Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Internal Link – AT Fed Independence

Congress would simply alter the Fed’s mandate

Sarah Binder and Mark Spindel, 2017, The Myth of Independence: How Congress Governs the Federal Reserve, Princeton University Press, p. 14, mm

The distributional consequences of monetary policy play a central role in generating Congress’s disproportionate attention to the Fed. As we show in chapter 2, legislators’ focus on the Fed is typically reactive, rising and falling with the state of the economy. Congressional attention is thus countercyclical because the Fed is especially salient to “single- minded seekers of re- election” Mayhew (1974) when they seek to avoid blame for a bad economy. When monetary policy stokes inflation or contributes to job losses, lawmakers respond in two ways. First, they blame the Fed for the state of the economy and its impact on their constituents. Second, in particularly poor economic times, politicians are likely to prevent the Fed from making the same mistakes again, proposing and sometimes securing changes to the powers, mandate, or organization of the Fed.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Internal Link – AT Fed Independence

Congress would reshape the Fed to support the broader economic goal of the plan

Sarah Binder and Mark Spindel, 2017, The Myth of Independence: How Congress Governs the Federal Reserve, Princeton University Press, p. 5-6, mm

The image of the Federal Reserve as a body of technocratic experts belies the political nature of the institution. By defining the Fed as political, we do not mean that the Fed’s policy choices are politicized. To be sure, policy making within the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) is rarely a matter of applying partisan prescriptions to generate appropriate monetary policy, although accusations as such are common. Given internal frictions, especially during times of economic stress, the Fed chair faces the challenge of building a coalition within (and beyond) the FOMC to support a preferred policy outcome, akin to committee or party leaders in Congress, or Supreme Court justices working to secure majorities for proposals or opinions. Former Fed chair Ben S. Bernanke once described a central challenge of leading the Fed in precisely this way: “In Washington or any other political context you have to think about: how can you sell what you want to do to others who are involved in the process” (Dubner 2015). That said, the Fed is not just another partisan body reflecting the views of the presidents who appoint the Board of Governors in Washington or boards of directors who select the Fed’s reserve bank presidents who then vote on monetary policy. Decision making inside the Fed surely involves technocratic, macroeconomic policy expertise, even within a political institution. We deem the Fed “political” because successive generations of legislators have made and later remade the Federal Reserve System to reflect temporal, political, and economic priorities. Most important, because the Fed is a product of and operates within the political system, its power derives from and depends on the support of elected officials. Institutions are political not because they are permeated by partisan decision making but rather because political forces endow them with the power to exercise public authority on behalf of a diverse and at times polarized nation.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Internal Link – AT Fed Independence

Political pressure thumps – the Fed will bend to Congressional demands

Sarah Binder and Mark Spindel, 2017, The Myth of Independence: How Congress Governs the Federal Reserve, Princeton University Press, p. 2 - 3, mm

By concentrating on Congress’s relationship with the Fed, we challenge the most widely held tenet about the modern Fed: central bankers independently craft monetary policy, free from short- term political interference. Instead, we suggest that Congress and the Fed are interdependent. From atop Capitol Hill, Congress depends on the Fed to both steer the economy and absorb public blame when the economy falters. Indeed, over the Fed’s first century, Congress has delegated increasing degrees of responsibility to the Fed for managing the nation’s economy. But by centralizing power in the hands of the Fed, lawmakers can more credibly blame the Fed for poor economic outcomes, insulating themselves electorally and potentially diluting public anger at Congress. In turn, the Fed remains dependent on legislative support. Because lawmakers frequently have revised the Federal Reserve Act over its first century, central bankers (despite claims of independence) recognize that Congress circumscribes the Fed’s alleged policy autonomy. Fed power— and its capacity and credibility to take unpopular but necessary policy steps— is contingent on securing as well as maintaining broad political and public support. Throughout the book, we highlight the interdependence of these two institutions, exploring the political- economic logic that shapes lawmakers’ periodic efforts to revamp the Fed’s governing law.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Internal Link – AT Fed Independence

The Fed isn’t independent – Congress will use appointments and revisions to the Federal Reserve Act to lock-in the plan

Alexander Salter, 7/28/20, Foundation for Economic Education, “The Federal Reserve is Both Too Politicized and Too Powerful,” https://fee.org/articles/the-federal-reserve-is-both-too-politicized-and-too-powerful/, mm

As the COVID-19 catastrophe unfolded, the Federal Reserve intervened swiftly in financial markets. Many praise the Fed’s response, including its new role as the “market maker of last resort.” Others are impressed the Fed steered clear of politics during the crisis. The Fed demonstrates what an effective and independent central bank can accomplish, its defenders proclaim. There’s just one problem: Federal Reserve independence is a myth. The vagaries of day-to-day politics very much affect what goes on at the Fed. This inescapable truth casts the Fed’s emergency policies in a very different light. Politicians with interest groups to placate are already taking advantage of the new Fed regime. Given the extraordinary expansion in the Fed’s mandate since COVID-19, we must rein in political pressure on the Fed while we still can. Many believe the Fed has been politically independent since the 1951 Treasury-Fed Accord. But in reality, political influence has simply become less overt. Scholars of the political economy of central banking concur that the Fed is not independent. Jerry Jordan, former president and CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, and William Luther, a professor at Florida Atlantic University, analyze Fed independence in a recent study. They survey several metrics of central bank independence, including the comprehensive dataset compiled by Ana Garriga, Lecturer in International Relations at the University of Essex. According to Jordan and Luther, compared to other countries, US central bank independence ranks near the bottom. Their conclusion: “The Fed is not independent—and it is not even close.” There are several ways elected officials can pressure central bankers. First, there’s the appointment process. Members of the Fed’s Board of Governors, including the Chair and Vice-Chair, are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Politicians can pick monetary policymakers whose pre-existing views are more favorable to politicians’ goals. Second, there’s Congressional oversight. Congress has modified the Federal Reserve Act several times to suit its goals, and can credibly threaten to do so again. In addition, members of the House Committee on Financial Services or the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs can give Fed officials a dressing-down while offering testimony.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Internal Link – AT Fed Independence

The Fed is politicized now – that independently drives inflation

Millsap ’22 [Adam; April 8; Senior Fellow for Economic Opportunity Issues at Stand Together and Stand Together Trust, Master’s and PhD in Economics from Clemson University, BS in Economics from Miami University in Ohio; Forbes, “We Are Seeing Why A Politicized Federal Reserve Is Bad For The Economy,” ], wm

