2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Young 19, Alston & Bird Professor of Law at Duke University
[Ernest A. Young, former Charles Alan Wright Chair in Federal Courts at the University of Texas at Austin School of Law, one of the nation's leading authorities on the constitutional law of federalism, active commentator on foreign relations law, focusing on the interaction between domestic and supranational courts and the application of international law by domestic courts, writer on constitutional interpretation and constitutional theory, “Dying Constitutionalism and the Fourteenth Amendment,” Marquette Law Review, 3-1-19, ] /RS
III. THE LESSONS OF CONSTITUTIONAL FAILURE
2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Ponsa-Kraus 22, George Welwood Murray Professor of Legal History at Columbia Law School
[Christina Duffy Ponsa-Kraus, June 2022, the George Welwood Murray Professor of Legal History at Columbia Law School, o-editor of Foreign in a Domestic Sense: Puerto Rico, American Expansion, and the Constitution, and the author of several articles and essays on the constitutional implications of American territorial expansion, served as a law clerk to Judge José A. Cabranes on the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and to Justice Stephen G. Breyer on the Supreme Court, “The Insular Cases Run Amok: Against Constitutional Exceptionalism in the Territories,” Yale Law Journal, ] /RS
Suppose the Supreme Court overrules the Insular Cases. Then what?
2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Santana 23 – Assistant Federal Defender in Tennessee
Willie Santana, “The New Insular Cases,” William and Mary Journal of Race, Gender, and Social Justice, Volume 29 Issue 2 Article 4, pgs. 457-462, //MS
The damage that the Insular Cases inflict upon American notions of equal treatment and protection of the laws is pervasive.245 Disparate treatment of Americans in the territories continues in various fronts.246 For instance, Congress treats each territory in different ways when it comes to federal safety-net programs.247 Such classifications, ostensibly based on locality, are only required to satisfy rational basis review.248
2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Rana 20 – Law Professor at Boston College Law School
Aziz Rana, Expert on American Constitutional Law and Political Development, “How We Study the Constitution: Rethinking the Insular Cases and Modern American Empire,” Volume 130 Yale Law Journal, 11/02/20,
Engaging with the Insular Cases thus provides critical insights into central transformations in settler ideological and institutional practice during the early twentieth century. But beyond that, it also allows us to appreciate how basic constitutional adjustments helped set the stage for the increasingly dominant form of American power in the twentieth century—what I call U.S. imperial primacy. Today, U.S. citizens tend not to see their country in a story of demographic displacement and settler conquest. They also do not understand themselves as overseeing a global set of colonial dependencies. In many ways, this is because of the set of ideological choices made by governing elites about the basic direction of power in the wake of both the Spanish-American War and the Insular Cases.
2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Ponsa-Kraus 22, George Welwood Murray Professor of Legal History at Columbia Law School
[Christina Duffy Ponsa-Kraus, June 2022, the George Welwood Murray Professor of Legal History at Columbia Law School, o-editor of Foreign in a Domestic Sense: Puerto Rico, American Expansion, and the Constitution, and the author of several articles and essays on the constitutional implications of American territorial expansion, served as a law clerk to Judge José A. Cabranes on the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and to Justice Stephen G. Breyer on the Supreme Court, “The Insular Cases Run Amok: Against Constitutional Exceptionalism in the Territories,” Yale Law Journal, ] /RS
The Insular Cases have been enjoying an improbable—and unfortunate—renaissance. Decided at the height of what has been called the “imperialist” period in U.S. history, this series of Supreme Court decisions handed down in the early twentieth century infamously held that the former Spanish colonies annexed by the United States in 1898—Puerto Rico, the Philippines, and Guam—“belong[ed] to . . . but [were] not a part of the United States.”1 Although previous U.S. territories were “incorporated” into the United States upon annexation, these new ones had been annexed but not incorporated.2
2023
DDI
Affirmative
1AC › 1AC – Puerto Rico
Vélez'22 [Katerina Martínez; 2022; Hearing Officer University of Missouri-Columbia; " Trouble in Paradise: Puerto Rico's Routine Exclusion from Federal Benefit Programs as a Result of the Alien-Citizen Paradox," The Business, Entrepreneurship & Tax Law Review,, Vol. 6, Issue/2. , p. 17-18//JJB]
Adherence to the Insular Cases, which has no foundation in the Constitution and instead relies on racial stereotypes, has permitted the justification of exclusion from important social benefit programs, as exemplified by the Vaello-Madero decision. SSI is designed to support the neediest Americans; it is a program aimed at preventing severe poverty. In 2019, 43.5% of Puerto Rican residents lived below the poverty line, more than triple the national percentage of 12.3%.161 Despite a large portion of Puerto Ricans qualifying as “needy Americans,” its residents are continuously denied federal benefits solely based on residency.
