Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › BIG solves degrowth

UBI solves by recentering labor around care instead of production.

Frenzel 21 [Max (PhD), "Universal Basic Income, Degrowth, and the Future of Work," Medium, 7-27-2021 , GDI, TS]

Just as in a society where AI is replacing most routine jobs, so too in a degrowth society will creative, emotional, and care work play a central role. One tool that could support this is the introduction of a Universal Basic Income (UBI). Currently, a large fraction of care work goes entirely unpaid, such as the work of a stay-at-home mother, or someone taking time off to care for their elderly parent. UBI would support these people and remunerate them for their work. It would also generally facilitate wealth redistribution to those who decide to contribute to society through currently unpaid “jobs” like care or creative work. In practice, UBI would be financed as an additional tax. For those above a certain wealth or income threshold, this tax will be higher than the benefit they receive from UBI. As such, it could serve to shrink the wealth gap. According to Kallis, “Spain suggests that a basic income of €400–600 per month could be funded through increased taxation, leaving the after-tax income of the middle classes unchanged, redistributing from the very rich to the very poor.” A universal basic income is also not necessarily an incentive to be lazy and not work, as many people think. Unlike unemployment benefits, you still receive UBI even if you work. As most of us have probably realized at one point or another, doing nothing gets boring quickly, and many people opt for much more active — and productive — forms of leisure if given a chance. UBI takes some risks away from trying an uncertain and challenging pursuit. In situations of scarcity, whether that’s money or time, we lose the big picture view and only see the very next thing. The scarcity places a high cognitive load on us. Our focus narrows to solely the next item on our to-do list. Creativity and big breakthroughs become impossible. The support of UBI would help alleviate this. It is very likely that the arts, entrepreneurship, and moonshot thinking would flourish as a result.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – solvency › EBI [BI solves environment] › Solvency – general

EBI fosters post-productivist model – working conditions, squo unpaid work,

Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20

[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]

While a productivist model gives greater social and moral value to paid work and is interested in having as many individuals as possible performing a paid job, a post-productivist model is focused on the promotion of personal autonomy. As such, all the gains from the increase of productivity should serve to significantly reduce the amount of hours that societies commit to labour, increasing individuals’ discretionary time, i. e. the “time the use of which is not dictated by the ‘necessities of life’”, such necessities being divided into three realms: economic, social, and biological (Goodin, Rice, Parpo, & Eriksson, 2008, p. 34). For advocates of post- productivism, labour would be a matter of social choice, whereby many people could opt for a more relaxed way of life (Goodin, 2001, p. 15).7 Advocates of ecologism would certainly support the post-productivist approach, as removing the social relevance of a paid job and promoting the autonomous sphere is part of most of the ecological and degrowth accounts.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Race › BIG – solves racial capitalism

Basic income transforms approach to security – reorienting our understandings of racial capitalism and justice to address climate change crisis

Taiwo Olufemi, Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University 2021 [“Universal Basic Income, Racial Justice, Climate Justice” LPE Project 02/15/21 7/11/23 CB]

Basic income could play a key role in reorienting how our social systems answer this century’s most basic political question: who and what will be secured when crisis strikes? It is encouraging, then, that the Movement for Black Lives policy platform made it one of its initial proposals, while building reparations into the program and its larger political perspective. These ideas fit well together in any era, but especially our era – one marked by the present scourge of racial capitalism, the coming climate crisis, and the grave risks for justice that their intersection will pose over the next century. The Undercommons, an activist group in Los Angeles I was a part of, advocated for this aspect of the Movement for Black Lives proposal in 2017. To explain why we thought basic income was connected to racial justice, we appealed to two distinctions: one in what’s meant by “security” and the other in what kind of proposals for basic income would advance the cause of justice.The first distinction is between antagonistic security and collaborative security. Antagonistic security is security from other people: security that is created for some by the exclusion and/or precarity faced by others. As racial capitalism has developed, increasingly large and professionalized institutions perform much of the work of producing antagonistic security for those atop society’s racial and other hierarchies: the settler militia becomes the state military, the slave patrol becomes the police. Climate crisis could put these into overdrive as states, corporations, and social elites look to increasingly punitive and violent means to protect their increasingly precarious investments and social position. This stands in contrast to another approach to securing society and the freedom of those who depend upon it: collaborative security. Collaborative security is security with other people, the kind that mass vaccination schemes provide a community that develops herd immunity. A social system secured collaboratively relies, in the default, on providing the kind of protection accomplished with and often through protection of others. This is the kind of protection we could right now develop, for example, with a successful global effort to vaccinate as widely and deeply throughout our populations as possible. Our current love affair with antagonistic security prevents us from reaping the rewards of this alternative model. This is the kind of protection put at risk by the efforts of the richer countries of the world to hoard the vaccines and the efforts of multinationals like Pfizer-BioNTech and AstraZeneca to hoard the profits with the backing of the World Trade Organization (Moderna, for what it’s worth, pledged not to enforce its patents).

