Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Alliance Fragmentation Advantage Answers › 1NC — Alliance Fragmentation Advantage Answers

3. Euro-Pacific Alignment Not Key To Counter China — Asian partners are sufficient, Europe’s military won’t help, and Europe is bogged down with Russia.

Bekkevold 22 — Jo Inge Bekkevold, Senior China Fellow at the Norwegian Institute for Defence Studies, former Political Officer and Minister Counsellor at the Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2022 (“NATO’s New Division of Labor on Russia and China Won’t Be Easy,” Foreign Policy, July 11th, Available Online at https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/07/11/nato-strategy-china-russia-threat-europe-asia-geopolitics/, Accessed 07-15-2022)

Nonetheless, even though the new Strategic Concept sends a strong signal of trans-Atlantic unity, it is too early to conclude that it enables a joint and well-coordinated U.S.-European approach on China. The reason for caution is geography. The U.S.-China rivalry presents NATO with a different challenge than the U.S.-Soviet one. During the Cold War, from its pivotal position in the Eurasian heartland, the Soviet Union constituted a threat to the entire Eurasian rim, from Europe all the way to the Far East, and it was a two-flank challenge to the United States. Europe was the core area of the Cold War strategic theater, and this consolidated not only a united threat perception among the United States and its European allies but also a common military strategy. China’s geographic position, on the other hand, does not preordain trans-Atlantic unity in a similar way.

Moving from strategy to policy implementing the Strategic Concept, the United States and European NATO members will find that the geopolitical logic of U.S.-China rivalry will shape a new, and not always easy, trans-Atlantic division of labor in three major ways.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Alliance Fragmentation Advantage Answers › 1NC — Alliance Fragmentation Advantage Answers

1. Status Quo Solves — the Madrid Summit confirmed closer cooperation between NATO and Asia-Pacific allies.

Legarda 22 — Helena Legarda, Lead Analyst at the Mercator Institute for China Studies—a German think tank, holds an M.P.P. in Public Policy from Harvard University, 2022 (“China and Russia Bring NATO and the Indo-Pacific Together,” Internationale Politik Quarterly, July 14th, Available Online at https://ip-quarterly.com/en/china-and-russia-bring-nato-and-indo-pacific-together, Accessed 07-14-2022)

The Indo-Pacific is a long way from Madrid, but at the most recent NATO summit held in the city, it played a very prominent role. The leaders of NATO’s four Indo-Pacific partners—the “Asia-Pacific Four” (AP4) South Korea, Japan, Australia, and New Zealand—were invited for the first time to attend this decisive summit, where allies endorsed a new Strategic Concept. This roadmap for NATO’s next decade maintains a strong focus on Russia as the most direct threat to the alliance, but it also addresses the “systemic challenges” posed by China, which is a first.

Despite the focus on Russia amid the ongoing war in Ukraine, the Indo-Pacific has now firmly entered the NATO horizon. China’s partnership with Russia, together with Beijing’s decision not to distance itself from Moscow after the invasion, have played a key role in highlighting the linkages between the European and Indo-Pacific theaters. This may lead to an increased presence of individual NATO allies in the Indo-Pacific, in cooperation with regional partners—an outcome that China had sought to prevent.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “Status Quo Solves”

The status quo is sufficient to beat Russia and China.

Gill 22 — Jaspreet Gill, Defense Networks and Emerging Tech Reporter at Breaking Defense, 2022 (“NATO leaders establish new €1B innovation fund, accelerator,” Breaking Defense, June 30th, Available Online at https://breakingdefense.com/2022/06/nato-leaders-establish-new-e1b-innovation-fund-accelerator/, Accessed 07-03-2022)

NATO leaders this week launched a new innovation fund and defense innovation accelerator initiative in an effort to stay ahead of technological advancements and cyber challenges posed by Russia and China.

