Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Strategic Stability DA › 2NC --- Impact O/V

DA turns case – makes miscalc more likely

Johnson 20 – Dr. James Johnson is a postdoctoral research fellow at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS) at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies, Monterey. He holds a PhD in politics and international relations from the University of Leicester, where he is also an honorary visiting fellow with the School of History and International Relations. (James, "Artificial Intelligence: A Threat to Strategic Stability," STRATEGIC STUDIES QUARTERLY, Spring 2020, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/SSQ/documents/Volume-14_Issue-1/Johnson.pdf, Accessed 7-2-2022, LASA-SC)

AI-augmented conventional capabilities might affect strategic stability between great military powers. The nuanced, multifaceted possible intersections of this emerging technology with a range of advanced conventional weapons can compromise nuclear capabilities, thus amplifying the potentially destabilizing effects of these weapons. This article argues that a new generation of artificial intelligence–enhanced conventional capabilities will exacerbate the risk of inadvertent escalation caused by the commingling of nuclear and nonnuclear weapons. The increasing speed of warfare will also undermine strategic stability and increase the risk of nuclear confrontation.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Strategic Stability DA › 1NC --- Strategic Stability DA

US-China war causes extinction.

Brands 22 – Hal Brands is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. The Henry Kissinger Distinguished Professor at Johns Hopkins University’s School of Advanced International Studies, he is co-author, most recently, of "Danger Zone: The Coming Conflict with China" and a member of the State Department's Foreign Affairs Policy Board. (Hal Brands, "U.S. Isn’t Ready for Nuclear Rivalry With China and Russia," Bloomberg, 1-30-2022, https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-01-30/u-s-isn-t-prepared-for-a-nuclear-war-with-russia-and-china, Accessed 7-2-2022, LASA-SC)

Then there is Beijing’s buildup. China may once have possessed a “minimal deterrent” — a small, relatively vulnerable arsenal, designed solely to deter nuclear attack on China itself — but that’s no longer the case. The Chinese test of a fractional orbital bombardment system (in essence, a nuclear-weapon delivery system that orbits the earth before plunging toward its target) is only part of a much larger endeavor.

China is now building a more secure and sophisticated “nuclear triad” — a combination of nuclear-capable bombers, ground-based intercontinental missiles and submarine-launched ballistic missiles. Its ICBM force is expanding rapidly. The Pentagon predicts that China will have more than 1,000 deliverable warheads by 2030 — an arsenal worthy of a superpower.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Strategic Stability DA › 1NC --- Strategic Stability DA

That destroys strategic stability – ensures inadvertent escalation.

Johnson 20 – Dr. James Johnson is a postdoctoral research fellow at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS) at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies, Monterey. He holds a PhD in politics and international relations from the University of Leicester, where he is also an honorary visiting fellow with the School of History and International Relations. (James, "Artificial Intelligence: A Threat to Strategic Stability," STRATEGIC STUDIES QUARTERLY, Spring 2020, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/SSQ/documents/Volume-14_Issue-1/Johnson.pdf, Accessed 7-2-2022, LASA-SC)

Finally, in the maritime domain, unmanned underwater vessels (UUV), unmanned surface vessels (USV), and UAVs supported by AI-enabled intra-swarm communication and ISR systems could be deployed simultaneously in both offensive and defensive antisubmarine warfare operations to saturate an enemy’s defenses and to locate, disable, and destroy its nuclear-armed or nonnuclear attack submarines.64 Despite continued advances in sensor technology design (e.g., reduced size and extended detection ranges) to overcome quieting challenges, other technical challenges still remain. These include communicating underwater between multiple systems, processing power requirements, generating battery life and energy, and scaling the system.65 While some experts do not expect a technically reliable and effective capability of this kind will be operational for at least a decade, others are more optimistic.66 From a tactical perspective, drone swarms would not need ocean-wide coverage (or full ocean transparency) to effectively detect and track submarines. According to UK rear admiral John Gower, a relatively even spread of sensors might be sufficient to enable “a viable search and detection plan . . . conceived for the open ocean” (emphasis added).67 Moreover, advances in mobile sensing platforms could enable drones in swarms to locate submarines through chokepoints (or gateways) as they emerge from ports. Due to the current slowness of drones with extended sea ranges, however, trailing them autonomously seems implausible.68 Future iterations of machine-learning-augmented UUVs and USVs may eventually complement, and perhaps replace entirely, the traditional role of general-purpose nuclear-powered submarines (SSN) and manned surface vehicles in tracking and trailing submarines of adversaries at chokepoints while simultaneously mounting sparsely distributed and mobile distributed network systems (DNS) sensors on UUVs.69 If a state views the credibility of its survivable nuclear weapons (especially nuclear-armed submarines) to be at risk,70 conventional capabilities such as drone swarms will likely have a destabilizing effect at a strategic level.71 Thus, even if swarm sorties were not intended as (or indeed technically capable of ) a disarming first strike, the perception alone of the feasibility of such an operation would be destabilizing nonetheless.Moreover, the speed of AI could put the defender at a distinct disadvantage, creating additional incentives to strike first (or preemptively) technologically superior military rivals. Consequently, the less secure a nation considers its second-strike capabilities to be, the more likely it is to countenance the use of autonomous systems within its nuclear weapons complex to bolster the survivability of its strategic forces. According to analyst Paul Scharre, “winning in swarm combat may depend upon having the best algorithms to enable better coordination and faster reaction times, rather than simply the best platforms” (emphasis added).72 Combining speed, persistence, scope, coordination, and battlefield mass, AWSs will offer states attractive asymmetric options to project military power within contested A2/AD zones.73 Enhanced by sophisticated machine learning neural networks, China’s manned and unmanned drone teaming operations could potentially impede future US freedom of navigation operations in the South China Seas.74 Its air- and sea-based drones linked to sophisticated neural networks could, for example, support the People’s Liberation Army’s manned and unmanned teaming operations. Were China to infuse its cruise missiles and hypersonic glide capabilities with AI and autonomy, close-range encounters in the Taiwan Straits and the East and South China Seas would become more complicated, accident-prone, and destabilizing—at both a conventional and nuclear level.75 China is reportedly developing and deploying UUVs to bolster its underwater monitoring and antisubmarine capabilities as part of a broader goal to establish an “underwater Great Wall” to challenge US undersea military primacy. US AI-enhanced UUVs could, for example, theoretically threaten China’s nuclear ballistic and nonnuclear attack submarines.76

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Strategic Stability DA › 1NC --- Strategic Stability DA

Applying AI to ASW destroys nuclear deterrence – squo tech is sufficient but the aff pushes it too far.

Johnson 20 – Dr. James Johnson is a postdoctoral research fellow at the James Martin Center for Nonproliferation Studies (CNS) at the Middlebury Institute of International Studies, Monterey. He holds a PhD in politics and international relations from the University of Leicester, where he is also an honorary visiting fellow with the School of History and International Relations. (James, "Artificial Intelligence: A Threat to Strategic Stability," STRATEGIC STUDIES QUARTERLY, Spring 2020, https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/SSQ/documents/Volume-14_Issue-1/Johnson.pdf, Accessed 7-2-2022, LASA-SC)**corrected spelling error

On the one hand, several experts argue that deployed in large swarms, these platforms could transform antisubmarine warfare, rendering at-sea nuclear deterrence vulnerable. On the other hand, some consider such a hypothesis technically premature because (1) it is unlikely that sensors on board AWSs would be able to reliably detect deeply submerged submarines; (2) the range of these sensors (and the drones themselves) would be limited by battery power over extended ranges;52 and (3) given the vast areas traversed by SSBNs on deterrence missions, the chance of detection is negligible even if large numbers of autonomous swarms were deployed.53 Thus, significant advances in power, sensor technology, and communications would be needed before these autonomous systems have a gamechanging strategic impact on deterrence.54 However, irrespective of the veracity of this emerging capability, the mere perception that nuclear capabilities face new strategic challenges would nonetheless elicit distrust between nuclear-armed adversaries—particularly where strategic force asymmetries exist. Moreover, DARPA’s Sea Hunter demonstrates how the emerging generation of autonomous weapons is expediting the completion of the iterative targeting cycle to support joint operations, thus increasing the uncertainty about the reliability and survivability of states’ nuclear second-strike capability and potentially triggering use-them[-or]-lose-them situations. Conceptually speaking, the most destabilizing impact of AI on nuclear deterrence would be the synthesis of autonomy with a range of machinelearning-augmented sensors, undermining states’ confidence in the survival of their second-strike capabilities and in extremis triggering a retaliatory first strike.55 Enhanced by the exponential growth in computing performance and coupled with advances in machine learning techniques that can rapidly process data in real time, AI will empower drone swarms to perform increasingly complex missions, such as hunting hitherto hidden nuclear deterrence forces.56 In short, the ability of future iterations of AI able to predict based on the fusion of expanded and dispersed data sets and then to locate, track, and target strategic missiles such as mobile ICBM launchers in underground silos, on board stealth aircraft, and in SSBNs is set to grow.57

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › China Espionage Turn › Info sharing DA/Case Turn/DA to Open source CP

China steals the AFFs tech---fuels China’s military modernization

Xiu and Singer 21 — Ma Xiu is an analyst currently researching the PLA Rocket Force at BluePath Labs, LLC. P.W. Singer is Strategist at New America. Ma Xiu,Peter W. Singer, "How China Steals US Tech to Catch Up in Underwater Warfare," Defense One, 6-8-2021, https://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2021/06/how-china-steals-us-tech-catch-underwater-warfare/174558/, accessed 6-30-2022, WMK

In late April, Massachusetts-based businessman Qin Shuren became the latest person to plead guilty in the Justice Department’s crackdown on the illegal export of strategic technologies. Qin’s company, LinkOcean Technologies, falsified documentation to send a Chinese military-affiliated university some $100,000 worth of equipment, including hydrophones, sonobuoys, side-scan sonars, and even an autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV). The case is just one part of a long trail of open-source evidence that illustrates a larger issue: U.S. technology being used to advance Chinese military ends.

The trail begins with the Justice Department’s press release, which says that Mr. Qin was working at the direction of Northwestern Polytechnical University, in the northwest Chinese city of Xi’an. NWPU is one of the “Seven Sons of National Defense,” a group of universities known for particularly close ties to the People’s Liberation Army and which contribute a high proportion of China’s defense workforce and research. For two decades, NWPU has been on the U.S. Department of Commerce Entity List, the group of foreign organizations and individuals to which the export of certain U.S. strategic technologies is restricted.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Ptix DA › 1NC---L---Infighting

Fix tag – reducing existing submarines for modern submarines like the plan ignite fights in congress

Donnelly and Clevenger 22 [John M. Donnelly and Andrew Clevenger, John M. Donnelly is a senior writer for CQ Roll Call who specializes in defense. He has served as president of the Military Reporters & Editors Association, chairman of the National Press Club board of governors, and secretary of the Standing Committee of Correspondents in Congress. Andrew is a defense policy writer for Roll Call, 5-11-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, Roll Call, "Tensions rise in House over Navy shipbuilding - Roll Call", https://rollcall.com/2022/05/11/tensions-rise-in-house-over-navy-shipbuilding/ mimou]

Sharp divisions over the adequacy of President Joe Biden’s fiscal 2023 request for the Navy’s shipbuilding budget emerged at two House hearings Wednesday.

