Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Topicality
In The US › Excludes EEZ

Federal courts have held that the EEZ is not within the United States.

Hanna, J.D. Candidate, Case Western Reserve University School of Law 14 [Matthew T., “THE EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE: A ‘NO MAN’S LAND’ FOR UNITED STATES PATENT LAW,” Journal of Law, Technology & the Internet · Vol. 5 · 2014, Accessed 7/15/21]

E. WesternGeco v. ION Geophysical A prime example of judicial deference to Congress regarding § 271 was the district court’s decision in WesternGeco v. ION Geophysical, in which WesternGeco alleged infringement of its patented marine seismic streamer technology.92 Here, ION Geophysical applied for and received a permit from the U.S. Department of the Interior to conduct a threedimensional marine seismic survey in the Chukchi Sea approximately 100 miles northwest of Wainwright, Alaska and 150 miles west of Barrow, Alaska.93 The survey would cover ocean outside of the United States’ territorial sea, but within the boundaries of the United States EEZ.94 WesternGeco alleged that the defendants violated § 271 (a), (b), (c), and (f) by “‘making, using, offering to sell, selling and/or supplying in or from the United States products and services relating to steerable streamers and/or inducing and/or contributing to such conduct.’”95 The defendants countered that WesternGeco’s complaint failed to allege any action that could be an infringement occurred or would occur within the United States.96 The court analyzed WesternGeco’s infringement claims within the framework of the traditional presumption against extraterritoriality, stating:

[A]s the EEZ is outside of the territorial United States, and Congress has limited the reach of U.S. patent law to the United States and its territories, infringing activity would not be actionable under U.S. patent law. Even though U.S. jurisdiction has been extended to the EEZ for some, but not all activities, this begs the question of whether it takes U.S. patent law—which territorially limited—along with it. Congress could extend the reach of U.S. patent law to encompass marine scientific research occurring in the EEZ, as countries such as Australia and the United Kingdom have done.97

2023 GDI Topicality
In The US › Excludes EEZ

A federal appeals court has interpreted the EEZ as not “within the United States” in the only relevant case- other courts are likely to follow their lead.

Hanna, J.D. Candidate, Case Western Reserve University School of Law 14 [Matthew T., “THE EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE: A ‘NO MAN’S LAND’ FOR UNITED STATES PATENT LAW,” Journal of Law, Technology & the Internet · Vol. 5 · 2014, Accessed 7/15/21]

The judiciary has traditionally deferred to Congress’s law-making powers by invoking a strict presumption against applying United States law abroad. In WesternGeco L.L.C. v. ION Geophysical Corp., the court held that a plaintiff could not claim direct infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) because the defendant’s activities—occurring in the United States Exclusive Economic Zone—did not occur “within the United States.” This decision was significant because the United States possesses a bundle of rights in its Exclusive Economic Zone which approaches, but stops short of, full sovereignty. The United States has an economic interest in developing the natural resources that lie within its Exclusive Economic Zone, so expanding the scope of United States patent law to the Exclusive Economic Zone will spur that development. Other courts will likely conclude that the United States Exclusive Economic Zone is not “within the United States” for the purposes of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) by invoking the strict presumption against extraterritorial application. As a result, Congress should take notice of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a)’s deficient scope and enact a direct infringement cause of action for infringing activity in the United States Exclusive Economic Zone.

2023 GDI Topicality
In The US › Excludes Contiguous Zone and EEZ

Even if Congress has the power to create protections in the contiguous zone and EEZ, they are not considered “within the United States.”

Legislative Attorney for CRS 2009 [Name Redacted, “Marine Protected Areas (MPAs): Federal Legal Authority,” April 28, RL32486, Accessed 7/15/21]

An additional issue is whether the NWRSAA is meant to apply in the territorial sea and the EEZ. The statute states:

The mission of the System is to administer a national network of lands and waters for the conservation, management, and where appropriate, restoration of the fish, wildlife, and plant resources and their habitats within the United States for the benefit of present and future generations of Americans.169

2023 GDI Topicality
In The US › Excludes Contiguous Zone and EEZ

The contiguous zone is not “within the United States” for the purposes of federal law.

