2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › Redistribution Good
Havers, Trinity Western University PhD professor, 2020
[Grant, August 10 2020, Law and Liberty, “Nozick’s Radical Logic of Reparations,” https://lawliberty.org/nozicks-radical-logic-of-reparations/, July 2 2023, ah]
Locke’s idea of reparation, then, applies only to those who are either a first or second party to an exchange of property, not a third party. This implication would be too restrictive, according to Nozick, who rejects Locke’s idea that mixing one’s labor with the land somehow gives one greater entitlement to it. Nozick also finds it necessary to supplement Locke’s defense of property rights by pointing to the problem of injustices that go far back in time. Specifically, he contends that those who are made “worse off” as a result of an unjust acquisition of property are entitled to rectification, although he is vague on details. Nozick writes:
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › Redistribution Good
Lindsay, Brink, CATOs vice president of research, 2002 [Against The Dead Hand: The uncertain Struggle For Global Capitalism, Page 56]
Just as business enterprises operate within the larger economic order of the market, so the market system itself is situated within a larger political order. It is a crude mistake to equate free markets with the mere absence of government. On the contrary, markets only function properly by virtue of institutions created and maintained by government. Most fundamentally, markets rely on the elaboration and enforcement of basic property and contract rights. When property titles are insecure, and contracts are not reliably enforceable, the large-scale, long-term investments on which so much of wealth creation in modern society depends are discouraged and underdeveloped. Also, specialized rules for sophisticated commercial dealings must be structured properly if the wealth-creating power of competition is to fulfill its potential. Poorly designed rules on such matters as intellectual property, corporate governance, and bankruptcy can exert a significant drag on market performance. A sound legal framework for the market order includes a considerable amount of regulatory activity typically associated with "activist" government. Thus, safeguarding persons and property from harm is sometimes better accomplished by preventive health and safety regulation than by waiting for harm to occur and then assigning liability. Also, in areas where property rights are inherently difficult to define clearly (for example, with respect to. air quality), enforcement of standards by regulatory agencies can be the best or even the only practicable approach. In the commercial sphere, requirements to disclose financial information can prevent fraud and boost investor confidence. And restrictions on collusion and monopoly can help to preserve competitive vitality. The smooth functioning of the competitive market system thus requires the vigorous exercise of government powers. But securing this great public good does not necessarily exhaust the efforts of government in a liberal polity. Government may promote other public goods as well'—for example, care for the needy, education, conservation of the natural and cultural heritage, promotion of scientific research, and the construction of "safety nets" to ease dislocations caused by economic fluctuations and structural change. In a free society, a vibrant independent sector—neither profit-oriented nor governmental—will arise to provide these and other public goods. But because the independent sector provides social benefits regardless of the beneficiaries' ability or willingness to pay for them, it can encounter significant free-rider problems. Accordingly, it is possible for government, through its taxing and regulatory powers, to support and supplement private efforts and thereby ensure that public goods are provided more comprehensively and systematically.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › Property Rights Wrong- Unjust Acquisition
Exdell, K-State Philosophy Professor, 1977
[John, January 1977, Ethics Vol 87 No. 2, “Distributive Justice: Nozick on Property Rights,” https://www.jstor.org/stable/2380062?seq=2, July 3 2023, ah]
-Author Emphasis Applied
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › Property Rights Wrong- Unjust Acquisition
Bishop, Trent University Business Admin Prof, 97 [John Douglas, Retired Business Administration Professor, PhD in Moral Philosophy @ Edinburgh U., “Locke's Theory of Original Appropriation and the Right of Settlement in Iroquois Territory,” CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY 31 1 Volume 27, Number 3, September, p. 311-337 https://www.jstor.org/stable/40231987, Accessed 7/16/23]-grh
