2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---AT: Member States Only---Topic Education DA
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization 21, a military collective defense alliance including 30 European and North American countries that might come up in the 2022-2023 high school policy debate topic, August 25, 2021, “Relations with partners across the globe”, https://www.NATO.int/cps/en/NATOhq/topics_49188.htm, official NATO website \\SYang
NATO has nine “partners across the globe” or “global partners”, which the Alliance cooperates with on an individual basis. NATO’s global partners include Afghanistan, Australia, Colombia, Iraq, Japan, the Republic of Korea, Mongolia, New Zealand and Pakistan. NATO’s engagement with global partners is taking on increasing importance in a complex security environment, where many of the challenges the Alliance faces are global and no longer bound by geography.
The NATO 2030 agenda agreed by NATO Leaders at the NATO Brussels 2021 Summit seeks to strengthen NATO’s global cooperation with like-minded partners, especially with its global partners, to defend the rules-based international order and institutions, to set international norms and standards in space and in cyberspace, and on new technologies and global arms control.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---C/I---Distinct From Member States
Alain Pellet 1, Professor of International Law at the University of Paris X-Nanterre and member of the International Law Commission, December 1, 2001, “L’imputabilité d’éventuels actes illicites – Responsabilité de l’otan ou des Etats membres, inTomuschat”, https://brill.com/view/title/10865 , Kosovo and the international community: A legal assessment, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff, p. 198. **Translated to English with Google Translate. Original text in French.
The question is therefore left entirely open. 14 The fact remains that, in the absence of certainty and given the extreme rarity of the practice, one can at least use the draft of the C.D.I. by analogy and, in particular, on the one hand articles 4 to 9 and 11 of the preliminary draft of 2000 (which correspond to articles 5 to 10 of the draft of 1996), which relate to the attribution strictly speaking, and , above all, Articles 16 to 19 (27 to 28 old) These latter envisage three hypotheses in which the "responsibility of a State with regard to the act of another State" may be engaged. One clearly seems to have to be discarded: that of coercion (envisaged by the new article 18); it seems absurd to consider that the Member States of NATO were able to exert on it a constraint leading it to commit one or more internationally wrongful acts, and vice versa. Two possibilities therefore remain. That of complicity (aid or assistance in the commission of an internationally wrongful act - new article 16) and that of "direction and [du] control exercised in the commission of an internationally wrongful act" (article 17 new). In both cases, it seems to me that you have to ask yourself "who controls whom?" (article 17) and "who is an accomplice of whom?" (section 16). In other words, does NATO control the member states? or are the states controlling NATO? Firstly; and is NATO the accomplice of the Member States? or the contrary? on the other hand. Asked in this way, the questions are a little reminiscent of the children's game that is called in France "I hold you, you hold me by the goatee" ... And, to tell the truth, it is possible to support, reasonably, one as the other of the two theses. Member states control NATO - they make the decisions within its bodies and it depends on them for its financial resources, ammunition and men. But NATO controls its Members in the sense that they act on and in accordance with its decisions. That said, an essential element, clearly highlighted in Professor Stein's communication16 and which constitutes the starting point of the 1995 resolution of the Institute of International Law on "The legal consequences for Member States of non-performance by international organizations of their obligations towards third parties",17 must be taken into account: NATO is an international organization and, as such, it enjoys international legal personality.18 It is true that it is rather special organization, the institutionalization of which has been empirical and progressive. legal capacity and privileges and immunities, all of which led the International Court of Justice, with regard to the United Nations, to conclude, in its opinion of 11 April 1949 relating to Reparations for damage suffered in the service of the United Nations, that she was an "international person". "This means that the Organization is a subject of international law, that it has the capacity to be the holder of international rights and duties and that it has the capacity to avail itself of its rights by way of international claim".20 Moreover, this responsibility is objective,21 which means that it forms a screen between the Organization and not only its Member States, not only the third States which have recognized it, but also vis-à-vis other States, in much the same way that a State exists independently of the recognitions of which it is the object. Counterpart of the right belonging to the Organization to seek the responsibility of other subjects of international law, it can also be the addressee of a claim, in particular when an internationally wrongful act can, as in this case, be attributed to it. It alone bears the responsibility for its own acts and it seems impossible - except to deny, in reality, its international legal personality - that the responsibility of its Members be sought for its operations or "through it".
