Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Circumvention

Regardless of the aff’s intentions, their version of UBI will be shaped by institutions dominated by the right.

Battistoni, Yale, Political Science, PhD candidate 2017 [Alyssa, Editor at Jacobin, Dissent, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income,” Spring https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/false-promise-universal-basic-income-andy-stern-ruger-bregman/]

It’s often noted that Milton Friedman as well as Martin Luther King, Jr. supported basic income—and the new generation of advocates is similarly eclectic, running the gamut from Trump-supporting venture capitalists like Thiel to “fully automated luxury communists” like Peter Frase. There are, in short, many different reasons for supporting UBI—and just as many versions of what it could be.

One version functions as a kind of noblesse oblige—a handout to the unfortunates being made obsolete by robots smarter and more efficient than they are. Another version aspires to egalitarian universalism and challenges the legitimacy of privately accumulated wealth. There’s a version that sees UBI as the spark for a generation of entrepreneurs, and another that simply attempts to stave off a revolt of the precarious masses.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Economic Nationalism

Universalism abstracts notions of citizenship and the “common good” from particular histories of racial violence. We can only resist right-wing economic nationalism via an explicitly anti-racist politics.

Casey, American Federation of Teachers Albert Shanker Institute Executive Director, 18 [Leo, Winter 2018, Dissent Magazine, “The Perils of Universalism” Accessed 7/03/2023, RM]

Authoritarian efforts to diminish and degrade democratic citizenship are a central dimension of the crisis of democracy sweeping the globe. Such efforts include both the abrogation of particular rights of citizenship and the denial of citizenship itself to entire classes of people. Yet few on the left are approaching the current crisis in that way. Attention has been paid to attacks on particular rights of citizenship, such as voter suppression in the United States. But there is a failure to grapple with the broad dimensions and underlying logic of the offensive against democratic citizenship. Given the centrality of citizenship to the rule of the people, this failure ill prepares us to defend democracy.

This offensive is not limited to attacks on citizenship in a general, undifferentiated way; it takes particular aim at the rights of “racialized” others. In the United States, these attacks target not only groups historically subjected to racial oppression, such as African Americans, but others who fall outside a narrowly circumscribed notion of what it is considered “American”—immigrants and refugees, ethnic groups such as Latinos, and those adhering to minority religious faiths such as Muslims. The machinery of racial oppression is now increasingly applied to all of these groups, citizens and non-citizens alike, with respect to the rights they are entitled to in this country.

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Exclusive Citizenship Rights

UBI support decreases when applied to immigrants – backlash and racist implementations -- empirics

Bay and Pederson 2006 [Ann-Helén and Axel W, December 2006, Acta Sociologica, “The Limits of Social Solidarity: Basic Income, Immigration and the Legitimacy of the Universal Welfare State https://www.jstor.org/stable/20459958, July 3 2023, ah]

The application of our persuasion experiment suggests, however, that part of this coalition is rather frail. By simply pointing out that an unconditional basic income will include non

citizens living in Norway, many initial supporters are persuaded to change their mind. In addition, a group of initial opponents of basic income are willing to consider such a scheme

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Exclusive Citizenship Rights

Yang’s campaign proves- demands for universalism are easily coopted for racist ends- UBI attracts white nationalist support by excluding non-citizens.

Breland, Internet disinformation reporter, 19 [Ali, writing on technology, race, politics, etc, appeared in The Guardian, Vice and on NPR and CNN’s websites. “Here’s Why Andrew Yang’s Alt-Right Supporters Think He’s the 2020 Candidate for White Nationalists” Mother Jones, April 10, Accessed 7-16-23 ]-grh

Yang has also attracted a diverse and sometimes chaotic group of adherents. Beyond the centrist Democrats and Silicon Valley liberals Yang has wooed through traditional campaigning, he’s garnered support among white nationalists, self-described white identitarians, and white supremacists. The groups either mildly disagree with the others or outright hate them.

“Messy is an understatement,” said Louis, pointing to one 4chan thread where white supremacists and white nationalists viciously debated whether Yang’s politics had the potential to start a “white revolution.”

