Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---DPT True

The most exhaustive quantitative study finds DPT to be true.

Imai '21 - Professor of Government and of Statistics at Harvard University [Kosuke and James Lo, "Robustness of Empirical Evidence for the Democratic Peace: A Nonparametric Sensitivity Analysis," International Organization, Vol 75, Issue 3]

How should we resolve this empirical debate regarding the democratic peace?Footnote9 Unfortunately, in the absence of randomized experiments, we can never completely rule out the possible existence of confounding biases that arise from omitted variables. While scholars in this literature have exclusively relied on parametric regression models, this approach requires strong assumptions, namely that the model accurately characterizes the true data-generating process (correct set of variables, right functional form, valid distributional assumption, etc.). Given that these assumptions may not be verifiable from observed data, it is no surprise that various scholars advocate different regression models with diverging sets of variables, resulting in contradictory findings. The difficulty of adjudicating between these alternative modeling approaches has led to the ongoing controversy in the empirical democratic peace literature.

We propose an alternative approach based on nonparametric sensitivity analysis to formally assess the robustness of the empirical evidence.Footnote10 Specifically, we quantify the strength of confounding relationships that could explain away the observed association between democracy and peace. That is, we compute the precise level of unobserved confounding needed to render the observed association between democracy and conflict spurious. The idea is that although not all correlations imply causation, a very strong correlation suggests it. Unlike the parametric regression modeling approach prevalent in the literature, the proposed nonparametric sensitivity approach directly addresses the existence of unobserved confounders without assuming a particular regression model.Footnote11 Although one can never know with certainty from observational data whether democracy causes peace, this nonparametric sensitivity analysis can formally assess the robustness of empirical evidence for the democratic peace.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---AT: Decline Inevitable

Decline reversible

Nancy Bermeo 18, American political scientist, and senior research fellow at Nuffield College, University of Oxford. "Reflections: Can American Democracy Still Be Saved?" //pipk

This article reflects on whether the erosion of democracy in the contemporary United States can be halted. Using the cases and conclusions from McCoy and Somer’s eleven country collective project, it argues that democracy’s decline is not inevitable. A case for cautious optimism emerges from analyzing the coalitions around democracy’s disassemblers and democracy’s defenders. The actors disassembling democracy have activated cleavages and adopted a style of rule that exacerbates fault-lines on the Right. The actors defending democracy have thus far done what’s needed to eventually build the sort of winning coalition that has proven successful elsewhere. Creating broad, cross-class networks, mobilizing peaceful protest, and drawing on mass values that are still supportive of democracy bolster the likelihood of successful defense.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US Key to Global Democracy

US key to global democracy---counterplan establishes safeguards for three pillars, civic organizations are key

Larry Diamond 21, Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution and the Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies at Stanford University. "A World Without American Democracy?". Foreign Affairs. July 2. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/americas/2021-07-02/world-without-american-democracy

A prolonged global democratic recession has, in recent years, morphed into something even more troubling: the “third reverse wave” of democratic breakdowns that the political scientist Samuel Huntington warned could follow the remarkable burst of “third wave” democratic progress in the 1980s and the 1990s. Every year for the past 15 years, according to Freedom House, significantly more countries have seen declines in political rights and civil liberties than have seen gains. But since 2015, that already ominous trend has turned sharply worse: 2015–19 was the first five-year period since the beginning of the third wave in 1974 when more countries abandoned democracy—twelve—than transitioned to it—seven.

And the trend continues. Illiberal populist leaders are degrading democracy in countries including Brazil, India, Mexico, and Poland, and creeping authoritarianism has already moved Hungary, the Philippines, Turkey, and Venezuela out of the category of democracies altogether. In Georgia, the dominance of the Georgian Dream Party has led to the steady decline of electoral processes and a breakdown in the rule of law. In Myanmar, the military overthrew the elected government of Aung San Suu Kyi, ending an experiment in partial democracy. In El Salvador, president Nayib Bukele staged an executive coup by removing the attorney general and Supreme Court justices who were obstacles to his consolidation of power. In Peru, democracy hangs from a thread as the right-wing autocrat Keiko Fujimori advances vague claims of election fraud in a bid to overturn her narrow electoral defeat to left-wing opponent Pedro Castillo.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US-EU Relations Add-on

US-EU relations solve multiple existential risks

Bruce Stokes 20, fellow at the German Marshall Fund, a former international economics correspondent for the National Journal, a former senior transatlantic fellow at the German Marshall Fund and a former senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations. "Together or Alone? Choices and Strategies for Transatlantic Relations for 2021 and Beyond". October. //pipk

In 2021, the United States and the nations of Europe will face challenges that threaten their way of life: a catastrophic pandemic, a deep economic recession, accelerating climate change, a rising China, growing technological competition, and emerging security threats.

