Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

The inertia of European imperialism

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

The drivers of mass extinction prominently include globalisation, capitalism, and industrial economy.37 These societal processes (including economic and legal systems) are the legacy of European imperialism that shaped the modern world.38 Many years back when I first became aware of the threat of mass extinction in the groundbreaking work of Martin Gorke (2003), I found a disturbing list. Here – slightly elaborated – are the main causes of the drastically elevated extinction rates of the last several hundred years (this list is not ranked by order of impact):

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

Extinction. Caused by global order.

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

We can talk about the threat of mass extinction. The risks imposed by mass extinction are unimaginable in terms of our current order of life on Earth. Mass extinctions reorganise life’s rules, collapsing trophic structure and decimating planetary life for tens of thousands of years.28 Elizabeth Kolbert has a way of explaining what it means for life’s rules to reorganise: ‘[W]hole groups of once-dominant organisms can disappear or be relegated to secondary roles, almost as if the globe had undergone a caste change’.29

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

Decolonization key now because of cascading extinction ... colonized should manage their own decolonization

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

Much of the current order of life on Earth is dying.1 The central premise of this essay is that much of what leaves us open to mass extinction and drives its approach can be traced back to what is called ‘coloniality’.2 To respond morally to the threat of mass extinction thus demands decolonial work.3 This is a matter of prudence.4 Much Indigenous law involves good relationships with the order of life, or, as I will simply say, with ‘lands’.5 While much of the Earth’s order of life is dying, we all have much to learn from Indigenous law involving good relationships with the land.6 Accordingly, in such cases where Indigenous people have good relationships with lands, not only must we support decolonisation as a matter of justice7 but we should also support decolonising lands so that Indigenous nations may have sovereignty to live by their own laws and decolonising laws so that Indigenous law may regain jurisdiction. This introduces an additional reason of prudence during this time of cascading extinctions.8

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

Imperialism and Land Abstraction of Indigenous Lands Mass Extinction

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

The drivers of mass extinction today are societal processes (including economic and legal systems) inherited from European imperialism and embedded in the international state system. Their path dependencies demand that we engage in decolonial work. This work centrally involves countering land abstraction – the rendering instrumental of lands, waters, and skies for the sake of national territory, capitalist profit, or industrial resource use. Much Indigenous law is centred on moral relations with lands, internalising ‘ecological reflexivity’ within Indigenous society in highly articulated ways not present in the social memory of nation states. Prudential reasons thus support decolonising Indigenous lands, making room for the sovereignty and jurisdiction of Indigenous law. Such reasons are not exclusive but rather add to already evident reasons of justice in support of Indigenous decolonisation which have for some time been urgent calls for concern. This paper provides new reasoning for decolonisation concerning the practical relations between the disestablishment of our inherited colonial order and the curtailment of now alarming rates of extinction threatening the current order of life on this Earth.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! – Structural Violence

Clonialism reentrenches structural violence

Rivera 20 - Assistant professor in the Department of Landscape Architecture and Environmental Planning in the College of Environmental Design at UC Berkeley

[Danielle Zoe Rivera, “Disaster Colonialism: A Commentary on Disasters beyond Singular Events to Structural Violence,” 9/9/20, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/1468-2427.12950//MDC]

How does a shift to disaster colonialism change how planning and disaster response functions on the ground today? Following the case of Puerto Rico and the Caribbean, disaster colonialism foregrounds the systems of racial violence and dispossession, both historic and contemporary, that lie at the heart of disaster preplanning, recovery and reconstruction. While related to disaster capitalism, recentering the focus on colonialism disallows race-blind and ahistorical views of disaster. As an example, rather than casting post-disaster gentrification as a purely capitalist phenomenon, disaster colonialism examines the ‘gentrification’ taking place and asks if it is a logic of spatial dispossession (Oliver-Smith, 2010a: 2–5; Herscher, 2019), one that, free of the disaster, would easily be read as colonialism. Ultimately, it is imperative to consider how ongoing colonialism is operating through disasters. Again, colonialism, here, is not used as a metaphor (Tuck and Yang, 2012), but to directly expose the procedural vulnerabilities operating through pre-disaster and post-disaster response. Following Hurricane María, researchers have flooded the archipelago, many of whom lack an in-depth understanding of Puerto Rico’s colonial history and status. This perspective has led many researchers to conclude that Puerto Rico’s current post-disaster issues are related only to neoliberalism and the resulting national debt, without understanding why such extreme neoliberalism exists. In tying Hurricane 'Maria' to centuries of hurricanes and disaster colonialism, it becomes apparent that the type of governmental nonresponse Puerto Rico is currently experiencing mirrors many previous hurricanes, even before US neoliberalism––instead, nonresponse is more often than not tied to continuing efforts to colonize the archipelago. Puerto Rico is, unfortunately, just one example of disaster colonialism. Further research will enrich planning studies on disasters by bringing them into even greater contact with the longer histories of disasters and their effects on colonized lands and peoples. From this abbreviated essay, I would like to pose the following questions of urban planners

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - War

Colonialism War

Gani ‘21 – University of St Andrews, UK

[Jasmine K Gani, Senior Lecturer in the School of International Relations and Co-Director of the Centre for Syrian Studies at the University of St Andrews., “Racial militarism and civilizational anxiety at the imperial encounter: From metropole to the postcolonial state,” 52(6), 546–566., 2021, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/09670106211054901 //,1LEE]

Militarism cannot be fully understood without also recognizing its co-constitution with race and dependence on a civilizational schema, both in the imperial metropole and in the post colony. To demonstrate how that schema manifests in both contexts, I turned to Fanon’s discussion of racial hierarchy and the internalization of racial stigmas among the colonized, which is manifested in two ways: attempts to flee them by mimicking the ‘civilized’ European and attempts to transfer them onto an ‘Other’ within their own communities.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Climate

Changes in climate provided the basis for racialized colonial logic. Differences associated with climate were transplanted on the people within, constructing a Western imperial identity.

Mahony and Endfield ‘17 – Lecturer at University of East Anglia and Writer at University of Nottingham

[Martin Mahony: Lecturer in Human Geography at the University of East Anglia, he works on the history of atmospheric science and technology and on the politics of climate change, Georgina Endfield: Writer/Reader in Environmental History in the School of Geography at the University of Nottingham., “Climate and colonialism,” WIREs Clim Change. 2018;9:e510, 12/6/2017, https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.510//,1LEE]

Climate is “as much a philosophical concept as a material entity” (Endfield & Randalls, 2014, p. 36). Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, climate represented an “exploitable hermeneutic resource” (Livingstone, 2000, p. 93) used by writers and colonists to frame colonial experience and to give meaning to cultural and environmental distinctiveness (Howell, 2015). “Climate” has, at various times, featured both as an index of weather, stabilizing its vicissitudes into a sense of spatial and temporal coherence, and as an agent, exercising decisive influence on the forms of life which live under its meteorological regime (Fleming & Jankovic, 2011). Climatic determinism has loomed large in the intellectual history of the western world, affording climate agency in the shaping of human health, race, productivity, culture, politics, and conflict (Arnold, 1996; Hulme, 2011; Livingstone, 2002). Classical theories of climate dating back to Hippocrates have been reworked to explain the distinctive racial, pathological, economic, and moral characteristics between different parts of the world. In a European imperial context, climatically determined differences between human “races” and cultures were central to Western European self-conceptions of an inherent superiority over other peoples, offering to early expansionists apparently scientific grounds for believing in their own imperial sense of cultural supremacy. Ideas of empire were intimately bound with ideas of climate—a relationship perhaps best epitomized by Montesquieu’s observation that the “empire of the climate is the first, the most powerful of all empires” (Montesquieu, cited in Livingstone, 2012, p. 91).