Legislative Attorney for CRS 2009 [Name Redacted, “Marine Protected Areas (MPAs): Federal Legal Authority,” April 28, RL32486, Accessed 7/15/21]

Under UNCLOS III and customary international law, a coastal nation may claim a contiguous zone extending beyond its territorial sea and up to twenty-four nautical miles from the coast, in which a coastal nation may also claim jurisdiction and regulate as may be necessary to protect the territorial sea and to enforce its customs, fiscal, immigration, and sanitary laws.42 After the extension of the U.S. territorial sea, President Clinton issued Proclamation No. 7219, claiming a U.S. contiguous zone reaching twenty-four nautical miles from the coast.43 Consistent with UNCLOS III, the Proclamation states that the United States “may exercise the control necessary to prevent infringement of its customs, fiscal, immigration, or sanitary laws and regulations within its territory or territorial sea.”44

The exact contours of U.S. authority in the contiguous zone are not, however, clearly defined. In United States v. De Leon, the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit stated “[t]he contiguous zone is an area in which the United States claims certain rights short of sovereignty.”45 The court did not go on to define the U.S. rights in the area nor does it appear that other courts have had the opportunity to do so. Thus, while it is clear that Congress has directed legislation at contiguous zone resources and that the United States can exercise some amount of regulatory control over the zone, it would not appear that this area would constitute U.S. territory subject to full U.S. sovereignty or ownership.46 Accordingly, the regulatory authority of the United States or the applicability of federal laws directed at areas “within the United States” may be limited.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Fiscal = Spending and Taxes

“Fiscal” relates to revenue and spending.

MBN Financial Glossary No Date

[Market Business News, “What is fiscal? Definition and examples”, , Accessed 6/26/2023, RT]

Fiscal relates to government revenue and spending, i.e., tax revenue and government expenditure. It also relates to government borrowing, i.e., public debt. In the United States, the term also means ‘financial year.’

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Fiscal = Spending and Taxes

Fiscal Policy is government spending and taxation to influence the economy.

Horton, Assistant Director IMF European Department, and El-Ganainy, IMF Fiscal Affairs Economist, No Date [Mark and Asmma, No Date, International Monetary Fund , “FISCAL POLICY: TAKING AND GIVING AWAY,” https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/Series/Back-to-Basics/Fiscal-Policy, Accessed 06/25/2023, BS]

Governments use spending and taxing powers to promote stable and sustainable growth

Fiscal policy is the use of government spending and taxation to influence the economy. Governments typically use fiscal policy to promote strong and sustainable growth and reduce poverty. The role and objectives of fiscal policy gained prominence during the recent global economic crisis, when governments stepped in to support financial systems, jump-start growth, and mitigate the impact of the crisis on vulnerable groups. In the communiqué following their London summit in April 2009, leaders of the Group of 20 industrial and emerging market countries stated that they were undertaking “unprecedented and concerted fiscal expansion.” What did they mean by fiscal expansion? And, more generally, how can fiscal tools provide a boost to the world economy?

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Must Be Direct

Fiscal redistribution requires direct quantitative easing or taxation—it excludes effectual redistribution of government regulation.

Hicks, Northwestern University & Swank, Marquette University 84

[Alexander, Duane H. Marquette University; December 1984; “GOVERNMENTAL REDISTRIBUTION IN RICH CAPITALIST DEMOCRACIES”; Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 13, Issue 1; University of Kansas Libraries, ProQuest]

GOVERNMENTAL REDISTRIBUTION

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Specify Targets of Redistribution

“Fiscal Redistribution” requires targeting on tax and/or transfer side.