Jens Stoltenberg, NATO secretary general, said today during a signing ceremony at the close of the alliance’s Madrid Summit the first-of-its-kind fund will invest €1 billion in startups and deep-tech funds across 22 participating nations over the next 15 years.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “Status Quo Solves”

Status quo NIF and DIANA programs are sufficient — and the U.S. is providing enough support.

Harper 22 — Jon Harper, Managing Editor of DefenseScoop—FedScoop’s publication covering the Pentagon and military technology, 2022 (“New $1B NATO innovation fund will back wide range of emerging tech,” FedScoop, June 30th, Available Online at https://www.fedscoop.com/new-1-billion-nato-innovation-fund-will-back-wide-range-of-emerging-technology/, Accessed 07-04-2022)

NATO leaders on Thursday officially launched a $1 billion innovation fund that will invest in companies working on a slew of dual-use technologies with great military potential.

Billed as the world’s first “multi-sovereign” venture capital fund involving 22 nations, it is intended to make long-term investments in startups and other entities developing emerging technologies that the alliance is interested in including artificial intelligence, autonomy, big-data processing, quantum-enabled technologies, biotechnology and human enhancement; novel materials; energy; propulsion and space.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › 1NC — Status Quo Solves [Be Careful!]

Status Quo Solves —

Pons 22 — Juan Pons, Contributor at Atalayar (a Spanish magazine) and Hispaviación (a Spanish publication covering the aviation industry), Retired Colonel in the Spanish Army, former Colonel Director of the Military School of Educational Sciences of the Spanish Ministry of Defense, former Professor of Communication and International Relations at the Spanish General Military Academy, 2022 (“Disruptive dual-use technologies, a major focus of NATO's new Strategic Concept,” Atalayar, June 30th, Available Online at https://atalayar.com/en/content/disruptive-dual-use-technologies-major-focus-natos-new-strategic-concept, Accessed 07-03-2022)

An important line of action taken by NATO risks going almost unnoticed because it is not clearly and explicitly included in the Strategic Concept that the 30 leaders of NATO countries have just approved in Madrid.

But it is implicitly included in the text of the document that will guide transatlantic affairs over the next decade. It is an initiative to reinforce the defence organisation's commitment to science, industry and cutting-edge technologies, a crucial way to maintain superiority in the face of the threat posed by Russia and the challenge from China.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “AI Not Key To Military Power”

The AI technology itself is not key to military power—it is how it is used.

Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from )

Military and economic history suggests that the effect of narrow AI could be quite large, even if suggestions of AI triggering a new industrial revolution are overstated. Adoption capacity theory shows that changes in relative military power become more likely in cases of military innovations that require large organizational changes and the adoption of new operational concepts. Even if the United States, China, and Russia were to end up with similar levels of basic AI capacity over the next decade, the history of military innovations from the phalanx to blitzkrieg suggests it is how they and others use AI that will matter most for the future of military power.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “AI Not Key To Military Power”

Competition for AI technology will be multilateral and not bilateral.

Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from )

The commercial drivers of AI technology, and the speed with which new algorithms diffuse, would make competition much broader than it was during the bilateral space race. Competition is much more likely to be multilateral, featuring countries and companies around the world. A better analogy might be to the competition surrounding the development of Second Industrial Revolution technologies in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. France, Germany, Britain, Japan, the United States, and others vied for supremacy in steel production, chemicals, petroleum, electricity, and other areas.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “AI Not Key To Military Power”

Technological innovation rarely influences the balance of power.

Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from )

Decades of research demonstrates that the impact of technological change on global politics — whether it is change in economics, society at large, diplomacy, or military power — depends much more on how governments and organizations make choices about the adoption and use of new capabilities than on the technologies themselves.48 Scholarship on military innovation by Barry Posen, Stephen P. Rosen, and others shows that technological innovation alone rarely shapes the balance of power.49 Instead, it is how militaries use a technology that makes a difference.50 A military’s ability to employ a technology depends in part on the complexity of the technology, how difficult it is to use, and whether it operates in predictable and explainable ways. These factors influence the trust that senior military leaders have in the technology and whether they use it.51 Additionally, the more bureaucratically disruptive it is to adopt a technology, the more challenging it can be for older, more established organizations to do so — particularly if the organization is underinvested in research and development designed to integrate new technologies and ideas.52

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “AI Not Key To Military Power”

Agile bureaucracies, not the best technology, will win the global tech competition race.

