Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Inflation DA › 2AC --- AT: Inflation Link

Studies simulating single payer healthcare systems show that all systems would save money.

Kurtzman et al. 20(Laura Kurtzman, Assistant Director and Health communications director at UCSF, “Single-Payer Systems Likely to Save Money in US, Analysis Finds”, University of California San Francisco, January 15, 2020, https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2020/01/416416/single-payer-systems-likely-save-money-us-analysis-finds) JCG

A single-payer healthcare system would save money over time, likely even during the first year of operation, according to nearly two dozen analyses of national and statewide single payer proposals made over the past 30 years.

The study, published Wednesday, Jan. 15, 2020, in PLOS Medicine, comes as California Gov. Gavin Newsom has named a state commission to find ways to achieve universal coverage, possibly through a single-payer system, and as the Democratic presidential candidates are debating “Medicare for All” proposals on the national stage.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Inflation DA › 2AC --- AT: Inflation Link

Single-Payer healthcare decreases expenditures overall.

Himmelstein and Woolhandler ’20

(David U. Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, distinguished professor of public health and health policy and a lecturer at Harvard, “Single-Payer Reform: Heed the Evidence, Not the Soothsayers,” American Journal of Public Health, no. 4, April 1, 2020, -ERL

Even the most ambitious proposed tweaks to the ACA would leave millions uninsured or saddled with unaffordable copayments and deductibles. By contrast, single-payer systems have a track record of success. Until Canada implemented its single-payer reform, its health care financing and delivery systems mirrored those of the United States, health costs were virtually identical, and Canada trailed in life expectancy and infant mortality. Soon thereafter Canada pulled ahead on health outcomes and fell behind on expenditures. Today, Canada’s life expectancy is 3.4 years longer, its infant mortality rate 22% lower (https://bit.ly/2rVObD0), and its income-based health inequities2 are far smaller than ours. In conditions whose outcomes closely track care quality, such as type-1 diabetes, end-stage renal disease, and cystic fibrosis,3 Canadians fare better. Canada produces these superior outcomes at spectacularly lower costs: a difference of $6198 per capita in 2018. US private insurers’ overhead siphons $243.8 billion (13.2% of premiums) from patient care. Canadian private insurers—and those in Europe4—are similarly inefficient, but they play a miniscule role in those nations’ health systems. Meanwhile, the public Medicare programs in both nations (Canada’s single-payer system is also known as Medicare) subsist on 2% overhead. The United States wastes even more—$401 billion in 20175—on providers’ billing-related bureaucracy. Hospitals spend billions attributing costs and charges to individual patients, visits, and procedures and fighting with insurers to extract payment. Reliance on operating profits (labeled “surpluses” at nonprofit institutions) to fund the equipment purchases and renovations essential to survival drives CEOs to fritter away additional billions on upcoding, tailoring services to profitability, marketing to recruit profitable patients and demarketing to avoid unprofitable ones, and the other entrepreneurial exertions needed to generate profits and surpluses. A single-payer system could pay each hospital a lump sum to cover its operations with new buildings and major equipment financed through targeted grants rather than operating profits and surpluses—just as we fund public schools, fire departments, and health departments. In Canada and Scotland, this lump sum noncommercial payment strategy has kept hospital administrative costs at 12% of revenues, versus 25% in the United States. A single-payer reform would also spare doctors (and other practitioners) the expense and aggravation of negotiating contracts with payers and navigating varying billing and prior-approval requirements, referral networks, and formularies. The $600 billion in savings attainable through single-payer reform could be repurposed to make universal, first-dollar coverage affordable. Most single-payer cost estimates foresee modest initial cost reductions, with mounting savings thereafter (https://bit.ly/2O6d46X).

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity Firms

Levins 23 (Hoag Levins, Journalist and Producer at Upenn. "The Effect of Private Equity Investment in Health Care?" Jacobin. N.p., 10 March 2023. https://ldi.upenn.edu/our-work/research-updates/the-effect-of-private-equity-investment-in-health-care/#:~:text=Shortchanged%20Patients,patient%20outcomes%2C%E2%80%9D%20said%20Werner.) JCG

The controversial issue of private equity health care acquisitions was the subject of a University of Pennsylvania Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics (LDI) March 3 virtual seminar that brought together top financial and health care experts to explore the issue further.

Panel moderator and LDI Executive Director Rachel M. Werner, MD, PhD, explained that in 2010, there were 325 private equity deals in U.S. health care. But by 2021, that number had soared to well over a thousand deals. Private equity is a leveraged buyout (LBO) investment strategy that takes over a company like a steel plant, furniture manufacturer, grocery chain or hospital, and then greatly increases the target organization’s debt to finance the internal reorganization and expansions needed to increase the future sale value. The issue in the health care sector is whether this type of investment, which works well in manufacturing and retail sales, is well suited for organizations whose product is patient care. “Patients, health care providers, and policymakers are concerned about what the short-term private equity financial incentives are and how they might shortchange patients, result in consolidation in the health care markets, increase care costs, and perhaps worsen patient outcomes,” said Werner. The four panelists and researchers who were asked to provide their assessment of how private equity impacts patient care were Atul Gupta, PhD, LDI Senior Fellow and Assistant Professor of Health Care Management at The Wharton School; Sabrina Howell, PhD, Associate Professor of Finance, NYU School of Business; Ryan McDevitt, PhD, Professor of Economics at Duke University; and Brian Powers, MD, MBA, Vice President for Clinical Strategy at Humana. Howell, a Faculty Research Fellow at the National Bureau of Economic Research and a Research Fellow at the Private Equity Research Consortium, explained, “Private equity firms are basically more responsive to competitive and financial incentives than other types of firms. Whether customers are better off after an acquisition depends on the incentive structure of the particular market. We know unambiguously that private equity ownership increases productivity, but whether the operational changes are good for consumers—in this case, patients—depends on whether incentives to maximize profit are structured to be well aligned with consumer interests. I’ve [studied] for-profit colleges, nursing homes, local newspapers, and airports. And for the first three, I find evidence of adverse effects of private equity ownership along at least some dimensions.” Gupta, an applied microeconomist with research interests in health economics, public economics, and industrial organization, discussed his nursing home study findings in relation to private equity acquisitions. “Our headline result was that, unfortunately for Medicare patients who account for about 60% of all patients that pass through nursing homes, short term mortality within 90 days of discharge from the nursing home goes up by about 10%,” Gupta said. “In addition, we also found adverse effects on other measures of patient well-being. For example, scores on mobility, ulcers, and pain. We find a coherent, consistent picture of patients doing worse after the nursing home is bought by private equity. We also see evidence that the nursing home spending goes up for Medicare by about 6-8%.” Werner pointed out that studies of nursing homes during the COVID-19 pandemic found that private equity-managed institutions fared better than nursing homes that weren’t involved in private equity at the time. “The nursing homes owned by private equity in 2021 might be quite different than nursing homes during our sample period prior to the pandemic,” said Gupta “We have to think about COVID-19 as a slightly different time frame in the sense that there was a lot of scrutiny on nursing homes for obvious reasons. And we know that private equity firms respond to competition and probably also responded to greater scrutiny. And so, it’s perfectly understandable why, during a period where there was a lot of scrutiny on nursing home performance, private equity-owned nursing homes actually did a better job in some dimensions.” McDevitt, editor of the Journal of Industrial Economics, noted that “despite a lot of recent headlines about bankruptcies in private equity-acquired acute care hospitals, the data don’t actually support that narrative. There’s not a widespread financial instability after the acquisition. In some of our own work, on average, these hospitals actually improved their financial performance after being acquired by a private equity fund, and they did it by both reducing costs and increasing revenue. There seems to be this odd tension between policymakers wanting to bend the cost curve by making hospitals more efficient. But then they seem to be vilifying private equity firms when they do just that.” “On the technology side,” McDevitt continued, “Medicare’s made it virtually impossible to remain viable without scale. The reimbursements are pretty skimpy. The administrative burdens are quite high. And so, you need scale to be viable. And that’s one thing that private equity can provide.” Powers, editor of Healthcare: The Journal of Delivery Science and Innovation, said Humana “has concerns and questions over the extent to which the affordability of care for its members is impacted by private equity investment. There are pockets of concern around poor outcomes for individuals in our case, for our Medicare, Advantage, or Medicaid, or commercial beneficiaries, or for higher costs that may occur without a commensurate increase in quality. But there may also be pockets where that is less of a concern. We do have partnerships with primary care organizations that have been able to grow to serve more seniors largely through private equity financing.” “Access to growth capital does allow innovative businesses to scale more quickly,” continued Powers. “Traditional sources of capital, whether it’s public markets or private debt markets, creates some capacity constraints that growth capital might overcome. So, I think that’s one dimension of potential private equity benefits that I don’t think is necessarily discussed as often.” Werner asked about the impact of private equity investment strategies on health care market consolidation—a trend known to have a negative impact on costs and patient care. Howell explained that a common private equity investment strategy may circumvent antitrust regulations established in the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976. That federal law requires companies planning merger transactions above a certain threshold to inform the Federal Trade Commission and Department of Justice in advance of the transactions. “Roll-ups in which a firm buys many of a single sort of small company, or builds an initial platform and then adds onto it other small firms, are really a bread and butter strategy for creating value in private equity,” Howell said. “One by one, each purchase doesn’t hit the Hart-Scott-Rodino threshold as this kind of consolidation occurs over time. This model has been applied to health care in recent years, particularly for physician practices. A motivation for these deals is to reap efficiency gains by reducing back-office costs. That’s not necessarily a bad thing but there is some evidence that physician consolidation is associated with worse Medicare patient outcomes.” “So, from an antitrust perspective, these kinds of under-the-radar roll-ups might be a problem. If the issue is pulling together many small firms to gain market share and market power, I think private equity and non-private equity should receive the same scrutiny,” said Howell. Private Equity ventures often involve complex layers of corporate entities that can make it difficult to know exactly who owns what. This has been a particular problem in the nursing home industry and there have been growing calls for federal regulations that require more ownership transparency in health care-related private equity operations. As the panel approached its end, panelists were reminded that the Biden Administration has recently focused its attention on the role of private equity in health care. Each panelist was asked about the advice they would offer legislators as they contemplated the specifics of new regulations. McDevitt: “I would emphasize transparency. I wouldn’t separate private equity because we’re not finding any empirical evidence that private equity is different from any other investor. I would make changes to rules, regulations, and reimbursements that affect all corporate providers, even some nonprofit providers.” Powers: “I’ll echo ‘transparency.’ Another suggestion is measuring and embracing the nuance that comes from research about the areas involving poor outcomes for patients. There should be a focus on outcomes and not inputs.” Gupta: “Transparency and accountability for outcomes that we care about and then perhaps linking some payments to that to signal that (value-based reimbursement) is coming down the pike and is important.” Howell: “The incentives in private equity activity need to be aligned with the interests of taxpayers and patients. Private equity has the potential to help reduce soaring costs in some subsectors of health care if the incentives are well aligned.”

