Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Social media scams extort the U.S. military, leads to soldiers sharing valuable information with adversaries.

Lange July 31, 2019 Katie Lange, Social Media/Public Affairs specialist, senior digital producer, writer and editor, temple university bachelors degree of arts. These social media scams affect the military, U.S. Department of Defense, , Accessed 7-11-22, BVW-RB

Nowadays, you have to be cautious of everything you do online. Scammers are always trying to get money, goods or services out of unsuspecting people — and military members are often targets. Here are some scams that have recently been affecting service members, Defense Department employees and their families. Romance Scams In April, Army Criminal Investigation Command put out a warning about romance scams in which online predators go on dating sites claiming to be deployed active-duty soldiers. It's a problem that's affecting all branches of service — not just the Army. CID said there have been hundreds of claims each month from people who said they've been scammed on legitimate dating apps and social media sites. According to the alleged victims, the scammers have asked for money for fake service-related needs such as transportation, communications fees, processing and medical fees — even marriage. CID said many of the victims have lost tens of thousands of dollars and likely won't get that money back. Remember: Service members and government employees DO NOT PAY to go on leave, have their personal effects sent home or fly back to the U.S. from an overseas assignment. Scammers will sometimes provide  to make their case, but real service members make their own requests for time off. Also, any official military or government emails will end in .mil or .gov — not .com — so be suspicious if you get a message claiming to be from the military or government that doesn’t have one of those addresses. If you're worried about being scammed, know what . If you think you've been a victim, contact the  and the . DOD officials said task forces are working to deal with the growing problem, but the scammers are often from African nations and are using cyber cafes with untraceable email addresses, then routing their accounts across the world to make them incredibly difficult to trace. So be vigilant! 'Sextortion' Sexual extortion — known as "sextortion" — is when a service member is seduced into sexual activities online that are unknowingly recorded and used against them for money or goods. Often, if a victim caves on a demand, the scammer will just likely demand more.Service members [Who] are attractive targets for these scammers for a few reasons: They're often young men who are away from home and have an online presence. They have a steady income and are often more financially stable than civilians. Because of their careers, they're held to a higher standard of conduct. Military members have security clearances and know things that might be of interest to adversaries. To avoid falling victim to sextortion, don't post or exchange compromising photos or videos with ANYONE online, and make sure your social media privacy settings limit the information outsiders can see — this includes advertising your affiliation with the military or government. Be careful when you're communicating with anyone you don't personally know online, and trust your instincts. If people seem suspicious, stop communicating with them. DOD officials said sextortion often goes unreported because many victims are embarrassed they fell for it. But it happens worldwide and across all ranks and services. Here's what you should do about it if it happens to you: Stop communicating with the scammer. Contact your command and your local CID office. Do NOT pay the perpetrator. Save all communications you had with that person. Service Member Impersonation Scams Scammers love to impersonate people of authority, and that includes service members. These people often steal the identity or profile images of a service member and use them to ask for money or make claims that involve the sale of vehicles, house rentals or other big-ticket items. These scammers often send the victim bogus information about the advertised product and ask for a wire transfer through a third party to finish the purchase, but there’s no product at the end of the transaction. Lately, fake profiles of high-ranking American military officials have been popping up on social media websites using photos and biographical information obtained from the internet. Scammers often replicate recent social media posts from official DOD accounts and interact with official accounts to increase the appearance of legitimacy. As an example, there are impersonator accounts on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter for Marine Corps Gen. Joe Dunford, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. These accounts are also interacting with Joint Staff account followers in an effort to gain trust and elicit information. The only Joint Staff leader with an official social media presence is Senior Enlisted Advisor to the Chairman Army Command Sgt. Maj. John Wayne Troxell, who is listed as  on Facebook and  on Twitter.  Scammers are making these profiles to defraud potential victims. They claim to be high-ranking or well-placed government/military officials or the surviving spouse of former government leaders, then they promise big profits in exchange for help in moving large sums of money, oil or some other commodity. They offer to transfer significant amounts of money into the victim's bank account in exchange for a small fee. Scammers that receive payment are never heard from again.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Authoritarian states will take advantage of social media as a means to deck Soldier morale – Daesh proves.

Childs 16, Sean Childs Major Sean V. W. Childs is a serving member of the regular Australian Army. He holds a Bachelor of Science from Macquarie University and a Master of Arts (Strategy and Security) from the Australian Defence Force Academy. Prior to joining the Australian Defence Force in 2010, Sean was a video journalist and senior producer based in London covering global security conflicts for US-based The Associated Press Television News, a policy adviser for Free TV Australia and an account director with the media intelligence corporate, the iSentia Group.“Soldier Morale: Defending a Core Military Capability” Institute for Regional Security , Accessed 7-14-22, BVW-RB

Australia and the West’s soldiers of today are part of a globalised information age which is resulting in the West’s continued detribalisation.34 In other words, by today’s soldiers accessing and processing knowledge from across the world they are facilitating for themselves more diverse views and opinions that challenge dominant Western paradigms and which serve to erode a consensus. Put another way, their actions potentially serve to erode the will to fight, a will which relies on a “sense of identity, belonging and cause”.35 Quite simply, the already dynamic process of human relations and discourse is becoming even more dynamic. Daesh, seizing on the phenomenon, is making expert use of social media in its propaganda efforts by using it as an information weapon, and in the realm of stated war aims, social media is extenuating the strategic debate. The main allegation commentators level against the international coalition’s fight against Daesh in Iraq and Syria is its lack of strategy or, to put it another way, the purpose of its stated war aims. This is in the context of perceived previous politicomilitary failures in the Middle East, which many argue have resulted in the rise of Daesh. In a theoretical sense, what this means is that an already detribalising West along with its soldiers are afforded access via social media to an ever expanding, dissenting discourse which serves to lower morale. The important effect social media has here stems from the realm of memory studies and the way in which meaning is created. Put simply, meaning is created in the space between history and imagination, which in the present spectrum of modern conflict is a recipe for a decrease in the West’s will to fight for their ideals and values. In other words, the history of past failures coupled with proliferated online content makes for the questioning of the ends and a greater potential for dissent, with all of its attendant consequences. For example, the potential drop in voluntary military recruitment numbers and increase in military separations (people quitting or worse, disserting). Social media’s detribalising effect in the spectrum of modern conflict certainly requires further research. Turning to morale’s exogenous situational factor one can argue that in the spectrum of modern conflict social media has the greatest practical impact. Well before the notion of social media was fathomable, David Galula, a leading military and academic figure of counterinsurgency warfare, provided a prescient warning in 1968 which typifies the threat to morale posed by Daesh’s use of social media today when he said, “the insurgent [is] judged by what he promises, not by what he does ... the counterinsurgent [is] judged on what he does, not on what he says”.36 Certainly the increase in the amount of information available is synonymous with the information age and social media. Certainly also the quality and authenticity of much of that information is questionable—all of which feeds the potentiality of rumour and friction in the context of success and failure. From the Australian Defence Force’s force protection perspective, two practical examples of social media’s likely impact on the morale of the men and women of its Air Task Group (ATG) conducting combat operations against Daesh in Iraq and Syria are available. I say likely as this is an area also requiring further research. Force protection relates to the identification of threats to the force, and the mitigation and control of those threats, which is a process of risk management. In this sense then, it is not difficult to appreciate that defending morale falls within the remit of force protection. First, take the horrifically barbaric February 2015 burning-alive of the caged and conscious Jordanian pilot by Daesh in Syria, subsequently disseminated by social media and widely reported on by the Western media. That, more than likely, had a material impact on the ATG’s exogenous situational factor of morale. In an already heightened force protection state it is not hard to imagine that social media’s transmission of the act would have caused a high degree of increased ‘home-front’ friction for the families of the ATG’s aircrews. In other words, an increase in the ATG’s families’ associated levels of concern and worry. The impact too in turn potentially feeds back into morale’s political factor of the stated war aim, spurring the debate surrounding the question of ‘is this really worth risking lives for an apparently uncertain end?’ Daesh’s use of social media in this case, as with their media content from their victories in Mosul and Ramadi, is an example of degrading the West’s situational factor of morale by highlighting their perceived victory and the coalition’s failure. Separately, although related in the realm of morale, was Daesh’s so called ‘Hacking Division’s’ August 2015 publication via social media of a “hit list” containing, supposedly, around 1,400 peoples’ details, including mobile phone numbers, credit card details, online passwords and private emails. Of those 1,400 the Australian Government confirmed the leak included the personal information of Australian Defence Force (ADF) employees.37 If the ATG and their families were not already overly apprehensive, one imagines their perception of Daesh’s domestic threat and potential reach increased somewhat if not dramatically. How does the ADF Presently Defend and How Might It Better Defend against Social Media’s Threat to Morale? From a force protection perspective, the ADF has measures in place to defend against social media’s threat to morale. Personnel are educated on the use of social media and on what personal security measures should be followed and what operational security (OPSEC) measures must be followed. These are important and necessary requirements for defending the military capability of morale. From a technical perspective, however, there is not a lot else one may implement short of banning social media’s use,38 which like our existing approach would fall within the realm of information as data and commodity.39 Put another way, this relates to the military’s traditional approach to OPSEC and “the information security triad of confidentiality, integrity and availability”.40 The important point here is that that approach, although important, fails to acknowledge the greater power of information as image and perception in the world of social media.41 Information as image and perception means information must be seen as a resource for shaping perception and imagination, which in turn is a more potent way of defending and, more importantly, strengthening morale.42 In the realm of modern conflict, social media and morale; attack is the best form of defence. Rather than being overly shielding we must facilitate and encourage soldiers to take up social media and get deep into the discourse it richly enables. Soldiers must go ‘waist-deep’, get personal, communicate the reality, create bonds, expand networks and proactively contribute to the collective shaping of perception and image. Our soldiers need to be outfront. With clarity, simplicity, common intelligibility and realistic interpretation,43 their authentic first-hand social media content should evoke identities and perceptions that create meanings, which in turn serve to boost morale. Such an approach’s strength lies in the content’s authenticity. In this way, akin to a constructivist approach within security studies, the will can be positively influenced through “behaviour [which] is always socially constructed, historically determined, and culturally contingent”.44 Conversely, a weakness of such an approach will stem from the tension between the opportunity for the soldier to engage independently and the strategic imperative dictated by policy, which is inherently political.Conclusion Social media has and will continue to change the character of morale or the will to fight in the spectrum of modern conflict. More significantly, the West’s ‘rules-based’ democracies and their body politics’ will to uphold and defend international norms is being challenged by the proliferation of social media and its detribalising effect. What this means is that the role of the individual within the military institution and its use of social media is vital in order to defend the military capability of morale. Crucially, information as image and perception must be privileged above the twentieth-century’s mentality of information as data and commodity. Information is the resource for shaping perception and imagination, and is the most potent way of defending and strengthening morale.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Information is uniquely crucial to military morale, makes an information war the biggest threat.