Rob Murray, 9/1/2020 (head of the Innovation Unit in NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division, “Building a resilient innovation pipeline for the Alliance,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from )

Today, NATO’s competition is a global one and the race is one of technological adoption – that is, the acceptance, integration and use of new technology in society. From artificial intelligence to quantum and everything in between, governments are in a race to leverage these technologies at scale and speed – first adopter advantage for emerging disruptive tech could not be more prevalent in the world of geopolitics and deterrence. Indeed, the nations that win this race may be those with the most agile bureaucracy rather those with the best technology.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

The OECD solves the case—they have agreed to support the responsible and ethical approach to AI.

John R. Allen, 3/24/2021 (President of the Brookings Institution, “It is time to negotiate global treaties on artificial intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)

The good news is there are some international entities that already are working on these issues. For example, the Global Partnership on Artificial Intelligence is a group of more than a dozen democratic nations that have agreed to “support the responsible and human-centric development and use of AI in a manner consistent with human rights, fundamental freedoms, and our shared democratic values.” This community of democracies is run by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development and features high-level convenings, research, and technical assistance.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

The US leads in the AI tech race now.

Neil Savage, 12/9/2020 (Neil Savage is a science writer based in Lowell, Massachusetts, “The race to the top among the world’s leaders in artificial intelligence,” , Retrieved 8/20/2021)

