2023
CNDI
Counterplan
AFF › AT: FIIB › No Solvency- General
Charles Marohn June 14, 2021
A National Infrastructure Bank is a Stupid Idea; Strong Towns; https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2021/6/14/a-national-infrastructure-bank-is-a-stupid-idea
I suspect that this shell game is the kind of thing that a national infrastructure bank would do as well, which is why politicians wanting to spend trillions of dollars on infrastructure without having to go through that pesky process of raising taxes or borrowing money are lining up to support it. We should never do this. It’s a stupid idea pretending to address a problem that doesn’t exist, and that’s the best-case scenario. Worse case: It’s a Wall Street tool for pushing more debt on insolvent states and localities, certificates they can securitize and gamble with. No thank you. For cities and states struggling to fix infrastructure, the problem has never been a lack of money to be borrowed. The problem is decades of unproductive infrastructure investments: public expenditures that didn’t have a positive financial return the first time around, that now must be maintained without any plan or even vision for how to squeeze a greater return out of that expenditure.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
AFF › AT: FIIB › No Solvency- General
Charles Marohn June 14, 2021
A National Infrastructure Bank is a Stupid Idea; Strong Towns; https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2021/6/14/a-national-infrastructure-bank-is-a-stupid-idea
The other part of the fairy tale is the notion that there are worthy projects out there, investments that pay an actual financial return. There just isn’t, at least not at the scale that a national infrastructure bank would look to fund. Let me make sure we are all on the same page with what an “actual financial return” is. Say your city borrows $1 million to install a new sewer pipe in the ground. A real financial return would mean that the city, once they deducted their expenses, had new revenue from the installation of that pipe sufficient to retire that $1 million debt, plus interest. If those projects existed (and they really don’t anymore), they are easily funded. What cities are actually struggling with isn’t money for expansion but money for maintaining what they already have. It’s the backlog of past promises that is financially strangling them, and borrowing money from an infrastructure bank is not going to fix that insolvency problem. For example, Flint, Michigan, can borrow all the money it wants right now and use that money to fix their lead pipes. They can borrow the money, they just have no means to pay it back. And since replacing lead pipes with non-lead pipes is not exactly expected to supercharge growth in Flint, it’s not like there is an expectation of additional tax revenue that can be dedicated to loan repayment. Local government debt is not a federal revenue stream. An infrastructure bank would try to make it one, but it doesn’t work that way, at least not if the bank wants to remain solvent.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
AFF › AT: Unemployment Benefits › 2AC – Extended Benefits = More Unemployment
Hagedorn et al. 13 [Marcus Hagedorn, Department of Economics at the University of Oslo. Faith Karahan, Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Iourii Manovskii, Department of Economics at the University of Pennsylvania. Kurt Mitman, Institute for International Economic Studies at Stockholm University. “UNEMPLOYMENT BENEFITS AND UNEMPLOYMENT IN THE GREAT RECESSION: THE ROLE OF MACRO EFFECTS,” NBER Working Paper Series, [Working Paper 19499]. National Bureau of Economic Research [October 2013]. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w19499/w19499.pdf]
Column (1) of Table 1 contains the results of the estimation of the effect of unemployment benefit duration on unemployment using the baseline specification in Equation (14). We find that changes in unemployment benefits have large and statistically significant short-run effect on unemployment: a 1% rise in benefit duration for only one quarter increases unemployment rate by 0.049 log points. Equation (12) helps us extrapolate these effects and estimate the effect of a permanent unanticipated increase in benefit durations. Using the average quarterly separation rate of 10% in JOLTS data, we find that the effect of permanently (n = ∞) increasing benefits from ω1 = 26 to ω2 = 99 weeks is quite sizable: The effect on unemployment is 80%, meaning that such a permanent increase would increase the long-run average unemployment rate from 5% to 9.13%.As we have stresses several times by now, the strength of the effect of unemployment benefit extensions on labor demand depends on the full expected sequence of future benefit durations (see the direct evidence in Section 4.2 below). In particular, a permanent increase in benefit durations has the strongest negative impact on labor demand as firms expect to bargain with workers entitled to high benefits at all future dates. The benefit extensions enacted following the onset of the Great Recession, however, were not designed to be permanent and benefit durations varied over time. Assuming perfect foresight of future benefits, our estimate of 0.049 implies that if standard durations of unemployment benefits (26 weeks) had prevailed following the Great Recession, the unemployment rate in 2010 and 2011 would have been 2.7 and 2 percentage points lower, respectively. Although the duration of benefits was fairly similar in 2010 and 2011, the implied effect on unemployment was substantially larger in 2010. This is because firms creating jobs in 2011 expected benefit duration to decline in the following year (lowering the expected wage bill and making it easier to cover the costs of vacancy creation). In contrast, firms considering creating jobs in 2010 were confronted with an additional year, 2011, of high benefit durations, which discouraged vacancy creation. This example illustrates an important general property of the effects of unemployment benefits on unemployment. To the extent that employers anticipate future changes in benefits, unemployment evolves smoothly over time and fully responds to future changes in benefits before those changes actually occur. Thus, unless expectations are known or controlled for, the relationship between contemporaneous changes in benefits and unemployment is uninformative of the true labor market impact of unemployment benefit policies. When comparing the magnitude of the effect we find to the experience in the data, it is also important to keep in mind that it is based on the difference across pairs of border counties. Thus, the effects of various other shocks or policies that affect these counties symmetrically are differenced out. For example, the 2% reduction to an employee’s share of Social Security payroll taxes implemented in all states in 2011 and 2012 might have had a substantial negative impact on unemployment, counteracting some of the effects of unemployment benefit extensions.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › A2: › AT: Increased Benefits = Increased Unemployment
Moffitt 14 [Robert Moffitt, Professor of Economics at John Hopkins University. “Unemployment Benefits and Unemployment,” IZA World of Labor (2014). https://wol.iza.org/articles/unemployment-benefits-and-unemployment/long#:~:text=By%20replacing%20some%20lost%20income,their%20assets%20to%20maintain%20consumption.]