James Tully and others have argued recently that the theory of property Locke defends in the Second Treatise was designed to justify European settlement on the lands of North American Natives.1 If this view becomes generally accepted, and Tuck suggests it will be,2 doubts may arise about the impartiality of Lockean property theories. Locke, as is well established and documented again by Tully, had huge vested interests in the European settlement of North America and possibly in the enslavement of Native Peoples. Doubts about Locke may reflect on all rights theories of property and thus bring into question 'one of the major political philosophies of the modern world' (Tully, 'Rediscovering America/ 165). Raising these doubts is part of Tully 's declared intention (Tully, 'Rediscovering America/ 166). His article tries to show that the Native systems of property and government which Locke define illegitimate are in fact interesting and potentially beneficial alternatives to Lockean individual rights theories. In this paper I will accept Tully's scholarship on the purposes of Locke's property views and Tully's claims about the benefits of considering Native alternatives. There is, however, a philosophical issue which arises out of this which Tully does not systematically consider. Neither biased origins nor unpleasant consequences proves a theory of rights incorrect. The question is this: when 'Locke defines property in such a way that Amerindian customary land use is not a legitimate type of property,'3 does he have good arguments to establish his case? In other words, given our improved understanding of Native systems of prop- erty,4 it is time to reassess the philosophical underpinnings of Lockean rights theory to see if Locke has successfully refuted Native rights claims to land ownership. If not, then Native property rights may not only be an alternative to Lockean property theories; they may be justified by Locke's own principles. Did Locke get his theory of property rights wrong, and /or did he apply it incorrectly to the European settlement of North America? There may be a need to adjust Lockean-style property rights theory to eliminate Eurocentric and unjustified assumptions. The purpose of this paper is to look at this issue. The aim, of course, is to identify unjustified assumptions; Eurocentrism is a good reason for suspicion but is not in itself grounds for rejection. The technique used in this paper to assess the possible Lockean basis of Native property claims will be to ignore Locke's views on the 'proper' use of land and return to what Tully calls the 'background premis[es]' of Locke's argument (Tully, 'Rediscovering America,' 173). The result of this exercise will be to show that Native property claims can be justified on Lockean grounds unless Eurocentric assumptions, including an assumption in favor of certain farming techniques, are built into the argument as background premises. The implication of this result for current rights theories of property are briefly indicated.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › Property Rights Wrong- Unjust Acquisition
Bishop, Trent University Business Admin Prof, 97 [John Douglas, Retired Business Administration Professor, PhD in Moral Philosophy @ Edinburgh U., “Locke's Theory of Original Appropriation and the Right of Settlement in Iroquois Territory,” CANADIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY 31 1 Volume 27, Number 3, September, p. 311-337 https://www.jstor.org/stable/40231987, Accessed 7/16/23]-grh
The application of Locke's labor theory of original appropriation to Iroquoian land at the time of contact makes clear that Locke's concept of property rights was more narrow and Eurocentric than his own premises and arguments allow. Accepting Locke's background premises, we can conclude the following: (a) Enclosure need not be physical, but can be legal even prior to the establishment of government. (b) Private property ownership need not be by individuals. Family or group ownership should be recognized. (c) Investment of labor for improvement need not mean permanent improvement. (d) Care of the land and its resources by restraint establishes private property in the same fashion as labor for improvement. Accepting these conclusions would change the nature of property rights that are established by Lockean style arguments of original appro- priation. There is, however, a further major implication for contemporary uses of original appropriation arguments such as Nozick's or Narveson's. By resorting to Locke's background premises, we have been able to conclude that the Iroquoian at the time of contact already owned both the land they used for agriculture and their hunting grounds. To overturn this conclusion, it would have to be argued both that these lands were still the common property of humanity (i.e. that the Iro- quoians had not established private property rights by original appro- priation) and that the Lockean proviso was not violated by European settlement. To do the latter, the proviso must be interpreted in such a way as to establish that farming has rights over hunting.