Childs 16, Sean Childs Major Sean V. W. Childs is a serving member of the regular Australian Army. He holds a Bachelor of Science from Macquarie University and a Master of Arts (Strategy and Security) from the Australian Defence Force Academy. Prior to joining the Australian Defence Force in 2010, Sean was a video journalist and senior producer based in London covering global security conflicts for US-based The Associated Press Television News, a policy adviser for Free TV Australia and an account director with the media intelligence corporate, the iSentia Group.“Soldier Morale: Defending a Core Military Capability” Institute for Regional Security , Accessed 7-14-22, BVW-RB

Social media has and will continue to change the character of morale or the will to fight in the spectrum of modern conflict. More significantly, the West’s ‘rules-based’ democracies and their body politics’ will to uphold and defend international norms is being challenged by the proliferation of social media and its detribalising effect. What this means is that the role of the individual within the military institution and its use of social media is vital in order to defend the military capability of morale. Crucially, information as image and perception must be privileged above the twentieth-century’s mentality of information as data and commodity. Information is the resource for shaping perception and imagination, and is the most potent way of defending and strengthening morale.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Russia is restraining the extent of its info warfare abilities but is brainwashing Ukrainians and Russians, current US action fails

 and  both study information warfare, influence, and other defense operations in the information environment at the nonprofit, nonpartisan RAND Don’t Sleep on Russian Information-War Capabilities ," Defense One, 04-05-2022

It certainly appears as though Russia’s opening portrait of the “special operation” as a quest to emancipate the people of Ukraine from  has fallen too far outside of global audiences’ existing belief systems to gain traction. At the highest levels of government, world leaders have  come out in support of Ukraine, even hurling a  at Russia. On the other end of the spectrum,  now dot American neighborhoods as symbols of solidarity for Ukraine. From this vantage point, Ukraine looks to have Russia beat. But this is only part of the story.

Instead of fixating on Russia’s missteps, policymakers and analysts would benefit from studying Ukraine’s sophisticated information campaign while bearing in mind that Russia retains significant  and . Moreover, Russia is endowed with several related advantages such as a robust state-backed media apparatus, an increasingly hermetic [PB1] domestic information space, and the capacity for . In fact, we see evidence of these capabilities, advantages, and this willingness working on some of Russia’s target audiences. In Russia and small pockets of eastern Ukraine,  indicates that some audiences are buying the Kremlin line.  of Russians refusing to believe their Ukrainian family members’ own harrowing  have surfaced. 

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Russia is using info warfare to destroy Ukrainian military readiness

-Authoritarian countries are using info warfare to spread HR violations

Zara Abrams has a B.A. in neuroscience and an M.A. in science journalism, both from USC., 6-1-2022, "The role of psychological warfare in the battle for Ukraine," American Psychological Association https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/06/news-psychological-warfare

“The Ukrainians are fighting a 21st-century war, which is half on the internet,” said Stephan Lewandowsky, PhD, a professor of psychology at the University of Bristol who studies misinformation at the societal level. “That new approach has worked extremely well because it has preempted Russian attempts to rewrite history.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Morale**

Successful US Morale Information warfare ends the war in Ukraine

Daniel Karr et al., Daniel Karr is an intelligence consultant at Recorded Future, an intelligence company, and a former intelligence analyst at the US Department of Defense. Jacob Ware is the research associate for counterterrorism at the Council on Foreign Relations and an adjunct professor at Georgetown University’s Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service. 4-14-2022, "Hearts Not Minds: Morale and Inspiration in Insurgency and Territorial Defense," Modern War Institute at West Point , https://mwi.usma.edu/hearts-not-minds-morale-and-inspiration-in-insurgency-and-territorial-defense/

In war, morale always matters. The US military knows this better than most. In July 1965, Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara  additional deployments of US ground forces in Vietnam to “destroying” the morale of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and the Viet Cong, including through the use of “informational actions.” While McNamara accurately predicted the impact of the information environment on the morale of insurgents and counterinsurgents alike, he overlooked how these deployments would affect the morale of US soldiers in Vietnam and the US public at home. Despite suffering hundreds of thousands of casualties, the North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces held out, capturing Saigon a decade after McNamara’s request for additional forces. The relative willpower of US forces compared to that of the Viet Cong insurgents was one of  for this outcome.

Morale would similarly play a central role in US struggles in Afghanistan and Iraq. Although patriotic sentiment was widespread after the 9/11 attacks, US morale  over time, beaten down by improvised explosive devices, sniper attacks, and the knowledge that blood and sweat shed in conflicts in the Middle East and south Asia were yielding few strategic results. As one Taliban fighter is said to have , “You have the watches. We have the time.” Both insurgent and counterinsurgent in Iraq and Afghanistan were well aware of one of the golden rules of guerrilla warfare, once  in the Vietnam context by Henry Kissinger: “The guerrilla wins if he does not lose. The conventional army loses if it does not win.”

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Warming** › 2AC Warming Add-On

Extinction.

Kareiva 18, Ph.D. in ecology and applied mathematics from Cornell University, director of the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability at UCLA, Pritzker Distinguished Professor in Environment & Sustainability at UCLA, et al. (Peter, “Existential risk due to ecosystem collapse: Nature strikes back,” Futures, 102)