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---C/I---Distinct From Member States
David Nauta 17, 11-10-2017, "The International Responsibility of NATO and its Personnel during Military Operations", https://brill.com/view/book/9789004354647/B9789004354647_004.xml, Brill, Chapter 4, accessed 7-8-2022 \\SYang **text shrunk for readability and figures 2 and 3 omitted
This chapter describes the current institutional framework of NATO and the decision making process for its operations. This will provide further understanding of the powers of NATO and the relationship between NATO and the member States, which is relevant for the question of attribution of conduct of personnel to NATO, troop contributing nations or other international organizations such as the UN. Moreover, the overview provides in insight on whether NATO is an entity separate from its member States, i.e. whether it meets the indicia of an international organization with international legal personality. The conclusions in this chapter will be used further on in Chapters 5 and 7. Paragraph 4.2 gives a brief outline of the various organs of the Alliance, their composition, tasks and their position within the NATO structure. The intention of providing this outline is to facilitate understanding of the political-military structure and how hierarchically NATO is organised. Paragraph 4.3 examines the relationship between NATO and its member States and NATO’s decision-making process. Since the North Atlantic Council (NAC), in which all the member States participate, is the highest political decision-making organ of NATO, it is appropriate to examine both the relationship between NATO and States as well as NATO’s decision-making process. It is important to discuss the decision-making process in the NAC to establish to whom a wrongful act can be attributed: to NATO, to its member States or to both. It can also assist in establishing in which situations – i.e. under which conditions – NATO member States and / or NATO as an international organization will be held responsible. This paragraph will, additionally, examine the relationship between NATO and non-NATO member States, for the same reasons as indicated above and because non-member States regularly participate in NATO-led operations. The outline is followed by an analysis of the relationship between NATO and the UN. The choice to limit the analysis to the relationship between NATO and the UN is made in order to avoid an overly generic or exhaustive study on relationships between NATO and other international organizations or such organizations in general. Moreover, the relationship with the UN is the more straightforward choice to examine as the member States made explicit reference in the Washington Treaty to the context and position NATO takes within the UN system. The context is established by referring to Article 51 of the UN Charter – the right to take collective action against an armed attack – which forms the basis for the establishment of NATO. The Washington Treaty also acknowledges the primary role of the UN Security Council in the maintenance and restoration of international peace and security. Moreover, since NATO relies for its non-article 5 crisis response operations – which consist of the majority of NATO-led operations – on a mandate or authorization from the UN Security Council, the relationship between NATO and the UN is of relevance here. Finally, from a practical point of view, the UN is likely one of the most important partners of NATO. 4.2 Current Institutional Framework of NATO 4.2.1 Introduction NATO consists of two main types of institutional structures: a civilian structure and a military structure. The civilian structure is responsible for policy- and decision-making which provides for the functioning of the Organization both internally and externally. The military structure is involved in the planning and execution of military operations. All NATO operations are decided upon by the civilian structure and carried out by military structure. It means that both parts of NATO participate in the initiation, planning and execution of NATO operations. 4.2.2 The Civilian Structure a The North Atlantic Council The Washington Treaty stands out for its brevity, with a mere 14 articles and does expand a great deal on the structure, tasks and responsibilities of the Alliance. The treaty establishes only one organ, the North Atlantic Council (NAC), and attributes the necessary powers to implement the treaty.1 The NAC is the highest decision-making organ in the Organization. The Council is composed of the representatives of all Member States, which holds regular meetings at the level of Foreign- or Defence Ministers (Ministerials), Heads of States (Summits) or Permanent Representatives. As such, the NAC is the most important organ for the member States to express their views and to take collective decisions on political issues of the Alliance. This feature is of relevance to determine whether NATO has international legal personality. An indication that an international organization has international legal personality is – according to the theory of ‘objective legal personality’ which is further described in Chapter 5 – that an organization is not subject to the authority of any other State or organised community. Since the NAC is not subject to the authority of another legal entity other than the participating States, the assumption is that NATO has international legal personality.2 The Washington Treaty does not prescribe the way the Council should take its decisions, but the NAC adopted consensus as