In Germany the negative effects of unemployment benefit payments are much smaller during economic downturns than during normal economic times and are statistically insignificant in many cases [9]. Extensions of unemployment benefit payments in the US during the recent recession had very small effects on job-finding [10]. These effects were concentrated among the long-term unemployed and often took the form of reduced rates of leaving the labor force rather than reduced rates of entering employment. The extensions had only a small effect on increasing the unemployment rate. In addition, because the extensions most often simply delayed the exit from the labor force, the consequent increases in unemployment did not lower employment to any major extent.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › A2: › AT: Increased Benefits = Increased Unemployment
Economic Policy Institute 10 [Economic Policy Institute is an independent, nonprofit think tank that researches the impact of economic trends and policies on working people in the United States. EPI’s research helps policymakers, opinion leaders, advocates, journalists, and the public understand the bread-and-butter issues affecting ordinary Americans. “Extending unemployment insurance is the fiscally responsible thing to do,” May 28, 2010. https://www.epi.org/publication/extending_unemployment_insurance_is_the_fiscally_responsible_thing_to_/]
The Labor Department’s Rothstein argued that the current size of the jobs shortage made a much stronger case for extended unemployment insurance, to support both the jobless and the overall economy. “I don’t think there’s anybody advocating allowing the unemployed to receive 99 weeks of benefits in normal times,” he said. “But if there really are no jobs, that cost (of providing unemployment insurance) goes away.”
The so-called cost Rothstein referred to was not the actual cost of unemployment benefits but what critics have often argued is a disincentive cost, which effectively discourages unemployed workers from looking for jobs. Contrary to that argument, he stressed that even in more normal economic times, research has found only a slim disincentive effect. In times of severe jobs crisis, there is good reason to think that extending unemployment insurance actually increases job search efforts, since in order to qualify for benefits, a person must be actively looking for a job. “The shortage of job searching is not the problem,” he said. “The problem is a shortage of jobs.”
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › A2: › AT: Unemployment = Recession
Moffitt 14 [Robert Moffitt, Professor of Economics at John Hopkins University. “Unemployment Benefits and Unemployment,” IZA World of Labor (2014). https://wol.iza.org/articles/unemployment-benefits-and-unemployment/long#:~:text=By%20replacing%20some%20lost%20income,their%20assets%20to%20maintain%20consumption.]
The aim of all unemployment benefit schemes is to make up some fraction of the lost income for unemployed workers and thereby allow them to maintain their consumption at a reasonable level despite the loss of wages.
Although it might seem obvious that unemployment benefits would raise consumption, the amount by which it does so depends on several factors. One is the amount of savings a person has accumulated before becoming unemployed. Most households in developed economies have at least some savings and have built up assets for a “rainy day.” However, the amount of savings is typically small, and very low-income families often have no savings at all. But for people who have accumulated savings, consumption levels may remain fairly high even in the absence of unemployment benefits.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › UI Solvency Evidence › Economy/Countercyclical
Gabriel Chodorow-Reich and John Coglianese in 2019
Associate Professor of Economics - Harvard University AND Economist - Labor Markets Section, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System; Unemployment insurance and macroeconomic stabilization; https://www.brookings.edu/research/unemployment-insurance-and-macroeconomic-stabilization/
One factor limiting the scope UI plays in countercyclical stimulus is the limited receipt of benefits shown in figure 1. The hurdles to successful completion of an application have received notice in both the popular press (Robles 2014) and the academic literature (Chodorow-Reich and Karabarbounis 2016). Regarding limited eligibility, two factors stand out: (1) harmonizing monetary eligibility across states, including adoption of alternative base periods for calculating earnings; and (2) extending eligibility to part-time workers and individuals seeking part-time employment. Both these reforms would better align the eligibility criteria to a modern labor market in which many individuals have short spells out of the labor force or prefer part-time employment due to family obligations or other considerations.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › UI Solvency Evidence › Economy/Countercyclical
Gabriel Chodorow-Reich and John Coglianese in 2019
Associate Professor of Economics - Harvard University AND Economist - Labor Markets Section, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System; Unemployment insurance and macroeconomic stabilization; https://www.brookings.edu/research/unemployment-insurance-and-macroeconomic-stabilization/
A proposal by Gabriel Chodorow-Reich of Harvard University and John Coglianese of the Federal Reserve Board aims to strengthen the automatic stabilization functions of the unemployment insurance system. Specifically, the authors offer policy reforms that would make UI a better automatic stabilizer while preserving and improving its social insurance role, including increasing UI participation and payments during downturns, as well as strengthening extended benefits. Expand eligibility for unemployment insurance and encourage take-up of its regular benefits. Make extended benefits fully federally financed. Remove the “look-back provisions” from state eligibility in the Extended Benefits program. Create two new permanent triggers for the Extended Benefits program, extending eligibility for unemployment insurance to 60 weeks when a state’s unemployment rate crosses 9 percent and to 73 weeks when a state’s unemployment rate crosses 10 percent. When the Extended Benefits program is activated in a state, all UI recipients should receive an additional $50 in the weekly benefit amount.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › UI Solvency Evidence › Economy/Countercyclical
Gould-Werth 20 (Alix Gould-Werth - Ph.D. from the University of Michigan and a B.A. from Swarthmore College.Director of Family Economic Security Policy. “The long-run implications of extending unemployment benefits in the United States for workers, firms, and the economy.” Washington Center for Equitable Growth. 12/3/20. https://equitablegrowth.org/the-long-run-implications-of-extending-unemployment-benefits-in-the-united-states-for-workers-firms-and-the-economy/)
