2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – Link Turn
Mary Lawhon and Tyler McCreary 3/6. Lawhon works in the School of Geosciences, University of Edinburgh and Global South Studies Centre, University of Cologne and McCreary works in the Department of Geography, Florida State University and Department of First Nations Studies, University of Northern British Columbia, 3-6-2023. “Making UBI radical: On the potential for a universal basic income to underwrite transformative and anti-kyriarchal change”, Economy and Society. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03085147.2022.2131278
Cash transfers underwriting radical change The second key distinction we work to make here is that cash transfers, and particularly a durable, redistributive UBI, might well induce much greater political economic change. If cash transfers were merely ameliorative, reducing economic inequality, this might be reason enough to support them. The argument we make here, however, is that the impacts of cash transfers go beyond this, and that a redistributive UBI might well be used to underwrite postcapitalist economies. Greater economic security and improved relations with the state and each other might well increase many people’s willingness and ability to participate in political economic change. Further, progressive scholars and activists might well be able to shape practice, highlighting the benefits of using increased funds and time to underwrite radical political economic change. What might the securing of a state-provided universal, unconditional basic income do? In what ways might embracing modest statecraft, changing relationships between citizens and the state, rework how we see and interact with the state and each other? We point to four interrelated possibilities here: (i) freed time might be used to participate in democracy, (ii) increased incomes might be used to support diverse economies, (iii) reduced reliance on the capitalist economy might enable greater regulation as well as social and ecological re-embedding, and (iv) reconfigured state-citizenship relations might also transform how people collectively understand themselves and the possibilities for change. These impacts are not given, but might be created as part of a radical politics. First, it is easy to imagine that a UBI might free up time and that this might well enable citizens to be more informed, active and engaged with politics (Fitzpatrick, 2004). Further, cash transfers – especially those with limited conditions – have not led to docile populations, but often to more politically engaged citizens who, at the very least, fight to keep these benefits. The position we develop here advances the idea that freeing up time is politically useful, building on this towards understanding the role of a UBI in enabling a different type of politics, and a different type of economy. Leftist scholarship has suggested that a UBI might enable improved bargaining power for labour by providing a ‘permanent strike fund’; even the threat of striking may increase the overall gains for workers (Calnitsky, 2017; Stern, 2016). In this version, a UBI is seen as a tool for enabling iterative change towards a more empowered working class: change can be demanded through the threat of labour withdrawal. We see value in such a position, but also emphasize the potential of a basic income as a means for the actual withdrawal from capitalist relations and a resource to be used to build new political economic relations. Above, we noted that most studies of cash transfers have deployed developmentalist lenses, yet there are some exceptions. Exploring the politics of Seminole gaming in which cash is transferred to community members, Cattelino (2008; see also Lewis, 2017) observes that money enables a degree of material autonomy. This economic independence has provided the conditions for indigenous cultural revitalization, freeing people from dependency on conditional government programmes. It also enables monetary supports for members to engage in activities, such as language instruction, that remain culturally meaningful although undervalued in the capitalist economy. More broadly, we can also reinterpret existing data through a critical lens. Studies of cash transfers have suggested that money is often spent locally and enables the creation of new businesses (Gertler et al., 2012; Ribas, 2020; Yang, 2018), and such practices might well shift funds away from corporations towards more embedded enterprises. In short, people often use the money from cash transfers to do just the kinds of things that many advocates of diverse economies would want to see: end their reliance on capitalism for income, start small businesses, spend money locally, and devote more time to socially valuable practices. There is already a substantial community of practice in and, primarily, beyond the academy devoted to building postcapitalist community economies; a UBI might well underwrite these economies that have proven difficult to sustain and expand in the unequal world we have. It might make it easier both to spend time as scholars and activists working to build these alternative relations and garner increased public participation. Further, separating incomes from local economies might well subtend particular political economic conflicts, enabling increasing regulation and embedding of markets. Elsewhere, we have argued that a UBI might enable a reworking of longstanding conflicts over environment and development by reducing the reliance of particular states and citizens on extractive developments (Lawhon & McCreary, 2020). Such reworked spatialities and dependencies might enable new pressures, a point that could be extended for other kinds of political economic conflict. Finally, while a single policy may not substantively change the state, there is evidence from studies of cash transfers as well as wider social theory to suggest that cash transfers can change how citizens think about and interact with each other and the state. One shift that we find compelling is that cash transfers (sometimes implicitly, sometimes explicitly) reframe the economy as, at least in part, collective. Ferguson (2015), for example, suggests thinking of cash transfers as ‘shares’ of the economy. Others have argued for cash transfers as a recognition of common ecological inheritance (Ranalli, 2020; Standing, 2019; Van Parijs, 1992). More broadly, it has been demonstrated that recipients feel a greater sense of social trust (Kangas et al., 2019). This enriched sense of collectivism might well shape willingness to participate in social change.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – Link Turn
Edgar Manjarin and Maciej Szlinder 16. Manjarin works in the Department of Philosophy at Adam Mickiewicz University and Szlinder works in the Department of Sociology at Universitat de Barcelona, 7-17-2016. “A Marxist Argumentative Scheme on Basic Income and Wage Share in an Anti-capitalist Agenda”, Basic Income Studies; Berkeley, vol. 11(1) p. 49-59.
To evaluate if a proposal is a revolutionary reform, i. e. leads to strengthening workers to enlarge their possibilities to put an end to capitalism and establish a new mode of production, implies asking about its effects on the wage share. This is what we propose that should be done with universal basic income, one of the most discussed proposals in recent years. How should it affect the dynamics of wage/ profit share? We argue that a basic income should lead to a rise of the share of wages in the GDP, by significantly improving their bargaining position in various ways. Firstly, the bargaining position of workers would improve due to the macro-economic consequences of implementing a basic income system. This reform, by redistributing income to the advantage of the poorer groups of the society would increase internal effective demand creating a better ground for profitable investments. That should induce investment, which depends on sales and expected profitability, which may increase employment and decrease the unemployment rate.8 The existence of a huge group of unemployed or, as Marx puts it, the industrial reserve army, creates a downward pressure on wages, because it plays a role of a scarecrow discouraging the workers from struggling for their rights, better conditions of labour and higher wages. As this role is directly proportional to the level of unemployment, the smaller it is the lesser intimidated the workers are. Secondly, basic income would increase the wage share, because it would get the workers away from the tight corner – as long as this benefit would exist, they would never have to worry about the survival of themselves and their families. Therefore, in the worst of cases they could resign from some particular job if they perceived it as not satisfactory (in terms of wage or working conditions) and have time to look for a better job (also in a different city or region). In this sense a basic income would obviously improve workers’ bargaining position, especially in the pay negotiations (Vanderborght, 2006, p. 5–6). Thirdly, apart from an individual bargaining power, a basic income could also have a positive effect on the collective bargaining power, especially during a strike. As Yannick Vanderborght puts it: ... a BI would make each single strike less harmful financially, since workers would keep their entitlement to a guaranteed income floor outside the labour market. With a BI, strikers would be able to face long-lasting resistance from employers, and the collective powers of unions would therefore be enhanced. (Vanderborght, 2006, p. 5) Finally, basic income, by giving security and time, guarantees everyone the possibility to engage in alternative relations of production, such as cooperatives, build alternative non capital-labour relationships (by decommodifying different aspects of social life), and organize politically to struggle for a better situation of working people (including using the state policies and institutions). So it can foster non-capitalist social activities, which are worth in and for themselves, as well as helping directly and indirectly to the emergence of collective action with anti-capitalist goals.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – Permutation
Carlo Fanelli and Jeff Noonan 17. Fanelli worked in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, Canada at the time of publication and Noonan is a professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Windsor, 4-20-2017. “Capital and Organized Labor”, Reading ‘Capital’ Today: Marx after 150 Years, edited by Ingo Schmidt and Carlo Fanelli, p. 153-157.
