2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › ‘With’ Excludes Foreign-Only Action---1NC
Hartz ’18 [Harris; August 29; Court of Appeals Judge on the Tenth Circuit, dissenting; Westlaw, “United States v. Durham,” 902 F.3d 1180]
The panel opinion suggests that the text of the Commerce Clause indicates that power under the Foreign Commerce Clause exceeds that under the Interstate Commerce Clause. See Maj. Op. at 1201–02. It notes that the Clause speaks of commerce “with foreign Nations” but “among the several States.” But the difference in prepositions indicates the opposite. If the Clause permitted regulation of commerce “among foreign nations”—so that the two clauses used the same preposition—then Congress would be empowered to regulate commerce among France, England, and Italy, even if the United States were not involved at all. Thus, use of the preposition with instead of the preposition among obviously limits the extent of the Foreign Commerce Clause. See Colangelo supra at 970–71 (explaining the difference between the uses of the two prepositions in the Commerce Clause).7
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › ‘With’ Modifies Noun---1NC
Davis ’9 [Robert; April 30; Judge on the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims; Westlaw, “Smith v. Shinseki,” No. 07-1646, 2009 WL 1204792]
The second and third alternatives also include the preposition “with.” In this instance, the preposition modifies a noun and expresses a relationship. “With” indicates accompaniment. See WEBSTER'S 2626. Therefore, in order to receive a 100% schedular rating based on the second alternative, a veteran must show that cardiac involvement is accompanied by congestive heart failure. To receive a 100% schedular rating based on the third alternative, the alternative at issue in Ms. Smith's case, she must demonstrate that she has progressive pulmonary disease, and that the disease is accompanied by fever, night sweats, and weight loss despite treatment.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---2NC
Grey ’15 [Ellery Gray, Marty Jackley, and Mark Vargo; March 3; Attorneys; Westlaw, “Appellant's Reply Brief” in South Dakota v. Eagle, 2015 WL 3610506]
In its holding, the Viramontes court announced that the holding (or restraining) was unlawful because it was “for” the purpose of abandonment. This shift grammatically conflates the legality of the holding with the legality of the proscribed purpose. However, the Arizona kidnapping statute, like the South Dakota kidnapping statute, uses the preposition “with.” Prepositions, though often short words, are very powerful. Take for example the following: “My mother is at the hospital” and “My mother is in the hospital.” The shift in language by the court above was an even larger shift than the preceding example. Both words have multiple definitions, each dependent upon context. The Merriam-Webster dictionary provides several distinct uses of both “with” and “for.” Concerning “with” the dictionary has, in part, this to say: “'with... 4
a - used as a function word to indicate combination, accompaniment, presence, or addition <heat milk with honey> <went there with her> <his money, with his wife‘s, comes to a million> (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/with) This is the same use of “with” that both the Arizona and South Dakota kidnapping statutes use. In both cases, the unlawful holding is required to “accompany” the proscribed purpose. Concerning “for” the dictionary has, in part, this to say: “‘for’ 1
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---2NC
Lautenschlage ’3 [Peg; July 8; Attorney General of the State of Wisconsin; Westlaw, “Respondent-Respondent Berge's Brief and Appendix” in Wisconsin v. Berge, 2003 WL 23837809]
Moreover, the use of the preposition “with” is significant. The preposition “with” is “used as a function word to indicate one that shares in an action, transaction, or arrangement.” Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2626 (3d ed. 1986); see also Village of Menomonee Falls v. Falls Rental World, 135 Wis. 2d 393, 397, 400 N.W.2d 478 (Ct. App. 1986) (stating that it is proper for courts to look to dictionary definitions to determine the plain meaning of words.) Given “with's” plain meaning in this context, all correspondence either from Garrett to Ms. Spoo (a/k/a Diane Brice), or from Ms. Spoo (a/k/a Diane Brice) to Garrett, is suspended. If Garrett wanted to challenge the suspension of that privilege, he should have appealed to the warden within 10 days of Boughton's June 26, 2002, memorandum. The return is devoid of any indication that he did that. The circuit court's decision should be affirmed.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---2NC
Dean ’85 [Robert Dean, Thomas Cane, Daniel Larocque; May 14; Judges on the Court of Appeals of Wisconsin; Westlaw, “Engel v. Engel,” 125 Wis. 2d 568]
Their father's participation in the action as vendor does not give the trial court jurisdiction to partition. Their father may not bring the action because he does not hold the property in common with his sons. See sec. 700.18, Stats. Moreover, the preposition ‘with’ in sec. 842.02(1) is used as a function word to indicate a person who shares in an action, transaction or arrangement. Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary 1346 (1977). Only Werner, Sr., qualifies as a person having an interest in the real property. He therefore does not have an interest ‘with’ anyone.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---2NC
