2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Econ CP › 1NC---Econ CP
Baily 20, Martin Neil, 12-16-2020, Ph.D. in economics in 1972 at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Senior Fellow Emeritus in Economic Studies at Brookings. "How to boost long-run growth after COVID-19," Brookings, //BigSasher
Members of the workforce who have not completed a college degree and receive very little on-the-job training are shortchanged by our current educational system. These workers have seen their earnings stagnate, and they are undercutting their lifetime incomes by leaving the workforce early.[11] To improve the post-pandemic labor market and to help companies be more productive, policymakers should invest in an expanded skills training program. This is not a short-term policy, it is a long-run project. Achieving stronger productivity and more inclusive growth depends on creating a more skilled workforce.
In designing a training program it is vital to avoid the problems that have plagued such efforts in the past. Anthony Carnevale, a training expert now at Georgetown, has laid out the key problems. Many previous programs were designed to train workers for manufacturing jobs even though the availability of manufacturing jobs is limited. Most past programs were run in collaboration with unions and employers have adversarial relationships with them. Some past programs have been costly to employers and workers they have trained quit for a better jobs elsewhere. Some parents are opposed to training programs, seeing them as pushing their children into second-class careers.[12 ]Carnevale notes the federal training budget is only $8 billion, so we are not really trying to train the workforce. This proposal by Brookings expert Annelies Goger includes elements I just described. It recommends scaling up “earn and learn” programs in states and regions, in which employer and community college partnerships provide workers a compensation as they receive on-the-job training.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › China CP › 1NC---China CP---Hotlines
Kylie Atwood 21, national security correspondent and graduated cum laude from Middlebury College with a major in international studies and a minor in economics, Biden administration looks to set up 'red phone' to China for emergency communications, CNN, 7-14-2021, https://www.cnn.com/2021/07/14/politics/biden-red-phone-china-xi/index.html/shppp
A hotline to Beijing would let President Joe Biden, or top officials on his national security team, immediately send encrypted phone calls or messages to President Xi Jinping or those around him, according to the two sources. For example, urgent information could be shared about sudden military movements or warning messages sent about cyber hacks.
The idea of setting up a hotline with Beijing dates back to at least the Obama administration, though the concept wasn't codified into a classified national security memo until the final year of the Trump administration, according to a source familiar with the memo.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › China CP › 1NC---China CP---Hotlines
Robert Pape 14, Professor of Political Science and Director of the Chicago Project on Security and Terrorism at the University of Chicago, 4/29/14, Washington Post, “A hotline to cool Asian crises,” )
The “Red Telephone” connecting world leaders is the modern epitome of crisis management. Yet, it might surprise most Americans to learn that, despite the increasing power of China and the potential for conflict and misunderstanding, no such working connection exists between the U.S. and China. In the past five years, the East Asian region has been embroiled in a series of minor territorial disputes as China has asserted its regional dominance over its neighbors; some of these have directly involved China and the United States. There is no easier step to defuse potential conflict between these two great powers than to establish a hotline – to be known as CHILINK – between them.
The proposed hotline would be similar to the one between the United States and Russia (MOLINK) during the Cold War. Though popularized in “Dr. Strangelove,” MOLINK was not a telephone, but simply a plain text teletype transmission system. MOLINK was activated on Aug. 30, 1963, in response to the frantic and inefficient communication between the United States and the Soviet Union during the Cuban Missile Crisis. MOLINK has multiple terminals in key government buildings, only some of which are able to transmit a response. During the Cold War, the transmission traveled along multiple pathways to ensure reliable delivery; in 2008, the hotline was upgraded to a new fiber optic-enabled system, enabling both audio and e-mail messages.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Bioterrorism CP › 2NC---Bioterrorism CP
Erenler, Güzel, and Baydin 18 — Ali Kemal Erenler; Murat Güzel; Ahmet Baydin, 2018 (“How Prepared Are We for Possible Bioterrorist Attacks: An Approach from Emergency Medicine Perspective,” ScientificWorldJournal, July 8th, Available Online at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6076891/, Accessed 07-21-2022)