Conclusion: Socialism and the Continuum of Democratic Struggle
The need, therefore, for workers to go beyond traditional trade union based forms of struggle is unquestionable. At the same time, we exist at a moment of history where vanguard revolutionary parties have been discredited, and there is no evidence, in the European and North American contexts, that their fortunes will ever be revived. Thus the question remains: if trade unions and social democracy are incapable of solving the problems they address themselves to because they are not revolutionary, and the historical moment of vanguardist politics seems to have definitively passed, how is the struggle for socialism to be conducted today? The answer to that question lies in the creative intelligence of people in struggle; no theoretical intervention can substitute itself for political practice. What we aim to do in conclusion is not infer a new mode of struggle from abstract principles but instead try to draw out the implicitly radical significance of the struggles within capitalism (for higher wages, for free time, for public institutions) in support of the conclusion that socialism is part and parcel of the struggle for democracy, and the struggle for democracy (as all political struggles) should be understood along a continuum. Reconceiving the goals of struggle as progressively realizable frees the idea of revolution from the nineteenth century image of it as a one-off cataclysm, opening space for new ideas of organization and political strategy that are neither social democratic nor vanguardist (see Hudis, this volume). Here again, Lebowitz is an instructive starting point. He notes that even when struggles do not ‘transcend the capital/wage labour relation’, they can be significant for the life-value of working people’s lives because they express the fact that ‘a qualitative development ... takes place in the course of such struggle’ (2003: 99). The qualitative development is that workers improve the conditions of their own lives, create life-time and life-space for self-realizing activity and mutualistic interaction, and thus both teach themselves that society is not impervious to collective struggle, and make their lives better by realizing some elements of the socialist ideal in their day to day reality. Since every human life is finite, lived by mortal individuals, revolutionary politics must take into account both the short and the long term. Immanuel Wallerstein puts the point well: ‘People live in the present’, he argued. ‘Everybody has to eat today, not tomorrow. Everybody has to sleep today, not tomorrow. Everybody has to do all these just ordinary things today, and you can’t just tell people that they have to wait another five or ten or twenty years, and it is going to get better ... So you’ve got to worry about today, but you can’t worry only about today’ (quoted in Boggs 2012: 197). No one can be expected to sacrifice the whole of their present life for the sake of a distant future that they will never experience. A politics capable of motivating people must demonstrate its capacity to improve workers’ lives in their own here and now and not just function as a way-station on the way to a promised transcendence. Hence the struggle for free time by shortening the working day without loss of real wages has historically been (and could become again, if it were taken up once more by a revivified trades union movement) a victory over the power of capital over the whole of human life. So too the struggle for higher wages. If it is understood as a struggle against the power of capital over human life and not an end in itself or instrumental to higher levels of life-destructive consumption of capitalist commodities, it becomes a basis and a building block for more radical demands. Such struggles can become bases and building blocks if they are used as occasions to raise critical questions: why is it that capitalism permits both mass unemployment and resists shortening the working week without loss of real wages? Why is it that real wages have stagnated while corporate profits have soared? Why is it that capitalism continues to ravage the planet (see Holleman, this volume) even though there is an unshakeable scientific consensus that without drastic socio-economic changes a massive life-crisis awaits us in the not too distant future? When workplace struggles are connected to these sorts of questions workers can realize – without being preached at or otherwise dogmatically exhorted to overthrow capitalism – that the real implications of their struggles contest the power of capital over human (and planetary) life. Let us take another example to further illustrate the point – the struggle for universally accessible public institutions. Here too trade unions have historically played a decisive role. What does the creation of universally accessible public institutions mean? The re-channelling of wealth away from private accumulation towards life-requirement satisfaction on the basis of need, not the ability to pay. In other words, the funding of universally accessible public institutions through taxation is another inroad against the power of capital over life. When education, health care, access to cultural institutions, and pensions are taken out of the cycle of commodified exchange and made available to all people on the basis and to the extent of their needs for them, real life improves: ‘The public provision of goods and services, well-managed in a way that fosters sustainable development and social justice initiatives, and which is accountable to the community, significantly improves standards of living’ (Fanelli 2016: 86). Such improvements take society some way towards instantiating the principle of socialist society: ‘from each according to their abilities, to each according to their needs’ (Marx 1875). Of course, public institutions do not fully realize that principle, but nor do they fully ignore it, as commodified exchange does. Nor are actually existing public institutions free of invidious, often racialized and sexualized, oppressive hierarchies of power (see Sears 2014: 56, 88). Nevertheless, they do represent a victory over what Lebowitz calls the ‘mediating power’ of capital, i.e., the way it makes people dependent on the possession of money, as opposed to nature and each other, for their life-support. The road to socialism thus lies along a continuum of struggle against the power capital exerts over people’s ability to satisfy their real life-needs and express and enjoy their life-capacities. This struggle brings to light the deepest contradiction of capitalism, that it masks the real relations of dependence of human life on nature and collective labour with its own structurally imposed dependence on access to labour and commodity markets. Once workers peer behind this curtain of capitalist reification, they see that the real purpose of labour is not the production of private money-value for the capitalist, but life-capital – ‘the life wealth that produces more life wealth without loss and with cumulative gain’ (McMurty 2015) – for the need-based appropriation and use of all. Whatever struggles expose this contradiction, recapture wealth and resources for the production of life-capital, and create universally accessible pathways for all to appropriate life-capital are elements of the struggle for a socialist society. In sum, we have argued that the struggle for socialism must be reconceived as a struggle along a continuum. The ‘political economy of the working class’, implied but largely absent from Capital, focuses on the ways in which organized collective struggle can divert wealth from the circuits of capital to the circuits of collective life-capital through which real human beings preserve and develop themselves. Life can be better or worse in capitalism, and struggle that makes life better without overthrowing it should not be dismissed as ‘reformist’ but understood as part of a continuum of struggle towards socialism. People do not fight, normally, for abstractions or slogans, but for achievable goals that will improve their lives. To radicalize the struggle does not mean radicalizing slogans, but treating each victory as a plateau on which to rest for a moment before extending the counterlogic of public provision, need-satisfaction, and democratic control over wealth and resources further into the life-space and life-time dominated by capital.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – Alt Fails
Sebastiano Maffettone 21. Full Professor of Political Philosophy at Luiss Guido Carli University of Rome, 2021. Marx in the 21st Century, p. 84-87.