These challenges test our ability to deliver on our promise to safeguard and enhance the lives of our people. They confront the transatlantic community at a time when many citizens on both sides of the Atlantic continue to question whether their governments are able to deliver for them. These are issues that transcend national borders. They cannot be successfully dealt with alone. They can only be resolved through concerted, cooperative international action.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---AI Solves Disinfo---Democracy I/L

AI solves disinformation

David Calvo et al 21, Project Lead, NATO ACT Innovation Hub. Johns Hopkins University: David Calvo, Ricky Cheng, Marc Helou, Nyeli Kratz, Claire Liddy, Jolie McDonnell, Tyler Shin. Imperial College London: Jasneet Taak Georgia Institute of Technology: Jack Crawford, Meredith Furbish, Marc Al Haj, Nico Luzum, Omar Webb Under the Supervision of: Lawrence Aronhime, Associate Teaching Professor, and Alexander Cocron, Lecturer, Johns Hopkins University Whiting School of Engineering. Nicholas Nelson, Principal Researcher, Georgia Tech Research Institute (GTRI); Senior Fellow for Emerging Tech & Policy at the Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA). August 12. “Countering disinformation: Improving the Alliance’s digital resilience” //pipk

The Alliance needs a broadly effective strategy to counter the evolving threat of disinformation. Artificial intelligence (AI) tools can help to identify and to slow the spread of false and harmful content while upholding the values of pluralistic and open societies.

Disinformation: not exactly new

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US AI Coop key to Democracy

Solves democracy

Andrew Imbrie et al 20, Andrew Imbrie Ryan Fedasiuk Catherine Aiken Tarun Chhabra Husanjot Chahal. Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) at Georgetown’s Walsh School of Foreign Service is a research organization focused on studying the security impacts of emerging technologies, supporting academic work in security and technology studies, and delivering nonpartisan analysis to the policy community. February. "Agile Alliances: How the United States and its Allies Can Deliver a Democratic Way of AI" //pipk

How can the United States collaborate with allies and partners to shape the trajectory of AI in ways that will promote liberal democratic values and protect against authoritarian uses of this technology?

The evidence in this report suggests alliances are relevant to defending against Chinese and Russian efforts to wield AI for authoritarian ends, networking with partners to advance technological progress, and projecting shared democratic values in the age of AI.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US AI Coop key to Democracy

Plan builds a coalition that spills over to broader international collaboration---solves democratic alternatives to Chinese AI---countries will follow the model

Andrew Imbrie et al 20, Andrew Imbrie Ryan Fedasiuk Catherine Aiken Tarun Chhabra Husanjot Chahal. Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) at Georgetown’s Walsh School of Foreign Service is a research organization focused on studying the security impacts of emerging technologies, supporting academic work in security and technology studies, and delivering nonpartisan analysis to the policy community. February. "Agile Alliances: How the United States and its Allies Can Deliver a Democratic Way of AI" //pipk

The United States has a vested interest in setting the rules of the road for artificial intelligence. Western countries have already taken the lead in developing principles governing the application of artificial intelligence. China has produced its own set of principles and engages actively in international bodies, such as the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and the 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP), to establish standards for mobile network technologies and the future governance of AI.

