Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Cap Unsustainable

Cap unsustainable – targets global south and decreases wage labor

Bader & Bieri 23 – [Christoph Bader and Sabin Bieri, both Drs., Centre for Development and Environment (CDE), University of Bern, Switzerland, “Transitioning to Reduced Inequalities: ‘A World Drifting Apart: Challenges and Possibilities of Transitioning to a More Equitable Planet,’” Transitioning to Sustainables Series, vol 10, MDPI, 2/9/23, doi:10.3390/books978-3-03921-161-6] /jsam

Globalization unfolds on the basis of a specific institutional architecture that systematically creates opportunities for economic expansion, thereby transgressing political borders. Expanding global supply chains have been a major spur to economic growth in emerging economies, enabling them to narrow the income gap to advanced economies (see, e.g., chapter by Palan et al.). However, the same architecture simultaneously creates unequal terms for participation in global markets. Globalization has therefore not paid off for low-income countries. On the contrary, it appears that structural inequalities have been reinforced, and the gap between the Global North and the Global South has grown not least due to reforms during the Washington consensus and its structural adjustment programs (Hickel 2017). In the global South, this is illustrated by increasing land inequality. This is a direct impact of neoliberal globalization, producing particularly devastating effects on people’s resilience, especially in rural areas and in view of unpredictable pressure on resources due to the consequences of climate change (Wegerif and Guereña 2020). The conventional wisdom that attributes widening inequalities to globalization and technological change leaves out some of the largest and most significant economic and political disruptions that are constitutive of the globalizing forces. One of the biggest shifts since the 1980s is the systematic undermining of countervailing powers that offset the influence of large corporations, global financial markets, and the wealthy elite. Contrary to the rhetoric, it is not the free market that creates objectively fair outcomes—not for people, let alone for the environment. Markets depend on rules, and rules come out of legislator bodies, executive agencies, and courts (Reich 2019). Among potential countervailing powers are labor unions, state and local banks, cooperatives, small retail chains, and local communities (Rajan 2019). With shrinking checks and balances, we find ourselves in an unhinged system that produces structural inequalities. Robert Reich (2020) describes this as the vicious cycles in which big money, which emanates from large corporations, global financial markets, and the wealthy determine the rules of the economic and social game. Even more so, Nobel laureate Angus Deaton warns about the disruptive effects on liberal democracies if the wealthy are allowed to influence political outcomes to a degree that gives systematic preference to their particular interests (Deaton 2013). The weakening redistributive role of the state is an example of these dynamics. In OECD economies, taxes and transfers typically maintain disposable income inequality at one-fifth to one-quarter lower than typical market-income inequality. In recent years, the role of fiscal redistribution in offsetting the rise in market income inequality has shrunk because of the reduced progressivity of personal income taxes; lower taxes on capital, including those on inheritance and corporations; and tightening of public on social programs, including health and education programs in the wake of widely rolled-out austerity policies, such as those that were implemented after the 2007 financial crisis (Canterbery 2015). A second element that much of the inequality-related research has increasingly focused on is (skill-biased) technological change as a key driver of the rise in inequality during the last few decades. The rapid increase in digital technologies has been received with much hope for the broader, more inclusive participation of so far by-passed population segments in these developments and the opportunities that they offer access to. Digital technologies have indeed substantially transformed markets, including the way we work and do business. However, against initial hopes, the gains of these technological advancements have the tendency to be shared highly unequally, something that is largely due to the disadvantage of workers and the populations in the global South more generally. The characteristics of digital goods play well into the logic of a globalized economy, where they enjoy huge advantages due to their replicability, their weightlessness, and their non-rival, synchronized nature (Quah 2003). On the other hand, these new technologies require substantial investments, thus favoring capital and leading to shrinking income shares from wage labor (ILO 2019). Moreover, the skill set needed to operate and manage digital tools effectively requires educational initiatives, particularly in low-income countries. The results of these programs only pay off after years of investments—investments that are all too often far from realistic for the budgets of low-income economies. The current COVID-19 pandemic seems to amplify these trends of widening technology gaps between the global regions (Ferreira et al. 2021; Martínez et al. 2021). While the overall picture confirms the continuous exacerbation of inequality, the trajectories are different depending on a countries policies. In other words: policies matter (Piketty et al. 2020). However, much of what we have seen from governments so far is conventional sectoral politics, little of which has been linked to the pertinent question of sustainability.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Biopolitics

Capitalism is the root cause of every totalitarianism ideology, namely biopolitics, because of its productive nature; any resistance of capitalism is merely a reflection of the system itself.

Zizek ’06 [Slavoj, PhD, World-renowned public intellectual Professor, 2006. “Jacques Lacan's Four Discourses.” Lacan.com. https://www.lacan.com/zizfour.htm; JFan]

University discourse as the hegemonic discourse of modernity has two forms of existence in which its inner tension (“contradiction”) is externalized: capitalism, its logic of the integrated excess, of the system reproducing itself through constant self-revolutionizing, and the bureaucratic "totalitarianism" conceptualized in different guises as the rule of technology, of instrumental reason, of biopolitics, as the "administered world." How, precisely, do these two aspects relate to each other? We should not succumb to the temptation of reducing capitalism to a mere form of appearance of the more fundamental ontological attitude of technological domination; we should rather insist, in the Marxian mode, that the capitalist logic of integrating the surplus into the functioning of the system is the fundamental fact. Stalinist "totalitarianism" was the capitalist logic of self-propelling productivity liberated from its capitalist form, which is why it failed: Stalinism was the symptom of capitalism. Stalinism involved the matrix of general intellect, of the planned transparency of social life, of total productive mobilization- and its violent purges and paranoia were a kind of a "return of the repressed," the "irrationality" inherent to the project of a totally organized "administered society." This means the two levels, precisely insofar as they are two sides of the same coin, are ultimately incompatible: there is no metalanguage enabling us to translate the logic of domination back into the capitalist reproduction-through-excess, or vice versa.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Inequality

Capitalism is the root cause of sexism and gender violence.

Wynter ’15 [Coral, 08-14-2015. “What are the root causes of domestic violence?.” Green Left. https://www.greenleft.org.au/content/what-are-root-causes-domestic-violence; JFan]

Against misogyny Successful campaigns against sexual violence and misogyny do not involve talking to a handful of men at football clubs about not beating up women. This will not cut the mustard. We need to talk about how domestic violence is hardwired into capitalism — a system that oppresses the majority of women and men, but which relies on sexism and misogyny to ensure women stay second-class citizens. The argument that women are no longer a reserve army of workers is not true. Most women work but we are congregated in low-waged jobs, with little or no security and poor working conditions. Women are also still only able to easily get some types of jobs, and then only when bosses need more workers or want to undercut men’s wages and conditions. More worker-friendly industrial relations policies, and stronger unions with a good feminist orientation, are part of the solution. Accessible, affordable tertiary education and training is also part of the long-term solution for both women and men. Capitalism also makes most men feel powerless and frustrated. It perpetuates the myth that women and children are a type of property and as such have fewer rights. The structural inequalities that lead to this type of thinking have to be challenged and changed. Capitalism perpetrates the myth that women and children are revered in the family. The truth is the opposite. Women carry out an essential role in the home and that is to carry most of the burden of unpaid domestic labour — cleaning, cooking and raising the next generation of workers. The value of women carrying out this unpaid domestic work is around 50% of the national Gross Domestic Product. If we refuse to comply or step out of this role we can be beaten or, in the worst-case scenario, murdered. The economic unit on which capitalism relies — the family — has shown its weaknesses and failures. The high rate of domestic violence in the home underscores this in a chilling way. Capitalism relies on sexism and misogyny. It also divides men and women. We cannot get rid of the violence of men towards women until we also get rid of the economic system that puts women and men under the gun. But we can take steps to alleviate women’s suffering. Those steps include mounting campaigns to reverse the cruel funding cuts to shelters and refuges for women and children fleeing violence.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Inequality

Capitalism perpetuates inequality

William Robinson 22, Professor of Sociology at the University of California, Santa Barbara, “Capitalism and Global Inequality,” Global Dialogue, 2022, - EM

Radical sociologists who study such inequality observe that, contrary to the system’s apologists, such social polarization is inherent to capitalism, as the capitalist class owns the means of producing wealth and therefore appropriates as profits as much as possible of the wealth that society collectively produces. They also note that the system has constantly expanded outward over the 500-plus years of its existence in the relentless search for new opp ortunities to accumulate capital (to maximize profit). Capitalism expanded out of its original heartland in Western Europe through ongoing waves of colonialism, imperialism, and more recently globalization, eventually coming to engulf the entire planet. By the start of the twenty-first century, there were no longer any nations or peoples that remained outside of the system. Sociologists note that the world capitalist system generates two interwoven forms of inequality. One is among the rich and the poor worldwide, as Oxfam has noted in its reports, that is, inequality among people. The other is the stratification of the world’s people into rich and poor countries, or inequality among countries. The average annual income in the Congo stands at $785 per capita, whereas in Belgium, the country that colonized the Congo in the late nineteenth century, it stands at $47,400, according to World Bank data. In the academic lexicon, the world became polarized through colonialism into a rich “First World” core, encompassing the nations of Western Europe, North America, and Japan, while those regions in Latin America, Africa, and Asia that suffered centuries of colonialism and domination by this core were relegated to the “Third World” periphery. In more recent years, academics and pundits have referred to the former Third World as the Global South and to the former First World as the Global North. Drawing on Karl Marx’s analysis of capitalism and on classical theories of imperialism put forth by V.I. Lenin – the leader of the Bolshevik Revolution – and his generation of socialist revolutionaries, radical political economists and international relations scholars in the post-World War II period developed new theories of dependency, world-systems, and underdevelopment. They argued that colonialism organized the world economy in such a way that the wealth generated in the periphery was siphoned back to the core, leaving the former impoverished and the latter enriched, and that this explains inequality between the Global South and the Global North. Hence, they argued, capital accumulates unevenly in space and leaves some peoples developed and others underdeveloped.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Inequality

Capitalism locks in inequality and existential warming - only the AFF can achieve absolute decoupling necessary to solve

Lawrence and Langton ‘18 {Laurie is an associate fellow at IPPR and is leading a project on how future leaders can navigate the worsening environmental crisis} - ("Time for politicians to get real about the anthropocene," No Publication, published 7-2-2018, accessed 7-13-2023, https://www.redpepper.org.uk/time-for-politicians-to-get-real-about-the-anthropocene/)//marlborough-am/