A reconstruction of Marx’s historical materialism is a difficult and arduous task. The first reason for this is that Marx—despite the primary importance of the concept—never presents a unified theory of historical materialism in his writings. The second reason—probably at the root of the first—is that he does not seem to have a unitary and coherent vision of historical materialism itself. The first reason results from the fact that we must use at least four (sections of) different works to get a complete idea of it, an idea that in any case originates with the critique of Hegel in his early years. In the Manifesto Marx limits himself to presenting, in the first part of the work, history from the perspective of historical materialism as the history of the class struggle. In the preface to Critique of Political Economy there is the reconstruction of history in terms of the development of productive forces, and finally, in Capital and in the Grundrisse, history is presented in light of the systematic search for surplus value on the part of the dominant classes. Needless to say that these different versions are not always consistent with each other. More generally, as we said, Marx does not seem to have a unitary and coherent vision of historical materialism. For him, on the one hand, it consists of a theory of the structure of the modes of production, and on the other hand, in a reconstruction of their historical succession. The structural approach summarizes what the different modes of production have in common: a nucleus of productive forces (for example the technology used) and of production relations (based primarily on property) with a superstructure that includes the law, ethics and the culture of every society in general. The historical reconstruction instead presents what the different modes of production do not have in common, so that we can distinguish an Asiatic mode of production, one based on slavery, one on feudal servitude, up to the capitalist mode production. Here again, one cannot say that coherence is Marx’s strong suit in providing a reasonably uniform depiction of the question. This is made even more complicated by the fact that Marx has a generally ambiguous view of history (as we have already seen in the case of exploitation). Here, the ambiguity consists in coexistence, within his thinking of two different conceptions of history: a philosophical history of Hegelian ilk, and an empirical theory of history. The first offers an interpretation of events in light of their contribution to the realization of the end of history. The end of history for Marx is communism, and the philosophy of history that justifies its progressive advent is remarkably similar to a religious vision that foresees the final salvation of humanity. The second offers a set of socio-economic generalizations about social change. Without a doubt, Marx’s philosophy of history is now widely discredited, and few are willing to believe that the history of humanity is a kind of long wait for the advent of communism, but the problem is even more serious, if we consider that Marx’s empirical theory of history is strongly influenced by his philosophy of history (this type of objection, moreover, is at the heart of Benedetto Croce’s criticism of Marx). This confusion between two levels is clearly seen in what is perhaps the main defect of Marx’s whole vision, the underlying determinism. Determinism here means that in history there is an iron law that determines what will happen given what has already happened and in general that the laws of history are the equivalent of the laws of nature, an affinity for which Marx felt along with Darwin (Engels recalled the centrality of historical necessity in Marx’s thought in his speech at Marx’s funeral). Something like this, besides being completely unlikely, would take away from history what is perhaps its essential characteristic, that is, a relative unpredictability. Moreover, what is even worse, a vision of this type deprives human motives and reasons of all meaning and value. Given that determinism tells us where we are going, why should we work hard to realize the end of history? In short, Marxian determinism inevitably condemns us to a life of messianic expectation in which our efforts to understand and act on what we understand are superfluous. Furthermore, it is not easy to understand how Marx was a determinist, in the sense that humans are simply the object of a historical process that passes over their heads, but how much space is left for human choices and decisions. Among other things, it is not easy to understand how deterministic Marx was, in the sense that humans are simply the object of a historical process passing over their heads, and how much room there was for human choices and decisions. The determinism of Marx, if there is any, is still sophisticated. The basic thesis is that within each mode of production there is a dialectic between productive forces and production relations, or if you will between technology and legal regulation of ownership. This relationship is progressively realized until reaching a level of optimality. After this however, this fortunate correspondence degenerates sooner or later into contradiction and over time the production relations become incompatible with the productive forces. The contradiction is generated by the development of new productive forces that render existing production relations obsolete. At this point the necessity arises for “an era of social revolution” destined to remove the contradiction by bringing out new relations of production. It should be noted that this view is, if taken into consideration from a historical point of view, bizarre if not perverse. Take, for example, the necessary transition from capitalism to communism, which is what most interested Marx. His thesis tells us that the technological and productive progress of capitalism should, so to speak, make it rupture in the moment of its greatest development. To imagine something like this is very strange: people turn violent when things go wrong, not when development reaches its maximum! An impression of this kind seems to have been amply confirmed by history, as communist revolutions took place in countries that were on average backward in terms of the development of productive forces. Another weak point, in this perspective, concerns the absolute uncertainty that surrounds Marx’s communism when we consider it from the point of view of the balance between productive forces and relations of production. Once again in this case the Hegelian dialectic and Hegel’s philosophy of history seem to replace the arguments in favor of Marx’s thesis in this regard. We, in other words, can bet on communism only if we imagine it as an imminent end of history through a general dialectic which sees history go from primitive communism to capitalist alienation, which is then in turn removed by the final conquest of saving communism. But this is a quasi-religious vision that seems to have little to do with the desired balance between new modes of production and social relationships that can bring them to power. What has been said in the last paragraph shows how Marx, to reach the revolution, does not focus so much on an argument in favor of communism as on an argument against capitalism. Capitalism, in his opinion, is condemned to failure according to its own principles, and sooner or later it will fail to provide the material goods on which it had founded its hope of success. Although it is strange to imagine the two together, Marx often seems to think that capitalism will simultaneously lead to an extreme impoverishment of the working class and to the end of capitalist profit.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – Alt Fails
Kristian Niemietz 19. PhD in Political Economy from King’s College London and Institute of Economic Affairs’ Head of Political Economy, 2019. Socialism: The Failed Idea That Never Dies, Institute of Economic Affairs, p. 293-296.