Coady, IMF Fiscal Affairs Department Lead Social Spending Expert, 18

[David, 11-02-2018, International Monetary Fund, “FINANCING SOCIAL PROTECTION”, , Accessed 6-27-2023, RT]

Fiscal redistribution requires targeting; on tax and/or transfer side Optimal fiscal redistribution can be approximated with progressive income tax, consumption taxes and means-tested transfers Main challenge in developing economies is how to do means-testing of transfers with large informal economies and limited administrative capacity Categorical targeting involves trade-offs: undercoverage/leakage and fiscal cost PMTesting can improve, but issues of horizontal equity Can be (partially) overcome by PMTesting transfer levels as opposed to eligibility Choice reflects social preferences and constraints (admin, fiscal etc) Policy advice and evaluation should therefore reflect these preferences and constraints So should be country specific and could change over time.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Specify Targets of Redistribution

Must specify what the persons or groups resources are being distributed to and from- only way to determine whether redistribution has occurred.

Barry, Australian National University Philosophy Professor, 18

[Christian, Director of the Research School of Social Sciences @ANU, February 7, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Redistribution,” , Accessed 6/23/23 GAL Italics in original]

Redistribution refers to modifications of the holdings of particular persons, collective agents, or groups (as defined in terms of non-resource holding characteristics), or changes in holdings by groups (as defined by resource holdings). Sometimes those from and to whom resources are redistributed are defined as individuals, other times as groups to which individuals are rigidly assigned (for example, Whites and Hispanics), and other times to groups that are defined by their holdings (for example, the top and bottom quintile). We can identify patterns in terms of rigidly identifiable persons (John and Sally) or groups (Whites and Hispanics) or, alternatively, ‘anonymously’ (for example, as a percentile graph or Lorenz curve). We can imagine a scenario in which, pursuant to some institutional reform, the average holdings of the richest quintile and the poorest quintile shift from <5,3> at time t1 to <6,2> at time t2, while the average holdings of Whites and Hispanics or the actual holdings of John and Sally remain unchanged. Whether redistribution has occurred, then, can only be determined relative to the set of subjects that is identified.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Includes In-Kind Benefits

Fiscal redistribution includes in-kind benefits

Lustig, Tulane University, Professor of Latin American Economics & Higgins, Northwestern University Finance Professor ‘18 [Nora; Sean; “Commitment to Equity Handbook: Estimating the Impact of Fiscal Policy on Inequality and Poverty”; Brookings Institution, ISBN: 978-0-8157-3221-1, Chapter 1: THE CEQ ASSESSMENT Measuring the Impact of Fiscal Policy on Inequality and Poverty; University of Kansas Libraries, Springer Accessed 6/29/23, S.A.M]

1 The Theory of Fiscal Redistribution: Key Analytical Insights In this Handbook, “fiscal redistribution” refers to the process by which the state collects revenues from individuals and households(primarily through taxes) and spends these revenues on benefits (for example, cash transfers, price subsidies, and in-kind benefits such as education and health) intended for specific individuals and households. In so doing, the state changesthe postfiscal income distribution and poverty ratesthat would have prevailed in the absence of fiscal policy. Because of behavioral responses and general equilibrium effects, fiscal policy can also change the prefiscal income distribution and poverty rates. While at this point the CEQ Assessments do not estimate the counterfactual prefiscal income with these second-round effects in place, it is important to note that the analytical insights presented here and in chapters 2 (Enami, Lustig, and Aranda), 3 (Enami), 4 (Higgins and Lustig), and 5 (Enami) apply to fiscally included income redistribution regardless of the method used to estimate its extent. That is, regardless of whether fiscal redistribution is calculated using run-of-the-mill fiscal incidence analysis, microsimulation methods, or partial or general equilibrium modeling, the theoretical results discussed below and in the next four chapters apply. In addition to the taxes and benefits currently included in the CEQ Assessments, the state, or course, also spends on public goods, and collects revenues from and spends on subsidies that benefit corporations as well. While spending on public goods and taxing and subsidizing corporations also have redistributive effects, these forms of revenue collection and spending are not considered in the CEQ Assessment tool (at least, not for the moment).