The differences, which fell largely along party lines, were manifest at a House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense budget hearing with the Pentagon top brass and a House Armed Services Committee hearing with the leaders of the Navy and Marine Corps.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Ptix DA › 2NC --- Plan Unpop

Democrats and republicans both hate the plan

Cohen 22 [Steve Cohen, Mr. Cohen is an attorney at Pollock Cohen in New York. He is a former member of the Board of Directors of the United States Naval Institute., 4-2-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, New York The Sun, "Don’t Sink the Navy To Save It", https://www.nysun.com/article/dont-sink-the-navy-to-save-it mimou]

The Navy just  its Fiscal Year 2023 budget request. It calls for decommissioning 24 active warships, ostensibly to save $3.6 billion over the next five years — in order to use the savings to start building a mere nine new ships. The first problem is that both the Navy’s top officer and two successive civilian administrations have repeatedly  that the Navy must grow to 500 ships, up from 298 vessels today. Otherwise, the Navy will simply not be equipped to do the jobs demanded of it.  

The logic of cutting the fleet size today in order to fund its future growth is not finding traction among knowledgeable observers on either side of the aisle. It simply doesn't make any sense. “HINT: If you want to grow the Navy, stop decommissioning more ships than you build,” tweeted Representative Elaine Luria, a Democrat from Virginia who serves as Vice Chair of the House Arms Services Committee.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Ptix DA › 2NC --- Plan Unpop

Plans for new AI submarines are widely unpopular

Gooding 22 [Mike Gooding, Mike is the senior military and political reporter at 13news now, 5-13-2022, accessed on 7-5-2022, 13newsnow.com, "Navy 'not sized' to handle two wars at once: CNO", https://www.13newsnow.com/article/news/national/military-news/chief-naval-operations-says-navy-not-prepared-to-handle-two-wars-at-once/291-89e465f9-1f34-4748-b1a6-a2980ace86c1 mimou]

The current fleet stands at 298 ships. However, Gilday told the Senate Armed Services Committee on Thursday that he supports the Biden Administrations' proposal to reduce the fleet to 280 ships by 2027.

Gilday said it's smarter to invest now in newer, more sophisticated and more lethal ships, rather than wasting money on older, less capable vessels.

2022 Michigan Negative
DA/Case Turns › Ptix DA › 1NC---L---Unpopular

Congress hates increasing funding for submarines

Larter 19 [David Larter, David B. Larter was the naval warfare reporter for Defense News. Before that, he reported for Navy Times., 12-19-2019, accessed on 7-5-2022, Defense News, "Congress slashes funding for the Navy’s LCS sensors — again", mimou]

WASHINGTON — Congress again ’s mission modules in this year’s defense appropriations bill, which will likely create further delays in fielding capabilities designed to plug into the hulls that would enable the ships to hunt submarines or destroy mines — the missions they were built to perform in the first place.

With 35 ships funded, Congress has every year since at least 2015 cut funding to the long-delayed . As the program is currently structured, each ship is either a mine sweeper, submarine hunter or small anti-surface combatant, all made possible by mission modules still under development.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- Fairness

Disability justice can only be achieved through attempts to promote fairness through policy engagement. Only policy can engage the algorithms of AI and correct ableist notions behind AI.

Tilmes 22 – Nicholas Tilmes is in the field of bioethics and researches the intersection of philosophy, psychology, and biology at Cornell University. He is passionate about applying philosophical insights to concrete ethical dilemmas posed by emerging technologies, such as genetic engineering and functional brain imaging, and the relationship between official medical knowledge and the lived experiences of patients. (Nicholas Tilmes, “Disability, fairness, and algorithmic bias in AI recruitment”, Ethics of Information Technology, Springer Link, Article No. 21, 19 April 2022, ) || PZ

Disability justice Rather than attempting to promote fairness solely through technical adjustments to training data and input–output relations, data scientists should take up a disability justice approach. This view acknowledges that factors such as error rates and accuracy are necessary but insufficient to understand, identify, and address algorithmic bias. Disability justice serves as a framework for reasoning about how ableist structures and norms subtly configure and restrict the ostensibly objective aspects of AI design. A deeper analysis of disability and capacity not only draws attention to the value-laden nature of design processes but illuminates how data analytics and machine learning help to define and redefine those concepts. Instead, a disability justice approach suggests drawing a wider circle of considerations relevant to AI ethics; centering analysis of assumptions and values in design; closing gaps between stakeholders; and pursuing policies that empower further activism. Disability justice calls into question fair-ML’s dogged quest for objectivity and failure to confront broader socio-political norms, demanding that data scientists attend to the subjective choices intrinsic to algorithm design. This shifts from a sole focus on technical aspects of design—such as input–output relations and training data—and expands the problem space to include the social responses and outcomes that algorithms generate. While data scientists need not abandon technical considerations, these decisions must follow from an analysis of the normative choices that go into, e.g., generating classifications, formulating problems, labelling data, and selecting proxy variables. That is, designers should take a broader socio-technical perspective, which considers systems as not merely technological but enmeshed with embodied, organizational, social, and political factors (Simon et al., ; van der Bijl-Brouwer & Malcom, ). By considering how these dynamics interact and affect AI design together instead of assessing them in isolation, data scientists can better conceptualize, identify, and respond to biased algorithms. For instance, by reflecting on values woven into targets like ‘fit,’ one can parse out legitimate indicators of employability, such as word choice, from ones steeped in ableist norms and unrelated to performance, such as speech patterns and tone. Widening the circle of factors considered relevant to ethical AI design beyond data and input–output relations not only alters design processes but also renders thinkable a wider range of alternatives. Looking beyond the optimization of technical fairness criteria intervenes in solutionism and reveals a variety of other mechanisms for combatting bias and promoting social transformation. Notably, this gives us the tools to situate algorithms in a socio-technical context and raise the question of whether algorithms are appropriate instruments to measure and shape certain domains in the first place. For instance, given concerns about algorithms’ ability to capture shifting, contextual aspects of disability, what amount of discretion should they have over disabled people’s hiring outcomes, if any? While simply omitting groups from algorithmic models would exacerbate inequality, there may be reason to be much more skeptical of their inferences. Already, protests by Google employees about collaboration with the Departments of Defense and Homeland Security on Projects JEDI and MAVEN (Wakabayashi & Shane, ) and pledges by computer science students to refuse work at Palantir in light of its cooperation with Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (Birnbaum, ) point to the ways in which data scientists can affect change beyond the algorithm itself. As such, disability justice indicates that we ought to expand the scope of AI ethics and situate algorithms in their socio-technical context. Moreover, a disability justice approach suggests that data scientists should critically analyze the ways in which disability is defined, measured, and labelled. Given that most data about disability are medical, inferences from them typically are limited to the medical model, reducing disability to a biological dysfunction. Yet, by drawing on disability scholarship, we can uncover the ways in which these categories shift and trace their roots to ableist assumptions. For instance, consider proposals to increase the amount and quality of disability data by drawing from people’s electronic health records. While well-intentioned, these efforts would further entrench the medical model of disability, leave little room for self-identification, and underrepresent disabled people who lack access to health care. Making explicit the ways in which algorithms model disability creates space to imagine it differently through methods like value-sensitive design (Friedman & Hendry, ; Simon et al., ). Such an approach melds conceptual, empirical, and technical elements, e.g., assessing models of disability in terms of their assumptions, impact on data gathering, relationship to outcomes, and so on. In so doing, data scientists could better attend to the ways that different models influence people’s claims about their disabilities and how those claims are mediated by intersecting hierarchies of class, race, and gender. By investigating how different definitions and measures of disability shape who ‘counts’ as disabled, data scientists can intervene in these ongoing omissions. This requires altering how disabilities are operationalized so they are defined not solely as medical diagnoses but also in terms of how people navigate institutions, norms, and each other. While fair-ML idealizes abstraction so that data can be applied across contexts, (in)capacities emerge from a multitude of contextual factors like competing values and built environments. Instead, a disability justice framework suggests that an algorithm’s accuracy does not always trade off with its ability to accommodate contingency because many disabilities are intrinsically situational and resist quantification. Implementing this approach might involve, e.g., assigning more weight to contextual factors, assessing how aspects of a given disability shift over time, and designing scales that are sensitive to social values and attitudes. For example, some researchers have demonstrated that disability data can be disaggregated to more easily study the variables that cooccur with certain disabilities or contexts (Brown & Broido, ; Peña et al., ). Others have called for analyzing how people’s capacities expand and contract in relation to built accessibility, office culture, and the type of labor at hand (Bennett et al., ). This suggests that data scientists could model disability differently by altering processes of data collection, label generation, and proxy selection so as not to abstract away its context. In addition, disability justice demands more fundamental shifts in access, communication, and ownership across the AI design pipeline. Indeed, the biases that hiring algorithms exhibit are inseparable from developers’ sole focus on employer values and widening asymmetries between firms and applicants. Although applicants’ ability to secure jobs is shaped by these AI, they cannot examine or offer input on them easily, if at all. Expanding opportunities for these engagements and removing barriers to access is essential to designing more equitable algorithms. Already, initiatives like Access Computing offer accessible training in computer science (Trewin et al., ) and groups like (Dis)Ability in AI provide support to disabled people at conferences about AI (Whittaker et al., ). Despite efforts to increase disability representation at design forums and in training datasets, the mere presence of disability is not enough to transform existing institutions and restore trust. That is, vendors must design with disabled people, not merely for them. As the scope of design expands, data scientists ought to draw insights from other disciplines, including disability studies and socio-technical design, and team up with a wider range of stakeholders. This process cannot simply tack on these perspectives but must integrate and consult with them throughout the design pipeline. By collaborating with a diverse array of disciplines and voices, data scientists could better identify stakeholders in AI hiring, explore their values and needs, study how AI might implicate them, and involve them in design processes. This bears similarities to a participatory design perspective, in which workers are empowered by directly influencing the design of technologies they will take up (Korsgaard et al., ). Using a variety of techniques—from prototyping and mock-ups to future-oriented workshops and scenarios—stakeholders reflect on the situation, imagine innovative solutions, and transform those speculative approaches into realistic, concrete alternatives. This might involve, to give an example, asking stakeholders to evaluate whether automated interviews that assess affect and gestures align with their values, what they communicate about disabled applicants, and how they might be navigated. In parallel, insights from disability studies suggest granting disabled people’s perspectives significant weight in debates about, e.g., generating labels and selecting proxies for disability status. For instance, developers might look to data platform co-ops operated by people with rare disabilities, in which they oversee the use of their data and share profits (Scholz, ; Treviranus, ), to inform their own decisions about responsible data use. By working alongside these other disciplines and voices from the start of the design process, data scientists could help bridge gaps in knowledge, foster a common conceptual language, and develop new research methods. Beyond expanding the scope of AI ethics concerns, redefining design values, and changing stakeholder dynamics, a disability justice approach suggests pursuing policy measures that can empower data activism. While legislation often lags behind advances in computing, existing regulatory uncertainty allows AI vendors to selectively endorse transparency and fairness criteria in ways that preserve existing arrangements. Greater transparency could help promote the conditions necessary for activists and data scientists alike to study, uncover, and contest algorithmic bias. Despite the explanatory difficulties associated with the black box, policies ought to be introduced mandating that AI developers regularly audit and disclose the purview, inputs and outputs, and limitations of their algorithms. For example, some have suggested requiring employers to make public the automated inferences they make about applicants (Hoffman, ) and tasking them with retaining detailed records of their bias mitigation procedures (Hoffman, ). Developing legislation to establish minimum standards for data transparency and disclosure of bias mitigation measures—even for opaque machine learning AI—is necessary to identify and make claims against discriminatory algorithms. In addition to setting baselines for transparent design and implementation, recognizing how ableist structures can affect people’s identification with and disclosure of disability status highlights the importance of more robust privacy regulations. Existing protections are ill-equipped to grapple with the ethical risks posed by automated hiring tools or predictions of disability status. The ADA (1990) only shields those who are disabled, treated as disabled, or were disabled, while GINA (2008) and HIPAA (OCR, ) protect health data while it is being stored, transferred, and analyzed by certain classes of covered entities. However, since these laws neither cover AI vendors and data brokers nor explicitly forbid discrimination based on inferred risk factors for disabilities, AI can circumvent them (Givens & Morris, ). Similarly, while the ADA prohibits discrimination in places of public accommodation, it does not explicitly include algorithms, social media platforms, and so on (Rothstein, ). Expanding existing privacy protections would help make disability disclosure less precarious and, in so doing, assist efforts to gather more representative datasets.