The differential treatment of Puerto Ricans cuts deeper than simply denying them federal benefits. Contemporary law scholars view the Insular Cases as evidence of racist American imperialism, allowing the U.S. to expand its empire without being compelled by the Constitution to accept as citizen populations of an “uncivilized race.” In fact, Justice John Marshall Harlan’s dissent in Downes, decided in 1901, noted that he objected to the morality and unfairness of the incorporation doctrine, which is still in effect today.162 It is important to note that the same Court that decided the 1901 Insular Cases also decided Plessy v. Ferguson, in which the Court upheld the legality of racial segregation and of the “separate but equal” doctrine. Notably, Justice Harlan was the lone dissenter in Plessy.163 It is therefore evident that both the incorporation doctrine of the Insular Cases and the “separate but equal” doctrine were built on the same “racist worldview.” In fact, contemporary critics of the Insular Cases call the resulting doctrine “the doctrine of separate and unequal.”164
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Case › VM Good
Romoser’21[James Romoser was the editor of SCOTUSblog from June 2020 to March 2023. He also wrote "Case Studies," a weekly column on legal affairs for National Journal. He came to SCOTUSblog with experience as both a legal journalist and a litigator.]James Romoser In equal-protection challenge, court will review Puerto Rico’s exclusion from federal safety-net program Nov 9, 2021 https://www.scotusblog.com/2021/11/in-equal-protection-challenge-court-will-review-puerto-ricos-exclusion-from-federal-safety-net-program/HZ
Finally, the justices undoubtedly will be thinking about how a ruling in Vaello-Madero’s favor might affect the numerous other federal laws that carve out differential treatment for Puerto Rico and other territories. The government argues that applying strict scrutiny in this case would disrupt numerous longstanding policies — including the handful of policies (such as exemptions from most federal income taxes) that benefit, rather than harm, Puerto Rico residents.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC--Impact
Pester’ 21 [Patrick Pester is a staff writer for Live Science. His background is in wildlife conservation and he has worked with endangered species around the world. Patrick holds a master's degree in international journalism from Cardiff University in the U.K. and is currently finishing a second master's degree in biodiversity, evolution and conservation in action at Middlesex University London.] Patrick Pester, Could climate change make humans go extinct? August 30, 2021,
Humans are increasing the amount of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide and methane, in the atmosphere through the burning of fossil fuels and other activities. These gases trap and hold heat from the sun, causing global temperatures to rise and the climate to change much faster than it otherwise would, putting humanity on a dangerous path. A runaway greenhouse effect is probably the only way climate change impacts could directly cause human extinction, according to Luke Kemp, a research associate at the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. This effect happens when a planet is caught in an unstoppable, positive feedback loop of warming and absorbs more heat than it loses, until the planet's oceans evaporate and it can no longer sustain life. Fortunately, the runaway greenhouse effect is not a plausible climate change scenario on Earth. For the effect to occur, a planet needs carbon dioxide levels of a couple of thousand parts per million (Earth has a little over 400 parts per million) or a huge release of methane, and there isn't evidence for that at this time, Brian Kahn, a research scientist at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, told NASA in 2018. Venus has the runaway greenhouse effect, but it is much closer to the sun and has a much thicker, carbon dioxide-rich atmosphere that traps more heat than Earth's, Live Science previously reported. The science doesn’t support the notion of runaway warming scenarios, although climate doomists often make such claims, Mann said. "There’s no reason to exaggerate the climate threat. The truth is bad enough, and reason enough to take dramatic action." According to Mann, a global temperature increase of 5.4 degrees Fahrenheit (3 degrees Celsius) or more could lead to a collapse of our societal infrastructure and massive unrest and conflict, which, in turn, could lead to a future that resembles some Hollywood dystopian films. One way climate change could trigger a societal collapse is by creating food insecurity. Warming the planet has a range of negative impacts on food production, including increasing the water deficit and thereby reducing food harvests, Live Science previously reported. Food production losses can increase human deaths and drive economic loss and socio-political instability, among other factors, that may trigger a breakdown of our institutions and increase the risk of a societal collapse, according to a study published Feb. 21 in the journal Climatic Change. Past extinctions and collapses Kemp studies previous civilization collapses and the risk of climate change. Extinctions and catastrophes almost always involve multiple factors, he said, but he thinks if humans were to go extinct, climate change would likely be the main culprit.
It’s a big country with a lot of needs and a lot of challenges and a lot of existential crises that we’re facing: inequality, climate, the pandemic, which we just got out of but is still very much with us. Those needs demand response. When people are like, Oh, government is too big. It’s like, Well, do we want to solve these public problems or not? We have a big government because we have a big, complex society, and a lot of people need government to be responsive. That’s just a first principle. The question then becomes, if we’re actually committed to serving the various needs of the public and creating an egalitarian, inclusive democracy where everybody has the freedom and opportunity to thrive, then we need to resource and support that government to do that. A lot of the criticisms about government ineffectualness and so forth… I mean, there are very real problems, for sure, even from a racial justice and economic justice angle, there are a lot of things about government that don’t meet that North Star. But I would argue that a lot of the failures of government are failures of design and not intention. We’ve built a government to be ineffectual at some things, we haven’t resourced it enough, or we’ve built in other places, we’ve built a government that is counterproductive where we’ve created too much unchecked, unbridled authority. From a racial justice angle, if you think about the rise of mass incarceration, that’s government too. And that’s something that we need to tackle. I think the first principle is if we’re committed to this collective project of government serving our public problems, then we need to build it accordingly. On the Congress Article One, Article Two stuff, this may be a longer conversation about where the courts are going and where administrative law is going, but I think two things can be true at the same time. One, Congress is the most important branch of our government. I believe that. Article One sets the powers of Congress, and it’s the first article in the Constitution. It’s Article One for a reason, but part of what that means is that Congress said we should have clean air and it passes a clean air act. And it says the way we get clean air is we get experts in the Environmental Protection Agency to help figure out how many parts per million of carbon dioxide is okay. And how much is not okay. And that’s Congress.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC--Impact
GERSTEIN and GUILLÉN’2023[Josh Gerstein is POLITICO’s Senior Legal Affairs Reporter.Gerstein covers the intersection of law and politics, including Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation of President Donald Trump and his associates, as well as ensuing counter-investigations into the origins of the FBI’s initial inquiry into the Trump-Russia saga. Alex Guillén is an energy reporter for POLITICO Pro, where he covers EPA, the Clean Air Act, coal, mining and other energy regulatory issues. He wrote the Morning Energy newsletter from 2012 to 2015.] JOSH GERSTEIN and ALEX GUILLÉN, 05/01/2023, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/05/01/supreme-court-chevron-doctrine-climate-change-00094670/HZ