the standard. This translates to decisions being adopted without a formal voting procedure, provided that no member raises any formal objection.3 The decision-making process of NATO is described more elaborately when this book examines the relationship between the member States and NATO in paragraph 4.3. It is relevant to note here that decision-making through consensus is both seen as an argument in favour and against the existence of international legal personality of the Alliance. Arguments against such personality put emphasis on the fact that NAC decisions are collective decisions made by its member States, which assumes that the NAC expresses the will of the member States, rather than the Organization. On the other hand, member States have a right to express objections that they may have and block any decision, making the NAC’s decisions entirely reliant on the common agreement of all member States, rather than that of one State. The introduction of the “silence procedure” and opting-out mechanism enhances the autonomy of the Organization – referred to later in this chapter – and alludes to the possibility that NATO may have a volonté distincte from its member States. A volonté distincte, or ‘separate will’, may indicate under certain legal theories that the Organization has international legal personality. It is held here that the consensus rule on itself is not an indicator of either the existence or non-existence of international legal personality. Rather, a more distinguishing factor is to examine in how far the member States retain control in the decision-making process taken by the NAC. A conclusion on the existence of international legal personality of the Alliance will be given in Chapter 5. The Washington Treaty does not prescribe the span of topics which the NAC can decide upon. The Council’s authority is generally confined to the aim of NATO, which is to “safeguard the freedom, common heritage and civilization of their peoples” and to “promote stability and well-being in the North-Atlantic Area”. In that respect, the Washington Treaty leaves ample room for interpretation and discretion in decision-making.6 The founders have left to the discretion of the Council to “set up such subsidiary bodies as may be necessary.”7 The NAC created a variety of subsidiary bodies, of which the most important here are the Secretary General, the Military Committee and the various organs of the NATO Command Structure. b The Secretary General The Secretary General leads a unified international secretariat to assist the plenary organ – the NAC – and to serve as the Chairman of the Council.8 As such, he is the chief executive of NATO and responsible for promoting and directing the process of consultation and decision-making within the Alliance.9The Secretary General is supported by the International Staff, forming the so-called “civilian structure”. The Secretary General is also the representative for external relations. He maintains relationships on the level of Ministers of Foreign Affairs, - Defense and Heads of State during the operations.10 The Secretary General is usually the signatory for international agreements binding the Alliance, e.g. the exchange of letters with the Afghan authorities relating to the Status of ISAF Personnel in Afghanistan is signed on the side of the Alliance by the Secretary General.11 4.2.3 The Military Structure NATO’s military structure consists of the Military Committee, supported by its International Military Staff, and the NATO Command Structure. a The Military Committee The Military Committee (MC) is composed of the highest national military representatives from each Member State, assisting the Council with military expertise12 and works under the overall political authority of the NAC.13 It assists and advises the NAC on military matters and provides military guidance to the NATO Strategic Commanders of the NATO Command Structure. The MC takes its decisions by consensus; this way full commitment is achieved in both the military as well as the political requirements and objectives of the mission. The MC plays an important role in the drafting of NATO strategic concepts and advises the Council of the military situation in countries were NATO is conducting operations. The role of the Chairman of the MC is to represent and defend the consensus-based advice to the NAC. The Military Committee is supported by the International Military Staff. The Committee is an essential link between the political and military structure of NATO. The Military Committee provides the NAC with military advice agreed by all Chiefs of Defence. The consensus among the highest military authorities of NATO represents a firm commitment that the operation is militarily achievable with the forces available from the nations. b The NATO Command Structure The NATO Command Structure consists of two Strategic Commands, Allied Command Operations and Allied Command Transformation. In 1950, the NAC created the Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR)14 and gave it the responsibility to “organize [national units assigned to him] into an effective integrated defence force”.15 Currently, SACEUR is responsible for the planning and commanding all NATO-led operations. He is bound by the political constraints given by the NAC, who maintains political oversight of operations. The command structure enables NATO to plan and execute operations while maintaining strategic military and political coherence throughout the chain of command. SACEUR has at his disposition various subordinate commands which makes up Allied Command Operations, or