Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Politics DA › Link – Divisive

The House of Representatives remains divided on universal health care.

Frieden 22 (Joyce Frieden, reporter of MedPage Today's coverage of Washington and health policy, “House Members Remain Divided on Universal Healthcare — Republicans, Democrats differ on potential costs and effects of Medicare for All,” Medpage Today, March 29, 2022, https://www.medpagetoday.com/publichealthpolicy/healthpolicy/97933) VQ

WASHINGTON -- Democratic and Republican House members appeared as far apart as ever Tuesday on the issue of the best way to achieve universal healthcare coverage in the U.S. "Republicans are serious on this committee about trying to solve the healthcare problems we have in America, but bigger government and government-run healthcare is not the solution to the problem," said Rep. James Comer (R-Ky.), ranking member of the House Oversight and Reform Committee, which held a hearing on "Examining Pathways to Universal Health Coverageopens in a new tab or window." For a large number of Democratic committee members, however, government-run healthcare -- such as through a "Medicare for All" program -- was exactly the answer. "For my colleagues on this committee, you have a choice in front of you today," said Rep. Cori Bush (D-Mo.). "It's a choice to save lives or a choice to let people die ... I came to Congress because 'Medicare for All,' it's not a choice for me. It's a moral imperative." Contrary Presentations of Facts Viewers trying to figure out what the facts were on the issue would have been hard-pressed to do so. Would a government-run system cost more money? Absolutely, according to committee member Rep. Andrew Clyde (R-Ga.). He cited an Urban Institute reportopens in a new tab or window saying that a single-payer healthcare plan that would cover all residents -- including undocumented immigrants -- would cost the federal government $34 trillion over 10 years. No, it wouldn't cost more money -- instead, it would save money, according to committee chair Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.). "I would like to submit for the record a study from the University of California San Francisco, opens in a new tab or window which analyzed 22 single-payer proposals and found that every single one would result in long-term financial savings," she said. "If my Republican colleagues were really worried about inflation, they would support policies that bring down healthcare costs, instead of voting 60 times against the Affordable Care Act healthcare plan that has expanded healthcare to 30 million Americans."

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Politics DA › Link – Divisive

Single-payer is divisive – polarization will trigger in-fighting if aff passes.

Blendon et al. 21 (Robert J. Blendon, Richard L. Menschel Professor of Public Health and Professor of Health Policy and Political Analysis, John M. Benson, Managing Director, Harvard Opinion Research Program, Harvard University, Eric C. Schneider, Executive Vice President, Quality Measurement and Research Group, National Committee for Quality Assurance, “The Future of Health Policy in a Partisan United States,” JAMA Network, March 5, 2021, https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2777394) VQ

Universal Coverage and National Health Insurance Reform On the issue of universal health insurance coverage, the 2 parties’ constituents appear to be sharply divided. Nearly 9 in 10 Democrats (87%) (n = 703 surveyed) reported that they believe it is the responsibility of the government to ensure all individuals in the US have health insurance coverage, a view shared by fewer than 1 in 4 Republicans (23%) (n = 580 surveyed). Among Democrats, 75% reported that they prefer a health insurance system mostly run by the government, whereas 79% of Republicans reported that they prefer a system based mostly on private health insurance.5 The same survey of 2150 individuals also addressed specific coverage proposals and found majorities of Democrats (n = 703 surveyed) expressed support for each of 3 options: building on the Affordable Care Act (ACA) (93%), Medicare-for-All (85%), and a Medicare buy-in to the ACA sometimes called “the public option” (82%). In contrast, only 30% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed) expressed support for building on the ACA and 28% supported Medicare-for-All. While 62% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed) reported that they support a Medicare buy-in to the ACA, that support does not represent an endorsement of the notion that government should ensure universal coverage. In addition, 64% of Republicans reported that they support replacing the ACA with a state-based private health insurance alternative compared with 36% of Democrats (n = 703 surveyed).5 US Health Care System Reform Currently, enthusiasm for broad reform of the US health care system is limited among both parties’ constituents. In a Gallup poll from June to July 2020, 55% of Democrats (n = 407 surveyed) and 53% of Republicans (n = 323 surveyed) indicated that they have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in the current US medical system.6 Any debate about making substantial changes to the US health care system will encounter the deep division between the 2 parties’ constituents over future federal government involvement in health care. About two-thirds of Democrats (68%) (n = 703 surveyed) indicated that they believe the federal government should be more involved in health care, a view held by only 17% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed).5 Members of both parties view one issue as a high priority for federal government intervention. In a December 2020 poll that included 328 Democrats and 272 Republicans, taking action to reduce high prescription drug prices was listed by both Democrats and Republicans as among their top 6 priorities (from a list of 23) for the new president and Congress.2 However, Democrats and Republicans in Congress currently disagree on how best to achieve that goal.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › AT Aff Sets Prices

The AFF can’t set prices—special interests pay off bureaucrats and dictate policy based on their own interests—that makes cost inflation net worse and turns the AFF.

Pope 17

Chris Pope, senior advisor at the West Health Policy Center and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, The Single-Payer Mirage: Single Payer is No Solution, May 26, 2017, http://www.nationalreview.com/article/447967/health-care-reform-single-payer-no-solution-california-new-york

It provides no escape from the painful tradeoffs involved in purchasing health care. On May 16, New York’s state assembly passed legislation that would make the state government the sole payer for hospital and physician services. The state senate is only a few votes short of following suit, and California is considering similar legislation. Amid all the trouble reforming health care in Washington, some seem to be asking: Can’t the government just purchase medical services for everyone, and get a good deal in the process? Unfortunately, a single-payer system provides no escape from the painful tradeoffs involved in purchasing health care. While it may be possible for the government to reduce health-care spending by limiting access to care, single-payer is just as likely to make it easier for providers to inflate costs by eliminating competition. The bill under consideration by the New York legislature generously leaves the task of finding a way to pay for its proposed system to the governor. No thorough assessment of the likely cost has yet been undertaken, with proponents citing fantastical claims that increasing coverage could actually save money. A single-payer system for California was estimated to cost more than double the existing state budget, while a similar proposal for Vermont collapsed when it became clear that hospitals and physicians would not suddenly be able to deliver more services for less money. Single-payer advocates have enthusiastically cited polls showing Americans supporting the expansion of Medicare to cover all Americans. Yet Medicare is not a single-payer system for the 86 percent of its beneficiaries that opt for some form of private or supplemental coverage. Most individuals seeking full coverage outside the multi-payer Medicare Advantage option must purchase supplemental private Medigap plans, which required an average additional premium of $2,196 in 2010. UP NEXT Professional sports teams are avoiding Trump hotels 00:22 00:40 Powered by The dysfunction in the individual market for health insurance is the result of imposing expensive service mandates without considering the likely tradeoffs. The Affordable Care Act required insurers to cover the costliest chronic-care needs but did not make appropriate provisions to compensate plans for doing so. The vogue for single-payer health care derives from the same impulse. The reality is that you get what you pay for. Drive reimbursements for doctors and hospitals below market rates and there will not be enough providers to serve all patients. Providers who stay will be assured of customers and can let quality slip. A system of fixed pricing ossifies payment silos, encourages hasty clinical interactions, and inhibits innovations in the structure of care delivery. Regulated pricing by a single payer is presented as a remedy to the inflation of costs by hospitals, drug companies, and physicians — but these inflated costs are often the deliberate product of policy. Hospitals are shielded from competition by policymakers so that they may charge private insurers inflated amounts to pay for uncompensated care. Lower these rates by statute, and a new source of revenues to fund treatment for the uninsured must be found. Although politicians routinely promise to cut the cost of prescription drugs by “negotiating” with manufacturers, this is always ultimately a proposal to undermine patent rights, and hence a threat to the revenues on which any future drug development relies. The reality is that you get what you pay for. While it is not possible for the government to get more than it pays for, it is certainly possible for it to pay too much for what it gets. When policymakers set prices in the presence of a multitude of lobbyists scattering fears about diminished access to care, payments will frequently exceed the levels that competition would yield. Very few physicians are currently unwilling to accept Medicare patients, which suggests that the program’s payment terms (fees, claims reviews, and tax implications) are highly attractive for providers relative to those offered by other payers. Indeed, as providers have a veto over every major Medicare-payment change, reforms tend only to inflate the advantages they enjoy. For laboratory services, where government intervention has not deliberately sought to inflate the prices that private insurers must pay providers, Medicare routinely pays 18 to 30 percent more for the exact same products. Single-payer advocates claim that eliminating private insurers reduces administrative costs. It does this only by letting fraud, waste, and abuse go unchecked. In 2016, 11 percent of claims associated with the single-payer part of Medicare were improperly paid, at a cost of $1,422 per beneficiary. Having a single payer doesn’t remove tradeoffs from health care; it just places them out of patients’ sight. When many countries established single-payer health care soon after World War II, very few of the expensive procedures that characterize modern health care existed, and so it was simple to cover everything. As costly new drugs and surgical procedures have been invented, in nations where care is available only through a single payer, these have frequently been left unavailable to patients, who often don’t know what they’re missing.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › AT Lowers Administrative Costs

Single payer doesn’t decrease admin costs

Pearl, MD, professor of surgery at Stanford University, and faculty of the Stanford Graduate School of Business, ‘17

(Robert, “Why A Government-Run, Single-Payer Healthcare Approach Is Doomed To Fail,” March 16,

Myth 1: It Would Lower Administrative Costs

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › Link – Progressive Tax

Specifically, for single payer

Yevgeniy Feyman 16, is a fellow and deputy director of health policy with the Manhattan Institute. 2/11/16, “The Single-Payer Sacrifice: 11.6 Million Jobs” http://www.realclearpolicy.com/blog/2016/02/11/single-payer_sacrifice_116_million_jobs_1551.html

Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders recently released his health-care plan: a government-run single-payer system for the U.S., similar to what many European countries have. Criticism of the plan has so far focused on its lack of political feasibility, but there is an even more important reason to be wary: Accounting for costs and tax increases, it would reduce labor supply by 11.6 million. In a struggling economy, with tepid wage growth, hurting employment should be the last thing on any politician’s agenda. The plan truly promises everything under the sun. Not only will everyone be able to get any medical treatment needed — with no cost at the point of service — but the plan won’t require a terribly high tax increase. The funding mechanism boils down to an increase in payroll taxes: an “income-based premium” of 2.2 percent for individuals and a tax of 6.2 percent on employers. Because economists, as well as the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office and the Joint Committee on Taxation, recognize that the "employer share" of payroll taxes is mostly borne by workers in the form of lower wages, this translates to an 8.4 percentage point increase overall. These elements of the plan were the first to draw criticism. Not only do most single-payer countries fund their health-care systems with higher taxes on the middle class, but they also typically exclude a variety of services and drugs from coverage. Without being able to say no to some expensive drugs and services, the government would have a tough time driving down prices. But perhaps the most stinging rebuke came from veteran health economist Kenneth Thorpe of Emory University. In Thorpe’s estimation, Sanders’ plan would require a total tax hike of 20 percentage points, and would cost $1.1 trillion more each year than the campaign has estimated. This is at least partly because the government would have to pay more than Medicare’s low rates to keep doctors and hospitals in the system, and making health care free at the point of delivery would also increase use of health-care services. These criticisms alone should make Sanders’ plan a nonstarter. But that’s not the end of the laundry list of problems with the proposal. Few economists would dispute that tax rates can affect people’s decision to work. The higher a person’s marginal tax rate, the bigger the disincentive to work more; a 50 percent rate, for instance, means that earning another dollar nets only an extra 50 cents. This is what economists call the “substitution” effect. But there is a countervailing effect as well. As you pay more in taxes, you may want to try to maintain your previous standard of living, and thus decide to work more. This is called the “income effect.” The ultimate effect of taxes on the workforce depends on which of these forces is stronger. The CBO, for instance, has come to the conclusion that the Affordable Care Act’s combination of taxes, tax credits, and mandates will reduce full-time equivalent employment (one full-time equivalent employee works 40 hours per week; two part-time workers equal one full-time equivalent) by about 2 million in 2025. As it turns out, the ACA’s many taxes are relatively insignificant compared with those in the Sanders plan. Applying the CBO’s approach and assumptions, along with tax data from the National Bureau of Economic Research, to the Sanders plan indicates that the campaign’s assumed taxes would reduce employment by 4.9 million full-time equivalent workers in 2025. Not an insignificant number. When we take Thorpe’s more realistic assumptions and apply the same approach, the fully-implemented plan reduces employment by a whopping 11.6 million full-time equivalent workers. Under these assumptions, the average marginal tax rate would grow from around 22 percent to 42 percent, while the average total tax rate would increase from 11 percent to 31 percent. At the upper end of income, total tax rates would be far beyond 50 percent. And none of this factors in state and local taxes. Of course, some of drop in employment might be considered “voluntary.” Some would stop working because they no longer needed to be employed to receive health insurance — escaping "job lock," as House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi once put it. But others would simply find it meaningless to put in extra hours or look for more lucrative positions when so much of their earnings get sucked away as taxes. For employers, this would all mean a large increase in hiring costs, too. Sure, as Sanders’ campaign likes to remind us, employers would no longer pay for private health insurance. But economists also recognize that health insurance is a form of compensation. And if you cut health insurance (with or without raising taxes), wages must in turn go up. Sanders might be correct that health-care reform is unfinished. There remain many problems with the ACA that must be addressed and many problems that the ACA left untouched. But it’s quickly becoming apparent that the Sanders plan for American health care is the wrong way to fix these problems and offers a bad deal for workers.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › Link – Progressive Tax

Progressive taxes are economically destructive – they crush productivity and entrepreneurship

David Marotta 12, president of Marotta Wealth Management, "A Progressive Tax Code is Economically Destructive," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidmarotta/2012/09/10/a-progressive-tax-code-is-economically-destructive/#d1f30b65fb3d

Most Americans assume a progressive tax code is needed to promote equality and remove some of the burden of other taxes on those with the lowest income. But the progressive nature of the tax code changes behavior in many ways. As a result a progressive tax code is economically destructive. To start with an obvious example, let's assume the tax rates on a business start at 10% and after a certain point reach 100%. How much money would be collected at the 100% rate? The answer, of course, is zero. No business would bother earning more money only to be obligated to give it all to the government. Many statistics would hide this change of behavior. The average tax rate on businesses would seem a low 10%. But decisions are not made at the average. They are made at the marginal rate. When your hand first touches a hot stove, your average body temperature is still normal. Nevertheless you recoil quickly. Increasing marginal rates are like a hot stove to additional productivity. Businesses are like rich people. They can decide how much income they want to realize each year. Capping the income of otherwise productive companies is economically destructive. Not only does it restrict productivity and the creation of wealth, but it also limits employment and taxes paid. Imagine there is a proposal for a flat 20% tax. Liberals rage that would mean doubling the tax on the poor businesses while giving Big Greed an 80% tax cut. But what is the effect? Businesses that would have truncated their earnings no longer hold back. Productivity jumps and unemployment drops. All this while the tax collected could more than double. A Progressive Tax Code is Economically Destructive Now that an obvious case has established the concept, let's look at smaller tax progressions. Remember that all economic decisions are made at the margin. There has to be a decision, and we have to look at the marginal tax change. One such decision is how much money you should convert from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA each year. The more you convert in one year, the higher the tax bracket you get pushed into. Waiting until next year to convert the money is always an option, especially because you can decide to unconvert, or recharacterize, the money any time before you file your taxes. Getting pushed into a higher tax bracket sets up a hurdle that the conversion account must appreciate before keeping the conversion makes financial sense. Some of the hurdles are extremely high, even at very low incomes. Suppose you earn less than $17,400 and are in the lowest tax bracket of 10%. If you convert $100 from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, you will owe $10 more in federal tax. But if another $100 pushes you into the 15% tax bracket, you would owe $15 in tax. If you could wait until next year to convert at the 10% rate again, when would it be advantageous to convert this year even if it pushes you into the 15% bracket? In other words, what is the hurdle of added productivity you must surpass to overcome this minor increase in the marginal tax rate? It turns out the hurdle is a 50% annual return on your money. Unless your $100 grows to $150, you would pay less tax waiting until next year and converting at the lower rate. Ten percent of $150 next year is equivalent to 15% of $100 this year. Those who favor a progressive tax system do not realize that a small increment of 10% to 15% can truncate any decision to be more productive unless you have a good chance of earning more than 50% over the next year. If you think the poor can't or don't make such decisions, you are mostly wrong. The poor fear dropping off entitlement cliffs more than they do hitting the wall of higher taxes. And a vague perception of the effects causes most to err on the side of avoiding paying taxes or jeopardizing their benefits. There are places where it can cost you multiple dollars of benefit for every additional dollar you earn. The middle class and wealthy have even more discretion over the timing and amount of their income. We encountered such a case recently: clients with a base income of about $69,000 for whom we were considering a Roth conversion. Our federal Roth calculator computed they should convert up to the top of the 28% tax bracket, an additional $143,000 so long as their Roth account had not lost money. This would have resulted in the federal government receiving an additional $38,000 in tax revenue. The hitch was that these clients live in California. Virginia state taxes reach their maximum after only $17,000 of income. Beyond that point the rate is a flat 5.75%. But California tax rates are highly progressive, with rates from 1% all the way up to 10.3% for income over $1 million. In our clients' case, realizing this additional income would push them from the 6% state bracket to 9.3%. The hurdle for this marginal tax increase is a 55% annual return. A hundred dollars taxed at 9.3% this year is equivalent to $155 taxed at 6% next year. The effect is that neither the federal government nor California will be collecting that additional tax this year or ever. A progressive tax code discourages productivity, actually rewarding you for producing less. This system destroys much growth in the economy that would flourish otherwise. Purposefully doing this simply so the rich have less is evil, and it hurts society as a whole. Listen in political debates when the term "rich" is used with emotions that make it almost an economic slur. Our current system is complex enough to create many entitlement cliffs and marginal tax walls throughout the income spectrum. Tax simplification would eliminate many of these barriers to economic mobility and encourage greater productivity across the board. And one of these changes is a flatter tax and fewer deductions.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › Link - Generic

A single payer system would hurt the economy and increase inflation

Daily News 22 [Norfolk Daily News, Northeast/North Central Nebraska’s most trusted, comprehensive, and timely news source, “Democrats’ push for ‘single payer’ health care program will hurt Americans and the economy,” Bill Huse, 7/25/2022, https://norfolkdailynews.com/commentary/democrats-push-for-single-payer-health-care-program-will-hurt-americans-and-the-economy/article_c2f9c2a2-0c24-11ed-b8cd-33ccec42ef56.html#comments]@RN

Although the federal government’s deficit spending continues to spur inflation, which is negatively impacting Americans across the nation, some in Congress seem oblivious. They want to increase spending and the nation’s debt via health-care proposals that will prove more painful than helpful. The U.S. Senate’s Budget Committee recently convened a hearing on the “Medicare for All” proposal touted by Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont. In the House, most Democratic members have signed on to similar legislation that would eliminate private and employer-sponsored health insurance and instead establish a “single payer” system of national health insurance. The idea is to guarantee higher quality health care for all at lower government and personal costs. Sounds good, but will it be affordable and effective? The Democrats’ proposals focus on the concept but are void of the important financing provisions. Without that, neither the Congressional Budget Office nor independent economists can offer an estimate of its effect on the federal budget, the economy or taxpayers. But there is some educated guesswork that can help shed some light on the situation. At the Senate hearing on Sanders’ bill, Phillip Swagel, director of the Congressional Budget Office, said his agency previously analyzed five versions of the “single payer” universal coverage program. What were the results? 1. Any of the five versions would require massive taxpayer subsidies between $1.5 trillion and $3 trillion in 2030 alone. 2. Demand for health care services would outstrip the supply of medical services, resulting in congestion and delays much like is experienced in Britain and Canada, which have such systems. 3. The nation’s total production of goods and services would drop by up to 10 percent in 2030 because of the impact of higher income or payroll taxes on Americans. 4. Testifying at the same Senate hearing, Dr. Charles Blahous, a former trustee of the Medicare program, said that to provide “Medicare for All” level of benefits and services would require spending between $32.6 trillion and $38.8 trillion, or about $120,000 per person. Even at the lower estimate, Dr, Blahous said a “doubling of all currently projected federal individual and corporate income taxes would be insufficient to finance the added federal costs.” Robert Moffit, a senior fellow at The Heritage Foundation, said analysts at the foundation have concluded that a single-payer program would translate into 73.5 percent of Americans paying more for health care than they do today. “Washington’s frenetic spending is already exacting an exorbitant price. Because of bad federal policy, ordinary Americans are suffering from soaring inflation,” he added. So, let’s be clear: What Sen. Sanders and his ilk are promoting won’t work and won’t be affordable.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Inflation DA › Link - Generic

Single-payer would skyrocket inflation and increase healthcare bills.

