Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › At: War is Human Nature

Warfare and violence aren’t a human instinct- anthropological studies prove

R. Brian Ferguson 18 professor of Anthropology at Rutgers University, Scientific American “War is not part of Human Nature”,

Do people, or perhaps just males, have an evolved predisposition to kill members of other groups? Not just a capacity to kill but an innate propensity to take up arms, tilting us toward collective violence? The word “collective” is key. People fight and kill for personal reasons, but homicide is not war. War is social, with groups organized to kill people from other groups. Today controversy over the historical roots of warfare revolves around two polar positions. In one, war is an evolved propensity to eliminate any potential competitors. In this scenario, humans all the way back to our common ancestors with chimpanzees have always made war. The other position holds that armed conflict has only emerged over recent millennia, as changing social conditions provided the motivation and organization to collectively kill. The two sides separate into what the late anthropologist Keith Otterbein called hawks and doves. (This debate also ties into the question of whether instinctive, warlike tendencies can be detected in chimpanzees. If war expresses an inborn tendency, then we should expect to find evidence of war in small-scale societies throughout the prehistoric record. The hawks claim that we have indeed found such evidence. “When there is a good archaeological picture of any society on Earth, there is almost always also evidence of warfare.... Twenty-five percent of deaths due to warfare may be a conservative estimate,” wrote archaeologist Steven A. LeBlanc and his co-author Katherine E. Register. With casualties of that magnitude, evolutionary psychologists argue, war has served as a mechanism of natural selection in which the fittest prevail to acquire both mates and resources. This perspective has achieved broad influence. Political scientist Francis Fukuyama wrote that the roots of recent wars and genocide go back for tens or hundreds of thousands of years among our hunter-gatherer ancestors, even to our shared ancestor with chimpanzees. Bradley Thayer, a leading scholar of international relations, argues that evolutionary theory explains why the instinctual tendency to protect one's tribe morphed over time into group inclinations toward xenophobia and ethnocentrism in international relations. If wars are natural eruptions of instinctive hate, why look for other answers? If human nature leans toward collective killing of outsiders, how long can we avoid it? The anthropologists and archaeologists in the dove camp challenge this view. Humans, they argue, have an obvious capacity to engage in warfare, but their brains are not hardwired to identify and kill outsiders involved in collective conflicts. Lethal group attacks, according to these arguments, emerged only when hunter-gatherer societies grew in size and complexity and later with the birth of agriculture. Archaeology, supplemented by observations of contemporary hunter-gatherer cultures, allows us to identify the times and, to some degree, the social circumstances that led to the origins and intensification of warfare. In the search for the origins of war, archaeologists look for four kinds of evidence. The artwork on cave walls is exhibit one. Paleolithic cave paintings from Grottes de Cougnac, Pech Merle and Cosquer in France dating back approximately 25,000 years show what some scholars perceive to be spears penetrating people, suggesting that people were waging war as early as the late Paleolithic period. But this interpretation is contested. Other scientists point out that some of the incomplete figures in those cave paintings have tails, and they argue that the bent or wavy lines that intersect with them more likely represent forces of shamanic power, not spears. (In contrast, wall paintings on the eastern Iberian Peninsula, probably made by settled agriculturalists thousands of years later, clearly show battles and executions.). Debate over war and human nature will not soon be resolved. The idea that intensive, high-casualty violence was ubiquitous throughout prehistory has many backers. It has cultural resonance for those who are sure that we as a species naturally tilt toward war. As my mother would say: “Just look at history!” But doves have the upper hand when all the evidence is considered. Broadly, early finds provide little if any evidence suggesting war was a fact of life. People are people. They fight and sometimes kill. Humans have always had a capacity to make war, if conditions and culture so dictate. But those conditions and the warlike cultures they generate became common only over the past 10,000 years—and, in most places, much more recently than that. The high level of killing often reported in history, ethnography or later archaeology is contradicted in the earliest archaeological findings around the globe. The most ancient bones and artifacts are consistent with the title of Margaret Mead's 1940 article: “Warfare Is Only an Invention—Not a Biological Necessity.” My work disputes the claim that chimpanzee males have an innate tendency to kill outsiders, arguing instead that their most extreme violence can be tied to specific circumstances that result from disruption of their lives by contact with humans. Making that case has required my going through every reported chimpanzee killing. From this, a simple point can be made. Critical examination of a recent compilation of killings from 18 chimpanzee research sites—together amounting to 426 years of field observations—reveals that of 27 observed or inferred intergroup killings of adults and adolescents, 15 come from just two highly conflicted situations, which occurred at two sites in 1974–1977 and 2002–2006, respectively. From comparative case studies, I conclude that “war” among chimpanzees is not an evolved evolutionary strategy but an induced response to human disturbance. Case-by-case analyses will show that chimps, as a species, are not “killer apes.” This research calls into question as well the idea that any human tendency toward bellicosity might be driven by an ancient genetic legacy from a distant ancestor of chimpanzees and humans. 

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt Solves-Imperialism

Anti imperialism must be the center of any understanding of IR- it creates the tools needed move beyond theorization and create unifying struggles against capital

Anthony Pahnke in 2021

Associate Professor of International Relations at San Francisco State University; Regrounding Critical Theory: Lenin on Imperialism, Nationalism, and Strategy; International Studies Review, Volume 23, Issue 1, March 2021, Pages 181–203; https://academic.oup.com/isr/article/23/1/181/5850500

This article places key elements of Lenin's thought in discussion with dominant currents in Critical Theory. I argue that the latter shows signs of what I call depoliticization. This trend—in privileging norms such as neutrality and private, reclusive forms of reflection—leads theorists to wall themselves off from movements. Politics has become an area for the passive contemplating of affairs. Habermas, a principal voice in this variety of Critical Theory, advocates for dialogue as the preferred mode of social interaction. Such positions are blind to our historical moment when conflict and taking sides is the norm, on the right and the left. Central pillars of Critical Theory—a concern with emancipation and the understanding that concepts must work against domination—remain relevant. Frankfurt School theorists, such as Horkheimer, is particularly instructive in this regard. Fraser's work, as well, offers a way to conceptualize Critical Theory as a project for emancipation that is rooted in connecting with social movement struggles. To further improve our understanding of how this connection can take place, turning to Lenin, as I argue, is crucial. Lenin's thought on imperialism offers a way for us to rethink the place of theory when it comes to the importance of making strategic interventions in political life, especially concerning questions pertaining to territory. In this regard, Lenin highlights the central, yet problematic necessity of working with the state, while also confronting movement divisions to build unity. In Lenin's hands, Critical Theory is a tool to mobilize people, draw distinctions with antagonists, and build movement unity. The many ways he practiced and theorized political action, including writing editorials, producing abstract intellectual works, and delivering statements for conferences, provide multiple illustrations on how to bridge social movement activity with theory. Extreme inequality characterizes international political economy and life within many advanced capitalist states, as we live in what may be considered “a new gilded age.” Powerful states and corporations are connected, linked in ways that generate uneven, global chains of production, exchange, and circulation. Wars rage on in many parts of the world. Global flows have brought some of us together, while at the same time, stoked divisions within and between states. Lenin, at his time, saw similar problems and developments. As an organizer, he worked to build movements oriented around social transformation. He also saw nationalist movements, on the right and the left. While supporting the latter, he rejected the former. Furthermore, while seeing national self-determination as a potential force, Lenin also considered its limitations. His work on imperialism helped him reach this conclusion, which he used to mobilize rank-and-file movement members as well as other organizers. Lenin's relevance is here, precisely, in helping us think on how to bring people together and create unity out of fragmentation, setting the work of emancipation on a path toward creating new political, economic, and cultural relations.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt Solves-Imperialism

Centering a critical reading of imperialism is key to unite theory and praxis- it moves analysis beyond the nation-state and gives us the tools needed to carve out spaces of resistance

Anthony Pahnke in 2021

Associate Professor of International Relations at San Francisco State University; Regrounding Critical Theory: Lenin on Imperialism, Nationalism, and Strategy; International Studies Review, Volume 23, Issue 1, March 2021, Pages 181–203; https://academic.oup.com/isr/article/23/1/181/5850500

The argument put forward in this article is that we need to recapture key elements from the Critical Theoretic tradition—namely, a concern with strategy—to explore the nature of emancipation in our current historical moment. I agree with others who recognize the indispensable place of First Generation Frankfurt School thinkers in this tradition (Yalvaç 2015), yet also see the need to recognize that the Critical Theoretic project predates their work. Marx and Engels, for example, are integral, for not only providing concepts to analyze social relations, but also for intervening into affairs in ways similar to some ethnographers (Murphy 2007, 131–132). Marx's often referenced eleventh thesis on Feuerbach—philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to change it—includes a proviso that sits at the center of work on emancipation. Specifically, contemplation is insufficient for changing social relations. Emancipation, in following Fraser's understanding of the concept, is rooted in ambivalent claims of social movements to “erode” some form of domination in favor of transformation (2013). Ambivalence combines with transformation because there are no guarantees when seeking emancipation—collective efforts to fundamentally alter social relations may end in defeat or reversal. Kevin Anderson recognizes such qualities in Lenin's efforts to connect theoretic work with practical activity, leading him to state that the Russian Revolutionary deserves greater attention in the Critical Theory tradition (1995). My central argument, in building from Anderson's comment, foregrounds Lenin's work as a way to reground Critical Theory. The reason I turn to Lenin is analogous to Fraser's concern that we cannot reckon with our many crises—political, economic, and environmental—with the received thinking from the regularly cited Critical Theorists (2017). Yet, where Fraser turns to Polanyi, I propose calling upon Lenin, with special attention to his theorization of and political practice concerning imperialism. His multi-dimensional work around the concept, from writing theoretical texts and pamphlets, to organizing conferences and events (e.g., The Third Communist International, or Comintern), provides a way to reconsider the Critical Theoretic tradition within International Relations. Intrinsic to Lenin's work, as I argue, is a way to conceive of strategy. This concept, which speaks to Marxist discussions of praxis, ties abstract theorizing to political and economic analysis, as well as to movement building projects. Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School variety and after has moved steadily away from discussions of strategy to the promotion of dialogue. This tendency represents depoliticization, which as Schmitt described, elevates neutrality and privacy as values ([2008] 1929, 89–90). This development also characterizes some seemingly radical endorsements of civil society. This article contains five parts. In the first and the second, I detail the Theory of Communicative Action, featuring Habermas and Honneth, while also including the work of some International Relations theorists. I argue that this popular current of thought in the discipline depoliticizes Critical Theory by neglecting strategic considerations on internationalism, while also reifying the state/society divide. Section 3 focuses on the research of Cox and Ashley, as well as others, locating the presence of a more internationalist and engaged political sensibility within Critical Theory when compared to the proponents of Habermas’ discourse ethics. Still, these works feature flawed assumptions pertaining to civil society and political engagement. The fourth section introduces Lenin's thought as a way to address these concerns, particularly his work on imperialism. I offer a political reading of his work—both the famous pamphlet, as well as his extensive notebooks on the concept—detailing his preoccupation with organizers, intellectuals, and movements. I return to how nationalism connects to liberation in the fourth and fifth sections. Lenin's dual understanding of nationalism—as potentially a conservative force and an emancipatory one—moves us beyond taking the nation as the principal unit of politics. I do not argue for rejecting nationalism as a collective political project, but with Lenin's insights, show how such movements can bridge with more emancipatory struggles. Ultimately, Lenin pushes discussions of emancipation into moving beyond the state and the nation.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt Solves- Ideology First

The alt is key- only a paradigm shift can dismantle US militarism. Exposing the ideological roots of militarism is a crucial first step.