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity Firms

Private equity firms rarely deliver on their promises—their returns are overstated.

Celarier ‘21

(Michelle Celarier, award-winning journalist who writes about the world of money and power, “Is Private Equity Overrated?,” The New York Times, December 6, 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/04/business/is-private-equity-overrated.html)-ERL

But private equity’s returns increasingly may not provide the stellar performance that investors have been sold — and the returns can be misleadingly calculated in a way that overstates success. As of September 2020, private equity funds had produced a 14.2 percent median annualized return, net of fees, over the previous 10 years, compared with 13.7 percent for the S&P 500, according to an analysis of indexes by the American Investment Council, a lobbying group for the industry, using the latest numbers offered. Public pension funds invested in private equity actually had worse returns than from the S&P 500 — 12.8 percent, net of fees. (These returns, and others quoted in this article, do not include venture capital, which is typically viewed as a separate asset class.) Private equity firms have long engaged in contentious practices, including loading companies with debt and laying off workers. And calls for more transparency have arisen in Congress and the Securities and Exchange Commission. In October, Senator Elizabeth Warren, the Massachusetts Democrat who is one of Capitol Hill’s most vocal critics of private equity, reintroduced legislation that would, among other things, require more disclosure of returns and fees by private equity funds. The S.E.C. chair, Gary Gensler, has said the agency is taking a look at the same issues. Regardless, private equity is sitting on a mountain of cash. At the end of the first quarter this year, U.S. private equity funds had $841 billion in so-called dry powder, or money that was still to be invested, according to PitchBook. The deluge of dollars, which has continued apace in 2021, might be enough to make returns harder to come by. “Private equity is still outperforming public equity, but this outperformance is narrowing as all markets benefit from nonstop monetary and fiscal stimulus, and as private acquisition multiples rise,” Michael Cembalest, the chairman of market and investment strategy at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, wrote in a report this summer. Since 2009, Mr. Cembalest said in an interview, the median annual outperformance of private equity buyout funds has been “bouncing around on a median and average basis from 1 to 5 percent.” That’s down from around 15 percent in outperformance 20 years ago, according to his report, which also shows that private equity returns peaked in the early 1990s. “Since the financial crisis the industry has had a tougher time outperforming public equity benchmarks,” Mr. Cembalest noted. He also asked if today’s returns were high enough “given the illiquidity of private equity.” Ludovic Phalippou, a professor of finance at Oxford’s Said Business School, came to a harsher conclusion in a 2020 research paper that looked at North American private equity performance for funds launched between 2006 and 2015. It found that investors could have done just about as well with a stock index fund during that period, while the fees paid to private equity firms came to at least $230 billion, enabling the number of private equity multibillionaires to jump to 22 in 2020 from three in 2005. “The big picture is that they’re getting a lot of money for what they’re doing, and they’re not delivering what they have promised or what they pretend they’re delivering,” Mr. Phalippou said in an interview.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity › 2AC --- AT: Private Equity Firms

Private-equity firms’ involvement in health care increases prices, reduces quality, and encourages exploitation of patients due to pressure from investors.

Fuse Brown and Hall ‘23

Erin C. and Mark A., Director of Center for Law, Health, and Inequality at Georgia State University and Director of Health Law and Policy Program at Wake Forest University, “Private Equity and The Corporatization of Health Care”, Social Science Research Network, March 1 2023. @SL

Many public policy analysts are worried that PE investment in health care contributes to the commercialization of health care, fuels consolidation and rising costs, and is bad for patient access, outcomes, and professional practice. Private equity is exceptionally adept at identifying and exploiting market failures that can be turned into profit for investors. PE investors may not be the only ones who can capitalize on these market failures. However, they are more likely to find these opportunities to profit from payment loopholes or market dysfunctions and move aggressively into that space. Hence, as we have argued elsewhere, PE functions as a divining rod for finding market failures—where PE has penetrated, it is a good bet that there is a profit opportunity ripe for exploitation. There are three main risks that PE investment appears to pose to patients, medical professionals, and the health care market overall. First, PE investment spurs health care consolidation, which increases prices and potentially reduces quality and access.60 Second, the pressure from PE Investors to increase revenue can lead to exploitation of billing loopholes, overutilization, up-coding, aggressive risk-coding, harming patients through unnecessary care, excessive bills, and increasing overall health spending.61 Third, physicians acquired by PE companies may be subject to onerous employment terms and lose autonomy over clinical decisions and their practice of medicine.62 Although the data are still being developed, early evidence supports several of these concerns. In the hospital context, PE acquisition has been associated with increased net income, charges (the asking price), markups over costs, and the proportion of privately insured patients. 63 Among nursing homes, evidence of the impact of PE on patient outcomes is particularly troubling. Researchers found that Medicare patients in private equity-owned nursing facilities suffered a 10% increase in 90-day mortality between 2004-2016 (i.e., pre-pandemic), and that this increased risk of death could have been due to reduced staffing levels. 64 Other quality measures also declined following the acquisition, even as per-patient spending increased.65 The impact of PE investment in physician practices shows similar risks of higher prices, increased spending, and reduced staffing levels. One study, for instance, documented that when hospitals contracted with either of the two largest physician staffing companies for emergency services, both of which have PE investors, this led to substantially higher prices, increased testing and hospital admissions, and more aggressive billing practices.66 Another study found that PE-acquired physician practices specializing in dermatology, gastroenterology, and ophthalmology increased health spending and utilization, compared with controls. 67 A separate study of dermatology practices found that PE targeted larger practices for acquisition and that PE acquisition led to higher prices and patient volumes compared to controls, 68 and similar results were found for PE investment in anesthesia practices. 69 In terms of staffing impacts, PE ownership of surgical dermatology practices is associated with higher ratios of nonphysician providers to physicians and lower staffing levels overall, particularly for non-revenue generating staff. 70 Compared to non-PE-acquired practices, PE-owned dermatology, ophalmology, and gastroenterology practices showed higher physician turnover and a the addition of more mid-level staff, suggesting that physician satisfaction may be lower in PE-owned practices, and that additional PE-driven practice growth may be absorbed at a lower cost by a greater reliance on mid-level practitioners.71 To be sure, not all studies have shown clear adverse effects.72 Moreover, there are some potential benefits to consider, such as: access to capital, efficiencies, allowing physicians graduating with medical debt to join practices, and offloading practice management burden from physicians.73 Yet, regulators and policymakers must attend to the risks to patient care, health care spending, and physicians’ clinical autonomy posed by rampant PE-investment in health care.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Inequality Advantage › 2AC --- Income Inequality Nationalism

Nationalism and populism are attributed to high income inequality.