Reports reveal that we are not well-prepared to deal with a terrorist attack that employs biological weapons. As was done in response to the nuclear threat, the medical community should educate the public and policy makers about the threat. In the longer term, we need to be prepared to detect, diagnose, characterize epidemiologically, and respond appropriately to biological weapons use and the threat of new and reemerging infections. On the immediate horizon, we cannot delay the development and implementation of strategic plans for coping with civilian bioterrorism. [26]. As a result, education and training of the healthcare providers, especially emergency physicians, are the mainstay of the battle against bioterrorism. Emergency departments must be constructed in a way suitable for a possible chaos and overcrowding that may occur when a real event happens. Awareness and preparedness to biological warfare agents must be accepted as a part of national biodefense policy.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Bioterrorism CP › 1NC---Bioterrorism CP
Erenler, Güzel, and Baydin 18 — Ali Kemal Erenler; Murat Güzel; Ahmet Baydin, 2018 (“How Prepared Are We for Possible Bioterrorist Attacks: An Approach from Emergency Medicine Perspective,” ScientificWorldJournal, July 8th, Available Online at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6076891/, Accessed 07-21-2022)
A secure communication pathway in association with health departments and public health officials to outbreaks of bioterrorist events may be created between emergency services and governmental public health departments. Communication between medical health providers, emergency room personnel, infection-control personnel, and infectious-disease personnel in hospitals might be constituted and maintained through a health advisory network. In addition, at regular intervals, meetings may be performed in order to share information regarding planning responses in collaboration against bioterrorist attacks. Local health authorities, including emergency services, should examine their preparedness repeatedly for a potential bioterrorist attack and routinely review coordination issues with agencies that take place in response. Programs aimed to coordinate and direct emergency preparedness and response including antibioterrorism efforts should be created [18]. Training programs for health providers are also useful for preparedness and alertness. It was shown that when gaming simulations were used to test knowledge and skill of individuals who engage in antibioterrorism, better outcomes were obtained with trained personnel [19]. Association of better scores with training underline the importance of training programs when a real event is faced. However, in a survey study with 1028 participants in Canada, it was reported that most of the emergency service providers have not been trained enough to identify and work in contaminated environments under chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear attacks [20]. The situation must be considered worse in developing countries, and programs focusing on health providers, especially those in emergency services, must be initiated as quickly as possible. Public health providers can be trained either by online education programs or face to face [21]. Surveillance systems can also be developed to provide important new capabilities in responding to public health emergencies. However, these efforts may result in false alarms and related increased cost [22].
Measures to enhance diagnostic and therapeutic capabilities and capacities alongside training and education are thought to improve the ability of society to combat 'regular' infectious diseases outbreaks, as well as mitigating the effects of bioterrorist attacks [23].
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Bioethics CP › 2NC---Bioethics CP
Eman and Dankar 2008 — Khaled El Emam, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute; Fida Kamal Dankar, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute, 2008 (“Protecting Privacy Using k-Anonymity,” J am Med, October, Available Online at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2528029/?tool=pmcentrez, Accessed 07-13-2022)
There is increasing pressure to disclose health research data, and this is especially true when the data has been collected using public funds. However, the disclosure of such data raises serious privacy concerns. For example, consider an individual who participated in a clinical trial having all of their clinical and lab data published in a journal web site accompanying the article on the trial. If it was possible to re-identify the records of that individual from this public data it would be a breach of privacy. Such an incident could result in fewer people participating in research studies because of privacy concerns, and if it happened in Canada, would be breaking privacy laws.
It is therefore important to understand precisely the types of re-identification attacks that can be launched on a data set and the different ways to properly anonymize the data before it is disclosed.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Bioethics CP › 1NC---Bioethics CP
Eman and Dankar 2008 — Khaled El Emam, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute; Fida Kamal Dankar, Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario Research Institute, 2008 (“Protecting Privacy Using k-Anonymity,” J am Med, October, Available Online at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2528029/?tool=pmcentrez, Accessed 07-13-2022)
The way in which k-anonymity would be applied depends on the re-identification scenario one is protecting against. To protect against the prosecutor re-identification scenario, then k-anonymity should be used. If the prosecutor scenario is not applicable, then k-anonymity is not recommended, and k-map should be used instead (or our approximations of it using the hypothesis testing approach D4). If both scenarios are plausible, then k-anonymity should be used because this is the most protective. Therefore, being able to make a decision on whether the prosecutor scenario is applicable is important.