Booker and Ohlbaum in 2021

Salih Booker, president & CEO, Center for International PolicyAnd Diana Ohlbaum, senior strategist and legislative director, foreign policy, FCNL; Dismantling Racism andMilitarism in U.S. Foreign Policy; Center for International Policy;

Racism has always been closely intertwined with U.S. militarism. The American nation was born from the genocide of Indigenous peoples and conquest of their lands. Its brutal system of policing and mass incarceration, as well as its indulgence of private militias and widespread gun ownership, is rooted in the enslavement of Africans. From imperial control of the Philippines and Cuba to the atomic bombing of Japan, from the arming of dictators in Africa and Latin America to the endless wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, a sizable proportion of Americans have been willing to impose unthinkable pain and suffering on those perceived to be non-white and therefore less-than. A new study confirms the close linkage between anti-Black prejudice and support for bombing Iran. Dismantling entrenched racism and militarism, and the political and economic structures that reflect and reinforce them, will require new ways of working together. Systemic change will come not from a small group of elites or political insiders who revise policies, but from a broad grassroots movement that fundamentally shifts the dynamics of power. It will mean centering the views of those who have been marginalized and oppressed and bringing people together across racial lines. As Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. explained in 1965, “The segregation of the races was really a political stratagem employed by the emerging Bourbon interests in the South to keep the southern masses divided and southern labor the cheapest in the land.” By taking an anti-racist and anti-militarist lens to U.S. foreign policy and bridging the divide between organizations working on domestic and foreign policy issues, we can reject the corrosive and poisonous myth of American innocence and support the growth of a broad democratic movement to reshape America’s role in the world. We believe that supporting the movement that is already in motion will require the following: 1. A concerted effort to unmask the lies, myths, and false narratives about national security and the U.S. role in the world. For people who have experienced marginalization, criminalization, colonization, and dehumanization, these untruths are already obvious. But those who draw social, political, economic, emotional, professional, and reputational benefits from the current order are either willfully ignorant of or unconcerned about the harms it causes—or else they have been blinded to these harms by the system’s internal mechanisms to normalize white supremacy and militarism. We must expose, describe, and confront the moral, economic, and physical harms caused by the Racism-Militarism Paradigm; identify those who benefit from it; and reject the underlying notions of national and racial superiority (i.e., the lie that there is a hierarchy of human value in which some lives are worth more than others). However, we cannot expect those who currently draw power from these myths to recognize and repudiate them. Most of the power shift will come from supporting those who are mobilizing communities that already reject these false narratives to demand and achieve changes in representation and the exercise of political power.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › At: Policy Key

Policy changes will not stop the impacts of militarism- only a paradigm shift that recognizes the necessity of breaking away from militarist ideology solves

Booker and Ohlbaum in 2021

Salih Booker, president & CEO, Center for International PolicyAnd Diana Ohlbaum, senior strategist and legislative director, foreign policy, FCNL; Dismantling Racism andMilitarism in U.S. Foreign Policy; Center for International Policy;

Capitalism, at least as it is organized and practiced in the United States, is perhaps the deepest-rooted and widest-reaching system that perpetuates the Racism-Militarism Paradigm. In its prioritization of the interests of shareholders over workers, its socialization of costs and privatization of profits, its focus on short-term profits over long-term gains, and its failure to invest in human capital, the U.S. system of capitalism is inextricably intertwined with racism and exploitation. It has resulted in a carbon-based economy that is exceptionally reliant on the arms and extractive and carceral industries; a government that has failed to address climate change or promote climate justice in any meaningful way; and a population that suffers from extreme gaps in health, wealth, and income. The constant search for new sources of cheap labor, the competition for access to natural resources, and the need for ever-expanding markets has led to human and environmental degradation, military expansionism, and the promotion of consumerism. Closely associated with the capitalist system are the laws, policies, and regulations that enable its most detrimental impacts. A regressive tax system that tolerates massive tax evasion and avoidance by wealthy individuals and corporations has left federal coffers without resources to spend on the common good. The excessive influence of the military-industrial-carceralcongressional complex has led to a massive network of prisons and detention centers, a huge global military footprint, and an unrestrained arms race and bloated Pentagon budgets. War has become a permanent and largely unchallenged reality, with arms exports now determining many foreign policy priorities. The accelerated development of weapons whose use should be unthinkable is the new normal. The absence of responsible oversight and accountability mechanisms has given license to war profiteering, corruption, and waste—the burden of which falls upon U.S. taxpayers, disproportionately among the poor and middle class. But it is not just the formal state structures and government policies that operate to maintain white supremacy and advance U.S. global military supremacy. Christian, white, male dominance and military solutions are also bolstered by nonprofit organizations, religious and cultural institutions, the media, the education system, and multilateral institutions such as the United Nations and the International Monetary Fund (where power and influence are based upon national wealth, privileging the ruling elites of the G7 countries, which combined represent only 10% of the world’s population). These institutions often unwittingly perpetuate the same exclusionary and exploitative practices as the U.S. government and U.S.-based corporations, and they encourage individual obedience to and compliance with those practices. They generally tell the stories that those with power and privilege want to be told. Many of them advocate, tolerate, or commit violence; replicate racialized hierarchies; and socialize narratives and myths that support the Racism-Militarism Paradigm. Injustice of this magnitude will not be rectified by mere policy change. Even though transitions of administration and party control of Congress can result in meaningful policy shifts, the range of possible options is tightly constrained by this pre-existing set of beliefs and assumptions about the world and the U.S. role in it. What is needed is paradigm change. When we speak of dismantling racism and militarism in U.S. foreign policy, we are talking about the work of paradigm change. A paradigm is a distinct set of concepts and rules that establish boundaries and dictate behavior. It is a theoretical framework that informs the processes of defining U.S. national interests, establishing foreign policy priorities, determining the distribution of resources, and conceptualizing national security. And this is what must be changed.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt Solves NATO/GPW

Capitalist imperialism provides the best framework for understanding NATO and international conflict- it is a result of the generation of economic contradictions and the necessity of countries to protect market access

Alex Callinicos in 2022

political theorist and activist; The great power grab—imperialism and the war in Ukraine; Socialist Worker; https://socialistworker.co.uk/features/the-great-power-grab-imperialism-and-war-in-ukraine/

The mainstream media present the war in Ukraine as a struggle between “democracy”, represented by Ukraine and its Western backers, and “authoritarianism” in the shape of Vladimir Putin’s regime in Russia. But this is much too simplistic. For example, probably Ukraine’s most enthusiastic backer is the far right government in Poland, which is under investigation by the European Union for its authoritarian tendencies. Putin is supported by India, which, despite its own brutish fascist ­government, remains a multi-party democracy. The mainstream way of framing the conflict is designed to equate the Western bloc of liberal capitalist states with the “international community”.It is also a way of denying ­legitimacy to the interests of this bloc’s rivals because they are “authoritarian.” This gets forgotten however when it comes to, for example, the murderous Saudi autocracy. So are there better theoretical ­frameworks for understanding the conflict? One resource is provided by the idea of imperialism. After all, Putin seems intent on restoring the old Tsarist Empire that was destroyed by the Russian Revolution of October 1917. But it’s important to clear about what we mean by imperialism. We can ­understand it as a phenomenon that spans historical eras, as the way in which powerful states dominate, ­conquer, and exploit neighbouring societies. This has been a feature of class ­societies for thousands of years, going back to the ancient Persian, Chinese, and Roman empires. Now Russia is clearly behaving like an imperialist power in this sense, seeking to batter the Ukrainian state into ­submission and carve up its territory. But is it enough to understand the ­conflict in these terms? The Lebanese Marxist Gilbert Achcar thinks so. He has put forward what he calls a “radical anti-imperialist position” that focuses exclusively on the struggle between Russia and Ukraine. “A successful Russian ­takeover of Ukraine would encourage the United States to return to the path of ­conquering the world by force in a ­context of ­exacerbation of the new colonial division of the world and worsening of global antagonisms, while a Russian ­failure—adding to the US failures in Iraq and Afghanistan—would reinforce what is called in Washington the ‘Vietnam syndrome’. “Moreover, it seems quite obvious to me that a Russian victory would ­considerably strengthen warmongering and the push towards increased military spending in Nato countries, which has already gotten off to a flying start, while a Russian defeat would offer much better conditions for our battle for general disarmament and the dissolution of Nato.” It would indeed be good if the Ukrainian people were able to drive out the Russian invaders. But there is a small problem with Achcar’s argument that this would weaken the US and Nato. They are enthusiastically backing the Ukrainians, flooding them with arms, and boosting their own military budgets. If, thanks to these efforts and the courage of the Ukrainian fighters, Russia were defeated, would the US and its allies react by disarming and dissolving Nato? Of course they wouldn’t.They would celebrate this outcome as their victory, and boost Nato further. The US would feel invigorated in its world-historic competition with the real challenger to its hegemony, China. What is missing from Achcar’s approach, and that of other leftists that duck the issue of Nato such as Paul Mason, is the more historically specific understanding of imperialism offered by Marxism. We can see this theory emerging ­originally in Karl Marx’s Capital in the 1860s. But it is developed more ­systematically in the early 20th century, around the time of the First World War. Marxists were confronted with a ­reality similar to our own. The radical liberal economist JA Hobson wrote, “The novelty of recent Imperialism … consists chiefly in its adoption by several nations. The notion of a number of competing empires is essentially modern.” This geopolitical competition was expressed in conflicts over territory—the colonies and semi-colonies that the ­biggest states were striving to dominate— and in an accelerating arms race. The Marxist theory of imperialism was developed to explain these ­rivalries, which precipitated the two world wars of 1914-18 and 1939-45, drowning the world in blood. It was a theory of capitalist ­imperialism. The Russian revolutionary Vladimir Lenin called imperialism the highest stage of capitalism. His Polish-German comrade Rosa Luxemburg wrote, “The essence of imperialism consists ­precisely in the expansion of capital from the old capitalist countries into new regions and the competitive economic and political struggle among those for those new areas.” To put it another way, capitalist imperialism represents the ­intersection of economic and geopolitical competition. Economic competition is the driving force of capitalism—rival firms ­struggle against each other, investing in improved and expanded production to seize a larger share of markets. In the late 19th century, the ­geopolitical struggle among states was subsumed under the capitalist logic of competitive accumulation. This reflected changes in both warfare and capitalism. War was industrialised, as military power came to depend on mass ­production to arm, support, and transport huge armies. States therefore needed to ­promote industrial capitalism. Meanwhile capitalist firms increased in size and started to operate globally. They depended on state support against their rivals. During the depression of the late 19th century, seizing overseas colonies ­compensated for falling profitability. So capitalist imperialism isn’t just big states bullying and conquering smaller states—though there is plenty of that. It’s a global system of inter-capitalist ­competition. Just as before the First World War, today imperialism means geopolitical competition against the background of global economic integration. The power of the antagonists depends on their position in the capitalist world economy. The US dominates finance and big tech, China has a vast manufacturing machine, and Russia relies on energy exports. Today one can identify perhaps six leading imperialist powers—the US, China, Russia, Britain, France, and Germany. The most important antagonism is that between the US and China whose leaders aim to displace Washington’s hegemony, initially in the Indo-Pacific region. But Russian imperialism, ­manoeuvring to rebuild its power, creates a three‑way conflict. The big ­western European powers are pulled in different directions. They depend on Russian energy and are attracted by the vast Chinese market—but, as at present, they ­ultimately line up with the US. Now this understanding of ­capitalist imperialism as involving a system of interstate rivalry is completely missing from Achcar’s analysis. He denies that the Ukraine war involves a conflict among imperialist powers. “If any war where each side is supported by an imperialist rival were called an inter-imperialist war, then all the wars of our time would be ­inter-imperialist, since as a rule, it is enough for one of the rival imperialisms to support one side for the other to support the opposite side. “An inter-imperialist war is not that. It is a direct war, and not one by proxy, between two powers, each of which seeks to invade the territorial and (neo) colonial domain of the other.” This is much too narrow. The US waged a proxy war against the Soviet Union after the latter tried to seize Afghanistan at the end of 1979 Along with allies such as Britain, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan it armed and trained the mujahedin fighters who resisted the Soviet occupation. The ­conflict helped to drain Soviet resources and morale in the last decade of the Cold War. Of course, the mujahedin had their own political agendas. This became clear after Soviet forces withdrew in 1989, culminating in the Taliban’s ­support for al-Qaeda and its resistance to the US occupation following the 9/11 attacks on New York and Washington. But the US played a decisive shaping role in an important final episode of the Cold War. Of course, there are huge differences between Ukraine today and Afghanistan in the 1980s. But there is an important similarity, in that the Western imperialist powers are instrumentalising the Ukrainian national struggle against Russian imperialism for their own interests. Inter-imperialist struggles and wars of national defence often interweave. The First World War started when the Austro-Hungarian Empire attacked Serbia, which it blamed for the assassination of its crown prince Franz Ferdinand. Russia then backed Serbia, leading to an escalating process of military mobilisations that ended in a ­terrible general war. The German Marxist Karl Kautsky argued that the role played by the Serbian struggle for national ­self‑­determination meant the conflict wasn’t just an ­imperialist war. Lenin responded, “To Serbia, i.e., to perhaps one percent or so of the ­participants in the present war, the war is a ‘continuation of the politics’ of the bourgeois-liberation movement. “To the other ninety-nine percent, the war is a continuation of the politics of imperialism.” Of course, the balance is ­different in the present case since the direct ­fighting involves just Ukraine and Russia. Nevertheless the Nato powers’ efforts to stay out of the fighting—above all to avoid nuclear confrontation with Russia—don’t alter the fact they are doing ­everything they can short of this to defeat Russia. This too is “a continuation of the ­politics of imperialism”. The Marxist theory of imperialism is important politically. Without it we are confronted simply with a struggle between rival nation-states. But once we see the role of ­imperialism, we can identify the class antagonism at work. We can see the thread of class interest that binds together not just the Russian conscripts dying in Putin’s war and their families back home being walloped economically by the effects of Western sanctions. This thread also connects with ­working people all over the world, hit thanks to the war by food and energy inflation and threatened with nuclear destruction. It unites them all against the rival ruling classes busy feeding this terrible war.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt Solves Imperialism

The alternative is key to countering the domination of imperialism- we must focus analysis on understanding the structures and points of crisis that legitimize the military and capital expansion- this knowledge results in effective struggles against exploitation

Berch Berberoglu in 2022

Department of Sociology, University of Nevada, Reno, NV,; Berch Berberoglu (2022) Capitalism and Imperialism in the Twentieth andEarly Twenty-First Century: A Critical Analysis of Conventional and Marxist Theories of Imperialism,International Critical Thought, 12:1, 55-80, DOI: 10.1080/21598282.2022.2035794