Bosworth ‘19 Steven Bosworth is an Associate Professor in Economics at the University of Reading. His research explores how motivation influences cooperation. “Does Inequality Stoke Support for Nationalism?” Institute for global prosperity, July 3rd, 2019. https://www.rebuildingmacroeconomics.ac.uk/post/does-inequality-stoke-support-for-nationalism

It can have escaped no one that the political institutions in western democracies are going through a rough patch. Support for established political parties are in steady decline. Today, the Caravan and Motorhome Club has far more members than our three main political parties added together. The decline in support for mainstream political parties has coincided with the rise of nationalist and even far-right politicians in several countries. And of course, the UK has opened-up a yet-to-be resolved debate about how close it should be to its neighbours. These trends have caught most experts by surprise and prompted understandable worry about liberal democracy’s resilience. How can we understand this crisis of legitimacy? We can certainly identify responsibilities where governments have fallen short and are still falling short. The financial crisis ten years ago ended-up putting strains on the welfare state, while the actors responsible bore very few of the costs. The planet continues to warm, yet current policies will fail to avert catastrophic damage to life on earth if kept in place. But trying to understand recent politics in instrumental terms doesn’t get us very far. There’s an island in Chesapeake Bay which will disappear when sea levels rise, yet residents voted overwhelmingly for President Trump, a well-known climate change denier. Or take the Leave voter (2:20) who stands to lose his business if Brexit creates shipping delays. In my research project with Dennis Snower under the Social Macroeconomics hub of Rebuilding Macroeconomics, we argue that the disagreements paralysing our democracies are really about values and identities, and not regulations and trade agreements. Voters see themselves disconnected from those in power, and turn away from appeals to economic forecasts, especially if they don’t identify with the forecaster. Yet the forces driving the polarisation between a cosmopolitan elite and those “left behind” are far from irrational or impossible to predict. We must remember that, first and foremost, we are social creatures. The turn towards nationalism and populism may be in part a consequence of inequality of economic fortunes in modern societies. People who see their prospects “flat-line” may turn to other ways of finding meaning. Nationalism provides a notional community for which adherents can share in the nation’s successes. Political scientist Kyung Joon Han has observed that support for far-right parties tracks positively with income inequality among the poor and middle classes but negatively with inequality among the well-off. Our work looks to incorporate voter psychology into a political economy model where people select nationalist or cosmopolitan values based on the resulting consequences for their self-esteem. Placing more weight on individualist concerns confers pride if the individual compares favourably with others, but envy if they compare unfavourably. Placing more weight on nation-level identity replaces some of this psychological stress for those left behind.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- Universal Healthcare Solves Bioterrorism

Status quo preperation makes attacks likely.

Lyon ’21, Regan F Lyon, Department of Defense Analysis, Naval Postgraduate School, “Military Medicine,” Oxford Academic, 01, July, 2021, , @BC

Even though biological warfare is considered a “weapon of mass destruction” and is prohibited by a treaty drafted by the 1972 United Nations Biological Weapons Convention (BWC), not all adversaries adhere to these standards. Terrorist groups and covert operations have utilized biological weapons for small operations because the actors, by nature, are either non-eligible to ratify the treaty or would not do so if they could. Although there have been no intentional large-scale attacks, especially by adversarial nation states, this is not guaranteed to be the case in the future. The BWC does not prohibit ratified nations from having pathogens or toxins for peaceful purposes, such as the development of vaccines. After the natural outbreak of smallpox and its subsequent eradication accomplished by the World Health Organization in 1980, less virulent poxviruses have continued to be used in a variety of laboratories for research and development of vaccines for a variety of diseases. The original, more deadly strain of smallpox has been retained at two facilities in Russia and Atlanta. Because smallpox’s virology makes it an ideal biological weapon, the samples in Atlanta and Russia offer defense through researching countermeasures should an attack occur and simultaneously provide a repository from which a biological weapon can be acquired. “Deterrence” and “defense” are two concepts which are typically described in terms of nuclear warfare, but they can also be applied to national security from a biological attack. Deterrence is the ability to prevent an adversary from taking some action during peacetime. For biological warfare deterrence, vaccines and preventative medicine measures prevent susceptibility to a microbe. For a largely vaccinated and/or health-conscious population, the costs of production, storage, and dissemination of a bioweapon greatly outweighs the rare chance of the target contracting the disease. New Zealand’s robust public health measures, citizen compliance, and continued efforts to sustain a caseload under 20 since April is a strong deterrent for biological attack. Defense mechanisms decrease the effectiveness of the attack, putting a high cost-to-benefit burden on the adversary. A defense measure for bioterrorism would be an adequate medical treatment response to casualties of the bioweapon, decreasing mortality and the overall effectiveness of the weapon.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- Universal Healthcare Solves Bioterrorism

A better health care system would help combat bioterrorism.

Yao et al. 22 [Lulu Yao, Emergency Medicine, Institute of Disaster and Emergency Medicine, Tianjin University, China, Yongzhong Zhang, Epidemiology and Health Statistics, Institute of Disaster and Emergency Medicine, Tianjin University, China, Chao Zhao, Center for Biosafety Research and Strategy, Tianjin University, China, Feida Zhao, Institute of Disaster and Emergency Medicine, Tianjin University, China, Song Bai, Institute of Disaster and Emergency Medicine, Tianjin University, China, “The PRISMA 2020 Statement: A System Review of Hospital Preparedness for Bioterrorism Events,” National Library of Medicine, 12/05/22, ] WC

In this literature review, the authors screened 23 studies published between 2012 and 2022 that were highly relevant to hospital disaster preparedness, including both quantitative and qualitative studies on hospital preparedness. Based on the WHO Rapid Hospital Readiness Checklist, this study analyzed and summarized the relevant capability elements of hospital bioterrorism preparedness and discussed the role of key capabilities in hospital bioterrorism preparedness. The results show that a sound biological terrorism contingency plan should use existing resources, meet the demands of emergency coordination processes, play a key role in the effective response to the disaster, and assess hospital health facilities, as one of the most important factors of preparation. Another important consideration is the surge capacity of the hospital. Strengthening a hospital’s capacity in regard to patient management, human resources, material reserves, etc., has a positive effect on improving its coping capacity. This study found that current studies in the literature in this area mostly used questionnaires and lacked the methods, tools, or comprehensive indicators for a systematic review. Each country and organization has expanded indicators and methods that fit their cultural backgrounds, but these tools have not been used on a large scale. These evaluation indicators and tools need to be further developed after undergoing a systematic evaluation and expert discussions based on WHO standards and national conditions. The results of this study can be used as a reference standard for hospital preparation against bioterrorism and provide a basis for developing and designing hospital preparedness assessment indicators, thus helping hospitals respond to bioterrorism incidents more actively and effectively.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- AT: No Bioterrorism Impact

Social inequities must be considered in health emergency preparedness --- unequal coverage undermines community safety in the face of bioterror.

McKillop, Farberman, and Lieberman ‘23 (Matt McKillop, Rhea K. Farberman, Dara Alpert Lieberman, Senior Health Policy Researcher and Analyst, “Ready or Not: PROTECTING THE PUBLIC’S HEALTH FROM DISEASES, DISASTERS, AND BIOTERRORISM” Trust for America’s Health, March 15 2023, )-ERL

Priority Area 4: Build Resilient Communities and Promote Health Equity in Preparedness

Each new outbreak or disaster reiterates the urgency of addressing the social, economic, and structural reasons for health inequities that cause some populations to experience a disproportionate impact from disasters, receive fewer resources during the response, limit their access to healthcare, and take longer to recover. When the intersectionality of factors, such as homelessness, incarceration, disability, age, employment, LGBTQ+ status, and immigration status are taken into consideration, the inequities are compounded. The pandemic demonstrated the effectiveness of building partnerships between community-based organizations and leaders, governmental agencies, and community health and healthcare organizations. However, these partnerships will likely dissolve without sustained attention and funding.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- AT: No Bioterrorism Impact

The uninsured worsen bioterror, slowing identification and treatment of outbreaks.