The U.S. labor market is doing fairly well despite the war in Ukraine and the lingering presence of Covid-19. The recent jobs report showed payrolls grew by 431,000 while the unemployment rate fell to 3.6%, only slightly above the pre-pandemic 3.5% rate. But there’s a looming problem, too—inflation. The Fed has been acting more political lately, and if it fails to get inflation under control it will undermine its credibility, foster animosity among the states, and make stagflation more likely. The inflation tax is wreaking havoc on American consumers. The average U.S. household will spend $5,200 more in 2022 compared to last year for the same stuff as they face higher prices on everything from copper to chicken. The annual cost of gas is up by as much as $1,000 depending on the vehicle and driving habits. Meanwhile, the Biden administration is distracted by counterproductive policies like suspending student loan payments. Stagflation—low economic growth and high inflation—is not here yet, but the federal government is doing everything it can to create it. Inflation has been above the Fed’s 2% target for almost a year. Over the same period, the Biden administration has burdened the economy with more regulation and threats of higher taxes. So far, the final cost of Biden’s regulatory agenda is $197 billion and he has created 134 million hours of new paperwork. This is more than double President Obama’s final rule cost at the same point in his presidency and more than 50 times larger than President Trump’s. There are dozens of things President Biden could do to boost economic growth. He could suspend the Jones Act to unleash U.S. shipping or deregulate geothermal and nuclear energy to promote energy abundance. Instead, he is opting for more obstruction rather than more production. Too much money due to easy monetary policy and careless government spending is juicing the demand side of the economy while the pandemic and Biden’s policies continue to restrict the supply side. Combined, these create an environment ripe for inflation that the Biden administration initially overlooked, despite warnings from economists such as Larry Summers and John Cochrane. Throughout 2021, Fed Chairman Jerome Powell argued inflation was transitory and would subside on its own. That is not happening, so now Powell and other Fed officials need to figure out how to get inflation under control while not causing a recession—the so-called ‘soft landing’. It is not clear why Fed officials did not see higher inflation coming. One possible reason is that they, in cooperation with the Biden administration, were too busy contemplating how they could use their power to manipulate the economy to achieve political goals. Throughout the first half of 2021, Powell argued for “patiently accommodative monetary policy” for the explicit purpose of creating a hot labor market, something many progressives wanted as well. Powell subsequently downplayed inflation, and his reluctance to tap the brakes by increasing interest rates and winding down quantitative easing has given us the highest inflation rate in 40 years. Monetary policy is not the only way the Fed can impact the economy. It also has broad regulatory powers, which was highlighted in the nomination of Sarah Bloom Raskin as vice chair of supervision. Raskin recently withdrew her nomination, but before that she consistently argued that the Fed should play an active role in climate policy, primarily by incorporating climate risks into the Fed’s oversight activities. As she wrote “financial regulators must reimagine their own role so that they can play their part in the broader reimagining of the economy.” The Fed is supposed to be non-partisan and focused on its dual mandate of full employment and stable prices. Unfortunately, many folks currently at the Fed and recent nominees to key positions, such as Raskin, seem increasingly interested in politics. Several Democrats, including Maxine Waters (CA) and Elizabeth Warren (MA), appear to support this shift and want to use the Fed’s regulatory and oversight powers to promote racial equality in employment, access to credit, and small business lending. The American Banker noted that doing so would add a third leg to the Fed’s dual mandate. More economic opportunity for minority groups and lower-income people is a noble goal, but the Fed is not the appropriate means for achieving this goal. A significant degree of central bank independence is widely recognized as crucial to stable, pro-growth monetary policy. Overt politicization, on the other hand, carries short- and long-term risks. In the short-term, greater politicization of the Fed creates uncertainty in financial markets as banks and other firms find it harder to predict the Fed’s regulatory actions and its monetary policies. Uncertainty harms investment and is thus bad for economic growth. Greater politicization can also cause the Fed to lose track of inflation as political goals supersede its dual mandate or cause it to prioritize maximum employment at the expense of stable prices, as we are experiencing now. In the longer run, greater politicization will undermine trust in the Federal Reserve. Democrats and Republicans alike will accuse the Fed of furthering political goals whenever their side is not in power. The public will lose faith in the Fed’s ability to maintain stable prices. Already, Americans are expecting inflation to be 6% a year from now and 3.8% three years from now. This is evidence that the Fed is failing to anchor expectations regarding its ability and resolve to return inflation back to 2%. Losing control of expectations makes periods of hyperinflation more likely. Such events cause severe economic damage and disproportionately hurt people with lower incomes. More politicization also means Fed oversight policies will swing back and forth with elections. This will make it difficult for banks to execute long-term lending strategies and businesses to execute long-term investment strategies. Capital markets will be less efficient, the cost of capital will increase, and political connections will be more likely to impact lending decisions, thus amplifying cronyism. Industries disfavored by the Fed, which will often depend on the party in power, will find it hard to access capital to expand or hire new employees. To the extent such industries are clustered—like tech in California or oil in Texas—specific local economies will bear the brunt of the economic pain. This is likely to cause more resentment between those in middle America and the coasts as each side portrays the other as waging economic war on them. With Biden and the Democrats in power, the current disfavored industry is energy, particularly fossil fuels. However, if Republicans gain control, the disfavored industry could easily become “Big Tech”, “Big Pharma”, or “Big Finance”. This would disproportionately harm the economies of California, Massachusetts, or New York where many of the firms in these industries are located. Animosity between Democrats and Republicans is already high, so the last thing we need is a politicized Fed picking winners and losers via industry-specific regulations. The Fed’s primary purpose is to maintain stable prices, but Chairman Powell and others seem to have let themselves get distracted by politics. Now inflation is getting away from them. It is time for elected officials to quit politicizing the Fed and for Fed officials to ignore politics. Otherwise, we may enter a new normal of higher inflation, more regulatory uncertainty, and, as a result, slower economic growth. If that happens, stagflation will be just around the corner.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Link/Internal Link – Fed Won’t Spike Rates

No risk of interest rate overshoot – the Fed would tolerate higher levels of inflation instead of tanking the economy

Ernesto Talvi, 9/17/22, Merco Press, “Will the Federal Reserve strangle Latin America again?” https://en.mercopress.com/2022/09/17/will-the-federal-reserve-strangle-latin-america-again, mm