At the outset of the coronavirus pandemic earlier this year, millions of U.S. workers lost their jobs. In March, the U.S. Congress took notice and decided that the 26 weeks of Unemployment Insurance typically provided by states were not enough for an employment crisis that would likely extend beyond 6 months. Through the new Pandemic Emergency Unemployment Compensation program, it provided people who lost jobs through no fault of their own with an additional 13 weeks of benefits. Today, coronavirus cases counts are skyrocketing, hospitals are filling, businesses are closing, and long-term unemployment is surging. But some workers have already run out of benefits, and the PEUC program is set to expire on December 26, leaving 8.1 million workers without any income support through this emergency 13-week benefit extension. The expiration of the Pandemic Emergency Unemployment Compensation program means devastation for workers and their families this December. But research released earlier this year by Adriana Kugler and Umberto Muratori at Georgetown University and Ammar Farooq at Uber Technologies Inc. shows that the effects of the PEUC expiration are likely to persist far into the future for workers whose benefits expire, and ripple through the U.S. economy to affect firms and workers searching for well-matched employment relationships. The basic idea behind this research is intuitive. When people have resources to meet their basic needs while out of work, they can take the time they need to find the right job for them, rather than taking the first work opportunity that comes along. Workers benefit because they find jobs that pay more and meet their needs more broadly, and firms benefit because they recruit workers with the right skills for the job. While the idea makes sense, it hasn’t been backed by much evidence in the U.S. context, in part because of data limitations. This makes it particularly exciting that this research team was able to access data from the Longitudinal Employer Household Dynamics database, which matches administrative information about workers and their earnings with administrative information about their employers. Using these data, as well as information from the Current Population Survey and the natural experiment that occurred when different states offered different durations of unemployment benefits during the Great Recession of 2007–2009 and its aftermath, Farooq, Kugler, and Muratori take a close look at how job seekers and firms fare when the duration of unemployment benefits is extended. (See Figure 1.) Farooq, Kugler, and Muratori find that the longer you have access to unemployment benefits, the higher paying the job that you eventually find is and the more your skills and training get put to use. (See Figures 2 and 3.) Access to the full extended emergency benefits during 2009, which increased benefits from 26 weeks to 79 weeks, increases re-employment wages by 2.6 percent and also increases the probability that a worker will be re-employed in a job that requires more education than their previous job by 11.7 percentage points. The idea that workers match their talents with job openings that put their skills to use is not just good news for those workers. It matters for firms and the broader economy as well. Farooq, Kugler, and Muratori take advantage of their dataset, which allows them to follow individual workers over time and also to see the full workforce of the firms with which they eventually find re-employment. Using these features of the data, they find that higher-quality firms are better able to recruit workers that have the abilities they need. This creates a chain reaction that spreads through the U.S. economy. The authors describe it eloquently: These results suggest that if a worker can receive UI benefits for a longer period, she will be able to find a job with an employer that is closer to her in terms of quality. This worker then is likely to leave another job open for someone else who is also likely to be better matched, and in turn that other worker can also leave vacant another job and relieve it to someone else, generating a chain reaction that makes many other workers, beyond the one receiving the UI extension, match better in the labor market. In this manner, the benefits of extended unemployment benefits ripple past a worker’s current situation to affect their future job prospects, the productivity of firms, and the experiences of workers across the economy. Particularly striking is the fact that the positive effects of extended unemployment benefits are larger for workers who are members of groups that lack funds for a rainy day. Because of labor market discrimination, unequal access to education and training, caregiving obligations, and stagnating wage levels, members of demographic groups, including women, people of color, and less-educated workers, typically lack the private savings held by their counterparts who are members of more advantaged groups. Indeed, this research finds that during the Great Recession and its aftermath, women, people of color, and low-educated workers improve their job matches when they have access to unemployment benefits even more than their counterparts who are members of wealthier demographic groups. The research team finds that a 53-week increase in UI benefits improves the job-match quality by 0.9 percent for White workers, but improved match quality even more for workers of color: The effect size for workers of color is 1.2 percent. Similarly, Farooq, Kugler, and Muratori find that workers of color (along with women, less-educated workers, and young workers) see larger returns to increased weeks of benefits when it comes to wage levels. This supports the idea that the improved fit between workers and the jobs they find stems from workers’ ability to spend more time searching for a job that is a good match, without sacrificing their basic needs in the short term. Their findings also suggest that insufficient durations of unemployment benefits during moments of macroeconomic contraction exacerbate inequality in the U.S. labor market. This concern is magnified during today’s coronavirus recession because the sectors of the U.S. economy that have been hardest hit are the same ones where women, people of color, and low-educated workers are overrepresented.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › UI Solvency Evidence › Pandemic Expansions
Gwyn 22 [Nick Gwyn, “Historic Unemployment Programs Provided Vital Support to Workers and the Economy During Pandemic, Offer Roadmap for Future Reform,” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 3/24/2022, cbpp.org/research/economy/historic-unemployment-programs-provided-vital-support-to-workers-and-the-economy]
In March and April of 2020, the economy contracted sharply with the spread of COVID-19, costing the nation 22 million jobs. Many forecasters projected a difficult recovery, including the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), which estimated in May 2020 that unemployment would remain a stubbornly high 8.6 percent through the fourth quarter of 2021.[1]