And yet, that support for socialism as an ideal is not matched by a positive view of any particular example, contemporary or historical, of socialism in action. On the contrary: whenever any such example is mentioned, socialists invariably roll their eyes and dismiss it as a lazy straw man. Socialists have largely succeeded in distancing them-selves from previous attempts to build socialist socie- ties. Holding a real-world example of socialism against a self-described socialist is considered a cheap shot today. The conventional wisdom is that people who associate socialism with the Warsaw Pact countries, Maoist China, North Korea or North Vietnam are simply not clever enough to understand the difference between an idea and a distorted application. Holding the Gulags or the Berlin Wall against democratic socialists is considered just as boorish as holding the atrocities of Al Qaida or the Islamic State against peaceful Muslims. And yet, when asked what exactly was ‘unreal’ about previous variants of socialism, or what they would have done differently, contemporary socialists struggle to come up with a clear answer. When pressed, they escape into the abstract, talking about lofty aspirations rather than tangible characteristics. But the lofty aspirations that are usually cited are exactly the same old aspirations that have always been the aspirations of socialism. The idea that a socialist system should empower ordinary working people, rather than party apparatchiks, is not remotely as original as contemporary socialists think it is. That has always been the idea. Contemporary socialists define ‘real’ socialism in terms of the outcomes they would like to see, rather than the institutional setup which is supposed to produce those outcomes. By mixing a desired outcome of a system into the very definition of that system, the idea that ‘real’ socialism has never been tried becomes unfalsifiable. It is as if we defined a rain dance as ‘a dance that causes rainfall’, as opposed to ‘a dance that aims to cause rainfall’. Under the latter definition, it is possible to conclude, after a sufficiently large number of failed attempts, that rain dances cannot, after all, cause rain. Under the former definition, that is not possible. If an attempt at a rain dance does not cause rain, then by definition, it cannot have been a real rain dance. A real rain dance has never been tried. Those who claim that rain dances have ‘failed’ are just not clever enough to understand the difference between the idea of a rain dance and a distorted application. Socialism in the sense in which self-identified democratic socialists define it, namely, a democratised economy planned collectively by ‘the people’, has never been achieved anywhere, and could not be achieved. Economic planning can only ever be done in a technocratic, elitist fashion, and it requires an extreme concentration of power in the hands of the state. It cannot ‘empower’ ordinary workers. It can only ever empower a bureaucratic elite. But while this vision of socialism cannot be attained, it can be easily projected onto actually existing societies, by virtue of being so abstract and nebulous. For the same reason, that projection can just as easily be ended. This is what Western intellectuals have been doing for almost a century. Thirty years ago, Hayek (1988) wrote about ‘intellectuals’ vain search for a truly socialist community, which results in the idealisation of, and then disillusionment with, a seemingly endless string of “utopias”’. Since then, this string has only grown longer. The reception of socialist experiments usually follows a three-stage pattern. Socialist experiments often go through an initial honeymoon period, during which they have, or at least seem to have, some initial successes, and during which their international standing is relatively high. During this honeymoon period, the experiment is usually showered with enthusiastic praise from Western intellectuals. It is held up as a role model of ‘true’ socialism, as ‘proof’ that socialism does work, and as an inspiring alternative to the morally bankrupt capitalist systems of the West. This honeymoon never lasts forever. At some point, the model’s failures become more widely known in the West, and the respective country’s international standing de- teriorates. During this period, Western intellectuals look frantically for excuses. There is still widespread support for the model in question, but language and emphasis change drastically: a hopeful and optimistic case is replaced by an angry and defensive one. Western socialists shoot the messenger; they act as if the critics of the system were some- how responsible for the system’s failure. Outside forces and/or members of the old, discredited elites are accused of ‘undermining’ socialism. Western apologists engage extensively in whataboutery, raising counteraccusations and trying to shift attention to unrelated issues. But there comes a point when the system’s failures become so obvious, and its international reputation becomes so irreparably damaged, that defending it becomes a lost cause. This is the third and final stage. Small sects of true believers continue to defend the system, but mainstream intellectuals fall silent on the issue. After a while, the pilgrimages and eulogies fade from memory and Western intellectuals begin to dispute the system’s socialist credentials. The new narrative becomes that the system was never truly socialist, that only a handful of extremists ever claimed it was, and that only a complete ignoramus would hold it against a self-described socialist. This narrative then becomes the conventional wisdom. The reputation of socialism, as an idea, survives unblemished.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – No Link – Work Ethic
Olivia Hanks 18. Green New Deal political strategist and organizer, former editor, political researcher, and contributor to The Norwich Radical, 2018. “What we talk about when we talk about work”, It’s Basic Income, edited by Amy Downes and Stewart Lansley, p. 77-80.
Most of us define ourselves by our paid work. It’s what we spend more time doing than anything else. And the rest of our time is often defined by work: travelling to it, recovering from it, or lapsing into total lethargy during holidays as a reaction to it. Yet a 2013 Gallup poll of 142 countries showed that only 13% of people feel engaged by their jobs.14 This source of unhappiness and waste of human potential has led some to argue that the ideal would be to abolish work.15 This may be taking things a little far, even if we take ‘work’ to mean only ‘paid employment’ – I wouldn’t like to abolish doctors, for instance. Nevertheless, it gets us thinking about what work really is. Until the industrial revolution, most people were subsistence farmers, working to produce what they needed and no more. Work as a transaction – time in exchange for money – only became widespread with industrialisation and the mass movement of people into the cities in the 19th century. There, people had no access to land to provide their food, so were forced to ‘earn their living’ in factories, gaining only a fraction of the fruits of their labour as reward. Though working conditions in the UK have improved dramatically, this state of affairs remains fundamentally the same for employees today. The idea that your ‘living’ is something you have to ‘earn’ persists, for the most part quite unchallenged. Yet many people would freely admit that they see their job as essentially pointless. Phrases like ‘earning a living’ and, more recently, ‘hardworking families’ or the rhetorical division of citizens into ‘strivers’ and ‘skivers’ reinforce the view that paid employment is a virtue, and the more hours of it you do, the better. Other useful or fulfilling types of work such as caring and community work are disregarded. The anthropologist David Graeber writes in a 2013 essay that ‘bullshit jobs’ have been created because ‘the feeling that work is a moral value in itself, and that anyone not willing to submit themselves to some kind of intense work discipline for most of their waking hours deserves nothing, is extraordinarily convenient’ for the ruling class.16 This is almost an exact echo of the opening of William Morris’s 1884 lecture ‘Useful Work Versus Useless Toil’: ‘Most people, well-to-do or not, believe that, even when a man is doing work which appears to be useless, he is earning his livelihood by it – he is “employed,” ; and most of those who are well-to-do cheer on the happy worker with praises, if he is only “industrious” enough and deprives himself of all pleasure and holidays in the sacred cause of labour. In short, it has become an article of the creed of modern morality that all labour is good in itself – a convenient belief to those who live on the labour of others.’17 Graeber’s repetition of these thoughts well over a century later, despite the advances in productivity during that time, shows that this is not a question that will ever be solved by more technology or ever-greater productivity – it is clearly a political matter. Much has been written about the impact on jobs of the new wave of automation. Yet despite the widespread concern about the impact on employment, previous waves of automation have not led to a hike in unemployment. Instead, directly productive jobs now done by machines have been replaced by Graeber’s ‘bullshit jobs’ in the clerical, sales and service sectors. Unless we change the way we think about work, we will simply end up with a new generation of meaningless jobs to replace those lost; another generation of workers stuck in jobs they do not like and of which they do not see the point. If we see unemployment as the problem, as artificial intelligence renders vast numbers of jobs obsolete, we risk seeing the creation