We are currently living through an era of global environmental collapse. Resources are being consumed at around 1.5 times the Earth’s ability to regenerate them. The continued reliance on carbon to power our economies means that we are highly unlikely to limit global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, increasing the chance of severe climate disruption. Meanwhile, the global food system has destroyed a third of all arable land and, at current rates, global top soil degradation means that there may only be 60 global harvests left. Ours is the age of the sixth mass extinction – the last being the dinosaurs – with nearly two-thirds of all vertebral life having died since the 1970s. In all, human activity has pushed environmental systems into ‘unsafe’ operating spaces, threatening the conditions upon which life can occur and societies flourish. This has led scientist to suggest we live in a new age, the ‘Anthropocence’, in which humans are the decisive, destructive influence on the natural world. We have irrevocably changed our planet, ultimately threatening its ability to support life as we know it. This is the context in which MPs voted to approve Heathrow’s third runway. It seems that the short lived cycles of electoral politics means that politicians chase short-term goals, rather than tackling problems such as climate change which require long-term, global thinking. The test of a capable politician in 2018 is whether they take a stand against cavalier resource extraction. Most obviously, a third runway places our climate change obligations under severe threat. Every nation on earth has an obligation to avert planetary crisis by reducing carbon emissions, a responsibility enshrined in the Paris Agreement. In the UK, a law called the Climate Change Act sets a legal target of reducing carbon emissions by 80 per cent below 1990 levels. The Committee on Climate Change, the independent body that monitors progress toward the target, estimates that emissions from the UK aviation industry must not exceed 37.5 million tons (the level seen in 2005). Yet the Department of Transport’s own analysis suggests aviation emissions will hit 43 million tons by 2030 as a result of the expansion, threatening our ability to meet our decarbonisation target. All over the world, countries suffer from infrastructure ‘lock in’, where new coal power plants, roads or runways are built and, over lifetimes often spanning decades, condemn the planet to absorb millions of more tons of CO2. Let us not make the same mistake. What’s more, the UK has signed up to the Paris Agreement’s ambition of reducing carbon emissions completely by the middle of the century. This is a challenging ambition but one that is essential to avoid catastrophe. Heathrow expansion could mean we fall at the first hurdle. Closer to home, air pollution levels are expected to increase, from more air traffic and vehicles moving to and from the airport, providing a basis for the legal challenge being taken against the government. Air pollution is attributable to 40,000 early deaths a year in the UK and action to stop climate change will reduce air pollution, improving all our health in the process. In general, the actions needed to mitigate climate change are also those that can transform society for the better. These include reductions in household bills through higher efficiency, improvements in health from lower air pollution and increases in active living, more affordable and secure energy, reductions in waste and inefficient resource use, and resilient, more efficient infrastructure. Realising these benefits could produce a profound social and economic transformation, radically enhancing the sustainability of the economy while improving lifestyles for all citizens. Red Pepper - Big Solar Summer 23 Red Pepper - EPC July-Sept 23 Our ability to realise these benefits is a function of how we resist powerful vested interests. Fossil fuel companies, car manufacturers and purveyors of unsustainable consumption goods profit from the collapse of the environment, their attentions focussed on quarterly returns at the detriment of all. These interests are entrenched in the investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) procedures of existing and planned international trade agreements, many of which could be used to block environmental regulation. British consulates around the world are being taught the post-Brexit mantra of ‘trade, trade, trade’; any future left government will have to prise the right of corporations to sue sovereign nations in private courts out of their cold, dead hands. In attempting to do so, they will be encumbered by the current government’s breathless race to the bottom on regulation and trade standards as it bungles through the process of Brexit. Back at the global level, we need to realise that we no longer live in a stable world. Instead, we are entering a permanent era of compounding environmental crises. A warming climate, a reduced ability to grow food, and depleting water supplies – to name but a few – exacerbate existing problems and create a raft of their own. Take the civil war in Syria. Alongside a raft of complex factors, more droughts and rising food prices resulting from extreme weather ruining harvests around the world fed into already tense political and economic circumstances – all of which eventually led to war, a migration crisis, and political repercussions across Europe. The world seems destined to warm by more than 1.5C and deplete much of its soil by the 2040s. The millennial generation will be in their late forties and early fifties by this point. Over what horrors will they preside? The UK bears greater responsibility than most for crises present and future. Industrial capitalism took root here and the British Empire contributed to its spread and entrenchment across the world, gunboats and all. Later, neoliberal capitalism and its penchants for financial collapse and consumerism-at-all-costs gestated on these shores. While the perfect storm of environmental collapse will impact those who can least afford it and who contributed little to its awakening, the forces unleashed by unsustainable destruction of the natural world mean that no nation is safe. Last night’s decision was a terrifying signal of the complacency of our current political class to this reality, and a blindness to the effects of climate and other environmental change. This is not about polar bears and feeling bad while watching Blue Planet II; this is about war and social collapse. The Anthropocene really does change everything. The scale and pace of environmental disruption brought about by human activity requires two concurrent responses. The first is nothing less than a global socioeconomic transformation that brings our impact to within safe limits over the lifetime of the millennial generation. This is not guaranteed. A neoliberal Anthropocene could win out, hierarchical and undemocratic, imposing unevenly shared costs, operating beyond safe planetary boundaries, and looking to the anti-political technological ‘moonshots’ of Silicon Valley for salvation. Instead, we require a politics committed to democratic negotiation of environmental challenges, capable of collective restraint where necessary, while mobilising for shared abundance where possible. It will need to be attentive to global and intergenerational equity, capable of remaking economic institutions at scale, and rooted in new models of production and consumption, ownership and governance. The second is a concerted effort to ensure resilience to environmental shocks within and between nations as the impacts of environmental change begin to mount. Natural system breakdown is already feeding into societies and economies around the world. Risk in this new world is non-linear, compounding and systemic. Without resilient governments, markets and leaders, global cooperation could be threatened as countries turn inwards to protect themselves or lash outwards in order to gain advantage over resources. That’s what collapse looks like. Inaction is no longer an option. To do nothing risks the natural foundation upon which all human society rests, and unjustly robs generations of a healthy, secure future. The challenges of the Anthropocene must consequently be a trigger for new ideas and new ways to organise economy and society. Tinkering has no place here and the politics of Thatcher and Blair are as inappropriate as that of Attlee and Roosevelt – systemic risk implores systemic change. The growing movement to shift our political economy away from the failures of extractive and unequal neoliberalism should put this at the core of its development.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – War

Capitalism causes nations to enact imperial violence – Ukraine proves

Callinicos ‘22, Alex Callinicos, studied Philosophy, Politics, and Economics at Balliol College, Oxford, and Philosophy of Science at the London School of Economics before writing a DPhil on Marx's Capital, also at Balliol, 3-27-2022, "The great power grab—imperialism and the war in Ukraine," Socialist Worker, https://socialistworker.co.uk/features/the-great-power-grab-imperialism-and-war-in-ukraine/

Marxists were confronted with a reality similar to our own. The radical liberal economist JA Hobson wrote, “The novelty of recent Imperialism … consists chiefly in its adoption by several nations. The notion of a number of competing empires is essentially modern.” This geopolitical competition was expressed in conflicts over territory—the colonies and semi-colonies that the biggest states were striving to dominate— and in an accelerating arms race. The Marxist theory of imperialism was developed to explain these rivalries, which precipitated the two world wars of 1914-18 and 1939-45, drowning the world in blood. It was a theory of capitalist imperialism. The Russian revolutionary Vladimir Lenin called imperialism the highest stage of capitalism. His Polish-German comrade wrote, “The essence of imperialism consists precisely in the expansion of capital from the old capitalist countries into new regions and the competitive economic and political struggle among those for those new areas.” To put it another way, capitalist imperialism represents the intersection of economic and geopolitical competition. Economic competition is the driving force of capitalism—rival firms struggle against each other, investing in improved and expanded production to seize a larger share of markets. In the late 19th century, the geopolitical struggle among states was subsumed under the capitalist logic of competitive accumulation. This reflected changes in both warfare and capitalism. War was industrialised, as military power came to depend on mass production to arm, support, and transport huge armies. States therefore needed to promote industrial capitalism. Meanwhile capitalist firms increased in size and started to operate globally. They depended on state support against their rivals. During the depression of the late 19th century, seizing overseas colonies compensated for falling profitability. So capitalist imperialism isn’t just big states bullying and conquering smaller states—though there is plenty of that. It’s a global system of inter-capitalist competition. Just as before the , today imperialism means geopolitical competition against the background of global economic integration. The power of the antagonists depends on their position in the capitalist world economy. The US dominates finance and big tech, China has a vast manufacturing machine, and Russia relies on energy exports. Today one can identify perhaps six leading imperialist powers—the US, China, Russia, Britain, France, and Germany. The most important antagonism is that between the US and China whose leaders aim to displace Washington’s hegemony, initially in the Indo-Pacific region. But Russian imperialism, manoeuvring to rebuild its power, creates a three-way conflict. The big western European powers are pulled in different directions. They depend on Russian energy and are attracted by the vast Chinese market—but, as at present, they ultimately line up with the US. Now this understanding of capitalist imperialism as involving a system of interstate rivalry is completely missing from Achcar’s analysis. He denies that the war involves a conflict among imperialist powers. “If any war where each side is supported by an imperialist rival were called an inter-imperialist war, then all the wars of our time would be inter-imperialist, since as a rule, it is enough for one of the rival imperialisms to support one side for the other to support the opposite side. “An inter-imperialist war is not that. It is a direct war, and not one by proxy, between two powers, each of which seeks to invade the territorial and (neo) colonial domain of the other.” This is much too narrow. The US waged a proxy war against the Soviet Union after the latter tried to seize Afghanistan at the end of 1979 Along with allies such as Britain, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan it armed and trained the mujahedin fighters who resisted the Soviet occupation. The conflict helped to drain Soviet resources and morale in the last decade of the Cold War. Of course, the mujahedin had their own political agendas. This became clear after Soviet forces withdrew in 1989, culminating in the Taliban’s support for al-Qaeda and its resistance to the US occupation following the 9/11 attacks on New York and Washington. But the US played a decisive shaping role in an important final episode of the Cold War. Of course, there are huge differences between Ukraine today and in the 1980s. But there is an important similarity, in that the Western imperialist powers are instrumentalising the Ukrainian national struggle against Russian imperialism for their own interests. Inter-imperialist struggles and wars of national defence often interweave. The First World War started when the Austro-Hungarian Empire attacked Serbia, which it blamed for the assassination of its crown prince Franz Ferdinand. Russia then backed Serbia, leading to an escalating process of military mobilisations that ended in a terrible general war. The German Marxist argued that the role played by the Serbian struggle for national self-determination meant the conflict wasn’t just an imperialist war. Lenin responded, “To Serbia, i.e., to perhaps one percent or so of the participants in the present war, the war is a ‘continuation of the politics’ of the bourgeois-liberation movement. “To the other ninety-nine percent, the war is a continuation of the politics of imperialism.” Of course, the balance is different in the present case since the direct fighting involves just Ukraine and Russia. Nevertheless the Nato powers’ efforts to stay out of the fighting—above all to avoid nuclear confrontation with Russia—don’t alter the fact they are doing everything they can short of this to defeat Russia. This too is “a continuation of the politics of imperialism”. The Marxist theory of imperialism is important politically. Without it we are confronted simply with a struggle between rival nation-states. But once we see the role of imperialism, we can identify the class antagonism at work. We can see the thread of class interest that binds together not just the Russian conscripts dying in Putin’s war and their families back home being walloped economically by the effects of Western sanctions. This thread also connects with hit thanks to the war by food and energy and threatened with nuclear destruction. It unites them all against the rival ruling classes busy feeding this terrible war.