Karimova ’16 [Tahmina; 2016; Legal Officer at the International Labor Organization, Ph.D. from the Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva; Human Rights and Development in International Law, p. 122-124]
Edward McWhinney observes that as a term of art of international law, ‘cooperation’ emerged after World War II.2 No treaty or international decision defines the notion or the term ‘cooperation’, though. Wolfrum defines cooperation as ‘the voluntary coordinated action of two or more States which takes place under a legal regime and serves a specific objective’ and to ‘this extent marks the effort of States to accomplish an object by joint action, where the activity of a single State cannot achieve the same result’ or mutual benefit.3 What follows is that the duty to cooperate would lead to an obligation to enter into such an action to achieve a specific goal. In terms of substance, cooperation per se has no independent content;4 it must be tied to a specific area to acquire a specific meaning.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---2NC
Merriam-Webster’s ’22 [Online Dictionary, “with”, http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/with]
2 a —used as a function word to indicate a participant in an action, transaction, or arrangement <works with his father> <a talk with a friend> <got into an accident with the car>
b —used as a function word to indicate the object of attention, behavior, or feeling <get tough with him> <angry with her>
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › With › With---Not Unilateral---1NC
Gregory ’15 [Roger; Aug 19; Judge, United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit; States v. Bollinger, 798 F.3d 201]
The second textual limitation - the fact that commerce must be "with foreign Nations" - requires a nexus between [**30] the United States and a foreign country. See Goodno, supra, at 1202 (observing that dictionaries contemporary to the Constitutional Convention defined "with" as "noting the means" or "noting connection" (internal quotation marks omitted)). The use of the word "with" in the foreign clause, instead of the word "among" as used in the interstate clause, merely suggests the obvious: Congress cannot regulate commerce "among" foreign nations because other nations do not submit their sovereignty to our regulatory powers
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Congress Says DOD Only---2AC
US Code ’18 [United States Code Annotated; last amended Aug. 13, 2018; Title 10: Armed Forces, Subtitle A: General Military Law, Part I: Organization and General Military Powers, “Security Cooperation,” Chapter 16]
(7) The term “security cooperation programs and activities of the Department of Defense” means any program, activity (including an exercise), or interaction of the Department of Defense with the security establishment of a foreign country to achieve a purpose as follows:
(A) To build and develop allied and friendly security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Only DOD---1AR
Maroney ’13 [Jennifer D. P. Moroney and David E. Thaler; 2013; International Relations PhD at the University of Kent-Canterbury; Master of International Affairs from Columbia University; RAND, “Review of Security Cooperation Mechanisms Combatant Commands Utilize to Build Partner Capacity,” https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR413.html]
Security cooperation (SC) is an overarching term that defines “those activities conducted with allies and friendly nations to build relationships that promote specified U.S. interests, build allied and friendly nation capabilities for self-defense and coalition operations and supporting institutional capacity, [and] provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access.”1 Examples include training and combined exercises, operational meetings, contacts and exchanges, security assistance, medical and engineering team engagements, cooperative development, acquisition and technical interchanges, and scientific and technology collaboration. The Department of Defense (DoD) has a long history of conducting SC activities with partner countries for a variety of purposes, including building partner capacity (BPC), which is a primary focus of this report.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Only DOD---1AR
Lenze ’17 [Major Anthony Lenze; 2017; Judge Advocate in the United States Army; Military Law Review, “Traditional Combatant Commander Activities: Acknowledging and Analyzing Combatant Commanders' Authority to Interact with Foreign Militaries,” vol. 225]
Security cooperation is now a term that encompasses “any program, activity (including an exercise), or interaction of the [DoD] with the security establishment of a foreign country to achieve a [strategic] purpose ... [.]”85 The DoD assigns such strategic importance to security cooperation that, with the help of Congress, it created the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) to direct and guide the execution of all DoD security cooperation programs.86 The DSCA helps administer security cooperation, now a multi-billion dollar industry within the annual Defense appropriation.87 With all the money and strategic brainpower pouring into security cooperation, newcomers to the field may presume fully-vetted, standardized terms and definitions. However, this could not be further *656 from reality.