Moffit 22 (Robert E. Moffit, Senior Research Fellow, Center for Health and Welfare Policy, “Think Inflation Is Bad Now? Imagine if the Left Wins on Health Policy,” The Heritage Foundation, Jun 3, 2022, https://www.heritage.org/budget-and-spending/commentary/think-inflation-bad-now-imagine-if-the-left-wins-health-policy) VQ

Yes, it can get worse, much worse. Washington’s deficit spending has fueled punishing inflation, but self-styled “progressives” in Congress remain fully committed to ratcheting up federal spending and debt even more. Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders recently chaired a Senate Budget Committee hearing on his “Medicare for All” proposal. Like his earlier version, the Senate bill would abolish virtually all private and employer-sponsored health insurance, eliminate Medicaid and even Medicare itself, and establish a “single payer” system of national health insurance. Most House Democrats are co-sponsoring similar legislation. Their basic proposition is that their legislation, which will upend coverage of 90 percent of the population, will guarantee higher quality care for all at lower national and personal costs. The Sanders bill, like the House Democrats’ companion bill, is especially notable not for what it contains but for what is missing: the crucial financing provisions. Without specifying the kind or the size of taxes required to fund the program, neither the Congressional Budget Office nor independent economists can score the bill and provide anything close to a precise estimate of its effect on the federal budget, the economy or taxpayers. The economic effect is mostly left to educated guesswork. Educated guess-workers exist. Testifying before the Senate Budget Committee, CBO Director Phillip Swagel reported that the agency had not analyzed Sanders’ bill but had previously conducted an analysis of five versions of the “single payer” universal coverage program. Replacing current programs with any of the five “single payer” options would, according to the CBO analysis, require massive taxpayer subsidies: between $1.5 trillion and $3 trillion in 2030 alone. Moreover, new demand would outstrip the limited supply of medical services, resulting in “congestion” in the system and “delays and foregone care.” Curious what that looks like? Check out Britain and Canada. Americans will be left poorer, too. Whether the government health program is financed by an income tax or payroll tax, according to CBO, America’s gross domestic product, the nation’s total production of goods and services, would be “approximately 1 percent to 10 percent lower by 2030” than under current law. Why? Says CBO: “The net reductions in GDP would occur primarily because of the effects of increased taxes on labor and capital income. Taxes on labor income reduce after-tax wages, so they reduce the return on each additional hour worked. … In CBO’s assessment, therefore, higher labor taxes tend to reduce the number of hours worked in the economy. Higher taxes on capital income, such as dividends and capital gains, lower the average after-tax rate of return on private wealth holdings (or the return on investment), which reduces the incentive to save and invest and leads to reductions in the capital stock. Those effects lead, in turn, to lower income.” Printing money to cover the cost is a dead end. Says CBO: “Perpetually financing any of the single-payer systems CBO analyzed through increased borrowing—without a corresponding increase in revenues or a reduction in other spending at some point in the future—would be unsustainable.” And forget “soaking the rich.” Even they aren’t rich enough to cover the ballooning bills racked up under Medicare for All. Testifying at the same Senate hearing, Dr. Charles Blahous, a former trustee of the Medicare program and scholar at the Mercatus Center, said that to provide “Medicare for All” level of benefits and services would require spending between $32.6 trillion and $38.8 trillion, or about $120,000 per person, above and beyond any administrative cost-cutting measures. Even at the lower estimate, Blahous observed, a “doubling of all currently projected federal individual and corporate income taxes would be insufficient to finance the added federal costs of enacting M4A” (“Medicare for All”). The congressional “progressives” assure us, however, that individuals and families—no longer paying private insurance premiums and deductibles—would still come out ahead with a tax-financed government health program. Don’t bet on it. Examining previous “Medicare for All” legislation, Heritage Foundation analysts concluded that a “single-payer” program would require a tax of 21.2 percent of earnings (on top of current federal, state and local taxes), hitting nearly two-thirds of American households, meaning that 73.5 percent of Americans would pay more for healthcare than they do today. Recognizing the political difficulty of abolishing nearly all existing private and public health insurance and substituting a centralized “single payer” program, some lawmakers, including Sanders, propose a watered-down version that would reduce the normal age of eligibility from 65 to 60. Assuming implementation of that policy in 2026, CBO and the Joint Committee on Taxation estimate that over five years 7.3 million people—about twice the population of Oklahoma—would enroll in the financially troubled Medicare program. Of that 7.3 million, CBO and JCT estimate that 4.8 million would have otherwise had private, employer-sponsored health insurance coverage. In short, the policy would amount to a crowd-out of existing coverage and private payment at the expense of the taxpayer for that segment of the population, while adding an additional $155 billion (about $480 per person in the United States) to the federal deficit. Washington’s frenetic spending is already exacting an exorbitant price. Because of bad federal policy, ordinary Americans are suffering from soaring inflation. They are being threatened by an impending recession and are witnessing a steady depreciation of their savings and retirement income. Over the horizon, Americans’ financial future is already darkened by accumulating deficits and dangerous debt, now exceeding $30.4 trillion—about $94,000 per person in the country. Ignore silly promises of “free care” for all. If congressional “progressives” ever succeed in taking over American healthcare—nearly one-fifth of the American economy—our personal and public finances, bad as they are right now, will get much, much worse.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › UBI CP › 1NC - Solvency

A basic income for healthcare solves the aff better – more efficient with administration and guaranteed access.

Emanuel and Fuchs ‘07 [Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Department of Bioethics, National Institutes of Health, Victor R. Fuchs, Department of Economics and Department of Health Research and Policy, Stanford University, “A Comprehensive Cure: Universal Health Care Vouchers,” pgs. (15-19), Brookings Institution, 7/1/2007, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/a-comprehensive-cure-universal-health-care-vouchers/]@RN

Table 3 summarizes the principal differences between the proposed universal health care voucher system and proposals for individual mandates and single-payer systems. Unlike individual mandates, universal health care vouchers would simply and efficiently achieve universal coverage without the costly administration of income-based subsidies. The poor and the sick would be implicitly subsidized by the difference between the value of the voucher to them and the amount of VAT they pay. Also, unlike mandates, a voucher system would not prop up an inefficient and inequitable employment-based insurance system, nor would it require beneficiaries to change health plans when their income, employment, marital status, or other characteristics change. Finally, because the voucher system would be universal no coverage denial, it would not be subject to the adverse selection problem in which a disproportionate share of higher users of care are drawn into the system while the better insurance risks make other arrangements. Individual mandates by themselves remain subject to this serious problem. One very important difference between a universal voucher system and single-payer systems currently proposed is that the latter promise an open-ended entitlement that is often not tied directly to adequate funding. In the voucher system, by contrast, expenditure and revenue are explicitly connected through the dedicated tax. Also, single-payer systems generally provide only a monetary promise; they do not guarantee access to care. Many Medicare beneficiaries today have difficulty finding a physician to accept them as a patient. In a voucher system, everyone would be enrolled in a plan that is held responsible for providing care to its enrollees. Finally, a crucial difference between a voucher system and the other two models is that neither of the other two models makes a significant effort to improve efficiency in the organization and delivery of care. The projected universal voucher system, by contrast, would make plans accountable for quality and service by allowing only qualified plans to enroll patients. Paying a risk-adjusted fee per enrollee (that is, capitation) creates a strong financial incentive for insurance companies to be efficient in care delivery. In short, the projected universal voucher system would be more than just a funding mechanism. It would create a positive dynamic that moves the entire system toward more efficient use of resources and higher-quality care. Initially, all Americans who are not in Medicare, Medicaid, or SCHIP would be notified by their regional health board that they can now choose their health plan or health insurance company through the insurance exchange. Through mailings, the Internet, and other mechanisms, potential enrollees would be informed about the different plans available in their geographic area. Charts would identify the similarities and differences in the various plans: what local hospitals each plan uses, the physicians participating in the plan, the copayments required, and other relevant information. Americans would also be instructed on how to enroll. People with coverage today would be able to keep their current doctor, and many aspects of their plan would remain the same. As stated above, Medicare, Medicaid, SCHIP, and other government health programs would initially remain in place, but participants in these programs would be notified that they could now switch to the voucher system. Those who prefer not to switch would just stay in their current program. For most Americans, enrollment in a health plan under the universal health care voucher system would feel much like what they currently experience through their employer-based coverage, with four important differences. First, they would have a wider choice of health plans. Today most Americans who are covered by their employer have no choice of health plan (Kaiser 2006). They are told who will provide their coverage and what will be covered. Those currently uninsured would experience a new freedom to choose a health plan. Second, Americans would no longer have to be screened to determine their premiums or to determine what will be excluded from coverage for the first year. No health plan or insurance company would be allowed to subject Americans to pretesting or to deny coverage on the basis of preexisting conditions. No one could be denied enrollment or renewal of coverage for any reason. Instead of health plans choosing their enrollees, as is effectively the case today, enrollees would be allowed to choose their health plan. Third, enrollees would pay nothing directly for the set of standard health benefits. The universal health care voucher would cover the full cost. There would be no premiums deducted from paychecks or paid for out of pocket. There would be no deductibles, and many people would find their copayments to be less than what they are currently paying.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › States CP › 1NC - Compacts - Solvency

States solve the AFF.

Jackel, 17 --- Law Office of Robert Jackel Previous United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas, Defenders Association of Philadelphia Education University of Pennsylvania Law School, Alex Green, Research Associate @ Harvard Business School, 2/4, https://good-assurance.com/interstate-compacts-could-preserve-the-affordable-care-act/