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Climate

The origins of contemporary climate change discourse lies in imperial projects

Mahony and Endfield ‘17 – Lecturer at University of East Anglia and Writer at University of Nottingham

[Martin Mahony: Lecturer in Human Geography at the University of East Anglia, he works on the history of atmospheric science and technology and on the politics of climate change, Georgina Endfield: Writer/Reader in Environmental History in the School of Geography at the University of Nottingham, “Climate and colonialism,” WIREs Clim Change. 2018;9:e510, 12/6/2017, https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.510/,1LEE]

In its capacity to colonise the deepest recesses of the human mind, climate must surely constitute one of the world’s most successful imperial projects (Livingstone, 2015, p. 937). Contemporary narratives of climate change concern the anticipation of temporal change in the mean values and possible extremes of global climate. At a regional or local level, these visions of global, temporal change are often translated into spatial analogues—for example, arguments are made that the climate of Great Britain is set to transform at some future point into something like that of the present-day Mediterranean. Spatial analogues have proven popular techniques for constructing and communicating scenarios of future climate change, both within science and in wider cultural discourses (e.g., Jylhä et al., 2010). This cultural concern with the migration of “regional” climates also has a historical analogue, in the history of European encounters with foreign climates during the period of European colonial expansion. Here, it wasn’t climates which were on the move (although debates about climate change were prominent in colonial settings—see below), but people—most notably soldiers, sailors, missionaries, administrators, settler farmers, and laborers in various forms of bondage. Significant debates ensued about human adaptation to new climates, about understanding, predicting and perhaps taming climatic variability, and about the relationships between climate and new, trans-global forms of economic production and exchange.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Climate

Climate and colonialism are intertwined

Mahony and Endfield ‘17 – Lecturer at University of East Anglia and Writer at University of Nottingham

[Martin Mahony: Lecturer in Human Geography at the University of East Anglia, he works on the history of atmospheric science and technology and on the politics of climate change, Georgina Endfield: Writer/Reader in Environmental History in the School of Geography at the University of Nottingham., More Quals if Desired, “Climate and colonialism,” WIREs Clim Change. 2018;9:e510, 12/6/2017, https://doi.org/10.1002/wcc.510//IC]

Recent years have seen a growth in scholarship on the intertwined histories of climate, science, and European imperialism. Scholarship has focused both on how the material realities of climate shaped colonial enterprises, and on how ideas about climate informed imperial ideologies. Historians have shown how European expansion was justified by its protagonists with theories of racial superiority, which were often closely tied to ideas of climatic determinism. Meanwhile, the colonial spaces established by European powers offered novel “laboratories” where ideas about acclimatization and climatic improvement could be tested on the ground. While historical scholarship has focused on how powerful ideas of climate informed imperial projects, emerging scholarship in environmental history, history of science, and historical geography focuses instead on the material and cognitive practices by which the climates of colonial spaces were made known and dealt with in fields such as forestry, agriculture, and human health. These heretofore rather disparate areas of historical research carry great contemporary relevance for studies of how climates and their changes have been understood, debated, and adapted to in the past.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › UQ/Try or Die

Uniqueness - territorial exceptionalism is strong now - used to uphold territorial customs

Jason ‘23– Assistant Professor at Barry University School of Law

Buhi, Jason, Barry University School of Law, “Citizenship, Assimilation, and the Insular Cases: Reversing the Tide of Cultural Protectionism at American Samoa,” Seton Hall Law Review, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 779-838. HeinOnline, 2023, https://heinonline.org/HOL/P?h=hein.journals/shlr53&i=782.//JJB+IC]

As applied, the zone of autonomy provided to American Samoa's native customs has thus far proven fairly resilient. Notwithstanding its checkered beginnings, the approach to territorial governance outlined in the Insular Cases and carried forward in recent federal court decisions served a laudable purpose there: not to insulate the contiguous United States from cultural contamination, but to protect the insularity of its territorial peoples from mainland assimilation. 286 Whether intended or not, that framework for governance under the Territorial Clause provided the federal authorities space to allow traditional cultural practices in American Samoa to breathe, persist, and develop according to the democratic wishes of the local people. Indeed, the Fitisemanu court concluded, "[n]o circumstance is more persuasive to me than the preference against citizenship expressed by the American Samoan people through their elected representatives."287

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › 1NC

The alternative is for Congress to concede to the Diaspora movements of Puerto Rican Self-Determination and to give the state the right to choose its own destiny

Pedro Caban, 21, Professor Latin American, Caribbean & U.S. Latino Studies“Will the United States Finally Decolonize Puerto Rico?”, University at Albany, State University of New York. 5-11-2021. https://scholarsarchive.library.albany.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1048&context=lacs_fac_scholar

In summer 2019 hundreds of thousands of indignant Puerto Ricans finally had had enough. After two weeks of protests, they forced the resignation of Governor Rosselló, a reviled figure widely blamed for Puerto Rico’s interminable crises. The extraordinary protests set the stage for an unexpected political party realignment the following year. In the 2020 elections the still aggrieved population voted in record numbers for political parties that support independence and self-determination. The venerable Puerto Rican Independence Party (PIP), and upstart Movimiento Victoria Ciudadana (MVC), obtained 28 percent of the gubernatorial vote, and their candidates were elected to the legislature. Their victory was a stunning rejection of the political class. Both the MVC and PIP testified in support of H.R. 2070, and are actively advancing a progressive agenda in the legislature. Puerto Ricans are tired of politics as usual. Protests are now a way of life, and Puerto Ricans openly challenge the authority of an ailing colonial state whose legitimacy is in shreds. The young reject the PNP and PPD which are both obsessed with territorial status. They are resisting sweeping austerity measures and resolutely face the ensuing police brutality. Women feminists were a vital force in the summer 2019 uprising and established la Colectiva Feminista en Construcción. In the early days of May 2021 la Colectiva held fervent and boisterous demonstrations to protest the government’s failure to contain the plague of femicides. Hundreds of others are protesting the government’s continued failure respond to the transportation and health crisis that victimize the residents of Vieques. Labor unions are challenging Governor Pierluisi’s decision to sell the public electric utility to the LUMA corporation. Puerto Ricans in all walks of life have turned to a new politics of solidarity, resilience and resistance. They have broken with a culture of dependency on the government, or “assistenlialism.” Puerto Ricans have built a multitude of mutual aid associations that provide vital services the government has essentially forsaken. An array of other issue-specific organizations are challenging destructive environmental policies, are fighting gentrification driven by Americans attracted by generous tax incentives. Other organizations are fighting privatization of the publicly owned assets and resources, and others are working toward energy and food self-sufficiency. Indeed, one of the most remarkable developments of the last few years has been the politicization of the population and the emergence of a political consciousness that demands government accountability. One well known activist described the emergence of “an unforeseen duality between the self-management movement and the protests that were organized to defend the people” (author’s translation). The colonial state is floundering in this hyper-politicized environment. Many, if not most, of the 5.8 million Puerto Ricans who reside in the United States consider themselves members of the Puerto Rican nation. The Puerto Rican diaspora is actively promoting the Self Determination Act, while combating the PNP’s statehood campaign. H.R. 2070 has captured the attention of virtually all Puerto Rican diaspora organizations. Ninety organizations wrote to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer urging them “to support and prioritize the passage of the Puerto Rico Self Determination Act.” Boricuas Unidos en la Diaspora Puerto Rico (BUDPR), Diaspora en Resistencia, Power4PuertoRico and Our Revolution Puerto Rico have scores of thousands of followers on their social media platforms. These organizations joined forces with Vamos a Puerto Rico, a prominent Puerto Rican based social justice grass roots organization, to lobby for H.R. 2070. Diaspora organizations placed ads in the New York Times, convened webinars on decolonization and self-determination, organized zoom panels with representatives from the PIP and MVC, have held rallies, lobbied congress, and set up a tweeter account to contact key legislators. On April 20 diaspora organizations held a public hearing on H.R. 2070 and sent send the proceedings to the Committee on Natural Resources. Progressive organizations including LatinoJustice, the Center for Popular Democracy, Democratic Socialists of America, and Open Society Policy Center support H.R. 2070. The Center for American Progress applauded the bill, noting that the “landmark legislation would facilitate, not impose, a status resolution mechanism to resolve 123 years of colonialism on the island.” Pierluisi and the PNP were caught off guard by the scope of activism for H.R. 2070. The political realignment that is taking place in Puerto Rico creates a propitious moment for the self-determination act to become law. The federal government knows that the once reliable political class can no longer manage the colony. If H.R. 2070 becomes law, years may pass before Congress and the convention delegates agree on self-determination options. In the interim the anti-colonial forces can consolidate and expand their political base. With the Commonwealth excluded as a territorial option, and the PNP unable to generate support in Congress, independence or a sovereign free-associated state emerge as real possibilities for the world’s oldest colony.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › 1NC