In summary, six of the nine proposed planetary boundaries (phosphorous, nitrogen, biodiversity, land use, atmospheric aerosol loading, and chemical pollution) are unlikely to be associated with existential risks. They all correspond to a degraded environment, but in our assessment do not represent existential risks. However, the three remaining boundaries (climate change, global freshwater cycle, and ocean acidification) do pose existential risks. This is because of intrinsic positive feedback loops, substantial lag times between system change and experiencing the consequences of that change, and the fact these different boundaries interact with one another in ways that yield surprises. In addition, climate, freshwater, and ocean acidification are all directly connected to the provision of food and water, and shortages of food and water can create conflict and social unrest. Climate change has a long history of disrupting civilizations and sometimes precipitating the collapse of cultures or mass emigrations (McMichael, 2017). For example, the 12th century drought in the North American Southwest is held responsible for the collapse of the Anasazi pueblo culture. More recently, the infamous potato famine of 1846–1849 and the large migration of Irish to the U.S. can be traced to a combination of factors, one of which was climate. Specifically, 1846 was an unusually warm and moist year in Ireland, providing the climatic conditions favorable to the fungus that caused the potato blight. As is so often the case, poor government had a role as well—as the British government forbade the import of grains from outside Britain (imports that could have helped to redress the ravaged potato yields). Climate change intersects with freshwater resources because it is expected to exacerbate drought and water scarcity, as well as flooding. Climate change can even impair water quality because it is associated with heavy rains that overwhelm sewage treatment facilities, or because it results in higher concentrations of pollutants in groundwater as a result of enhanced evaporation and reduced groundwater recharge. Ample clean water is not a luxury—it is essential for human survival. Consequently, cities, regions and nations that lack clean freshwater are vulnerable to social disruption and disease. Finally, ocean acidification is linked to climate change because it is driven by CO2 emissions just as global warming is. With close to 20% of the world’s protein coming from oceans (FAO, 2016), the potential for severe impacts due to acidification is obvious. Less obvious, but perhaps more insidious, is the interaction between climate change and the loss of oyster and coral reefs due to acidification. Acidification is known to interfere with oyster reef building and coral reefs. Climate change also increases storm frequency and severity. Coral reefs and oyster reefs provide protection from storm surge because they reduce wave energy (Spalding et al., 2014). If these reefs are lost due to acidification at the same time as storms become more severe and sea level rises, coastal communities will be exposed to unprecedented storm surge—and may be ravaged by recurrent storms. A key feature of the risk associated with climate change is that mean annual temperature and mean annual rainfall are not the variables of interest. Rather it is extreme episodic events that place nations and entire regions of the world at risk. These extreme events are by definition “rare” (once every hundred years), and changes in their likelihood are challenging to detect because of their rarity, but are exactly the manifestations of climate change that we must get better at anticipating (Diffenbaugh et al., 2017). Society will have a hard time responding to shorter intervals between rare extreme events because in the lifespan of an individual human, a person might experience as few as two or three extreme events. How likely is it that you would notice a change in the interval between events that are separated by decades, especially given that the interval is not regular but varies stochastically? A concrete example of this dilemma can be found in the past and expected future changes in storm-related flooding of New York City. The highly disruptive flooding of New York City associated with Hurricane Sandy represented a flood height that occurred once every 500 years in the 18th century, and that occurs now once every 25 years, but is expected to occur once every 5 years by 2050 (Garner et al., 2017). This change in frequency of extreme floods has profound implications for the measures New York City should take to protect its infrastructure and its population, yet because of the stochastic nature of such events, this shift in flood frequency is an elevated risk that will go unnoticed by most people. 4. The combination of positive feedback loops and societal inertia is fertile ground for global environmental catastrophes Humans are remarkably ingenious, and have adapted to crises throughout their history. Our doom has been repeatedly predicted, only to be averted by innovation (Ridley, 2011). However, the many stories of human ingenuity successfully addressing existential risks such as global famine or extreme air pollution represent environmental challenges that are largely linear, have immediate consequences, and operate without positive feedbacks. For example, the fact that food is in short supply does not increase the rate at which humans consume food—thereby increasing the shortage. Similarly, massive air pollution episodes such as the London fog of 1952 that killed 12,000 people did not make future air pollution events more likely. In fact it was just the opposite—the London fog sent such a clear message that Britain quickly enacted pollution control measures (Stradling, 2016). Food shortages, air pollution, water pollution, etc. send immediate signals to society of harm, which then trigger a negative feedback of society seeking to reduce the harm. In contrast, today’s great environmental crisis of climate change may cause some harm but there are generally long time delays between rising CO2 concentrations and damage to humans. The consequence of these delays are an absence of urgency; thus although 70% of Americans believe global warming is happening, only 40% think it will harm them (http://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us-2016/). Secondly, unlike past environmental challenges, the Earth’s climate system is rife with positive feedback loops. In particular, as CO2 increases and the climate warms, that very warming can cause more CO2 release which further increases global warming, and then more CO2, and so on. Table 2 summarizes the best documented positive feedback loops for the Earth’s climate system. These feedbacks can be neatly categorized into carbon cycle, biogeochemical, biogeophysical, cloud, ice-albedo, and water vapor feedbacks. As important as it is to understand these feedbacks individually, it is even more essential to study the interactive nature of these feedbacks. Modeling studies show that when interactions among feedback loops are included, uncertainty increases dramatically and there is a heightened potential for perturbations to be magnified (e.g., Cox, Betts, Jones, Spall, & Totterdell, 2000; Hajima, Tachiiri, Ito, & Kawamiya, 2014; Knutti & Rugenstein, 2015; Rosenfeld, Sherwood, Wood, & Donner, 2014). This produces a wide range of future scenarios. Positive feedbacks in the carbon cycle involves the enhancement of future carbon contributions to the atmosphere due to some initial increase in atmospheric CO2. This happens because as CO2 accumulates, it reduces the efficiency in which oceans and terrestrial ecosystems sequester carbon, which in return feeds back to exacerbate climate change (Friedlingstein et al., 2001). Warming can also increase the rate at which organic matter decays and carbon is released into the atmosphere, thereby causing more warming (Melillo et al., 2017). Increases in food shortages and lack of water is also of major concern when biogeophysical feedback mechanisms perpetuate drought conditions. The underlying mechanism here is that losses in vegetation increases the surface albedo, which suppresses rainfall, and thus enhances future vegetation loss and more suppression of rainfall—thereby initiating or prolonging a drought (Chamey, Stone, & Quirk, 1975). To top it off, overgrazing depletes the soil, leading to augmented vegetation loss (Anderies, Janssen, & Walker, 2002). Climate change often also increases the risk of forest fires, as a result of higher temperatures and persistent drought conditions. The expectation is that forest fires will become more frequent and severe with climate warming and drought (Scholze, Knorr, Arnell, & Prentice, 2006), a trend for which we have already seen evidence (Allen et al., 2010). Tragically, the increased severity and risk of Southern California wildfires recently predicted by climate scientists (Jin et al., 2015), was realized in December 2017, with the largest fire in the history of California (the “Thomas fire” that burned 282,000 acres, https://www.vox.com/2017/12/27/16822180/thomas-fire-california-largest-wildfire). This catastrophic fire embodies the sorts of positive feedbacks and interacting factors that could catch humanity off-guard and produce a true apocalyptic event. Record-breaking rains produced an extraordinary flush of new vegetation, that then dried out as record heat waves and dry conditions took hold, coupled with stronger than normal winds, and ignition. Of course the record-fire released CO2 into the atmosphere, thereby contributing to future warming. Out of all types of feedbacks, water vapor and the ice-albedo feedbacks are the most clearly understood mechanisms. Losses in reflective snow and ice cover drive up surface temperatures, leading to even more melting of snow and ice cover—this is known as the ice-albedo feedback (Curry, Schramm, & Ebert, 1995). As snow and ice continue to melt at a more rapid pace, millions of people may be displaced by flooding risks as a consequence of sea level rise near coastal communities (Biermann & Boas, 2010; Myers, 2002; Nicholls et al., 2011). The water vapor feedback operates when warmer atmospheric conditions strengthen the saturation vapor pressure, which creates a warming effect given water vapor’s strong greenhouse gas properties (Manabe & Wetherald, 1967). Global warming tends to increase cloud formation because warmer temperatures lead to more evaporation of water into the atmosphere, and warmer temperature also allows the atmosphere to hold more water. The key question is whether this increase in clouds associated with global warming will result in a positive feedback loop (more warming) or a negative feedback loop (less warming). For decades, scientists have sought to answer this question and understand the net role clouds play in future climate projections (Schneider et al., 2017). Clouds are complex because they both have a cooling (reflecting incoming solar radiation) and warming (absorbing incoming solar radiation) effect (Lashof, DeAngelo, Saleska, & Harte, 1997). The type of cloud, altitude, and optical properties combine to determine how these countervailing effects balance out. Although still under debate, it appears that in most circumstances the cloud feedback is likely positive (Boucher et al., 2013). For example, models and observations show that increasing greenhouse gas concentrations reduces the low-level cloud fraction in the Northeast Pacific at decadal time scales. This then has a positive feedback effect and enhances climate warming since less solar radiation is reflected by the atmosphere (Clement, Burgman, & Norris, 2009). The key lesson from the long list of potentially positive feedbacks and their interactions is that runaway climate change, and runaway perturbations have to be taken as a serious possibility. Table 2 is just a snapshot of the type of feedbacks that have been identified (see Supplementary material for a more thorough explanation of positive feedback loops). However, this list is not exhaustive and the possibility of undiscovered positive feedbacks portends even greater existential risks. The many environmental crises humankind has previously averted (famine, ozone depletion, London fog, water pollution, etc.) were averted because of political will based on solid scientific understanding. We cannot count on complete scientific understanding when it comes to positive feedback loops and climate change.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Warming** › 2AC Warming Add-On

Science disinformation hinders solutions to existential crises---climate change and vaccines

ALLEA, 21, ALLEA is the European Federation of Academics of Sciences and Humanities, representing more than 50 academies from over 40 countries in Europe; “Fact or Fake? Tackling Science Disinformation”, ALLEA, 05-2021, https://allea.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Fact-or-Fake-Discussion-Paper.pdf/chuo

===tbh this card is kind of similar to Gerbina but is better lol; not specific to undermining trust though this is about just wrong information makes people do the wrong things

The overall success of the scientific method also means that when someone wants to make claims that go against established scientific knowledge and are not grounded in the scientific method, they must seek to undermine the trustworthiness of the scientific method or scientists per se. Thus, paradoxically, scientific language is often adopted at the same time as scientific activities themselves are being questioned. An extreme and particularly harmful form of anti-scientific activity appears in the form of conspiracy theories with notable examples in the three areas chosen for analysis in this discussion paper: climate change, vaccines, and pandemics.3

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Biodiversity** › 2AC Biodiversity Add-On

Biodiversity loss cascades and is existential

Torres, 16 - founding director of the X-Risks Institute, an affiliate scholar at the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, and author of the forthcoming Morality, Foresight, and Human Flourishing: An Introduction to Existential Risks ( Phil, ‘Biodiversity loss: An existential risk comparable to climate change’, April 11 2016, )//hecht

Catastrophic consequences for civilization. The consequences of this rapid pruning of the evolutionary tree of life extend beyond the obvious. There could be surprising effects of biodiversity loss that scientists are unable to fully anticipate in advance. For example, prior research has shown that localized ecosystems can undergo abrupt and irreversible shifts when they reach a tipping point. According to a 2012 paper published in Nature, there are reasons for thinking that we may be approaching a tipping point of this sort in the global ecosystem, beyond which the consequences could be catastrophic for civilization. As the authors write, a planetary-scale transition could precipitate “substantial losses of ecosystem services required to sustain the human population.” An ecosystem service is any ecological process that benefits humanity, such as food production and crop pollination. If the global ecosystem were to cross a tipping point and substantial ecosystem services were lost, the results could be “widespread social unrest, economic instability, and loss of human life.” According to Missouri Botanical Garden ecologist Adam Smith, one of the paper’s co-authors, this could occur in a matter of decades—far more quickly than most of the expected consequences of climate change, yet equally destructive. Biodiversity loss is a “threat multiplier” that, by pushing societies to the brink of collapse, will exacerbate existing conflicts and introduce entirely new struggles between state and non-state actors. Indeed, it could even fuel the rise of terrorism. (After all, climate change has been linked to the emergence of ISIS in Syria, and multiple high-ranking US officials, such as former US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel and CIA director John Brennan, have affirmed that climate change and terrorism are connected.) The reality is that we are entering the sixth mass extinction in the 3.8-billion-year history of life on Earth, and the impact of this event could be felt by civilization “in as little as three human lifetimes,” as the aforementioned 2012 Nature paper notes. Furthermore, the widespread decline of biological populations could plausibly initiate a dramatic transformation of the global ecosystem on an even faster timescale: perhaps a single human lifetime. The unavoidable conclusion is that biodiversity loss constitutes an existential threat in its own right. As such, it ought to be considered alongside climate change and nuclear weapons as one of the most significant contemporary risks to human prosperity and survival.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Biodiversity** › 2AC Biodiversity Add-On

Specifically, misinformation devastates biodiversity through misplaced conservation

Ford et al, 21, Ford is the associate professor at the department of biology at the University of British Columbia; the articles they write focus mainly on conservation. “Understanding and avoiding misplaced efforts in conservation”, FACETS, 2021, chuo

===5 main reasons (misallocating resources, misinforming supporters, alienating partners, delegitimizing evidence, & other one is direct---an action intended to enhance biod has a direct, negative impact on a wild population) why disinformation/misinformation (same effect so it’s the same here) is bad for biodiversity & conservation (problem of “misplaced conservation”)

