Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Evidence

GND---Link---2NC

Green New Deal Legislation risk national security.

Senate RPC 22, The United States Senate Republican Policy Committee, 5/4/2022, “DEMOCRATS' GREEN AGENDA RISKS NATIONAL SECURITY”, , eb

Democrats point to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine as a reason to charge forward with their radical Green New Deal agenda, meaning a massive shift to electric vehicles and renewable energy.

2023 Michigan Evidence

FF Good---Turn---2NC

Fossil Fuels are necessary for Climate Mastery---Only an increase in Fossil Fuel production means that all communities have access to energy.

Alex Epstein 22, Alexander Joseph Epstein is an American author and commentator who advocates for the expansion of fossil fuels, Fall/2022, “Fossil Future: Why Global Human Flourishing Requires More Oil, Coal, and Natural Gas--Not Less.,” The Objective Standard,, 17(3), pp 96+, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A717087152/AONE?u=umuser&sid=bookmark-AONE&xid=c91478ac, eb

Epstein shows how and why many of today's supposed experts get things disastrously wrong. His claim is not that fossil fuels do not emit C02 that contributes to global warming--they do; nor that we should ignore the side effects of energy-we should not. Rather, Epstein argues that when we examine these effects, we need to be honest, objective, and thorough in identifying and evaluating the full context of relevant facts.

2023 Michigan Evidence

AT: Climate---Solvency---2NC

New Renewables do nothing but perpetuate climate change.

Benjamin Zycher 19, Benjamin Zycher is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), where he works on energy and environmental policy, 10/10/2019, “The Trouble with ‘renewable’ Energy,” https://www.aei.org/articles/the-trouble-with-renewable-energy/, eb

Renewable” electricity — predominantly wind and solar power — is all the rage, described by numerous commentators, politicians, pundits, journalists, and other such “experts” as cost-competitive, clean, and a major part of the solution to the “existential crisis” now purportedly looming large as an attendant effect of anthropogenic climate change. A massive expansion of wind and solar power is a central component of the various proposals subsumed under the heading “Green New Deal” (GND), which has faded from the headlines for now, but which is very likely to return to prominence as next year’s presidential race intensifies.

2023 Michigan Evidence

War---Impact---2NC

Renewables drive global conflict.

Ahern 23, MA in Philosophy from Memorial University of Newfoundland and environmental and outreach coordinator for numerous climate justice programs. (Andrew, 2-21-2023, “How Degrowth Can Help Reduce Global Conflict,” Science for the People, https://magazine.scienceforthepeople.org/online/how-degrowth-can-help-reduce-global-conflict/)

Let’s use the example of electric vehicles. The batteries in these vehicles rely on minerals like nickel, cobalt, and lithium, which, according to the World Bank, could drive demand up to 500 percent depending on the mineral, all else being equal. Indonesia, for instance, holds the world’s largest nickel reserves and environmental degradation is already underway in the pursuit of such a mineral. According to the Environmental Justice Atlas, “Fisheries are declining and health is deteriorating in Kawasi since the local nickel mining and smelting project started dumping waste in the sea.” Such local deterioration is explored in visual detail in the Yale Environment 360 film contest winner “From Dreams to Dust,” which shows how the pursuit of materials for green technologies result in polluted drinking water, barren landscapes, and threatened workers and communities. Since 2012, at least fourteen Indonesian environmental defenders have been killed. This extractive logic applies to other green technologies like solar panels and wind turbines as well, since renewables are still materially intensive (although less so than fossil fuels). While it is no doubt true that we need to get off fossil fuels, there are choices to be made about how much energy we use, where it comes from, and who is faced with the risks and benefits.

2023 Michigan Evidence

Inequality---Turns Case---2NC

Renewables perpetuate inequality---forcing them to make the decision between Food and Energy.

PSU 19, Portland State University, 07/12/2019, “ Shifts to renewable energy can drive up energy poverty, study finds”, , eb

Efforts to shift away from fossil fuels and replace oil and coal with renewable energy sources can help reduce carbon emissions but do so at the expense of increased inequality, according to a new Portland State University study.