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR= Taxes/Cash Only- Excludes In-Kind Benefits

“Fiscal Redistribution” is taxes and cash benefits only- does not include in-kind benefits.

de Mooij, Erasmus University Rotterdam public economics professor, 6

[Ruud, 03/2006, Centraa planbureau, “Reinventing the Welfare State”, , Accessed 6-28-2023, RT]

a Fiscal redistribution involves redistribution via taxes and cash benefits; benefits in kind are not included. b Gini coefficient for individual yearly incomes, corrected for household size. Figures refer to an average of different years between 1980 and 2000 for which income data were available in the LIS. c Difference between Gini for pre-tax income and disposable income, divided by Gini for pre-tax income.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Includes Upwards Redistribution

The topic is bidirectional- fiscal redistribution includes reverse Robin Hood upwards redistribution.

Dyck, Department of Finance Employee, Government of Canada 5

[Dagmar; 2005; “Fiscal Redistribution in Canada, 1994-2000”; Canadian Tax Journal, Vol. 53, No. 4; University of Kansas Libraries, Hein Online Accessed 6/29/23, S.A.M]

The policy decisions of governments, whether at the federal, provincial, or local level or in the public pension sector (Canada Pension Plan/Quebec Pension Plan (C/QPP]) have an impact on Canadians' pocketbooks. Families pay taxes in exchange for the benefits of government expenditure, such as unemployment insurance, health care, or defence. Of course, the exchange is not exact for all families—taxes may be either more or less than benefits received— and so there may be a broad relationship between a family's income and its gain or loss from the fiscal operations of government. This gain or loss may be called "fiscal redistribution." Fiscal redistribution could vary from the situation, at one extreme, where all tax revenues are collected from higher income groups and all benefits are distributed to lower income groups ("government as Robin Hood") to the other extreme, where lower income groups pay all of the taxes while higher income groups receive all of the benefits ("government as reverse Robin Hood").' This article examines where the Canadian public sector fits on this continuum by first apportioning, across all family income groups, both the amount of taxes paid and the amount of benefits received, and then attempting to determine the impact of fiscal redistribution across and between income groups.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › FR Excludes Upwards Redistribution

Tax cuts for the rich just allow them to keep their money- it’s not redistribution.

Dorfman, UGA Economics Professor, 17 [Jeffrey, “Tax Cuts for the Wealthy are Not Income Redistribution,” Forbes, July 10, Accessed 7/5/23 GAL]

I had a Twitter debate with Noah Smith and Matt Bruenig a few weeks ago on whether or not tax cuts for the wealthy should be considered income redistribution. I argued they should not since people were simply being allowed to keep money they had earned. Matt Bruenig (with an assist from Noah Smith) took the opposite side, claiming that since virtually all income was only earned thanks to various government-bestowed advantages and government-installed infrastructure, the original income was essentially distributed by the government. According to Noah, I lost. If so, it was not because my side of the argument was inferior, but my quickness of thought. Here is the argument I should have made.

The argument advanced by Mr. Bruenig is that by protecting property rights, investing in infrastructure, organizing public education, and similar actions, government is the true fount of virtually all wealth. Thus, the original income (or wealth) distribution was created by the government so any change in tax policy that affects the distribution is redistribution, even allowing people to keep more of their own money.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Redistribution Excludes Benefit and Consumption Taxes

Redistributive taxes are distinct from benefit and compensation taxes.

Barry, Columbia Philosophy Professor, 18 [Christian, Stanford Encyclopedia of philosophy, “redistribution”   6/25/23 KCD]

Discussions of redistribution have often focused on the permissibility of levying taxes. And it may therefore be tempting simply to identify the baseline with pretax income. Not all taxes, however, are generally considered redistributive. Indeed, economists and legal theorists have typically distinguished between ‘redistributive’ and ‘benefit’ taxation. Benefit taxes are typically understood (Biehl 1982, Cappelen 2000) as user charges: taxes that are paid to cover the costs of the use of public and private goods, services, and enabling social conditions (for example, security, the legal system, social cohesion, public health) that are secured by the government or taxing authority.

