Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Preexistence---1NC

To “increase” means expanding already-existing cooperation.

Buckley ’6 [Jeremiah S, Joseph M. Kolar; November 13; partners at Buckley Kolar LLP; Westlaw, Brief of Amici Curiae for “Mortgage Insurance Companies of America and Consumer Mortgage Coalition,” WL 3309503]

First, the court said that the ordinary meaning of the word “increase” is “to make something greater,” which it believed should not “be limited to cases in which a company raises the rate that an individual has previously been charged.” 435 F.3d at 1091. Yet the definition offered by the Ninth Circuit compels the opposite conclusion. Because “increase” means “to make something greater,” there must necessarily have been an existing premium, to which Edo's actual premium may be compared, to determine whether an *26 “increase” occurred. Congress could have provided that “adverse action” in the insurance context means charging an amount greater than the optimal premium, but instead chose to define adverse action in terms of an “increase.” That definitional choice must be respected, not ignored. See Colautti v. Franklin, 439 U.S. 379, 392-93 n.10 (1979) (“[a] definition which declares what a term ‘means' … excludes any meaning that is not stated”).

Next, the Ninth Circuit reasoned that because the Insurance Prong includes the words “existing or applied for,” Congress intended that an “increase in any charge” for insurance must “apply to all insurance transactions - from an initial policy of insurance to a renewal of a long-held policy.” 435 F.3d at 1091. This interpretation reads the words “existing or applied for” in isolation. Other types of adverse action described in the Insurance Prong apply only to situations where a consumer had an existing policy of insurance, such as a “cancellation,” “reduction,” or “change” in insurance. Each of these forms of adverse action presupposes an already-existing policy, and under usual canons of statutory construction the term “increase” also should be construed to apply to increases of an already-existing policy. See Hibbs v. Winn, 542 U.S. 88, 101 (2004) (“a phrase gathers meaning from the words around it”) (citation omitted).

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Net---2NC

“Increase” must be on net.

McGuffey ’20 [Carroll; Summer; partner at Troutman Pepper Hamilton Sanders LLP; Natural Resources & Environment, “Reforming New Source Review: What Project Emissions Accounting Really Means, and Why It Should Survive,” p. 37]

The debate over how to count changes in emissions when determining NSR applicability is as old as the program itself. The CAA requires permitting for any “increase” in emissions, 42 U.S.C. §§ 7411, 7475, 7479, but it does not define the word “increase,” leaving room for interpretation. Such ambiguity leaves EPA in charge of deciding how sources must determine whether an “increase” will occur. New York, 413 F.3d at 22-24. In fact, a different dispute over the ambiguities in the very same statutory provision resulted in the Supreme Court's now famous (or infamous) Chevron decision on agency deference. Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Natural Res. Def. Council, 467 U.S. 837, 865 (1984) (concluding that the EPA's method of calculating emissions is a reasonable policy choice).

In an attempt to define the ambiguous word “increase,” EPA has adopted increasingly complex regulations, but those rules have consistently maintained that source owners must be allowed to consider the overall “net effect” of a project on the stationary source as a whole. This idea has taken on many names and forms over time--referred to variously as the “bubble concept,” “contemporaneous netting,” “project netting,” and now “Project Emissions Accounting.” The only debate has been in deciding what rules are needed to right-size the NSR permitting program so that permits are required only for those projects that truly warrant such review.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Net---2NC

“Increases” must be on net.

Hall ’72 [Pike; February 1; Judge on the Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit; Westlaw, “O. C. Lanier, v. Trans-World Life Insurance Company,” 258 So. 2d 103]

1The key terms used in the agreement have well defined meanings in the ‘debit’ insurance filed. ‘Increase’ means the net increase in premiums generated by an agent calculated by subtracting ‘lapses' or premiums lost on policies previously issued from gross premiums added by new policies sold. ‘One time’ means a payment made as salary or bonus to the agent on a dollar for dollar or ‘one for one’ basis measured by the net increase.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Net---1NC

“Increase” must be net increases.

Ortega ’91 [Reuben; December 31; Associate Justice on California’s Second Appellate District; Westlaw, “Department of Water & Power v. Energy Resources Conservation & Development Commission,”2 Cal. App. 4th 206]

Action was brought to determine whether California Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission could exercise certification jurisdiction over electrical power plant repowering project. The Superior Court, Los Angeles County, No. BS003230, John Zebrowski, J., ordered issuance of preemptory writ of mandate commanding Commission to cease its exercise of such certification jurisdiction, and Commission appealed. The Court of Appeal, Ortega, J., held that: (1) term “increase,” as used in statute giving the Energy Commission modification jurisdiction over any alteration, replacement, or improvement of equipment that results in increase of 50 megawatts or more in power plant's electrical generating capacity, referred to “net” increase in power plant's total generating capacity, and (2) Commission could exercise construction jurisdiction only over construction at new, not existing, sites.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Make Greater---1AR

“Increase” means to make greater in quality or strength.