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Links › Universalism Bad- Exclusive Citizenship Rights

Universal social policies are based in limited notions of citizenship that exclude the undocumented and formerly incarcerated.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 Accessed 7/2/2023, PE]

However, Warren goes on to acknowledge the limitations of the universality of basic income when understood as reparations. He points out that all too often, nominally universal policies exclude minorities, for instance by excluding formerly incarcerated populations. Yet even if a universal basic income were to be designed to be truly universal, Warren wonders if a UBI is simultaneously too broad and too narrow to address issues of racial injustice in a post-slavery society. It might be too broad in its universality — its net beneficiaries would be anyone below a set income level,8 which would include those that might be economically disadvantaged, but do not face racial discrimination and the injustices of living in a post-slavery society. Warren also worries that a universal basic income would allow the US to evade the question of direct investment in Black communities. In many ways, this point mirrors the feminist debates around basic income. While some feminist UBI advocates argue that a UBI would disproportionately benefit women and those engaged in unpaid care, others point out that it would also support men who chose to ignore or evade care work responsibilities, and make the case that there should be either special or additional support for carers.9

At the same time, Warren argues that a UBI's benefits could be too narrow because of its typical focus on citizenship rights. As he points out, many UBI models propose that the income goes to all of a country's citizens. However, what happens to immigrants who are not citizens, including immigrants who face racial discrimination? And what about incarcerated populations, who are frequently deprived of some citizenship benefits (such as voting rights)? Yet while Warren is correct that many UBI proposals have traditionally focused on citizens, this has recently shifted. James Ferguson's work on rightful shares has made the case that a universal payment should be disbursed not on the basis of citizenship, but rather on presence (or, to put it more practically, residence) within a nation state (Ferguson, 2021).

2023 GDI Kritik
Universalism Neg › Universalism Bad 1nc

Universal social protections obscure the role of historical and contemporary racism in creating wealth inequalities. The alternative is to endorse an ethics of distribution that prioritizes reparative justice.

Klein, ANU Canberra Public Policy Lecturer & Fouksman, King’s College Social Justice Lecturer, 22 [Edward & Elizaveta, 11/21/2021, Development and Change, Volume 53, Issue 1, January “Reparations as a Rightful Share: From Universalism to Redress in Distributive Justice] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/dech.12695 07/02/2023, Accessed 7/16/23 RM]

Universalism has long been a cornerstone of claims to both resources and rights. Such claims range from the universal in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, to more recent interest in universal social protection floors, universal health care and universal basic income within international development and social policy debates. Many of these claims for universalism, such as for human rights, are based on long-standing philosophical conceptions of a fundamental, universal and shared humanness. Others, such as that for universal social protection floors and universal basic income (UBI), are based not only on the administrative efficiency and political expediency of universal policy, but also on a long tradition of justice-based arguments around the universal nature of collective and historical wealth creation (Kropotkin, /1955; Paine, ; Sloman, ). Indeed, though universal social protection in the form of guaranteed income or unconditional direct cash transfers has garnered increasing appeal as a social policy intervention around the globe, there has also been a revival of interest in the justice-based and rights-based case for universal and unconditional access to a share of national or global wealth (Fouksman and Klein, ).

Rights-based and distributory justice-based claims to universal payments have a long history, ranging from Thomas Paine's ‘universal inheritance’ (), meant to rectify the unjust distribution of land, through T.H. Marshall's () writing about the right to economic security as a key part of full social citizenship, and extending to Guy Standing's proposal for a universal basic income framed as a ‘commons dividend’ (Standing, ). Within the field of international development, James Ferguson has argued that the rising popularity of cash transfers as a social policy tool in the majority world heralds a larger political shift. Ferguson terms this shift ‘a new politics of distribution’ — a politics in which people demand universal basic income as a share of collectively and historically created wealth (Ferguson, ), and make such demands on the basis of nothing more than physical presence (rather than contribution, or even citizenship) (Ferguson, ). In other words, ‘the entire production apparatus must be treated as a single, common inheritance’ (Ferguson, : 186) — ‘a rightful share’. Such framings all underscore that wealth in society is largely collectively generated, and that as such all residents have a right to a share in that wealth — in particular both the wealth created by previous generations, and the benefit of commons such as natural resources. This socially generated wealth must thus be shared universally.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › K Framing against UBI

Prefer the philosophical consequences of a UBI over the materiality of the 1AC

Harris 2023 (Neal, Department of Social Sciences, Oxford Brookes University, Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income, Critical Sociology, sagepub.com/journals-permissions DOI: 10.1177/08969205231151562 p.11-12)-TL