It has not been shown in this paper that similar arguments apply to other indigenous peoples and their claims to owning territory, but it is worth examining the status of original appropriation arguments based on this assumption. Since humans have occupied all significant land areas of the planet earth for at least the last ten thousand years, if the property claims of indigenous peoples are recognized as having a Lockean basis, it follows that there has been no significant original appropriation for many thousands of years. European ideas of settling vast 'empty' and 'wasted' continents was based on a failure to see, or a dismissal of, the land uses of indigenous peoples. Original appropriation in not a historical fact. What then is it? The onus clearly is on those who use it to explain; here I will only indicate three possibilities compatible with the conclusions of this paper. First, original appropriation might be a hypothetical case elucidating certain logical aspects of the nature of property rights. Locke's use of the argument has been interpreted in this fashion.46 Locke, on this interpretation, was trying to show that property rights are prior to, and not based on, the contracts that created civil society and government. A hypothetical theory of original appropriation would show that such a view of property was coherent; this would help establish this theory of property, even if the hypothetical nature of original appropriation would mean that no specific property claim could be based on it. Second, even if original appropriation has no historical basis, it could be used to clarify or help define property rights. It is generally recognized47 that property rights are actually a cluster of rights which can be defined in various ways. A non-historical theory of original appropria- tion could be viewed as an attempt to show that any acceptable definition of the right to property must recognize a certain relationship between laboring to improve a piece of land and owning it. On this interpretation, actual historic processes are irrelevant; the theory only says that we ought to treat current property owners as though they acquired the property in a line of succession from people who settled the land by investing their labor in improving it. Finally, we can transfer to original appropriation Waldron's theory48 of the social contract as a template that allows normative judgment to be passed on actual historical processes. On this interpretation, original appropriation establishes a normative relationship between labor and land ownership which can be used to judge the actual treatment of property in specific historical situations. This would allow us to judge, for example, the European settlement of North America, and pass normative judgment on the process by judging how far the process departed from the ideal version of original appropriation. How a non-historical theory of original appropriation is interpreted would have to depend on the use it is put to. But any use needs to be consistent with the failure of Lockean arguments to establish a right of settlement by European farmers on lands used by Native Peoples at the time of contact.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI = Ethical Redistribution- Rawls
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” , Accessed 6/30/23, EP]
Today, a middle or upper-class person who does not need UBI may ignore the concept. However, if the same person were asked to build a new just society without knowing his or her position, he or she would not be too reckless about UBI as he or she was before the experiment. Here we observe a behavioral transformation in the approach to UBI and justice in general. The individual's self-interest (starting to consider UBI in the next unknown society) may also play a role in these circumstances. A Turkish proverb, “bana dokunmayan yılan bin yıl yaşasın,”6 is a significant sociological and psychological analysis related to the example. When the snake starts biting, that is another case to evaluate.
Immanuel Kant also mentions careful thinking when it comes to moral decisions. Kant is a philosopher who advocates for a particularly severe view of the role of emotions in moral life (Rohlf, 2013; Warburton, 2011). For Immanuel Kant, one should decide what is moral and immoral based on the principles of “kategorischer Imperativ”7 . From a Kantian perspective, if anyone supports Universal Basic Income as they feel pity or sadness for poor people, this is not an ethical standpoint. The proper ethical standpoint should not derive from emotion but a rational mind and the responsibility of duties.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI = Upgraded Capitalism
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” , Accessed 6/30/23, EP]
To sum up, we can call UBI an upgraded version of capitalism with socialist characteristics. This case is similar to the early 20th century when Sidney Webb and his wife Beatrice Webb formulated the idea of "The National Minimum" - today's concept of minimum wage. Webb (1911), a socialist, has mentioned that this minimum wage proposal is only for the necessary basis of a healthy society. It works for either Individualist or Collectivist systems. With his explanation, I think he wanted to persuade the reader that minimum wage is not an evil socialist idea (in 1911, this was a helpful remark), but an efficient way to run capitalism - if this is the way we will continue. In retrospect, the role of minimum wage must have played a significant role in the success of capitalism in the 20th century. UBI is not just a cash transfer. It also means that people will face less stress for their employment choices. In many senses, UBI is compatible with trade/labor unions. The minimum wage example shows that UBI is not the first proposal to upgrade capitalism 15 with socialist-like features. Fifty years later, economists and policymakers may evaluate UBI as a “minimum wage" proposal, a successful extension of capitalism.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI prevents Coercion by Employers
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” , Accessed 6/30/23, EP]
Marx (1844) wrote: “Labor produces not only commodities; it produces itself, and the worker as a commodity. The object which labor produces – labor’s product – confronts it as something alien, as a power independent of the producer”. UBI can be harmonious with Marx's theory of alienation because UBI recipients will have the possibility to choose a job that suits and treats them better. Therefore, they will be more emotionally attached to their jobs and will not feel foreign to the products of their labor. It is, for human dignity, fundamental to find meaning. It is also good and safe for the society that its members find meaning in their lives. It is also possible that people will start to work as an option, not an obligation, which would make them feel psychologically better. UBI can create the opposite effect of alienation. UBI improves mental health, increases motivation and job performance (Mahabir et al., 2021). As a result, it is beneficial for both employee and employer. Obviously, for Marx, UBI can not erase the problem of alienation because the workers will still not own the means of production and they will create surplus value for the capitalists. Under capitalism, labor will always stay as a commodity.