By assuming leadership in AI, the United States and its allies face risks and opportunities. The risks are twofold. On the one hand, standard setting could become a casualty of geopolitical competition as leading countries precipitate a race to the bottom. On the other hand, China already asserts its principles and standards through a variety of multilateral fora. The opportunity is that the United States and its allies can act now to set global standards for AI reflecting and supporting human rights and liberal democratic values, while addressing critical questions surrounding the rollout of 5G, facial recognition for surveillance, automated cyber exploitation and defense, and autonomous weapons systems. A Japanese official responding to the CSET survey noted that the United States and its allies should adopt a citizen-centric AI strategy. Such citizen-centric strategies would seek to develop and deploy AI for the benefit of democratic societies, including strengthened data privacy standards and respect for civil liberties; economic empowerment of citizens within rules-based market economies; greater access to education, precision medicine, energy efficiency, and more inclusive social service provision.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US AI Coop key to Democracy

US EU cooperation on AI key to global US leadership and democratic AI

Julia Voo and Lauren Zabierek 20, Cyber Fellow, leads the team behind Belfer’s National Cyber Power Index, and is the former Research Director for the Belfer Center’s new China Cyber Policy Initiative. Her areas of research include the Digital Silk Road, industrial policy, and technical standards for strategic technologies. Voo also has research affiliations with the Future of Humanity Institute (Oxford), the Hague Program for Cyber Norms (Leiden), and the China-Africa Research Initiative (Johns Hopkins). A 2019 graduate of Harvard Kennedy School’s mid-career Master in Public Administration program, Julia served earlier at the British Embassy in Beijing where she covered China’s cyber and artificial intelligence policy from a commercial perspective, technical standards, and other trade policy issues. Executive Director of the Cyber Project at Harvard Kennedy School’s Belfer Center where she leads research and programming on domestic and international cyber and emerging technology policy issues; her driving vision for the Project is “Cybersecurity is National Security.” She comes to this role as a 2019 graduate of the Kennedy School’s mid-career MPA program. Lauren served as an intelligence officer in the United States Air Force at the beginning of her career. Later, as a civilian intelligence analyst with the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency (NGA) assigned to the Office of Counterterrorism, she completed three war zone deployments where she worked to identify and dismantle terror networks. The Cyber Project Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs Harvard Kennedy School. "The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence" August. //pipk

The next decade will be a decisive time for the US to shape its future role in the world. Democracies are being tested and toyed with by malign powers, as seen in the form of Russian interference in the 2016 US Presidential elections and subsequent disinformation campaigns by other nations. Great power politics and the national security implications of emerging technologies, such as AI, are breaking up supply chains and further fragmenting the internet. We’re witnessing shocks to the liberal economic order and global governance as a result of several economic crises and the aftermath of the biggest public health crisis in a century. Societies across the world will be looking to develop and implement new technology to deal with crises and recover from economic losses faster. The rise of revisionist powers and the transformative potential of emerging technologies means that the US and its European allies need to prioritize investing in capabilities and its relationships to ensure that emerging technologies align with liberal, democratic values. While the US currently maintains a slight edge in research and development of AI capabilities, that advantage is eroding as a result of a shortage of AI talent, lack of engagement between the federal government, academia, and the private sector, and overall gaps in federal government funding. US innovation has its roots in an open and multicultural society. American leadership in innovation is the result of decades of attracting, training, and recruiting the brightest minds in the world. While recognizing that there are some national security risks, efforts to cut off the flow of students will be detrimental to long-term US innovative capabilities. The European Union while maintaining its role as a leader in AI ethical guidelines, also faces challenges stemming from a lack of talent as well as insufficient funding and uncoordinated AI expertise and application across the Member States. Moreover, the EU suffers from other institutional challenges that are most glaringly demonstrated by the UK’s vote to leave the EU in 2016—which unbeknownst at the time dealt a major blow to the EU’s AI ecosystem. The US and EU need to enhance cooperation in the development and application of AI in healthcare, environmental science, and defense. When the US and EU work together on global challenges such as healthcare and environment science, the rest of the world benefits. And there are other key geopolitical challenges that the US and EU face that can only be balanced together. We are delighted to share with you this analysis of the AI landscape between the US and EU, written and researched by our students working with the Cyber Project and China Cyber Policy Initiative, Christie Lawrence and Sean Cordey. We feel this report provides a strong evidence base for further collaboration, and puts forth thoughtful recommendations. The importance of the transatlantic relationship cannot be understated. The world needs strong leadership in these uncertain times and the US and EU bring unique strengths to the table that collaboratively can strengthen the other’s advantage in the face of unprecedented technological and geopolitical challenges. The US and the EU need to work together.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---US AI Coop key to Democracy