Members of the DoD frequently mischaracterize security cooperation or outright disagree with respect to its doctrinal definition.88 For example, the 2010 National Security Strategy (NSS) used the term security cooperation to include rebuilding damaged infrastructure and establishing conditions necessary to end military operations in Afghanistan.89 With the exception of combat operations, it would seem that almost any military action could fit under the 2010 NSS's version of security cooperation.90 Nevertheless, if security cooperation is in fact an evolving term in the DoD, making sense of the authorities under which the military executes security cooperation events is even more troublesome.91 This is especially true when authorities are based upon a set of specific terms. Hence, with doctrine lagging behind and accompanied by undefined terminology, no authority in the realm of security cooperation is more ambiguous than the authority for military-to-military contacts.92 With ambiguity surrounding military-to-military contacts, planners and lawyers should defer to commanders to decide the best way to employ these strategic interaction events. The fate of 10 U.S.C. §168 and its ultimate repeal is illustrative of this point.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Only DOD---2AC
Zaccor ’5 [Albert; August; Colonel in the US Army and Atlantic Council Senior Fellow; the Atlantic Council of the United States, “Security Cooperation and Non-State Threats: A Call for an Integrated Strategy,” https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/46290/2005_08_Security_Cooperation_and_Non-State_Threats.pdf]
It is an oft-repeated mantra that in order to defeat transnational terrorism, and by extension other related non-state threats, the United States must apply all the elements of national power, including diplomatic, informational, military, and economic.34 The OSD SCG directs that DOD Security Cooperation “will be integrated with other elements of national power…in order to achieve national security, defense, and foreign policy objectives.”35 This formulation, while helpful, obscures two key facts. First, Security Cooperation includes activities that by their very nature involve the simultaneous application of more than one element of national power. Security Cooperation at a minimum requires the combination of diplomatic relations, military assistance, military-to-military contacts, and public diplomacy. In other words, Security Cooperation is itself an application of at least three of the classic elements of national power.36 Second, DOD is not the only entity in the USG that interacts with foreign governments to achieve the stated objectives: relationships, capabilities, information and intelligence, and access. The Department of State, the Intelligence Community, and to a lesser extent, other departments and agencies, conduct activities aimed at the accomplishment of these objectives, broadly understood. There is, however, no common USG, or interagency, definition or concept of Security Cooperation.37 We will return to this issue in the final section of this paper. For the purposes of the present discussion, this paper offers the following working definition of Security Cooperation:
Footnote 37.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: JCS Categories Only---2AC
JCS ’17 [Joint Chiefs of Staff; May 23; publishing with the Army, Marine Corp, Air Force, Navy, and Coast Guard; Security Cooperation, Joint Publication 3-20, “Appendix A: Security Cooperation: Related Programs and Authorities,” https://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/Doctrine/pubs/jp3_20_20172305.pdf]
This appendix describes DOD and DOS programs that have been used to support a variety of SC activities. This appendix is not all inclusive and provides only an overview of the programs. In most cases, planners should consult with legal advisors to identify the proper USC section, regulation, or directive prior to any expenditure of resources. As a matter of fiscal law, funds may only be expended for the purpose for which they were authorized. Consequently, the planners and appropriate commander must ensure any expenditure of funds for an SC activity complies with the associated fiscal mandates. Failure to do so can result in a violation of the Anti-Deficiency Act.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Excludes NATO---2AC
Davids ’19 [Douglas; December; Center for Army Lessons Learned; News from the Front, “The Front of Military Education and Security Cooperation: Defense Security Cooperation University,” https://usacac.army.mil/sites/default/files/publications/17981.pdf]
