Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 2AC---A2: Humiliation Turn

Nuclear deterrence theory – Putin will only lose a nuke if he barely wins – a crush means he’ll be deterred.

Geist 22 [Edward Geist, policy researcher with a PhD in history, 03-8-2022, "Is Putin Irrational? What Nuclear Strategic Theory Says About Deterrence of Potentially Irrational Opponents", No Publication, https://www.rand.org/blog/2022/03/is-putin-irrational-what-nuclear-strategic-theory-says.html, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

As nuclear strategists recognized decades ago, deterrence is necessary—but it isn't always sufficient. The analysts and theorists who worked on these issues were bedeviled, in particular, by the problem of nonrational opponents. As the nuclear strategist Herman Kahn put it in 1962, “We want to deter even the mad.”

Kahn took comfort in his conclusion that “irrationality is a matter of degree,” so scaling up nuclear deterrence might still impress a “need for caution” upon irrational adversaries. Furthermore, “if the irrationality is sufficiently bizarre, the irrational decisionmaker's subordinates are likely to step in.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 2AC---A2: Humiliation Turn

Russia won’t lash out against America – he knows he’ll lose.

Sanger et al 22 [David E. Sanger, Eric Schmitt, Helene Cooper and Julian E. Barnes, 3-23-2022, "U.S. Makes Contingency Plans in Case Russia Uses Its Most Powerful Weapons", No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/23/us/politics/biden-russia-nuclear-weapons.html, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

If Mr. Putin did strike a NATO country intentionally, he would not only bring the force of the military alliance to bear on Russia, but also probably find himself facing NATO troops inside Ukraine, Artis Pabriks, Latvia’s defense minister, told reporters traveling in his country this month with Gen. Mark A. Milley, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

“He will get Article 5,” Mr. Pabriks said, in a reference to the NATO pledge that an attack on one alliance member is an attack on all.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 2AC---A2: Humiliation Turn

Crushing Russia is good – the squo is the worst of all worlds – future Russian attacks, China invades Taiwan, collapse of the LIO, and middle power attacks.

Mongrenier 6-10 [Jean-Sylvestre Mongrenier, Professor of History and Geography and researcher at the French Institute of Geopolitics, 6-10-2022, "Why do we Want Ukraine to Win?", Desk & Russie, https://en.desk-russie.eu/2022/06/10/why-do-we-want-ukraine-to-win.html, DOA: 7-2-2022 //ArchanSen]

The political-media system is prone to cyclothymia. After having feared the collapse of Ukraine in the days following the Russian offensive of February 24, the resistance and the affirmation of a “nation in arms” gave rise to the greatest optimism. The question now was how far to support the Ukrainian counter-offensive. Shouldn’t Vladimir Putin’s Russia be spared “humiliation” by offering it a “way out”? Even if it means rewarding the aggressor, humiliating the aggressed and sanctifying ethnic cleansing with bombs?

It is first of all a question of principle and of the prevalence of the general norms of law: the sovereignty, territorial integrity and inviolability of the borders of a national state fully recognized on the international scene and a member of the UN since its foundation! An independent state since the dissolution of the USSR, a decision not imposed by the West but desired by the Russian, Belarusian and Ukrainian presidents at the time. The Ukrainian borders were recognized by Russia itself. Let us recall the signing of the Budapest Memorandum (1994) and the Russian-Ukrainian friendship treaty (1997). On a general level, the Helsinki Final Act (1975) excludes the modification of borders by force, a principle taken up in the Charter of Paris (1990), which marked the end of the Cold War.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Turkey Alliance Good

Turkey is good for NATO – shields NATO, prevents anti-Islam bias, decreases RCA, terror, NATO military capability, influence.