The US-China conflict is rooted in inter-capitalist competition

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Climate

Idk what to tag this card

Blok and Lemmens 15 (Vincent, PhD in Philosophy of Technology and Responsible Innovation from Leiden University, Pieter, post-doctoral fellow at Wageningen University and Research, Communication, Philosophy and Technology, “The Emerging Concept of Responsible Innovation. Three Reasons Why It Is Questionable and Calls for a Radical Transformation of the Concept of Innovation”, Tilburg Law School, - SH)

With regard to the output of responsible innovation processes, it is assumed that the incorporation of societal and ethical aspects in the innovation process decreases unintended societal impact of technological developments and will therefore lead to more responsible innovations (cf. Rogers-Hayden and Pidgeon 2007). Although stakeholder involvement may result in more desirable outcomes, the involvement of stakeholders doesn’t necessarily guarantee a more responsible output of the innovation process. For example, many stakeholders were involved during the development of biofuels and this innovation seemed to be promising according to various stakeholders; biofuel is inherently renewable, locally produced, less polluting, etc. An unexpected outcome of the increased demand for biofuels however, was that food prices increased because farmers started to grow more and more crops for biofuel production. Although multiple stakeholders were involved, it turned out that especially people in developing countries were negatively affected by the increased food prices. Unexpected outcomes can be seen as a main characteristic of innovation processes. Recent literature tends to see innovation as a cumulative, stepwise process of collaboration between multiple actors with often unexpected outcomes (Rammert 1997). If innovation is a highly uncertain process, though, which is characterized by interdependency, serendipity etc., it is questionable whether this uncertainty can ever be steered in desired directions through relatively simple means. Well-known puzzles like the Jevons Paradox—innovations that increase energy efficiency for instance tends to increase the consumption of energy as well—show that the outcome of innovations may be contrary to what was intended (cf. Owen 2012). Also, most of the responsible innovation literature starts from the plausible premise that innovations are radically uncertain and that their societal and environmental consequences are virtually unpredictable (for an example, see Ozdemir et al. 2011). The question then is what responsibility could mean if this premise were indeed true. Are responsible innovations those forms of science and technology development whose protagonists are willing and able to take accountability for, or ‘stand up for’, the societal and environmental consequences of their endeavors? If there is practically no way to predict or foresee such consequences, however, all talk about responsibility in this context would seem groundless and misleading. This point can be illustrated with the requirement of ‘accountability’ that has found its way in the recommended Code of Conduct for Responsible N&N (Nano sciences and Nanotechnologies) Research for the European Union: “Researchers and research organizations should remain accountable for the social, environmental and human health impacts that their research may impose on present and future generations” (European Commission 2008).2 This extremely far-reaching commitment exposes Nano researchers, as two analysts rightly point out, to “unbounded hazards of moral luck” (Grinbaum and Groves). In the future, researchers could be held liable for any untoward effects of their research that are as yet impossible to predict but that may manifest themselves only after decades. Their fate could be even worse than that of the Italian seismologists who were sued and convicted for failing to accurately predict an impending earthquake. Or is being held ‘accountable’ deemed to have no consequences for the researchers? Then the stipulation in the Code of Conduct is just an empty play of words.3 We have to admit that the EU Code of Conduct for Responsible N&N Research is not representative for the essential meaning of responsible innovation. Nevertheless, while the radical uncertainty of innovations and the unpredictability of their societal and environmental effects is fully acknowledged, it is suggested that this uncertainty can somehow be overcome by making the whole process more inclusive and more reflexive from the very outset (cf. Flipse 2012). Owen and Goldberg for instance argue: “Embedding iterative risk (and benefit) analysis with technology assessment and public/stakeholder engagement approaches within innovation research proposals was seen as offering a mechanism that considers technical risk issues and associated uncertainties, but that could also provide opportunities for identifying as yet unforeseen effects (economic, societal, and ethical) as these emerge. It may also facilitate upstream engagement with stakeholders and the public as to how these emerging impacts are received” (Owen and Goldberg 2010, p. 1705). Regardless of the inherent unpredictability of the future, ‘foresight’ can still be exercised, it is claimed, when stakeholders are involved to deliberate on various scenarios for possible futures; societal values and concerns can still be taken on-board ‘midstream’ and then ‘modulate’ on-going technological trajectories. René von Schomberg expresses the underlying view as follows in an interview in LEV: “You need a smart innovation process in which you do not place your bets too much on one particular technology, because technology development is unpredictable. Bring all involved societal parties together and let them jointly determine what they expect from the research trajectory. Then you can formulate research agendas, which can be mutually adjusted in order to arrive at the desired end result”. In another publication he wrote that societal actors become “co-responsible for the innovation process by a constructive input in terms of defining societal desirable products” (Schomberg forthcoming). While he acknowledged that “an ethics focused on the intentions and/or consequences of actions of individuals is not appropriate for innovation”, he nevertheless held that there is “collective responsibility both for the right impacts and negative consequences” (von Schomberg 2013). Arguably this still presumes that these impacts and consequences, although perhaps not attributable to the actions of individuals, can somehow be foreseen by the various societal actors that are involved in the innovation process, a presumption that had initially been denied. The third reason to question the possibility of responsible innovation is, that the ‘responsibility’ or ‘accountability’ is principally limited because of the radical uncertainty of innovation processes. This uncertainty even increases in case of wicked problems like sustainable development, because no simple solutions exist; all our proposed solutions will have unintended consequences and remain finite and provisional compared to the complexity and depth of the sustainability problem itself. Because our knowledge of the solution of wicked problems is principally limited, we can call this an epistemic insufficiency (cf. DeMartino 2013). If the output of responsible innovation processes is characterized by a fundamental uncertainty, which means that our knowledge of the impact of our innovations is not only limited but principally insufficient, the presupposed ‘foresight’ of responsible innovation becomes questionable. In other words, our knowledge is principally insufficient to assess the impact of innovation processes and there will always be unintended consequences of our innovations which can be harmful. The analysis of the input, throughput and output of innovation processes raised several questions with regard to the possibility of responsible innovation and pointed at several difficulties which undermine the responsible character of innovation processes. It became clear that the practical applicability of the concept of responsible innovation is highly problematic and that a more thorough inquiry of the concept is required. In the next section, we therefore ask what concept of innovation is presupposed in the responsible innovation literature. 2.3 The Presupposed Concept of Innovation in the Responsible Innovation Literature What concept of innovation is self-evidently presupposed in the responsible innovation literature? In a recent paper, Benoît Godin sketched the history of the innovation concept. Although innovation always existed throughout history, it became only very recently “the emblem of the modern society” (Godin 2009, p. 5; cf. Nowotny 2008). While the concept originally concerned novelties in the broadest sense of the word—including imitation, invention, creative imagination, change—it became only recently restricted to technological innovation and commercialized innovation. Nowadays, it is almost self-evident that innovation does not only concern the exploration of new technologies, but also the commercial exploitation of these new technologies. According to Godin (2009, p. 21), the restriction of innovation to technological innovation is rooted in what he calls, the ‘culture of things’ or material culture: “The origins of this culture go back to the Renaissance: due to commercial exchanges, exploration and travel, natural and artificial objects have been what is valued in arts, science, and real life”. The focus on technological innovations is further enhanced by the introduction of patent laws from the fourteenth century onward, because only these kinds of innovations can be patented (cf. Macleod 1988). With the emergence of economic thought in the seventeenth century, the utilitarian value of innovations became most important (Godin 2009; Schumpeter 1943). As a consequence of this economic paradigm of technological innovation, alternative forms of innovation like systems innovations (for instance agro-ecological innovations) or attitudinal innovations (for instance prevention or life style interventions) receive less attention because it is difficult to develop a business model on the basis of these kinds of innovations. A good example is the case of agricultural science and technology (S&T). Because of the current technological regime of agricultural S&T, technological innovations like genetic engineering are locked in and systems innovations like agro-ecological innovations are locked out (Vanloqueren and Baret 2009; cf. Mortensen et al. 2012). The same economic paradigm of technological innovation is presupposed in case of responsible innovation. The Dutch research council for instance started recently with a new responsible innovation program which is intended for “short-term research projects into the ethical and societal aspects of new technology”. Besides the scientific quality of the research projects on responsible innovation, the “added value, societal relevance and knowledge utilisation” are the most important criteria for funding (our emphasis, NWO 2012; cf. Technology Strategy Board 2012). Also from the EU perspective, responsible innovation is, among others, characterized by “Assessing and effectively prioritising social, ethical and environmental impacts, risks and opportunities, both now and in the future, alongside the technical and commercial” (Matter 2011). The economic paradigm of technological innovation is also reflected in the fact that investments in responsible research and innovation (RRI) is primarily legitimized by the macro-economic arguments, i.e. that RRI will lead to the creation of jobs and economic growth (von Schomberg 2013). In the Lund declaration for instance, it is claimed that “meeting the grand challenges will be a prerequisite for continued economic growth and for improved changes to tackle key issues” (cited in von Schomberg 2013, p. 12). The applicability of the economic paradigm of technological innovations on the concept of responsible innovation may be questioned, because exactly the imperative of economic growth and profit is at odds with the other P’s People and Planet, to say the least. Some philosophers even argue that the growth imperative is above everything else ‘responsible’ for the rapid environmental destruction, resource depletion and impoverishment of populations all over the globe. Huesemann and Huesemann (2011, p. 256) for instance argue, that “our economic system’s inherent dependence on growth for survival (i.e. more of everything: more markets, more consumers, more raw materials, more energy, more cheap labor, etc.) is the root cause of many environmental problems and is in direct conflict with sustainability”. For our discussion of the applicability of the economic paradigm of technological innovations on the concept of responsible innovation, it is sufficient to raise the question whether the fundamental tensions between the growth imperative and the demand for sustainability can ever be overcome, as long as we embrace the economic paradigm in our concept of responsible innovation. It is striking, in this respect, that corporate innovation is underrepresented in current research on the concept of responsible innovation. Another assumption in responsible innovation is that innovations are inherently good, as they produce prosperity and jobs and meet societal challenges at the same time (von Schomberg 2013). Innovation is seen as a panacea for all problems (Godin 2009) and responsible innovation in particular serves the ‘public good’ (Matter 2011). Some researchers even argue for cognitive enhancement in order to increase the innovative abilities of the species (Greely et al. 2008, cited in Godin 2009). With this focus on the inherently good of innovation, the ‘Faustian’ aspect of innovation processes is neglected. According to the godfather of innovation studies, Joseph Schumpeter (1883–1950), innovation is the product of creative destruction. To Schumpeter, “Capitalism […] is by nature a form or method of economic change and not only never is but never can be stationary. […] The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist engine in motion comes from the new consumers’ goods, the new methods of production or transportation, the new markets, the new forms of industrial organization that capitalist enterprise creates. […] The opening up of new markets, foreign or domestic, and the organizational development from the craft shop and factory to such concerns as U.S. Steel illustrate the same process of industrial mutation […] that incessantly revolutionizes the economic structure from within, incessantly destroying the old one, incessantly creating a new one. This process of Creative Destruction is the essential fact about capitalism. It is what capitalism consists in and what every capitalist concern has got to live in” (Schumpeter 1943, p. 82–83). According to Schumpeter, it is exactly innovation which is responsible for creative destruction. The construction of new and innovative solutions is accompanied by the annihilation or destruction of the old rules and the old order (including the ‘writing off’ of ‘obsolescent’ skills, technologies and capital stocks), i.e. the positive impact of responsible innovation and contribution to the public good, is therefore accompanied by negative impacts elsewhere. This Faustian aspect of innovation processes is largely ignored by the responsible innovation literature. Furthermore, in line with the idea that innovation is a cumulative process with often unexpected outcomes (Sect. 2.2), we cannot claim that the outcome of responsible innovation will automatically contribute to the public good. Well-known puzzles like the Jevons Paradox—innovations that increases energy efficiency for instance tends to increase the consumption of energy as well—show that the outcome of innovations may be contrary to what was intended (cf. Owen 2012). Innovation implies pain, annihilation and destruction, and it is questionable whether this ‘Faustian aspect’ of innovation can ever be overcome by integrating social and ethical aspects in the design process. The effort to integrate social and ethical aspects in the design process shows another assumption of responsible innovation. Mutual responsiveness means that multiple stakeholders participate or are able to participate in the formation of societal and ethical norms. These norms are valid if the participants agree to it as participants of practical discourses (Habermas 1990, 1993). In order to form societal and ethical norms together, stakeholders should be able to listen to others, to be empathetic with regard to the interests of others, to take the perspective or standpoint of the other etc. (Kaptein and van Tulder 2003). Mutual responsiveness therefore presupposes symmetry between moral agents and moral addressees (Mackin 2011). Only because stakeholders can hear the voice of the other and can take the perspective of the other, they can become mutual responsive. Given the existing information asymmetries and investment imbalances, let alone the epistemic insufficiency with regard to future generations for instance (cf. Sect. 2.2), it is highly questionable whether the presupposed symmetry between moral agents and moral addressees is legitimized. The analysis of the concept of innovation which is presupposed in current literature on responsible innovation, shows that innovation is self-evidently seen as (1) technological innovation, (2) which is primarily perceived from an economic perspective, (3) is inherently good and (4) presupposes a symmetry between moral agents and moral addressees. 2.4 Conclusions In Sect. 2.2, we raised several questions with regard to the possibility and applicability of responsible innovation processes. We pointed at several difficulties with regard to responsible innovation, i.e. with attaining a more socially just and environmentally sound trajectory of innovation that will appeal to all the stakeholders involved. Especially with respect to the ‘grand challenges’ or wicked problems, it turned out to be very difficult if not impossible to satisfy the ideal of responsible innovation. But also more generally, it became clear that the wish for (more) responsibility clashed with the realities of existing innovation processes. As we have pointed out with respect to the input, throughput and output of innovation processes, the demand for responsibility runs into serious problems. The main difficulty of responsible innovation revolves around the response-ability of actors in the innovation process, due to ‘epistemic’ factors like the inherent complexity, uncertainty and unpredictability of technological innovation on the one hand, and ‘moral’ and ‘political’ factors like conflicting worldviews, interests and value systems among stakeholders and power imbalances on the other. We concluded that the practical applicability of the concept of responsible innovation is highly questionable. In Sect. 2.3, we analyzed the presupposed concept of innovation in responsible innovation. With regard to the first two characteristics—innovation is technological and primarily seen from an economic perspective—we have to conclude that the prevailing concept of innovation is uncritically taken over in the concept of responsible innovation. With regard to the third characteristic of innovation—innovation is inherently good—we showed that the current concept of responsible innovation is highly naïve. Finally, our discussion of information asymmetries and our epistemic insufficiency to assess the future impact of our innovations (Sect. 2.2) raised fundamental questions with regard to the fourth assumption of responsible innovation—the symmetry of moral agents and moral addressees. 32 V. Blok and P. Lemmens Because the possibility and applicability of responsible innovation is highly questionable and the presupposed concept of innovation is uncritical, narrow and naïve, we have to conclude that the conventional concept of innovation—innovation is technological and seen from an economic perspective—cannot be upgraded to a more responsible concept of innovation; responsible innovation calls for a radical transformation of the concept of innovation itself. Based on the findings in this article, we propose the following research agenda for future research on responsible innovation: • With regard to the input of innovation processes, future research should focus on the question how to deal with power-, vision-, goal-, sector- and motive-deviations among stakeholders involved in responsible innovation processes, especially with regard to social and ethical aspects.4 • With regard to the throughput of innovation processes, future research should focus on the question how stakeholders become mutual responsive to each other, given the remaining investment- and risk imbalances and given the remaining information asymmetries among stakeholders involved in responsible innovation processes. • With regard to the output of innovation processes, future research should focus on the question how to assess the future impact of responsible innovation processes, given the fundamental uncertainty of innovation processes and given our epistemic insufficiency with regard to the future impact of responsible innovation processes. We can also raise more fundamental question with regard to the concept of responsible innovation itself. With regard to the concept of innovation which is presupposed in the majority of the responsible innovation literature, future research should broaden our conception of innovation, including non-technological innovations and non-market environments. Furthermore, future research should consider the concept of response-ability in the context of alternative strategies of innovation, in which the relationships between stakeholders substantially differ from those involved in conventional innovation processes. A particularly promising direction for future research might be the examination of user-based or user-centered innovations, free and open source, and commons-based peer-to-peer (p2p) innovation strategies. These alternative strategies have steadily proliferated over the last two decades in various domains of the economy, may possess characteristics that are less susceptible to the flaws that we have diagnosed in this article, and may therefore provide directions for more responsible innovation processes in the future. With regard to the concept of responsibility which is presupposed in the majority of the responsible innovation literature, future research should consider the question what consequences our epistemic insufficiency will have for our concept of responsibility in general and responsible innovation practices in particular.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Climate

