Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Georgetown Disadvantage

1NC – DA [Russia]

NATO will double down on collective defense against Russia now.

Kochis & Spoehr, 6/23 – senior policy analyst in European affairs in the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom (Daniel Kochis and Thomas W. Spoehr; "NATO Summit Madrid: Reinforcing Deterrence at This Crucial Time Is in the U.S. National Interest"; The Heritage Foundation; https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2022-06/IB5276_0.pdf; 06-23-2022, Accessed 6-25-2022)//ILake-NoC

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO’s) summit in Madrid on June 29 and 30 comes at a consequential moment for the Alliance. Russia’s unprovoked second invasion of Ukraine, the ensuing war that has resulted in the deaths of at least 4,000 Ukrainian civilians,1 and the displacement of over 14 million people is very likely a fulcrum in history. The transatlantic community will not return to the pre-invasion relations with Russia and must plan accordingly. As the shock of Russia’s invasion on February 24 has evolved into the realization that the war is likely to grind on, the transatlantic community must steel itself for the long haul.

2022 Georgetown Disadvantage

Notes

At: Ukraine/thumpers

Ukraine did not require shift priorities, just shifting where existing budget is spent

Plan requires rewriting military strategy

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › IR K › Alt – Paradigm Shifts

The alternative is to vote negative to refuse the 1AC’s prescriptions in favor of paradigm shifting experiments that center de-racialization against white supremist techno-futurity

Mbembe 22, interviewed by TORBJØRN- Achille is a member of the staff at the Wits Institute for Social and Economic Research (WISER) at the University of the Witwatersrand, visiting appointment at the Franklin Humanities Institute at Duke University PhD in History at the Sorbonne, DEA in Political Science at the Instituts d'études politiques [Achille, “Thoughts on the Planetary: An Interview with Achille Mbembe,” Decolonizing the Neoliberal University – Law, Psychoanalysis and the Politics of Student Protest, Interview first Conducted in 2018, Re-Published in this book and Edited by Jaco Barnard-Naudé, Professor of Jurisprudence in the Department of Private Law, University of Cape Town, DKP]

TORBJØRN: Some would then argue that there are still colonial or postcolonial structures operating in the neoliberal project. Would you say that there is then still a genocidal potential?

MBEMBE: Perhaps more than at any other moment in our recent past, we are increasingly faced with the question of what to do with those whose very existence does not seem to be necessary for our reproduction; those whose mere existence or proximity is deemed to represent a physical or biological threat to our own life.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › IR K › Link – AI = Whiteness

The fantasy of AI is the fantasy of Whiteness – a futuristic world where white servants serve white masters – the aff cements the domination of the future by an Anglo-European worldview of White Supremacy that conflates Whiteness with intelligence

Cave and Dai 20 – * Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK, ** Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK, [Stephen, Kanta, “The Whiteness of AI,” Philosophy & Technology volume 33, pages685–703 (2020), DKP]

This paper focuses on the fact that AI is predominantly portrayed as white—in colour, ethnicity, or both. We first illustrate the prevalent Whiteness of real and imagined intelligent machines in four categories: humanoid robots, chatbots and virtual assistants, stock images of AI, and portrayals of AI in film and television. We then offer three interpretations of the Whiteness of AI, drawing on critical race theory, particularly the idea of the White racial frame. First, we examine the extent to which this Whiteness might simply reflect the predominantly White milieus from which these artefacts arise. Second, we argue that to imagine machines that are intelligent, professional, or powerful is to imagine White machines because the White racial frame ascribes these attributes predominantly to White people. Third, we argue that AI racialised as White allows for a full erasure of people of colour from the White utopian imaginary. Finally, we examine potential consequences of the racialisation of AI, arguing it could exacerbate bias and misdirect concern.