Kristl ’4 [Kenneth T, James R May, Keri N Powell, Howard I Fox, John D Walke, David G McIntosh, Ann B Weeks, Jonathan F Lewis; October 26; Partner at Winston & Strawn LLP, Former Law Clerk to District Court Judge William C. Lee, J.D. from Chicago-Kent College of Law; Westlaw, Appellate Brief in “the State of New York v. United States Environmental Protection Agency,” WL 5846438]

The sole textual basis EPA asserts for its extraordinary position is an argument based on the word “increases” in §111(a)(4). Specifically, EPA claims that, even when a change causes emissions to rise to the highest level reached in the past ten years, it does not “increase[]” them. EPA Br. 69-71, 86. According to EPA's untenable argument, Congress did not specify how an increase is to be measured, and thus left EPA free to interpret “increases” as it wishes. Id.

The term “increases” is not an empty vessel that EPA can fill as it chooses. Instead, absent further congressional guidance, the term must be given its ordinary meaning. Engine Mfrs. Assn. v. South Coast Air Quality Management District, 124 S. Ct. 1756, 1761 (2004); Bluewater Network v. EPA, 370 F.3d 1, 13 (D.C. Cir. 2004). The ordinary meaning of “increase” is “to make greater, as in number, size, strength, or quality.” Random House Webster's Unabridged Dictionary, 2d Ed. (1999), at 969. Thus, a change that makes emissions greater “increases” them. EPA's interpretation contravenes the Act's plain meaning under Chevron Step One, or in the alternative “diverges from any realistic meaning” under Chevron Step Two. See, e.g., NRDC v. Daley, 209 F.3d 747, 753 (D.C. Cir. 2000).2

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Make Greater---2AC

“Increase” means adding extent.

Phillips ’2 [Louis M; May 1; Judge on the Bankruptcy Court of M.D. Maryland; Westlaw, “In re Goldberg,” 277 B.R. 251]

In determining the plain meaning of the phrase “increases the obligor's insolvency,” the Court initially notes that this phrase makes no reference whatsoever to a “reasonably equivalent value” test26 or even to the “fair consideration” test of the Section 3 of the UFCA.27 Instead, Article 2036 of the Civil Code merely uses the word “increases,” and the absence of “reasonably equivalent value” language or “fair consideration” language rings loudly in the Court's judicial ear. Accordingly, the Court will focus on the plain meaning of the term “increases.” Taking note from one of the dictionaries of choice of the United States Supreme Court,28 the Court finds that the definition of the word “increase” in Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary reads as follows:

*270 [T]o become progressively greater (as in size, amount, number, or intensity) .... to make greater: AUGMENT .... INCREASE, ENLARGE, AUGMENT, MULTIPLY mean to make or become greater. INCREASE used intransitively implies progressive growth in size, amount, intensity; used transitively it may imply simple not necessarily progressive addition ... the act or process of increasing: as ... addition or enlargement in size, extent, quantity.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Causal---2NC

“Increase” in the transitive active voice requires causation.

Ho ’17 [Derek T, Silvija A Strikis, Hilary P Gerzhoy, H Blair Hahn, and Christiaan A Marcum; August 18; Partner at Kellogg, Hansen, Todd, Figel, & Frederick PLLC, J.D. from Harvard Law School, Former Law Clerk to Justice David H. Souter; Partner at Kellogg, Hansen, Todd, Figel, & Frederick PLLC, Former Law Clerk to Justice Sandra Day O'Connor; the list goes on; Westlaw, Appellate Brief for “In Re: Lipitor (Atorvastatin Calcium) Marketing, Sales Practices and Products Liability Litigation,” WL 4050003]

The district court held Dr. DeMicco's admission insufficient to avoid summary judgment because it was “at best, evidence of association, not causation.” JA2055(CMO 97, at 22); JA2155(CMO 100, at 46). That ruling is contrary to the *64 plain language of Dr. DeMicco's email. The verb “increase,” when used in the transitive active voice (i.e., with a direct object, here, “the risk”) means “to make greater” – i.e., to cause an increased risk. See Webster's Third New International Dictionary 1145 (2002). That is the very definition of general causation. See, e.g., Kuhn v. Wyeth, Inc., 686 F.3d 618, 626 (8th Cir. 2012) (defining general causation as the requirement “that use of [a drug] increases the risk of [a disease]”); Jenkins v. Slidella L.L.C., No. 05-370, 2008 WL 2649510, at *4 (E.D. La. June 27, 2008) (defining general causation in a toxic tort as the requirement that “exposure to the substance at issue increases the risk of a particular injury”).43

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Increase › Increase---Causal---1NC

The transitive “increase” implies a cause-and-effect relationship.

