Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution Must Be Progressive › Extend Our Interpretation

Regressive transfers like the plan aren’t fiscal redistribution.

Hicks 86 — [Alexander Northwestern University; 1986; “CLASS INFLUENCE ON REDISTRIBUTIVE POLICY: THE CASE OF U.S. STATE GOVERNMENTS, 1951-1961*”; Journal of Political and Military Sociology, Vol. 14; University of Kansas Libraries, JSTOR]

The present redistributive policy focus is on a particular type of government redistribution that may be called direct fiscal redistribution to the poor (hereafter DFRP). Fiscal redistribution refers here to redistribution of money and in-kind income among strata of households by means of both government spending and taxing (i.e., fiscal) activities. For example, increased generosity in public assistance payment levels and reliance upon progressive income as opposed to regressive sales taxes can provide positive fiscal redistribution. Direct fiscal redistribution refers to that part of such redistribution that can be accounted for in terms of government's relatively direct and immediate give-and-take of expenditures and taxes to and from income strata of households. Current evidence suggests that such redistribution is considerable in advanced capitalist political democracies, especially vis-à-vis the poor (e.g., Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977; Hicks and Swank, 1984b). During the 1970s DFRP apparently augmented the "pre-fisc" income share of poor households in the U.S. by over 100 percent (see Reynolds and Smolensky, 1977: 74 on the U.S.; and Hicks and Swank, 1984b on advanced capitalism).

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution Must Be Progressive › 1NC — T “Fiscal Redistribution” vs. BIG with Welfare Cuts

Violation — UBI funded from preexisting resources is anti-topical — it distributes UPWARD.

Conesa et al 20 — JUAN CARLOS CONESA, BO LI AND QIAN LI January, 2020. “Universal Basic Income and Progressive Consumption Taxes,” WORKING PAPER 2020-01, STONY BROOK UNIVERSITY, https://www.stonybrook.edu/commcms/economics/research/papers/2020/UBI_Ctax_2001.pdf

We first consider the long-run impact of distributing equally among all working-age households the average amount of targeted transfers in the benchmark economy. A key question regarding the implementation of UBI is how the rest of the tax system adjusts. In Table 6 we report the macroeconomic and welfare implications of introducing UBI under four different policy scenarios: 1. Adjusting upward capital income taxes, 2. Adjusting upward labor income taxes, 3. Introducing consumption taxes keeping income taxes fixed, and 4. Removing income taxes and switching to a consumption-based tax system. In alternatives 3 and 4 we obtain the combination of taxes on basic and non-basic goods that maximizes the ex-ante expected welfare of a newborn. Keeping income taxes unchanged, adjusting consumption tax rates to balance the government budget (alternative 3) yields a long run optimal combination of τc1 = −0.20 and τc2 = 0.13, introducing consumption tax progressivity. Eliminating income taxes (alternative 4) results in an optimal combination of consumption taxes that is also very progressive, with τc1 = 0.10 and τc2 = 0.49.

In all these cases, capital shock falls with the exception of alternative 4, in which the elimination of income taxes encourages capital accumulation. All these policies stimulate labor supply, espe- cially for the non-college group. There are two reasons for that. First, under the targeted transfer system of the benchmark these households receive an annual transfer as high as $4,838, if they fall into the first quintile. However, UBI only pays them $2,488 per year. This negative income effect drives low educated households to supply more labor. Second, since UBI is not income tested the distortion on labor supply at the bottom of the distribution is eliminated. In contrast, college educated households adjust their labor supply slightly, and in different directions depending on the different policy scenarios.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution Must Be Progressive › 1NC — T “Fiscal Redistribution” vs. BIG with Welfare Cuts

Interpretation — “Redistribution” must reduce inequality.

Brewer et al 12 — Mike, Monica Costa Dias, Research Fellow Institute for Fiscal Studies, and Jonathan Shaw, Research Fellow Institute for Fiscal Studies “Lifetime inequality and redistribution ,” October 2012, https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/wp1223.pdf Accessed 6/29/23 S.A.M

Throughout, we use the term redistribution applied to tax and benefits systems to signify inequality reducing policies, which is achieved when the relative position of individuals at the bottom of the earned income distribution is improved by the tax and benefits system. Thus, for example, a pure flat tax rate would not be redistributive; instead, it is the progressivity of the tax system that makes it redistributive. A progressive tax system is one where the average tax rate (ATR) is increasing in earned equivalised income, where the ATR is the ratio of total family tax liability (net of benefits) to earned income.