Overall, I construe race, racialization, and racial identities as on-going sets of political relations that require, through constant perpetuation via institutions, discourses, practices, desires, infrastructures, languages, technologies, sciences, economies, dreams, and cultural artefacts, the barring of nonwhite subjects from the category of the human as it is performed in the modern west.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › IR K › Link – AI Integration

The expansion of even “friendly AI” builds a bridge to a post-human hellscape, where geopolitics is structured around techno-dystopic racialized violence

Grove 20 – Associate Professor of Political Science and Director of the Hawai’i Research Center for Future Studies at the University of Hawai’I at Mānoa, PhD in International Relations at Johns Hopkins University [Jairus, “From geopolitics to geotechnics: global futures in the shadow of automation, cunning machines, and human speciation,” International Relations 2020, Vol. 34(3) 432 –455, DKP]

In Cavell’s account the general economy of violence that characterized the sadism of slavery could return again but differently. Rather than a great chain of being or the superiority or some races over others, the very concept of violence as a category distinct from force or change could be lost. Although extreme, can we not already see this transformation underway in the extreme forms of instrumentality that characterize decisions regarding collateral damage, counter-value targeting, or economized discourse on immigration and refugees?56

More than a transformation of moral economies, the automation of humans and the augmentation of humans, represents the possibility of making physical and habitual what is now normative and discursive. Resembling Cavell, David Roden proposes what he calls the disconnection thesis, in which Cavell’s nightmare scenario unfolds only among some humans for whom the sentimentality of bodies, reproduction, and human connection impede further evolution of the species.57 Whether it is those who dream of a singularity in which human consciousness becomes digital or one of the U.S. veterans who have had mood altering computer chips implanted into their brains, some humans will increasingly alter or altered their brain-body networks to alter their cognitive and perceptive capacities.58

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › IR K › Link – AI Integration

The integration of AI via security cooperation constitutes the unshackling the nation-state from the population at the level of economic and military power – that turns case – it paves the way for unchecked racialized necropolitics as a value that informs politics and replaces human governance with AI that kill with impunity and result in endless, endemic warfare

Grove 20 – Associate Professor of Political Science and Director of the Hawai’i Research Center for Future Studies at the University of Hawai’I at Mānoa, PhD in International Relations at Johns Hopkins University [Jairus, “From geopolitics to geotechnics: global futures in the shadow of automation, cunning machines, and human speciation,” International Relations 2020, Vol. 34(3) 432 –455, DKP]

The automation of war and the reduction of human troop sizes has a similar effect. Wars aided by drones and as a result significantly smaller numbers of soldier casualties continue on for decades in a kind of sustainable warfare.28 The political and material cost of casualties like the material cost of striking are being removed from the political equation making states less and less accountable in the case of social justice and the pursuit of violence outside their borders.

The feedback between these two trends is potentially catastrophic. At the same time that war becomes easier, governments become less accountable to their people, and people are deprived of the means to support themselves, it is also the case that people will matter less to their governments as they will not possess the labor power to cause pain to the economic productivity of the country by means of striking nor the capacity to refuse to fight. Zygmunt Bauman has spoken of disposable populations, a kind of human waste or surplus where the value of one’s existence is meaningless for the state.29 However, we ought to go further down this path by way of Achille Mbembe’s creeping necropolitics.30 It is not merely that chronically or even intergenerational unemployed people have no value; it is that the marginalization and even murder of people can now generate value. In what Mbembe refers to as the ‘enclave economies’ of war machines:

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › IR K › Link – AI – Tech Thesis

The advent of modernity is marked by the disappearance of humanity – the global integration of AI is a strategy of racialized governance via digitalized corporatization that has exceeded sovereignty and become a Leviathan built on speed and acceleration into a dystopic future that marks populations deemed unworthy for death

Mbembe 19 – member of the staff at the Wits Institute for Social and Economic Research (WISER) at the University of the Witwatersrand, visiting appointment at the Franklin Humanities Institute at Duke University PhD in History at the Sorbonne, DEA in Political Science at the Instituts d'études politiques, [Achille, “Bodies as Borders,” From the European South 4, pg. 5-18, DKP]

My intervention is a set of urgent, fragmentary, and unfinished reflections on our global present. When I say ‘our global present’, what I truly have in mind is the sustainability and durability of our planet. As a matter of fact, this is an almost existential preoccupation, which is increasingly expressed in many different voices and shared by various people all over the world.

Indeed, many are wondering how we should inhabit anew and share as equitably as possible a planet whose life-support system has been so severely damaged by human activities and that is in dire need of repair. In view of the deep state of fragmentation the planet finds itself in, they are asking: how should we re-member it, that is, put back together its different parts, reassemble it and reconstitute it as an integrated system in which humans and nonhumans, physical, chemical and biological components, oceans, atmosphere and land-surface are all interlinked in a grand gesture of mutuality?