Interstate Compacts Could Preserve the Affordable Care Act Across the country, Democrats have vowed to fight efforts from congressional Republicans and the White House to repeal the Affordable Care Act—a task that grows more complicated by the day. Yet even if the law is repealed, with or without a replacement, progressives could still have recourse at the state level. A widely used form of treaty between states could allow them to bond together and set up their own multistate health-care programs to fill the gaps created by the federal government. In an age of retreating federal programs, interstate compacts could be a tool for progressive states to enact a regional or even nationwide agenda. Large states would have little trouble replacing the ACA, often called Obamacare, with a state-run program on their own. California has the resources and population to run its state health-care exchange, Covered California, from Sacramento, and could even fund the Medicaid expansion it implemented under the ACA. To the north, less populous states like Oregon and Washington would struggle to do the same without comparably sized economies. But if they join together with California in an interstate compact, they could potentially reap the benefits of the economy of scale—saving on costs through the sheer size of the enrollment pool and bargaining power. Interstate compacts allow individual states to maintain consistency in their laws by coordinating on a multistate level. While they may not rival the power of the federal government, compacts may be a next-best option for states facing sudden cutbacks in support from Washington, D.C. States could use them to preserve ACA-initiated programs, or create new systems from scratch. There are currently over 200 active interstate compacts, many of which are regional. Twenty-two agreements are national in scope, and each one addresses a different issue facing the states. The Interstate Compact for Adult Offender Supervision, for example, oversees the transfer of parole and probation between states. And the Gulf States Marine Fisheries Commission is one of roughly two dozen water-related compacts that govern everything from fish stocks to the fair use of river basins by adjoining states. Agencies that monitor compacts have authority, delegated from the states, to generate revenue and engage in rule-making—that is, they can create regulations to enforce the powers granted by a given compact. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the Delaware River Port Authority, and the Washington Metro Area Transit Authority are all interstate-compact agencies that run rapid-transit systems. There are constitutional limitations on these agreements, even though some actually predate the Constitution and were used to settle land disputes between the colonies. But states can largely work around those constraints. “Congressional consent is not necessarily a legal judgment, it’s a political one.” The Compacts Clause of the Constitution—Article I, Section 10—says, “No State shall, without the Consent of Congress … enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State.” Despite that limiting language, states have regularly entered into these agreements without lawmakers’ approval at all, and the Supreme Court has supported them, curbing the scope of federal involvement in the process. In 1893, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government’s authority to approve such agreements was only applicable when an agreement “may encroach upon or interfere with the just supremacy of the United States.” It was not completely clear what constraints this left on the states. Nearly a century later, the Court took up the issue again, building on their earlier ruling in U.S. Steel Corporation v. Multistate Tax Commission in 1978. The Court found that the commission’s policies, which were intended to reform state taxation of multistate businesses, could have been enacted individually by each state. As a result, the Court ruled that the Multistate Tax Compact did not require the consent of Congress. To date, the test for when states need approval remains murky, but in general, when states enact programs they each could have done on their own, congressional approval is not necessary. “Congressional consent is not necessarily a legal judgment, it’s a political one,” said Colmon Elridge, director of the National Center for Interstate Compacts, a division of the nonpartisan Council of State Governments that provides information and assistance on how to establish and run compacts. So the standard for lawmakers deliberating whether they should approve a compact is usually, as Elridge put it, “Is this in my political best interest?” Moreover, Congress rarely says no to states that want to enter into them. “When it gets to that level,” he said, referring to agreements that are ready for congressional review, “especially in this climate, it’s more dangerous politically to not respect the will of the states.” Congressional approval can confer advantages, too, even if it’s not necessarily required for compacts to take effect. Agreements that are backed by Congress carry the force of federal law, and once granted, Congress cannot take back its consent. But there can be drawbacks for states that decide to enter into compacts without congressional approval. The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, the Northeast’s auction-based cap-and-trade program for reducing greenhouse-gas emissions, has been operating for years without congressional approval. Nine states are currently members of the compact: Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, and Vermont. As a mandatory program, the RGGI has claimed reductions in lifetime energy bills of $4.67 billion for 4.6 million residences. However, because it lacks congressional consent, the compact does not have the force of law that prevents state governments from interfering from term to term. The program relies instead on individual states for regulation, and their general willingness to continue to participate. Any dispute between states in a congressionally approved compact is brought directly to the Supreme Court of the United States, as part of the Court’s original jurisdiction. But compacts that have not sought congressional approval have no easy mechanism to resolve disagreements. This has exposed the RGGI to the whims of changing state governments. In 2011, for example, a dissatisfied New Jersey Governor Chris Christie withdrew from the compact, claiming that “it doesn’t make any sense environmentally or economically.” Even though the state legislature voted to bring New Jersey back into the program, Christie then vetoed the bills to rejoin the agreement. The states considering compacts in recent years have been red states looking to dodge Obamacare—not blue states. While at this point only New Jersey has left—and will likely return after Christie leaves office—the ability of states to leave congressionally unapproved compacts creates vulnerabilities and makes long-term planning harder. As other states, including California, continue to build regional, and even international, climate initiatives without congressional support, New Jersey’s example casts a shadow over their efforts. Given the ACA’s origins as a state-level initiative in Massachusetts, interstate health-care exchanges could be operable without lawmakers’ consent under the Supreme Court’s holding in U.S. Steel Corporation v. Multistate Tax Commission, though they would be exposed to the same vulnerabilities as the RGGI. But given Republican support for states’ rights, they might even get congressional approval. A recent Republican plan to replace Obamacare would permit states to “keep the Affordable Care Act if it is working for their residents,” as Senator Susan Collins described. While its future is unclear, the plan is a sign that there’s appetite for honoring states’ health-care decisions, which could include interstate agreements. Elridge is not even certain that multistate exchanges would be seen as controversial as interstate compacts go, despite the charged political climate. “If Kentucky and Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, and West Virginia said, ‘We understand the health challenges in these states, we’re going to develop some kind of interstate compact that works in terms of expanding access to care, making it quality, and making it affordable,’ they can absolutely do that,’” he said. Phil Scott, the new Republican governor of Vermont, has already suggested as much. Scott ran on a platform promising to merge Vermont’s exchange with that of another state, possibly New Hampshire, to save money on maintenance and operating costs. This could be the first step toward creating regional health-care exchanges that build on the ACA. Even with congressional approval, there could still be some limitations on multistate exchanges. The Constitution puts limits on the ability of individual states to hamper interstate commerce or discriminate against out-of-state economic interests. For instance, a climate compact that bans the importation of electricity from a state outside the compact could violate the Constitution. State legislatures may also be wary of approving expenditures that are tied to the actions of other states, even if they isolate their own revenue, as is done with RGGI. Administrative agencies that oversee enforcement of the compacts may also fall prey to political meddling and corruption, because appointees who run them are often friends of elected officials and there can be lax oversight of their activities. Governor Christie’s own woes involving the New York-New Jersey Port Authority’s links to the Bridgegate scandal point to such a reality. Like all legislation, compacts appear likely to succeed where participants are eager to join. On health care, the first states to consider them in recent years have been red states looking to dodge Obamacare—not blue states. In 2014, nine largely conservative states put forward their own Health Care Compact to get around the health-care law. The proposal promised to let the participating states use federal funds to run health-care programs, while allowing each member state to define priorities and administer programs at the state level. It stalled because of the unclear language of the legislation and the wariness of governors to give up states’ rights. Elridge sees new state leaders taking up health-care compacts again, but not before they know more about what a Trump administration plans to do. For now, he said, they seem to be “taking a wait-and-see approach.” When they choose to act, they may see fit to take matters into their own hands, but do so together.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › States CP › 1NC - Solvency

States solve and cause federal follow-on.

Hervey 17

Douglas Hervey, Director based in Salt Lake City and leads the Investor Services practice, Sean Mullin, and Austin Bordelon, State Single Payer And Medicaid Buy-In: A Look At California, New York, And Nevada, June 30, 2017, http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2017/06/30/state-single-payer-and-medicaid-buy-in-a-look-at-california-new-york-and-nevada/

Rising insurance premiums, lack of access, uncertainty, and commotion around Affordable Care Act (ACA) repeal, have all contributed to the growing discontent and unease surrounding health care reform. Pressure to act continues to mount. Insurance titans Humana, United Healthcare, and Aetna have all rolled-back participation on the ACA Marketplaces. Anthem recently announced that it would exit the Ohio health insurance Marketplace, potentially leaving at least 18 counties without an exchange plan next year. Missouri and Washington State are also facing similar Marketplace participation issues. States such as Alabama, Arizona, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, and Tennessee have seen individual market exchange premiums increase more than 45 percent since 2016. Furthermore, participating exchange plans are asking for steep rate increases for next year—averaging between 11.1 percent and 44.7 percent. These events have contributed to an economic and political climate ripe for disruptive legislation. While Congress and the current administration pursue solutions to address premium and access issues, more states are inserting themselves in the conversation. More than a dozen states have explored options to leverage federal 1332 and 1115 waivers, which would provide flexibility to develop market stabilizing programs and regulatory changes to their respective individual and Medicaid markets. More recently, a few state legislatures have leapfrogged one-off programs such as reinsurance or high-risk pools, and sought to create a truly different market structure. Three states’ legislatures, California, New York, and Nevada, have developed high-profile state-driven solutions to address consumer access and price-related concerns. While state-led waiver initiatives such as those from Alaska and Oklahoma are meant to provide an incremental stabilizing force to their respective markets, the models that California, New York, and Nevada legislatures proposed could fundamentally reshape the framework of state health markets more akin to what Massachusetts did 11 years ago. State Models These state legislative developments are essentially falling into two camps, termed “state single payer” and “Medicaid buy-in.” State single payer describes almost any system that creates a single coverage mechanism for health care that is administered through a centralized authority. California and New York fall into this first bucket. The Medicaid buy-in proposal that the Nevada legislature approved did not expand the Medicaid program to everyone, but it attempted to leverage the structure and negotiated rates of the Medicaid program to enable commercial insurance carriers to replicate these features in the private market. California On June 1, 2017, the California State Senate passed SB 562 23-to-14, creating what is known as “Healthy California”—a program intent on eliminating the segmentation of the health insurance market into different coverage types such as Medicare, Medicaid, employer-sponsored, and individual insurance. Instead, there would be a single health care market for everyone. The benefits would be simplified as individuals would not be subject to premiums, copayments, or deductibles. Medical, pharmaceutical, dental, vision, and long-term care would be provided to all residents—including undocumented immigrants—free of charge. The state would seek to pay providers Medicare rates, and a nine-person panel would administer the program. Experts estimate the program would cost approximately $400 billion per year—double California’s current budget. California could cover about $200 billion from current federal and state spending—including Medicaid and Medicare. An additional $100 to $150 billion would come from what employers are already spending. The additional funding needed could involve a 15.0 percent payroll tax, a 2.3 percent sales tax, and/or a business tax increase. On Friday, June 23, Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon decided to hold the bill within the Assembly Rules Committee until further notice. While Rendon’s actions did not entirely kill the bill, it will not be revived until next year. The bill may have a stronger prospect for passage next year if more thoughtful attempts to address financing, care delivery, and cost controls emerge. New York On Tuesday, May 16, the New York State Assembly passed a bill (A.5062) that resembles California’s in several core ways. Universal statewide coverage would be provided throughout the state, and enrollees would no longer be subject to out-of-pocket costs or network restrictions. This is the fourth time in recent history that the State Assembly has passed a similar bill. The savings or costs—depending on who you talk to—range anywhere from $45 billion in savings to a need for $225 billion in tax increases. A hike of approximately $90 billion in annual new tax revenue appears to be the consensus estimate. Identified funding sources would be progressive payroll taxes and/or non-earned income tax increases. Nevada Nevada’s State Assembly and Senate recently passed a bill that was unique in its own merits but not quite as transformative. AB374—known as “Sprinkle care”—after its namesake State Rep. Mike Sprinkle (D) who introduced the bill—focused reforms solely on the individual insurance market and directed the state to contract with insurers to offer a commercial health plan based on the state’s Medicaid coverage. Employer-sponsored insurance and Medicare would have been maintained, but a commercial insurance product resembling the state’s Medicaid coverage would have provided consumers a new option. The plan would have offered a different benefit structure and leveraged the state’s lower Medicaid reimbursement rates. On June 17, Nevada’s Republican Governor, Brian Sandoval, vetoed the bill hours before it would have become law. The bill’s failure may speak more to its hasty drafting than its potential to serve as a roadmap for future legislation. While Gov. Sandoval expressed concerns of moving too fast too soon without solid factual foundations, a more thoughtful version of Nevada’s plan could serve as a model for future legislation within Nevada or other states. Possible Implementation Scenarios First off, it’s important to note that any single-payer model proposed by California and New York are likely years away from implementation as significant market restructuring and government infrastructure would need to be in place to enact such a drastic shift. Nevada proposed its solution be implemented in 2019, which was aggressive given that much of the plan’s details were not fully developed (the original bill is only four pages). We foresee three potential scenarios playing out across the state legislative movements: limited adoption, a Massachusetts-like scenario in which the federal government uses a state’s plan as a blueprint for national reform, or nothing happens at all. Under the limited adoption model, a state such as California passes a single-payer model, and other like-minded and potentially neighboring states adopt similar models over time. For example, one could envision California passing a bill that Oregon and Washington later adopted and tweaked according to the needs of their specific populations. Further adoption would be limited, however, given many states’ reticence to increase taxes, adversely affect their labor markets, and abandon private-sector solutions. In a Massachusetts-like scenario, a state such as New York, California, or some other state adopts a single-payer model that serves as a template for a federal single-payer approach. Just as Massachusetts provided a roadmap for the ACA’s enactment, a trailblazer state could provide a workable model for an expanded federal government single-payer program. A final scenario assumes that states either do not pass single-payer or other disruptive models given consumer and business community pushback or the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services does not grant federal waivers necessary to implement the programs. As to the latter point, there will be a host of regulatory hurdles and waiver applications necessary under any of these models, and getting approval could be challenging despite the prospect of increased waiver flexibility within the current administration. Let us consider Nevada, given that it was likely the least disruptive of the three proposals. The designation of a commercialized Medicaid policy as a Qualified Health Plan and the potential application of federal tax credits toward such a product may have required the use of Section 1332 to apply for a State Innovation Waiver. Alternatively, current federal law prohibits a state from using federally matched Medicaid funding to reimburse a health care provider for services provided to a person who earns more than 138 percent of the federal poverty level or for other expenses that are unrelated to the administration of Medicaid. To the extent that the Nevada Care Plan relied on state or federal Medicaid dollars, the state may have also needed to consider applying for a Section 1115 or similarly oriented Medicaid waiver. These waivers were never crafted, and it’s unknown if the current administration would have been receptive to these changes. At least for the short run, the “nothing happens” scenario has a high probability of playing out. Other states have tried and failed to create single-payer systems in the past. For example, consider the original Washington State effort in the early 1990s, Vermont’s attempt a couple years ago, and Colorado’s failed ballot measure last year. Potential Local And National Impact What would happen to markets if states passed legislation resembling any of these models? The answer depends on the model. In the California and New York scenarios, private insurance companies and brokers would cease to operate within the state. If a single-payer model spread to other states and/or the federal government, then the insurance and brokerage markets would be decimated. It is beyond this post’s scope to discuss in meaningful detail consumer implications associated with the various models. One thing is certain, consumer premium, coinsurance, and copayment responsibilities would either drop completely or be heavily reduced. Accessibility would improve in the sense that more people would have coverage, but it would also depend on agreed reimbursement rates and the percentage of providers who would be willing to accept new patients. Even if a state passed legislation, implementation could eventually become unworkable as was the case in Vermont. In a Nevada-like scenario, private payers would continue to compete for Medicaid insurance lives as the state leverages aspects of the Medicaid program to reform commercial markets. Brokers would continue to sell group and individual market plans. Employers would continue to offer insurance, although fewer would likely offer over time given the tax advantages associated with qualified small employer health reimbursement arrangements. Regardless of what scenario occurs, the broader industry trend of states engaging in thoughtful attempts to innovate amid difficult market conditions is one that will likely have broader impacts across the country. While the US health insurance system is unique in its reliance on the private market to facilitate and manage health care coverage, much of the regulatory construct of the market is still shaped by the federal government. As more states seek to develop their own unique systems and solutions, we appear to be in a time where states are truly the laboratories of health care policy.

