Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Why Republicans Are Favored to Win The House,

JUN. 30, 2022

Republicans are substantial favorites to take over the U.S. House of Representatives following this November’s midterm elections, but the U.S. Senate is much more competitive, according to , which launched today. Democrats are also favored to hang on to the governorships in a trio of swing states in the Rust Belt — Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Michigan — although they are significant underdogs to win high-profile gubernatorial races in Georgia and Texas against Republican incumbents.

The split diagnosis reflects the difference between macro- and micro-level conditions. The national environment is quite poor for Democrats. Of course, this is typical for the president’s party, which has lost seats in the House in . But Democrats are also saddled with  and a series of challenges for the country, including inflation levels that haven’t been seen in decades, the lingering effects of the still-ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and  — caused, in part, by . 

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Voter dissatisfaction with POTUS gives the GOP an edge to win in November.

Zurcher 5/3 [5/3/2022] Anthony Zurcher is BBC’s senior North American reporter, covering US politics and cultural happenings across the continent. He joined the BBC in 2013 and has covered the US Supreme Court, Congress, the technology sector and Texas state politics; https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-61280069 _Amber 

The Republican party is widely expected to win back at least one chamber of Congress in the mid-term elections later this year. But its leaders have been reluctant to say what it would do with that power — and that could mean trouble in the not-so-long run.

Some Republican 2024 presidential hopefuls have each released multi-point policy agendas that they may try to build a campaign around. But those in the Republican congressional leadership seem to believe that the path to power will be smoother if they keep the details of their agenda intentionally vague. It keeps their party united and gives Democrats less of a target to attack.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Democrats Lose --Roe can’t save Democrats in Midterms – Filibuster thumps

Marshall ‘ 6/22 [June 06, 2022] Josh Marshall; Mr. Marshall has covered politics and elections for 25 years. _Moonyoung

Democrats hope to make November’s midterm elections a referendum on Roe v. Wade, the linchpin decision upholding abortion rights, which the Supreme Court is almost certain to strike down this summer. That strategy makes sense. Polls show that roughly two in three Americans oppose overturning Roe and almost 60 percent support passing a bill to set Roe’s protections in a federal law. What’s more, polls showed a rising number of voters listing abortion as their top midterm issue after news of Roe’s imminent demise leaked in the form of a draft court opinion published by Politico. Unfortunately, their current plan is almost sure to fail. After the Democrats came up with just 49 votes to bring a Roe-protecting bill before the Senate on May 11, they promised to keep fighting and, in the words of Senator Amy Klobuchar, “take that fight right to the ballot box” in November. But you can’t make an election into a referendum on an issue if you can’t point to anything winning the election would accomplish. To make the 2022 elections a referendum on Roe, Democrats have to put protecting Roe and abortion rights on the table. Here’s one way to do that: get clear public commitments from every Senate Democrat (and candidate for Senate) not only to vote for the Roe bill in January 2023 but also to change the filibuster rules to ensure that a majority vote would actually pass the bill and send it to the White House for the president’s signature. At present, there are likely 48 Senate Democrats who can make that pledge. Senators Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema are dead set against any changes to the filibuster — a fact you likely know because most of President Biden’s agenda has been bottled up behind their refusal for the past year. Some claim that Senators Manchin and Sinema are just taking the public heat for a number of other Senate Democrats who are also unwilling to change the filibuster rules. That’s highly unlikely. But if any do have misgivings, that’s why the public commitments are so important. Getting a list of holdouts down to a publicly named handful is the first step to persuading them to fall in line. If my math is right and there are 48 Senate Democrats ready to make that pledge, they need two additional Democratic senators in the next Congress. And that is the party’s message that makes the 2022 midterms a referendum on Roe: “Give us the House and two more senators, and we will make No ambiguity, no haggling, no living in Senator Manchin’s head for a year. You give us this, and we’ll give you that. That tells voters exactly what will be delivered with a Democratic win. It also defines what constitutes a win: control of the House and two more Senate seats. The campaign message is clear: If you want to protect Roe, give us those majorities. If this is your passion, here’s where to channel that passion. These are the Senate seats we need to hold (in New Hampshire, Arizona, Georgia and Nevada) and here are the ones we need to win (in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin and possibly in Ohio, Florida and North Carolina). With those commitments in hand, one question should be on the lips of every Democratic candidate. Will you make a firm commitment to never vote for a federal law banning abortion nationwide? Few, if any, Republicans would be able to make that pledge. And their evasions wouldn’t just make them look ridiculous; that would put squarely on the table the very real threat that Republicans would enact a nationwide abortion ban as soon as January 2025. That could prove enough to win Senate races in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Ohio. In a way, though, this strategy isn’t so much about winning the 2022 midterms or even making Roe into a federal law, although it’s the best way to accomplish both. It’s just an example of how you win elections. Effective campaigns are built on connecting the intense beliefs of the electorate — their hopes and fears — directly to the hard mechanics of political power. You’ve got to connect those wires. If you were testing some new electrical contraption, that’s the first thing you’d do: make sure the energy supply is wired to the engine that makes it run. This is no different. Without tying a specific electoral result to a clear commitment to a specific legislative action after the elections, you’re not connecting those wires. What Democrats would be proposing is a classic small-c conservative solution in the best sense of the word. Codifying Roe would preserve the set of rights and protections that the vast majority of Americans have lived their entire adult lives with and that the overwhelming majority of Americans do not want to change. The threat that the court will strike down such a law is real but overstated. And in any case, refusing to act because of what opponents might do is the definition of political paralysis. So how do Democrats get from here to there? They likely can’t rely on the party’s leaders, at least not at first. But they’re not essential. It’s really up to voters and activists and particularly committed members of Congress. Probably half the Democrats in the Senate would be happy to sign on this dotted line by the end of the day. Those who are up for re-election, even in safe races, will come around quickly. Some senators may resist at first. And that wouldn’t be surprising. Politicians seldom see any advantage to committing themselves in advance or reducing their room for maneuver. It’s always safer to keep your options open and be as general as possible until the final moment. That’s why assembling a clear public list of commitments is critical. Once the list gets down to a handful of hesitaters, the pressure from Democrats nationwide, focused on those members, will be overwhelming. If there are real holdouts, they’ll fold in short order. You don’t need to wait on Nancy Pelosi or Chuck Schumer or President Biden. You can get the ball rolling by calling up your Democratic senator today.

Gallup 6/14 [Gallup, Inc., 6-14-2022, "Usual Midterm Indicators Very Unfavorable for Democrats," Gallup, ] Jeff and Liam

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Democrats expected to lose big.

Roche 7/7 [Darragh Roche, 7-7-2022, "Democrats' worst case scenario for the midterms," Newsweek, ] Liam and Jeff

Democrats are widely expected to suffer defeats in the upcoming 2022 midterm elections, with Republicans aiming to retake the House of Representatives and the Senate. The serving president's party usually performs poorly during midterms and while it seems likely President Joe Biden will see major losses this November, it's not clear just how bad things will be for the Democrats. Polls suggest the Democrats are on course for disappointment and that the party could potentially lose control of both chambers of Congress and see newly empowered Republican majorities stymying Biden's agenda in the run up to the next presidential election. A GOP gain in either chamber would hamstring the Biden administration, but the worst case scenario would see comfortable Republican majorities in both chambers, potentially leading to a slew of investigations and possibly even impeachment of the president. Losing the Senate. Poll tracker FiveThirtyEight's 2022 election forecast rates the Senate as a toss up with 35 seats up for re-election. Fourteen are currently held by Democrats and 21 by Republicans. FiveThirtyEight gives Republicans [have] an 80 percent chance of holding between 47 and 54 seats. If that latter figure is reached, it would represent a major defeat for Biden's party. The Senate is currently divided between 50 Republicans, 48 Democrats and two independents who caucus with the Democrats. Vice President Kamala Harris has had to use her casting vote on a number of occasions and a single Democratic loss in the midterms would hand control to the Republicans. FiveThirtyEight rates the Senate races in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and Pennsylvania as toss-ups. If Republicans can win all four, it would be a major loss for the Democrats. Three of those seats are held by incumbent Democrats, while Republican Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania is retiring. However, it's highly unlikely that Republicans could gain enough seats in November to secure a 60-vote, filibuster proof majority. This means Democrats are likely to deploy the filibuster if the GOP retakes the chamber. Nonetheless, a Republican-led Senate could hold up Biden's judicial nominees and potentially prevent him filling any vacant seats that might arise on the U.S. Supreme Court, as Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell did in 2016 when he was majority leader. A new poll found that nearly 60 percent of Americans disapprove of the job President Joe Biden is doing as president. Republicans are favored to win the House, according to FiveThirtyEight, while Democrats currently hold 220 seats to Republicans' 210, with five seats vacant. The poll tracker's analysis gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 215 and 258 seats. If the larger figure proves accurate, that would be a huge gain for the GOP, though it remains an outside possibility. The single worst midterm loss of House seats occurred in 2010 when Democrats lost 63 seats under then President Barack Obama. However, Obama's party retained control of the Senate until the 2014 midterms. It seems likely that Republican gains this year will be more modest but that the GOP will still win the House. That will allow House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to become speaker for the first time and possibly mean the end of Speaker Nancy Pelosi's political career. FiveThirtyEight's generic congressional ballot shows Republicans with 44.8 percent support to the Democrats' 43.2 percent, as of July 6 - a margin of just 1.7 percent. If Republicans retake the House, recent reporting suggests they will launch a series of investigations into the Biden administration. Those probes could include the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, the business dealings of Hunter Biden and even an investigation into the House Select Committee currently examining the events of January 6, 2021. Republican investigations could dominate the political agenda heading into the 2024 presidential election. Democrats may also be concerned about potential impeachment charges against President Biden, as some Republicans have previously suggested. An impeachment push could center on the withdrawal from Afghanistan or accusations relating to Biden's involvement in his son's business. He has denied any involvement with Hunter Biden's foreign business affairs. If the GOP controls both the House and Senate, investigations could multiply and the possibility of impeachment could be even greater. Losses in the midterms will prove disappointing for Democrats and politically difficult for Biden, but Thomas Gift, founding director of University College London's Centre on U.S. Politics, told Newsweek the president's party may have even bigger problems. "For Democrats, the worst case scenario isn't just that they lose big in November. It's that they lose big—and learn the wrong lessons about why they got beat," Gift said. "There's a certain faction within the Democratic Party that will argue that its looming defeats in the midterms are the result of not leaning hard enough into the progressive agenda. That's not just wrong. It's delusional," he said. Gift said that data showed centrist positions "poll well with American voters. Far-left positions don't." "If Democrats continue to embrace policies that most voters perceive as unacceptably liberal, 2022 will only be the harbinger of more losses in 2024," he said. "The sooner Democrats realize that what earns likes on Twitter doesn't earn votes in swing states, the sooner they'll figure out what it takes to beat the eminently beatable Republican Party," Gift added.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