As nations vie for leadership, AI research output is increasing rapidly. According to our analysis of journal publications and conference papers tracked by the Dimensions database, the global output for AI research grew from just over 52,000 globally in 2000 to roughly 403,000 in 2019, representing an increase of more than 600%. Now the most popular specialization among computer-science PhD students in North America, AI is set to continue its steep, upward trajectory. Rising revenues The United States has historically been the leader in AI-related research output, having accumulated the highest number of publications over the past two decades. But China has ramped up its output in recent years. In each year from 2016 to 2019, China produced more AI-related papers than any other nation, according to Dimensions. Over this period, China’s output of AI-related research increased by just over 120%, whereas output in the US increased by almost 70%. In 2019, China published 102,161 AI-related papers, and the US published 74,386. India, which came in third, published 23,398. Publication numbers aren’t the whole story, says Jeffrey Ding, a PhD student at the Future of Humanity Institute at the University of Oxford, UK, who studies China’s AI strategy. In the AI Index Report, which uses citation numbers to measure the quality of AI papers, papers from China were cited about 20% less than the world average in 2019, whereas papers from the US were cited about 40% more than average. “Just pumping out raw numbers of papers that don’t have a lasting impact isn’t really useful,” says Ding. “It’s more important to keep up with the technology frontier.” A Nature Index analysis for this supplement looked at the number of AI-related articles published in the 82 high-quality natural-science journals tracked by the index, which primarily concern the application of AI to research in the broad fields of chemistry, the physical sciences, life sciences, and Earth and environmental sciences. Between 2015 and 2019, the US was the leader, with the UK, Germany and China in second, third and fourth place, respectively. But China has increased its output in journals tracked by the index. Although it was the fourth-most prolific country in the index in 2015, with roughly half as many AI-related papers as Germany, China crept up over the next three years, then leapt to second place in 2019, showing an increase of 340%. The US, UK and Germany slightly more than doubled their output over the same period. For the near future, Ding says, the US is likely to remain the world leader in AI. “Though China has some exceptional universities, such as Tsinghua University, the US dominates in terms of maybe the top 20 universities doing AI research, and that is reflected in the quality of the papers. It’s very unlikely that China will become the singular innovation centre by 2030.” Many countries see AI as providing a competitive edge, not only economically, but militarily, says Husain. He likens the competition in AI to the Space Race of the mid-twentieth century, in which the US and the Soviet Union vied to be the first to achieve milestones in space travel. “The Space Race yielded contributions that differentiated the American technological ecosystem from all others for decades to come,” says Husain. “If a country invests heavily in this area, it will yield technologies that will form the pillar of defence capability and economic differentiation for the rest of the century.” Technologies that can be developed based on AI will indeed have both economic and military benefit, says Daniel Araya, a policy analyst at the Center for International Governance Innovation, a think tank in Ontario, Canada. “We’re talking new weapons, data-driven innovation for industry and automation, and redesigning how our society works from the ground up.” Husain points to Germany, which maintains a strong economy that relies on exports of products such as machine parts and automobiles, even though lower-income countries can provide low-wage labour for manufacturing. Germany has been able to compete by using automation to keep manufacturing costs down, while keeping quality and productivity high. AI could reinforce this advantage by powering the next generation of automation technologies. “Anybody that has mastery over this technology and is investing in implementing it retains an economic lead,” says Husain. Institutions in Germany, such as the Fraunhofer Society, Europe’s largest application-oriented research organization, have been emphasizing Industry 4.0, a national strategic initiative from the German government to introduce more digital innovation and advanced robotics into manufacturing and supply-chain management. In China, the ability offered by AI systems to monitor public spaces and scan Internet traffic in an effort to glean user intentions may provide the state with improved tools for social control, enhancing its capability for monitoring the population or censoring information. Even in countries that don’t officially track their populaces, facial-recognition technology, such as that produced by New York-based company, Clearview AI, is being used by law enforcement to identify suspects. The technology has been met with deep concern by some researchers, who say that biases built into its algorithms could result in ethical and human rights abuses. Amid the controversy that surrounds certain applications of AI, some groups are highlighting the good it can do. In 2019, the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence, a scientific society in Menlo Park, California, launched its Artificial Intelligence for the Benefit of Humanity award, a US$1-million prize funded by Squirrel AI, an education technology company based in Shanghai, China. The inaugural winner, Regina Barzilay from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in Cambridge, Massachusetts, received the award in September 2020 for developing a machine-learning algorithm that can examine mammograms and predict which women are at a higher risk of breast cancer. Barzilay has also developed a pattern-recognition algorithm that predicts which molecules might make good candidates for new medications. Publishing in the journal Cell, Barzilay and her colleagues described how their system identified a molecule, dubbed halicin, as a potentially potent new antibiotic (J. M. Stokes et al. Cell 180, 688–702; 2020). When the molecule was synthesized and tested, it was found to kill antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Barzilay continues to work on halicin and hopes to progress it to clinical trials. Money to spend With an eye to the potential benefits of AI-based technologies, the US National Science Foundation (NSF) announced in August 2020 that it is establishing five new institutes focused on different topics, each led by a different university, and each to receive $20 million over five years. One, led by the University of Oklahoma in Norman, will use AI systems to improve climate forecasting accuracy. Another, at the University of Texas at Austin, will focus on the next generation of machine-learning algorithms. A third, led by the University of Colorado Boulder, will apply AI technologies to teaching and learning. The fourth, headed by the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, will explore the discovery and synthesis of new materials and drugs using AI systems. And a fifth, led by MIT, will investigate how AI can improve research in fundamental physics. The NSF has put out a call for proposals for eight more AI institutes, which it plans to announce next year. “We have a long history of supporting basic research in artificial intelligence,” says Erwin Gianchandani, the NSF’s deputy assistant director for computer and information science and engineering. In addition, the US Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture has committed to funding another two institutes each with $20 million over five years to apply AI to questions of crop yield, pest resistance and food distribution. Access to massive data sets on which to train machine-learning systems is one advantage that both the US and China have, says Araya. Europe, on the other hand, has stringent data laws, which protect people’s privacy, but limit its resources for training AI algorithms. “So, it seems unlikely that Europe will produce very sophisticated AI as a consequence,” he says. “China is at the opposite end of the spectrum, where it has few data protections, and huge access to varied and diverse pieces of data.” The NSF doesn’t make decisions based on global competition, says Rebecca Keiser, the organization’s first chief of research security strategy and policy. Her position is designed to safeguard the security of federally funded research, while promoting international collaborations. “We think of it more in terms of the impact that our funding is going to have, rather than from a nation perspective. The fact that it also contributes to US global science leadership is fabulous,” says Keiser. As for competing against China in AI, she says, “We don’t really know how much, and where, they’re investing, so it’s hard to compete against that.” With funding from other major US agencies, including the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency and National Institutes of Health, the US government expected to spend almost $5 billion on unclassified AI research in 2020. Other countries are investing, too. The UK’s Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council gave out nearly £160 million (US$212 million) in 2020. The European Commission, which has been supporting research through its Horizon 2020 programme, says public and private investment in AI should reach €20 billion (US$23 billion) across Europe by the end of 2020. Even with other countries placing emphasis on AI research, including Israel, Japan, Singapore and Australia, the race comes down to China versus the US, Araya says. The refinement of AI systems is driven not simply by academic questions, but by applying the systems’ intelligence to practical problems. Countries will probably make advances by using AI in areas where they already have expertise, says Ding, such as automation in Germany or robotics in Japan. Having so many researchers around the globe tackling all aspects of AI should advance the whole field, says Keiser. “It’s always good to have a bit of healthy competition.”