Imperialism today, in the early twenty-first century, has a dual, contradictory character whose dialectical resolution is an outcome of its very nature—a product of its growth and expansion across time and space within the confines of a structure that promotes its own demise. However, while the process itself is a self-destructing one, it is important to understand that the nature of the class struggle that these contradictions have generated is such that the critical factor that tips the balance of class forces in favor of the working class to win state power is strong political organization, the building of class alliances among the oppressed and exploited classes, the development of a theoretically wellinformed revolutionary leadership that is organically linked to the working class, and a clear understanding of the forces at work in the class struggle, including especially the central role of the state and its military and police apparatus in defense of the empire—the focal point of the struggle for state power (Szymanski 1978; Knapp and Spector 2011). The success of the working class and its revolutionary leadership in confronting the power of the imperialist state thus becomes the critical element assuring that once captured, the new proletarian state can become a political instrument that the workers can use to establish their rule and in the process transform society and the state itself to promote proletarian interests in line with its vision for a new socialist society free of exploitation and oppression—one based on the rule of the working class and the laboring masses in general. The necessity for change and social transformation, which is a political one, demands a clear, scientific understanding of modern imperialism in its late twentieth and early twenty-first century form, so that this knowledge can be put to use to facilitate the class struggle in a revolutionary direction. In this context, one will want to know not only the extent and depth of global capitalist expansion, but its base of support, its linkage to the major institutions of capitalist society (above all the state, but also other religious, cultural, and social institutions), the extent of its ideological hegemony and control over mass consciousness, and other aspects of social, economic, political, cultural, and ideological domination. Moreover—and this is the most important point—one must study its weaknesses, its problem areas, its vulnerabilities, its weak links, and the various dimensions of its crisis—especially those that affect its continued reproduction and survival. Armed with this knowledge one would be better equipped to confront capital and the capitalist state in the struggle to transform capitalist globalization and imperialism in the twenty-first century. Together, these struggles have been effective in frustrating the efforts of imperialism to expand and dominate the world, while at the same time building the basis of an international working class movement that finally overcomes national, ethnic, cultural, and linguistic boundaries that artificially separate the workers in their fight against imperialism. The solidarity achieved through this process has helped expand the strength of the international working class and increased its determination to defeat imperialism and all vestiges of global capitalism throughout the world and build a new egalitarian world social order that advances the interests of the working people and ultimately all of humanity.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt/FW- Education Key

Critical resistance in educational spaces is the key first step to raise consciousness and build alternate worlds for an egalitarian future- we must start by resisting militarism and imperialism

Maria Nikolakaki in 2020

Associate Professor of Pedagogy at the Department ofSocial and Educational Policy of the University of Peloponnese, Greece; The Hope of Critical Pedagogy in the New Dark Ages of NeoliberalGlobalization and Imperialism; Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies; http://www.jceps.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/18-1-10-marnik-.pdf

Although crucial, resistance alone is not enough to stop globalized neoliberalism, in education or more widely across societies. Stopping neoliberal reforms through resistance is a necessary, initial step. There is an urgent need to go beyond such resistance and to build a global revolt, across societies, to struggle against the class war being waged by the ruling class on their futures, and to create the other, alternative, societies and worlds, based on social justice, that are necessary and possible. 'Critical educators can indeed recognize that education has the potential to fuel the flames of resistance to global capitalism as well as the passion for socialist transformation' (Hill, 2006). Peter McLaren (2003) says: 'Schools consciously and unconsciously justify oppression and the tyranny of governments. Government officials claim that schools in capitalist societies such as the United States are equal and that as long as students remain comfortably ensconced within the cultural hegemony of consumerism, and adhere to the dictates of the administration (which are meant to be in tandem with the logic of the market), the country can enhance the value of its international capital and can compete within the international market'. This provides a useful description of imperialism, as justified and driven through militarism in education. I agree with Saltman (2007) when he says: 'The movement against militarism in education must go beyond the schools and challenge the many ways that militarism as a cultural logic enforces the expansion of corporate power and decimates public power. Such a movement must include the practice of critical pedagogy and ideally, also link with other movements against oppression, such as the anti-globalization, feminist, labor, environmental, and antiracism movements. Together, we can form the basis for imagining and implementing a just future.' As Dinerstein and Denuline (2012) suggest: 'Hope is a fundamental human driving force. The principle of hope has a two-fold significance. On the one hand, it informs present individual and collective forms of resistance that intend to move beyond global capitalism. It presents an alternative vision to development that will not come about through state power. Alternatives to development initiatives have put at the center not only the significance of nature, the collective use of natural resources, the construction of a solidarity economy, the idea of substantive equality and radical democracy (Santos and Rodriguez Garavito, 2006), but also the idea that it is necessary to imagine another world in order to change this one (Acosta, 2010). By imagining we mean the concrete experience of anticipating a better future in the present.' Hannah Arendt (1954), proposes that ‘education is the point at which we decide whether we love the world enough to assume responsibility for it’. As Freire claims: 'Man's onotological vocation is to be a Subject who acts upon and transforms his world, and in so doing moves toward ever new possibilities of fuller and richer life individually and collectively' (Shaull, 2004). ' It is our duty, in building this better world, to become fully human”. Overall, as I have been arguing through this paper, capitalism in recent decades has been becoming more aggressive and totalitarian. Education has been suffering from imperialism and militarism along with other sections of society. In order for change to happen, one must never abandon hope. Fear and despair is the basis for an immobilized society that will passively accept the ruling class’s dictums. This is something we cannot allow for the sake of humanity itself. Critical Pedagogy, even in the darkest times, is connected to hope by definition, since it visions another world that is possible and struggles for it. For as Brecht said: In the dark times Will there also be singing? Yes, there will also be singing About the dark times. Critical pedagogy is one of the strongest powers for social change, for it builds in the minds of the future generation, the whys and the how to resist and claim back humanity. It is our duty for everyday struggle to make the future more egalitarian and prosperous by erasing exploitation of humans by humans. 'The future isn't something hidden in a corner. The future is something we build in the present.' - Paulo Freire

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › Alt/FW- Education Key

The alt is key- we must work in educational spaces to interrogate and critically reject the militarized forms of logic that govern our drive to fuel military power and secure national interests-it’s try or die for the alternative

Acheson in 2022

Ray Acheson is the Director of WILPF’s Disarmament Programme, which provides analysis, research, and advocacy across a range of disarmament issues from an antimilitarist feminist perspective; Militarism Cannot Prevent War: An urgent call for de-escalation, demilitarisation, and disarmament in relation to Ukraine and beyond; NATO Watch; https://natowatch.org/default/2022/militarism-cannot-prevent-war-urgent-call-de-escalation-demilitarisation-and

Beyond this immediate context, action is needed to prevent future armed conflict and threats of nuclear war. Instead of maintaining opposing military alliances, all parties should engage in building a common, demilitarised security strategy that places cooperation and the collective fulfilment of the needs of people and planet in the forefront of all policies and actions. NATO, for example, should be disbanded and non-militarised, non-divisive alliances for peace and cooperation should be built instead, with international solidarity as its guiding principle. All countries should reduce their military spending immediately, and agree to phased reductions through the implementation of Article 26 of the UN Charter, the mandate for which should be taken from the UN Security Council and given to the UN General Assembly. All countries should join the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons and work urgently for the timebound elimination of all nuclear weapons. Through the treaty’s provisions for disarmament, the elimination of nuclear weapons could be pursued through verifiable process and achieved within a decade. The process of nuclear weapon abolition could provide a foundational path to broader changes in the world order. Eliminating nuclear weapons would help establish a new cooperative paradigm in international relations and free up resources help address the climate crisis. It would also help generate momentum for broader disarmament and demilitarisation and redirection of money and human ingenuity towards meeting human and planetary needs. At the core of our efforts, we must put the lives of civilians and care for the planet above perceived military, political, and economic interests. To this end, a people-centred peace process is imperative. As Almut Rochowanaski writes,“We must apply the lessons of 21st-century peacebuilding to create a peace process that is people-centred, women-led and rights-based.” Without this, “patterns of exclusion and victimisation will not be remedied, and memories of pain and injustice will turn into grievance and alienation lasting generations. A broad range of stakeholders can be heard and validated through proven peacebuilding practices, and can go on to build a different future for their country.” In the Ukraine context, we echo the call of the Ukrainian Pacificist Movement for “open, inclusive and comprehensive negotiations on peace and disarmament in the format of a public dialogue between all state and non-state parties to the conflict with the participation of pro-peace civil society actors.” This type of inclusive process, a process that is not driven or dominated by those who created the crisis in the first place, must be applied to other contexts. We know that more inclusive processes lead to more stable peace, yet time after time, only men with guns dictate the terms of “peace”. These solutions invariably lead to the imposition of neoliberal economic policies, gender and racial oppressions and inequalities, and endless militarisation. The old ways of doing things have proven over and over again that they do not work. We need a new vision of global peace, grounded in the intersectional experiences of people and the needs of the entire planet. Creating and achieving that vision requires changing who is invited to the table: out with the ruling elites, who are bound to personal interests and gains, and in with everyone who stands to lose from conflict. Land and water protectors, feminists, antinuclear activists, those organising for demilitarisation, equality, and care must lead the work for peace, not the people who profit from conflict. Abolition for transformation We need a paradigm shift in international relations, stemming from this kind of people-centred peace process. We need to alter the relations between United States and Russia, but more broadly we need to dismantle the militarised global order, militarised conceptions of security, and the dominance of the military-industrial complex over world affairs. The hegemony of colonial-corporate extractivism must also be transformed — for the climate, for relations with First Nations, for the protection of land, water, air, and animals. An abolitionist framing is useful for cultivating such transformation. Instead of investing in weapons and preparing for war, we must be investing instead of care for people and planet. Abolition is a tool to build a world that works for all, instead of just a few. The abolition of war, globally, requires disarmament and arms control, systems for demilitarisation and reduction of military spending. But it also requires building structures for peace, solidarity, cooperation, and nonviolence to flourish. It means replacing weapons with renewable energy, war with diplomacy, capitalism with a redistributive feminist political economy that is centered on equality, social justice, degrowth and ecological sustainability. Unlearning the necessity of violence is essential to exploring what could be built in its place. This means turning on its head so much of what we are taught about what’s necessary for safety and security in our world. It means learning to reject violence as a solution to all problems, interrogating and challenging systems of power that assert they exist to protect while instead they persecute and oppress. Understanding and responding to the “bigger picture” doesn’t mean we each as individuals need to solve every piece of it. But it does mean we need to recognise and support each other’s efforts and reflect in our own work the analysis and organising of various movements and projects for peace. The sum of our whole is greater than our parts, and going up against the machine of capitalist violence can feel immense — unless we break it down and rebuild something else, together.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Alt › FW- Epistemology/Research First

Research practices should frame your ballot—the 1AC’s militarist assumptions trade off with the educational value of critical reflection in security politics

Bellanova ’20 (Rocco Bellanova, Assistant Professor Critical Data Studies at University of Amsterdam, holds a double PhD in Political & Social Sciences and in Law, which has been awarded in 2014 by the Université Saint-Louis-Bruxelles and the Vrije Universiteit Brussel; 12/14/20, “Taking the trouble: science, technology and security studies”, Critical Studies on Security, DOA 6/24/22)//nm