The US is at fault when it comes to Puerto Rico’s economic crisis — more intervention makes things worse

Fonseca 19(Melody, Department of Political Science, University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras Campus, Puerto Rico. BEYOND COLONIAL ENTRAPMENT: THE CHALLENGES OF PUERTO RICAN “NATIONAL CONSCIOUSNESS” IN TIMES OF PROMESA. Interventions. International Journal of Postcolonial Studies. 3/17/2019. . DOA 7/19/2023)//NPR

As “underdeveloping countries” (Fernández Retamar 1993), colonial nations exercise quotidian exploitation and violence through the material and economic spheres. As stated by Fanon, the economic dependency of a recently independent country from its former oppressor was a reality that should be fought for through decolonization. This fight should take the form of national and popular action against colonial elites, beneficiaries of the colonial entrapment. The colonial elite pursue the benefit of their businesses and have no problems with transforming newly independent countries into tourist and investment destinations to improve profits (Fanon 2004, 100–102). This reality allows Fernández Retamar to affirm “only the Third World knows in its wholeness the horrors of capitalism” (2016a, 82); that finds in colonialism one of its most atrocious expressions. In Puerto Rico this economic dependency is also a strategy of colonial entrapment. A decade after the establishment of the commonwealth, official reports suggested “Puerto Rico’s capital yield overseas was 26.9 million dollars, while the foreign capital yield in Puerto Rico was 238.9 million dollars,” a net loss of 212 million dollars (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 160). At the same time, by 1965 foreign debt was 573 million dollars, and a year later Puerto Rico would be paying 3.3 per cent of its GDP in interest. However, by 1967 the total amount of dollars paid in interest was 25.5 per cent higher than a year before (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 160). In this same context, it is important to underline that 80 per cent of imports came from the United States and that 78 per cent of locally established industries were from foreign capital, mostly American (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 156–158). In general terms, this colonial economy included the institutionalization of massive emigration of Puerto Ricans to the United States (Duany 1999; Pol 2014) and the use of unincorporated status to avoid taxing US corporations on the island (Ayala and Bernabe 2016). Both policies paved the way for an economy dependent on the capitalist necessities of the “underdeveloping” nation. Nowadays, one could argue that Puerto Rico has been entrapped in a unilateral “free trade agreement” without having the chance even to discuss the clauses of such an “agreement.” An example of this is the socalled Leyes de Cabotaje that imply that any good imported to, or exported from, Puerto Rico has to go through the United States Merchant Marine. This means a US vessel, flag, and crew; plus, customs are registered at a continental port. In other words, to buy any goods from the neighbouring island of the Dominican Republic, those products should arrive first at any port of continental United States, switch to a US vessel for transport, and then arrive in Puerto Rico. These restrictions were first established by the Foraker Act of 1900, were extended by the Jones Act of 1917, and remained in place after the establishment of the commonwealth through the Federal Relations Act. Its terrible impact on Puerto Rico’s economy has been evident since the economic crisis in the early decades of the twentieth century (Scarano 1993; Curet-Cuevas 2003). It drastically raised the values of imported/exported goods, affected the production, consumption, and exportation of local products, and has since sustained the relation of dependency in two directions: Puerto Rico’s industry is highly dependent on the US market, as Puerto Ricans are dependent on US goods. In this way, colonial entrapment becomes visible: nothing enters or leaves the island without the authorization of the colonial being. Recently, the economist Gustavo Vélez pointed to the roots of Puerto Rico’s crisis being our colonial relationship with the United States. Since the establishment of the Foraker Act, Puerto Rico’s economy has been adversely affected and devalued on behalf of the US economy – firstly, with the conversion of the Spanish peso to the US dollar with an exchange rate of one peso per sixty cents. This facilitated US sugar corporations’ use of this devaluation to buy land at lower prices. Secondly, with the establishment of the US dollar as the official currency in Puerto Rico, devaluations have not occurred directly to money, but rather to property on the island. Thirdly, with significant tax cuts to US investment, as illustrated in Law 20 and Law 22 of 2012 (Vélez 2018), which paved the way for capital investment. And, finally, under the current imposition of PROMESA. Moreover, while the hegemonic discourse on Puerto Rico’s debt insists on local government corruption and mismanagement of federal funding, recent economic research is suggesting that the breaking point of the colonial crisis could be found in the process of “deindustrialization” of the Puerto Rican economy (Caraballo-Cueto and Lara 2018). This process, deepened by neoliberalism and austerity measures within a colonial scenario, has strengthened the colonial entrapment of Puerto Rico’s economy. While Puerto Rico has an external debt of around 70 billion US dollars, colonial status has also become a straitjacket for a possible resolution. In 1984 Puerto Rico was withdrawn from the protection of the US Bankruptcy Code. With this loophole, the local government established a local bankruptcy law (Ley de Quiebra Criolla) in 2014, later derogated as it was considered unconstitutional by the US Supreme Court. Under Title III of PROMESA, it has been established that La Junta has the power to decide everything about Puerto Rico’s debt: what will the government pay; to whom; and if they (La Junta) will call for bankruptcy protection in particular instances or not. None of these decisions will be made by the local government (Colón Colón and Jiménez 2016). Although a large number of Puerto Ricans support an audit of the debt, La Junta opposes this claim and insists on having the expertise to carry out the restructuration and payments to every creditor by imposing an agenda of severe austerity. In this sense, the local government and each of its public agencies has the task of designing a fiscal plan that meets the austerity agenda. This plan will be taken into consideration by La Junta that has the power to accept it, ask for a new plan, or impose a different one. As has been the case since the early stages of US colonialism in Puerto Rico, the colony is portrayed as a primary sector reservoir, holiday resort, the source of cheap labour, human resources for military service, and land to explore and practice military strategies, all within “domestic” territory. Under the control of an “underdeveloping” colonial power, Puerto Rico’s economy is entirely entrapped by the colonial relationship with the United States.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › 1NC

Congressional legislature is shrouded in colonialism. By demanding governmental action, the AFF re-entrenches Puerto Rico in a cycle of colonial violence.