If we assume a threshold risk of 0.2, then under the prosecutor scenario the data custodian would just k-anonymize with k = 5. Under the journalist scenario the data custodian would determine An external file that holds a picture, illustration, etc.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 2NC--- Biodiversity---NB: Politics
Sharon Udasin, 2-9-2022, staff writer at The Hill, "House Dems, green groups demand national biodiversity strategy from Biden," Hill, CROSSINGS BY
Fifty House Democrats — with the support of more than 100 environmental groups and academics — demanded the creation of a national biodiversity strategy in a letter to President Biden on Tuesday.
“The loss of biodiversity presents a direct threat to our security, health, and well-being,” , sent by Rep. (D-Colo.). “As species decline and habitats degrade, we lose critical ecosystem services that provide us with clean water, fertile soils, food, and the very air we breathe.”
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 2NC--- Biodiversity---Solvency---States
NCEL, 5-20-2022, National Caucus of Environmental Legislators is a collective group of state legislators committed to environmental protection, "365 State Legislators From 48 States and Territories Call for a National Biodiversity Strategy," National Caucus of Environmental Legislators, https://www.ncelenviro.org/articles/national-biodiversity-strategy/ CROSSINGS BY
Today more than 360 state legislators sent a letter to President Biden urging the creation of a National Biodiversity strategy to address the biodiversity crisis we’re facing. As species and habitats are disappearing at record rates, we need a unified national solution. The United States is one of the only nations without such a national strategy. The bipartisan letter was signed by 365 legislators from 48 states and territories.
The letter’s release coincides with Endangered Species Day. Globally, there are around one million species at risk of extinction. The unprecedented loss in species and habitats directly impacts our security, economy, health, and well-being. Our biodiversity provides us with crucial ecosystem services needed for clean water, healthy soils, nutritious food, and clean air.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 2NC--- Biodiversity---Solvency---States
Eric Galatas, 7-9-2022, producer and head writer for Public News Service, "State Lawmakers Press Biden to Create National Biodiversity Strategy," No Publication, CROSSINGS BY
More than 350 state lawmakers from across the U.S. are urging President Joe Biden to create a national strategy to protect, restore and secure the nation's rich biodiversity for generations to come.
Rep. Alex Valdez, D-Denver, was among 22 Colorado lawmakers to sent to the White House late last week. He said as more species and habitat are lost, the risks to ecosystems supplying clean water, food and even the air we breathe begin to compound.
"We're seeing a massive impact, and frankly, moving toward extinction of a number of different species," Valdez asserted. "We need to do something about it, because we're kind of a part of that full picture in a healthy environment."
Scientists estimate roughly one million species are at risk of extinction globally, a number well above historic norms and largely due to human activity. Climate change, habitat loss, pollution, invasive species and overfishing are seen as the biggest ecosystem disrupters.
Robert Dewey, vice president of government relations and external affairs for Defenders of Wildlife, said it is critical for the federal government to work with states and local governments to identify strategies to address these leading causes. He explained the letter from state legislators is part of a growing chorus urging the president to respond to what he calls a biodiversity crisis.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 2NC--- Biodiversity---Solvency---International Leadership
Kurt Repanshek, 2-10-2022, writer for National Parks Traveler, "Groups Call On Biden Administration To Create National Biodiversity Strategy," No Publication, https://www.nationalparkstraveler.org/2022/02/groups-call-biden-administration-create-national-biodiversity-strategy / CROSSINGS BY
Nearly 200 countries have developed various forms of biodiversity strategies, but the United States is not one of them, according to a coalition of conservation groups that wants the Biden administration to create a national biodiversity strategy in a bid to slow the sixth mass extinction.
Worldwide, 1 million species are threatened with extinction, according to Defenders of Wildlife, Earthjustice, World Wildlife Fund, International Fund for Animal Welfare, Wildlife Conservation Society, and the Natural Resources Defense Council. Against that threat, the United States must adopt an effective, whole-of-government approach to prevent the loss of species, "the collapse of ecosystems, and the increasing threats these pose to our health, security and well-being," the groups said in a joint release.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 1NC--- Biodiversity---National Biodiversity Strategy
Dehara Weeraman, 5-26-2022, Communications Fellow at One Nature, "A Letter to President Biden: It’s Time for a National Biodiversity Strategy," OneNature, CROSSINGS BY
On May 20th, 2022, the National Caucus of Environmental Legislators (NCEL) released a urging him to develop a national biodiversity strategy.