Moreover, UBI would be constructive to overcome the exploitation of labor and increase the bargaining power of employees. This is also one of the main arguments of Erik Olin Wright (2006) in support of UBI as he claims the bargaining position of individual workers will increase with the socialist features of UBI. These would still not satisfy Marx because UBI can not singlehandedly give enough bargaining power to employees to fight against the problem of "surplus value."
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI prevents Coercion by Employers
Baron-Galbavi, Denison University Economics Student, 2021 [Daydeon, 5/5/21, Denison Digital Commons, “Migrant Labor Mark and Labor Market Coercion: a Hayekian Approach,” https://digitalcommons.denison.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1047&context=studentscholarship, 6/29/23, EP]
Universal basic income raises the fallback position for everyone. Consequently, wages from capitalists become relatively less essential to the worker. This balances power in the labor relationship. When a boss threatens to fire his employee, this is threatening because the worker prefers employment over unemployment. She relies on that income to live. The basic income ensures that the worker always has a viable next best alternative. The fallback position is a minimum standard of living, rather than no standard (as currently exists). Unemployment becomes less intolerable to the laborer. Losing her job becomes less costly. Her relative preference for her current employment diminishes. The employer’s power to coerce her diminishes. The threat to fire her turns from “do what I say, or you will starve,” to “do what I say, or you will revert to a subsistence living standard.” The second is notably less threatening because the wage is made less essential to the worker. She can revert to living off of a gratuitous 21 rent at any point. She does not need to continue to work for him to continue to subsist. Basic income is a worker’s viable alternative to any particular employer. This increases her power to evade any employer who issues unpleasant commands. This pervasive ability to exit causes the employer to be more cautious about coercing her. This balances power in the labor relationship.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI Reduces Coercion- Welfare Tradeoff
Dolan, Economist, 17 [Edwin, Welfare and Poverty Adjunct for Niskanen Center, 02-06-2017, Niskanen Center, “Why Should a Libertarian Take Universal Basic Income Seriously” Accessed 7-13-2023, RM]
Philosophical issues aside, what galls many libertarians most about government is the failure of many policies to produce their intended results. Poverty policy is Exhibit A. By some calculations, the government already spends enough on poverty programs to raise all low-income families to the official poverty level, even though the poverty rate barely budges from year to year. Wouldn’t it be better to spend that money in a way that helps poor people more effectively? A UBI would help by ending the way benefit reductions and “welfare cliffs” in current programs undermine work incentives. When you add together the effects of SNAP, TANF, CHIP, EITC and the rest of the alphabet soup, and account for work-related expenses like transportation and childcare, a worker from a poor household can end up taking home nothing, even from a full-time job. A UBI has no benefit reductions. You get it whether you work or not, so you keep every added dollar you earn (income and payroll taxes excepted, and these are low for the poor).
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Aff › UBI Good- Freedom
Zwolinski, University of San Diego philosophy associate professor, 19
[Matt, November 6 2019, Niskanen Center, “Hayek, Republican Freedom, and the Universal Basic Income,” https://www.niskanencenter.org/hayek-republican-freedom-and-the-universal-basic-income/, July 3 2023, ah]
The name “Freedom Dividend” is, of course, a nice bit of political rhetoric for an electorate largely inclined to view any large-scale scheme of income redistribution as a form of socialism. But beneath the rhetoric lies a legitimate, substantive point. Yang is right: There’s a good case to be made for a UBI based on the importance of individual freedom. Indeed, the foundations of that case have already been laid by none other than the renowned champion of economic and personal liberty, Friedrich Hayek.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Turns War
Martin, 90
[Brian, “Uprooting War,” http://www.bmartin.cc/pubs/90uw/uw07.html]
Is the state system really so bad? War is the most obvious indictment of the system, and this alone should be enough to justify questioning the state. As wars have become more destructive, there is no sign that any steps to re-examine or transform the state system are being taken by state elites. This should not be surprising. War is not simply a by-product of the state system, to be moderated and regulated when it becomes too dangerous to populations. Rather, war is part and parcel of the state system, so the destructiveness of war makes little difference. State elites [and many others] see the world as a state-structured world, and all action is premised on this perspective. War is the external manifestation of state violence. Political repression is its internal form. Political freedoms are not only at a premium under military dictatorships and state socialism, but are also precarious in the representative democracies, especially in relation to 'national security.' One of the most telling indictments of the state system is found in Leo Kuper's book Genocide. Kuper documents the most horrific exterminations in this century, including the killing of the Jews by the Nazis, the massacre of the Bangladeshis by the Pakistan army in 1971 and the extermination in Cambodia beginning in 1975. What is damning of the state system is the reluctance of governments [and of that assemblage of state actors, the United Nations] to intervene against even the most well documented genocidal killing. The reason for this reluctance is the concern for the autonomy of the state. In short, maintaining the 'integrity' of the state system is more important for state elites than intervening against genocide. There are many other social problems caused, sustained or aggravated by the state, including suppression of dissent, state support for corporate elites, and the activities of spy agencies and secret police. These problems stem essentially from the system of unequal power and privilege which the state both is part of and sustains. The state is not the only way to embody and sustain unequal power and privilege: it is a particular way involving bureaucracies for administration and military forces for defending against external and internal enemies.