2022 Michigan Kritik

1NC --- Solvency

Creating intersectional movements and policy is the only way to address ableist and discriminatory policy

Jampel, 18 (Catherine Jampel), “Intersections of disability justice, racial justice and environmental justice.” Environmental Sociology. . Accessed 7-22-2021. ALS

Philosopher Anna Carastathis (2013) recuperates one of Crenshaw’s early metaphors in order to illustrate this point. Crenshaw’s (1989) metaphor of a basement with a trap door illustrates how single-axis or limited-axis movements may fail people facing multiple systems of oppression. By system of oppression, I mean historical and institutionalized patterns that disadvantage a particular group of people based on their social identity. Systems of oppression include racism, sexism, heterosexism, ableism and so forth. In the ‘basement’ metaphor, ‘all people who are disadvantaged on the basis of race, sex, class, sexual preference, age, and/or physical ability’ occupy a basement with ‘those on the bottom being disadvantaged by the full array of factors, up to the very top, where the heads of those disadvantaged by a singular factor brush up against the ceiling’ (Crenshaw 1989, 151). In Crenshaw’s initial work on intersectionality, which examined why Black women facing discrimination did not have legal recourse, White women and Black men could say they would be out of the basement ‘but for’ the ceiling. However, Black women faced two ‘but fors’ – racism and sexism – and became legally invisible. Truly intersectional work aims to address all of the systems of oppression that might leave someone in the metaphorical basement. The ‘Applications: bringing intersectionality and disability justice to EJ work’ section of this paper will include examples of how EJ work can avoid perpetuating ableism, the system that oppresses people with nonnormative bodies and minds.

2022 Michigan Kritik

1NC---Ballot K

Radical care work is impossible within the paradigm of competition. Their call for the ballot individualizes and neoliberalizes care relationships, turning the case.

Laurence Simard-Gagnon 16, Department of Geography, Queen’s University, “Everyone is fed, bathed, asleep, and I have made it through another day: Problematizing accommodation, resilience, and care in the neoliberal academy,” April 2016, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cag.12274

Following the principle of competition, if some are to succeed it is necessary that some fail. Neoliberalism entails letting die, smothering even, the casualties of marketization. It entails individualization of life circumstances, including needs and, importantly, struggles and failures that occur when needs come in the way of an individual’s capacity to compete. Neoliberalism entails exhaustion.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- Alt solves

Crip theorizations are currently organized around material change to cut back against capitalism.

Hamraie and Fritsch 19 – Aimi Hamraie (they/them) is Associate Professor of Medicine, Health, & Society and American Studies at Vanderbilt University, and director of the . Trained as a feminist scholar, Hamraie’s interdisciplinary research spans critical disability studies, science and technology studies, critical design and urbanism, critical race theory, and the environmental humanities. They are author of  (University of Minnesota Press, 2017) and host of the on disability and design. With Kelly Fritsch, Mara Mills, and David Serlin, Hamraie co-edited a special issue of Catalyst: feminism theory technoscience on “” Hamraie’s research is funded by the Social Science Research Council, the Smithsonian Institution, the Mellon Foundation, the Graham Foundation for Advanced Studies in the Arts, and the National Humanities Alliance; Prior to joining the Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Kelly Fritsch earned her Ph.D. in Social and Political Thought at York University (2015) and was a Banting Postdoctoral Fellow at the Women & Gender Studies Institute and Technoscience Research Unit, University of Toronto (2015-2018). Her research broadly mobilizes crip, queer, and feminist theory to engage disability, health, technology, risk, accessibility, and social justice. Fritsch is also cross-appointed to the Pauline Jewett Institute of Women’s and Gender Studies and the Institute of Political Economy.  , [“Catalyst: Feminism, Theory, Technoscience”, Crip Technoscience Manifesto, Volume 5 Section 1, 7-8, SGH]

Crip technoscience centers the work of disabled people as knowers and makers. Crip technoscience privileges disabled people as designers and world-builders, as knowing what will work best and developing the skills, capacities, and relationships to make something from our knowledge. Unlike typical approaches to disability that objectify disabled people and situate expertise in medical professionals and non-disabled designers or engineers, crip technoscience posits that disabled people are active participants in the design of everyday life. Not only do disabled people make access in our everyday lives in ways that do not get recognized as design, but the lived experience of disability, and the shared experience of disability community creates specific expertise and knowledge that informs technoscientific practices.

2022 Michigan Kritik

Capitalism’s drive for productivity forms the basis for Modern ableism by bracketing out those deemed as “un-productive”. Only resolving capitalism makes it possible to fracture and resolve existing ableist structures.

Shi 20- ( Abbigale ; Abbigale Shi is an author for The Daily free press and has written multiple articles on bioethics and sociological relations; "Mind Your Business: Ableism Is Rooted In Capitalism – The Daily Free Press". Dailyfreepress.Com, 2020, https://dailyfreepress.com/2020/11/19/mind-your-business-ableism-is-rooted-in-capitalism/. Accessed 5 Dec 2021.) SV

Capitalism prioritizes productivity: your value and worth lie in how much you can produce for profit. The idea of constantly striving toward production is interwoven at the individual level, as evidenced by the urge to ask kids what job they want when they grow up — as if we dream about labor — and at the societal level, where a price tag is put on everything we do. This productivity-driven mindset permeates everything in a capitalist society. I grew up idolizing certain jobs: doctors, lawyers and scientists. But, my admiration wasn’t based on how these professions helped people. It was mostly because I was taught to prioritize their salary, recognition and prestige. In turn, people who didn’t choose a traditional corporate job were knocked to the bottom and unfairly branded as lazy, useless and undeserving of respect. I’m still working to dismantle this mindset that has become ingrained in me, but I’ve realized it’s even more important to do so when capitalism is integral to modern day ableism. So, what does capitalism have to do with ableism? Ableism is a product of capitalism. Simply put, the system isn’t made for people who are different. This includes people who have different ambitions, prioritize happiness or family over work, or have a different scope of ability. The ableist-capitalist relationship means that even if not explicitly, society makes it unnecessarily difficult for disabled people to find work. Non-manual labor jobs often tack on extraneous physical requirements that are inherently discriminatory, despite claiming to hire regardless of disability. Especially in academia, when jobs listings require “walking, talking and hearing,” for example, it sends a very clear message. When a disabled person secures a job, the employer might have to shift the functions of their role, or spend small sums of money to comply with requirements set by the Americans with Disabilities Act. So, the net profit exploited from a disabled worker may be less than that from an able-bodied worker. To compensate, many businesses use a loophole in the Fair Labor Standards Act to justify paying disabled workers subminimum wage. It’s worse than it sounds — disabled workers often earn pennies, or even gift cards, and are labeled as “substandard” because their disability can affect productivity. Before 2014, disabled people who received benefits such as Medicaid payments or Social Security Disability Insurance were disqualified if they had assets totaling more than $2,000 or if their monthly earnings exceeded $700. The job hunt is very discouraging when you know you’re going to face these obstacles and could eventually be forced to forfeit your benefits. If you were to lose your job, you would have to reapply for these programs, which often have waitlists a mile long. The Achieving a Better Life Experience Act was passed in December of 2014, allowing disabled individuals to open savings accounts for certain disability costs such as education, housing, transportation, health and basic living expenses. But the limitations of the ABLE Act still put disabled people at a disadvantage — the annual gift tax exclusion, which was $15,000 in 2020, is the limit for account contributions, and individuals must be diagnosed with a disability before turning 26 to be eligible. As if that’s not enough, the ableist-capitalist treatment extends beyond the workplace into daily life. Social Security rules create penalties for disabled people who want to get married. Sure, they’re legally allowed to marry. But if they do so, they’re faced with the possibility of losing their health insurance, earning a lower monthly income or losing their benefits altogether. Why do people have to choose between basic necessities and love? Able-bodied, heterosexual people can joke about getting married for the “tax benefits” while disabled people are forced to forfeit their right to marry so they can survive. By only rewarding those who are able-bodied, capitalism feeds into ableism. It produces and then exacerbates inequalities between the “normal bodies” and those who are disabled. It seems obvious a system that relies on the exploitation of individuals would in turn enable the devaluing of disabled people because they may require more accommodations and aren’t as easily exploited. During the pandemic, it’s also become obvious that accessibility is possible. Remote work is possible. But until a global pandemic struck, our capitalist society has not considered it a possibility — even for disabled people who could greatly benefit from these accommodations. It certainly makes one thing very clear: capitalism deems disabled people unworthy of the time and effort it takes to dismantle the barriers it is responsible for. If we able-bodied people want to be allies for those who are disabled, we need to take on an anti-capitalistic lens. You can’t separate the two. If you want to fight ableism, you must be able to recognize that it is, and has been for a long time, rooted in capitalism.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- Root Cause

The political economy is the best analytic to explain forms of ableist violence that lead to material impacts that disabled populations must face. Only understanding “competence” as indebted to the structures of productivity and labor relations can reshape WHAT society values.