A legal doctrine long despised by conservatives for giving federal regulators wide-ranging power is making yet another march to the gallows at the Supreme Court. The high court announced Monday that it is taking up a case squarely aimed at killing off the nearly-four-decade-old precedent that has come to be known as Chevron deference: the principle that courts should defer to reasonable agency interpretations of ambiguous provisions in congressional statutes and judges should refrain from crafting their own reading of the laws. Overturning the doctrine would have major implications for the Biden administration’s climate agenda. It would complicate the administration’s efforts to tackle major issues such as climate change via regulation, including possibly derailing the Environmental Protection Agency’s push to mitigate carbon emissions from the electricity and transportation sectors — the two highest polluting industries in the United States. The Supreme Court’s move is another signal that the court’s conservatives have not tired in their efforts to weaken the administrative state. The top target is the case that played a pivotal role in expanding the powers of federal agencies after it was handed down in 1984: Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council. The Chevron doctrine has “been in a coma for a while, so we’ll see whether they want to revive it or take it off life support,” said David Doniger, who in 1984 argued that case before the Supreme Court for the NRDC. The NRDC technically lost that case when the Supreme Court upheld a Reagan administration pollution rule as a reasonable interpretation of the law. But over the subsequent decades, the Chevron doctrine became a central pillar of administrative law and a key part of the legal defense for any number of environmental and other rules by both Democratic and Republican administrations. Although agencies did not win all the time, studies have shown more often than not the courts used it to uphold regulations. “This would have the potential of being one of the most destabilizing decisions that this court has issued, if it chooses to go there,” said James Goodwin, a senior policy analyst at the Center for Progressive Reform. The challenge the justices just agreed to take up involves the power of a Commerce Department unit to require herring fishing operations to pay for federal monitors on their boats. In announcing its decision to review the case, the court excised the question of what powers Congress gave the Commerce Department to regulate fisheries. That leaves the potential demise of Chevron deference as the only issue to be briefed and argued in the case, known as Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo. In recent years, the high court has taken up a series of cases that seemed to spell doom for Chevron deference, but has stepped back from the brink each time. However, most of the cases managed to brush back the regulators by rejecting their legal interpretations. Last June, for instance, the court decided a case involving Medicare reimbursements in which some conservatives and business groups had urged the justices to overturn Chevron. In a narrow and unanimous opinion, the court ruled against the Medicare’s managers — but without even mentioning Chevron. The Supreme Court’s decision to hear the fishing case, which is likely to be argued this fall or winter with a decision in the first half of 2024, indicates that at least four justices wanted to grant review — and that those who want to overturn Chevron feel they may now have five votes to do so. Several justices have railed against Chevron in recent years, sometimes openly bridling at their colleagues’ unwillingness to deliver the coup de grace and overturn the case that critics say displaces judges from their usual role of determining what the law means. Just last fall, Justice Neil Gorsuch said the court had flinched too many times. “At this late hour, the whole project deserves a tombstone no one can miss,” he wrote as the court passed up a Chevron-related case in November. “We should acknowledge forthrightly that Chevron did not undo, and could not have undone, the judicial duty to provide an independent judgment of the law’s meaning in the cases that come before the Nation’s courts.” Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in 2020 that “Chevron is in serious tension with the Constitution,” repudiating one of his own majority opinions from 2005 concluding that the Federal Communications Commission could invoke Chevron deference to justify decisions regulating internet services. The new case on regulators’ powers will also test the high court’s continuing willingness to overturn longstanding precedents rather than quietly whittle away at them. Last June, the court took the momentous decision to overturn Roe v. Wade on a 5-4 vote, unleashing a wave of criticism that the justices were disrespecting the legal principle that precedents should only be reversed under extraordinary circumstances. The Supreme Court in recent years has moved away from Chevron, the Cato Institute noted in a survey of recent rulings it described in a “friend of the court” brief urging the justices to overturn Chevron. In the past six years, agencies lost 70 percent of Supreme Court cases that addressed Chevron, Cato found. Instead, the high court increasingly “has been applying the rules of statutory interpretation even more closely,” Cato wrote. That includes last year’s ruling in West Virginia v. EPA, which strengthened and for the first time named the “major questions” doctrine as a way to strike down regulations. The lower courts, however, continue to apply Chevron since it is still Supreme Court precedent. In 2020 and 2021, Cato found 142 rulings involving Chevron. Agencies won almost 60 percent of the time in those cases, Cato said. Some judges have already found ways to reach “outcome-oriented decisions,” argued CPR’s Goodwin. Releasing the lower courts from having to apply Chevron could accelerate that trend. “I think it does free up activist judges to base their review of regulations upon their policy preferences,” Goodwin said. Undoing the Chevron doctrine would also throw a wrench into Congress’ legislative agenda. In recent decades, lawmakers have increasingly chosen to draft broad guidelines and delegate the technical details to the agencies. Supporters of Chevron deference say it’s appropriate to give agency experts breathing space to craft granular policies to respond to problems that Congress might not anticipate or fully understand. Critics contend that shifting so much policymaking power to bureaucrats violates the separation of powers. In many instances, gridlock has left Congress unable to pass anything at all, leaving aggressive interpretations of decades-old statutes as the only vehicle for presidents and agencies eager to take action. Climate change is one major area where that approach has been brought to bear. Although Democrats passed major clean energy investments in recent years, Congress has been unable to agree on almost any significant new regulatory power for EPA on climate change. That has left the agency to try to craft sweeping regulations on greenhouse gases. EPA recently proposed a rule for cars and trucks that would require two-thirds of new vehicles be electric in 2032, and in the coming weeks is expected to float a new regulation for power plants. The Biden administration is trying to craft those rules carefully to avoid another loss under the “major questions” doctrine. But undoing Chevron doctrine could also make justifying powerful climate regulations under old laws more difficult. “Biden’s environmental and energy agencies were already facing a heavily tilted playing field in the federal judiciary,” Goodwin said. “I think eliminating Chevron, like officially eliminating Chevron, would make the prospects of surviving judicial review all the more daunting.”