2023 GDI Topicality
Fiscal Redistribution Must Be Progressive › 1NC — T “Fiscal Redistribution Must Be Progressive (General)

Interpretation — “Redistribution” must reduce inequality.

Brewer et al 12 — Mike, Monica Costa Dias, Research Fellow Institute for Fiscal Studies, and Jonathan Shaw, Research Fellow Institute for Fiscal Studies “Lifetime inequality and redistribution ,” October 2012, https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/wp1223.pdf Accessed 6/29/23 S.A.M

Throughout, we use the term redistribution applied to tax and benefits systems to signify inequality reducing policies, which is achieved when the relative position of individuals at the bottom of the earned income distribution is improved by the tax and benefits system. Thus, for example, a pure flat tax rate would not be redistributive; instead, it is the progressivity of the tax system that makes it redistributive. A progressive tax system is one where the average tax rate (ATR) is increasing in earned equivalised income, where the ATR is the ratio of total family tax liability (net of benefits) to earned income.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP › 2AC PDB

Perm do both, monetary and fiscal policy are both key.

Gopinath International Monetary Fund deputy managing director 21 (Gita, August 27th 2021, Jackson Hole Symposium, , ac 7-03-2023 [CC]

• Monetary and fiscal support are both essential for macroeconomic stabilization and financial stability

• Fiscal policy particularly beneficial if at the effective lower bound for policy rates

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

Schnabel, Executive Board of the European Central Bank member and economist, 2021

[Isabel Schnabel, Executive Board of the European Central Bank member and economist, September 2021, Internationa Monetary Fund, “Climate Change And Monetary Policy”, https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2021/09/isabel-schnabel-ECB-climate-change, Accessed 7-10-23 DD]

First, the consequences of climate change might impair the transmission of central banks’ monetary policy measures to the financing conditions faced by households and firms, and hence to consumption and investment. Losses from materializing physical risks or stranded assets (such as oil reserves that will not be tapped as the world moves away from fossil fuels) could weigh on financial institutions’ balance sheets, reducing the flow of credit to the real economy. In addition, the longer climate change is insufficiently addressed, the greater the risks to policy transmission from a sharp and abrupt rise in credit risk premiums. Central banks themselves are exposed to potential losses—from securities acquired in asset purchase programs and on the collateral provided by counterparties in monetary policy operations.

Second, climate change could further diminish the space for conventional monetary policy by lowering the equilibrium real rate of interest, which balances savings and investment. For example, higher temperatures might impair labor productivity or increase rates of morbidity and mortality. Productive resources might be reallocated to support adaptation measures, while climate-related uncertainty may increase precautionary savings and reduce incentives to invest. Collectively, these factors can reduce the real equilibrium interest rate and therefore increase the likelihood that a central bank’s policy rate will be constrained. But this is far from certain; equilibrium rates might instead rise because of green innovation and investment and chart a path out of the current low-inflation, low-interest-rate environment.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

The main consequence of all monetary policy actions is that it increases inflation

Taylor, George P. Shultz Senior Fellow in Economics at the Hoover Institution, being interviewed by De Witt, 2022 (John, interviewed by Melissa, What causes inflation? Stanford scholar explains, SEPTEMBER 6, 2022, accessed, 07-13-23, https://news.stanford.edu/2022/09/06/what-causes-inflation/#:~:text=When%20monetary%20policy%20is%20too,as%20we%20are%20seeing%20now.)-TL

What is the relationship between monetary policy and inflation?

