Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › Aff Answers › 2AC – UQ

The EU is pursuing a military strategy against Russia

EU Neighbors East 7/21 ("War in Ukraine: EU adopts ‘maintenance and alignment’ package against Russia", 7-21-2022, EU Neighbors East, https://euneighbourseast.eu/news/latest-news/war-in-ukraine-eu-adopts-maintenance-and-alignment-package-against-russia/, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

In response to Russia’s aggression against Ukraine, the European Union today adopted new measures intended to tighten existing economic sanctions targeting Russia, improve their implementation, and strengthen their effectiveness.

This ‘maintenance and alignment’ package introduces a new prohibition to purchase, import, or transfer, directly or indirectly, gold, if it originates in Russia and it has been exported from Russia into the EU or to any third country after. This prohibition also covers jewelry.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – AT: EU Upsets Diplomacy

EU is a neutral actor that would not disrupt negotiations

Menafn 7/20 ("What Happens If The Black Sea Blockade Is Lifted?", 7-20-2022, MENAFN, https://menafn.com/1104563351/What-Happens-If-The-Black-Sea-Blockade-Is-Lifted, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

(MENAFN- Swissinfo) A deal allowing Ukraine to resume its grain exports is urgently needed. The harvest season starts in July, but storage facilities are still full of last winter's grain. Meanwhile in Somalia, which used to import all its wheat from Ukraine and Russia, hundreds of thousands of people are at risk of famine. Copyright 2022 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved

United Nations and Turkey-led negotiations with Moscow and Kyiv to allow Ukrainian grain exports to resume in the Black Sea are moving forward. But even if a deal is signed, its impact to alleviate the food crisis could take months.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Turns Case

The war destroys global security architecture

Adams 7/15 (Mubarak Adams, Department of Political Science, University of Ghana; “THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINE WAR THREATENS GLOBAL PEACE: AN EXAMINATION,” Research Gate, 7/15/2022)//sposten

Russian Ukraine War: An Implication for Global security Architecture The war in Ukraine has destroyed global peace architecture generally in the United Nations Security Council and particularly in Europe which has been in existence for decades. The repercussions are already evident far from the battlefield. The war has increased NATO’s presence (40,000 NATO forces) in Eastern Europe to defend and protect its allies (Pszczel, 2022). The fear is that the war might spread to other parts of the world mainly Russian neighbors like Moldova, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Poland, Lithuania, Finland, Sweden, etc. Russia’s threat has altered decades of military policies of neutrality by Finland and Sweden. The result for these small nations (Finland and Sweden) was to seek a military alliance with NATO (Ibid). The growing concern of the war is the Russian capabilities to use its nuclear weapons on western nations and the US. This has weakened the efforts of western powers to be directly involved in the war but rather send military equipment to Ukrainian forces. Russia’s desire to bring Belarus into the nuclear calculation has stoked fear of escalation (Pszczel, 2022)

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Iran Impact

US-Iran conflict causes infinite war---“but we won’t go extinct” does not matter and only serves to prop up incoherent foreign policy

Kristian 20 (Bonnie Kristian; "Iran can't conquer America. But we can still lose.", 1-3-2020, Week, https://theweek.com/articles/887290/iran-cant-conquer-america-but-still-lose, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten

When Americans imagine losing a war, this is our default imagery. Our mental stage is set with props from World War II — where the Axis powers potentially could have conquered the United States had things gone very differently — and the Cold War — which, had it turned hot, could have seen Soviet nukes decimating major American cities (and vice versa). Pondering defeat takes us to The Man in the High Castle, a compelling alternate history precisely because its fanciful premise is still plausible, just as the idea of Iran accomplishing a comparable conquest is utterly implausible. (Iran's entire GDP, $440 billion as of 2017, is less than the Pentagon's annual budget; and even though it began breaching terms of the nuclear deal following Trump's withdrawal from the agreement, Iran does not have nuclear weapons. The power disparity between Tehran and Washington is immense.)