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC--Impact
Fard’09[Professor at the Faculty of Management and Economics]Hasan Danaee Fard, An Administrative Manifesto for Survival in the Twenty-First Century, Dec., 2009, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/40469019.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A95d75dd02d13d59ae16acb88b98e03d0&ab_segments=&origin=&initiator=&acceptTC=1/HZ
In summary, Professor Farazmand first analyzes the characteristics of the contemporary world and the origin of these changes - that is, the globalization of corporate capitalism. Second, he explains the positive and negative consequences of globalization and warns not to give the keys to the "transworld train" to the private sector. Farazmand s suggestion for the survival of the world is "building new administrative capacity" by the modern state. He provides this prescription not only for the United States and other industrialized na- tions, but for all countries concerned, both developing and developed. Why is the administrative capacity so important? Why Administrative Capacity? There are four managerial systems in all political states: (1) a meta- policy system, (2) a public policy system, (3) a public administra- tion system, and (4) a private management system. The linkage between the four systems is an alignment between meta-policy (level 1), policy (level 2), strategy (level 3), and strategy (level 4). Many scholars of public administration and economics emphasize the central role of public administration in this pack- age. Although its role has changed overtime, its philosophy is not ignored. New authors claim that the key role of public administra- tion is governance - a new claim. The degree of this governance has changed over time. Today - as for the last 28 years - the key of administration has been given to, or held by, the private sector. For the protection of the global public interest, strengthening adminis- trative capacities is necessary to get the key back. The domination of market theory worldwide has been based on this rhetorical strategy, which argues that government is not a good employer; it has had dangerously negative consequences for a viable world, especially in developing countries. Capitalism has constructed an artificial social reality that says, "government is bad," "efficiency belongs to the private sector/' and "an efficient government is a privatized one," or, as the extremist of the Old West American white settlers would say, "The only good Indian is a dead Indian." Failure of the socialist paradigm has accelerated the speed of the capitalist machinery. Governments have given their authority to market elites and have lost their ability and capacity for dealing with crises. The slogan "A citizen is a citizen only on voting day" has decreased government legitimacy and capacity. The dependence of government on the market is a big barrier to promoting administrative capacity. We should consider the Hurricane Katrina crisis, the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, and the Balkan war, and then focus on the current global financial crisis, and ask ourselves, "Where is the invis- ible private hand?" We find it hidden everywhere. Looking carefully, and we find inefficiency attributable to a lack of, or paralyzed, global administrative capacity everywhere. These crises are not problems of a particular government, or in fact the problem of governments at all. As Farazmand rightly argues, we must deal with global crises through global administrative capacities. Does this capacity exist? Moreover, we remember the devastating earthquake that struck Iran's ancient city of Bam and killed more than 50,000 of its 85,000 population a few years ago; it destroyed the entire city, including 75 percent of its 2,600-year-old Citadel (the worlds largest and oldest). Iranian people responded massively and helped the government in emergency management - which became a global benchmark of performance for others; the government administrative capacity was strong, effective, and managed the crisis well in an anticipatory way, which considered possible foreign military invasion in the aftermath of the crisis. Yet this was not sufficient - more was expected. Today, in the unrestrained market system that dominates modern governance, market slavery has replaced traditional colonial slavery. To avoid this bad - or ugly - fate, enhancing administrative capacity is inevitable. Based on Farazmand s manifesto, promoting admin- istrative capacity has desirable consequences, such as (1) halting extremist market maneuvering, (2) promoting managerial ability and capacity for dealing with global crises, (3) moderating the gaps between the rich and poor, (4) strengthening civil society and social capital, and (5) conducting the market in pursuit of global interests. Therefore, Farazmand's perspective is macro, not micro - the latter requires a separate presentation. His concerns reflect the concerns of all saviors of the universe. I think that the promotion of administra- tive capacity will help the world cope with big problems that are too dangerous for the survival of the world. Additionally, I think that building new administrative capacity can affect some of the big is- sues surrounding our world. The following are three examples.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC--Impact
Posner’14[Eric A. Posner is a law professor at the University of Chicago Law School, Posner has taught international law, contract law, and bankruptcy, among other areas.]Eric A. Posner, The Presidency Comes With Executive Power. Deal With It., February 3, 2014, https://newrepublic.com/article/116450/obama-use-executive-power-unexceptional/HZ
Be that as it may, it is worth understanding what is at stake in these debates. We all learned in school that the founders feared executive power and so gave policy-making authority to Congress. In fact, the founders feared a too-powerful Congress as well, and they sought to create a strong executive. But the idea that Congress makes law and the president executes it—and any deviation from this pattern is tyranny—is burned into our political culture. This system of separation of powers was cumbersome from the start. The country did well in its first few decades probably because state governments led the way, and state government structure was far less rigid than federal structure, which finally collapsed with the Civil War. When the communications and transportation revolutions created national markets and new opportunities and threats in foreign relations, it was finally clear that the federal separation-of-powers system could not manage policy at a national level. The problem was that Congress was an enormously clumsy institution. Its numerous members fiercely advanced their deeply parochial interests. Policies of great importance for one section of the country, or one group of people, could not be embodied in legislation unless logrolling could be arranged, which was slow, difficult, and vulnerable to corruption. As a public, deliberative body, Congress could not react swiftly to changing events, nor act secretly when secrecy was called for. No one held a constitutional convention to replace the eighteenth-century constitution with a twentieth-century one. Instead, political elites acting through the party system adjusted the government structure on their own. Congress created gigantic regulatory agencies and tasked the president to lead them. Congress also acquiesced as presidents asserted authority over foreign policy. The Supreme Court initially balked at the legislative delegations but eventually was bullied into submission; it hardly ever objected to the president’s dominance over foreign affairs. This was not a smooth process. The rise of executive power sometimes hurt important interests and always rubbed against the republican sensibilities that Americans inherited from the founders. From time to time, Congress reaped political benefits from thwarting the president. But today Congress reacts rather than leads. It investigates allegations of corruption in the executive branch. It holds hearings to torment executive officials. It certainly doesn’t give the executive the budget he always wants, or pass every new law that he believes that he needs. But existing laws and customs almost always give the president the power he needs to govern. And when they don’t, Congress will sooner or later give him the power he wants. Witness the Dodd-Frank Act and the Affordable Care Act—two massive expansions of executive power. In monarchies, the official position was that the king made policy but everyone understood that his ministers did. In our system, the official story is that Congress makes policy and the president implements it—such is the inertia of history. But the reality is that the president both makes policy and implements it, subject to vague parameters set down by Congress and to its carping from the sidelines. Presidents can defy the official story and assert the reality if they want. That is what the George W. Bush administration did, to its eventual sorrow. In hindsight, the broad assertions of executive power by Bush administration lawyers in signing