Goldstein ’1 [Thomas C, Jonathan S Massey, Amy Howe, George J Fowler, III, Lawrence R Demarcay; December 4; former clerk for Judge Patricia Wald of the D.C. Circuit, co-founder of SCOTUS Blog, notably second chair for Laurence Tribe and David Boies on behalf of Vice President Al Gore in Bush v. Gore; J.D. from Harvard Law School, former clerk to Justice William J Brennan, Jr; the list goes on; Westlaw, Appellate Brief for “Republican National Committee v. Taylor,” WL 36038162]

The rules of grammar confirm that the Contest Statement is untruthful because it implies a cause-and-effect relationship between the Bill and Medicare increases. When a subject and verb are not followed by an object - e.g., in the sentence, “Under the bill, Medicare spending increases” - the verb is intransitive. When an object follows the verb- as in the Contest Statement (the “bill... increases... spending on Medicare”)-the verb is transitive. The definition of the intransitive verb “increase” is “to become greater in size, amount, degree, etc.; grow.” Webster's New World College Dictionary 684 (3d ed. 1995). But the definition of the transitive verb “increase” - the verb used in the Contest Statement - is “to cause to become greater in size, amount, degree, etc.; add to; augment.” Id. (emphasis added). It cannot be said that the Bill would have caused Medicare spending to become greater in size in the period from 1995 to 2002, or that the Bill would have added to or augmented Medicare spending in those years.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Numerical---1AR

Percentages are arbitrary.

Viscasillas ’4 [Pilar; October 24; Professor at the Universidad Carlos III de Madrid; CISG Advisory Council Opinion, “Contracts for the Sale of Goods to Be Manufactured or Produced and Mixed Contracts (Article 3 CISG),” ]

2.8. Legal writers who follow the economic value criterion have generally quantified the term "substantial part" by comparing Article 3(1) CISG (substantial) with Article 3(2) CISG (preponderant): substantial being less than preponderant. In this way, legal writers have used the following percentages to quantify substantial: 15%,[14] between 40% and 50%,[15] or more generally 50%.[16] At the same time, other authors, although they have not fixed any numbers in regard to the quantification of the term "substantial" have declared that "preponderant" means "considerably more than 50% of the price" or "clearly in excess of 50%".[17] Thus it seems that for the latter authors, the quantification of the term "substantial" is placed above the 50% figure. Also, some Courts have followed this approach.[18]

2.9. To consider a fixed percentage might be arbitrary due to the fact that the particularities of each case ought to be taken into account; that the scholars are in disagreement; and that the origin of those figures is not clear.[19]

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Numerical---1AR

Throw out cutoffs.

Prost ’4 [Sharon; June 18; Federal Court of Appeals Judge on the Federal Circuit; Westlaw, “Comm. for Fairly Traded Venezuelan Cement v. United States,” 372 F.3d 1284]

The URAA and the SAA neither amend nor refine the language of § 1677(4)(C). In fact, they merely suggest, without disqualifying other alternatives, a “clearly higher/substantial proportion” approach. Indeed, the SAA specifically mentions that *1290 no “precise mathematical formula” or “ ‘benchmark’ proportion” is to be used for a dumping concentration analysis. SAA at 860 (citations omitted); see also Venez. Cement, 279 F.Supp.2d at 1329–30. Furthermore, as the Court of International Trade noted, the SAA emphasizes that the Commission retains the discretion to determine concentration of imports on a “case-by-case basis.” SAA at 860. Finally, the definition of the word “substantial” undercuts the CFTVC's argument. The word “substantial” generally means “considerable in amount, value or worth.” Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1993). It does not imply a specific number or cut-off. What may be substantial in one situation may not be in another situation. The very breadth of the term “substantial” undercuts the CFTVC's argument that Congress spoke clearly in establishing a standard for the Commission's regional antidumping and countervailing duty analyses. It therefore supports the conclusion that the Commission is owed deference in its interpretation of “substantial proportion.” The Commission clearly embarked on its analysis having been given considerable leeway to interpret a particularly broad term.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Numerical---2AC

“Substantially increase” doesn’t imply a numerical cutoff.