US cooperation with allies on AI key to democracy

Andrew Imbrie et al 20, Andrew Imbrie Ryan Fedasiuk Catherine Aiken Tarun Chhabra Husanjot Chahal. Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET) at Georgetown’s Walsh School of Foreign Service is a research organization focused on studying the security impacts of emerging technologies, supporting academic work in security and technology studies, and delivering nonpartisan analysis to the policy community. February. "Agile Alliances: How the United States and its Allies Can Deliver a Democratic Way of AI" //pipk

The United States has long benefited from its network of allies and partners that contribute forces, specialized capabilities, and legitimacy to U.S. leadership in the world. In recent years, however, this network has come under strain. Disputes over burden sharing and mutual recriminations have raised questions about the cohesion and durability of existing alliance structures. Recent U.S. policy shifts and withdrawal from certain international agreements have deepened fears that the United States no longer sees its allies and partners as central to U.S. strategic objectives and national security.

America’s alliances are weakening at a time of growing competition between democratic nations and authoritarian regimes. Authoritarian regimes are surviving longer and becoming more adept at using AI-enabled surveillance and censorship technologies to export their values abroad.5 China and Russia present a significant challenge to liberal democratic societies.6 A world in which China and Russia deploy AI to widen the net of information controls is a world of diminished rights and protections for the individual, fewer safeguards for privacy and the rule of law, more data exploitation, and limited opportunities for judicial redress or public dissent.7

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › Cooperation Advantage › 2AC---NATO AI Coop Solves Democracy

NATO AI cooperation is key to preserve democracy

Andrea Gilli et al 20, Senior Researcher at the NATO Defense College where he works on issues related to technological change and military innovation. He has been visiting and postdoctoral fellow at Johns Hopkins University and Columbia University as well as Stanford University (where he remains an Affiliate) and Harvard University. Mauro Gilli is a Senior Researcher in Military Technology and International Security at the Center for Security Studies (CSS) at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, ETHZurich. Before joining CSS, he was a post-doctoral fellow at the Dickey Center, Dartmouth College. Ann-Sophie Leonard is a former Mercator Fellow on International Affairs, focusing on the intersection of international security and technology. She was a Visiting Fellow at the Research Division of the NATO Defense College in Rome from September to December 2019. Zoe Stanley-Lockman is an Associate Research Fellow in the Military Transformations Programme at the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore. “NATO-Mation”: Strategies for Leading in the Age of Artificial Intelligence. NDC Research Paper No.15 – December 2020 //pipk

The ongoing technological transformation has not only renewed great powers’ longforgotten competition in areas like technology, with the so-called AI race,330 but it has also given rise to new instruments for political competition and influence.331 The effect of these instruments is particularly subtle, because they undermine the very principles and institutions – such as democracy, freedom of speech and free markets – on which NATO is built and which, as an Alliance, it tries to promote.

Propaganda, disinformation, deception and counter-intelligence have always existed. However, the possibility of applying emerging technologies with disruptive potential to these domains is relatively unprecedented.332 For instance, forensic evidence related to popular digital platforms like WeChat and TikTok shows that specific hashtags, accounts or information have been suppressed by foreign actors or governments, likely for political reasons.333 Similarly, in the past few years, autocratic regimes have recurrently relied on chatbots, troll farms and diffusion of disinformation through Facebook or Twitter with a view to altering political competition within, and outside, NATO.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---Deterrence Solves Climate

Deterrence solves climate change

Shruti Samala 21, Staff Assistant Intern for the Wilson Center's Environmental Change and Security Program. "Climate Change and Nuclear War: Existential Threats on a “Split Screen”" October 26. //pipk

“In international relations today, we face two truly existential threats—in climate change and in nuclear war,” says Robert Litwak, Senior Vice President for Scholars and Director of International Security Studies, in a new episode of Wilson NOW. The interview with Litwak focuses on his new article, “Geostrategic Competition and Climate Change: Avoiding the Unmanageable,” recently published in 21st Century Diplomacy: Foreign Policy is Climate Policy.

