Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Job Guarantee › Circumvention---Link---Admin

Implementation fails---vagueness ensures it totally blows up in practice.

Jonathan Chait 18, New York Intelligencer political columnist, “Democrats Are Rushing Into a Job Guarantee. It Could Be a Huge Mistake.,” Intelligencer, 4/25/18, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/04/democrats-are-rushing-a-jobs-guarantee-its-a-huge-mistake.html //MRK

Two years ago, the notion that the federal government would hire anybody who didn’t have a job was so obscure that it did not even qualify for Bernie Sanders’s blue-sky social-democratic wish list of a platform. Since then, the jobs guarantee plan has materialized almost out of nowhere and ascended nearly to the status of Democratic Party doctrine. Last spring, the Center for American Progress, a progressive think tank with a close relationship to the Democratic Party, proposed a version of a federal jobs guarantee. Another liberal think tank, the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, commissioned a report by outside scholars Darrick Hamilton, William Darity, and Mark Paul that proposed a more fleshed-out version. It has cornered the progressive small-magazine market, with fulsome endorsements in The Nation, The New Republic, the Intercept, and Democracy Journal. In recent weeks, some version of a job guarantee has gained endorsements from senators and potential presidential candidates Cory Booker, Kirsten Gillibrand, and Bernie Sanders (in exactly that somewhat surprising chronological order). The customary years, or decades, it takes for a policy concept to matriculate from academic white papers to party platform has been compressed into mere months.

The party’s rapid embrace of a job guarantee is understandable, since the idea has enormous power as both an abstract social ideal and as a political messaging vehicle. The weak point of the Democrats’ economic appeal has always been the (heavily racialized) accusation that they are subsidizing sloth. Even working-class people who stand to benefit directly from government activism often recoil at the notion that their own hard work might subsidize lazy neighbors. A job guarantee neutralizes that objection, co-opting the conservative themes of self-sufficiency and hard work.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › K of Durable Fiat

The transmission belt model depoliticizes the exercise of democratic power---this legitimizes a form of techno managerialism that will culminate in extinction. The alternative is expanding public power.

Matthew Cole 22, received his PhD in political science from Duke in 2017, “What’s Wrong with Technocracy?,” Boston Review, 2017, https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/whats-wrong-with-technocracy/

The word “technocracy” has been around for a century, but as a term of political derision it has flourished since the global financial crisis of 2008, especially in the context of the European Union’s austerity-driven response to recession. Critics have alleged, in particular, that EU policy was overdetermined by unelected experts—especially those within the European Central Bank, whose positions insulated them from democratic accountability. The Occupy Wall Street movement of the early 2010s gave voice to similar outrage in the United States.

In hindsight, these debates now register as early flashpoints in a twenty-first-century political showdown over the relationship between experts and citizens—what political scientist Archon Fung has called the rise of “wide-aperture, low-deference democracy.” The signs of that showdown are everywhere. Since the COVID-19 pandemic plunged the world into a series of interlocking crises, public health agencies like the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have been accused of mismanagement, miscommunication, and even outright deception, while economic institutions like the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank have exercised wide discretionary power over the path of recovery. Whatever one makes of the details of these debates, it is undeniable that democratic citizens in many nations find themselves in a position of dependence and distrust, reliant on technocratic institutions but lacking in meaningful mechanisms of oversight and accountability. Technocracy cannot be dismissed as a mere specter of the paranoid populist imagination.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---AT: Other Cuts Solve

You could not cut other programs nearly enough to add up to an emancipatory UBI.

Alex Gourevitch & Lucas Stanczyk 18, Gourevitch teaches political theory at Brown University and writes on strikes, work, and freedom; Stanczyk teaches philosophy at Harvard University, “The Basic Income Illusion,” Catalyst, March 2018, https://catalyst-journal.com/2018/03/the-basic-income-illusion

On close inspection, all of the familiar arguments for the emancipatory rather than the merely ameliorative potential of basic income are at bottom instances of the so-called “exit” argument for basic income. This is the idea that a generous basic income would allow people to exit from the labor market — to take care of family, to be entrepreneurial, or simply to say “no” to an abusive employer — because it would allow people to live without wage income on, at least, a bare subsistence income. Clearly, then, such arguments require extending something approximating at least a bare subsistence income.

Now, what level of payment is required for this purpose will differ widely with geographical differences in purchasing power. We shall focus initially on the United States. As the world’s richest large industrialized country with the single leanest public sector, it is also the country presently most able to afford a universal basic income approximating bare subsistence.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---Watered Down

History proves---underspecified programs will be watered down due to intransigent political commitments.

Lynn D. Lu 20, Associate Professor of Law and Co-Director, Economic Justice Project, CUNY School of Law., “From Stigma to Dignity? Transforming Workfare with Universal Basic Income and a Federal Job Guarantee,” South Carolina Law Review, vol. 72, no. 3, 2021/2020, pp. 703–734

V. NEITHER MAGIC BULLET NOR BLANK SLATE: PROCEEDING WITH CAUTION

UBI and a JG are not magic-bullet solutions for the wide range of ills they seek to address, but neither are they emerging onto a blank slate. Prior experiences reveal the ideological disagreements that hinder the creative reform of existing programs. Previous attempts to enact UBI or a JG through social safety net programs have resulted in political compromises by guaranteeing economic security only for those deemed deserving through work effort.148 Under these programs, those fortunate enough to achieve prosperity are viewed as deserving of all the credit, and those who fail are viewed simply as lacking the will to succeed and are consigned to the meanest work or circumstances. To the contrary, a minimum guarantee of social support free of work requirements, even if not constitutionally required, recognizes that individuals should not be indebted to private employers, breadwinners, or society at large for the basic necessities of life.149

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---Inflation

A UBI would be subverted through inflation. Political manipulation would prevent payment amounts from rising in a way that corresponds

Brian O’Boyle 21, author of Austerity Ireland and a lecturer at St Angela's College, Sligo, “A Socialist Case Against Universal Basic Income,” Rebel News, 7/5/21, http://www.rebelnews.ie/2021/07/05/universal-basic-income-socialist-case-against/

Victories won by the working class would also be more difficult to take back versus a UBI issued by the state and vulnerable to inflation. An economy owned and controlled by the ruling class is one in which any UBI paid for through progressive taxes would be one that would also be vulnerable to higher prices administered by employers.

Politically, it is also more tangible to argue for a significant increase in the core rates of social welfare than to call for the tens of billions required for a pro-worker UBI. While it is very unlikely that every adult would be given €1,000 per month, workers have become accustomed to receiving €350 from a Pandemic Unemployment Payment and would likely respond well to any social movement that fought to retain this alongside a living wage.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---Conditionality

Conditionality turns the case---it requires the existence of poverty to serve as punishment for failing to meet the condition.

Karl Widerquist 23, excerpt from a forthcoming 2024 book, “The False Promise of Conditional Social Policies (Mandatory Participation on Trial, Part 11),” US BIG, 2023, https://usbig.net/the-false-promise-of-conditional-social-policies-mandatory-participation-on-trial-part-11/

As my book, Universal Basic Income: Essential Knowledge, discusses, the traditional approach to poverty and inequality relies on conditional programs designed to make most forms of aid to the disadvantaged consistent with mandatory participation.

Programs with genuine conditions cannot eliminate poverty, homelessness, or economic destitution because they have to have some punishment for people who fail to fulfill their conditions. Either the conditions are phony, meaning that they are so easy no one could fail to meet them, or some people will fail to meet them, become ineligible for aid, and live in poverty or homelessness. Without a credible threat, the conditions will become phony. Therefore, the conditional safety net we use to fight poverty actually requires poverty to get people to do what policymakers—who are by-and-large, if not entirely made up of more advantaged people—want them to do.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---2NC

No consensus on a UBI program—could lead to tradeoffs

Vanessa Brown Calder 17, Director of Opportunity and Family Policy Studies, Cato Institute, “Universal Basic Income — Disease or Cure?,” Cato Institute, 4/26/17, https://www.cato.org/commentary/universal-basic-income-disease-or-cure //MRK

When we discuss UBI, we accept a high degree of uncertainty about the details. But those details matter, because the strange bedfellows that support the idea often only favor it under incompatible conditions. For example, while some advocates lend support to the concept contingent on a promise to dissolve the existing social safety net, others maintain that UBI is only acceptable in conjunction with existing programs.

Regardless of political feasibility, in an era of rising populism, exercising restraint in advocating for a costlier, more comprehensive welfare program seems essential. For those that support open society policies like immigration, the provision of a larger benefit package with fewer strings attached is likely to reduce political support for friendly immigration policies. Taxpayers intuitively understand that a comprehensive policy like UBI will place extra pressure on government finances and institutions.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---2NC

It is impossible to solve this problem via a credible commitment.