Responding to this rapid job loss, Congress passed the most expansive set of temporary unemployment benefits in our nation’s history. These steps were necessary largely because the permanent unemployment insurance (UI) system does not cover many unemployed workers and often provides inadequate benefits.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › FIIB Solvency Evidence › NB = Inflation DA
David Dreier August 17, 2020
Dreier served 22 years in the U.S. House of Representatives, including 10 years as chairman of the Rules Committee. He chairs the Annenberg-Dreier Commission, which seeks to strengthen the free flow of goods, services, capital, ideas, information and people throughout the greater Pacific region; How to Rebuild America at No Cost to Taxpayers; Real Clear Policy;
Meanwhile, we desperately need to restart an economy ravaged by COVID. This is the time. Interest rates are at rock-bottom, and investors are ready to deploy capital in the world’s largest market. Massive investment in infrastructure will quickly put Americans to work at home improving roads, bridges, sewage systems, energy pipelines, an electric grid that ranks 26th in the world, airports that are a global embarrassment, and much more. What’s missing? Money. A 2017 report card on the condition of infrastructure from the American Society of Civil Engineers gave the U.S. a grade of D+ and estimated that $4.5 trillion was required by 2025 for remediation; that figure is now $1.5 trillion higher. While there is bipartisan will in Congress and the White House to address the problem, the cupboard is bare. The U.S. faces a record $3.7 trillion budget deficit this year. Reviving infrastructure, however, does not require taxpayer dollars. A new private institution can attract investment money from around the world and put it to work in rebuilding projects in the United States. That institution is a nationwide infrastructure bank that requires zero federal funding or loan guarantees. As a “non-bank bank,” it would take no deposits. Its model is the Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB) system, which is privately owned, managed, and funded. With $1.3 trillion in assets, the FHLB has been a safe source of funds for the U.S. housing market for the past 88 years. During the 2008 financial crisis, for example, the FHLB provided $1 trillion in advances when other sources of credit dried up. The U.S. is the only major developed country without an infrastructure bank. The European Investment Bank (EIB) has helped Europe become “more adept than America at mobilizing private capital for public infrastructure,” writes Terrence Keeley, global head of the official institutions group at BlackRock, the largest investment management firm in the world. The EIB is credited with creating 1.7 million jobs. The U.S. has state infrastructure banks, but most are moribund or tiny. The proposed new private infrastructure bank would provide funding to help revive these state banks so they can put money to work. Funds, as well, would go to private-sector projects. According to a Cato Institute study, just 3% of fixed assets are held by the federal government, 19% by state and local governments, and 78% by private owners. No matter who owns the assets, every trillion-dollar investment creates 12 million new jobs, according to Georgetown University researchers. There are hundreds of important projects waiting for the funding an infrastructure bank could offer: the Camden Spaceport in Georgia, the Gateway Tunnels in New York and New Jersey, the Texas Central Railway (high-speed train line), the Sites Reservoir in California, and many more. Where would the money come from? The U.S. is a magnet for investors around the world — investment and pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, wealthy individuals, banks and other financial institutions. What these investors demand is a responsible manager for their money, a bank that can select and oversee the right projects to produce a profit. The federal government’s role — as outlined in a bill introduced just last month, the Infrastructure Bank for America Act — would be to charter the bank, oversee it, and offer a tax credit. The five-year credit would amount to 10% annually of the amount of equity an investor purchases in the bank. This is not an unusual incentive for directing funds to socially valuable projects, and the foregone revenues would pale in comparison to the hundreds of billions that the Treasury would receive in new taxes from the projects. The equity would provide the capital cushion that all banks need, and shareholders would elect directors, who in turn would hire management — all without political interference. The Federal Reserve would provide oversight for the bank, which would be designated, like any large commercial bank, as a SIFI, or systemically important financial institution, to ensure its safety. The Fed might also use funds from its quantitative easing program to buy infrastructure bank bonds – purchases that have no effect on the federal debt. A national private infrastructure bank will make America a better, more productive place to live – all the while generating millions of new jobs at no cost to taxpayers a time of high unemployment. The question now is whether Democrats and Republicans can get together in this time of crisis to rebuild America.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › FIIB Solvency Evidence › Federal Action Key
BPC in 2016
Bipartisan Policy Center; BPC staff produced this report in collaboration with a distinguished group of senior advisers and experts. BPC would like to thank Aaron Klein, Fellow, Economic Studies and Policy Director, Initiative on Business and Public Policy, the Brookings Institution, and the council's staff for their contributions and continued support; Bridging the Gap Together: A New Model to Modernize U.S. lnfrastructure; https://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/BPC-New-Infrastructure-Model.pdf
Private investment in infrastructure is happening around the globe, serving as a major source of capital in countries such as Canada, Australia, and the UK. Yet, here in the United States it is rare, due to a number of unique barriers associated with the American market. We identified three major risks hindering the flow of private capital to US. infrastructure: the lack of a project pipeline, political risk, and permitting risk. Lack of a project pipeline. The key barrier is the lack of identified projects that are both attractive to private investors and tied to a clear public benefit. Public agencies, including the federal government, are not conducting the analyses needed to put forward projects that satisfy these criteria, so there are few opportunities for private investment.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › FIIB Solvency Evidence › Solves Competitiveness
Business Wire 2020
Proposed Privately-Funded Infrastructure Bank Offers Innovative Solution to U.S. National Infrastructure Crisis; https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200731005118/en/Proposed-Privately-Funded-Infrastructure-Bank-Offers-Innovative-Solution