Peterson ’14 (Kimberly Peterson, graduate degree in Homeland Security and Defense, “THE AFFORDABLE CARE ACT: A PRESCRIPTION FOR HOMELAND SECURITY PREPAREDNESS?” Naval Postgraduate School, October 30, 2014, )-ERL

Bioterror and the Health Care Surveillance System The initial identification of a bioterror attack requires a functional health care surveillance system. Unless the attacker(s) announces the specifics of the attack, or the country’s biosensors are activated by the biological weapon, it is likely we would only become aware of a biological attack via the health care system’s surveillance program. Hospitals, health care providers and clinical laboratories around the U.S. routinely report infectious disease diagnoses and food and water-borne illnesses to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The CDC manages the Emerging Infections Program (EIP) as part of its Division of Preparedness and Emerging Infections. The EIP is a network of 10 state health departments53 and their collaborators that include local health departments and health care providers, clinical laboratories, academic institutions, and other federal agencies. These institutions gather data on disease outbreaks and foodborne illnesses. The EIP compiles data and analyzes it. Once it spots clusters or identify outbreaks, it communicates and collaborates with state and local health care networks and regulatory agencies such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in an effort to trace the origin of the disease and find appropriate treatments.54 Strength of the health care surveillance system aside, if the sickened do not report for diagnosis and treatment, the entire system is rendered ineffective. And if the sickened merely wait longer to report for treatment because they lack health insurance, they are more likely to have poor health outcomes, which can worsen the overall effect of the outbreak.55 A perfect example would be the anthrax attack of 2001, which occurred only one week after the defining act of terrorism against America. With anthrax infection, early diagnosis and treatment are critical factors in determining whether the victim lives or dies.56 In the 2001 event known as “Amerithrax,”57 22 individuals were infected with the anthrax spores, five of whom died, after a still unconfirmed suspect58 sent the spores through the mail. Anthrax is treatable via antibiotics if correctly diagnosed early enough in the progression of the illness. In order to diagnose the disease, the stricken must present to a health care provider. Decades of research has shown a strong association between health insurance and access to health care.59 In other words, if people have health insurance, they are more likely to go to the doctor when they are ill. Conversely, a lack of health insurance equals worse health outcomes because patients wait longer to seek care and present at a later stage of illness.60 Anthrax is not contagious; a person sickened with anthrax cannot pass the disease to another person. If a bioattack involves a contagious disease, early identification and treatment are even more critical. In such a case we would be vulnerable to the initial infections as well as the ensuing spread. Without accessible health care, the lack of assessment, isolation and quarantine would allow the disease to spread unchecked. An example of how 48 million uninsured Americans create a homeland security gap would be a low-tech suicide attack, such as one where a terrorist self-infects with an Ebola virus.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- AT: No Bioterrorism Impact

The U.S. has no effective system to treat the uninsured population in the event of a bioterror attack.

McBride ‘20 (Dr. David McBride, research specialist and public historian, “Bioterrorism: The History of a Crisis in American Society,” Routledge, Volume 1, July 11, 2022)-ERL

After the anthrax attacks in 2001, officials seemed to advise members of the public to call their private doctor. What should an American do if be or she doesn't have a regular doctor or health insurance? Examining the number of minority individuals lacking health insurance in the United States, a national study found that roughly 11 percent of non-Hispanic whites were uninsured in 1999, compared with 33 percent of Hispanics and 21 percent of African Americans. Additionally, compared with 10 years ago fewer African American and Latino working adults are provided health insurance by their employers. QJ ] As noted by a Commission researcher, " [t]he nation's health care safety net has, by default, cared for many of the uninsured." However, as the number of uninsured grows, this safety net is being strained beyond endurance. tn.) In the event of a mass anthrax attack, the federal government, through the efforts of HHS, will respond by providing "appropriate antibiotics: from its stockpile to wherever they are needed." Furthermore, the government advises against asking one's doctor in advance for antibiotics, because these will be made available by the government when needed. In] Reiterating this point, the GAO states that the needed drugs will be provided: from a national pharmaceutical stockpile provided by the federal government and not via normal health insurance coverage. Additionally, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) policy is to vaccinate only those individuals who have been exposed to a contaminant, not the universal populace, regardless of the quantity of vaccine available, according to the GA0.(1_:! ] One HHS official states that HHS' policy of selective vaccination may change once enough vaccine becomes available. . 11. il Lastly, the distribution of pharmaceuticals and treatment of affected individuals is, apparently, a multilevel process including the federal, state, and local governments. At the federal level, HHS' Office of Emergency Preparedness (OEP) is developing the Metropolitan Medical Response Systems (MMRS). MMRS encompasses public contractual relationships permitting the use of “existing emergency response systems emergency management, medical and mental health providers, public health departments, law enforcement, fire departments, EMS and the National Guard to provide a unified response to a mass casualty event." To date, OEP has contractual agreements to develop MMRS with 97 municipalities. Furthering its distribution and treatment abilities, OEP also coordinates the National Disaster Medical System (NDMS), a group of more than 7,000 volunteer health and support professionals who can be deployed anywhere in the country to assist communities in which local response systems are overwhelmed or incapacitated. In the event of a biological attack, 44 Disaster Medical Assistance Teams (OMA Ts) consisting of these volunteers would be responsible for providing "on-site medical triage, patient care and transportation to medical facilities." In addition to OMA Ts, there are four National Medical Response Teams (NMRTs) that possess their own pharmaceuticals and the ability to detect biological contaminants, "decontaminate victims, provide medical care and remove victims from the scene." Three NMRTs respond nationally, while the fourth is permanently situated in Washington, D.C. [?!iJ At the state and local levels, the procedures for distribution of pharmaceuticals and treatment of affected individuals, as well as the general level of readiness, vary among localities. The state of Illinois currently appears to have the most organized system. Illinois has contracted with pharmaceutical packagers and distributors so that the drugs it receives from the national pharmaceutical stockpile can be redistributed into 1.5 million individual doses within 24 hours. It took the National Guard in Colorado several days to accomplish this feat during a trial run. To date, Illinois is the only state to have implemented this system.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- AT: No Bioterrorism Impact

Bioterrorism attack is coming and governments around the world are aware but still not doing enough --- conventions prove.

Jammi ‘21

Saaketh, Damodaram Sanjivayya National Law University, “Biological Warfare and Bioterrorism – Global Perspective and Need for Reforms in Legislation”, Delhi Metropolitan Education. @SL

The public is unaware of the biological programs conducted by nations during World Wars I and II. After World War II, hundreds of news articles were published about the disease outbreaks caused by foreign entities armed with biological weapons. It is quite evident that the Geneva Protocol is not effective enough to control the biological programs carried out by countries. Disarmament of both chemical weapons and biological weapons were addressed together shortly after the Second World War. Due to various reasons the Disarmament talks were incomplete. After the states finalized the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in 1968, the United Kingdom pushed an initiative to make a separate disarmament discussion for biological weapons. The BWC was negotiated in Geneva, Switzerland from 1969 and continued for 2 years by the Eighteen Nation Committee of Disarmament. On 16th December 1971, the Convention was proposed by the United Nations General Assembly after the agreement between US and the Soviet Union to merge their 2 separate drafts into one. After the ratification of 22 governments, including the depositaries of the Convention, the Convention would have to come into force. After the depositing of the ratification, the Convention entered into force on 26th March 1975.With enormous concerns raised by the public for a ban on biological weapons due to its unpredictable nature, the Biological Weapons Convention came into force with the hope that it will control the biological weapons in a better way than its predecessor. “Convention on the prohibition of the development, production, and stockpiling of bacteriological and toxin weapons and on their destruction” shortly called the bioweapons Convention. The Treaty mainly deals with the prohibition of the development, production, and stockpiling of specific pathogens or toxins. The Convention required states to not develop, stockpile, acquire any types of biological warfare, and also required to discard said biological weapons or convert them into peaceful uses. Transfer of biological warfare technology and expertise is also prohibited in this Treaty. The Convention further required parties to the BWC to destroy stockpiles and delivery systems in 9 months of ratifying the Treaty along with an undertaking from the states to ensure necessary precautions to prevent stockpiling and producing and acquiring biological weapons. BWC doesn’t provide firm guidelines for inspections and control of disarming, adding to that there are no specific set of guidelines for law enforcement and hot to deal violations. The definition of “defensive research” and the quantities of pathogens necessary for the research. In case of any violations, the alleged violations need to be submitted to the UN security council, which will initiate an investigation, but the permanent member’s veto right will make this provision inefficient. The BWC mainly concerned on the biological weapons programs conducted by countries but there are no specific set of guidelines to control the biological weapons programs conducted by terrorist organizations as terrorism was not a pressing issue at the times of 1970’s, However there is no notable changes in the Convention even after many experts warned the possibility of bioweapon attack by terrorist organizations.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Bioterrorism Advantage › 2AC --- Single Payer Solves Bioterror