Security cooperation is defined as "all Department of Defense (DOD) interactions with foreign security establishments to build security relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, develop allied and partner-nation military and security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, and provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to allied and partner nations."1 Security cooperation is a multifaceted effort that requires more than just planning to develop the skills of a foreign security force. In 2017, the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) created the DOD Security Cooperation Workforce Development Program (SCWDP) to develop and manage supporting security programs, improve the quality of the security cooperation workforce, and ensure personnel have the appropriate level of expertise and experience to perform their missions.2
The 2017 NDAA directed the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) to manage the SCWDP's training and education standards, as well as identify and define training and certification requirements. Specifically, DSCA was required to "establish and maintain a school to train, educate, and certify the security cooperation workforce ... ." To meet this obligation, DSCA established the Defense Security Cooperation University (DSCU) in September 2019, to educate and certify 20,000 U.S. government employees' security cooperation and standardize their training.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Excludes Hostilities---2AC
Smith et al. ’17 [Kevin, Mark Lauber, and Lt. Cl. Matthew Robbins; April 1; Senior Analyst in the Joint Center for International Security Force Assistance at Joint Staff J7 Joint Force Development; Senior Special Operating Forces Analyst in the Joint Center for International Security Force Assistance; Joint Doctrine Development Officer in the Joint Doctrine Analysis Division at the Joint Staff J7 Joint Education and Doctrine Division; Joint Force Quarterly, “Joint Publication 3-20, Security Cooperation: Adapting Enduring Lessons,” 85]
Today’s security environment demands that the Department of Defense (DOD) employ a robust strategy and assortment of capabilities across the entire range of military operations and in support of America’s national security interests. A preponderance of these activities falls under the umbrella of security cooperation (SC) in which few, if any, U.S. forces participate directly in combat operations. As DOD continues to develop the “four plus one” threat baseline described by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Joint Force Development Directorate has taken steps to better align joint doctrine with the National Military Strategy as part of an approach that emphasizes the need for adaptive doctrine.1 Within this effort, the need to synergize U.S. capacity and capabilities with those of its partners remains paramount.2
To this end, ongoing efforts to adapt the disparate entities and authorities associated with SC into a unified strategy serve as an important next step. In 2008, DOD published a directive that elevated the requirement for DOD expertise for SC activities to the same level as other “integral [conventional] DOD activities.”3 To achieve parity, the Joint Doctrine Development Community (JDDC) identified the need to incorporate the topic of SC into the joint publication library as Joint Publication (JP) 3-20, Security Cooperation. The approval of JP 3-20 is a major step toward the joint force recognizing SC as a way to apply the military instrument of national power in support of partner nations (PNs) around the globe to achieve strategic objectives and to help shape the operational environment for current and future operations. This article outlines the continued adaptation of SC and the inextricable doctrinal security force assistance (SFA) principles discussed in JP 3-20 that are applicable to the joint force.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Excludes Training/Interoperability---2AC
Bowne ’18 [Andrew; 2018; Major and Judge Advocate in the United States Air Force, Contract and Fiscal Law Professor, The Judge Advocate General's School, United States Army; Military Law Review, “Defending the New Fulda Gap: Deterring Russian Aggression Against the Baltic States Through Fiscal Legislation, 226 Mil. L. Rev. 147, lexis]
The lack of clarity for EDI authorities notwithstanding, efforts to build defense capacity in the Baltic States were bolstered by the overhaul of the security cooperation regime in the FY17 NDAA. In an attempt to simplify the quagmire that security cooperation authorities had become over the past fifteen years, Congress streamlined the dozens of various temporary and permanent sources of authority and codified them under one chapter in Title 10 of the U.S. Code. 125 Congress noted the increasingly more important role security cooperation plays in DoD operations, 126 and the below discussion of how EUCOM can leverage these new authorities to augment EDI demonstrates the potential utility such activities can have within NATO's deterrence strategy.