Córdova 08(Nathaniel I., Willamette University American Ethnic Studies Program, Latin American Studies Program, and the Center for Religion, Law, and Democracy. Expert in Philosophy, Rhetoric, and Theory. The Incomplete subject of Colonial Memory: Puerto Rico and The Post/Colonial Biopolitics of Congressional Recollection. The Communication Review. 2008. . DOA 7/18/2023)//NPR

The Mnemonic Power of the Law: Establishment of Congressional Memorial Superiority Over That of the Colonial Subject Congress further extended the legitimacy of its recollection by asserting its memorial superiority and establishing an incomplete colonial subject just arriving at the gates of political maturity. Puerto Ricans were (and are) deemed incomplete subjects by virtue of their political immaturity, their inability to resolve their problem of political status. Such incompleteness, combined with the already established congressional authority, marks the subject’s absence of memory and thus “world,” creating an ever-expanding master’s universe in which the subject can participate. This master’s universe is deployed in the registers of congressional memory. Moreover, congressional memory excludes the U.S.’s role in forging a fragmented colonial situation in the first place, but takes the fragmentary nature of the subject’s recollection and pits it against Congress’ own unified “whole and coherent” recall based on access to a legal archive that can re-member selves through officially sanctioned mechanisms like the referendum. The preponderance of institutional and judicial evidence that the Young Act, and the Task Force Report marshall in support of official recollection invests them with a mantle of moral superiority by virtue of their capacious memory, and the sovereign exception to dictate the space of the nation occupied by their unincorporated possession.21 The imprimatur of congressional authority even legitimates its claims to memory over those of its colonial subjects by countering the viability of Puerto Ricans using such documents as the Puerto Rico Federal Relations Act (48 U.S.C. 731 et seq.), which some Puerto Rican leaders had rightfully claimed described the relationship between the United States and the island as being “in the nature of a compact, based on the principle of consent,” as memorial touchstone in support of their own recollection (48 U.S.C. 731b): Based upon the present status of Puerto Rico under Public Law 81–600, the Federal courts have ruled that for purposes of U.S. law this arrangement for local territorial government has not changed Puerto Rico’s status as an unincorporated territory subject to the plenary authority of Congress under the Territorial Clause; that the right to due process and equal protection of the law applies to Puerto Rico, but this does not include equal enfranchisement in the political process or equal rights and benefits under Federal law as available to citizens residing in the States; that the authority of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is limited to purely local affairs not governed by provisions of the Federal Constitution and Federal laws applicable to Puerto Rico; and that the establishment of local constitutional self-government with the consent of the people was authorized through an exercise of Congressional discretion under the Territorial Clause which is not binding on a future Congress. Harris v. Rosario, 446 U.S. 651 (1980); Examining Board v. Flores de Otero, 426 U.S. 572, 81–600 (1976); Rodriguez v. Popular Democratic Party, 457 U.S. 1 (1982); U.S. v. Sanchez, 992 F.2d 1143 (1993). (H.R. 105–131, p. 13) The tone of the Young Act is one of correcting and disciplining the recollection of its colonial subjects, an approach also clearly seen in H.R. 105–131’s section titled “Puerto Rico’s International Legal Status,” especially in the paragraph noting that, “those who suggest that U.S. diplomats overstated the degree of self-government achieved under the Constitution to get the U.N. to go along may be partially right, but that is why countries submit written statements to clarify ambiguities and set the record straight” (p. 15). Once again, we are reminded of the legal archive upon which congressional memorial superiority is grounded, setting the record straight as to the intent of the United States, and disciplining any counter-memorializing. Official congressional recollection declares not only that Puerto Rico has been a colonial backwater since 1898, but remembers Puerto Ricans as “statutory citizens,” a colonial limbo with no guarantee of protection under the U.S. Constitution unless one of the options provided by Congress is adopted. The language of statutory citizenship emerges as a citizenship class that embodies the “included excluded” status that firmly locates the subject at the margins of the political order, with less than equal rights: While the U.S. citizenship of persons born in Puerto Rico is expressly recognized in the local constitution, the current citizenship of persons born in the territory is not created, defined or guaranteed by the local constitution or the commonwealth structure of local self-government. Rather, the current U.S. citizenship of persons born in Puerto Rico is created and defined by Congress in the exercise of its Territorial Clause power and in implementation of Article IX of the Treaty of Paris. (H.R. 105–131, p. 13) Through this “exclusionary inclusion” Puerto Ricans are thus ambivalently inscribed into the political order arriving at self-determination if and when they choose the course of action provided by the United States. To this end, the Young Act included a provision proposed by Representative Dan Burton (R-Indiana) which stipulated that in the event the initial referendum was deemed inconclusive and Puerto Ricans chose to continue commonwealth status, another referendum would take place no less than once every 10 years or until such a time when a viable status was selected. Thus, although 1998 conceivably marked the moment at which Puerto Ricans as colonial subjects had finally arrived at the gates of political maturity, it did not guarantee self-determination. The colonial subject remains an incomplete subject until such a time when it remembers to choose properly from a menu provided by the colonial master and Congress deems the choice appropriate. Congressional memory relies on legal doctrine as universalizing discourse, displacing contingency and replacing it with the mnemonic power of the law. Ensconced within the mantle of legal discourse, Congress masks an attempt at “departicularizing” the U.S.-Puerto Rico relationship, that is, erasing any semblance of localized or concretely situated meaning, by using a barrage of legal detail and technical reference (Alonso, 1988).22 Paradoxically, the law’s mnemonic power also grants congressional memory the appearance of particularity. Not only does the minute level of recollection establish institutional authority, but it numbs us by the sheer weight of its rhetorical prowess. This departicularization or universalization is achieved by diverting our attention to a set of legal specificities, such as Supreme Court decisions and constitutional clauses to which Congress holds privileged access and thus special institutional recollection. Its reliance on the mnemonic power of law grants Congress the semblance of a detached observer, an objective institution through which knowledge of the past flows. As a result, Congress appears as speaking with a unified voice, one that bestows upon congressional memory a sense of normalcy and correctness, what sociologist Ana Maria Alonso refers to as “transparent objectivity” (Alonso, 1988, p. 36). As Alonso also tells us, the “voice” of the “I” who “sees” is that of the observer, an observer who claims to hear the colonial subject’s voice while remaining eyewitness to the past, and thus its sole legitimator (p. 45). As sole legitimator of the past, Congress retains the power to define Puerto Rico’s present and future, prohibiting Puerto Ricans living in the U.S. from voting in the referendum, and demanding compliance with language admonitions for entrance into the union as a state. These demands once again reveal the logic of sovereign exception that suffuses congressional claims to a process of self-determination, reasserting a biopolitical practice that required the locals to subject their bodies and lives to the various demands of the colonial master. The weight of legal precedent displayed in these artifacts, and the exclusion of the U.S.’s responsibility in forging the colonial impasse, coupled with the newly remembered moral responsibility of Congress, and the declarative style in which the Young Act reasserts the U.S.’s national interest, do not countenance any opposition to the U.S.’s authority to act as it sees fit with the island. As Congressman Burton, a member of the House Committee on Resources that initiated H.R. 856, oxymoronically noted during the first hearings on the Act, “If the Puerto Rican people choose to maintain Commonwealth status, turning away from self-rule, we as a Congress will maintain the supreme administrative control of the island” (Young Act Hearings Report: #105–16, 1997, p. 4). In essence, Rep. Burton’s comment was an invocation of traditional authority which sought to establish itself, as Hannah Arendt’s dictum in the introduction to Walter Benjamin’s Illuminations reminded us, as sovereign: “Insofar as the past has been transmitted as tradition, it possesses authority; insofar as authority presents itself historically, it becomes tradition” (Arendt, 1969, p. 38). Hence, Congress’s memorial superiority, buttressed by the mnemonic power of the law, and by the vision of the incomplete memory of the colonial subject now finally arriving at the gates of political maturity, grants Congress, the Young Act, and the proposed referendum as sites of remembrance, an unapologetic aura of tradition, authority, and full sovereignty over the incomplete subject of colonial memory that it constitutes, and which inhabits an indistinct zone of exception in a U.S. post-colonial imaginary. Congress takes great pains to make sure its authority is firmly established by asserting their right and authority under the territorial clause of the U.S. Constitution to determine federal policy and resolve issues of self-determination for the island. Of foundational value among the historical claims is the recognition of congressional authority over Puerto Rico as stipulated in article IX of the Treaty of Paris and thus in U.S. Constitutional law: “under the Territorial Clause of the Constitution, Congress has the authority and responsibility to determine Federal policy and clarify status issues in order to advance the self-determination process in Puerto Rico” (H.R. 856, Part 2, 12). Although claims to authority do not culminate with this next passage in the Young Act, titled Authority of Congress to Determine Status, it is perhaps the most telling of them all: Since current unincorporated territory status of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is not a permanent, unalterable, or guaranteed status under the Constitution of the United States, Congress retains plenary authority and responsibility to determine a permanent status for Puerto Rico consistent with the national interest. (H.R. 856, Part 6, 3)