Our planet is amidst a catastrophic biodiversity crisis, a crisis so harmful that states alone cannot solve it. U.S. states have been working diligently to conserve their plants and wildlife, but the threats to biodiversity come in various forms and don’t adhere to state boundaries; we must look to the federal government for help. This biodiversity strategy would not only protect, restore, and secure the prosperous biodiversity found throughout our nation but also solidify a better world for future generations.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 1NC---Biodiversity---Natural Climate Solutions
Molly Cross, 03-23-2021, The lead of the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) Climate Change Adaptation Program in North and South America, and the Science Director for the WCS Climate Adaptation Fund. They have a Ph.D. in Environmental Science, Policy and Management from the University of California-Berkeley, "Testimony of Dr. Molly Cross Climate Adaptation Scientist for the Wildlife Conservation Society & Science Director for the WCS Climate Adaptation Fund Before the House Natural Resource Committee " No Publication, / CROSSINGS BY
There are a wide range of strategies for addressing climate change, from actions that aim to reduce the buildup of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere (climate mitigation) to those that help nature and people proactively prepare for and adapt to the impacts of a changing climate (climate adaptation). Natural Climate Solutions (also called “nature-based solutions to climate change”) are conservation, restoration, and improved land management actions that remove carbon from the atmosphere while also safeguarding biodiversity and providing benefits to people such as clean air and water, and protection from climate disturbances such as floods and wildfire.
A recent study in the journal Science Advances estimated that up to 21% of the U.S.’s current annual greenhouse gas emissions can be removed from the atmosphere by restoring and responsibly managing our forests, farms, ranches, grasslands, and wetlands. The protection, restoration, and responsible management of natural resources is also a key strategy for adapting to the impacts of climate change. The Global Adaptation Commission, World Economic Forum, and United Nations Decade on Ecosystem Restoration have called for greater investment in the natural environment as a cost-effective and critical part of building resilience for human communities, while helping fish, plants and animals thrive in the face of a changing climate. When carefully planned and implemented, nature-based solutions can offer both climate mitigation and adaptation benefits by reducing emissions and helping people cope with an altered environment. Although most investments in climate action have focused on mitigation to-date, support for adaptation activities is growing. It is essential that we increase our investment in climate adaptation strategies alongside climate mitigation actions; the latter may slow impacts and help give time for people and nature to adjust to climate changes and its impacts.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Biodiversity CP › 1NC---Biodiversity---Natural Climate Solutions
fund new natural climate solutions nationwide,
accelerate science-based, participatory, and socially equitable investments in the protection and responsible stewardship of our Federal lands and waters,
continue and expand funding for all current state led biodiversity initiatives
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Baltic War CP › 2NC---Baltic War CP--- BALTBAT CP---Solvency
Chinchilla and Poast 18, Alexandra and Paul, Ph.D in Political Science from the University of Chicago; associate professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Chicago, Ph.D from the University of Michigan, Summer-Fall 2018, "Defense Institution Building from Above? Lessons from the Baltic Experience on JSTOR," Connections, https://www.jstor.org/stable/26934691?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
But while the door to immediate NATO membership was closed, external assistance was on offer. Taking the lead in this effort were the Nordic countries, particularly the NATO member Denmark. The Nordic countries and the Baltics agreed that a peacekeeping-oriented international arrangement, the Baltic Battalion (BALTBAT), could serve as a vehicle for quickly bolstering Baltic security. This was for two reasons. First, BALTBAT was, in the words of one commentator with some involvement in the project, of “symbolic and political importance.” 16 By creating and cooperating through BALTBAT, the Baltic states signaled their willingness to find joint solutions to security problems. In other words, they demonstrated a desire and ability to fulfill a core function of NATO: provide collective defense. Second, BALTBAT facilitated the distribution of technical assistance and material resources from the established democracies to the Baltics. With respect to technical assistance, established democracies offered training in “Western” practices of military organization (such as the proper role of civil-military relations), and even English language classes (as English proficiency is necessary for operating within NATO). With respect to material assistance, through BALTBAT the Baltic states received everything from basic military supplies (from uniforms to office equipment) to light weaponry. 17 While far from onerous for the established democracies, these basic resources helped the Baltic states not only strengthen their ties with the West but also improve their military capabilities, professionalize their armies, and learn from the West about civil-military relations in a democratic setting.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Baltic War CP › 1NC--- Baltic War CP---BALTBAT CP
Estonian Defence Forces 20, 12-08-2020, unified military forces of the Republic of Estonia. "Aims of the Baltic military co-operation – Estonian Defence Forces," //BigSasher
Baltic military co-operation projects have assisted in developing the Estonian, Latvian and Lithuanian defence structures in accordance with the traditions and procedures of Western countries. The projects provide Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania with experience in international co-operation and consensus building, and give the defence forces of the three states more visibility at home and abroad.