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA

Chinese AI dominance increases incentives for China to be assertive in foreign policy

Chang 18 – Benjamin Angel Chang is the inaugural Andrew W. Marshall Fellow at Georgetown University's Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET).

Benjamin Angel Chang, December 2018, “Chapter 14. AI and US-China Relations,” in “AI, China, Russia, and the Global Order: Technological, Political, Global, and Creative Perspectives,” https://nsiteam.com/social/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/AI-China-Russia-Global-WP_FINAL_forcopying_Edited-EDITED.pdf

Independent of effects on the US-China relationship, intensified PRC use of AI for domestic security may also encourage greater Chinese assertiveness. Again, I highlight two potential reasons. First, a pacified domestic sphere might free up attention for expanded external aims. China’s relative ability to weather the 2008 financial crisis significantly motivated its recently more assertive turn (Chen & Wang, 2011). Whereas many Chinese intellectuals had previously sought to emulate Western economic development, viewing the American stage of development as if a higher rung on a universally climbable ladder, the crisis incubated the view that, instead, the Chinese model might be a fine endpoint in and of itself. Similarly, if the CCP were to feel AI had successfully and permanently allowed it to address the full panoply of possible sources of broad public unrest, ranging from unbalanced growth to Xinjiang to income inequality, it would likely see this as one of the Party's Chang 109 crowning achievements in its leadership of the Chinese people. Chinese spending on domestic security has exceeded spending on external defense since 2010, with the gap increasing each year. In 2017, according to the best open-source estimate available, the former exceeded the latter by 18.6 percent (Zenz, 2018). Were the domestic sphere to be “solved,” some of this attention might then be turned outward. Second, concentrations of power generally tend to lead to more belligerence on the international stage. In particular, by substituting technology for manpower in carrying out the state's policing functions, an AI-empowered PRC may enable ever-smaller groups of elites to retain equivalent amounts of power. For de Mesquita et al. (1999, 2003), as the size of the coalition required for political survival (the "winning coalition") shrinks, corruption and war may become more likely, as leaders no longer fear being punished by other domestic actors for selfish arrangements or military defeats.37

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA

Saalman, 18

Lorea Saalman, EastWest Institute Asia-Pacific Program Vice President, “"Fear of false negatives: AI and China's nuclear posture"; Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. April 2018. https://thebulletin.org/2018/04/fear-of-false-negatives-ai-and-chinas-nuclear-posture

New pockets of excellence. In its relations with Russia and the United States, China has long contended with nuclear asymmetry. AI and autonomy, in contrast, offer Beijing the long-term potential to disrupt Washington’s traditional strengths. They open the door for swarm and other technologies that could overwhelm conventional and nuclear platforms that are larger, more cumbersome, and less agile. While China may be concerned about potential adversaries tracking its own nuclear platforms and systems, Beijing is just as likely to avail itself of these relatively inexpensive methods of disrupting US activities. Also, Chinese publications indicate that Beijing is building autonomy into its own “bolt-out-of-the-blue” systems, for example in hypersonic glide vehicles such as the DF-ZF. As China debates integration of automation via launch-on-warning, doing so with a greater range of AI and autonomy in its tool kit could lead to destabilizing trends. Again, the most sensational advances in these enabling technologies do not necessarily carry the greatest implications for China’s military and nuclear force structure. Instead, what counts is the level of AI and autonomy introduced into Beijing’s command and control structure.

When it comes to platforms, this author’s preliminary review of Chinese technical writings on AI and autonomy reveals that Beijing’s greatest emphasis, at least where the most flexible systems are concerned, is on unmanned aerial and underwater vehicles. In China’s view, these systems can be leveraged for a range of activities, including enhanced accuracy in: battlefield reconnaissance, surveillance, patrolling, electronic reconnaissance, communications, electronic interference, combat assessment, radar deception, projectile firearms, laser guidance, target indication, precision bombing, interception and launch of tactical missiles and cruise missiles, and anti-armor, anti-radiation, and anti–naval vessel capabilities; as well as nuclear, chemical, and biological detection and operations. When the topic turns to leveraging new means of warfare, Chinese writings discuss the use of swarm systems (link in Chinese) for a number of purposes, with battlefield applications focusing on anti-submarine warfare and countering integrated air defense.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 2NC---Link

Turns the AFF: Military regulations destroys AI control by driving it underground, abroad, or into higher-risk areas

Watson 21 --- PhD in Engineering from the University of Gloucestershire, Degree in AGI Safety Fundamentals from the University of Cambridge, Senior Scientific Advisor to The Future Society at Harvard University, Fellow at the British Computing Society and Royal Statistical Society.