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

Even if America were to share capabilities, allies still lags behind

Sapolsky and Gholz 18 — Harvey M. Sapolsky, Professor Emeritus at MIT, the former Director of the MIT Security Studies Program, M.P.A. and Ph.D. in Political Economy and Government at Harvard University, Eugene Gholz, associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, served in the Pentagon as Senior Advisor to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Manufacturing and Industrial Base Policy, former chair of the international security section of the International Studies Association, 2022 (“Calm Down, Folks: Enemies Still Fear US Military Tech Innovation,” Defense One, May 17th, Available Online at https://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2018/05/us-military-innovation-doing-just-fine-thanks/148287/)

U.S. investment has created a thick infrastructure of laboratories, test facilities, technology development centers, and program analysis units that is unmatched anywhere. It includes government agencies, universities, and firms, and it involves the efforts of hundreds of thousands of individuals. It is an amazing system, devoted entirely to developing better weapons, better ways of killing with advanced technologies.

Three uniquely American factors drive the system. First, there is inter-service rivalry. Most nations have a dominant service, their army or their navy, determined by their geography. The United States, a continent away from troubles, has rivalrous services, each vying for prominence and pushing for technologies that further its role as America’s best defender. Despite pledges of jointness, we have several armies (the Army, Marine Corps, Special Operations), several air forces (the Air Force, Navy, Army, Marine Corps), and a Navy and a half (Coast Guard), and we have just added a Cyber Force and are talking about a Space Force. Decentralization and competition spur innovation.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

The U.S. is currently winning the AI race against China.

JAMES COOPER AND KASHYAP KOMPELLA 02/03/22 (OPINION CONTRIBUTORS, https://www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/news-updates/2021/06/10/the-biden-administration-launches-the-national-artificial-intelligence-research-resource-task-force/, “No, China is not winning the AI race”, Retrieved 2/23/22)

The global competition between the United States and China continues apace. Technology is rightly seen as providing unique leverage to win this geopolitical race. The U.S. long has been the global technology powerhouse, but not surprisingly, we have heard much about the Chinese government’s  high-tech industries such as 5G telecommunications, autonomous vehicles, blockchain, and semiconductor chips.  In this light, as a horizontal technology that can be applied across all sectors, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a strategic priority and the  on superiority in this field is touted as something about which the U.S. should be concerned. Some have gone so far as to conclude that . Don’t believe the hype. To be sure, the availability of large amounts of data is at the heart of AI success. It is tempting to think that less-democratic regimes that amass huge amounts of data about their citizens and have scant regard for privacy can develop better AI systems using that data. However, all other things being equal, better and higher quality AI systems emerge from countries with strong data privacy and data protection regulations because AI systems must undergo greater scrutiny during their development and deployment.  of this can be seen in the United States regarding fair lending practices and consumer protection from credit bureaus. Further, the market for AI is global, and such high-quality AI systems find buyers in other countries as well. Around the globe, Big Tech’s rising power has resulted in calls for more oversight. In a drastic move that stunned the industry and analysts alike, the Chinese government  the rulebook for the country’s technology industry. In effect, China is vacating entire swaths of digital and creative industries, arenas that serve as training grounds and talent factories for other industries. This more restrictive approach may not bode well for China’s AI industry in the long term. China may find itself constrained on the extent of automation and AI in its manufacturing sector — labor-intensive manufacturing remains China’s main strength, and a high degree of automation can result in job losses, labor unrest, and instability. Meanwhile, there is bipartisan support for AI in the United States. Former  proposed  for AI development through the National Science Foundation. The  of 2020 signaled a sense of urgency and suggested that several federal agencies create a national strategy on artificial intelligence. The Biden administration has formed the Artificial Intelligence Research Resource Task Force to develop a roadmap to foment AI research and spark innovation nationwide. There is draft legislation, at both the state and federal level, to promote responsible use of AI and prevent its misuse. Strong objections to the use of facial recognition and other AI systems by law enforcement in the U.S., raised by civil liberties advocates, have led some local authorities, such as the City of San Francisco, to . To use a Silicon Valley phrase, these debates are “not a bug, but a feature.” They shine a light on the limitations of AI systems and help to set the “rules of the road” for proper use of AI. This will establish the U.S. as a global leader in AI regulation, once lawmakers and regulators do their work. China, meanwhile, has faced strong  for using facial recognition software to  in its Xinjiang region. China has outlined a set of , but the jury is still out on enforcement and how they function in practice. The increasing number of AI research papers and  by Chinese researchers is often cited as proof that China has caught up with the United States in this field. The increased focus is good for the Chinese AI ecosystem, and it will help them solve China-specific problems. But dominance in this emerging strategic industry is not guaranteed. The U.S. has several strategic advantages, including: the strengths of its higher education and research institutes, which attract the best STEM talent from across the world; the ; and the largest number of technology unicorns (start-ups with private valuations greater than $1 billion).  Beijing says Taiwan is 'not Ukraine,' has always been part of China Big Tech allies point to China, Russia threat in push to squash... China is not overtaking the U.S. in artificial intelligence. The current evidence and trajectory paint a clear picture: The conditions for AI to flourish, such as incentives to experiment, freedom to pursue opportunities without restrictions, and the coming guardrails to prevent misuse, favor U.S. leadership. This is still the United States’s game to lose — though maybe both countries could win through collaboration. To solve planet-scale problems such as climate change, we are going to need AI solutions from both competitors. 

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

Allied open democracies are better for innovation than other forms of government.

Rob Murray, 9/1/2020 (head of the Innovation Unit in NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division, “Building a resilient innovation pipeline for the Alliance,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from )

The reason is simple: the competition and creativity generated by start-ups is good for the Allied defence ecosystem. Allied open democracies and open educational models bring about levels of creativity which other forms of government are unable to do. This maximises disruptive innovation efforts and, as such, forces incumbents (large companies) to compete with new, fresh thinking – it builds resilience.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › Extend: “U.S. Wins Tech Race Now”

It’s all political — current weapons are enough

Sapolsky and Gholz 18 — Harvey M. Sapolsky, Professor Emeritus at MIT, the former Director of the MIT Security Studies Program, M.P.A. and Ph.D. in Political Economy and Government at Harvard University, Eugene Gholz, associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, served in the Pentagon as Senior Advisor to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Manufacturing and Industrial Base Policy, former chair of the international security section of the International Studies Association, 2022 (“Calm Down, Folks: Enemies Still Fear US Military Tech Innovation,” Defense One, May 17th, Available Online at https://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2018/05/us-military-innovation-doing-just-fine-thanks/148287/)

The complaints that the United States is falling behind are part of the political process. So are new government organizations like the Defense Innovation Unit – Experimental. Because we already have the best weapons, proponents for new systems must claim that we are failing and need new initiatives. That is how they gain their budgets. And just as we have a thick infrastructure to develop weapons, we have also a thick network of threat assessors worrying that we aren’t worried enough

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › 1NC — RMA Advantage Answers

3. China Won’t Win The EDT Race — it’s too dependent on foreign innovation.

Frey and Osborne 20 — Carl Benedikt Frey, Oxford Martin Citi Fellow, Future of Work Director at the Oxford Martin School at Oxford University, author of The Technology Trap: Capital, Labor, and Power in the Age of Automation, Michael Osborne, Professor of Machine Learning at the University of Oxford, a Fellow at the Oxford Martin School, Co-Founder of Mind Foundry an organization which has a mission to enable Humans and AI to work together to solve the world’s most important problems, 2022 (“China Won’t Win the Race for AI Dominance,” Foreign Affairs, June 19th, Available Online at https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/united-states/2020-06-19/china-wont-win-race-ai-dominance)

Decentralized experimentation and decision-making will likewise be critical if the world is to harness the benefits of artificial intelligence. China is at a disadvantage in this regard. The country’s recent surge in patent filings is often cited as evidence of its innovativeness, but simply counting patents isn’t a good way to measure innovation: studies show that ten percent of patents account for roughly 90 percent of total patent value, meaning that the vast majority are of little value. Patent citations offer a more useful indicator, and if we look at the 100 most cited patents since 2003, not a single one comes from China. Moreover, China’s leading artificial intelligence companies, including Tencent, Alibaba, and Baidu, are merely copies of Facebook, Amazon, and Google, tailored to the Chinese market.

As the late economic historian Alexander Gerschenkron observed, when a country lags behind the technological frontier, imitation and the adoption of foreign technology can take it a long way—and, in general, the further a country has fallen behind, the greater the role the state must play in driving industrial catch-up. Thanks to state investment in mass production technology, the Soviet Union grew rapidly during much of the Cold War, as did Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan. Indeed, numerous scholars have attributed the “Asian Miracle” to state-driven industrial catch-up. But while they were successful in closing some of the gap, these countries never managed to overtake the United States. Unlike imitation, which can be planned and coordinated, innovation is a voyage of exploration into the unknown, to paraphrase the economist and philosopher Friedrich von Hayek. And switching from imitation to innovation is hard: if it were easy, most countries would be innovating at the technological frontier.

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › 1NC — RMA Advantage Answers

2. AI Not Key To Military Power — it has no current military applications.

Horowitz 18 — Michael C. Horowitz, professor of political science and the associate director of Perry World House at the University of Pennsylvania, received the 2017 Karl Deutsch Award from the International Studies Association presented annually to a scholar under age 40 who is judged to have made the most significant contribution to the study of international relations and peace research, 2022 (“Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Texas National Security Review, May, Available Online at https://tnsr.org/2018/05/artificial-intelligence-international-competition-and-the-balance-of-power/#article)

It is important to distinguish these potential technological innovations from military innovations. While military innovations are often linked to changes in technology,41 it is not always the case. Military innovations are significant changes in organizational behavior and ways that a military fights that are designed to increase its ability to effectively translate capabilities into power.42 The use of aircraft carriers as mobile airfields by the United States and Japan is a prototypical example. While AI could potentially enable a number of military innovations, it is not a military innovation itself, and no applications of AI have been used in ways that would count as a military innovation at this point.