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Race › Racial stereotypes

UBI addresses the racial stereotypes of welfare programs- lessens inequality

Bidadanure, Assistant Professor of Political Philosophy, 2019

[Juliana Uhuru, “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income”, Annual Review of Political Science, March 5, access info [https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-polisci-050317-070954#_i15] accessed 7/13/2023 GDI- JY] 

Last, but not least, UBI could help disrupt the racial tropes and racial resentment pervasive around the existing welfare system. Negative racist stereotypes of lazy black youth and welfare mothers have important consequences. For a start, they force those in need to think twice before claiming benefits, the risk of stigmatization and demonization being high. This explains in part low take-up rates. Racial tropes also serve to shame recipients to keep them in check and incentivize them further to find employment. Furthermore, there is now ample evidence that racial resentment contributes to low support for welfare. Even when programs do not in fact benefit nonwhites more than whites, the myth of the lazy black recipient contributes to a welfare backlash. The pervasiveness of racial stereotypes is thus concerning both because demonized populations are less likely to enjoy the full benefits of assistance and because it contributes to a welfare backlash that is worrying from a progressive perspective. A universal income support system would be less likely to stigmatize the target population, since all members of the community would get a UBI. If benefits are destigmatized, those worse off are less likely to suffer self-respect harms and to drop out of programs they require to live well. The recent conversation on UBI and race, as well as the conversation that took place in the 1960s among those resisting racial injustices, have not been sufficiently picked up in the political theory literature. Except for Shelby's (2012, 2017) contributions, little has been written on UBI from a racial justice perspective. And yet there are central issues at the intersection of racial justice and UBI that also happen to resonate with broader issues in the UBI field. One of them is the tension between equality, on the one hand, and universality, on the other. For inequalities to be corrected, we tend to think that reducing the gap between advantaged and disadvantaged is the way forward. Basic income is universal—it is aimed at all, including those well off. Targeting, therefore, seems to be more on the side of equality than universality. This basic issue has led a lot of progressives to disregard the policy as inefficient, at best, or wasteful, at worst.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Race › Racial wealth gap

Racial gap exists – discrimination and effects persist over generations

Mineo, Harvard Staff Writer, 2021 [Liz, “Racial wealth gap may be a key to other inequities”, Harvard Gazette, June 03, access info [https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2021/06/racial-wealth-gap-may-be-a-key-to-other-inequities/] Accessed 7/12/23 GDI- JY]

Most scholars agree that the legacy of slavery and other subsequent forms of legal discrimination against African Americans have hindered their ability to accumulate wealth. “Today’s African American adults and children are living with the legacy of discrimination, inequality, and exclusion, from slavery to redlining and other discriminatory practices,” said Killewald. “And in turn, white Americans are benefiting from legacies of advantage.”The typical white American family has roughly 10 times as much wealth as the typical African American family and the typical Latino family. In other words, while the median white household has about $100,000-$200,000 net worth, Blacks and Latinos have $10,000-$20,000 net worth. Depending on the year or how it’s measured, those numbers may change, as shown by a report by the Pew Research Center, but the wealth racial gap has continued for decades. “It’s a staggeringly large number,” said Killewald.The divide persists across generations, said Killewald, who researched the subject with co-author Fabian Pfeffer of the University of Michigan in an article that included striking visualizations. One of them shows that Black parents tend to have much lower wealth than white parents, and that Black and white children tend to follow the wealth position of their parents, reproducing inequality across generations. The study concludes that “today’s black-white gaps in wealth arise from both the historical disadvantage reflected in the unequal starting position of black and white children and contemporary processes, including continued institutionalized discrimination.”