2023 Michigan Evidence

Turn---1NC

Green Energy innovation cause international conflict---US and Chinese tensions cause World War III.

Hal Brands 22, Writer for Bloomberg, 11/01/2022, “The Green-Energy Revolution Will Make the World More Dangerous,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-green-energy-revolution-will-make-the-world-more-dangerous/, eb

Think a green transition will free America from high-stakes competition over energy supplies? Think again. Since the Industrial Revolution, changing patterns of energy consumption have propelled international conflict. Today, the world is entering a very messy period, in which rivalry over sources of renewable energy will steadily intensify, even as older clashes over oil and other hydrocarbons continue to play out.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 IRA solves

IRA is not enough – Green New Deal is needed to be a true transformation of the system, rather then technocratic fix to climate change.

, and March 1, 2023 A Green New Deal on the Ground https://nonprofitquarterly.org/a-green-new-deal-on-the-ground/

The IRA is insufficient—and it is not a Green New Deal. It is dominated by opaque mechanisms like tax credits and rebate programs, leaving environmental justice communities feeling . Nonetheless, the $369 billion that the bill earmarks for clean power, electric vehicles, home retrofits, and myriad other needs offers an initial investment on the path to just decarbonization. The IRA package shows a shift in US politics away from climate denialism, but now the struggle is to move beyond delaying change and technocratic fixes. Downplaying urgency and condemning mitigation, too many still seek to slow transition timelines by insisting that acting is both expensive and futile. Similarly, dangerous technological distractions like or purport to offer a green future without fundamentally altering the social, political, or economic structures that created our present problems.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Federalism

Treating environmental federalism as a zero-sum game between the federal government and the states trades off with actual action on climate change

Roesler 2019. Shannon Roesler, Professor of Natural Resources and Environmental Law at the Oklahoma City University School of Law “Competitive Federalism: Environmental Governance as a Zero-Sum Game” 49 ELR 10858 ENVIRONMENTAL LAW REPORTER 9-2019 <https://www.eli.org/sites/default/files/docs/49.10858.pdf> Accessed 6/25/20. ARJH

Today, political support for new environmental regulations at the federal level is less uniform, particularly given the resistance to federal regulation by a sizeable number of states during the Barack Obama Administration. Along with industry, states routinely filed lawsuits challenging new environmental regulations as abuses of federal power. Instead of thinking seriously about shared governance, the political default in many red states was to litigate with the hope of invalidating the federal rule. This turns environmental governance into a zero-sum jurisdictional game; if the federal rule is invalidated, the state wins, and if the rule stands, the state loses. Of course, environmental regulation is not a zero-sum game; the optimal combination of local, state, and federal regulation depends on a number of factors, including geographic scale, existing regulatory structures, and various market forces. Unfortunately, when states treat environmental governance as a zero-sum game, they preclude the consideration of win-win shared-governance scenarios. Along the way, time, effort, and money are wasted in protracted legal battles that delay important protections for human health and the environment.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Federalism

Federalism especially fails in environmental contexts – pollution spillover and race to the bottom

Daniel Fiorino and Carley A. Weted Environmental Federalism in a Polarized Era First Published January 8, 2021 journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0160323X20986225

A central justification for a federal role in environmental policy is pollution spillovers (Millimet 2014). Air and water pollution cross state lines, and many common property resources extend beyond political boundaries. In water policy, the Chesapeake Bay, Great Lakes, and Missouri River exemplify such spillovers. An entirely state-centered system would be cumbersome, costly, and ineffective. Take air quality as an example: Much of the ozone and particulate pollution on the East Coast can be traced to origins in Appalachia and the Midwest. This causes issues when states like Maryland and New Jersey cannot meet the National Ambient Air Quality Standards if the federal EPA does not require controls on pollution from other states.

