Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Wealth tax fails

A wealth tax fails – causes high productivity households to migration

Esmkhani, Sauder school of Business Department of Finance Member, 21

[Khalil, Jack Favilukis, Sauder school of Business Department of Finance Member, Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, Graduate school of business Department of Finance Member, Jain Family Institute, “Universal Basic Income and the City”, , Accessed 6/26/2023, S.P.]

These different types of taxes also have different effects on the spatial dimension. For example, when the tax is targeted at the most wealthy (the progressive and wealth tax experiments) then high productivity and high wealth households tend to leave the city center for the suburbs. For example, with a progressive tax, the average productivity of those living in the city center falls by 9.4%, and the average income falls by 25.8%; with a wealth tax the average productivity falls by 5% but the average wealth by 15%. Despite this, the population of the city center actually grows because they are replaced by lower income and lower wealth households who consume less real estate per household, leading to more density. This is in contrast to the baseline model, where lower income households move to the suburbs, leading to city center density falling, and wealth and productivity rising. On the other hand, when the tax burden is spread more evenly (the corporate tax and exogenous funding experiments), the spatial effects are more similar to the baseline model.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Welfare trade-off cards

Improving current social services is better than UBI – more realistic and more effective

Marco Annunziata, Senior Contributor to Forbes, ’18, July 27, “Universal Basic Income: A Universally Bad Idea,” FORBES, https://www.forbes.com/sites/marcoannunziata/2018/07/27/universal-basic-income-a-universally-bad-idea/?sh=41e7673a3269

Rich societies have a moral obligation to fight poverty and homelessness. To help when you fall on hard times because of health problems or because you lost your job. They have an obligation—and an interest—to broaden access to opportunity, so that your chances of success depend more on how talented and hard-working you are, less on your family circumstances (recognizing that we can never completely level the playing field).

This means a strong and targeted social safety net. The building blocks are familiar: unemployment benefits, health care for the poor, scholarships for bright low-income students.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Welfare trade-off cards

Welfare trade-off hurts the same people UBI wants to protect

Alyssa Battistoni, PhD candidate in political science at Yale University and an editor at Jacobin magazine, 17, Spring 2017, “The False Promise of Universal Basic Income,” DISSENT https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/false-promise-universal-basic-income-andy-stern-ruger-bregman/

But you don’t need to be Robespierre to be suspicious of a proposal that explicitly announces its intent to protect the rich from working-class rage—particularly when one of the major questions of UBI is where the free money will come from. Stern cautions UBI supporters against advocating a “soak the rich” tax on political grounds: the broad coalition that UBI requires will be impossible if the rich are against it from the start. (Alas, this is already the metric for most policies.) Instead, he proposes to fund UBI by cashing out major welfare programs (food stamps, housing assistance, the earned income tax credit) and charging a value-added tax on consumer goods; more tentatively, he considers a wealth tax, a financial transaction tax, and cuts to military spending. But funding a basic income by cannibalizing existing welfare programs and imposing regressive consumption taxes perversely places the burden of subsidizing low wages on the poor and working-class people making them in the first place.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Welfare trade-off cards

Basic income can only be funded by defunding everything else

DANIEL ZAMORA ’17, December 28, TRANSLATION BY JEFF BATE BOEROP, “The Case Against a Basic Income,” JACOBIN, https://jacobin.com/2017/12/universal-basic-income-inequality-work

No existing economy can pay for a generous basic income without defunding everything else. We would either have to settle for the minimalist version — whose effects would be highly suspect — or we’d have to eliminate all other social expenditures, in effect creating Milton Friedman’s paradise. Faced with these facts, we should question UBI’s rationality; as Luke Martinelli put it: “an affordable UBI is inadequate, and an adequate UBI is unaffordable.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Welfare trade-off cards

UBI is expensive – requires doubling federal taxes or a trade-off with existing social services

Hilary W. Hoynes, Richard & Rhoda Goldman School of Public Policy, and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy and Department of Economics, ‘19, February, “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME IN THE US AND ADVANCED COUNTRIES,” Working Paper 25538, https://gspp.berkeley.edu/assets/uploads/research/pdf/w25538.pdf