No chance for Dems

Durkee 6/14, , Alison, is a breaking news reporter at Forbes and an NYC-based arts writer specializing in theatre, dance, politics, and cultural tourism, Democrats’ Midterm Nightmare: Polls Suggest Party Could Face Historic Loss, Jun 14, 2022 , Forbes,

Democrats could experience a “greater-than-average” loss in the midterm elections this November, new Gallup polling suggests, finding that voters’ satisfaction with the country and federal government are largely at record lows compared with other midterm years. President Biden Returns To The White House From Delaware President Joe Biden waves as he returns to the White House June 13 in Washington, DC. GETTY IMAGES KEY FACTS The Gallup poll, conducted May 2-22 among 1,007 U.S. adults, found only 41% approve of President Joe Biden’s job performance, 18% approve of Congress’ performance and 16% are “satisfied with the way things are going in the U.S.” Only 14% have a positive view of economic conditions right now and 46% rate the economy negatively, meaning Americans have a 32-point net negative view of the economy. All of those metrics are at least 10 points below the average for midterm years, based on Gallup’s polling going back to 1974. PROMOTED Americans have a 51% approval rating for the president on average during midterm election years, a 30% congressional approval rating, 35% satisfaction with the state of the U.S. and a nine-point net positive rating of the economy. Other than presidential approval rating—where Biden’s 41% approval is tied with former President Donald Trump’s in 2018 and higher than President George W. Bush’s 38% in 2006—every metric recorded this year marks a historic low. Gallup suggests the low ratings mean Democrats will likely lose seats in the election this year—as a president’s party typically does during the midterms—and their losses would likely be even larger than usual if these low ratings hold. BIG NUMBER 23. That’s the average number of House seats a president’s party loses during the midterms, Gallup found based on data going back to 1974. Parties suffer even bigger losses when Americans aren’t satisfied with how things are going, though: Republicans lost 40 seats in 2018 when Americans had a 21% positive view of Congress and 41% approval of Trump, for instance, and Democrats lost 63 seats in 2010 during Barack Obama’s presidency. Though Obama was slightly more popular than Biden (45% approval), Americans similarly had a 21% approval of Congress, 22% satisfaction with the U.S. and 31-point net-negative view of the economy that year. WHAT TO WATCH FOR How Democrats will fare in the midterms. Republicans only need to flip five House seats to gain control of the chamber, and one seat in the Senate, where the parties are now evenly split. Based on current trends, Gallup projects the midterms will potentially be a “wave election” for the GOP and give them a “comfortable governing majority.” WHAT WE DON’T KNOW How things could change before November for Democrats. The Supreme Court is poised to likely overturn Roe v. Wade and let states ban abortion in the coming weeks, for instance, which recent polling has suggested may help galvanize Democrats and get more to the polls. Gun control could also come into play in the wake of a string of mass shootings, Gallup notes, as polling shows most Americans favor stricter gun measures and thus could be motivated to vote against Republicans who oppose them. KEY BACKGROUND Gallup’s polling comes as Biden has seen record-low approval ratings in recent months, with a FiveThirtyEight analysis finding 39.7% approve of him on average—the lowest share at any point during his presidency. The president has not had an average approval rating over 50% since August 2021. Other polls have similarly found Republicans are likely to have a clear advantage in the midterms, with a FiveThirtyEight poll analysis finding 45% of Americans prefer to vote for a Republican candidate in November versus a Democrat (42.6% would support the Democrat). A Morning Consult/Politico poll from May found Republicans were still more enthusiastic about voting in the midterms than Democrats (61% versus 54%), even after Politico leaked a draft opinion suggesting the Supreme Court will overturn Roe v. Wade.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Republican’s red wave will hit congress

Cillizza 6/17, Chris, a CNN Politics Reporter and Editor-at-Large, covering national politics including the White House, Congress and every district they represent, June 17, 2022 could house democrats lose 70 seats this fall, cnn, cs/midterm-election-house-gains-republican-democrat/index.html_Patrick

(CNN)Last month, Newt Gingrich made a bold (and seemingly wild) prediction about the . "I think we'll pick up between 25 and 70 seats in the House," the former Republican House speaker . Seventy seats! That would not only eclipse the 63-seat gain Republicans made in the 2010 midterm elections, but would also be the largest seat switch in the House since 1948. Gingrich, as he often does, was likely just riffing -- going for an outlandishly high ceiling on Republican gains to draw headlines and attention. Which, well, mission accomplished. Gingrich's ceiling of 70 seats is well in excess of where nonpartisan political handicappers are -- at least at the moment. David Wasserman, the House editor at the , is projecting Republicans gain between 20 and 35 seats. Nathan Gonzales hasn't released his range just yet -- it's coming next week -- but says, "Republicans are well positioned to win the majority." New data from Gallup suggests that the national political environment is arguably worse for Democrats than it was in 2010 -- raising at least the possibility that the party suffers even larger losses than currently predicted. : "The party of the president typically loses U.S. House seats in midterm elections -- an average of 23 since 1974. However, 2022 is not shaping up to be an average year. Rather, as of May, Gallup finds presidential job approval and three other key national mood indicators well below the historical averages measured in past midterm election years. On their own, those numbers would all predict a greater-than-average loss of seats for the Democratic Party this fall." A glance at the -- which looks at presidential approval, congressional approval, satisfaction with the direction of the country and overall judgment of economic conditions -- reveals that the environment that was measured in May looks a lot like it did at the end of the 2010 cycle. Consider: 2022 Biden approval: 41% Congressional approval: 18% US satisfaction: 16% Economic conditions (net): -32 2010 Obama approval: 45% Congressional approval: 21% US satisfaction: 22% Economic conditions (net): -31 Pretty similar, right? If anything, the national political environment -- as understood through these four factors -- is worse for Democrats now than it was in 2010. Now, before you sign on to Gingrich's 70-seat prediction, it's worth considering that: a) The past two national redistricting processes (in 2011 and 2021) have, broadly speaking, created more safe districts that are virtually certain to elect a member of one party. b) The 2020 election, in which Republicans netted 12 House seats, likely limits the ceiling of GOP gains since some of the lower-hanging fruit has already been, um, picked. To be very clear here: A 70-seat Republican gain in the fall still feels more like a Gingrich fever dream than a fact-based possibility. But as : "The current Democratic congressional majority is facing an extremely unfavorable election environment." The Point: Democrats are in as bad a shape as they have been at this point of a midterm election as they have been in many decades. And what's worse for the party is that there's no obvious event or series of events that could (or will) turn things around.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Dems set to suffer huge losses at midterms

Roche 7/7, Darragh, reporter at US News. “Democrats Worst Case Scenario for the Midterms” 7/7/2022 Newsweek.com. https://www.newsweek.com/democrats-worst-case-scenario-midterms-joe-biden-republicans-1722543_Albert

Democrats are widely expected to suffer defeats in the upcoming 2022 midterm elections, with aiming to retake the House of Representatives and the . The serving president's party and while it seems likely President will see major losses this November, it's not clear just how bad things will be for the . Polls suggest the Democrats are on course for disappointment and that the party could potentially lose control of both chambers of and see newly empowered Republican majorities stymying Biden's agenda in the run up to the next presidential election. A GOP gain in either chamber would hamstring the Biden administration, but the worst case scenario would see comfortable Republican majorities in both chambers, potentially leading to a slew of investigations and possibly even impeachment of the president. Poll tracker FiveThirtyEight's 2022 election forecast rates the Senate as a toss up with 35 seats up for re-election. Fourteen are currently held by Democrats and 21 by Republicans. FiveThirtyEight gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 47 and 54 seats. If that latter figure is reached, it would represent a major defeat for Biden's party. The Senate is currently divided between 50 Republicans, 48 Democrats and two independents who caucus with the Democrats. Vice President has had to use her casting vote on a number of occasions and a single Democratic loss in the midterms would hand control to the Republicans. FiveThirtyEight rates the Senate races in Arizona, Georgia, Nevada and Pennsylvania as toss-ups. If Republicans can win all four, it would be a major loss for the Democrats. Three of those seats are held by incumbent Democrats, while Republican Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania is retiring. However, it's highly unlikely that Republicans could gain enough seats in November to secure a 60-vote, filibuster proof majority. This means Democrats are likely to deploy the filibuster if the GOP retakes the chamber. Nonetheless, a Republican-led Senate could hold up Biden's judicial nominees and potentially prevent him filling any vacant seats that might arise on the U.S. , as Senate Minority Leader did in 2016 when he was majority leader. A new poll found that nearly 60 percent of Americans disapprove of the job President Joe Biden is doing as president. Above, Biden bows his head in prayer Tuesday before presenting the Medal of Honor to four Army soldiers who fought in the Vietnam War. Republicans are favored to win the House, according to FiveThirtyEight, while Democrats currently hold 220 seats to Republicans' 210, with five seats vacant. The poll tracker's analysis gives Republicans an 80 percent chance of holding between 215 and 258 seats. If the larger figure proves accurate, that would be a huge gain for the GOP, though it remains an outside possibility. The single worst midterm loss of House seats occurred in 2010 when Democrats lost 63 seats under then President . However, Obama's party retained control of the Senate until the 2014 midterms. It seems likely that Republican gains this year will be more modest but that the GOP will still win the House. That will allow House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to become speaker for the first time and possibly mean FiveThirtyEight's generic congressional ballot shows Republicans with 44.8 percent support to the Democrats' 43.2 percent, as of July 6 - a margin of just 1.7 percent. If Republicans retake the House, recent reporting suggests they will launch a series of investigations into the Biden administration. Those probes could include the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, the business dealings of and even an investigation into the House Select Committee currently examining the events of January 6, 2021. Republican investigations could dominate the political agenda heading into the 2024 presidential election. Democrats may also be concerned about potential impeachment charges against President Biden, as An impeachment push could center on the withdrawal from Afghanistan or accusations relating to Biden's involvement in his son's business. He has denied any involvement with Hunter Biden's foreign business affairs. If the GOP controls both the House and Senate, investigations could multiply and the possibility of impeachment could be even greater. Losses in the midterms will prove disappointing for Democrats and politically difficult for Biden, but Thomas Gift, founding director of University College London's Centre on U.S. Politics, told Newsweek the president's party may have even bigger problems. "For Democrats, the worst case scenario isn't just that they lose big in November. It's that they lose big—and learn the wrong lessons about why they got beat," Gift said. "There's a certain faction within the that will argue that its looming defeats in the midterms are the result of not leaning hard enough into the progressive agenda. That's not just wrong. It's delusional," he said. Gift said that data showed centrist positions "poll well with American voters. Far-left positions don't." "If Democrats continue to embrace policies that most voters perceive as unacceptably liberal, 2022 will only be the harbinger of more losses in 2024," he said. "The sooner Democrats realize that what earns likes on doesn't earn votes in swing states, the sooner they'll figure out what it takes to beat the eminently beatable Republican Party," Gift added.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › DEM WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS-Dems will Lose in November

Democrats expected to take historic loss in midterms – Gallup Poll proves.