ACO. ACO includes two Joint Force Commands (JFC Brunssum and JFC Naples), each of which is capable to plan, conduct and sustain a major joint operation16 at the operational level. There are also three other specialised commands (Air Command, Land Command and Maritime Command) directly under SACEUR’s command, which provide support to the Joint Force Command, but are also able to plan, conduct and sustain a smaller joint operation by themselves and report directly to SACEUR. Supreme Allied Command Transformation has the lead role for the transformation of NATO’s military structure, forces, capabilities and doctrines in order to improve the military effectiveness of the Alliance. SACT does not have a specific role in commanding operations and will not be further examined in detail as it is not of particular relevance to NATO’s responsibilities during its operations. In NATO-led operations, SACEUR will appoint one of its subordinate headquarters to plan and execute the mission (figure 2). One of the Joint Force Commands, or – in case of a smaller mission, the Maritime-, Land- or Air Command – can establish a headquarters in the mission area that will be responsible for running of day-to-day operations. SACEUR will retain Operational
<<<FIGURES 2 AND 3 OMITTED>>>
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---C/I---Distinct From Member States
Martin Reichard 4, member of the Austrian Mission to NATO, dealing with Civil Emergency Planning, South East Europe, Trust Funds, and EU-NATO relations, February 2004, “Some Legal Issues Concerning the EU-NATO Berlin Plus Agreement”, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233708215_Some_Legal_Issues_Concerning_the_EU-NATO_Berlin_Plus_Agreement, Nordic Journal of International Law (73) \\SYang
Concerning the particular subject matter of the Berlin Plus, it is moreover difficult to see how, in the process of building a common security and defence policy, the EU should exercise its functions, given its present lack of technological, logistic and infrastructure resources in the military sphere, without being able to rely on external help, such as from NATO.76 This factual deficiency arguably makes international legal personality for the EU a priori indispensable, at least on a functional basis, and limited to the subject matter of the agreement. Indeed, in the time preceding the conclusion of the Berlin Plus agreement, such military support from NATO to the European Union was expected to be eventually realized through conclusion of a binding international agreement." In conclusion, legal personality in the specific case of the Berlin Plus can therefore be implied from the Union's powers enshrined in the relevant provisions on external representation in Title V of the TEU, mainly Articles 18 and 24. This is a case of the general principle of implied powers. NATO's quality as a subject of international law is today undisputed. 79 Even though it has until recently not endeavoured to conclude treaties on the international level, " it has for a long time had agreements with its member states on its status in their respective internal legal systems.'
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 1AR---C/I---Distinct From Member States
Marten Zwanenburg 5, professor of Law During Military Operations at the Faculty of Law at the University of Amsterdam, April 15, 2005, “Accountability of peace support missions”, https://brill.com/view/title/11419 **corrected for typos
There is no similar international judicial authority with regard to the international legal personality of NATO. The constitutive instrument of the organization does not expressly provide that it has legal personality in international law. Explicit recognition is not the only way in which international legal personality is conferred on international organizations. Application of the objective as well as application of the subjective theory of international legal personality leads to the conclusion that NATO is an international legal person." The organization is a permanent association of states established by the 1949 North Atlantic Treaty with the lawful object of collective self-defense. It is equipped with organs, the most important of which is the North Atlantic Council. The functions of the organization are distinct from those of the member states. The most recent statement of these functions is in section 10 of the 1999 Strategic Concept of the organization.'? The organization exercises powers on the international plane, notably treaty-making power. Article 25 of the 1951 Ottawa treaty on the status of the organization for example provides that the North Atlantic Council acting on behalf of the organization may conclude supplementary agreements with member states. The organization also concludes international agreements on other issues with member states" and with non-member states." There is also state practice supporting legal personality of the organization. In the Banliouic case before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) the French government argued that a bombardment during Operation Allied Force was not imputable to its member states but to NATO as an organization with an international legal personality separate from that of the respondent states. The challenge of the admissibility of the case by all the respondent states on the ground that the ECHR would be determining the rights and obligations of NATO itself also points in this direction. This challenge assumes that NATO itself has rights and obligations under international law, which can only be the case if the organization