Despite Powell’s tough rhetoric, the Fed will not engineer the aggressive interest-rate hikes that many experts think are needed. Faced with a choice between allowing inflation to overshoot its target and increasing interest rates substantially above current inflation levels, the Fed will choose the former. The reason is straightforward: Choosing the latter might trigger a domestic financial and economic crisis. In 1980, highly indebted Latin American countries paid a high price for the Fed’s anti-inflationary measures. But while Latin America’s external debt burden is the same today, the US is highly indebted, too. Given the Fed’s concern for the health of the US financial system, there is a limit to how fast and how high it can jack up interest rates. A steep rise in interest rates in today’s highly leveraged US economy would put household, corporate, and possibly government balance sheets under tremendous stress, generating a wave of bankruptcy and insolvency that would compromise the stability of the entire financial system. This implies that inflation will most likely overshoot the Fed’s target of 2% for the foreseeable future. As a bonus, above-target inflation will help dilute high levels of indebtedness.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Link – AT UBI

UBI experiments prove that at worst, UBIs don’t cause inflation and at best, they decrease inflation

Miller 21 (Joshua Z. Miller; June 2021; “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME AND INFLATION: REVIEWING THEORY AND EVIDENCE,” UBI Center, URL: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3920748)//NTG

The most important studies done in the realm of measuring the price effects of universal basic income have been two general equilibrium studies, one looking at transfers from the NGO GiveDirectly in Kenya25 and the other studying the Mexican food assistance program “Programa de Apoyo Alimentario”.26 Both studies evaluated transfer programs to very impoverished places and the latter to a relatively closed economy, so obviously we can expect discrepancies between the evidence and what would happen in reality given a universal basic income in North America.

Egger et al. find that there was less than 1% price inflation on average as a result of the transfers. The greatest price effect is to housing, which the authors do not find statistically significant. There is a strong increase in consumption and firm profits, akin to an aggregate demand increase, with spillover effects, and little-to-positive labour hours change. The authors believe they found a transfer multiplier effect of over 2. Additionally, there was a formation of a strong potential growth effect in terms of permanent consumption and income as estimated by the authors. This overall aligns with my model; that is that is, cash transfers caused growth in both permanent output and output level and almost-nonexistent price change. This checks out intuitively: an increase in income resulted in more consumption and more output in an economy that has room to grow, so there will not be additional money-per-unit-of-output that ultimately underlies the Quantity Theory of Money.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Link – Medicare for All

Medicare for All is key to reduce long-run inflation – monetary policy alone fails

James Galbraith, 2/18/22, The Nation, “How the Left Should Think About Inflation,” https://www.thenation.com/article/economy/inflation-federal-reserve/, mm

Why can’t the Federal Reserve hold the line without hurting workers? Because to keep to any given inflation target—2 percent per year, say, as the Fed would prefer—when some prices are rising by much more than that, means that some other prices must rise much less, or even fall. What other prices are there? In a service economy, it’s mainly wages. But to cut back wages, you need recession and mass unemployment. Want to know how that works politically? Ask Jimmy Carter. The idea that the Federal Reserve can (somehow) bring down inflation without cost is backed by nonsense and non-thought. Milton Friedman’s old slogan “Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon” demonstrates how far economic thought can depart from reality. There is a notion that “labor markets” somehow adjust on their own to preserve full employment. There is a claim that the Covid stimulus programs were too big and that the economy is running “too hot.” All of it is false, which becomes obvious once you realize there are 2 million fewer jobs in America now than there were in 2019, when there was no inflation to speak of. Obviously we’re running into structural changes induced by the pandemic, some of which cannot be reversed and some of which should not be reversed, but none of which the Fed can just wave away by pushing up interest rates. And more and bigger structural changes are coming, whether we like them or not. Most important, the United States no longer runs the world. We must move away—quickly, before any new disasters occur—from failed efforts to preserve a military and financial domination that we cannot maintain. Second, we must move away from fossil fuels. Third, the pandemic showed that we must move away from the global supply chain—not everywhere, but in some critical areas, restoring domestic manufacturing capacity to meet emergencies. Each of these coming transitions will generate pressures on the price level. And the argument just made will again apply: Some price increases should be accepted, and some should be managed, as best we can, with policies that keep things under control and share the burdens. What are those policies? They include large investments in infrastructure, mass transit, housing, and rebuilding cities; action on climate change; and legislation for higher minimum wages and guaranteed jobs. Once again, all of these efforts will tend to push up prices, at first. That’s because they generate incomes that cannot be spent immediately on more consumer goods, barring what economists call “a perfectly elastic supply”—meaning more goods from China at no extra cost, flowing in smoothly over the supply chain. Forget about that. Instead, we can assume that consumers will buy houses, used cars, and other fixed assets, driving those prices up—and those purchases will register, directly or indirectly, in the price index. How should we handle those pressures? First, by making resources available that we’re now wasting. Above all, we should demilitarize and redirect those valuable materials, skills, and personnel to tackle the big investments we need here at home. Reckless war policies, pursued for 20 years, have already ended the global dominance we once enjoyed—Iraq, Afghanistan, and now the situation in Ukraine are proof. The only way out of this decline is to get busy and rebuild on the home front. That, by the way, is what Germany, Japan, Korea, and China have all done—and exactly why they are the top or rising economic powers while we are the declining one. Second, the US should definancialize. Since the time of Reagan, the American economy has ridden waves of speculation—in real estate, in information technology, in mortgages, and now in real estate once again—each leading to a bust. Here the way out is twofold. First, break up or take over the large banks, restore effective regulation, and create a public banking system that serves a public purpose—as France did following the Second World War. Second, heavily tax speculative assets, including land, mineral rights, and so-called intellectual property, bringing our oligarchs back to earth and lowering taxes on working people, consumers, and ordinary business profits. This will deflate the plutonomy—that part of the consumer economy driven by the excesses of the very rich. Want to call this “socialism?” Go ahead. Third, control health care costs. How? By enacting Medicare for All, including the power of a government purchaser to negotiate drug prices. Medicare for All is a system of strategic price control aimed at a critical sector; it is potentially the most powerful anti-inflationary tool the government has.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Link – Carbon Tax

Turn - A carbon tax would decrease long-run inflation

Richhild Moessner, 2022, Center for Economic Studies and ifo Institute, “Effects of Carbon Pricing on Inflation,” Working Paper No. 9563, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/252080/1/cesifo1_wp9563.pdf, mm