Hartmann ’7 [August 20; Hon; Judge in the High Court of Hong Kong; Legal Reference System, “In the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Court of First Instance Matrimonial Causes No. 6 of 2007,” ]

19. The word ‘substantial’ is not a technical term nor is it a word that lends itself to a precise measurement. In an earlier judgment on this issue, that of S. v. S. [2006] 3 HKLRD 251, I said that it is not a word —

“… that lends itself to precise definition or from which precise deductions can be drawn. To say, for example, that ‘there has been a substantial increase in expenditure’ does not of itself allow for a calculation in numerative terms of the exact increase. It is a statement to the effect that it is certainly more than a little but less than great. It defines, however, a significant increase, one that is weighty or sizeable.”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Immediate---2NC

“Substantially” means immediately.

Words and Phrases ’4 [Words and Phrases; 1904; Collected, Edited, and Compiled by the Members of the Editorial Staff of the National Reporter System; Judicial and Statutory Definitions of Words and Phrases, “Outward,” vol. 7, p. 5124]

The words “outward, open, actual, visible, substantial, and exclusive,” in connection with a change of possession, mean substantially the same thing. They mean not concealed; not hidden; exposed to view; free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve, or disguise; in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is opposed to potential, apparent, constructive, and imaginary; veritable; genuine; certain; absolute; real at present time, as a matter of fact, not merely nominal; opposed to form; actually existing; true; not including admitting, or pertaining to any others; undivided; sole; opposed to inclusive. Bass v. Pease, 79 Ill. App. 308, 318.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Immediate---1NC

“Substantially” is immediate.

Shepard ’98 [Justice Shepard on the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District; March 1, 1898; Westlaw, “Bass v. Pease,” 79 Ill. App. 308]

“Outward,” “open,” “actual,” “visible,” “substantial” and “exclusive” mean, in the connection that they are employed in the cases referred to, substantially the same thing. They mean “not concealed,” “not hidden, exposed to view,” “free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve or disguise;” “in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is, opposed to potential, apparent, constructive and imaginary;” “veritable, genuine, certain, absolute;” “real, at present time, as a matter of fact;” “not merely nominal, opposed to form,” ““actually existing, true;” “not including, admitting or pertaining to any others; undivided, sole;” “opposed to inclusive.” Anderson's Law Dictionary and The Century Dictionary, under appropriate headings.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---AT: Not Covert---2AC

U.S. law treats MOUs as binding treaty obligations concluded by the executive

Barrett ’20 [Jill; 2020; Visiting Reader in the School of Law at Queen Mary University of London; and Robert Beckman, Emeritus Professor of Law at the National University of Singapore; Handbook on Good Treaty Practice, p. 105]

The Name of the Document Does Not Determine its Legal Status

A document which meets the legal criteria for being a treaty is a treaty, whatever its particular designation. No matter how non-binding the title sounds, if the content and context make clear that it is governed by international law, it may be a treaty. Conversely, a document could be entitled ‘treaty’ or ‘agreement’, but if it is evident from its contents or context that it is not governed by international law, it is not a treaty. This can make the task of distinguishing treaties from non-binding international instruments difficult. The document signed by the Foreign Minister of Bahrain which was interpreted by the ICJ as a binding agreement to take the dispute with Qatar to the ICJ, was called ‘Minutes’. Minutes of meetings do not usually have treaty status, but if an internationally binding agreement is entered into at the meeting, the record of the meeting could bind the parties.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---AT: Not Covert---2AC

Private talks can limit a public treaty.

James D. Morrow 2K, PhD, Professor, Poli Sci, Stanford University, June 2000, "Alliances: Why Write Them Down?", Annual Review of Political Science, Vol. 3, https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev.polisci.3.1.63

Signaling could also occur within alliances. Secret alliances pose a particular problem for this argument; how can something private signal information (Ritter 2000)? Often, there may be a problem of uncertainty between possible allies. They may not know the extent of one another's commitment. Private talks that limit the applicability of the alliance address some of the problems of entrapment and abandonment by allowing each ally to declare what interests it is willing to fight for, allowing the other to adjust its actions accordingly. Secrecy would be a benefit because the allies might not wish to communicate the limits of their commitment to states outside the alliance. This concern could lead to secret provisions appended to a public treaty.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---AT: Not Covert---2AC

Contextually, action in defense alliances like NATO can be secret.