Climate catastrophe and nuclear war are often conceptualized as separate and distinct—as if on a split screen, says Litwak. At this critical juncture—when “the risk of conflict between the United States and its Great Power rivals, China and Russia, is at the highest point since the end of the Cold War”—the two crises must be understood as interconnected.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---War Outweighs

War makes everything else harder to manage

Bryan Walsh 2/26, Editor, Future Perfect, Vox. "The war in Ukraine could portend the end of the “long peace”"The war in Ukraine could portend the end of the “long peace” //pipk

Those abandoned fallout shelters were on my mind on Wednesday night as I watched Russia overturn decades of seemingly settled international policy with an invasion of Ukraine that was as premeditated as it was shocking. What sets this action apart from the countless conflicts, large and small, that have unfolded over recent decades, is the specter of nuclear weapons.

That was implicit in Russia’s decision to exercise its strategic nuclear forces in the leadup to the invasion, in Putin’s absurd casus belli claim that Ukraine was going to develop its own nuclear weapons, in his threat that countries that interfered with Russian actions would face “consequences you have never seen.” As Roger Cohen pointed out in the New York Times, Putin’s speech “seemed to come closer to threatening nuclear war than any statement from a major world leader in recent decades.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---Yes Hybrid Threats---Russia

Russia is weaponizing AI through hybrid warfare---that undermines NATO decision-making

Franz-Stefan Gady 21, Research Fellow for Cyber, Space and Future Conflict, International Institute for Strategic Studies. “NATO Decision-Making in the Age of Big Data and Artificial Intelligence” Editors: Sonia Lucarelli; Alessandro Marrone; and Francesco Niccolò Moro. Sonia Lucarelli is Professor of International Relations and European Security at the University of Bologna, and member of the Board of Directors of the Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI). Alessandro Marrone is Head of the Defence Programme of IAI and teaches at the Istituto Superiore di Stato Maggiore Interforze (ISSMI) of the Italian Ministry of Defence. Francesco N. Moro is Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Bologna and Adjunct Professor of International Relations at the Johns Hopkins University Europe Campus. This publication is the result of the Conference “NATO Decision-making: promises and perils of the Big Data age”, organized by NATO Allied Command Transformation (ACT), the University of Bologna and Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI) of Rome. //pipk

This chapter seeks to offer preliminary answers to two questions. First, to what degree will Artificial Intelligence (AI)-enabled information warfare exacerbate hybrid threats to NATO decision-making? Second, what can NATO countries do to alleviate the threat? To narrow the research scope, this chapter will principally look at threats posed by Russian AI-enabled information warfare operations under the concept of gibridnaya voyna. The study argues that given that AI-enabled information warfare has the potential to amplify societal polarization, elite disagreement within domestic politics, and reshape the perception of the “Russian threat” in NATO member countries, it can have a direct negative impact on national and NATO decision-making. Such operations, however, only amplify existing symptoms of polarization and disagreement found within NATO member states and are not their root causes. The chapter concludes that NATO must better integrate tech-centric so-called “whack-a-troll” tactics with a whole-of-nation strategy to better safe-guard NATO decision-making and alliance cohesion. Renewed discussion of whole-of-society defense concepts to inform national security strategies may be useful in this regard.

Introduction NATO defines hybrid threats as threats that “combine military and non-military as well as covert and overt means, including disinformation, cyber attacks, economic pressure, deployment of irregular armed groups and use of regular forces” (2019). Such hybrid methods are used to blur the line between war and peace and “attempt to sow doubts in the minds of target populations.” NATO further emphasizes that “[t]he speed, scale and intensity of hybrid threats have increased in recent years.” The latter can partially be traced back to various technological advances including in the fields of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and offensive cyber capabilities, utilized in conjunction with deliberate attempts by competitor nations to undermine the political cohesion of NATO member states from within.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---Yes Hybrid Threats---China

Chinese hybrid threats risks mischaracteriziation---being able to successfully characterize attacks is key