of a new wave of ‘bullshit jobs’ as the solution. Instead, we should seize upon the growth of artificial intelligence (AI) as the ideal opportunity to introduce a universal basic income, alongside a more progressive system of taxation. A guaranteed, subsistence-level income would end extreme poverty and allow people time to look for meaningful work instead of relying on jobs that are short-term, insecure and exploitative. Recognising that material wealth comes from the earth’s resources and belongs to society as a whole, it would more fairly distribute the wealth created by technological advances, rather than concentrating that wealth in fewer and fewer hands. When we no longer see paid work as an immediate necessity for survival, other reasons for working will come to the fore: intellectual challenge or physical fitness, social interaction, the sense of doing something useful. Once the financial imperative to accept poor pay and conditions has vanished, workers will start demanding that their jobs fulfil some of these other needs. UBI would also give people more choice about how much they work. The result would be better health, both physical and mental; better family life, as parents are no longer forced by financial necessity and social pressure to go back to work at the earliest possible opportunity; and more engagement with politics and community life. Paid employment would no longer be the only or principal determiner of people’s identity, status and self-esteem. One of the most common arguments against UBI is that large numbers of people would give up work. This rests on two assumptions: first, that most people only work for the money, and would stop working if they could; second, that people leaving the workforce would be a terrible thing. The first is unlikely to be the case: most people want to work in some form. Insofar as people do work ‘only for the money’ because they have meaningless, unfulfilling jobs, the greater bargaining power would make employers offer more appealing jobs, whether through improved pay or other means. And while UBI would be sufficient for survival, it would not pay for a life of material comfort. Those who wanted more would still need to be part of the paid workforce. Given that there are always concerns about a shortage of jobs, it cannot logically be argued that some people withdrawing from the workforce would cause society to collapse. Rather, the second assumption is based principally on the belief that everyone has a moral duty to ‘pay their way’ financially, and that any other system is unfair. This is a symptom of the tendency of modern political discourse to place the economy above all else; to refer to it as though society existed to serve its needs, and not the other way round. UBI implicitly recognises a fundamental point: that paid work has no intrinsic value, and that not all valuable work is paid. Many people contribute in other ways, as carers, as artists or as volunteers; some people are simply unable to work full time, and UBI would enable those people to live dignified, meaningful lives.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – No Link – Reform
Richard Delgado 87. Distinguished Professor of Law at Seattle University School of Law, 1987. “The Ethereal Scholar: Does Critical Legal Studies Have What Minorities Want?”, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, Vol. 22. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2712365
2. The CLS Critique of Piecemeal Reform Critical scholars reject the idea of piecemeal reform. Incremental change, they argue, merely postpones the wholesale reformation that must occur to create a decent society.38 Even worse, an unfair social system survives by using piecemeal reform to disguise and legitimize oppression.39 Those who control the system weaken resistance by pointing to the occasional concession to, or periodic court victory of, a black plaintiff or worker as evidence that the system is fair and just.40 In fact, Crits believe that teaching the common law or using the case method in law school is a disguised means of preaching incrementalism and thereby maintaining the current power structure.41 To avoid this, CLS scholars urge law professors to abandon the case method, give up the effort to find rationality and order in the case law, and teach in an unabashedly political fashion.42 The CLS critique of piecemeal reform is familiar, imperialistic and wrong. Minorities know from bitter experience that occasional court victories do not mean the Promised Land is at hand.43 The critique is imperialistic in that it tells minorities and other oppressed peoples how they should interpret events affecting them.44 A court order directing a housing authority to disburse funds for heating in subsidized housing may postpone the revolution, or it may not. In the meantime, the order keeps a number of poor families warm. This may mean more to them than it does to a comfortable academic working in a warm office. It smacks of paternalism to assert that the possibility of revolution later outweighs the certainty of heat now, unless there is evidence for that possibility. The Crits do not offer such evidence. Indeed, some incremental changes may bring revolutionary changes closer, not push them further away. Not all small reforms induce complacency; some may whet the appetite for further combat. The welfare family may hold a tenants' union meeting in their heated living room. CLS scholars' critique of piecemeal reform often misses these possibilities, and neglects the question of whether total change, when it comes, will be what we want.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC – No Link – Reform
Carlo Fanelli and Jeff Noonan 17. Fanelli worked in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, Canada at the time of publication and Noonan is a professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Windsor, 4-20-2017. “Capital and Organized Labor”, Reading ‘Capital’ Today: Marx after 150 Years, edited by Ingo Schmidt and Carlo Fanelli, p. 141-142.
According to Lebowitz (2003: 27–8), Marx intended to explain the role of class struggle on the operations of capitalism in a volume on wage labour that he never wrote. We are not interested here in the Marxiological question of whether Marx ever formally abandoned the original six-volume plan for Capital. Rather, we are interested in the practical question of what the struggle for socialism looks like when we take seriously, as Marx typically did in his political work and as Lebowitz does, struggles within capitalism for a shorter working day, higher real wages, and universal access through public provision of needed life-goods. When we take those struggles seriously we discover that the struggle for socialism is neither the necessary product of the working out of the endogenous laws of capitalism nor the result of a voluntaristic, all or nothing, once and for all revolutionary movement, but a process arrayed along a continuum of better or worse lives for working people, determined by the degree of democratic control they are able to assert over the production process, the amount of time outside of alienated labour they are able to secure, the extent to which they are able to satisfy their human life-requirements, and the extent to which the private accumulation of capital is redirected towards the public provision of life-requirement satisfiers. These struggles occur within the dynamics of capitalist society, but react back against them, modifying their impact on real human lives. Lives can be better or worse for working people in capitalism depending on whether or not their struggles are successful. The laws of capitalism that Marx explains in Capital are not, in reality, forces that can exist independently of the combined actions of people (if they were, they could never be overthrown but only transform themselves into different laws or exist in perpetuity). The difference between natural laws and social laws is that the latter emerge from human action and interaction and change when those patterns of interaction change (see Gose and Paulson, this volume). As Marx himself notes in Capital, ‘the economic categories ... bear the stamp of history’ (Marx 1986: 120). While Marx himself in Capital often fails to follow out consistently the implications of this position, frequently referring to capitalist dynamics as governed by ‘iron laws’, we must interpret these claims in the philosophical context furnished by historical materialist method, which, as the quotation above reveals, is rooted in the principle that humanity is ultimately a self-determining subject (see, for example, Marx 1986: 7). As such, nothing that the exploited and alienated segments of humanity do to free themselves from alienation and exploitation is irrelevant, nor are the organizations through which those class struggles are expressed irrelevant just in case they are not directed immediately to the overthrow of capitalism. What matters, in our view, is whether the struggles aim at reducing the structural power of capital over human life, and whether they are rooted in explicit recognition of a shared life-interest in reducing that power over human beings, and not whether they are led by trade unions or revolutionary parties, or explicitly aim at revolution in the short term or only at demonstrable improvements in human life within capitalism.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC Shell
Carlo Fanelli and Jeff Noonan 17. Fanelli worked in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, Canada at the time of publication and Noonan is a professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Windsor, 4-20-2017. “Capital and Organized Labor”, Reading ‘Capital’ Today: Marx after 150 Years, edited by Ingo Schmidt and Carlo Fanelli, p. 141-142.