Because AI research and technology are still in their early stages, usage of AI in warfare is not even yet analogous to the first use of the tank in World War I, let alone effective use of combined arms warfare by the Germans in World War II (the military innovation now known as blitzkrieg). This limits analyses about how narrow AI might one day affect the balance of power and international politics. Most research on technology and international politics focuses on specific, mature technologies, such as nuclear weapons, or on military innovations.43

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › RMA Advantage Answers › 1NC — RMA Advantage Answers

1. U.S. Wins Tech Race Now — it won’t fall behind in defense R&D.

Sapolsky and Gholz 21— Harvey M. Sapolsky, Professor Emeritus at MIT, the former Director of the MIT Security Studies Program, M.P.A. and Ph.D. in Political Economy and Government at Harvard University, Eugene Gholz, associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, served in the Pentagon as Senior Advisor to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Manufacturing and Industrial Base Policy, former chair of the international security section of the International Studies Association, 2022 (“The defense innovation machine: Why the U.S. will remain on the cutting edge,” Journal of Strategic Defense, June 24th, Available Online at https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01402390.2021.1917392)

It is not that the United States cannot lag behind in some fields of militarily relevant technology or be surprised on the battlefield. Technology advances on many fronts and is pioneered in many places. Technological investment by potential adversaries surely can raise the costs to the United States of blithely sticking to operational concepts that previously promised great effectiveness at low cost.8 However, the United States has been mobilized on such scale, for so long, with a special emphasis on applying its vast science and engineering resources to its defense, that it will not readily fall behind in weapons technology or quality.

The United States invests heavily in defense-related research and development (R&D) activities. Figure 1 shows the past 40 years of history of U.S. inputs to defense research and development. Currently the United States invests more than 75 billion USD each year in defense R&D plus billions more in Department of Energy R&D investment for nuclear weapons. That is about two-thirds of what all other countries in the world, American friend or foe, spend on defense R&D.9 China is the only great power that spends more on its entire defense effort than the United States spends on just defense R&D. Seventy-five billion dollars is more than Russia, the United Kingdom, France, Germany, or Japan spends on defense.10

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Unilateral/Domestic CP › 1NC — Unilateral/Domestic Innovation CP

The other planks solve EDT competition — focus on basic research is key to operationalizing future EDT benefits

“war for talent”

Avoids DoD O/S DA because the NSIC will provide a budget report to congress – that means its priced in all the time

NSIC solves businesses not wanting to invest in basic research – clarifies what the government wants to fund, giving stability to pursue it

2022 SDI Negative
Emerging Tech Innovation Negative › Unilateral/Domestic CP › 1NC — Unilateral/Domestic Innovation CP

The first plank solves EDT innovation and tech leadership — dual-path budgetary reform is key.

Zakheim 21 (Dov S. Zakheim, senior advisor at the CSIS, vice chairman of the board for the Foreign Policy Research Institute, former undersecretary of Defense and CFO for the DOD; "Reform the Pentagon’s budget process, or lose our military and tech advantages", 4-2-2021, The Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/546097-reform-the-pentagons-budget-process-or-lose-our-military-and-tech-advantages/, DOA: 7-15-2022)//ATJ

What do artificial intelligence, quantum computing, the Defense Innovation Unit and reprogramming requirements have to do with one another? The answer is, “Everything.” For unless both Congress and Department of Defense (DOD) seriously reform the manner in which they move funds from one appropriations account to another, the DOD’s ability to introduce new technologies rapidly will be seriously compromised — and with it, potentially, the nation’s defenses.

The development and fielding of new technologies involve a considerable amount of risk. Not all programs that are attractive on paper actually will succeed in the laboratory. Not all that succeed when subjected to developmental testing will succeed when put to the operational test. The earlier a potential cutting-edge program is determined unlikely to succeed, the sooner its funds should be transferred to a different program, via a system termed “reprogramming.” Unfortunately, congressional restrictions render it exceedingly difficult to transfer funds from one new program to another with any degree of alacrity.