Access to care acts as an active deterrent to potential bioterror attacks

Kosal 14 – Margaret E. Kosal, PhD, Georgia Institute of Technology, Sam Nunn School of International Affairs (“A new role for public health in bioterrorism deterrence”. December 10th, )

This commentary will explore the creation of new relationships between deterrence, infectious disease, and public health to reduce the threat of biological terrorism and increase international security. Examining the global spread of re-emerging infectious disease, such as the re-emergence of polio from northern Nigeria, offers a novel case study for thinking about how to deter potential bioterrorists who seek to use infectious disease. Polio outbreaks have more directly affected the developing world compared to the US or other nations with robust public health sectors. This example suggests that a bioterrorist attack would also be more devastating for developing countries in low-resource settings compared to the western world. Credibly, communicating this may offer a new approach to deterring bioterrorism by foreign actors. Although a robust public health sector has long been noted to reduce the vulnerability to a bioterrorism attack, actively promoting the strength of US public health can also serve as a powerful deterrent in its own right. The issue of terrorist groups utilizing biological weapons against other states is a mounting concern, yet little deterrence research in the field of political science addresses methods of dealing with the threat of bioterrorism. Thus, creating new conversations among the life sciences, public health, and political science can lead to new perspectives on deterring bioterrorism. The issue of bioterrorism deterrence, if addressed, has been often added or subsumed under the auspices of deterrence strategies associated with nuclear weapons. In the second half of the twentieth century, nuclear deterrence dominated geopolitics and national security strategies. At its height, the threat of mutually assured destruction (MAD) existed in which both superpowers possessed arsenals with second-strike capabilities, i.e., the ability to respond to a first nuclear strike on land via use of nearly undetectable submarine-launched ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads. These historical approaches, however, undermine and oversimplify the distinct challenges of deterring bioterrorism. One such method attempted is focusing on pathogen security, or securing and denying access to the materials necessary to develop biological weapons (i.e., deterrence by denial). Based on the nuclear non-proliferation model, pathogen security strives to control the materials, equipment, and personnel involved with production and use of biological agents. With nuclear weapons, controlling fissile materials proved successful because of key characteristics of the critical materials: fissile material is man-made and can be tracked. Those same characteristics that make nuclear weapons easier to track are those that make biological weapons material difficult to monitor. These characteristics include the presence of biological agents in nature, lower production costs, increased diversity of materials that could be used in bioweapons attacks, and multiple legitimate uses for biological materials. These differing features have not always been fully considered by policy-makers (1). Rather than focusing solely on securing biological materials and laboratories from misuse, other recommendations and strategies that the US has pursued include prevention measures such as biosurveillance, global laboratory and research cooperation, research and development of diagnostics and countermeasures,international stockpiles of effective medical countermeasures, and increased response and mitigation capabilities (2–6). These approaches aim to reduce consequences of an attack, afford earlier detection, and reduce vulnerability; they do not address the challenge of deterring use and reducing motivation directly, however. To date, discussions about public health and deterrence have focused on measures such as regular vaccinations; access to timely medical care to treat infected, isolate suspected infected, and mitigate the spread of disease; confidence in the professional nature of health providers, etc. These are largely passive, defensive deterrence measures, in that they demonstrate credible capacity by a state to respond and mitigate the consequences of an attack (post-exposure) or reduce vulnerability to an attack by making it ineffective (preexposure) (7–9). Both approaches mentioned thus far, pathogen security and a defensive approach to terrorism, which ultimately aim to decrease vulnerability by fortifying civilian populations, are examples of deterrence by denial adapted from the realm of nuclear deterrence. In contrast to these passive approaches, active deterrence strategies have not been explored. Active deterrence is actions and policies preventing a specific opponent from doing something they may wish to do. Traditionally, robust active deterrence has involved the application of expressive force to change the policy or character of the target government or group (10). Forces and policies are used to send a political message. In contrast to passive strategies, active deterrence is more dynamic and may incorporate escalating threats in response to an adversary. What this would look like at the nexus of international security and public health is largely an unexplored area of study or policy. Therefore, there are limited models for thinking about deterrence that have been developed exclusively for bioterrorism. As a consequence, the role of a robust public health system for twenty- first century active deterrence remains to be explored. There has not been a substantive consideration of robust public health system as a strategic asset in a more active deterrence role.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Solvency › 2AC --- Universal Healthcare Solvency

Medicaid redistributes wealth by allowing more people to put less money into healthcare and more into other assets.

Jackson et al. 21 (Margot Jackson, Associate Professor of Society, “The Effects of State-Level Medicaid Coverage on Family Wealth”, RSF, August 2021, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10284574/) -JCG

Medicaid access could be associated with family wealth in several ways. First, increased coverage may be positively associated with households’ wealth by freeing up funds that would otherwise be used for medical expenses, better enabling families to save money or purchase assets. This possibility may have become more likely after the OBRA86 expansion, when the vast majority of states ended their previous use of asset testing for determining Medicaid eligibility. Previously, Medicaid eligibility for pregnant women and infants had been tied to their AFDC eligibility, which involved asset testing to qualify. The asset test allowed “a home of any value, an automobile worth up to $1,500, and any other real or personal property essential for day-to-day living worth up to $1,000” (Government Accountability Office 1987, 18). Income and asset limits for Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Medicaid through SSI eligibility, and those for the medically needy program were higher (Government Accountability Office 1987). In addition to expanding access based on income limits, OBRA86 also provided states with options to simplify the Medicaid eligibility process for pregnant women and infants. For example, states shortened application forms, out-stationed eligibility workers at provider sites, and expedited maternity-related applications (National Governors’ Association 1990, 3). States also dropped the asset test required for Medicaid eligibility among pregnant women and infants. In 1990, “44 states no longer review clients’ assets when determining eligibility for pregnant women and children” (National Governors’ Association 1990, 3). The seven states that retained the asset test were California, Colorado, Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, North Dakota, and Texas. Additional states dropped the test over time: Colorado and Missouri by July 1990 and Illinois and Texas by July 1991. Beginning in 1992, some states (Nevada, Utah, and Arkansas) began reinstating asset tests for Medicaid eligibility among pregnant women or children (National Governors’ Association 1992).

The elimination of asset testing as a condition for Medicaid enrollment among pregnant women and young children increased the possibility for participating families to build wealth. Greater access to Medicaid for low- and middle-income families may reduce the amount these families spend on out-of-pocket medical expenses, private insurance premiums, expensive copayments, or other directly purchased services. Although many pregnant women and young children who became eligible for Medicaid with the expansions were uninsured, more than a third were covered under private insurance plans (Cutler and Gruber 1996; Dubay and Kenney 1997), which typically have higher out-of-pocket costs for premiums and copayments. The ability to substitute public insurance for private insurance may therefore free up economic resources for some families, enabling them to save money or to purchase assets such as a home.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
2AC Blocks › 2AC Solvency › 2AC --- Universal Healthcare Solvency

Medicare flattens inequality by effectively redistributing resources.

Chilkoti & Ordway 17 (Avantika Chilkoti & Denise-Marie Ordway, Journalist and Author, "How Medicaid and Medicare influence income inequality,” Harvard Kennedy School, March 16 2017, https://journalistsresource.org/economics/medicaid-medicare-income-inequality-insurance-poor/)-JCG

While adding the value of Medicare and Medicaid to family income does not actually put more money into the pockets of the poor and elderly, it does change overall income calculations, resulting in a lower 90-10 ratio. An analysis of data from 2012 suggests that including the value of Medicare and Medicaid reduces the ratio by approximately 30 percent.

Adding the value of employer-provided insurance to personal income increases the 90-10 ratio — on paper. That increase suggests a wider gap between the poor and the wealthy and a higher level of income inequality.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › Advantage 3 – Solvency

Universal healthcare overcomes the fundamental inefficiencies of privatized health insurance and guarantees universal coverage at lower cost.