De Cabral 22 – Vinicius Neves de Cabral holds a PhD in Education from the State University of Londrina (UEL) and currently works as a lecturer in the Department of Pedagogy at the State University of Parana (UNESPAR) in Brazil. He is a researcher associated with the Centre for Critical Studies and Research in Education and Social Inequality (UEL), and member of the Editorial Board of the The Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies (JCEPS) and of the Journal of Class and Culture. His main research interests lie in the fields of education, culture, literature, and film, drawing on Marxist methodologies. Recently published articles: (1) The Portrait of Exclusion in Brazilian Universities: the limits of inclusion, (2) Roma: images of dictatorial regimes and Human Rights abuse in Latin America, and (3) Capitalism, Class and Meritocracy: A Cross-National Study Between the UK and Brazil. (Vinícius Neves de Cabral, “A Marxist Approach to Disability: Notes on Marx’s Relative Surplus Population”, State University of Paraná (UNESPAR), Brazil and State University of Londrina, pgs. 51-65, June 2022, ) || PZ

Disability and the Ideology of Competence As stated, I am not going to analyse the disabling phenomena beyond the sphere of capitalism, but rather to understand them as part of the complex system of ontological maintenance of the capital (Mészáros 2011). One way (not the only way) to do that is to approach, from a materialist perspective, the ideological discourse of competence. It unveils not only what is expected from the working class but also what is to be discarded. Competence is a concept that is in dialectical relation with the concepts of class, exploitation, and individual. Social class, one’s position in the economic and political structure of capitalism, will have a direct impact on the limits imposed on and possibilities opened up to individuals. That is, humans make their history, but they are determined by sociohistorical forces beyond their control (Marx & Engels 1968). Therefore, a materialist reading of disability may largely contribute to deepen and expand the scientific knowledge around the disabling phenomena. Social class, albeit a commonly forgotten category in the analyses of disability, is an essential aspect of it. There are complex divergencies between facing an impairment in the higher classes, in the middle-classes, or in the lower-classes7 (See Erevelles 2011; Cabral 2021; Russel 2019; Santos 2020). Wright (1998) argues that exploitation is a grounding concept when it comes to class analysis because it creates a fissure between the higher classes (the owners of the capital, land, and means of production), who exploit, and the rest who are exploited. The development of capitalist relations, however, engendered new classes, a class that originates from the social and technical divisions of labour (Wayne 2020; Wright 1998). The middle-classes are constituted by those in the working class who perform jobs that require more complex skills in contrast to those who are working in manual jobs - and thus tendentiously share contrasting interests with them. These are also called in sociological works primary and secondary sector jobs, which respectively represent “those with high wages, high skill levels, good working conditions, job security, and ample opportunities for promotion” in contrast to “low wages, low skill levels, poor working conditions, little job security, and few if any possibilities for advancement.” (Barnes 1992b, p. 57). Wayne (2020, p. 5) keenly highlights that The social division of labour is linked to class formation because across the various branches of productive activity designed to meet variable social needs, the same social types in control of those branches have more in common with each other than they do with their immediate workers, who have the least control, least power and lowest remuneration in the production process. The maintenance of class structure and the inducement of competition and individualism in the working-classes is a fundamental trait to the ontological continuation of capitalism. The social division of labour focuses on the formation of an un-critical, individualist, and indebted working-middle class with no sense of unity or class consciousness (Marx & Engels 2008; Mészáros 2008; 2011). The spread of meritocratic values amongst the professional and managerial strata of the working-class gives them a glamorous look and the false impression that they are closer to the top than to the bottom, that they share more with those in power than with those in classes below them (Wayne & Cabral 2021). The relevance of the discussion of class lies in the fact that when we talk about inclusion without questioning capitalism, we are usually referring to the right to enter the labour force and be exploited. Disability in the working-class demands the absence of one of the non-disabled members of the family from the labour market to provide care for the disabled member. This care may also be relegated to a philanthropic special institution - in the latter, allowing all working members of the families to be absorbed by the capital (Russel 2019). It may be argued, however, that the concepts and definitions of what it means “to be able to work” are variable (Stone 1984). Indeed they are, but those are regulated by the State and by the capitalists themselves, and they vary not only influenced directly by pressures of society, but by the demands of the capital (Russel 2019). In other words, it means to say that their jobs and the place they occupy are both part of a regulatory system of the capital, as Russel (2019) argues, and a special kind of charity - in either case their workforce is easily disposable. If we consider here Robert Young’s (2009) analyses of Marx’s concept of use of value, we may indicate that: in the Capital’s commodity structure when those deemed disabled are exchanged, they are exchanged for less. Erevelles (2011, p. 252) argues that “[…] “becoming disabled is also a historical event where disability also has a use value that is deployed simultaneously with race to justify the creation of the enslaved un-gendered body. ” and that the “[…] actual act of impairment that is used both to create and at the same time to justify this construction.” Proof of that have also been the recent changes in the Brazilian legislation regarding the regulations for the mandatory employment of disabled people. Advancements in laws and legal regulations are indeed an important part of the struggles of the working class, but they “are ‘solutions’ which promote conflict between groups of disadvantaged workers, rather than making it a right of every citizen to have a living-wage job and health care” (Russel 2019, p. 77). They are part of what Mészáros (2008; 2011) regards as corrections in the structure of the capital. They play a fundamental role in the ontological conservation of capital when softening the tensions between the owners of the capital and the working class. Barnes (1992) advocated in favour of anti-discrimination legislation as a solution to improve the participation of disabled workers in the labour market, as we all should. No one would deny that even within the limits of the capital one should always fight against discrimination, prejudice, and deprivation of access to better living conditions. Notwithstanding, the market finds its ways to ‘dodge’ the legislation. When it comes to disabled workers that usually happens through what Samuels (2014) calls biocertification. Biocertification is the process companies and industries use to certify that a new employee will follow their not-so-secret internal rules, using medical reports, exams, and tests. By means of biocertification processes individuals are reduced to their biological characteristics and are erased as social subjects, “[b]iocertification materializes the modern belief that only science can reliably determine the truths of identity and generally claims to offer a simple, verifiable, and concrete solution to questions of identity” (Samuels 2014, p. 122). The structure of capital and its relations of material and cultural production, distribution, and exchange convey ideological models of individuals, social relations, and patterns of social behaviour that must be assimilated to guarantee the right to actively participate in everyday life, from the most trivial activities to the most complex forms of social participation. These representations will revolve around the notions of gender, race, age, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and, in the case of the working classes, labour skills. They carry labels of non-deviant and deviant. The archetype of an ideal individual is linked to the project of society: Hence, the oppression that disabled people face is rooted in the economic and social structures of capitalism. And this oppression is structured by racism, sexism, homophobia, ageism, and disablism, which is endemic to all capitalist societies and cannot be explained away as a universal cognitive process. (Oliver 1990, p. 165). Oliver is arguing that the foundations of prejudice are in fact part of the ideological structure of capitalism. It a structure founded on an ideological and hegemonic set of “ideas, values, belief systems, habits and practices that defend and legitimise the interests of groups at the expense of other groups in relationships of inequality” (Wayne 2020, p. 136, author’s highlights). Hence, it is important here to clarify my understanding of five concepts that are usually present in discussions of inequality, prejudice, and disability: oppression, segregation, exploitation, and inclusion/exclusion. It is my understanding that, from a materialist perspective, they are all class-related issues. Oppression derives from the idea that due to one or more deviant characteristics one is deprived from access to some or all material, cultural, and social conditions that would allow them to carry on a fulfilling life or, as Wright (2019) calls it, a flourishing life. Oppression represents an image of someone being crushed, smashed, held (socially) against their own will and despite their own efforts to change. Oppression is a product of ideologies embedded in the social structure of capitalism and it is related to inequality. Segregation revolves around marginalisation. The social process in which those who are unable to follow one or more social expectations are centrifuged, sent to the borders of society. They are not welcomed to participate in everyday life. Segregation comes as an alternative to the idea of social exclusion, as we shall see below. Exploitation, in turn, is the essential concept that sustains capital every day. The act of extracting surplus value out of those who own nothing else but their labour power (Marx 2012). Stripped of all properties and material conditions, workers have no way to sustain life other than by selling their labour power to those who own those material conditions. Modern capitalism, however, has become even more complex than it used to be when Marx’s wrote Das Kapital (Wright 2019). In order to guarantee its own survival, the structure of class conditions was reshaped based on the social and technical divisions of labour. Different class interests will clash between those who own the capital, those in positions that require higher qualification and more sophisticated skills (the modern middle-classes), and the ones performing jobs that are socially characterised as lower jobs (Wayne 2020). A material approach to these concepts understands that the condition of class will determine - imposing starting points, limits, and ends, as Williams (1988) and Wright (2019) define it - their extensions and impacts on an individual’s life. It means to say that one may be segregated but not so much oppressed. So, the extent of the processes of oppression, segregation, and exploitation is class-determined. Going back to Wayne’s definition of ideology, he understands that: there is capitalism itself which has a built-in cultural tendency to decontextualise social phenomena, individualise social phenomena and de-historicise social phenomena. We may also add that capitalism prematurely or falsely universalises capitalist culture and value systems (e.g., the only way to live) (Wayne 2020, p. 137). Therefore, there is a paramount comprehension of capitalist practices when it comes to the analysis of the disabling phenomena. When we look at Marx’s exposition of the sphere of pauperism, we were in fact targeting how this process of decontextualisation, individualisation, and de-historicisation affect those who are considered unable to adapt. Historically and traditionally, capitalist ideologies have treated disability as a personal, individual tragedy, which is brought out of context and history, in an attempt to exempt society from any obligations it might have. Against this, Russel (2019, p. 51) argues that: Our institutions (particularly medical and social welfare institutions) have historically held disablement to be an individual problem, not the result of economic or social forces. They have equated disability with physiological, anatomical, or mental “defects” and hegemonically held these conditions responsible for the disabled person’s lack of full participation in the economic life of our society. This