We study how carbon pricing has affected consumer price inflation ex-post, using dynamic panel estimation of New-Keynesian Phillips curves across countries for 35 OECD economies from 1995 to 2020. As carbon pricing we consider carbon taxes and prices of emissions trading systems (ETS). Carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions are a key driver of global warming and climate change, and have continued to increase globally in recent years. With current climate policies, standard climate change models predict an increase of 3°C in global temperatures compared with preindustrial levels by the end of the century (IPCC, 2014). Climate policies therefore need to be enhanced in order to reduce CO2 emissions (Stern, 2008). To limit an overshoot of the goal of the Paris agreement of 1.5°C global warming above pre-industrial levels, global net anthropogenic CO2 emissions need to decline by about 45% from their 2010 level by 2030, reaching net zero around 2050; however, total global greenhouse gas emission in 2030 are expected to be 16% above their 2010 level (United Nations, 2021). Carbon pricing can be an effective policy to reduce carbon dioxide emissions (Kohlscheen et al., 2021). Higher carbon prices make low-carbon energy more competitive, provide incentives to reduce emissions, and reduce demand for carbonintensive fuels (OECD, 2021; Martin et al., 2016). Climate change and climate policy are likely to affect inflation and the monetary policy transmission mechanism, and are therefore relevant for monetary policy (Smets, 2020; NGFS, 2020). Carbon pricing could lead to higher inflation via market-based emissions trading or new taxes on high carbon emissions, in particular from fossil fuels (Andersson et al., 2020; Batten et al., 2020). But such higher inflationary pressure could be more than offset by further innovation in renewable energy in response to carbon pricing, leading to lower electricity prices and increased energy efficiency, which could also reduce the weight of energy in the CPI consumption basket (Andersson et al., 2020). A shift in consumer preferences in response to carbon pricing towards climate-friendly products and services, which enter the CPI consumption basket when the consumer basket weights are updated, can also contribute to lower inflation (NGFS, 2020). The overall effect of carbon pricing on inflation is therefore unclear, and is an empirical question, on which there have been surprisingly few studies. Most of the research on the effects of climate change and climate policy on macroeconomic variables so far has focussed on the effects on growth.1 Monetary policy makers have discussed possible effects of climate policies on inflation. For example, ECB Governing Council member Schnabel (2021) mentioned that the direction of the effect of climate change on inflation was unclear; carbon prices could increase prices, but prices for sustainable energy sources could decline if more efficient technologies were developed, so that it could become cheaper to generate electricity from renewable energy sources. Climate change has been considered within the ECB’s monetary policy strategy review (Eurosystem work stream on climate change, 2021; Smets, 2020; ECB, 2021). Following the conclusion of this monetary policy strategy review, the ECB Governing Council stated its strong commitment to further incorporating climate change considerations into its monetary policy framework (ECB, 2021). The ECB Governing Council also decided to conduct theoretical and empirical analyses on the implications of climate change and related policies for the economy and the transmission of monetary policy (ECB, 2021). Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) find for Europe and Canada that higher carbon taxes do not have to be inflationary and may even be deflationary, with an increase in energy prices having been more than offset by a fall in the prices of services and other non-tradables.2 They mention that their study is the first to emphasize the impact of carbon taxes on inflation, so that more research on this topic is needed. Similarly, McKibbin et al. (2021) find for the euro area that the inflationary effects of carbon taxes on headline inflation have been contained, and that the impact on core inflation tended to be negative. They conclude that carbon taxes mainly affected relative prices rather than the overall price level. Kaenzig (2021) finds that surprises in carbon prices in the European ETS had a positive effect on energy and consumer prices. Using model simulations, McKibbin et al. (2021) find that carbon taxes only have a transitory effect on inflation.3 Our paper contributes to this literature by providing ex-post empirical analysis of the effects of both carbon taxes and prices of ETS on consumer price inflation and its food, energy and core subcomponents, for a broad sample of countries. In contrast to Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) and McKibbin et al. (2021), who only study carbon taxes, we also consider carbon ETS prices. In contrast to Kaenzig (2021), who only considers surprises in ETS prices, we also consider carbon taxes. Moreover, in contrast to Konradt and Weder di Mauro (2021) and McKibbin et al. (2021), whose empirical specification for inflation includes only carbon taxes, lagged inflation and fixed effects, we estimate New-Keynesian Phillips curves, which are commonly used for modelling inflation dynamics in monetary policy analysis, and which also control for output gaps, inflation expectations and exchange rate changes. Furthermore, we consider a wider range of countries globally (35 OECD economies), instead of just European countries and Canada. New-Keynesian Phillips curves are the standard way to model inflation dynamics in modern monetary policy analysis (Clarida et al., 1999; Smets, 2003; Woodford, 2003; Levin and Moessner, 2005). We choose cross-country panel estimation of New-Keynesian Phillips curves based on Jasova et al. (2019, 2020), in order to capture inflation dynamics well by including the effects of output gaps, exchange rate changes and inflation expectations. This approach allows to exploit cross-country variation to mitigate the difficulties of identification present for country-specific estimates, as discussed by Reichlin (2018) and Forbes (2019) in the case of the output gap. We find that an increase in prices of ETS by $10 per ton of CO2 equivalents increases energy CPI inflation by 0.8pp at the 1% significance level after one year, and headline inflation by 0.08pp at the 10% significance level, but has no significant effects on food and core CPI inflation. We also find that an increase in carbon taxes by $10 per ton of CO2 equivalents increases food CPI inflation by 0.1pp at the 5% significance level after one year, but has no significant effects on energy CPI inflation, headline and core inflation. Our findings are relevant for future climate policies. They suggest that higher carbon taxes and prices of permits in ETS have not led to large increases in headline inflation. Consequently, based on this evidence the use of carbon pricing to speed up the necessary transition to net zero carbon emissions need not be held back by concerns about large overall inflationary effects. This is relevant since these carbon pricing policies have been shown to be effective in reducing carbon emissions (Kohlscheen et al., 2021).4

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT Link – Carbon Tax

A carbon tax won’t increase core inflation – 25 years of empirical evidence proves

Richhild Moessner, 2022, Center for Economic Studies and ifo Institute, “Effects of Carbon Pricing on Inflation,” Working Paper No. 9563, https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/252080/1/cesifo1_wp9563.pdf, mm

We studied how carbon taxes and prices of ETS have affected inflation ex-post for 35 OECD economies from 1995 to 2020, using dynamic panel estimation of New-Keynesian Phillips curves across countries in order to capture inflation dynamics well. We find that an increase in prices of ETS by $10/t CO2 equivalents increased energy CPI inflation by 0.8pp at the 1% significance level after one year, and headline inflation by 0.08pp at the 10% significance level, but had no significant effects on food CPI and core CPI inflation. We also find that an increase in carbon taxes by $10/tCO2 equivalents increased food CPI inflation by 0.1pp at the 5% significance level after one year, but had no significant effects on energy CPI inflation, headline and core CPI inflation. Our findings are relevant for future climate policies. They suggest that higher carbon taxes and prices of permits in ETS have not led to large increases in headline CPI inflation. Consequently, based on this evidence the use of carbon pricing to speed up the necessary transition to net zero carbon emissions need not be held back by concerns about large overall inflationary effects. This is relevant since these carbon pricing policies have been shown to be effective in reducing carbon emissions (Kohlscheen et al., 2021).