Randall Wray ’17, professor of economics at Bard College, taught at the University of Missouri–Kansas City from 1999 to 2016 and at the University of Denver from 1987 to 1999, and has been a visiting professor at the Universities of Paris and Rome (La Sapienza), recently completed a Fulbright Specialist Grant at the Tallinn University of Technology in Estonia, “WHY THE COMPULSIVE SHIFT TO SINGLE PAYER? BECAUSE HEALTHCARE IS NOT INSURABLE,” Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, pgs. 2-4,

Our peers use a wide variety of methods of provisioning and paying for healthcare, ranging from full-on “socialization” with government ownership of the hospitals to market-based private ownership of medical practices. Many use a single-payer system (whether provisioning of healthcare is nationalized or privatized), with government covering the costs, while some use private insurers. What is unique about the United States is that we rely so extensively on private for-profit insurers—in other countries that allow participation by private insurers, these are run more like heavily regulated, not-for-profit charities. Foreign health insurance plans largely exist to pay bills and improve health, not to make a profit (Reid 2010). Not coincidentally, the United States is also the only wealthy nation with such a large segment of its population still lacking adequate health coverage—even after Obamacare.

Alongside its expansion of Medicaid, Obamacare doubled down on the use of private insurers by requiring all individuals to purchase insurance, with rising tax penalties assessed on those who do not. In return, Obamacare offers two big “carrots”: government subsidies of premiums for lower-income people and some regulation of private insurers who choose to participate—most importantly, requirements for coverage of preexisting conditions. The success of Obamacare relies on providing insurers with a diversified pool of enrollees, including, most importantly, many young, healthy people. The idea is that insurers would overcharge the healthy in order to subsidize the unhealthy with preexisting conditions. Obamacare’s “stick” is the penalty on individuals who opt out—many of whom are those healthy, young people.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › Advantage 3 – Solvency

Empirical evidence proves single-payer is feasible, cost-effective, and easily implementable.

Steffie Woolhandler and David Himmelstein ’17, *Woolhandler: MD, MPH, distinguished professor of public health and health policy at the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College and an adjunct clinical professor at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and lecturer in medicine at Harvard Medical School, where she formerly co-directed the general internal medicine internship program, **Himmelstein: MD, distinguished professor of public health and health policy in the CUNY School of Public Health at Hunter College, an adjunct clinical professor at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, and a lecturer at Harvard Medical School, “Single-Payer Reform: The Only Way to Fulfill the President's Pledge of More Coverage, Better Benefits, and Lower Costs,” Annals of Internal Medicine 166:8,

Although Republicans' proposals seem unlikely to achieve President Trump's triple aim (more coverage, better benefits, and lower costs), single-payer reform could. Such reform would replace the current welter of insurance plans with a single, public plan covering everyone for all medically necessary care—in essence, an expanded and upgraded version of the traditional Medicare program (that is, not Medicare Advantage). The economic case for single-payer reform is compelling. Private insurers' overhead currently averages 12.4% versus 2.2% in traditional Medicare (2). Reducing overhead to Medicare's level would save approximately $220 billion this year (Table) (3). Single-payer reform could also sharply reduce billing and paperwork costs for physicians, hospitals, and other providers. For example, by paying hospitals lump-sum operating budgets rather than forcing them to bill per patient, Scotland and Canada have held hospital administrative costs to approximately 12% of their revenue versus 25.3% in the United States (4). Simplified, uniform billing procedures could reduce the money and time that physicians spend on billing-related documentation. All told, we estimate that single-payer reform could save approximately $504 billion annually on bureaucracy (Table). Any such estimate is imprecise; however, this figure is in line with Pozen and Cutler's estimate ($383 billion, updated to reflect health care inflation) (5), which excludes potential savings for providers other than physicians and hospitals. Additional savings could come from adopting the negotiating strategies that most nations with national health insurance use, which pay approximately one half what we do for prescription drugs. Of course, single-payer reform would bring added costs as well as savings. Full coverage would (and should) boost use for the 26 million persons in the United States who remain uninsured despite the ACA. And plugging the gaps in existing coverage (abolishing copayments and deductibles, covering such services as dental and long-term care that many policies exclude, and bringing Medicaid fees up to par) would further increase clinical expenditures. Studies provide imperfect guidance on the probable magnitude of changes in use under single-payer reform. Microlevel experiments indicate that when a few persons in a community gain full coverage, their use surges (6). But when many persons gain coverage, the fixed supply of physicians and hospitals constrains community-wide increases in use. For example, when Canada rolled out its single-payer program, the total number of physician visits changed little; increased visits for poorer, sicker patients were offset by small declines in visits for healthier, more affluent persons (7). Despite dire predictions of patient pileups, Medicare and Medicaid's start-up in 1966 similarly shifted care toward the poor but caused no net increase in use (8). Despite some uncertainties, analysts from government agencies and prominent consulting firms have concluded that administrative and drug savings would fully offset increased use, allowing universal, comprehensive coverage within the current health care budgetary envelope (9). International experience with single-payer reform provides further reassurance. It has been thoroughly vetted in Canada and other nations where access is better, costs are lower, and quality is similar to that in the United States. The potential health benefits from single-payer reform are more important than the economic ones. Being uninsured has mortal consequences. Covering the 26 million persons in the United States who are currently uninsured would probably save tens of thousands of lives annually. And underinsurance now endangers many more by, for example, delaying persons from seeking care for myocardial infarction or causing patients to skimp on cardiac or asthma medications. Single-payer reform would also free patients from the confines of narrow provider networks and lift the financial threat of illness, a frequent contributor to bankruptcy and the most common cause of serious credit problems.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › Advantage 2 – Inequality

Nationalistic wars go nuclear.

Andrew Lichterman, 2-2-2023, "Nuclear Weapons and Nationalism: An Incendiary Mix," Portside, [Andrew Lichterman is a policy analyst and lawyer with the Oakland, California-based Western States Legal Foundation.]

Seventy-seven years ago, the United Nations General Assembly passed its first resolution. The subject the governments represented there thought important enough to be first on their agenda was the establishment of a commission to develop proposals for the control of atomic energy and “for the elimination from national armaments of atomic weapons and of all other major weapons adaptable to mass destruction.” In a joint statement proposing the Commission, the three governments that had participated in the development of the atomic bomb, the United States, Great Britain, and Canada, stressed that the tasks of controlling atomic energy and eliminating the threat of nuclear weapons and other weapons of mass destruction could not be achieved by monitoring and control measures alone. “No system of safeguards that can be devised,” they wrote, “will of itself provide an effective guarantee against the production of atomic weapons by a nation bent on aggression.” To end the threat posed by rapidly developing technologies that could yield ever more destructive weapons, they emphasized that a far more ambitious goal must be sought: “Faced with the terrible realities of the application of science to destruction, every nation will realize more urgently than before the overwhelming need to maintain the rule of law among nations and to banish the scourge of war from the earth.” A number of the most trenchant commentators of the early atomic age argued that the inquiry must go deeper, focusing not only on the horrific effects but on the causes of modern war. In 1946, journalist and disarmament advocate Norman Cousins wrote, “Let us have a National Concentration Week, during which we can ponder not only the implications of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, moral and political but the problem of competitive national sovereignty in an atomic age.” A year later, the Emergency Committee of Atomic Scientists, which included Albert Einstein and several of the physicists who had participated in developing the atomic bomb, warned that “Through the release of atomic energy, our generation has brought into the world the most revolutionary force since prehistoric man's discovery of fire. This basic power of the universe cannot be fitted into the outmoded concept of narrow nationalisms.” These insights were clear to many in the immediate aftermath of a catastrophe brought on by competing nationalisms. World War II was a global conflagration of industrialized warfare and genocidal extermination, with the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki only being the culmination. The United Nations and the broader system of international organizations constructed at the close of World War II was crafted to bring competing nationalisms under control and also to manage the economic forces that had played a central role in driving the underlying conflicts that had led to war. With the rapid onset of the Cold War in the late 1940s, the focus on the dangers posed by nationalisms in the atomic age faded into the background. The Cold War brought a different kind of competition, a global confrontation between competing political and economic systems with different dynamics and potential flashpoints. The collapse of the Soviet Union brought both the Cold War political confrontation and the Cold War arms race to a stunning close. With the Cold War confrontation seen as the reason for the existence of vast nuclear arsenals and the risk of nuclear war, mass movements for nuclear disarmament disappeared. And in the first two decades after the fall of the Berlin Wall, the dangers of competitive nationalisms leading to conflict among nuclear-armed states foreseen by Cousins and the atomic scientists were not immediately apparent. One of the two most powerful states had collapsed and was significantly diminished geographically, economically, and militarily. China’s emergence as a first-rank economic power still lay in the future. The other leading states were preoccupied with the project of integrating much of the Eurasian continent into the global neoliberal circuit of trade and investment. And yet, despite these decades of momentous change, nuclear arsenals and the institutions that sustain them carried on, largely without sustained debate by the government or publics. Although their magnitude was reduced in comparison to immense Cold War stockpiles, enough nuclear weapons remain to inflict irreparable harm on humanity and the ecosystems that sustain us. At the same time, the threat of militant nationalism was slowly growing once more to the point where all of the world’s nuclear-armed countries have authoritarian nationalist parties in power or exercising significant influence in their politics. Today we find ourselves confronted once more by the extreme danger that many believed had been safely consigned to the past: war driven by identity-based nationalism and involving the world’s most powerful states. And this time around, as prophetic voices warned at the dawn of the nuclear age, the aggressor is nuclear armed. In a world bristling with high-tech weapons of all kinds, nuclear weapons are unlikely to be eliminated until the forces driving military competition among nuclear-armed countries are eliminated. Meaningful progress towards disarmament will require social movements broad and deep enough to address the causes of high-tech militarism and war. Movements of this kind also will be needed to stave off catastrophic wars in the near term. These movements will need to bring together work for peace and disarmament with the disparate strands of work against environmental breakdown, polarization of wealth and economic injustice, erosion of democracy, and the targeting of migrants, national minorities, and other vulnerable people. The connections between these issues will have to be understood at the level of their common causes in a global economy whose central dynamic for centuries has been endless material growth driven by ruthless competition among authoritarian organizations of ever-increasing size and power. To avoid catastrophe, we will need new movements and politics broad and deep enough to transform our economy, our technology, and how we conceive “the state” and its purposes. Nuclear disarmament will come only through the vehicle of such movements, such as politics. This same path also is our best hope for reducing the risk of war.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › Advantage 2 – Inequality