Recent social trends have seen rising polarization in political affiliations and on key issues (Bail et al. 2018), along with the amplification of misinterpreted or false information in public discourse (Lazer et al. 2018). These two trends may have negative effects on many aspects of health, politics, science, and the conservation of biodiversity. For example, as early as the 1940s, and for decades after, the spread of misinformation overwhelmed scientific evidence suggesting a link between tobacco smoking and cancer (Proctor 2012). Today, similar misinformation regarding the efficacy of vaccinations (Lazer et al. 2018) or responses to the public health orders (e.g., the use of masks to reduce the spread of COVID-19) foments polarization and threatens public health (Paes-Sousa et al. 2020). The mere suggestion of human-caused climate change has become polarizing, impeding actions that could minimize harm to human health, livelihoods, and biodiversity (Biddle and Leuschner 2015). Polarization threatens cooperative approaches to problem solving and decision-making (Barber and McCarty 2015; Maher et al. 2018), while misinterpreted or false information distracts the public and decision-makers from acting upon pressing needs and may waste resources in doing so (Oreskes and Conway 2011; Barnes et al. 2018). The conservation of biodiversity is a globally significant challenge, and inherently requires cooperation and evidence to be successful. However, success in conservation can be influenced by actions that undermine cooperation and evidence—i.e., polarization and misinformation. To better understand how polarization and misinformation affects biodiversity, we define the term “misplaced conservation”, which occurs when actions increase the scientific, financial, political, or social resources required to achieve a positive outcome for biodiversity in the present or future. Misplaced conservation is distinct from other human activities that are also direct threats to biodiversity, such as habitat loss or overexploitation. The concept of misplaced conservation focuses on activities where conservation resources are expended on an improper, unsuitable, or unworthy activity and the intended outcome of such activity was: (i) to maintain or restore biodiversity, but this outcome is impeded by lack of cooperation and evidence and (ii) to intentionally impede the use of cooperation and evidence in the context of doing conservation. For these reasons, misplaced conservation arises from the combined underlying influences of polarization and misinformation on conservation activities. By articulating the concept of misplaced conservation (Fig. 1), we hope to provide a framework to help overcome barriers to more effective conservation actions. At its most benign, misplaced conservation may arise from genuine motivations to conserve biodiversity. These motivations may quickly give rise to incremental actions that appear as “baby steps” or “raising awareness”. Too often, the success of these actions is not supported with evidence of their positive effect on biodiversity and may instead be distracting or otherwise placating people into a false sense of success (Hagmann et al. 2019). For example, “nudging” is a concept that alters the architecture of choice or the context in which choices are made to provide options that have smaller benefits, with lower costs, with quicker pay offs (Thaler and Sunstein 2009). While nudging has proven effective in many circumstances (Sunstein 2017), it can also lead to complacency that undermines support for more impactful policies and decision-making. Using an experimental approach, Hagmann et al. (2019) found that people overestimated the effectiveness of small gains in environmental policy, when a more costly but more effective alternative was presented. Similarly, simply “raising awareness” does not always lead to positive changes for conservation. In a behavioral experiment, Dunn et al. (2020) found that after watching a documentary about marine conservation, people increased their subject matter knowledge, but they did not change their behaviour with respect to ocean pollutants. While many impactful environmental movements began with smaller, incremental successes, nudges, and awareness campaigns, it should not be assumed that these are effective tools for conservation. The effectiveness of such interventions needs to be evaluated against the potential costs incurred by the fomentation of complacency. Misplaced conservation also occurs when actions are intended to impede successful conservation. This malicious intent could, for example, involve attacking the credibility of an opposing scientist when competing lines of evidence are part of a conflict between stakeholders (Horton et al. 2016; Harvey et al. 2018; Loss and Marra 2018). For example, Hmielowski et al. (2014) found that when the mainstream media work to deliberately decrease trust in scientists, it increases uncertainty that global warming is happening. Giving equal weight to dissenting views, often a hallmark of journalism, without consideration of expertise may further exacerbate the credibility of science (Brown and Havstad 2017) and lead to policies that are inconsistent with the best available evidence to solve problems (Anderegg et al. 2010). [fig. 1 omitted] Whether people are motivated by truly benign outcomes and happen to be misguided or ignorant in their execution of conservation actions or they are motivated to be deliberately malevolent or negligent, we consider all of these intents to be part of misplaced conservation. The outcomes, rather than intentions, help determine misplaced conservation. Here, we describe some of the key actions that create misplaced conservation, supported by case studies to demonstrate this concept. We begin by describing five nonexclusive actions and then discuss solutions to better understand and resolve it—a critical step towards biodiversity conservation in an era of polarization and lies. Broadly speaking, there are direct (1) and indirect (4) pathways through which the actions of people lead to misplaced conservation (Fig. 1). Direct misplaced conservation has a proximate, negative impact on a wildlife population or biodiversity. In contrast, indirect, misplaced conservation impedes the ability of the public, conservation practitioners, stakeholders, or scientists to do conservation. The indirect impacts of misplaced conservation arise from (i) misallocating of resources, (ii) misinforming supporters, (iii) alienating partners, and (iv) delegitimizing evidence. These actions are not mutually exclusive and can combine to influence conservation outcomes (Table 1). For example, this misallocating resources can lead to a direct loss of biodiversity (Bottrill et al. 2008; Gilbert et al. 2020) or the misuse of evidence can entrench alienization of potential partners (Hodgson et al. 2019). Misplaced conservation can arise when an action intended to enhance biodiversity has a direct and negative impact on a wild population, species, or ecological community (Table 1). For example, domestic sheep (Ovis aries) were removed from a private ranch ahead of the area’s forthcoming designation as Patagonia National Park, Chile (Wittmer et al. 2013). A primary motivation to create this protected area was to conserve populations of huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus). However, by removing an important prey item (i.e., sheep) for local carnivores (Vulpes spp. and Puma concolor), predation rates on native deer species increased. The well-intentioned action of creating a more “pristine” environment to benefit huemel deer accelerated their decline. In another case of direct harm, members of the public planted a species of milkweed to help provide habitat for monarch butterflies (Wade 2015). However, some people used a milkweed species that is not native to the temperate species range of monarch butterflies. As a result, monarchs interrupted their migration and were exposed to higher rates of egg parasites. Exposure to this non-native milkweed created a direct threat to monarchs (Satterfield et al. 2015). Lastly, kokanee salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) stocks in Okanagan Lake, British Columbia, were declining through the 1950s (Shepherd 1999). The planned introduction of the exotic mysid shrimp (Mysis relicta) in 1966 was intended to provide productive forage for the native salmon with the intention of bolstering the fishery. However, shrimp were able to escape predation from salmon through diel migration through the water column and then compete with juvenile kokanee for plankton. As a result, the introduction of mysid shrimp reduced forage for juvenile salmon, reducing recruitment, and directly hastening the decline of the salmon fishery. Consequently, there have been calls for the application of additional, costly control measures to lower mysid numbers (Shepherd 1999). The well-intentioned but misplaced effort to conserve biodiversity may exacerbate declines. Efforts to bolster evidence through pilot studies and adaptive management and to improve the uptake of evidence in policy through cooperative approaches in decision-making are needed to minimize the prevalence of direct misplaced conservation. It is a common experience for people working in conservation to operate with under-supported resources. These resources include funding, time, volunteer effort, media attention, or social or political capital. Misplaced conservation occurs when such fixed and limited resources are misallocated to issues that have minimal gains for biodiversity (Table 1). This misallocation of resources makes it more difficult to act upon higher priority action because fewer resources are then available. [table 1 omitted] Misallocating resources has often occurred when conservation agencies decide which species to prioritize for recovery or enhanced management. Species recovery efforts are often targeted at a subset of species under threat—this subset may have a higher “profile” (i.e., is more charismatic) and a lower threat profile than other species. Consequently, species with a lower public profile are underresourced (Donaldson et al. 2016). In some cases, habitat protection for less-charismatic species can be far more cost-effective approach to restoring biodiversity than efforts focused exclusively on high-profile species (Neeson et al. 2018). Similarly, the rise of individually focused conservation outcomes, or “compassionate conservation” (Ramp and Bekoff 2015) pulls resources away from more proximate causes of species or population decline to serve the welfare outcomes of individual animals, usually from a limited subset of large charismatic species (Hayward et al. 2019; Oommen et al. 2019). While animal welfare is embodied in many aspects of wildlife management and research, it is often unstated how attention given to the fate of individuals elevates the conservation of a species, population, or community. For example, many people were upset when “Cecil” the lion was killed by a hunter in 2015, yet policy reforms to support lion conservation have moved little since that time (Carpenter and Konisky 2019). Still, the legacy of Cecil’s death remains a rallying cry for some conservation groups (Darimont et al. 2020). Efforts to address the negative impacts of habitat loss, invasive species, or human–wildlife conflict through compassionate conservation approaches would make unavailable some of the most cost effective and successful tools developed to preserve and restore biodiversity (Callen et al. 2020). To minimize the misallocation of resources, there either needs to be better use of existing allocations, or more resources, and preferably both (Bonebrake et al. 2019). To improve use of existing allocations, conservationists have put forward prioritization schemes to quantify tradeoffs in decision-making (Martin et al. 2018). In some cases, such priority allocation could lead to the loss of some components of biodiversity, but preserve a larger, more valued component (Gilbert et al. 2020). This so-called “conservation triage” has been hotly contested (Bottrill et al. 2008), but until resources are enhanced, there will likely remain a need to prioritize allocations in a world of finite resources. While we argue there is no “most correct” conservation action that inherently deserves priority resource allocation, a more transparent, evidence-based and cooperative decision-making process should at least reveal tradeoffs in resource use. Questions of whose priority matters the most are critical to resolving allocation in a just and equitable manner. As such, the underlying human dimensions of conservation governance are central to mobilizing cooperative approaches to evidence-based decision-making (Decker et al. 2016). Misplaced conservation outcomes can arise when the public is misinformed about which threats are most pressing, which species are a priority for action, and (or) which actions are most beneficial for biodiversity (Table 1). A misinformed public also diverts resources away from actions that benefit conservation. For example, in the 2010s, a series of amateur-made online petitions to ban shark finning in Florida (USA) attracted tens of thousands of signatures. However, shark finning was banned in Florida in 1994, such that these petitions cannot possibly achieve their stated goal. These “finning” campaigns also contribute to the misunderstanding of threats facing sharks by incorrectly suggesting that the shark fin trade is the only threat these animals face (Shiffman and Hueter 2017). In contrast, government-sponsored (e.g., National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), a Federal agency that houses the National Marine Fisheries Service agency (NMFS)) petitions that would lead to tangible policy directions receive little attention. For example, three recent and evidenced-based proposals aimed to improve the sustainability of fisheries: an 2016 NMFS proposal to modify recreational angling regulations for threatened dusky sharks (81 FR 71672), a 2017proposal to alter the US-Atlantic coast shark fishing season (82 FR 55512), and a 2017 proposal to require tuna fishing vessels to release threatened sharks that they capture (82 FR 56177). None of these petitions received substantial public support or commentary (only 87, 13, and 1 comment(s) were posted, respectively). Similar to the case of using non-native milkweed to help monarch butterflies, recent awareness of pollinator conservation has focused largely on campaigns to “save the bees”. However, confusion over how to best do this has been impeded by the conflation of native pollinators and managed, non-native bees (Dicks 2013). Managed bees contribute to the decline of native biodiversity via pathogen spillover and competition for floral nectar (Colla and MacIvor 2017). Broadscale policies to conserve pollinators, such as the US-based Pollinator Partnership Action Plan, focus on land uses and pesticide bans that will benefit non-native honey bees at the expense of native bumblebee species (Nicholls et al. 2020). While wild honey bee conservation is a concern within its native range (Requier et al. 2019), misinformed support for such “insect livestock” and feral, non-native species across North America threatens native pollinators which are truly at risk of extinction (Dicks 2013). Ocean plastics have emerged as a central issue in marine conservation. For example, “straw shaming”—even at the cost of infringing on the needs of people experiencing physical disabilities— is one extreme outcome of the plastic pollution response (Krueger 2019). However, technological solutions to remove ocean garbage (i.e., through surface skimming) may not target the areas of the ocean where most pollution occurs (i.e., at depth) (Stafford and Jones 2019). Like the nudging of decarbonization policy (Hagmann et al. 2019), contemporary approaches to plastic pollution may have created a “convenient truth to distract environmental policy from more serious and urgent threats” (Stafford and Jones 2019). Overcoming these distracting discourses in conservation will not only require effective science but also effective communication of knowledge to support behavioral changes. As with the other dimensions of misplaced conservation, supporters become misinformed when evidence is not communicated clearly or used appropriately. Such misinformed support can be the outcome of conservation leadership failing to “do their homework” for how to best focus the efforts of people invested in positive