There is a close relationship. When monetary policy is too easy – either because the Federal Reserve sets the interest rate too low or because it increases money growth too rapidly – there will be an increase in inflation, as we are seeing now. This close relationship is grounded in economic theory and has been observed in practice in many countries around the world over many years.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

Increasing interest rates hurts economic growth – resulting in higher unemployment

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 2020

[Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System , August 27, 2020 , Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System ,“How does the Federal Reserve affect inflation and employment?”, , Accessed 7-12-23, DD]

As the Federal Reserve conducts monetary policy, it influences employment and inflation primarily through using its policy tools to influence the availability and cost of credit in the economy.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

Monetary federalism works in small instances, but in entities with many states creates instability that crashes federal currency valuation-empirics prove

Theret, professor at Paris Dauphine-PSL University, 2018 (Bruno, Monetary federalism as а concept and its еmpirical underpinnings in Argentina’s monetary history, MONETARY AND ECONOMIC RESEARCH CENTER 4 th ANNUAL CONFERENCE NEW REALITIES IN THE EU AND THE PLACE OF BALKAN COUNTRIES 11-12 October 2018, .p.30-31, https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nikolay-Nenovsky/publication/346538778_Monetray_Research_Center_Annual_Book_2018/links/5fc6780f45851568d131ffdf/Monetray-Research-Center-Annual-Book-2018.pdf#page=5)-TL

In most federations, federal tax transfers are of three kinds: general revenue sharing (equalization); earmarked for a particular use ; purely discretionary. But in Argentina the boundaries between these categories are blurred, since, even when fixed rules of automatic revenue sharing and/or earmarking are edicted, it is recurrent that these rules are either bypassed through bilateral negociations between the federal President and Governors, or permanently renegociated. Before the updated institutionalization of revenue-sharing in the Act of coparticipacion of 1988, bypassing federal rules was dominating; afterwards, it has been permanent renegociation of these rules (Bonvecchi 2005). For these reasons provinces suffer a great instability and uncertainty concerning the true amount of federal money they are going to receive annually, monthly, daily. Permanent discussions about the effective amounts of federal engagements is coupled with federal discretion relative to the agenda of payments, since funds distribution is often conditioned to political support to the President’s initiatives in Congress (Bernadou 2009). This uncertainty is increased when the federal government is itself the prey of a fiscal crisis. Moreover money shortage is a daily problem for Provinces since transfers’ payments tend to feed provincial treasuries at irregular pace. In fact federal transfers and devolution of public spendings to provinces are often the primary variables of adjustment in the management of the Nacion federal budget. And because the argentinian economy knows a high degree of volatility and strong dependance vis-à-vis external shocks, federal and then provincial fiscal crises are recurrently expected and always feared Thus it is no surprise in Argentina to see payments of wages to public employees and/or debts visà-vis small providers belated and delayed for months. It is not surprising too to see these waiting periods correlated with social unrests and emergency situations where provincial governments have to borrow money to banks and/or on financial markets, in order to finance current spendings. This large dependance of provincial governments on federal resources explains that their public debt is primarily a floating debt that is funded at high cost.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

Parameshwaran, Economic Writer, 2022

[Shankar Parameshwaran, Economic Writer, 10-4-2022, ,Knowledge at Wharton, “Why Presidential Influence Over Monetary Policy Should be Checked”, , Accessed 7-12-23 DD]

The debate on the monetary policy response to curb spiraling inflation has focused primarily on the role of the Federal Reserve. The role of the president in the factors that contributed to the recent bout of inflation has been largely overlooked, according to Wharton professor of legal studies and business ethics Christina Parajon Skinner.

In a recent paper titled “The Monetary Executive,” she wrote that the president has “far more influence over money in the economy — and levers for ‘fiscal dominance’ — than the Constitution arguably allows, casting a long shadow over the Federal Reserve’s ability to properly rein in inflation.” According to her, those powers could potentially be used to further political agendas and to unfairly disadvantage sections of the economy. Among the remedies she suggested are Congressional actions to scale down those presidential powers or limit those granted in emergency, a more assertive Fed, and a more vigilant public.

2023 GDI Counterplan
AFF Answers – MP CP

Nasrudin, PT Pemeringkat Efek Indonesia - economic Analyst ,2022

[Ahmad Nasrudin, PT Pemeringkat Efek Indonesiaeconomic Analyst,April 12, 2022, Penpoin,”Why is monetary policy ineffective?”,, Accessed 7-12-23 DD]

Monetary policy is a means to influence the economy through changes in the money supply. Changes in the money supply affect aggregate demand. As far as economic capacity is available, changes in aggregate demand will affect short-run aggregate supply (actual real GDP).

