Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Kritik
AFF Answers › Author Indicts

Balko is biased!

McMichael 16 (Christopher, PhD in Politics from Rhodes University, research include organized crime, Libertarian Marxism, and Fascism, “Pacification and Police: A critique of the Police Militarization Thesis,” November 29 2016, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0309816816678569)

 Strikingly, and little commented on by liberal or leftist outlets, some of the most vocal proponents of the ‘militarization’ thesis (at least within the context of the United States) have been from the Libertarian Right. An article published by the Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) portrays the disturbing arrival of a ‘new breed of cop’ with a ‘military mentality’ (), while an essay in the journal of the Independent Institute claims that a long standing separation between the domestic police and military functions of the US government has been irrevocably breached (: 501). By far the most influential advocate of the militarization doctrine is Radley Balko, a former writer and analyst for libertarian institutions Reason Magazine and the Cato Institute, the latter of which has intimate ties with the powerful Koch Brothers, who have also increasingly become concerned with police reform. Balko, currently of the Huffington Post, is a prolific and outspoken journalist, who has written countless media articles and policy reports and two books on the subject: Overkill: The Rise of Paramilitary Police Raids in America () and the more recent Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America’s Police Forces ().  maintains that domestic law enforcement has become dangerously invasive: ‘Americans have long maintained that a man’s home is his castle and that he has the right to defend it from unlawful intruders. Unfortunately, that right may be disappearing’ (p. iv). His main contention is that such tactics have encouraged a dangerous blurring between the police and military, in which the police work of protecting public safety is confused with the military work of seeking and destroying enemies (: 15). Despite Balko’s work focusing primarily on the United States, it has transcended its North American trappings, with his work referenced in a report prepared by the South African government, which called for the ‘demilitarization’ of the national police force (: 392). Although his work is often cited in progressive or radical publications, Balko’s politics are squarely on the right: getting his start with Fox News, and then working long stints for Republican Party aligned think tanks, calling for the privatization of social welfare and prisons and, of course, defending the public influence of the Koch Brothers ().

2022 Michigan Kritik
AFF Answers › 2ac – Small States

If not already, aff increases coordination and quality of life for smaller states

James Jay, 8-10-2018, "Why Small States Matter to Big Powers," National Interest, https://nationalinterest.org/feature/why-small-states-matter-big-powers-28362//CDMoney

Building Bridges to Small Nations The United States has an inherent advantage over adversarial powers in partnering with small nations. China and Russia don’t have allies. They have underlings. No country wants to be a suburb of Beijing or Moscow. America, however, has to up its game. Here is a ten-step process to get the job done. Step 1. Set the Right Objectives for Friends. In reducing vulnerabilities of friends, allies and strategic partners to adversarial influences, American objectives should be framed less in driving particular political outcomes or agendas (e.g., promoting marriage equality) than in achieving good stable governance, strong institutions and a reduction in corruption. This will make our partners more resilient and self-confident. Step 2. Avoid Us-or-Them-ism. The goal of a small-state strategy is not to exclude adversarial competitors. For example, America can’t ask countries not to do business with China. After all, the United States does business with China. The goal is not to get countries to takes sides but to engage and help them act consistent with their own interests—eschewing, for instance, economic engagement detrimental to national security or that undermines the rule of law and good governance. Step 2. Promote Economic Freedom. China and Russia can buy influence because, in poor nations with weak governance, a little money goes a long far. The best way to make these states more resistant to malicious influence is to help them become wealthier and better governed. This is best accomplished by promoting economic freedom. Step 3. Enter Free Trade Agreements (FTA). Trade agreements fundamentally have to be about liberalizing trade and making markets freer. That said, prioritizing agreements with states where the United States is seeking friendship, and common cause makes sense. America, for example, ought to have an FTA with Tunisia. Step 4. Be There. In many small, like-minded nations, all the United States has to do to win friends is, simply, to be there. Too much American engagement rests on foreign assistance and not enough on building human-to-human relationships and a more robust presence by the U.S. private sector.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AFF Answers › 2ac – Small States

NATO and the US have a vested interest in protecting and incorporating smaller states

James Jay, 8-10-2018, "Why Small States Matter to Big Powers," National Interest, https://nationalinterest.org/feature/why-small-states-matter-big-powers-28362//CDMoney

Nobody is bigger than the United States of America. No big power more appreciates small powers. No small state will find a better friend than the United States. In an era of great power competition, “small” matters a good deal. Little nations are not sand to be ground between the great wheels of major powers. They are made up of people, not pawns. Citizens in small states have the same hopes, aspirations and natural rights as those in world powers. These people have every reason to expect and demand a life of freedom, peace and prosperity. Further, it is in the interests of bigger states to help small states flourish. Great powers, if wise, will support the best hopes of smaller states. There are three reasons why the United States, in particular, ought to take small states seriously. Sonovia 1. Geography Matters. In geopolitics—as in real estate—a critical consideration is “location, location, location.” To a major power, a country’s greatest asset might be its map coordinates rather than the size of its arsenal or bank account. Geography matters when it comes to economic integration, transportation, energy distribution and physical security. Even in a digitized world, the freedom to move people, goods, and services across physical space is a valuable commodity. Recognizing the importance of connecting dots on the ground is not an argument for hardened spheres of control (such as during the Cold War) or carving up the world (like seventeenth-century mercantilists). On the other hand, there is a case to be made for building bridges between like-minded nations that want to live together with surety in commerce and share peaceful borders. Thus, a small state in the right place can be very important to a big power. Iceland is a case in point. Even though it has no armed forces, the island’s location makes the nation a lynchpin in transatlantic security. That’s the reason Iceland was included as one of twelve founding members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Without question, Iceland’s strategic location is of far greater importance to U.S. security than the state’s size and resources would suggest. Washington should be working hard to make that bilateral relationship even stronger. Part of the reason NATO continues to keep the membership door open is because there are nations still not included whose accession would enhance collective security due to their location. These include Macedonia, Georgia, Ukraine and Kosovo. And there are states in other regions where stronger bilateral relations would greatly serve U.S. interests. Closer ties with Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, for example, would further U.S. efforts to sustain a free and open Indo-Pacific. In the Middle East, few states are smaller than Jordan. Yet, a peaceful, prosperous Jordan is a keystone for regional stability, and regional stability is a vital interest of the United States—as important to this administration as it should have been to the last one. Similarly, Tunisia is an important state for extending an umbrella of regional stability in the greater Middle East to North Africa. 2. Freedom Matters. Like-minded nations make better partners. One of the reasons NATO works is because the alliance is a partnership of free nation-states. The foundational rationale of the transatlantic alliance is that free states have the right to associate for the purpose of collective security. To close NATO’s open door would undermine what NATO stands for: the right of free peoples to choose their future.

2022 Michigan Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Militarization Good

Militarization is key to Russia deterrence

Sherr 17 (Sherr, James. “Policy Implications.” The Militarization of Russian Policy, German Marshall Fund of the United States, 2017, pp. 15–17. JSTOR, ) // OA

Since February 2014, NATO Allies have become increasingly aware of Russia’s determination to disrupt the cohesion of the West as we have come to define it. However, doubts persist about the degree of strategic thinking that motivates its policy. The picture we have presented not only outlines a strategic framework. It delineates, even by Russian standards, an unusual degree of integration between the political objectives of the state and the expansion of its military power. That expansion is not a Brownian motion. It is a coherent and purpose-driven activity designed to challenge Western dominance of an international order that Russia’s state leadership perceives as harmful to its interests and intrinsically vulnerable. For understandable reasons, many in the West are also addressing the critical question of how our own policy tools might be used to change Russian mindsets and perceptions. But the underlying challenge, much as Putin has aggravated it, is not Russian perceptions, but its interests. And, where European security is concerned, Moscow’s interests can be expected to diverge from ours in significant respects even if Putin is replaced by a successor with different priorities. The more immediate challenge is to change Western mindsets rather than Russian ones. Our homo economicus, business school metrics do not explain very much about Putin’s Russia. State mobilization might impose serious diseconomies on an already overburdened resource base. But as long as it continues, it continues and produces consequences that NATO needs to confront and counter. Those who believe that compromise, vigorous dialogue, or neorealist grand bargains will resolve our differences have been neither watching nor listening. Dialogue will never be more effective than the policy underpinning it. Angela Merkel’s exhaustive discussions with Vladimir Putin have provided useful reinforcement to a moderately tough policy. John Kerry’s indefatigable dialogue with Sergey Lavrov over Syria only amplified weakness. The Kremlin is willing to match us in talking as well as fighting. Its curt and pre-emptive rejection of a grand bargain with the United States at the start of the Trump administration is telling in itself. Russia expects material changes to the structure of international relations and is determined to press its perceived advantages until concessions are forced upon us. The only way to diminish the threats Russia poses is to diminish these advantages. Once that imperative is accepted, we will find that the news is not all that bad. Time does not favor Russia. True enough, Russia has defied repeated Western forecasts about the unsustainability of its economic model. Low oil prices and Western sanctions have brought its proverbial coping mechanisms and organizational ingenuity to the fore. Nevertheless, Russia’s economy is in decline, its technological base is stagnant, and the mobilization reflex merely postpones the day when its structural problems are either addressed or wreak vengeance. Thus, the West has good grounds for strategic patience. However, time is not a strategic actor. It has to be used. For strategic patience to bear fruit, there must be a strategy as well as patience. Deterrence is only a strategy if it addresses the threat to be deterred. As serious students of Russian strategy have noted, war with Russia means war with all of Russia. Yet the war Russia is preparing to fight has limited objectives: to shatter the cohesion of NATO, destroy its forces in the operational theater, and force it to concede defeat at the earliest possible moment. Without confidence in these outcomes, Russia will not go to war. The aim of NATO’s deterrence must be to convince Russia that any war against NATO means war with all of NATO, wherever its forces are based. To this end, the priority for Western military establishments is not to outmatch the Russians where they are naturally strong, but to invest in the antidotes to these strengths. The Alliance confronted a similar challenge at the height of the Brezhnev era. Its “dual track” decision of 1979 forced the Soviets to contend with mobile, high-readiness, theaterbased nuclear systems that could have been used to devastating effect at the outset of conflict. Coupled with the exploitation of then revolutionary “smart” non-nuclear U.S. Army weapons and war-fighting concepts (AirLand Battle), the West effectively threatened to annul ten years of Soviet investment in a “strategic offensive operation” against NATO. NATO undertook this task in the teeth of unprecedented internal opposition to its policy (focused on the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament) and an intense Soviet active measures campaign in Europe. The result of the new NATO policy was not an apocalyptic confrontation, but a change of course for the USSR and a process of mutual de-escalation of military threats and political tensions in Europe. Today’s conditions are in one respect more promising than those that confronted NATO 35 to 40 years ago. Gerasimov’s anxiety, “the destruction of military forces and key state assets in several hours,” derives from “prompt global strike” and shorter range non-nuclear systems against which Russia might only be able to threaten nuclear retaliation. Strategically, they have the potential to threaten assets critical to war-waging and state management without producing nuclear devastation. Operationally, they might cut several of Russia’s pathways to escalation dominance that presently exist. From a Russian perspective, this new generation of weapons is destabilizing; from a Western perspective, the opposite. Investment in these systems will not absolve NATO of the need to maintain a coherent nuclear posture. But when combined with other means of enhancing the West’s robustness and resilience, it will constrain Russia’s ability to fight war on its terms. If it cannot do so, it is most unlikely to fight at all. The observation of Finland’s leading expert on Russian military policy is worth citing: In the Georgian and Ukrainian crises and Syrian air operations, Russia has demonstrated its high readiness for limited military operations to secure and promote its national interests in situations when, according to its estimation, success is easily gained and risk of unfavourable escalation is low.36 In these respects, Vladimir Putin is a good steward of Russian tradition. Only two conditions have provoked Russia during his tenure: weaknesses (Ukraine in conditions of state collapse and Syria after a geopolitical vacuum had been created by the United States) and bluff (NATO’s ill-judged 2008 promise that Georgia and Ukraine “will become members of NATO”). No example can be found of Russia attacking a stronger opponent that understood its own strength. A strong opponent afraid of its own strength is only asking for trouble. The simple and most basic object of deterrence is to persuade would-be opponents that force is not the solution to their problems. But it is not simple to achieve. In 1987 the Soviet Union concluded that  “the application of military means to resolve any dispute is inadmissible under current conditions.”37 It is not beyond our means to bring Russia to the same conclusion

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

US military is one of the biggest causes of climate change now; the aff’s militarization of the military locks into a cycle of hydrocarbon use.