Durkee 6/14 - Alison, New York-based journalist covering breaking news at Forbes, Previously covered politics and news for Vanity Fair and Mic, and a theater critic that serves as a member of the New York Outer Critics Circle, “Democrats’ Midterm Nightmare: Polls Suggest Party Could Face Historic Loss”, 06-14-2022, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2022/06/14/democrats-midterm-nightmare-polls-suggest-party-could-face-historic-loss/?sh=2ae68e8f5193. Edwin

Democrats could experience a “greater-than-average” loss in the midterm elections this November, new Gallup polling suggests, finding that voters’ satisfaction with the country and federal government are largely at record lows compared with other midterm years. President Biden Returns To The White House From Delaware President Joe Biden waves as he returns to the White House June 13 in Washington, DC. The Gallup poll, conducted May 2-22 among 1,007 U.S. adults, found only 41% approve of President Joe Biden’s job performance, 18% approve of Congress’ performance and 16% are “satisfied with the way things are going in the U.S.” Only 14% have a positive view of economic conditions right now and 46% rate the economy negatively, meaning Americans have a 32-point net negative view of the economy. All of those metrics are at least 10 points below the average for midterm years, based on Gallup’s polling going back to 1974. PROMOTED Americans have a 51% approval rating for the president on average during midterm election years, a 30% congressional approval rating, 35% satisfaction with the state of the U.S. and a nine-point net positive rating of the economy. Other than presidential approval rating—where Biden’s 41% approval is tied with former President Donald Trump’s in 2018 and higher than President George W. Bush’s 38% in 2006—every metric recorded this year marks a historic low. Gallup suggests the low ratings mean Democrats will likely lose seats in the election this year—as a president’s party typically does during the midterms—and their losses would likely be even larger than usual if these low ratings hold. BIG NUMBER 23. That’s the average number of House seats a president’s party loses during the midterms, Gallup found based on data going back to 1974. Parties suffer even bigger losses when Americans aren’t satisfied with how things are going, though: Republicans lost 40 seats in 2018 when Americans had a 21% positive view of Congress and 41% approval of Trump, for instance, and Democrats lost 63 seats in 2010 during Barack Obama’s presidency. Though Obama was slightly more popular than Biden (45% approval), Americans similarly had a 21% approval of Congress, 22% satisfaction with the U.S. and 31-point net-negative view of the economy that year. WHAT TO WATCH FOR How Democrats will fare in the midterms. Republicans only need to flip five House seats to gain control of the chamber, and one seat in the Senate, where the parties are now evenly split. Based on current trends, Gallup projects the midterms will potentially be a “wave election” for the GOP and give them a “comfortable governing majority.” WHAT WE DON’T KNOW How things could change before November for Democrats. The Supreme Court is poised to likely overturn Roe v. Wade and let states ban abortion in the coming weeks, for instance, which recent polling has suggested may help galvanize Democrats and get more to the polls. Gun control could also come into play in the wake of a string of mass shootings, Gallup notes, as polling shows most Americans favor stricter gun measures and thus could be motivated to vote against Republicans who oppose them. KEY BACKGROUND Gallup’s polling comes as Biden has seen record-low approval ratings in recent months, with a FiveThirtyEight analysis finding 39.7% approve of him on average—the lowest share at any point during his presidency. The president has not had an average approval rating over 50% since August 2021. Other polls have similarly found Republicans are likely to have a clear advantage in the midterms, with a FiveThirtyEight poll analysis finding 45% of Americans prefer to vote for a Republican candidate in November versus a Democrat (42.6% would support the Democrat). A Morning Consult/Politico poll from May found Republicans were still more enthusiastic about voting in the midterms than Democrats (61% versus 54%), even after Politico leaked a draft opinion suggesting the Supreme Court will overturn Roe v. Wade.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › IMPACT SCENARIOS

CLIMATE-Failure to Pass Climate Legislation ASAP Catastrophic

Failure to Keep Control Of Congress Jeopordizes Climate Legislation that Will Avert Climate Catastrophe

Grandoni et al. 7/16. Dino Grandoni, Brady Dennis and Juliet Eilperin “Democrats push sweeping climate legislation amid a scorching summer The Senate budget plan, which would compel power plants to slash emissions and impose a tax on laggard nations, still faces major hurdles” The Washington Post. July 16, 2022. LV

While the $3.5 trillion budget deal that emerged Wednesday could change in key ways in the months ahead, the proposal represents one of the biggest efforts yet that Congress has undertaken to address climate change. It underscores how cutting U.S. greenhouse gas emissions — and spurring other nations to do the same — has emerged as a central priority for President Biden and his party after years of relative indifference from lawmakers in Washington. “We are facing a planetary crisis, not in the future or somewhere far away, but in every community across the country,” said Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), who along with several other Senate Democrats has said he won’t support more traditional infrastructure spending without a separate bill that includes meaningful climate action. “So what we do has to be bold enough to meet the moment.” Still, the climate measures unveiled this week face significant political, legal and technical hurdles — including some from within the Democratic Party itself. Already, Sen. Joe Manchin III (D-W.Va.), a crucial vote Democrats will need to pass any legislation opposed by Republicans, has expressed skepticism over the push to rapidly phase out fossil fuels. The package represents the best chance of locking in the emissions cuts required to meet Biden’s goal of cutting U.S. greenhouse gas emissions at least in half by 2030, compared to 2005 levels. Senate Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) and other Democrats have assembled policies that would help realize that goal, while nudging the rest of the world to do the same. A central element in the plan would allow the United States to impose a tax on nations lagging in reducing their own pollution, as well as a fee on emissions of methane, a greenhouse gas more potent than carbon dioxide in the short term. Domestically, Democrats also want to institute a new set of requirements — called a clean-electricity standard — on power providers to shift them toward wind, solar, hydroelectric, nuclear and other cleaner forms of energy generation, with the goal of achieving 80 percent clean electricity by the end of the decade. The package would also offer a slew of tax breaks for buying electric vehicles and producing clean energy, and would create a Civilian Climate Corps, modeled after Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal-era Civilian Conservation Corps, which would enlist young Americans in planting trees, hardening coasts against rising tides and otherwise preparing the country for changing conditions. The details of the budgetary package will be fleshed out in the coming months, and it remains an open question as to whether the cuts in emissions that would result — both here and abroad — would be enough to help meet the goals of the Paris climate agreement, which calls for keeping warming “well below” 2 degrees Celsius, compared to preindustrial levels. By packing the climate provisions into a budget measure, Schumer is aiming to avoid a Republican filibuster and pass the bill through budget reconciliation, which requires a simple majority of 51 votes. But Democrats hold the narrowest of margins in the Senate, and Schumer probably will need to rally the support of every member of his caucus to pass the legislation. He and other Democrats know the clock is ticking, in more ways than one. Passing far-reaching climate measures, much less the litany of other infrastructure-related priorities, will become only more difficult as the midterm election year approaches and Democrats risk losing the House, Senate or both. In addition, environmental advocates have kept up pressure on Biden to make good on promises to combat climate change. The youth-led Sunrise Movement, for example, said the House needs to go even bigger than the Senate proposal to fund climate-friendly policies. “This is the first time since 2009 that Democrats have control of both chambers of Congress and the White House,” Lauren Maunus, the group’s advocacy director, said in a statement. “They cannot afford to waste this opportunity.” For many Democrats, nature has been displaying another form of urgency in the kind of startling and deadly events that scientists say are made more frequent and intense by the Earth’s warming. A series of brutal heat waves has roasted the Pacific Northwest and western Canada in recent weeks, setting temperature records, fueling intense wildfires and causing hundreds of deaths. A Canadian town burned. Once unthinkable triple-digit temperatures baked landscapes, contributing to what the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration called the hottest June on record for the United States. Meanwhile, crippling floods swept through Belgium and Germany this week, killing dozens of people and sweeping away cars and buildings. The catastrophe came amid a stretch of extreme weather in parts of Europe, including unusually heavy rains. All that may just be a prelude of what’s to come. Climate scientists say the United States and the rest of the world have less than a decade to get greenhouse gas emissions under control, or countries can expect ever more calamitous consequences from warming. Paul Bledsoe, a former Senate Finance Committee staffer and Clinton White House climate adviser, noted that the climate elements of this week’s budget proposal are in line with policies Biden promised to pursue during his presidential campaign. “He ran on it,” Bledsoe said of the border tariff proposal in particular. “He characterized it in his campaign climate plan as a way to curb China's emissions, specifically.” As to whether it will ever become a reality, that could take months or even years to fully play out. Even if the United States passed such an emissions-based tariff similar to that proposed this week by the European Union, the ultimate question is whether such measures would survive scrutiny by the World Trade Organization. European Commission proposes ambitious climate change policies, urging U.S. and other nations to follow “In my view, at this stage, the carbon tariff is more important as a political mechanism rather than in policy terms,” Bledsoe said. “It sends a global message that the U.S. does intend to eventually pursue carbon border taxes. It also sends a message to Republican critics who claim we are not forcing other nations to reduce their emissions, especially China.” Danny Richter, vice president of government affairs at the Citizens’ Climate Lobby, said the United States may ultimately need to place a price on carbon for domestic producers if it wants to tariff carbon pollution abroad without running afoul of global trade rules. “They want to keep it even-steven between countries,” Richter said of the WTO. The proposal from Senate Democrats also comes as the European Commission this week unveiled its own ambitious blueprint to tackle climate change, with a goal of cutting greenhouse gas emissions by 55 percent in coming years, compared to 1990 levels. The swath of proposals announced Wednesday in Europe included its own carbon border tariff mechanism, as well as potentially phasing out new gas-powered vehicles by 2035. They also include dozens of other measures, from ramping up support for renewable energy to planting billions of trees. On this side of the Atlantic, the push for a clean-energy standard that would shift the nation closer to Biden’s goal of carbon-free electricity by 2035 could prove a tough sell for more conservative Democrats. “That jumps out at me as the most vulnerable,” said Bledsoe. Not only will a clean-energy standard probably need the support of every Senate Democrat, it also will require a favorable ruling from the Senate parliamentarian, Elizabeth MacDonough, to be included in a budget bill — a tall order given her rejection of a minimum-wage increase, another Democratic priority, in a pandemic relief measure. Some parliamentary experts caution that because the primary aim of the policy is not related to federal revenue, it is likely to be ruled out. Sen. Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.), a longtime advocate of more ambitious climate action, said Democrats have no choice but to try however possible to pass legislation that tackles a looming global problem. “This is the most significant moment for climate action in years,” Markey said in a statement Thursday. “We’ve got work to do in order to get these programs right, but I’m confident we will construct a final bill that has justice and equity, creates jobs, and reduces emissions in a meaningful way.” One major hurdle is Manchin, chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee and a conservative Democrat from the coal- and gas-producing state of West Virginia who has already expressed concern to other Democrats about moving too quickly. “I told them that I was concerned about some of the language I’ve seen that moves away from fossil [fuels],” Manchin told reporters Wednesday, without going into specifics. One coal state senator holds the key to Biden’s ambitious climate agenda. And it’s not McConnell. On the other side of the Capitol, Rep. Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.), chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, said the Senate budget proposal “makes significant down payments,” but he ultimately wants to see even more funding to combat climate change. “I will say we were hoping for more, but we’re dealing with the Senate,” he said. Some Republican opponents made clear they want less, not more. In a statement Thursday, Sen. John Barrasso (Wyo.), the ranking Republican on the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, criticized the border tax proposal and said the Democratic version of a clean-energy standard “would be disastrously expensive and harmful to U.S. competitiveness.” “Instead of mandating expensive energy and starting a global green trade war,” Barrasso said, “we need to focus on finding ways to use all of our nation’s energy sources and make them cleaner and more affordable.” If Congress fails to pass requirements for power plants to cut greenhouse gas emissions, it will fall to the Environmental Protection Agency to write climate rules on its own. But doing so has proved in the past to be difficult. The Supreme Court blocked the Obama administration’s Clean Power Plan from ever taking effect. With former president Donald Trump having appointed three justices, the high court has only become more conservative since that 2016 ruling. Bob Perciasepe, a senior adviser at the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions and former deputy EPA administrator under Barack Obama, said existing law is “not well done when it comes to trying to deal with something like greenhouse gases and different kinds of power plants all over the place.” Despite the uncertainties ahead for Biden-era climate proposals, Schatz said he remains optimistic. “We are determined, hopeful and unified,” he said. “That doesn’t mean there won’t be multiple near-death experiences for this effort — there always is — but we are in a position to succeed. And we must.” Mike DeBonis and Jeff Stein contributed to this report.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › IMPACT SCENARIOS