has international legal personality. Trial Chambers of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) have also treated NATO as an international legal person separate from its member states. Trial Chamber I in the Todorovic case ordered the NAC to disclose to the defense copies of documents and the identity of certain individuals in connection with the arrest of the accused." The order was based on article 29 of the ICTY Statute which provides that states shall cooperate with the Tribunal. The Trial Chamber stated that: A purposive construction of the Statute yields the conclusion that such an order should be as applicable to collective enterprises of States as it is to individual States; Article 29 should, therefore, be read as conferring on the International Tribunal a power to require an international organization or its competent organ such as SFOR to cooperate with it in the achievement of its fundamental objective of prosecution of persons responsible for serious violations of international humanitarian law, by providing the several modes of assistance set out therein.?" In the Legality of the Use of Force cases before the IC] several of the respondent states explicitly mentioned that NATO is an international legal person during the hearings held in April 2004. Portugal drew attention to NATO's development since its establishment, in particular the institutionalization of the organization." It maintained that "NATO is an international organisation in the strict sense, with its own international legal personality."> France referred to the criteria for international legal personality identified in the Reparations for Injuries case. It submitted that under these criteria NATO possesses international legal personality." The applicant accepted NATO's international legal personality. However, it maintained that this personality is "limited" on the basis of NATO's founding instrument and other NATO documents.:"
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---Distinct From Member States
David Nauta 17, 11-10-2017, "The International Responsibility of NATO and its Personnel during Military Operations", https://brill.com/view/book/9789004354647/B9789004354647_004.xml, Brill, Chapter 5, accessed 7-8-2022 \\SYang
This chapter examined the existence of international legal personality of NATO. Legal personality is relevant to the responsibility of NATO and its personnel during military operations. Without international legal personality, NATO cannot be responsible. Unfortunately, there is little jurisprudence on the concept of international legal personality. In 1949, the ICJ formed an Opinion on the personality of the un, but remained vague on how this was determined. This resulted in various theories on how legal personality is acquired. The two mainstream theories in academic literature are the ‘subjective theory’ and ‘objective theory’, which both give explanations on how international legal personality can be determined to exist, but also have received criticism. The practical approach of Klabbers’ ‘presumptive personality’ reconciles to some degree both theories.88 This theory presumes the existence of international legal personality of an international organization if it performs acts that can only be explained on the basis of international legal personality. This chapter has examined NATO’s legal personality on the basis of the two mainstream theories, but also inclined towards the ‘presumptive theory’ to give a practical answer. Some authors doubt whether the Alliance has legal personality.89 These authors argue that NATO has not acted on the international level. The often-used example in this respect is the compensation by the us (in lieu to NATO) to China for the damages suffered during NATO’s intervention in Kosovo. Other arguments denying the international legal personality of NATO is the fact that NATO takes its decision by consensus, leading to believe that the Alliance does not have any “will” of its own. These doubts would be to some degree valid, if the focus was on the earlier years of the NATO. During the Cold War – and probably during its first non-article 5 operation as well – it may have been difficult to consider that the Alliance has international legal personality. NATO’s static defence operations against the former Soviet Union did not require an autonomous role separate from its member States. The member States were fully capable to independently devise military plans and coordinate these with each other. The establishment of SACEUR in 1952, which integrated military forces, marked the beginning of a transformation, but NATO started to evolve into an organization with legal personality only after the Cold War. Since then, the Alliance has gone through a significant transformation, as described in Chapters 3 and 4. The Organization has concluded international agreements with States and other international organizations. NATO and its personnel enjoy privileges and immunities in its member States, but also in Afghanistan, Iraq, in the States of the former Yugoslavia and in various other mission areas. It should not be ruled out that the Alliance might bring and receive international claims in the future if the exercise of the jurisdiction by the courts would be made possible. It is not required that an international organization show all the indicia of international legal personality. If this were the case, barely any international organization would have such status in international law. NATO is presumed to have international legal personality on the basis of the fact that it has concluded