Conclusion This is the conundrum of UBI for the left: there is an obvious quantitative gain – which is seemingly undeniable. The poorest in society will benefit from better healthcare outcomes, may live longer and may have greater access to the market economy. However, these quantitative benefits do not signal the move to a more emancipated socialistic society. The counterpoint to these quantitative benefits is the further colonisation of social domains by capitalist forms of cognition and subjectivity. As such, in this paper, I have argued that the further dominance of pathological forms of desire and consciousness need to be factored into the discussion of whether the left should embrace UBI as a policy. As such, despite the claims made by its progressive advocates, when viewed from a critical theory perspective, it seems possible that implementing a UBI may entrench neoliberalism, rather than challenge it. Critical theory is thus of importance to this conversation, as it is through a fusion of Marxian, Weberian, neo-Hegelian, and psychoanalytic insights that reification and can be interrogated. From a critical theory perspective, one may suggest that the implementation of UBI payments could defer, rather than expedite, progressive qualitative transition. Unlike ‘Traditional Theorists’, who proclaim a scholarly objectivity, critical theorists make no such pretensions towards ‘apolitical’, or value-free, research (Horkheimer, 2002). Critical theorists are explicit about their politics and reflexively acknowledge their research contribution sits as part of a broader political goal: socialistic transition. I have done so here: this paper is explicitly a leftwing critique of UBI. However, for critical theorists, such reflexivity is not merely limited to admitting one’s positionality and political preferences. No investigation of UBI would be complete without reflecting on the political implications of introducing a UBI. A further, obvious question must be considered in conclusion: is it a good idea in the existing political world? To this end, I offer the briefest strategic argument as an addendum to this paper, as to why the implementation of a UBI should be resisted by progressive activists to compliment my critical theoretical rejection of UBI. Because the idea of introducing a UBI enjoys ‘support from the both the left and right’ (Murphy, 2019: 13), a la Brexit, it is possible that a coalition of populist forces could be united to rally to the call. The promise of a left UBI would appeal broadly and the power of the neoliberal media could succeed, again, in obtaining the necessary support to propel the idea. However, once initiated, the proclaimed ‘capitalist road to communism’ could echo post-Brexit developments in the United Kingdom: the policy could be pushed hard right and could actually serve to normalise right-libertarian values (see Dearden, 2020). What may start as a UBI accompanying the welfare state may slowly shift to the idea of UBI enabling expedited privatisation. As Martinelli (2017: 5) notes, for right-libertarian supporters of UBI, crucially the idea is not to supplement the welfare state, but to ‘replace it’. With a dismantled welfare state, the next logical step for the neoliberal elite would be the gradual reduction of the UBI payment. This would likely occur in two ways: one, creeping conditionality, through conduct policing – targeting activists and those who oppose neoliberal norms, and two, reducing the UBI level to the minimum needed to enable repressive desublimation. As the Bank of England sets interest rates in the United Kingdom today, UBI would be similarly adjusted to optimally inculcate public support and repress dissent, while providing only the smallest possible redistribution of wealth. When van Parijs was writing of UBI as the ‘capitalist road to communism’ in 1986, my political-strategic consideration above may rightly have been deemed deeply dystopian. However, in the populist, Trumpian world, with ever-decreasing space for critical judgement (see Thompson, 2022), such a calculated rejection of UBI on this political basis may now appear a more rational and sensible course to adopt.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Inflation link

UBI without taxation guarantees inflation

Jason Leman ’18, September 27, “WHY SHOULD A UBI PILOT BE TAXING?” https://www.ubilabnetwork.org/blog/should-a-ubi-pilot-be-taxing

Let’s say that we ignore the current tax and benefits system completely and give out additional money to everyone. This might reflect a UBI funded through, for example, ‘helicopter money’. This is the scenario on the left in Figure 1. For a pilot, we would need to pay each person the full UBI, as we would not be adjusting the payment for any current income. This is therefore the most expensive UBI pilot, which is the 100% comparison in Figure 2 below. Aside from the cost, there are also questions of feasibility. Printing money and distributing it to everyone sounds great, but at the levels required by a reasonable UBI there is a risk ‘helicopter money’ will simply drive inflation upwards. As inflation rises, income and savings are worth less, making ‘helicopter money’ a stealth tax on income and savings. If we do not properly consider the impacts of how we fund a UBI, these impacts could end up removing any benefits of a basic income scheme. If we are to have any confidence that the results from a pilot are meaningful, then we also need to be confident that we have considered the impacts of our funding model.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Politics link – UBI