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Turns Stability
Haagh, 12
[Louise Haagh, Ph.D. in Politics @ Oxford, “Democracy, Public Finance, and Property Rights in Economic Stability: How More Horizontal Capitalism Upscales Freedom for All,” Polity, Vol. 44.4, pg 548-49]
But, finally, how can wider forces in the external environment improve the chances that this overall state of control is attained, that is, to enjoy control in all three dimensions? I want to argue that this is a function of the degree of general extension of a sense of property right in stability as derived from a bundle of sources. Individuals today are more dependent on vast and complex distribution networks beyond their control. In this context, stability of expectations has become a non-tangible aspect of opportunity and of ownership in this sense which can only be secured through a mix of social security and strict egalitarian rights both inside and outside production. This is what makes the positive connection between stability and responsibility as highlighted before. Indeed, this four-fold mix is uniquely important in a modern setting, where individual freedom is highly valued yet insecurity is a major risk. The greater separation between the occupational and the familial realms of activity and economic security potentially gives the individual greater autonomy from familial relations. However, it also poses a risk to her social security. Therefore, the response that optimizes real autonomy is one that offers more independent sources of economic security in each of the three core realms of social activity or being—the familial, the occupational, and the personal, that is, to enjoy at the same time, static, dynamic, and constant control. The upshot for egalitarian theory is that the modern economy generates demands for rights along strict egalitarian dimensions [to raise basic autonomy], as well as for rights to social security, that is, for more resources, where relevant, to generate equal opportunities for stability and to respond to needs. An example of the first kind of right is the unconditional right to a basic life-time income for all, a basic income [BI]. In principle, its defense can be likened to that of the unconditional right to vote, and to universal preventive health care or initial schooling. In practice the BI furnishes something like the basic control and autonomy that, in the past, private ownership of land or common access to the forest [which the modern strict dependence on employment removed] might afford, but for everyone.20
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Turns Environment
Logomasini, 10
[CEI's Senior Fellow in Environmental Risk, Regulation and Consumer Freedom [Angela, “Embrace Private Conservation of Land and Natural Resources”; Chapter of “Liberate to Stimulate”, Competitive Enterprise Institute, http://cei.org/sites/default/files/CEI%20-%20Liberate%20to%20Stimulate.pdf]
Private stewardship and markets play a critical role in land and natural resource conservation. Much of America’s land and other natural resources have suffered because government ownership encourages mismanagement and overuse, because no individual has a long-term stake in protecting resources owned in common. In addition, public lands are managed based on political priorities that often produce misguided political management decisions. Examples include the devastation caused by uncontrolled forest fires, overgrazing, and destruction of species and habitat. Lawmakers should consider marketplace incentives and private property-based approaches to encourage land and natural resource conservation. Existing laws impede private conservation by making property owners lose use of their land. These laws should be reformed. These include measures in the Endangered Species Act, wetlands regulations, and potential invasive species laws. Lawmakers should look for ways to privatize resources owned in common to allow private conservation. Areas in which this has been done successfully but could be expanded include the establishment of fishing rights, privatization of coral reefs, and privatization of species and their habitats in private wildlife refuges.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Turns Climate Change
Kling, 10
[Independent scholar who writes about a wide variety of economic issues. He was an economist on the staff of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System from 1980-1986, and served as a senior economist at Freddie Mac from 1986-1994 [Arnold, “The Era of Expert Failure”, Cato Institute, http://www.cato.org/policy-report/septemberoctober-2010/era-expert-failure]