international agreements and that the organization and its personnel enjoy privileges and immunities. This presumption may be rebutted if there is evidence to the contrary. Practice of States and international organizations, as well as the jurisprudence of international courts and tribunals, confirm the presumption that NATO has international legal personality. The military intervention in the former Yugoslavia gave rise to several claims for damages resulting from NATO military operations. Yugoslavia filed complaints against several member States of NATO, while individuals turned their claims for damages to individual member States of NATO instead to NATO itself.90 The respondent States in both cases argued that the claims should have been filed against NATO – on the basis of that it had international legal personality – instead of the individual nations. These early cases are not indicative of either the existence or non-existence of international legal personality, but of the absence of NATO’s locus standi in the courts. Claimants may have chosen to start their proceedings against individual States, so to avoid their claim being regarded non-admissible. International courts and tribunals have confirmed NATO’s legal personality. Both the ICTY and the ICC came to this conclusion in relation to NATO operations in respectively the Balkans and Libya. International organizations, including the UN, have addressed NATO in relation to alleged breaches of international obligations binding upon the organization. The UN International Commission of Inquiry, notably, addressed NATO – and not individual member States – with respect to airstrikes in Libya that may have caused incidental loss of civilian life and damage to civilian infrastructure.91 Finally, States have confirmed NATO’s legal personality in the ILC’s commentary to the Articles on Responsibility of International Organizations, where they stated that “NATO is an international organization within the meaning of draft article 2(a) of the draft articles, and as such a subject of international law. It possesses international legal personality as well as treaty-making power”.92 The scepticism regarding the international legal personality of NATO diminished gradually from the 1990s. Academic writers, States and international organization increasingly argue in favour of the Alliance’ status under international law. Even NATO itself had to become convinced of its own personality. The out-of-area operations required the conclusion of Status of Force Agreements (SOFAs) with third States. NATO aptly took the initiative and concluded SOFAs with Bosnia-Herzegovina, Afghanistan, Libya and other countries, thereby affirming its status in international law. In conclusion, NATO certainly meets several indicia of international legal personality as is evidenced by its performance of actions on the international level, notably treaty-making power and privileges and immunities. The existence of international legal personality is – in a way – also confirmed by the practice of States and other international organizations. Recent academic literature furthermore supports this conclusion.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › Affirmative › 2AC---C/I---NATO = Partner States
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization 21, a military collective defense alliance including 30 European and North American countries that might come up in the 2022-2023 high school policy debate topic August 25, 2021, “Relations with partners across the globe”, https://www.NATO.int/cps/en/NATOhq/topics_49188.htm, official NATO website \\SYang
NATO has nine “partners across the globe” or “global partners”, which the Alliance cooperates with on an individual basis. NATO’s global partners include Afghanistan, Australia, Colombia, Iraq, Japan, the Republic of Korea, Mongolia, New Zealand and Pakistan. NATO’s engagement with global partners is taking on increasing importance in a complex security environment, where many of the challenges the Alliance faces are global and no longer bound by geography.
The NATO 2030 agenda agreed by NATO Leaders at the NATO Brussels 2021 Summit seeks to strengthen NATO’s global cooperation with like-minded partners, especially with its global partners, to defend the rules-based international order and institutions, to set international norms and standards in space and in cyberspace, and on new technologies and global arms control.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---AT: Partner States
Claudette Roulo 19, writer for the Department of Defense, March 22, 2019, “Alliances vs. Partnerships”, https://www.defense.gov/News/Feature-Stories/story/Article/1684641/alliances-vs-partnerships/, official Department of Defense website \\Syang
Alliance, partnership, partnership, alliance. It seems like those terms are used interchangeably by Defense Department officials in every other speech. However, those officials are choosing their words carefully, because in the world of international relations, alliances and partnerships are two very different things.
Alliances
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---Ukraine Violation
CNN 22, the Cable News Network is a multinational cable news channel, January 28, 2022, “What is NATO and when does it act?”, https://www.cnn.com/2022/01/27/world/NATO-explainer-intl-cmd/index.html \\SYang
Twelve founding countries -- the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France and eight other European nations -- signed the North Atlantic Treaty in 1949, pledging to protect each other by political and military means.