A second argument for a federal role is concern over a “race to the bottom,” where “states compete for economic growth by enticing industry with less stringent—and less costly—regulations” (, 335; ). Research finds evidence of a race-to-the-bottom in federal rules and oversight (Konisky and Woods 2012; Sjoberg and Xu 2018) and in enforcing surface mining regulation (). Still, there is conflicting evidence. States may exceed federal standards if voters and activists prefer it (), and “for some states, regulatory behavior in competitor states pulls their own regulatory efforts up, not down” (Konisky 2007, 868). Studies of state enforcement of federally-delegated programs find limited evidence of a race-to-the-bottom, but this is with federal rules and oversight (Konisky and Woods 2012; Sjoberg and Xu 2018). Research has found evidence of strategic interaction leading to less enforcement effort in surface mining regulation when regional competitor states were less stringent, supporting a race-to-the-bottom thesis (). A study of air, water, and hazardous waste programs (all with a substantial federal presence) found evidence that states reduced enforcement in response to laxity by other states but increased their efforts when competitors were tougher: “for some states, regulatory behavior in competitor states pulls their own regulatory efforts up, not down” (Konisky 2007, 868). Federalism may minimize pressure for laxity while, in some conditions, encouraging a race-to-the top, leading to a “California Effect” that can enhance standards overall ().

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Federalism

Federal action on the environment does not undermine federalism.

Jonathan H. Adler Case Western University School of Law, jonathan.adler@case.edu 2020 Uncooperative Environmental Federalism 2.0 https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3058&context=faculty_publications

It is often remarked that environmental problems do not respect state borders. This is unquestionably true, and the observation provides ample justification for federal measures to address transboundary pollution problems.29 Where pollution or other environmental problems span jurisdictional borders there is less reason to believe state and local jurisdictions will respond adequately.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Federalism

National preemption necessary to solve environmental concerns using a common pool of resources.

Daniel Fiorino and Carley A. Weted Environmental Federalism in a Polarized Era First Published January 8, 2021 journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0160323X20986225

There is yet another justification for national preemption in an era of long-term issues like climate change, ecosystem degradation, and environmental sustainability. The key concept is that of common pool resources, especially those that are seen to be critical or where damages can be irreversible. Do higher levels of government have an obligation to act when lower levels (or the reverse) do not? That logic was applied to wilderness areas and highly valued habitat early in the last century. It was formally extended to endangered species in the 1970s. The environmental laws of the 1970s aimed not only to protect critical ecological resources like wetlands and coastal estuaries but human health, where harm may be irreversible, not only within lifetimes but across generations. Degrading the conditions that allow human populations to flourish leads to critical loss. Discussion of environmental federalism should take these sustainability issues into account.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Inflation DA

Won’t spark inflation – we can counter tendencies to boost income at the top by shifting resources correctly and using taxes to deal with excesses.

Yeva Nersisyan and L. Randall Wray Can we afford the Green New Deal? 2020 JOURNAL OF POST KEYNESIAN ECONOMICS https://doi.org/10.1080/01603477.2020.1835499