U.S. House members have filed a bill to set up a private infrastructure bank designed to provide more than one trillion dollars to rebuild America's crumbling bridges, tunnels, roads, railways, airports, electric grid and more. The new bank could break a logjam in Congress that has lasted more than a decade. Republicans and Democrats, Congress and the President all say they recognize the need for reviving U.S. infrastructure, but there is no money in the Treasury to fund projects. As highways, dams, ports and utilities across the U.S. face a state of decay, repeated attempts at federal legislation to address the problem have clearly demonstrated that government funding is not the answer. The bank outlined in the bill would require no government funding or loan guarantees. The current bill, H.R. 7231 – Infrastructure Bank for America Act of 2020, proposes to establish a federally chartered bank that will be privately owned, privately managed and privately funded, removing partisan priorities and spending. The bill’s initial sponsors are Rep. Daniel Webster (R, FL-11), Rep. Daniel Meuser (R, PA-9), Rep. Doug LaMalfa (R, CA-1), Rep. Tom Reed (R, NY-23). They represent major urban, industrial and rural areas and are seeking broad bipartisan support. The founders of the Infrastructure Bank for America (IBA) plan to establish a trillion-dollar wholesale bank modelled after the highly successful Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB), established in 1932 to pump money into the economy in response to the Great Depression. “Infrastructure is the foundation of all economic activity; as it crumbles, so does our economy,” said William T. Nolan, president of Infra-Bk, LLC, the development entity that plans to establish the new bank. “There are ample funds worldwide willing to invest in U.S. infrastructure. As a private bank, The Infrastructure Bank for America will provide a conduit to access those funds and direct them to areas in need across the U.S.” A major benefit to the IBA plan is that it will divert some of the trillions of dollars currently being invested in China into the U.S. economy. IBA will provide a new investment vehicle for private investors including domestic and global institutions, corporations, retirement funds, and more. It will strengthen both infrastructure and the economy, funding projects that will create jobs nationwide, while enabling the U.S. to regain its footing on the global playing field.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › FIIB Solvency Evidence › Solves Competitiveness
BPC in 2016
Bipartisan Policy Center; BPC staff produced this report in collaboration with a distinguished group of senior advisers and experts. BPC would like to thank Aaron Klein, Fellow, Economic Studies and Policy Director, Initiative on Business and Public Policy, the Brookings Institution, and the council's staff for their contributions and continued support; Bridging the Gap Together: A New Model to Modernize U.S. lnfrastructure; https://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/BPC-New-Infrastructure-Model.pdf
We have an extraordinary opportunity in America — to confront the pressure being placed on our nation's roads, water systems, ports, airports, and energy grid with available private capital. This report establishes the frame work to unite projects that need funding with private capital ready to invest in a transparent system that allocates risks and resources to the public 's benefit. America is a nation of innovators — we are inspiring new industries through interconnected devices, commercializing suborbital space flight, and advancing cures to life-threatening diseases. Yet if we hope to foster the next generation of entrepreneurs that can push our economy forward and maintain our quality of life, we must invest in our infrastructure. Wise infrastructure investments would create millions of jobs, maintain the health, safety, and security of our communities, and set our nation on track for decades of greater prosperity. This is a choice between action and paralysis. Not making decisions today has serious consequences for tomorrow. We are already confronting prior mistakes as our infrastructure today is failing us. We are living at risk: driving every day on eroding roadways, questioning whether our water is really safe to drink, and sending our children off to schools built for our parents' generation. The problem is growing worse. It shouldn't be this way in a country that for so long has led and inspired the world. The Challenge We Face: Short-Term Focus Fuels Mounting Liabilities The investments made 50 to 100 years ago are nearing the end of their useful life. We have no coordinated vision or plan for their replacement. And public agencies have struggled to maintain existing assets or plan for their replacement, let alone to make the investments necessary to support future population growth and economic needs. The price tag to adequately prepare America for the future is hefty — likely requiring trillions of dollars to upgrade, modernize, and expand our infrastructure. Long-term needs — operations and maintenance, repair, expansion and modernization of infrastructure systems — are too often ignored in favor of a focus on short-term costs. There are many competing demands for public resources — healthcare, public pensions, and existing debt — that are expected to overwhelm public budgets. If we are to meet our nation's future needs and preserve our American quality of life, the public sector cannot continue to cover the cost and absorb the risk of our degrading infrastructure alone. We have to act before lasting damage is done to our economy and the next infrastructure- related failure consumes another American community. The Solution Is Clear: Long—Term Outlook Compels New Model, Delivers More Infrastructure There is another way. The private sector stands ready to partner and assist — bringing an appetite for risk, necessary capital, and valuable expertise. Investors with hundreds of billions of dollars to deploy are actively seeking infrastructure projects to support. Unfortunately, there are a number of barriers preventing the investment of private capital into US. infrastructure projects. As a result, America is leaving dollars on the table as capital flows to more receptive shores. Together the public and private sectors can establish a new model for infrastructure investment that confronts risk and captures value over a project's full life-cycle — propelling America's infrastructure into a modern, technologically advanced, and integrated network that enables prosperity long into the future. Our council aims to increase the flow of private capital into US. infrastructure projects — by: - addressing the pervasive underappreciation of future infrastructure liabilities in America; - encouraging partnerships with the private sector to share risks and maximize the value the public receives from infrastructure assets; - ensuring communities across the country have tools to make necessary investments. The challenge before us is enormous, but we have the resources to address it — if we can overcome the barriers that are pushing those resources away.