A fully implemented program with these universal and basic income elements would be extremely expensive. A universal payment of $12,000 per year to each adult U.S. resident over age 18 would cost roughly $3 trillion per year.8 This is about 75 percent of current total federal expenditures, including all on- and off-budget items, in 2017. (If those over 65 were excluded, the cost would fall by about one-fifth.) Thus, implementing this UBI without cuts to other programs would require nearly doubling federal tax revenue; even eliminating all existing transfer programs – about half of federal expenditures – would make only a dent in the cost. To bring this cost down, most UBI proposals and pilots in the developed world fail to meet the conditions of the canonical program in some way, either by reducing the payment below a subsistence level or by limiting eligibility based on income or other family characteristics.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › War turns justice

War outweighs and turns every impact

Horgan 14 (John, “War Is Our Most Urgent Problem--Let’s Solve It.” Scientific America, 8/12/20, , Accessed 7/17/20, GDI – JMoore)

Is there a more urgent problem in the world today than war? And when I say "war" in this post, I mean also militarism, the culture of war, the armies, arms, industries, policies, plans, propaganda, prejudices, rationalizations that make lethal group conflict not only possible but also likely.

My answer to the above question: No, there is no more urgent problem than war. Not climate change, pollution, overpopulation, oppression, poverty, inequality, hunger, disease.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Util good

Staying alive is a prerequisite to determining the value to your own life – value to life is subjective – we shouldn’t decide it for others

Schwartz, et al 2002 (Lisa, Lecturer in Philosophy of Medicine, Department of General Practice, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK; Paul Preece, Theme Coordinator of Medical Ethics, Dundee Medical School, Ninewells, Dundee, UK; and Rob Hendry, Medical Advisor, Medical & Dental Defense Union of Scotland, Mackintosh House, Glasgow, UK, Medical Ethics: A Case-Based Approach, p. 112, November)

The second assertion made by supporters of the quality of life as a criterion for decisionmaking is closely related to the first, but with an added dimension. This assertion suggests that the determination of the value of the quality of a given life is a subjective determination to be made by the person experiencing that life. The important addition here is that the decision is a personal one that, ideally, ought not to be made externally by another person but internally by the individual involved. Katherine Lewis made this decision for herself based on a comparison between two stages of her life. So did James Brady. Without this element, decisions based on quality of life criteria lack salient information and the patients concerned cannot give informed consent. Patients must be given the opportunity to decide for themselves whether they think their lives are worth living or not. To ignore or overlook patients’ judgement in this matter is to violate their autonomy and their freedom to decide for themselves on the basis of relevant information about their future, and comparative consideration of their past. As the deontological position puts it so well, to do so is to violate the imperative that we must treat persons as rational and as ends in themselves.

2023 GDI Affirmative
NEG › ***CASE NEG*** › Util good

Extinction and mass death is a prerequisite to ethical concerns

Wapner 03 [Paul, Associate professor and director of the Global Environmental Policy Program at American University, DISSENT, Winter, http://www.dissentmgazine.org/menutest/artiles/wi03/wapner.htm

The third response to eco-criticism would require critics to acknowledge the ways in which they themselves silence nature and then to respect the sheer otherness of the nonhuman world. Postmodernism prides itself on criticizing the urge toward mastery that characterizes modernity. But isn't mastery exactly what postmodernism is exerting as it captures the nonhuman world within its own conceptual domain? Doesn't postmodern cultural criticism deepen the modernist urge toward mastery by eliminating the ontological weight of the nonhuman world? What else could it mean to assert that there is no such thing as nature? I have already suggested the postmodernist response: yes, recognizing the social construction of "nature" does deny the self-expression of the nonhuman world, hut how would we know what such self-expression means? Indeed, nature doesn't speak; rather, some person always speaks on nature's behalf, and whatever that person says is, as we all know, a social construction. All attempts to listen to nature are social constructions-except one. Even the most radical postmodernist must acknowledge the distinction between physical existence and non-existence. As I have said, postmodernists accept that there is a physical substratum to the phenomenal world even if they argue about the different meanings wc ascribe to it. This acknowledgment of physical existence is crucial. We can't ascribe meaning to that which doesn't appear What doesn't exist can manifest no character. Put differently, yes, the postmodernist should rightly worry about interpreting nature's expressions. And all of us should be wary of those who claim to speak on nature's behalf (including environmentalists who do that). But we need not doubt the simple idea that a prerequisite of expression is existence. This in turn suggests that preserving the nonhuman world-in all its diverse embodiments-must be seen by eco-critics as a fundamental good. Eco-critics must be supporters, in some fashion, of environmental preservation.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Risk homeostasis