The riches of STS We propose that one way to take the trouble is focusing on the devices, technologies, objects, knowledge and materialities that shape security. Notably, we want to highlight that understanding ever-evolving technologies and their applications requires security scholars to go beyond disciplinary boundaries. History, ethics, law, computer sciences and media studies all bring valuable perspectives to the study of security politics. Deploying resources from other disciplines pushes the researcher away from that which feels comfortable and towards new modes of thinking, new analytical distinctions and new conceptual apparatuses. Illustrative of this is the rich literature from various security scholars who have already looked to STS when developing new analytical approaches to issues ranging from drones (Leander 2013) to stoves (Abdelnour and Saeed 2014). Our invitation, of course, does not mean abandoning CSS, but provokes an ongoing questioning of its dynamics and ontological and philosophical underpinnings. Therefore, it does imply a commitment to being curious about the value of approaching the study of security through a new lens, as a way to gain appreciation of additional dimensions. Ultimately, this brings the risk of becoming even further detached from more orthodox understandings of what IR and security studies are expected to be, what they should be concerned with, and which conceptual terms are useful. Yet, such an apprehension would be not dissimilar to the suspicions advanced by scholars like Stephen Walt (1991, 213) with respect to the programme of ‘broadening the notion of “security” to include topics such as poverty, AIDS, environmental hazards, drug abuse, and the like.’ Moreover, a object-driven transdisciplinary journey may trigger worries about CSS consistency. We believe the contributions to this Special Issue demonstrate how these conceptual, empirical and methodological troubles are troubles worth taking Acknowledging that science and technology are core aspects of security studies shows great promise. This is different from claiming that science and technology are de facto more important today than a few decades ago. Rather it means that recent technological developments like the internet (Carr 2015; Herrera 2002), cybersecurity (Dunn Cavelty 2013; Fichtner 2018) and new weapons (Boyle 2013; Huelss 2019) require that we pay attention to their (in)security politics. However, not all technology-focused research in security studies takes its inspiration from STS, and nor do all studies of security technologies and the intersection of science and (in)security take place within the field of security studies. In fact, STS scholars have had a long-standing concern with providing analyses of security practices and objects. For instance, in her contribution Lucy Suchman (2020) engages with Donald MacKenzie’s (1990, 4) work on the ‘invention of accuracy’ of ballistic nuclear missiles, to unpack the discursive and practical effects of the increased automation of warfare. She thus demonstrates the value of engaging with an STS literature that, despite focusing on security, to date remains little known and mobilised by security scholars. In their chapter focusing on STS research on security practices, Kathleen Vogel et al. (2017) emphasise the increasing attention to knowledge (and non-knowledge) practices as well as the challenges of carrying out STS-informed research in the field of security. Unfortunately, STS researchers studying security pay only marginal attention to research carried out by critical security studies scholars (Evans, Leese, and Rychnovská 2020). Similarly, CSS has thus far shown limited interest and engagement with STS research focusing on security practices. Besides STS works explicitly focusing on (in)security, we insist that STS has a lot to bring to the study of security politics. CSS researchers already acknowledge STS as a rich source of concepts and ontological approaches, but some of this work forgets the diverse ‘genealogies of STS’ (Jasanoff 2012). To put it bluntly, CSS has fallen prey to a narrow focus on Latourianism, which has collapsed STS as a whole into Actor-Network Theory (ANT), with the latter being understood primarily as the work of a single author, that is, Bruno Latour (1987, 2005). Latour’s work has indeed marked most of the ‘new materialist’ turn mentioned above (Salter and Walters 2016). Our suggestion to read STS beyond Latour is not to put into question the value of ANT for the study of (in)security practices. As Pieter Lagerwaard (2020) demonstrates in his contribution, there is still much to be gained in engaging with Latour’s works and ANT more generally (cf. also Bellanova 2017), and to connect them with work on ‘boundary objects’ (Star and Griesemer 1989). But the success of ANT within CSS risks failing to appreciate the differences and divergences within ANT (Latour 1999; Law and Hassard 1999) and across diverse STS approaches (Bijker and Law 1992). Importantly, it also risks missing the chance to take the trouble to engage with, and thus discover, the heuristic and political potential of many other approaches such as feminist and post-colonial technoscience (see Hayles 1999; Harding 2009), those exploring the co-production of science and society (Jasanoff 2004) as well as work on the social construction of technology (Bijker 1995) and the design and deployment of large technological systems (Hughes 1987). The conceptual exchange The growing interest of STS in IR is also due to the fact that it speaks to adjacent trends. These trends include an emphasis on the socio-political significance of the seemingly mundane (Guillaume and Huysmans 2018; Lisle and Johnson 2019), the conditions of possibility for politics and contestation (Mandelmaum, Friis Kristensen, and Athanassiou 2016; Monsees 2019), and the need for creative methods and deeper methodological reflection (Aradau et al. 2015; Naumes 2015). Recent conceptual exchange with IR also places an emphasis on those entanglements (Bellanova and Fuster 2013; Voelkner 2011) and processes (Jackson and Nexon 1999; Passoth and Rowland 2010) that create both the ‘state’ and the ‘international’, which make them look like frictionless wholes. Advancing existing work that draws on STS to emphasise ‘entanglements’, Rothe’s article (2020) shows how these insights are useful in developing an analytical framework through which to better appreciate local entanglements that partly consist of technology, in his case, explored through the case of jellyfish-killer robots. Rune Saugmann (2020) discusses in his contribution how entanglements joining cameras, the police, media and audiences play out in different contexts, demonstrating how the assumed factuality of pictures can be contested. This leads him to explore what it means to make claims about the agency of the digital camera. Saugmann thereby contributes to a long-standing debate in STS on the question of agency of objects. Although these questions have also been discussed in IR (Hoijtink and Leese 2019, Lindskov Jacobsen and Monsees 2019), Saugmann’s original contribution highlights the need to think about what it means politically to talk about digital cameras’ agency. Indeed, methodological insights stemming from STS have been used to analyse world politics beyond the realm of science and technology. As contributions to this Special Issue demonstrate, STS can be of value for a range of themes not primarily associated with STS such as disinformation (Monsees 2020) or financial regulations (Lagerwaard 2020). What emerges from reading across the diverse contributions to this Special Issue is that the relation between researchers and research objects is of special concern when we take the trouble to analyse the roles of science and technology in security practices (see also de Goede 2020). Besides seeking new ways of politicising, critiquing and raising novel questions, it is also important to emphasise that ‘taking the trouble’ to engage with STS also enables us to see different things that can then be politicised and explored critically – for example, the use of tweets as evidence in court cases (Anwar 2020), or the role of roadblocks and prisons in intervention practices (Schouten 2019; Lindskov Jacobsen 2020), to name but a few. The relation between researchers and research objects can be best understood as a dynamic process that starts with our research apparatus (methods). Such an understanding invites us to better conceptualise the politics that are at stake in our research and to clarify what practices we are examining, if not directly partaking in, through our research. The contributions to this Special Issue all highlight that the encounter between STS and CSS affects our methods, politics and practices – i.e., the perspective we choose, how we do research, and with which consequences. Studying security politics and practices requires methodological reflections, especially in contexts where secrecy and unknowns are constitutive of the dominant security and surveillance practices (Balmer 2012; de Goede, Bosma, and Pallister-Wilkins 2019; Walters 2015). As a result, this Special Issue is not only relevant because of its analysis of timely empirical issues – like disinformation, terror financing and terror fighting – but also because it fosters debate about methodological questions and what kind of trouble is caused by deploying authors and concepts from STS. In different ways, these articles demonstrate how taking the trouble with STS and thinking with STS enriches our methodologies and modes of critical scholarship. Two contributions in particular explicitly show how engaging with STS insights adds to ongoing debates about doing critique in critical security studies (Austin, Bellanova, and Kaufmann 2019; Berling and Bueger 2017; Koddenbrock 2014). de Goede (2020) invites us to think of the ‘practice’ of critique as a form of ‘communing,’ which for Stengers means ‘participating in an ongoing, adventurous, unguaranteed, but generative process of making sense in common’ (Stengers 2019, 18, cited in de Goede 2020). Suchman (2020) demonstrates how technoscientific claims about accuracy presented as evidence of an ethical approach to warfare are fallacious, and that their core function is legitimating further violence.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › Ukraine/US-Russia

US militarism is not the solution to the war in Ukraine, it’s the root cause

Petersen-Smith, ’22 (Khury Petersen-Smiths, the Michael Ratner Middle East Fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies. 02-09-2022, " US-NATO Militarism Is the Cause, Not the Solution," Mayer

The rising tensions between Ukraine, Russia, the United States and other NATO countries—and the resulting discourse in U.S. media—show that American leaders love an international crisis. In a crisis, the American public is often discouraged from asking questions—and when they do, militarism is usually the answer. Even as Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky discourages panic and downplays the idea that a Russian invasion is imminent, American officials are portraying armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine as inevitable—and U.S. military support of Ukraine as necessary. "What's the alternative?" asked retired Brigadier General and former Defense Attaché to Moscow Peter Zwack in an interview on NPR. ​"Do we just let them get invaded, or do we make the cost so high on the ground-level military—but also the diplomatic and the economic?" The choice being put forward is between military action or inaction; to opt for ​"inaction" is presented as an abandonment of Ukraine. Zwack's prescription is ​"lethal weapons"—specifically Javelin anti-tank missiles and Stinger anti-aircraft missiles. And the U.S. is delivering. In just over a week, the U.S. made four shipments of weapons to Ukraine—a move that has U.S. arms manufacturers anticipating soaring profits for their shareholders. The particular kind of crisis story that American officials are deploying in the situation with Ukraine is a familiar one: An underdog faces a threat from an authoritarian regime, so the United States must come to the rescue with a military response. In an interview on NPR, Republican Representative and Chair of Congress's Ukraine Caucus Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania offered a historical analogy often invoked by American officials to justify military action. "When we defended Kuwait in Operation Desert Shield," Fitzpatrick said, ​"we sent a message to the world that you cannot violate the territorial integrity of an independent nation. And Ukraine should be no different. We have to send a very strong and unequivocal message to Vladimir Putin, which would also be a message to Xi Jinping, to Kim Jong Un and other bad actors around the world that this is not OK to do." Fitzpatrick's interviewer didn't question his response. But his example of U.S. military action in Iraq in 1991 shows exactly why it's critical to question the narrative being pushed by U.S. media, especially during times of crisis. In Fitzpatrick's account of the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, the U.S. appears to be a bystander responding to Iraqi actions. But his story conveniently omits the fact that just prior to its invasion of Kuwait, Iraq counted the U.S. as an ally—one that supplied it with weapons during the Iran-Iraq War of the 1980s. It also ignores that the story did not end with Desert Shield. The U.S. quickly shifted its supposed defense of Kuwait into its own invasion—Operation Desert Storm—of Iraq. In that assault, the U.S. killed some 100,000 Iraqis and shattered the country. It then imposed catastrophic economic sanctions on Iraq, which were responsible for the deaths of another million Iraqis. It accompanied this policy with air patrols of Iraq, and bombed the country intermittently over the next decade. And finally, the U.S. invaded once again in 2003, occupied Iraq after and maintains about 2,500 troops there to this day. Cherry-picking past examples of U.S. intervention excludes vital context and falls short of telling the whole story. Narratives like these obscure ongoing, longstanding military operations and other policies that make the world more dangerous and which have no end in sight. Still, there are moments when officials share details that unintentionally reveal that U.S. involvement in the crisis on the Ukrainian border is far more complicated than they have been acknowledging. With 8,500 U.S. troops readied for deployment, a journalist asked during a White House press conference if sending forces to the countries that NATO counts as its ​"Eastern Flank" might escalate the situation rather than calm it. ​"We've had troops in the Eastern Flank countries for decades," Press Secretary Jen Psaki replied. Indeed, the U.S. maintains an enormous, nuclear armed military presence in Europe—and in the years leading up to the current crisis, it has spent millions of dollars arming Ukraine in particular. Since the 2014 conflict in Ukraine, in which Russia annexed the Crimean Peninsula, the U.S. has sent hundreds of millions of dollars' worth of weapons to Ukraine—in 2015, 2018, 2019 and 2020—including its celebrated Javelin missiles. Psaki's admission begs some follow-up questions: If U.S. troops and weapons have already been in Ukraine for years—and in Europe for decades—but their presence has not deterred Russia from mobilizing troops to the Ukrainian border, why does the Pentagon think that more weapons and troops will do so now? And could it be, perhaps, that this same U.S. militarism is a cause of rising tension in Eastern Europe, rather than its solution? It would be wrong to minimize the potential devastation of a Russian invasion of Ukraine should one occur. But U.S. actions are raising tensions rather than resolving them. While they speak of Ukrainian sovereignty, it is clear that U.S. officials are primarily preoccupied with Russian military aggression that they see as threatening a world order that the U.S. presides over. And as Representative Fitzpatrick makes clear, they also want to send a message to China and other states that they consider hostile. Ultimately, increased U.S. militarism in Eastern Europe—as history has repeatedly made clear—will only make the situation worse.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › Ukraine/US-Russia

The crisis in Ukraine is a symptom of the broader decay of neoliberal capitalism- underlying economic and social crises make collapse inevitable- calls to “solve Russia” are a facile attempt to paper over these structural contradictions

Alastair Crooke, New Cold War, 2022

THE WORLD DOESN’T WORK THAT WAY ANYMORE; Popular Resistance; https://popularresistance.org/the-world-doesnt-work-that-way-anymore/

The Fixation With Ukraine Essentially Is But A Gloss Pasted Over The Realities Of A Global Order In Decomposition. The First World War signaled the end to a mercantilist order that had evolved under the aegis of European powers. One hundred years later, a very different economic order was in place (neoliberal cosmopolitanism). Believed by its architects to be universal and everlasting, globalization transfixed the world for an extended moment, but then started the subsidence from its zenith – precisely at the moment the West was giving vent to its triumphalism at the fall of the Berlin Wall. NATO – as the order’s regulatory system – addressed its attendant ‘identity crisis’ by pushing for eastward expansion toward Russia’s western borders, disregarding the guarantees it had given, and Moscow’s virulent objections. This radical alienation of Russia triggered its pivot to China. Europe and the U.S. however, declined to consider issues of due ‘balance’ within global structures, and simply glossed over the realities of a world order in momentous metamorphosis: with the steady decline of the U.S. already apparent; with a European faux ‘unity’ that masked its own inherent imbalances; and in the context of a hyper-financialized economic structure which lethally sucked out the juice from the real economy. The present war in Ukraine therefore simply is an adjunct – the accelerant to this existing process of ‘liberal order’ decomposition. It is not its center. Fundamentally geo-strategic in their origin, the explosive dynamics to today’s disintegration can be seen as blowback from the mismatch from diverse peoples’ looking now to solutions tailored to suit their non-western civilizations, and from the western insistence on its ‘one size fits all’ Order. Ukraine thus is a symptom, but is not per se, the deeper disorder itself. Tom Luongo has remarked – in connection with the ‘messy’, confusing events of today – that that which he fears most, is so many people analyzing the intersection of geopolitics, markets and ideology, and doing so with such striking complacency. “There is a stunning amount of normalcy bias in the punditocracy, too much ‘cooler heads will prevail’ and not enough ‘everyone’s got a plan until they’re punched in the mouth’”. What Luongo’s retort doesn’t fully explain is the shrillness, the outrage, with which any doubting of the accredited ‘punditocracy’ of the moment is met. Plainly, there is a deeper fear stalking the lower depths of western psyche that is not being made fully explicit. Wolfgang Münchau, formerly at the Financial Times, now authoring EuroIntelligence, describes how such a canonized Zeitgeist implicitly has imprisoned Europe in a cage of adverse dynamics which threaten its economy, its autonomy, its globalism and its being. Münchau relates how both the pandemic and Ukraine had taught him that it was one thing to proclaim an interconnected globalism ‘as cliché’, but “It is quite another to observe what actually happens on the ground when those connections get torn apart … Western sanctions were based on a formally correct, but misleading premise – one that I believed myself – at least up to a point: That Russia is more dependent on us than we are on Russia … Russia however is a provider of primary and secondary commodities, on which the world has become dependent. But when the largest exporter of those commodities disappears, the rest of the world experiences physical shortages and rising prices”. He continues: “Did we think this through? Did the foreign ministries that drew up the sanctions discuss at any point what we would do if Russia were to blockade the Black Sea and not allow Ukrainian wheat to leave the ports?… Or, did we think we can adequately address a global starvation crisis by pointing the finger at Putin?” “The lockdown taught us a lot about our vulnerability to supply chain shocks. It has reminded Europeans that there have only two routes to ship goods en masse to Asia and back: either by container, or by rail through Russia. We had no plan for a pandemic, no plan for a war, and no plan for when both are happening at the same time. The containers are stuck in Shanghai. The railways closed because of the war … “I am not sure the west is ready to confront the consequences of its actions: persistent inflation, reduced industrial output, lower growth, and higher unemployment. To me, economic sanctions look like the last hurrah of a dysfunctional concept known as The West. The Ukraine war is a catalyst of massive de-globalization.” Münchau’s response is that unless we cut a deal with Putin, with the removal of sanctions as a component, he sees “a danger of the world becoming subject to two trading blocs: the west and the rest. Supply chains will be reorganized to stay within them. Russia’s energy, wheat, metals, and rare earths will still be consumed, but not here – We [just] keep with the Big Macs”. So again, ‘one’ searches for an answer: Why are the Euro-élites so shrill, so passionate in their support for Ukraine? And risk heart-attack from the sheer vehemence of their hatred for Putin? After all, most Europeans and Americans until this year knew next-to-naught about Ukraine. We know the answer: the deeper fear is that all the landmarks to liberal life – for reasons they do not understand – are about to be forever swept away. And that Putin is doing it. How will ‘we’ navigate life, bereft of landmarks? What will become of us? We thought the liberal way-of-being was ineluctable. Another value-system? Impossible! So, for Europeans, the endgame in Ukraine crucially must reaffirm European self-identity (even at the cost of its citizens’ economic well-being). Such wars historically, mostly have ended with a dirty diplomatic settlement. That ‘end’ probably would be enough for the EU leadership to spin a ‘win’. And there was a big EU diplomatic drive to persuade Putin to do a deal, only last week. But (paraphrasing and elaborating Münchau), it is one thing to proclaim the desirability of a negotiated ceasefire ‘as cliché’. “It is quite another to observe what actually happens on the ground when blood is being spilled to put facts on the ground …”. Western diplomatic initiatives are premised on Russia needing a ‘way out’, more than does Europe need one. But is that true? Paraphrasing Münchau again: “Did we think this through? Did the foreign ministries that drew up the plans to train and arm a Ukrainian insurgency in Donbas in the hope of weakening Russia – discuss at any point what effect their war and their expressed contempt for Russia might have on Russian public opinion? Or what ‘we’ would do if Russia simply opted instead to put facts on the ground until it finished its project … Or did we even address the possibility of Kiev losing, and what that would mean for a Europe loaded to the gills with sanctions that then would never end?”. The hope for a negotiated settlement has given way to a more somber mood in Europe. Putin was uncompromising in the talks with European leaders. The realization is dawning in Paris and Berlin that a fudged settlement is not something that benefits Putin, nor is one that he can afford. The Russian public mood will not easily accept that its soldiers’ blood was spent in some vain exercise, ending in a ‘dirty’ compromise – only to have the West resuscitate a new Ukraine insurgency against the Donbas again, in a year or two. The EU leaders must be sensing their predicament: They may have ‘missed the boat’ for getting a political ‘fix’. But they have not ‘missed the boat’ in respect to inflation, economic contraction, and of social crisis at home. These ships are heading in their direction, at full steam. Did the EU foreign ministries reflect on this eventuality, or were they carried along by euphoria and the credentialed narrative issuing out from the Baltics and Poland of ‘Bad Man Putin’? Here is the point: The fixation with Ukraine essentially is but a gloss pasted over the realities of a global order in decomposition. The latter is the source of the wider disorder. Ukraine is but one small piece on the chess board, and its outcome will not fundamentally change that ‘reality’. Even a ‘win’ in Ukraine would not grant ‘immortality’ to the neoliberal rules-based order. The noxious fumes emanating from the global financial system are wholly unconnected to Ukraine – but are that much more significant for they go to the heart of the ‘disorder’ within the western ‘liberal order’. Perhaps it is this primordial unspoken fear that accounts for the shrillness and rancor directed at any deviation from sanctioned Ukraine messaging? And Luongo’s normalcy bias in discourse is never more in evidence (Ukraine aside), than when addressing the strange self-selectivity of Anglo-American thinking about their neoliberal economic order. The Anglo-American system of politics and economics, James Fallows a former White House speechwriter has noted, like any system, rests on certain principles and beliefs. “But rather than acting as if these are the best principles, or the ones their societies prefer, Britons and Americans often act as if these were the only possible principles: And that no one, except in error, could choose any others. Political economics becomes an essentially religious question, subject to the standard drawback of any religion—the failure to understand why people outside the faith might act as they do”.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › Racialized Violence

Militarism results in racialized violence around the globe as the US secures its interests through the exploitation and control of other populations

Booker and Ohlbaum in 2021

Salih Booker, president & CEO, Center for International PolicyAnd Diana Ohlbaum, senior strategist and legislative director, foreign policy, FCNL; Dismantling Racism andMilitarism in U.S. Foreign Policy; Center for International Policy;

To many living between its shores, the United States is a land of freedom and promise, a haven for unfettered practice of religion, a place where the son of a black man from Kenya and a white woman from Kansas can not only dream of a better future but rise to become president. To many outside U.S. borders, the torch of liberty offers a beacon of hope for equality and opportunity. But to others—particularly people of color at home and abroad—the reality is very different. The United States is a country that has failed to publicly acknowledge, apologize for, or make amends for its long history of genocide and slavery—despite loudly proclaiming itself as a leader in combating these very evils in other countries. It is a nation that explicitly seeks global military primacy and conducts aggressive military operations on multiple continents with seeming disregard for their impact on innocent civilians. It is a country whose political leaders are willing to spend trillions on senseless foreign wars and weapon systems but not on building racial, economic, and environmental justice. American political culture celebrates the nation’s virtues while demonstrating collective amnesia about its sins. Particularly, but certainly not exclusively, in the foreign policy and national security sphere, elites ignore, reject, and rationalize the enormous harms that the United States has caused through its long history of imperial expansion, structural racism, and economic and military domination. This is not accidental: it is a result of belief systems— manifested in policies and institutions—that we refer to collectively as the Racism-Militarism Paradigm. The Racism-Militarism Paradigm is a way of looking at the world, widely shared among the U.S. policymaking community and much of the public, that arises from a largely unacknowledged doctrine of white supremacy and the necessity of using violence to uphold it. This paradigm establishes a rigid hierarchy, based on race, that values white lives above all others—at home and abroad. It embraces militarism as the most effective mechanism to guarantee this ordering of society and the world. The Racism-Militarism Paradigm has a number of core theories/myths and is manifested in a myriad of concrete and abstract ways. The principal belief is in the racial superiority of whites and their entitlement, exceptionalism, and indispensability. This is then used to justify global military domination and economic exploitation by the United States. The paradigm assumes that we live in a zero-sum world defined by scarcity and competition over resources and that humans are by nature selfish and greedy. In such a world, each man is therefore “out for himself”—but the needs and desires of white men are viewed as synonymous with those of the United States as a nation and are thus considered more important and more valuable than those of all others. A key component of this paradigm is the belief that violence is effective. Domination through the use of military force is considered a necessity that offers the ultimate guarantee of protection of rights and physical safety to those who wield it. For example, since 2018 the United States has engaged in combat in eight countries and conducted military counterterrorism operations in 85 countries. The Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Syria, Yemen, and other wars have cost U.S. taxpayers at least $6.4 trillion and resulted in the deaths of at least 800,000 mostly brown and Black people. The Pentagon budget, nearing $750 billion, is higher now than at the peak of the Vietnam War or the Cold War and is larger than the defense budgets of the next ten highest-spending countries combined. It also constitutes more than half of the discretionary funding requested by U.S. presidents and approved by Congress—for decades. A corollary to this paradigm is the old European justification for colonialism and imperialism known as the white man’s burden, which holds that African and Asian nations and peoples need European and white American tutelage and discipline and that the white race has a moral obligation to civilize such people. These racist and paternalistic attitudes permeate not only official U.S. diplomacy and development efforts, but also the civilizing mission of many churches and private voluntary aid organizations. The evolution of this paradigm is not surprising, given that America’s economic and military might were built on land stolen from the Indigenous people of North America and the labor of enslaved Africans. From genocide and enslavement to westward expansionism, hemispheric domination, and global imperialism, the United States has consistently relied upon coercion, intimidation, and violence to enforce white supremacy while describing it throughout history as a mission of enlightenment. With the conscious and unconscious establishment of the Racism-Militarism Paradigm in the minds of most Americans, those who are defined as others, both domestically and internationally, are routinely marginalized, dehumanized, and exploited. The narrow interests of wealthy and powerful white men are mythologized and legitimized as the national security interests of the United States. In parallel, the national faith in violence is romanticized as patriotism, and as a result, Americans treat the U.S. armed forces and law enforcement personnel with cultish devotion, affording them unparalleled resources, trust, and respect. This addiction to militaristic solutions heightens the fear of chaos, propels a lust for strength in all its forms, and engenders a culture of military reverence. The military capabilities of rival countries are interpreted as threats, and U.S. credibility is defined by the ability and willingness to carry out violence to destroy others. Superior capacity for violence is purported to keep Americans safe. War crimes, police brutality, mass incarceration, border militarization, and capital punishment are excused as unfortunate but unavoidable means of deterring crime and aggression. Other types of coercion and intimidation— often economic, but with harmful physical impacts—are also used routinely and without question. It is essential to note that acceptance of the Racism-Militarism Paradigm, while widespread, is largely unconscious. Few of those who have internalized its precepts recognize it as a mechanism for enforcing systemic white supremacy. Importantly, individuals need not be white, Christian, male, or avowed racists to believe that the United States has the right, the responsibility, and the power to control what other nations do. The paradigm is so pervasive throughout U.S. society that it masquerades as objective truth, blinding most Americans and their leaders to its origins and purpose. Because it draws on a number of deeply held and/or widely promoted values—honor, discipline, order, loyalty, authority—it can seem like common sense rather than the ideological construct that it is.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › War/Structural Violence

Militarism is the root cause of mass war and structural violence by fostering the buildup of military power in the name of securing a capitalist economic order- policy makers must prioritize structural violence over the inflated threat scenarios of the 1AC

Acheson in 2022

Ray Acheson is the Director of WILPF’s Disarmament Programme, which provides analysis, research, and advocacy across a range of disarmament issues from an antimilitarist feminist perspective; Militarism Cannot Prevent War: An urgent call for de-escalation, demilitarisation, and disarmament in relation to Ukraine and beyond; NATO Watch; https://natowatch.org/default/2022/militarism-cannot-prevent-war-urgent-call-de-escalation-demilitarisation-and