2023
CNDI
Counterplan
NEG › FIIB Solvency Evidence › 1NC Solvency
Teveia Barnes & John Kramer in 2022
Teveia Barnes is the former commissioner of the California Department of Financial Institutions and executive director of the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank. John E. Kramer is the former chief financial officer and assistant secretary of the U.S. Department of Transportation. Both are members of the advisory board of Infra-Bk, LLC.
The Urgent Need for a Private Infrastructure Bank; Real Clear Politics; https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2022/05/24/the_urgent_need_for_a_private_infrastructure_bank_147645.html
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Competitiveness
Steve Chan 9-6-2021. College Professor of Distinction and Chair of the Political Science Department at the University of Colorado. "Challenging the liberal order: the US hegemon as a revisionist power". International Affairs, Volume 97, Issue 5, September 2021, Pages 1335–1352. https://academic.oup.com/ia/article/97/5/1335/6363965. Pen-DL
What about Chinese misconduct? Various objections can be raised to the conclusion just stated. For example, one may argue that the United States has adhered to the norm of territorial integrity by withdrawing from countries that it had invaded, and that it has opposed secession movements, whereas China has not adhered to this norm, claiming a large portion of the South China Sea and pursuing territorial disputes with Japan and India. However, during its years of ascendancy the United States acquired vast amounts of territory by defeating Mexico and Spain (equivalent to all or parts of today's Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming, in addition to Guam, Puerto Rico and the Philippines), and no scholar to my knowledge has considered the United States to be revisionist on account of this conduct. Germany's historical territorial acquisitions appear puny by comparison. Whether the United States opposes secession depends on one's perspective. Was Saigon attempting to secede from Vietnam, and Taiwan from China? Washington surely enabled the breakup of the former Yugoslavia. It also supported Panama's secession from Colombia with the aim of building a canal there. China withdrew its troops from North Korea after the 1953 armistice, but US troops are still in South Korea. China has the world's largest number of land borders with other countries. It has settled nearly all of them, usually on terms favourable to its smaller neighbours.55 Its boundary disputes with India and Nepal are the sole exceptions. It does have maritime disputes with several countries, and it has rejected the Permanent Court of Arbitration's jurisdiction in its dispute with Manila in the South China Sea. Other signatories of UNCLOS have also invoked this provision to be exempted from dispute settlement by an international tribunal. But the United States has not even signed this convention. It has refused to accept the International Court of Justice's ruling that it had violated international law when it mined Nicaragua's ports, and it also challenged the freedom of navigation when ‘quarantining’ Cuba in 1962. Quoting Singapore's former ambassador to the United Nations, Kishore Mahbubani, that ‘China is the only great power today that has not fired a single bullet across its borders in 30 years [as of 2010]’, David Kang notes that ‘by contrast, even under the peaceful American presidency of Barack Obama, the United States dropped 26,000 bombs on seven countries in 2016’.56 China has also been accused of undertaking predatory trade policies. Yet Daniel Drezner reports that ‘China's compliance with adverse WTO rulings was better than that of either the United States or the European Union’, and concludes that ‘China, far from acting like a spoiler, acted primarily as a responsible stakeholder to reinforce the preexisting rules of the global economic game’.57 By contrast, Broz and colleagues note that the United States has made more frequent use of WTO exceptions to protect domestic industries from foreign competition than any other nation … Foreign nations have initiated more complaints at the WTO against the US for violating trade-exception rules than against any other nation or region, including the European Union.58 These remarks do not excuse Beijing's malpractices, but do put them in a comparative light. What about election meddling? Washington has alleged Russian interference in its 2016 presidential election, and Chinese and Iranian interference as well in its 2020 election. The United States has, however, meddled in other countries' elections far more frequently and flagrantly, dating back at least to its efforts to prevent a communist victory in Italy's 1948 election.59 It was also complicit in military coups or engaged in outright invasions that overthrew foreign governments (e.g. in Chile, Grenada, Guatemala, Iran, South Vietnam and, unsuccessfully, Cuba). It has even physically seized another country's leader (Panama's Manuel Noriega) and assassinated a foreign official in a third country (Iran's General Qasem Soleimani in Baghdad). By contrast, China has not been associated with such actions or the assassination of other countries' nuclear scientists.60 Again, there should be some consideration of frequency and magnitude in evaluating any country's conduct or misconduct. Washington has accused China of cyber espionage and has lobbied other countries to ban Huawei from their 5G infrastructure on the grounds that this Chinese telecommunications company may gain access to sensitive information and be required to turn it over to the Chinese government. The irony is not lost on Germany's economics minister Peter Altmaier, who remarked that it was the United States that surreptitiously taped Angela Merkel's telephone conversations in 2015, and that ‘the US also requires its companies to provide certain information needed to fight terrorism’.61 Edward Snowden disclosed mass surveillance undertaken by the National Security Agency with the cooperation of European governments and US telecommunications companies. Public media have reported the United States planting listening devices on a Boeing aircraft sold for use by China's president.62 Media reports have also pointed to the United States and Israel using a computer virus (Stuxnet) to damage Iran's nuclear programme. In short, ‘hacking’ and ‘cyber warfare’ are not being undertaken just by the Chinese. China's mistreatment of its domestic political dissidents and ethnic minorities can also give rise to scepticism about its foreign policy. A country that mistreats its own citizens is unlikely to treat foreigners better. The irony here is that Sino-American relations were much more cordial and cooperative during the Nixon, Ford and Carter years when China had an even more authoritarian government than it does today. Although one should not condone any violation of human rights or political repression, a degree of introspection and a comparative perspective would again be welcome. Recent protests in Hong Kong occurred around the time of mass demonstrations in Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, France, Iran, Iraq, Lebanon and the United States (‘Black Lives Matter’). In January 2021, there were also mass protests in the Netherlands (over curfews imposed in response to the pandemic), India (over government subsidies for farmers), the United States (over alleged election irregularities) and Russia (by supporters of Alexei Navalny). Which countries have had more casualties and arrests as a result of police action? Many Americans were horrified by the spectacle of Trump's supporters storming the Capitol and called them ‘insurrectionists’; but many of them would also have seen scenes of rioters seizing and vandalizing Hong Kong's Legislative Council, and few would use the same label to describe those demanding Hong Kong's independence. These episodes point to people's asymmetric access to information, and their application of seemingly different standards of evaluation. One usually does not hear much reference to the plight of Palestinians or Native Americans in judging whether Israel or the United States is or was ‘revisionist’.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Competitiveness