THO nd [THO Contributors, xx-xx-xxxx, "Turkey’s NATO membership is an asset for both Turkey and the Alliance", Turkey’s NATO membership is an asset for both Turkey and the Alliance, https://www.turkheritage.org/en/publications/analysis-by-tho-contributors-and-liaisons/turkeys-nato-membership-is-an-asset-for-both-turkey-and-the-alliance-9620, DOA: 7-2-2022 //ArchanSen]

Just as Turkey derives immense benefits from NATO membership, the alliance in general and the United States in particular also benefit from Turkey's membership. First, since its entry to the alliance Turkey has played a key role in European security by shielding the continent from the east and the south. Turkey does not only act as a buffer zone insulating the Kantian Europe from the Hobbesian Middle East but also as a spearhead enabling NATO allies to reach out to the Caucasus, Black Sea, Central Asia and wider Middle East. During the Cold War Turkey acted as a bulwark against Soviet penetration into the wider Middle East and helped lessen the Soviet military pressure on central Europe by tying up sizable Soviet troops. Turkey's role as an unsinkable aircraft carrier has been well noted.

Second, Turkey is the only ally within NATO which has a Muslim-majority population. Turkey's membership serves as an antidote to the claims that NATO is an alliance of Christian nations. This has become more and more important in the post-9/11 era, as civilizational and identity-related considerations have increasingly colored international politics. For NATO's military operations across the globe not to be seen as biased against Islamic nations, Turkey's presence inside the alliance has been vitally important.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine---Thumpers

There’s been a couple instances of SC with Ukraine – I’ll insert a list.

DoS 6-23 [United States Department of State, 6-23-2022, "U.S. Security Cooperation with Ukraine", https://www.state.gov/u-s-security-cooperation-with-ukraine/, DOA: 7-1-2022 //ArchanSen]

United States security assistance committed to Ukraine includes:

Over 1,400 Stinger anti-aircraft systems;

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine---Impact

Nuke war causes extinction.

Solomon 7-3 [Norman Solomon is co-founder and national director of , 7-3-2022, "Nuclear War Could Mean Human Extinction. Biden and Congress Should Stop Messing Around.", Truthout, https://truthout.org/articles/nuclear-war-could-mean-annihilation-but-biden-and-congress-are-messing-around/, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

President Joe Biden and top subordinates have refused to publicly acknowledge the danger of nuclear war — even though it is now higher than at any other time in at least 60 years. Their silence is insidious and powerful, and their policy of denial makes grassroots activism all the more vital for human survival.

In the aftermath of the 1962 Cuban missile crisis, President John F. Kennedy was more candid. Speaking at American University, he said: “A single nuclear weapon contains almost 10 times the explosive force delivered by all the allied air forces in the Second World War.” Kennedy also noted, “The deadly poisons produced by a nuclear exchange would be carried by wind and water and soil and seed to the far corners of the globe and to generations yet unborn.” Finally, he added, “All we have built, all we have worked for, would be destroyed in the first 24 hours.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine---Impact

A Russian nuke would make escalation inevitable – regardless of what NATO does.

Slocombe 22 [Walter Becker Slocombe is a former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy and was the Senior Advisor for Security and Defense to the Coalition Provisional Authority in Baghdad., 5-10-2022, "Will Putin use nuclear weapons in Ukraine? Our experts answer three burning questions.", https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/will-putin-use-nuclear-weapons-in-ukraine-our-experts-answer-three-burning-questions/, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

Assuming the United States, NATO, and Ukraine could agree on any action, there are several possibilities. If the Russian attack caused little damage, NATO might first try to issue an ultimatum with the aim of reaching a settlement on the Alliance’s and Ukraine’s terms. But if Putin had convinced himself that there was no other option but to strike, he would be unlikely to acquiesce to any allied proposals for such a settlement. Similarly, a non-nuclear military response (for example, conventional strikes on military bases and infrastructure in Russian territory that are supporting the invasion) would probably not be decisive and would appear inadequate to many—in addition to carrying its own risks of escalation.

That leaves the option, for which NATO forces are fully adequate, of a strike tailored to the scale and character of the Russian one. Some would understandably argue that continuing to defend Ukraine is simply not worth risking a nuclear escalation. But while it is easy to see the risks of a nuclear counterstrike, there are also serious implications of not doing it: The absence of a US nuclear response would gravely weaken the credibility among both friends and adversaries of the entire strategy of deterring nuclear attack through the prospect of US nuclear retaliation. This, in turn, would make a bigger war more likely. May we never need to face the choice.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine---Impact

Unless stopped with a quick, crushing defeat, Putin will escalate.