Orlando Lazar 21, St. Edmund Hall & Balliol College, University of Oxford, “Work, Domination, and the False Hope of Universal Basic Income,” Res Publica, vol. 27, no. 3, 08/01/2021, pp. 427–446

The Stability of the Income: The Problem of State Domination

Another difculty for proponents of a work-oriented UBI lies in the required stability of that income. Again, a comparison with UBIs suitable for other purposes is helpful—assume now that the level of the income remains the same between examples. A UBI that reduces poverty will do so for as long as it is provided, and will stop doing so as soon as it is withdrawn or reduced to below the poverty line. A UBI that reforms a degrading, conditional welfare regime will do so for as long as it is provided, and will stop doing so as soon as it is made conditional. The problem of an unstable UBI—one that could be reduced or eliminated at any moment—is indeed a problem for these purposes, but it is a future-oriented problem. For as long as that unstable UBI is in place, it has its intended efects, but it would be better if we could ensure that those efects would continue for as long as possible. The issue of stability for a domination-oriented UBI is more complicated. Republican proponents already appreciate this, for distinctively republican reasons. In this section and the next I want to briefy highlight quite how demanding that republican stability criterion is, and then give another, more general reason—one that non-republicans must accept as well—to doubt that an unstable UBI is adequate for the purposes of transforming work.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › UBI › Circumvention---1NC

UBI would be gutted in the process of implementation.

Rob Lyon 20, Fightback editor, “Socialism or UBI?,” Fightback, 12/18/20, https://www.marxist.ca/article/socialism-or-ubi

An added weakness of UBI is that even when it is proposed with the best of reformist intentions, the fact that it is also being put forward by the right wing means that it is open to co-option. A Liberal government fighting to survive may rhetorically adopt UBI to steal NDP votes, only to turn around and use it as a fig-leaf for cuts in social programs. An NDP government capitulating to capitalist pressure could do something similar, jettisoning the expansion of the welfare state and corporate taxes, leaving behind only a cash payment funded via deficits and inflation.

The left-UBIers also cannot escape the problem of any proposal to tax the rich while they continue owning the means of production. Any plan that genuinely taxes the rich and redistributes wealth will not be accepted by the capitalists. If you tax the rich they will not invest. They will take their capital overseas, close factories and make millions unemployed. This is why the key question is not taxation and redistribution, but ownership. You cannot plan what you do not control and you cannot control what you do not own.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Movement Turn › Movement Turn---JG

Policies of full employment cannot be meaningfully secured without building political support ahead of time.

Alex Gourevitch & Lucas Stanczyk 18, Gourevitch teaches political theory at Brown University and writes on strikes, work, and freedom; Stanczyk teaches philosophy at Harvard University, “The Basic Income Illusion,” Catalyst, March 2018, https://catalyst-journal.com/2018/03/the-basic-income-illusion

To see this, consider the long-standing opposition of business to a policy of full employment. As the economist Michal Kalecki long ago pointed out, it should at first glance be puzzling why profit-seeking businesses normally do not support a policy of full employment. “Clearly, higher output and employment benefit not only workers but entrepreneurs as well, because the latter’s profits rise. And the policy of full employment [need] not encroach upon profits because it [need] not involve any additional taxation. The entrepreneurs in the slump are longing for a boom; why do they not gladly accept the synthetic boom which the government is able to offer them?” Kalecki’s answer had three parts.

First, when the level of unemployment depends on the state of investor confidence, this gives businesses and investors extensive power over economic policy: “everything which may shake the state of confidence must be carefully avoided because it would cause an economic crisis.” Yet once the government learns the trick of alleviating unemployment through direct public investment, “this powerful controlling device loses its effectiveness.” Second, a government policy of subsidizing mass consumption is normally even “more violently opposed than public investment. For here a moral principle of the highest importance is at stake… ‘You shall earn your bread in sweat ’— unless you happen to have private means.” Finally, even if the opposition to temporary Keynesianism and active industrial policy were entirely overcome, “the maintenance of full employment would cause social and political changes which would give a new impetus to the opposition of the 28 29 30 business leaders.” Why? Because “under a regime of permanent full employment, the ‘sack’ would cease to play its role as a disciplinary measure.” Accordingly, “[t]he social position of the boss would be undermined, and the self-assurance and class-consciousness of the working class would grow.” To be sure, “profits would be higher under a regime of full employment than they are on the average under laissez-faire; and even the rise in wage rates resulting from the stronger bargaining power of the workers is less likely to reduce profits than to increase prices, and thus adversely affects only the rentier interests. But ‘discipline in the factories’ and ‘political stability’ are more appreciated than profits by business leaders.”