CIVIL WAR Election Chaos/Democratic Decline

The impact of a civil war outweighs all aff impact scenarios – civil war is probable in this context, goes international and effects become widespread

Elshelmani 2015 Arij, a studious author with multiple publications all revolving around unique socio-economic, political, cultural issues, “Why Are Civil Wars so Protracted and Difficult to End?”, 10-20-2015, E-International Relations, end/#:~:text=While%20the%20populations%20of%20warring,large%20number%20of%20civilian%20casualties. //EddyV

As interstate war has become less common, academic attention has shifted to the plethora of armed conflicts occurring within the boundaries of states. These civil wars have proven to be more protracted and difficult to terminate for numerous reasons that vary according to their unique socio-economic, political and cultural contexts. Hence, providing a perfect general theory is problematic. Nevertheless, a number of critical factors that affect the duration of civil wars and their inability to be resolved relative to interstate wars can be distinguished. Firstly, unlike interstate wars, which occur between clearly-defined armies and are generally amenable to compromise, civil wars tend to be low-intensity, existential struggles, making them, therefore, inherently-protracted affairs. Moreover, the decentralized organizational structure of contemporary insurgencies and their tendency to fragment and become engulfed in internecine fighting further undermines attempts at reaching a political settlement. Third, peace is difficult to achieve when, for many actors, war is preferable. Often ignored is the capacity of war to endow belligerents with profits and power. Various cases of “enemies” colluding to prolong violence challenge the common assumption that the ultimate objective of war is victory. Finally, the essay questions what an “end” to civil war implies. Even when one side claims total victory or in the rare cases where peace accords are signed and the war is formally concluded, the transition from large-scale civil violence to peace is not so clear. Collective memories of mutual violence persist into the post-conflict period, and cultures of violence are sustained. If not fully addressed, along with the underlying grievances that originally inspire violence, peace will remain at best fragile, and violence may continue in other forms. In this light, even the success stories of post-accord societies in Latin America and Lebanon appear to be “unfinished” civil wars.[1] The Asymmetric Nature of Civil Wars: Given that interstate wars are generally fought in a series of direct confrontations between professional armies and across defined frontlines, they are relatively quick and decisive. In contrast, intrastate wars are distinguished by the asymmetric distribution of material power among the main parties of the conflict, usually the incumbent government or power and the rebels or insurgents opposing it. The asymmetric nature of internal conflicts forces insurgents to adopt a strategy of guerrilla warfare in which the evasion of the enemy is a matter of survival. To overcome its military weakness, the insurgent force gradually wears down the enemy through hit-and-run tactics. Civil war is thus an inherently-protracted affair. What adds complexity to these wars is that they are almost never wholly internal. In an age of interconnectivity and interdependency, their outcome is often of strategic interest not only to neighboring powers but also to the international community at-large. The role of external intervention in influencing the balance of power between parties and therefore the trajectory of civil wars is critical. When external intervention is balanced between the opposing sides it can increase the duration of war.[2] This was most evident when the Cold War superpowers played out their ideological struggle in the conflict theater of the global South. The weaponry and supplies they provided fueled some of the most ferocious internal conflicts. Similarly, the internationalization of the contemporary Syrian conflict seems to have reconfigured the balance of power towards a prolonged stalemate.[3] Here, negotiation may only be contemplated when both parties reach a “mutually hurting stalemate,”[4] that is, a stage of deadlock when both sides simultaneously perceive continued fighting as offering little returns and mounting costs. However, with external actors distorting the perception of warring parties’ prospects on the battlefield, arriving at this stage may take many years. Limited Space for Compromise Interstate wars may be driven by border disputes; they could be a reaction to some existential threat, an attempt at regional hegemony, or a contest for access to trade routes and resources, to name a few. In theory, all of these factors are amenable to compromise, even if they too can produce long and costly wars. The Persian Gulf War is but one example; after eight years of conflict, Saddam Hussein relinquished his demands for complete control over Shatt-Al Arab and began withdrawing his forces from Iran, effectively bringing the war to a close. Where civil wars are driven by limited aims and objectives, the government can respond with the necessary reforms and negotiate with the aggrieved parties to stifle the conflict. When the objective is to secede, to overthrow the government, or even to radically transform social structures, compromise is improbable if not impossible. Secession is unfeasible for there can only be one government. Such wars are existential struggles with each side framing the conflict in terms of “victory or death.” Unsurprisingly, they take an intensely violent nature. Where belligerents cannot envision a common future of power sharing, incumbents have attempted to delegitimize their opponents by labeling them “terrorists,” “criminals,” or “ foreign agents.” This de-politicization of the opposition is a common feature of civil wars and serves as a serious impediment to their termination through civil means. As long as insurgents are excluded from the political arena, violent force will remain their primary means of communication. In other cases, parties may be willing to compromise on their original political goals and form a united government. However, the vulnerability of disarming and demobilizing entails, given the absence of mutual trust and the lack of a third party entity to monitor and enforce the agreement, can encourage combatants to reject opportunities for a peace settlement.[5] Here, it is the security dilemma, rather than the limited scope of compromise that inhibits the resolution of civil wars.[6] Organizational Structure: Fragmentation and Internal Rivalry A central requirement for any effective peace settlement is the presence of strong, representative leaders at the negotiating table. Interstate wars meet this condition more easily. Governments tend to maintain a unified hierarchical structure, with a strategic apex that exerts a tight reign over its security apparatus. In contrast, contemporary insurgencies are decentralized coalitions, plagued by factionalism and weak command and control.[7] Their propensity for fragmentation is a serious impediment to their resolution, which only becomes more potent as the war goes on and as new sub-groups emerge with their own interests and agendas. As the number of parties to a conflict increases, the prospects for agreement shrink, and, consequently, the duration of the internal war expands.[8] The contemporary experience of Syria is telling. As the war enters its third year, the broad coalition of groups constituting the armed opposition has grown to include thousands of foreign fighters and Salafist groups such as Jabhat al-Nusra, Ahrar al-Sham, and the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant, who all possess their own unique ideological vision of Syria’s future.[9] These increasingly potent groups, among other factions, refuse to succumb to the influence and control of the Free Syrian Army and its political wing, viewing the latter as an elite grouping of self-interested exiles. The detachment between the political wing of the opposition and those on the battleground is problematic. Any decision made on the negotiating table at the national or international level is of limited value without the consent of those who control the reality on the ground. The Personalization of Civil Wars Though fragmentation can prolong civil wars, strong leadership is not necessarily a panacea. The Syrian civil war, like others, has also been sustained by its deeply personalized nature. The reputation of Bashar Al Assad among loyalists has achieved a “non-negotiable” status, while the opposition has refused to accept anything short of his removal from power. Gaddafi and Milosevic are two examples of leaders who opted for their own political survival over the national interest, manipulating and inflaming existing social divisions to escalate the war and secure their power.[10] Jonas Savimbi appeared to be the main “spoiler” of the Bicesse peace accords, rejecting the outcome of 1992 presidential election and returning the country to a state of war. Indeed, it was only with his death that his successor, Paulo Armindo Lukamba returned UNITA to the negotiating table and large-scale violence subdued.[11] General Michel Awn’s sense of omnipotence drove him to reject numerous invitations to join the post-Ta’ if government, and instead to declare a “war of liberation” against the Syrian military presence that would claim more than a thousand lives.[12] Of course, leaders are not always the all- powerful decision makers who the media portrays, and placing too much emphasis on their character can lend to their demonization. Nonetheless, the role of the individual cannot be completely discredited either. Indeed, breakthroughs in peace negotiations have frequently coincided with changes in the top leadership.[13] A Political Economy Perspective: Entrenched Interests in the Continuation of Violence The amount of material destruction and human suffering a civil war produces is immense. Yet, while the majority of the population may seek its end, a minority can develop an entrenched interest in its continuation. Thus, attempts to explain the longevity of civil wars are only complete with reference to the political and economic incentives they present. As the civil war rages on, the state’s capacity to control all its territories, enforce the law, and provide basic goods and services are eroded. A range of informal actors, from warlords, militias, and gangs, emerges to fill the vacuum, often carving out their own enclaves where they can become the prime source of social administration and coercion as well as the de-facto owners of the area and its resources. In this context of the state collapse, ordinary civilians can become willing participants in violence. For young uneducated and unemployed men and women, joining an armed band may be the only alternative to a life of destitution. Violence becomes a means of subsistence, supplying its members with shelter and food as well as a sense of protection, belonging and status in a society in which family networks and state institutions have disintegrated.[14] State collapse does not imply an inherent descent into anarchy and senseless violence. Rather, an organized war economy based on looting, extortion, and protection rackets forms around the armed groups. Militias originally relying on volunteers to fill their ranks and finance their operations mutate into professional business entities with profitable links to regional and international trading networks. This has been particularly the case after the end of Cold War. With the sudden absence of external patronage, the warring parties to many conflicts in the South still had to look beyond their borders for alternative means of financing their operations. Therefore, even if economic globalization may not cause civil wars, for their roots often lay in cultural, historical and political grievances, one cannot deny its role in empowering violent sub-national actors by sustaining contemporary war economies. [15] As sub-national actors develop their taste for the status, power and profits violence accrues, they may show small interest in capturing a weak state with no means of enforcing its control over its territories and resources. In the current state of conflict there is a sense of familiarity and economic security. Meanwhile, peace represents uncertainty. For a negotiated peace is ultimately based on promises of political and economic inclusion that can easily be betrayed. A popular assumption is that the objective of each of the warring parties is the total defeat of the enemy’s capability.