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Race › Racial inequality

UBI closes the racial wealth gap- two warrants

Bidadanure, Assistant Professor of Political Philosophy, 2019

[Juliana Uhuru, “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income”, Annual Review of Political Science, March 5, access info [https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-polisci-050317-070954#_i15] accessed 7/13/2023 GDI- JY] 

The contemporary proposal for UBI on grounds of racial justice comes from Dorian Warren (2016) in the Movement for Black Lives' manifesto. Under most UBI proposals [excluding those that would overall reduce the benefits available to the worse off, like Charles Murray's (2016)] those most disadvantaged stand to benefit most. Since black families in the United States are disproportionately found at the bottom of the wealth and income distribution, and since unemployment is twice as high among black workers as among white workers, black families stand to gain most from the policy. Warren (2016) also argues that the proposal's commitment to universality would make[s] it harder for governments to exclude felons and ex-felons from the safety net. Under a system designed to target the deserving and screen out the undeserving, those tied up in the criminal justice system would be more easily excluded. This is important for racial justice given the overrepresentation of people of color in prisons, and given the discrimination experienced by ex-convicts in the labor market.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › AT targeted BI for homelessness only

Universality is key to resolve stigma of support programs and ensure long-term viability of the program – research proves

Clarke, lecturer in sociology at the University of New South Wales, 2022

[Andrew, “Can a basic income help address homelessness? A Titmussian Perspective”, Journal of Sociology, November 15, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/14407833221135986 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

Beyond addressing the structural drivers of homelessness, I argue that a BI can also help increase support for, and reduce the stigma and blame arising from, responses to homelessness generally. One way a BI will do this is by replacing targeted measures with a universal one that benefits, and thus will enjoy the support of, a broader political constituency. As colleagues and I have argued elsewhere, governments – and by extension publics – tend to support actions to address homelessness when these actions produce benefits for the broader community (Parsell et al., 2020). This can be seen in the willingness of even conservative governments to invest in expensive housing first programs because these programs are shown to produce overall savings to taxpayers (Culhane, 2008; Parsell et al., 2017). It can also be seen in the large-scale investment in accommodating the homeless during the Covid-19 pandemic because this group was identified as a potential source of virus transmission and thus a threat to public health (Parsell et al, 2020). Given a BI would be paid to everyone on an individual basis, more people would have a stake in its continuation, unlike the targeted measures that support people experiencing or at risk of homelessness alone. A BI is also less likely to attract the stigma that is attached to existing targeted measures for addressing homelessness. As noted above, research on BI-like measures that involve broad-based payments show that these are perceived as more ‘normal’ by publics than targeted measures, because they do not mark out their recipients as uniquely needy or deficient (Calnitsky, 2016). A BI would thus constitute an important break with prevailing liberal responses to homelessness, which (a) are highly targeted and restricted to minimise the possibility of dependence and market disengagement (Evans et al., 2021); and (b) treat homelessness as the product of individual pathologies or proclivities, and thus attract substantial stigma (Farrugia & Gerrard, 2016; Mitchell, 2011; Willse, 2015). In this way, a BI is superior to existing measures used to address the income side of the housing affordability problem in liberal welfare regimes, such as rental subsidies and vouchers (see also Kerman, 2021, pp. 6–7 on this point). These measures are typically highly targeted (through means tests and assessment of individual needs/pathologies) Clarke 13 and thus mark out their recipients as problem individuals, leading to stigmatisation and discriminatory treatment. Indeed, research shows that users of housing vouchers, such as the Section 8 housing voucher in the United States, experience significant stigma and discrimination from private landlords (Desmond, 2016). Voucher holders are perceived as ‘riskier’ tenants and thus struggle to compete with other renters in tight rental markets, despite having the same capacity to pay. A BI is also superior to simply increasing existing income support payments (although this would certainly be a positive development). For, such a move does little to combat the divisions and resultant stigma produced by these measures and which Bauman (2005) argues are a core reason why they have deteriorated to such an extent in the first place.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › UBI – Homelessness