Behind this current crisis lies a history of militarised and economic violence. Both Russia and the United States are settler colonial states, forging their countries by expanding their “frontiers” and killing and repressing Indigenous populations. Both engage in imperialist actions outside of their now-established borders, interfering, through military and economic action, in countries they deem to be within their “spheres of influence”. Both use militarism, aggression, and forced economic ties to guide their conduct in international relations, and both deal with domestic inequality, poverty, and resistance through policing and punishment. The governments of both countries critique each other for the same type of behaviour. Russia criticises US imperialism, yet invades and occupies its neighbours, bombs civilians, and engages in cyber-attacks against critical infrastructure that harm ordinary people. The United States criticises Russia as an autocracy yet overthrows democratically elected governments if they threaten US interests, builds military bases and engages in wars and military operations in hundreds of countries around the world, and spends billions of dollars a year on militarism while so many of its citizens live without health care, housing, or food security. Both countries have built up their militaries, military alliances, and nuclear arsenals to challenge the other. The North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO)’s expansion eastward is about constraining Russia, just like Russia’s invasion of countries to the west are about constraining NATO. Ukraine, in this context, is a pawn being used by both “sides”. This gamesmanship runs the serious risk of mass destruction. Between them, Russia and the United States possess more than 11,850 nuclear weapons. NATO members France and the United Kingdom have a few hundred each. The US also stations about 100 nuclear weapons in NATO members Belgium, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, and Turkey. These weapons are not remnants of a past Cold War — they are actively deployed right now, ready to be used. The stockpile numbers, alarming as they are, don’t convey the sheer horror each weapon packs within it. Every single bomb is designed to melt flesh, burn cities, decimate plants and animals, and unleash radioactive poison that lasts for generations. Even the use of one of these weapons would be disastrous. A nuclear exchange would be catastrophic. Russia and the United States, along with France, United Kingdom, and China, together recently agreed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, echoing a statement from Gorbachev and Reagan in 1985. Yet each of these countries has been investing billions in the “modernisation” and expansion of their nuclear arsenals, preparing not for nuclear disarmament but for nuclear Armageddon. Each maintains doctrines and policies for the use of nuclear weapons. And some within the US nuclear complex, at least, apparently believe that nuclear war can be fought — and won. This is an incredibly dangerous message to be sending to those responsible for the potential destruction of the world, but one that benefits the military-industrial complex. There are other corporate interests behind the festering conflict, including in relation to weapons production and sale, pipelines and “energy security,” and access to “natural resources,” with profits to be made at the expense of human lives as well as the protection of the planet. In the midst of a climate emergency, in which capitalist extraction and exploitation has decimated biodiversity, ecosystems, and land, water, and air, the governments of NATO members and Russia continue to use fossil fuels and refuse to embrace a degrowth economy that would drawdown the use of energy, especially in the global north, and prioritise the creation of systems of care and equality for people and planet. Militarised world order and the abstraction of harm There is plenty of blame to go around when it comes to the current crisis and the historical moments that have led us here. All parties involved have contributed actively to this situation; arguing that one side or the other has been “provoked” only serves to obscure the reality that each of the countries involved have together, deliberately, built a militarised, capitalist world order that exclusively serves the interests of the war profiteers and the political and economic elite. What is happening right now over Ukraine is bigger than Ukraine. Tectonic shifts in global geopolitics are taking place and Ukraine is but one field of “play” for the heavily militarised states. Gamesmanship between the United States and China is on the rise; proxy wars, occupations and aggression, and military and economic pressure is occurring throughout the world; extraction primarily by the global north and exploitation of the so-called global south is rampant, exacerbating and accelerating poverty and inequalities and environmental devastation; militarism and military spending is on the rise globally. Approaching the situation in Ukraine without recognising this larger context is like applying a band aid to a global haemorrhage. It is a piece of a much bigger puzzle: of a world order dictated and dominated by the militarised elite. This is a world order that sees war as a legitimate means to an end. It celebrates militarised masculinities, empowering the culture of militarism and violence as brave and noble pursuits, while rendering invisible the gendered and racialised harms of militarism. It is a world order that uses a technostrategic language to sanitise the image of war. Think tanks and politicians, media, and war gamers act as if countries are chess pieces and people are numbers on a page. US government officials, for example, have estimated that a war in Ukraine could kill 25,000 to 50,000 civilians, 5,000 to 25,000 Ukrainian military personnel, and 3,000 to 10,000 Russian soldiers. The fighting since 2014, in eastern Ukraine it should be noted, has already killed more than 14,000 people and displaced millions. Instead of seeing these people as individuals, whose lives have value and meaning, who are part of families and communities, the number crunchers calculate “acceptable loss” and risks of “collateral damage,” and look the other way as the bodies pile up. Also accounted for is the disruption to daily life — the interruption of education, of food production, of supply chains; the destruction of hospitals, homes, markets, water and sanitation facilitations, and all of the other critical infrastructure that people rely on to survive. These numbers don’t take into account the psychological terror of living in conflict, of hearing bombs dropped or drones hovering overhead, of being afraid to leave your house, of watching loved ones die. These figures also don’t take into account the environmental impacts of war, the toxic or explosive remnants of weapons, the damage to land and water and animals. These humanitarian and environmental impacts should be at the forefront of all policy making decisions. Yet they are completely ignored by those talking in board rooms in capital cities far from where the harm will be felt, deciding what choices to make for the sake of “geopolitical strategy” or “balance of power”.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › K Turns Cyber

K turns the aff- expanded cybersecurity industry results in technology being sold to adversaries- it undermines US national security objectives

Adi Gaskell in 2022

Tech Writer at Cybernews, and has published over 6,000 articles on technology and the workplace. His focus is the industrial and policy aspects of cybersecurity. Adi has a masters degree in IT, specialising in artificial intelligence. Adi currently advises the European Institute of Innovation & Technology; Report highlights the growth in the cyber military-industrial complex; CyberNews; https://cybernews.com/security/report-highlights-the-growth-in-the-cyber-military-industrial-complex/

Kaspersky's recent advanced persistent threat report highlighted the growth in state-sponsored hacking groups, with the likes of the Kremlin-backed APT29 and Nobelium prime examples of the willingness of nation-states to deploy private-sector hackers for geopolitical ends. It’s part of a growing cyber military-industrial complex that is emphasized in a recent report from the Atlantic Council, which attempts to shed some light on what has often been a murky and secretive industry. "State cyber capabilities are increasingly abiding by the “pay-to-play” model—both US/NATO allies and adversaries can purchase interception and intrusion technologies from private firms for intelligence and surveillance purposes," the report says. Into the shadows The murky nature of this industry is largely something that suits both sides, but it has made a detailed analysis of it hard. The paper attempts to correct that and shed some light on both the active players in the market and their capabilities. The researchers were able to identify a wide range of actors offering a panoply of interception and intrusion technologies before exploring how these entities accessed the market and who they are selling to. The authors believe that they have been able to identify a number of firms headquartered in both the Middle East and Europe that are actively selling their wares to adversaries of NATO and the United States. What's more, many of these firms are not shy in promoting their wares, with an active presence at major international trade shows, such as Security & Policing UK and Milipol France. A booming industry The scale of the industry was reflected in the finding that 75% of companies selling these technologies have done so outside of their home continent. The companies, which the authors brand as "irresponsible proliferators", have found especially willing buyers outside of NATO and the United States. "By marketing to these parties, these firms signal that they are willing to accept or ignore the risk that their products will bolster the capabilities of client governments that might wish to threaten US/NATO national security or harm marginalized populations," the authors warn. "This is especially the case when the client government is a direct US or NATO adversary." The global nature of the industry illustrates the growing proliferation of advanced cyber capabilities around the world, with these companies increasingly willing to use their nation-state clients to provide them with an air of respectability and legitimacy. It's an argument that rests on flimsy ground, however, not least due to the fact that nation-states are willing and able to shift the focus of attacks into other intelligence areas once capabilities have been established. In total, the researchers analyzed over 200 firms operating in the surveillance space, including Israeli firm Cellebrite, which develops a range of forensics and phone hacking tools that are commonly deployed in countries such as China and Russia. Indeed, the company’s technology was used during the Chinese crackdown of anti-government forces in Hong Kong. National security concerns The authors argue that both the nature of the technology and its customers should trigger significant national security concerns, with the breadth of sales signifying considerable problems with oversight, especially as the firms appear to show no real willingness to self-regulate who they sell to or for what purpose. The phrase “irresponsible proliferators” is deliberately provocative, with the authors hoping that it will encourage lawmakers to do more to regulate the sector and help protect what are often extremely vulnerable groups. Various governments have made moves in this direction in recent years, with the European Union adopting more stringent rules on surveillance technology in a bid to make the industry more transparent than it currently is. Meanwhile, the US has also introduced new licensing rules to help regulate the sale of intrusion tools, with the likes of Israeli spyware firm NSO Group among those who have been blacklisted. “While some argue for an arms-control treaty for cyberspace, regulating cyber capabilities themselves is largely ineffective,” the authors say. “Instead, shaping the behaviors of companies proliferating cyber capabilities, and limiting their activities where they conflict with national security priorities, should be the top priority.” Tackling the industry To do this, you first have to be aware of the true extent of the industry and the behavior of those operating in it. The authors hope that their report will be a useful first step towards achieving this. With the UN recently warning against the use of cyber-mercenaries, it is clear that there is growing concern about the use of cyber-criminals to cause real damage in the real world. “It is undeniable that cyber-activities have the ability to cause violations both in armed conflicts and in peacetime, and thus that a whole variety of rights are engaged,” Jelena Aparac, Chair Rapporteur of the Working Group on the use of mercenaries, said. “This includes the right to life, economic social rights, freedom of expression, privacy, and the right to self-determination.” Successfully controlling the industry is made that much harder by the obfuscation that surrounds it, with various shell companies and resellers making it hard to truly identify either the buyers or the sellers. Nonetheless, there is a growing appreciation that even tools developed for “friendly” regimes often end up in unsavory hands, and therefore there is a strong need to better govern tools that can do so much harm, not least by limiting the access to the kind of cyber-surveillance events that allowed the researchers to examine the industry in the first place.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › US-Russia NW

Militarism makes conflict with Russia inevitable- it leads to expansion that heightens Russian nationalism and encourages aggression

Smith 4/22 (James Smith, political and historical relations analyst; 4/22/22, “Obsession with NATO expansion: a deeply ideological move inevitable in provoking conflicts”, Global Times, DOA 6/21/22)//nm

Although NATO was initially a defensive alliance against the Soviet Union, the ideological triumphalism which followed the events of 1991 saw it orient itself into an offensive proponent of consolidating the "New World Order" and these aforementioned regime changes. Thus, even though there was no major state adversary, the US subsequently violated its promises to post-Cold War Russia that the alliance would not be enlarged. In fact, the West subsequently began to expand NATO eastward, citing the self-determination of the countries involved as an ideologically irrefutable choice, a position that remains to this today. The post-Cold War Russia was not initially an enemy of the West, and sought to integrate itself into it. However, the country found that having made peace and goodwill with the West in the late days of the USSR, ceding influence over Western Europe and gutting its own economy in favor of Western capitalist dominion would in fact be a mistake which would leave Moscow inherently worse off. The 1990s in Russia were characterized by poor living standards for ordinary people, where new mega wealthy "oligarchs" exploited the new environment and of course for what? For the West not to see Russia as an equal partner in a new consensus of peace, but to effect just continue in a bid to strategically subjugate the country anyway. The expansion of NATO combined with Western intervention in Yugoslavia were both critical turning points which promulgated a new Russian distrust toward the intentions of the West. NATO and the EU's attempts to subsequently encroach Russia's own periphery would prove to be the decisive straws which "broke the camel's back" and provoked conflict. It is a logical feature of international relations theory, as reiterated by leading scholar John Mearsheimer, that attempting to ensnare and encircle one country with a hostile military alliance is a straight route to conflict. The West makes no apology for it, believing that it is their ideological right and destiny to do so, as the "end of history" logic goes. Western expansion soon provoked in the Euromaidan crisis of 2013 in Ukraine, sparking a tidal wave of anti-Russian nationalism which then opened up a geopolitical struggle over the future of Ukraine. The West in turn failed to acknowledge how the ultra-nationalist assault on Russian identity and language in the country has also been humiliating to Moscow. The US and its allies in their hubris refused to compromise, setting off a chain reaction of events leading to the present day. Russia's reactions to this context are branded as aggression and zero-sum moral evil. However, they are in the strategic sense necessary for Moscow to safeguard its own national security and offset military and political domination by an adversarial military alliance. This whole scenario was ultimately preventable. But Western governments and media continue to gravely mislead the public about its causes. They're pushing the never-ending ideological crusade that Western liberal democracy, must without any questions and at all costs for that matter, dominate the entire earth. It's an attitude the Western world has held since 1991, and it is on that note ironically that such an attitude become a self-fulfilling prophecy in instigating the largest conflict in Europe since the World War II. An opportunity to build a consolidated peace and unity on the continent was jeopardized by ideological and strategic puritanism. This is, as what Mearsheimer titled in his signature book, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › US-Russia NW

Capitalism generates resource competition that makes global war inevitable- specifically causes US-Russian conflict that goes nuclear

Williams in 2022

Sam, economist and author, Comparative Advantage, Monopoly, Money, John Maynard Keynes, and Anwar Shaikh; A Critique of Crisis Theory; https://critiqueofcrisistheory.wordpress.com/comparative-advantage-monopoly-money-john-maynard-keynes-and-anwar-shaikh/