2023 CNDI Negative
Off-Case › Cap K › Link

The 1AC is part of a broader post-political shift

Nappalos ’17 (S Nicholas, Nurse and Writer, “What’s at stake in the health care debate?,” Recomposition: Stories About Work and Resistance, March 2017)

The 2016 election cycle has shown that health care is lining up to be a key fight in the next few years. The Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare) is looking increasingly weak as soaring costs of insurance, drugs, and equipment are eroding whatever meager benefits there were in reigning in the all consuming burden of the American health system.1 Bernie Sanders made a medicare-for-all proposal a cornerstone of his campaign, something which the National Nurses United (NNU) and Our Revolution has vowed to keep fighting for.2 Colorado had a similar single-payer plan on the ballot where insurance bureaucracies would have been replaced by a state-run insurance program, but would retain private health institutions and medical industries.3 Hilary Clinton fended off the insurgent challenge of Bernie supporters, but not without having to pay lip service to their cause.4 Poll after poll demonstrates popular support for nationalized health programs across Americans.5 While Clinton indicated a need to revisit the vague “public option” Wikileaks later exposed her method of dividing her private positions, disclosed to Wall Street firms in her infamous paid speeches, and a separate public one.6 None of this is earth shattering, but it shows that all the power brokers have been honed in on health. A slow moving crisis It looks to become even more central however. Estimates are the medicare funds will have to reduce benefits within two decades.7 States that did not expand Medicaid have offered private market based plans that within a few years are already not affordable even with subsidies.8 Where Medicaid was expanded projections for expenses are to rise significantly putting strain on already underfunded systems that suffer from severe shortages of specialists and resources.9 In reality we are witnessing the slow unfolding of a multi-decade health care crisis. Health-related spending makes up roughly a quarter of the entire federal budget and is expanding rapidly. Medicare, Medicaid, and Children’s Health Insurance Programs alone represent 16% of the federal budget and are projected to grow substantially.10 It is the largest portion of federal spending outpacing both social security and the military. The drivers of this are our nearly singular combination of unregulated profiteering industries and particularly pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, and a multi-layered mediating bureaucracy that introduces inefficiencies into an already top heavy industry. The American health crisis is deepening not only because of excessive bureaucracy introduced by the byzantine insurance system, but also due to its embrace of both protecting industry through strict intellectual property [ip] rights and placing barriers to any regulation of prices for pharmaceuticals and equipment. It’s worth noting that health insurance and hospitals themselves are barely profitable with the median around 3% which is near inflation levels only. The profit tends to go to all the feeder industries selling products used by patients and purchased by health institutions.11 An Institute of Medicine report identified nearly 800 billion dollars in waste created by unnecessary services, excess administration, inefficient service delivery, overcharging, fraud, and failing to utilize potential preventative measures.12 These factors have made it the most expensive health system in the world.13 The people of the United States pay more than any other country for our health care, and with poor outcomes across a wide array of metrics. The political implications of this are not hard to see. The more political discourse digs in around the health system as a test of capitalism itself, the stiffer the resistance to reforming the obvious and preventable issues with it. The main players still see defense of vested interests in health care as an ideological defense of capitalism. Holding to that position increases public spending however and is increasing the federal deficit each year. Dismantling the drivers of those costs, in private hands, would lead to real economic losses with implications for the world market. Some authors have noted that pharmaceuticals were the stars of the market for decades, and have been in a decline that has not been recovered.14 Further cutting into those losses may have more disruptive effects in an economy that already has challenges ahead represented by geopolitical conflicts in Asia and Europe, and an anemic recovery to the global economic crisis of 2008. With the failure of Colorado is to forge ahead (and other states before it) and the victory of the Republicans across the board in this year’s election, meaningful reform seems quite unlikely in absence of a movement that can force their hands. Some other states may try the route of the ballot initiatives that failed in Colorado, Oregon, or Vermont’s legislature’s push. The disparity of forces between vested capitalist interests and their lobbying power and the electoral process itself makes it a near certainty of failure without a widespread popular change in attitude and action. Can single-payer save us? These problems will not go away for the rulers simply by ignoring them. With a single-payer program there would be substantial savings for the country as a whole and indeed millions of people will have their lives changed for the better. Any reduction in the vast waste that we’re chained to and an expansion in access to quality care is something we should cheer and fight for. Single payer would reduce some of these costs, in part through eliminating unnecessary layers of bureaucracy and negotiating lower prices through economies of scale. This has been the traditional progressive answer for these reasons to all things health related. Despite whatever positives however the fundamentals would remain, with much of the control in the hands of the same drug companies, equipment and product manufacturers, and broken institutionalized practices of American medical professionals (such as reliance on specialists, the persistence of fee for service payment, and over use of capital intensive health techniques). Cutting the costs of the insurance industry would be a positive step, but it’s not a panacea, and it’s not clear whether it could prevent a crisis that is already happening. Universal Medicare would certainly be more expensive than the system of the Veterans’ Administration (VA). One Congressional Budget Office study showed the VA to be twenty one percent cheaper than care under Medicare.15 The VA which shares some similarities to the National Health Service of the UK wherein the system owns the entirety of health services from hospitals, pharmacies, equipment, and hires the staff. By eliminating paying outside private entities, the VA and NHS thereby reduces the profit otherwise paid to private companies at each stage. While Medicare-for-all would eliminate insurers as secondary payers, such companies are deeply entangled in Medicare itself. Private companies provide supplemental plans for necessary services not covered by Medicare and as well as processing claims for Medicare itself.16 Without an elimination of private billing for services those additional administrative costs would remain. Medicare-for-all would not mean an end to Blue Cross, Aetna, or United Health necessarily. Nor should health advocates glamorize European style public health. Across the world public health is under attack. Right and left governments have target slashing spending and limiting access. Ideology certainly is a component of this, but objective budget pressures are driving these forces. Universal public health care is worthy, but it is not a panacea. Americans would likely face the same attacks even were there such a victory as institutional pressure to put the burden of care onto the working class will remain. If legislation granting universal Medicare is unlikely, VA-for-all is a lone voice in the wilderness. One could imagine the resistance likely to nationalizing private hospitals, clinics, and pharmacies. And yet if there is no substantial reform, what is the real cost paid to all of those services with a shrinking working population, jobs being lost to automation, and a growing base of those who will need care for decades? Should conflicts heat up, what would be the effect on the market if health advocates won such a struggle and take health institutions outside of the world of profit so to speak? Health care is at the center of stressing both market and state forces and this presents an opportunity for movements that challenge capitalism. This crisis in health is not just about the policies of different players (liberal and conservative, socialist and reactionary), but about more fundamentally capitalism’s capacity to provide for health needs. Market allocation and private industry are central to the failures of the American system, things not easily hidden when confronted head on. Globally speaking the industries that profit off health, both public and private systems, have been some of the leaders for investors generally. Losses within health care could spell deep trouble for the economy across the board and perhaps tip us back into recession or depression in the context of a world that has not fully recovered from the shocks of 2008. Even in countries with overtly state-provided healthcare similar elements of crisis have been building in the past decades around run away costs, shortages, and declining quality of care. Health care is a key sector for radicals to make our case and put the ruling class on the defensive. Health is bigger than our health care Demanding universal health care has been a broad call amongst US progressives for the past 50 years or so. Is that really the main issue though? At its heart single-payer is about how we allocate existing health resources. Yet we do not only want to more equitably and economically distribute health, but also improve it. If you think about it, universal health is a fairly open demand. It could be redirected to any number of outcomes including universally terrible health. There is an insidious medical apartheid that punishes various sectors (workers, women, blacks, latinos, and indigenous, etc.) while granting luxury health services to a tiny elite. There is a clear move towards diminishing care for the public in general with overall declining standards of living. This year life expectancy declined for the first time in decades without much protest or reaction from the political establishment.17 Instead we are utilizing our collective resources towards the high-tech capital intensive care that benefits a tiny section of the population. Merely asserting universal care without contesting the monopoly on wealth and power that the entrenched capitalist class wields would not fundamentally change the exclusion of the working and under classes from quality health care.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › AT: Aff Reduces Costs