3. Defense Security Cooperation and the Baltic States
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Excludes Training/Interoperability---2AC
Fraser ’15 [Douglas; October 21; General (Retired), LLC, Former Commander of United States Southern Command; Statement of General Douglas M. Fraser before the House Armed Service Committee on Security Cooperation, https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=789068]
Close Relationship Between Security Cooperation and Security Assistance Mr. Chairman, while this hearing is focused on security cooperation, from my experience, I think it is important to acknowledge the close relationship between Department of Defense security cooperation programs and Department of State security assistance programs. During my time in U.S. Pacific Command and U.S. Southern Command, both commands worked closely with the Department of State and the respective U.S. Embassies to coordinate security cooperation and security assistance programs. Training and exercise programs conducted through security cooperation meshed closely with the education and equipping programs conducted through security assistance programs. In fact, in many cases, more funding assistance to a country was provided through Department of State programs to enhance the capability of a nation’s armed forces, like Foreign Military Financing, than came from Department of Defense programs.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---AT: Excludes Cyber---2AC
Bilms ’21 [Kevin; January; career Department of Defense civilian serving in the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and Low-Intensity Conflict; War on the Rocks; “What’s in a name? Reimagining irregular warfare activities for competition,” https://warontherocks.com/2021/01/whats-in-a-name-reimagining-irregular-warfare-activities-for-competition]
Merge “Civil-Military Operations” and “Security Cooperation” Into “Security Partner Engagement”
Civil-military operations and security cooperation are similar, but each term contains ambiguity that prevents non-practitioners from fully understanding how they fit in competition. For example, “civil-military operations” risks confusion with “civil-military relations,” the study of the dynamic between the military and civil society writ large. As a term, “security cooperation” is broad enough to encompass virtually anything involving a partner.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---Includes Title 22---2AC
Bowne ’18 [Andrew; 2018; Major and Judge Advocate in the United States Air Force, Contract and Fiscal Law Professor, The Judge Advocate General's School, United States Army; Military Law Review, “Defending the New Fulda Gap: Deterring Russian Aggression Against the Baltic States Through Fiscal Legislation, 226 Mil. L. Rev. 147, lexis]
However, funding non-Article 5 activities contingent upon the demonstrated commitment to defense spending and collective security can promote NATO member spending and influence increased defense spending across the Alliance. 208 Such conditions would demonstrate the prioritization of collective defense. Conditioning foreign assistance on matters unrelated to defense capabilities can encourage allies to increase their own defense spending in order to maintain or improve their status with the United States. While maintaining the paramount importance of deterrence strategy through collective defense in NATO, the United States should tie some of its foreign assistance spending in Europe for non-Article 5 activities to a country's defense spending. Examples of such activities include counterterrorism training, refugee support, or even trade incentives.
Congress already places conditions on the appropriation of authorized funds on foreign assistance; however, it has not utilized this powerful foreign policy tool to influence NATO member defense spending. When drafting future conditional authorizations, Congress should look to its own example in the FY17 NDAA, for its specific and technical conditions imposed on Ukraine in the Extension and Enhancement of Ukraine Security Assistance Initiative. 209 While $ 350 million was authorized to be appropriated in Fiscal Year 2017, Congress made available not more than $ 175 million in funds to be used for the authorized purposes. The Secretary of Defense, in coordination with the Secretary of State, certified that Ukraine "ha[d] taken substantial actions to make defense institutional reforms, in such areas as civilian control of the military"; increased transparency and accountability in defense procurement; improved transparency to decrease corruption; and sustained improvements of combat capability, among other requirements. 210 By limiting the amount of assistance, and placing measurable requirements on the beneficiary as a condition to receiving a portion of the funding, Congress is able to maintain some control over the purpose and amount of spending that, absent such conditions, are within the exclusive purview of the recipient.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Security Cooperation---Aff › SC---Includes JCS Categories---2AC
JCS ’17 [Joint Chiefs of Staff; May 23; publishing with the Army, Marine Corp, Air Force, Navy, and Coast Guard; Security Cooperation, Joint Publication 3-20, “Appendix A: Security Cooperation: Related Programs and Authorities,” https://www.jcs.mil/Portals/36/Documents/Doctrine/pubs/jp3_20_20172305.pdf]
Security Cooperation Categories with Related Programs and Authorities
Legend FMF foreign military financing OSD Office of the Secretary of Defense P&R Personnel and Readiness USC United States Code