Hurd 6-6 [Dale Hurd, 6-6-2022, "Russian Officials Openly Discuss Using Nukes", CBN News, https://www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/2022/june/russian-officials-openly-discuss-using-nukes-nobody-is-going-to-refuse-putins-orders, DOA: 7-2-2022 //ArchanSen]

Rebekah Koffler, born in the Soviet Union and a former intelligence officer for the US government, is the author of Putin's Playbook. She says Putin would "absolutely" use a nuclear weapon.

"This type of conflict is exactly the type of situation for which Putin, on his orders, the so-called nuclear warfare doctrine was developed that is called 'escalate to de-escalate,'" Koffler said. "You are escalating by popping a nuke in a conventional conflict, in order to de-escalate the conflict. A tactical nuclear warhead could be detonated on the territory, in this case of Ukraine, in order to dislodge the opponent psychologically. If Russian intelligence services assess accurately or by mistake that the U.S. and NATO are about to intervene, Putin would preemptively activate that doctrine."

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 2AC---Ukraine---UQ

PGMs are successful, but Ukraine needs more.

NB 7-2 [News Beezer, 7-2-2022, "Modern American weapons characterize the war in Ukraine", No Publication, https://newsbeezer.com/vietnameng/modern-american-weapons-characterize-the-war-in-ukraine/, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

The Ukrainian military is eagerly awaiting the first shipment of satellite-guided missile launchers with a range of more than 40 miles, far exceeding the missile launchers previously owned by Ukraine.

Analysts say even some on the Russian side are reluctant to acknowledge the accuracy and power of these weapons.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine

They are key.

Magnuson 6-15 [Stew Magnuson, 6-15-2022, "", No Publication, https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2022/6/15/ukraine-to-us-defense-industry-we-need-long-range-precision-weapons, DOA: 7-1-2022 //ArchanSen] *Brackets were in original text

Sharapov: The party that will win in this war will be the party that will first start using contemporary high precision equipment and weapon systems. And those drones that you mentioned, they are a part of the modernized, highly accurate, highly precise, modern equipment. It gives us an advantage that allows us to accurately strike the enemy.

Gen. Karpenko: Regarding the first question, I want to add something to what the deputy minister has said in terms of the need for equipment and armaments. I just want you to understand the intensity of the conflict. While the deputy minister was talking, I drafted some numbers to just show you the intensity of combat along those … kilometers where the combat is most active.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine

PGM sales on June 29th prove their effectiveness, thump every DA, but don’t solve the aff.

Schmitt and Ismay 7-1 [Eric Schmitt is a senior correspondent covering national security for The New York Times. John Ismay is a Pentagon correspondent in the Washington bureau, and previously served as the At War reporter covering armed conflict for The New York Times Magazine. 7-1-2022, "Advanced U.S. Arms Make a Mark in Ukraine War, Officials Say", No Publication, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/01/us/politics/himars-weapons-ukraine.html, DOA: 7-1-2022 //ArchanSen]

The most advanced weapons that the United States has so far supplied Ukraine are making an impact in their first several days on the battlefield, destroying Russian ammunition depots and command centers, American and Ukrainian officials say.

Ukraine’s military had eagerly awaited the arrival of the first batch of truck-mounted, multiple-rocket launchers, whose satellite-guided rockets have a range of more than 40 miles, greater than anything Ukraine had possessed. The weapons have even won grudging respect from some Russians for their accuracy and power, analysts said.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine

PMGs are key to get the upper hand.

Magnuson 6-15 [Stew Magnuson, 6-15-2022, "", No Publication, https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2022/6/15/ukraine-to-us-defense-industry-we-need-long-range-precision-weapons, DOA: 7-1-2022 //ArchanSen]

Ukraine has a message it wants to convey to the U.S. defense industrial base and the government.

The war-torn nation desperately needs artillery and artillery rounds, but what can truly give it the upper hand over its Russian invaders are long-range precision weapons such as armed Predator drones, loitering munitions and the multiple launch rocket system.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---Ukraine

The tide has turned – Russia is going to win the war.