While the GND may move the economy to full employment of resources, with well-targeted spending, we can implement it without sparking inflation. Although many sectors of our economy really were at full capacity before the COVID crisis, others lagged far behind with substantial excess capacity.11 The same can be said for parts of our labor force, e.g., labor force participation rates for prime-age males have been on a long downward trajectory (Dantas and Wray 2017). We need to be careful to direct as much GND spending away from the sectors that might be at or beyond full employment—which tend to be the most advanced sectors, with oligopoly or monopoly pricing. Wages and prices in these sectors could rise and boost measured inflation rates, which is precisely what we need to avoid. Where possible, we need to prioritize spending to the underutilized resources, and we need to counter the tendency for growth to disproportionately boost income and spending at the top. In spite of the conventional wisdom, rising tides now raise all yachts—not the little dinghies. As Pavlina Tcherneva has clearly demonstrated, over the entire postwar period the share of income growth grabbed by the richest households during economic expansions has increased. Almost all the gains from growth now go to the top—with roughly 80% of income growth captured by the top 10% of the distribution (Tcherneva 2017). Where we cannot avoid competing for already employed resources, it could become necessary to use wage and price controls along with rationing. Lastly, through the GND, we will shift resources to better uses and (gradually) reduce the need to devote resources to dealing with the problems created by destructive processes (dirty production processes require us to devote resources to cleanup; high inequality forces us to devote resources to dealing with the consequences of poverty, idleness, inadequate access to preventive care and early treatment, social isolation, and crime). Taxing the “rich” If the GND does generate inflationary pressures, we can use the tax system to curb them. To do that, however, we need to approach taxes functionally. Proponents of the GND often propose raising taxes on the rich, imposing taxes on financial turnover or offshore income taxes to pay for it. Similarly, during WWII some had argued that the rich should bear the whole cost of the war, while the working classes should be allowed to increase their consumption. In a chapter titled “Can the Rich Pay for the War?” Keynes (1940) demonstrated that even with very high rates of taxation of the rich, we could not get the necessary decrease in consumption to avoid inflation. He argued we would have to take 75% of the incomes of the “rich” and “middle class” to accomplish this. To reiterate the MMT position, a government with its sovereign currency does not need to rely on the rich, going to them hat in hand asking for money to finance important public priorities (and not being able to do so if it cannot tax them). The government has the financial wherewithal to fulfill the public purpose. Since a nation with its sovereign currency “pays” for things in terms of real resources, the way taxes would help “pay for” the GND would be by lowering aggregate demand and thus releasing real resources. For this, however, we need “targeted” taxes that would be effective for that purpose. To achieve a significant release of resources from the high earners, alone, we would probably require high marginal tax rates—perhaps even higher than a top marginal tax rate of 70% advocated by Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. The political and technical barriers to imposition of sufficiently high tax rates would also be significant: the rich have the means and incentive to fight any move to raise their taxes, as well as to avoid tax payments if rates are raised.12 Thus while the GND should include new taxes on high incomes and high wealth, we do not expect those to have a sufficient effect on freeing resources for the GND. Importantly, these taxes achieve other important objectives, such as lowering income inequality, financial speculation, incentives to move profits offshore and tax avoidance by the rich—benefits we don’t discount. Indeed, we would argue that these are the features of taxes that proponents of the GND should focus on—their functions—and not their ability to raise “revenue.”

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Business Confidence

Green New Deal fosters business confidence – creates job, boosts productivity, reduces inflation

Julian Potter 2019 https://overland.org.au/2019/03/aocs-green-new-deal-is-the-socialist-solution-the-world-needs/

I suggest you research the economics behind the GND. It does not recommend abolishing the market or private enterprise. In fact it does the opposite: by bolstering demand through employment creation, it fosters business confidence, which in turn will help with the lack of capital investment that the monetarist countries currently suffer. It will also lower the welfare bill, as more people will be working productively, so the net cost to the state is lower than the price tag of the program. And on top of that tax receipts will increase, lowering the chances of inflationary episodes.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Business Confidence

Green New Deal boosts small business and supports a sustainable economy

ALYSSA SATARA, 2019 3 Ways the Green New Deal May Impacts Small Businesses and the US Economy https://www.inc.com/alyssa-satara/3-ways-green-new-deal-could-help-small-businesses-us-economy.html