UBI provides critical support for female-led households and childcare

Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021

[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

UBI may also have unique implications for preventing family homelessness. Many families experiencing homelessness are female-headed with young children who become homeless due primarily to financial instability (Grant et al., 2013; Sylvestre et al., 2018). The unaffordability of child care can keep low-income women out of the workforce and without the income needed to sustain their tenancies (Gulliver-Garcia, 2016; Polillo & Sylvestre, 2021; Rabiah-Mohammed et al., 2020). Mothers of young children in the NIT experiments reviewed by Gibson et al. (2020) were found to have reductions in workforce involvement. The authors theorized that this was due to mothers using the cash payments as de facto paid maternity leave, which was often unavailable to women in the studies. As paid maternity leave is linked to better maternal mental health (Aitken et al., 2015), UBI has the potential to concurrently strengthen the housing stability and mental health of families at-risk of homelessness by providing sufficient income to engage in instrumental, unpaid work activities, such as child care.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › UBI – Homelessness

UBI solves many sources of mental health problems that can lead to homelessness

Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021

[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

Mental health problems can play a prominent role in many pathways into homelessness. Substance use problems, psychosis, mood and anxiety disorders, trauma symptoms, and personality disorders are each independently associated with increased risk of becoming homeless (Nilsson et al., 2019). High rent burden, which refers to spending a greater percentage of one’s income on housing costs, can also produce chronic stress (Padgett, 2020) that increases vulnerability for developing or exacerbating mental illness or substance use problems (Brady & Sinha, 2005). Accordingly, improving mental health and well-being has implications for preventing homelessness. Income is a key social determinant of mental health (Allen et al., 2014; Sareen et al., 2011). As found in the scoping review by Gibson et al. (2020) and Finnish pilot experiment (Kangas et al., 2020), UBI and NIT schemes had positive, interconnected effects on mental health and financial well-being. The financial security generated by a guaranteed livable income may not only improve the mental health of people with low incomes and high rent burdens but also those with serious mental illness who face an increased risk of homelessness.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › UBI – Homelessness

UBI solves housing access & stability and reduces housing discrimination

Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021

[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

A fundamental part of the experience of homelessness is a lack of choice and control; people’s freedom over where they live, what and when they eat, and where they go each day is limited (Kerman & Sylvestre, 2020; Nicholls, 2010). As people look for housing, their options are often restricted by their low incomes, further perpetuating their homelessness or forcing them to accept inadequate or unsafe housing that does not meet their needs (Fisher et al., 2014; Tischler, 2008). By providing cash payments that are sufficient to live on (i.e., payments would be greater than existing income support program rates) and are not scaled back during episodes of homelessness, UBI could offer a pathway out of homelessness by promoting more housing choice and control. Instead of people feeling that they need to accept the first available housing option out of desperation, the increased funds could provide people with several options from which to choose, including not only subsidized units but also affordable market rent housing. Past research has shown a positive relationship between housing choice and stability, albeit a weak association that may be time limited (Srebnik et al., 1995; Tsai & Rosenheck, 2012). A sense of control in housing has also been linked to an increased likelihood of housing sustainment (Boland et al., 2018). Accordingly, there is a continued need to prioritize interventions that promote housing choice and control for people experiencing homelessness, or have that potential, as is the case with UBI. Another way that UBI may foster housing choice is by reducing landlords’ discrimination against people experiencing homelessness. For example, in the U.S., landlords have been found to discriminate against individuals who hold housing choice vouchers, despite this group causing no more problems than tenants without vouchers (Tighe et al., 2017). Income source-based discrimination in housing could be prevented by the universality of UBI, as all prospective tenants have a common income source. It is important to note that many people experiencing homelessness encounter multiple forms of housing discrimination (e.g., related to race and ethnicity, gender identity and sexual orientation, family composition, unemployment, history of involvement in the criminal justice system; Ecker et al., 2019; Paul et al., 2020; Walsh et al., 2016) that extend beyond income source and for which UBI may have less of an effect. Accordingly, on its own, the impacts of UBI on housing discrimination are more likely to be incremental than transformative.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › UBI – Homelessness