According to Lebowitz (2003: 27–8), Marx intended to explain the role of class struggle on the operations of capitalism in a volume on wage labour that he never wrote. We are not interested here in the Marxiological question of whether Marx ever formally abandoned the original six-volume plan for Capital. Rather, we are interested in the practical question of what the struggle for socialism looks like when we take seriously, as Marx typically did in his political work and as Lebowitz does, struggles within capitalism for a shorter working day, higher real wages, and universal access through public provision of needed life-goods. When we take those struggles seriously we discover that the struggle for socialism is neither the necessary product of the working out of the endogenous laws of capitalism nor the result of a voluntaristic, all or nothing, once and for all revolutionary movement, but a process arrayed along a continuum of better or worse lives for working people, determined by the degree of democratic control they are able to assert over the production process, the amount of time outside of alienated labour they are able to secure, the extent to which they are able to satisfy their human life-requirements, and the extent to which the private accumulation of capital is redirected towards the public provision of life-requirement satisfiers. These struggles occur within the dynamics of capitalist society, but react back against them, modifying their impact on real human lives. Lives can be better or worse for working people in capitalism depending on whether or not their struggles are successful. The laws of capitalism that Marx explains in Capital are not, in reality, forces that can exist independently of the combined actions of people (if they were, they could never be overthrown but only transform themselves into different laws or exist in perpetuity). The difference between natural laws and social laws is that the latter emerge from human action and interaction and change when those patterns of interaction change (see Gose and Paulson, this volume). As Marx himself notes in Capital, ‘the economic categories ... bear the stamp of history’ (Marx 1986: 120). While Marx himself in Capital often fails to follow out consistently the implications of this position, frequently referring to capitalist dynamics as governed by ‘iron laws’, we must interpret these claims in the philosophical context furnished by historical materialist method, which, as the quotation above reveals, is rooted in the principle that humanity is ultimately a self-determining subject (see, for example, Marx 1986: 7). As such, nothing that the exploited and alienated segments of humanity do to free themselves from alienation and exploitation is irrelevant, nor are the organizations through which those class struggles are expressed irrelevant just in case they are not directed immediately to the overthrow of capitalism. What matters, in our view, is whether the struggles aim at reducing the structural power of capital over human life, and whether they are rooted in explicit recognition of a shared life-interest in reducing that power over human beings, and not whether they are led by trade unions or revolutionary parties, or explicitly aim at revolution in the short term or only at demonstrable improvements in human life within capitalism.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC Shell
Mariana Mazzucato 21. Professor in the Economics of Innovation and Public Value at University College London where she is the founding director of the UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose, 1-28-2021. Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism, p. 204-10.
This book has applied what I believe is the immensely powerful idea of a mission to solving the ‘wicked’ problems we face today. In it, I have argued that tackling grand challenges will only happen if we reimagine government as a prerequisite for restructuring capitalism in a way that is inclusive, sustainable and driven by innovation.
First and foremost, this means reinventing government for the twenty-first century – equipping it with the tools, organization and culture it needs to drive a mission-oriented approach. It also means bringing purpose to the core of corporate governance and taking a very broad stakeholder position across the economy. It means changing the relationship between public and private sectors, and between them and civil society, so they all work symbiotically for a common goal. The reason for the emphasis on rethinking government is simple: only government has the capacity to bring about transformation on the scale needed. The relationship between economic actors and civil society shows our problems at their most profound, and this is what we must unravel.
2023
ENDI
Kritik
Answers to Capitalism Kritik › 2AC Shell
Carlo Fanelli and Jeff Noonan 17. Fanelli worked in the Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, Canada at the time of publication and Noonan is a professor in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Windsor, 4-20-2017. “Capital and Organized Labor”, Reading ‘Capital’ Today: Marx after 150 Years, edited by Ingo Schmidt and Carlo Fanelli, p. 153-157.
Conclusion: Socialism and the Continuum of Democratic Struggle
The need, therefore, for workers to go beyond traditional trade union based forms of struggle is unquestionable. At the same time, we exist at a moment of history where vanguard revolutionary parties have been discredited, and there is no evidence, in the European and North American contexts, that their fortunes will ever be revived. Thus the question remains: if trade unions and social democracy are incapable of solving the problems they address themselves to because they are not revolutionary, and the historical moment of vanguardist politics seems to have definitively passed, how is the struggle for socialism to be conducted today? The answer to that question lies in the creative intelligence of people in struggle; no theoretical intervention can substitute itself for political practice. What we aim to do in conclusion is not infer a new mode of struggle from abstract principles but instead try to draw out the implicitly radical significance of the struggles within capitalism (for higher wages, for free time, for public institutions) in support of the conclusion that socialism is part and parcel of the struggle for democracy, and the struggle for democracy (as all political struggles) should be understood along a continuum. Reconceiving the goals of struggle as progressively realizable frees the idea of revolution from the nineteenth century image of it as a one-off cataclysm, opening space for new ideas of organization and political strategy that are neither social democratic nor vanguardist (see Hudis, this volume). Here again, Lebowitz is an instructive starting point. He notes that even when struggles do not ‘transcend the capital/wage labour relation’, they can be significant for the life-value of working people’s lives because they express the fact that ‘a qualitative development ... takes place in the course of such struggle’ (2003: 99). The qualitative development is that workers improve the conditions of their own lives, create life-time and life-space for self-realizing activity and mutualistic interaction, and thus both teach themselves that society is not impervious to collective struggle, and make their lives better by realizing some elements of the socialist ideal in their day to day reality. Since every human life is finite, lived by mortal individuals, revolutionary politics must take into account both the short and the long term. Immanuel Wallerstein puts the point well: ‘People live in the present’, he argued. ‘Everybody has to eat today, not tomorrow. Everybody has to sleep today, not tomorrow. Everybody has to do all these just ordinary things today, and you can’t just tell people that they have to wait another five or ten or twenty years, and it is going to get better ... So you’ve got to worry about today, but you can’t worry only about today’ (quoted in Boggs 2012: 197). No one can be expected to sacrifice the whole of their present life for the sake of a distant future that they will never experience. A politics capable of motivating people must demonstrate its capacity to improve workers’ lives in their own here and now and not just function as a way-station on the way to a promised transcendence. Hence the struggle for free time by shortening the working day without loss of real wages has historically been (and could become again, if it were taken up once more by a revivified trades union movement) a victory over the power of capital over the whole of human life. So too the struggle for higher wages. If it is understood as a struggle against the power of capital over human life and not an end in itself or instrumental to higher levels of life-destructive consumption of capitalist commodities, it becomes a basis and a building block for more radical demands. Such struggles can become bases and building blocks if they are used as occasions to raise critical questions: why is it that capitalism permits both mass unemployment and resists shortening the working week without loss of real wages? Why is it that real wages have stagnated while corporate profits have soared? Why is it that capitalism continues to ravage the planet (see Holleman, this volume) even though there is an unshakeable scientific consensus that without drastic socio-economic changes a massive life-crisis awaits us in the not too distant future? When workplace struggles are connected to these sorts of questions workers can realize – without being preached at or otherwise dogmatically exhorted to overthrow capitalism – that the real implications of their struggles contest the power of capital over human (and planetary) life. Let us take another example to further illustrate the point – the struggle for universally accessible public institutions. Here too trade unions have historically played a decisive role. What does the creation of universally accessible public institutions mean? The re-channelling of wealth away from private accumulation towards life-requirement satisfaction on the basis of need, not the ability to pay. In other words, the funding of universally accessible public institutions through taxation is another inroad against the power of capital over life. When education, health care, access to cultural institutions, and pensions are taken out of the cycle of commodified exchange and made available to all people on the basis and to the extent of their needs for them, real life improves: ‘The public provision of goods and services, well-managed in a way that fosters sustainable development and social justice initiatives, and which is accountable to the community, significantly improves standards of living’ (Fanelli 2016: 86). Such improvements take society some way towards instantiating the principle of socialist society: ‘from each according to their abilities, to each according to their needs’ (Marx 1875). Of course, public institutions do not fully realize that principle, but nor do they fully ignore it, as commodified exchange does. Nor are actually existing public institutions free of invidious, often racialized and sexualized, oppressive hierarchies of power (see Sears 2014: 56, 88). Nevertheless, they do represent a victory over what Lebowitz calls the ‘mediating power’ of capital, i.e., the way it makes people dependent on the possession of money, as opposed to nature and each other, for their life-support. The road to socialism thus lies along a continuum of struggle against the power capital exerts over people’s ability to satisfy their real life-needs and express and enjoy their life-capacities. This struggle brings to light the deepest contradiction of capitalism, that it masks the real relations of dependence of human life on nature and collective labour with its own structurally imposed dependence on access to labour and commodity markets. Once workers peer behind this curtain of capitalist reification, they see that the real purpose of labour is not the production of private money-value for the capitalist, but life-capital – ‘the life wealth that produces more life wealth without loss and with cumulative gain’ (McMurty 2015) – for the need-based appropriation and use of all. Whatever struggles expose this contradiction, recapture wealth and resources for the production of life-capital, and create universally accessible pathways for all to appropriate life-capital are elements of the struggle for a socialist society. In sum, we have argued that the struggle for socialism must be reconceived as a struggle along a continuum. The ‘political economy of the working class’, implied but largely absent from Capital, focuses on the ways in which organized collective struggle can divert wealth from the circuits of capital to the circuits of collective life-capital through which real human beings preserve and develop themselves. Life can be better or worse in capitalism, and struggle that makes life better without overthrowing it should not be dismissed as ‘reformist’ but understood as part of a continuum of struggle towards socialism. People do not fight, normally, for abstractions or slogans, but for achievable goals that will improve their lives. To radicalize the struggle does not mean radicalizing slogans, but treating each victory as a plateau on which to rest for a moment before extending the counterlogic of public provision, need-satisfaction, and democratic control over wealth and resources further into the life-space and life-time dominated by capital.