Risk homeostasis is a debunked theory

Barry Pless ’16. “Risk Compensation: Revisited and Rebutted,” MDPI, Safety 2016, 2(3), 16; https://doi.org/10.3390/safety2030016https://www.mdpi.com/2313-576X/2/3/16

An early topic chosen to support the RC theory was traffic accidents in general and seat belt use in particular. It was argued that any traffic safety measure was entirely offset by increased speeding or more careless driving (as Peltzman asserted it would). However, as Evans writes, “to examine the validity of this claim, using a wide variety of traffic accident data, all the data examined are found to be incompatible with the risk homeostasis theory… The accident data provide evidence that a rich variety of user responses occur. While it is possible for users to collectively respond in such a way that safety benefits are completely cancelled, such a response is not particularly common; it is certainly not universally occurring, as suggested by the risk homeostasis theory. It is concluded that the risk homeostasis theory should be rejected because there is no convincing evidence supporting it and much evidence refuting it.” [10].

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Capitalism K

UBI empowers workers and consumers to protect the environment

Alyssa Battistoni, doctoral candidate in political science at Yale University, November 9, 2015, “More Future, Less Work,” Dissent Magazine, https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/more-future-lesswork-alyssa-battistoni-universal-basic-income-environmental-justice.

One of the most useful things about a basic income is that it gives workers more power and leverage. This has particularly important implications for connecting environmental justice struggles to the labor movement: a basic income gives workers more power to say no to industries that are damaging the environment, their health, and the health of their communities. The communities most impacted by environmental injustice tend to be communities of color and working-class communities. People in these communities, working these jobs, are usually the first to know about the harmful effects of the industries they rely on for their livelihoods. Yet they often feel they don’t have any choice but to keep working in those industries. A basic income could be one piece in a puzzle of offering alternatives. The second benefit of a basic income in environmental terms is the challenge it presents to the implied link between production and consumption: if you have a job where you produce and make money, you can then consume and have the things that you need to live, and you need to consume enough to keep the economy booming so that there are enough jobs to go around. Meanwhile there’s a tendency in environmentalism to talk a lot about overconsumption and how we need to cut back, which can easily tip into the language of austerity. I think that’s very dangerous to any sort of environmentally just vision. Whatever problems there may be with current consumption patterns, we shouldn’t point the finger at everyday people for wanting to lead comfortable lives. If we really want to challenge overconsumption, we need to look at it within that vicious cycle of production and consumption: the conventional economic wisdom imposes a kind of consumption blackmail, where we’re told that if you don’t consume enough, you’re putting people out of work. Let’s start by challenging that.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Capitalism K

UBI creates new visions of success, which aren’t tied to environmental destruction

Alyssa Battistoni, doctoral candidate in political science at Yale University, November 9, 2015, “More Future, Less Work,” Dissent Magazine, https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/more-future-lesswork-alyssa-battistoni-universal-basic-income-environmental-justice

But another equally important part of the transition to an ecologically sustainable and just society is to move toward working less. There are several studies that suggest that working less is beneficial to people’s wellbeing: people like to choose more leisure when they actually have an option—as opposed to the current reality, which is that more leisure time usually means that you are un- or underemployed. Working less also tends to decrease energy use and ecological footprints, as scholars like Juliet Schor have shown. Related to this point is my third one. Basic income suggests a new vision of the good life to which we can aspire: one that’s sustainable but not austere, where we work less and have more time to do the other things that make life worthwhile. The underlying question here is: how can we build a world that is less resource intensive but more enjoyable in other ways? And low-carbon leisure is part of the answer.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Farm bill

Basic income would help farmers with financial security that can help support the agricultural industry.

Morgan, Doctoral candidate in Food Systems at the University of Vermont, 2019

[Caitlin, 12/12/19, doctoral candidate in Food Systems at the University of Vermont, resilience, “Why the Green New Deal should give farmers a Basic Income”, https://unevenearth.org/2019/12/a-just-food-transition/, 6/26/23, PE]