Through its inclusionary nature, UBI will be of more aid in assisting homeless people in escaping houselessness

Kerman, project scientist at Campbell family mental health institute, 2021

[Nick, “The Role of Universal Basic Income in Preventing and Ending Homelessness”, International Journal on Homelessness, September 28, https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/ijoh/article/view/13337 7-13-2023 GDI-SPB]

Most existing income support programs in North America function on the basis of means testing. That is, people must meet eligibility criteria, whether it be having an income and assets below a designated threshold, having a verifiable and accepted disability, having a sufficient history of involvement in the workforce, agreeing to actively look for a job and returning to the workforce, or another requirement. Means testing produces categorization of people with deleterious consequences; a person in need is either deserving or undeserving (Moffitt, 2015). People who do not meet the values-based criteria of income support programs are excluded (Lowrey, 2018). People who are not disabled enough, are not poor enough, are not old enough, are not able to work enough, or have not previously worked enough are deemed not deserving enough and are left to fend for themselves. Rejection or termination of income support can precipitate and perpetuate homelessness (Wallace et al., 2006; Zlotnick et al., 1999). As a universal cash payment, UBI would do away with means testing, preventing the exclusion of people based on neoliberal values. UBI would provide a buffer against homelessness by ensuring that people have a stable source of income that is not affected by one’s able-bodiedness or labor market noninvolvement, nor would it be terminated due to changes in life circumstances (e.g., acquisition of a job, improvement in an episodic mental illness). Further, some existing income support programs in North America have allowances for housing and shelter costs. If people do not have housing and shelter costs, which is often but not always the case in the context of homelessness, they do not receive the allowance – another form of means testing. By providing cash payments that do not fluctuate as a result of housing status, UBI would enable people experiencing homelessness to save the money that would have been allocated to paying rent or living costs. Like the New Leaf project that provided a large, lump sum cash payment to people experiencing homelessness (Foundations for Social Change, 2020), accumulated UBI income during homelessness could help people to afford a rent deposit (e.g., first and last month’s rent) and expedite exits out of homelessness.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › BIG Solves Housing

BIG stabilizes precarious housing situations, especially for those denied access to rental assistance

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

Many housing subsidy programs are designed to prevent worst-case housing scenarios, such as homelessness, especially for populations whose needs are deepest, like people with mental illness and few resources. However, as noted above, a substantial portion of first-time homeless are people experiencing short-term financial shocks due to often hard-to-predict financial setbacks like job loss, divorce, or health crises (Ellen and O'Flaherty 2010). Given the many barriers to access inherent in categorical housing policies, cash infusion may be the most efficient mechanism for stabilizing households who struggle to pay the rent on only a transitory or intermittent basis but who cannot easily access standard housing supports because of eligibility gaps and long waiting lists. In turn, this could relieve stress on emergency solutions like homeless shelters and transitional housing. As noted by İmrohoroğlu and Zhao (2021), “Economic theory [could] help us design mechanisms that will reduce the flow to homelessness for the fraction of the population who become homeless due to bad shocks. If such polices could be useful, then the burden on the system to deal with the rest of the homeless population would be more manageable.” A look at data emerging from research on flexible rent subsidies provides a glimpse into how cash might be the most finely tuned instrument for helping families who are currently housed but remain one shock away from homelessness. A flexible subsidy allows renters to decide how much of the subsidy to spend each month, up to their total rent. This flexibility can be particularly valuable for workers whose earnings fluctuate, such as seasonal workers and those in the gig economy, who have been especially hard hit this past year.22 Typically, local housing entities send flexible rent subsidies directly to landlords. Among the most rigorously studied of these programs is Project Independence in Alameda County, California. Project Independence is a shallow rent subsidy program with services coordination support for people with very low incomes living with HIV or AIDS. On average, participants were paying 68 percent of their monthly income on rent before receiving the subsidy, and 42 percent of their monthly income on rent with the subsidy. Although most Project Independence participants remained at least moderately rent-burdened, the subsidy was sufficient to keep them stably housed. Two years from the baseline survey, 96 percent of Project Independence participants were still in rental housing, versus 10 percent of the comparison group. Over the five-year study period, the average time in rental housing for Project Independence participants was 3.9 years versus one year for the comparison group. Thus, although the shallow subsidy left most participants moderately rent-burdened, it appeared to be sufficient for keeping them stably housed. However, the authors noted that unobserved differences between the treatment and control groups, such as prior rental history, may help explain the stark differences in housing stability (Cunningham and Leopold 2014).