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT UQ – Inflation

Inflation is staying high now – Fed chair testifies.

Smialek 6/21 [Jeanna; The New York Times, “Fed Chair Sees ‘Long Way to Go’ on Inflation Fight,” ] VY

Jerome H. Powell, the chair of the Federal Reserve, told House lawmakers that the United States remains a “long way” away from low and stable inflation even 15 months into the central bank’s campaign to cool the economy and wrestle down rapid price increases. Mr. Powell testified before the House Financial Services Committee on Wednesday. He told lawmakers that the labor market remained very tight and that inflation — while it has come down notably from its peak last summer — was still too fast. In light of that, the Fed could raise interest rates even higher than their current level of just above 5 percent. “Inflation has moderated somewhat since the middle of last year,” Mr. Powell said. “Nonetheless, inflation pressures continue to run high, and the process of getting inflation back down to 2 percent has a long way to go.” Fed officials left interest rates unchanged last week following 10 straight increases. But central bankers have been adamant that the decision to hit pause did not amount to a declaration of victory over inflation. Instead, moving more gradually will give policymakers time to assess how well higher rates are working to slow the economy as they try to strike a delicate balance of doing enough to cool growth without doing too much. “Given how far we’ve come, it may make sense to move rates higher, but to do so at a more moderate pace,” Mr. Powell said in response to a lawmaker’s question, explaining that it was like moving from a highway to more local roads. “As you get closer to your destination, as you try to find that destination, you slow down even further.” Central bankers forecast in their fresh economic projections last week that they will probably raise interest rates to around 5.6 percent this year, which would amount to two more quarter-point rate increases. Mr. Powell said during his news conference following the decision last week that the Fed’s July 25-26 meeting will be “live,” meaning that a rate increase is possible at that gathering. “I think that’s a pretty good guess of what will happen if the economy performs as about as expected,” Mr. Powell said Wednesday, referring to Fed officials’ forecast for two more rate moves this year. Mr. Powell’s comments prompted a slight pullback in stock prices, though they ultimately did little to shift market expectations of future rate increases. Investors expect the Fed to raise rates once more this year, less than what most Fed policymakers anticipate. The Fed will need to assess how much the economy is slowing, and whether that is likely to be enough to return inflation to their 2 percent goal over time, as officials decide what to do with rates. Overall growth and the housing market have cooled since 2021, but consumption and even home prices have shown recent signs of renewed strength and hiring has remained rapid. And inflation itself has been sticky. “Inflation has consistently surprised us, and essentially all other forecasters, by being more persistent than expected,” Mr. Powell said. “And I think we’ve come to expect that — expect it to be more persistent.” Mr. Powell was asked about price increases globally. Many economists pointed to the United States’ large pandemic spending packages as a driver of the initial jump in inflation, but now inflation is beginning to fade in America even as it remains stubbornly very high in Europe and the United Kingdom. “Our recovery is by far the strongest,” he said. “Everybody has very high inflation.” He added that there’s a “common factor” that has driven price increases higher. “It’s the pandemic, and it’s everything about the pandemic: the closing of the economy, the reopening of the economy, the fiscal support, the monetary support. All the things that happened went into high inflation.”

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT UQ – Interest Rates

Fed says rates still hiking to fight inflation

Rugaber 6/21/23, [Christopher, June 21, Associative Press. Aiken Standard, “Fed’s Powell: More Rate Hikes Are Likely This Year to Fight Still-High Inflation.” ], ms

With inflation in the United States still excessive, most Federal Reserve officials this year, Chair Jerome Powell said in prepared testimony to be delivered to a House committee Wednesday. “Inflation pressures continue to run high, and the process of getting inflation back down to 2% has a long way to go,” Powell said on the first of two days of semi-annual testimony on Capitol Hill. Even so, the Fed last week after 10 straight hikes so it could take time to gauge how higher borrowing rates have affected the economy, Powell said. The contrast between the Fed’s stated concern over still-high inflation and its decision to skip a rate hike has heightened uncertainty about its next moves. The hazier messaging suggests that Powell is seeking to balance competing demands from those Fed officials who want to keep raising rates and others who feel the central bank has done enough. In his remarks Wednesday, Powell also indicated that the Fed chose to keep its key interest rate steady last week so it could assess the impact of this spring on the banking sector and whether the failures would reduce credit to consumers and businesses and slow the economy. Most economists have said they believe that a rate hike at the Fed’s next meeting in late July is all but assured. What actions the central bank might take after that remains much less clear. The policymakers indicated last week that they expect to raise rates twice more this year. Yet they might not follow through if economic data suggests that inflation is falling quickly back to their 2% target. Speaking at a news conference last week, Powell said there were no plans to raise rates at every other meeting or to follow any other particular time frame. Instead, as he reiterated Wednesday, Fed officials will monitor economic data and make their rate decisions “meeting by meeting.” The central bank’s streak of rate increases have made and businesses more expensive across a range of loans, including home and auto loans, credit cards and business borrowing. The goal has been to cool inflation by slowing spending and hiring. Last year, the Fed jacked up its benchmark rate at a breakneck pace, including by three-quarters of a point on four occasions. Now, with year-over-year inflation having eased from , Powell has indicated that the Fed wants to move much more slowly. A slower pace of rate increases, Powell has said, could help the Fed achieve a tricky feat: Weaken the economy enough to tame inflation, without undermining it so much as to cause a deep recession. Yet on Wednesday, Powell repeated a warning he has often made: Defeating inflation won’t be painless. “Reducing inflation is likely to require a period of below-trend growth and some softening of labor market conditions,” he said. “Softer labor market conditions” would include rising layoffs and a higher unemployment rate. Fed officials, though, have said they hope to curb inflation mainly by reducing the number of open jobs rather than through mass layoffs. Cutting demand for workers would allow employers to slow their wage increases, thereby helping keep a lid on inflation. Last week, 12 of the 18 Fed’s policymakers indicated that they envision at least two more rate hikes this year, and four predicted one additional increase. Only two officials forecast that the central bank will keep its key rate at its current level of 5.1% through year’s end.