Lancaster University 6/20/19. REF 2021 rated 99% of Lancaster's overall research environment as 4* 'world leading' or 3* 'internationally excellent'. Lancaster University. Lancaster University is a collegiate public research university in Lancaster, Lancashire, England. "U.S. military consumes more hydrocarbons than most countries -- massive hidden impact on climate." ScienceDaily. ScienceDaily, 20 June 2019. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/06/190620100005.htm.

The US military's carbon footprint is enormous and must be confronted in order to have a substantial effect on battling global warming, experts argue. Research by social scientists from Durham University and Lancaster University shows the US military is one of the largest climate polluters in history, consuming more liquid fuels and emitting more CO2e (carbon-dioxide equivalent) than most countries. The majority of greenhouse gas (GHG) accounting routinely focuses on civilian energy use and fuel consumption, not on the US military. This new study, published in Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, calculates part of the US military's impact on climate change through critical analysis of its global logistical supply chains. The research provides an independent public assessment of the US military's greenhouse gas emissions. It reports that if the US military were a nation state, it would be the 47th largest emitter of GHG in the world, if only taking into account the emission from fuel usage. Report co-author Dr Patrick Bigger, of Lancaster University Environment Centre, said: "The US Military has long understood it is not immune from the potential consequences of climate change -- recognising it as a threat multiplier that can exacerbate other threats -- nor has it ignored its own contribution to the problem. "Yet its climate policy is fundamentally contradictory -- confronting the effects of climate change while remaining the largest single institutional consumer of hydrocarbons in the world, a situation it is locked into for years to come because of its dependence on existing aircraft and warships for open-ended operations around the globe." Despite the recent increase in attention, the US military's dependence on fossil fuels is unlikely to change. The US is continuing to pursue open-ended operations around the globe, with the life-cycles of existing military aircraft and warships locking them into hydrocarbons for years to come. The research comes at a time when the US military is preparing for climate change through both its global supply networks and its security infrastructure. This study brings transparency to one of the world's largest institutional consumers of hydrocarbons at a time when the issue is a hot-button topic on the US Presidential campaign trail. Leading Democratic candidates, such as Senator Elizabeth Warren, are asking critical questions of the role of the US military in climate change and examining its plans for the future. Co-author Dr Benjamin Neimark, Associate Director of the Pentland Centre for Sustainability in Business at Lancaster, said: "This research provides ample evidence to support recent calls by activist networks to include the US military in Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's Green New Deal and other international climate treaties." Co-author Dr Oliver Belcher, of Durham University's Department of Geography, said: "Our research demonstrates that to account for the US military as a major climate actor, you must understand the logistical supply chain that makes its acquisition and consumption of hydrocarbon-based fuels possible. "How do we account for the most far-reaching, sophisticated supply chains, and the largest climate polluter in history? While incremental changes can amount to radical effects in the long-run, there is no shortage of evidence that the climate is at a tipping point and more is needed." The researchers' examination of the US military 'carbon boot-print' started with the US Defense Logistics Agency -- Energy (DLA-E), a powerful yet virtually unresearched sub-agency within the larger Defense Logistics Agency. It is the primary purchase-point for hydrocarbon-based fuels for the US Military, and a powerful actor in the global oil market, with the fuels it delivers powering everything from routine base operations in the USA to forward operating bases in Afghanistan. "An important way to cool off the furnace of the climate emergency is to turn off vast sections of the military machine," added Dr Neimark. "This will have not only the immediate effect of reducing emissions in the here-and-now, but create a disincentive in developing new hydrocarbon infrastructure integral to US military operations." Other key findings of the report include: In 2017 alone, the US military purchased about 269,230 barrels of oil a day and emitted more than 25,000 kt- CO2e by burning those fuels. In 2017 alone, the Air Force purchased $4.9 billion worth of fuel and the Navy $2.8 billion, followed by the Army at $947 million and Marines at $36 million. If the US military were a country, it would nestle between Peru and Portugal in the global league table of fuel purchasing, when comparing 2014 World Bank country liquid fuel consumption with 2015 US military liquid fuel consumption. For 2014, the scale of emissions is roughly equivalent to total -- not just fuel -- emissions from Romania. According to the DLA-E data obtained by the researchers, which includes GHG emissions from direct or stationary sources, indirect or mobile sources and electricity use, and other indirect, including upstream and downstream emissions. The Air Force is by far the largest emitter of GHG at more than 13,000 kt CO2e, almost

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

Militarization causes climate change and there can be no real ecological protection in the world of the aff.

Jorgenson 2012. Andrew Jorgenson is Professor and Chair in the Department of Sociology, Professor of Environmental Studies, and coordinates the  at Boston College. Jorgenson, Andrew K., et al. "The environmental impacts of militarization in comparative perspective: an overlooked relationship." Nature and Culture, vol. 7, no. 3, winter 2012, pp. 314+. Gale Academic OneFile, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A313972354/AONE?u=umuser&sid=bookmark-AONE&xid=c3de5be4.