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Housing/homelessness › BIG Solves Housing

BIG solves housing instability – cuts bureaucratic nightmare of rent assistance programs

Bogle et al, principal research associate at MHCPC, 2022

[Mary, “Guaranteed Income as a Mechanism for Promoting Housing Stability”, Urban Institute, December 30, https://www.urban.org/research/publication/guaranteed-income-mechanism-promoting-housing-stability, 7-11-2023 GDI- SPB] 

Some in the housing advocacy and research fields argue that, given the often slow pace and high costs of affordable housing development, allocating a greater balance of limited resources to direct cash subsidies for rent-burdened households could be a far more efficient and cost-effective means of getting housing relief to families experiencing the deleterious effects of ongoing rent burden. As one pilot leader said, “I think [approaching] housing affordability with rent assistance programs, [such as HCVs and emergency rental assistance], has been really helpful. But I think if you talk to families about the rent assistance program, it is a bureaucratic nightmare and a hardship.” The argument goes that getting a direct payment to a cost-burdened family addresses their cost differences right now, rather than leaving them languishing on waiting lists, funneling their payments to landlords, or giving them “vouchers to nowhere.” Roger Valdez, director of the Center for Housing Economics and a research fellow at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, a leading proponent of cash as a housing solution, writes, Direct cash payments mean fewer operating costs, financing costs, and construction costs assumed by funding agencies and taxpayers. Cash payments for housing would mean letting the private sector take on more of the risk and costs but still help families who need housing without having to buy land and build. A finely tuned cash-based program could also allow families to set aside money in a savings account if their income increases over time, allowing them to capture some of the subsidy for a future home purchase or for college expenses. Now these payments and other costs savings would mean the cadre of attorneys, consultants, and tax credit syndicates would lose money for their own operations. But is that a priority? Instead a cash benefit system could be part of an overall improvement in efficiency and empower families with more cash, cash that could, with support, mean getting them out of poverty in the long term. We’ve forgotten that subsidized housing, in most cases, ought to be about ending the cycle of poverty, not perpetuating an expensive unit-building, bureaucratic machine.34

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Solves – independence for women

UBI has a laundry list of advantages— social and economic.

Kowalska, Wroclaw University of Economics and Business, 2023

[Milena, “Impact of the unconditional basic income on the professional situation of women”, Financial Internet Quarterly, 3-17-2023, https://sciendo.com/pdf/10.2478/fiqf-2023-0009 accessed 7-13-2023 GDI- SB]

Philosophers, sociologists, and economists consider unconditional basic income. Supporters of the introduction of unconditional basic income mention among the advantages and motivations (Fitzpatrick, 1999; Offe, 1996; Van Parijs, 1992; Frase, 2018):

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Solves – independence for women

UBI empowers women in the labor market and in households

Kowalska, Wroclaw University of Economics and Business, 2023

[Milena, “Impact of the unconditional basic income on the professional situation of women”, Financial Internet Quarterly, 3-17-2023, https://sciendo.com/pdf/10.2478/fiqf-2023-0009 accessed 7-13-2023 GDI- SB]