Capitalism locks in existential warming - only the AFF can achieve absolute decoupling necessary to solve

Reese ’20 [Ted; 9-2-20; author of Socialism or Extinction and The End of Capitalism: The Thought of Henryk Grossman, “‘Socialism or extinction’ is a scientific fact, not just a slogan”, https://grossmanite.medium.com/socialism-or-extinction-is-a-fact-not-a-slogan-3cb97b198c50, emuse)] //marlborough-am/

‘Socialism or extinction’ is not just a slogan; it is a statement of scientific fact. Even if the climate has at times been warmer in the past few centuries, the rate of carbon dioxide emissions and warming is much higher than at any point in the past 1,000 years and must therefore be treated seriously, like nuclear weapons, as a serious potential existential threat. If XR does not stand for socialism — the social, collective ownership of all production — then it must necessarily stand for extinction, rendering its own alleged purpose redundant.[1]In short: capitalism is dependent on the production of value and profit, and must therefore continue to expand production (via economic contractions, on average once a decade, in order to cheapen the costs of production when an inevitable rise in surplus/overaccumulated capital that is unprofitable to re/invest forms a barrier to productiviry growth). The more abundant production becomes, the less profit tends to be contained in each commodity, so the capitalist must offset this by expanding production, only to intensify the contradiction. Since profit comes from capital’s exploitation of commodity-producing labour — the theft of its surplus labour time — the intensity of subtractive production (where materials are subtracted from nature rather than added or grown, as with additive prodution), particularly in the form of fossil fuel and toxic, fuel-intensive metal mining, is (increasingly) necessary (in absolute terms). To flesh this out a bit: capital’s exploitation of commodity-producing labour is the sole source of profit — the capitalist appropriates surplus value (surplus labour time) from the worker, i.e the worker keeps less value than they create, covering their living costs (necessary labour time), and surplus value is then realised as profit through commodity sales. This social relation is obscured by the money-wage relation, or commodity fetish (money being the money-commodity). Therefore, capital’s evermore demanding need to accumulate is based on the continual expansion of intensive production, i.e. the extraction of fossil fuel and metals, deforestation, intensive farming, etc., that is releasing carbon and other ‘greenhouse’ emissions trapped in nature into the atmosphere — not to mention that they are fuel-intensive practices in the first place and usually toxic to the local environment — making the planet warmer and threatening runaway global heating that, according to numerous scientific studies, will make the planet uninhabitable for humans, probably before the end of the present century. (Capital’s exploitation of labour is therefore also the root cause of alleged plummeting sperm counts (down a reported 59% from 1973 to 2011), further threatening extinction. The microplastics, nanoparticles and toxic chemicals sourced from fossil fuels and metal mines and consumed in everyday products penetrate and damage human cells.) Although extractive industries are usually now very capital-intensive — the source of capitalism’s (now existential) economic crisis, i.e., since automated production is abolishing the source of profit — the rate of exploitation of the remaining workers is extremely high. It is not capitalism’s need for ‘infinite growth on a planet of finite resources’, as most ‘leftists’ seem to put it, that is the central or immediate problem; rather, it is the pace of production and its expansion — determined by the size of an ever-larger total capital and its need to expand yet further by feeding off labour — relative to nature’s ability to replenish itself (something capitalism’s dependence on intensive extraction obviously hinders); and, most importantly, on the basis of extractive, labour-intensive production, i.e. the necessarily increasing rate of exploitation. Just as surplus value is converted into capital faster than it is produced — resulting in (on average) decennial recessions and, eventually, a historical limit to capital accumulation — so nature is converted into capital faster than it can be replenished.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Climate

Capitalism fuels the production of CO2, make climate change inevitable.

Vijay ’22 [Last name not disclosed, 9-1-2022. “Capitalism Created the Climate Catastrophe; Socialism Can Avert Disaster. The Thirty-Fifth Newsletter (2022).” Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research. https://thetricontinental.org/newsletterissue/climate-crisis-green-new-deal/; JFan]

In November 2022, most member states of the United Nations (UN) will gather in the Egyptian resort city of Sharm El Sheikh for the annual UN Climate Change Conference. This is the 27th conference of the parties to assess the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, commonly referred to as COP 27. The international environmental treaty was established in Rio de Janeiro in 1992, with the first conference held in Berlin in 1995; the agreements were extended in the Kyoto Protocol of 2005 and supplemented by the Paris Agreement of 2015. No more needs to be said of the climate catastrophe, which threatens mass species extinction. The move away from carbon-based fuel has been stalled by three main impediments:

Right-wing forces which deny the existence of climate change.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Climate

Capitalism cause climate change which is on the brink now. It outweighs the nuclear war and cause every impact.