Over the decades since, the alliance has grown to include a total of 30 members.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---Member States
Merriam Webster English Dictionary 22, American company that publishes reference books and is especially known for its dictionaries, “be”, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/be \\SYang **Note: dictionary entry for “be”. “is” is a form of “be”**
to have identity with : to constitute the same idea or object as
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---Member States
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization 22, a military collective defense alliance including 30 European and North American countries that might come up in the 2022-2023 high school policy debate topic, May 10, 2022, “10 things you need to know about NATO”, https://www.NATO.int/cps/en/NATOhq/126169.htm, official NATO website \\SYang
Collective defence: The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was founded in 1949 and is a group of 30 countries from Europe and North America that exists to protect the people and territory of its members. The Alliance is founded on the principle of collective defence, meaning that if one NATO Ally is attacked, then all NATO Allies are attacked. For example, when terrorists attacked the United States on 9/11 2001, all NATO Allies stood with America as though they had also been attacked.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---Member States
Kimberly Amadeo et al. 22, expert on U.S. and world economies and investing, March 6, 2022, “What is NATO?”, https://www.thebalance.com/NATO-purpose-history-members-and-alliances-3306116 \\SYang
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) is an alliance of 30 countries that border the North Atlantic Ocean. The Alliance includes the United States, most European Union members, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Turkey.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 2NC---NATO---Member States
US 22, the U.S. Mission to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization is the official representation of the United State of America to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, accessed July 4, 2022, “About NATO”, https://NATO.usmission.gov/about-NATO/ \\SYang)
Formed in 1949 with the signing of the Washington Treaty, NATO is a security alliance of 30 countries from North America and Europe. NATO’s fundamental goal is to safeguard the Allies’ freedom and security by political and military means. NATO remains the principal security instrument of the transatlantic community and expression of its common democratic values. It is the practical means through which the security of North America and Europe are permanently tied together. NATO enlargement has furthered the U.S. goal of a Europe whole, free, and at peace.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 1NC---NATO---Member States
Dictionary.com 22, Dictionary.com is an online dictionary whose domain was first registered on May 14, 1995, accessed July 4, 2022, “NATO”, https://www.dictionary.com/browse/NATO \\SYang
North Atlantic Treaty Organization: a political and military alliance of countries in Europe and North America established in Washington, D.C. (1949) for the purpose of collective defense against aggression, comprising Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, the United Kingdom, the United States, Greece, Turkey, Germany, Spain, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Albania, Croatia, Montenegro, and North Macedonia.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
NATO › 1NC---NATO---Civilian and Military
David Nauta 17, 11-10-2017, "The International Responsibility of NATO and its Personnel during Military Operations", https://brill.com/view/book/9789004354647/B9789004354647_004.xml, Brill, Chapter 4, accessed 7-8-2022 \\SYang
NATO consists of two main types of institutional structures: a civilian structure and a military structure. The civilian structure is responsible for policy- and decision-making which provides for the functioning of the Organization both internally and externally. The military structure is involved in the planning and execution of military operations. All NATO operations are decided upon by the civilian structure and carried out by military structure. It means that both parts of NATO participate in the initiation, planning and execution of NATO operations.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Security Cooperation › Aff---General › 2AC – Security Cooperation
Congressional Research Service ’21 [05/17/21; “Defense Primer: DOD ‘Title 10’ Security Cooperation,” CRS, //smarx, AZG]
SC activities aim to achieve particular objectives in support of U.S. national security and defense strategies. Specifically, SC may build defense relationships that promote U.S. security interests, enhance military capabilities of U.S. allies and partners, and provide the United States with access to PNs. Under the overarching goal of furthering U.S. national security and foreign policy interests, SC emphasizes partnerships, aiming to be mutually beneficial for the United States and its partners. SC activities aim to develop and strengthen a PN’s ability to provide internal security, contribute to regional security efforts, combat shared threats, and increase military interoperability with the United States. The 2018 National Defense Strategy (NDS) signaled the Trump Administration’s intention to shift SC activities from nearly two decades of prioritizing counterterrorism toward “great power competition” (GPC) with Russia and China. The shift raised questions as to how SC should be realigned to meet this objective and what the implications could be for scaling down counterterrorism-focused SC activities in Africa and the Middle East, especially as Russia and China increase their influence. Some DOD officials and defense analysts have suggested that rather than a shift, counterterrorism, as well as irregular warfare, should remain priorities within GPC. The Biden Administration has yet to release a new NDS; however, its Interim National Security Strategic Guidance broadly identifies authoritarianism and strategic competition as priority threats that require coordination and cooperation with allies and partners.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Security Cooperation › Neg---Interp---SC---State of Being