outcomes for biodiversity. Efforts to better connect conservation biology and conservation social science (including communication science) are critical to channeling clear and accurate information to supporters (Kareiva and Marvier 2012; Bennett et al. 2017). Misplaced conservation can occur when the partners (groups or individuals) become alienated from a shared vision of success that was caused by, or results, in greater polarization. Alienation occurs when short-term gains are elevated over long-term benefits and when individual gains are elevated over collective benefits, giving rise to conservation social dilemmas (Cumming 2018) or conservation conflict (Redpath et al. 2013). While alienation may result from different value systems held by conservation partners and the perceptions of inequity (i.e., superiority) in those value systems relative to others (Saunders et al. 2006; Manfredo et al. 2017), the outcome is disrupted partnerships. For example, hunting, animal welfare, and conservation organizations may not share the same ethical, instrumental, or utilitarian values towards wildlife, yet all of these groups advocate for better conservation outcomes for wildlife (Butler et al. 2003; Treves 2009; Dickman et al. 2019). When these groups are pitted against one another over a subset of values (e.g., consumptive use of wildlife; evidence vs. anecdote; science vs. emotion), it generates conflict and weakens their collective ability to affect change on commonly shared values (e.g., the persistence of wildlife populations) (Redpath et al. 2017). Given the importance of partnerships in achieving conservation success (McNeely 1995; Cooke et al. 2020), efforts that disrupt partnerships can have dire and long-lasting consequences. One common way alienation manifests is through geopolitical structures that are decoupled from diverse value systems and worldviews. As in many countries, people in rural Sweden had a more favorable view of lethal approaches to human–wildlife conflict than people in urban areas (Gangaas et al. 2013). Urban populations can influence policy on human–wildlife conflict policy without facing the proximate consequences of loss of safety, interruption of livelihood, or damage to property (Ericsson and Heberlein 2003). Rural residents may therefore act outside of regulations (Gangaas et al. 2013) unless given more appropriate tools and resources to resolve conflict with wildlife (König et al. 2020). Similarly, Indigenous perspectives in conservation often are alienated by colonial governments. Recently, The Tahltan Nation in British Columbia offered bounties for grizzly bear and wolf harvest following a province-wide ban on grizzly bear hunting—which the Tahltan had vocally opposed (Simmons 2020). The persistence of stakeholder conflict, unregulated actions, and centralized or colonial decision-making makes it more difficult to conserve biodiversity for rural, urban, and Indigenous people. The emergence of alienated partners speaks clearly to the role of cooperation as an antidote to polarization. In some cases, evidence can help support or bring together groups in a cooperative manner and reduce polarization (Baynham-Herd et al. 2020; Williams et al. 2020). However, science can also become “weaponized” by all sides in public debate, such that more information will not always generate better decisions (Peery et al. 2019). Instead of conflating conservation with a “data gap” per se, efforts to improve processes that lead to better decisions (i.e., in a manner the improves stakeholder or public support) may be needed to overcome the alienation of partners and increase the success of conservation actions. Misplaced conservation can arise [or] when the products (i.e., facts) and generators (i.e., scientists) of evidence are delegitimized in the political or decision-making realm (Table 1). Here, we refer to evidence in the context of biological and social “western science”, and recognize that there are other systems that create, hold, and share knowledge (e.g., Indigenous knowledge) that make important contributions towards conservation (Garnett et al. 2018) and also face delegitimization. Delegitimization may arise when scientists representing different world views, or interpretations of data, come into debate over a policy. The perception of scientific uncertainty is then exploited to undermine conservation outcomes. When decision-makers or the public perceive a lack of scientific consensus, it undermines the value of evidence and confidence in evidence-based decision-making (Lewandowsky et al. 2013). For example, special interest groups may inflate perceptions of uncertainty, via doubt mongering, in a practice that has been seen in polar bear conservation (Harvey et al. 2018), the impact of free ranging cats on biodiversity (Loss and Marra 2018), and responses to climate change (Oreskes and Conway 2011). In some cases, delegitimization may arise from competing interests in the uptake of certain types of information, rather than a lack of information per se. “Whose science matters” becomes central to these debates and evidence may reinforce, rather than neutralize, polarization among groups (Hodgson et al. 2019). Such debates have been documented in raptor conservation (Hodgson et al. 2019), deer management (Freddy et al. 2004), bear hunting (Maji´c et al. 2011), and climate change (Hayhoe 2018). Peery et al. (2019) described the challenge of agenda-driven science in conservation: “because conservation conflicts in an increasingly polarized world might tempt some to engage in agenda-driven science to win a conflict.” Finally, scientists may delegitimize their own contributions to positive conservation outcomes. Unlike fundamental scientific disciplines, conservation sciences actively encourage the blending of curiosity-driven, basic research with mission-oriented applied research and advocacy (Horton et al. 2016; Smol 2018). Conservation scientists often engage in public discourse and play an important role in disseminating facts to the public, stakeholders, and decision-makers (Chan 2008; Smol 2018). However, conservation scientists risk depleting the credibility of the research community in general if values and facts are conflated (Horton et al. 2016; Redpath et al. 2017). Indeed, as Baynham-Herd et al. (2020) showed, trustworthiness of intervenors is seen as a key predictor of cooperation in conservation with integrity ranking as a key dimension of how trust is built. For this reason, transparency in the facts (i.e., scientific consensus) vs. the expressed values of the scientist require clear articulation. As Chan (2008) argued, conservation scientists must clearly communicate where the facts stop and where their own values begin, or they risk abusing goodwill and trust towards science and its practitioners. To avoid or mitigate misplaced conservation efforts, we recommend that more effort be made to adopt an intentional, transparent process of decision-making that accounts for the gains and losses to both cooperation and biodiversity (Saunders et al. 2006). While this effort may at first appear to be conservation dictum, we underscore that cooperation has too often taken a back seat to short-term gains in biodiversity. Finding pathways cooperation, in spite of knowledge gaps and differences in attitudes or beliefs, remains an essential and yet understudied tool in formal conservation education and training (Cinner 2018). Rather than try to change or undermine the values of potential partners, it is usually more effective to find alignment with the existing values of conservation partners (Decker et al. 2016; Manfredo et al. 2017; Hayhoe 2018). Seeing conservation efforts as a push towards better cooperation and use of evidence is one way to suppress the negative effects of polarization and misinformation. Scientists and managers should invest in (and be supported to do so) efforts to monitor the outcomes of conservation action, then interpret, share, and respond adaptively to evidence as it accrues. Such an “adaptive management” approach is often discussed in conservation but not clearly executed (Keith et al. 2011). For example, recent efforts to ban (British Columbia, Canada in 2017) or restore (in Wyoming, USA) grizzly bear hunting have focused on ethics and individual welfare; however, there has been little or no advocacy by conservation groups to create processes that quantify the impacts of these policy changes on bear populations and the people who must co-exist with them. Adaptive management as a means of understanding and solving conservation problems is vulnerable to many of the same challenges faced in misplaced conservation writ large, with self interest, conflicts, and deliberate overconfidence in data serving to undermine management goals (Walters 1997). Reducing uncertainty is a central goal of evidence-based decision-making, yet progress in science is often nonlinear and unpredictable. Debate and paradigm shifts are a normal and important part of the scientific process (Kuhn 2012). Conservation science is no different, with some debates unresolved after decades of research (Young et al. 2010). As such, we do not suggest that conservation scientists should abandon productive and civil debates about science generally or conservation specifically, but we hope that such debates will focus on critical and transparent analysis of data, analyses, techniques, and interpretations, rather than a critique of scientists or the inferred motivations or values of potential conservation partners. Conservation actions often are motivated by perceptions of scarcity and imbue a sense of urgency— the time to act is “now”. However, the risks that come from passionate, but misinformed, people advocating for preferred policy outcomes that misalign with evidence can be high. Cooperation, as antidote to extinction, needs to transcend the roles played by people concerned with biodiversity, of which scientists are but a limited sector. Many groups (e.g., public, experts, scientists, governments, and conservation organizations) are responsible for promoting the importance of biodiversity and acting to averting loss. For this reason, it is not necessary for every concerned member of the public to know every technical detail and nuance of complex environmental problems, nor the policies that can help address them. Nonexperts can help by joining, or working to amplify the message of, expertled and evidence-based conservation campaigns. Nonexperts can also volunteer their time or help raise funds for expert-driven campaigns, or they can write to decision-makers expressing support for (or opposition to) policies as recommended by experts. Ultimately, people should consider that without specific knowledge, training, or experience, that there are real risks to people and biodiversity if ineffective solutions are promoted to resolve complex problems. [table 2 omitted] In addition to cooperation across levels of “expertise”, efforts to promote cooperation across backgrounds and identities has demonstrated positive outcomes for science. Conservation actions stemming from diverse and inclusive processes that include a variety of views and experiences should produce the best outcomes. For example, greater gender diversity on research teams leads to more productive scientific outcomes, in addition to the benefits of creating more equitable workspaces (Nielsen et al. 2017). Likewise, integrating local and macro-scale institutions is a critical step towards recognizing the diversity of power, scope, and governance structures that affect biodiversity (Berkes 2007; Popp et al. 2019). Including local peoples in decision-making increases their agency over resources and should increase acceptance of any changes to their daily lives that come from conservation actions. An important vehicle for cooperation is open, transparent, and respectful communication with all relevant partners (Lundquist and Granek 2005). Stakeholders and rights holders who believe that regulations were developed in a reasonable, fair manner that incorporates collective priorities are more likely to follow resulting regulations and laws (Kennedy 2010; Dressel et al. 2020). Likewise, when stakeholders feel like they and their concerns are being ignored, they are more likely to ignore the resulting regulations (Suman et al. 1999; Freddy et al. 2004). Shiffman (2020) documented how strategically communicating key scientific facts and science-based policy solutions resulted in passing new environmental regulations while minimizing inter-stakeholder conflicts. Social media has transformed how people communicate with one another, a transformation that has important implications for both environmental advocacy and for conservation scientists who wish to engage in public outreach (Parsons et al. 2014; Lamb et al. 2018; Smol 2018). This transformation may not always result in positive gains for biodiversity (i.e., via the spread of misinformation; Vosoughi et al. (2018)); nonetheless, social media is a powerful form of intervention and feedback. When used well, social media also has the potential to infuse public discourse with expert-supported approaches to conservation and pushback on misinformation (Thaler and Shiffman 2015; Shiffman 2020). In addition, scientists can now hear the concerns people are expressing on social media about biodiversity-related policies and this, in turn, can help design more cooperative approaches to conservation and nuanced communication strategies. This insight needs to be contextualized of course, as the media channels available to a scientist are constructed through the same biased algorithms as the information leading from the scientist to the public. As much as there are positive steps people can take to reduce misplaced conservation, acting poorly can make a bad situation worse. There is a need for conservation scientists to acknowledge that people trying to help is not the same as helping, and good intentions do not excuse easily foreseen or managed harm. Case studies of misplaced conservation often highlight people who wanted to help but may have not foreseen the myriad outcomes of their actions. However, conservation decisions affect the existence of species, peoples’ livelihoods, or the intactness of cultures—the onus on better decision-making leaves little room for error (Foote and Wenzel 2009). Misplaced conservation asks scientists and stakeholders to acknowledge that outcomes—rather than intentions—are the arbitrator of conservation success. Society has enshrined into law the concept of negligence to help guide responsible behaviour when the outcomes were reasonably anticipated. For example, driving while intoxicated is against the law in many places because it is a known and well-established risk to public safety—the intentions of the driver (e.g., to get home) are not at issue. There often are no explicit laws to protect against misplaced conservation (i.e., excluding environmental regulations) and this is unlikely to occur. However, there is a need to better hold people involved in making conservation decisions accountable for their role in promoting polarization and misinformation. The benefits of cooperative and evidence-based approaches to conservation are well described and are generally regarded as essential for achieving conservation gains (Keith et al. 2011). These approaches build policy with evidence and integrate wholistic dimensions of conservation practice—including the roles of governance, politics, social justice, and fundamental ecology. Yet, the adoption of these concepts is far from universal practice. There is a need to better understand and then address the practices that run counter to the body of knowledge that has described pathways to effective conservation practice (Table 2). Society is witnessing one of the largest and most rapid mobilizations of scientific focus and public policy in history in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Along with the urgency and scope of this crisis, lessons are quickly emerging about the critical role of scientific integrity and accountability and the need for accurate communication between science, policy, and the public (Piller 2020). Conservation science will benefit from these lessons as society continues to cope with accelerating global extinctions. Articulating the mechanisms of, and solutions, to misplaced conservation will help ensure that efforts to restore and protect biodiversity are successful.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Biodiversity** › 2AC Biodiversity Add-On

