Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Counterplan
Affirmative Answers › EITC doesn’t solve › 2ac – EITC fails – general

EITC fails – laundry of reasons – universal programs better

Bruenig, president - People’s Policy Project and former policy analyst at Demos Think Tank - 2020

[Matt, “The Myths of the Earned Income Tax Credit” People’s Policy Project – socialist and social democratic economic ideas think tank , May 18 2020 accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Affirmative Answers › EITC Expansion bad - General › Extension – waste/inefficiency

EITC inefficient – administrative costs

Bruenig, president - People’s Policy Project and former policy analyst at Demos Think Tank - 2020

[Matt, “The Myths of the Earned Income Tax Credit” People’s Policy Project – socialist and social democratic economic ideas think tank , May 18 2020 accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Affirmative Answers › EITC Expansion bad - General › 2ac – EITC waste turn

EITC expansion bad – waste undermine the effectiveness of the program –no reforms likely in the Squo means EITC should not be expanded

CAVANAUGH, senior editor for the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, 2022

[Tim, “Beware of expanding the earned income tax credit” The Hill December 31 2022 accessed 6.15.23 preJCP-TM]

In a healthy republic there would be no need to explain, to both Democrats and Republicans, why they should not expand a program that misspends more than a fourth of its money. Yet here we are. Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer last week announced the expansion of the state’s earned income tax credit (EITC) as the top priority of the state’s new Democratic majority. Michigan is one of many states that piggyback on the federal earned income tax credit by offering credits against the state’s personal income tax. The shrewd governor is getting behind a popular bipartisan plan to push the state’s credit from 6 percent to 20 percent. There is just one problem. The federal EITC is a magnet for waste, fraud and abuse. The Internal Revenue Service estimates that nearly 28 percent of all earned income tax credit payments, totaling $19 billion a year, are made improperly. Expanding the state program likely will put Michigan taxpayers on the hook for tens of millions in false spending. Not all of these illegitimate payments are the result of conscious fraud. Because the size of the credit depends heavily on how many dependents live in a household, the definition of proper and improper payments can change as children grow, marriages dissolve, single parents cohabit, and other life events occur. Improper payments result largely from cases wherein the same child is claimed multiple times because of shared custody or other nontraditional living situations, according to a 2019 report from the Tax Foundation. But to say that not all the improper payments involve malice aforethought is only to say that the program obviously lacks sufficient oversight and controls. The most recent report from the Office of Management and Budget shows total overpayments in the EITC program to have come to $18.9 billion in 2021. Overpayments were 27.76 percent of the program’s total outlays. There are ideas for addressing this problem. Then-National Taxpayer Advocate Nina E. Olson recommended in 2019 that the definition of “qualifying child” be revised and that the family-size element be separated from the credit. The Tax Foundation suggests making EITC a per-worker, rather than a per-household, tax credit. Congress could put in place incentive and penalty structures that encourage more recipients to ensure they are not accepting improper payments. But the bottom line is, right now, the program is so poorly administered it probably should not be continued, let alone expanded.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Answer to Answer Blocks › AT States can’t solve › AT – states without income tax

Answer to states can’t solve – no income tax not an obstacle

Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023

[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Answer to Answer Blocks › Answers – EITC links to Net Benefits › AT EITC decrease work incentives

EITC doesn’t impact employment – data proves

Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023

[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › UBI – Specific › EITC > UBI – solves automation

EITC expansion to universal tax credit for individuals to maximum of 10k provides support and reduces poverty – and if automation claims of the aff are correct, could convert to UBI

Capps, 2019

[Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 prejcp-tm]

As it’s currently construed, the Earned Income Tax Credit supports working low-income households with children. It’s a substantial enough subsidy that these households plan their annual spending around it. Anyone who has ever eagerly anticipated a tax refund understands this, although for some working families the credit can amount to as much as 40 percent of annual household income. Yet the Earned Income Tax Credit is only progressive-ish at best, since it provides little to no help for working households without children or for middle-class families. Burman’s paper calls for replacing the Earned Income Tax Credit with a Universal Earned Income Tax Credit, which would “provide meaningful assistance for low- and middle-income workers whether or not they have children living with them.” This universal tax credit “would not directly penalize two-earner couples,” he writes. The fixes are straightforward, albeit ambitious: The universal tax credit would be based on individual income, not household income, so dual-income households would benefit. Family makeup would no longer be a factor, so childless workers would earn more from the credit, too. The universal credit would apply to 100 percent of earnings up to a maximum $10,000, extending its reach into the lower middle class. Burman also tacks on changes to the the Child Tax Credit, making it fully refundable, which would be a huge boost for very low-income parents. Further, Burman proposes a way to pay for the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit: a new value-added tax of 11 percent. If nobody works at all, thanks to the robots, then the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit could easily be converted to a traditional UBI program. That pay-for element distinguishes the Tax Policy Center concept from Senator Cory Booker’s Rise Credit, Senator Kamala Harris’s LIFT the Middle Class Act, Senator Sherrod Brown’s Working Families Tax Relief Act, or the Economic Security Project’s Cost of Living Refund—all of which are otherwise fairly same-same. Any eventual effort to improve or expand the tax refund as part of the social safety net is bound to draw from some or all these drafts. The idea is to accomplish through the tax code what might be impossible through legislation, given the current partisan gridlock.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › UBI – Specific › EITC > UBI – jobs

Universal EITC solves better than UBI – DC proves more effective method given current job market conditions

Capps, 2019

[Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 prejcp-tm]

The best demonstration of the potential for expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit may not be the UBI experiment playing out in Stockton but rather a local tax tweak enacted in Washington, D.C. The District passed a 40 percent match for all federal Earned Income Tax Credit recipients and doubled the number of childless workers eligible for the local credit. The city has found that the expanded tax credit has encouraged work and offset poverty for low-income wage households. That’s in essence the goal of a universal basic income. “In the short run, the effects of the UEITC and enhanced CTC might not differ that much from a UBI,” Burman writes. “The primary market problem at present is not that jobs are unavailable, but that they pay poorly. A wage credit deals with this shortcoming directly.”

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › UBI – Specific › EITC > UBI – avoids Econ DA

EITC solves better than UBI—work incentive and cost link differential

Progressive Policy Institute ‘19

[staff, “UBI Is the Wrong Way to Fight Poverty,” Progressive Policy Institute, 10—3—19, , accessed 6-14-23]

If UBI doesn’t make economic sense, what does? Expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a better way to supplement the market income of Americans in need. The EITC is a refundable tax credit that phases in at a percentage of a taxpayer’s earned income until the credit reaches a maximum benefit. If the taxpayer’s income rises above a certain threshold, the EITC begins to phase out. This benefit structure incentivizes taxpayers whose incomes are in the phase-in region to work more because each additional dollar they earn also raises the value of their tax credit. The opposite is true for people whose incomes are higher than the phase-out threshold, as earning more income reduces the value of the credit, which may dampen the incentive to work. But people who do not have jobs only face an incentive to begin working, and empirical evidence shows that the EITC’s incentives to work strongly outweigh the disincentives. As such, expanding the EITC would put money in the hands of working people without the risk of discouraging too many people from participating in the labor force.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › FJG – Specific › FJG Bad – laundry list

FJG causes private sector worker shortages and raises prices

Riedl, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, 2018

[Brian “Fantasyland Economics” City Journal, May 1 2018 prejcp-tm]

The compensation level for these guaranteed jobs, meantime, would destroy many private businesses. If any worker can take a government job with a $15 wage, full-time hours, and full benefits, then many industries operating on tight margins will not be able to compete for workers. Retail would likely shift further to the Internet, and fast-food restaurants would accelerate their shift to automation. Restaurants, landscapers, and industries dependent on cashiers and manual labor would survive on a limited basis, with notably higher prices.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › FJG – Specific › FJG Bad – laundry list

FJG induces workers to quit while costing huge amounts of government spending

Riedl, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, 2018

[Brian “Fantasyland Economics” City Journal, May 1 2018 prejcp-tm]

Despite a rapidly improving job market, senators such as Bernie Sanders, Cory Booker, and Kirsten Gillibrand have called for a new program in which the federal government would provide a full-time job to every American adult who wants one. Their proposal differs from programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), which partially subsidize private-sector jobs, not government jobs. And unlike the public-works programs of the New Deal, this taxpayer-funded federal job program—details to come—would be permanent. Universal employment is a worthy goal. Chronic joblessness depresses lifetime earnings substantially (even after the joblessness ends), damages relationships, and leads to serious health problems. But the new proposal is unworkable and implausible. Advocates estimate that 10.7 million currently unemployed and under-employed Americans would sign up. Yet the guaranteed wage of $15 per hour, plus benefits—which exceeds the current compensation levels for 40 percent of all workers—would induce millions of working Americans to quit their jobs and join the new program. Millions of others not currently looking for work, including retirees, would find the benefit package irresistible. Advocates estimate that the cost of salary, health care, child care, transportation, supplies, and capital goods would total $56,000 per employee. If participation rises to 20 to 35 million—which seems likely—the annual cost would swell to between $1 trillion to $2 trillion. An accompanying reduction in welfare benefits for these workers would offset only a small fraction of this cost. Even the low-end estimate of $1 trillion would create the largest federal program, exceeding even Social Security. It would be five times as expensive as the recent tax cuts and 12 times costlier than the recent defense-spending boost. Raising $1 trillion annually would require 70-to-80 percent federal income tax rates for single adults earning over $80,000 and couples earning more than $160,000. State and payroll taxes would leave these families paying total tax rates in the 80 to 90 percent range. Meanwhile, the federal jobs guarantee would reduce funding for other programs. Social Security and Medicare face an $82 trillion cash deficit over the next 30 years. Liberal politicians have rallied around a single-payer health plan estimated to cost $32 trillion over ten years, as well as free college, more K-12 education spending, and universal pre-K. Yet once lawmakers have imposed 80-to-90 percent combined marginal tax rates to pay for a guaranteed jobs program, where would the money come from to pay for Social Security, Medicare, and these other items? Cutting defense spending to European levels would merely close one-seventh of the Social Security and Medicare funding shortfall. The liberal wish list would have no room for other priorities.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › FJG – Specific › EITC > FJG – laundry list