War has long contributed to ecological degradation, including the diversion of rivers, scorched earth practices, the destruction of plants and animals, oil spills, the burning of oil wells, and the use of chemical and biological weapons. The atmospheric testing of atomic and nuclear bombs produced radioactive fallout that spread throughout the world via wind, water, and living creatures (Commoner 1967, 1971). In fact, the detonation of Trinity--the first atomic explosion--in the New Mexico desert on 16 July 1945 ushered in the nuclear era, which coincides with the age of ecology (Hagen 1992; Worster 1998). The environmental impacts of militarization are not limited to war and the testing of nuclear weapons. Military institutions, often in the name of national security and geopolitical circumstances, have created large-scale built and social infrastructures to sustain and support the coercive power of nations. Advances in military technologies, the resource demands to maintain the social and built infrastructures of militaries, the testing of machinery and weapons, and the  of soldiers and weapons to distant places have increased the overall ecological and environmental impacts of the world's militaries (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). As a result of these activities, "the world's armed forces are the single largest polluter on earth" (Renner 1991: 132). In what follows we direct attention to the relationships between the environment and the world's national militaries. We present a general discussion of the treadmill of destruction theory, a sociological perspective that highlights the expansionary tendencies and environmental impacts of militarism. We then offer a brief account of recent military developments and expenditures, with a focus on the ascent of the military in the . Following this discussion, we examine how the growth and structure of militarization contributes to an array of environmental impacts. We conclude by calling for future sociological research to seriously consider the environmental impacts of the world's militaries. In this call we suggest fruitful avenues for future research, while recognizing some of the unique challenges faced by those who do research on the effects of the world's militaries on the environment. "Militarization" is recognized as "the single most ecologically destructive human endeavor" (Gould 2007: 331). Yet, with few exceptions, the environmental impacts of militarism and militarization are mostly overlooked in environmental sociology and other environmental social sciences. The general inattention to such relationships, given the scale and range of influence, is problematic. Military preparedness impinges--in a highly deleterious fashion--on the nation's physical environment and, all too often, that of their neighbors as well. From depleting resources, eroding the physical environment, destroying natural flora and fauna, or leaving behind a vast array of toxins and radioactive elements, all aspects of military activity defile our environment in some way. (Singer and Keating 1999: 326). Military operations, land holdings, forces, and production facilities are often exempt from environmental laws, at home and abroad, "in the name of national security" (Gould 2007: 331; Singer and Keating 1999: 327). Within sociology, the treadmill of destruction perspective examines how the expansionary dynamics and structure of militarism produce profound environmental impacts (Hooks and Smith 2004, 2005). This theoretical approach is influenced by and related to the treadmill of production tradition within environmental sociology, which is one of the area's foundational orientations. Thus, prior to discussing the treadmill of destruction perspective, we first provide a brief description of the treadmill of production theory. The treadmill of production theory posits that environmental degradation and  are an inherent part of  (Schnaiberg 1980; Schnaiberg and Gould 1994). Given that a capitalist economy is predicated on the constant pursuit of profit and expansion, its operations have "direct implications for natural resource extraction," the generation of pollution, and the overall state of environmental conditions (Gould et al. 2004: 297). The economy generates ecological problems, as it must continually withdraw resources from the environment to produce goods and power machinery, and such activities inevitably generate waste. The state, while often caught in contradictory positions, is an important social institution that supports economic expansion through negotiating trade agreements, bailing out industry and banking, promoting military spending, and protecting private property. According to treadmill of production scholars, the growth imperative of  creates an "enduring conflict" between human societies and the environment (Schnaiberg and Gould 1994). Nature--in the form of matter and energy--is used to fuel industry and to produce commodities for the market. "As societies increase their production," Schnaiberg (1980: 20) pointed out, "they 'discover' resources and 'create' new products." Each expansion in the production process creates a higher level of demand for  from , often at rates that exceed the regenerative capacity of these systems, in order to sustain economic operations on a larger and more intensive scale (Gould et al. 2008; see also Foster 2005). Ecosystems are actively transformed to meet the needs of the economic system, which contributes to ecological disorganization (Schnaiberg 1980). Producers attempt to externalize environmental costs as much as possible, as this has the potential to enhance profits. From this perspective, there is a strong relationship between economic development and , and this applies to both developed nations and developing nations (Jorgenson and Clark 2012). Hooks and Smith (2004, 2005) argue that while the military is linked to the economy, it is not simply a derivative of the latter. Militarism has its own distinct expansionary dynamics and produces specific forms of environmental degradation, part and parcel of the treadmill of destruction. Primarily for geopolitical reasons, states declare and wage wars (Mann 1998; Tilly 1990). Militaries are institutions that actively seek to shape and control information to secure funding and to expand their infrastructure (Bond 2011). As nations attempt to maintain and increase power, it spurs military development, which increases the lethality and ferocity of conflict (Tilly 1990). At the same time, these military developments increase the scale, intensity, and danger of environmental degradation (Hooks and Smith 2004). Militarism produces a treadmill of destruction that effectively restricts . The focus of the military in relation to the environment is made clear by a US military base commander, who, when responding to citizen's concerns about pollution, stated: "We are in the business of protecting the nation, not the environment" (Renner 1991: 152; see also Clark and Jorgenson 2012). Geopolitical competition often drives arms races as well as attendant technological advances, infrastructural development, and growth in troop size. The environmentally damaging capabilities of militaries, especially for developed nations, are partly a function of technological developments with weaponry and other machinery (Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). Capital-intensive militaries employ advanced weaponry and utilize state-of-the-art transportation systems to facilitate the rapid movement of troops and to enhance the strike capabilities of nations, including an extensive system of vehicles and infrastructure to aid in the deployment of equipment and personnel (Clark et al. 2010). Further, capital-intensive militaries are likely to increase their material infrastructure or become more spatially dispersed, bringing more land under their operations (Kentor et al. 2012). The structure and organization of the military requires access to and consumption of vast amounts of resources, such as oil, to maintain its basic operations. The growth dynamics of militarism further expand the treadmill of destruction, increasing the overall environmental demands of and degradation caused by this institution (Clark and Jorgenson 2012; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). International superpowers have historically used part of the social surplus generated through economic dominance to invest in military development (Hooks and McLauchlan 1992; Kentor 2000). Domestic politics, the position of nations within the global interstate system, and actual and perceived threats shape the course of military development. During the twentieth century, technological, political, economic, and ideological changes contributed to the ascendancy of the military into the power elite (Mills 2000). These changes expanded the influence and scale of militaries, deeply rooting the treadmill of destruction within national and international politics. The discussion that follows is largely focused on the military within the United States, in part due to the predominance of this nation's military within the world and the magnitude of annual military spending of this country. However, it is important to note that recent scholarship has extended the treadmill of destruction perspective to the comparative-international level. Multiple cross-national and longitudinal studies within sociology indicate that the relative size (i.e., military participation rate) and technological capacity (i.e., military expenditures per solider) of nations' militaries both contribute to growth in energy consumption (Clark et al. 2010), carbon dioxide  (Jorgenson et al. 2010; York 2008), and overall resource consumption in the form of the ecological footprints of nations (Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson and Clark 2009, 2011). These cross-national studies and their results indicate that the environmental impacts of national militaries are far beyond trivial, net of other human drivers of pollution and degradation, including levels of economic development,  size, , manufacturing levels, and various forms of globalization. Furthermore, and in the context of generalizability, many of these studies indicate that the environmental impacts of national militaries are observable for samples of all countries as well as for samples restricted to only developed countries and only  (e.g., Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). Figure 1 is a scatter plot that illustrates the relationship between carbon dioxide emissions per capita and military expenditures per soldier (i.e., technological capacity of national militaries), both presented in logarithmic form. These data include observations of 72 nations from 1970 to 2000 in five-year increments (i.e., 1970, 1975 ... 1995, 2000). Military expenditures per soldier is calculated by dividing total military expenditures by total military personnel. Figure 2 is a scatter plot that illustrates the association between carbon dioxide emissions per capita and military participation rate (i.e., relative size of national militaries), both in logarithmic form, and for the same nations and time points as in Figure 1. Military participation is the ratio of military personnel per 1,000 people in the general population. These data in both figures are the same data analyzed by Jorgenson et al. (2010). (1) Consistent with treadmill of destruction theory, Figure 1 indicates that the association between per capita carbon dioxide emissions and military expenditures per solider is positive and strong in magnitude (correlation = 0.802), while Figure 2 suggests that the relationship between per capita emissions and military participation rate is also positive and moderately strong (correlation = 0.486). Both world wars in the twentieth century resulted in an unprecedented scale of destruction, in part due to the use of new, more deadly weapons. C. Wright Mills (2000) explains that following the Second World War the military joined the economic and political elite in the United States. He indicates that other historical developments and transformations in the social order facilitated the ascent of the military into the power elite. The scale of military operations--including troops, equipment, and the theater of war--had greatly expanded. The military catalyzed scientific research and development, especially in the production of high-tech equipment and the development of new weapons. In fact, technological innovation became closely linked to the weapons industry (Galbraith 1998: 257). The expansion of the military provided economic benefits for powerful segments within industry due to armament and other military contracts. The destructive potential of nuclear weapons elevated military matters, increasing the influence of the military in both the state and the economy within the United States. The power elite increasingly adopted a "military definition of reality" (Mills 2000: 198). Due to geopolitics and the ascendancy of the military, the overall expenditures on military and expenditures per soldier continued to increase, helping create a permanent war economy. Figure 3 provides the total annual military expenditures (defined as the "total military budget") for the United States for the 1900 to 2007 period, while Figure 4 provides the annual expenditures per soldier (2) for the same range of years. These data, which are reported in 1990 international Geary-Khamis dollars (3) and thus adjusted for inflation, were obtained from the Correlates of War online data set (www.correlatesofwar.org/). As indicated by Figure 3, total military expenditures increased from $439,960 in 1900 to $649,800,000,000 in 2007. Turning briefly to Figure 4, military expenditures per soldier increased from approximately $3 in 1900 to $431,460 in 2007. In 1961, President Dwight Eisenhower noted that following the Second World War the United States, and by extension the world, had entered a new era of militarism. Prior to this period, domestic industrial operations were redirected to support the war effort during times of conflict. Geopolitical competition and the ascent of the military helped create "a permanent armaments industry of vast proportions" and an expansive military structure that included millions of enlisted soldiers. While Eisenhower is known for warning against the "unwarranted influence" of the military-industrial complex--a concept that had been introduced in the late 1940s (Riefler 1947)--he also upheld the imperative need for its development (Eisenhower 1961). The ascent of the military increased the interaction and traffic between the corporate and military realms. Mills (2000: 213) indicates that following the Second World War, "[m]ilitary demands continued to shape and to pace the corporate economy," especially given major military contracts. What is more, "military production helped prop up the entire economic edifice in the United States, and was a factor holding off economic stagnation" (Foster 2006: 110). In reflecting on the interconnections between the power elite, the expanding military budget, and the growth imperative of the larger system, Charles H. Anderson (1976: 76-77) explained, "Military spending is ideally suited to the growth system since it pumps money into private production, redistributes income upward, and always finds an outlet, that is, there is never enough military power or sophisticated enough military hardware." The expansion in military spending wedded "big science" to the military in the United States (and elsewhere), as research and development were geared to addressing the specialized technological needs for advanced military performance (Hooks and McLauchlan 1992). The military directed social resources to designing, developing, testing, and deploying superior vehicles, planes, boats, and weapons for national security and potential use in future conflicts. The new equipment was made of special materials, corresponding to advances in weapons. These technological developments have made the military more capital- and material-intensive (Shaw 1988). Technological advances allow the military to move massive amounts of equipment and soldiers throughout the world more easily, covering more land in less time (Collins 1981). These advances have increased the expense of military operations, especially the costs associated with operating special equipment such as aircraft carriers, planes, helicopters, and tanks. Such trends encourage the international arms race between the global powers, as novel technologies and weapons set a new standard for warfare (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). While the military (i.e., the treadmill of destruction) is connected to the economy (i.e., the treadmill of production) in complex ways, given the military-industrial complex, it also generates its own growth dynamics that require immense amounts of capital, supplies of energy, and other raw materials to sustain its operations (Clark et al. 2010; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). Figure 5 provides primary energy consumption (coal, petroleum, electricity, and natural gas) for the United States, measured in thousands of coal-ton equivalents, for every twenty years (i.e., 1900, 1920 ... 1980, 2000) from 1900 to 2000, as well as for the year 2007. These data were also obtained from the Correlates of War online data set. The consumption of such energy sources leads to increases in greenhouse gas emissions and thus contributes to climate change (IPCC 2007). As indicated by Figure 5, primary energy consumption in the United States increased from 256,081 thousands of coal-ton equivalents in 1900 to 5,548,023 thousands of coal-ton equivalents in 2007, and the general pattern of the increase is quite similar to the upward trajectories for both military expenditures measures in Figures 3 and 4. Militarism contributes to environmental degradation during times of war and peace. The environmental and public health harms associated with war are more obvious, so we provide only a few examples to illustrate the range of impacts. Biological and chemical weapons contaminate ecosystems and devastate landscapes. Agent Orange was used to defoliate the  during the Vietnam War, polluting the land and water and causing significant health problems for citizens of Vietnam and US soldiers. More recently, depleted uranium has been used in the manufacturing of bullets, shells, and bombs. This material contributes to the contamination of the land during and following war and presents serious health risks for human and animal populations (Birchard 1998; Sanders 2009; White 2008). Waging war also produces a broad range of debris that accumulates as pollution within the nations where war is being waged, as well as at the military bases used in the military campaign. Debris, in this particular case, includes fuel deposits, ammunition dumps, drums filled with oil and solvents, asphalt, grease, paint, tires, cables, unexploded munitions, gunpowder, and fiberboard. These materials introduce an array of chemicals and other toxins into ecosystems that will continue to harm both flora and fauna unless a "clean operation" is conducted (Lanier-Graham 1993). Military campaigns consume enormous amounts of fossil (and nuclear) fuels in planes, ships, and tanks (Grimes 1999; Klare 2002; Lanier-Graham 1993; Marshall 2005; Pellow 2007; Thomas 1995). Michael Klare (2007) indicates that the US military consumes at least 1.3 billion gallons of oil annually in the Middle East alone--more than the annual consumption of Bangladesh. Such levels of fossil fuel use contribute to the global accumulation of carbon dioxide emissions and thus cause climate change (IPCC 2007). War also contributes to  and the loss of wildlife habitat, as people attempt to rebuild what was lost during the conflict (Lanier-Graham 1993). Too often the environmental impacts of militarism are overlooked. This situation is especially true in terms of the expansionary dynamics and environmental impacts of militarism during periods of peace (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). The constant preparation for future conflicts by vested military interests and persistent geopolitical concerns escalate the scale and operations of militaries. As a result, the treadmill of destruction expands even in the absence of armed conflict. Military institutions and their activities consume vast amounts of nonrenewable energy and other resources for research and development, maintenance, and operation of the overall infrastructure (Dycus 1996; Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson et al. 2010; Sidel and Shahi 1997; York 2008). At the same time, military operations generate large amounts of toxic substances and waste, which contribute to the contamination of land and water. The testing of nuclear weapons released strontium-90, iodine-131, and other radioactive isotopes directly into the environment, leading to the bioaccumulation of these materials throughout the food web (Commoner 1967; Hastings 2000; LaDuke 1999; Shulman 1992; Ward 1999). Other hazardous toxins are introduced into the environment through the production, storage, transportation, and disposal of biological and chemical weapons (Lanier-Graham 1993). In the 1940s, the Hanford Project was built in the state of Washington in the United States to manufacture nuclear weapons. Nuclear reactors were used to produce plutonium. When this plant was decommissioned, there remained millions of gallons and cubic feet of radioactive waste. The groundwater in the area is contaminated. This site, located along the Columbia River, is generally deemed to be one of the most polluted sites in the world (McNeill 2000). Likewise, Rocky Mountain Arsenal, also within the United States, which manufactured chemical weapons, remains a Superfund site, as the "by-products from the production of mustard gas, napalm, incendiary weapons, and other types of munitions were dumped on the land for decades" (Lanier-Graham 1993: 80). Pesticides, solvents, mercury, lead, and arsenic also contaminate this land. These toxins are known to pollute groundwater. Military bases throughout the world have been identified as sites of toxic contamination, and in the 1960s and 1970s, millions of gallons of radioactive waste were dumped by the US Navy into Pearl Harbor (LaDuke 1999: 173). Singer and Keating (1999: 330-331) detail how military preparedness includes use of "rare and poisonous metals such as titanium, beryllium, germanium, cobalt, thallium, and depleted uranium," which "are extremely toxic to extract and refine." These materials, as well as other potentially dangerous chemicals, are often exclusively employed in the production of military goods. Part of the everyday operation and maintenance of military equipment includes the use of a broad range of thinners, solvents, lubricants, degreasers, fuels, pesticides, and propellants. As a result, "the Department of Defense . generates 500,000 tons of toxic waste annually, more than the top five US chemical companies combined, and it is estimated that the armed forces of the major world powers produce the greatest amount of hazardous waste in the world" (Singer and Keating 1999: 338). Thus, "the most ecologically devastated locations on Earth" are found wherever "military production facilities" operate (Gould 2007: 331). Armed forces have used a steadily increasing amount of land for bases, other installations, and training exercises over the last century ( Center for Disarmament 1982). The end of the Cold War did not reduce the use of public lands for military operations, training, testing, and exercises (Singer and Keating 1999). In 2003, the United States alone had over 900 military bases located domestically and operated over 700 military bases in 130 countries (Johnson 2004). By 2007, there were over 800 US military bases overseas (Sanders 2009). A network of military bases encompasses the globe, requiring a vast amount of  and other resources to staff, operate, and transport equipment and personnel between destinations. Even with advanced technologies, military operations require bases close to theaters of action to supply energy and personnel needs (Collins 1981). To a significant extent military power remains dependent upon access to land (Foster 2006; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). Militaries must have ready supplies of raw materials and energy as well as the infrastructure to support their operations and to meet the needs of their personnel. Consequently, military-oriented resource use involves strategic stockpiling of munitions, spare parts, fossil fuels, and other ancillary equipment to sustain its operations. The resource consumption of the military is further increased by  that produce marginal equipment for the armed forces and their support economies (Jorgenson 2005). The production of such marginal equipment and stockpiling of fuels places greater demands upon the environment. The populations of armed forces also use large quantities of materials for uniforms and specialized forms of clothing that would not otherwise be consumed. Furthermore, the labor intensity of militaries increases the resources required for training, armaments, transportation, and the  of troops and support personnel (Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). During regular operations, including peacetime activities, the armed forces consume large amounts of fossil fuels, adding to the accumulation of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere (Jorgenson et al. 2010; Roberts et al. 2003). Vaclav Smil (2000) points out that the three branches of the US military consumed approximately 25 million tons of fuel per year in the 1990s, excluding energy consumed in both the Gulf War and the bombing of Kosovo. He indicates that this amount was "more than the total commercial energy consumption of nearly two thirds of the world's countries" (Smil 2000: 38). The high consumption of fossil fuels is, in part, a reflection of the high-tech equipment employed by the armed forces. Additionally, soldiers must be constantly trained to use this equipment, and the high-tech machinery and vehicles must be tested. Planes, helicopters, ships, tanks, and armed vehicles all require enormous amounts of oil to make them move--not to mention the various ancillary infrastructures that are required for their operation, such as air strips, roads, and supply vehicles. For example, one hour of operation of a nonnuclear aircraft carrier consumes 21,300 liters (over 5,621 gallons) of fuel; large, high-tech military helicopters burn 5 gallons of fuel for every mile that they travel; and fighter planes, such as the F-15 and F-16, consume between 1,500 and 1,700 gallons of fuel per hour. If their afterburners are used, up to 14,400 gallons are exhausted per hour (Cutler 1989; Renner 1997: 120; Sanders 2009; Smith 2003). Renner (1997: 120) states that "a modern battle tank's fuel consumption is so voracious that it is better measured in gallons per mile than in miles per gallon." Of the top ten fuel guzzlers, eight of them are support vehicles that carry fuel and supplies. Only two are combat vehicles--the Apache helicopter and the M-1 Abrams tank (Karbuz 2007). As the military pursues "bigger, faster, and more sophisticated weapons, fuel efficiency continues to plummet" (Smith 2003). Superior combat performance of equipment is a greater priority than energy efficiency for military institutions. In the 1980s, "nearly a quarter of all jet fuel" was consumed by militaries throughout the world; and approximately three-quarters of the petroleum used by the armed forces fuels vehicles, aircrafts, sea vessels, and other forms of warfare machinery (Renner 1991, 1997: 120). The Pentagon has the largest fleet of high-tech military equipment, which is fueled almost entirely by oil. According to Klare (2007), it is perhaps the "leading consumer of petroleum" in the world. Figure 6 provides the results of Jorgenson et al.'s (2010) cross-national longitudinal study of per capita carbon dioxide emissions (emissions resulting primarily from fossil fuel consumption) for 72 nations from 1970 to 2000. The reported coefficients, which are all statistically significant, are estimated from fixed effects regression analysis and standardized, allowing for comparisons of the relative magnitude of the effects of the explanatory variables. Of particular relevance, the effects of both military variables are positive and larger in magnitude than the effect of manufacturing as percent of total gross domestic product (GDP). These results also hold in analyses restricted to just developing nations as well as for analyses of total carbon emissions. Besides directly contributing to carbon emissions through the consumption of fossil fuels, militarization appears to influence the willingness and timing of nations to ratify environmental treaties. In a recent cross-national study, Givens (2012) employs event history analysis techniques and finds that higher levels of militarization, in the context of both military expenditures and military participation rates, are associated with longer periods of time until ratification and/or failure to ratify the Kyoto Protocol. Along these lines, Christoff (2008) explores how the United States' position as a global "superpower," with unrivaled military and economic power, did not exempt it from censure when it refused to agree to the proposed text at the Bali climate conference. He also explores how the economic and military positions of the United States and China in the global system influence their actions on climate negotiations and notes the importance of the United States' internal budgetary issues and external attempts to retain military supremacy in shaping climate discussions (Christoff 2010). In conclusion, we forcefully assert that the environmental impacts of the nation's militaries must be seriously considered in future research on the anthropogenic drivers of environmental harms. Doing so will not be easy, but this broader perspective is imperative given that global climate change and unsustainable resource consumption are among the most serious challenges currently facing the world.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