The introduction of a UBI would recognize socially helpful work as equivalent to paid work. People taking up unpaid work could do it for more time because they would have a livelihood. This could encourage work that is not paid in a market economy, such as volunteering and charity work (Nawrocka, 2018). It would also support people who look after the home, children, or people with disabilities and contribute to women’s emancipation in the labor market (Pateman, 2003). In western culture, women take up professional activities but less often work full-time, earn less, and work in less prestigious positions. Men in households often play the role of "free riders" who do not perform household chores and benefit from unpaid work performed at home by women (Pateman, 2003). That is why feminist circles are more and more often in favor of a UBI, believing that this benefit favors feminist postulates more than any other because it enables the realization of individual preferences, making it independent from the requirement of participation in formal social relationships (such as marriage or family). The financial independence guaranteed by the UBI would allow women to reconcile their work and parental responsibilities (women would not be forced to work full time, as this part of the income would be provided by a social grant), would allow them to free themselves from the compulsory guardianship of tyrant husbands (also in times of crisis related to with material difficulties, such as divorce or single child-rearing), would neutralize the male-centered bias in the labor market and possible injustices of a bureaucratic and administrative nature (Karalus, 2015). Therefore, more and more often, feminist circles support unconditional basic income, they believe that this benefit favors feminist postulates more than any other because it enables the economic independence of women and it is an element of emancipation. Not only can women gain an income that can keep them safe, but they will also be able to engage more in public and political life as the link between living standards, and employment will be weakened. Thanks to this instrument, the perception of work as purely paid work would change. The efforts made by women, among other things, in caring for children, the sick, and the disabled could be appreciated. However, there is a risk that it may also strengthen the gender division of labor. Women who receive an unconditional income and are homemakers anyway may stop looking for paid work and engage in unpaid domestic activities even more. On the other hand, men, encouraged by women's presence at home, will be even less involved in housework.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Caregiving

Unpaid caregiving furthers gender wage gaps and crushes Social Security money

Hess et al, COO at the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, 20

[Cynthia, “Providing Unpaid Household and Care Work in the United States: Uncovering Inequality”, Institute for Women’s Policy Research, January 2020, https://iwpr.org/providing-unpaid-household-and-care-work-in-the-united-states-uncovering-inequality/ 7/12/23 GDI- SC]

The disproportionate share of unpaid household and care work that women perform has a range of costs for them, including employment and economic costs. Caregiving takes time, and when caregiving duties become extensive, many caregivers cut back time in paid work (Lilly, Laporte, and Coyte 2007), in part because the high cost of paid care makes it unaffordable for many families (Hess et al. 2015). Most caregivers who reduce their hours at work or step out of the paid labor force altogether are women (U.S. Department of Labor 2018b), since for many families it makes economic sense for the woman to be the one to reduce her time in the paid workforce, given women’s lower average earnings. While some women may want to reduce their hours at paid work to spend more time with children or other family members who need care, for others the “choice” to not participate in paid work is constrained by the impossibility of meeting the demands of both their paid employment and their family’s needs (Hegewisch and Lacarte 2019). A lack of family-friendly work policies in many workplaces, such as paid family and medical leave and paid sick days that would allow one time off from work to care for a sick child without penalty, exacerbates the challenges many workers face in meeting both family care and work demands, and results in lower rates of labor force participation for women in the United States compared with other high-income countries (Blau and Kahn 2013).

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Caregiving

Squo caregiving expectations both increase stress and destroy women’s careers

Hess et al, COO at the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, 20

[Cynthia, “Providing Unpaid Household and Care Work in the United States: Uncovering Inequality”, Institute for Women’s Policy Research, January 2020, https://iwpr.org/providing-unpaid-household-and-care-work-in-the-united-states-uncovering-inequality/ 7/12/23 GDI- SC]

Spending time on care for elders or children can be satisfying and a source of considerable happiness. Connelly and Kimmel (2014) find, however, that while parents often enjoy spending time caring for their children, fathers are much more likely to enjoy such time than mothers. This is possibly because for fathers the time spent on unpaid care is more likely to represent a positive choice and less likely to have come at the cost of dialing back career advancement. At the same time, fathers report growing work-family conflict, which may be partly a result of lower social acceptance in the sphere of employment for their role as care providers (Connolly and Kimmel 2014). While both women and men may want to provide more care for their children or for other family members, without adequate resources and external supports their provision of this care can lead to significant stress.