Dr. Nell, “Regulatory Challenges to Catastrophic AI Risk”, ExO Insight, 11/24/2021, https://insight.openexo.com/regulatory-challenges-to-ai/

Rick Increase Factors:

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 2NC---Link

It stifles the positive benefits of AI development.

Gürkaynak 18 --- Founding Partner of ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, LL.M. from Harvard Law School, İlay Yılmaz, Partner at ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law, and Güneş Haksever, LLM from Istanbul Bilgi University, Attorney at IBM Turkey.

Gönenç, “Stifling Artificial Intelligence: Human Perils”, Computer Law & Security Review, Volume 32, Issue 5, 12/12/2018, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3285264

Although scientists have calculated the significant positive welfare effects of Artificial Intelligence (AI), fear mongering continues to hinder AI development. If regulations in this sector stifle our active imagination, we risk wasting the true potential of AIs dynamic efficiencies. Not only would Schumpeter dislike us for spoiling creative destruction, but the AI thinkers of the future would also rightfully see our efforts as the ‘dark age’ of human advancement. This article provides a brief philosophical introduction to artificial intelligence; categorizes artificial intelligence to shed light on what we have and know now and what we might expect from the prospective developments; reflects thoughts of worldwide famous thinkers to broaden our horizons; provides information on the attempts to regulate artificial intelligence from a legal perspective; and discusses how the legal approach needs to be to ensure the balance between artificial intelligence development and human control over them, and to ensure friendly artificial intelligence.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 2NC---Link

Forcing all NATO countries to adhere to uniform ethical guidelines hamstrings innovation and the competitiveness of the DIB.

Castro & McLaughlin 19 --- *Vice President, ITIF, and Director, Center for Data Innovation. **Research Analyst Information Technology and Innovation Foundation

Daniel & Michael, 2-4-2019, "Ten Ways the Precautionary Principle Undermines Progress in Artificial Intelligence," ITIF, https://itif.org/publications/2019/02/04/ten-ways-precautionary-principle-undermines-progress-artificial-intelligence/

1. Slower and More Expensive AI Development

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 1NC---DA

Maintaining our innovative lead solves nuclear war

Kroenig and Gopalaswamy 18 – Associate Professor of Government and Foreign Service at Georgetown University and Deputy Director for Strategy in the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council; Director of the South Asia Center at the Atlantic Council

Matthew Kroenig and Bharath Gopalaswamy, "Will disruptive technology cause nuclear war?," Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 11-12-2018, 

Rather, we should think more broadly about how new technology might affect global politics, and, for this, it is helpful to turn to scholarly international relations theory. The dominant theory of the causes of war in the academy is the “bargaining model of war.” This theory identifies rapid shifts in the balance of power as a primary cause of conflict.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 1NC---DA

Continued AI innovation enables us to out-compete China.

Wheeler, visiting fellow in Governance Studies at The Brookings Institution, Chairman of the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) from 2013 to 2017, ‘20

(Tom, “Digital Competition With China Starts With Competition At Home,” )

The United States and China are engaged in a technology-based conflict to determine 21st-century international economic leadership. China’s approach is to identify and support the research and development efforts of a handful of “national champion” companies. The dominant tech companies of the U.S. are de facto embracing this Chinese policy in their effort to maintain domestic marketplace control. Rather than embracing a China-like consecration of a select few companies, America’s digital competition with China should begin with meaningful competition at home and the allAmerican reality that competition drives innovation.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Military Innovation DA › 1NC---DA

The AFF saps funding for AI research AND eliminates beneficial dual-use technology.