Small businesses are the backbone of the US economy. Still, they depend on a flourishing economy to thrive and prosper. Here are three ways the Green New Deal could affect small business owners, entrepreneurs, and the entire US economy. 1. The right to fair taxation will change the way we do business. The Green New Deal aims to ensure that fair taxation is a right available to every American. One way this will shift the business and entrepreneurial landscape is the way in which it will require that all corporate subsidies become transparent. This means corporations will be required to explain any tax subsidies in their public budgets. In turn, making them available for the public to see so that the subsidies cannot be disguised as tax breaks. Part of its purpose is to even the playing field for all business owners--regardless of the kind of company your manage. Whether you running a startup, small business, or multimillion dollar corporation you will be paying your fair share of taxes. This is intended to even out the burden of paying taxes and ensure that individuals can't use their power or wealth to bypass paying taxes. Making the US economy a safer, and more equal place for small business and startups to compete with major corporations. 2. Green businesses and cooperatives will be incentivized. The Green New Deal aims to transition the US economy to a sustainable and green economy. This goal is to make American businesses ethical, sustainable, and environmentally sound across the board. Which is why this proposed economic program plans to incentivize small businesses who support this mission. If you're an entrepreneur or small business owner and sustainably is one of your main pillars, this is for you. If your startup or small business isn't sustainable or promote clean energy, for example, if it continually produces carbon emissions or fossil fuels, this might be a time to rethink the way you produce your goods. The Green New Deal will support green businesses by supplying them with low-interest loans and grants. With the intention of creating jobs domestically and bolstering communities, this specific goal's objection is to especially nurture small business and locally-based companies. Small business owners, your financial needs and goals will be prioritized through this aspect of the Green new deal. 3. The democratization of the media will be reinforced. The Green New Deal highly prioritizing a fully functioning and reliable democracy. One way that this economic program will do this is by empowering and backing locally-owned media publications and stations. If you're a small business owner or entrepreneur with a broadcast or print media company, this program aims to make your voice louder, and your reach wider. It makes small and local media companies a priority, by ensuring they get support on a federal level. If you aren't in the media industry, this initiative could make it easier for your small business or startup to receive credible PR. By empowering local media companies, this program, indirectly empowers local businesses and business owners to become the news, and have the impact they are making in their community become newsworthy. By creating a system that prioritizes equality, democracy, and our environment, the Green New Deal makes the economy a more stable place to navigate for small business owners, entrepreneurs, and Americans across the country.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC – Answers To: › A2 Politics

Green New Deal is popular

Gustafson, et.al., 2018 By Abel Gustafson, Seth Rosenthal, Anthony Leiserowitz, Edward Maibach, John Kotcher, Matthew Ballew and Matthew Goldberg CLIMATE NOTE · Dec 14, 2018 The Green New Deal has Strong Bipartisan Support https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/publications/the-green-new-deal-has-strong-bipartisan-support/

Some members of Congress are proposing a “Green New Deal” for the U.S. They say that a Green New Deal will produce jobs and strengthen America’s economy by accelerating the transition from fossil fuels to clean, renewable energy. The Deal would generate 100% of the nation’s electricity from clean, renewable sources within the next 10 years; upgrade the nation’s energy grid, buildings, and transportation infrastructure; increase energy efficiency; invest in green technology research and development; and provide training for jobs in the new green economy. While the Green New Deal has been a fixture of the post-election news cycle, and at least 40 members of Congress (to date) have endorsed the idea, little is known about the American public’s support for or opposition to it. To inform this question, we surveyed a nationally-representative sample of registered voters in the United States. In the survey, we showed respondents a brief description of the Green New Deal, which was identical to the first paragraph of this report (above). The description was followed by the question “How much do you support or oppose this idea?” The survey results show overwhelming support for the Green New Deal, with 81% of registered voters saying they either “strongly support” (40%) or “somewhat support” (41%) this plan.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage › A2: No Econ Impact

Economic decline causes nuclear war – loose nukes, counterbalancing, and regional instability

Mann ’14 (Eric Mann is a special agent with a United States federal agency, with significant domestic and international counterintelligence and counter-terrorism experience. Worked as a special assistant for a U.S. Senator and served as a presidential appointee for the U.S. Congress. He is currently responsible for an internal security and vulnerability assessment program. Bachelors @ University of South Carolina, Graduate degree in Homeland Security @ Georgetown. “AUSTERITY, ECONOMIC DECLINE, AND FINANCIAL WEAPONS OF WAR: A NEW PARADIGM FOR GLOBAL SECURITY,” May 2014, )