The Department of Energy has decided that it has the expertise to select specific energy projects, such as the electric car that is being developed by Fisker Automotive of California, the recipient of a $500 million loan guarantee. In theory, if the economic prospects for this electric car were good enough, venture capitalists would be willing to risk money on its development. Now, with a loan guarantee, private investors enjoy only the potential gains while taxpayers bear the risk. Many citizens who would never have considered investing in this electric car company are now partners in the venture, except that we have only the downside and no upside. The officials who are putting taxpayer money at risk may or may not have better expertise than venture capitalists who put their partners’ money at risk. What the officials certainly have is more power. The threat of climate change, like the threat of terrorism, can be characterized in such a way as to justify an unlimited attempt at expert control. Regardless of whether experts really can accurately measure, predict, and explain climate change, some will be tempted to exercise power as if their analysis were precise and certain.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Coercion Kills VTL
Hayek – Nobel Prize winner for Economics – 1960 (F.A., The Constitution of Liberty, p.20)
By “coercion” we mean such control of the environment or circumstances of a person by another that, in order to avoid greater evil, he is forced to act not according to a coherent plan of his own but to serve the ends of another. Except in the sense of choosing the lesser evil in a situation forced on him by another, he is unable either to use his own intelligence or knowledge or to follow his own aims and beliefs. Coercion is evil precisely because it thus eliminates an individual as a thinking and valuing person and makes him a bare tool in the achievement of the ends of another. Free action, in which a person pursues his own aims by the means indicated by his own knowledge, must be based on data which cannot be shaped at will by another. It presupposes the existence of a known sphere in which the circumstances cannot be so shaped by another person as to leave one only that choice prescribed by the other.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Impacts › Coercion => Tyranny
Browne, 95 (Harry, Former Libertarian Party candidate for President and Director of Public Policy for the DownsizeDC.org, Why Government Doesn't Work, p.66-67)
The reformers of the Cambodian revolution claimed to be building a better world. They forced people into reeducation programs to make them better citizens. Then they used force to regulate every aspect of commercial life. Then they forced office workers and intellectuals to give up their jobs and harvest rice, to round out their education. When people resisted having their lives turned upside down, the reformers had to use more and more force. By the time they were done, they had killed a third of the country’s population, destroyed the lives of almost everyone still alive, and devastated a nation. It all began with using force for the best of intentions — to create a better world. The Soviet leaders used coercion to provide economic security and to build a “New Man” — a human being who would put his fellow man ahead of himself. At least 10 million people died to help build the New Man and the Workers’ Paradise.37 But human nature never changed — and the workers’ lives were always Hell, not Paradise. In the 1930s many Germans gladly traded civil liberties for the economic revival and national pride Adolf Hitler promised them. But like every other grand dream to improve society by force, it ended in a nightmare of devastation and death. Professor R. J. Rummel has calculated that 119 million people have been killed by their own governments in this century.38 Were these people criminals? No, they were people who simply didn’t fit into the New Order — people who preferred their own dreams to those of the reformers. Every time you allow government to use force to make society better, you move another step closer to the nightmares of Cambodia, the Soviet Union, and Nazi Germany. We’ve already moved so far that our own government can perform with impunity the outrages described in the preceding chapters. These examples aren’t cases of government gone wrong; they are examples of government — period. They are what governments do — just as chasing cats is what dogs do. They are the natural consequence of letting government use force to bring about a drug-free nation, to tax someone else to better your life, to guarantee your economic security, to assure that no one can mistreat you or hurt your feelings, and to cover up the damage of all the failed government programs that came before.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Links › AT: UBI Solves Employer Coercion
Coote, New Economics Foundation Principal Fellow, 2018
[Anna, 2/8/18, New Economics Foundation, “THERE ARE FAIRER WAYS TO SPREAD PROSPERITY THAN UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME,” , 7/8/23, PE]
When an idea stirs the popular imagination, pundits and politicians find it hard to resist. Never mind if there is no evidence to support it. Never mind if closer scrutiny suggests putting it into practice will be counterproductive or plain impossible. What matters is the platform it provides for its champions, the energy it generates, the votes it wins. Brexit is one example. Donald Trump’s Mexican wall is another. And I would add a third: universal basic income (UBI) – the idea that every citizen receives a weekly or monthly lump sum from the government, whether they’re in work or not. UBI’s billionaire backers The case against UBI is building rapidly. But so is the clamour to try it out in states and cities around the world. That the latter seems immune to the former is alarming. And the fact that it’s promoted by radicals at both ends of the political spectrum should ring alarm bells. As Daniel Zamora argues, this is an idea ‘whose time has come’ not because it is good or practicable, but because it is a creature of the moment. ‘As politics move to the right and social movements go on the defensive, UBI gains ground… not as an alternative to neoliberalism, but a capitulation to it,’ he says. We have to assume, as do almost all of its protagonists, that a basic income could only be implemented in very small amounts. The most generous UBI scheme envisaged by the UK campaign group, Compass falls well below the poverty line. This means a range of additional benefits would need to be paid to people unable to work – wiping out the much-vaunted promise that UBI ‘simplifies’ the social security system and removes the stigma of claiming. In fact, all it offers is a small rise in the floor above which conditional benefits are required. And even at that level, we would need massive tax hikes to pay for it. In a nutshell, ‘an affordable UBI would be inadequate and an adequate UBI would be unaffordable.’ Why bother to construct what UK economist Ian Gough calls a ‘powerful new tax engine to pull along a tiny cart’? Whose interests are really at stake here? Empty promises UBI is an individualistic, monetary intervention that undermines social solidarity and fails to tackle the underlying causes of poverty, unemployment and inequality. These are systemic problems that need to be addressed by people getting together and building shared control over local economic development, wage bargaining and decisions about national investment in industry and infrastructure, not by governments giving individuals small amounts of money. Leftist advocates of UBI Nick Srnicek and Alex Williams claim that it ‘overturns the asymmetry of power that currently exists between labour and capital’ by partially de-commodifying labour and loosening the coercive aspects of paid employment. But here’s the catch: it will only happen, they say, if UBI ‘provides a sufficient amount of income to live on’. As we have seen, this not remotely possible. If UBI isn’t generous enough to let you refuse work, it can only suppress wages and support a multiplication of lousy jobs (that you still can’t refuse). Waving goodbye to welfare The idea of giving money to individuals sits comfortably with the neoliberal claim that services are better when markets provide and customers choose. Indeed, where UBI has been piloted in countries without free public services, it is often used to buy such essentials as education and healthcare. One of the most dangerous aspects of this ‘radical’ idea is that it can help to dismantle welfare states – both by supporting the ideology of privatisation and monetisation, and by draining huge amounts of money from the public purse. But collectively provided public services, available to all according to need, give far better value for money than commercialised services; they are more likely to be inclusive and egalitarian, and to encourage solidarity. They represent a very substantial virtual income that is also highly redistributive. According to the charity Oxfam, this ‘social wage’ reduces income inequality by 20 per cent. Cradle to grave Far more compelling than UBI is ‘UBS’, or the idea of ‘universal basic services’ currently being developed by economists at London University’s Global Prosperity Institute. Their goal is ‘public services that enable every citizen to live a larger life’ by ensuring access to security, opportunity and participation. This means reaching beyond education and health services, to provide transport, access to information, shelter and food ‘all of which are generally considered to be essential to full participation in a modern, developed economy.’ Their technical analysis finds that access to services can be financed through fairly modest adjustments to the tax system; they will meet needs more directly for those on lowest incomes and will ‘always deliver greater value for the same expenditure as a cash distribution’. The reforms will ‘deliver value across the economy, stimulating new activity and increasing the size of the “pie”.’ Many left-wing supporters of UBI claim they also want to defend public services. However, they pay no attention to how these services can be strengthened or improved, and ignore the very obvious danger of robbing Peter to pay Paul. As the UBI fan base grows, it is capturing political energy that is urgently needed for more serious causes. Deceptive simplicity There are viable alternatives that have far stronger claims – in philosophical, economic and political terms – to address the challenges of poverty and inequality. For example, it is worth building a campaign for a minimum income guarantee combined with more generous child benefits and a system of credits for carers based on the principles of time banking, so that time spent on caring for others earns a reciprocal contribution to one’s pension or care costs later in life. And we desperately need a strong defence of essential public services that are sorely threatened by austerity measures. But the snake oil of a deceptively simple idea is charming the public gaze in another direction. Implemented in any remotely viable form, UBI will do nothing to help workers gain more control through collective bargaining – the ability to negotiate their salary and working conditions. It will do nothing to encourage employers to pay a decent living wage or narrow the gap between the top and bottom of the workplace hierarchy. It will do nothing to alter power relations between labour and capital. A ‘no-strings-attached’ pay-out will not eliminate poverty or insecurity. It will only harm the hard-won social democratic tradition of public services available to all according to need. It will not, in fact, disturb a hair on the head of modern capitalism. No wonder it is popular with the moguls of Silicon Valley. In their world, where automation is the name of the game, they think their interests are best served by a docile population who cannot hold their bosses’ feet to the fire but may have just enough money to keep on shopping. What could be more attractive than a government prepared to spend more public money to subsidise low wages and dwindling supply of precarious jobs?