Hanna Smith 21, Director of Research and Analysis at the Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats and visiting professor for the academic year 2020–2021 at the College of Europe, Bruges. “NATO Decision-Making in the Age of Big Data and Artificial Intelligence” Editors: Sonia Lucarelli; Alessandro Marrone; and Francesco Niccolò Moro. Sonia Lucarelli is Professor of International Relations and European Security at the University of Bologna, and member of the Board of Directors of the Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI). Alessandro Marrone is Head of the Defence Programme of IAI and teaches at the Istituto Superiore di Stato Maggiore Interforze (ISSMI) of the Italian Ministry of Defence. Francesco N. Moro is Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Bologna and Adjunct Professor of International Relations at the Johns Hopkins University Europe Campus. This publication is the result of the Conference “NATO Decision-making: promises and perils of the Big Data age”, organized by NATO Allied Command Transformation (ACT), the University of Bologna and Istituto Affari Internazionali (IAI) of Rome. //pipk

Recent digital and technological developments have enabled many completely new tools, which have given rise to new virtual platforms that fall outside current norms and rules. These new tools have also brought unprecedented speed to all kinds of action. Interconnectivity and globalization have created new possibilities for network-based action, lowered borders, changed geopolitics and made sure that there is more data around us than ever before. New actors have emerged in international politics, who are looking to enhance their status. Authoritarian and democratic states appear to be entering into a new form of ideological battle. In this situation one can ask: what are the rules of the game? An important weapon in this new battle is hybrid threats. Hybrid threats constitute a shadow policy for authoritarian states that supports their strategic aims and is based on their strategic culture traditions. The clear dividing lines, unwritten rules, players and goals of the Cold War are history. This situation is challenging for planners, decision-makers and foresight building.

The concept of hybrid threats has entered into political normality by appearing in the discourses and documents of the EU, NATO and their member states. The concept has been examined through many different disciplinary lenses: international relations, strategic studies, security studies, military studies, history and political science – to name a few. This multidisciplinary analytical mosaic also blurs the picture of what hybrid threats really are. The Report “The Landscape of Hybrid Threats: A Conceptual Model”, issued by the European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats (Hybrid CoE) together with the European Union (EU) Commission’s Joint Research Center, uses hybrid threats as an umbrella concept, under which different types of activity occur: interference, influence, operations, campaigns and even warfare (Giannopoulos, Smith and Theocharidou, 2020). The approach adopted would enable a comprehensive analysis including civilian, political, military and academic thinking. This chapter will take the report’s conceptual model as its starting point for hybrid threat analysis.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---AI Solves Decision-Making

AI solves military decision-making---being adopted now, effective implementation solves

Matej Tonin 19, current Slovenian Minister of Defense, was an active member of the NATO PA from 2012 to 2020. He served as rapporteur and Chairperson of the Assembly's Sub-Committee on Technology Trends and Security and as Deputy Head of the Slovenian delegation to the NATO PA. "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: IMPLICATIONS FOR NATO’S ARMED FORCES" Report from the Sub-Committee on Technology Trends and Security. October 13. //pipk

10. AI is already becoming a reality in armed forces around the world. All modern armed forces are, at a minimum, thinking through AI’s implications, including the ethical and legal implications, and many are introducing concrete AI solutions (see also Section IV). AI holds enormous potential for the defence sector but also presents a set of technical and non-technical challenges. Moreover, the strategic implications of AI remain unclear.

11. Tackling all opportunities, challenges, and uncertainties in depth would go beyond the scope of this report (see also Box 4). Therefore, this section delves into two key areas of opportunity (information and decision support as well as robotic autonomous systems), crucial technical and non-technical challenges, including the debate about lethal autonomous weapons systems, and some potential strategic implications.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---AI Solves Violence

AI integration solves kinetic warfare

EU Institute for Security Studies 19, The European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS) is the Union’s agency dealing with the analysis of foreign, security and defence policy issues. Its core mission is to assist the EU and its member states in the implementation of the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP), including the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) as well as other external action of the Union. "The EU Nato and Artificial Intelligence" November 14. //pipk

At the event it was agreed that AI should be conceptualised as a key part of a broader nexus of emerging disruptive technologies, alongside big data, quantum computing and autonomous systems. While its exact impact remains unclear, there was consensus that AI-enabled systems would inevitably transform defence across the board. AI could enhance data management and situational awareness capacities, leading to costsavings, improved feedback control systems and decision-making, new operational concepts and greater freedom of action. On the battlefield, AI could function as an enabler across all future platforms and capabilities, with main areas of application including C2, ISR, training and logistics. As such, it would become a key factor in interoperability. AI could also change the organisational structure of military institutions in numerous – and often unpredictable – ways. In strategic terms, it could potentially lead to a reduction of the level of kinetic violence in conflict, altering the military’s role in controlling the battlefield.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---NATO AI key to Deterrence