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Movement Turn › Movement Turn---2NC

It is the only way to produce a meaningful UBI.

Adam Booth 17, editor of Socialist.net, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” In Defense of Marxism, 2/10/17, https://www.marxist.com/universal-basic-income-utopian-dream-or-libertarian-nightmare.htm

Again, we should stress that the wealth is most definitely there in society to fund a genuinely progressive UBI system. But the only way such a reform would ever actually be introduced in any meaningful way is if the capitalists felt threatened to the point that they feared losing everything; that is, if the class struggle reached such intense and heightened levels that the ruling elites offered reforms from above to prevent revolution from below. And even then, in such a situation, the demand would have to be not for UBI, but for socialist revolution!

If the demand for UBI is to be posed and fought for by the Left, then it cannot be done so in a manner divorced from the question of class struggle. We cannot rely on the altruism of the rich and the compassion of the capitalist state, the essence of which – as Engels explained and Lenin underlined – consists of “special bodies of armed men” in defence of the property and interests of the ruling class.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Movement Turn › Movement Turn---2NC

Backlash that destroys the project can only be overcome by building political support, starting with a pilot program.

Alex Gourevitch & Lucas Stanczyk 18, Gourevitch teaches political theory at Brown University and writes on strikes, work, and freedom; Stanczyk teaches philosophy at Harvard University, “The Basic Income Illusion,” Catalyst, March 2018, https://catalyst-journal.com/2018/03/the-basic-income-illusion

II. THE QUESTION OF CAPITAL FLIGHT AND INVESTMENT STRIKE 19 20 21 22

This brings us to our second caveat. Our oversimplified observations assume that there would be zero negative effects on GDP from the requisite massive increase in taxes. If there were a substantial drop in GDP — because of, say, extensive capital flight or investment strike — then financing a $15,000 per person annual basic income would cost proportionately more than a quarter of total output. Anyone who claims it would cost much less is claiming, in effect, that enabling millions of people not to work would substantially grow our existing capitalist economy. There are no strong reasons, theoretical or empirical, to support this speculative conclusion.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Movement Turn › Movement Turn---2NC

‘Thick’ versions of universal programs are good, ‘thin’ versions are bad---the former can only be achieved by first building political support.

Bryant W. Sculos 18, Adjunct Professor, Politics and International Relations, Florida International University, “Socialism & Universal Basic Income,” 2018, Vol. 6, Iss. 1, https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1120&context=classracecorporatepower

The idea of providing a stipend to every person in a given country—or even across the globe— seems like it would be a project that socialists would love. And while there are certainly a large number of socialists that do or would support the establishment of a universal basic income (UBI), there are many left criticisms of UBI that have produced a great deal of skepticism about the idea. Most of the critics of UBI treat its advocates as though they believe UBI would solve all or most socioeconomic problems, at least in the Global North.1 I have yet to come across any serious UBI advocate who takes such an expansive position. My point here will be to provide reasons for why socialists should support a thick conception of UBI as a kind of radical reform from within capitalism, as part of a broader left agenda.2

In order to make this case, this essay will focus on three main contentions that are generally raised by left critics of UBI: (1) UBI would be used to dismantle existing social welfare programs, leaving the poor worse off than they were before; (2) UBI doesn’t do anything for workers within the workplace; and (3) UBI doesn’t challenge capitalism.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Movement Turn › Movement Turn---1NC

Only a strong UBI solves any of the case---that kind of UBI would be impossible without first building political support for the program.

Orlando Lazar 21, St. Edmund Hall & Balliol College, University of Oxford, “Work, Domination, and the False Hope of Universal Basic Income,” Res Publica, vol. 27, no. 3, 08/01/2021, pp. 427–446

Taking the broad sweep of academic and non-academic work, criticisms of UBI work across a number of levels of ideality, from ‘a UBI would strip work of dignity and therefore be morally wrong’, to ‘a liveable UBI would not sufciently reduce the domination of workers’, to ‘a UBI of any kind is not politically possible given the current electoral arithmetic’. These are very diferent kinds of critique. Some cut to the very heart of the idea of a UBI, and others merely raise doubts about its implementation. UBI might violate some important principle of reciprocity, or might constitute the exploitation of productive citizens by less productive citizens, for instance.12 Two criticisms are especially relevant for my purposes here, and both are well represented in the work of Alex Gourevitch (2013, 2016) and Lucas Stanczyk (Gourevitch and Stanczyk 2018). Respectively, they claim that an anti-domination UBI would be inefective, and that even a modest UBI would be impractical.