Polychroniou ’21 [C. J., a political scientist/political economist, author, and journalist who has taught and worked in numerous universities and research centers in Europe and the United States, 4-1-2021. “Is Saving the Planet Under Capitalism Really Possible?” Global Policy Journal. https://www.globalpolicyjournal.com/blog/20/04/2021/saving-planet-under-capitalism-really-possible; JFan]

The theme of the 51st Anniversary of Earth Day is “Restore Our Earth.” To be sure, while there has been a growing level of environmental consciousness since the first Earth Day and environmental policies have changed dramatically over the last fifty years, we are really in a race to save the planet. As things stand, the world now faces two existential crises that threaten organized human life as we know it, and life in general on planet Earth. The first one stems from the continued presence of nuclear weapons. The second one comes from global warming. However, while a nuclear war is actually preventable, we are not sure about global warming. Allow me to elaborate. The world has been faced with a threat from a nuclear war since the end of the Second World War. It is an intolerable threat to humanity, and it may just be the case that we have managed so far to avoid a nuclear holocaust by sheer accident. But a nuclear war can be prevented by addressing the sources of conflict and going beyond arms control. We can actually abolish nuclear weapons. On the other hand, global warming is a certainty. It is already happening. According to the 2020 Global Climate Report from NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information, the global annual temperature has increased at an average rate of 0.08 degrees Celsius per decade since 1880, but the average rate of increase since 1981 (0.18 degrees Celsius) has been more than twice that rate. Moreover, the effects of global warming are already present and include excessive heat waves, frequent wildfires, more droughts, greater frequency, intensity and duration of hurricanes, and higher sea levels which will have profound impact on low-lying coastal areas. The effects of global warming will also be felt most severely on all categories of human movement: displacement, migration, and planned relocation. The data on human movement in the context of the climate emergency is already daunting. The Internal Displacement Monitoring Center (IDMC), which has been compiling data since 2008 on displacement due to natural disasters, estimated that between 2008 and 2019 there were 265 million new displacements associated with disasters such as storms, floods, and wildfires. This figure does not include estimates on displacement related to drought or estimates on migration and planned relocation associated with the climate emergency. The impact of human migration due to the climate crisis is expected to be simply overwhelming. A report released by the World Bank in 2018 estimates that three regions of the world (Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa, and Southeast Asia) will produce 143 million more environmental migrants by 2050. Make no mistake, global warming is the defining crisis of our time. Climate change has always happened on planet Earth, but there is overwhelming scientific evidence that the Earth’s globally averaged temperature surface temperature has been rising due to anthropogenic factors. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) fifth assessment report, human emissions and activities have caused 100% of the observed increase in temperature since 1950. Global warming is human-caused and the culprit is industrial capitalism and its addiction to fossil fuels. The burning of fossil fuels (coal, oil, and natural gas) releases carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases which trap heat in the atmosphere and contribute to temperature increases. Scientists have known for decades how exactly carbon dioxide causes global warming. Nuclear physicist Edward Teller warned the oil industry all the way back in 1959 that its product will end up having a catastrophic impact on human civilization. Moreover, scientific studies have established a proportional correlation between global mean surface air warming and cumulative carbon dioxide emissions. Unsurprisingly, therefore, the 2010s, in which emissions from greenhouse gases grew faster over this decade than they did over the previous three decades, were the hottest decade. So the heat is on, yet action to contain global warming has been very slow. At COP 21 in Paris, on December 12, 2015, nearly every nation on earth agreed to combat global warming by “holding the increase in the global average temperature well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels.” This goal is to be attained through substantial cuts in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions. However, the Paris Agreement is a toothless climate accord. It lacks an enforcement mechanism and contains very few direct requirements. Most of the countries that signed the Paris Agreement are not on track to meet their pledge, and while some investors move away from coal, new coal-fired plants continue to be built in many parts of the developing world. Indeed, perhaps indicative of all of the above, a recent United Nations Environment Programme report suggests that we are on track for an average temperature rise well above 3 degrees Celsius. At this stage, while a quick wind-down of fossil fuel production is absolutely critical to slow the rate of global warming, we must accept the fact that the Earth’s temperature would continue to rise over the next several decades. At this point, even reducing carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases to zero won’t stop global warming. Nonetheless, zero emissions is a must if we don’t want to see human civilization crumble within a few decades from now - a distinct possibility if we don’t take immediate action this decade, according to a policy paper by the Breakthrough National Center for Climate Restoration in Melbourne.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Climate

Capitalism is the root cause for climate change.

Pollock ’20 [Lauren, “How Capitalism is a Driving Force of Climate Change – PIT Journal”; 2020, The People, Ideas, and Things Journal, https://pitjournal.unc.edu/2022/12/24/how-capitalism-is-a-driving-force-of-climate-change/; JFan]

Global capitalism and economic expansion are driving forces for both income inequality and climate change. The global economy within New York 2140 reflects the same systems in place today, with the existence of global capitalism driving production and consumption. Most climate scientists have come to agree that the cause of climate change is the increased emission of greenhouse gases, specifically carbon dioxide, which have increased rapidly since the Industrial Revolution (Baer 2). Progressive scholars recognize the serious damage that results from a global capitalist drive. Endless efforts of private owners to expand and increase their profits force a “perpetual treadmill of production and consumption” relying mainly on fossil fuels or alternative sources of greenhouse gas emissions (Baer 4). In 2010, the International Energy Agency projected that by 2030, global energy use would rise over 50%, with fossil fuels still the primary source of energy (Baer 64). Our continued dependence on the fossil fuel industry will continue to raise global temperatures as a direct result of global capitalism. The most profitable decisions will never be the most environmentally friendly, thus private owners of corporations will refrain from making environmentally conscious decisions without regulations.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Root Cause › RC – Violence

Capitalism drives structural violence

Allinson et al. ’21 [Jamie, DR. Senior Lecturer, School of Social and Political Science at the University of Edinburgh, 2021. “The Tragedy of the Worker: Towards the Proletarocene.” Verso Books, p. 14-17; JFan] [*we don’t endorse gendered language]

This is the question that vexed us as we set out to write The Tragedy of the Worker. From the vantage point of the present, the history of capitalist development is, as Marx expected, the history of the development of a global working class, the proletarianisation of the majority of the world’s population. But the very same process of that development has brought us to the precipice of climate disaster. Our position, to recall Trotsky’s rationalisation of War Communism in 1920, is in the highest degree tragic.

It is now clear that we will pass what scientists have long warned will be a tipping point of global warming, accelerating the already catastrophic consequences of capitalist emissions. How do we imagine emancipation on an at best partially habitable planet? Where once communists imagined seizing the means of production, taking the unprecedented capacities of capitalist infrastructures and using them to build a world of plenty, what must we imagine after the apocalypse has befallen us? What does it mean that as capitalism has become truly global, the gravediggers it has created dig not only capitalism’s grave, but also that of much organic life on earth?

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – MMT

MMT is a mechanism to further capitalist mechanisms of control

Lapavitsas and Aguila ’21 (Costas Lapavitsas and Nicolas Aguila, Lapavitsas is a professor of economics and academic staff at the Japan Research Centre and Aguila holds a BA in Economics from the Universidad de Buenos Aires where he was TA of Gender and Economics and Microeconomics for Economists, 3-17-2021, "Monetary policy is ultimately based on a theory of money: A Marxist critique of MMT," Developing Economics, https://developingeconomics.org/2021/03/17/monetary-policy-is-ultimately-based-on-a-theory-of-money-a-marxist-critique-of-mmt/)

The specificity of capitalism is crucial to understanding money. Capitalism is an economic formation in which general social relations are no longer direct but are mediated by the products of work that take the form of commodities. Even the ability to work becomes a commodity in the labor market. Thus, capitalism requires the emergence and constant presence of money as the universal equivalent allowing commodities to express their values and exchange with one another (Lapavitsas, 2005). Money is a commodity that emerges spontaneously and proceeds to act as the organizer of the total social labor, when production is dominated by private, autonomous, and independent units. For Marxist theory, money is not the creation of the state or any other authority external to markets. On the contrary, money is endogenously and constantly created through the characteristic interactions of capitalist markets. Capitalism extrudes money from every pore. What is the role of the state? Regarding the role of the state in the functioning of money, MMT argues that the unit of account is arbitrarily imposed by the state. In particular, modern nation-states impose a liability in the form of a tax obligation and name the “thing” they will accept in payment (Tcherneva, 2006). Since agents must possess it to pay taxes, the “thing” becomes the general means of exchange and payment, and thus money. From this standpoint, money is an institutionalized social relationship based on state authority, which has the monopoly to issue and can choose anything to be money irrespective of material (Wray, 2010). The state can also define money’s value by unilaterally determining the terms on which it is offered, for example through a Job Guarantee (Tcherneva, 2016). For Marxist political economy, similarly to MMT, the state is able to determine the unit of account and the central bank can issue money that functions as legal tender (Lapavitsas, 2017). However, the state operates within parameters set by the endogenous creation of money and money’s character as the universal equivalent. The functioning of the unit of account is part of the broader functioning of money as measure of value, which is certainly not within the power of the state. Money is a creature of commodities and not of the state. When it comes to state economic policy, MMT follows the approach of Functional Finance, including the idea that the state can issue money to command resources up to the limit given by the inflationary constraint (Lerner, 1943). The true limit to state power is not a financial constraint on the public budget, but rather the availability of real resources. In this way, the state can seemingly alter the distribution of income without taking income from anyone: it has the power to simply create money to buy output from some people to give to others. It could, for example, provide a job guarantee at a living wage for everyone who wants to work and direct those jobs toward socially useful activities, such as the green transition or providing care (Wray et al., 2018). How does Marxist policy analysis differ? While the goals of full employment, green transition, and the universal provision of care are shared by Marxists, the conception of how to achieve them is significantly different, and the theory of money is an important part of it. Marxist economic theory postulates the unity of social relations of production and distribution. Printing money, while operationally feasible, is a small part of tackling inequality, the climate and care crisis, and the other evils of contemporary capitalism. There is no real hope of achieving these aims without a radical shift in the economic formation of society that involves income and wealth redistribution. For Marxists, taxation and income transfers are a legitimate part of government policy even when real resources are lying underutilized. Moreover, a systemic response to the social problems created by capitalism would require a profound transformation going far beyond monetary policy, or a Job Guarantee. It would involve property rights, above all, expropriating capitalists and rentiers and creating a democratically planned society with radically different ways of producing and distributing. Socialism is necessary, not just a version of capitalism with better distribution and employment. Monetary sovereignty and World Money Finally, on the issue of monetary sovereignty, MMT advocates generally treat the lack or limitation of such sovereignty as a self-imposed ordinance by several nation-states (Tcherneva, 2016; Tymoigne, 2020). According to Wray (2019), monetary sovereignty comprises of: i) the national government choosing a unit of account; ii) the national government imposing obligations denominated in that unit of account; iii) the national government issuing currency in that unit of account and accepting it in payment; iv) the national government issuing other obligations denominated and payable in national currency; and v) a flexible exchange rate. For Marxist political economy, monetary sovereignty depends on the relationship between capitalist accumulation in a nation-state and the ability to acquire world money, which in turn reflects a country’s place in the world market. The need for world money becomes clear once we consider capitalism as a global system, as it is needed for commodity transactions, the transfer of value, and the settlement of obligations among different parts of the world. The passage from the national to the international realm is a major problem for neo-Chartalist theory as there is no supranational state choosing units of account or having the power to tax at the international level. The capacity to acquire world money necessary for participation in the world market differs dramatically among nation-states, and thus the global monetary system is hierarchically structured. In contemporary capitalism, one country, the U.S.A., issues quasi-world money, subject to competition by others. The lack of monetary sovereignty for other countries, far from being a policy choice, results from their subordinated position in the international hierarchy. This is particularly relevant for analysing economic policy in developing countries, where MMT prescriptions lose much of their appeal (Bonizzi et al., 2019; Prates, 2020; Vernengo & Caldentey, 2019).