Militarization is the biggest cause of climate change now; increasing it will kill the environment.

Simon Dolittle 2003 works for the Program on Development, Peacebuilding, and the Environment at the Political Economy Research Institute. Originally produced by the Population and Development Program at Hampshire College. doolittle, simon. “Ten Reasons Why Militarism Is Bad for the Environment - Peri.” Ten Reasons Why Militarism Is Bad for the Environment, Mar. 2003, https://peri.umass.edu/fileadmin/pdf/s_doolittle_paper.pdf.

As the world faces war with Iraq, many are understandably concerned with the immediate horror that war would bring. Beyond these very real dangers, we should take this opportunity to re-examine whether militarism is a healthy thing for our society and our planet. Reducing dependence on the rule of force and de-militarizing society would not only make the world more peaceful and free up resources to address the underlying causes of terrorism, it would also have a dramatically positive impact on global health and the environment. Here are ten reasons why. 1. Militaries are notorious polluters. According to geographer Joni Seager, “anywhere in the world, a military presence is virtually the single most reliable predictor of environmental damage.” Since the end of the Cold War, many plans to convert military bases to civilian use have been cancelled because the sites are contaminated beyond any hope of restoration. And military pollution isn’t limited to bases, it does significant damage to the environment at large. In the US – the world's most oil-thirsty country – the largest single consumer of oil is the Pentagon. Together, the world’s militaries consume as much petroleum as Japan – the world's second largest economy – and produce an estimated 6-10% of global air pollution. As Seager concludes: “Militaries…that have little else in common share a distinctive environmental sensibility – namely, one of disregard.”1 2. Militarism robs other social needs. As President Dwight Eisenhower said, “Every gun that is made, every warship fired, signifies in the final sense a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and not clothed” – and, one should add, pressing environmental needs. In 2004, President Bush hopes to increase the US military budget to $399.1 billion. Worldwide military spending – about $798 billion in 2000 – has recently increased for the first time since the end of the Cold War. That’s a lot of money not spent on finding ways to reduce poverty, hunger, and environmental degradation. Allowing social ills such as poverty, illiteracy, and hunger to fester only deepens the disparities that often lie at the heart of many environmental problems. Since militaries are such notorious polluters, heavy military spending is also a dramatic pollution subsidy. It fosters a military culture that casts aside environmental concerns as not “serious” enough to warrant attention. As one American military commander put it, “We’re in the business of protecting your country, not protecting the environment.”2 3. Nuclear weapons are an environmental catastrophe. Nuclear weapons pose an environmental threat to humanity unprecedented in human history. Although the world escaped nuclear holocaust during the Cold War, the nuclear arms race has not stopped. India and Pakistan now have nuclear weapons and North Korea may have them as well. According to some estimates, the radiation from weapons testing alone will eventually cause about 2.4 million cancer deaths worldwide. Hiroshima and Nagasaki offer a frightening reminder of the terror of nuclear weapons used in combat. A year after the US bombed the two cities, 140,000 were dead in Hiroshima and 70,000 in Nagasaki. Because of the much greater destructive capacity of modern nuclear weapons, a nuclear exchange between India and Pakistan could kill up to 30 million people. A massive nuclear war involving half the world’s weapons could trigger a worldwide “nuclear winter,” blocking virtually all of the sun’s light with debris, potentially for weeks, threatening everyone not killed directly in the blasts.3 4. Nuclear waste is an environmental catastrophe. Even if they are never used, nuclear weapons leave in their wake wastes unlike any other in human history, remaining deadly for hundreds of thousands – sometimes millions – of years. There is no completely safe place for these wastes over geological time. A volcano erupted just 20 kilometers from Yucca Mountain in Nevada, where the US plans to store much of its nuclear waste, only 20,000 years ago, a mere blip on the geological timeline. Leaving such long-lived waste for future generations is profoundly irresponsible. The Soviet military is guilty of probably the single most egregious failure to contain nuclear waste (although the American record is far from spotless): dumping waste directly into Lake Karachay, creating what a Natural Resources Defense Council official has called “the most polluted spot on the planet.” Standing at the shore of Lake Karachay for an hour would kill you within weeks.4 5. Military toxins poison the poor and people of color. Those who pay the price for military pollution tend to be society’s weakest and most vulnerable. For decades the US Army contaminated a poor and largely black neighborhood in Memphis, dumping chemical weapons and other hazardous toxics without informing the residents. Pollution by Kelly Air Force Base in San Antonio has elevated the cancer rates and birth defects in the surrounding Latino neighborhoods. For more than fifty years, the US Navy has contaminated Vieques, Puerto Rico, leaving residents with cancer rates 26% higher than the Puerto Rican average. Sadly, the same pattern holds internationally. As Joni Seager observes, “most nuclear weapons in the United States and Europe have been tested on indigenous peoples’ land with dramatic health consequences,” most severely for women and children. Even within the US military, soldiers whose health is threatened by poisonous weapons such as Agent Orange and Depleted Uranium (DU) – not to mention combat – are disproportionately poor and people of color. For both civilians and the rank and file, the pattern is clear: the poor and marginalized are poisoned by the pollution of the rich and powerful.5 6. Militaries are exempt from environmental regulation. Militaries are routinely exempted from environmental regulations in the name of “national security”. In the US, many major environmental laws give the military dramatic regulatory loopholes, including the Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act, Occupational Safety and Health Act, all laws governing nuclear activity and waste, and many more. As the Military Toxics Project and the Environmental Health Coaltion observe, “These exemptions have serious consequences when … the Department of Defense and Energy are the nation’s leading polluters.” Internationally, a treaty banning plastic dumping at sea explicitly exempts militaries – despite the fact that the US Navy alone dumps over 5 tons of plastic overboard daily – and agreements governing foreign military bases almost never include provisions for environmental protection. Although the Pentagon tries to put a green spin on its activities with initiatives such as “green bullets,” which pollute soil less than conventional lead bullets, it fiercely resists regulation and aggressively covers up information about its pollution. One person fired from a military facility for voicing concerns over environmental health likened the intimidation directed at him to the work of the KGB and the Gestapo, calling it a “police state”. An EPA official once described the Department of Energy’s attitude about regulation of their nuclear activities as: “Look, Buster, don’t bug me with your crap about permits. I’m building atomic weapons.”6 7. War destroys ecosystems and livelihoods. From “carpet bombing” to “scorched earth” campaigns, war routinely leave ecosystems ravaged and agricultural livelihoods destroyed. In the Vietnam War, US Air Force planes that dropped Agent Orange were emblazoned with the slogan, “Only we can prevent forests.” Beyond the 19 million gallons of Agent Orange, the US dropped some 25 million bombs on South Vietnam, wiping out half of the mangrove forests and eliminating almost 5 million acres of forest. In Central America, sociologist Daniel Faber reports that “Vietnam-style ‘scorched earth’ operations and military maneuvers have obliterated vast agricultural lands and crucial ecosystems, pushing millions of refugees into overcrowded cities and overtaxed hillsides.” A US military official happily reported that in Honduras “you don’t need to worry…about the EPA or…the environmentalists. Those are not concerns down there.”7 8. War destroys health and sanitation infrastructure. War undermines public health. This grim reality was on full display in the Gulf War. A UN observation team at the end of the war found that the “recent conflict has wrought apocalyptical results on the infrastructure” leaving “means of modern life support…destroyed or rendered tenuous.” By dropping 5,000 tons of bombs, allied forces destroyed water and sewage facilities, electrical generators, and communication centers. Raw sewage flowed into drinking water supplies, and public health systems collapsed. Security scholar Michael Klare writes that the wrecked “water, electricity, and transportation systems have resulted in extensive death, disease, and hunger.”8 9. War poisons many generations of civilians. War is the curse that keeps on killing. Vietnamese parents and children today are still being poisoned by the 19 million gallons of Agent Orange the US dumped on them during the war. Congenital birth defects more than tripled between 1966 and 1996, while Vietnamese women suffer spontaneous abortion and cervical cancer at rates among the world’s worst. What’s more, the country remains littered with unexploded weaponry. As one doctor put it, “No one can be certain when the war’s remnants will disappear.” In Iraq, allied forces fired between 320 and 350 tons of DU, and as a result radioactivity has been found in Iraq’s ground water and both plant and animal tissues. The level of damage done by this “recycled” radioactive waste won’t be fully understood for years, but we know that DU can cause kidney failure, cancers, reproductive problems, genetic damage, and weakened immune systems. The bombing of Iraq’s oil infrastructure released thousands of tons of very toxic hydrocarbons and chemicals. Baghdad has seen dramatic increases of lead and particulate matter in the air. Infant mortality and death of children under five each doubled between 1989 and 1999, while birth defects have also dramatically increased. Since the war, cancer rates have gone up by five times, and cancer victims are getting younger. Dr. Huda Ammash describes the combined effects of war and sanctions as “a health crisis of immense proportions.”9 10. War kills people. Any environment with bullets whizzing and bombs dropping is polluted in the most lethal way. As the technology of warfare has advanced, the deadliness of humanity’s militarism has grown by leaps and bounds. War killed up to 175 million people, most of them civilians, in the 20th century alone – history’s most bloody century. We must work now to ensure that our present century is known for peace – not war.10

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

INCOMPLETE ---- Further US-NATO support promotes disastrous militarism, greenlighting a laundry list of impacts that feed the military industrial complex.