2023
ENDI
Topicality
Answers to Topicality – Redistribution › 2AC – Predictability
Yelena Dzhanova 20. CNBC news associate covering breaking news and politics with a Bachelor’s degree in English, political science, and journalism from Baruch College, 7-29-2020. “Why Andrew Yang’s push for a universal basic income is making a comeback”, CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/29/why-andrew-yangs-push-for-a-universal-basic-income-is-making-a-comeback.html
For months, lawmakers have been paying attention to and pushing for some form of a universal basic income as the coronavirus pandemic roiled the economy and forced millions of Americans out of a job. It’s the main pillar that former presidential candidate Andrew Yang took up in his campaign, centered around the premise that a UBI could alleviate or resolve many American issues. The gravity with which a UBI is now regarded is a complete reversal of the reaction Yang first got when unveiling his platform. Pundits and Democratic strategists didn’t take his campaign seriously, but suddenly the push for a UBI does not seem so far-fetched. Just as the pandemic was taking full shape in the United States, progressives who’ve long criticized Yang’s UBI stance urged in March for direct payments to workers around the country. Among them was Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who in August of last year found fault with instituting a UBI. Shortly after Sanders and other lawmakers spoke up, President Donald Trump signed into law a coronavirus stimulus package that offered a $1,200 payment to struggling Americans to offset any economic damage brought on by the virus. And now Congress is in discussions about the next round of stimulus relief, with the potential for another $1,200 direct payment.
2023
ENDI
Topicality
Answers to Topicality – Redistribution › 1AR – XT We Meet
Thomas Piketty 22. Professor of economics at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences, Associate Chair at the Paris School of Economics, and Centennial Professor of Economics in the International Inequalities Institute at the London School of Economics, 2022. A Brief History of Equality, p. 263-264.
We must also remember that progressive taxation, as it functioned in the course of the twentieth century, enabled us not only to more fairly distribute taxes on wealth and income but also to impose narrow limits on inequalities before taxes. This role of predistribution and not just redistribution was absolutely central. It shows to what extent progressive taxation is also a form of intervention at the very heart of the process of production—together, of course, with other practices, such as labor law or the presence of employees on boards of directors. Let us stress that the drastic reduction of the salary scale that progressive taxation permits, particularly the 30—90 percent rates applied to the highest incomes, is also an indispensable tool for confronting the commercial sector on equal terms. If capitalist enterprises in the information technology sector pay extravagant remunerations in order to poach almost all the most expert computer scientists on the market, that can seriously complicate the task of the public agencies entrusted with regulating them (unless they choose to encourage the race toward ever greater differences in pay). The same holds true in finance or law. The fact that salaries have been reduced to a scale of one to five and no longer one to twenty, or even one to a hundred, is not only a matter of distributive justice. It is also a matter of efficiency for public regulation, and it contributes to the construction of alternative modes of economic organization.
2023
ENDI
Topicality
Answers to Topicality – Redistribution › 2AC Shell
Malte Luebker 15. Senior Researcher at the Institute of Social and Economic Research (WSI) with a doctoral degree in political science from the University of Bamberg, 1-14-2015. “Redistribution policies” in Labour Markets, Institutions and Inequality: Building Just Societies in the 21st Century, p.214-215, edited by Janine Berg, published by International Labor Office.
Such a broad definition of redistribution underlines the fact that most government action has redistributive consequences. To gain support for unpopular decisions such as the opening of trade, governments sometimes try to compensate the losers and impose a corresponding tax on the winners (ibid.). At this stage, redistribution becomes more apparent since it directly alters the primary distribution of incomes. This direct intervention in the form of taxes and transfers is commonly at the heart of public debates over redistribution, simply because it is more visible, even though the impact can be minuscule when compared with the original policy decision. For example, trade compensation schemes are commonly thought to redistribute less than 5 per cent of the gains from trade (ibid., p. 75). The concept of ‘fiscal redistribution’ captures these direct interventions that governments make through taxes and transfers. A key policy concern is often their net effect on income inequality, usually expressed as the change in a summary measure such as the Gini coefficient between the primary and secondary distribution. The impact can be further disaggregated into the direct effect of taxes and mandatory social contributions and the contribution of transfers (see section 8.6).
2023
ENDI
Topicality
Answers to Topicality – Redistribution › 2AC Shell
Thomas Piketty 14. Professor of economics at the School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences, Associate Chair at the Paris School of Economics, and Centennial Professor of Economics in the International Inequalities Institute at the London School of Economics, 2014. Capital in the Twenty-First Century, p. 495-496.