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

Degrowth requires authoritarianism – This is the only way to implement changes on the scale required by the Aff

Alessio Terzi, 1-09-2023, author of Growth for Good (Harvard University Press, 2022). He is also an Economist at DG ECFIN of the European Commission, and an Adjunct Professor at Sciences Po and at HEC Paris. Prior to this, he was Affiliate Fellow at Bruegel, the leading European economics think-tank, and Fulbright Scholar at the Harvard Kennedy School. PhD from the Hertie School, "“Degrowth would lead to authoritarianism"," European Magazine, https://the-european.eu/story-29211/degrowth-would-lead-to-authoritarianism.html

It is a fringe, but increasingly popular theory. Greta Thunberg’s new book includes articles from degrowth theorists who see capitalism as the root cause of climate change. Usually economists dismiss degrowth on the grounds that it will cause a recession, which people would never vote for. This is rather shallow, because the degrowth movement argues that it’s only involuntarily shrinking of the economy that generates bad effects like unemployment. My theory is that degrowth rests on the idea of voluntary scarcity, an old concept that starts with Plato’s theory of finding happiness in human relationships, rather than material consumption. Many religions, including Christianity, use similar rhetoric. So degrowth scholars believe they will succeed where Jesus Christ didn’t. If you cannot persuade people that this is good for them, you need a government to dictate what they are allowed to do in granular detail, because every activity generates CO2 emissions. That’s where authoritarianism comes in.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

National degrowth fails – Absent changes to the international economy, it only leads to capital flight

Nadia Johanisova and Stephan Wolf, August 2012, Department of Environmental Studies Faculty of Social Studies, Masaryk University, RNDr., Ph.D., University of Freidburg, Chair of Environmental Economics and Research Management, Ph. D. "Economic democracy: A path for the future?," Futures, https://www.degrowth.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Johanisova_Wolf-2012.pdf

However, as pointed out e.g. by Hines [26, pp. 19–20] and, more recently, Latouche [27, pp. 72–76], in a deregulated international economic framework, where governments are to a large extent held hostage to capital markets, radical economic changes are next to impossible to implement in a single country. This includes reforms envisioned by degrowth proponents, such as ecological tax reform. Ecological tax reform (which entails higher taxation of material and energy capital consumption and lower taxation of work) could help internalise the environmental externalities of large corporations as well as change consumer behaviour [28]. As a policy suggestion, it has been with us for decades [29], but meaningful implementation has been stalled by fears of ‘‘reduction in competitiveness’’: in an economically deregulated world, higher ecological taxation might just drive corporations to greener pastures elsewhere [30, pp. 10–11]. Similarly, other needed reforms on a national level, such as attempts to introduce shorter working hours [28 (p. 883),27 (pp. 81–88)] or regulation and reform within the financial sector (especially urgent from a degrowth standpoint – see Section 2.3) could trigger an exodus of capital from the country in question, paralysing the initiative, and/or render products and companies uncompetitive both in their country and globally. Desai and Riddlestone [31, pp. 40–42] describe the impact of a green tax in Great Britain2 which increased manufacturing costs. British paper manufacturers passed the costs down to the consumer, which led to British recycled paper becoming more expensive than imported virgin paper, and predictably to the imports increasing, along with the British consumer’s ecological footprint.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

Global South opposed to degrowth – Too many downsides for degrowth policies to elicit follow-on

Amanda Herath, June 2016, University of Colombo, Department of Business Economics, "”Degrowth”; a literature review and a critical analysis," International Journal of Accounting and Business Finance, https://www.maco.jfn.ac.lk/ijabf/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Vol2_Issue1_4.pdf

If the North is to follow a policy of consumption degrowth what will happen to the exports of the global South, which are highly dependent on the markets of global North? In such a situation what are the steps that global South should follow in order to protect their export-incomes?

If the global North is to charge high taxes on international capital movements will the global South be able to find enough capital to maintain their growth models of progress? If the global North is to contract their economies and to redistribute income within, what will be the future of the foreign aid? Overseas Development Aid (ODA) has failed to reach its aimed levels of 0.7% of rich nations GNI. Under a scenario of GDP contraction will ODA too contract? Then what would be the plight of the global South aid recipients?

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

Implementing degrowth alone fails – Laundry list of impacts absent global cooperation on degrowth

Riccardo Mastini and Giorgos Kallis, 10-31-2018, PhD candidate in Ecological Economics and Political Ecology in the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, environmental scientist working on ecological economics, political ecology, and water policy. He teaches political ecology and ecological economics at the Autonomous University of Barcelona "Beyond the choke hold of growth: post-growth or radical degrowth?—Tim Jackson in conversation with Giorgos Kallis," Centre for the Understanding of Sustainable Prosperity, https://cusp.ac.uk/themes/aetw/blog_interview_tj_gk/

Riccardo Mastini: Zooming out from national politics, what would a post-growth world mean for the international system, which sees states trade and compete with one another?

