actual transferee/buyer of the firearm(s) listed on this form . . . ?]

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AT: Advantage CPs › AT: REM/REE

$140 million from the infrastructure bill went to domestic supply chains– proves investment alone is not enough

DOE ‘2/14 ( US Department of Energy, federal government agency that manages the United States' nuclear infrastructure and administers the country's energy policy and funds scientific research, published 2/14/22 by the DOE, accessed 7/19/22, “DOE Launches $140 Million Program to Develop America’s First-of-a-Kind Critical Minerals Refinery”, https://www.energy.gov/articles/doe-launches-140-million-program-develop-americas-first-kind-critical-minerals-refinery)//mw

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) today released a on the design, construction and operation of a new facility to demonstrate the commercial feasibility of a full-scale rare earth element (REE) and critical minerals (CM) extraction and separation refinery using unconventional resources. When built, this first-of-a-kind facility, supported by $140 million investment from the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, will support American manufacturing jobs, and help build a strong domestic supply chain for the next generation of clean energy technologies vital to reaching President Biden’s goal of a net-zero emissions future. “Applying next-generation technology to convert legacy fossil fuel waste into a domestic source of critical minerals needed to strengthen our supply chains is a win-win — delivering a healthier environment and driving us forward to our clean energy goals,” said U.S. Secretary of Energy Jennifer M. Granholm. “With the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law’s investment in the build out of this first-of-its kind critical minerals refinery, we are moving ideas from the lab to the commercial stage and demonstrating how America can compete for the global supply chain to meet the growing demand for clean energy technology.” Across the United States, there are billions of tons of coal waste and ash, acid mine drainage, and produced water. The legacy wastes left behind by coal mining and related activities all contain a wide variety of valuable minerals and materials. Each of them offers an untapped resource for producing a wealth of critical minerals. REEs and CMs are essential materials that are used in a broad range of technologies that are significant to national security and energy, such as advanced aircraft, wind turbines, electric vehicles, semiconductors, and hydrogen fuel cells. Currently, even when REEs are being mined within the U.S., they are shipped overseas for processing, before being sold back to the U.S. in more expensive products.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AT: Advantage CPs › AT: REM/REE

Biden already invested $35 million

Hirneisen ‘2/22 (Madison, a staff reporter covering California for The Center Square, published 2/22/22 by The Center Square, accessed 7/19/22, “Biden, Newsom announce $35 million investment in rare-earth mineral mining”, https://www.thecentersquare.com/national/biden-newsom-announce-35-million-investment-in-rare-earth-mineral-mining/article_8d1060e6-9434-11ec-a9cf-6f20234b1569.html)//lexmw

Biden a $35 million investment for Mountain Pass Materials on Tuesday, the only rare-earth mining and processing site in the United States. Biden said the funds will help create a "fully domestic supply chain" for the magnets that power technology like wind turbines and electric vehicle motors. The new multi-million dollar investment announced on Tuesday comes on top of $700 million that Mountain Pass Materials plans to invest by 2024 to create a rare earth supply chain in the U.S. "These new investments are going to do more than create good paying jobs, they are also going to set America up to lead the world and build a clean energy economy and the clean energy future," Biden said on Tuesday. Mountain Pass Materials, which is based in California, was started five years ago and has since become the second-largest producer in the world of rare earth materials, James Litinsky, CEO of Mountain Pass Materials, said during Tuesday's news conference. The company rare earth elements used to power digital technologies, electric vehicles, clean energy, and even certain military control systems. The company estimates that through a partnership with General Motors, it will be able to produce enough magnets for 500,000 electric vehicles per year with the materials it recovers at its facility. Biden noted on Tuesday that investments in these kinds of processes and operations would help the U.S. compete with China, which currently controls most of the global market for these minerals. "We can't build a future that's made in America if we ourselves are dependent on China for the materials, the power [and] the products of today and tomorrow," Biden said.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AT: Advantage CPs › AT: REM/REE

Environmental costs cause backlash

Subin, BA, ‘21(Samantha, associate reporter for CNBC Pro and CNBC.com and has a BA in in multiplatform journalism and general business from the University of Maryland, Published 4/17/22 by CNBC, accessed 7/19/22, “The new U.S. plan to rival China and end cornering of market in rare earth metals”, )//mw