Rita Floyd 19, Senior Lecturer in Conflict and Security at the Department of Political Science and International Studies at the University of Birmingham (UK). Her work on securitisation theory, environmental security and IR theory has appeared in a number of peer-reviewed journals including most recently in the Review of International Studies. Her monograph The Morality of Security: A Theory of Just Securitization was published by Cambridge University Press in 2019, 2-4-2019, "Security cooperation as a primary institution of western international society", https://www-tandfonline-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1080/14781158.2021.1876015 \\SYang
In order to understand what is meant by security cooperation it is necessary to break down this concept into its components. Security tends to have one of two meanings. On the one hand, it refers to the condition of feeling and being secure,13 which is achieved when states and individuals enjoy freedom from fear (i.e. negative peace) and want (comprehensive human security). On the other hand security refers to a particular form of politics, to wit the high politics of security that may involve an extraordinary policy response, or at least the credible threat thereof. Importantly, security politics may or may not lead to greater overall security as, in Jonathan Herington's14 terms, ‘a state of being’, but – for the most part – security action is motivated by the idea to achieve or increase security as a state of being in international society. Depending on the type and nature of the threat, this may or may not involve the use of military force.15 In security cooperation, security thus refers to defensive actions aimed at ensuring security as a state of being.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Security Cooperation › 1AR---SC---Extensions › SC---AT: Only DoD
Ronald H. Reynolds 19, DPA, “The Management of Security Cooperation”, 2019, Defense Institute of Security Cooperation Studies, /lg
While all of the programs previously mentioned are authorized under 22 U.S.C, or Title 22, and are under the general control of the Department of State (DoS), the Department of Defense (DoD) administers many of them. Since Title 10 U.S. Code Section 301 defines security cooperation programs and activities of DoD as any program or interaction of DoD with the security establishment of a foreign country to build capabilities, to provide access or to build relationships, many of the previously described FAA and AECA-authorized security assistance programs administered by DoD in accordance with the SAMM fall under the broad definition of security cooperation. The following is a categorization of programs, and a brief explanation, based upon a partial list presented in the 2016 DoD Guidance for Security Cooperation. For more detail on the different programs that can be found under each category access and download the ‘Security Cooperation Programs’ book found on the DISCS website or use the SC Programs Viewer on the Security Assistance Network Web (SANweb):
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Security Cooperation › 1AR---SC---Extensions › SC---AT: Only DoD
Major Nicholas R. Simontis 13, chief of strategy at Third Army/U.S. Army Central with an MA in security studies from Kansas State University and an MMAS in theater operations from the School for Advanced Military Studies, “SECURITY COOPERATION: AN OLD PRACTICE FOR NEW TIMES”, 29/03/2013, School of Advanced Military Studies, /lg
While security cooperation is a shared effort between DOD and DOS, DOD has, by a significant margin, the preponderance of personnel and organizational structure that comprise the security cooperation infrastructure. DOD defines security cooperation as “all DOD interactions with foreign defense and security establishments to build defense relationships that promote specific US security interests, develop allied and friendly military and security capabilities for internal and external defense and multinational operations, and provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to the HN [host nation].”14 It is important to note that the DOD definition includes developmental and humanitarian assistance activities focused on enhancing foreign governments’ abilities to care for their people. The goal of all these activities is to reduce or eliminate factors leading to a crisis or conflict that requires U.S. intervention.15 Security assistance activities are a subset of security cooperation and deal principally with foreign military financing (FMF), foreign military sales (FMS), and international military education and training (IMET) activities. The Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Policy has overall responsibility for the execution of DOD’s security cooperation activities, which DSCA administers.
2022
Michigan
Topicality
Security Cooperation › 1AR---SC---Extensions › SC---AT: Only DoD
Nina M. Serafino 16, Specialist in International Security Affairs, “Security Assistance and Cooperation: Shared Responsibility of the Departments of State and Defense”, 05/26/2016, Congressional Research Service, /lg
DOD uses an overarching term, “Security Cooperation,” to denote the State Department security assistance administered by DSCA as well as all other DOD “interactions with foreign defense establishments to build defense relationships.” This term addresses the lack of common terminology for DOD’s many noncombat activities and contacts, including not only the provision of defense articles and services, but also humanitarian assistance, exercises, and military-tomilitary contacts that benefit both U.S. and foreign forces. These “interactions” include programs to provide defense articles and services to foreign governments for which Congress provides DOD with specific authority, as well as programs and military exercises conducted under DOD’s organic Title 10 authority