Single Payer healthcare would cost too much, reducing costs leads to huge healthcare negatives

Sanger-Katz 16 (Margot Sanger-Katz is a domestic correspondent for The New York Times, where she writes about health care for The Upshot, the Times site about politics, economics and everyday life, “A Single-Payer Plan From Bernie Sanders Would Probably Still Be Expensive,” The New York Times, May 18, 2016, ) LAB

But also last week, a detailed analysis of the Sanders health care plan from researchers at the Urban Institute showed that it would probably cost the government double what the campaign proposed. It is the second credible analysis to suggest that the Sanders plan costs more than advertised. (The other comes from the Emory health policy professor Kenneth Thorpe.) The Sanders plan is light on some key details, but even in sketch form, it seems clear that it would require even bigger tax increases than the sizable ones the campaign has called for. If you look around the world, lots of countries have single-payer systems. And all of them pay substantially less for health care than we do in the United States. I am reminded of this often, in the comments by readers in some of my articles. So how could a single-payer system here still be so expensive? Health Care in the United States Private Equity’s Takeover: A new study has found that private equity firms have been gobbling up physician practices to form powerful medical groups across the country. Drug Shortages: The nation’s monthslong shortage of highly potent cancer drugs is grinding on, forcing patients and their doctors to confront gut-wrenching situations and delays in treatment. Medicare Advantage: People enrolled in these private plans may not be getting the mental health services they need because they cannot find a psychiatrist within their network, according to a new study. A Moral Crisis: The corporatization of health care has changed the practice of medicine, causing many physicians to feel alienated from their work. One reason is that the Sanders plan covers far more than typical insurance plans in the United States — or abroad. The Sanders plan would charge no premiums, require no out-of-pocket spending and would pay for services like dental care and long-term nursing home stays. Those things boost the total price tag. But imagine a universe where we had a single-payer health plan that was more like normal insurance. Perhaps it would be a true “Medicare for all,” where everyone has exactly the insurance that the federal government currently provides to older people and the disabled. That Medicare-for-all plan would still cost more than single-payer plans in other countries. Here’s why: Medicare pays doctors and hospitals higher prices than single-payer systems do in other countries. “The big thing is that providers here make quite a bit more money than they do anywhere else, and in order to get in the ballpark of where these other countries are, you’d have to reduce payment rates to physicians to much, much lower levels,” said John Holahan, one of the authors of the Urban analysis. “That’s just hard to do.” Editors’ Picks I Dated a Celebrity. Do I Have to Tell My Wife? She Steals Surfboards by the Seashore. She’s a Sea Otter. Men Are Baring Midriffs in Crop Tops SKIP ADVERTISEMENT The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, which looks at a group of developed countries, has found that the United States pays substantially higher prices for doctors, hospital stays and prescription drugs than the rest of the group. Medicare pays less than the United States average, but not enough less to make up that difference. Making the American health care system significantly cheaper would mean more than just cutting the insurance companies out of the game and reducing the high administrative costs of the American system. It would also require paying doctors and nurses substantially lower salaries, using fewer new and high-tech treatments, and probably eliminating some of the perks of American hospital stays, like private patient rooms. The average family physician in the United States earns $207,000, according to the Medscape Physician Compensation Report. General practitioners in Britain, which has a single-payer system, earn an average pay of around $130,000. The gaps in pay for specialists are even bigger. The Urban Institute report assumes that the Sanders plan would cut pay for doctors substantially, but not by half. That’s a reasonable assumption. We also pay more for drugs than the rest of the world, but many experts think that a single-payer health plan could push down drug prices because drug companies earn such high profit margins. The Urban analysis assumes that the country could quickly get to prices 25 percent lower than what Medicare pays. (That change assumes a political revolution, of course, because the pharmaceutical companies are an extremely effective lobby.) The Sanders campaign and its academic allies dispute some of the Urban Institute’s assumptions. A critique of the Urban analysis from David Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, professors of public health at the City University of New York, argues, for example, that drug prices could be pushed even lower. And the Sanders team says that the researchers overestimated the costs associated with administering the government program. But it doesn’t argue that the prices paid to medical providers could be cut more sharply. The same problem exists for other attempts to reduce health spending in the United States. Efforts by the Obama administration to pay doctors and hospitals differently are designed to squeegee some waste out of the system, by eliminating extra care that may not help people’s health. But it has done little to change the prices paid for medical care. That means that its best hope is to “bend the cost curve,” or reduce the rate that health spending grows. Republican proposals to make health care into more of a free market also tend to assume that they will slow spending growth, not actually reduce it. The Sanders plan would require a huge reorganization of the country’s health care system. Overnight, it would put the private insurance industry out of business, along with many other businesses that support it. It would shift billions of dollars of spending from individuals, workers and states into the federal budget. Doing that might well reduce some of the country’s health care spending that is going toward insurer profits and paper-pushing. But more than 80 percent of the dollars we currently spend on health care actually go toward health care. And making big cuts all at once to doctors and hospitals could cause substantial disruptions in care. Some hospitals would go out of business. Some doctors would default on their mortgages and student loans. Even if the country decided that medicine should become a more middle-class profession — not an obvious outcome, given the substantial public support for the medical professions — it would be difficult to get there at once. All of that means that bringing a government-run, single-payer health care system could achieve many of the goals of its advocates: more equity, lower complexity and some reductions in cost. But the United States would probably continue to have the most expensive health care system in the world. And we’d have to raise taxes high enough to pay for it.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › AT: Aff Reduces Costs

A single-payer system won’t reduce health care costs

McArdle 14 [Megan, Columnist at Bloomberg View former senior editor at The Atlantic, author of "The Up Side of Down: Why Failing Well Is the Key to Success," Bloomberg, 4-30-2014, https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2014-04-30/single-payer-would-make-health-care-worse#xj4y7vzkg]@RN