While companies like Lynas and MP Materials are eager to ramp up the domestic supply chains, extracting rare earths is a difficult process due to a combination of environmental, technical and political factors. Many regions, including the European Union, have an abundance of these resources but lack the expertise that other countries like China have in the processing and magnet production, Nakano said. The rare earths industry has come under fire for environmental concerns. Many rare earth elements reside among mineral deposits with radioactive materials that can leach into the water table. Mining, processing and disposal can also contribute to ecosystem disruption and release hazardous byproducts into the atmosphere. Although the U.S. is making strides to advance the rare earths supply chain and develop alternatives to mining rare earths, environmental regulations are often more stringent than inside China. In recent years, Lynas came under scrutiny from activists and the Malaysian government for radioactive waste that it produces as part of its enrichment process. Lynas has said that the low-levels of radioactive waste were not dangerous and the Malaysian government ultimately and for a permanent disposal and waste treatment facility in August 2020.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
AT: Advantage CPs › AT: Russian Sanctions

Sanctions fail – They hurt the people NOT the military or leaders

Rami Al-Khalifa Al-Ali 6-5-22 Writer for Saudi Gazette [The failure of Western sanctions against Russia, ] //DHS WAgustin

Historically, sanctions have failed to achieve any political goals. It is the worst weapon that the modern and contemporary international system has produced. Every time when sanctions were imposed, it was the people who paid the price, while these sanctions failed to harm the leaders and officials in the targeted countries. With the beginning of the Russian war on Ukraine, a series of Western sanctions are being slapped on the Russian side, and that has covered almost all fields. This is up to the extent that one of the Western universities canceled a lecture on Tolstoy on the pretext that he was a Russian! The Western nations wished that their sanctions would be so crushing and thus deal a fatal blow to the Russian economy, and hence they have frozen Russian deposits as well as Russian assets abroad, leaving no room for the Western hand to reach unless it was punished. The worst scenario was the attempt to isolate Russia from the global banking payment system called SWIFT (The Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication) as this makes import and export a very complicated affair even though it would be possible. The Russian economy absorbed the first blow, despite the sagging ruble, but it quickly recovered, and even achieved higher gains than before the war. The obvious question that must be asked by Western circles: what is the purpose of these sanctions? The answer, as presented by Western politicians, is twofold: the first is the weakening of the Russian economy, which affects the stability of the Putin government and undermines confidence in Russian President Vladimir Putin on the Russian street. However, the results of these sanctions were counterproductive and the proportion of opponents of the war is very small on the Russian street, and President Putin’s popularity is on the rise. The second aspect is the effect on the Russian war machine. It is true that there were many difficulties experienced by the Russian forces, especially in the beginning of the war, and the failure to capture Kiev, and this forced the Russian leadership to change its military plans. But this has nothing to do with the Western sanctions. Rather, the armed forces, like the Russian economy, have regained their solidity and seemed more capable of achieving breakthroughs and steady military progress. This does not mean victory in the war, but it means that the Russian forces were not affected by the aforesaid sanctions. The Western sanctions on Russia made the supply of Ukrainian grain a very difficult issue, even if it was done in relatively small quantities, and Russia's isolation from the SWIFT regime made the supply of Russian grain no less difficult. If we know that both countries export 30 percent of the grain worldwide, it can be understood that the food crisis that the world is beginning to suffer from, and which threatens impending famines that might afflict a large number of the third world countries, even though these countries have no part in the Ukrainian war or in the conflict between the West and Russia. The worst is that the European societies themselves have begun to suffer from the rise in the prices of essential goods, as the prices of fuels increased by up to 40 percent, and this led to a rise in most essential goods, especially foodstuffs. After the experience of the past months, the Western sanctions on Russia are like those who shoot themselves in the feet. In fact, Moscow has benefited from sanctions on the energy sector. What it was unable to export was compensated by the rise in oil prices. It is clear that the West must change its strategy, and this can only be done by bitterly admitting that it has failed miserably in its policy of imposing sanctions against Russia.