[16] In reality, the state of violent conflict can endow criminal activities with a rare legitimacy, and therefore every effort is made by belligerents to eschew decisive battles.[17] Indeed, governments may form informal alliances with their enemies to exploit unarmed civilians and natural resources. In Sierra Leone, the poor pay and training of government forces and their affiliated irregulars encouraged them to prey on civilians rather than engage in costly combat with the Revolutionary United Front. Demonstrating this, elite figures in the Angolan administration and security forces have been accused of selling weapons to UNITA on multiple occasions.[18] Similarly, an authoritarian government may deliberately prolong the civil war as a means of concentrating its power and destroying all opposition. In the name of combating “terror” and suppressing “rebels,” a government may declare a state of emergency; introduce draconian laws to limit the freedom of expression, assembly, and association; and indefinitely delay elections. The actions of the Algerian government’s in its contest with Islamist insurgents during the 1990s seem to follow this logic. In the series of massacres of the mid and late 1990s, government forces merely watched from a close distance as Islamist guerrillas slaughtered and mutilated civilians for hours.[19] As the war progressed, the population became alienated from the Islamist cause while the government enjoyed an increase in its support. Only by escalating and prolonging the war could Algeria’s military regime entrench its political power. Unfinished Civil Wars: Sustained Cultures of Violence and the Legacy of Atrocities Even where these barriers to negotiated settlement have been overcome and contesting forces have engaged in dialogue and agreed to end all military confrontations, the transition from war to peace has been less than clear. In Nicaragua, El Salvador, and Guatemala, the ideological violence of their protracted civil wars seems to have been merely substituted with extreme levels of criminal violence.[20] There are many explanations for why “peace” can be difficult to distinguish from war. However, in all cases where the peace process has failed to address the roots of the conflict and to challenge the political structures, social divisions and economic inequalities that gave rise to insurgencies in the first place, violence has been renewed. In the case of Nicaragua and Guatemala, the continued economic marginalization of its youth and the incomplete efforts to reintegrate ex-combatants into civilian life have manifested in the plethora of criminal gangs that dominate urban and increasingly rural areas and threaten the rule of law.[21] The same failure to reintegrate demobilized fighters was a feature of the Dayton and Abouja peace processes.[22] Post- Ta’if Lebanon’s peace is at best described as a fragile one. The incessant paralysis of state institutions, which is to a large extent the product of the accords’ consociational formula, has allowed crime to fester and the country to be consumed by political assassinations and kidnappings. More problematically, it has led citizens to increasingly rely on their own sects for economic and social security.[23] Consequently, the relationship between the various confessional groups in Lebanon is still dominated by a degree of distance, suspicion, and even animosity. Problematically, these social divisions have proven to be easily inflamed by regional developments and external forces as well as local elites.[24] It follows that Post-Ta’if Lebanon is more accurately conceptualized as a prolonged ceasefire, rather than as a consolidated peace as virtually the same socio-economic and political structures that gave rise to the civil war remain intact. In such an environment the threat of renewed large-scale violence is omnipresent. Critical to understanding the fragility of post-conflict societies peace are the legacies of atrocities, which remain unaddressed. While the populations of warring states are separated and secured by their respective borders, civil wars do not offer such sanctuary. By their nature, civil wars occur among and between the people and, therefore, claim large number of civilian casualties. With the objective of controlling the populace, factions resort to coercive and brutal means. When so many civilians are displaced, brutalized and killed, a once unified society becomes a deeply polarized one. Healing the psychological wounds of a protracted civil war to avoid its renewal proves to be a long and challenging process. The consolidation of peace is further endangered by the culture of violence that protracted civil wars can breed and sustain, and which often persists into the post-war period. During the civil war, the barrel of the gun becomes the main means of resolving disputes, making demands, and attaining perceived rights among large swaths of the population. The intensity of battle and the level of atrocities against civilians can erode the social norms that may have regulated the use of violence in the past. In the post-civil war environment, often characterized by a weak security apparatus and criminal justice system, the widespread availability of weapons and weak civil society, and with the collective memories of atrocities still fresh, every incentive is available for an individual to distribute his or her own retributive justice. When violence is not sanctioned and barely condemned it becomes normalized and legitimated. Conclusion This essay has attempted to present a number of structural explanations for the protracted and persistent nature of civil wars relative to interstate conflicts. At the most fundamental level, civil wars’ protracted nature stems from the material asymmetry between the incumbent and the insurgents, their tendency to become internationalized, and the limited space of compromise they involve. The essay has also highlighted the role of their factionalized as well as personalized nature as barriers to a negotiated settlement. Given the immense physical destruction protracted civil wars entail, they are often reduced to irrational and meaningless conflicts. However, such views disregard the economic and political incentives that the continuation of violence presents to both sub-state actors and the state itself. The structural aspects of intrastate conflict present clear barriers to a negotiated settlement, but even in the cases where it has been reached, it has rarely succeeded in putting a decisive end to the war. As long as the root causes of civil war: insecurity, poverty, overpopulation, political exclusion as well as the legacy of atrocities and cultures of violence, are not addressed, violence continues, even if it mutates into different forms and occurs between different parties.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › INTERNAL LINKS

Any Legislation Passed Now that is Not Core to Dem Base Saps Finite PC

Olsen, Henry. ”As Biden reaches his 100-day mark, his approval ratings suggest he’s no FDR” The Washington Post. Apr 26, 2021.

Many Democrats dream that President Biden can transform America as thoroughly as Franklin D. Roosevelt did. But Biden's political standing as he approaches his administration's 100-day mark has more in common with Bill Clinton and Barack Obama than with the legendary FDR. Roosevelt took office after winning a massive landslide at the depths of the Great Depression. Backed by a nearly 200-seat majority in the House and a 58-to-37 Senate majority, FDR pushed through law after law designed to pull the country out of the economic doldrums. Growth and confidence returned, and he and his party were rewarded with more historic victories in the 1934 and 1936 elections. In just four years, FDR had pulled America leftward and entrenched his party's dominance for nearly 50 years. Compare this with the tenures of Clinton and Obama. Both Democratic presidents won office with comfortable, but not landslide, wins. Their parties also controlled the House and Senate with comfortable, but not enormous, margins. Both men set to work reviving the economy, Clinton from a mild recession and Obama from the 2008 financial collapse. Both succeeded in pushing through significant stimulus measures by spring. But after that initial success, they diverged from FDR's playbook. Each changed their focus from economic recovery to pushing longtime Democratic priorities. They made health reform the centerpieces of their presidencies and promoted other issues (e.g., allowing gay people to serve in the military for Clinton, addressing climate change for Obama) that were not priorities for the swing voters who had empowered them and their party. The results were dire for each: Record-setting Republican midterm victories stopped their efforts to change America in their tracks. Biden and House Democrats are pushing an even more aggressive agenda with smaller political capital. Democrats hold a thin majority in the House and control a 50-50 Senate only by virtue of Vice President Harris's ability to break ties. Yet, Democrats under Biden, after pushing through their covid-19 stimulus bill, are signaling another lurch to the left. The House is busy passing bills that have nothing to do with the crisis that got them elected, such as their election reform bill and D.C. statehood. Biden is proposing more massive expansions of government power and spending that have more to do with Democratic priorities than aiding post-pandemic recovery. Biden's job approval ratings also have much more in common with his predecessors than with FDR. As of Friday morning, Biden has a 52.7 percent approval rating on the RealClearPolitics polling average. That's a lot higher than Donald Trump's rating was at this point of his presidency, but it's lower than every other one of Biden's predecessors since 1980 at this stage of their presidencies except Clinton, whose approval rating at this point was statistically identical to Biden's. Some of this is surely due to the country's polarized politics, but it also reflects that Biden might not be pulling new voters into his coalition. His 52.7 percent rating is only 1.4 percentage points higher than the 51.3 percent of the vote he received last November. That's the smallest improvement over a president's prior share of the vote of any president in decades, again with the exception of the terminally unpopular Trump. History suggests the political outlook for Democrats is grim, should they stay on this track. Clinton's job approval rating hovered around the 50-percent mark until the summer of 1994, with one dramatic dip in the summer of 1993. As the public focused on his priorities, however, they started to sour on him. By mid-October, the Gallup poll gave him only a 41 percent approval rating. Obama's approval rating also stayed above 50 percent for a long time, dipping below it in May 2010. It bottomed out at a higher level than Clinton's, about 46 percent, but that still did not prevent Republicans from gaining 63 House seats and the lion's share of gubernatorial and state legislative races. This should be ringing Democratic alarm bells, but instead it seems to be having the opposite effect. Biden is trying to do more legislatively, apparently on the theory that if enough change happens fast enough, Republicans can't undo it even if they tried. It's the political version of throwing everything on the wall and seeing what sticks. Progressives might tell Biden to damn the torpedoes and full speed ahead. As captain of the Democratic navy, Biden looks like he will take their advice. We'll see if his moderate helmsmen among Senate Democrats are willing to go down with the ship.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › INTERNAL LINKS