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Internal link – racial and gender inequality

Systematic exclusion of groups ensures wealth disparities

Bhattacharya, vice president of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development, 19

[Jhumpa, “EXPLORING GUARANTEED INCOME THROUGH A RACIAL AND GENDER JUSTICE LENS”, Roosevelt Institute, 6/19/19,) , accessed 7/11/23 GDI- SC]

Historical Policies and Practices

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › Internal link – racial and gender inequality

Racial and gender disparities are ingrained within squo standards of wealth and inequality

Bhattacharya, vice president of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development, 19

[Jhumpa, “EXPLORING GUARANTEED INCOME THROUGH A RACIAL AND GENDER JUSTICE LENS”, Roosevelt Institute, 6/19/19,) , accessed 7/11/23 GDI- SC]

WEALTH: THE TRUE INDICATOR OF ECONOMIC STABILITY

2023 GDI Affirmative
Case – advantages › Gender and Gender diverse people › LGBTQ – advantage

Fleming, Senior Writer at the World Economic Forum, 2021

[Sean, A Californian City Gave Californian People $500 With No Strings Attached. Here’s What Happened, WeForum 5/15/2021, , 7/14/23, GDI-CB]

Giving people money can encourage them to become more economically productive. This seemingly counterintuitive conclusion is one of the findings of a real-life trial of the consequences of universal basic income (UBI) programmes – where people receive a regular payment, usually from the state. Around 150 kilometres east of San Francisco lies the city of Stockton, population 300,000, which was . In 2019, an organization called the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration (SEED) was established to administer UBI to 125 low-income residents of the city. Each of the for two years. The project’s findings indicate that the additional money has been beneficial in a number of ways.Mental and physical well-being improved, with reductions in depression and anxiety recorded. Households were able to avoid or limit their exposure to financial ups and downs often experienced by low-income families, especially in the event of unexpected costs. SEED found that those in the UBI trial “experienced clinically and statistically significant improvements in their mental health ... moving from likely having a mild mental health disorder to likely mental wellness over the year-long intervention”. But one of the most potentially significant findings was that people in receipt of the $500 UBI payments were more likely to find full-time employment. At the start of the project, in February 2019, 28% of the UBI recipients were in full-time work. That had risen to 40% a year later. The SEED trial included a control group, not in receipt of the payments. In that control group, full-time employment increased by 5% over the same period.UBI is a contentious issue for some people. Milton Ezrati, who is described as a Wall Street veteran, dismissed the idea of UBI as “wrongheaded” in Forbes, in 2019. He refers to a “study of people on unemployment (that) discovered, for instance, that ”.Ezrati is far from being a lone voice when it comes to criticism of UBI. The UK’s Centre for Social Justice, a think tank set up by former government minister Iain Duncan Smith, ”. The former mayor of Stockton, California, Michael D Tubbs would most likely disagree. “Poverty is the biggest issue. Everything we deal with stems from that. There’s so many people working incredibly hard, and if life happens, there’s no bottom,” he states in the report on the first 12 months of the SEED trial. SEED has been anonymously tracking participants’ spending. It found that the biggest target of spending was food. Non-food purchases at supermarkets, large stores and wholesale outlets was the next largest. Transportation costs and utility payments were another large part of the spending breakdown. Alcohol and tobacco accounted for less than 1% of spending. As well as the increase in the number of people working, the SEED researchers found that recipients were able to make long-term choices about their lives and livelihoods. The report quotes a man in his mid-30s who had been “eligible for a real estate license for more than a year, but could not afford taking the time off work to complete it. With the $500, he says that his life was ‘converted 360 degrees… because I have more time and net worth to study… to achieve my goals’”.There are also examples of people being able to pursue training or internship opportunities, as the additional $500 income meant they were able to quit low-paying, dead-end jobs. UBI schemes have been trialled in several places around the world. A scheme currently operating in South Korea makes lower monthly payments via a localized form of currency. In Gyeonggi Province, which surrounds the capital Seoul, recipients of the $220 quarterly payment get their money via a special bank account that that have registered to support the scheme. The payments have a use-by expiration date, too, meaning they cannot be stockpiled or saved. Instead, the money circulates into the local economy.