Growing economic inequality drives diversionary nationalism and makes war inevitable.

Solt ’11 Frederick Solt is Assistant Professor of Political Science and Sociology at Southern Illinois University, “Diversionary Nationalism: Economic Inequality and the Formation of National Pride” The University of Chicago Press, August 3rd, 2011. https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/10.1017/s002238161100048x.pdf

How can the rise of nationalist populism in contemporary Western societies in the context of increasing socioeconomic inequality be explained, then? I will suggest here a tentative and succinct answer on the basis of the preceding theo- retical argument. The concept of 'nationalist populism' (or, for short, just 'populism') is used here to refer to the political ideas propagated by such parties as the Front Na- tional in France, the AfD in Germany, the FPÖ in Austria, the UKIP in Britain, the PVV in the Netherlands, the Lega Nord in Italy as well as the branch of the Republican Party embodied by the new president of the United States. Popu- lism in these different manifestations claims to represent the will of 'the peo- ple' or 'the nation' in opposition to a political and cultural 'elite' that sets itself apart from the large majority, serves its own interests to the detriment of the common good, and favours outsider groups of foreigners, immigrants, and ethnic and racial minorities. Populist leaders claim to voice the opinions of the people, defined as united and indivisible; therefore, their opponents can only be enemies of the people. In its stress on national unity and homogeneity, popu- lism is anti-liberal and anti-pluralistic (cf. Mudde 2007; Müller 2016). Two kinds of social scientific explanations for the growing attraction of populism in recent years have been advanced: a cultural explanation, which HSR 42 (2017) 4 | 35 This content downloaded from 205.118.22.70 on Thu, 13 Jul 2023 03:23:33 +00:00 All use subject to https: views populism's popularity as a backlash, a reaction against large cultural transformations in Western societies during the past few decades in the direc- tion of secularization, individualism, permissiveness, cosmopolitanism, and gender equality; and an economic or materialistic explanation, which views the movement primarily as a response to increasing relative deprivation and eco- nomic insecurity (Inglehart and Norris 2016). While both explanations find a degree of support in empirical research, they are, at best, only partial, even if combined. The cultural thesis cannot explain why populist movements of the kind and the size that we see today in Western societies, did not arise already in the 1960s and subsequent decades, when the cultural transformations that populism is supposed to be a reaction against were particularly strong. Moreover, not all populist parties distinguish themselves by an outspoken and comprehen- sive cultural conservatism. While the Christian Right, with its stress on family values and strict sexual morality, is a feeding ground and supporter of right- wing populism in the United States, this is not, or much less, the case in West- ern Europe. Thus, the Dutch populist leader Geert Wilders (PVV) stresses the national values of gender equality and sexual freedom against Islamic intoler- ance, traditionalism, and oppression of women (cf. Brubaker 2017). The economic explanation falls short as it does not make clear why material deprivation, economic insecurity, and increasing inequality would give rise to nationalist populism, and why these tendencies did not lead to more support for, and radicalisation of, established socialist or social-democratic parties (but rather to the contrary), to a renewed intensification of class conflicts, and to mass protests against the growing power and wealth of the corporate rich. True, in recent years there have been, in various countries, waves of radical, anti- capitalist opposition to growing inequality (such as the Occupy movement that started in New York in 2011), but these movements were mainly articulated and supported by intellectuals and high-educated young people with uncertain career prospects. Among the supporters of anti-immigration populist parties and politicians, on the other hand, people with lower educational qualifications and in economically vulnerable positions (manual workers, low-paid service workers, small entrepreneurs) are overrepresented (Inglehart and Norris 2016). In the broader explanation that I propose here, the recent rise of nationalist populism in Western societies is viewed as a manifestation of habitus changes that are related to transformations in the class structure: processes in which the growth of class inequalities combines with the blurring of class boundaries and the weakening of class identities. With the shrinking of the industrial working class since the 1970s, the decline of labour unions (in membership and bargain- ing power), the shift toward a postindustrial service economy and the increas- ing flexibilisation of work relations, 'class' has largely lost its significance as a basis of group identification and political outlook. Instead, and connected with these economic changes, an ethos of meritocratic individualism, which legiti- mates economic inequality as the result of fair competition on the basis of HSR 42 (2017) 4 | 36 This content downloaded from 205.118.22.70 on Thu, 13 Jul 2023 03:23:33 +00:00 All use subject to https: individual achievements and merits, has become more dominant. In this ideol- ogy, high incomes and large private fortunes reflect outstanding achievements by successful individuals rather than unjust social arrangements. With the power shift in favour of the owners and managers of transnational firms, these members of the economic elite enlarged not only their economic capital, but also their symbolic capital; popular media gave them increasing publicity as models of success to be followed; and the inclination to upwards identification with this economic elite among the less well-to-do grew stronger. Changes in power-interdependence relations on national and international levels also had an impact on the ideological orientations of politicians and political parties. Neo-liberalism, as it came to be called, with its core idea that government regulation of the economy should be kept to a minimum and that free markets serve the general interest, became the dominant creed. This ex- tended to parties that traditionally claimed to serve the interests of the under- privileged, such as Britain's Labour Party, the Social Democratic parties on the European continent and the Democratic Party in the USA, which accepted and instigated policies of privatization, deregulation, lower tax rates on profits and high incomes, and cuts in social expenditures (cf. Bourdieu 1999, 2001). What- ever one may think of this reorientation, its effect was that these parties could hardly function anymore as objects of identification for members of lower and middle strata, or canalize and articulate their grievances. Progressive parties came to align with 'identity movements' of women, gays, and ethnic and racial minorities, which had a strong base at universities and attracted high-educated people in particular. This only contributed to the growing distance between these parties and non-minority members of lower strata. Terms like leftist, progressive and (in the American discourse) liberal came to be associated in- creasingly with high-educated, intellectual, and elitist. At the same time, non-minority members of middle and lower classes in Western societies - comprising manual workers, small entrepreneurs, and service workers with low or intermediate educational qualifications - experi- enced material deprivations and status degradation, which fuelled grievances and resentment. They underwent, we may say, a fourfold relative loss. First, as citizens of rich nation-states they lost part of their privileged position with respect to the inhabitants of non-Western, poorer countries. Second, within their own societies their economic position worsened in comparison to wealthy and high-income groups. Third, with the strong expansion of formal education and the overall upgrading of educational requirements they lost ground - in terms of numbers, economic position, and social status - in relation to the growing stratum of high-educated professionals. And fourth, their position weakened in relation to people who are not counted as belonging to the ethnic- national majority, the overlapping (but not identical) categories of recent im- migrants and their offspring, and ethnic and racial minorities. Whereas the first and the fourth developments are connected with tendencies of decreasing ine- HSR 42 (2017) 4 | 37 This content downloaded from 205.118.22.70 on Thu, 13 Jul 2023 03:23:33 +00:00 All use subject to https: quality on a global scale, the second and the third ones reflect shifts of increas- ing inequality within national societies. The fourth development in particular is the feeding ground and primary mo- tive of nationalist populism. Mass immigration from poorer to richer countries as part of wider processes of globalization contributed to the dissolution of class identities, the blurring of class lines and the growth of class inequalities within the richer countries. Whereas members of upper and upper-middle strata can easily distinguish themselves from the large majority of these immigrants, this is more difficult for the less privileged, whose class position is more simi- lar to that of most immigrants. These minority groups became an easy target for grievances and antagonist sentiments, as they were defined as the others who threaten 'our' jobs and incomes, material security, physical safety, and ways of living. Antagonism is reinforced by resistance to 'integration' among groups of immigrants, who often remain strongly attached to their own ethnic group and country of origin, and sometimes embrace a militant version of Islam that de- fines itself as fundamentally anti-Western. This is a form of counter- stigmatisation that only contributes to negative stigmatisation on the part of the native population. This downward negative targeting of outsider groups is combined with the upward negative targeting of the (political and cultural) 'elite,' who are at- tacked for their supposed readiness to allow the outsiders to come in, to protect them and give them special advantages. Populist leaders try to win votes by promising to do away with this elite and 'give the country back to the people.' Among their followers, distrust toward politics and politicians often goes hand in hand with high trust in the new leader, anti-elitism with admiration for the strong man. The recent rise of nationalist populism reflects not only a change, but also continuity in habitus formation; or, to put it differently, habitus change builds on previous habitus formation that is connected with long-term social devel- opments. The ethnic or nativist nationalism that is at the core of present-day populism is a continuation of national we-feelings that spread in the course of the nineteenth and twentieth century in tandem with the intensification of inter- dependencies on the national level (cf. Gellner 1983; Elias 2013 [1989], 156- 68; Wilterdink 1993). Immigration and growing ethnic diversity have kindled these feelings and given them a more nativist character, in which sharp symbol- ic boundaries are drawn between the national we-group, defined in cultural, religious, ethnic and sometimes racial terms, and the non-native outsiders. This nationalism is now turned against 'the elite,' which is accused of abandoning the national values and neglecting the common national interests. Nationalist feelings are also strengthened by a perceived loss of national power and autonomy in relation to other nation-states. In Europe, the main culprit is the European Union, regarded by populist parties as an elitist project directed against the national interests. In the United States, the fear of losing HSR 42 (2017) 4 ļ 38 This content downloaded from 205.118.22.70 on Thu, 13 Jul 2023 03:23:33 +00:00 All use subject to https: global dominance has provoked similar reactions. In both Europe and the United States, populism aims at the restoration of national power, glory, and autonomy by retreating from organized international cooperation - which may have the paradoxical effect that the nation's power and international status actually weaken. There are, of course, important variations in the nature of populism and its social origins between countries and regions. The USA differs from Western European countries not only in its (still) hegemonic position in the world and the relatively strong impact of strict Christian religiosity within the country, but also in the long history of immigration, the strong cultural tradition of merito- cratic individualism ('the American dream'), and the legacy of racism and ethnic-racial dividedness - interconnected features that in turn may explain why the increase of socioeconomic inequality has been stronger there than in Western Europe (Wilterdink 2016), and why there is more upward identifica- tion with the wealthy entrepreneurial and managerial class and a more wide- spread popular aversion to government regulation and welfare state provisions. In several of these respects, however, Western European societies have become more similar to the USA in the past few decades. In spite of all the country-specific differences, nationalist populism in its various manifestations has common features and backgrounds. With the help of the theories of Elias and Bourdieu, we can understand its rise as manifestations of habitus changes that are rooted in transformations in power-interdependence relations and class structures on national and international levels. Present-day populism in Western societies, we may say, is a flawed revolt against rising socio-economic inequality and functional de-democratisation. Flawed, because it rests on illusions of national homogeneity and autonomy, because it is not primarily directed against the main driving forces and central actors of rising inequality, and because, if successful, it will not reverse tendencies of de- democratisation but rather reinforce them - most directly by excluding minori- ties. However, the current popularity of nationalist populism points to serious problems, for which no easy solutions are available.