A few weeks back, I wrote a story on Vermont's adventures in single-payer health care. "So this is going to be expensive. So expensive that I doubt Vermont is actually going to go forward with it," I concluded. "This should be instructive for those who hope -- or fear -- that Obamacare has all been an elaborate preliminary to a nationwide single-payer system. It isn't. The politics are impossible, and even if they weren't, the financing would be unthinkable." I was inundated by complaints from proponents of more government intervention in the health-care system. Permit me to summarize the many individual exchanges I had with these interlocutors. Ah, you will say, but the U.S. is so much richer! We are the biggest rich country and the richest big country. Of course we spend more. There is indeed a strong, though not perfect, correlation between how rich a country is and how much it spends on health care. But that alone can't explain why we spend so much: Even if you look at spending as a fraction of national income, the U.S. is an outlier. The figures above are for 2010; we now spend close to 20 percent of our national income on health care. One in every five dollars earned goes to buy health-care services, while no other nation cracks 15 percent. The implication that many people draw from this is that the U.S. could realize fabulous savings from switching to a government-run health-insurance system. But wait: The U.S. already has a government health-care system. Actually, it has several: Medicare, Medicaid, Veterans Affairs, military, federal employee benefits, state and local government benefits. And this system already spends more per capita than most other rich-world governments: The numbers get a little better if you look at them as a percentage of gross domestic product. But not much better. We are spending almost as high a percentage of gross domestic product as every other country, just to cover a fraction of our population. How can that be? Well, let's think about the general theories of why government makes health care cheaper. The first idea is that you get big discounts for buying in bulk. Because governments cover a lot of people, they can negotiate the best prices, which can't be matched in America's fragmented market. The problem with this idea is that U.S. health insurers already buy in bulk. They cover more people than many of the countries cited as cost-control models for the U.S.: A more sophisticated version of this argument says that the power comes from setting prices and controlling administrative costs. This is the idea behind a "public option." But we already have a public option. As mentioned, we have several. And Medicare doesn't control costs noticeably better than the private sector does: Medicaid controls costs significantly better. That's because it's a program for poor people who don't vote much, and politicians don't necessarily care if doctors refuse to take it. So states set reimbursement rates that are so low that you could pay more to take your kid to Panera than the government would pay for you to take him to see a general practitioner. On the other hand, seniors vote, and thus, politicians are very reluctant to tinker with reimbursements. Prices are set the way that other governments set them -- by a centralized committee. But they're set high. There are two potential outcomes for a "public option" health insurer: It could set rates high, in which case it wouldn't control costs, or it could jam them down to Medicaid levels, in which case no one but the very healthy or the very desperate would buy that insurance because it will be hard to actually use that coverage. That brings us to the most sophisticated version of the argument: that we can use monopoly power to bring our health-care spending in line with that of other countries. As long as there is private-sector competition, the argument goes, prices will stay high, because doctors can refuse to accept government reimbursement. But if the government is the single provider of health care (or at least, the single price setter), then we can drive down reimbursements and drug prices to something approaching European levels. This idea has a number of problems, starting with its constitutionality. Here's a big one: Most of the time, since the 1980s, growth in government spending has been higher than total growth, not lower. This represents coverage expansion, as well as price growth. What it does not represent is significant cost control. Think that's just because conservative ideologues are preventing the government from doing its job and controlling costs? Well, here's an even bigger problem with the idea that getting government involved is going to bring our costs down: What's the problem? I hear you cry. Well, the problem is what you don't see in that picture. What you don't see is any government cutting health spending by any significant amount. Oh, Germany managed, once. Canada kept it level for a while. But no one has cut by anything like 35 to 40 percent -- which is what we'd need to get our spending in line with Canada's. I've only shown a few countries, to keep the graph easy to read, but these examples aren't cherry picked, except that they're big rich countries like us. When you dig into the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development data, you don't see any government, anywhere, making sustained cutbacks in the health-care system, except for situations such as in Greece, which cut back substantially in the middle of an economic meltdown and a sustained run on its government debt. Absent the impetus that a whopping financial crisis provides, at best, you see them hold down cost growth. Holding down growth rates is feasible -- give people a smaller bump in what they were expecting. Cutting spending is absurdly difficult, because it means cutting people's incomes. Incomes that they counted on to help make their mortgages and car payments. Maybe you don't feel so bad for expensive surgeons who have to sell the Bimmer, and I don't, either. But America's cost inflation is not just fancy surgeons. It's everything: surgeons, general practitioners, nurses, respiratory technicians, private hospital rooms, MRIs, CT scanners -- and I haven't even gotten to drug prices: It's theoretically possible that we could demand that all those folks take a pay cut. But so far, as the Official Blog Spouse chronicles, the U.S. political system hasn't even been able to get doctors to take a cut in their Medicare reimbursements, much less their whole incomes. Here's the basic electoral math: If you try to cut the incomes of doctors, nurses, radiology techs, phlebotomists, etc., voters may be glad of the price break, but I'd be surprised if 1 percent would go to the polls and vote for you because you're the guy who cut doctor reimbursements by 17 percent. On the other hand, 100 percent of the doctors, nurses, radiology techs and phlebotomists will storm the voting places and make sure that they cast their vote against the jerk who wants to cut their incomes and, oh, by the way, destroy American health care. Here's the advanced electoral math: Americans like and trust their health-care providers far more than they do their politicians or journalists, or, for that matter, practically anybody. So when you try to cut the reimbursements that fund their salaries, and all the providers band together to run ads claiming that cost-cutting, health-hating American politicians are trying to kill you in order to save a few measly dollars, guess who wins that showdown? We might be able to hold down future costs, but there is no evidence that we can cut the costs we already have back down to the level of those European nations that single-payer advocates like to cite. In fact, I'd say there's quite a bit of evidence to the contrary. Well, that's something, isn't it? Let's get a government system in there, get our cost growth down to the level of other OECD countries instead of the insane rates that our inefficient private system produces. Eventually, as the economy grows, health care will shrink relatively, if not absolutely, and the proportion of national income that Americans spend on health care will come to resemble that of the rest of the world. Here's the problem with that idea: America doesn't have a cost-growth problem. The rate of cost growth in our "insane," "inefficient," "free market" system isn't particularly high by OECD standards. It's the level that's so high. We're growing at a normal rate, but off a much higher starting expenditure -- an expenditure that we've so far proven unable to cut by even a bit. We are not a nation that has a cost-growth problem; we're a nation that used to have a cost-growth problem, in the 1970s and 1980s: Once we pulled away from the other countries, even an average growth rate meant that the gap between our spending as a percentage of GDP, and theirs, would continue to widen -- especially if their GDP grew faster than ours for any length of time. That is why we cannot count on financing single-payer with the fabulous cost savings to be gained by making our system more like Europe's. Europe didn't gain fabulous cost savings by making their systems more like Europe's: Its nations started from a lower base, and held down cost growth, but they did not actually use single-payer systems to cut what they were spending. Once spending is in the system, it's hard to get rid of. I've already covered the political difficulties with using government power to take income away. But those aren't the only problems. For example, in the middle of the last century, the U.S. decided that private or at most two-person rooms were best, because they made it easier to control infection and to let patients rest. For decades, we built hospitals to this standard; when my mother was in the hospital for a complicated appendectomy, there weren't even any semi-private rooms on the surgical ward. Private rooms drive up costs in a lot of ways: They take up more space, you have to duplicate equipment, and because the nurses can't see the patients, you need more monitors and/or staff circulating to make sure no one has stopped breathing. Basic hospital rooms in many other countries look spartan and overcrowded compared with what most Americans are used to, because they have more people and fewer beeping machines. But even if we got a single-payer system tomorrow, we would not be able to do what those other countries have done, which is not build expensive single hospital rooms in the first place. Those hospitals were built over time, as funds became available and as the old buildings wore out. Trying to replace them all at once with semi-private rooms or wards would cost more than just sucking up the extra expense of the hospitals we have. Of course there are ways in which single-payer might be better. Whether the strengths outweigh the weaknesses is an argument best left for another day. Today I'll just finish by reiterating the point I made at the outset: The financing is impossible, in part because the politics is impossible. And the politics is impossible in part because the financial hit would be too big. Single-payer would have to be paid for at the extremely high prices that Americans pay, not the lower European prices that we'd rather have. And when you look at the taxes needed to finance a government takeover, you quickly realize that most people just aren't willing to pay the price.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › Alt Causes – Inequality

Unemployment and diminishing bargaining power contribute to rising inequality

Cooper and Mishel 23 (David Cooper is a senior researcher at the Economic Policy Institute and director of the Economic Analysis and Research Network (EARN). Lawrence Mishel is the former president of the Economic Policy Institute (2002–17) and retired as a distinguished fellow. He has a Ph.D. in economics from the University of Wisconsin–Madison. “America's Vast Pay Inequality Is a Story of Unequal Power.” American Bar Association. 1/06/23. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/wealth-disparities-in-civil-rights/americas-vast-pay-inequality-is-a-story-of-unequal-power/)

Our organization, the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), has rigorously documented the factors that explain the divergence between productivity and worker compensation—effectively, the choices that have suppressed wage growth for most U.S. workers. The largest and most obvious factor is excessive unemployment. The Federal Reserve (Fed) is charged with the dual mandate of pursuing the maximum level of employment consistent with stable inflation. However, since 1979, while the Fed has aggressively sought to tame inflation, it has been far more tolerant of high unemployment. Operating under the theory that tighter labor markets inevitably lead to higher inflation as rising wages push up consumer prices, the Fed has consistently reined in job growth by hiking interest rates whenever unemployment approached the allegedly “natural rate,” regardless of whether there was any evidence that inflation was on the rise. Congressional and state lawmakers share culpability here too—until the COVID-19 pandemic-induced recession, fiscal policies to spur recoveries were weak and sometimes sabotaged by state-level austerity, as happened in the recovery after the Great Recession. The result was an unemployment rate that averaged 6.3 percent from 1979 through 2017, a full percentage point higher than during the previous three decades, denying workers the opportunity to benefit from tighter labor markets. (When jobs are plentiful, workers have more leverage to demand higher pay because the implicit threat of an outside job option becomes more real.) Our research estimates that had unemployment averaged 5.5 percent (a modest goal) rather than 6.3 percent, median wages would have been 10 percent higher in 2017. Had the unemployment rate averaged 5 percent, median wages would have been 18 percent higher. The erosion of collective bargaining was the second most important factor. In 1979, 27 percent of U.S. workers were union members. By 2019, less than 12 percent of the workforce was unionized. This drop in unionization occurred across many industries, the result of increasingly aggressive corporate anti-union practices, weak labor laws, and the proliferation of an entire industry of union-avoidance consultants that emerged in the 1980s. EPI estimates that the drop in collective bargaining suppressed wages at the median by 7.9 percent overall and by 11.6 percent for the median male worker. The third most significant factor was globalization; however, it’s again critical to recognize that globalization occurred through the intentional corporate and political choices that deliberately offshored manufacturing and drove increased imports from low-wage nations. This reduced wages by roughly 5.6 percent, or about $2,000 annually, for a full-time U.S. worker earning the median wage. These three factors alone—excessive unemployment, eroded collective bargaining, and corporate-driven globalization—can account for more than half of the divergence between net productivity and median hourly compensation. The COVID-19 pandemic was an inflection point in these trends. The federal government’s unprecedented relief programs—broad expansions to unemployment insurance and direct cash assistance to households—provided millions of workers left jobless by lockdowns with a financial cushion that kept them afloat until the economy reopened. This, combined with a jobs recovery that was dramatically faster than previous ones—again, a result of strong federal relief programs—has given workers more bargaining power than they have had in decades. Ample job openings have facilitated quitting to take a new, better job. Consequently, wage growth since early 2021 for low-wage workers has been strong. High rates of inflation, caused by pandemic-induced supply chain snarls and exacerbated by the war in Ukraine, have moderated the impact of these gains, but not entirely. Low-wage workers have experienced real wage growth over the past year, narrowing slightly the gap between those in the middle and those at the bottom of the pay distribution. However, the high inflationary period has been a boon for corporate profits—meaning those at the top have pulled even further away from everyone else. Reversing the United States’ seemingly unstoppable growth in inequality will require doing more to empower America’s workers. The pandemic recovery illustrates what is possible: a tight labor market, precipitated by strong government protections against financial hardship, and greater public salience around adjacent aspects of job quality—e.g., access to paid sick leave, childcare, remote work—have spurred greater worker organizing, interest in unions, and measurable wage gains in many sectors. Whether this momentum will be sustained remains to be seen; without reforming weak and outdated labor laws, America’s working class still faces an uphill battle.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › Alt Causes – Inequality

Wage stagnation fuels rising inequality – the aff doesn’t solve

Cooper and Mishel 23 (David Cooper is a senior researcher at the Economic Policy Institute and director of the Economic Analysis and Research Network (EARN). Lawrence Mishel is the former president of the Economic Policy Institute (2002–17) and retired as a distinguished fellow. He has a Ph.D. in economics from the University of Wisconsin–Madison. “America's Vast Pay Inequality Is a Story of Unequal Power.” American Bar Association. 1/06/23. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/wealth-disparities-in-civil-rights/americas-vast-pay-inequality-is-a-story-of-unequal-power/)