Disinformation wrecks public confidence in science which undermines solutions to climate change and diseases---plan is key to solve

T. V. Gerbina, 22, Gerbina is from an Institute for Scientific and Technical Information from Russia; “Science Disinformation: On the Problem of Fake News”, Springer, 2-25-2022,

This article is devoted to an important socio-cultural phenomenon that undermines public confidence in science, that is, fake science news. The term fake news is analyzed and data on the dissemination of fake news on social networks is provided. Information sources for science news and fake science news are identified. Special attention is paid to the dissemination of fake science news during the COVID-19 pandemic.

According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the 2016 word of the year was post-truth. According to the definition of British linguists, this concept means circumstances in which objective facts have less influence on the formation of public opinion than emotions or personal beliefs [1]. This phenomenon arose due to the influence of the media: by manipulating society, they create a different reality. One of the main reasons for the post-truth era is the abundance of fake news that the audience is unable to recognize.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › NATO key

Increased information guarding with NATO’s resources is the linchpin of countering Russian, Chinese, and COVID disinformation

Dale F. Reding and Bryan Wells, 22, Reding and Wells are from the office of the chief scientist, NATO headquarters; “Cognitive Warfare: NATO, COVID-19 and the Impact of Emerging and Disruptive Technologies”, Springer, 05-04-2022, https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/978-3-030-94825-2_2.pdf/chuo

===can be used as not just NATO key but also the actions they do---if the warrants & solutions the card mentions aligns w/ the aff then this card can be used

===definitely not the best card (unless the strat specifically focuses on the cognitive warfare side of things) but talks about NATO’s strategy in the past and how NATO can work on this w/ disinformation increasing moving forwards

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › NATO key

NATO key to countering disinformation---multiple warrants

Tomasz Chłoń, 5/16; Chłoń was the ambassador of Poland to Estonia (2005-2010) and to Slovakia (2013-2015), and the director of NATO Information Office Moscow (2017-2020); “NATO and Countering Disinformation The Need for a More Proactive Approach from the Member States”, GLOBSEC, 16-05-2022, chuo

===[last part also talks about cohesion key!] Russian disinfo is high now b/c of the war & false narratives they’ve spread in the past, so it’s up to NATO’s cohesion (and coordinating capabilities), credibility, expertise, guidance, financial support, mandates, and the ability for them to create a global snowball to organizations and nations to counter it.

One of the founding myths of Russian foreign policy (developed below) relates to a betrayal by the West. Many in Russia are either unwilling or too scared to challenge the veracity of this tale since it has become national dogma. As the freedom of speech constitutes one of the fundamental and respected rights of democracies, this myth is also widely spread throughout the West. Moreover, the West’s culture of open debates, which respects differing points of view, puts Russian masterminds of false narratives in a privileged position when it comes to influencing Western societies and their decision-making processes. It also renders NATO and EU countries increasingly vulnerable to influence from pro-Kremlin propagandists spurred on by an unbridled sense of initiative and combined with active measures as well as armed conflicts. The matrix of the myth of Western betrayal and Russian self-victimisation is the “broken promise of not enlarging NATO to the East”. The Kremlin has also used this myth to justify the full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022 – a move that has potentially incalculable consequences for European and even global security. This new stage in Russia’s confrontational policy has been further solidified with support from the increasingly belligerent Belarusian dictator although Alyaksandr Lukashenka’s standing has also been weakened through his complete dependence on Russia. Minsk, assisted in turn by Moscow, created a migration crisis on the Belarusian border with Poland, Lithuania and, to a lesser extent, Latvia, thereby opening an additional hybrid front. Increased tension on NATO’s entire eastern flank and the war waged by Russia against Ukraine have been exacerbated by Russian and Belarusian hostile disinformation activities, which are unprecedented in terms of scope, intensity and toxicity. In both Russia and Belarus, the highest political authorities, diplomats, state-controlled media, special services and their proxies have been actively involved in spreading familiar but intensified false narratives as well as new concoctions that are particularly harmful to the public in the Russian-language, state-controlled information environment. Unfortunately, some of these narratives fall on fertile ground in certain circles in the West and are cynically exploited in local political struggles. The goal of disinformation is to undo the cohesion of the transatlantic community, undermine the credibility of NATO and EU members and, ultimately, derail the existing rules-based international order. The “new-old” story is that: Russia, and now Belarus, are surrounded by foes, and the heightened security crisis is the fault of the West, which had been allegedly pushing Ukraine towards war. Having rejected the Minsk agreements, Ukraine had been preparing to launch military operations against the inhabitants of Donbas, occupied Crimea and regions in Russia itself; to this end, Kyiv had been concentrating its forces and resources (including weapon systems received from NATO countries) in the east of the country. Polish and American mercenaries were also operating and preparing armed provocations in the east of Ukraine; this means that not only Ukraine but also the West itself had been preparing to attack the Russian Federation and Belarus. Ukraine had been mobilising troops on the border with Belarus, against which Poland has been making territorial claims. Finally, Vladimir Putin justified his illegal assault on Ukraine with the need to demilitarise and denazify Ukraine. He did so despite the fact that the Ukrainian nation lost 8 million people in World War II fighting Nazi Germany and is a country led by a Jewish president who won the popular vote in a free, fair and democratic election; an election which showed the Ukrainian neo-Nazi parties having less support than probably anywhere else in Europe.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › Vaccine Extensions

A new pandemic will cause severe economic failure

IMF, 20 — [IMF The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is an international organization that promotes global economic growth and financial stability, encourages international trade, and reduces poverty, “World Economic Outlook Update, June 2020: A Crisis Like No Other, An Uncertain Recovery,” 6-24-2020 https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2020/06/24/WEOUpdateJune2020, accessed 7-11-2022, Rachel]