One solution, in line with a just transition in food and agriculture, is basic income for farmers. “Universal basic income,” recently brought into mainstream debate by Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang, is a monthly stipend provided by the government to all citizens. While there is a compelling argument for UBI for everybody, basic income may be critical for especially for agriculture. Proponents of UBI argue that one of its essential functions is allowing people freedom to make choices based on what they truly want or need in life, without potential financial crisis dictating their options. For people who work in agriculture, that freedom is the freedom to farm. Farmers in the United States are in historic levels of debt. In order to make enough money to continue, many farmers have to expand their farms—regardless of whether it is a sustainable or desirable choice—which usually means building or purchasing expensive infrastructure and equipment. The result is a race to increase profit margins and pay down debt, often prohibiting farmers from making choices based on land stewardship or care for workers. Over half of American farms earn negative income, losing more than they make, and rely on off-farm income for survival. There is increasing recognition that agroecology, the science of farming in tune with local ecosystems, is one way forward for just and sustainable food systems. But in the United States, where land is expensive, industrial agriculture subsidized, environmental regulations minimal, and parity pricing absent, it can be economically untenable for people to start agroecological farms in a rabidly capitalist system. Young farmers interested in raising sustainable, healthy food cannot make enough money to do so. Thus, a basic income would be a way for people to produce food without needing to exploit themselves, their employees, or their land. (India recently announced that it will be providing UBI for farmers, expecting it to double farmer incomes.) Anyone working in agriculture should be eligible for this support, without making distinctions between farm owners and farm workers. Because up to half of farmworkers are undocumented, this policy would likely necessitate a corresponding reform in immigration policy, at least for the food sector, as put forth recently by the Sanders Campaign’s Green New Deal plan. It is also possible that another aspect of food justice—access to fresh and healthy foods, mentioned in the GND—would also benefit from basic income for farmers, by supporting agricultural livelihoods without astronomically raising the cost of their products. Basic income would be one step toward creating safety for people who want to farm but lack financial security. Furthermore, a basic income begins to address historic injustice. Reversing the trends of land theft and ongoing dispossession in the food system is difficult for many reasons, one of them being that farmers from marginalized communities do not have access to the same wealth, credit, and financial safety nets of more privileged farmers. Basic income would be one step toward creating safety for people who want to farm but lack financial security. Yang’s UBI proposal, the “Freedom Dividend,” is $1,000 per month. This might not be enough for farmers. The Freedom Dividend is designed with the idea that it will encourage people to find jobs to supplement UBI that alone keeps them at the poverty line. But farmers already have jobs. We need a debate among stakeholders about the benefits of parity pricing—ensuring farmers are paid enough to cover their costs and living expenses—versus basic income, in terms of allowing farmers to stop overproducing to cover their debt, and make both environmentally and socially sustainable management choices. A just level for farmers might instead be the living wage for their area. Other social programs that could make farming, and sustainable farming in particular, a more viable option: free childcare, free health care, free education, and a guaranteed farming pension. The latter could allow farmers to keep their land in agriculture, rather than selling it to cover retirement costs. The bottom line: anyone growing food for other people, especially if they are growing it in ecologically-sound ways, should be able to provide for themselves and their employees. If we want to make sustainable farming desirable, viable, and just, we must support it by reorienting policy to support such worthy goals.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Politics – link turns that don’t rely on welfare

Link turn – plan builds a coalition between the right and left to replace programs with UBI

Rich Whitney ’21, September 22, 2021. “How Universal Basic Income Can Help Build a Solidarity Economy,” NON PROFIT QUARTERLY, https://nonprofitquarterly.org/how-universal-basic-income-can-help-build-a-solidarity-economy/

Because it would be universal, UBI would allow government to eliminate a great deal of the wasteful bureaucracy and the time-consuming and often humiliating means-testing practices that accompany most current welfare programs.

This is something of a double-edged sword. Some critics raise the specter of UBI being used as an opportunity for right-wing or rightward-leaning legislators to cut existing social-welfare programs.36 Here again, though, the same criticism could be leveled against any proposed social-welfare reform. Yes, reactionary elites will always have the inclination to intentionally underfund or otherwise undermine a beneficial reform, but that is not a legitimate objection to advocating for the reform in the first place.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***UBI 2AC*** › 2AC Politics – link turns that don’t rely on welfare

UBI creates a coalition of support that transcends political loyalty

Olga Lenczewska ’21, January 4, a fellow with the Stanford Basic Income Lab and 5th PhD student at Stanford looks at a how universal basic income (UBI) has a rare potential to gather supporters who hold vastly different beliefs and ideological commitments. “Can people with vastly different political beliefs support a Universal Basic Income?” https://basicincome.stanford.edu/news/lab-updates/can-people-with-vastly-different-political-beliefs-support-a-universal-basic-income-1/

I am a fifth-year PhD candidate in philosophy at Stanford University and I have been involved with the Basic Income Lab since its beginning in 2017. My work at the Lab has focused on surveying the academic literature on the impact of basic income on gender justice, racial justice, and wellbeing. By reviewing the interdisciplinary literature on this topic, I sought to put into dialogue the normative and the empirical dimensions of this debate. My biggest takeaway from this work has been the realization that universal basic income (UBI) has a rare potential to gather supporters who hold vastly different beliefs and ideological commitments.