Behind this current crisis lies a history of militarised and economic violence. Both Russia and the United States are settler colonial states, forging their countries by expanding their “frontiers” and killing and repressing Indigenous populations. Both engage in imperialist actions outside of their now-established borders, interfering, through military and economic action, in countries they deem to be within their “spheres of influence”. Both use militarism, aggression, and forced economic ties to guide their conduct in international relations, and both deal with domestic inequality, poverty, and resistance through policing and punishment.

The governments of both countries critique each other for the same type of behaviour. Russia criticises US imperialism, yet invades and occupies its neighbours, bombs civilians, and engages in cyber-attacks against critical infrastructure that harm ordinary people. The United States criticises Russia as an autocracy yet overthrows democratically elected governments if they threaten US interests, builds military bases and engages in wars and military operations in hundreds of countries around the world, and spends billions of dollars a year on militarism while so many of its citizens live without health care, housing, or food security.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

The 1AC’s language perpetuates and normalizes militarism as a cultural system and stuff yay

Gusterson and Besteman 19 (Hugh, Professor in the Department of Anthropology and Elliott School of International Affairs of George Washington University, Catherine, Professor in the Department of Anthropology of Colby College, “Cultures of Militarism: An Introduction to Supplement 19”, February 2019, “Current Anthropology Volume 60, Supplement 19”) // Ilake LT

In contrast, anthropologists’ interest in militarism has taken shape in the context of post–cold war transformations in the management of violence. These years have seen the violent reorganization of some cold war client states; the proliferation of militia-led insurgencies; the interpenetration of organized crime and drug trafficking with insurgency and counter in-surgency in parts of the global south; the articulation of coun-ter insurgency abroad with domestic policing at home in many Western countries; the reformulation of the United Nations into an institution of militarized peacekeeping and occupation; the increasing use of military labor to perform civil, humanitarian, policing, and development activities; and a growing awareness of the ways in which militarism as a set of cultural practices and ideologies pervades all domains of social life. The anthropologists in this volume see militarism as a cultural system; it is shaped through ideology and rhetoric, effected through bodies and technologies, made visible and invisible through campaigns of imagery and knowledge production, and it colonizes aspects of social life including reproduction, self-image, and notions of community. We interrogate militarism in its established and emergent forms, probing its genealogies, its facility at colonizing daily life, and its ability to present itself as a response to insecurities it has itself provoked.4This collection of papers draws on the rich discussions at the symposium from which this volume emerged to capture some of the distinctive features of cultures of militarism. The papers emphasize militarization as a contingent process over militarism as a measurable object;5decenter the state as the core locus of such processes; probe the relationship between militarism, experience, and identity, with a special focus on the body; examine connections between militarism and social injustice; and evince a commitment to critique and under-mine militarism while, at the same time, respecting the force of its appeal. The New Anthropology of Militarism: Four Features Threat Constructions These papers understand militarism as a process rather than as a bounded, measurable thing enmeshed in deterministic relationships with other reified variables. Militarism as an in-flective force or bundle of processes acts upon society in pow-erful and expansive but uneven and contingent ways. Although militarism carves its way deep into social structures, it is also shaped and reshaped in the dialectical interaction between in-grained structures on the one hand and human agency and contingency on the other. It is capillary, shape-shifting, always in motion as it constructs threats, enrolls constituencies, colonizes cultural life, and generates new loci of resistance. As Michel Foucault (2007:44) writes, security apparatuses “have the con-stant tendency to expand; they are centrifugal. New elements are constantly being integrated....Security therefore involves or-ganizing, or anyway allowing the development of ever-wider circuits.” And there is no domain of social life it does not touch. Just as contemporary wars seem to have no clearly demarcated end, so militarism has no discernible edge; it increasingly seeps into every corner of the world, every aspect of social life, in someway. Military/intelligence logics and personnel are now being directed to manage arenas of life formerly understood as outside the purview of the military, like development projects in Africa, humanitarian aid, and responses to environmental catastrophes, black markets, and the hacking of political parties’ computers. In the words of Catherine Lutz, one of the foremost anthropological theorists and observers of militarism, the process of militariza-tion“ has reshaped almost every element of global social life over the 20th century.” It involves an intensification of the labor and resources allocated to military purposes, including the shaping of other institu-tions in synchrony with military goals. Militarization is simul-taneously a discursive process, involving a shift in general societal beliefs and values in ways necessary to legitimate the use of force, the organization of large standing armies and their leaders, and the higher taxes or tribute used to pay for them. Militarization is intimately connected not only to the obvious increase in the size of armies and resurgence of mil-itant nationalisms and militant fundamentalisms but also to the less visible deformation of human potentials into the hierarchies of race, class, gender, and sexuality, and to the shaping of national histories in ways that glorify and legiti-mate military action. (Lutz 2002:723)As Lutz’s comment indicates, the material base of militarism is connected with ideologies and discourses through which proliferating militarized infrastructures and rationalities are normalized, naturalized, and legitimized. Such ideologies and discourses valorize the ethos of the warrior (Gibson 1994; Orr2004; Webb 2018) and construct threats in such a way as to validate military spending, military interventions, and the mil-itarization of formerly nonmilitary arenas of life. To say that threats are “constructed” does not mean that they are imaginary or unreal. But threats can be figured through different narratives and addressed in different ways, and the choice of narrative figuration may have enormous material consequences. The So-viet missiles deployed to Cuba in 1962 were quite real and, if used, would have inflicted crushing damage on the United States. But the United States could have chosen to regard them as a reasonable counterweight to its own Jupiter nuclear-tipped mis-siles in Turkey, on the Soviet Union’s doorstep, rather than pro-voking a global crisis by narrating them as an existential threat (Weldes 1999). Likewise, based on the evidence of the last 2 de-cades of US-Vietnamese relations, the United States could plausibly have decided in the 1960s that its vital interests would have suffered little if a small country on the other side of the planet were allowed to “go Communist. “Instead, it fruitlessly expended the lives of over 50,000 Americans and 2–3 million Vietnamese in what American national security elites wrongly perceived, thanks to the consensually accepted domino theory, as a struggle it could not afford to lose. Or, as discussed in this volume, Turkey in the early twentieth century could have constructed Armenians as constituency to be accommodated, not exterminated, and Guatemalan and Colombian elites could have constructed rural challenges against inequality and injustice as a social problem to address through development and land reform, not a military threat that demanded counterinsurgency. In these cases, the preferred threat constructions militarized the problems at hand, mobilizing more resources for military projects and saturating the social field with militarized violence.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Impact

The War in Afghanistan cost the US trillions and corruption.

WILPF 21 – Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, 2021 (“Militarism And Afghanistan: Costs And Profits,” WILPF, December 2, available online at , accessed 07/13/2022)

The Death, Destruction and Other Deliverables blog explored the various forms of violence that have resulted from the past twenty years of war in Afghanistan, including the use of explosive weapons in populated areas, drone strikes, torture, special operations, and the broader harms caused by the “Global War on Terror”. These brutal costs of war run in parallel to the economic costs.

None of the violence described in the Death, Destruction and Other Deliverables blog has been cheap. The Cost of War Project at Brown University estimates that the war in Afghanistan cost the United States $2.3 trillion to date. The governments of other countries participating in the invasion and occupation have also spent billions: the United Kingdom spent about $28.2 billion, Canada about $13 billion, Germany about $11 billion, Italy about $9 billion, France about $4 billion, Australia about 10 billion AUD, Norway about 11.5 billion NOK.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › ! – Democracy

Militarism exacerbates racism and inequality and decks Liberal Democracy

Crawford 21 Crawford Neta C. Crawford is professor and chair of the Department of Political Science at Boston University and co-director of the . “The militarization of American democracy https://thehill.com/opinion/national-security/534424-the-militarization-of-american-democracy/

In October, Thomas Weiss and I urged all of us to in the face of what might be a violent election and transition season. We foresaw the need to say, among other things, that the military should affirm the rule of law and their oath to the Constitution. Sadly, the felt the need to do just that last week. When extolled “” to a nascent mob in Washington on Jan. 6, he wasn’t talking about moral force. In militarized societies, the model of political change is often military. War is the assertion of “might makes right,” the negation of the rule of law. Political scientists worry these days about democratic erosion, when the norms and institutions of previously stable representative democracies decline. We usually ponder the causes of erosion in other countries. Democracy is, on one hand, democratic elections where the people decide who will govern them, and processes for horizontal and vertical oversight and accountability. There is also a deeper conception of democracy — the norms of citizen deliberation, and human and civil rights that guarantee expression, inclusion and collective action. Democratic legitimacy depends on the ability of citizens to engage in public reason. The more democratic a society is, the greater the limits it has on the use of force both at home and abroad. We don’t take out weapons to resolve our disputes. Democratic erosion or backsliding occurs when democratic institutions, norms and values are gradually — and sometimes almost imperceptibly — reduced. Democratic erosion includes the decline of competitive elections, the reduction in forums where citizens can deliberate and form policy preferences, and the diminished ability for accountability. The indicators of erosion also include constraints on freedom of the press, which reduces transparency and accountability, the unchecked accretion of power in the executive branch, and the loss of civil rights, including the right of assembly. Democratic erosion has various causes. Some blame power-hungry executives who don’t want to give up power. The question, here, is why democratic institutions aren’t able to stop power-hungry elites who would concentrate power and economic resources. Suzanne Mettler and Robert Lieberman, in their book “,” also highlight excessive executive power but then add political polarization, racism and nativism, and economic inequality that prompts the wealthy to mobilize to protect their position. War and militarism exacerbate all those things. But more than that, war and militarism are antipodal and undermining of democratic norms, institutions and practices. At the beginning of the post-9/11 wars, we worried about the effects on our civil liberties and democracy. But after nearly 20 years, we’ve almost forgotten about these wars and have underappreciated their effect on our democratic institutions and values. The urgency of war is often used to justify the concentration of executive power and deference to the executive in times of national emergency. In the United States, the trend toward the concentration of power in the executive was accelerated in the George W. Bush administration. John Yoo, working for President Bush, argued the legal basis for what he called the unitary executive theory where, in war, the president’s powers are essentially . Other officials excused secrecy and torture because the United States was at war. President Trump has continued in that tradition, acting as if the laws and the rule of law do not apply to him. President Dwight Eisenhower is usually given credit for pointing out the dangers of a military industrial complex. Eisenhower rejected massive conventional forces quite explicitly because he sought to prevent the United States from becoming a garrison state: If the U.S. were to do so, , “we might as well stop any further talk about preserving a sound U.S. economy and proceed to transform ourselves forthwith into a garrison state.” Militarization is a perennial concern. James Madison warned in the in 1795 that “Of all the enemies of true liberty, war is, perhaps, the most to be dreaded, because it comprises and develops the germ of every other. … No nation can preserve its freedom in the midst of continual warfare.” Madison worried that “war is in fact the true nurse of executive aggrandizement” that could increase public debt and lead to a “degeneracy in manners and morals.” George Washington, in his 1796 , urged Americans to protect their union and “avoid the necessity of those overgrown military establishments which, under any form of government, are inauspicious to liberty, and which are to be regarded as particularly hostile to republican liberty.” In war, fear is often part of the equation — and fear may be deliberately heightened, threats inflated. We have been living in fear for nearly two decades. When humans are fearful, they tend to pay more attention to fearful information and think less critically. This can bolster groupthink dynamics among decision-makers who otherwise might provide horizontal checks and accountability for leaders. Trump’s was, if anything, rooted in fear of another terrorist attack and racial animus. Elements of our political culture also have been militarized. And, as Kathleen Belew’s shows, veterans also flock to the white power movement and paramilitary organizations. Veterans are often at the forefront of these movements — including the Air Force veteran who was trying to get into the chambers of the House of Representatives on Jan. 6 and another who was recently arrested. Active duty also were present. Militarized right-wing extremism emulates the military, even if the actors aren’t veterans themselves. It is no accident that many who marched in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 at the , who occupied the in 2020, and who stormed the U.S. Capitol wore military-style uniforms, khaki camouflage and bulletproof vests. In sum, we don’t just have a right-wing violence problem. We have a democracy problem fueled by a war problem.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › ! – Democracy