Downside risks, however, remain significant. Outbreaks could recur in places that appear to have gone past peak infection, requiring the reimposition of at least some containment measures. A more prolonged decline in activity could lead to further scarring, including from wider firm closures, as surviving firms hesitate to hire jobseekers after extended unemployment spells, and as unemployed workers leave the labor force entirely. Financial conditions may again tighten as in January–March, exposing vulnerabilities among borrowers. This could tip some economies into debt crises and slow activity further. More generally, cross-border spillovers from weaker external demand and tighter financial conditions could further magnify the impact of country- or region-specific shocks on global growth. Moreover, the sizable policy response following the initial sudden stop in activity may end up being prematurely withdrawn or improperly targeted due to design and implementation challenges, leading to misallocation and the dissolution of productive economic relationships. Some of these aspects are featured in the Scenario Box, which presents growth projections under alternative scenarios. Beyond pandemic-related downside risks, escalating tensions between the United States and China on multiple fronts, frayed relationships among the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)+ coalition of oil producers, and widespread social unrest pose additional challenges to the global economy. Moreover, against a backdrop of low inflation and high debt (particularly in advanced economies), protracted weak aggregate demand could lead to further disinflation and debt service difficulties that, in turn, weigh further on activity.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › Vaccine Extensions

Widespread diseases like a covid variant will be devastating

Mooney 21— [Tom Mooney; Senior Communications & Advocacy Manager, CEPI, “Preparing for the next “Disease X” – CEPI,” CEPI, 2-1-2021, https://cepi.net/news_cepi/preparing-for-the-next-disease-x/, accessed 7-11-2022, Rachel]

We also know that beta coronaviruses that cause SARS and MERS are associated with case fatality rates of 10-35% (25-88 times worse than COVID-19) and that coronaviruses circulate widely in animal reservoirs. The emergence of a coronavirus variant combining the transmissibility of COVID-19 with the lethality of SARS or MERS would be utterly devastating. We must minimise this threat as a matter of urgency. One way to do this in the long-term would be to develop a vaccine that provides broad protection against coronaviruses in general.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › Vaccine Extensions

Herd immunity key to keep disease in control

Randolph and Barreiro ‘20 — [Haley E. Randolph, Genetics, Genomics, and Systems Biology, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA; Luis B. Barreiro; Genetics, Genomics, and Systems Biology, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA Department of Medicine, Section of Genetic Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA Committee on Immunology, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA; “Herd Immunity: Understanding COVID-19,” Immunity; Volume 52, Issue 5, 5-19-2020, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1074761320301709, accessed 7-10-2022, Rachel]

 is established at the level of the individual, either through natural infection with a pathogen or through immunization with a vaccine. Herd immunity (Box 1) stems from the effects of individual immunity scaled to the level of the population. It refers to the indirect protection from infection conferred to susceptible individuals when a sufficiently large proportion of immune individuals exist in a population. This population-level effect is often considered in the context of vaccination programs, which aim to establish herd immunity so that those who cannot be vaccinated, including the very young and immunocompromised, are still protected against disease. Depending on the prevalence of existing immunity to a pathogen in a population, the introduction of an infected individual will lead to different outcomes (Figure 1). In a completely naive population, a pathogen will propagate through susceptible hosts in an unchecked manner following effective exposure of susceptible hosts to infected individuals. However, if a fraction of the population has immunity to that same pathogen, the likelihood of an effective contact between infected and susceptible hosts is reduced, since many hosts are immune and, therefore, cannot transmit the pathogen. If the fraction of susceptible individuals in a population is too few, then the pathogen cannot successfully spread, and its prevalence will decline. The point at which the proportion of susceptible individuals falls below the threshold needed for transmission is known as the herd immunity threshold (Anderson and May, 1985). Above this level of immunity, herd immunity begins to take effect, and susceptible individuals benefit from indirect protection from infection (B).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › Vaccine Extensions

misinformation abt vaccines high now - covid proves

Terry-21 (Ken Terry is an expertise in health care and health IT, an award winning journalist, webmd, 11/10/2021 Most Americans Have Been Duped by COVID Misinformation: Survey, )

Nearly 8 in 10 U.S. S adults either believe or aren't sure about at least one of eight false statements about the COVID-19 pandemic or the COVID-19 vaccines, according to a new Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) survey. Unvaccinated adults and Republicans are among those most likely to hold these misconceptions, the nationally representative poll shows. Overall, 78% believed at least one piece of misinformation. Nearly two-thirds of unvaccinated adults (64%) believe or are unsure about at least half of the eight false statements, compared with 19% of vaccinated adults. Forty-six percent of Republicans believe or are unsure about at least half of the statements, 3 times the share of Democrats in that category (14%). Independent voters were not factored into the survey results.

The topline results show: Sixty percent of adults say they've heard that the government is exaggerating the number of COVID-19 deaths by counting deaths due to other factors and either believe it to be true (38%) or aren't sure if it's true (22%). Four in 10 (39%) respondents say they've heard that pregnant women should not get the COVID-19 vaccine and believe it to be true (17%) or aren't sure if it's true (22%). Three in 10 (31%) say they've heard that the vaccine has been shown to cause infertility and either believe it (8%) or aren't sure if it's true (23%). Thirty-five percent of respondents say they've heard that the government is hiding deaths from the COVID-19 vaccine; 18% believe it, and 17% say they're not sure if it's tru. Other statements attract less but substantial support: Twenty-eight percent of respondents have heard that the antiparasitic drug ivermectin is a safe and effective treatment for COVID; 14% believe it, 14% are not sure if it's true. Twenty-four percent of Americans have heard that you can get COVID from the vaccine; 14% believe that to be true, while 10% are unsure. Twenty-four percent of respondents have heard that the vaccines contain microchips; 7% believe it, 17% say they've heard that but don't know if it's true. Twenty-one percent of Americans have heard claims that the vaccine can change DNA or don't know if it's true. Misinformation by News Source. The report notes that "people's trusted news sources are correlated with their belief in COVID-19 misinformation." At least a third of those who trust information from CNN, MSNBC, NPR, and local and network TV news do not believe any of the eight false statements. Depending on their mix of these news sources, only 11%-16% of this group believe or are unsure about at least four of the eight false statements. In contrast, 36% of people who trust Fox News, 37% of those who trust One America News, and 46% of those who trust Newsmax say they believe or are unsure about at least half of the eight false statements. It's also notable that 44% of people who trust NPR, 48% of those who trust MSNBC, 50% of those who trust network news, and 49% of those who trust CNN believe or are unsure about one to three of the false statements. While larger shares of people who trust COVID information from conservative news sources believe misinformation, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation, the researchers say the survey cannot explain those beliefs. "Whether this is because people are exposed to misinformation from those news sources, or whether the types of people who choose those news sources are the same ones who are pre-disposed to believe certain types of misinformation for other reasons, is beyond the scope of the analysis," they write. The poll results show the role partisanship plays in which networks are trusted. Democrats trust COVID-19 information from network (72%) and local (66%) television, CNN (65%), MSNBC (56%), and NPR (51%). Republicans' most trusted news sources for COVID-19 information are Fox News (49%), local (34%) and network (25%) news, and Newsmax (22%). Few adults say they trust social-media sources for COVID-19 information, such as YouTube (13%), Facebook (9%), Twitter (6%), and Instagram (5%). However, the researchers write that the groups influenced by information they see on those platforms may be larger than these percentages indicate, as previous KFF surveys have found that nearly as many adults get information about COVID-19 vaccines from social media as from cable, network, and local TV news. Partisan COVID Mortality Gap. Wherever people get their news, misinformation that determines their attitudes about COVID-19 and the vaccines has likely had real-world consequences. According to a recent article in The New York Times, a gap between the higher COVID death tolls in more Republican areas and lower death tolls in more Democratic areas of the country has developed in 2021 — with an association emerging between attitudes toward the COVID vaccines and the resulting willingness to be vaccinated between those regions. In October, the Times reports, 25 out of every 100,000 residents of counties that voted heavily for Donald Trump in the last presidential election died from COVID. That's 3 times higher than the mortality rate in counties that strongly supported Joe Biden (7.8 per 100,000).

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › Vaccine Extensions

Misinformation affects underserved communities the most

Scheufele and Krause 18 — [Dietram A. Scheufele; Department of Life Sciences Communication, College of Agricultural and Life Sciences, University of Wisconsin–Madison, Madison, WI 53706., Nicole M. Krause; Department of Life Sciences Communication, College of Agricultural and Life Sciences, University of Wisconsin–Madison, Madison, WI 53706 “Science audiences, misinformation, and fake news,” PNAS, 11-9-2018, https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1805871115, accessed 7-11-2022, Rachel]

A last area with a dearth of systematic empirical work are mechanisms to reach audiences that are often underserved by traditional channels for science communication. Newspapers, science television, or even science museums, for instance, tend to reach more educated and higher-income audiences (). Furthermore, from work dating back to the 1970s on widening knowledge gaps, we also know that citizens with higher socioeconomic status (levels of education and income) are able to learn more efficiently from new information than their peers. As a result, quality scientific information is not only more likely to reach more educated and higher-income audiences, but, when it does, the ability of citizens with higher socioeconomic status to process new information more efficiently can further widen existing gaps between the already information-rich and the information-poor.