These taxes are, in effect, user charges. Redistributive taxation is also commonly distinguished from Pigouvian (after the economist Arthur Pigou), or what might most aptly called ‘compensation’ taxes, which pays for harms that persons cause to the environment or to other people through their activities.[] Taxes on carbon emissions, maritime dumping, non-renewable resource extraction, and even currency transactions, have often been characterized in this way. Let us call this understanding ‘redistribution as tax and transfer’.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › UBI Financed By Welfare Cuts Regressive

Financing UBI by cutting existing programs increases inequality and redistributes income upwards

Greenstein, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities Founder and President Emeritus, 19 [Robert, “Commentary: Universal Basic Income May Sound Attractive But, If It Occurred, Would Likelier Increase Poverty Than Reduce It,” CBPP, June 13, Accessed 7/6/23 GAL]

UBI’s daunting financing challenges raise fundamental questions about its political feasibility, both now and in coming decades. Proponents often speak of an emerging left-right coalition to support it. But consider what UBI’s supporters on the right advocate. They generally propose UBI as a replacement for the current “welfare state.” That is, they would finance UBI by eliminating all or most programs for people with low or modest incomes.

Consider what that would mean. If you take the dollars targeted on people in the bottom fifth or two-fifths of the population and convert them to universal payments to people all the way up the income scale, you’re redistributing income upward. That would increase poverty and inequality rather than reduce them.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Net Effect Must be Progressive

Fiscal Redistribution requires that transfers would need to be more progressive than taxes

Coady IMF, fiscal affairs department, head of expenditure policy division et al., 19

(David, Devin D’Angelo, IMF, Research Analyst, Brooks Evans, IMF, Senior Economist, February 2019, International Monetary Fund, “Fiscal Redistribution and Social Welfare”, , accessed 6-29-23, ED)

Fiscal progressivity is affected by both the progressivity of taxes (lower λT) and transfers (higher λM). Fiscal redistribution requires that transfers are more progressive than taxes, i.e. the social cost of transfers needs to be less than the social benefit of transfers. Figure 4 shows the variation in tax and transfer progressivity across countries. While, on average, taxes reduce fiscal redistribution by around 56 percent (the ratio of the social cost of taxes, λT, to the social cost of transfers, λM), there is very little systematic relationship between the two. In some countries, such as Ireland and Belgium, high transfer progressivity is reinforced by high tax progressivity. In others, such as Hungary and Poland, low transfer progressivity is reinforced by low tax progressivity. In the Netherlands and Belgium, high transfer progressivity is offset by low tax progressivity, whereas in Portugal and Cyprus low transfer progressivity is offset by high tax progressivity. 

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Redistribution Excludes Benefit and Consumption Taxes

Redistributive taxes are distinct from benefit and compensation taxes.

Barry, Columbia Philosophy Professor, 18 [Christian, Stanford Encyclopedia of philosophy, “redistribution”   6/25/23 KCD]

Discussions of redistribution have often focused on the permissibility of levying taxes. And it may therefore be tempting simply to identify the baseline with pretax income. Not all taxes, however, are generally considered redistributive. Indeed, economists and legal theorists have typically distinguished between ‘redistributive’ and ‘benefit’ taxation. Benefit taxes are typically understood (Biehl 1982, Cappelen 2000) as user charges: taxes that are paid to cover the costs of the use of public and private goods, services, and enabling social conditions (for example, security, the legal system, social cohesion, public health) that are secured by the government or taxing authority.

These taxes are, in effect, user charges. Redistributive taxation is also commonly distinguished from Pigouvian (after the economist Arthur Pigou), or what might most aptly called ‘compensation’ taxes, which pays for harms that persons cause to the environment or to other people through their activities.[] Taxes on carbon emissions, maritime dumping, non-renewable resource extraction, and even currency transactions, have often been characterized in this way. Let us call this understanding ‘redistribution as tax and transfer’.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Be Progressive/Reduce Inequality

Fiscal redistribution must go from higher-income folks to lower-income folks

Mulle, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies Reasercher, 18 — [Emmanuel Dalle, 2018; “The Nationalism of the Rich: Discourses and Strategies of Separatist Parties in Catalonia, Flanders, Northern Italy and Scotland”; Routledge, ISBN: 978-1-315-15895-2, Chapter 2: Catalonia Fiscal plundering and the end of federalism; University of Kansas Libraries, Taylor & Francis]