According to Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov, the “collective West” launched a “total hybrid war” against Russia. The shooting war in the Donbass (1) and Ukraine is only part of it. Thousands of dead Ukrainian and Russian soldiers are bad enough. But this is only the beginning of the story. The disruption of trade as well as grain and fertilizer production — of which both Russia and Ukraine are critical suppliers — is threatening to create global food shortages and, in some areas, full-scale famine. Food shortages bring death to people of the Global South and beyond. Deaths occur not only from starvation but also from weakening immune systems making them more susceptible to COVID and other infectious diseases. But the biggest threat is that it could end in nuclear war. What has led to this dangerous, disastrous state of affairs in the relationship between the two powers? Anyone who has taken college-level economic courses has run into the theory that claims that comparative advantage, not absolute advantage, rules international trade. This theory holds that free trade is equally in the interests of all nations regardless of their degree of economic development. Yet the governments of underdeveloped nations showing any independence from imperialism often follow policies neoclassical economists call neo-mercantilist. Comparative advantage supporters claim that such policies are harmful to both developing and developed countries alike. Left-wing economists who reject neoclassical economics generally support neo-mercantilist policies for developing countries. These economists learned the theory of comparative advantage from neoclassical teachers. But, unlike orthodox neoclassical economists, they admit the law of comparative advantage doesn’t work out as the textbooks say it should. Left economists claim that if free competition genuinely prevailed, comparative advantage in international trade would work for the benefit of all nations. But they and other heterodox economists believe the growth of capitalist monopoly negates those laws. Anwar Shaikh rejects this analysis. He says monopoly isn’t necessary to explain why comparative advantage doesn’t work the way it is supposed to. He says comparative advantage does not govern international trade under capitalism at all. He also believes the capitalist with the lowest costs wins the battle of competition in the home market as well as in international trade and therefore absolute advantage prevails in international trade as well as domestic. Shaikh doesn’t agree with Lenin’s theory that imperialism is the monopoly stage of capitalism. He says the whole history of capitalism is imperialism. I have a lot to cover before examining Shaikh’s view that a monopoly stage of capitalism does not exist. I will cover this at a later date. The concrete history of capitalism is that of wars between capitalist nation-states. Before Lenin developed his theory of imperialism, Marx and Engels used another concept, that of commercial wars. From Lenin’s point of view, modern imperialist wars are a special kind of commercial war. We are not interested in the special case of modern imperialism based on monopoly capitalism. We want to know why wars occur throughout capitalism’s history. Some eras have seen more commercial wars than others. These more peaceful eras are marked by the domination of one powerful capitalist nation. The period between 1815 and 1914 was an era of domination by Britain. Another relatively peaceful era is the era since 1945. This was marked by the domination of the United States. This relative peace now threatens to come to an end. Even in relatively peaceful eras, wars between capitalist nations of various degrees of capitalist development never stopped. Are these wars, big or small, the result of evil leaders like Adolf Hitler, or more recently, George W. Bush? Bush ordered the invasion of capitalist, though non-imperialist, Iraq. Or are wars of capitalist countries the result of false political and economic policies, such as those pursued by France and Britain toward defeated Germany after World War I? If false policies and evil leaders are to blame for wars there is hope the capitalist state can learn from history and avoid policies giving rise both to evil leaders and wars. If wars are the result of capitalist production combined with the nation-state, there is little hope of ending wars between them as long as they continue to exist. The current state of relations of the United States and NATO with capitalist Russia makes a correct answer to this question urgent. If wars between capitalist states are not inevitable, we might be able to muddle through for a while longer, though the climate crisis makes this dubious. If total hybrid war between U.S.-NATO and Russia is not due to evil Vladimir Putin or evil Joseph Biden, but the result of capitalism and the nation-state, then how much longer can capitalism last before nuclear bombs go off? The inevitably of war between capitalist states Long before Russia launched its special military operation on February 24, there was talk about a New Cold War between the United States and Russia. I have never liked the term “New Cold War” to describe the crisis in relations between the two countries. First, we can’t be sure this new war will remain cold. But a more important reason: The original Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union involved a struggle between two different classes presiding over two different economic and social systems. The U.S. capitalist class vs. the Soviet working class ruled over two different systems. The U.S. capitalist system vs. the Soviet socialist system under construction. (2) That Cold War was a global class war. Today, the United States and Russia are both ruled by the capitalist class, and the capitalist economic and social system prevails. Even the political systems are similar: Both have federated republics with presidential systems. There are only some minor differences in constitutional details. But there are important differences between the two, that if ignored, will cause grave political errors. Russia produces raw materials and agricultural commodities it exchanges for consumer commodities. It has a classical colonial or neocolonial relationship within the global capitalist economy. Economically, if not geographically, Russia belongs to the Global South. To paraphrase Malcolm X, the Global South begins at the north pole. (3) One thing the two countries have in common is that both underwent the process of deindustrialization. The processes have different characters and causes in each country. Large-scale deindustrialization in the U.S. began with the 1979-1982 Volcker Shock. The U.S. deindustrialization has not gone as far as Russia’s. There are similarities between the conditions found in many former Soviet industrial production centers and the rust belt of the United States. But U.S. deindustrialization is fundamentally the product of uneven development, a consequence of capitalism. Russian deindustrialization began at the end of the 1980s as a consequence of the 1985-1991 political and social counterrevolution (4) restoring capitalist rule in the former Soviet Union republics. This more radical deindustrialization reflected a transition from a higher mode of production to a lower one. This regressive transformation of production’s social relations was achieved with the destruction of the productive forces of former Soviet republics. Both countries produce raw materials, agricultural commodities and gold bullion. But the United States is the center of world finance capital. The U.S. dollar remains the world’s chief reserve currency. The international monetary system can be called the dollar system. The Russian ruble has never been used as a reserve currency. As Lenin stressed in his book “Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism” finance capital is dominant over industrial capital. And while both countries have huge arsenals of nuclear weapons, the United States spends about 12 times more than Russia on defense. (Source: Military Spending by Country 2022) The United States only maintains a high level of military spending because it leads the world in finance capital. The U.S. dollar as the global currency plays a key role. This allows the huge military budget beyond Russia’s financial capacity. Russia engages only in defensive wars near its borders. In contrast, the United States maintains military bases and fights aggressive wars across the globe. Russia became an oppressed nation in the world capitalist economy due to the 1985-91 political and social counterrevolution. The United States remains the leading oppressor nation in the world, with Britain a distant second, and France and other imperialist powers trailing behind. However, this doesn’t change the fact that both Russia and the U.S. are capitalist countries, politically ruled by the capitalist class. Since Russia has adopted the U.S. social, economic, and even political system, there’s no basis for a global class war between them. Yet relations are now so bad that a shooting war is at least as close as during the Cold War. How did we arrive at this state of affairs and what is behind it? During the counterrevolution in the Soviet Union dubbed “perestroika,” its supporters justified their policy of surrender to U.S. imperialism on the grounds it would end the danger of global nuclear war. Newspapers of the time quoted Soviet political scientist Georgi Arbatov, a perestroika supporter, as saying: “We are going to do a terrible thing to you. We are going to deprive you of an enemy.” Now 30 years later it is clear the claim that the Soviet surrender to global imperialism freed the world from the threat of nuclear war was an illusion. A study of 20th-century history should have proved that Russia’s embrace of capitalism could only increase the threat of nuclear war. Let’s look at the 20th-century’s world wars. During World War II, the United States and Britain went to war against Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. Both had capitalist economies much like the United States and Britain. Japan had a parliamentary system. In the late 1930s and 1940s, Japan was imperialist, militaristic and repressive, but it wasn’t a fascist dictatorship. This did not prevent Washington and London from claiming World War II was to defeat global fascism represented by Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, and Imperial Japan. Going back to World War I, there were no fascist dictatorships. The chief powers involved were Britain, Germany, France, Austria-Hungary, Czarist Russia and the United States. These powers all had similar social, economic and political systems. There were differences concerning the degree of capitalist development and the extent of the lingering elements of feudalism. Instead of feudal remnants, the United States had the aftermath of modern slavery. (5) This existed in the form of the Southern states’ legal Jim Crow system and second-class citizenship for the descendants of the African slaves in all the other states. France had the least feudalism thanks to the French Revolution of 1789-94, while Japan and Russia had the most. The United States, under racist President Woodrow Wilson, claimed to represent democracy as opposed to autocratic Germany. Germany had an autocratic monarchy and the feudal remnants of the militarist caste of Prussian Junkers. It also had a mass workers party, the Social Democratic Party of Germany. Slavery had never existed in Germany. The U.S. Socialist Party was weak. The working class in the U.S. was less well-organized than in Germany. And we shouldn’t forget that none of them, the democratic-republican United States, France, monarchical-autocratic Germany, or Czarist Russia, allowed women to vote. Differences in political systems did not line up with the alliances of the contending powers. Czarist Russia was allied with republican France! Today, the Biden administration is embarrassed by the similarities between U.S. and Russian social, political, and economic systems. It is reduced to claiming the current war is about democracy and autocracy, reminiscent of the claims made by World War I’s Wilson administration. In contrast, during the Cold War, there really were differences between the social, political and economic systems of the two countries. The current struggle is not over forms of government, nor is it ideological. It is not a class war, since the governments and states of both countries have the same class character. This struggle is about the drive of U.S. imperialism to bring Russia’s and Ukraine’s colossal wealth in natural resources under its control. Both countries are rich in farmlands as well as mineral- and fossil-fuel-bearing lands but this isn’t enough for the economic needs of U.S. imperialism that have long outstripped the resources available within its borders. U.S. imperialism wants the resources of Western Asia, Africa, Latin America, Ukraine, and Russia under its control. Russian capitalists are forced to fight to maintain control of their own natural resources. Russia’s capitalists are too weak to control the resources of the rest of the world. This war now threatens to turn into a global war and a nuclear holocaust.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › US-China War

US imperialism driven to constrain China’s sovereign equality requires increasing nuclear arsenal and encircling the territory to assert hegemonic dominance—that explodes to war

Foster ’21 (John Bellamy Foster, American professor of sociology at the University of Oregon and editor of the Monthly Review, received his PhD from York University; 7/1/21, “The New Cold War on China”, Monthly Review, DOA 6/26/22)//nm

China’s Third Revolution and the U.S.-Led Global Counterrevolution In his October 18, 2017, report to the Nineteenth National Congress of the CPC, Xi stated that “the Chinese nation, which since modern times began had endured so much for so long [an allusion to the Opium Wars and the Century of Humiliation], has achieved a tremendous transformation: it has stood up, become better off, and grown in strength; it has come to embrace the brilliant prospects of rejuvenation.” For those aware of the history of the People’s Republic of China, it was clear that Xi was speaking of the entire revolutionary process of national rejuvenation. Mao famously declared that, with the Chinese Revolution, China had stood up. The Deng Xiaoping era, often referred to as the second era in the process of national rejuvenation, was just as clearly about China becoming better off, through rapid economic development and integration within the capitalist world economy. The New Era, in the period of Xi’s leadership, has been directed toward constructing a strong, self-sufficient, and sustainable Chinese system, aimed at “building a moderately prosperous society in all respects” by 2021, and “of moving on to all-out efforts to build a great modern socialist country” by 2049. Each stage in the Chinese Revolution has meant a major shift in the revolutionary process, so that the Mao, Deng, and Xi periods are sometimes referred to as China’s First, Second, and Third Revolutions. The “principal contradiction” in the New Era (or Third Revolution), the surmounting of which is necessary if China is to achieve its objectives, according to Xi, is the “unbalanced” or uneven and thus “inadequate” nature of Chinese development, characteristic of the capitalist growth model. This is manifested in deepening class inequality, divisions between rural and urban areas, promotion of economic development at the expense of cultural development, and an unsustainable human relation to the environment. Hence, a socialist-motivated shift toward greater economic equality, national self-sufficiency, ecological civilization, rural revitalization, cultural development, and the forging of a “dual circulation” model (designed to reduce China’s dependence on foreign markets and technology) are all seen as crucial to China’s emergence as a “great modern socialist society.” The CPC leadership has continued to define China as “the world’s largest developing country,” albeit one in “the primary stage of socialism,” thus emphasizing its direct connections to the Global South of which it sees itself a part. Its official international stance is dictated by the “five principles of peaceful coexistence,” defined as: (1) mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, (2) mutual nonaggression, (3) mutual noninterference in each other’s internal affairs, (4) equality and mutual benefit, and (5) peaceful coexistence. Although China as an emerging global power has been increasingly accused of setting a new agenda and seeking to overturn the existing rules-based international order imposed by the core capitalist states, this, rather than presaging anarchy or “might makes right,” as indicated by Blinken at the March 18 bilateral meetings, has largely taken the form of a strong defense of the concept of sovereign equality, which necessarily goes against the structure of the existing imperial system. The path forward in China’s Third Revolution will not of course be easy, and what Xi has referred to as the “principal contradiction” in the form of uneven development is evident in vast struggles taking place at all levels in the society—and in China’s external relations. It would not be an exaggeration to say that China’s Third Revolution has been greeted by the United States and the other core capitalist powers with a combination of disbelief, shock, and anger. Unaccustomed to thinking historically and dialectically, relying on mere formalistic frames of analysis, and believing in the inevitable triumph of capitalism, the dominant ideology in the West has been one quite literally of “the end of history.” The idea that China’s sovereign project would eventually lead to a critical challenge to, rather than absorption within, the existing capitalist and imperialist order was thus scarcely entertained in Washington. As Kurt M. Campbell, former assistant secretary of state for East Asia and Pacific Affairs in the Barack Obama administration, and Ely Ratner, Biden’s nominee for assistant secretary of defense for Indo-Pacific security affairs, wrote in “The China Reckoning: How Beijing Defied American Expectations” in Foreign Affairs in February 2018, the notion that “U.S. power and hegemony” would fail to “mold China to the United States’ liking” was until recently completely foreign to the U.S. establishment. Even more shocking was the discovery that China’s New Era, associated with Xi, would begin to look in many ways more like the revolutionary China of Mao than the reform era of Deng. The enraged response of the U.S. power elite to China’s undeterred pursuit of its own sovereign project has been to launch the New Cold War centered on China (also encompassing its allies like Russia and Iran). This is now seen in U.S. ruling class circles as a new war for hegemony—though minus any genuine historical analysis, which would require an honest assessment of imperialism past and present. Rather, Allison’s Destined for War, which directly influenced Biden, drew its supposed historical frame, not from a conception of the capitalist world system, or from an understanding of the imperial imposition of unequal treaties on China. Instead, it turned to a transhistorical law of conflict associated with the “realist” perspective on international relations, derived from Thucydides, the ancient Greek historian of the Peloponnesian War, who wrote in 411 BCE: “It was the rise of Athens and the fear that this instilled in Sparta that made war inevitable.” In contrast, from a Marxian perspective, any meaningful assessment of hegemonic transition in the context of the modern world must be seen as a product of the internal dynamics of the capitalist world economy, which has been characterized throughout its history by the imperialism of the core directed at the periphery and by periodic wars over imperial hegemony: the only “answer” that the capitalist system is capable of providing to the question of world power. Reflecting this logic, the New Cold War on China initiated by the United States seeks to draw together the leading imperial capitalist states in a global alliance aimed at binding Beijing, together with its allies and the entire periphery of the capitalist system, to the rules-based international order controlled by the triad, while at the same time keeping the Chinese economy, the motor of world economic growth, going. China, it is recognized, is too big simply to be conquered, and too big economically to be allowed to fail. What is required, therefore, according to the ruling Washington Consensus, is a counterrevolution unleashed by the reigning powers directed at reimposing a new global set of unequal treaties on China, along with the bulk of the developing world. The object is less to contain than to constrain China. Ultimately, such a strategy is to be backed up by military force. This was what Bill Clinton’s secretary of state Madeleine Albright was to call “assertive multilateralism.” For Hillary Clinton, speaking at Chatham House on May 6, 2021, it is essential in this context for the United States to “take back the means of production” from China to ensure that the latter is kept in a perpetual subaltern state. To say that these conditions puts the world’s population in an era of almost unprecedented danger would be an understatement. No New Cold War can take place without a nuclear arms race and increased danger of thermonuclear war. China, whose nuclear warheads are in the low 200s, compared to the 1,400 deployed nuclear warheads of the United States, is seeking to double its number of warheads by 2030. The United States, for its part, is currently committed to spending $500 billion on its nuclear forces alone over the next decade, $50 billion a year. This includes $100 billion on its so-called Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent, a land-based nuclear missile system designed to replace the aging Minuteman III Intercontinental Ballistic Missile system. The Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent missiles will be capable of traveling six thousand miles with greater throw weight and accuracy, each one carrying a warhead twenty times as powerful as the bomb dropped on Hiroshima. The world survived the Cold War. We do not know if it will survive the New Cold War. Twenty-first-century humanity is now faced, in every sphere of its existence, with an inescapable choice: “ruin or revolution.”