Over the past five decades, growing wage inequality has been one of the defining features of the American economy. Since the late 1970s, inflation-adjusted pay for most U.S. workers has largely stagnated, while pay for the country’s highest earners has skyrocketed. This sluggish wage growth for middle-income Americans has been widely acknowledged and recognized by economists and politicians across the political spectrum. Yet, the root causes of these trends have frequently been wrongly attributed as an unfortunate result of apolitical market forces that one neither can nor would want to alter, such as automation and globalization. In fact, disappointing wage growth for most workers in the U.S. economy was not an unintended consequence—it was the intentional outcome of legislative, regulatory, and corporate policies deliberately implemented to constrain labor costs, decisions made on behalf of the rich and corporations and validated by many economists. Bargaining power is the central though often unspoken determinant of wage outcomes. Generations of economics students have been taught that markets efficiently set wages through supply and demand and that an individual worker’s pay reflects their productivity. This naive textbook model assumes that employees and employers have equal bargaining power, that any worker being underpaid relative to the value they produce for a firm can simply quit and find a better-paying option. But this perfect textbook market is the exception, not the rule. Employers almost always have disproportionate bargaining power, and for much of the last half-century, public policy has been shaped to ensure that outcome. The simplest illustration of this unequal bargaining power is shown in the divergence between labor productivity and typical worker compensation. Between 1979 and 2019, economy-wide productivity (the amount of income generated in an average hour of work, net of depreciation) grew by 59.7 percent, while the compensation (wages plus benefits) of the median U.S. worker rose by only 13.7 percent—a 46 percentage point divergence between the growth in value of what American workers produced and what the typical worker was paid. During this time, the bottom 90 percent of U.S. workers experienced wage growth slower than the economy-wide average, while top wage earners (mostly in finance and corporate management) and owners of capital reaped large rewards made possible only by this anemic wage growth for the bottom 90 percent. Three wage gaps aptly describe how pay has diverged over the last four decades: the gap between low- and middle-wage workers, the gap between middle-wage and highly paid workers, and the gap between the very highest-paid earners and everyone else. From 1979 to 2019, wages for the lowest wage workers—measured by the tenth percentile wage—barely budged over a 40-year stretch, rising just 3 percent after inflation. Remarkably, the bulk of this minuscule growth occurred only in the more recent past. Wages for low-wage workers fell drastically during the 1980s when the federal minimum wage was frozen amid high inflation. Since 1988, the gap between low-wage workers and middle-wage workers has shrunk somewhat but remains larger today than it was in 1979. As already noted, wage growth in the middle has been sluggish, with median pay rising just 13.7 percent from 1979 to 2019. In contrast, annual pay for high earners, measured as those in the 90th to 95th percentiles, rose by 51.8 percent over this same period. Still, this pales in comparison to pay growth for those at the top. From 1979 to 2019, the wages of the top 1 percent rose by 160 percent after inflation, while wages rose 345 percent for the highest 0.1 percent of earners. A major factor driving these changes was the astronomical growth in CEO compensation at large firms, which rose nearly 1,200 percent from 1978 to 2019. As a result of this astronomical growth, these workers’ share of the pie has doubled: the top 0.1 percent went from receiving 1.6 percent of overall earnings in 1979 to 5 percent by 2019, while the top 1 percent share rose from 7.3 percent to 13.2 percent. In summary, wage growth for the vast majority—those in the bottom 90 percent—has been relatively weak, while those in the top 10 percent, especially those in the top 1 percent, have done exceedingly well.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › Alt Causes – Bioterror

The aff isn’t enough – deterring bioterror requires securing US labs, building stockpiles of PPE, and collaborating internationally

Pavel and Venkatram ‘21

Barry Pavel and Vikram Venkatram, 2021, Barry senior vice president and director of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council, Vikram senior vice president and director of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council, “Facing the future of bioterrorism.”, Atlantic Council, July 13th 2023, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/commentary/article/facing-the-future-of-bioterrorism/

Given the broad scope and scale of this growing threat, the United States should take a series of actions to mitigate the risks, without unduly stunting the growth of the biotechnology field. To date, bioterrorist attacks have been low-risk, high-impact events. While they have been extremely rare, their frequency will only increase as will their ramifications. However, overregulating the spread of biotechnological tools could stunt innovation and the profound potential of this increasingly important sector. Furthermore, existing methods of preventing bioterrorism may no longer be effective. The government could previously monitor the purchase of expensive and dangerous biotechnology tools and the laboratories that owned them in large quantities. This is no longer possible to the same degree when such tools are increasingly cheap, widespread, and usable in a garage. The FBI is currently attempting to address this risk by building relationships with the iGEM community and with life scientists so that they can report suspicious behavior. These efforts should continue, but are wildly insufficient, since some bioterrorists may have minimal contact with the larger community of biologists and biology hobbyists.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › No Solvency – Inequality

Medical Care disproportionately expensive for the middle class – increases inequality and turns the aff

Gordon 22 [Deb Gordon, co-director of the Alliance of Professional Health Advocates and the author of The Health Care Consumer’s Manifesto: How to Get the Most for Your Money, BA in bioethics from Brown University and an MBA with distinction from Harvard Business School, “With Inflation Rising, Medical Costs Hurt The Middle Class Most, New Report Shows,” Forbes, 3-30-2022, https://www.forbes.com/sites/debgordon/2022/03/30/with-inflation-rising-medical-costs-hurt-the-middle-class-most-new-report-shows/?sh=66861bf62088]@RN

With inflation growing 7.9% last month—a rate not seen in the United States since the 1980s—experts worry there may be no end in sight. But for all the media attention focused on rising gas and grocery prices, the real pain consumers increasingly feel is due to healthcare costs, according to new research released today. The new report from the Center for the New Middle Class measures the level of financial strain—none, some, or a lot—caused by a range of household costs, as reported by individual consumers. The report compares the strain on Americans with FICO credit scores below 700—known as non-prime consumers—to those with higher scores—known as prime consumers. In the last quarter of 2021, the number of households reporting that normal expenses were causing a lot of strain on their finances rose sharply, particularly for non-prime Americans. Utility costs caused financial strain for the most non-prime Americans, but the biggest increase in strain for this group was healthcare, which rose more starkly than any other category of expense. Overall, 31% of non-prime Americans reported financial strain due to out-of-pocket healthcare costs—a nearly 50% increase between October 2021 and February 2022 compared to the pre-pandemic period. In contrast, 23% of prime Americans reported strain due to healthcare costs, still substantial but just a 3-point increase from before the pandemic. One-quarter of non-prime Americans said the cost of health insurance was causing them strain—a greater than 50% jump since before the pandemic. "We’ve known for years that the cost of healthcare squeezes American households, but non-prime Americans in particular are increasingly strained by healthcare costs as overall inflation takes its toll,” said Jonathan Walker, executive director of the Center for the New Middle Class and the report’s author. “The increase in the number of households that are feeling the pinch is concerning.”

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › No Solvency – Inequality

Single payer healthcare doesn’t solve inequality – it makes most Americans financially worse off

Haislmaier and Hall 19 (Edmund Haislmaier is an expert in health care policy and markets at The Heritage Foundation, Jamie Hall is a quantitative analyst at the center for Data Analysis, “How “Medicare for All” Harms Working Americans,” The Heritage Foundation, November 19, 2019, https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2019-11/SR219.pdf)

That assertion is incorrect. Our analysis finds that in order to fund such a program, it would be necessary for the federal government to impose substantial, broad-based taxes equal to 21.2 percent of all wage and salary income. Those taxes would be in addition to the payroll taxes that most workers already pay for the existing Social Security and Medicare programs, bringing total payroll taxes to 36.5 percent for most workers.3 We also find that nearly two-thirds of American households (65.5 percent, comprising 73.5 percent of the population) would experience reductions in their disposable income, making them financially worse off. Those households would pay more in new taxes to fund the program than they would save as a result of the program eliminating their current spending on private health insurance and out-of-pocket medical expenses. After accounting for both the tax increases and the reductions in private spending for health insurance and medical care, we find that average annual household disposable income would decline by $5,671 (or 11 percent) under a new government-run health care program. Among households with employer-sponsored health benefits, 87.2 percent would be worse off financially under a new government-run health care program, and their annual disposable income would be $10,554 lower, on average. That would occur despite those households receiving wage increases, as employers responded to the new program by converting the value of current tax-free, employer-provided health benefits into additional taxable cash income.4 The reason: Workers would pay much higher taxes to fund the cost of the new program because workers would need to (1) replace their own private spending, (2) replace non-workers’ private spending, and (3) pay for the additional spending that would result from the program stimulating increased use of medical care.

2023 CNDI Negative
Single Payer Neg › AT: Solvency › No Solvency – Healthcare

Bureaucratic red tape slows any government response to a public health crisis. Covid proved that a single-payer system would be disastrous.

White 2020 (Kaylee McGhee White, Restoring America editor for the Washington Examiner, “Coronavirus shows again why 'Medicare for all' is a bad idea”, Washington Examiner, March 13, 2020, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/coronavirus-shows-again-why-medicare-for-all-is-a-bad-idea) VQ

As the coronavirus spreads, many are beginning to question the federal government’s ability to contain and mitigate this crisis. One group, however, remains confident that the government could do more if given the chance. That group is led by none other than Bernie Sanders, an out-and-proud socialist who is using the coronavirus outbreak to push for a single-payer healthcare system. COVID-19 and the current testing shortage, he improbably argues, is actually proof that the United States would be better served by a nationalized bureaucratic healthcare system. “It has never been more important to finally guarantee healthcare as a human right by passing Medicare for All,” he said in a Feb. 27 statement. Sanders isn’t the only one, either. Sen. Ed Markey issued a similar statement on Friday afternoon, and he was joined by several other Democrats. One glance at how this virus has affected the rest of the world, however, quickly dispels this idea. Italy, which has a single-payer healthcare system, has seen its hospitals overwhelmed. Hundreds of elderly citizens are going without treatment. Hundreds more have died already. Its system was woefully unprepared for this pandemic, and, as a result, the country has been unable to react to COVID-19's effects in a timely fashion. The result has been disastrous. In Britain, ventilators are in vastly short supply. Intensive care beds have already been filled, and doctors are beginning to tire, one physician told the New York Times. The British socialized healthcare system, which American socialists often tout as a base model, has been incapable of handling this outbreak, even though the United Kingdom has been dealing with far fewer cases than other parts of the world. The U.S. government can and should do more to help the public prepare for coronavirus’s continued spread. Already, the Trump administration has adopted a hands-on approach, working with health insurance companies to wave co-pays, partnering with Congress to provide two weeks of paid sick leave, and providing additional funding for small businesses as economic activity slows. The greatest amount of relief, however, has not come from the federal government but from the private sector. At least two vaccines have been submitted to the Food and Drug Administration for approval, and several private health companies, such as the Michigan-based NeuMoDx, have rolled out technology that can be adapted and used to test for the coronavirus. All of this happened within a matter of weeks. "You have to embrace the private sector," Anthony Fauci, the head of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, said during a press conference Friday afternoon. "You can't do it without it." Compare this to the federal government’s response, which has been lethargic at best and negligent at worst. We’ve known about this virus for months, yet the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s early screening process was “slow” and full of “missteps,” as Fauci has readily admitted. Even now, testing is severely limited in even the states that have done the most to expand it. The simple truth is that government is not very good at handling fast-paced, widespread problems. There is too much red tape, too much politicking, and too much fighting over territory. Just consider Washington Gov. Jay Inslee, whose unprofessional and partisan behavior is the norm in government. Rather than work constructively with the Trump administration on a bipartisan solution to a real-world problem, he went straight to blame-casting and name-calling the moment the first stateside infections reached his state. Despite all this, Sanders and the other socialists would have us believe that the solution is government intervention, more politicians and their egos, and more bureaucratic regulation. This is nonsense. We have the “best public health system in the world,” as former FDA Director Scott Gottlieb said last month. It is equipped with “the best infection control procedures, well-equipped hospitals, and skilled providers,” he explained. If any country can beat the coronavirus and come out on top, it will be the U.S. And we will have the free market to thank.