The formation of ERC’s claims of fiscal exploitation and their degree of credibility also depend on other factors than just the existence of a fiscal deficit with the central administration. While the ‘adequate’ level of social redistribution is a political question that does not concern us here, what can be discussed from a technical perspective is whether there are major flaws in the system that might nourish discontent with concrete forms of social redistribution. Ways of looking at this include the evaluation of: overcompensation effects, considerations of efficiency and regional economic convergence, trends in taxation and public finances, and the overall evolution of the economy. A minimal definition of fiscal redistribution entails that regionsshould contribute in accordance with their income but receive equal per capita spending. Hence, those with a higher than average income should be net contributors and those with a lower one net recipients. Uriel and Barberan (2007, p. 412) show that, in the period 1991–2005, Catalonia’s position was in line with this assumption. Yet, there also are some overcompensation effects,6 although their precise size is unclear. Using data for 2005, Espasa and Bosch (2010) argued that Catalonia received between 12 per cent and 14 per cent less than the Spanish average. Yet, De la Fuente (2005) calculated the same amount at 6 per cent below the average for the period 1990–97. Furthermore, this has affected other contributory regions and not exclusively Catalonia (Tortella 2016, pp. 441–443). What, instead, seems to be uncontroversial is the disproportionately low amount of infrastructural investment received by Catalonia. De la Fuente – who has otherwise provided very conservative estimates of the fiscal deficit (e.g. De la Fuente 2001) – has pointed out that the Generalitat received less investment than all other autonomous communities during the 1990s. Such spending represents a small share of the deficit claimed by ERC, but it probably had a sizable negative impact on the development of the Catalan economy in recent years.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Be Progressive/Reduce Inequality

Redistribution must go from the rich to the poor

Decoster, KU Leuven professor at the Faculty of Business and Economics and Camp, University of Antwerp Researcher 98 (Andre and Guy Van, 2000 “The unit of analysis in microsimulation models for personal income taxes: fiscal unit or household?,” Center for Economic Studies, Papre DPS 98.33 Accessed 6/29/23, S.A.M.)

If the main objective of the evaluation of a tax reform is to give empirical content to the redistributive effects of different tax systems before and after the reforms, a formal expression of the concept of redistribution is required. Redistribution is defined here as the shift of income which occurs in the post-tax distribution from high to low incomes. Hence, it can be measured by comparing the pre-tax Lorenz curve with the post-tax concentration curve. Our measure of redistributive effect is therefore defined as: Π [ ] RS = − ∫ L p L p dp XT X − 2 0 1 () () (2) where the superscript of ΠRS refers to Reynolds and Smolensky (1977) who applied this measure to the US tax system, and L p xf x dx X y ( ) ( ) = ∫ µ 0 0 1 ≤≤ = p p Fy and ( ) (3) L p x t x f x dx t X T y − = − − ∫ ( ) ( ( )) ( ) µ( ) 1 0 0 1 ≤≤ = p p Fy and ( ) (4) are, respectively, the Lorenz curve of pre-tax income ( x ) and the concentration curve with respect to pre-tax income of after-tax income ( x tx − ( ) ), with: p : the population shares of the pre-tax distribution f x( ) : the density function of x F x( ) : the distribution function of x µ : mean income (pre tax) t x( ) : the tax liability corresponding with taxable income x t : the average tax rate.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution › Must Be Progressive/Reduce Inequality

“Fiscal Redistribution” combines progressive taxation and transfers.

The Herald, 18 [MCEBISI JONAS, 03/09/2018, “Let us talk about inequality”, p. L/N accessed 06/29/2023, RT]

Fiscal redistribution (progressive taxation combined with state spending on grants, public services and social infrastructure) is a proven method of increasing inclusivity, and must be sustained despite its limits. Quality public education both increases economic growth potential and increases the employment prospects of the marginalised. Improving education must be our primary focus.