Rapp-Hooper 15 – Mira Rapp-Hooper, Political Science PhD at Columbia University (earned by submitting this paper), Political Science MPhil at Columbia University. [Absolute Alliances: Extended Deterrence in International Politics, PhD thesis at Columbia University, https://doi.org/10.7916/D85Q4TWX]//BPS

Defense pacts may be symmetric or asymmetric, both in terms of the capabilities of member states and in terms of treaty obligations. They may form between major and minor powers, or between equals, and the treaty obligations may vary between partners or may be identical. If defense pacts specify an alliance duration when they enter into force, the mean specified length is seven and one-half years. In actuality, a typical defense pact lasts for about 20 years.36 Most defense pacts are public, but occasionally states sign defensive alliances in which part or all of the treaty is kept secret.37 Moreover, many defense pacts are quite specific—approximately half of non-security guarantee defense pacts specify an adversary, theater, alliance, or particular military contingency as the target of the pact.38

Footnote 37 begins:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Covert---2NC

“Substantially” excludes covert action.

Shepard ’98 [Justice Shepard on the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District; March 1, 1898; Westlaw, “Bass v. Pease,” 79 Ill. App. 308]

“Outward,” “open,” “actual,” “visible,” “substantial” and “exclusive” mean, in the connection that they are employed in the cases referred to, substantially the same thing. They mean “not concealed,” “not hidden, exposed to view,” “free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve or disguise;” “in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is, opposed to potential, apparent, constructive and imaginary;” “veritable, genuine, certain, absolute;” “real, at present time, as a matter of fact;” “not merely nominal, opposed to form,” ““actually existing, true;” “not including, admitting or pertaining to any others; undivided, sole;” “opposed to inclusive.” Anderson's Law Dictionary and The Century Dictionary, under appropriate headings.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Covert---2NC

“Substantially” excludes covert action.

Edwards ‘8 [Richard; 2008; Professor of Communication Studies at Baylor University, Ph.D. in Communication Studies from the University of Iowa; Competitive Debate: The Official Guide, “Policy Debate Final Round,” p. 227]

And, “substantial” means the increase must be definite. Potential future increases are not topical. Words and Phrases, 1964, accessed online: “Substantial means not concealed, denoting that which not merely can be, but is supposed to be, potential, certain, absolute, real at the present time.”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not Covert---1NC

“Substantial” increases in cooperation cannot be concealed

Words and Phrases 64 (40W&P 759)

The words" outward, open, actual, visible, substantial, and exclusive," in connection with a change of possession, mean substantially the same thing. They mean not concealed; not hidden; exposed to view; free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve, or disguise; in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is opposed to potential, apparent, constructive, and imaginary; veritable; genuine; certain: absolute: real at present time, as a matter of fact, not merely nominal; opposed to form; actually existing; true; not including, admitting, or pertaining to any others; undivided; sole; opposed to inclusive.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Considerably---1AR

“Substantially” is NOT a term of art, so you should avoid defining it in a limiting fashion.

Arkush ’2 [David; January 1; J.D. Candidate at Harvard Law School; Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, “Preserving "Catalyst" Attorneys' Fees Under the Freedom of Information Act in the Wake of Buckhannon Board and Care Home v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources,” vol. 37, p. 151]

Since the Supreme Court appears to have emphasized the classification in Buckhannon,(FN96) plaintiffs may find it useful or necessary to discuss whether "substantially prevail" is a legal term of art. The only clear consequence of classification as a "legal term of art" is that courts may be more likely to consult Black's Law Dictionary to define such words. The Buckhannon Court declared "prevailing party" a term of art and seems to have relied heavily on the 1997 edition of Black's, which defined the phrase as a "party in whose favor judgment is rendered."(FN97) Justice Scalia's concurrence similarly emphasized the special status of the term "prevailing party," writing, "[w]ords that have acquired a specialized meaning in the legal context must be accorded their legal meaning."(FN98)

Plaintiffs should argue that the term "substantially prevail" is not a term of art because if considered a term of art, resort to Black's 7th produces a definition of "prevail" that could be interpreted adversely to plaintiffs.(FN99) It is commonly accepted that words that are not legal terms of art should be accorded their ordinary, not their legal, meaning,(FN100) and ordinary-usage dictionaries provide FOIA fee claimants with helpful arguments. The Supreme Court has already found favorable, temporally relevant definitions of the word "substantially" in ordinary dictionaries: