2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – Squo disparity
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
States vary dramatically in the generosity of their credits. The EITC provided by the District of Columbia, for example, is 70 percent of the federal credit this year for most eligible families, and will increase to 100 percent of the federal amount by tax year 2026 (matching their existing 100 percent credit for workers without dependents in the home). Part of D.C.’s EITC will be available to recipients in monthly payments.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – solves regressive taxes
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) boosts low-paid workers’ incomes and offsets some of the taxes they pay, providing the opportunity for lower-income families to move toward meaningful economic security. The federal EITC has kept millions of Americans out of poverty since its enactment in the mid-1970s. Over the past several decades, the effectiveness of the EITC has been amplified as many states have enacted and expanded their own credits.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – solves regressive taxes
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
State Earned Income Tax Credits Help Low-Paid Workers and Improve State Tax Codes
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – solves racial inequality
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – decoupling
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
To date, nearly two-thirds of states (31 states plus the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico) offer EITCs based on the federal credit (see Appendix). With a few exceptions (California, Minnesota and Washington), most taxpayers calculate their state EITC as a percentage of the federal credit. This approach of linking state credits to the federal amount makes it easy for taxpayers to claim the credit (since they have already calculated the amount of their federal credit) and straightforward for state tax administrators. However, there are also benefits to decoupling from aspects of the federal credit to help strengthen the benefits available to workers without children in the home, immigrants filing with Individual Taxpayers Identification Numbers (ITINs) and extremely low-income families.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › State EITC – childless workers
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC – age limits
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
Eight states have now recognized the need to allow more young workers to enjoy the benefits of the EITC. And three states have taken steps to include older workers (65+) without dependent children in the home.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand States EITC › States EITC + child tax credit – general
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC – federal only › Federal EITC - Remove upper age limit
Weiss, 2022
[Laura, “Earned income credit backers aim to keep expansion on the radar” RollCall December 13, 2022https://rollcall.com/2022/12/13/earned-income-credit-backers-aim-to-keep-expansion-on-the-radar/ accessed 6.14.23 preJCP-TM]
'Hugely powerful tool' AARP, which advocates for individuals over age 50, is pressing Congress to scrap the upper age cap in a lame-duck tax package. That’s among a handful of year-end priorities that AARP highlighted in a letter this month to party leaders. “Here’s a group of workers who are not being treated the same as their younger counterparts and who could very well find it affordable to have a job, and that’s really the way to think about it,” Cristina Martin Firvida, AARP vice president of financial security, said in an interview. “The EITC maybe makes that difference.” Firvida said removing the age cap would aid both individuals and businesses by making it more cost-effective for people over 65 to participate in the labor market during a time when high inflation can raise costs associated with having a job — like paying for gas to commute. She added that while the benefit hasn’t gotten as much attention as some others in the mix, AARP believes the age cap cuts off 2 million older workers from the benefit and is working to remind lawmakers of its importance.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC – federal only › Federal EITC – childless workers
Weiss, 2022
[Laura, “Earned income credit backers aim to keep expansion on the radar” RollCall December 13, 2022https://rollcall.com/2022/12/13/earned-income-credit-backers-aim-to-keep-expansion-on-the-radar/ accessed 6.14.23 preJCP-TM]
AARP has worked on the issue with the Critical Labor Coalition, which includes trade groups like the National Restaurant Association, American Hotel and Lodging Association and Coalition of Franchisee Associations, and has reported lobbying to permanently open the tax credit to everyone 18 and older. Misty Chally, who is lobbying on behalf of the coalition, said in an interview that supporting a broader earned income credit for workers without dependent children is among the ways the group is hoping to address labor shortages. Chally described the benefit as a “hugely powerful tool” for incentivizing people to participate in the workforce. Several groups that are asking Congress to revive Democrats’ 2021 child tax credit expansion — another feature of their pandemic aid law that lapsed at the start of this year — are also urging them to take up the earned income tax credit boost, though the child tax credit has won a larger spotlight. While separate programs, the expansions are often linked because the child credit covered families with dependent kids while the “childless” earned income tax credit aided other workers.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC – federal only › Federal EITC Expansion – solves income inequality
Davis, state policy director – ITEP, 2022
[Aidan, “Boosting Incomes and Improving Tax Equity with State Earned Income Tax Credits in 2022” BRIEF – Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, September 15, 2022 accessed 3.14.23 GDI-TM]