approach presumed a biological inferiority of disabled persons. Their deviation from social models of adaptation to everyday life and productivity in the cycle of the capital, established by social standards of normality, promotes processes of social marginalisation, from institutionalising policies of discrimination to deprivation of social participation (Barnes 2012; Bueno 2001; Ferreira 1994; Vygotski 2004). It is in and from everyday life that the concepts, values, and norms that represent, regulate and organise a concrete social formation are executed (Heller 2016). Daily life is the expression of the real life of the subjects that are part of it, it is the immediate unity of action and thought and expression of concepts, values and norms formed from the hegemonic ideology conveyed and foisted upon individuals (Chauí 2016; Heller 2016). Everyday life is ordinary thinking, common sense, and the expression of uncritical thinking. It is the embodiment of men's life, and it is from it that they express their truth, build their beliefs, and guide their lives (Heller 2016). Everyday thought, the common sense, is based on experience in the complex ideological network that maintains the socio-metabolic functioning of capital and aims at the “orientation towards stability and relatively quiet social reproduction” (Mészáros 2004, p. 486- 487). The process of stigmatisation in the case of disabled people permeates the complex social construction of everyday life. The distancing of adaptation to the patterns of normality established in everyday life crystallises the stigma and removes from the person with an impairment the condition of ‘human’ and projects it socially as the ‘non-human’ – as Marx’s pointed out a spectre to political economy. The representation of the stigma occurs by a reduction of the subject to only one of its characteristics - usually that which is downgraded or socially overvalued (Goffman 1963). The possible overcoming of these conditions, or even the performance of more basic daily actions, can raise the stigmatised subject to the condition of superhuman, keeping them still in a non-human status. A stigmatised person may, however, reformulate the rules when they reach a position a social prestige. They are taken to the level of representation of their group and will be considered the example of self-determination, meritocracy, and success (Goffman 1963; McNamee & Miller 2009; Wayne & Cabral 2021). Leonard Kriegel (1987) scrutinised the images of representation of disabled characters reproduced in literature and narrowed them down to four categories, namely: Demonic cripple, Charity cripple, Realistic cripple, and Survivor Cripple. I will not discuss all of these categories, but the last one may be useful here to illustrate my previous arguments. The Survivor Cripple “[…] is the man who endures and, in his endurance, discovers survival as a cause in itself […]. His endurance is attractive, both to himself and to the audience, for it is constructed around his understanding of the limitations it has imposed on him.” (KRIEGEL, 1987, p. 38). The survivor cripple is the counterpart of the disabled person as pitiable and pathetic, as an object of pity, it is the representation of meritocratic values - the one who fights against all odds and thrives. The bridge between class conditions and the idea of a (disabled) survivor relies on capitalist meritocracy that seems to be reproduced in the image of the survivor, both in the lower and in the middle classes. The image of the disabled person has been used as a motivational strategy, to trigger feelings of determination, and has been associated with struggle and the power to overcome difficulties, usually followed by the question “What is your excuse?”. This may be perceived in the real-life based cinematic representations of disability, as they may imprint more credibility and cause a greater effect on the audiences. The Survivor Cripple makes the impairment a tragedy and overcoming it the objective or the solution to the problem. The use of disability in motivational campaigns and films projects the disabled person as an object of ridicule and as their own worst and only enemy – “if they wanted, they could.” – and cement meritocratic values – “if they did, what’s your excuse?”. As examples, I could mention the biographical films based on the lives of Christy Brown (Sheridan 2008), Gabriela Brimmer (Mandoki 1987), and Stephen Hawking (Marsh 2014). The decades after 1990 have been marked by various events and political and social reviews on the role and place of disabled people in society (Jannuzzi 2004). However, the system of justification and ideological reproduction of stereotypes in the categorisation of the socially conceived human body, the labour body and mind, as perfect permeates concrete social relationships in everyday life and triggers processes of stigmatisation of the deviants (Samuels 2014; Stone 1984). Stigma is thus very much in constant relation with the ideologies that are working through culture – as I have demonstrated with some examples in the previous paragraph. Competence, structured by bourgeois ideological pillars, conveyed by the media, and absorbed by the cultural industry, sells signs and images of youth, health and happiness (Chauí 2016). It is a powerful method of manipulation that “inoculate[s] individuals with the bourgeois appetite for personal success” (Freire 1970, p. 147). The social process of constructing the discourse of the competent produces its dialectical counterpart, the incompetent. The social and ideological role of the competent, valued by the social power of science, as an unquestionable source of knowledge, underlies and justifies the domination and economic exploitation of one class, considered superior in material and cultural capital, over the other, expropriated from the whole (Chauí 2016; Samuels 2014). The analysis of perfection, based on a neoliberal ideology, established mainly after the 1980s (Harvey 2011), subjugates disability in the working class mainly to spaces of pauperism, marginalisation and segregation and is marked by the sociopolitical order and the power of science. The ideological projection of the perfection of productivity, sociability, independence, meritocracy characterises in the opposite pole the lack and the insufficiency, emphasising the defect and erasing individuals beyond their disability and making the construction of their social relations unfeasible (Barnes 2012; Heller 2016; Soldatic & Meekosha 2012a; 2012b; Vygotski 1993). The naturalising element of capital is propagated and foisted upon individuals that reproduce the social structure through complex ideological systems of conservation, keeping individuals locked in the relationships of everyday life. Everyday life is, therefore, the life of every social subject, without being able to be totally out of it or completely trapped by it. It is in everyday life that the dominant metabolic ideological processes are emptied and reified as absolute and natural truths (Heller 2016; Mészáros 2004; 2016). Mészáros (2005, p. 401) argues that the dominant ideology of capitalism is “[…] sustained by the practical evidence of the established material structures within which people have to reproduce the material and cultural conditions of their existence and ‘feel at home as a fish in water’”. Most of the population is conditioned by the ideological standards set by the ruling class. Its ideological structure is: a logical, systematic, and coherent set of representations (ideas and values) and norms or rules (of conduct) that indicate and prescribe to the members of a society what they should think and how they should think about it, what they should value and how they should value it, what they should feel and how they should feel it, what they should do and how they should do it. (Chauí 2016, p. 53). The dominating force of ideology lies in pacification, naturalisation of the hegemonic social organisation and unity of interests, although they are conflicting (Mészáros 2008; Wayne 2020; Zizek 2012). Ideology, in its hegemonic sense, structures life lived and represents “a sense of reality for most people in the society, a sense of absolute because experienced reality beyond which it is very difficult for most members of the society to move, in most areas of their lives” (Williams 1980, p. 38). It is in the everyday life that the ideological patterns of normality are executed. Heller (2016, p. 37) indicates that [t]he maturation of man means, in any society, that the individual acquires all the essential skills for the daily life of the society (social layer) in question. It is an adult who is able to live his daily life for himself. Ideological patterns of normality are socially and historically established attributes and characteristics that are reproduced as natural and ordinary and that categorise subjects as normal and abnormal deviant. They establish the norms that define what it means to be a socially desired human (Amaral 1995; Everlles 2011; Heller 2011). Stigma disqualifies the individual due to a singular characteristic that deviates from the ideological norms and standards imposed and determines the limits of their social participation. Lastly, I would like to go back to inclusion. Inclusion is part of the ideological process of self-correctness and self-preservation of the bourgeois society. It is an attempt to lessen the weight of structural injustices, inequalities, segregations/exclusions that are part of the ontological foundations of the capital. Marx’s thought elucidates how contradictory the concept is: when analysing the production of relative surplus-value, that within the capitalist system all methods for raising the social productivity of labour are put into effect at the cost of the individual worker; that all means for the development of production undergo a dialectical inversion so that they become means of domination and exploitation of the producers. (Marx 1990, p. 799). Some lines below, he famously concludes that: Accumulation of wealth at one pole is, therefore, at the same time accumulation of misery, the torment of labour, slavery, ignorance, brutalization and moral degradation at the opposite pole, i.e., on the side of the class that produces its own product as capital. (Marx 1990, p. 799). Inclusion, therefore, is the movement of opening opportunities to share material and cultural capital with (some of) those who were deprived from access to them. It does so without questioning or challenging the very essence of the society that created deprivation in the first place. Inclusion and exclusion are part of the same dialects. One is the dialectical inversion of the other. The need to include only exists because of a society that engenders exclusion. Thus, as I suggested, exclusion might not be a real thing, in immediate cultural and material access perhaps it does, but not as part of the structure of the system itself, i.e., the individual is not excluded from the system, they are a product of it. Inclusion and exclusion were uncritically adopted by all postmodern studies of identity, and inclusion became a motto to be fought for - as Wayne suggested (2020, p. 39), “change without real change”. In other words, these changes are constrained within the limits of capitalism and do not represent a threat to the structure of the system. Notwithstanding its core contradictions, it is something we shall all fight for. If within the limits and contradictions of the capital this is the only possibility - or the closest possibility - some individuals will have to access a flourishing life - meaning access to education, health, cultural expressions, housing, food - then until the whole system changes, perhaps it is what one should fight for. In the case of disabled people, it applies even to the access or opportunity of access to be exploited – as cruel as this may sound; that is what the “inclusion for disabled people” is in fact fighting for. In that sense, “[b]asic changes must be made in the economic, social, and political structure in order to advance economic solutions that reach beyond capitalism’s instability. The reserve army, itself, must be made a disposable concept” (Russel 2019, p. 77). Despite the limitations of what Wayne calls (following Gramsci) passive revolution – “the paradox of massive change within the social relations of capitalism: change without real change” (Wayne 2020 p. 39, author's highlights) -, these seem to represent a possibility to improve the lives of those who are now in need, not only focusing on disabled people, but also on other forms of discrimination as well. My favourite and paramount argument in that regard is that Every reasonable and reasoned action proposed in an attempt to accelerate the social and political inclusion of the poor in the process of economic development in order to bring equality to social development is historically welcomed. As much within the scope of the State and its public policies as within civil society. It would be equally wicked to deny the diversity of the aspirations and intervention actions in the problematic reality. (Martins 2012, p. 1). Nonetheless, we should not be satisfied with them, for they do not interrupt the flow and the logics of the capital.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- Cap Links