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – Infrastructure

Infrastructure jobs cause detrimental ecological challenges – the work exploits resources and energy

Hoffmann & Paulsen ‘20 [a Department of Socioeconomics, Vienna University of Economics and Business, Vienna, Austria] “Resolving the ‘jobs-environment-dilemma’? The case for critiques of work in sustainability research, Environmental Sociology”, 6:4, 343-354, DOI: 10.1080/23251042.2020.1790718 () // marlborough-am//

Fourthly, the factor Work-induced Mobility, Infrastructure, and Consumption concerns ecological impacts that work induces structurally, independently of the labour process itself. Work-induced Mobility comprises phenomena such as commuter traffic or business travel; mobility that only exists because work necessitates it. Notably, it needs to be fast, i.e. energy-intensive, owing to business-people’s busyness and employees’ time constraints (Feenberg Citation1999). Work-induced Infrastructure includes built infrastructure such as office buildings, factories, warehouses and industrial estates, their water, power and heating/cooling supply, ancillary power plants, roads, tracks and parking sites, as well as technical and supportive service infrastructure. This infrastructure is built and maintained only for the purpose of allowing abstract work to ‘take place’, which is ecologically problematic due to its land, resource and energy consumption (Torisson Citation2017). Work-induced Consumption entails purchases of goods and services like work clothing, second cars, or daycare centres; consumption that would be needed considerably less if work was reduced. It also includes compensatory consumption to recompense for stressful, meaningless, alienating, or ‘bullshit’ work (Graeber Citation2018; Gronemeyer Citation2012). The additional employment generated for the provision of all these goods and services (Graeber Citation2018) may be described as work-induced work, with all the ecological impacts as described.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – Green Tech/GND

“Green jobs” offered by GND have inherently capitalist ideals which prioritize economic development and productivity.

Hoffmann & Paulsen ‘20 [a Department of Socioeconomics, Vienna University of Economics and Business, Vienna, Austria] “Resolving the ‘jobs-environment-dilemma’? The case for critiques of work in sustainability research, Environmental Sociology”, 6:4, 343-354, DOI: 10.1080/23251042.2020.1790718 () // marlborough-am//

However, problem definitions and proposed ways forward are contested.Approaches under the notions of ‘sustainable work’, ‘decent work’, or ‘green jobs’, lately often as part of a ‘Green New Deal’, mostly follow the political agenda of continued economic growth, industrial development, and (labour) market expansion worldwide, under the guiding principles of development and the ‘green economy’ (ILO Citation2012, ILO Citation2015; UNDP Citation2015; UNEP Citation2008). These notions regard work and rising labour productivity as ends in themselves. They usually focus on ‘green jobs’ in certain sectors and their ‘green growth’ prospects, while taking the compatibility of sustainability, job creation, and technologically advanced industrial growth economies for granted (Bowen Citation2012).Other (yet related) approaches are normatively motivated in a more subtle manner. Two cases in point are environmental labour studies and the debate on ‘Just Transition’. Environmental labour studies focus on work and environment from the perspective of labour organisations and their relation to ‘nature’ also under the global green economy agenda, but partly with a critical stance towards the latter (e.g., Barca Citation2019; Barth, Jochum, and Littig Citation2016; Hyde and Vachon Citation2019; Lundström, Räthzel, and Uzzell Citation2015; Räthzel and Uzzell Citation2013; Rosemberg Citation2010; Stevis, Uzzell, and Räthzel Citation2018). Through their common ideological grounding in Marxist theory – disregarding Marx’ famous discussion of the ‘realm of freedom’ beyond labour and the necessity to shorten the working-day – work is taken for granted in the Marxist notion of work as an ‘eternal natural necessity’ and as something inherently good to be secured and expanded (an interpretation predominating in the Marxist and socialist tradition).Footnote3 Accordingly, it needs to be reconciled with ecological concerns, but not be questioned as a potential part of the problem. The debates on ‘Just Transition’ for example are selective about who deserves justice and on what grounds, and the priority lies clearly with the industries and workers immediately affected (Hyde and Vachon Citation2019). Contributions like these also underrate the scale of ecological challenges by focusing on certain ‘green’ sectors and too often disregarding, or disproportionately downplaying, the sectors that cannot be ‘greened’ and need to be reduced or discontinued entirely (ILO Citation2012).

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – Green Tech/GND

Tech innovation causes surveillance and strengthens the capitalism.

Naughton ’19 [John, professor of the public understanding of technology at the Open University, 1-20-2019. “'The goal is to automate us': welcome to the age of surveillance capitalism.” The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/jan/20/shoshana-zuboff-age-of-surveillance-capitalism-google-facebook; JFan]

The headline story is that it’s not so much about the nature of digital technology as about a new mutant form of capitalism that has found a way to use tech for its purposes. The name Zuboff has given to the new variant is “surveillance capitalism”. It works by providing free services that billions of people cheerfully use, enabling the providers of those services to monitor the behaviour of those users in astonishing detail – often without their explicit consent.

“Surveillance capitalism,” she writes, “unilaterally claims human experience as free raw material for translation into behavioural data. Although some of these data are applied to service improvement, the rest are declared as a proprietary behavioural surplus, fed into advanced manufacturing processes known as ‘machine intelligence’, and fabricated into prediction products that anticipate what you will do now, soon, and later. Finally, these prediction products are traded in a new kind of marketplace that I call behavioural futures markets. Surveillance capitalists have grown immensely wealthy from these trading operations, for many companies are willing to lay bets on our future behaviour.”

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – Green Tech/GND

The Green New Deal is a refining of neoliberalism’s power using the façade of grassroots and leftist rhetoric to garner an ascetic of radicalism.

Alexander M. Stoner, 04 Jun 2020, (“Critical Reflections on America’s Green New Deal: Capital, Labor, and the Dynamics of Contemporary Social Change”, ) #Gay Frog

Aside from denial, the more rational options available to confront GCC (e.g. cutting emissions through renewables, financial tax and/or getting rid of subsidies for fossil fuel companies) were explicitly stated or implied in the House Resolution for Green New Deal (GND hereafter), submitted by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 7 February 2019.2 The GND illustrates the entry of climate change politics into the U.S. political mainstream and represents the most comprehensive attempt to confront related issues within this domain to date. The House Resolution seized upon the urgency of the twin economic and ecological crisis. Its action plan emphasized the importance of incorporating both indigenous peoples and deindustrialized communities. Of concern for the purpose of this paper is the twin crisis of labor and the environment, which I shall return to elaborate on below. Although the measure died in the Senate the following month, its issues promise to live on, and therefore warrant further examination. The GND had three main goals: (1) achieve net-zero emissions through a fair and just transition for communities and workers; (2) create jobs; (3) invest in sustainable infrastructure and industry. Its action plan included public investment for the public good, including public banks and other public financing. The language of the GND harkens back to the 1930s moment, albeit with a 21st century ecological imperative, implying that a return to the 1930s moment, or at least the approach to social problems that prevailed during this time, is desirable and possible. But is this the case? The 1930s New Deal administration put an end to the U.S. tradition of federal minimalism, and its policies were necessary to save the U.S. from the destructive effects of finance capitalism (Dahms 2000). The changing relations between large investment banks and the federal government in turn, enabled the reconfiguration of business-labor-government relations that took hold following WWII. The post-WWII configuration of business-labor-government relations facilitated the economic boom associated with capitalism’s so-called “golden age”—a “productivist” approach to development later criticized by U.S. environmentalists. With the development of Keynesian state planning and economic coordination, the U.S. was able to overcome the decline in industrial output that beset the 1930s. The shift toward Keynesianism allowed capital to institutionalize a variety of productivity deals that linked increasing wages and profits to increasing productivity. Technological change geared toward steady productivity growth was fostered by collective bargaining and industrial union contracts as well as tax and investment policies of the state. Workers’ struggles for less work and more pay could be funded with increased investment and increasing productivity. What appeared to be a potentially destabilizing political atmosphere soon turned into a corporate endorsement of Keynesianism and conservative power realignment, as labor’s support of the New Deal administration’s social democratic affinities gradually inverted from 1945 to 1980 (Stoner and Melathopolous 2015). The tremendous advancements in productivity and related forms of accumulated knowledge that fueled the post-WWII approach to economic development in the U.S. accelerated environmental degradation and facilitated the growth of contemporary environmentalism. New environmental needs and desires emerged based on the growing recognition that a productivist industrial society is not adequate to the well-being of the natural environment. As the post-WWII form of “economic growth” expanded, environmental critics questioned its necessity. The targets of environmental discontents during the 1960s—namely, technology and affluence counter-positioned against finitude (e.g. “limits to growth”)—reflected this problematic. However, much like the labor unrest of the 1930s, the social crisis of the 1960s, including the crisis associated with the rise of contemporary environmentalism, was readily stabilized. By 1970 environmentalist concerns in the U.S. had become integrated into the system it sought to oppose (Stoner and Melathopolous 2015). Environmental discontents merged with the administrative state or became managed via class action lawsuits; social order was maintained while the underlying destructive processes continued. As the end of the 20th century unfolded, the integration of environmentalism paralleled the shift toward neoliberal capitalism—illustrated, for example, by the shift away from previous criticisms of “limits to growth,” which prevailed during the peak of monopoly capitalism, and toward a form of market environmentalism, according to which market mechanisms provide the best means of protecting the environment. The premise of market environmentalism—the autonomous eco-consumer—perniciously reflects competitive, individualistic value systems, i.e. the absence of social solidarity. At present, it is not clear how the social norms of cooperation and solidarity necessary for effective international GCC mitigation strategies might emerge as an effective counterweight to the cutthroat individualism characteristic of U.S. capitalism. While those on the Right may suffer from “structural amnesia,”3 without seriously confronting the underlying dynamics driving social change, some environmental advocates, including supporters of the GND, risk downplaying the transformations of capitalism, especially the impact these changes had on culture, politics, and identity formation.4 Such historical distortions problematically preclude insight into the limitations and possibilities of related contemporary initiatives. One must bear in mind that the U.S. House Resolution may not reflect the politics or ideologies behind it. It is also important to consider how the GND is mediated by politics itself. While such a consideration is beyond the scope of this paper, it is likely that the House Resolution is authored through comprmise and strategic thinking rather than a straightforward expression of what proponents at the grassroots want. The GND, as an ideological expression, reflects this compromise. Within the wider historical context of the GND, grassroots politics has arguably pulled the federal-level conversation to the left.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Jobs Guarantee › Link – Green Tech/GND

Advocating for green tech without tackling the fundamental systemic issues merely results in another form of capitalism which strengthens the grip of capitalism and reinforces its inherent damages.