Giorgos Kallis: That’s the question we have thought about least in the degrowth movement because it’s the most difficult. A lot of our thinking tends to look at how one nation could be made stable without growth. But it is true that we live in a globalised economy characterised by competition. Trade is not the first thing that concerns me; I am thinking more about international competition and geopolitics. Geopolitics has its own logic. The power dynamics of the military sphere and economic domination play out with a logic of competition different to that of capitalist competition. Vladimir Putin wants a sphere of influence for Russia to export oil and to strengthen its economy. China wants to build the Belt Road. The United States wants to control oil supplies. Big dynamics of growth come from this competition, which is also competition over military dominance. To think that somehow these power dynamics will wither away by themselves might be too romantic.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

Even international degrowth fails – International competition makes coordination impossible as each government tries to circumvent degrowth policies

Kenta Tsuda, March 2021, MPhil/PhD candidate, Harvard Law School, J.D. magna cum laude, 2014; Cambridge University, MPhil, 2008; Brown University, B.A. magna cum laude, 2007 "Kenta Tsuda, Naive Questions on Degrowth, NLR 128, March–April 2021," New Left Review, https://newleftreview.org/issues/ii128/articles/kenta-tsuda-naive-questions-0n-degrowth

Domestic policy is only the start. Degrowthers do not directly address the issue of international coordination, but presumably all large economies would need to contract in order to achieve the required material-throughput reductions. Degrowth in one country is a non-starter. International coordination of degrowth, however, threatens to reproduce the domestic coordination problem within the anarchic dynamics of inter-state politics, where economic magnitude comes armed with military power. It seems likely that every state will aim to maximize its relative position in a degrowth world—that is, to degrow the least relative to other nations. Recognizing this problem, powerful states will then aim to establish an international agreement—a Global Degrowth Pact, say—to constrain each other. The Pact would include mechanisms to monitor and punish defection. Pact members would settle on metrics against which national contraction could be measured. Where national statistics failed to conform to the degrowth schedule, punishment would kick in—escalating economic sanctions, for example.

So much for the Pact on paper. What about in practice? The Pact would need to define criteria for degrowth to be applied to widely varying economies, with each government wanting the discretion to define these for itself. Most would no doubt argue that their proportion of degrowth should be reduced, invoking the degrowth principle of ‘localized growth in the public interest’, or other specific national circumstances. In the absence of determinate public-interest criteria, each government’s claims would be hard to contest. How much contraction is demanded of each nation is likely to take on an arbitrary character, accommodating the will of the powerful rather than optimizing for achievement of ecological targets.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › Degrowth Fails

Turn—degrowth’s reduction of economic activity worsens inequality by preventing the poor from taking advantage of growing global market.

Zimet ’22. [ Saul Zimet is a Website and Data Coordinator for HumanProgress.org at the Cato Institute and a graduate student in economics at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice at the City University of New York.] “Why Economic Degrowth Is Terrible For Everyone—Especially the Poor.” June 5, 2022. https://fee.org/articles/why-economic-degrowth-is-terrible-for-everyone-especially-the-poor/

The economic growth numbers have come in for the first quarter of this year, and they’re dismal. In the United States’ highly regulated economy, we’ve come to expect low growth rates. But negative growth is especially bad, occurring only during terrible economic conditions. And yet, degrowth is precisely what the US economy did in the first three months of 2022. According to astatement by the Commerce Department, inflation-adjusted gross domestic product (GDP) declined 0.4 percent in this year’s first quarter, which is an annualized decline of 1.4 percent. That contraction makes Q1 of 2022 the weakest quarter for GDP growth since the pandemic-related recession of 2020. Economic degrowth is terrible for almost everyone, but it endangers the poor most of all. Therefore, it is remarkable that the problems with degrowth are appreciated least by those who claim to be most focused on the interests of the lower classes. The Downplaying of Degrowth New York Times that the White House was “dismissive” of the recent news from the Commerce Department, rebutting that “consumer spending, business investment, and residential investment increased at strong rates.” If people are consoled by the Biden administration’s cherry-picked metrics of success within an economy that is suffering overall, it is likely in part because economic growth is considered a low priority at best among a substantial subset of the political commentariat. Robert Pollin, Distinguished Professor of Economics and co-director of the Political Economy Research Institute at the University of Massachusetts Amherst who hashelped draft legislation for Senator Bernie Sanders, has stated in aninterview that, “To just have growth, unless you change the political environment and make economic policies more egalitarian, means all the growth is going to go into the pockets of the rich, which more or less has happened, certainly since the end of the recession. So, growth is bad if it’s more unequal.” Ben Burgis, Jacobin columnist and adjunct professor of philosophy at Morehouse College, argues in favor of a worker-cooperative economywhile admitting that, “probably in a co-op dominated economy, because people aren’t going to have the same kind of incentives to do that kind of rapid expansion that the owners of more traditional companies might have, I think that does mean you probably are going to have slower economic growth… But I’m not sure that’s an unambiguously bad thing, especially when you start to think about the ecological effects of constant growth for the sake of growth.” Socialist political commentator Ian Kochinski, who goes by the pseudonym Vaush,has said that, “One of the unfortunate truths of being a socialist is you have to accept that your nation will not get to enjoy the skyrocket GDP growth that capitalist nations get to enjoy. There is going to be a sacrifice of some economic efficiency, to the benefit of hopefully making life better for everybody.” Some growth critics go even further than to question the importance of growth as a policy target. For example, in her New York Times bestselling bookThis Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. The Climate, Naomi Klein calls economic growth “reckless and dirty” and advocates a policy of “radical and immediate degrowth” in order to reduce global carbon emissions to manageable levels. Growth and the Poor University of Oxford economist Max Roser haspointed out that the number of people in extreme poverty has fallen by roughly 137,000 individuals every single day for the past 25 years. That’s over a billion people—more people than there were on Earth just. This miraculous occurrence has been called “the most important fact about wellbeing in the world since World War II” by the Nobel Prize winning Princeton University economist Angus Deaton in his bookThe Great Escape. And as CNN host and Washington Post columnist Fareed Zakaria hasobserved, these data indicate that more people have escaped extreme poverty in the last fifty years than had done so in the preceding five hundred. Harvard University cognitive scientist Steven Pinker notes in his 2018 bookEnlightenment Now that if this trend were to continue, the extreme poverty rate would reach zero by the year 2026. The COVID-19 pandemic and lockdowns set the global economy back a few years, but the virtual end of extreme poverty remains broadly within reach, which is an unprecedented circumstance to be in as a species. As Deaton and Pinker delineate in their aforementioned books, and as Harvard University Department of Economics chairman Benjamin M. Friedman explains in his bookThe Moral Consequences of Economic Growth, improving the material fortunes of the poor causes their physical health, educational opportunities, life expectancies, safety from violence, trust in their neighbors, and countless other standards of living to improve. As Pinker writes, “Though it’s easy to sneer at national income as a shallow and materialistic measure, it correlates with every indicator of human flourishing.” Notably, those brought out of extreme poverty, which have mostly been in places like China and India, were largely not helped by massive social programs but by a growing global market for their labor. If redistribution of pre-existing wealth were the cause of this phenomenon, then the reduction in extreme poverty would have been accompanied by a reduction in extreme wealth in some other subset of the population. To the contrary, there is no significant demographic with massive losses to match those massive gains. Rather, as Americans and other denizens of wealthy countries have becomewealthier on average, their increased demand for overseas labor has brought people from farms to factories, from factories to office parks, and so on. That has been made possible by gross world productroughly doubling since 1990. This widespread growth has been unfolding ever since it began around the time of the industrial revolution, which is whyover 90 percent of the human population lived in extreme poverty throughout all of human history before 1800, and why less than 10 percent live in extreme poverty today. It was economic growth, not redistribution programs, that has brought the masses out of extreme poverty like never before in human history. Growth as a Policy Target George Mason University economist Tyler Cowen explains in a Foreign Affairs that, “In the medium to long term, even small changes in growth rates have significant consequences for living standards. An economy that grows at one percent doubles its average income approximately every 70 years, whereas an economy that grows at three percent doubles its average income about every 23 years—which, over time, makes a big difference in people’s lives.” To concretize this point, Cowen proposes a thought experiment in his bookStubborn Attachments: “Redo U.S. history, but assume the country’s economy had grown one percentage point less each year between 1870 and 1990. In that scenario, the United States of 1990 would be no richer than Mexico of 1990.” It is not just wealthy Americans that would be worse off in such a scenario—the lower and middle classes of Mexico are much worse off than the lower and middle classes of the United States, and this is largely a function of the general success of each country’s economy. In political and economic discourse today, there are two major strategies being proposed to alleviate poverty. One strategy is to redistribute wealth from those who have a lot, the most economically powerful members of society, to those who don’t, the most economically weak members of society. This zero-sum strategy is virtually destined to fail because it requires making enemies of the most economically powerful members of society, who are definitionally both incentivized and empowered to prevent the redistribution. This is largely why every major socialist experiment in history has resulted in some elite class taking control and enriching themselves to the enormous detriment of the lower classes. The other strategy is to increase the abundance of wealth so much that an ever-expanding portion of the population can afford to meet their needs. This positive-sum strategy is built on economic growth. Just like increasing the supply of apples causes their price to come down, increasing the supply of wealth reduces the barriers to earning enough resources to get your needs met in a market economy. As others become wealthier, they will be willing and able to pay more for your labor. And as the economy grows, more technological and scientific progress can be funded, which eventually increases the capabilities of thevast majority of humanity. Instead of making enemies out of the economic elite, this strategy makes allies out of them, which means it is far more likely to succeed in practice. And as we have seen, unlike any other strategy ever attempted, this has already proven effective at a global scale for reducing poverty and improving the human condition in other ways through technological and scientific progress. In the fullness of time, even a small change in the economic growth rate means the difference between starvation and survival for millions or billions of people, not to mentionthe difference between humanity’s extinction and its ability to fund enough technological progress to eventually become sustainably multiplanetary. The critics of growth are wrong aboutits environmental dangers, but they’re also wrong to downplay its role in the fight against poverty. If winning that fight is indeed their goal, policymakers should put reversing America’s dismal growth trend near the top of their priority list.