The trouble is conquest is not the only negative outcome of war. And I suspect failure to add that realization to recognition of America's near-total imperviousness to traditional conquest accounts for much of the stupidity in our foreign policy. Because we know one bad consequence isn't possible, we invade, airstrike, assassinate, and sanction at will as if no bad consequences are possible.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Iran Impact

An aggressive stance towards Russia draws in Iran

Troianovski et. Al 7/12 (Anton Troianovski, Ivan Nechepurenko and Dan Bilefsky; "Russia Reaches Out to Iran for Help in Countering West", 7-12-2022, New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/live/2022/07/12/world/russia-ukraine-war-news#in-a-frontline-town-the-city-council-is-not-working-and-the-few-who-venture-out-dont-stray-far, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten

President Vladimir V. Putin will visit Tehran next week for meetings with the leaders of Iran and Turkey, taking him into challenging diplomatic terrain as he seeks to burnish ties with two nations sometimes aligned, and sometimes sharply at odds, with Russia and with each other.

Mr. Putin, who radically limited his travel during the pandemic, has been engaging in a spree of recent diplomacy, seeking to shore up military and economic backing with non-Western countries to counter the West’s military assistance to Ukraine and its sanctions against Russia.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Automobiles Impact

Otherwise, loss of megacities is an inevitable existential risk---increased technological efficiency is key to solve

William E. Rees 20, Professor Emeritus at the University of British Columbia and former director of the School of Community and Regional Planning at UBC, “Megacities at Risk: The Climate–Energy Conundrum,” Handbook of Megacities and Megacity-Regions, Edward Elgar Publishing, 09/04/2020, by sposten

• The consumptive node cannot survive in isolation. Every modem city depends utterly on being able to maintain continuous intimate contact and exchange with the lands/waters that constitute its eco-footprint. A megacity imports many million kilograms o f low-entropy energy and material daily and exports a nearly equivalent mass of degraded wastes.

• The total human EF is about 20.6 billion hectares (ha) while Earth has only 12.2 billion ha of productive ecosystems, that is. the human enterprise is in ‘overshoot’ by 69 percent (2014 data from GFN, 2018). Since cities account for -7 0 percent o f global consumption and waste production, urban populations alone require the biocapacity equivalent o f -1.2 planet Earths to maintain their present lifestyles.*

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Automobiles Impact

Current cities are doomed---BUT, smart cities solve---COVID proves

Rook 21 (Tim Rook, chief markets officer at Clade Engineering, holds a BA in engineering from Cranfield University and a BA in mechanical engineering from the University of Surrey; "Has Covid-19 strengthened the case for smart cities?", 8-10-2021, https://www.eco-business.com/opinion/has-covid-19-strengthened-the-case-for-smart-cities/, DOA: 3-10-2022)//ATJ

There is no denying that the Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted the challenges faced by many cities across the globe. From digital connectivity to safety and security, education and work, we have already seen some sections of society progress in leaps and bounds, whilst the challenges for others have been laid bare. As we emerged from a turbulent 18 months, the case for smart cities appears to be stronger than ever.

A smart city is a place where traditional networks and services are made more efficient with the use of digital and telecommunication technologies for the benefit of its inhabitants and businesses. Insights gained from that data are used to manage assets, resources and services efficiently; in return, that data is used to improve operations across the city.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Automobiles Impact

Job-shift key to tech-mastery

Pistrui, 18 (Joseph Pistrui, co-founded Kinetic Thinking, a learning and development framework to provide educational experiences for managers to develop as kinetic thinkers, worked for academic institutions such as IE Business School and IE University, Duke Corporate Education, London School of Economics and Political Science, Bocconi University, IESE Business School, and Corvinus University of Budapest; "The Future of Human Work Is Imagination, Creativity, and Strategy", Harvard Business Review, 1-18-2018, https://hbr.org/2018/01/the-future-of-human-work-is-imagination-creativity-and-strategy, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten

It seems beyond debate: Technology is going to replace jobs, or, more precisely, the people holding those jobs. Few industries, if any, will be untouched.

Knowledge workers will not escape. Recently, the CEO of Deutsche Bank predicted that half of its 97,000 employees could be replaced by robots. One survey revealed that “39% of jobs in the legal sector could be automated in the next 10 years. Separate research has concluded that accountants have a 95% chance of losing their jobs to automation in the future.”