Prudham ’9 [Scott, Department of Geography and Centre for Environment, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M5S 3G3, Canada, 1-1-2009. “Pimping Climate Change: Richard Branson, Global Warming, and the Performance of Green Capitalism.” Sage Journals. https://doi.org/10.1068/a4071; JFan]

On 21 September 2006 UK u«ber-entrepreneur and Virgin Group Chairman Richard Branson pledged approximately »1.6 billion, the equivalent of all the profits from Virgin Atlantic and Virgin Trains for the next ten years, to fighting climate change. Since then, Branson has restated his commitment to action on global warming, including investment in technologies for sequestering carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. In this paper, I critically examine and engage with Branson's announcements as a specific entre¨e into a dialog about so-called `green capitalism'. I am particularly interested in the role of the entrepreneurial subject in environmental policy and environmental action. There are glaring problems associated with green capitalism as a mash-up of environmentalism with capitalism. One of these is the tethering of environmentalism to a political economy whose mantra is growth for growth's sake, or, in Marx's terms, accumulation for accumulation's sake. This has been discussed by some as the problem of capitalism's ecological metabolism or `metabolic rift'. Yet, while accumulation for accumulation's sake may well be anathema to progressive environmentalism and sustainability, I argue that this is not only an objective, quantitative problem but also one of the qualitative dimensions of produced nature and the cultural politics of environmentalism. Appreciation of this can be gleaned by reexamining Marx's discussion of the role of the bourgeois subject in the relentless drive to reproduce and expand capital accumulation via anarchic, entrepreneurial investment. Green capitalist orthodoxy relies on this source of innovative dynamism, but in the process obscures or overlooks the fact that accumulation for accumulation's sake is by definition guided by the anarchic and amoral search for profitable realization of surplus value. Moreover, in order for green capitalism to succeed, its legitimacy must be secured. I argue that this legitimacy derives in part from specific performances of green capitalism by entrepreneurial elites, also made evident by Branson and his commitments to climate action. All of this raises questions about the political, cultural, and ecological character of green capitalism, issues brought to the fore by Branson's brand of climate activism based on his status as the quintessential post-Thatcher entrepreneur. He is a `model' post-Keynesian entrepreneurial subject in a neoliberalized economy of opportunity, particularly but by no means only iconic in the UK. Branson is thus a rare example of the business elite with a large climate footprint who has embraced action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. But, in addition, Branson's announcements also suggest a synthesis or fusion between celebrity entrepreneurialism, on the one hand, and climate change policy, on the other. This fusion in the context of climate politics and policy is a specific thrust in the wider movement toward so-called `green capitalism': a set of responses to environmental change and environmentalism that relies on harnessing capital investment, individual choice, and entrepreneurial innovation to the green cause. No environmental challenge is now more salient, and thus no item on the green capitalism agenda is more important, than global warming. In the words of prominent green capitalism advocate and President of the Environmental Defense Fund Fred Krupp, ``We've put Earth at the brink of climate calamity, thanks to rapid industrialization and market forces. That's part one. The sequel is how we get out of this fix. I believe it's those same forces, innovation and profitöand nothing elseöthat can stop global warming'' (Griscom Little, 2008). There is every possibility that Branson's championing of action on climate change will deepen commitments to meaningful attempts to abate greenhouse gas emissions, and also bolster efforts to redress the expected impacts of climate change. This is important. Global warming and its expected impacts constitute a serious issue, with potentially catastrophic implications for the poorest people of the world (Parks and Roberts, 2006; Roberts, 2001). Nevertheless, this paper is a critique of Branson's announcements and the notion that they are somehow a `good thing'. I seek to add to an emerging critical literature on the role of cultural elites in the fight over climate change (eg Boykoff and Goodman, 2008; Gajda and Kieffer, 2007). However, my focus is specifically on the elite bourgeois subject as a subset of the phenomenon. Drawing on Branson's example, I interrogate the would-be `green capitalist' in order to elucidate some aspects of and challenges to this particular brand of elite-led action in the climate policy arena, issues that, in turn, speak to the central but somewhat overlooked role of the entrepreneurial subject in the political and cultural logic of green capitalism more broadly. The paper features two interrelated arguments. First, Branson's announcements (particularly the first one) point to a central contradiction in the green capitalist agenda. This agenda pivots in large measure on the problematic suggestion that more sustainable futures can be secured via capitalist investment and entrepreneurial innovation. Whatever truth there may be in particular cases, this obscures the relentless, restless, and growth-dependent character of capitalism's distinct metabolism, an argument most closely associated with the work of Bellamy Foster (Clark and York, 2005; Foster, 2000), but which draws in turn on Karl Marx. The metabolism critique rightfully identifies a tendency in capitalist political economies for aggregate throughput of material and energy to grow, outstripping any efficiency gains (ie the so-called `Jevons paradox'). But accumulation for accumulation's sake also entails dynamic confrontation, transformation, and redefinition of material, social, and cultural conditions in ways that confound coherent articulation of any notion of fixed `limits' (including ecological ones) to continued expansion. This essentially qualitative problem originates in the microeconomics of the entrepreneurial subject who is compelled to accumulate on an expanded scale if only to reproduce himself or herself. What results is a systemic logic of the production of new natures integrally connected to the production of space and uneven development more generally (Smith, 2008 [1984])öby the anarchic, restless drive to accumulate capital as an end in and of itself. Thus, I argue that, when thinking of capitalism's so-called `biospheric rift' (Clark and York, 2005), it is crucial to attend not only to quantities of aggregate material and energy throughput, but also to issues of quality. Secondly, focus on the elite entrepreneurial or bourgeois subject points to the need for a politico-cultural perspective on green capitalism as a sort of `drama' which must be performed. That is, the viability of green capitalism is not only an `objective' question of whether or not entrepreneurial energy, unleashed by neoliberalized green markets, can give rise to sustainable technoeconomic trajectories. Rather, it is also a political agenda whose viability turns on whether or not capitalism and environmentalism are seen subjectively to be compatible. Seen in this way, green capitalism has interwoven material semiotic dimensions (Haraway, 1997), one central facet of which is the `performance' of the entrepreneurial subject as environmental crusader. Performances such as Branson's not only stage the political and cultural fusion of capitalism and environmentalism as green capitalism; they also act to augment the economic foundations of bourgeois power by making the entrepreneur a central figure in climate policy, and, by extension, environmentalism.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › M4A

Healthcare expansion increases and centralizes the power of wealthy elites through stratifying access to coverage on macro, meso, and micro levels.

Adele E. Clarke et al. 2003 (Professor of Sociology and of History of Health Sciences at the University of California, San Francisco) “Biomedicalization: Technoscientific transformations of health, illness, and U.S. biomedicine” April 2003. May 28, 2017. (http://search.proquest.com.proxy.library.umkc.edu/docview/218770736?pq-origsite=summon&accountid=14589)

CENTRALIZATION, RATIONALIZATION, AND DEVOLUTION OF SERVICES. Centralization of facilities, health-care services, and corporate health-care coverage has been on the rise through the merger and acquisition of hospital facilities, insurers, physician groups, and pharmaceutical companies. This has resulted in the loss of many community, public, and not-for-profit facilities that either could not compete or were acquired expressly for closure. The underlying objectives are to boost the efficiency and uniformity of services, to centralize and rationalize decision-making about service provision, to capture more markets and arenas of health for profit, and to exert greater economic control within these arenas. In practice, Foucauldian panoptical patterns of physical decentralization with administrative centralization are common (Foucault 1975, 1991). These patterns are greatly facilitated by meso-level computer and information science practices and programs that automatically monitor highly dispersed developments for centralized management operations. Although such health-care consolidations bring some efficiency, they also pose numerous dangers as a result of corporate concentration. Such dangers include, for example, inflationary tendencies from the concentration of pricing power, new administrative burdens, and the enhanced political power of conglomerates. Such consolidations now exert significant leverage over political and regulatory processes, as well as decision-making that affects provider groups, patient care, and service options in highly stratified ways (Waitzkin 2001; Waitzkin and Fishman 1997). For example, in Northern California recently, Blue Cross (a health insurance company) and Sutter Health (a for-profit corporatized provider network) were locked in contractual conflicts over reimbursement rates. Because of Sutter's acquisition of large numbers of health-care facilities in the area, it was able to effectively deny services to many Blue Cross subscribers by not accepting Blue Cross insurance, eventually compelling the insurer to agree to higher rates. Devolution of health-care services also demonstrates the trend toward rationalization. That is, there are attempts to routinize and standardize health services while also shifting increasing proportions of the expensive labor of hands-on care to families and individuals (Timmermans and Berg 1997). Outpatient surgery, home health care, and elaborating subacute care facilities (e.g., skilled nursing facilities, nursing homes) are a few examples of devolution. Devolution also contributes to the fragmentation of health care and its geographic dispersal, making rationalizing more difficult. STRATIFIED BIOMEDICALIZATION. Morgan (1998) recently reasserted the unevenness and instabilities of medicalization processes, reminding us that medicalization was not monolithic and unidirectional but heterogeneous and fraught with paradoxical problems of exclusion, inclusion, participation, and resistances. Such arguments were initially elaborated in Ehrenreich and Ehrenreich's (1978) critical elucidation of the dual tendencies of medicalization. The first tendency, cooptative medicalization, refers to the jurisdictional expansion of modern medicine-extending into areas of life previously not deemed medical. The second tendency, exclusionary disciplining, refers to the simultaneous exclusionary actions of medicine that erect barriers to access to medical institutions and resources that target and affect particular individuals and segments of populations. Historically, these dual strategies have stratified the U.S. medical market by race, class, gender, and other attributes. For example, cooptative tendencies have long predominated for white middle- and upper-class groups, especially women, while exclusionary tendencies or particular kinds of cooptative medicalization (such as provision/imposition of birth control and sterilization) have prevailed for peoples of color and the poor (Riessman 1983; Ruzek 1980; Ruzek, Olesen, and Clarke 1997). Medicalization was stratified, and so too is biomedicalization. We term the reformulation and reconstitution of such processes in the biomedicalization era stratified biomedicalization.10 The cooptative and exclusionary tendencies noted above persist and become increasingly complex, and new modes of stratification are also produced. Even as technoscientific interventions extend their reach into ever more spaces, many people are completely by-passed, others impacted unevenly, and while some protest excessive biomedical intervention into their lives, others lack basic care. Such innovations are far from the goal of universally accessible and sustainable health care promoted by some bioethicists and others (e.g., Callahan 1998). Even rationalization itself is stratified, producing fragmentation. For example, availability of routine preventive care, screening services, pharmaceutical coverage, and "elective" services such as bone-marrow transplants or infertility treatments are differentially available depending on one's health insurance plan, or lack thereof. There are still over 1,000 different insurers in the United States, all providing different kinds of coverage, and thus, as a whole, the system is highly uncentralized, inefficient, and uncertain-the very things that, in theory, rationalization attempts to eliminate. In 2001, the share of the population wholly uninsured for the entire year rose to 14.6 percent or 41.2 million people up from 14.2 percent in 2000 and an increase of 1.4 million people (Mills 2002:1). In 2001 and 2002, about 75 million people under age 65 went without health insurance for at least one month; nearly 3 in 4 were in working families and more than half were white (Meckler 2003:A4). Cutbacks in government coverage of medical care are also widespread, and are being made in concert with reductions in a range of social services that affect the health status of individuals and groups down-stream. There has even been research on the efficacy of group medical appointments for the poor instead of (or with) short individual examinations (McInaney 2000). Such gate keeping becomes ever more imperative in efforts to make economic profits from increasingly expensive and highly technological procedures, and from providing services to less desirable but financially still necessary markets and population groups. At the same time, there are dramatic increases in stratifying fee-for-service options for those who can afford them. The most common and affordable alternatives are choosing high-end preferred providers through such an insurance plan. Here providers to whom you pay a higher co-payment are often more available (within weeks rather than months) and may have better reputations. Some plans offer high-end hospital options-you pay more to go to certain "better" hospitals. Out-of-pocket boutique medicine options usually range from cosmetic surgeries to new reproductive/conceptive technologies to some organ transplants. In addition, there are emerging options for "boutique or concierge primary care" based on privately paid annual fees to individual physicians in private practice. Here, individuals pay providers an annual amount (from a few thousand dollars to many thousands of dollars). In return they get appointments within 24 hours and for longer durations than the average patient, cell phone and e-mail access to their physicians, house calls, and so on. High-end versions (at about $13,000 per year) are located in chic spa-like offices with marble baths, terry robes, and complete privacy, and are being organized through franchises. This "concierge" model is popular with wealthy seniors, people with chronic illnesses, and the youthful rich (Heimer 2002). In short, even "good" medical insurance no longer ensures good primary care. In sum, the politico-economic transformations of the biomedical sector are massive and ongoing, ranging from macro structural moves by industries and corporations to meso- and micro-level changes in the concrete practices of health and medicine. Not only do such transformations produce new and elaborated mechanisms through which biomedicalization can occur, but also biomedicalization, in turn, drives and motivates many of these economic and organizational changes.