AI key to effective NATO deterrence versus Russia and China

Simona R. Soare 21, was a Senior Associate Analyst at EUISS from 2019 to end May 2021. Her research focused on United States security policy, transatlantic security and EU-NATO relations. Prior to joining EUISS, Simona served as advisor to the Vice-President of the European Parliament (2015-2019) and as an analyst with the Romanian Ministry of Defence, working on transatlantic and European security. She has also been a research associate with the Institut d’Études Européennes (IEE) at Université Saint Louis-Bruxelles. Simona holds a PhD in Political Science from the National School for Political and Administrative Studies in Bucharest where she lectured on international security (2008-2015). She is the recipient of a U.S. Department of State fellowship on U.S. Grand Strategy and has published extensively on American and transatlantic security. "Innovation as Adaptation: NATO and Emerging Technologies" June 11. //pipk

Throughout NATO’s history, defense innovation has been critical to its technological edge and its deterrence and defense posture against multiple threats. The unprecedented progress in emerging and disruptive technologies (EDTs) offers the prospect and challenge of transformative defense innovation for allied armed forces and societies at large. Technological progress in artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning, advanced robotics, biotechnologies and human enhancement, quantum technologies, big-data analytics, and fifth-generation telecommunication systems, as well as growing autonomy in the critical functions of military systems, promise to change how wars are fought, how fast, where, and by whom. These technologies enable new forms of military presence, coercive action, and power projection in and across old and new domains (for example, cyberspace and outer space) and below and above the conventional threshold of armed conflict.

However, NATO and the transatlantic allies are neither the only nor the most agile actors investing in emerging and disruptive technologies. China and Russia already invest substantially in and have accelerated their adoption of these technologies in military applications. To maintain its strategic advantage against China and Russia, NATO needs to become an agent of innovation and be more agile and strategic in supporting allies to jointly exploit new technologies for deterrence, defense, and resilience purposes. NATO has prioritized EDTs and signaled it has joined “the technological adoption race” against China and Russia.1 Much work remains to be done. Allies remain divided on the ethical and legal specifics of the military use of EDTs and by their national-industrial preferences. Technological capacity across the alliance also varies significantly and, as always, funding is in short supply. Concrete decisions on how to consolidate innovation in EDTs, a critical task for NATO’s mission and future adaptation, are expected at this month’s Brussels summit. Specifically, allies will respond to calls for a “strategic surge” in EDTs2 innovation by establishing a Defense Innovation Accelerator, an opt-in instrument funded through dedicated national contributions, which NATO hopes will incentivize innovation and transatlantic cooperation on emerging technologies.3

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---AI key to NATO---Interoperability

Intra NATO AI gap decks interoperability---cooperation through NATO is key

Matej Tonin 19, current Slovenian Minister of Defense, was an active member of the NATO PA from 2012 to 2020. He served as rapporteur and Chairperson of the Assembly's Sub-Committee on Technology Trends and Security and as Deputy Head of the Slovenian delegation to the NATO PA. "ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: IMPLICATIONS FOR NATO’S ARMED FORCES" Report from the Sub-Committee on Technology Trends and Security. October 13. //pipk

63. Second, the defence technology gap between Allies must remain small enough to be bridged by interoperability. The large diversity of Allies is ultimately a primary source of NATO’s strength, but it also means that large differences exist in defence capabilities. There is a danger that the significant investment in AI in leading Allied nations could lead to substantial interoperability problems and a loss of NATO’s overall military effectiveness in the future. However, the good news is that AI efforts do not need to be capital intensive, as the Committee witnessed during its fact-finding visit to Singapore in May 2019. Small- and medium-sized Allies with smart scientists and engineers can play an outsized role in AI development and adoption if they so choose. This could indeed be a very effective contribution to Allied burden sharing from the smaller Allied nations. To increase interoperability, cooperation through NATO’ structures has a large role to play. Interoperability should be at the heart of AI efforts carried out by the STO, ACT, the NCI Agency, NIAG, and others. Allies leading in the S&T sector should encourage open architecture standards and regulations for technology sharing and transfer among Allies in order to narrow the technology gap, in line with all national obligations and the sensitive nature of technologies