Only our critical analysis of capital at the level of labor functions can explain lived, material realities of disabled bodies as the surplus population.

De Cabral 22 – Vinicius Neves de Cabral holds a PhD in Education from the State University of Londrina and currently works as a lecturer in the Department of Pedagogy at the State University of Parana in Brazil. He is a researcher associated with the Centre for Critical Studies and Research in Education and Social Inequality, and member of the Editorial Board of the The Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies and of the Journal of Class and Culture. His main research interests lie in the fields of education, culture, literature, and film, drawing on Marxist methodologies. Recently published articles: (1) The Portrait of Exclusion in Brazilian Universities: the limits of inclusion, (2) Roma: images of dictatorial regimes and Human Rights abuse in Latin America, and (3) Capitalism, Class and Meritocracy: A Cross-National Study Between the UK and Brazil. (Vinícius Neves de Cabral, “A Marxist Approach to Disability: Notes on Marx’s Relative Surplus Population”, State University of Paraná (UNESPAR), Brazil and State University of Londrina, pgs. 41-51, June 2022, ) || PZ

Capitalism, Disability, and the relative surplus population I would like to start by establishing the grounds on which I shall build my reflections. My first and final argument is that disability in capitalism is a social product of the contradictions produced by the clash between forces of exploitation and forces of labour. It is rather important to clarify, perhaps to the despair of postmodern perspectives (Eagleton 1998; 2016; Harvey 1990), that I shall focus my considerations on what we could call a materialist universalising view of the body and the mind, a body and mind that are expected by capitalism, the labour body/mind. The body/mind that is able to work and to sell its labour force in the market, so that it may extract surplus value from this abled-to-work body/mind. The contrast of the abled labour body/mind is the disabled body/mind, which is a term “used to classify persons deemed less exploitable or not exploitable by the owning class who control the means of production in a capitalist economy” (Russel 2019, p. 42). Those “deemed less exploitable or not exploitable”, deviant from the ideal labour body/mind, may be considered part of what Karl Marx calls a Stagnant Surplus Population (Figure 1), or the third category of the Relative Surplus Population (floating, latent, and stagnant) or Industrial Reserve Army (Marx 1990) – discussed in chapter 25 “The General Law of Capitalist Accumulation” of the first volume of the Capital. Although a famous quotation amongst Marxists is commonly used to summarise the author’s arguments3 , I would like to linger a little longer on his discussion of the Relative Surplus Population in order to establish a theoretical connection between a stagnant surplus population and the materiality of the lives of people labelled disabled in the capitalist society of the 21st century. Marx (1990, p. 794) argues that The relative surplus population exists in all kinds of forms. Every worker belongs to it during the time when he is only partially employed or wholly employed. Leaving aside the large-scale and periodically recovering forms that the changing phases of the industrial cycle impress on it, so that it sometimes appears acute, in times of crisis, and sometimes chronic, in times when business is slack, we can identify three forms which it always possesses: the floating, the latent, and the stagnant. David Harvey (2010, p. 145) clarifies that the surplus population is what “permits capitalists to super-exploit their workers without regard for their health or wellbeing”. Marx understands that there is a relation between the growth and accumulation of capital and the demand for a labour force, as capital expands so does the need for more workers - “[a]ccumulation of capital is therefore multiplication of the proletariat” (Marx 1990, p. 764). However, if the number of workers employed increases, so does the price of labour - an increase on wages - which means “a reduction in the unpaid labour the worker has to supply” (Marx 1990, p. 770). Despite its apparent simplicity, this movement is nevertheless more complex than it appears to be4 , but it can be summarised as follows: it is capitalistic accumulation itself that constantly produces, and produces in the direct ratio of its own energy and extent, a relativity redundant population of labourers, i.e., a population of greater extent than suffices for the average needs of the self-expansion of capital, and therefore a surplus-population. (Marx 1990, p. 782, my highlights). For starters, we should not forget that the sole aim of the capitalist is to produce profit5 . Capitalists are ruled by what Harvey calls “the coercive laws of competition” (2010, p. 146), in Marx’s words: “a coercive force external to him” (1990, p. 381). When wages rise, they become an obstacle between capitalists and the maximum amount of profit that can be extracted. More elements will then come into place, among others, the intensification of the exploitation of the work force and the use of technology to increase productivity and profitability (Harvey 2010; 2011; Marx 1990). One example that may be useful to illustrate such an abstract relation is that of bank workers in Brazil in the last 30 years. In the 1990s, bank employees in Brazil created influential labour unions to exert pressure on banks, therefore demanding higher quality jobs - higher salaries, less working hours, more job places, amongst others. When going on strikes, until the early 2000s, those unions would still have some influence in the decision-making process in the organisation of banks. In 2020, the widespread use of the new technology, which allows users to solve most of their needs using their smartphones, has caused demands for higher productivity, wage drops, more working hours, and an increase in unemployment in the sector - industrial reserve army. While strikes of the sector in the 1990s were catastrophic (crowds of employees on the streets, freezing of banks, very little or no money available, the support of the population), a strike in 2020 gathers a few dozen with signs in the streets that are usually ignored by most passerby, looking down at their smartphones. Leading us then to an important hallmark of capitalist labour exploitation practices: The Industrial Reserve Army as a regulator of the tensions between the exploiters and the exploited. As capital multiplies and grows, it also tends to follow two internal movements, namely concentration and centralisation. Respectively, the augmentation of capital and control of this capital in the hands of fewer people. At the other pole, it also produces what Marx called in the previous quote “a relatively redundant working population”, that is, the surplus population (Marx 1990, p. 782). This surplus population forms an army of workers who may at times be absorbed or rejected by the capital, according to the capital’s own needs (variation in the number of workers in a certain area), requirements (level of education, expertise, and/or experience), rules (wages/salaries, working hours, holidays, health insurance). In other words, “the working population therefore produces both the accumulation of capital and the means by which it is itself made relatively superfluous; and it does this to an extent to which is always increasing” (Marx 1990, p. 783). In the case of Brazilian bank clerks, the introduction of new technological machinery, as Marx calls it, allowed banks to dispose of thousands of employees and change the rules of the game, it developed new needs and new requirements. The first category of the relative surplus population characterises workers that are “sometimes repelled, sometimes attracted again in greater masses” by the job markets (Marx 1990, p. 794). A modern example may be the situation of engineering workers in Brazil - when the economy is growing, they are the first ones to be absorbed and to get higher salaries and better conditions of work. However, as the economy slows, they are repelled by the companies, made redundant, and will be unemployed again. The latent category represents those with potential to be part of the capitalist labour force but are in agricultural areas still struggling to survive with their own practices against massive capitalist companies; it is the representation of the death of a rural lifestyle. As cities and companies grow, they swallow small family farms and ranches, leaving those families with no other option but to sell their properties to the big companies, move to the cities, and sell their labour force. It is a situation portrayed in literature by Theodore Dreiser in The Lost Phoebe (1918) and by Graciliano Ramos in Vidas Secas (1938), and more recently in the American sitcom The Ranch (2016-2020), and vastly discussed in the works of Raymond Williams. The last category, the stagnant, is formed by those who must subject themselves to the lowest conditions of work, to the most irregular forms of employment, and to “a maximum of working time and a minimum of wages” (Marx 1990, p. 796) - a sediment of the working class that lives in the poorest conditions of life. Now that we have reached the stagnant category, we should remember that when Marx is discussing the three forms of relative surplus population, he is categorising workers, in other words, those who are forced to sell their workforce because they do not own any means of production – der Arbeitsmensch. They are those who are able to sell their workforce; those who are at their full capacity in body and mind to create surplus value at the lowest cost, with the lowest adaptation possible, as it is remarked by Marx (1990) and by Engels (1987). In contrast, when dealing with disability, we are considering those who have been labelled by capitalist practices, symbols, and meanings as disabled, unproductive, and as a burden to the rest of the working class. A burden to the rest of the working class because “what becomes of the operative…, in case he cannot work, is no concern of the employer” (Engels 1987, p. 543). Engels here sheds light on an important element of our discussion: the class condition is a fundamental aspect of analysis when we are discussing disability. Marx (1990, p.797, my highlights) enumerates three categories of those who dwell in pauperism – the lowest sediment of the relative surplus population’, (1) those who are able to work but who are not working; (2) orphans and pauper children; and, finally, (3) ‘the demoralized (sic), the ragged, and those unable to work, chiefly people who succumb to their incapacity for adaptation, an incapacity which results from the division of labour… Note that here he is dealing with the incapacity of adaptation. And he goes on to identify these workers as those “who have lived beyond the worker’s average lifespan; and the victims of industry… the mutilated, the sick…” (1990, p. 797, my highlights). Marx approaches both the issues of ageism and ableism in the same category to indicate that those who are deemed useless by capitalist practices and excluded from the labour market will dwell in pauperism. To clarify, pauperism is The hospital of the active labour-army and the dead weight of the industrial reserve army. Its production is included in that of the relative surplus population, its necessity is implied by their necessity; along with the surplus population, pauperism forms a condition of capitalist production, and of the capitalist development of wealth. It forms part of the faux frais of capitalist production: but capital usually knows how to transfer these from its own shoulders to those of the working-class and the petty bourgeoisie. (Marx 1990, p. 797). It seems to be implied that he differentiates the surplus population and pauperism. They are both conditioned to the ontological structure of the capitalist system and its ongoing wealth-making process. When Marx brings them together, he binds them, stating that one will be responsible for the other (the dead weight of the industrial reserve army), he is providing arguments against the traditional categorisation of disability as a personal and individual problem. Once again, disability is approached as a social, cultural, historical, and class-related issue. In a recent study, Santos (2020) scrutinised data on the living conditions of the Brazilian population comparing and contrasting the categories of race, gender, and disability with class condition. The author identifies how these elements come together to derail people’s access to a flourishing life in a racist, sexist/ patriarchal ableism, neoliberal Brazilian society. According to her, 30,06% of the population with a disability live with within the range of 0-1 minimum wage (R$ 1,100 reais) – in Brazil this means deprivation from a wide variety of essential goods and services, i.e., living in pauperism or close to pauperism. From another geographical perspective, in the United States, according to Erevelles (2011, p. 56), “[…] “one out of every four disabled people lives below the poverty line, and more than 75 percent have an individual income of less than $20,000.” In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx discusses the existence (Dasein) of the Arbeitsmensch in the labour-capital relationship. He points out that “[p]olitical economy… does not recognise the unoccupied worker, den Arbeitsmenschen, in so far as he happens to be outside [the] labourrelationship” (1988, p. 86), that is, it does not recognise their Dasein, their existence. According to Marx, “they are figures (Gestalten)…, specters(sic) (Gespenster) outside the domain of political economy” (1988, p. 86). Those deemed less exploitable or not exploitable are ghosts to a system that values profit over anything else. As I pointed out, when we consider the “class-disability” relationship in the working class, we are dealing with the sphere of pauperism – those on the lowest, poorest, most degrading conditions of life. These are either those who refuse to follow the system of discipline imposed by the capital or those who deviate from the ideal labour body/mind. Harvey (2010, p.149) points out that: there is the problem of what to do with people who don't conform and are therefore dubbed odd or even deviant. And this is Foucault's as well as Marx's point: they are called mad or antisocial and incarcerated in insane asylums or prisons; or as Marx notes, they get put in the stocks, mocked and punished. To be a "normal" person, therefore, is to accept a certain kind of spatiotemporal discipline convenient to a capitalist mode of production. What Marx demonstrates is that this isn't normal at all - it's a social construct that arose during this historical period in this particular way and for these particular reasons. According to Harvey, to be normal is to conform. Those who deviate will be labelled as abnormal, irrelevant, will be deemed useless, and set aside. So, normality does exist for capitalism – and it is very specific. On the one hand, it does not mean that we should simply accept it as a universal truth. On the other hand, we should not deny normality either but address it and question it. Theoretical and methodological perspectives that aim to refuse the existence of these antagonistic forces – normality and abnormality – in capitalist practices, symbols, and meanings, in an attempt to promote equality and the so-called inclusion, contribute to the ontological reproduction of the system that created the antagonism in the first place. Labelled as irrelevant and disposable to the political and economic structure, disabled people may be allocated in the Stagnant category of the Relative Surplus Population. In fact, even when they are absorbed by the system in times of need or when the system is forced to absorb them by affirmative action policies, those in the stagnant category “can be rendered superfluous at the slightest downturn of the business cycle” (Russel 2019, p. 76). Barnes (1992, p. 55) defines disability as “a diverse system of social constraints imposed on people with impairments by a highly discriminatory society — to be a disabled person means to be discriminated against”. A social approach to disability, therefore, does not deny the impairment, but understands that there is a socio-historical difference between impairment, disability, and disabled: the impairment is biological, the disability is social, and disabled is the end result of disabling a person with an impairment6 . Vygotsky (1993, p. 36) argues that “[i]n the final analysis, what decides the fate of a personality is not the defect [impairment in today’s terminology] itself, but its social consequences”. And it is this socio-psychological realisation that may or may not be a disabling one. In their development, disabled children will only require processes that will stimulate them in other ways rather than those traditionally applied at home, school, and any other social situation. As deviants of the patterns of normality, however, disabled people are many times completely or partially deprived of social participation. Deviant bodies and minds are expected to either follow the stabilised rules of society or not be part of it at all. Let us take a scene in Jack Nicholson’s One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest as an example. His character, Randle P. McMurphy, is in the swimming pool of a total institution for those considered mentally ill and/or intellectually disabled and tells one of guards that within six days he is going to leave the institution. To his surprise, according to the guard, he will only leave the institution when allowed to, when the doctors and nurses consider that he is able to adjust to social order. Randle is only pretending to have a disability to dodge prison, but to many of his companions it means never leaving the institution, because according to the rules, requirements, and needs of the capital they have already been deemed deviant and disposable or, as Harvey put it, they are “incarcerated in insane asylums or prisons […] they get put in the stocks, mocked and punished” (2010, p. 149).