The conclusions reached in this thesis demonstrate how economic considerations within states can figure prominently into the calculus for future conflicts. The findings also suggest that security issues with economic or financial underpinnings will transcend classical determinants of war and conflict, and change the manner by which rival states engage in hostile acts toward one another. The research shows that security concerns emanating from economic uncertainty and the inherent vulnerabilities within global financial markets will present new challenges for national security, and provide developing states new asymmetric options for balancing against stronger states. The security areas, identified in the proceeding chapters, are likely to mature into global security threats in the immediate future. As the case study on South Korea suggest, the overlapping security issues associated with economic decline and reduced military spending by the United States will affect allied confidence in America’s security guarantees. The study shows that this outcome could cause regional instability or realignments of strategic partnerships in the Asia-pacific region with ramifications for U.S. national security. Rival states and non-state groups may also become emboldened to challenge America’s status in the unipolar international system. The potential risks associated with stolen or loose WMD, resulting from poor security, can also pose a threat to U.S. national security. The case study on Pakistan, Syria and North Korea show how financial constraints affect weapons security making weapons vulnerable to theft, and how financial factors can influence WMD proliferation by contributing to the motivating factors behind a trusted insider’s decision to sell weapons technology. The inherent vulnerabilities within the global financial markets will provide terrorists’ organizations and other non-state groups, who object to the current international system or distribution of power, with opportunities to disrupt global finance and perhaps weaken America’s status. A more ominous threat originates from states intent on increasing diversification of foreign currency holdings, establishing alternatives to the dollar for international trade, or engaging financial warfare against the United States.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage › Extension – GND stimulates sustainable economy

Green New Deal makes economic sense – will revitalize the post-pandemic economy.

A Green New Deal Makes Economic And Environmental Sense April 25, 2021 Updated April 25, 2021 at 6:33 pm https://www.bcheights.com/2021/04/25/a-green-new-deal-makes-economic-and-environmental-sense/

In addition to being a comprehensive and innovative piece of public policy, the Green New Deal makes economic sense. Climate change is both a threat to our existence and a fantastic opportunity to rebuild our economy in an equitable and sustainable manner. It is helpful to view the Green New Deal as more of an investment than anything else—if Congress is bold in its climate action, it could create an estimated , expand job training for skilled laborers, and revitalize the role of unions in protecting American workers. By investing in sustainable infrastructure and labor, sweeping legislation could put millions of people to work with fair wages and jumpstart a post-pandemic economy, functioning to lift people out of poverty and rebuild the middle class. By shrinking income inequality and the influence of environmental racism, we could make our new green economy open to everyone.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage › Extension – GND stimulates sustainable economy

Green New Deal guarantees energy security and on balance reduces full economic costs.

Mark Delucchi and Mark Z. Jacobson 2019 Why The Green New Deal Cuts Consumer Energy Costs & Unemployment https://cleantechnica.com/2019/03/09/why-the-green-new-deal-cuts-consumer-energy-costs-unemployment/

The Green New Deal is a proposal to transition the United States entirely to clean, renewable, zero-emission energy in all energy sectors, to promote removal of carbon from the air through natural reforestation and land preservation, and to create jobs. By focusing on renewable energy that is both clean and zero-emission, the Green New Deal reduces, in one fell swoop, energy insecurity due to the fossil fuel and nuclear industries, 62,000 deaths and millions more illnesses annually from US energy-related air pollution, and the US’ contribution to global warming. Critics claim, though, that the Green New Deal is unaffordable and uneconomical and will sink the US into more debt. Having led the research team that developed science-based plans to transition each of the 50 states to 100% wind, water, and solar (WWS) in all energy sectors (electricity, transportation, heating and cooling, and industry), we conclude the opposite is true: the benefits of clean energy systems greatly exceed the costs. similarly find that 100% renewable energy systems are low cost without fossil fuels with carbon capture or nuclear power. However, a 100% transition of all energy sectors by 2030, while technically and economically possible and desirable, may not occur that fast for social and political reasons. As such, we have consistently proposed a goal of 80% transition by 2030 and 100% no later than 2050 and hopefully earlier. The electricity sector, for example, can transition by 2035. If accomplished worldwide, this goal limits global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius. Converting the US energy infrastructure to 100% WWS will reduce both consumer costs and full economic costs (consumer costs plus air-pollution and global-warming costs) and create many more jobs than lost.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage › Extension – GND stimulates sustainable economy