2023 MNDI Disadvantage
Aff › AT UQ – Interest Rates

Federal Reserve says more inflation hikes soon

Cox 6/21/23, [Jeff, June 24, financial journalist. CNBC, “Powell Expects More Fed Rate Hikes as Inflation Fight has a ‘Long Way to Go’.” ], ms

Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell on Wednesday affirmed that more interest rate increases are likely ahead until additional progress is made on bringing down inflation. Speaking a week after Federal Open Market Committee officials decided for the first time in more than a year not to push rates higher, the central bank leader indicated that the move likely was just a brief respite rather than an indication that the Fed is done hiking. “Nearly all FOMC participants expect that it will be appropriate to raise interest rates somewhat further by the end of the year,” Powell said in prepared remarks for testimony he will deliver to the House Financial Services Committee. The speech is part of his semiannual appearance on Capitol Hill to update lawmakers on monetary policy. Following last week’s two-day FOMC meeting, officials indicated they see through the end of 2023. That would indicate two additional hikes, assuming quarter-point moves. The Fed’s benchmark borrowing rate is currently pegged in a range between 5%-5.25%. Noting that inflation has cooled but “remains well above” the Fed’s 2% target, Powell said the central bank still has more work to do. “Inflation has moderated somewhat since the middle of last year,” he said. “Nonetheless, inflation pressures continue to run high, and the process of getting inflation back down to 2% has a long way to go.” Fed officials generally prefer to look at “core” inflation, which excludes food and energy prices. That is showing inflation running at a 4.7% year-over-year rate through April, according to the central bank’s preferred measure of personal consumption expenditures prices. The was at 5.3%. Monetary policy moves, such as rate hikes and the Fed’s efforts to shed bond holdings on its balance sheet, tend to work with lags. As such, officials decided to skip hiking at this month’s meeting as they observed the impact that policy tightening has had on the economy. Powell said the labor market is still tight though there are signs that conditions are loosening, such as an increase in labor force participation in the prime 25-to-54 age group and some moderating in wages. However, he noted that the number of open jobs still far exceeds the available labor pool. “We have been seeing the effects of our policy tightening on demand in the most interest rate-sensitive sectors of the economy,” he said. “It will take time, however, for the full effects of monetary restraint to be realized, especially on inflation.” Powell later said that the Fed has adjusted its approach to policy after implementing rate hikes at the most aggressive pace since the early 1980s. Included in that run was a streak of four consecutive 0.75 percentage point increases, a pace that Powell said doesn’t seem appropriate now. “Given how far we’ve come, it may make sense to move rates higher but to do so at a more moderate pace,” he said during the question-and-answer session with committee members. Inflation expectations, considered a key variable for where prices are heading over time, are “well-anchored,” Powell said. The closely watched , for instance, showed that the inflation outlook for a year from now dipped to 3.3%, the lowest since March 2021. However, Powell also noted that getting inflation lower will require slowing down the economy to below-trend growth. He also emphasized that rate decisions will be made based on incoming data and meeting by meeting, rather than on a preset course. The remarks also briefly touched on the . Powell said the episode served as a reminder that the Fed needs to make sure its supervisory and regulatory practices are appropriate.

2023 MNDI Negative
Link – Race K

Colour Blindness turns the case - The racial blindness in the discourse of a UBI will be reflected in the political implementation of the policy.

Nwogbo, 2021 – PhD Candidate in Philosophy at University of Sussex [Johnbosco, Dec 20, Doctoral Thesis “Racial Injustice And Philippe Van Parijs’ Distributive Justice Basis For The Universal Basic Income: Introducing The Filtered Leximinning Of Modified Real Freedom Theory Of Distributive Justice” TA]

In chapter two, I argued that Van Parijs's theory of distributive justice is blind to institutional racism, which is a form of racial injustice. I demonstrated this by showing that given the choice between two societies that are similar in every respect except in terms of the distribution of people of different races across opportunity strata, i.e. sections of the population defined by having the same amount of opportunities, a person choosing between them using Van Parijs's leximin principle would not prefer a non-institutionally racist society to an institutionally racist one. This, I suggest, is a serious charge to be brought against a theory of justice. And insofar as Van Parijs's theory of distributive justice is the basis of his universal basic income offer, this blindness to racial injustice also implicates the basic income offer. If the theory of distributive justice that grounds the basic income offer is blind to institutional racism, it can be argued that it follows that the basic income offer itself that results is similarly problematic vis a vis institutional racism.

2023 MNDI Negative
Link – Race K

A UBI focused on justice and poverty cannot address racial inequality

Nwogbo, 2021 – PhD Candidate in Philosophy at University of Sussex [Johnbosco, Dec 20, Doctoral Thesis “Racial Injustice And Philippe Van Parijs’ Distributive Justice Basis For The Universal Basic Income: Introducing The Filtered Leximinning Of Modified Real Freedom Theory Of Distributive Justice” TA]

To conclude, in this thesis, I have argued that Van Parijs’ theory of distributive justice, which grounds his basic income offer, is blind to racial inequality, and therefore to racial injustice. I revised his theory to make it insusceptible to charges of blindness to racial injustice as well as suitable for grounding a basic income that can help reduce or eliminate racial inequality. According to Van Parijs’ theory, people’s freedom should not only incorporate the absence of hindrance in doing what they might want to do. It should also include their real access to the opportunities to do what people might want to do, hence he defines freedom as critically including a principle of the leximinning of real freedom, or more precisely, of opportunities. I have argued that on this account, a leximin chooser would be unable to consider a racially equal society as more just than a racially unequal society. That is, Van Parijs’ theory is blind to racial injustice. To deal with this, I argued for racially-sensitive versions of leximin and real freedom. I proposed a filtered leximinning of modified real freedom theory of distributive justice. And as I have suggested earlier in this conclusion, this theory will ground a basic income offer, albeit with close resemblances with Van Parijs’s, that can help eliminate or at least reduce racial inequality.