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Automobiles Impact

Key to smooth AV transition

Caporal et. Al 21 (Jack Caporal, Former Fellow, Scholl Chair in International Business; William O’Neil, Intern, Scholl Chair in International Business; Sean Arrieta-Kenna, Intern, Scholl Chair in International Business; "Bridging the Divide: Autonomous Vehicles and the Automobile Industry", 4-14-2021, No Publication, https://www.csis.org/analysis/bridging-divide-autonomous-vehicles-and-automobile-industry, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten

TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY AUTO MANUFACTURING CLUSTERS: BATTERIES, CHIPS, AND FACTORY UPGRADES

Motor vehicle production in the United States has created clusters of economic activity. Original equipment manufacturer (OEM) assembly plants and those that make core parts attract and support suppliers—from tier one suppliers that produce significant components like suspensions and chassis to tier two and tier three suppliers that produce less complex components. Local universities can play a pivotal role as talent pipelines, innovation centers, and testing locations for AV research and development of smart vehicles. Key examples of this include the Ohio State University's Center for Automotive Research and the University of Michigan's Mcity, which each collaborates with industry partners in Detroit and Columbus to target resources toward the exploration and testing of advanced automotive technologies and the cultivation of a highly skilled and engaged future workforce. These clusters have generated three benefits: intra-industry benefits like access to specialized workers and a pool of supporting goods and services; inter-industry spillovers stemming from the spread of knowledge across industries; and spinoffs, or new firms created by former employees from the industry.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Automobiles Impact

War disrupts automobile sector supply chains

Adams 7/15 (Mubarak Adams, Department of Political Science, University of Ghana; “THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINE WAR THREATENS GLOBAL PEACE: AN EXAMINATION,” Research Gate, 7/15/2022)//sposten

Russian-Ukraine war: Impact on the Automobile sector According to Ruta (20220), disruptions in global and regional supply chains have resulted in input shortages and price increases. Ukraine is a major provider of inputs such as car ignition wires, neon gas for semiconductors, and iron ore for steel mills. Companies that manufacture transportation equipment, machinery, electronics, and food goods rely heavily on Russian metals, chemicals, fertilizers, and other commodities. According to the World Trade Organization (2022), Russia is one of the world's leading exporters of palladium and rhodium, which are critical inputs in the production of catalytic converters in the automobile industry and semiconductor manufacturing. Semiconductor manufacturing is also influenced by several factors.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Ext Famine Impact

Africa’s forests are the “lungs of the world”---best internal link to climate change

Fleshman 08 (Michael Fleshman; "Saving Africa’s forests, the ‘lungs of the world’", January 2008, https://www.un.org/africarenewal/magazine/january-2008/saving-africa%E2%80%99s-forests-%E2%80%98lungs-world%E2%80%99, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten

It is difficult to imagine that such vast ancient woodlands are at risk of extinction. But they are disappearing at an alarming rate. According to the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), indigenous (also known as “old-growth”) forests in Africa are being cut down at a rate of more than 4 mn hectares per year — twice the world’s deforestation average. According to the FAO, losses totalled more than 10 per cent of the continent’s total forest cover between 1980 and 1995 alone.

Saving Africa’s forests from the chainsaw and axe of encroaching humanity is essential to the health and productivity of much of the continent’s economy, experts point out. They cite the forests’ roles as watersheds, defences against soil erosion and regulators of local weather conditions.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Ext Famine Impact

Otherwise, poverty in Africa spurs deforestation

Erickson-Davis 22 (Morgan Erickson-Davis, Senior Editor, Mongabay; "What is the link between rising deforestation and poverty in Nigeria," World Economic Forum, 3-31-2022, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/03/deforestation-on-the-rise-as-poverty-soars-in-nigeria/, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten

Established in 1936 and situated just 200 kilometers (125 miles) from the sprawling megacity of Lagos, Akure-Ofosu Forest Reserve has long been a sanctuary for Nigeria’s diverse and dwindling wildlife. Species such as red-capped mangabeys (Cercocebus torquatus), putty-nosed monkeys (Cercopithecus nictitans) and perhaps even endangered Nigeria-Cameroon chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes ellioti), roam its woodlands. Together with neighboring Owo, Ohosu and Idanre forest reserves, Akure-Ofosu protects one of the largest remaining tracts of forest in the country.