Davis 6-22 [Daniel Davis is a Senior Fellow for Defense Priorities and a former Lt. Col. in the U.S. Army, 6-22-2022, "Russia May Win the War in Ukraine", 19FortyFive, https://www.19fortyfive.com/2022/06/russia-may-win-the-war-in-ukraine/, DOA: 7-4-2022 //ArchanSen]

On Sunday, NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said “nobody knows” how long the Russian war in Ukraine might last, but, he added, “we need to be prepared for it to last years.” Retired Army General Jack Keane told a Fox & Friends audience on Monday that Ukraine had the ability, will, and troops to win the war. All they lacked, he claimed, “is the weapons to do it.”

The historical record and a growing mountain of evidence, however, suggest that such claims are unrealistically optimistic, as there is a growing possibility that the Ukrainian Army may be months away from losing the ability to defend the country.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---New Baltics Cards

Squo ammunitions aren’t enough.

Emmott 6-15 [Robin Emmott, 6-15-2022, "The Baltic states want more NATO. They won't get all they seek", Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/baltic-states-want-more-nato-they-wont-get-all-they-seek-2022-06-15/, DOA: 6-30-2022 //ArchanSen]

Since Russia invaded Ukraine in February, the Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania have been calling for their region to receive the biggest build-up of combat-ready NATO forces in Europe since the end of the Cold War, to be agreed at a summit on June 28-30 in Madrid.

It will not happen, interviews with seven senior diplomats and officials from leading NATO allies show.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › 1AC---New Baltics Cards

Baltics invasion is coming within the year – Russia views it as an easy dub.

Grady 6-16 [John Grady, editor of Navy Times, retired director of communications for the United States Army, 6-16-2022, "Baltic States Need More NATO Forces to Deter a Russian Invasion, Says Estonian Official", USNI News, https://news.usni.org/2022/06/16/baltic-states-need-more-nato-forces-to-deter-a-russian-invasion-says-estonian-official, DOA: 6-30-2022 //ArchanSen]

Despite the Kremlin’s heavy losses in invading Ukraine, the Russians are “going to come back stronger” in a year or so to threaten the Baltics, Estonian Ministry of Defence Permanent Secretary said on Thursday.

Speaking at a Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessment event, Kusti Salm said that even given Moscow’s rising number of casualties, destruction of armored forces and depletion of precision-guided weapons, the Kremlin can still mass fires as it is showing in fighting in eastern and southern Ukraine.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › *1AC---Russia Revisionist

*Russia revisionist.

Malmgren 6-3 [Harald Malmgren, 6-3-2022, "Putin's war is just beginning", UnHerd, https://unherd.com/2022/06/putins-war-is-just-beginning/, DOA: 7-2-2022 //ArchanSen]

Putin talked at length about the historic tragedy of the collapse of the Soviet Union, but also added that the Soviet Bloc was the wrong model for what Russia needed. He made an impassioned explanation that what Russia really needed was a new Peter the Great. He talked almost lovingly about Peter’s attempts to upgrade Russia’s institutions and education system from 1682 to 1725. He argued that after the total collapse of the USSR, it had become necessary to rebuild a Greater Russia under the leadership of a new version of Peter.

Peter, he told me, had set in motion the magnificent strengthening of Russia completed by Catherine the Great: the establishment of Novorossiya, or Imperial Russia, spanning all of the Baltic Sea, the Nordics and Poland, as well as the peoples and nations to the west and to the south to the Azov and Black Sea. He then made it clear he did not think the Soviet Bloc was the right model to achieve this, and what he longed for was a return of Imperial Russia, not Soviet Russia.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › *1AC---Russia Revisionist

*Russia revisionist.

Natsios 22 [Andrew S. Natsios, Former Administrator of the United States Agency for International Development, 02-17-2022. “Putin’s New Russia: Fragile State or Revisionist Power?” . DOA: 07-02-2022 //ArchanSen]