2023 MNDI Negative
Link – Race K

A UBI based on race blind justifications will reproduce racial inequality – distributive justice arguments only use income to determine those least well off in society, ignoring racist obstacles to opportunity

Nwogbo, 2021 – PhD Candidate in Philosophy at University of Sussex [Johnbosco, Dec 20, Doctoral Thesis “Racial Injustice And Philippe Van Parijs’ Distributive Justice Basis For The Universal Basic Income: Introducing The Filtered Leximinning Of Modified Real Freedom Theory Of Distributive Justice” TA]

This thesis is written by a supporter of a universal basic income. What I argue, in essence, is that the blindness to racial injustice present in the theory of justice Van Parijs uses to ground it leads to a basic income proposal that is likely to perpetuate racial injustice. And over and above demonstrating how Van Parijs's theory is susceptible to the charge that it is blind to racial injustice, I propose revisions to his theory aimed at proofing it against that charge. In the conclusion, I suggest ways that the changes I make to the theory could be said to affect what a basic income offer that ameliorates racial injustice should look like but systematic research in this last area will have to take place outside this thesis. This thesis is laid out in the following way: in chapter one, I discuss Van Parijs's theory of distributive justice. I describe the components of Van Parijs's conception of real freedom, namely, security, self-ownership and leximin opportunity. Security is the idea that a free society incorporates a well-enforced regime of property rights. Self-ownership is the idea that each person owns themselves and cannot be forced to perform actions they do not want to. Combined these two components make up formal freedom on which freedom is merely the absence of hindrance from exercising your property or selfownership rights. But for Van Parijs, real freedom must also offer an answer to our intuition that if I do not have the money to get on a cruise, I am not really free to get on that cruise. The last component of real freedom is opportunity, which is the absence of being hindered from what you might want to do by any other circumstance, and which is especially given effect by providing people with the means and resources to do the things they might want to do or live as they might want to. With the addition of the opportunity component, Van Parijs argues that to achieve distributive justice opportunity should be leximinned, subject to formal freedom being respected. Leximinning opportunity means that a society should be considered more just than another society if those with the least opportunities in that society have more opportunities than those with the least opportunities in the other society. Van Parijs justifies the introduction of the basic income as the result of taking the leximinning of people’s opportunities seriously. For him, monetary incomes serve as a measure of people’s opportunities in market societies. In chapter two, I offer one criticism of this theory of justice outlined in chapter one. I argue that this theory of justice is blind to institutional racism.4 I demonstrate this using a thought experiment involving two societies that are identical in every way (they have the exact same number of income strata and the occupants of each stratum have the exact same amount of opportunities in both societies) except that race is a determining factor in membership in the lowest stratum of one of the societies, whereas it is not the case for the other. I argue that the society in which race is a determining factor in people ending up in the lowest stratum is an institutionally racist society, but also that a Van Parijsian leximin chooser (that is, someone choosing between both societies solely based on the leximin principle) would be unable to prefer the non-institutionally-racist society to the institutionally racist society. In essence, the leximin principle would judge both societies as equally just.

2023 MNDI Negative
Link – Race K

The affirmative discusses poverty and inequality in a race neutral way – they fail to look at racist root causes of inequality, which makes their solutions fail. Only centering race in the discussion can provide solutions that work.

Kraus et al, 2019 - Sustainability Research Institute at the University of Leeds [Michael, with Ivuoma N. Onyeador, Natalie M. Daumeyer, Julian M. Rucker, Jennifer A. Richeson September 10 Perspectives on Psychological Science, “The Misperception of Racial Economic Inequality” https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1745691619863049#tab-contributors KB]

Toward a science of inequality that centers race Just as we believe that policymakers should engage with race in their messaging about economic inequality, so, too, must social scientists in our research. Racial domination and colonialism have been the primary engines by which much of the wealth has accumulated in the Western postindustrial world (Fanon, 1963; Foucault, 1977/1979). Yet, despite these trends, researchers in the social sciences are largely guilty of analyzing the impacts of inequality in ways that do not also consider its racial patterning. A study of economic inequality that ignores racial patterning misses a central causal pathway in our understanding of inequality, a pathway supported by a historical and contemporary analysis of economic inequality in individual cities (Shedd, 2015) and in America writ large (Alexander, 2012). A consideration of inequality without attention to race is likely to perpetuate some of the mistaken ideas about racial progress that we have discussed in this review. Failing to center or even acknowledge the racial patterns of economic inequality perpetuates a dangerous myth about American contemporary political life: that economic politics and policy can be divorced from the racial identities of the people these policies disproportionately affect. It is particularly important that the social sciences make direct connections between race and economic inequality, because much of political discourse on the topic takes cues from our analyses (or lack thereof; e.g., Chetty, Hendren, Jones, & Porter, 2018; Darity et al., 2015; Laurin, Engstrom, & Alic, 2018; Piff, Kraus, & Keltner, 2018; Piketty, 2015). To treat economic inequality as a color-blind issue oversimplifies the political landscape surrounding economic policies and how they are typically racialized (Brown-Iannuzzi et al., 2017) and obscures the reality that social safety-net policies are often opposed because they are perceived to threaten the group status of White Americans (Lowery et al., 2007; Wetts & Willer, 2018). Though we have focused this analysis on the U.S. context, much can be gained from a global study of inequality that also centers race. Such an analysis is necessary to understand past and contemporary patterns of globalization on the economy: How wealthier countries such as the United States define their borders and divide their global labor continues to perpetuate global economic inequality (Fanon, 1963; Massey, 2008). An understanding of the racial patterns of economic inequality will also situate the psychological understanding of race and racism in the context of the societal structures that maintain racial advantage and disadvantage in society. Far too many psychological studies of racial bias concern themselves solely with the intentions of individual actors, examining the extent to which bias is implicit versus explicit (Greenwald, Nosek, & Banaji, 2003) and whether people are or are not motivated to control or express prejudice (Devine, 1989; Plant & Devine, 1998). As social psychologists, we advocate for an understanding of race and racism in the context of the large and systemic structural and cultural forces that create and maintain racial patterns of inequality in economic, social, and health domains (Daumeyer, Rucker, & Richeson, 2017; Payne, Vuletich, & Lundberg, 2017; Richeson & Sommers, 2016; Salter, Adams, & Perez, 2018). Centering race in scholarship on economic inequality has the added benefit of focusing attention on the structural components of the psychology of racism, which will help scholars better articulate the ways in which the psychology of racial prejudice extends from individuals to institutions and back again. A psychological science that considers economic inequality in its full context, including its racial patterning, is poised to provide insights about economic inequality that will intersect with the fields of history, economics, sociology, and political science. Only such a multidisciplinary approach to this pressing societal problem is likely to identify and promote evidence-based policies that have the potential to combat it.