Militarism Weakens Democracy

Giroux 06 Henry Armand Giroux (born 1943) is an American-Canadian scholar and . Giroux earned a  degree in history at  in 1977. One of the founding theorists of  in the United States, he is best known for his pioneering work in public , , , , , and . In 2002  named Giroux as one of the top fifty educational thinkers of the modern period. “The Emerging Authoritarianism in the United States: Political Culture under the Bush/Cheney Administration” https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/40550717.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3Ac6a3b26f52206ea8b79ff616be0edb22&ab_segments=&origin=&acceptTC=1

In the contemporary context of globalization, militarism has become what David Theo Goldberg calls a "new regime of truth," a new epistemology defining what is fact and fiction, right and wrong, just and unjust (qtd. in S. Giroux). Not only are Americans obsessed with military power, but "it has become central to our national identity" (Bacevich 1). How else to explain the fact that the United States now has "725 official military bases outside the country and 969 at home" or that it "spends more on 'defense' than all the rest of the world put together" (Judt 16)? As President Bush explained at a news conference on April 13, 2004, and has repeated again and again in different public venues as 2006 has unfolded, "This country must go on the offense and stay on the offense" (qtd. in Judt 16). By regarding military power as the highest expression of social truth and national greatness, the Bush administration has opened a dangerous new chapter in American military history that now gives unfettered support to what C. Wright Mills has called a "'military metaphysics' - the cast of mind that defines international reality as basically military" (222). As Andrew Bacevich indicates, this mentality leads to a "tendency to see international problems as military problems and to discount the likelihood of finding a solution except through military means" (2). Similarly, Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri point out in Multitude that in the current era war has become the organizing principle of society and the foundation for politics and other social relations (12-3). Broadly speaking, militarization refers to the related instances of the increasing centrality of the military in American society, the militarization of U.S. culture, and the growing propensity to suppress dissent. The process of militarization has a long history in the United States and is varied rather than static, changing under different historical conditions.12 The militarizing of public space at home contributes to the narrowing of community and an escalating concentration of unaccountable political power that threatens the very foundation of democracy in the United States. Militarization is no longer simply the driving force of foreign policy, it has become a defining principle for social changes at home. Catherine Lutz captures the multiple registers and complex processes of militarization that have extensively shaped social life during the twentieth centur

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › RC – Violence

The drive to militarize destroys the value to life – We live life in our seatbelts instead of embracing the things that make life worth living. Their method only locks us in a cycle of violence and counter-violence

Der Derian 98 (James, Prof of PoliSci at the U of Massachusetts, "The Value of Security: Hobbes, Marx, Nietzsche, and Baudrillard," Cianet, http://www.ciaonet.org/book/lipschutz/lipschutz12.html, AD: 7/10/09) jl

The desire for security is manifested as a collective resentment of difference--that which is not us, not certain, not predictable. Complicit with a negative will to power is the fear-driven desire for protection from the unknown. Unlike the positive will to power, which produces an aesthetic affirmation of difference, the search for truth produces a truncated life which conforms to the rationally knowable, to the causally sustainable. In The Gay Science , Nietzsche asks of the reader: "Look, isn't our need for knowledge precisely this need for the familiar, the will to uncover everything strange, unusual, and questionable, something that no longer disturbs us? Is it not the instinct of fear that bids us to know? And is the jubilation of those who obtain knowledge not the jubilation over the restoration of a sense of security?" The fear of the unknown and the desire for certainty combine to produce a domesticated life, in which causality and rationality become the highest sign of a sovereign self, the surest protection against contingent forces. The fear of fate assures a belief that everything reasonable is true, and everything true, reasonable. In short, the security imperative produces, and is sustained by, the strategies of knowledge which seek to explain it. Nietzsche elucidates the nature of this generative relationship in The Twilight of the Idols : The causal instinct is thus conditional upon, and excited by, the feeling of fear. The "why?" shall, if at all possible, not give the cause for its own sake so much as for a particular kind of cause --a cause that is comforting, liberating and relieving. . . . That which is new and strange and has not been experienced before, is excluded as a cause. Thus one not only searches for some kind of explanation, to serve as a cause, but for a particularly selected and preferred kind of explanation--that which most quickly and frequently abolished the feeling of the strange, new and hitherto unexperienced: the most habitual explanations. A safe life requires safe truths. The strange and the alien remain unexamined, the unknown becomes identified as evil, and evil provokes hostility--recycling the desire for security. The "influence of timidity," as Nietzsche puts it, creates a people who are willing to subordinate affirmative values to the "necessities" of security: "they fear change, transitoriness: this expresses a straitened soul, full of mistrust and evil experiences." The unknowable which cannot be contained by force or explained by reason is relegated to the off-world. "Trust," the "good," and other common values come to rely upon an "artificial strength": "the feeling of security such as the Christian possesses; he feels strong in being able to trust, to be patient and composed: he owes this artificial strength to the illusion of being protected by a god." 40 For Nietzsche, of course, only a false sense of security can come from false gods: "Morality and religion belong altogether to the psychology of error : in every single case, cause and effect are confused; or truth is confused with the effects of believing something to be true; or a state of consciousness is confused with its causes." 41 Nietzsche's interpretation of the origins of religion can shed some light on this paradoxical origin and transvaluation of security. In The Genealogy of Morals , Nietzsche sees religion arising from a sense of fear and indebtedness to one's ancestors: The conviction reigns that it is only through the sacrifices and accomplishments of the ancestors that the tribe exists --and that one has to pay them back with sacrifices and accomplishments: one thus recognizes a debt  that constantly grows greater, since these forebears never cease, in their continued existence as powerful spirits, to accord the tribe new advantages and new strength. 42

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › RC – Violence

Militarism paints human existence as nothing more than war and individuals are essentially agents of violence

Marzec 9 (Robert P., Associate Professor of English literature and postcolonial studies at Purdue University, and associate editor of Modern Fiction Studies. The Global South, Volume 3, Number 1, “Militariality” Spring 2009. Project Muse AD 7/9/09) JM

These stratocratic controls of planetary human activity reveal more than the ideology of a single administration; they are an extension of what we can now see as the complete devotion to an apparatus that captures all cultural and political energies in terms of what Clausewitz defined as “policy.” The original state of “emergency” as defined by the Bush Administration in the wake of the World Trade Center and Pentagon attacks has been naturalized and sedimented as to become a fundamental starting point of human existence. Consequently, understanding the full intensity of the age of militariality requires more than the common critical awareness of Clausewitz’s central doctrine: “War is merely the continuation of policy by other means” (28). It requires first an understanding that for Clausewitz, war is the very ontological basis of human existence, a basis that transcends culture, history and temporality. War defines the very structure of human subjectivity, a juridico-natural “code of law” that is “deeply rooted” in a people, an army, a government: “war is a paradoxical trinity—composed of primordial violence, hatred, and enmity, which are to be regarded as a blind natural force; of the play of chance and probability within which the creative spirit is free to roam; and of its element of subordination, as an instrument of policy” (30). Clausewitz assigns a constituency to each of the registers of this trinity: “The first of these…mainly concerns the people; the second the commander and his army; the third the government” (30). In a totalizing problematic organized according to the idea of war serving as the basis of human existence, the people of a nation are equated with that of a blind primordial force of violence: “the first,” which refers to “primordial vio- lence, hatred, and enmity” identifies the people living in the nation. “Government” therefore names that entity constituted for the exclusive purpose of controlling its unstable citizenry by reorienting the energies of the people to- wards warfare. This reorientation lays the groundwork and delineates the horizon of human creativity, and determines the single legitimized space of freedom: the army, where the “creative spirit is free to roam.” The space of in- stability, of chance, which is the condition for the possibility of creativity, en- ters into the war-footing picture of reality only on this register of militarized human activity. This connection here is not a matter of association; military activity defines the very essence of freedom and human creativity. The army and its state are not defined in this picture in traditional terms of democracy, protection, and service to a people. Nor are they the a sign of the discourse of biopower, for biopower has its eyes on the productivity of a population and functions according to a general administration of life that, although affecting “distributions around a norm,” still invites and produces a certain amount of heterogeneity (Foucault 266).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › ! – Climate

Militarization causes climate change woo hoo.

Dunlap and Brock 19 (Alexander Dunlap and Andrea brock, Alexander Dunlap is a postdoctoral research fellow at the Centre for Development and the Environment, University of Oslo, Andrea Brock is a lecturer at the Department of International Relations, Centre for Global Political Economy and STEPS Centre at the University of Sussex, xx-xx-xxxx, "," Palgrave Macmillan Cham,  The outsized influenve of military actors can serve to delegitimize and dis

The outsized influence of military actors can serve to delegitimize and disempower civilian actors, reinforce existing global power imbalances, and constrain the ability of communities to adapt to climate and environmental change (Jayaram and Brisbois, 2021). Further, so-called strategic interests are then translated into policy and persuasion overseas, such as pressuring members of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) to increase military spending in their domestic budgets. Coupled with a commitment to military dominance relative to perceived adversaries, the effect is to drive military spending and its related impacts upward among allies and adversaries alike. Relatedly, the U.S. military must also then ensure continued access and security for sites of extraction and global supply chains for fossil fuels and critical minerals (Belcher et al., 2019; Schwartzman, 2020). These logistical and policing functions heighten tensions in regions with longstanding conflicts, including the Middle East and the South China Sea, and increasingly across less accessible locations, such as the Arctic, the deep sea, and outer space. More fundamentally, there is a conflict between military logics that frame the world in terms of “national security” and the logic of cooperation and shared-yet-differentiated responsibilities required to respond equitably to ecological catastrophe (Jayaram and Brisbois, 2021). As mentioned previously, military use of fossil fuels has historically been excluded from climate targets and reporting (Belcher et al., 2019), exempting militaries from accountability and undermining the pursuit for greater transparency. As dominant perspectives on the global scene, militarized logics can exert substantial influence on climate action as more people experience the direct impacts of climate change. Military modes of operation escalate the problems rather than strategize their prevention and effective remediation, which require cooperation, diplomacy, and sustained coalition building. The focus on national interests preempts possibilities for building real trust and alliances with other nations and incentivizes each nation to adopt an isolationist policy in their own foreign relations, even if public statements attempt to assert differently. True collective security arises from social and political peace and well-resourced infrastructure and institutions to meet the real human security needs for healthy food and environment, meaningful, sufficiently compensated livelihood, quality housing, education, healthcare, and sel fdetermination. These social needs are currently deprived of the resources they need, because the funds are diverted into increasing militarization, which generates more conflict while drastically reducing capacity to meet human needs. Decarbonization must mean demilitarization, and demilitarization in turn requires a just transition.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › ! – Eco

Militarization causes and enforces the structure for ecological destruction

Burke and Smolyr, 22 (Matthew Burke and Nina Smolyr, 6-30-2022, accessed on 7-15-2022, Enforcing Ecocide, ""Demilitarize for a Just Transition", https://link-springer-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/content/pdf/10.1007/978-3-030-99646-8.pdf)