Or rather, it used to. Between 2002 and 2020 Akure-Ofosu lost 44% of its primary forest, according to satellite data from the University of Maryland (UMD) visualized on Global Forest Watch. Preliminary data from UMD indicate forest loss continued at a quick pace in 2021, and has only increased so far in 2022.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC Impact Toolbox › 2NC – Ext Famine Impact

Ukraine food imports key to sustainable development in Africa

Eziakonwa 22 (Ahunna Eziakonwa, Director, UNDP Regional Bureau for Africa and UN Assistant Secretary General; "Averting an African food crisis caused by the war in Ukraine", 5-16-2022, , World Economic Forum, DOA: 7-19-2022)//sposten

In Nigeria in the late 1960s, one million people died of starvation during the Biafran war. A decade and a half later, food shortages and hunger in Ethiopia triggered by a natural disaster cost the lives of 1 million Africans.

Today, a fresh disaster — the war in Ukraine — threatens to plunge the continent into yet another episode of famine and deprivation.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link – T/L

US-NATO-Russia relations are zero-sum because of a lack of trust---win-wins are impossible

Ukraine invasion is more uniqueness for the loss of trust

NATO 15 ("Zero-Sum? Russia, Power Politics, and the post-Cold War Era,” 3/20/2015, NATO, https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/opinions_118347.htm, DOA: 7-8-2022)//sposten

JENS STOLTENBERG: We have suspended all practical cooperation with Russia as a result of what we saw in Ukraine last spring. We continue to have open channels for political contact, but let me just address in a way the fundamental question you asked in the beginning, whether this is a zero-sum or a win-win situation? I can recall when I was a student, and also later when I worked in the Norwegian Central Bureau of Statistics and I worked on economic theory and game theory, and there we learned about cooperative games and win-win situations, and non-cooperative games and zero-sum outfalls or outcomes. The main message then was that it all depends on the rules. If you have the right rules and you have a minimum trust, then you are able to move from a zero-sum situation to a win-win.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link – T/L

All-out diplomacy is critical to solve the Ukraine war---otherwise, Russia will fight to the bitter end, prolonging the war as long as possible---plus, military engagement draws-in China

Harris 7/14 (Scott Harris; *interview with Melvin Goodman, a senior fellow at the Center for International Policy, and former CIA and State Department analyst*; "The Urgency of Pursuing Diplomacy to End the Ukraine War", 7-14-2022, BTL, https://btlonline.org/the-urgency-of-pursuing-diplomacy-to-end-the-ukraine-war/, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten

So your recent article lays out some of concerns that you have regarding the current situation in Ukraine affecting you know issues across the globe. And I was just reading a dispatch from the G20 meeting in Indonesia and I'll just quote from it. Briefly G20 foreign ministers called for an end to the war in Ukraine and grain blockade on Friday as Russia's top diplomat. Walked out of a meeting and denounced the West for frenzied criticism and squandering a chance to tackle global economic problems. Russia's invasion of Ukraine and its impact on food security and energy dominated the meetings at the G20 summit on the island of Bali in Indonesia. And the meeting ended with no joint statement and no announcements of any agreements being reached. Anyway, it looks like not much progress was reached there and not a good sign for ending the war in Ukraine. That there is really not even any discussion between. The US and Russia at this point about where this conflict may head. Now, maybe you can summarize your concerns about where the war in Ukraine may be headed and the different direction you'd like to see U.S. policy at least attempt to find a diplomatic solution here. Yeah yeah I have a lot of concerns. Or in day I don't know about 138. There's a certain sameness about these days. The Russians continue to make incremental advances. Very small advances but extremely costly for Ukraine for its people, for its infrastructure, for its it's villages, it's towns. The Russians are busy fast tracking citizenship to Ukrainians living in eastern Ukraine, and the Donuts, and they show no sign of backing down. And at the same time, Zelensky still feels he's winning and can win the war and you have too many American officials who are at least agreeing with that publicly. I don't know what they genuinely believe. I can't believe they think that. Ukraine can actually win this war and take back significant amounts of territory as well. So the nuclear background is something that's always concerned me because the Soviets fought a war or losing war in Afghanistan and never raised the issue of nuclear weapons. We fought losing wars in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and the idea of nuclear weapons never came up. Putin raises it as a threat from time to time. We seem to believe he wouldn't do it, but who knows what Putin will do when his back is against the wall? Given the fact that he's already conducted the war with such? Brutality and senselessness that it's hard to say what he'll do and unlike Khrushchev, who had to face a. A politbureau in the wake of the disastrous decision to put missiles in Cuba. Putin faces no possible counter, let alone opposition, and no one who's probably arguing a different point of view. And and when you mentioned the G20 meeting, I I just think it's wrong for Secretary of State Anthony Blinken, who doesn't really impress me. In fact, you wonder where has the State Department been during the Biden administration? What is the role of diplomacy? Or are we still active in the diplomatic arena? Uh, he went out of his way to make it clear that he had nothing to say to Lavrov and there was no. Point in meeting with him, you know, Lavrov is the foreign minister. But he he's not a power center in the in the Moscow Arena. But he is a voice that probably could reach Putin on some level, and the lines of communication I think need to be kept open. Uh, I know the Pentagon has gone out of its way to keep lines open to their Russian counterparts in the defence ministry. And there have been a couple talks, not many, and I think they're they're probably inadequate, but we have deconfliction zones in Syria between Russian and American forces. Uh, I think we have to talk about confidence building between Russians and Americans. In Ukraine, because as far as Putin is concerned, I think he believes now he's fighting not only Ukraine, he's fighting the West and he's fighting the United States. That's why I refer to what we're doing as a special military operation. This is what Putin calls his war in Ukraine. A special military operation, and he does that to downplay the notion that there's going to be any need for a draft or mass mobilization or extensive measures to get more citizens involved in this war he's trying. To have it both ways, guns and butter the same thing that Lyndon Johnson thought he could do in Vietnam, which. Became a failure and we're just continuing to send more arms, more sophisticated arms, and now the high mobility artillery rocket system. These himars we're going to send four more. They have a range of 40 to 50 miles and it will be possible for Ukraine to hit targets. Inside of Russia and there have been a couple targets hit inside of Russia. Russia has not called any attention to that. Because I don't think they've decided what they're going to do about it, it does raise the stakes and how this war is going to. Be thought but. I think back to really the 2nd 30 years war, which is how I define World War One and World War Two. Because when you think about it from 1914 to 1945 with this brief. Interruption in the 20s. There was a world. War going on. How long is this Ukraine war going to last? What are the implications now? You mentioned food. We could add energy to that list because. 'cause I'm seeing signs of war fatigue in Europe, and I certainly think we're going to see more signs in the coming winter as gas and oil deliveries get interrupted and the Germany German economy. Has some real problems with not fulfilling its energy needs, so there's more unwinding that can take place. None of it is good. None of this. Healthy and at the same time we're doing this, we're going out of our way to antagonize both Russia and China. And now the Pentagon and their military appropriations that they send up to the hill are talking about the need to fund A2 front war. But do they really believe they can take on Russia and China at the same time? I played war games when I was at CIA and the National War College that involved Taiwan. And we didn't win one of them. China always was the winner in a war game that involved Taiwan, and at some point we're going to have to discuss. Are we really going to defend Taiwan militarily? UH, is Taiwan part of our national security posture? Do we need to defend Taiwan? But if so, I think the best way to defend Taiwan is to improve our relationship with China to make sure China sees some good coming out of a bilateral relationship with the United States right now. Beijing must think Jinping must think he has nothing to lose in worsening relations with the United States because Biden has really followed