One of the crucial challenges for contemporary democracies is to arrive at agreements over particular policies despite growing antagonisms and deep polarization across ideological lines. Drawing on a body of theoretical and empirical literature, I show that people holding vastly different political beliefs, illustrated through six theoretical frameworks of justice, have reasons to support the same policy: universal basic income. This table, Supporting UBI from the Perspective of Different Frameworks of Justice, describes how a UBI policy would be supported through different frameworks of justice. (You can also view a tabbed version of this document in the section below.) Some examples where there could be consensus on UBI include:

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › Plan – 12k UBI

Their defense assumes abstract proposals – plan hits the sweet spot

MICHAEL HILTZIK, BUSINESS COLUMNIST, ’17. JUNE 23, 2017, “Column: Conservatives, liberals, techies, and social activists all love universal basic income: Has its time come?” LOS ANGELES TIMES, https://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-ubi-20170625-story.html

The main challenge for UBI advocates is defining just what such a program would look like on a large scale. “UBI proposals tend not to be fully baked,” observed liberal economist Max Sawicky. That was in 2013. Some four years later, it’s still true. Some projects are operating under the radar, including the Oakland project, on which Y Combinator’s Altman declined to comment.

Indeed, one reason UBI attracts adherents across the ideological spectrum is that it can be so variously conceived. It’s a bit like the story of the blind men and the elephant, with every promoter visualizing the totality based on the features he or she considers most important.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › VAT – not T

VAT distributes away from low-income households

JEFF SPROSS ’19, SEPTEMBER 24, “Andrew Yang's UBI problem,” THE WEEK, https://theweek.com/articles/858097/andrew-yangs-ubi-problem

In brief, a value added tax (VAT) is a form of sales tax that's applied to every step in the supply chain. Exactly how business models pass along the costs of the tax is debatable, but economic studies are pretty unanimous that most of the burden gets handed off to the end consumer. Since lower-income households spend more of their budgets on basic consumption, that makes a VAT regressive: it takes a bigger percentage of poor Americans' income than of wealthier Americans' income.

Yang says his VAT won't apply to basic staples like groceries and clothing. But the research suggests these sorts of carve-outs don't really help with the overall regressive impact. He also argues no lower-income person could ever buy so much that their VAT burden cancels out their UBI. But the point is, for the poorer Americans who already rely on the safety net, Yang's UBI is partially offset by eliminating current welfare benefits. Therefore, any jump in their consumption costs due to a VAT will leave those individuals with even less of a net gain and in a few cases a net loss. It's not an enormous problem: An analysis from Max Ghenis of The UBI Center found most current welfare beneficiaries would see at least a 5 percent increase to the total cash in their pocket — including at least 85 percent of people making under $10,000. But this all highlights the strangeness of financing a UBI with a VAT.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › CP – VAT

UBI funded through a progressive value-added tax is economically feasible and solves

William G. Gale, The Arjay and Frances Fearing Miller Chair in Federal Economic Policy, Senior Fellow - Economic Studies, Director - Retirement Security Project, Co-Director - Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, January 30, 2020. “How a VAT could tax the rich and pay for universal basic income,” BROOKINGS, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-a-vat-could-tax-the-rich-and-pay-for-universal-basic-income/

The Congressional Budget Office just projected a series of $1 trillion budget deficits—as far as the eye can see. Narrowing that deficit will require not only spending reductions and economic growth but also new taxes. One solution that I’ve laid out in a new Hamilton Project paper, “Raising Revenue with a Progressive Value-Added Tax,” is a 10 percent Value-Added Tax (VAT) combined with a universal basic income (UBI)—effectively a cash payment to every US household.