Link turns the case – lack of support hurts long-term solvency

Rich Whitney ’21, September 22, 2021. “How Universal Basic Income Can Help Build a Solidarity Economy,” NON PROFIT QUARTERLY, https://nonprofitquarterly.org/how-universal-basic-income-can-help-build-a-solidarity-economy/

This criticism fails to recognize that the benefits of any such reform measure always depend upon political will. For example, just because public funding of higher education in the United States has been inadequate for decades, this does not make higher education a bad idea. The public housing system in the United States is horrible, but that does not make public housing a bad idea. The success of any reform always depends, in the final analysis, on sufficient mobilization to not only win the gain but also maintain it over time.

Therefore, the only legitimate aspect of this criticism of reforms like UBI is that the political mobilization needed to obtain it and sustain it over time will divert time and energy from other projects that may more directly advance us toward a solidarity economy. In short, it comes down to a judgment call on whether work on this reform merits the expenditure of time, effort, and political capital needed to secure it versus other projects that would advance the ball.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Politics link – UBI

Their link-turn is hollow – support for UBI is all talk

Jurgen De Wispelaere and Ruslan Yemtsov ’20, “Chapter 6: The Political Economy of Universal Basic Income,” Exploring Universal Basic Income: A Guide to Navigating Concepts, Evidence, and Practices,” online but it’s a book

A factor leading to the lack of resilience of UBI proposals is that many expressions of political support for the UBI are “cheap”: they come with no real political commitment, which means they are both easy to express and an unreliable indicator of current or future willingness or expend political capital in support of UBI. A good example is political actors endorsing UBI when in the opposition, only to fail to act on their earlier endorsement once in government.47 A UBI coalition is highly instable when much of the support for a UBI is cheap. 48

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Politics link – UBI

Passing UBI would be a huge battle

Bourne, CATO Chairman for the Public Understandings of Economics, ‘18 [Ryan, 08-03-2018, CATO, “A Basic Income Would Crash on the Rocks of Politics”] 06-29-2023, RM

We are told poverty would be eliminated, job‐​killing automation protected against, innovation would flourish, and working improve dramatically. Opponents aren’t much less hyperbolic. A UBI would supposedly blow up the public finances, drive mass worklessness, and undermine families. But this polarized debate hides the messy truth: the UBI as an idea exposes the current welfare state’s flaws. And any simple UBI would be crushed on the rocks of politics and its inherent trade‐​offs. Provided that it was not set at an extremely high level, this need not result in huge swathes of people not working. No doubt some people would pocket the income and not engage in the formal labor market, especially if they currently feel compelled to work to get by. On the margin, more students may prefer to focus on their studies. More parents might decide to spend time with children. Those between jobs may take longer to find positions that genuinely match their skills and talents. A UBI would remove these disincentives for progression or investment in your own human capital. As such, it could increase employment levels for many.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Capitalism k

Basic income settles for peanuts and undermines any momentum toward truly changing capitalism

DANIEL ZAMORA ’17, December 28, TRANSLATION BY JEFF BATE BOEROP, “The Case Against a Basic Income,” JACOBIN, https://jacobin.com/2017/12/universal-basic-income-inequality-work

Beyond arguments of feasibility or the effects on the labor market, we need to ask a more fundamental question: is distributing €1,100 to the whole population the best use of 35 percent of GDP? Isn’t the best way to fight against capitalism to limit the sphere in which it operates? Establishing a base income, by contrast, merely allows everyone to participate in the market.