To claim that an anti-domination UBI would be inefective is to deny the mechanisms I describe in the last section, to deny that a UBI could redress power imbalances between workers and employers, transform the labour market, and so on. So for this first criticism, the question of how difficult it would be to win a UBI of this sort is irrelevant—assume that we could click our fingers and implement such a policy. Gourevitch makes two arguments against the transformative potential of that UBI. The first argument denies that a UBI, of whatever level of income, could sufciently meet the costs of leaving a job, and would therefore fail to give workers the power to credibly threaten to do so. He distinguishes between instrumental costs, which include ‘work-related social standing…the needs of family, ties to community, [and the] value of workplace relationships’ (Gourevitch 2016, p. 24), and intrinsic costs of exit, where ‘many [workers] will still validly feel an obligation to work and/or they will seek a creative outlet for their capacities’ (Gourevitch 2016, p. 24). These are things that money cannot buy. You can make leaving a job less costly, but these non-material costs establish a hard foor to the project of giving workers a credible threat of exit.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Aff

Details are less significant than the topline policy commitment.

Chris Hughes 20, co-founder of the Economic Security Project, “Why Americans Need a Guaranteed Income,” The New York Times, 5/1/20, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/01/opinion/universal-basic-income-coronavirus.html

Proposals vary, but a consensus is emerging that every American adult in a family making less than $100,000 should get at least $1,000 a month, and each child in these families should get $500 a month. A family of four would receive $3,000 a month or $36,000 a year.

Some proposals provide more for children, and others distribute the funds to all Americans, regardless of how much money a family makes. The details matter, but the shared commitment to some sort of guaranteed income matters more.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---UBI---ASPEC

They didn’t specify their agent---reject the team!

Ben Laurence 20, Philosophy, University of Chicago, “The Question of the Agent of Change,” Journal of Political Philosophy, vol. 28, no. 4, 2020, pp. 355–377

This naturally raises the question of who the agent of change is that Anderson thinks might bring about the substantial policy reorientation required to dismantle residential segregation. Although she once again could be more explicit, her answer appears to be that hope lies with an African-American-led social movement that renews the aspiration for integration that (she believes) was central to the civil rights movement of the 1960s. This is why her extended discussion of the epistemology of social movements occupies center stage in her crowning chapter on democratic theory.36 In keeping with her Deweyan epistemological conception of democracy as the collective exercise of our practical intelligence to solve social problems, she views social movements as engaged in democratic acts of teaching and learning, under conditions where the epistemological functions of ordinary democratic politics have been disabled by political pathologies. Through targeted disruption of business as usual, collective agents with certain special properties are capable of breaking through the clubby and exclusionary routines that insulate us epistemically and morally from the legitimate claims of others. If such a social movement aimed at racial integration, then targeted gains could be won that would help to undermine the psychological underpinnings of a politics of white resentment, allowing for further egalitarian transformations down the road.

In short, Anderson argues from views about the plausible agent of change to views about what remedies to pursue.37 [FOOTNOTE 37 BEGINS] 37 Other recent arguments that take this direction include Tommie Shelby’s critique of the political proposals of the Black Power movement—on the grounds that class divisions in the black community pose a significant challenge to the formation of an all-black agent of change—and Alex Gourevitch and Lucas Stanczyk’s argument against basic income as a replacement for the efforts of a flagging labor movement—given the organized obstacles that face an ambitious basic income, the only plausible potential agent of change is a mobilized and vastly empowered labor movement. Tommie Shelby, We Who Are Dark: The Philosophical Foundations of Black Solidarity (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2015), pp. 101–35; Alex Gourevitch and Lucas Stanczyk, “The Basic Income Illusion,” Catalyst, 4 (2018), 22–43. [FOOTNOTE 37 ENDS] Her diagnosis of the problem of black/white inequality in the US has implications for identifying the plausible agents of change, and she uses these implications to support one set of remedies (policies fostering integration) over another set of remedies (policies that directly address inequality). What this shows is that in nonideal theory the problem of the agent of change is tightly connected with the other core tasks of diagnosing a problem and proposing a set of remedies. To diagnose a problem is already to identify various political actors harmed or benefited by, or otherwise implicated in, the perpetuation of an injustice, and to specify structural obstacles to the formation of political agents capable of addressing the problem. Views about the plausible potential agent of change can have consequences for what remedies should be pursued to overcome the problem identified. Entailments thus run in multiple directions, and these questions must be thought through together.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---UBI---2NC

The pros and cons of a subsistence UBI are totally different than the pros and cons of a stingier UBI. Not specifying which one they adopt makes debating totally impossible.