An important part of the Baltic defence co-operation is achievement of interoperability between the defence structures of the three states and NATO. Joint projects help to implement common command and operational standards in the Baltic region. The procedural, language and equipment standards used in the projects and applied in the framework of NATO/PfP improve the interoperability of the Baltic states and NATO/PfP. The projects are led by permanent multinational staffs which follow NATO procedures and formats to the greatest extent possible.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Baltic War CP › 2NC--- Baltic War CP--- Suwalki CP---Solvency
Karnitschnig 22,Matthew, 6-20-2022, POLITICO’s chief Europe correspondent, based in Berlin. "The most dangerous place on earth," POLITICO, //BigSasher
The worry is that in a conflict with the West, Russia could sweep into the corridor simultaneously from the east and the west, severing the European Union’s Baltic countries from their allies to the south. “It’s a huge vulnerability because an invasion would cut off Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia from the rest of NATO,” said Ilves.
Such a move would also result in an immediate faceoff between Moscow and NATO’s nuclear-armed members, pushing the world to the brink of world-ending confrontation.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Baltic War CP › 1NC---Baltic War CP---Suwalki CP
Deni 22, John R, 3-3-2022, a research professor at the U.S. Army War College’s Strategic Studies Institute and a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council. "NATO Must Prepare to Defend Its Weakest Point—the Suwalki Corridor," Foreign Policy,
As the Biden administration monitors Moscow’s reaction to dramatic U.S. and allied increases in assistance to Ukraine as well as the punishing Western economic and financial sanctions on Russia, it should turn its focus to a relatively small corner of northeastern Europe that is familiar to military strategists but often overlooked by most policymakers and the general public.
The Suwalki corridor (also known as the Suwalki Gap) separates the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad on the Baltic Sea from Belarus, now host to thousands of Russian troops and soon home to permanently stationed Russian forces, including advanced fighter jets and nuclear weapons. It is also the only way to get by road or rail from Poland and Central Europe to the Baltic states—arguably NATO’s most exposed members.
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Animal Biotech CP › 2NC---Animal Biotech CP
Quarles 20 — Ryan Quarles, Kentucky Agriculture Commissioner and President of the National Association of State Departments of Agriculture, 2020 (“Opinion: A Healthy and resilient world needs animal biotech innovation,” Agri Pulse, September 30th, Available Online at https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/14589-opinion-a-healthy-and-resilient-world-needs-animal-biotech-innovation, Accessed 07-13-2022)
The COVID-19 crisis has delivered a devastating blow to every segment of our society, and our nation’s agriculture sector is no exception. Our food supply chain has been tested; our rural economies are suffering; and our farmworkers are on the front lines of risk. The need for innovation and resilient solutions has never been more urgent.
These unprecedented challenges were top of mind during the recent annual meeting of the National Association of State Departments of Agriculture (NASDA). I’m very proud that NASDA has adopted a new vision statement: “Agriculture leads the way toward a healthy and resilient world.”
2022
Michigan
Counterplan
Neg › Animal Biotech CP › 1NC---Animal Biotech CP
Hallerman et al. 22 — Eric M. Hallerman, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; Justin P. Bredlau, U.S. Department of Agriculture; Luiz Sergio A. Camargo, Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation; Maria Lucia Zaidan Dagli, School of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science, University of Sao Paulo; Margaret Karembu International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications AfriCenter; Godfrey Ngure, International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications AfriCenter; Rhodora Romero-Aldemita, ISAAA SEAsia Center; Pedro Jesu´s Rocha-Salavarrieta, InterAmerican Institute for Cooperation On Agriculture; Mark Tizard, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation; Mark Walton; Diane Wray-Cahen, U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2022 (“Towards progressive regulatory approaches for agricultural
applications of animal biotechnology,” Transgenic Res, January, Available Online at https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11248-021-00294-3, Accessed 07-13-2022)
Regulatory approval is a long and uncertain process in many countries, and regulatory uncertainty is a significant concern to both developers and academic