Instead of the question of can we afford it – the question is can we afford to not act – The Green New Deal is our best hope at creating a future forward sustainable society.

Yeva Nersisyan and L. Randall Wray Can we afford the Green New Deal? 2020 JOURNAL OF POST KEYNESIAN ECONOMICS https://doi.org/10.1080/01603477.2020.1835499

Proposals for a Green New Deal (GND) that tackles climate change have sprung into the debate, both in the US and across the Atlantic. Some of these proposals echo the original New Deal by including comprehensive economic and social reform, in addition to addressing climate change. Advocates of the GND argue that many of problems facing society, such as climate change, rising inequality, and an economy that leaves too many with inadequate access to food, shelter, healthcare, and affordable education are linked. They, therefore, insist on tackling them with an array of programs that have hitherto been seen as disconnected: a carbon-neutral energy policy and reversing climate change; universal single-payer healthcare; student debt relief and free public college; prison reform; ending “forever wars”; increasing care for the young, sick, and old; and the job guarantee.

The cost of the GND is usually estimated in financial terms, adding the projected costs of the various programs which leads to the conclusion that large tax hikes would be needed to pay for it. In this paper, we argue that the cost of the GND must be measured in terms of real resources, not financial costs. Whether or not we can “afford” the GND or any other government program depends not on finance, but on the availability of real resources to implement it. This question cannot be answered by adding up the financial costs of the various components of GND. What is required instead is a careful accounting of the resources the GND will require, weighing those against resources it will release and what is already in excess supply. The difference between resources required and what can be made available is the true cost of the GND. Only once we know this cost can we determine whether a reduction of aggregate demand is needed, and consequently, whether we need counter-inflationary measures, such as tax hikes. We provide a first step toward real resource accounting for the GND estimating resources that can be released from current uses and resources needed for GND projects while acknowledging the major uncertainties involved in such an exercise.1 Our analysis is rooted in Modern Money Theory (MMT) and Keynes’s methodology in How to Pay for the War. Keynes’s approach is simple but also profound: calculating resources available to prosecute the war while sustaining the consumption needs of the population. If the available resources fall short of what is needed, the solution cannot be found in the finances. Government can always spend more to shift resources to the war effort, but without reducing private spending the result is inflation that generates a combination of voluntary saving and excess profits while consumption in real terms falls. To prevent this undesirable outcome, government must relieve pressure on scarce resources by reducing private demand. Keynes’s methodology illustrates what Modern Money Theorists (MMT) have long explained—what constrains government spending is the availability of real resources, not finance. As MMT explains, a government with its sovereign currency, such as the United States federal government, does not face financial constraints. A sovereign government’s finances are not like the budgeting by households and firms; the government uses its monetary system to mobilize the nation’s real resources and to move some of them to pursuit of the public purpose. As long as real resources are for sale in the government’s currency, it can financially afford to buy them. As J. Fagg Foster (1981) said, “what is technically feasible is financially possible.” It is possible that tax hikes and spending cuts elsewhere in the government budget might be necessary to implement the GND. That depends on whether or not we need to constrain aggregate spending in order to release resources for the GND in a noninflationary manner. Even then, the problem is not that we cannot financially afford the GND—government can always bid resources away from private use by paying higher prices—but that spending on the GND will generate private income that can support higher bids in competition with the government for scarce resources. This is the real reason that tax hikes might be desirable: to reduce private income and thereby remove competition for resources. Admittedly, uncertainties remain concerning the technologies, the quantity of resources needed, the suitability of those made available, the political feasibility, and the capacity of our democracy to successfully face the challenges ahead. But we believe our approach provides more guidance about the question of the GND’s “affordability” than does the conventional approach that merely adds up the dollar costs of GND projects. Keynes believed his proposal would “snatch from the exigency of war positive social improvements” (1940, iii). Not only would it move the necessary resources to the war effort with a minimum amount of inflation, it would also make “an advance towards economic equality greater than any which we have made in recent times” (1940, iii–iv). This turned out to be a prescient description of the social and economic conditions of the postwar democracies—the build-up of productive capacity provided the base for the “Golden Era” of capitalism. The GND promises a similar outcome if done correctly. Its benefits would go far beyond the reversal of climate change to include environmental sustainability, greater equality, shared prosperity, jobs for all, healthcare for all, childcare for all, and an end of the forever wars. In order to build the necessary political consensus, whatever sacrifices might be required during the implementation of GND must be more than compensated for by tangible benefits.