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › US-China War

The 1ac’s struggle for technological expansion is a means of extending US imperialism to contain and dominate china—this leads to indirect forms of war

Chen ’21 (David Chen, PhD student in the Department of Sociology at the University of Toronto; December 2020, “Rethinking Globalization and the Transnational Capitalist Class: China, the United States, and Twenty-First Century Imperialist Rivalry”, Guilford Press Periodicals, DOA 6/26/22)//nm

The Sino–U. S. struggle for high-tech supremacy and the U. S. plan to torpedo China’s state-initiated program, “Made in China 2025,” which aimed to push the Chinese economy up the global value chain, is suspected to be the real reason behind the Huawei prosecution (Tabeta and Kawanami, 2018) and for the trade war (Zhou and Wang, 2019). President Donald Trump, for example, has frankly admitted when speaking to Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chair Ajit Pai, “We cannot allow any other country to out-compete the United States in this powerful industry of the future. We are leading by so much in so many different industries of that type, and we just can’t let that happen. The race to 5G is a race America must win” (U. S. White House, 2019). The U. S.’ attempted takedown of Huawei therefore signifies a larger battle for high-tech supremacy between the two countries: one is positioned as the Lockean heartland hegemon and the other as a Hobbesian contender state challenging a weakened American hegemon (van der Pijl, 1998). The technology war and the trade war have unveiled a larger geopolitical and geoeconomic contest. The United States’ Pivot to Asia and China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) are two grand strategies being used to counter one another. The Pivot to Asia is a foreign strategy first developed under the Obama administration to target the emerging China by shifting the geographical focus from the Middle East to East Asia, which constitutes economic as well as 86 SCIENCE & SOCIETY political–military means. The U. S. government has planned to deploy 60% of its naval power to Asian and Pacific regions by 2020 (Shifrinson, 2018; Wang, 2016). The military reinforcement parallels arms sales to Taiwan, ongoing navy presence in South China Sea and Taiwan Strait, soaring military budgets, and improving state relations and deepening military cooperation with China’s neighboring countries. The economic arm, in contrast, has been exercised in a less coherent but increasingly forceful way with the regime change from Obama to Trump. The Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) previously constituted an essential part of the Pivot to Asia, which, by building one of the most massive free trade zones in history, was also seen by the United States and its allies as a geopolitical weapon to curb China’s rise (Harvey, 2018, 161). The TPP therefore aimed to exclude rather than to engage China (de Graaff and van Apeldoorn, 2018; Yu, 2017). Robinson (2017) cannot be more mistaken when citing the TPP as a victory of transnational capital rather than an indicator of an escalated Sino–U. S. geopolitical struggle. The TPP was dropped by the Trump administration and yet the Sino–U. S. geopolitical struggle did not cease thereafter; instead, it has been carried out on other fronts, which involves more head-to-head combat. The mounting trade war and technology war (with Huawei being at the center of the storm) are important examples of the increasingly naked confrontation. Even though the Pivot to Asia is not a new invention but more a continuation of the long-term U. S. policies to engage and simultaneously to contain China (Rachman, 1996; Wang, 2016), it does show signs of growing hawkishness in the U. S.’ China policy: from a rather minimal containment approach to comprehensive containment (Etzioni, 2016). Similarly, China’s BRI (complemented by the establishment of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank [AIIB]) was launched with both economic and political–military ambitions. The BRI project was first proposed by Chinese President Xi Jinping in 2013 with the sequential foundation of the AIIB to allocate support funds for the project (Yu, 2017). It can be seen as a new development as well as a continuation of China’s previous efforts — with the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, and Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership, for instance — to deepen its geopolitical and geoeconomic influence (Womack, 2013; Yu, 2017). On the one hand, the BRI is aimed to cope with the country’s economic challenges, such as overcapacity, growing energy dependence, and economic slowdown, by GLOBALIZATION AND TRANSNATIONAL CAPITAL 87 reconstructing the ancient (land and maritime) Silk Roads that allow Chinese capital and products to go westward: a land road traversing through central Asia and the Middle East to reach Europe, and a sea route spanning the South China Sea through the Indian Ocean to the Mediterranean (Shambaugh, 2018). Such an economic corridor is expected to include over 60 countries and regions and “is believed to be the world’s most promising economic zone” (Wang, 2016, 456), which would act as a counterbalance to the TPP. On the other hand, the BRI was also launched with a political– military objective: to act against the geopolitical dimension of the Pivot to Asia by expanding China’s regional influence and deepening economic integration with its neighboring countries through infrastructure building and cross-border trade (Shambaugh, 2018). Infrastructure modernization projects that link other Asian countries with China will foster not only economic interconnections but also political exchanges, which can help reiterate China’s win-win notion that stresses the country’s peaceful rise (Womack, 2013). The BRI therefore is rooted as part of China’s geopolitical strategy to renovate relations with its neighbors that deteriorated over the past decade (Wang, 2016; Yu, 2017). At the least, it is hoped to ameliorate the tensions and concerns regarding China’s rapid military expansion, including its island building in the South China Sea which is also claimed by other countries, ballooning defense budgets, ambitious navy modernization project, and threat of using armed force against Taiwan.

2022 CNDI Kritik
Neg › Impact/Turns Case/RC › US-China War

US imperialism results in cold war tensions with china that could spill over

Singh ’18 (Ajit Singh, journalist and graduate student. He is a contributing author to Keywords in Radical Philosophy and Education: Common Concepts for Contemporary Movements, April 9th 2018, “China’s rise threatens U.S. imperialism, not American people” MROnline, )

Washington’s hostility towards Beijing is rooted in the foundation of modern U.S. foreign policy. The fall of the Soviet Union in 1991 and end of the Cold War, ushered in an era during which the U.S. has sought to establish unipolar global dominance. Explicitly outlined in a 1992 Defense Policy Guidance paper authored under neoconservative Paul Wolfowitz, the principal objective of U.S. foreign policy in this period has been “to prevent the re-emergence of a new rival” capable of challenging U.S. aspirations for global hegemony. In the quarter-century since, the U.S. has aggressively pursued this aim, engaging in endless wars, “regime change” efforts, and military build-ups around the world, now operating over 900 military bases globally. Despite these most destructive efforts, the U.S. has been unable to stop China’s momentous rise, which has emerged as the primary obstacle to U.S. aims for unipolar dominance. Although Washington has sought regime change in Beijing ever since the socialist revolution of 1949, the U.S. has generally pursued a strategy of “containment through engagement” following the normalisation of bilateral relations in the 1970s. In part, Washington had hoped that China’s economic reform and the fall of the Soviet Union would lead to political reform in Beijing and the abandonment of Communist Party leadership and socialism with Chinese characteristics, in favour of Western-oriented neoliberalism. History has confirmed that China has no such intention. Recognizing its own declining leverage and that China will not become “more like us”, Washington is attempting to launch a new Cold War against China. The identification of China as the primary target of U.S. foreign policy originated during the Obama era with the “Asia pivot” seeking to encircle China, shifting 60 percent of U.S. naval assets to Asia by 2020. As Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton argued that the U.S. must reorient the focus of its foreign policy from the Middle East to the Asia-Pacific to ensure “continued American leadership well into this century.” The developments under Trump, mark an escalation of this bipartisan strategy. The unipolar-multipolar struggle The importance of U.S.-China relations cannot be overstated, with the two countries at the core of a broader unipolar-multipolar struggle over the shape of the international order. While the U.S. seeks to secure global dominance, China’s rise is central to a multipolarisation trend, in which multiple centres of power are emerging to shape a negotiated, more democratic world. China’s political orientation has been fundamentally shaped by its history of subjugation to foreign powers during its “century of humiliation” and anti-imperialist struggle for national liberation. Under the leadership of the Communist Party, China has always identified itself as part of the Third World or global South and the collective struggle of formerly colonized and oppressed nations against the global inequality wrought by imperialism. Under the banner of “South-South cooperation”, China continues to champion this collective struggle today, promoting greater say for developing countries in global governance and the construction of a rules-based international order in place of the unilateral actions of major powers, in particular the U.S. More than mere rhetoric, China provides crucial investment, infrastructure construction, technology transfers, debt forgiveness, and diplomatic support to developing countries. Most importantly, unlike the U.S. and West which engage in destructive foreign interventions, China abides by the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of other countries and does not impose conditions on its relations. China’s respect for the self-determination of other countries has made it an indispensable partner for nations resisting foreign domination and pursuing independent development, including Cuba, Venezuela, Bolivia, Zimbabwe, Syria, Iran, and North Korea. It is for this reason that the late Cuban revolutionary Fidel Castro declared in 2004 that “China has objectively become the most promising hope and the best example for all Third World countries … an important element of balance, progress and safeguard of world peace and stability.” Venezuelan foreign minister Jorge Arreaza echoed these sentiments last December, saying “Thank God humanity can count on China,” as his country faces sanctions, economic sabotage, and threats of regime change from the U.S. Contributing to the declining global authority of the U.S, China’s international relations have prompted Washington to cynically accuse China of fostering dependency in Africa and being an “imperial power” towards Latin America. In fact, rather than behaving in a predatory manner, China provides sorely needed funding, on favorable terms, to African borrowers, and as we have seen above China supports Latin America’s struggle against imperialism. That China is praised by fiercely independent nations of the global South and faces such charges from the U.S.—the most powerful empire in history—reveals the absurdity of such claims. Anxious about its own decline, the U.S. seeks to both drive a wedge between China and the South, and also restrict the right of developing nations to choose their own partners and path. China has demonstrated that its rise is compatible with the self-determination of other nations—whether capitalist or socialist; what it comes into contradiction with is U.S. imperialism. It is important to recognize that U.S. hostility towards China is not simply a product of narrow competition with the Asian power, it is a resistance to the empowerment of the global South and democratization of international relations. China is the primary target of U.S. imperialism because of its strategic importance at the heart of the world multipolarisation trend.