Lei 20, PhD and MA in International Politics, associate research fellow with the China Institute of International Studies. (Cui, 7-24-2020, "Despite heated talk, risk of a US-China hot war is small", South China Morning Post, )
Many observers are pessimistic about deteriorating US-China relations and believe the two countries are heading towards a cold war. Even worse, some argue that the situation might be more dangerous than the US-Soviet Union Cold War, and that a hot war might break out between the two. This argument is unconvincing. First of all, deterrents to a flare-up are much stronger in US-China relations than in US-Soviet relations. Although economic and people-to-people ties between China and the US are declining, they are still close compared to US-Soviet ties. It is hard to decouple two closely intertwined economies and societies. Take two examples. China is expected to become the world's largest consumer market, a temptation hard to resist for exporters, including those from the US. And in education, more than 300,000 Chinese students study in the US, bringing in huge revenues for the US education industry. Many universities go to great lengths to woo international students. Recently Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology even sued the government over its new visa restrictions, now aborted, on international students. Second, even if there is decoupling, the pain would not be too great and can be kept out of the national security sphere if properly handled. In fact, for national security reasons, a modest degree of isolation will make both sides more secure and comfortable. For instance, if China’s information technology equipment cannot capture Western markets, the US will be more relaxed. If China cannot get advanced technologies from the US and its technological progress slows down, the US will be less anxious. In the same vein, China feels assured knowing that if the Trump administration does impose a travel ban on Communist Party members, it would be abandoning one of the tools available to the US to promote “peaceful evolution” in China. Economic decoupling is undeniably more painful for China than for the US. But unlike Japan during WWII, which was hit hard by the US oil embargo because of its lack of natural resources, China has no such problems. Given its large domestic market, losing the US as a major customer is not a disaster for China, and can be compensated through more dynamic economic activities at home. China can also make up for being freezed out of technological exchanges by turning to indigenous innovation. As for the US, it can import goods from other developing countries, albeit less cheaply. The relative loss is acceptable when weighed against the heightened perception of economic independence and security. Third, the ideological confrontation between China and the US is less intense than that during the Cold War. Unlike the obsession with ideology in those days, the line between capitalism and socialism is blurred today. The market economy has become universally recognised as the best way to promote economic growth and, politically, many countries have embraced democracy. Even North Korea calls itself the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. Although ideological hawks in the US still long for the day when the beacon of freedom will light up the world, after many years of fighting bloody wars overseas, most American people are not interested in promoting democracy abroad. Meanwhile, China just wants to preserve its political system and has no interest in exporting it to other countries, as the Soviet Union did. Thus, ideological antagonism in China-US relations can easily be eased by calculations of realistic interests, which create conditions for compromise and cooperation. Fourth, both China and the US have many options other than war to achieve their policy goals. While they have no allies to serve as a buffer, given the nature of the potential conflict in the South China Sea or Taiwan Strait, both countries are adept at operating in grey zones and fighting psychological, public opinion or diplomatic warfare below the threshold of war. The forced closure of the Chinese consulate in Houston by the US government is just the latest act of brinkmanship. In addition, given China’s huge economic and financial interests in the US, the latter can wield the stick of sanctions when use of force is highly risky or not worth it. When both sides have many tools and options, why would they rush to war to achieve their goals? Last but not least, the imbalance of power will act as a deterrent. Some say the US and Soviet Union did not fight a hot war because they were evenly matched. It was not the case, actually. At the beginning of the Cold War, the Soviet Union was at a relative military disadvantage. Moreover, a country needs the will to fight before going to war, even if it is stronger militarily than its adversary. Having fought years of meaningless wars, the US is weary of war. China, too, abhors war. Having a clear understanding of US strength, especially when its own economy is slowing down and it is facing various domestic challenges, China would not wish to recklessly start a war with the US. In summary, the possibility of a hot war between China and the US is very small. The greatest danger for China is not a cold or hot confrontation with the US, but policymakers’ interpretation of the momentary hostility towards Beijing of a portion of the American population and the larger world. An erroneous interpretation could end China’s march to further opening up, and see it turn instead towards self-isolation.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Competitiveness
Roy 21 – Denny Roy, Political Science PhD at the University of Chicago. Professor at the Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies. [Rumors of War in the Taiwan Strait, 3-12-2021, https://thediplomat.com/2021/03/rumors-of-war-in-the-taiwan-strait/]
For Taiwan and its friends, however, the situation is not as dire as portrayed by those warning that Beijing will soon opt for war even in the absence of a major provocation from Taiwan.