statements, executive orders, and secret memos were naïve. They described, with only some exaggeration, the actual workings of the government, but their account conflicted with the official narrative and thus played into the hands of critics, who could invoke tyranny, dictatorship, and that old standby, the “imperial presidency.” Democratic presidents have been shrewder. Bill Clinton and Obama have been just as muscular in their use of executive power as Ronald Reagan and Bush, but they resisted the temptation to brandish the orb and scepter. Whereas Republican presidents cite their constitutional powers as often as they can, Democratic presidents avoid doing so except as a last resort, preferring instead to rely on statutes, torturing them when necessary to extract the needed interpretation. Thus did Obama’s lawyers claim that the military intervention in Libya did not violate the War Powers Act because the U.S. bombing campaign did not amount to “hostilities” (the word in the statute). A more honest legal theory—one that does not require such a strained interpretation of a word—is that the War Powers Act infringes on the president’s military powers, but a theory like that would have provoked howls of protest. In most cases, lawyers do not need to resort to such measures because Congress has already granted authority. The president’s power to raise the minimum wage comes from the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949, which, in typically broad language, permits the president to set contract terms with federal contractors so as to promote “efficiency.” Far from being a bold assertion of executive power, this is the type of humdrum presidential action that takes place every day. Congress gave the president the power to determine contract terms because Congress did not want to—practically speaking could not—negotiate those terms itself every time the U.S. government entered a contract. This principle explains why Congress gives the executive branch enormous discretion to determine health, education, environmental, and financial policy. Congress directed the financial regulators to implement the Volcker Rule, but it would be entirely up to those regulators to make the rule meaningful or toothless. Nor can Congress block Obama’s decision to effectively implement the Dream Act—which was not passed by Congress—by not enforcing immigration laws against those who would have benefited from the act. Meanwhile, the founders’ anxieties about executive tyranny have proven erroneous. The president is kept in check by elections, the party system, the press, popular opinion, courts, a political culture that is deeply suspicious of his motives, term limits, and the sheer vastness of the bureaucracy which he can only barely control. He does not always do the right thing, of course, but presidents generally govern from the middle of the political spectrum. Obama’s assertion of unilateral executive authority is just routine stuff. He follows in the footsteps of his predecessors on a path set out by Congress. And well should he. If you want a functioning government—one that protects citizens from criminals, terrorists, the climatic effects of greenhouse gas emissions, poor health, financial manias, and the like—then you want a government led by the president.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—Link
Vise’2023[A graduate of Wesleyan and Northwestern universities, he has written five books and worked at the Washington Post, Miami Herald and four other newspapers. He shared a 2001 team Pulitzer Prize and has garnered more than two dozen other national and regional journalism awards. His investigative reporting twice led to the release of wrongly imprisoned men. His last book, King of the Blues, was longlisted for the 2022 PEN America award in biography.]Daniel De Visé, "The American public no longer believes the Supreme Court is impartial," 1-11-2023, https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/3807849-the-american-public-no-longer-believes-the-supreme-court-is-impartial/HZ
Public approval of the nine-justice panel stands near historic lows. Declining faith in the institution seems rooted in a growing concern that the high court is deciding cases on politics, rather than law. In one recent poll, a majority of Americans opined that Supreme Court justices let partisan views influence major rulings. Three quarters of Republicans approve of the high court’s recent job performance. But Democrats’ support has plummeted to 13 percent, and more than half the nation overall disapproves of how the court is doing its job. Public support for the high court sank swiftly last summer in response to Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, a landmark ruling that revoked a constitutional right to abortion. The decision delighted many conservatives but defied a large majority of Americans who believe abortion should be legal. Yet, partisan anger runs deeper than Dobbs. Liberals are fuming about a confluence of lucky timing and political maneuvering that enabled a Republican-controlled Senate to approve three conservative justices in four years, knocking the panel out of synch with the American public. Judged by last year’s opinions, the current court is the most conservative in nearly a century, at a time when a majority of Americans are voting Democratic in most elections. Democrats say the court no longer mirrors society, a disconnect that spans politics and religion. All six of the court’s conservatives were raised Catholic, a faith that claims roughly one-fifth of the U.S. population. Republicans counter that the high court’s job is to serve the Constitution, not to please the public. “The Left was used to, for the most part, getting its way with the court,” said John Malcolm, a senior legal fellow at conservative think tank the Heritage Foundation. “Now that the Left is not getting its way with the court, they’re trying to tear it down and delegitimize it.” Legal scholars may not care much about the high court’s popularity, but they care deeply about its legitimacy. And what is legitimacy? James L. Gibson, a political scientist at Washington University in St. Louis, defines it as “loyalty to the institution. It is willingness to support the institution even when it’s doing things with which you disagree.” Americans remained steadfastly loyal to the high court for decades, Gibson said, embracing it even after the powder-keg Bush v. Gore decision of 2000, which decided an election. But then, with Dobbs, the high court suffered “the largest decline in legitimacy that’s ever been registered, through dozens and dozens of surveys using the same indicators,” Gibson said. “I’ve never seen anything like it.” One Gallup poll, taken after someone leaked a draft of the Dobbs ruling, found that only 25 percent of the American public had confidence in the court, the lowest figure recorded in a half century of polling. Around the same time, journalists revealed that Ginni Thomas, wife of high court Justice Clarence Thomas, had pressed state lawmakers to help overturn former President Trump’s 2020 defeat at the polls. “The idea that you have the spouse of a Supreme Court justice advocating for overthrowing the government — sui generis, I think,” said Caroline Fredrickson, a visiting law professor at Georgetown University, invoking the Latin term for “unique.” With the high court’s legitimacy eroding, Gibson said, the panel faces “greater institutional vulnerability to congressional manipulation.” An unsympathetic legislature could add seats to the court, “packing” it to dilute the influence of the conservative majority. Congress could impose term limits on justices who now serve for life. Lawmakers could narrow the court’s jurisdiction, limiting its authority to hear contentious cases. “Practically nothing about the court is free from congressional manipulation,” Gibson said. “And, man, John Roberts is aware of this.” The chief justice has emerged as a voice of moderation on the right-leaning panel. One Gallup poll, taken in December 2021, found that 60 percent of Americans approved of how Roberts was handling his job. Roberts outpolled other A-list leaders, including the president, vice president and leaders of the House and Senate. “He’s the justice who twice saved Obamacare,” Malcolm said. Roberts joined the court’s liberals in rejecting legal challenges to health care reform by a popular president. “He’s the justice who said, ‘I would not have overturned Roe v. Wade,’” Malcolm said. While he joined his conservative colleagues in the majority on Dobbs, Roberts wrote in a concurring opinion that he would have preferred not to reverse the 1973 abortion decision, but instead to rule more narrowly on the case at hand. Roberts, chief justice since 2005, has defended the court’s legitimacy in public remarks since Dobbs. Legal scholars say he is keenly aware that his court is drifting away from the mainstream of public opinion.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—Link
Kanu’2023 [Hassan Kanu writes about access to justice, race, and equality under law. Kanu, who was born in Sierra Leone and grew up in Silver Spring, Maryland, worked in public interest law after graduating from Duke University School]Hassan Kanu, Even some justices are raising questions about the U.S. Supreme Court's legitimacy, July 10, 2023,