Our inability to reach all segments of the population equally well with high-quality scientific information is particularly troubling, given that the need for antidotes to misinformation might be particularly pronounced among certain groups of the public. One indicator of this problem is the educational and income gaps related to seeing fake news as a problem in the first place. In a 2016 Pew survey after the US presidential election (), almost three in four Americans (73%) with a household income over $75,000 thought that completely made-up news caused “a great deal” of confusion. Comparatively, fewer than three in five (58%) respondents with a household income of $30,000 shared that concern. However, socioeconomic gaps also emerge with respect to people’s confidence in their own ability to spot fake news in the first place. A 2018 US survey commissioned by The Economist asked respondents about their ability to distinguish real and fake news (); 83% of respondents with a family income of at least $100,000 felt “very confident” or “somewhat confident” that they could “tell real news from fake news.” Among respondents with an income of less than $50,000, that number dropped to 63%.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › 2AC Vaccines Add-On

Future pandemics cause extinction

Eleftherios P. Diamandis 21 (works for the Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada; Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute, Mount Sinai Hospital, Toronto, Canada; Department of Laboratory Medicine and Pathobiology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada. “The Mother of All Battles: Viruses vs. Humans. Can Humans Avoid Extinction in 50-100 Years? 4/13/21 https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202104.0397/v1)//conway

The recent SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, which is causing COVID 19 disease, has taught us unexpected lessons about the dangers of human extinction through highly contagious and lethal diseases. As the COVID 19 pandemic is now being controlled by various isolation measures, therapeutics and vaccines, it became clear that our current lifestyle and societal functions may not be sustainable in the long term. We now have to start thinking and planning on how to face the next dangerous pandemic, not just overcoming the one that is upon us now. Is there any evidence that even worse pandemics could strike us in the near future and threaten the existence of the human race? The answer is unequivocally yes. It is not necessary to get infected by viruses of bats, pangolins and other exotic animals that live in remote forests in order to be in danger. Creditable scientific evidence indicates that the human gut microbiota harbor billions of viruses which are capable of affecting the function of vital human organs such as the immune system, lung, brain, liver, kidney, heart etc. It is possible that the development of pathogenic variants in the gut can lead to contagious viruses which can cause pandemics, leading to destruction of vital organs, causing death or various debilitating diseases such as blindness, respiratory, liver, heart and kidney failures. These diseases could result n the complete shutdown of our civilization and probably the extinction of human race. In this essay, I will first provide a few independent pieces of scientific facts and then combine this information to come up with some (but certainly not all) hypothetical scenarios that could cause human race misery, even extinction. I hope that these scary scenarios will trigger preventative measures that could reverse or delay the projected adverse outcomes.

2022 Michigan Affirmative
Aff Addendum › **Vaccines** › 2AC Vaccines Add-On

Vaccines are also crucial to stopping future pandemics—but reassuring the public about their safety is crucial:

Julie L. Gerberding, M.D., M.P.H., and Barton F. Haynes, M.D., 2/4/2021 (New England Journal of Medicine, “Vaccine Innovations — Past and Future,” , Retrieved 8/2/2021)

Vaccination is a powerful method of disease prevention that is relevant to people of all ages and in all countries, as the Covid-19 pandemic illustrates. Vaccination can improve people’s chances of survival, protect communities from new and reemerging health threats, and enhance societal productivity. But achieving the promise of vaccination requires much more than the vaccines themselves. It requires appropriate incentives to encourage the timely discovery and development of innovative, effective, safe, and affordable products; effective financing and delivery programs; and credible scientific leaders who can provide evidence-based policy recommendations and reassure the public about the value of the vaccines. Since its inception 50 years ago, the National Academy of Medicine (NAM), previously known as the Institute of Medicine (IOM), has been an authoritative resource on medical issues, including vaccination, and a global leader in vaccine-policy development. FDA Licensure Dates for Selected Innovative Vaccines since 1970. It’s hard to overstate the benefits that innovative vaccines deployed in the past five decades have had on morbidity and mortality (see timeline).1 The incidence of vaccine-preventable diseases among U.S. children has decreased dramatically, an achievement that is attributable in part to high vaccine-coverage rates. By the 2018–2019 school year, coverage rates among kindergarteners exceeded 90% in all but two states, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Four vaccine-preventable illnesses have been eliminated from the Americas: smallpox in 1971, poliomyelitis in 1994, and rubella and congenital rubella syndrome in 2015 (one of us is an executive vice president at Merck, which produces vaccines for rubella, among other vaccines). Moreover, between 2011 and 2020, immunization programs in low-income countries saved an estimated 23.3 million lives.2 Perhaps the most notable immunization-related accomplishment during the past half century was the eradication of smallpox, which was verified by the World Health Organization (WHO) in 1980. In addition, global cases of paralytic polio have decreased by 99.95% from the estimated 350,000 cases in 1988,3 when the global polio-eradication program was announced, and two of the three wild-type polioviruses, WPV types 2 and 3, have been eradicated. Other important achievements during this period include the 1986 approval of the first vaccine based on recombinant technology, a hepatitis B vaccine that not only has reduced rates of the infection in many countries but was also the first vaccine to reduce cancer risk. In 1987, the first polysaccharide-protein conjugate vaccine was licensed; since then, the incidence of invasive Haemophilus influenzae type b disease among children has fallen dramatically. In 2009, a vaccine for Neisseria meningitidis group A became the first licensed vaccine specifically designed for certain people in low-income countries. Achieving broad population health benefits associated with vaccination requires effective policies that create incentives for vaccine development, ensure financing of vaccines, and improve access. After a measles outbreak in 1989–1991, the U.S. Vaccines for Children Program was authorized in 1993 to ensure that eligible children would have free access to all CDC-recommended vaccines. To address remaining gaps, the IOM in 2000 issued a landmark report that recommended policy and programmatic improvements to strengthen U.S. immunization programs. One outcome of this effort was the requirement included in the 2010 Affordable Care Act that plans provide first-dollar coverage (coverage without copayments or other cost sharing) for vaccines recommended by the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices for children and adults up to age 26. Policy advances have also enhanced the effects of vaccination globally. The WHO launched the Expanded Program on Immunization in 1974 to increase access to vaccines. Beginning in 2000, the benefits of this program were greatly enhanced by the creation of Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, an international public–private partnership that provides financial and programmatic support to ensure that children in the poorest countries have access to vaccines. In 2017, with the support of the NAM and other organizations, this model was used as a framework for the creation of the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations to fund innovative vaccines and other countermeasures against pathogens that cause devastating public health consequences, such as the Ebola virus and now SARS-CoV-2. Because vaccines are usually administered to healthy people, maintaining the highest safety standards isn’t only an ethical imperative but is also essential to sustaining public trust. The story of vaccine progress has been punctuated by both real and misguided safety concerns for as long as vaccines have been in use. Such concerns have included adverse events associated with vaccination itself, quality lapses in the manufacturing process, and false alarms regarding vaccine safety. The potential for financial gain has fueled liability suits related to putative safety concerns. The NAM has conducted ongoing objective assessments of vaccine safety to help address concerns. Between 2000 and 2004, its Immunization Safety Review Committee evaluated evidence pertinent to various vaccine-safety topics and set a new standard for independent scientific review that remains relevant as the NAM contributes to coronavirus-related policies. Vaccine confidence depends on trust in the safety and efficacy of the products themselves, trust in vaccine manufacturers and the clinicians who administer vaccines, and trust in policymakers who assess the scientific evidence and promulgate vaccination recommendations. Failures in any of these areas can have substantial long-term public health consequences, as was the case with misinformation about measles vaccines. Enduring mistrust stemming from a discredited study that associated childhood vaccination with autism has been linked to recent outbreaks of measles in the United States. Sustaining both vaccine safety and trust in vaccination will become increasingly complex. Vaccines continue to be approved, and more vaccines have become accessible in resource-limited countries, but safety surveillance systems are less evolved in many low-income regions than in high-income regions. Similarly, vaccines are being manufactured in regions where regulatory oversight isn’t always optimal, and counterfeit vaccines remain a threat. Emerging infections may require rapid availability of new vaccines before comprehensive safety studies are complete. Perhaps most important, the speed and reach of communication on social media platforms have created unprecedented opportunities for users to amplify misinformation and flame the fears of parents and other stakeholders in the immunization ecosystem. Moving forward, vaccines against a range of infectious agents will need to be developed. New and reemerging pathogens, such as SARS-CoV-2 and new influenza strains, regularly appear. Viruses that are capable of spreading by vector or airborne routes — one of the most important pandemic threats — continue to emerge. More than 1.5 million as yet unknown viruses are estimated to exist in animals worldwide, and 38 to 50% of them are candidates to spread to humans.4 Global-surveillance and virus-discovery programs are therefore important, and they may be able to predict pandemics. In 2011, the IOM commissioned the development of a strategic multiattribute ranking tool for vaccines to facilitate evaluation of new vaccine targets and help guide decisions about prioritizing vaccine-development efforts. When pandemics emerge, rapid responses are necessary. Vaccines aren’t the only available tool: passive administration of antibodies for prevention or treatment of infectious diseases has been used for many years. The Pandemic Prevention Platform program of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency aims to develop a new form of passive antibody protection that can slow viral epidemics starting within 60 days after identification of the pathogen and until a vaccine can be made. Thanks to new technology, the vaccine-development process is also being condensed. Experimental vaccines were developed and ready for phase 1 clinical trials in 20 months for SARS after the epidemic began in 2003 and in slightly more than 3 months for Zika virus in 2016. The response to the Covid-19 pandemic is a prime example of how rapidly new vaccines can now be designed. By the time the WHO declared Covid-19 a pandemic on March 11, 2020, at least 37 groups from biotechnology companies and academic institutions were working on vaccine candidates.5 These candidates include live attenuated, inactivated, DNA, messenger RNA, viral vector, and spike-protein–based vaccines. Less than 1 year later, the first Covid-19 vaccine-efficacy trials have now been completed, and the first vaccines are authorized for emergency use. Many approved vaccines, such as those against measles and polio, were made using attenuated or killed versions of the virus without detailed knowledge of viral pathogenesis. In contrast, current strategies for vaccine design rely on new technologies that lead to a deeper understanding of the immune system and of host–pathogen interactions. For new experimental HIV and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) vaccines, a detailed structural understanding of antibody interactions with the HIV envelope or the RSV prefusion form of the fusion (F) protein is needed. Vaccines remain the most effective tool for preventing infectious diseases and improving global health. Remarkable progress has been made with the use of vaccines, including the eradication of smallpox and the control of childhood diseases such as measles, mumps, rubella, and polio. New insights into the functioning of the immune system on a cellular and molecular level have made possible the rapid development of new vaccines. Difficulties facing vaccinologists include predicting the type and timing of the next pandemic; developing vaccines to combat rapidly changing pathogens such as HIV-1, influenza, and multidrug-resistant bacteria; and establishing rapid-response strategies to control emerging and reemerging infectious diseases. The future holds great promise for vaccine-mediated control of global pathogens, but providing affordable access to effective vaccines for everyone who could benefit from them remains an important challenge.