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- Root Cause

The white body becomes the center of disability, creating a savage degeneracy at the heart of disabled blackness

Tommy Curry 17 [JOURNAL of SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY, Vol. 48 No. 3, Fall 2017, 321–343., “This Nigger’s Broken: Hyper-Masculinity, the Buck, and the Role of Physical Disability in White Anxiety Toward the Black Male Body,” African American scholar, author and professor of philosophy. As of 2019, he holds a Personal Chair in Africana philosophy and Black male studies at the University of Edinburgh. In 2018, he won an American Book Award for The Man-Not: Race, Class, Genre, and the Dilemmas of Black Manhood, -ekh-]

On September 23, 2015, Mr. Jeremy McDole was executed by Wilmington, Delaware police officers. Mr. McDole was allegedly a threat to himself and suicidal. The police were responding to a “911 call reporting that [Mr. McDole] had shot himself.”1 The 911 caller can be heard yelling: “A man just shot himself in the AutoZone parking lot ... he’s fallen out of a wheelchair.”2 Mr. McDole was reported to the police as a victim, not a criminal. He was described as a disabled man with injury. A man who was suicidal; in need of help. His need, his victimhood, was not seen. He was not recognized by the police as a vulnerable person. He was seen as a Black man; a threat—a body marked for death by the danger he posed to others. This stereotype applied to his body, despite him being confined to a wheelchair. Like the deaths of hundreds of other Black males in America, his execution was recorded and subsequently released to the American public for summary judgment—just or unjust killing of a Black man. Unlike the hundreds of Black men killed every year in America, however, Mr. McDole was paralyzed from the waist down from an injury he sustained after being shot at the age of 18. What threat did this disabled Black man pose to anyone? Was he armed? Did he have a gun? These are the questions that define Black male death in this country, and despite Mr. McDole’s disability, they now define him. Why is it so easy to frame the lives of Black men and boys by one act, that same moment all the public sees where it is almost willed in unison that these Black males are in fact yearning for death? What was it about him being Black-male-disabled that resists consideration—did not diffuse the presumed danger—and convey that he was not a threat?

2022 Michigan Kritik

1NC --- Link

Their attempt to refuse ableism within the structures of civil society is only the upending of a conflict that mystifies the fundamental antagonism that structures civil society and the world writ large: The non-being of blackness – Anti-blackness provides coherence to the “human” subject.

Kim 13,[ Hyo K. Kim, an assistant professor of English at Medgar Evers College, City University of New York, where he teaches Asian American literature and literary theory. He is currently involved in two research projects; one editing a collection of critical essays on Theresa Cha’s Dictee; another is a book-length study exploring the connections between minor affects and the aesthetics of minority literatures in the United States, Published in Penumbra: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Critical and Creative Inquiry, , JMH]