2023 CNDI Kritik
Negative › Social Security › M4A

Capitalist health provision guarantees increasingly worse health outcomes for marginalized populations while creating the conditions for a health bubble collapse. State action is only stabilizing the system through imperialist expansion.

Lee HUMBER 17, former special needs teacher currently working as a tutor in Health and Social Care at Ruskin College, Oxford [“Neoliberalism and the crisis in health and social care,” International Socialism, June 29, 2017, http://isj.org.uk/neoliberalism-and-the-crisis-in-health-and-social-care/]

The huge cost of US healthcare is serviced by individual expenditure, with the average “healthcare consumer” now facing far greater financial exposure to medical costs. Between 2010 and 2015, employees’ contributions to health insurance grew almost three times faster than wages. Recent research showed that so-called “middle class” Americans are feeling this burden the most—their healthcare spending as a percentage of household income has increased 60 percent since the 1990s with their healthcare costs now almost half of a typical mortgage payment.29 Americans are going into debt to service health insurance, spreading health costs to the financial sector more generally.30 This rising cost of healthcare has seen share prices in health-related industries soar. In 2017 three vast health conglomerates were in the top 10 of the US Fortune 500. As a result, US health industries have never been as powerful, or as rich. In the Fortune 500 the three health companies—at numbers five, six and seven—are each richer than former market giants such as General Motors and AT&T. Health market leader McKesson is a pharmaceutical distributor also concerned with the development and distribution of health technologies—a kind of health Walmart. At number six, United Health, largely a health insurance provider has, it is estimated, over 100 million customers globally. An accelerating context of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) has accompanied and further facilitated this process.31 The tendency for capital to evolve into a smaller number of large, industry-specific companies, has been recognised from capitalism’s beginnings and the process is currently very much in evidence in health. Health industry mergers in the US have been accelerating over the last 10 to 15 years, peaking in 2015 and 2016. The total reported deal value of M&A in the US health industry in 2016 was $71.7 billion.32 That was down 59.6 percent from 2015, the record year for M&A in the sector when the figure, in excess of $100 billion, was equivalent to over a third of the total UK GDP for that year.33 This is—on a somewhat smaller scale—a worldwide phenomenon. As I show below, mergers and acquisitions have been actively promoted by UK governments. This growing tendency towards merger in the US as elsewhere is a process of what Karl Marx called the “centralisation of capital”, the coming together of individual capitalists into fewer, larger conglomerates. This article discusses this process in full in the section below looking at the concentration and centralisation of capital in the UK health and social care context. Here, it is important to recognise that the centralisation of capital is an important tendency identified in capital formation in its imperialist phase. In the US the trend towards, and the capitalists’ rationale for actively promoting and pursuing M&A, was outlined at the beginning of the 21st century, when it was argued that “facing the drivers of change—deteriorating public health, poor quality and safety, and unaffordable health care—the industry is poised to experience convergence among the major suppliers”.34 “Poor quality and safety” here refers to the fact that US hospitals increasingly represent a danger to your health. In 2013 medical errors in hospitals were the leading cause of preventable death in the country, accounting for nearly a quarter of all preventable deaths that year, beating smoking and obesity-related illness into second and third place.35 In 2005 it was estimated that there were over 98,000 preventable deaths each year in US hospitals, costing the system over $38 billion annually.36 The point also refers to the seemingly uncontrollable and utterly unethical practices of global drug companies, extensively documented by Ben Goldacre and others, with drug companies routinely hiding data seen as problematic to the development of new drugs, while laws remain largely toothless to prosecute them even if such data and practice is exposed.37 These are some of the, if you like, material reasons put in defence of the ongoing M&A trend. The financial press is littered with claims of the benefits for US workers’ health of the ever-expanding, though fewer in number, health conglomerates.38 Global expansionist sentiment is the other driver of health industry dominance, and capital is currently being sucked into the health industry as never before by the promise of the growing potential of a global health market, which has been called the “Rising Billions”39 This is the idea that, over the next five years, between three and five billion new consumers will be connected to the internet for the first time and are reachable by internet and mobile devices. The rising billions are consumers of goods and services, but are also patients in need of medical care and therefore potential customers for health-related commodities, so called “health customers”. An example of this health technology salesmanship is the “Hemafuse” autotransfusion device. Currently being touted across sub-Saharan Africa and elsewhere, Hemafuse helps patients to deal with internal bleeding, as the advertising literature says “perhaps from a car accident or a complication during pregnancy”.40 In order to survive, patients need to have their blood removed, filtered and returned. As the publicity for Hemafuse claims, the simple device allows even untrained persons safely to treat internal bleeding. No need to call on the services of potentially expensive—or non-existent—health and social care workers, with your own Hemafuse, perhaps bought cheaply via eBay, your next door neighbour could help you with your internal bleeding problems! It sounds ridiculous, but this kind of “blue sky” thinking is currently contributing to the sky-rocketing market in US health industry shares. Technological innovation, fenced by grubby, unscrupulous hucksters, is driving this forward, unsupported by case study, ungoverned by ethical practices of any rigour. Alongside the physical technologies outlined above, eHealth systems are a massive growth area in the US and elsewhere. eHealth covers a broad field including systems of communication between health practitioners: remote health monitoring (many people already use such devices—Fitbit for example—to monitor their own physical wellbeing), and virtual consultations between doctors and other professionals and patients. The list of technologically-driven change seems endless and without boundaries. If we move to virtual consultations then why not use call-centres of doctors based in areas around the world with low labour costs? You can see why the brokers are salivating. Some of the consequences of this technologically-driven approach in the UK context are already evident. Jay Stickland, director of Southwark Council’s adult social care department, is quoted in the Financial Times extolling the virtues of using motion detectors to replace care workers in older people’s homes: “We could pop in [to see someone] at lunchtime, at one o’clock. [But at] five past one, she could be on the floor. So there’s no real value to this”.41 And, of course, once you move to a motion detector system of monitoring patients or service users more broadly, there’s no need for monitoring staff to be in the same borough or city, or even the same country. Why not employ the cheapest staff around the globe, as other industries have already done? Potentially, with a smaller care staff on standby locally, the monitors can raise an alert when a crisis arises in a “just-in-time” approach to healthcare delivery! In later texts, Marx talks about the drive towards technological advance inherent in capitalism, and the labour-saving machinery produced by it potentially eliminating arduous labour for future societies.42 But ­technological advance under capitalism, as Marx was at great pains to point out, primarily aims to replace some workers while increasing the rate of exploitation of those left. Marx describes the three “circumstances” of exploitation rates—the length of the working day, or the extensive magnitude of labour; the intensity of labour, or its intensive magnitude, and the overall productivity of labour.43 In the global health industry, manipulation of all three of these is currently evident, in differing combinations in different geopolitical circumstances, underpinned by and reinforcing austerity, technological changes and the centralisation of capital. The increased potential for a quick profit resulting from this is sucking finance capital into US health like never before. Some commentators at least are uneasy about this: What is larger than the UK’s entire economy, soaring in price, wildly profitable, the leading cause of personal bankruptcy, bankrupting the United States and a massive economic bubble that nobody has heard of yet? Healthcare in America…a modern-day gold rush is on as young Americans clamour for healthcare careers in the same way that young adults were jockeying for technology careers at the peak of the Dot-com bubble in 1999.44 The threat of a health bubble collapse makes previous industry collapses—like those in the US auto and building industries—seem like child’s play in comparison. The US auto industry contributes around 3.5 percent of US GDP and employs 1.7 million people. This industry was deemed “too big to fail” so the US government bailed it out, investing around $80 billion from 2009 to 2014 to keep it from collapsing. Healthcare is five times larger than the auto industry in terms of its percentage contribution to GDP, and is ten times larger in terms of the number of people it employs. It’s estimated that any comparative bail-out of the health industry would cost the government upwards of $400 billion.45 Already, the health industry has a parasitic relationship with the US state, dependent on it to open up new international markets. US military interventions around the globe have made areas “safe” for health industry expansion. Countries including Iraq and Afghanistan, others in the Middle East and parts of Africa are considered regions worthy of US health industry investment.46 Writing in 1917 Nikolai Bukharin wrote: In the epoch of finance capitalism…the centre of gravity is shifted to the competition of gigantic, consolidated and organised economic bodies possessed of a colossal fighting capacity in the world tournament of “nations”. Here competition holds it orgies on the greatest possible scale, and together with this there goes on a change and a shift to a higher phase in the process of capital centralisation. The absorption of small capital units by large ones, the absorption of weak trusts, the absorption even of large trusts by larger ones is relegated to the rear, and looks like child’s play compared with the absorption of whole countries that are being forcibly torn away from their economic centres and included in the economic system of the victorious “nation”.47 The interests of the US state are in many ways already partially fused with those of the US health industry and the finance capital driving its expansion, and together these contextualise an increasingly impoverished home country and the increasing subjugation of foreign lands. Sounds like Victorian Britain. Trump’s “America First” rhetoric and anti-globalisation tone might be perceived as representing a potential threat to the future profitability of these health behemoths, and with it a potential threat to the wellbeing of the US economy itself. A collapse of the US health industry would be disastrous for US capital generally; meanwhile its profitability is teetering on the razor edge of a globalised eHealth promise.