Trump policy with regard to China. You know the tariffs are still in place, even though it would relieve some inflationary pressure if he drops some of them. Uh, so the the entire international picture, the international arena. I think is really fraught when you think of the consequences of a war that could easily get out of hand, and then when you think that we've taken this opportunity to expand NATO to bring into Scandinavian countries, Finland and Sweden, which will double the length of the. Border between NATO states. And Russia then it allows Putin to make the case that he needs Ukraine as a buffer zone because he can tell his own people. And I think there are already signs that he has told his people and. They don't need real. Convincing that it was that buffer zone that saved them against Napoleon in the 19th century. And certainly save them against Hitler in the 20th century. So So what we've done with our actions is given Putin a. A car. Was to fight this war that. Will be attractive to the Russian people. And the one thing I learned in. Terms of dealing with Russians over the years both at CIA and at the National War College. If there's one area of superiority that the Russians contend, it's they feel they can make greater sacrifices than other people. They don't believe themselves to be materialistic the way we are or the European states are. They can deal with setbacks. They can deal with failures. They certainly did it in World War Two and. Over 25 million Russians died. In a war. Which was overwhelmingly fought on the Eastern Front. When you think of where most of the German army. Uh was located and where most of the German fatalities and casualties took place, so I don't. I don't think time is on our side I, I think Putin can play a long game. He's indicated that he can, and he seems to believe this, and I guess I take him at his word and and we don't have. Any new way of looking at the problem? Whenever there's an issue that needs to be addressed, what we do is send up another military appropriations to the hill. The last one was for $8 billion more. Actually, $400 million in this increment to raise the total value of our arms transfers just in recent months to $8 billion over $50 billion. Overall. When you think of military aid and economic aid and infrastructure aid, so it's a it's a very. We're speaking with Mel Goodman this evening on counterpoint. Mel is a senior fellow at the Center for International Policy and a former CIA analyst, and we're talking about his recent article on Counterpunch that you can read yourself, titled Moscow's War in Ukraine versus Washington special military operation. There has been some concern expressed about how the Biden administration is fighting this war in Ukraine and what its goal. Those are and. We had Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin say a couple of months ago. That the Biden. Administration's goal was to number 1 degrade Russian military capacity and their economy. If that's still in play now, what's the danger of that goal? If if that indeed is where? If that is indeed what the priority is of this administration, when it comes to the conflict in Ukraine. Well, I still think there are a lot of people in the administration who believe that, and if they had their druthers would say it. But Austin was called on the carpet for saying it. Apparently he did get a personal phone call from President Biden saying that that was. A totally gratuitous statement that you made. Don't make it again, and Austin hasn't. But I know from my contacts with general officers over the years and I, 18 years of the war college. There there are a lot of high-ranking officers who grow up from their training from their experience from their exposure internationally. Thinking that Russia must be denied any military capability to conduct this kind of military operation. So I think what Austin was saying was sort of conventional wisdom. Within the military, don't allow Russia to come out of this war with the ability to. Fight another war in any area. In other words, Russia would not even be in a position to defend itself, and Russia is a country that is surrounded by adversarial interests. This is this is part of of Russian self belief about their own history. In their own national security situation, they envy our geostrategic. A superiority over them surrounded by oceans east and West and friendly neighbors North and South. They don't have that. They have a sensitive military border on the southern front and they refer to that as their sensitive border because they go back in history that Genghis Khan and various. Muslim and insurgencies on the border that created problems for Soviet and Russian interests and then when you think of the Caucasus, the fighting that takes place in the caucuses where actually Russia had to become a peacemaker between Armenia and Azerbaijan and it got very little credit for that several months ago. And then when you think of East Europe and the Warsaw Pact, the Warsaw Pact, I think, was not so much a way of opposing the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. It was a way of putting troops into Eastern Europe to ensure the loyalty of East Europeans who, with the exception of Bulgarians, detested Russia. And now Putin has made himself such a pariah, that even the Bulgarians have joined with their other East European neighbors, in being opposed to Russian interests. So to me we're playing right into. Russia beliefs about itself and the threat to national security that the United States represents by expanding NATO by creating a military headquarters, meaning permanent forces now will be in Poland by increasing the number of naval combatants in Rota, Spain. By increasing the squadrons of F. 35's in England. I mentioned Sweden and Finland coming into NATO. Onshore Russia was counting on Erdogan, Turkish President Erdogan to put up more of a fight to keep the Scandinavian countries out because of the Kurdish issue. But actually Biden handled that very well and heard on caved in very quickly. In fact, Putin in terms of his assumptions about the the West, the West is generally hung together. K now. More tightly and for a longer period of time than I think he anticipated. Well, we've run out of time now. Thank you so much for the work you do in analyzing current crises and for joining us tonight. And people can find your articles at counterpunch.org. Is that right? With that counter comment counterpunch.org on the national security columnist there and I tend to write once a week. Thank you ma'am.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link – T/L