Putin has positioned himself and Russia as a culturally and religiously conservative alternative to western secular liberal democracies. This world view is described in Project Russia which is a curious, if alarming, collection of essays published in five-volumes as a semi- official government publication that describes the political ideology of the State, the Orthodox Church’s religious vision, geographic determinism, and social analysis shared by Putin and his circle of oligarchs who rule Russia. These essays form a strange amalgam of anti-democratic, reactionary, ultra-nationalist attacks on western democratic values, combined with an unhealthy dose of conspiracy theories, paranoia, xenophobia, and a defense of autocratic government and dictatorship.18 One view of Project Russia is that its publication simply reflects Putin’s understanding as a former KGB agent that a great power must have an ideology to defeat and undermine its rivals in propaganda battles. But a more sinister and alarming view is that the five volumes are Putin’s blue print for Russia’s grand strategy, evidence of a revisionist power seeking to overthrow the existing international order. If this interpretation of Project Russia is correct, it suggests a greater level of future conflict with the western democracies and international institutions. If Project Russia is a blue print and not just a propaganda tool, the risk of an accidental global conflagration between Russia and the NATO alliance is a real, even if less than likely, possibility.

Vladimir Putin must find ways of explaining to the Russian people why the country is so far behind the western democracies, as did his predecessors in the Soviet Union. Putin continues to pursue the Soviet strategy of keeping the memory of World War II alive to stir up Russian nationalism among the population but also as an explanation for Russia’s underdevelopment. The evidence suggests that this strategy faces increasing hurdles. Russia’s epic and very real sacrifices during World War II no longer have much resonance with the younger generation, who know little about the war, and the older generation, who tire of a war 70 years ago being used to explain Russian inability to match Western living standards today. Thus, what had been a powerful historical experience of collective suffering and sacrifice during World War II, has now become a fading memory which lacks the magnetic power it held over the Russian people during the Cold War.19

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff – PGMs 2 – BFHR › Case › *1AC---Russia Revisionist

Russia is revisionist – only deterrence solves.

Charalambides 6-26 [Yiannos Charalambides, doctorate and head of Ledra College’s International Relations department, 6-26-2022. “A Russian Revisionist Strategy on the Rise?”, DOI: 10.1080/09700161.2022.2076303. DOA: 07-02-2022 //ArchanSen]

The better we understand why Russia intends to increase its geopolitical and geostrategic position and role in the regional arena, the better we can realize why and how the Russian revisionist policy has been developing since 2008, from Europe to the Middle East, via the Caucasus region. Since 2008: a) Russia prevented NATO’s expansionist policy through the wars in Georgia, Crimea and Ukraine. Russia returned stridently to the international arena; b) Russia has consolidated its position as a leading and dominant power in the Caucasus region; c) It took action in the Middle East and defended its strategic interests in Syria.

Moscow uses all the necessary factors available to realize its revisionist strategy. Such factors are:

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › AT: DIB

The DIB is in the dumps

Tegler 22, 2-4-2022, Eric Tegler is a Contributor for Forbes in "The Defense Industrial Base’s Vital Signs Aren’t Looking Good," https://www.forbes.com/sites/erictegler/2022/02/04/the-defense-industrial-bases-vital-signs-arent-looking-good/?sh=215e90c02101

For the last three years, the  has issued an annual report on the health of America’s Defense Industrial Base. While the state of the U.S. defense industry has been a source of angst for decades, the NDIA’s latest report is the first to assess the environment in which its members operate as broadly failing.

The study, , found deteriorating conditions for the Defense Industrial Base (DIB) in eight categories, including industrial security, supply chains, productive capacity and surge readiness.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › AT: No NATO-Russian compromise

Russian response to Finland and Sweden being added into NATO proves that NATO and Russia can compromise – the only threats including violence are defensive

Ellyatt and Marcias 7/1 [Holly Ellyatt (Correspondent for CNBC focusing on European macro-economics and politics.) and Amanda Macias (National security reporter for CNBC focusing on national security and foreign policy.), 7-1-2022, ”‘Everything was going fine between us,’ Putin says of NATO expansion; Russian forces withdraw from Snake Island,” CNBC, ] // st

Russian President Vladimir Putin has responded to NATO’s forthcoming expansion, saying he has no problem with Sweden and Finland joining the military alliance, but that if infrastructure is deployed to those countries, Russia will respond in kind. Putin’s comments come after the Western military organization officially invited Sweden and Finland to join it in a historic move on Wednesday. That was made possible after a deal was forged with Turkey to accept the membership bids after initial objections from Ankara. The alliance also reiterated its condemnation of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, outlined plans to beef up its defenses in Europe and said China posed a “challenge” to its interests.