Our current economic crisis goes beyond the problem of income inequality. While inequality garners the most attention, it’s a secondary feature of capitalism. One of capitalism’s most remarkable achievements (but also one of its most violent) is that it made market exchange the nearly exclusive means to acquire the goods necessary for our own reproduction. In doing so, it turned money into almost the only valid medium of exchange and it made the majority of the population dependent on capital, enforcing a fundamentally asymmetric power relation between the boss and the worker. This profoundly unequal relationship not only subordinates people within the sphere of labor, but outside it as well, through the powerful influence economic power exerts on politics, ideology, and culture.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Vagueness

The plan is vague – specificity is key to NEG ground, research, and clash

Philippe Van Parijs, Hoover Chair of Economic and Social Ethics @ University of Louvain, Louvain, Belgium, Nuffield College, Oxford, UK, ’13, “The Universal Basic Income: Why Utopian Thinking Matters, and How Sociologists Can Contribute to It” Politics & Society 41(2) 171–182, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0032329213483106

No precise speculation can get off the ground without a specification of the level of basic income, of what it is meant to replace, and of the scale at which it is going to be funded. Typical proposals in developed countries involve, as a first step, the introduction of an individual basic income at half the level of the means-tested welfare benefit currently paid to a couple without any other income, combined with the retention of means-tested supplements for single people and with the abolition of tax exemptions in the personal income tax system. More ambitious or longer-term proposals pitch the unconditional basic income at a level high enough to live a decent life, even when living alone, and consequently involve the total replacement of means-tested schemes. But whatever the level and other features of the scheme, the core of the investigation of its economic sustainability tends to take the form of simple economic models that try to capture the so-called income effects and substitution effects of the proposed scheme on the supply of labor.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › T – UBI must tax to be T

Taxed and transfers are intertwined – otherwise not possible to assess the effects of a transfer

N. Gregory Mankiw ’19, October 18, “How to Increase Taxes on the Rich (If You Must)” Essay for Combating Inequality, edited by Olivier Blanchard and Dani Rodrik, https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/mankiw/files/how_to_increase_taxes_on_the_rich_amended_feb2020.pdf

The second lesson from this example is how misleading it can be to focus on taxes and transfers separately. It is accurate to say that Plan A has lower taxes, more progressive taxes, and more progressive transfers. But so what? Those facts do not stop it from being precisely equivalent to plan B. The equivalence is clear only when taxes and transfers are considered together.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › T – UBI must tax to be T

UBI funded from preexisting resources is not T – actually distributes UPWARD

JUAN CARLOS CONESA, BO LI AND QIAN LI January, 2020. “Universal Basic Income and Progressive Consumption Taxes,” WORKING PAPER 2020-01, STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY, https://www.stonybrook.edu/commcms/economics/research/papers/2020/UBI_Ctax_2001.pdf

We first consider the long-run impact of distributing equally among all working-age households the average amount of targeted transfers in the benchmark economy. A key question regarding the implementation of UBI is how the rest of the tax system adjusts. In Table 6 we report the macroeconomic and welfare implications of introducing UBI under four different policy scenarios: 1. Adjusting upward capital income taxes, 2. Adjusting upward labor income taxes, 3. Introducing consumption taxes keeping income taxes fixed, and 4. Removing income taxes and switching to a consumption-based tax system. In alternatives 3 and 4 we obtain the combination of taxes on basic and non-basic goods that maximizes the ex-ante expected welfare of a newborn. Keeping income taxes unchanged, adjusting consumption tax rates to balance the government budget (alternative 3) yields a long run optimal combination of τc1 = −0.20 and τc2 = 0.13, introducing consumption tax progressivity. Eliminating income taxes (alternative 4) results in an optimal combination of consumption taxes that is also very progressive, with τc1 = 0.10 and τc2 = 0.49.

In all these cases, capital shock falls with the exception of alternative 4, in which the elimination of income taxes encourages capital accumulation. All these policies stimulate labor supply, espe- cially for the non-college group. There are two reasons for that. First, under the targeted transfer system of the benchmark these households receive an annual transfer as high as $4,838, if they fall into the first quintile. However, UBI only pays them $2,488 per year. This negative income effect drives low educated households to supply more labor. Second, since UBI is not income tested the distortion on labor supply at the bottom of the distribution is eliminated. In contrast, college educated households adjust their labor supply slightly, and in different directions depending on the different policy scenarios.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***OFF-CASE*** › Social services – link uq for the NEG

Social services won’t be big or permanent in the status quo

Claire Cain Miller and Alicia Parlapiano ’23, May 11, 2023. “The U.S. Built a European-Style Welfare State. It’s Largely Over.” NEW YORK TIMES, https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/04/06/upshot/pandemic-safety-net-medicaid.html

Political polarization and congressional gridlock have made a permanent expansion of social benefits more difficult. So has the current economic climate, with high inflation and interest rates. While Republicans argue that the increases in government spending during the pandemic fueled inflation, people in the Biden administration have countered that other factors have played a bigger role, like the oil shock from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, and pandemic-related challenges like supply chain tangles and shifts in what Americans have wanted to buy.