The U.S. military contributes significantly to ecological catastrophe and prevents the realization of a more ecological society. First, we consider the direct environmental impacts. The U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) is the single largest consumer of energy and the largest institutional consumer of oil in the world, using billions of gallons of fuel annually (Eisenscher, 2014; Steichen and Koshgarian, 2020). Energy use for daily operations of the DoD, approaching 400,000 barrels of oil, exceeds that of any other private or public organization as well as more than 100 nations (Crawford, 2019; Reisch and Kretzmann, 2008; Warner and Singer, 2009). Military vehicles, from tanks, fighter jets and bombers, to battleships and aircraft carriers consume petroleum-based fuels at extraordinarily high rates; for example, four to eight miles per gallon of diesel fuel for HUMVEEs, just over half a mile per gallon for tanks, 134 barrels per hour for non-nuclear aircraft carriers, four gallons of jet fuel per nautical mile for B-2 Bombers and 25 gallons per minutes for F-15 fighter jets (Crawford, 2019; Eisenscher, 2014). Indirect applications would further account for fuel consumed by private contractors and weapons manufacturing. While U.S. average per capita energy use is already among the highest in the world [https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-cap ita-energy-use], the per capita rate for active-duty military and civilian personnel is 35% higher still than this average. The corresponding emissions amount to 59 million metric tons of greenhouse gases annually, the single largest volume of produced emissions in the world, even exceeding that of industrialized countries such as Sweden, Denmark, and Portugal. Since 2001, the U.S. military has emitted 1.2 billion metric tons of greenhouse gases and is one of the highest emitters historically (Crawford, 2019). Further, it would not be possible for fossil-fuel-dependent global production and consumption levels to keep growing and to remain so high without the U. S. military war machine deploying missions to protect oil supplies. Up to one half of all interstate wars since have been driven by this purpose, though often not officially (Steichen and Koshgarian, 2020). Intimidation and threat of military action and violence undergird the dynamics of uneven power relations between, on the one hand, Global North state interests to secure their levels of consumption, and on the other hand, communities often in the Global South, whose lands and livelihoods are devastated by the extractive industries and infrastructure protected by the military. Compounding and obfuscating the situation is the absence of military greenhouse gas emissions in global climate negotiations and agreements, resulting in a highly inaccurate depiction of the scale of the problem that these enormous international efforts seek to solve (Steichen and Koshgarian, 2020). This absence is not an accidental oversight. In 1997, the U.S. team at the United Nations climate talks in Kyoto, Japan, successfully lobbied for exemptions from requirements in emission reductions for the military. Even though the U.S. did not even ratify the Kyoto Protocol, military exemptions remained for all the nations that did sign, and continue to present day (Buxton, 2015). Many U.S. military practices are also ecologically destructive and have wreaked havoc on the local environments where they operate. The very notion of ecocide, as the mass destruction and extermination of ecosystems, arose in the context of the U.S. military’s devastating use of the chemical weapon Agent Orange in Vietnam (Falk, 1973; Higgins, 2015). More recently, the toxicity accumulated from using depleted uranium munitions and burning trash in open pits during military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq has resulted in high incidences of crippling birth defects and cancer among civilians in both places (Webb, 2017; Hussain, 2019). Even if we were to accept the rather dubious notion that military operations have strengthened the cause of democracy in these parts of the world and solidified U.S. security, their devastated environments result in huge losses to local livelihoods. A cascading effect is that these governments and societies become further entrapped and dependent on international aid while instability is perpetuated. The financial instruments arising from these foreign aid regimes are structured by geopolitically powerful countries to extend their neocolonial power over those already enduring ongoing dispossession, extraction, and marginalization (Hickel, 2018).

2022 Michigan Kritik
Root cause › RC – War

Militarism institutes warfare as a state of being - "deterrence" is a myth that implies war is temporary, denying our existence in a constant state of war

Gelot and Sandor, 19 (Linnea Gelot and Adam Sandor, 12-5-2019, accessed on 7-17-2022, Conflict, Security & Development, "African Security and Global Militarism", https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/14678802.2019.1688959)

The concept’s intuitive nature, however, obscures two important features of threat governance in contemporary African politics. First, as pointed out by Frowd and Sandor, while militarisation aims to capture processes of change in the legitimation and extension of military power, it nevertheless lacks the analytical flexibility necessary to bring into view varied practices and different forms of violence associated with contemporary interventions. For example, it is increasingly the case that interventions operationalised in Africa by leading states, international organisations and NGOs, including those that involve the military, engage in various forms of ‘armed social work’. The pursuit of such practices, however, does not always signal a logic of war preparation and military power, but rather one of pastoral forms of power and selective (in)security. In other words, military actors are not always involved in martial pursuits, but the pursuit of such practices are nearly always defined or informed by logics of security, notably human security. Secondly, if militarisation constitutes the entrenchment of society’s acceptance of military approaches to resolving problems, such that it affects all aspects of our everyday lives, then how do we know when that process is operative from when it is not? Certainly, we live with the complex legacies of past military practices and ideologies, even if today they are not presently operative or immediately coercive. Yet, when researchers use the Internet to research African politics, or communicate at a distance via WhatsApp with African interlocutors, does this constitute the militarisation of our everyday lives since these technologies were originally developed by military institutions? Indeed, if it is so inexorably pervasive, how can we analytically disentangle a civilian-centred society constituted by banal acts such as these from military-centred ones that regularise the constant possibility of the use of martial force? We pose these questions to highlight tensions in the concept of militarisation. Its theorisation in the literature has signified a set of processes that blurs political phenomena and boundaries like the public and private, police and military, and inside and outside. Nevertheless, as a concept it ultimately struggles to escape the rigidities of those distinctions and categories. The Special Issue equally shares the questions (posed as a critique) advanced by Anna Stavrianakis and Maria Stern: ‘if disciplines and practices central to civilian and military life grew up together, is it appropriate to talk of militarisation, as though ostensibly civilian practices were not already enmeshed with military power, itself central to the constitution of social order and the state?’ Militarisation implies some pre-war, peaceful, normal state of affairs when war and its fighters kept to their corners instead of having shaped the arena of politics and the political itself. This is not to say that societal transformations regarding the use of force (e.g. militarisation, demilitarisation and the like) do not occur, or will not occur in the future. Our point is to stress that war, security and society have always been mutually imbricated, and that studying the use of force should always involve giving full recognition of those imbrications. Only by fully recognising this can we capture the diverse forms of political violence operating in and on transnationalised African spaces. There is a danger that some usages of militarisation to explain the governance of threats in/on Africa result in an underestimation of war-like forms of politics because it blithely assumes that war is somehow an historical and social aberration in African settings, or elsewhere. The same danger applies as a result of frequent unquestioning usages of security as a predominant guiding concept. That said, an IPS approach to militarism that takes war and security into account can carve out analytical room for a fluidity in our use of concepts; that is, the possibility exists to pursue careful treatments of these concepts that successfully navigate a middle ground.

Militarism is the root cause of ALL war in the current era

2022 Michigan Kritik
Alt › Alt – Rejection

The Alternative is to reject all instances of militarism

Maguire 18 Mairead Maguire (born 27 January 1944), also known as Mairead Corrigan Maguire and formerly as Mairéad Corrigan, is a peace activist from Northern Ireland. She co-founded, with Betty Williams and Ciaran McKeown, the Women for Peace, which later became the Community for Peace People, an organization dedicated to encouraging a peaceful resolution of the Troubles in Northern Ireland. Maguire and Williams were awarded the 1976 Nobel Peace Prize. Abolish Militarism and War: Mairead Maguire to the International Conference against US/NATO Military Bases https://cpnn-world.org/new/?p=14245

Dear Friends, It is good to be here with you all. I would like to thank the organizers for inviting me to address the conference. Firstly I thank you all for your work for peace. It is good that we will have an opportunity in the next few days to get to know each other and together discuss what kind of a world we want to live in? There will be many different perspectives on this and the way forward, but let us agree to respect each other and to engage in deep listening and conversation no matter how hard and where the dialogue might take us! Let us be encouraged by the fact that we have made an important first step when we agree to enter into dialogue, and when we agree that peace is both the means and the great achievable gift. It would be wonderful too no matter what area of social/political change we work in, if we can unite on a shared vision of a demilitarized world and find strength in agreeing we will not limit ourselves to civilizing and slowing down militarism, but demanding its total abolition. Some people might argue that peace is not possible in such a highly militarized world. However, I believe that peace is both possible and urgent. It is achievable when we each become impassioned about peace and filled with an ethic that makes peace our objective and we each put into practice our moral sense of political/social responsibility to build peace and justice. To build peace we are challenged to reject the bomb, the bullet, and all the techniques of violence. Unfortunately, we are constantly bombarded with the glorification of militarism and war; therefore building a culture of peace and nonviolence will not be an easy task.  We are hearing about the building of a European army and we are asked to accept austerity and budget cuts to our health, education, etc. whilst increasing money to our own armies and also European military expansion. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization-NATO, which should have been disbanded when the Warsaw Pact was dissolved, continue to carry out wars and proxy wars in many countries pushing towards the borders of Russia and resurrecting a cold war between the East and West. I believe that NATO should be disbanded and should be made accountable and make restitutions to the millions of people in countries such as Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, and many others it has illegally attacked, invaded, destroyed.  We will never be allowed by our governments, or our mainstream media, to hear many of the stories of the lives of so many civilians killed by US/NATO forces.  NATO forces have targeted and assassinated individuals and entire families.

2022 Michigan Kritik
Alt › AT: alt fails › Education possible

Demilitarization key to education – Change this goofy ass tag

Gwyn Kirk, 2018 has taught courses in women’s and gender studies at various US colleges and universities for nearly thirty years. She has written widely on ecofeminism and women’s peace organizing; coauthored work includes Greenham Women Everywhere, Women’s Lives: Multicultural Perspectives, and the documentary, Living along the Fenceline. Gwyn Kirk is a founding member of the International Women’s Network against Militarism, and Women for Genuine Security, the USbased partner in this Network. She is on the Steering Committee of Women Cross DMZ and a member of the Bay Area Comfort Women Justice Coalition. She holds a PhD in sociology from the London School of Economics.Demilitarization for Social Justice Gwyn Kirk Feminist Formations, Volume 30, Issue 3, Winter 2018, pp. 34-44 (Article)https://muse-jhu-edu.proxy.lib.umich.edu/article/705523/pdf//CDMoney