DEM AGENDA-GOP Win Crush Dem Agenda incl. Climate Legislation

Manchin Hasn’t Fully Crushed Dem Climate Agenda-Midterms Key

Sobczyk 7-18, Nick, covers Capitol Hill and climate change for E&E News. Since joining the company as an intern in 2016, he has reported on the Department of Defense, infrastructure, permitting rollbacks under the Trump administration and American Indian issues. He holds a degree in government and creative writing from Hamilton College, DEMS GRAPPLE WITH CLIMATE DEFEAT, SEARCH FOR PATH FORWARD, JULY 18, 2022, E&E News,

West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin left his party in a climate bind, as Democrats prepare to move ahead this week on a budget reconciliation bill without the clean energy provisions they negotiated for nearly a year. President Joe Biden on Friday called on Congress to pass a narrow bill that includes only an agreement on drug pricing and Affordable Care Act subsidies after Manchin said he would not vote on climate provisions and tax hikes this month in the wake of another round of high inflation numbers. It would effectively mean meeting Manchin’s requests and putting an end to Democrats’ effort to pass climate policy along party lines under the Senate’s reconciliation rules. Manchin said he was open to finalizing a climate deal in September if next month’s Consumer Price Index numbers improve (Greenwire, July 15). But with the midterm elections nearing — and potential ACA premium increases next month ahead of the midterms — the prospect for legislating on climate change in this Congress is all but dead. It’s a stinging defeat for climate activists and Democrats who watched the last major congressional effort to legislate on climate change die in the Senate in 2010. “He has sabotaged the president’s agenda,” Senate Budget Chair Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said yesterday on ABC’s “This Week.” “The problem was that we continued to talk to Manchin like he was serious. He was not,” Sanders said. “This is a guy who is a major recipient of fossil fuel money, a guy who has received campaign contributions from 25 Republican billionaires.” Democrats are left with few remaining options. Some want to continue negotiating for a bigger legislative deal in the next two months, and most are calling for more robust executive action on climate from the Biden administration. Others are holding out slim hopes of simply electing more Democrats to pass a climate bill in the midterms. “If the Senate will not move to tackle the climate crisis and strengthen our domestic clean energy industry, I will take strong executive action to meet this moment,” Biden said in a statement last week (E&E News PM, July 15). “My actions will create jobs, improve our energy security, bolster domestic manufacturing and supply chains, protect us from oil and gas price hikes in the future, and address climate change.” It’s not entirely clear yet what that would entail. Biden has pledged to slash U.S. emissions 50 to 52 percent by 2030 compared to 2005 levels, and the clean energy provisions under negotiation were seen a crucial policy to get there. For now, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is preparing to move ahead with the narrow drug pricing deal this week, POLITICO reported, sending it to the parliamentarian for review. Negotiations on the bipartisan innovation and competition bill have gotten tied up with reconciliation after Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) threatened to kill it should Democrats move forward on their social spending package. The Senate is set to move ahead with a slimmed down version — centered on $52 billion for the semiconductor industry — this week, but it’s unclear what the package might look like. Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas), who is close to McConnell, tweeted that the demise of the Democrats’ broad budget reconciliation effort with climate spending and new taxes would pave the way for bipartisan action on innovation. Still, the atmosphere on Capitol Hill remains tense. Many Democrats are bitterly disappointed and distrustful of Manchin, who whittled away at their climate policy options for months before sinking them entirely last week. Progressives, in particular, viewed climate legislation as a key selling point to younger voters ahead of the midterms. The failure to pass broader climate and social spending policies “has already hurt Democrats” on the campaign trail, Congressional Progressive Caucus Chair Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) told reporters. “We’re going to have to get two more Democrats, real Democrats [in the Senate], who will actually help us to implement the president’s agenda, not obstruct it,” Jayapal told reporters. KEEP TALKING? Key House committee chairs, however, said last week they would be willing to continue waiting it out until September if it meant they could secure a broader deal. “If he’s leaving a gap in the door, then that’s the way it is,” said House Natural Resources Chair Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.). Ways and Means Chair Richard Neal (D-Mass.) similarly noted that House lawmakers have spent a lot of political capital negotiating and working on a framework for a larger deal over the last year. “I want to believe, for the purpose of getting a big deal, that [Manchin] wants to act in good faith,” Neal told reporters. Despite the fact that talks have fallen apart multiple times over the last year, “it’s never a bad deal to try and reengage,” said House Budget Chair John Yarmuth (D-Ky.). “Do I think it would be productive to do it? No. Do I think it would be advisable to do it? Yeah, sure,” Yarmuth told reporters. Many environmental groups have essentially written Manchin off and even called for him to be removed as chair of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee. But Tiernan Sittenfeld, senior vice president for government affairs at the League of Conservation Voters, said she’s not giving up on a legislative deal quite yet. “The Senate is not supposed to go out for August recess for three weeks,” Sittenfeld said Friday at a news conference on Capitol Hill. “That is plenty of time for Sen. Manchin to come back to the table today, right now, and get this bill passed before they go out on their August recess.” CALLS FOR EXECUTIVE ACTION Climate rally and press conference. Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) during a press conference with lawmakers and environmental advocates on Capitol Hill on Friday. | Francis Chung/E&E News The focus for many Democrats now is on the executive branch, where Biden still has power to stiffen emissions regulations and halt new fossil fuel projects. Top of the mind for progressives is declaring a climate emergency. Many Democrats have called for Biden to do it for years now, and now they see an obvious opening because Biden no longer has to walk a delicate line to please Manchin. As Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) put it, Biden should “open the full suite of emergency authorities to do big things on the clean energy transition.” It would offer the administration authority to support lawsuits against the fossil fuel industry and accelerate things like heat pump manufacturing and the transition of the federal fleet to electric vehicles, Huffman said. “We’re not powerless, and I think it’s important to make that distinction,” Huffman said. “Nobody is surrendering here. Nobody is putting up the white flag and saying, ‘Joe Manchin wins,’ but it is time to change tactics.” Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) offered up a ten-point plan for executive action. It includes buffing up the federal social cost of carbon, requiring all major emitters to install carbon capture, using the bully pulpit to call out corporations who obstruct climate action and limiting co-pollutants from fossil fuel power plants. “With legislative climate options now closed, it’s now time for executive Beast Mode,” Whitehouse tweeted last week. Still, gas price politics remain a factor. The Biden administration — and many moderate Democrats — are wary of the optics of any move that could be seen as exacerbating high energy prices with the midterms around the corner. The Manchin news last week, for instance, came as Biden was in oil-rich Saudi Arabia, where the president said he was “doing all I can to increase the supply for the United States of America.” And the reality is that executive action would be fundamentally limited in scope without Congress pumping big money into the deployment of new and existing clean energy technology. “I’m not there yet. I think some stuff you have to do through legislation,” Rep. Scott Peters (D-Calif.) said in an interview. “I wouldn’t want to suggest this is something you can’t backfill with executive action — you can — but this is something we will not have the opportunity to do again.” The Supreme Court also limited EPA’s power to regulate power plant greenhouse gas emissions in last month’s West Virginia v. EPA decision, another blow to the administration’s efforts. “It’s clear that there needs to be swift progress on all fronts of government if the US is going to get on track to achieving the target. This means that Congress, the Biden administration, and states all need to accelerate progress this year towards closing the emissions gap,” researchers at the Rhodium Group wrote this month. “If any front fails to act, it will be increasingly difficult to see a reasonable path to the 2030 climate target.” With current policy trajectories, the Rhodium Group found the United States is on track to cut emissions 24 percent to 25 percent below 2005 levels in 2030. That’s well under Biden’s promise under the Paris agreements to halve emissions by 2030. Grijalva acknowledged the uncertain path forward. “I don’t know,” he told reporters Friday when asked what executive action the administration should take. “It’s something you can’t delay, and you can’t hide it with smoke and mirrors. Essentially, no action and the crisis gets worse.” WHAT HAPPENED? With little legislative recourse left, Democrats on Capitol Hill have largely been left to fume at Manchin and unleash months of pent-up frustration. And even if some want to hold out for the broader deal, Manchin has repeatedly called for delays and slimmer spending since Democrats began talking about a reconciliation bill last year. In September of last year, the West Virginia Democrat called for a “strategic pause” and said he would not support the original proposed price tag of $3.5 trillion. As negotiations continued, Manchin ruled out the so-called Clean Electricity Performance Program — once the centerpiece of the bill’s climate provisions — and took issue with electric vehicle incentives and the fee on methane emissions. He eventually sunk the entire effort in December amid increasing inflation fears. When Schumer and Manchin began talking again this year, discussions centered around a much smaller package with some $500 billion in spending and $1 trillion in revenues. Adding to the current Democratic frustration is the fact that the pair were close to a deal on the climate provisions, according to staffers familiar with the negotiations and Democratic lawmakers. Manchin himself said Friday that climate talks had been headed in a “very, very productive” direction. The House-passed version of the “Build Back Better Act” contained $555 billion in climate spending. In the latest round of talks, Schumer had agreed to slash that to $375 billion to secure Manchin’s support, according to a Democrat briefed on the matter. That essentially left a suite of clean energy tax credits for a host of wind, solar, energy storage, carbon capture and nuclear energy technologies. Schumer had also agreed to nix direct pay options and electric vehicle credit expansions — two major Manchin sticking points — according to the Democrat. “Sen. Schumer will have to decide whether he wants to continue this tease with Joe Manchin, but I think we should stop empowering this guy to be his own branch of government,” Huffman said. “And if you care about climate in particular, it’s time to just accept that he’s going to screw us every single time.” Manchin, for his part, said he had simply told Schumer he supports much of the clean energy package but could not move on it immediately while inflation is at 9.1 percent. “He took that as ‘no,’ I guess, and came out with this big thing last night. I don’t know why they did that, I guess to try to put pressure on me, but they’ve been doing that for over a year now,” Manchin told Hoppy Kercheval of West Virginia MetroNews on Friday. However, since last year, Manchin has gone from from supporting the climate portion of the reconciliation package to questioning its price tag, its provisions and its very purpose. Manchin has expressed concerns about the minerals needed for clean energy and said the transition to renewables is already happening. But Manchin’s view, Schumer’s move “doesn’t make any sense at all.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › INTERNAL LINKS