The Federal Earned Income Tax Credit Provides Critical Income Boost to Millions The federal EITC has been boosting the income of low-paid workers since 1975. Lawmakers have improved the credit over time so more working families can put food on the table, pay their bills and be better positioned to secure meaningful economic stability. Last year, the American Rescue Plan Act temporarily increased the federal EITC for low-paid workers without children in the home and made it more widely available by expanding both age and income limits. These critical expansions expired on January 1, 2022, though some members of Congress would like to see those enhancements revived. The federal EITC delivered about $60 billion to 25 million working families and individuals in 2021, through claims on their 2020 tax returns.[4] Used mostly as a source of temporary support, the EITC helps millions of families each year. The expanded federal EITC, together with the enhanced federal Child Tax Credit (CTC), lifted an estimated 5.3 million people out of poverty in 2021.[5] The EITC is based on earned income like salaries and wages. For example, for each dollar earned up to $15,410 in 2022, families with three or more children will receive a tax credit equal to 45 percent of those earnings, up to a maximum credit of $6,935. Because the credit is designed to boost incomes for low- and moderate-income workers, income limits restrict eligibility for the credit. Families continue to be eligible for the maximum credit until income reaches $20,140 for single heads of household. Above this level, the value of the credit is gradually reduced to zero and is unavailable when family income exceeds the maximum eligibility level. Single-parent households with three or more children earning $53,070 or more a year are ineligible, as are married couples earning $59,200 or more. Absent federal action to revive recent EITC enhancements, the credit will remain much less generous and available to fewer workers without children in the home: the maximum credit for such workers is just $560, roughly a third of what was made available to this population as a result of the 2021 enhancement.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
Solvency – Expansion EITC – General › Expand EITC – federal only › Federal EITC Expansion – solves income inequality
Weiss, 2022
[Laura, “Earned income credit backers aim to keep expansion on the radar” RollCall December 13, 2022https://rollcall.com/2022/12/13/earned-income-credit-backers-aim-to-keep-expansion-on-the-radar/ accessed 6.14.23 preJCP-TM]
Outside groups are urging Congress to bolster a key tax benefit for low-income workers in a year-end legislative package after a previous expansion lapsed. Organizations including anti-poverty advocates, civil rights groups, seniors group AARP and business representatives are calling on lawmakers to boost earned income tax credits for workers without children at home, arguing it’s a critical program for low-wage workers and would boost the economy amid lagging workforce participation. Under Democrats’ pandemic relief law, the maximum dollar value increased for the earned income tax credit for workers without dependent children who live with them a majority of the year, the benefit phased in faster, and the benefit became available at higher income thresholds. Democrats also made the benefit available to most qualifying workers age 19 or older, scrapping age limits. The roughly $12 billion, one-year expansion lapsed after 2021, reverting to a smaller credit and shrinking the pool of those who qualify to workers age 25 to 65. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a think tank that has lobbied in favor of the expanded credit, estimated that with the expansion’s end, almost 6 million working adults without children would be taxed into, or deeper into, poverty. Kris Cox, deputy director of federal tax policy at the CBPP, said the 2021 expansion was “long overdue” after workers without qualifying children hadn’t seen a meaningful increase in benefits since they became eligible for the credit in 1993. She added it has a significant impact on income inequality, citing benefits flowing to a significant portion of young Black adults under the 2021 expansion. “This group is a group of people who are working important jobs for very low pay and not raising children at home, and this has been a topic of discussion among policymakers for many years,” Cox said.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
1ncs › Versus BIG
Capps, 2019
[Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 prejcp-tm]
As it’s currently construed, the Earned Income Tax Credit supports working low-income households with children. It’s a substantial enough subsidy that these households plan their annual spending around it. Anyone who has ever eagerly anticipated a tax refund understands this, although for some working families the credit can amount to as much as 40 percent of annual household income. Yet the Earned Income Tax Credit is only progressive-ish at best, since it provides little to no help for working households without children or for middle-class families. Burman’s paper calls for replacing the Earned Income Tax Credit with a Universal Earned Income Tax Credit, which would “provide meaningful assistance for low- and middle-income workers whether or not they have children living with them.” This universal tax credit “would not directly penalize two-earner couples,” he writes. The fixes are straightforward, albeit ambitious: The universal tax credit would be based on individual income, not household income, so dual-income households would benefit. Family makeup would no longer be a factor, so childless workers would earn more from the credit, too. The universal credit would apply to 100 percent of earnings up to a maximum $10,000, extending its reach into the lower middle class. Burman also tacks on changes to the the Child Tax Credit, making it fully refundable, which would be a huge boost for very low-income parents. Further, Burman proposes a way to pay for the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit: a new value-added tax of 11 percent. If nobody works at all, thanks to the robots, then the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit could easily be converted to a traditional UBI program. That pay-for element distinguishes the Tax Policy Center concept from Senator Cory Booker’s Rise Credit, Senator Kamala Harris’s LIFT the Middle Class Act, Senator Sherrod Brown’s Working Families Tax Relief Act, or the Economic Security Project’s Cost of Living Refund—all of which are otherwise fairly same-same. Any eventual effort to improve or expand the tax refund as part of the social safety net is bound to draw from some or all these drafts. The idea is to accomplish through the tax code what might be impossible through legislation, given the current partisan gridlock.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