It would be wrong, however, to conclude that progressive taxation plays only a limited role in modern redistribution. First, even if taxation overall is fairly close to proportional for the majority of the population, the fact that the highest incomes and largest fortunes are taxed at significantly higher (or lower) rates can have a strong influence on the structure of inequality. In particular, the evidence suggests that progressive taxation of very high incomes and very large estates partly explains why the concentration of wealth never regained its astronomic Belle Époque levels after the shocks of 1914–1945. Conversely, the spectacular decrease in the progressivity of the income tax in the United States and Britain since 1980, even though both countries had been among the leaders in progressive taxation after World War II, probably explains much of the increase in the very highest earned incomes. At the same time, the recent rise of tax competition in a world of free-flowing capital has led many governments to exempt capital income from the progressive income tax. This is particularly true in Europe, whose relatively small states have thus far proved incapable of achieving a coordinated tax policy. The result is an endless race to the bottom, leading, for example, to cuts in corporate tax rates and to the exemption of interest, dividends, and other financial revenues from the taxes to which labor incomes are subject.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - AT: Net benefit links to politics (Compacts)
Michael R. Harpring, 91. Lawyer. “Out Like Yesterday's Garbage: Municipal Solid Waste and the Need for Congressional Action,” 40 Catholic University Law Review 851 (1991). Available at: https://scholarship.law.edu/lawreview/vol40/iss4/6
Interstate compacts are the most effective device available to states seeking to bring uniformity to a region. n249 They create common procedures and [*889] standards as well as common interpretation of the rules they establish. n250 Interstate compacts can be especially useful when addressing politically controversial issues. n251 While the procedure for creating a compact varies, states typically form a "joint compact commission" to negotiate and draft the terms of an agreement. n252 The enactment of a compact by one state functions as an offer that other member states may accept by enacting identical statutes. n253 Once ratified, the compact may not be modified without the signatory states' unanimous consent. N254
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - AT: Net benefit links to the counterplan – Politics
Monica Prasad & Steven Munch, 12. Monica Prasad is a sociology professor at Northwestern University. Munch is a J.D. and Ph.D. Candidate, 2013, Northwestern University School of Law and Department of Sociology. “State-level renewable electricity policies and reductions in carbon emissions,” Energy Policy, 45 (2012): 237-242.
Despite the hesitant pace of environmental policy at the national level, there is a proliferation of environmental policy at the state level, where ‘‘an almost stealth-like process of policy development’’ has been underway for over two decades (Rabe, 2004:11). Many state governments have determined that environmental policy is necessary and feasible, and have experimented with several different policy approaches, particularly on the question of facilitating alternative energy. These state policies are surprising in many ways. For example, they are often driven by bipartisan coalitions, and, perhaps because of their lower visibility, they seem to have escaped the partisan wrangling that has limited national-level policy. Both George W. Bush and Christine Todd Whitman were pioneers of alternative energy policy at the state level, as governors of Texas and New Jersey respectively, before they went on to obstruct environmental policy at the federal level as president and head of the EPA (Rabe, 2004: 1). Texas, a state that produces reliably conservative and anti-environmental contingents at the national level, is a leader in wind energy (Rabe, 2004: 50). Environmental policy-making at the state level is pragmatic and catholic, with many different approaches being tried. Because electricity generation accounts for 41% of all CO2 emissions and is the largest single source of CO2 emissions (EPA, 2011:ES-8; Carley, 2011), many states have focused their efforts on the electric power sector. One of the main sites of policy innovation has been the attempt to increase the generation of electricity from renewable sources.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - AT: Net benefit links to the counterplan – Politics
Mohamed Akram Faizer, 22. Professor of Law at the Lincoln Memorial University-Duncan School of Law (LMU) in Knoxville, Tennessee. “Madison 2.0—Applying the Constitution’s Taxing and Spending Clause to Revitalize American Federalism.” Seattle University Law Review Vol. 46:69 (2022). https://digitalcommons.law.seattleu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2807&context=sulr
Support for a guaranteed income has failed to gain traction within the Biden Administration, which has seen opposition to his Administration’s fiscal stimuli, COVID-19 relief and student loan forgiveness measures grow increasingly vociferous. Indeed, centrist Democratic opposition to the Biden Administration’s fiscal program is akin to that from conservative and moderate opponents to the FAP in 1970, in the sense that the COVID relief and student loan forgiveness measures are seen by moderates as expensive and inflationary measures that create the wrong incentives. This is why the key component of my proposal is the provision of federal funds directly to state governments to improve their inhabitants’ living standards.
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - AT: Net benefit links to the counterplan – Politics
Economic Security Project, 22. The Economic Security Project (ESP) works to advance economic prosperity by providing research, supporting campaigns to get from pilot to policy, and working to change narratives about economic inequality and poverty. “Reimagining the Social Safety Net Through Implementation of a Guaranteed Income.” “States Lead the Way.” April 13, 2022.
Economic Security Project, Shriver Center on Poverty Law. Report.
In light of the current limits at the local and federal level, there is an opportunity for state governments to explore ambitious, publicly funded cash transfer policies that:
2023
ENDI
Counterplan
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan › 2NC/1NR - AT: Net benefit links to the counterplan – Federalism
Oren Cass & Wells King, 21. *Oren Cass is the executive director at American Compass. *Wells King is the former research director at American Compass. “The Family Income Supplemental Credit.” February 2021. https://americancompass.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/American_Compass-The_Family_Income_Supplemental_Credit-2021Feb18.pdf
Discouraging Work and Encouraging Dependence. A core concern animating opposition to many family-benefit proposals is the potential for cash payments to non-working families to undermine work incentives and cultural norms. One worry is that households finding themselves with more money would then choose to work less, in some cases preventing prospective workers from taking initial steps onto or up the economic ladder. Another worry is that people will become dependent on the payments and see the state as having the responsibility to provide for their families, devaluing the breadwinner’s role in supporting the household and crowding out other sources of support like the extended family, the neighborhood, and the church. The Fisc’s work requirement addresses these concerns directly, drawing a clear distinction between working and non-working families and using the existing safety net to address the needs of the latter. The proposed structure does have the potential to reduce work effort for families that might choose to spend fewer hours in the labor force—whether the middle-income household that decides it can now make do without a second earner, or the single mother who finds it possible to go part-time and spend more afternoons with her kids. We see this as a benefit—the importance of work is in the role it assigns people as productive contributors, the habits and social interaction it promotes, and the opportunity for upward mobility it provides. This does not mean that more work is always better or that the two full-time earners or the single mother working double shifts are the desirable outcomes for public policy to promote. Undermining Effective Anti-Poverty Programs. The American safety net is not just a provider of last resort. It also operates programs to address root causes of dysfunction like addiction, develop real-world employment and parenting skills, and provide wraparound support to people trying to get back on their feet. These are not things people can easily buy with cash, and in many cases the conditioning of support on participation is a vital tool to move people away from dependence. The Fisc does not reduce or eliminate existing anti-poverty programs; to the contrary, by creating an important contact point midway through pregnancy it provides a new opportunity for engagement. Further, by increasing the rewards to workforce participation—get and keep any job and become eligible for a large supplement—it reinforces the efforts of anti-poverty programs to move people toward self-sufficiency. Commodifying Family. People rightly worry that society may come to see a family benefit as a “parenting wage,” which some indeed argue it should be, converting family relationships of obligation into economically tinged transactions under public oversight. Whether a family benefit will be understood as a “parenting wage” is a matter of perception as well as design and implementation. Insisting upon work as a prerequisite for receipt makes clear that the work of being a parent is not what entitles one to the benefit. Framing the program as a social compact and emphasizing its role as a supplement to family income rather than a “child allowance” can help as well. Federalizing Policy. Policymakers often default to federal solutions, which in many cases are the wrong ones. Varied local conditions, the importance of robust sub-federal institutions, and principles of federalism and subsidiarity all argue for deferring to state and local governments where feasible.