Supply side shocks case

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › AT: PDCP

Perm do the CP servers, at best fiscal policy requires either the executive or legislative branch.

Ross editor-in-chief at Financial Poise 20 (Sean, July 30th, 2021, Congressional Research Service, , ac 7-10-2023 [CC])

Fiscal policy refers to the actions taken by governments to help direct their economies. This is done through a variety of measures, including taxation. There isn't just one central body responsible for fiscal policy. In fact, both the President and the U.S. Congress have a hand in it, which means it is directed by both the executive and legislative branches of the U.S:

In the executive branch, the two most influential offices in this regard belong to the President and the Secretary of the Treasury, although contemporary presidents often rely on a council of economic advisers as well.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › AT: PDB

The reason the counterplan avoids the net benefit is because it doesn’t go through Congress, perm do both still requires congress.

Labonte Congressional Research Service Specialist in Macroeconomic Policy 20 (Mar, February 2020, Congressional Research Service, , ac 7-03-2023 CC)

Congress has delegated responsibility for monetary policy to the Federal Reserve (the Fed), the nation’s central bank, but retains oversight responsibilities for ensuring that the Fed is adhering to its statutory mandate of “maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates.” To meet its price stability mandate, the Fed has set a longer-run goal of 2% inflation.

The Fed’s control over monetary policy stems from its exclusive ability to alter the money supply and credit conditions more broadly. Normally, the Fed conducts monetary policy by setting a target for the federal funds rate, the rate at which banks borrow and lend reserves on an overnight basis.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Automation

Monetary Policy is key to combating unemployment caused by automation.

Fornaro London School of Economics PHD, and Wolf Financial Times Chief Economics Advisor, 22 [Luca and Martin, September 2022, Universitat Pompeu Fabra Department of Economics and Business “Monetary policy in the age of automation”, , DOA 7-5-23 [CC]

We provide a framework in which monetary policy affects firms’ automation decisions (i.e. how intensively capital and labor are used in production). This new feature has far-reaching consequences for monetary policy. Monetary tightenings may depress firms’ use of automation technologies and labor productivity, even permanently, while having a transitory impact on inflation and employment. A protracted period of weak demand might translate into less investment and de-automation, rather than into deflation and involuntary unemployment. Technological advances that increase the scope for automation may give rise to persistent unemployment, unless they are accompanied by expansionary macroeconomic policies.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Tech/ Innovation

Increased monetary policy motivates tech innovation

Moran, M.Phil., Economics, University of Oxford, Queralto, , Ph.D., Economics, New York University, 2017 Patrick Moran, M.Phil., Economics, University of Oxford, and Albert Queralto, Ph.D., Economics, New York University, November 2017, International Finance Discussion Papers, “Innovation, Productivity, and Monetary Policy”, DOA 7-3-23 [DD}

Growth in total factor productivity (TFP) has slowed dramatically in recent years: as

seen in Figure 1, U.S. TFP growth in the post-1980s has never been as low for as long as

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Food Prices

HEALEY, Senior editor on the Utility Journalism team, 2023

[JON] HEALEY, Senior editor on the Utility Journalism team, March 3, 2023, Los Angeles Times, ‘Paying more for gas and food? Here’s what the Federal Reserve can do”, DOA 7-3-23 [DD]

After two decades of little or no inflation, Americans have seen prices jump for gasoline, fuel oil, electricity and cars, while also creeping up for apparel, food and other commodities. Overall, consumer prices were 7.5% higher in January than they were a year ago, the biggest increase in 40 years, easily outpacing the 4.4% growth in average wages.