FJG inefficient – lack of training, quality of work and cost make it comparatively worse then EITC

Riedl, senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, 2018

[Brian “Fantasyland Economics” City Journal, May 1 2018 prejcp-tm]

Imagine that Washington has hired 10 million unemployed and underemployed workers, raided industries like retail and fast food, and attracted millions of people who have been out of the labor force for years. What does the government do with 20 to 35 million lower-skilled workers? As Megan McArdle notes, most infrastructure projects require extensive training in operating heavy machinery. Teaching and day care require degrees and certifications. Basic landscaping, janitorial services, and beautifying public property require little training, but the economy does not need 20 million people performing them. The senators’ proposal is inspired by a vision of workers as widgets that can be easily slotted into any function, wherever they’re needed. In practice, though, the kinds of projects that get done will be dictated not by public need but by the characteristics of workers with few skills and little training. Having workers cycle in and out of the system based on the business cycle, seasonal job trends, and the ability to find private sector work would saddle these public projects with constant turnover, retraining, and upheaval. There is a moral hazard to the proposal, as well. If everyone is guaranteed a $15 per hour government job with full benefits, can they never be fired? If so, then there will be little incentive to work hard. A guaranteed government jobs program would also attract those who cannot keep a private-sector job due to behavioral issues such as harassment, threats, and abuse. Perhaps these workers would simply be transferred from project to project, or segregated from others—essentially collecting a $30,000 salary, plus benefits, without adding any real value. The families paying enormous taxes to support such individuals may not be amused. Expecting the government that brought us the DMV, Post Office, and an unusable Obamacare website to operate competently a jobs program for more than 20 million workers is fantasyland economics. The scale of the program would require the largest federal bureaucratic structure in American history, outside of World War II. Massive incompetence, corruption, and mismanagement would be inevitable. There is no easy path to creating plentiful, well-paying jobs. Rather than launching another break-the-bank government program, lawmakers should instead focus on encouraging economic growth, supporting education and job training, and expanding policies such as the EITC.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › FJG – Specific › EITC avoids politics DA [comparative FJG] – plan popular

Progressives support EITC – and using tax code as mechanism avoids politics DA – compared to UBI

Capps, 2019

[Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 prejcp-tm]

Progressives are circling around the Earned Income Tax Credit for good reason. Work is popular, as Burman notes, and a credit that both rewards and encourages employment avoids the “welfare” specter that has haunted means-tested transfer programs for years. President Donald Trump, a lifelong welfare opponent, has made work requirements a cornerstone of his domestic agenda; his administration even floated consolidating aid for food, health, and housing into a single Department of Welfare, a likely ploy to undercut these programs. Washington’s willingness to tamper with the tax code gives the tax credit more flexibility than spending programs that are inevitably in the crosshairs. For example, the category of eligible work could be expanded to include full-time caregivers, which would make it far more inclusive. And if, eventually, nobody works at all, thanks to the robots, then the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit could easily be converted to a traditional UBI program—the politics of which will likely change once algorithms replace lawyers, accountants, and professional bloggers.

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Advantage internal links and avoids net benefits › General internal links › Innovation incentives – Solvency

Expanded EITC and child credits solve innovation

Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023

[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › **Specific changes** › Expand – immigrants

Expanding coverage to immigrants – states proves expansion solves lack of federal eligibility

Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022

[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]

Expanding Eligibility to Immigrant Workers

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › **Specific changes** › Expand – immigrants

Expand federal and state EITC make refundable and end immigrant exclusion

Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023

[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC + child tax credit › Federal EITC +child tax credit – federal key

COVID EITC expired – Congress and the states should expand EITC and child tax credits

Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023

[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]

*figure omitted

2023 GDI Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC + child tax credit › Federal EITC +child tax credit – federal key

Federal EITC expansion to childless workers solves – failure increases risk of poverty for low wage workers – and states that follow federal EITC eligibility don’t fill in the gap

Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022

[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]

Expanding Age Eligibility and Increasing the Credit for Childless Workers