The final days of the U.S. Supreme Court’s latest term were marked by a series of decisions that seem to bear out longstanding criticism that the court has historically functioned as a bulwark against equal legal status for minority groups. The court’s conservative majority effectively overruled affirmative action on June 29, and, a day later, permitted businesses to discriminate against LGBTQ people based on religious belief. The decisions have been widely panned by civil rights groups, universities and liberal organizations, among others, for manipulating legal doctrine and relying on a revisionist history of the Constitutional and civil rights movements, all in an apparent effort to enact right-wing policy preferences. There was another striking development in the final opinions of the term, one that was prompted by the outcomes in those decisions and the hollow legal reasoning underneath: Several sitting Supreme Court justices themselves - the court’s liberals – indicated that they agreed with the increasing criticism of the current court, including concerns about the erosion of the Supreme Court’s fundamental legitimacy as a policy-making institution.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—Link
Daniels’2023[Race and Politics Reporter at The Hill. Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism with a specialization in Politics, Policy and Foreign Affairs.]CHEYANNE M. DANIELS, Black leaders blast Supreme Court for overturning affirmative action, 06/29/23
Others, like Rep. Cori Bush (D-Mo.), declared the Supreme Court is dedicated to “moving backwards” and pointed to the consequences that ending affirmative action could have on Black and brown students. “Ending affirmative action in higher education—which the Court had already held to be legal—will have devastating impacts on our communities,” Bush said in a statement. “Universities have historically denied Black, brown, and Indigenous people from accessing institutions of higher education. Affirmative action helped level the racist and uneven playing field. Colleges and universities must ensure students benefit from the diverse perspectives and experiences of qualified students from all backgrounds. This is yet another example of why we must double down on our efforts for Court reform, pass the Judiciary Act and reclaim democracy.” Rep. Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) said the decision, made by a “far-right” Supreme Court, will only exacerbate systemic oppression Black and brown students have faced for decades. “This damning decision to overturn decades of legal precedent and ban race-conscious admissions is just the latest in the white supremacist assault on equity in education,” Pressley said in a statement. She called on universities to reaffirm their commitment to racial and ethnic diversity, and for all levels of government to create legislation that addresses structural barriers that contribute to racial disparities in educational access. “With this extremist Supreme Court demonstrating time and again its contempt for our most vulnerable, we must expand the court to build its integrity and bring balance to the bench,” Pressley added.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—Link
Ura’23[Professor of Political Science at Texas A&M University and Texas A&M University at Qatar.]Joe Ura, Will Supreme Court opinions provoke public backlash?, JULY 12, 2023, https://www.niskanencenter.org/will-supreme-court-opinions-provoke-public-backlash/HZ
Joe Ura: What we’ve done in some new research that we presented at the Midwest Political Science Association this last year, is look at Gallup data over the last 20 years or so that asked Americans whether the Supreme Court is too liberal, too conservative or about right. As you point out, part of the equation is that as the court gets more liberal, more people think it’s getting too liberal. As the court gets more conservative, more people think it’s getting too conservative. The other part that matters is how liberal or conservative the public is because that question asked for a relative judgment. If the court is staying consistent, but I’m getting more conservative, I might start to think at some point that the court is too liberal, even though it hasn’t changed, I have. To figure out what Americans think about the Supreme Court, we need two big pieces of information. What’s the ideological tenor of what the Supreme Court’s doing and then on the demand side, what do Americans want out of the court? If those things are in alignment, we would think that a lot of Americans would say the court is doing pretty well and that it’s about right, but if the public is more conservative than the court, then they would think the court is too liberal and vice versa.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—Link
Fontana and Krewson’22 [David Fontana is a professor at George Washington University Law School, Washington and Christopher N. Krewson is a professor at Brigham Young University Political Science Department]David Fontana and Christopher N. Krewson, The Costs of Policy Legitimation: A Test of the Political Capital Hypothesis, 13 July 2022, https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridgecore/content/view/13B5885410D434DED0A31C5A23249881/S2164657022000134a.pdf/div-class-title-the-costs-of-policy-legitimation-a-test-of-the-political-capital-hypothesis-div.pdf/HZ
Affirmative action is a useful issue for testing the political capital hypothesis. It is an area in which the Court has directly shaped national policy, beginning in 1978 with its Regents of the University of California v. Bakke decision and continuing today in cases like Fisher v. University of Texas (2016). It is a salient issue. Black Lives Matter and other social movements have put affirmative action and other policies geared toward racial equality in the spotlight. And Republicans and Democrats are divided in their views over the desirability of affirmative action programs. Using a policy that is both salient and contested is crucial for testing the political capital hypothesis. In our experiment below, we employ a treatment in which the Court approved of affirmative action.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—AT: Chevron overrule
Coyle’2023[Marcia Coyle is the Chief Washington Correspondent for The National Law Journal, a national weekly newspaper that covers law and litigation. Marcia, a lawyer as well as a journalist, has covered the Supreme Court for 25 years. She is also a regular contributor of Supreme Court analysis to PBS' The NewsHour.]Marcia Coyle, Could fishing companies upset a boatload of federal agencies with their Supreme Court challenge? May 3, 2023 https://constitutioncenter.org/blog/could-fishing-companies-upset-a-boatload-of-federal-agencies-with-their-supreme-court-challenge/HZ
Three justices have been critical of Chevron in recent years. In 2015 in Michigan v. EPA, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that Chevron’s deference to agencies “wrests from the Courts the ultimate interpretative authority ‘to say what the law is’ and hands it over to” the executive branch. In a 2022 dissent in Buffington v. McDonough, Justice Neil Gorsuch argued that the court “should acknowledge forthrightly that Chevron did not undo, and could not have undone, the judicial duty to provide an independent judgment of the law’s meaning in the cases that come before the Nation’s courts.” And when he was a judge on the D.C. Circuit, Brett Kavanaugh was an outspoken critic of the doctrine In a 2017 speech, Justice Samuel Alito said the result of Chevron deference has been “a massive shift of lawmaking from the elected representatives of the people to unelected bureaucrats.” And Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. has said, “The Framers could hardly have envisioned today’s ‘vast and varied federal bureaucracy’ and the authority administrative agencies now hold over our economic, social, and political activities.” But neither justice has called for overruling Chevron. Chevron has its defenders as well. They argue that agencies have greater knowledge than judges of the often complex statutes that they administer and because of that, they are better able than judges to make policy choices. And bottom line is that Congress has delegated authority to agencies to enact rules and regulations. More than a dozen friend-of-the-court briefs were filed on behalf of the fishing companies urging the justices to take the case. That number is a sign of how significant the case could be. The briefs are from other fishing companies, conservative and libertarian legal organizations, and anti-abortion, religious and anti-union groups, among others. What’s At Stake The Roberts Court in recent decisions has avoided applying Chevron deference and instead has relied on those traditional tools of statutory interpretation to answer challenges to agency rules. It also has adopted the so-called “major questions doctrine” which requires explicit congressional authorization of rules or regulations on matters of “vast economic or political significance.”