2023 MNDI Negative
Politics Links

A basic income is the Least acceptable form of reparation – polls prove that they have the least support.

Blazina and Cox ‘22 – Formal digital producer and research associate at Pew Research Center [Carrie and Kiana, November 28, Pew Research Center, “Black and White Americans are far apart in their views of reparations for slavery, , June 21, 2023 LN]

Reparations supporters were also asked how helpful the following forms of repayment would be: educational scholarships, financial assistance for starting or improving a business, financial assistance for buying or remodeling a home, and cash payments. These adults are most likely to say educational scholarships would be very or extremely helpful (82%), followed by financial assistance with businesses (75%), financial assistance with home buying or remodeling (73%) and cash payments (57%). There are some racial, ethnic and partisan differences in Americans’ views of both the institutions that would be responsible for reparations, as well as the specific forms that reparations might take. For example, more than six-in-ten Black and Hispanic reparations supporters (63% and 69%, respectively) say colleges and universities that benefited from slavery bear all or most of the responsibility for repaying descendants of enslaved people. By comparison, White and Asian American supporters of reparations are notably less likely to hold this view (41% and 44%, respectively). Among those who support reparations, Democrats are 20 points more likely than Republicans to say the federal government bears all or most of the responsibility for repayment (77% vs. 57%). When it comes to various forms of repayment, majorities of Black American reparations supporters say all four forms of assistance would be extremely or very helpful, and those in other racial and ethnic groups largely agree. Americans in each racial and ethnic group are least likely to say cash payments would be helpful.

2023 MNDI Negative
Politics Links

Race reparations would ignite controversy – polls show low and divided support for them

Blazina and Cox ‘22 – Formal digital producer and research associate at Pew Research Center [Carrie and Kiana, November 28, Pew Research Center, “Black and White Americans are far apart in their views of reparations for slavery, , June 21, 2023 LN]

Americans view the prospect of reparations mostly negatively, a 2021 Pew Research Center survey found. Three-in-ten U.S. adults say descendants of people enslaved in the U.S. should be repaid in some way, such as given land or money. About seven-in-ten (68%) say these descendants should not be repaid. Views of reparations for slavery vary widely by race and ethnicity, especially between Black and White Americans. Around three-quarters of Black adults (77%) say the descendants of people enslaved in the U.S. should be repaid in some way, while 18% of White Americans say the same. There are also notable differences by partisan affiliation. Among Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, views are split: 48% say descendants of enslaved people should be repaid in some way, while 49% say they shouldn’t be repaid. By comparison, only 8% of Republicans and GOP leaners say these descendants should be repaid in some way, and 91% say they should not. When it comes to age, younger adults are more likely than older ones to say the descendants of enslaved people should be repaid: 45% of adults under 30 take this view, compared with 18% of adults 65 and older. When Americans are asked about the legacy of slavery’s effect on Black people today, 58% of the overall public says this affects the position of Black people in American society at least a fair amount, with 28% saying it affects them a great deal. Four-in-ten U.S. adults say the legacy of slavery has not much or not at all affected the position of Black Americans in the country today. As with views of reparations, racial and ethnic differences on this question are notable. Black Americans (85%) are more likely than Hispanic (64%) and White (50%) Americans to say the legacy of slavery affects the position of Black people in the U.S. a fair amount or a great deal.

2023 MNDI Negative
Alternative Reparations CP

Educational assistance, housing and business grants are the best reparations for African Americans.

Ray and Perry 2020 – Senior Fellows at the Brookings Institution [Rashawn Ray and Andre M. Perry, April 15, 2020, Brookings Institution, “Why we need reparations for Black Americans” , June 22, 2023, LN]

People should be able to use the tuition remission to obtain a bachelor’s degree or an associate’s/vocational or technical degree. Tuition should be available for public or private universities. Considering the racial gap in the ability to obtain degrees at private schools, this part of the package will further help to reduce racial disparities by affording more social network access and opportunity structures. Student loan forgiveness for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Student loan debt continues to be a significant barrier to wealth creation for Black college graduates. Among 25-55 year olds, about 40 percent of Blacks compared to 30 percent of whites have student loan debt. Blacks also have nearly $45,000 of student loan debt compared to about $30,000 for whites. Recent research finds that Blacks are more likely to be allocated unsubsidized loans. Furthermore, graduates of Historically Black Colleges and Universities, compared to Predominately White Institutions, are more likely to receive subprime loans with higher interest rates. Universities including Georgetown and Princeton Theological Seminary, which is the second-oldest seminary in the country, are aiming to atone for the fact that the sale of slaves helped to fortify their university endowments and establish them as elite institutions of higher education on a global scale. Descendants of the slaves sold by Georgetown and Princeton Theological Seminary are now entitled to full rights and benefits bestowed by those universities to obtain degrees across the higher education pipeline. The Virginia state legislature voted for some of its state universities to atone for slavery with reparations. Other universities, along with state legislatures and the federal government, should follow suit. Down payment grants and housing revitalization grants for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Down payment grants will provide Black Americans with some initial equity in their homes relative to mortgage insurance loans. Housing revitalization grants will help Black Americans to refurbish existing homes in neighborhoods that have been neglected due to a lack of government and corporate investments in predominately Black communities. Given recent settlements for predatory lending, low and fixed interest rates as well as property tax caps in areas in which housing prices are significantly devalued should be part of the package. After accounting for factors such as housing quality, neighborhood quality, education, and crime, owner-occupied homes in Black neighborhoods are undervalued by $48,000 per home on average, amounting to a whopping $156 billion that homeowners would have received if their homes were priced at market rates, according to Brookings research. As gentrification occurs, Blacks are typically priced out of neighborhoods they helped to maintain, while the historical and current remnants of redlining and restrictive covenants inhibited investments. Some Black Americans are being forced from their family home of decades because of tax increases as neighborhoods are gentrified. This is an important point because some 2020 Democratic presidential candidates aimed to redress the racial wealth gap by focusing on historically redlined districts. Perry’s research shows that these policies fall short of capturing a large segment of Black Americans. Business grants for business starting up, business expansion to hire more employees, or purchasing property for descendants of enslaved Black Americans Black-owned businesses are more likely to be located in predominately Black neighborhoods that need the infrastructure and businesses. However, Black business owners are still less likely to obtain capital from banks to make their businesses successful.