For instance, what at first glance seems merely naïve―that is the observation that in the U.S. “[b]eing disabled is just like being black”―actually does index how disability cannot be synonymous with Whiteness. For what is suggested through the forced parity between the construction of blackness and disability is that the disabled body or mind cannot properly embody Whiteness in toto. And that is what Anna Stubblefield demonstrates in “‘Beyond the Pale’: Tainted Whiteness, Cognitive Disability and Eugenic Sterilization,” which iterates how disabled white persons have historically been categorized as embodying a tainted form of whiteness. She convincingly argues that beginning from the 1800s in the U.S. those who were considered feebleminded, a form of cognitive disability, lost the full privileges attendant with white citizenship. As she writes, “… to grasp feeblemindedness fully as a signifier of tainted whiteness, it is important to understand that the state-sponsored, involuntary sterilization of tainted whites meant that they had, in effect, lost the full protection that whiteness conferred in a white supremacist society” (178; emphasis added). Not only did the so-called feebleminded whites come to embody a compromised form of whiteness but also the “ … white men [and women] labeled as criminal, sexually deviate, homosexual, … or insane … ” (Stubblefield 178). What Stubblefield emphasizes is that disability as a social construct cannot easily be detached from its imbricated positioning within a network of material forces that include not only race but sexuality, class, and gender. Her study foregrounds the need for Disability studies to attend to racialization as not a tangential focus but central to its overall theoretical and political project. Interestingly Stubblefield’s study of how disability can dispossess whites of their “full personhood” under U.S. law seemingly lends support to what “Dismodernism” authorizes, which is the idea that the suffering of blacks can be made equivalent to not only what disabled whites come to embody but also to all those other Others represented under the category of “people of color.” In short, disability has the potential to democratize civil society by recalling how all citizens are common in their humanity―that is, equally exposed to disability. Yet, if we read between the lines of Stubblefield’s summary of how “feebleminded whites” can become “tainted,” the singularity of “blackness’s grammar of suffering” emerges. For what distinguishes “blackness grammar of suffering” is how it does not operate according to the assumptive logic of capability. In other words, to approach “blackness’s grammar of suffering,” Wilderson insists that one must be able to imagine “an ethicality … so terrifying that, as a space to be inhabited and terror to be embraced” (41), it resists language. It is a “grammar of suffering” based not upon the logic of a “lost” capacity but that of a deontologized property, the Slave that is not “exploited and alienated” but rather “accumulated and fungible.” The effect of this singular grammar on Asian American and Disability studies is significant, but the impact of Wilderson’s critique on the “scholarly and aesthetic production” of the “Black theorist” is radical by comparison. As he writes: This [“blackness’s grammar suffering”] makes the labor of disavowal in Black scholarly and aesthetic production doubly burdensome, for it is triggered by a dread of both being ‘discovered,’ and of discovering oneself, as ontological incapacity. Thus, through borrowed institutionality―the feigned capacity to be essentially exploited and alienated (rather than accumulated and fungible) in the first ontological instance (in other words, a fantasy to be just like everyone else, which is a fantasy to be)―the work of Black film theory [and by extension Black studies] operates through a myriad of compensatory gestures in which the Black theorists assumes subjective capacity to be universal and thus ‘finds’ it everywhere. (42) Placed within the frame of “blackness’s grammar of suffering,” I want to examine the consequences of Davis’s attempt to render disability cosmopolitan. While the move has the virtual effect of equalizing all bodies around human capacity to suffer―such an ethical cum political strategy requires the disavowal of how concepts such as “human” and “civil society” in the U.S. have structurally depended on the production of social death, i.e. the Black (and the Red). As it should be obvious by now, what is therefore unthinkable in Davis’s attempt to make civil society cohere around the universality of human suffering is the contingent nature of the term human itself. This in fact is what Bells intuits but cannot name in his influential essay entitled “Introducing White Disability Studies: A Modest Proposal.” Bell’s hesitation is partly attributable to how pain or suffering is both social (that is communicable, sharable by all humans in equal measure) and incommunicable within Disability studies. That is, Disability studies’ uneven attention to the incommunicability of suffering is seemingly capable of accommodating the unrepresentability that is constituent of “blackness’s grammar of suffering.” As Siebers insists, “[i]ndividuality derived from the incommunicability of pain easily enforces a myth of hyperindividuality, a sense that each individual is locked in solitary confinement where suffering is the only object of contemplation. People with disabilities are already too politically isolated for this myth to be attractive” (176). Yet in an attempt to intervene in the poststructuralist tendency to idealize “physical pain” as site of either transcendent power or pleasure, Siebers also adds, “… [p]hysical pain is [at once] highly individualistic, unpredictable, and raw as reality. Pain is not a resource of political change. It is not a well of delight for the individual” (178). What is directly pertinent to the present essay is how the universal figure of the “individual”- human marks the critical horizon of Disability theory. Or, to put a finer point to it via Widerson’s reading of Frantz Fanon’s Black Skin, White Mask, “… the Negro … ‘is comparison,’ nothing more and certainly nothing less, for what is less than comparison? … [And as such] ‘No one knows yet who [the Negro] is, but he knows that fear will fill the world when the world finds out’” (42). We find in the most sophisticated Asian Americanist deployment of poststructuralist strategies of reading―such as the one advanced in the influential work by Kandice Chuh―a similar call to abandon politics based on social identity.6 While I am in agreement with both Davis’s and Chuh’s overarching critique of uniform identity, I find troubling their wholesale critique of all identity formation as a priori essentialist. For such framing of social identity as necessarily restrictive can only lead to the return of the repressed in our present era of colorblindness―the ideal of abstract citizenship. As she writes: “‘Asian American’ … connotes the violence, exclusion, dislocation, and disenfranchisement that has attended the codification of certain bodies as variously, Oriental, yellow, sometimes brown, inscrutable, devious, always alien. It speaks to the active denial of personhood to the individuals inhabiting those bodies” (Chuh 27). In this, Chuh―along with Davis and Siebers―unwittingly announces the displacement and the erasure of “blackness’s grammar of suffering,” as their strategies of reading the presence or absence of justice within U.S. civil society is predicated upon exploitation and alienation of the a priori human subject. Nevertheless, by embodying the self―Disability studies helps to shift (though only slightly) critical theory toward an alternative ethicality that does not programmatically endorse the idea and ideals of abstract citizenship. For contrary to the liberal model of the political subject that achieves “hyperindividuality” through social and material detachment, the alternative model of subjectivity that is afforded through the disabled body is a self that is always already in the process of negotiating complex relations to the materiality of the social. Thus, the embodied model of subjectivity helps to re-imagine “personhood” as relation itself, leading not to the reification or essentialization of self, this relational model of subjectivity demands that any identity whatsoever be thought not as autonomous substance but rather as a site, comprising of unfinished, mobile, heterogeneously constituted relations across an embodied hermeneutic horizon. It bears mentioning here that it is this interconnected and radically open vision of “personhood” as relation that is foreclosed in the liberal model of abstract citizenship. For in the liberal model of the self, the ideal is to attain singular indeterminacy through the negation of such social relations, without which no self can hope to attain intelligibility. As Alcoff’s important work suggests: Social identities … are more properly understood as sites from which we perceive, act, and engage with others. These sites are not simply locations or positions, but also hermeneutic horizons comprised of experiences, basic beliefs, and communal values […] . We are not boxed in by them, constrained, restricted, or held captive―unless … it makes sense to say that we are boxed in by the fact that we have bodies . … (287) Interestingly it is by attending to how the self is embodied and embedded in social reality that clarifies the radical singularity of the Black’s structural non-relationality, which in turn helps to bring into focus not only what Wilderson calls the “structural antagonisms” that contour U.S. civil society but also unexplored ethico-political limits and possibilities of sub-fields such as Disability and Asian American studies. For according to Wilderson’s Red, White & Black what gives internal coherence to such terms as “human” and “civil society” in the U.S. is the disavowal of the structural (historical) relation blacks have with what is essentially non-human, a form of social death known as slavery. As he summarizes: During the emergence of new ontological relations in the modern world, from the late Middle Ages through the 1500s, many different kinds of people experienced slavery. … But African, or more precisely Blackness, refers to an individual who is by definition always already void of relationality. Thus modernity marks the emergence of a new ontology because it is an era in which an entire race appears, people who, a priori, that is prior to the contingency of the ‘transgressive act’ (such as losing a war or being convicted of a crime), stand as socially dead in relation to the rest of the world. (17-8) Wilderson’s intervention therefore hinges on isolating and exposing this dual operation by which civil society makes sense of itself to itself―the simultaneous disavowal of and parasitic dependency on the Black. In other words, the desire to make blackness an analogue of disability amounts to denying the structural relevancy of slavery to the formation of U.S. civil society. Wilderson’s reading of Fanon helps to articulate the radical singularity of “blackness’s grammar of suffering,” as it emphasizes how “… the gratuitous violence of the Black’s first ontological instance, the Middle Passage, ‘wiped out [his or her] metaphysics … his [or her] customs and sources on which they are based.’ Jews went into Auschwitz and came out as Jews. Africans went into the ships and came out as Blacks” (38). What Wilderson calls the “blackness’s grammar of suffering,” consequently, has no analogue in either the assumptive figure of the “individual” that subtends Disability studies and those other Others within U.S. civil society that have become included within the frame known as “people of color.” In this, “blackness’s grammar of suffering” gestures toward what is unnamable, a form of suffering that is in excess of any ethical language which is based upon the universal figure of the human. This is how Wilderson radically undermines the desire to transpose “blackness’s grammar of suffering” into the ethico-political language upon which civil society’s depends to make suffering (physical, psychic or otherwise) intelligible. As he writes: The ruse of analogy erroneously locates Blacks in the world―a place where they have not been since the dawn of Blackness. This attempt to position the Black in the world by way of analogy is not only a mystification, and often erasure, of Blackness’s grammar of suffering (accumulation and fungibility or the status of being non-Human) but simultaneously also a provision for civil society, promising an enabling modality for Human ethical dilemmas. It is a mystification and an erasure because … their grammars of suffering are irreconcilable. (37) Such is the logic that animates Bell’s critique of Disability studies but it does not, cannot obtain the force of Wilderson’s intervention because Bell cannot or dare not disarticulate the Black from the world. Nevertheless both Wilderson and Bell help foreground the important fact that even suffering obtains a “grammar,” that is, has a way of indexing―whether positively in the form of identification or negatively through dis- or even through non-identification, the presence or absence of a world. What Bell’s and especially Wilderson’s critique bring into sharp relief is that anti-blackness is part and parcel of the episteme that gives internal coherence to U.S. civil society. To approach “blackness’s grammar suffering” is therefore to contemplate, albeit always indirectly, not the paradigm of disability which is always already predicated on agency but a radical non-capacity. Wilderson’s illumination of how the “antagonism” that obtains around blackness is structural to the formation of U.S. civil society has the effect of clarifying the positioning of sub-fields such as Disability and Asian American studies, especially when their protocols aim toward establishing some form of political justice based upon “exploitation and alienation,” which is at odds with “blackness’s grammar of suffering.” As previously mentioned, Wilderson draws a sharp distinction between “conflict” and “antagonism.” And this is key, as it is only when anti-blackness is positioned as an “antagonism” that the residual and structural effects of the Slave (the non-human) can be allowed to erupt into the living present of U.S. civil society. As such, though by comparison far more optimistic than Wilderson’s study, Alexander’s The New Jim Crow (2010) gives powerful evidence to Wilderson’s theory of the “structural antagonisms” that contour U.S. civil society. This is how a critical theory based upon advancing a colorblind world or an ethicality based upon the universal human effectively silences the suffering of the Black. As Alexander argues: Far from being a worthy goal … colorblindness has proved catastrophic for African Americans. It is not an overstatement to say that the systematic mass incarceration of people of color in the United States would not have been possible in the post-civil rights era if the nation had not fallen under the spell of a callous colorblindness. … Saying that one does not care about race is offered as an exculpatory virtue, when in fact it can be a form of cruelty. … Our blindness also prevents us from seeing the racial and structural divisions that persist in society: the segregated, unequal schools, the segregated, jobless ghettos, and the segregated public discourse―a public conversation that excludes the current pariah of caste [the incarcerated black males in U.S. civil society]. (228) In this, Wilderson’s Red, White, & Black and Alexander’s The New Jim Crow bring into sharp focus why the framing of blackness within U.S. civil society cannot do without the ruse of analogy which effectively puts under erasure a “… violence which turns a body into flesh, ripped apart literally and imaginatively, destroy[ing] the possibility of ontology because it positions the Black in an infinite and indeterminately horrifying and open vulnerability, an object made available (which is to say fungible) for any subject” (Wilderson, 38). Put otherwise, this “violence” which is in excess of that ideologically saturated term called Humanity demands the infinitely difficult yet necessary encountering with what gives U.S. civil society the simulacrum of ethical and political decency.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2NC --- A2: Mollow

The aff cannot solve – violence against the disabled is inevitable and attempting to reconcile creates more violence

Mollow, 15 [Anna Mollow, University of California, Berkeley; Ph.D. in English, Tufts University; B.A. in English & French, Minor in Women’s Studies, has written countless books in disability studies, Spring 2015, Berkeley, “The Disability Drive” -ekh- + jmk]

Afterword: Done with the Drive?

2022 Michigan Kritik

Disability must be politicized---this is the only way to secure collective rights---the retreat from politics reifies ableist tropes of charity politics and naively tries to wish problems away

Ruckelshaus 17, (Jay Ruckelshaus is a Rhodes Scholar and graduate student in political theory at the University of Oxford, and the founder and president of Ramp Less Traveled, a nonprofit organization that helps students with spinal cord injuries pursue higher education, The Non-Politics of Disability, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/18/opinion/denouncing-trump-wont-help-disability-rights.html)

Disability rights enjoy a seemingly ironclad moral consensus, an ostensible unanimity that is striking given America’s entrenched polarization and the antagonism surrounding other identity movements. Many are wary of L.G.B.T. rights or the Black Lives Matter movement, but it seems beyond the pale — almost cruel — to oppose disability rights. Nobody wants to be anti-disability. Initially, this harmony would seem helpful. Free from partisan discord, advancements for the approximately 57 million Americans with disabilities should be easier to achieve, borne aloft by the wings of certain progress. Why, then, do rampant unemployment and educational disparities endure, and why does success remain the exception? I think part of the reason is the insulation of our pro-disabled political consensus. Its logic is rooted not in any deep belief in the equal worth of citizens with disabilities, but rather in a general aversion to disability. This is related to the charity impulse that has always surrounded disability — and has constrained liberation efforts by assuming that inequities are unfortunate but natural realities to be mitigated through compassion, rather than politically structured injustices. There is also a profound lack of disabled people in the public sphere, meaning any substantive discussion that does occur is extremely rare. I suspect many people I talk to about disability maintain an implicit hope that, if they nod as vigorously as possible, the issue will simply go away. In this way, support for disability rights is similar to the act of expressing perfunctory thanks to military veterans. It temporarily absolves us of the responsibility to address the heart of the matter. Moreover, the apparent moral consensus may be mostly superficial. In trying to enact accessibility, disability advocates encounter increasing resistance as the effort and costs involved in proposals come closer to being realized. (Consider the neighborhood store that decides it’s just too costly to install a ramp, or the community lecture that excludes deaf attendees by refusing to hire a sign-language interpreter.) Instead of facilitating change, false unity actually restrains change. It stifles the more substantive conversations true progress requires. And our inability to speak honestly — and contentiously — about disability shows how the politics of disability is in this sense non-political. We are the worse for it. In addition to greater participation in the public sphere, true progress for citizens with disabilities will require a willingness to confront the issues head-on, even when — especially when — citizens disagree on competing solutions. We must politicize disability — not in the cable-news, grandstanding kind of way, but in the term’s more formal sense. The work of the Belgian political theorist Chantal Mouffe can help illuminate what’s at stake. Mouffe begins with the premise that human relations are inherently antagonistic: Political change always requires controversial transfers in power or prestige, and it is an illusion to imagine politics without confrontation. Per this “agonistic” conception of democracy, a healthy political order is one that prefers vigorous, good-faith argumentation to complacent consensus. Until we publicly recognize real disagreements surrounding disability and accessibility, Mouffe would insist, we are doomed to a vacuous, empty debate that is neither political nor productive. Recall the Kovaleski incident. I’m not suggesting that the abhorrence of Mr. Trump’s actions is open to legitimate questioning. But in their forcefully reassuring comments and messages, my friends prevented any serious discussion of disability at the level where reasonable disagreement does exist. Where will the money come from to fund disability employment schemes? How do we even define “disability”? Despite — and, I would argue, partly because of — the broad condemnation of Mr. Trump for his insensitivity, there was no substantive public discussion of such issues. You may be thinking, haven’t we had enough politics lately? Maybe it’s a blessing that disability isn’t as political as it might be; it avoids the drama and messiness that now seem to define our common life. Avoiding politics might be possible if disability were an exclusively private affair. But it is fundamentally a public concern, affecting everyone directly or indirectly and revealing our obligations to one another as members of a democratic society. Issues of accessibility can be fully addressed only through public institutions and collective effort. For the disability community, there is no answer but politics.