For domestic political reasons, China is extremely unlikely to embark on a war of choice against Taiwan in the next year. In February 2022 Beijing will have the opportunity to present itself in the best possible light to a massive international audience when it hosts the Winter Olympics, in which the Chinese government has invested lavishly. A cross-strait war would ruin this party. In October 2022, the CCP will hold its 20th National Party Congress. Xi Jinping will be up for a third term as CCP general secretary. It is hard to imagine Xi starting an unnecessary war with Taiwan prior to his re-appointment because of the high risk that war-related economic and even political turmoil would erode Xi’s popularity.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Competitiveness
Dennis C. Blair 19, Chairman of the Board and Distinguished Senior Fellow (Non-Resident) of Sasakawa Peace Foundation USA, Would China Go Nuclear? https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/2018-12-11/would-china-go-nuclear
Talmadge’s basic argument is that in any conflict with China, the United States will immediately launch a full-scale air and missile assault against military targets in mainland China and against Chinese attack submarines at sea. In so doing, she argues, the United States will inadvertently hit either China’s ballistic missile submarines or its mobile nuclear missiles. That, in turn, will present Chinese leaders with a “use it or lose it” dilemma concerning their nuclear arsenal, and they may well decide to launch a nuclear attack against the United States.
Such a scenario is extremely unlikely; indeed, I would say the odds are somewhere between nil and zero. A U.S.-Chinese conflict would be a maritime campaign in which the two sides tried to conquer or defend islands. Attacks on land targets beyond the contested islands and the waters around them, whether carried out by the United States against Chinese territory or by China against U.S. overseas bases, would be aimed at military installations and systems that supported the maritime campaign—ports, air bases, and command-and-control centers. The intercontinental nuclear deterrent forces of both countries are physically separate from these facilities.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2AC › Impact › Competitiveness
Wendy Wu & Minnie Chan 22. (Wendy Wu is a Beijing-based reporter focusing on international finance and diplomacy. Minnie Chan is an award-winning journalist, specializing in reporting on defence and diplomacy in China. "Chinese military told not to fire first shot in stand-off with US". South China Morning Post. 08-11-2020. https://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy/article/3096978/south-china-sea-chinese-military-told-not-fire-first-shot)
China has told its service personnel “not to fire the first shot” as Beijing looks to de-escalate tensions with the United States in the South China Sea, sources familiar with the situation told the South China Morning Post. Both sides have stepped up their operations in the disputed waters, increasing the risk of incidents that spiral out of control, but Beijing does not want to give American hawks the opportunity to escalate things further. The sources said Beijing had ordered pilots and naval officers to exercise restraint in the increasingly frequent stand-offs with US planes and warships. Meanwhile, further details have emerged about a phone conversation between the two countries’ defence ministers last week. The call was first suggested by the US side about “a month earlier” but was initially given a frosty reception in Beijing. But a source said the Chinese leadership later had a change of heart and decided to reach out as tensions escalated in the South and East China seas. Last month, the US deployed two aircraft carrier battle groups, the USS Nimitz and USS Ronald Reagan, for drills near Chinese waters and has also carried out rare nighttime aerial reconnaissance missions close to Guangdong and Fujian provinces in recent weeks. China has also conducted naval drills and flyover missions around Taiwan and the South China Sea. Despite tough public language dismissing the US carrier strike groups as “paper tigers”, sources said the PLA was wary of accidental clashes. One source close to the military also said Beijing had communicated through “various channels” to the US that it had told its military “never to fire first” in a goodwill gesture to keep the situation under control. “It’s easy to give the order to shoot, but neither China nor the US is able to control the consequences. The current situation is highly tense and very dangerous,” the their person said. He said the PLA was a “different military force” from 2001 – a reference to the Hainan incident when a US intelligence aircraft collided with a PLA fighter jet. The Chinese pilot Wang Wei was killed and the US plane was forced to land on Hainan island. The crewmen were eventually released after the US issued a carefully worded statement on the incident. “Today, the PLA has developed many countermeasures. The Americans won’t be able to return in one piece if such an accident ever happens again,” he said. “But we are very clear that we will respond with force only as the last resort, when everything else has failed.” Another source said the two sides had established protocols to handle military encounters but these arrangements needed to be updated to reflect the latest situation. The source did not elaborate on whether this was discussed by the two defence ministers, Mark Esper and Wei Fenghe, in their August 6 conversation. China and the US established the military maritime consultative agreement in 1998 to avoid accidents during close encounters. In 2014 they agreed on an initiative to notify each other of major military operations and a code of conduct for naval and military encounters. But in recent years the relationship between the two countries has steadily worsened. US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has become increasingly belligerent in his rhetoric against China, taking aim directly at the Communist Party and declaring that the policy of engagement with China was “a failure”. Apart from increasing its operations in the South China Sea, the US has also rejected China’s sweeping claims in the disputed waters, saying they were “unlawful” and threatened the freedom of navigation. Meanwhile, the Chinese leadership has become increasingly concerned about security, with President Xi Jinping telling the Politburo late last month that “uncertain and unstable factors” were an increasing threat. But in recent weeks, senior Chinese diplomats have subtly changed their combative tone and called for dialogue to contain risks. Foreign Minister Wang Yi also picked up a more conciliatory approach when discussing the South China Sea in an interview with the state news agency Xinhua last week. Wang did not mention the “nine-dash line”, which marks out China’s claims over 90 per cent of the disputed waters. Instead he said the South China Sea wass “the shared home for the countries in the region” but should not be “a wrestling ground for international politics”. But Wang said the US had breached its commitment not to take sides in Beijing’s dispute with the other South China Sea claimants and accused it of seeking to drive a wedge between China and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations. On Monday the foreign ministry in Beijing called for “candid and effective dialogue” to control conflicts, but said it would firmly defend the nation’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.