Alt Causes - A federal jobs guarantee can’t solve the effects of incarceration job opportunities. LeTourneau ’18. [ Nancy LeTourneau is a political writer for The Washington Monthly.] “The Problem a Federal Jobs Guarantee Won’t Solve.” April 30, 2018. https://washingtonmonthly.com/2018/04/30/the-problem-a-federal-job-guarantee-wont-solve/

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs KB Degrowth › Case › FJG Fails

FGJ is unrealistic and an impossible imaginary and exacerbates harms

Gulker PhD 18 [Max Gulker, PhD, Senior Research Fellow, “The Job Guarantee: A Critical Analysis,” American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, https://www.aier.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/JobGuarantee_0.pdf, accessed 7-23-2023] EAY

5 The Reality of Running a Federal Job Guarantee An employer normally pays an employee because the latter is doing something of value. Under a federal job guarantee, that logic is reversed: the government must find something for ten million or more workers to do because they are being paid. The difference is of great importance. The work handed out under a job guarantee is subject to complex criteria. In the view of the Levy report, these jobs must • Be able to “quickly accommodate new entrants into the program and let them go without disruption should they find alternative employment” • Help low-skilled workers build human capital to “enhance their chances to obtain work outside the program. They will gain work experience as well as on-the-job training.” • In every community, “provide visible benefits, meeting specific local needs” • Put millions to work “without competing for employees or displacing private sector undertakings” or “conventional public-sector work” These points, taken together, are astonishing.14 The work given to enrollees must teach valuable skills, but not so valuable that someone securely employed in the private sector would want to enroll. And while the work needs to result in “visible benefits,” these benefits should not be so great that any firm or government agency would be willing on its own to pay a wage of fifteen dollars per hour.15 The Levy report’s authors see concerns about finding such work as a failure of imagination: Is there really a dearth of useful things that might be done by our unemployed workers? Have we become so blind that we cannot see our failing infrastructure, our understaffed parks with their closed swimming pools and unkempt trails, the unmet needs of our seniors and our children, our polluted ponds and streams that require clean- up, and our low-income housing that would benefit from repairs and insulation? Are we really so unimaginative that we cannot think of a way to match our jobless with paid work tackling the unmet tasks surrounding us? Beyond examples such as these, both reports leave the job guarantee’s implementation, and its feasibility, to the reader’s imagination. The remainder of this section will consider the logistical details of finding and assigning work to over ten million people without the aid of the market, while also meeting the above criteria. While large- scale, centralized proposals can sound good in the abstract, even scratching the surface of the logistics involved shows how they quickly break down, sometimes catastrophically. 5.1 Two Approaches to Finding Work: Local and National Since the work done by job-guarantee enrollees cannot be created by mutual economic opportunity, it must be somehow found through a bureaucratic process. We will assume that the goal of the agency given this task is to find the work with the most value to society. But whether this is done at a local, state, or national level, the process inevitably runs into fatal flaws. Both reports emphasize, to varying degrees, the importance of relying on smaller units of government to administer the program. The Levy Report relies almost exclusively on “communities” (taken here to mean local or county governments) to find and assign work: While we recognize some advantages to designs that feature a federally administered program like the [New Deal program] WPA [Works Progress Administration], we prefer a highly decentralized program. Today, the federal government directly employs only 2.8 million workers (less than 2 percent of US employment). Advocates of a universal job guarantee recognize that the program might employ five times that number of workers. We worry about the political feasibility of expanding federal employment on such a scale. We also see the advantages of decentralizing administration to the community level. Since the goal is to create jobs in every community, and to create projects that are beneficial to every community, it makes sense to involve the local communities in these projects, from the proposal stage through to implementation, administration, and evaluation. The CBPP report is less explicit about who administers its program, but seems to envision a larger role for the federal government alongside input from states and localities: Because of the vital role of state and local governments in providing public workers and services, it is essential that federal agencies and the NIEC [National Investment Employment Corps] are empowered to work closely with these governments. Local and state governments will be encouraged to develop employment proposals in conjunction with community leaders, local government officials, labor organizations, and local residents to ensure the proposals will serve the needs of the constituents and available pool of labor. The employment proposals may not be used to employ individuals who will replace or speed the displacement of existing employees or individuals who would otherwise perform similar work. The program will cover wage, benefits, and material expenses. This structure will largely parallel the direct employment programs under the New Deal, whose projects were developed and proposed by local and state governments. Fostering partnerships and buy-in from local and state partners is critical to the success of but with the hiring and pay decisions already made by mandate, the advantages of a market structure are wiped away. To understand the process of finding and assigning work on a local level, we will look at a concrete example. There are few places where unemployment and its consequences are clearer than Hampden County, Massachusetts, whose 5 percent unemployment rate16 is well above the national average. Home to state capitol Springfield and several other small cities and large towns, Hampden County’s population in the 2010 census was 463,490.17 We estimate18 that under the projections of the CBPP and Levy (upper bound) reports, respectively, the local governments of this county of less than 500,000 people would have to find work for between 17,000 and 28,000 job-guarantee enrollees, between 3.6 and 6.0 percent of the population. As we showed above, these numbers could increase by 50 percent or more during a recession. How would a medium-sized county such as Hampden create work on this scale? The Levy report lists a litany of laudable ideas in the quote above, but how much work would these ideas really create? And how would they fare under the criteria stated in the Levy report? Allow us to consider some of those details by looking directly at the ideas proposed. “Our failing infrastructure” Infrastructure projects have been a favorite of hiring plans since the New Deal (including, to some extent, the current CBPP plan), but the Levy report mostly rejects them out-of-hand: “We would limit the use of PSE [Public Service Employment] workers on infrastructure projects to small-scale projects or for approved apprenticeship or other trainee positions.” There is no evidence that “small-scale” projects would create more than a small number of transitory jobs for the program or provide much value in return. “Our understaffed parks” Online searches do not reveal any discussion of a labor shortage in Hampden County’s parks. The census reports 124 paid employees in Hampden County parks, museums, and historical sites,19 meaning any shortage would be trivial relative to the county’s obligation to staff 17,000 to 28,000 jobs. the program, as localities may be most aware of the skills of their available workers as well projects that will provide the greatest benefit their communities. 