2023 SDI Affirmative
2AC › 2AC --- Sustainable Economy Advantage › Extension – GND stimulates sustainable economy

The Green New Deal will also avoid a host of factors that will be a drag on economic growth far into the future – including the economic losses associated with global warming and income inequality.

Noah Diffenbaugh, Marshall Burke on March 14, 2019 https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/the-climate-benefits-of-the-green-new-deal/

The Green New Deal represents one possible approach to addressing the climate challenge. It is an that includes direct climate mitigation and adaptation actions like reaching zero-emissions from the power sector in the next 10 years. And it also sets out a broader set of goals like ensuring high-quality health care, affordable housing and economic security, as well as a series of mechanisms such as ensuring the rights of workers to unionize and of businesses to be free from monopolies and unfair competition. Much of the debate since the unveiling has centered on whether it is politically wise to mix the more narrow climate-focused actions with the broader social and economic goals. However, given the scale of the climate-focused actions, it is critical to carefully and rigorously evaluate whether the costs of those actions—such as decarbonizing the electricity sector, or retrofitting all existing buildings in the country—are worth the benefits that they will generate. Fortunately, scientists have made enormous progress in quantifying the potential impacts of global warming on of the economy and society. That work has produced three findings that can be used to evaluate whether the climate actions in the Green New Deal are likely to be worthwhile investments. First, there is that continuing on the “business as usual” trajectory will create a drag on global economic growth, costing the world trillions of dollars. The United States is not immune to these economic effects. On the contrary, achieving the emissions reductions outlined in the Paris Agreement the United States several trillion dollars (in today’s dollars), relative to continuing on the business as usual trajectory. Second, we can expect continued global warming to exacerbate income inequality in the U.S. This is partly because poor and marginalized communities are more vulnerable to the impacts of extreme events and other climate stresses. In addition, shows that economic impacts will not be uniform, with poor counties in the U.S. experiencing economic losses that are approximately as rich counties. Third, curbing climate change will avoid a host of other damages that are not directly reflected in economic growth. These include the such as heat waves, heavy rainfall and storm surge flooding that . They also include such as ocean acidification, larger and more intense wildfires, interpersonal violence, and . Research over the past decade has also identified a number of additional benefits from climate-related actions. For example, California recently issued a plan that will help the state simultaneously upgrade its infrastructure and reduce damages from climate change. Likewise, meeting the greenhouse gas reductions outlined in the Paris Agreement would also of air-pollution-related deaths worldwide, mostly in the next few decades. And the Clean Power Plan—which the Trump administration has pledged to roll back—would have saved in the United States by 2030. Debating the outcomes and investments envisioned in the Green New Deal is a task for Congress, presidential candidates and the voters. As that debate takes place, it should be grounded in our best knowledge of the costs and benefits of avoiding further climate change. While the climate-related actions envisioned by the Green New Deal will require investment, our best evidence suggests that the benefits are likely to .