“The politics of trying to make these programs permanent just isn’t there today, not to mention budget constraints,” said Samuel Hammond, an economist at the Lincoln Network, a right-leaning think tank. “The macro environment has turned in a way that has sort of reaffirmed the fiscal conservatives.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › A2 no spillover

Err negative – risk spillover is unpredictable but ensured in one form or another

SafetyRisk ’22, “Risk Homeostasis Theory–Why Safety Initiatives Go Wrong,” https://safetyrisk.net/risk-homeostasis-theorywhy-safety-initiatives-go-wrong/

The ineffectiveness of safety and risk controls may extend beyond specific hazards or individual issues and is not always immediately obvious. With the traditional narrow focus of many safety initiatives resulting from say controlling specific hazards and risks or root cause analysis of incidents, there are trade-offs and by-products for what may seem like short term success of any simplistic initiatives implemented. Long refers to these as “Band-aid Solutions” (Long, 2014, p. 103).

It is interesting that when we try to solve problems simplistically and in isolation, we create by-products that are either shifted or hidden till later……….On the surface it appears that the problem in solved yet, under the surface, a whole new problem has emerged.(Long, 2014, p. 103).

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Risk Homeostasis – automation

Automation supercharges risk homeostasis

Dr Cosima Gretton ’17. June 24, “The dangers of AI in health care: risk homeostasis and automation bias,” https://towardsdatascience.com/the-dangers-of-ai-in-health-care-risk-homeostasis-and-automation-bias-148477a9080f

The performance of a system when applied to messy, real-world clinical practice will no doubt have an accuracy of less than 100%, so human operators must know when to trust, and when not to trust the system. How we design the interaction between the human and machine becomes of utmost importance to prevent new biases and errors being introduced.

Risk homeostasis would suggest that over-automating aspects of clinical practice might lead to complacency and an increase in errors and accidents. Studies from other fields have shown that humans do indeed suffer from automation bias and a reduction in personal accountability when their tasks are taken over by machines.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Turn – risk homeostasis

Risk homeostasis skew makes climate change inevitable

Gordon Kubanek ’12, August 09, “How to Change People’s Perspective on Energy Efficiency,” https://www.adecesg.com/resources/blog/how-to-change-peoples-perspective-on-energy-efficiency/

However, according to his risk homeostasis theory and research done in Germany [1], drivers who have better technology without a change in attitude towards the risk of accidents DO NOT have fewer accidents! As a matter of fact, they simply drive faster and tailgate closer to cars in front of them because they know that ABS gives them a reduced braking distance and greater sense of security. Ergo, the challenge in designing any technology that hopes to change human behavior—in our case perceptions towards energy and carbon use—is to simultaneously change the attitudes and values that people have about the real problem that the technology is trying to address.

So now, let’s apply this theory to energy and carbon use. Currently, energy is relatively cheap again because of shale gas fracking and new technologies to develop hard-to-extract tar sands oil deposits. It appears that technology has saved the day! But really there are at least two problems with this rosy picture:

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Turn – risk homeostasis

UBI increases daily risk-taking

Thomas Straubhaar, University of Hamburg, ’17. “On the Economics of a Universal Basic Income,” INTERECONOMICS, Volume 52, 2017 · Number 2 · pp. 74–80,

The UBI would empower people to more readily take on some risks of daily life. If people are assured that a failure will not lead to a bottomless case of destitution and poverty, and that their subsistence minimum is secured, they will assess future challenges as opportunities rather than threats. This applies to all people, and not just to those who behave in accordance with social norms and traditional values or behaviours. On the contrary, nonconformists often help to see the world through different eyes and from novel perspectives. New ideas and innovative solutions can emerge from the new thinking of outsiders.

The economics of insurance behaviour can convincingly show that insured people are willing to accept more risks.24 And a larger share of risk-takers within the total population correlates positively with the macroeconomic performance of a society. This empirical observation is the justification for compulsory insurance, for example motor vehicle liability insurance or health and accident insurance. However, the positive correlation between being insured and taking more risks also contains sound economic reasons for a state social policy which serves the purpose of securing the subsistence minimum for everybody.