The pinch is widely felt, particularly among low- and moderate-income Americans. That helps explain why polls show inflation to be a top concern among U.S. adults in recent months.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Bargaining Power

Krueger, Princeton University Professor of Political Economy, 2018

Alan, August 24, 2018, Luncheon Address at the Jackson Hole Economic Symposium, ‘Reflections on Dwindling Worker Bargaining Power and Monetary Policy”, , DOA 7-10-23 [CC]

A high-pressure labor market tends to boost wages and opportunities for low-wage workers. This was convincingly demonstrated by Arthur Okun in a 1973 Brookings paper, and confirmed by experience in subsequent recoveries, including the current one.2 In a 1999 Brookings paper follow-up to Okun’s work, Larry Katz and I similarly found that the Wage Phillips Curve relationship is steeper at the lower deciles. In other words, wage growth is more responsive to unemployment for less skilled and lower paid workers. Given the tremendous rise in earnings inequality and deterioration in opportunities for workers in the bottom half of the income distribution, the benefits of a high pressure economy cannot be understated. Katz and I also found that the Wage Phillips Curve moves around over time. For a worker paid the median wage, the unemployment rate threshold required to generate positive real wage growth for the median worker (which we infelicitously called URZERCG, for unemployment rate associated with zero expect real compensation growth), fell from 6.8 percent in the late 1970s and 1980s to 5.4 percent in the 1990s. It appears to have fallen even further in the 2000s (see Bivens 2014), suggesting a tighter labor market is now required to support real wage growth.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Bargaining Power

Mishel, Economic Policy Institute fellow and Eisenbrey, Economic Policy Institute – Vice President, 2015

[Lawrence] Mishel, Economic Policy Institute – economic fellow, and [Ross] Eisenbrey , Economic Policy Institute – Vice President ,March 19, 2015,Economic Policy Institute, “How to Raise Wages, Policies That Work and Policies That Don’t” , DOA 7-8-23 DD]

Monetary policy that targets full employment, with wage growth matching productivity gains

The most important economic policy decisions being made about job growth in the next few years are those of the Federal Reserve Board as it determines the scale and pace at which it raises interest rates. The decision to raise interest rates is essentially a decision to slow the economy and weaken job and wage growth. There are many false concerns about accelerating wage growth and exploding inflation based on the mistaken sense that we are at or near full employment. Policymakers should not seek to slow the economy until wage growth is comfortably running at a 3.5 to 4.0 percent rate—wage growth consistent with a 2 percent inflation target (since trend productivity is 1.5 to 2.0 percent, wage growth 2 percentage points faster than this yields rising unit labor costs, and therefore inflation, of 2 percent). Thereafter, the Fed should pursue monetary policy conducive to allowing wage growth to match productivity gains. In short, the key danger is slowing the economy too soon rather than too late.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Labor/Unemployment

Monetary policy solves unemployment and perpetuating racial discrimination.

Scherer, LSF Editorial Senior Editor ’22 [Lauri] S. Scherer, LSF Editorial Senior Editor ,March 2022, National Bureau of Economic Research, “Monetary Policy’s Disparate Impact on Labor Market Subgroups” [CC]

Employment among populations with lower labor force attachment responds more to expansionary monetary policy in tight labor markets than employment among more attached groups, according to Nittai K. Bergman, , and  in Inclusive Monetary Policy: How Tight Labor Markets Facilitate Broad-Based Employment Growth (NBER Working Paper ).

The findings suggest that by tightening labor markets, the Federal Reserve’s recent move from strict to average inflation targeting especially benefits workers with lower labor force attachment.

2023 GDI Counterplan
2NC › 2NC Solves Inflation

Monetary policy solves inflation, has direct control of interest rates.

Ross, Free Lances Ltd founder and Financial Advisor, 21 [Sean] Ross, Free Lances Ltd founder and Financial Advisor, October 08, 2021, Investopedia, “Monetary Policy and Inflation”, DOA - 7-2-23 [DD]

Using these specific parameters, the term deflation is used to describe productivity increasing faster than the money stock. This leads to a general decrease in prices and the cost of living, which many economists paradoxically interpret to be harmful. The arguments against deflation trace back to John Maynard Keynes' paradox of thrift. Due to this belief, most central banks pursue a slightly inflationary monetary policy to safeguard against deflation.

Most modern central banks target the rate of inflation in a country as their primary metric for monetary policy. If prices rise faster than their target, central banks tighten monetary policy by increasing interest rates or other hawkish policies. Higher interest rates make borrowing more expensive, curtailing both consumption and investment, both of which rely heavily on credit. Likewise, if inflation falls and economic output declines, the central bank will lower interest rates and make borrowing cheaper, along with several other possible expansionary policy tools.