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—AT: Chevron overrule
Posner’ 2023[Cydney Posner, the blog’s author, served as co-chair of Cooley’s public companies practice from 2006–2016. For four consecutive years, she has been named a Top Author by JD Supra in its Readers Choice Awards for her authorship of Cooley PubCo, a blog that produces dynamic thought leadership and curated content for public companies. In 2020, she was selected as a National Association of Corporate Directors (NACD) Directorship 100 Honoree: Governance Professionals and Institutions.], Will Chevron deference survive? Why you might really care about a case about fishing, May 11 2023,
On May 1, SCOTUS granted cert in the case of Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, a case about whether the National Marine Fisheries Service has the authority to require fishing vessels to pay some of the costs for onboard federal observers who are required to monitor regulatory compliance. So why is this relevant to public companies? Because one of the questions presented to SCOTUS was whether the Court should continue the decades-long deference of courts, under Chevron U.S.A., Inc. v. Nat. Res. Def. Council, to the reasonable interpretations of statutes by agencies (such as the SEC). The doctrine of Chevron deference, articulated in that case, mandated that, if there is ambiguity in how to interpret a statute, courts must accept an agency’s interpretation of a law unless it is arbitrary or manifestly contrary to the statute. The decision, expected next term, could narrow, or even completely undo, that deference. Of course, the conservative members of the Court have long signaled their desire to rein in the dreaded “administrative state.” (See, for example, the dissent of Chief Justice John Roberts in City of Arlington v. FCC back in 2013, where he worried that “the danger posed by the growing power of the administrative state cannot be dismissed.”) But, in recent past cases, the Court has resolved issues and avoided addressing Chevron. This case, however, may well present that long-sought opportunity. Depending on the outcome, its impact could be felt far beyond the Marine Fisheries Service at many other agencies, including the SEC. SideBar Does that 2013 statement portend that Roberts will take the same position 11 years later? Perhaps the Court’s recent decision regarding Auer deference may be instructive. You’ll recall that Auer, often viewed as complementary to Chevron, stands for the proposition that courts should defer to the reasonable interpretations by agencies of their own ambiguous regulations (in contrast to laws, as in Chevron). In his dissent in City of Arlington above, Roberts also said that “[o]verturning Auer would be a modest but important check on ‘the danger posed by the growing power of the administrative state.’” But, in 2019, in Kisor v. Wilkie, to the question of whether SCOTUS should overturn Auer deference, the Court, with Justice Kagan writing the majority opinion and Roberts as the swing vote), said no. Auer deference, she wrote, was “rooted in a presumption about congressional intent—a presumption that Congress would generally want the agency to play the primary role in resolving regulatory ambiguities.” But, the key is that it doesn’t always apply, and that determination requires a nuanced analysis. As Kagan summarized, the “upshot of all this goes something as follows. When it applies, Auer deference gives an agency significant leeway to say what its own rules mean….But that phrase ‘when it applies’ is important—because it often doesn’t.” As she explained, while Auer “gives agencies their due,” it also obligates “courts to perform their reviewing and restraining functions.” In the end, the decision took care “to reinforce the limits of Auer deference, and to emphasize the critical role courts retain in interpreting rules.” Chief Justice Roberts agreed with the portions of Kagan’s opinion regarding stare decisis and the limitations on Auer, thus making a majority to retain Auer. But several of the Justices made clear in concurrences that they would have been happy to bid farewell to Auer and, as Justice Gorsuch wrote, viewed Kisor as simply a “stay of execution.” Justice Kavanaugh, joined by Justice Alito, in a separate concurrence, believed that Auer “should be formally retired.” Roberts wrote “separately to suggest that the distance between the majority and Justice Gorsuch is not as great as it may initially appear.” So will the Court take the same middle path in Loper Bright? Hmmmm. Importantly, for this purpose, in his concurrence, Roberts took pains to distinguish Chevron, emphasizing that “[i]ssues surrounding judicial deference to agency interpretations of their own regulations are distinct from those raised in connection with judicial deference to agency interpretations of statutes enacted by Congress…. I do not regard the Court’s decision today to touch upon the latter question.” Kavanaugh also agreed with Roberts with respect to the inapplicability of that
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—AT: Robert Fails
Chait’ 2023[Jonathan Chait has been a political columnist at New York since 2011 and writes the newsletter &c. He is the author of Audacity: How Barack Obama Defied His Critics and Created a Legacy That Will Prevail.] Jonathan Chait, The Last Republican Politician, JULY 3, 2023, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/07/john-roberts-supreme-court-republican-party.html/HZ
The Republican Party has been in desperate need of a pragmatic leader who can gauge public opinion, shrewdly husband political capital, and advance the party’s agenda in sustainable ways. That leader has materialized in the form of John Roberts. The chief justice of the United States is attempting to navigate the disjuncture between voters, who on the whole are sharply divided but have slightly favored Democrats, and the power Republicans have accumulated through the Supreme Court, which is quasi-permanent and unbounded by any other political branch. In theory, Republicans could use their hammerlock on the high court to settle a long series of social and economic disputes in their party’s favor. This is the course many conservatives hoped, and liberals feared, the conservative Court would take, especially after Donald Trump was able to seat three justices and pad its right-wing majority. Instead, Roberts has pursued a more cautious strategy, and the question is if this will be enough to shore up the Court’s falling popularity and disarm Democratic threats to overhaul it. While he has given conservatives high-profile victories on long-standing social divisions like abortion rights and affirmative action, he has also given victories to liberals. In the term that ended in late June, the Roberts Court definitively repudiated the “independent state legislature” theory, which Trump’s supporters had pushed as his vehicle to attempt to overturn the 2020 election and with which other Republicans hoped to enable gerrymandered legislatures to entrench their power. Liberals, having fretted the case was a ticking time bomb for the Republic, exhaled in relief. Former federal judge J. Michael Luttig called the decision “the single most important constitutional case for American Democracy since the Nation’s Founding almost 250 years ago.” More surprisingly, the Court, which under Roberts in 2013 undid a crucial pillar of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, issued an expansive voting-rights ruling that will create more Black-majority legislative districts in southern states, which had previously been free to marginalize Black voters. Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh voted with the Court’s three liberals in these recent cases, joined by Amy Coney Barrett in the “independent state legislature” case. If you were to ask Roberts to explain this pattern, he would no doubt insist he is merely interpreting the law as written. As a nominee in 2005, he famously likened his role to an umpire calling balls and strikes, a conceit he has clung to even as the Court’s reputation for above-the-fray independence has dwindled. “We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges,” he said in 2018 after Trump lashed out at a federal judge over an immigration ruling. But very few people actually believe him. A decade ago, Roberts reportedly reversed himself in deliberations about a lawsuit to overturn the Affordable Care Act, ultimately crafting a compromise that left in place parts of the law. Last year, reporting indicated he was lobbying Kavanaugh to pull back from a full-scale repeal of Roe v. Wade. The Wall Street Journal ran an extraordinary editorial hinting at the Court’s divisions and urging its conservatives to stand firm. (Shortly afterward, Politico obtained the preliminary draft of the court’s Roe repeal, a leak that conservatives employed as an argument for forging ahead.) The chief justice may not be taking polls and holding focus groups, but he is acting like a man who is well aware that the popular legitimacy of the institution he leads is in danger. The historical shadow looming over Roberts’s calculations is the confrontation between Franklin Roosevelt and the Supreme Court some 90 years ago. Roosevelt had found his economic reforms repeatedly overturned by a right-wing Supreme Court. After winning a landslide election, Roosevelt sought to take control of the Court by adding seats and appointing new and more liberal justices, only for the Court’s majority to reverse itself in 1937 and cede economic policy to Congress and the president. Liberals have long feared that once the new generation of conservatives had gained control of the Supreme Court, it would revert to something like its pre-’37 stance. Perhaps the new right-wing jurisprudence would be less overbearing on economic policy, and more aggressive on social policy, than the version of a century ago, but the overall contours of the scenario that kept progressive legal analysts up at night was an unshackled Supreme Court throwing around its weight without fear of backlash. Why would Roberts hesitate to seize the full range of power at his disposal — to the extent that he appears to be going against his own predilections? One reason is that the Court’s Republican majority is a historical accident. Unlike the Court that bedeviled FDR, which was the product of decades of Republican dominance that preceded him, the Roberts Court did not earn its majority as the result of Republicans winning a bunch of presidential elections. Democrats have won five of the last eight presidential elections and seven of the last eight popular votes. The GOP majority on the Court is a combination of better actuarial luck and more selfless partisan teamwork by Republican justices and some ruthlessness by Senator Mitch McConnell. An aging Thurgood Marshall did not stay on the Court long enough for a Democrat to succeed him; McConnell used his Senate majority to prevent Obama from installing Antonin Scalia’s replacement; Ruth Bader Ginsburg simply refused to step down despite her cancer diagnoses, even while Democrats held the presidency and the Senate; then Anthony Kennedy, despite being a swing justice, stepped down under Trump. Those four events created the current right-wing majority. It is perfectly legal, but it hardly derives from anything like a mandate to reshape American law. The rules of the Constitution make this result legitimate, too. But the Constitution also allows Democrats to either pack the Court or to reform it fundamentally in ways that would eliminate its Republican majority. They held off using this power when they controlled Congress and the presidency during Biden’s first two years. But if the Court exerts its authority in an abusive or too nakedly partisan fashion, the next Democratic Party–controlled government might decide it has to act. In the aftermath of the affirmative-action decision, President Biden ruled out packing the Court, though he told reporters, “This is not a normal Court.” This is the exact equilibrium Roberts wants: bad for Democrats, but not existentially bad. The legitimacy of the conservative Court has been the thematic crux of its burgeoning ethics scandals. The conservative movement has rallied around Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito even as they accepted undisclosed patronage from billionaires, branding reporters uncovering these financial relationships as activists seeking to discredit its prized majority. Roberts took a more conciliatory line, conceding ethics was an “issue of concern inside the Court.” The respective styles of Roberts and the Court’s right wing on ethics mirror their contrasting approach to jurisprudence: He seeks to conserve power by modulating it, and the right-wing justices seek to perpetuate their power by flaunting it. Roberts’s strategy appears to be giving Democrats enough trust in the fairness of the Court’s decisions, and hope that they can win some future cases, to keep them from flipping over the game board. By the same token, the threat of a Democratic Court-reforming response is a helpful one to keep the Republican judicial majority in check. It remains to be seen whether Roberts and his colleagues will take that bargain or continue a run of precedent smashing that causes Democrats to see the Republican Court as an existential threat.
2023
DDI
Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Court DA › 2NC—AT: Robert Fails
Hasen’ 2023[Richard L. Hasen is an American legal scholar and law professor at the University of California, Los Angeles. He is an expert in legislation, election law and campaign finance.]Richard L. Hasen, John Roberts Throws a Curveball, June 8, 2023, /HZ
The Supreme Court’s voting rights ruling on Thursday in Allen v. Milligan is as shocking as it is welcome. The Voting Rights Act has lived to see another day, with implications for 2024 and beyond. The court ruled that Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act requires Alabama to draw a second majority-Black congressional district in which its voters can elect the candidate of their choice. In an opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts and joined by Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson, Elena Kagan, Brett Kavanaugh and Sonia Sotomayor, the court also reaffirmed Section 2’s constitutionality and beat back Alabama’s arguments that the race-conscious statute should be read in a race-neutral way. Milligan is not a ruling that expands minority voting rights. But had the dissenting justices — Samuel Alito, Amy Coney Barrett, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas — gotten their way, it would have decimated effective minority representation as Congress, statehouses, county and school boards and city councils became much whiter and less broadly representative. The big mystery is why Chief Justice Roberts would write an opinion confirming that race-based remedies in politics are sometimes appropriate, given his role in 1982 as President Ronald Reagan’s point man opposing the expansion of Section 2, his 2013 opinion in Shelby County v. Holder striking down as unconstitutional another key part of the act and numerous recent decisions reading the act narrowly. It’s possible that he had a change of heart, but it’s more likely that his institutionalist side kicked in. He may have sided with Black Alabamians because he has genuinely changed his skeptical views about race-conscious remedies since he wrote the opinion for Shelby County, a case he did not even cite in his opinion in Milligan. He could have seen Milligan as simply applying well-settled precedents. But as recently as last year, when Alabama sought a stay before the 2022 elections of the lower-court ruling the court just affirmed, Chief Justice Roberts suggested rethinking or tinkering with those precedents even as he opposed the stay. (Justice Kavanaugh joined the other conservatives in imposing the stay, but he said he did so because the lower-court ruling came too close to the election, not on the merits of Alabama’s arguments on appeal.) But perhaps a more plausible answer for the chief justice’s blinking is that he could foresee the additional social upheaval and opprobrium that would have been generated against the Supreme Court had it ended significant minority representation in Congress and statehouses. Showing the court as an institution sometimes willing to side with minority plaintiffs could prove very important, especially if, as expected, Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kavanaugh soon join the other conservative justices in rejecting race-based affirmative action in college admissions.