64. Allied armed forces alone will not be able to solve the AI-specific challenges laid out in this report, including the ethical and legal questions. This will need a much broader push across the entire AI ecosystem. However, governments, NATO, and the EU can and must play a critical role in overcoming the investment, innovation, and workforce challenges of adopting AI. Just as national governments across the Alliance are rising to the challenge of AI, so should their armed forces. They should move beyond scanning the horizon and, instead, invest in real research, experimentation, development, and adoption efforts. It should be underlined that all dual-use and military AI efforts should, however, tackle all ethical, legal, and social questions right from the beginning, including privacy considerations and the definition of appropriate human involvement in decisions about the use of force. Allies should consider examining whether an ethics code of conduct could put the adoption of AI in the armed forces on a more stable foundation. At a strategic level, Allies must also address the geopolitical challenges, including the ones arising from Chinese and Russian investments in military AI systems. As this report has shown, Russia and China see AI as critical to future military power and invest heavily into AI-enabled military systems. For its part, the NATO PA Science and Technology Committee will continue to monitor AI developments in the defence sector through fact-finding visits and expert testimony.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---AI key to NATO---Interoperability

Interoperability key to NATO---successful integration of AI is key

Martin Dufour 18, Colonel in the Canadian Army, working with NATO. This Policy Brief is a revised version of a paper that was awarded the Eisenhower Prize for the best Individual Paper of NDC Senior Course 132. NATO Defense College, Research Division. NDC Policy Brief, No. 6. December. "Will artificial intelligence challenge NATO interoperability?" //pipk

NATO has arguably been the most successful alliance of its kind, and much of this success can be attributed to its cohesion in the face of various threats. At the heart of this cohesion lie two important notions: burden sharing between members; and interoperability. The Alliance’s cohesion however has increasingly come under pressure over the last two decades, and there are growing challenges with the level of interoperability between member countries. While numerous technical and political factors influence interoperability, the emergence of disruptive technologies such as genetic engineering, nanotechnology, additive manufacturing and robotics, are likely to make this challenge more acute in the next two decades.

Of the many technologies rapidly emerging, none is likely to have as significant an impact as that of artificial intelligence, which combines with other technologies and multiply their effect by allowing the development of advanced autonomous systems. And while the latter holds the promise of developing new classes of weapons with great military potential, its asymmetrical adoption among the various NATO allies could also lead to significant interoperability problems.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff---AI Logistics---Starter Pack › NATO Advantage › 2AC---AI key to NATO---Interoperability

Interoperability collapsing---AI integration is key

Martin Dufour 18, Colonel in the Canadian Army, working with NATO. This Policy Brief is a revised version of a paper that was awarded the Eisenhower Prize for the best Individual Paper of NDC Senior Course 132. NATO Defense College, Research Division. NDC Policy Brief, No. 6. December. "Will artificial intelligence challenge NATO interoperability?" //pipk

At the operational and strategic levels, the adoption of artificial intelligence-enabled autonomous systems connecting sensors, battle management, command and control systems, as well as defensive and offensive assets in a network of learning, adaptive systems will enable “a form of algorithmic warfare and machine learning approach to targeting”10 which will compress the decision-action cycle to such an extent that countries not connected to the system will be unable to keep up.

The 2017 report Future War NATO argues that the “technologically-driven US military strategy is advancing so fast compared to European allies that, sooner rather than later, all-important NATO military interoperability might well become a thing of the past”.11 This echoed a 2016 report from the Armament Industry European Research Group, which concluded that “a further boost in US defence technology could promote a wider US-Europe gap and the emergence of a two-tier alliance”.12 It was furthermore observed that the USD3.6 billion invested in Third Offset Strategy technologies in 2017, while representing only 5 percent of the overall US military research and development budget corresponded “to more than 40 percent of the overall EU-European R&D budgets”.13