Castro & McLaughlin 19 --- *Vice President, ITIF, and Director, Center for Data Innovation. **Research Analyst Information Technology and Innovation Foundation

Daniel & Michael, 2-4-2019, "Ten Ways the Precautionary Principle Undermines Progress in Artificial Intelligence," ITIF, https://itif.org/publications/2019/02/04/ten-ways-precautionary-principle-undermines-progress-artificial-intelligence/

Many groups have started movements to ban lethal autonomous weapons—autonomous robotics systems that can independently identify and engage targets based on programmed constraints—due to fears that they will lead to armed conflict on a scale greater and faster than ever before. For example, 116 founders of mostly small robotics and AI companies, including Elon Musk, signed a letter to the United Nations (UN) in 2017 that urges the body to ban lethal autonomous weapons.36 In 2018, the UN Secretary-General António Guterres stated that “machines that have the power and the discretion to take human lives are politically unacceptable, are morally repugnant, and should be banned by international law.”37 Also in 2018, members of the European Parliament adopted a resolution asking member states and the European Council for “the start of international negotiations on a legally binding instrument prohibiting lethal autonomous weapons systems.”38 If policymakers enacted such a ban, it would slow research into AI, as historically, at least in the United States, defense agencies have been a source of significant funding for technology advancement, such as the Internet. And much of the research to support autonomous weapons would yield dual-use technology that could be used for commercial purposes. For example, a fully autonomous tank will likely rely on large portions of the same algorithms and data used to develop a fully autonomous military transport vehicle.39 These same algorithms would be relevant to developing autonomous vehicles for civilian use.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Case › AT: AI Impact---2NC

It's super far off and won’t be threatening

Dr. Oren Etzioni 16, Professor of Computer Science at the University of Washington, CEO of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence, Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University and BA from Harvard University, “No, the Experts Don’t Think Superintelligent AI is a Threat to Humanity”, MIT Technology Review, 9-20, https://www.technologyreview.com/s/602410/no-the-experts-dont-think-superintelligent-ai-is-a-threat-to-humanity/

If you believe everything you read, you are probably quite worried about the prospect of a superintelligent, killer AI. The Guardian, a British newspaper, warned recently that “we’re like children playing with a bomb,” and a recent Newsweek headline reads, “Artificial Intelligence Is Coming, and It Could Wipe Us Out.”

Numerous such headlines, fueled by comments from the likes of Elon Musk and Stephen Hawking, are strongly influenced by the work of one man: professor Nick Bostrom, author of the philosophical treatise Superintelligence: Paths, Dangers, and Strategies.

2022 Georgetown Affirmative
NEG › Case › AT: AI Impact---2NC

No runaway AI

Edward Moore Geist 15, MacArthur Nuclear Security Fellow at Stanford University's Center for International Security and Cooperation, Former Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the RAND Corporation, Doctorate in History from the University of North Carolina, “Is Artificial Intelligence Really An Existential Threat to Humanity?”, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 8-9, https://thebulletin.org/2015/08/is-artificial-intelligence-really-an-existential-threat-to-humanity/

Superintelligence: Paths, Dangers, Strategies is an astonishing book with an alarming thesis: Intelligent machines are “quite possibly the most important and most daunting challenge humanity has ever faced.” In it, Oxford University philosopher Nick Bostrom, who has built his reputation on the study of “existential risk,” argues forcefully that artificial intelligence might be the most apocalyptic technology of all. With intellectual powers beyond human comprehension, he prognosticates, self-improving artificial intelligences could effortlessly enslave or destroy Homo sapiens if they so wished. While he expresses skepticism that such machines can be controlled, Bostrom claims that if we program the right “human-friendly” values into them, they will continue to uphold these virtues, no matter how powerful the machines become.

These views have found an eager audience. In August 2014, PayPal cofounder and electric car magnate Elon Musk tweeted “Worth reading Superintelligence by Bostrom. We need to be super careful with AI. Potentially more dangerous than nukes.” Bill Gates declared, “I agree with Elon Musk and some others on this and don’t understand why some people are not concerned.” More ominously, legendary astrophysicist Stephen Hawking concurred: “I think the development of full artificial intelligence could spell the end of the human race.” Proving his concern went beyond mere rhetoric, Musk donated $10 million to the Future of Life Institute “to support research aimed at keeping AI beneficial for humanity.”