From 2014 to 2017, I taught an intensive January term course, Cultures of War and Peace, at St. Mary’s College of California, a Catholic liberal arts school. I wanted students to see that the United States is a highly militarized society, bolstered by massive corporate investments in military contracts and political support for high military spending, and to think about what could be gained, in terms of social justice and everyday security, by changing this. Students came into these classes with a wide range of knowledge and opinions. They had grown up on video games, war movies, mass shootings, and drone strikes. They had heard repeated assertions that war is “a necessary evil” or that “diplomacy doesn’t work.” Many believed that America (their term) is the “good guy” and strongly identified with the nation (“We went into Iraq . . .”). Two-thirds were young men, mostly first year students and mostly white. A few were veterans or enrolled in ROTC. Most had family members who had served in the military. Their affection and respect for these relatives made it difficult for many of them to question militarism as an institution. I provided a lot of information, which I hoped would help students contextualize and evaluate what they already knew. I emphasized the scale of US military spending, for example. This was $611 billion in 2016, more than the next eight countries combined.1 Over $700 billion is projected for 2019, over half the Federal discretionary budget.2 Yet we are told money is not available for public schools, Head Start, elder care, Veterans benefits, and many other socially useful programs that have been cut without remorse or apology. In researching Federal budget trade-offs many students were shocked to discover what their cities and counties could have bought with the money they contribute to the military.3 Some students felt the course was too negative about this country and war in general. They thought of themselves as realists—mature, pragmatic, and willing to accept “necessary evils.” They scorned moves toward demilitarization as idealistic. I asked what ideas and projects “realism” excludes, makes unsayable, or unimaginable? The course materials referenced the vast damage war and militarism cause.4 What is realistic about this? What might be useful about idealism? I wanted students to be able to question government policy and the role of the United States internationally. What does it mean to be American? Is there only one place to stand? How to widen the limited public discourse on Gwyn Kirk · 37 these issues? Could this country play a more constructive role internationally? If so, how should it do this? I wanted students to see that it is absolutely legitimate to desire something better than the current militarized, unsustainable state of the world. The college’s stated principles of social justice, religious faith, and respect for all persons created the space for a course like this. Even so, it was a hard sell. I discarded many readings I thought these students might dismiss as rhetorical. I tiptoed around feminist concepts like “militarized masculinity” (Enloe 2000, 235). I had to learn how to carry on this intensive discussion as a white woman older than their grandmas, with students I would probably not otherwise teach. I focus on militarism here, but those who teach about the impacts of globalization or the role of the nation-state face similar challenges. Liberal perspectives do not question the fundamental assumptions and institutions of our society, which is essential for addressing the root causes of injustice. By contrast, seeking equal access to combat roles or Senate seats, difficult as that may be, is a very limited goal. Further, many students know little about the effects of US policies on people in other nations, or how the United States exercises power worldwide—culturally, economically, politically, and militarily. Some students’ sense of patriotism made them highly resistant to thinking about such issues (Hase 2002). A few dismissed virtually all the course materials as “ridiculous rubbish,” “hippy nonsense,” or laughably naïve. In their papers, I commented that, in college, students’ work must engage with the ideas presented. You can rebut them but you can’t simply dismiss them with “put-downs” like this. I asked the group, If you find yourself feeling defensive about a reading or something said in class, what is being attacked? What is at stake for you? Could you respond with curiosity instead of feeling offended? What else would it help you to know? As a group, the students knew much more about war than they did about peace, a concept that seemed hazy and weak. We watched Facing Fear (Cohen 2013), featuring Tim Zaal, a former neo-Nazi skinhead, and Matthew Boger, the gay victim of Zaal’s hate-crime attack. Remarkably, these men met again twenty-five years after that incident. They were challenged to grapple with their feelings and fears about each other, and against the odds, they became friends. I asked students about their own experiences of forgiveness and reconciliation and what it takes to change their hearts and their behavior. We watched Regret to Inform by Barbara Sonneborn (2000), who visited Vietnam to learn about other widows’ experiences twenty years after her husband was killed there. Vietnamese women were touched by this and thanked her for wanting to know how they’d coped with the devastation of that war in their own land—a small moment of personal reconciliation between women who had been defined as enemies. A guest speaker, formerly in the Navy and now a youth worker, explained why and how he became a conscientious objector. Students read about US Army veterans who knelt before indigenous elders at Standing Rock and apologized for US wars against their people. They read about community truth-telling efforts as part of healing from violence and conflict, and about dedicated behind-thescenes work to hammer out agreements between groups or nations. Following Enloe (2000), I emphasized demilitarization as a step-by-step process rather than peace as a static condition. Nations may become more or less militarized, depending on many factors. Creating Resources for Teaching and Learning Thanks to Franklin Graham, our first editor, Margo Okazawa-Rey and I were able to include a chapter on women and the military in Women’s Lives: Multicultural Perspectives. This focuses on militarism as a central institution in this country. It considers how militarism deploys gender and race, the impact of war and US bases on women overseas, and it discusses feminist opposition to militarism and war. Although not all teachers who use the book assign this chapter, the increase in militarization, especially since 9/11, makes it a salient topic for an introductory course. Another resource is Living along the Fenceline, a low-budget documentary featuring grassroots women leaders from Okinawa (Japan) to Texas and Puerto Rico (Hoshino, Kirk, and Lee 2012). Although not considered war zones, these strategic sites are part of a network of roughly 1,000 overseas bases that allow the United States to go to war anytime, anywhere. These women are not fourstar generals or White House strategists. Their expertise comes from living with the effects of militarism on a daily basis. Director Lina Hoshino focused on women’s stories. She filmed barbed wire fences around the bases, DANGERKEEP OUT signs, fighter jets zooming overhead, and the grassy spot in a park where a woman was raped by soldiers and tells us, this is where it happened. Despite different locations, the film shows recurring patterns: gender-based violence, environmental destruction, the impacts of colonization, and the importance of women’s organizing and leadership. Our goal was to affirm each woman’s work in responding to the US military presence in her backyard, and to show the possibility of a very different kind of security centered on respect for people and the land. I have helped to organize antimilitary fashion shows as a way to discuss militarism in accessible terms (Ahn and Kirk 2009). The Women of Color Resource Center staged the first one at a standing-room-only event in Oakland in 2005 featuring original designs as well as street “camo” and demo wear (Enloe 2007). As models walked the “runway,” a narrator read a script describing each outfit.5 Feminist scholar Cynthia Enloe talked about the military origins of khaki. Spoken word artists and musicians added to the event’s energy and political analysis. Since then, various groups have put on their own versions of this show. Local artists and designers, thrift-store bargain hunters, and people handy with a needle, glue gun, stapler, or duct tape have made remarkable outfits: Bomb Gown, Military Carbon Footprint, Bikini, Respirator Bra, Fence Dress, War Is Not Sexy, People’s Budget, Uncle Spam, and more. These shows can be theatrical events as in Oakland and at the University of Oregon, or pared down as part of a talk or workshop. Much of the excitement is in designing original outfits and scripts that encapsulate the stories people want to tell. Another community project was an event at the Comfort Women memorial in San Francisco. This memorial, located in a public park, commemorates some 400,000 young women forced into sexual slavery by the Japanese Imperial Army from 1931 to 1945 (McGrane 2017).6 For International Women’s Day 2018, members of local groups created altars representing other examples of systemic violence against women—in addition to the plight of WWII comfort women—and celebrating resistance to it: • missing and murdered indigenous women, • women victims of war and drone strikes, • migrant women crossing the US-Mexico border, • women impacted by US military bases in Asia, • violence against Palestinian women living under Israeli occupation, and • violence against trans women in this country. In each case, soldiers, prison guards, police officers, or Border Patrol have assaulted, raped, and killed women or gender nonconforming people. This may be based on state policy as with WWII comfort women, or on militarized assumptions and cultures of law enforcement that condone, justify, or encourage gender-based violence. Those in authority may ignore these crimes. They may refuse to believe survivors’ testimony, close down public discussion, and cover up evidence. Culprits may be promoted, protected, or let off with a slap on the wrist. These factors make it imperative for feminists to speak out about such issues in public and demand that they be stopped. It was moving to see the care with which women had created their altars, placing photos and women’s names among flowers, candles, and colorful fabrics.7 Participants made brief presentations about these items as a way to explain each issue and to recognize the work of organizations that oppose these blatant violations of women’s human rights. Sharing these harrowing stories was an inspiring way to connect struggles across racial, ethnic, and national lines—an opportunity for learning, networking, and affirming shared beliefs about social justice and human integrity. Contexts and Frameworks In my experience, teaching for social justice requires focus and patience. It takes work to go against the grain. It may carry unacceptable personal and professional risks, especially for those responsible for children and other family members. As well as personal conviction, feminist scholars and teachers also need contexts that sustain us in this work. I am grateful for the support and encouragement I have received over the years from department chairs, colleagues, students, editors, and publishers. Also, I have benefitted enormously from working with Women for Genuine Security, a small but vibrant political community that is part of the International Women’s Network Against Militarism (Cachola et al. 2010).8 As teachers concerned with social justice, we are up against the teachings of the corporate media, right-wing talk shows, the stereotypes circulating in news reports and popular culture, and the echo chamber of social media. An iconic figure like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. has been reduced to a “dreamer” by the news networks, while his hard-hitting speech linking “the giant triplets of racism, materialism, and militarism” is far less well known (King 1967). We are up against endless distractions, shorter attention spans, the price of tuition and textbooks, and other economic pressures students face. We are up against everyday psychological explanations that see inequality and injustice in terms of low-self esteem, poor identity development, learned helplessness, or a few “bad apples” that spoil the barrel. We juggle these considerations as we construct our courses, create assignments, and help students to absorb class materials, including structural analyses necessary to explain these systems of oppression.9 As well as identifying complexities and contradictions, intersectional feminist theorizing reminds us that academia was not set up to promote social justice, despite the development of fields like ethnic studies, women’s and gender studies, and queer studies that embrace this goal. As National Women’s Studies Association (NWSA) members know, these programs were created as a result of strong social movements and student demands. Determined faculty members generated the intellectual rationale for them. They negotiated with university administrators, got curriculum committees to approve courses, made connections across academic departments, and so on. In turn, they have needed Deans willing to validate such programs and direct resources to them. In the past twenty years, the political climate for WGS on campuses and in the wider society has become more challenging as misogynist, racist, and xenophobic viewpoints have gained ground through official rhetoric, legislation, policy, and the narrowing of public discourse. Increasingly, faculty members may face challenges to their teaching methods and course content; their work may be written off as “biased,” unscholarly, or politically motivated (Nisenson 2017). Indeed, such attacks on academic freedom have made many teachers’ lives more difficult, in some cases seriously affecting their physical and mental health, even leading to dismissal. Also, academic institutions have become increasingly beholden to corporate funding and values. Budget cuts, department mergers, and the fact that two-thirds of faculty are on part-time or temporary contracts these days all affect the organization and viability of interdisciplinary programs like women’s and gender studies. These turbulent times make the political nature of education explicit. It is crucial that we organize collectively on campuses and in communities to support teaching for social justice, and that we are part of strong, vocal, professional organizations that also do this. Tenured or tenure-track faculty must challenge the normalization of contingent labor and the professional and economic vulnerability of the many teachers hired on short-term contracts (Betensky 2017). As a community of feminist scholars and teachers, we must support those whose work is threatened by conservative voices and organizations on and off campus. We should help support feminist activist writers who have contributed to scholarship, teaching, and course materials over the years without regular remuneration for this. We should urge other professional associations to do the same. I believe our job as feminist scholars and teachers is to think big, to help provide spaces where students and community members can confront current challenges, and where they are affirmed as people who care about social justice, not based on guilt or pity, but as part of a “common context of struggle.”10 Ethnic studies, women’s and gender studies, and queer studies programs have all contributed to such understandings and communities of praxis. A silver lining in this wild time is that even as some political spaces are being closed down, new social movements are opening up others. The strong tradition of organizing for social justice in this country as well as the many efforts currently underway need to be much better known. They provide lessons, models, and inspiration. We cannot afford to despair or to nurture despair in others. We must continue to work for and hold out the possibility of progressive change even as past gains are being attacked and unraveled. In this regard, the 2018 NWSA conference theme, Just Imagine, Imagining Justice, is well chosen. A focus on values, beliefs, and visions is much needed in these challenging times. In October 2018, a Women’s March on the Pentagon seeks to refocus national attention on the immense costs of militarism at home and abroad.11 The organizers highlight the fact that both major political parties support war and militarism, and see the March as a call for a radical redefinition of security. Working for social justice means taking on the world as it is currently constructed. We need all our passion, creativity, skills, life experience, and the conviction that things can and must be organized differently, based on justice and love. How does your work contribute to such a vision? Who and what inspire you to do it? Who are your allies and accomplices? How do you cope with the challenges you face? What new processes, tools, and understandings do we need to create, as feminist scholars and teachers, to help us move forward?

2022 Michigan Kritik
Alt › AT: alt fails › SPF

Systemic Militarization results in serial policy failure.

Giroux 06 Henry Armand Giroux (born 1943) is an American-Canadian scholar and . Giroux earned a  degree in history at  in 1977. One of the founding theorists of  in the United States, he is best known for his pioneering work in public , , , , , and . In 2002  named Giroux as one of the top fifty educational thinkers of the modern period. “The Emerging Authoritarianism in the United States: Political Culture under the Bush/Cheney Administration”

As militarization spreads through the culture, it produces policies that rely more on force than on dialogue and compassion; it offers up modes of identification that undermine democratic values and tarnish civil liberties; and it makes the production of both symbolic and material violence a central feature of everyday life. As Kevin Baker points out, we are quickly becoming a nation that "substitute[s] military solutions for almost everything, including international alliances, diplomacy, effective intelligence agencies, democratic institutions - even national security" (38). Within this ideology, masculinity is associated with violence, and action is often substituted for the democratic processes of deliberation and debate. Militarization is about the rule of force and the expansion of repressive state power. In fact, democracy appears as an excess in this logic and is often condemned by militarists as being a weak system of government. Echoes of this anti-democratic sentiment can be found in the Patriot Act with its violation of civil liberties, in a rancorous patriotism that equates dissent with treason, and in the discourse of public commentators, who, in the fervor of a militarized culture, fan the flames of hatred and intolerance. One example that has become all too typical emerged after the September 11 attacks. Columnist Ann Coulter, in calling for a holy war on Muslims, wrote "We should invade their countries, kill their leaders and convert them to Christianity. We weren't punctilious about locating and punishing only Hitler and his top officers. We carpet-bombed German cities; we killed civilians. That's war. And this is war/715. While this statement does not reflect mainstream of American opinion, the uncritical and chauvinistic patriotism and intolerance that inform it not only have become standard fare among many conservative radio hosts in the United States but are increasingly being legitimated in a wide variety of cultural venues. By blurring the lines between military and civilian functions, militarization deforms our language, debases democratic values, celebrates fascist modes of control, defines citizens as soldiers, and diminishes our ability as a nation to uphold international law and support a democratic global public sphere. Unless militarization is systematically exposed and resisted at every place where it appears in the culture, it will undermine the meaning of critical citizenship and do great harm to those institutions that are central to a democratic society