2023 CNDI Affirmative
AFF › 1AC › Advantage 2 – Inequality

Income inequality is growing now.

Bernard Sanders 9-2-2022

["The US has a ruling class – and Americans must stand up to it," https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/02/the-us-has-a-ruling-class-and-americans-must-stand-up-to-it]

Let’s be clear. The most important economic and political issues facing this country are the extraordinary levels of income and wealth inequality, the rapidly growing concentration of ownership, the long-term decline of the American middle class and the evolution of this country into oligarchy. We know how important these issues are because our ruling class works overtime to prevent them from being seriously discussed. They are barely mentioned in the halls of Congress, where most members are dependent on the campaign contributions of the wealthy and their Super Pacs. They are not much discussed in the corporate media, in which a handful of conglomerates determine what we see, hear and discuss. So what’s going on? We now have more income and wealth inequality than at any time in the last hundred years. In the year 2022, three multibillionaires own more wealth than the bottom half of American society – 160 million Americans. Today, 45% of all new income goes to the top 1%, and CEOs of large corporations make a record-breaking 350 times what their workers earn. Meanwhile, as the very rich become much richer, working families continue to struggle. Unbelievably, despite huge increases in worker productivity, wages (accounting for real inflation) are lower today than they were almost 50 years ago. When I was a kid growing up, most families were able to be supported by one breadwinner. Now an overwhelming majority of households need two paychecks to survive. Today, half of our people live paycheck to paycheck and millions struggle on starvation wages. Despite a lifetime of work, half of older Americans have no savings and no idea how they will ever be able to retire with dignity, while 55% of seniors are trying to survive on an income of less than $25,000 a year. Since 1975, there has been a massive redistribution of wealth in America that has gone in exactly the wrong direction. Over the past 47 years, according to the Rand Corporation, $50tn in wealth has been redistributed from the bottom 90% of American society to the top 1%, primarily because a growing percentage of corporate profits has been flowing into the stock portfolios of the wealthy and the powerful. During this terrible pandemic, when thousands of essential workers died doing their jobs, some 700 billionaires in America became nearly $2tn richer. Today, while the working class falls further behind, multibillionaires like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos and Richard Branson are off taking joyrides on rocket ships to outer space, buying $500m super-yachts and living in mansions with 25 bathrooms. Disgracefully, we now have the highest rate of childhood poverty of almost any developed nation on Earth and millions of kids, disproportionately Black and brown, face food insecurity. While psychologists tell us that the first four years are the most important for human development, our childcare system is largely dysfunctional – with an inadequate number of slots, outrageously high costs and pathetically low wages for staff. We remain the only major country without paid family and medical leave. In terms of higher education, we should remember that 50 years ago tuition was free or virtually free in major public universities throughout the country. Today, higher education is unaffordable for millions of young people. There are now some 45 million Americans struggling with student debt. Today over 70 million Americans are uninsured or underinsured and millions more are finding it hard to pay for the rising cost of healthcare and prescription drugs, which are more expensive here than anywhere else in the world. The cost of housing is also soaring. Not only are some 600,000 Americans homeless, but nearly 18m households are spending 50% or more of their limited incomes on housing. It’s not just income and wealth inequality that is plaguing our nation. It is the maldistribution of economic and political power. Today we have more concentration of ownership than at any time in the modern history of this country. In sector after sector a handful of giant corporations control what is produced and how much we pay for it. Unbelievably, just three Wall Street firms (Blackrock, Vanguard and State Street) control assets of over $20tn and are the major stockholders in 96% of S&P 500 companies. In terms of media, some eight multinational media conglomerates control what we see, hear and read. In terms of political power, the situation is the same. A small number of billionaires and CEOs, through their Super Pacs, dark money and campaign contributions, play a huge role in determining who gets elected and who gets defeated. There are now an increasing number of campaigns in which Super Pacs actually spend more money on campaigns than the candidates, who become the puppets to their big money puppeteers. In the 2022 Democratic primaries, billionaires spent tens of millions trying to defeat progressive candidates who were standing up for working families. Dr Martin Luther King Jr was right when he said: “We must recognize that we can’t solve our problem now until there is a radical redistribution of economic and political power” in America. That statement is even more true today. Let us have the courage to stand together and fight back against corporate greed. Let us fight back against massive income and wealth inequality. Let us fight back against a corrupt political system. Let us stand together and finally create an economy and a government that works for all, not just the 1%.