Brian Barry 1, Philosopher, “UBI and the Work Ethic,” What’s Wrong With a Free Lunch?, Beacon Press, 05/08/2001, pp. 60–69

It need hardly be said that it is one thing to identify where the money could come from and another to explain where the political motivation to raise it is to be found. A time of serious proposals to cut income taxes, abolish the inheritance tax, and even reduce the gas tax is less than propitious. We should bear in mind, however, that sometimes things move a lot faster and a lot further—and a lot sooner—than is generally expected. In politics, as in geology, seismic events resist prophecy. In a spirit of speculation, however, let me mention three conceivable ways in which a move to a universal basic income could be precipitated.

Imagine, then, some kind of really dramatic evidence of global warming—the disappearance of a medium-sized Pacific island under the sea, for example. This justmight jolt public opinion into support for massive energy taxes. Returning the revenue to everybody equally would just by itself constitute a basic income at some level or other.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---UBI---2NC

Vague UBI proposals are totally undebatable. Rejoinder for these proposals is impossible.

David James Hogg 23, social policy postgraduate from Liverpool interested in UBI and the Italian operaismo movement, “‘The Left Will Find That It Has Bought a Trojan Horse’: The Dialectics of Universal Basic Income,” Critical Social Policy, vol. 43, no. 1, SAGE Publications Ltd, 02/01/2023, pp. 140–156

On the surface, basic income does indeed appear radical, suggesting that its appeal ‘seems to lie partly in its very transgressiveness’ (Sloman, 2018: 638). But there are also dangers posed by its implementation, which is evident from the bourgeois support for UBI both historically and today.

A ‘shape-shifting social policy’

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---UBI---2NC

Without knowing the details, a ‘UBI’ could be revolutionary or counter-reformist. This makes the 1AC meaningless---vote neg on presumption.

Adam Booth 17, editor of Socialist.net, “Universal basic income: utopian dream or libertarian nightmare?,” In Defense of Marxism, 2/10/17, https://www.marxist.com/universal-basic-income-utopian-dream-or-libertarian-nightmare.htm

Marxists will fight for any reform that genuinely improves the living standards of workers and the poor. But in order to ascertain whether we can support this-or-that demand, we must first ask: is it really a reform that is being proposed, or – in fact – a counter-reform?

In this respect, the call for a UBI in the abstract is meaningless. The devil is in the detail. Above all, it is necessary to analyse the question from a class point of view and look at who is raising the demand, and – most importantly – in whose (class) interest.

2023 DDI Counterplan
Circumvention › Vagueness › Vagueness---UBI---1NC

Vague UBI proposals are watered down to nothingness. And, underspecification makes debating the merits and downsides impossible.

Juliana Uhuru Bidadanure 19, Department of Philosophy, Stanford University, “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income,” Annual Review of Political Science, vol. 22, no. 1, 2019, pp. 481–501

Universal basic income (UBI) is a radical policy proposal of a monthly cash grant given to all members of a community without means test, regardless of personal desert, with no strings attached and, under most proposals, at a sufficiently high level to enable a life free from economic insecurity. In recent years, UBI went from a utopian proposal to a policy with growing currency. UBI experiments have been conducted in countries as different as Kenya, Finland, Namibia, India, and Canada. In the United States, variants of the UBI proposal were very much alive in the early second half of the twentieth century—including through figures like Martin Luther King, Jr., and Milton Friedman—but the conversation did not pick up much in subsequent decades.

This changed around 2016, when several American personalities wrote on the policy, including former Service Employees International Union president Andrew Stern, former Secretary of Labor Robert B. Reich, and futurist Martin Ford. Notably, the technology incubator Y Combinator started testing UBI in Oakland, California, in 2016; the Economic Security Project was launched in 2016, devoting millions to research and advocacy on UBI; and the mayor of Stockton, California, announced the launch of a pilot program starting in 2019. The growth of income and wealth inequalities, the precariousness of labor, and the persistence of abject poverty have all been important drivers of renewed interest in UBI in the United States. But it is without a doubt the fear that automation may displace workers from the labor market at unprecedented rates that primarily explains the revival of the policy, including by many in or around Silicon Valley (Ford 2015).