Any military activities trade off with negotiations to resolve the war in Ukraine

Falk 7/11 (Richard Falk, member of the TRANSCEND Network, Albert G. Milbank Professor Emeritus of International Law at Princeton University, Chair of Global Law, Faculty of Law, at Queen Mary University London, Research Associate the Orfalea Center of Global Studies at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and Fellow of the Tellus Institute. He directed the project on Global Climate Change, Human Security, and Democracy at UCSB and formerly served as director the North American group in the World Order Models Project. Between 2008 and 2014, Falk served as UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Occupied Palestine. His memoir, Public Intellectual: The Life of a Citizen Pilgrim was published in March 2021 and received an award from Global Policy Institute at Loyala Marymount University as ‘the best book of 2021.’ He has been nominated frequently for the Nobel Peace Prize since 2009; "A European Call for an End to the Ukraine War", 7/11/2022, TRANSCEND Media Service, https://www.transcend.org/tms/2022/07/a-european-call-for-an-end-to-the-ukraine-war/, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten

Europe faces the task of restoring and securing peace on the continent. This requires the development of a strategy to end the Russian war in Ukraine as soon as possible.

Ukraine has been able to defend itself against Russia’s brutal war of aggression for three and a half months now, partially thanks to massive economic sanctions and military support from Europe and the United States. However, the longer this support continues, the less clear it becomes which goals are being pursued with it. A Ukrainian victory with the recapture of all occupied territories, including the Donezk and Luhansk Oblasts and Crimea, is considered unrealistic by most military experts, given Russia’s military superiority and ability to further escalate militarily.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Link – T/L

Every second is critical for negotiations---aggressive actions make Putin less likely to come to an agreement

Telesur 22 (Telesur; "Putin: Delay in Negotiations With Ukraine Poses High Risk", 7-7-2022, TeleSUR, https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/Putin-Delay-in-Negotiations-With-Ukraine-Poses-High-Risk-20220707-0029.html, DOA: 7-17-2022)//sposten

"We do not refuse peace negotiations, but those who refuse should know that the more time they waste, the more difficult it will be for them to negotiate with us," Putin said.

The Russian president made such a warning at a meeting with the leaders of the State Duma and the heads of party factions.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Grain UQ

Negotiations are ‘advanced’ but fragile

FCN 7/21 ("Grain negotiations ‘advanced’ but fragile: Kuleba", 7/21/2022, First Channel News, https://www.1lurer.am/en/2022/07/20/Grain-negotiations-%E2%80%98advanced%E2%80%99-but-fragile-Kuleba/764117, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

Negotiations on the resumption of the export of Ukrainian grain, which was blocked in the ports of the Black Sea by the Russia, have reached an advanced stage, but everything can break at any moment. This was stated by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Ukraine Dmitry Kuleba in broadcast telethon.

Kuleba stressed that the negotiations are very difficult.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Grain UQ

Grain deal is possible but depends on continued US and EU cooperation---Turkey is optimistic

AFP 7/21 ("Turkey Says 'Optimistic' Russia Can Agree To Grain Deal", 7-21-2022, Barron’s, https://www.barrons.com/news/turkey-says-optimistic-russia-can-agree-to-grain-deal-01658392207?tesla=y, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

Turkey's foreign minister said Thursday he was "optimistic" a deal could be reached soon that addressed Russian concerns and allowed Ukrainian grain to flow across the Black Sea.

Mevlut Cavusoglu's comments came less than a day after Russian President Vladimir Putin set an unexpected new condition for resuming the blocked deliveries.

2022 Michigan Counterplan
EU-Russia Relations › 2NC UQ/Link Toolbox › 2NC – Grain UQ

Talks are ongoing over food

Crawford 7/21 (Alan Crawford; "Ukraine Latest: Russian Annexation Plans; Currency Devalued", 7-21-2022, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-21/ukraine-latest-russian-gas-resumes-but-italy-raises-more-risks, DOA: 7-21-2022)//sposten

Russia Says Grain Export Talks Happening Via Video (2:31 p.m.)

Talks on resuming Ukrainian grain exports are being held via video, with hopes of reaching an agreement in the near future, Interfax reported, citing Andrey Rudenko, Russia’s deputy foreign minister.