DEMOCRACY-GOP Win Endangers Democracy

House Republicans will reverse work of Jan 6 committee if they retake House

Porter 7/6: Tom Porter, A reporter at Business Insider based in London. ”Republicans plan ways to get revenge on Jan. 6 Committee if they retake the house, report says.” July 6, 2022. Business Insider. https://www.businessinsider.com/gop-plans-undermine-jan-6-committee-if-retakes-house-axios-2022-7

House Republicans are planning to subpoena records from the Jan. 6 committee if they take back control of the lower chamber in the midterm election, The plan is part of a wider effort to get revenge on the committee and undermine its findings per the report. Its hearings have proved damaging for former President Donald Trump and his wider party. The committee has in a series of hearings presented testimony about Donald Trump's campaign to overturn the election, the Republican lawmakers who supported him, on the day of the riot. Although they have not had great success responding in real time, according to Axios the party hopes to unpick the work of the committee after the midterm elections in November, where many predict they will retake the House of Representatives. "When Republicans retake the majority, we will exercise our oversight responsibilities including subpoena authority to review all transcripts and information that the committee has access to in order to identify the truth," a senior GOP staffer on the House Administration Committee told Axios. Rep. Rodney Davis, an Illinois Republican has charted a course for Republicans looking to damage the findings of the committee if they win a House majority. The top Republican on the Administration Committee, Davis told Axios the committee would seek to investigate House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and had requested the preservation of Jan. 6 committee records. Some Republicans have baselessly sought to blame Pelosi for the riot, wrongly claiming that it was her job to ensure sufficient security at the Capitol on the day of the riot. Decisions on security are actually made by Capitol security chiefs, with some input from the House Speaker as well as the Senate Majority Leader, who at the time was Republican Mitch McConnell. House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy boycotted the Jan. 6 committee after Pelosi blocked two of his selections for the panel. The two Republicans sitting on the panel, Rep. Liz Cheney and Rep. Adam Kinzinger, defied McCarthy to take part and have been made pariahs in the GOP as a result. Trump and other Republicans have since expressed regret at not having seats on the committee that would let them rebut its findings during the hearings themselves.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › INTERNAL LINKS

NATO-GOP Win Bad for US/NATO Partnership--Turns Case

Trumpism and right-wing isolationist opinions are collectively moving the GOP away from NATO – Republican win in the midterms is going to enable them to ditch NATO altogether.

Bernstein 4/7, Jonathan, Jonathan Bernstein is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering politics and policy. He taught political science at the University of Texas at San Antonio and DePauw University and wrote A Plain Blog About Politics, “Are Republicans Turning Against NATO?”, 4-7-2022, Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-04-07/are-republicans-turning-against-nato //EddyV

When it came to public policy, Donald Trump’s presidency was marked by repeated defeats whenever he attempted to take on Republican orthodoxy. When he championed tax cuts, the party was right there with him. When he urged massive spending for infrastructure, they ignored him. On several foreign-policy questions, including Trump’s antagonism toward NATO, congressional Republicans actively opposed him. Those foreign-policy issues reflected the enduring triumph of Dwight Eisenhower. Republicans were always anti-communists. But before Ike, conservatives had also been isolationists, preferring that the U.S. stay out of the world, and especially out of long-term alliances. Harry Truman had worked with internationalist Republicans in Congress to commit the U.S. to the United Nations, NATO, the Marshall Plan, and more, but the rank and file was less than comfortable with all of that, and it wasn’t at all clear where a Republican president would take the party. In fact, Eisenhower only narrowly won the Republican nomination in 1952, defeating the conservative wing of a party that was desperate after losing five consecutive presidential elections and happy to have a war hero leading the ticket. Eisenhower’s popular and effective two-term presidency moved isolationism to the fringe. His vice president, Richard Nixon, followed his lead during his own presidency. Even when conservatives fully took control of the party with the election of Ronald Reagan, the old isolationist impulse was reduced to occasional UN-bashing. There were plenty of real differences on foreign policy between the parties during the Cold War, but Ike’s presidency put Republicans firmly on the side of an active continuing role for the U.S. in world affairs, including participation in a series of alliances and agreements. Indeed, that commitment outlasted the Cold War. Trump didn’t care much about public policy when he was president. But he did undermine this internationalist consensus, even using the old “America First” slogan from an isolationist (and anti-Semitic) movement from the 1930s. And while he had little success actually implementing his foreign-policy preferences — as he was repeatedly rolled by Congress, the bureaucracy and allied nations — it’s quite possible he could have the last laugh. Earlier this week, an astonishing 63 House Republicans opposed a resolution supporting NATO. That’s still not a full third of the Republican conference, but it’s not exactly a tiny fringe, either. To be fair, some of those objecting claimed to oppose the non-binding, symbolic resolution because of some of its specific wording rather than because they opposed the alliance — but quite a few seem to be wary of the whole concept of an alliance of democracies against authoritarianism. These lawmakers are only reflecting where their party appears to be heading. In two recent polls, strong minorities of Republicans — 40% of respondents in one survey — supported leaving the alliance altogether. If a Republican committed to the old consensus wins the 2024 nomination and is elected president, I’d expect all of that to dissipate pretty rapidly. Both parties will once again be strong supporters of NATO in particular and of the general overarching direction of U.S. foreign policy since the 1940s. But if Trump is nominated, and especially if he wins the presidency, it’s hard to see the party working as hard to constrain his foreign-policy choices as it once did. And if Democrats remain in the White House for another four years (or more)? It’s easy to imagine partisan polarization extending into this area, as it has so many others, with Republicans automatically opposing whatever it is that Democratic presidents are doing — including participation in the alliances that Eisenhower, Nixon, Gerald Ford, Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and George W. Bush all strongly supported. Preventing that result would require strong, responsible leadership from Republican politicians. I’m not optimistic that will happen.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › LINKS

Majority of Americans don’t support AI military initiatives

Darrell M. West, ‘18 [8-29-2018, "Brookings survey finds divided views on artificial intelligence for warfare, but support rises if adversaries are developing it," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2018/08/29/brookings-survey-finds-divided-views-on-artificial-intelligence-for-warfare-but-support-rises-if-adversaries-are-developing-it/]

Thirty percent of adult internet users believe AI technologies should be developed for warfare, 39 percent do not, and 32 percent are unsure, according to a survey undertaken by researchers at the Brookings Institution. However, if adversaries already are developing such weapons, 45 percent believe the United States should do so, 25 percent do not, and 30 percent don’t know. There are substantial differences in attitudes by gender, age, and geography. Men (51 percent) are much more likely than women (39 percent) to support AI for warfare if adversaries develop these kinds of weapons. The same is true for senior citizens (53 percent) compared to those aged 18 to 34. Those living in the Northeast (51 percent) were the most likely to support these weapons, compared to people living in the West (41 percent). Support AI for Warfare and Support AI for Warfare if Adversaries Develop Weapons. The Brookings survey was an online U.S. national poll undertaken with 2,000 adult internet users between August 19 to 21, 2018. It was overseen by Darrell M. West, vice president of Governance Studies and director of the Center for Technology Innovation at the Brookings Institution and the author of The Future of Work: Robots, AI, and Automation. Responses were weighted using gender, age, and region to match the demographics of the national internet population as estimated by the U.S. Census Bureau’s Current Population Survey.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › LINKS

AI Unpopular

People don’t trust AI, especially after the Ukraine Crisis 

UAE NEWS 22, a broadcasting company that based in UAE, Fear of ‘killer robots’ using AI to target humans grows as Ukraine war rages on, June 23 2022, EAU NEWS, https://uaenews.ekumkum.com/fear-of-killer-robots-using-ai-to-target-humans-grows-as-ukraine-war-rages-on/ 

KILLER robots have raised ethical concerns as the conflict between Russia and Ukraine demonstrates the carnage of modern warfare. Autonomous weapons are powered by artificial intelligence algorithms and fire at targets without human intervention. Ukrainian soldiers taking part in a military exerciseCredit: AFP-Getty Russian President Vladimir Putin has expressed interest in growing Russia's AI sector Russian President Vladimir Putin has expressed interest in growing Russia’s AI sectorCredit: Getty Images-Getty There are no confirmed cases of an autonomous weapon being used to kill humans (although there are suspicions that an operatorless freewheeling drone was deployed in Libya in 2020). Autonomous weapons could reduce the amount of risk human soldiers are exposed to, an obvious strategic benefit for a country at war. But weapons systems could also make mistakes that result in destroyed cities and civilian casualties, potentially committing war crimes in the process. Nations with the capacity to produce autonomous weapons face a strategic and moral dilemma, especially as the conflict between Russia and Ukraine continues. The AI ​​system could scan a battlefield and select targets for destruction; it’s pretty simple, on paper. But James Dawes, an expert on the weaponization of AI, wrote a harsh review of autonomous weapons and their potential for The Conversation: “When selecting a target, will autonomous weapons be able to distinguish between hostile soldiers and 12-year-olds playing with toy guns? Between civilians fleeing a conflict site and insurgents making a tactical retreat?” Worse, a robot cannot be held accountable for mistakes in battle – the charge of responsibility has nowhere to go. Attempts to regulate autonomous weapons have run into walls erected by threat actors, while human rights organizations advocate for their ban. Russia boycotted a February 2022 conference on autonomous weapons regulation and will refrain from further discussions this month. Meanwhile, the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, a nonprofit organization, conducted a survey and found that 61% of respondents from 26 countries oppose the use of lethal autonomous weapons. Devastating Update in Search of Missing Family Members as Police Investigate Mysterious Deaths Derek Chauvin's house for sale for $475k after it was painted For experts, the most likely cause of an autonomous arms race is the use of killer robots against the Ukrainians. “I can guarantee that if Russia does deploy these weapons, some people in the US government will ask, ‘Do we need comparable capabilities now or will we need later for an effective deterrent?'” diplomacy expert Gregory Allen told New Scientist. . 