1ncs › Versus FJG
Pethokoukis, Senior Fellow AEI, 2018
[James “Thinking About (much) Better Pro-work Ideas Than a Cartoonish Federal Jobs Guarantee” AEI May 01, 2018https://www.aei.org/economics/thinking-about-much-better-pro-work-ideas-than-a-cartoonish-federal-jobs-guarantee/ accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-TM]
The idea of a federal jobs guarantee, perhaps last seen in the enjoyable 1993 film “Dave,” is the hot-take economic policy on the left at the moment. (Sorry, universal basic income, your 15 minutes appear to be up.) Now there are many, many problems with a federal jobs guarantee. In a recent blog post, economist Timothy Taylor highlights lots of them, at least regarding the undercooked Bernie Sanders version. There’s a government managerial problem, a jobs-skills mismatch problem, a geographical mismatch problem, a worker displacement problem, a worker discipline and incentive problem, a “what happens to existing anti-poverty programs” problem, and, of course, a budgetary problem. Lots of problems. You really can’t hand-wave these away. Taylor also includes some commentary by Mother Jones’ Kevin Drum, which really shows why the jobs guarantee fails the sniff test. Drum: Since this is just a proposal, let’s also suppose that Bernie is proposing universal health care and a minimum wage of $15, which we know he supports. In that case, everyone with a job would be just as well off keeping it. However, there would still be millions who don’t have a job and want one, and more millions who might not like their jobs and would prefer a government job that’s a little cushier. How many is that? Maybe 5 million? 10 million? And probably more like 15-20 million during a recession. That’s still pretty damn close to insane. It’s about 3-10 percent of the labor force effectively nationalized forever by the federal government, which makes it roughly comparable to the emergency labor force employed for a few years by the WPA during the depths of the Depression. This is why even our lefty comrades in social democratic Europe don’t guarantee jobs for everyone. It would cost a fortune; it would massively disrupt the private labor market; it would almost certainly tank productivity; and it’s unlikely in the extreme that the millions of workers in this program could ever be made fully competent at their jobs. That’s what we in the commentary business call a reality check. But of course government should not be indifferent to encouraging work. This from my AEI colleague Michael Strain in a piece for Bloomberg: The right place to start is with policies to help individuals become more successful workers. One example is the federal earned-income tax credit, which uses taxpayer dollars to subsidize the earnings of low-income, working households. By increasing the financial rewards of working, previous EITC expansions have pulled people into the workforce. Or take work-based learning programs, like apprenticeships, which can be successful by combining skill-building with formal instruction in order to increase workers’ productivity and wages.
2023
GDI
Counterplan
1ncs › Generic › 1nc – fed and states EITC/child credits
Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023
[SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 GDI-TM]
*figure omitted
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Skills Mismatch—2NC
Taylor, Journal of Economic Perspectives Managing Editor, ‘18
[Timothy T. Taylor, Managing Editor, Journal of Economic Perspectives, “The Job Guarantee Controversy,” Conversable Economist, 4—30—18, , accessed 5-1-23]
The job skills mismatch problem
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Skills Mismatch—1NC
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘19
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research, “The Job Guarantee Strikes Back,” American Institute for Economic Research, 3—8—19, , accessed 6-8-23]
Miller implies that I am wrong to worry about the job guarantee leading to “economic disaster.” By peeling away millions from the private sector into a system that is necessarily inferior in assigning jobs, disaster could indeed ensue. Miller accurately summarizes concerns expressed by economist Dean Baker and me that the program would attract millions more than the authors intend. But before he has a chance to explain why we’re wrong or why this wouldn’t be a bad thing, he suddenly pivots.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Rent-Seeking—2NC
Harsanyi, Federallist senior editor, ‘18
[David Harsanyi, senior editor, The Federalist, “Democrats' Universal Job Plan Would Be a Socialist Disaster,” REASON, 4—27—18, , accessed 6-9-23]
Of course, it's more likely that our state-run workforce would be deployed for ideological and political priorities rather than economic ones. If history is any indicator, it would be used to prop up politically useful projects and keep failing industries afloat, undermining creative destruction, innovation, and long-term growth.
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Rent-Seeking—2NC
Bourne, Cato analyst, ‘18
[Ryan Bourne, R. Evan Scharf Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics, Cato Institute, “A Jobs Guaranteed Economic Disaster,” CATO AT LIBERTY, Cato Institute, 4—24—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
Corruption and incentives
2023
GDI
Negative
Solvency Answers › Solvency: Rent-Seeking—1NC
Gulker, AIER Senior Research Fellow, ‘18
[Max Gulker, PhD, Economics, Stanford University, Senior Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, THE JOB GUARANTEE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS, American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, p. 15]
6.3 Rent-Seeking and Corruption