5.2 The Local Approach as to The Levy report touts a “highly decentralized” program, federally funded but run almost entirely on the local level. While the authors’ instinct that local governments will have more detailed knowledge about their communities’ needs is correct, they apparently misunderstand the term “decentralized.” In a labor market, employees and employers gather information about each other and each can commence, negotiate, and terminate relationships based on what benefits them most. This decentralized decision-making enables our labor market to process the information necessary to put millions of workers in the right place to create value. The Levy report’s job-guarantee program can better be described as “delegated,” where a decision that has already been made is given to others down the chain of command to execute. This structure may afford some informational advantages in the process of finding and assigning work to program enrollees, 12 The Job Guarantee “The unmet needs of our seniors and our children” Teachers’ aides and elder care are prominent suggestions in both the Levy and CBPP reports. Hampden County public and charter schools employed 4,604 teachers and 2,115 teachers’ aides in the 2017– 18 school year.20 In theory, the county could occupy the time of up to 2,500 job-guarantee enrollees by giving every public school teacher an aide. This is yet another proposal that sounds nice enough until one takes even a cursory look at the details. Does every teacher want an aide? Would the county’s system for handing out work do a good job of finding the best people available for the classroom? And wouldn’t a flood of fully federally subsidized teachers’ aides violate the stated goal of not competing with the current private and public labor markets for paraprofessionals? These details become even more troubling when looking at elder care. Hampden County has more than eleven thousand residents over the age of eighty-five,21 and that number will grow in the coming decade.22 The county currently has just over three thousand home health care workers. Couldn’t they mandate that thousands of job-guarantee enrollees each be assigned as a forty-hour-per-week companion to an elderly person? “Companion” is a more apt term in this instance as current home health aides have essential job-specific skills and are employed by the existing private or public sectors, both violations of the Levy report’s criteria. “Our polluted ponds and streams” According to a 2015 op-ed in the Boston Globe,23 polluted waterways are indeed a problem in Massachusetts. An in-depth analysis of environmental cleanup is beyond the scope of this report, but none of the several fixes proposed in the article appear to benefit from a large number of unskilled laborers. “Low-income housing... repairs and insulation” Hampden County has a sizable amount of low- income housing: 16,670 units deemed “affordable,” including 11,475 that set rent based on one’s income.24 Data on the repair status of these housing units are not readily available, but two points are in order. First, this work, especially insulating, is likely temporary, rather than a source of ongoing labor for enrollees. Second, while low-skill labor may be useful for home repairs, it also likely requires a large presence by managers with construction know-how, again underscoring human capital as a neglected part of both reports’ cost estimates. Adding It Up The sum total of the examples listed in the Levy report’s impassioned plea does not appear to realistically account for more than a few thousand workers, almost certainly less than half of the lower estimate of seventeen thousand workers that Hampden County would be mandated to employ. Finding work for projected job-guarantee programs would be a long and costly process, which cannot be fully replicated in a brief report. The infeasibility of finding work for millions of participants is one of the most frequently levied criticisms against job-guarantee proposals. The fact that proponents have not even attempted to produce a proof-of-concept showing how workers might be deployed is quite telling. There are other ideas such as blight cleanup and community theaters mentioned in the Levy report. We invite the authors to show, in much greater detail, how so many enrollees could be put to work without placing a huge bureaucratic burden on local governments already stretched thin such as those in Hampden County. 5.3 The National Approach The CBPP report also leans heavily on local administration, and therefore must answer the same questions posed above. However, the authors place more emphasis on the federal government to create work and make frequent comparisons to New Deal programs such as the WPA. This approach carries with it an additional set of problems. The invocation of the WPA and New Deal in general is problematic given the vastly different economic circumstances faced by the United States today. The WPA was created in 1935 to provide temporary employment to jobless heads of household, employed a maximum of 3.3 million workers in 1938, and was wound down after the start of the Second World War.25 Public works projects, including road construction, sewers and other utilities, parks, and public buildings, accounted for at least three-quarters of the WPA’s workers. The other quarter or less were in smaller, locally focused projects more like those proposed by the Levy report. The WPA offered temporary relief to those out of work during a national emergency of unprecedented proportions. While debates rage to this day as to the efficacy and impact of New Deal programs, those debates are of limited relevance to our current situation, where unemployment rates are near twenty-five-year lows. The infrastructure-construction projects that dominated WPA employment rolls26 would be more capital intensive than the other ideas put forward in both reports, adding further cost to the program. In addition, the lack of information conveyed by market signals would be compounded by more centralized program management. There is evidence that these issues arose during the years of the WPA itself. That program initially had a tiered wage-and-hours structure like the structure described in the CBPP report, which raised familiar concerns about competition with existing private sector jobs. Officials tried other schemes, including linking wages to those “prevailing” in private sector versions of the same work, and simply fixing hours and wages. These attempted solutions underscore the blunt instruments with which administrators must work when attempting to design a rational system from the top down. Whether nationally administered or delegated locally, it appears that finding and assigning work on the scale both reports propose would quickly turn their vision of a public good into a public burden. But the disruptive effects on the wider economy, to which we now turn, might prove far more burdensome.