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › LINKS

NATO Unpopular

L - Plan increases Trumpist populism in the US politisphere via anti-NATO GOP

Lemon 7/13 Before joining Newsweek, Jason Lemon was a contributor to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, where he wrote primarily about health, science and the environment. Prior to that, he spent five years living in Lebanon, where he helped build a Middle East-focused viral media startup called StepFeed. He has also written for a range of Middle Eastern and Western publications including The Christian Science Monitor, The Palm Beach Post, Al Fanar Media and A Magazine.https://www.newsweek.com/marjorie-taylor-greene-warns-nuclear-war-russia-calls-protests-1720722 – MH

GOP Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene has raised alarms about the possibility of nuclear war, claiming that President Joe Biden and his administration are "sending" the U.S. into a direct conflict with Russia. Biden and other top administration leaders have consistently said they do not want a war with Russia and will not send troops to fight in Ukraine. However, the president has repeatedly pushed for and sent substantial military aid to the Eastern European nation. In addition, Congress, with wide bipartisan support, has approved billions of dollars in support for Kyiv as it fights against Moscow's aggression. Meanwhile, Greene, a Georgia Republican, has consistently opposed supporting Ukraine with military aid. While she has criticized Vladimir Putin's invasion, she has contended that Kyiv's forces cannot win and that Western support is only prolonging the conflict. In a Thursday morning Twitter post, she called for protests against the Biden administration's response to the war. "Maybe now is the time to go 'into the streets' to stop this insane President and his cabinet from sending us into a NUCLEAR WAR with Russia. With our current fragile state, WW3 will destroy us all," she tweeted. "And it won't matter how you vote. Stop the drums of war! China is cheering.” In a follow-up post, Greene wrote: "Everywhere I go on Main Street America people say, 'our federal government is failing us.' NO ONE says, 'we must go to war with Russia.' NO ONE." She added, "All of those in the DC bubble who want war with Russia should suit up and go fight it yourself. Take the all knowing commentators with you. Send your kids and leave ours alone." No one in the White House or Congress has suggested sending U.S. troops to fight the Russians or engaging in other kinds of direct conflict with them. To the contrary, Biden has pushed back against taking any military action that could provoke Russia, such as a no-fly zone over Ukraine, and risk a nuclear confrontation. Russia has the world's largest stockpile of nuclear weapons, with 6,255, according to the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons. The U.S. has the second-largest number, with 5,550. China is a distant third with 350. The U.S. has increased the number of troops it has stationed in Europe since Putin launched the internationally condemned invasion of Ukraine. Before the war, the number of U.S. troops in allied nations was 80,000, and that has been elevated to 100,000. Biden announced this week at the NATO summit in Spain that those numbers would remain elevated in an effort to deter Russia. "In a moment when Putin has shattered peace in Europe and attacked the very, very tenets of the rules-based order, the United States and our allies—we're going to step up. We're stepping up," the president said Wednesday. "We're proving that NATO is more needed now than it ever has been and it's as important as it has ever been," he added. Polling data collected by the University of Maryland from May 6 to 16 showed bipartisan support for mobilizing NATO support against Russia. Fifty-eight percent of Republicans said they viewed this effort "very" or "somewhat" favorably, as did 54 percent of independents and 85 percent of Democrats. Furthermore, 64 percent of Republicans had a favorable view of supplying Ukraine with weapons, as did 65 percent of independents and 83

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS

GOP Infighting/ Trump/ RINO Extremism Threaten GOP

Trump may threaten GOP’s expected win

Bolton 7/6 [Alexander Bolton, 7-6-2022, "Trump White House bid threatens GOP midterm strategy," Hill, and Jeff

Former President Trump’s plans to announce his 2024 presidential campaign as early as this summer, well before what he previously indicated, throws a wrench into Republicans’ strategy for winning back the Senate and House majorities in November. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) and House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) made clear they want the 2022 midterms to be a referendum on President Biden and his handling of inflation and the economy. But that strategy will run into trouble if Trump announces his plans to run for president again in 2022. An early Trump campaign kickoff would give plenty of opportunity for Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) and other Democrats to make November a referendum on Trump instead of Biden. Republican and Democratic strategists say Trump will also provide a shot of energy and motivation to a dispirited Democratic base that right now feels less enthusiastic than Republicans about voting in the midterms. “Midterm elections tend to be referenda on the governing party and given President Biden’s rock-bottom job approval rating, anything that detracts from a focus on the Biden administration and its many failures weakens the Republicans’ ability to take control of Congress,” said Whit Ayres, a leading Republican pollster. Biden’s job approval rating now stands at 38 percent, according to an average of recent polls compiled by RealClearPolitics.com. Ayres says Republican voters are significantly more motivated than Democrats to vote given liberal disappointment over the Biden agenda. “No question about it. The administration has managed to increase Republican enthusiasm and depress Democratic enthusiasm by the way it has governed,” he said. Former Rep. Jim Walsh (R), who represented a swing district in upstate New York, said a Trump 2024 announcement could hurt Republican candidates in competitive races. “I think it causes problems for Republicans. If Trump were to announce this summer, I think it definitely causes problems for Republicans,” he said. Walsh said if Trump launches his campaign, “it’s not going to bring Republicans out this election but what it may do is motivate Democrats.” The nonpartisan Cook Political Report races four New York House races as toss-ups. Democrats acknowledge they face an enthusiasm gap but say that would likely change if Trump announces plans to run again for president. They say their voters are already more energized in the wake of the 6-3 Supreme Court decision striking down Roe v. Wade, the landmark abortion rights case. Trump considered announcing his White House bid last year in the aftermath of the chaotic withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan when Biden’s approval ratings began their downward spiral but was talked out of it by his advisers. Trump advisers cautioned the former president at the time that he didn’t want to “own” the midterm results if Republicans fell short of winning back the Senate and House, according to a Washington Post report in October of 2021. The former president is now motivated to announce a bid as polls show he is losing popular support amid the damaging revelations from the House select Jan. 6 committee’s hearings. This has opened the door for potential rivals, such as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who led Trump 39 percent to 37 percent among likely Republican voters in New Hampshire, an early primary state, according to a recent University of New Hampshire poll. Republican leaders in Congress fear a new Trump bid would ensure the midterms will be a fight over Trump’s false claims that he won the 2020 election. Leaders in Congress repeatedly advise Republican candidates to focus on Biden’s agenda and the economic problems facing the nation today instead of re-litigating the 2020 election. “Objectively speaking it would be best if this midterm were run as a referendum on Biden, his overall performance and inflation, the economy and quality of life. That’s an unassailable fact,” said Scott Jennings, a Republican strategist who has advised McConnell’s past campaigns. But Jennings said analysts can’t assume “Donald Trump cares about whether Republicans win the midterms or not.” “His tactical objectives here are different than the party’s and he’s never shown much of an interest in what’s best of the party in this regard,” he added. Many Senate Republicans blamed Trump for contributing to their loss of two Senate seats in last year’s election runoff in Georgia because he claimed fraud in the 2020 November election, depressing GOP turnout in the following January runoff. “Case in point the Georgia special we had in January of last year. Trump gave no thought whatsoever to what it meant to tell Republicans their vote no longer counted,” Jennings pointed out. McConnell on Tuesday hammered Biden’s successful push for the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan, which Congress passed in March of last year without a single Republican vote, which Republicans say fueled inflation. “On a party-line basis, not a single Republican in the House or Senate voting for it, they dumped almost two trillion [dollars] on the economy,” he said during remarks to the Paducah Area Chamber of Commerce, echoing what has become his midterm election message. McConnell regularly deflects questions about Trump and his actions in the run-up to the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol when asked by reporters, usually replying that he’s paying more attention to the issues immediately before the Senate. Jennings predicted that McConnell and other Republicans will find a way to adapt if Trump launches his White House campaign early, even if it’s not an ideal scenario. He also said that Democrats were always planning on making Trump central to their midterm campaign message for the Senate and House, even though Democratic candidate Terry McAuliffe’s effort to do just that in the Virginia 2021 gubernatorial race failed to earn him a victory. Ford O’Connell, a GOP strategist who was close to the Trump White House, acknowledged the GOP establishment doesn’t want Trump to jump into the presidential race early but argued Republican leaders in Washington don’t fully understand Trump’s effectiveness on the campaign trail. Bidens wish Muslims celebrating Eid al-Adha ‘a joyous holiday’ Ukrainian Foreign Ministry hits Rep. Spartz over ‘baseless speculation’ on Zelensky chief of staff. “If he’s driving the conversation, you could make an argument that he could help the Republicans even more because it’s not like the Democrats aren’t trying to focus on Trump anyway as part of their plan to scrape back some seats in the House or the Senate,” he said. “Democrats are underestimating the fact that Trump is a one-man political force of nature.” “Mitch McConnell’s a very establishment person and he’s going to go along with the conventional wisdom” that Republicans are better off in November with Trump on the sidelines, Ford said. “That’s what Mitch is probably thinking but I don’t if Mitch is right on that front,” he added. “It’s not like the Democrats aren’t trying to run on Trump already.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
MIDTERMS POLITICS DA- BLV 2022 › GOP WIN BAD SCENARIO › UNIQUENESS

Dems Will win in Nov- Abortion Ruling has Mobilized Dem Voters

Unified opinions of abortion of the Democrats gives them an edge to win in the midterm election 

Borter and Oliphant 5/3 [5/3/2022] Gabriella Borter and James Oliphant; Borter is a U.S. News correspondent for Reuters, currently based in Washington, DC and covering abortion, politics and national breaking news; Oliphant is a writer and editor who excels in entrepreneurial enterprise pieces and also a lawyer, having practiced in commercial litigation for several years, and have a firm grasp of policymaking, government legal affairs, campaigns, and power politics; _Amber

WASHINGTON, May 3 (Reuters) - Democrats have needed something to turn around their flagging midterm election fortunes, and the U.S. Supreme Court may have just given it to them.

2022 Michigan Evidence
Aff AT Democracy QPQ › AT Russia/Say No

Hungary will not escalate against Russia

Coakley 22

[Amanda Coakley ; 3-22-2022; "The Exception to Europe's United Front Against Russia"; Time; https://time.com/6159342/european-union-russia-hungary/; accessed 7-22-2022; MT]

In a European Union that answered Russia’s invasion of Ukraine with an economic war against Moscow, Hungary stands apart. While Orban stopped short of vetoing E.U. sanctions on Russia, he has said Budapest will block any E.U. sanctions on Russian oil and gas, and refuted calls to stop the expansion of the Paks Nuclear Plant, which is being funded by Russia’s nuclear power company, Rosatom. Arguing that Hungarians should not be faced with higher bills because of energy sanctions, Orban believes he is skilled enough to navigate a relationship with Russian President Vladimir Putin.