The plan would raise substantial net revenue, be very progressive, and be as conducive to economic growth as any other new tax. The VAT would complement, not replace, any new direct taxes on affluent households, such as a wealth tax or capital gains reforms.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › Proportional income tax – Plan & Solvency

Proportional income tax provides enough resources for UBI

Nezih Guner et al, researcher at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, associated to CEPR and IZA, Remzi Kaygusuz, Economics professor at Sabanci University in Turkey, and Gustavo Ventura, Economics professor at Arizone State University, Published on June 29, 2022, “'With a proportional income tax, the best universal basic income can be more generous,'” LEMONDE, https://www.lemonde.fr/en/opinion/article/2022/06/29/with-a-proportional-income-tax-the-best-universal-basic-income-can-be-more-generous_5988397_23.html#

Is it possible to make things better? We find that a UBI and a tax reform that moves from the current progressive taxes to a proportional income tax can do better. A proportional tax provides stronger incentives for work and savings than a progressive income tax.

As a result, it is possible to collect more taxes and expand the size of the transfers. With a proportional income tax, the best UBI can be more generous. The US government can now give each 3,900$ (3,700 euros) annually, and the size of transfers increases to 7.3% of GDP, more than three times the current level.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › No tax – grows econ

UBI would make US economy trillions of dollars larger

Matthews, Senior Correspondent and Lead Writer, 17’

[Dylan, 8-30-2017, Vox, “Study: a universal basic income would grow the economy,” https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/8/30/16220134/universal-basic-income-roosevelt-institute-economic-growth, 6/25, DG]

A universal basic income could make the US economy trillions of dollars larger, permanently, according to a new study by the left-leaning Roosevelt Institute. Basic income, a proposal in which every American would be given a basic stipend from the government no strings attached, is often brought up as a potential solution to widespread automation reducing demand for labor in the future. But in the meantime, its critics typically allege that it is far too expensive to be practical, or else that it would spur millions of Americans to drop out of the labor force, wrecking the economy and depriving the government of a tax base for funding the plan. The Roosevelt study, written by Roosevelt research director Marshall Steinbaum, Michalis Nikiforos at Bard College's Levy Institute, and Gennaro Zezza at the University of Cassino and Southern Lazio in Italy, comes to a dramatically different conclusion. And it does so using some notably rosy assumptions about the effects of large-scale increases to government spending, taxes, and deficits, assumptions that other analysts would dispute vociferously. Their paper analyzes three different models for a universal basic income: A full universal basic income, in which every adult gets $1,000 a month ($12,000 a year) A partial basic income, in which every adult gets $500 a month ($6,000 a year) A child allowance, in which every child gets $250 a month ($3,000 a year) They find that enacting any of these policies by growing the federal debt — that is, without raising taxes to pay for it — would substantially grow the economy. The effect fades away within eight years, but GDP is left permanently higher. The big, $12,000 per year per adult policy, they find, would permanently grow the economy by 12.56 to 13.10 percent — or about $2.5 trillion come 2025. It would also, they find, increase the percentage of Americans with jobs by about 2 percent, and expand the labor force to the tune of 4.5 to 4.7 million people. They also model the impact of the plan if it's paid for with taxes. That amounts to large-scale income redistribution, which, the authors argue, would stimulate the economy, because lower-income people are likelier to spend their money in the near-term than rich people are. Thus, they find that a full $12,000 a year per adult basic income, paid for with progressive income taxes, would grow the economy by about 2.62 percent ($515 billion) and expand the labor force by about 1.1 million people.

2023 GDI Affirmative
AFF › ***Plan & solvency extensions*** › UBI is T – taxation is key

Extra taxation is the only way to make UBI topical

JUAN CARLOS CONESA, BO LI AND QIAN LI January, 2020. “Universal Basic Income and Progressive Consumption Taxes,” WORKING PAPER 2020-01, STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY, https://www.stonybrook.edu/commcms/economics/research/papers/2020/UBI_Ctax_2001.pdf

Advocates for UBI argue that there are multiple gains from eliminating the complex and inefficient existing network of welfare programs. Our results provide mixed partial support for such a view. When substituting for existing targeted transfers, UBI must be generous enough in order to prevent substantial welfare losses at the bottom of the income distribution. But such a program would require large tax increases that would negatively affect economic efficiency. Only when combined with a comprehensive efficiency-enhancing tax reform (in our case a switch from income taxation to progressive consumption taxes) such alternatives have a chance at generating welfare gains in the long run. But still, the analysis of the transitional dynamics suggest that most households would experience welfare losses on impact.