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Links › AT: Rawls Supports UBI
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” , Accessed 6/30/23, EP]
As Van Parijs (2009) clarifies, John Rawls disagreed that UBI is justified. The statement of "those who surf all day off Malibu must find a way to support themselves and would not be entitled to public funds" by John Rawls in 1988 was anti-UBI. Nobel-prize-winning economist Phelps (2000) explained that Rawlsian Justice is entitled to only those competent and willing to participate and contribute at least a portion of the economy's pie. In response to Rawls's "Malibu surfers" statement, Van Parijs defended the rights of every person to get unconditional and guaranteed basic income in his famous "Why Surfers Should Be Fed" essay. Van Parijs (1991) concluded that liberal justice entitles them to sufficient income.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Coercion Neg › Links › Links- UBI- AT: SQ Worse
Caplan, Professor of economics, 2017
[Bryan, 2/20/17, EconLog, “Why Libertarians Should Oppose the Universal Basic Income,” https://www.econlib.org/archives/2017/02/why_libertarian_2.html, 7/2/23, PE]
Libertarians have a standard set of fundamental criticisms of the welfare state. 1. Forced charity is unjust. Individuals have a moral right to decide if and when they want to help others. 2. Forced charity is unnecessary. In a free market, voluntary donations are enough to provide for the truly poor. 3. Forced charity gives recipients bad incentives. If the government takes care of you, you’re less likely to take care of yourself by work and saving. 4. The cost of forced charity is high and growing rapidly, leading to a future of exhorbitant taxes or financial crisis. Taken together, I think these criticisms justify the radical libertarian view that the welfare state should be abolished. But this is an extremely unpopular view, so it’s natural for libertarians to consider more moderate reforms like the Universal Basic Income. And when you’re considering moderate reforms, the right question to ask isn’t: “Is it ideal?” but “Is it better than the status quo?” My claim: the Universal Basic Income is indeed worse than the status quo. In fact, all the fundamental criticisms of the welfare state apply with even greater force. 1. Some forced charity is more unjust than other forced charity. Forcing people to help others who can’t help themselves – like kids from poor families or the severely disabled – is at least defensible. Forcing people to help everyone is not. And for all its faults, at least the status quo makes some effort to target people who can’t help themselves. The whole idea of the Universal Basic Income, in contrast, is to give money to everyone whether they need it or not. Of course, the UBI formula normally reduces the net payment as income rises; but if a perfectly able-bodied person chooses never to work, the UBI gravy train never stops. 2. The UBI is an extremely wasteful form of forced charity. Helping the small minority of people who can’t help themselves doesn’t cost much. Giving an unconditional grant to every citizen wastes an enormous amount of money. If you were running a private charity, it would never even occur to you to “help everyone,” because it’s such a frivolous use of scarce charitable resources. Instead, you’d target spending to do the most good. And unlike the UBI, the status quo makes some effort to so target its resources. 3. Overall, the UBI probably gives even worse incentives than the status quo. Defenders of the UBI correctly point out that it might improve incentives for people who are already on welfare. Under the status quo, earning another $1 of legal income can easily reduce your welfare by a $1, implying a marginal tax rate of 100%. But under the status quo, vast populations are ineligible for most programs. Such as? You guys! If you’re an able-bodied adult, aged 18-64, who doesn’t have custody of any minor children, the current system doesn’t give you much. Switching to a UBI would expand the familiar perverse effects of the welfare state to the entire population – including you. And if taxes rise to pay for the UBI, the population-wide disincentives are even worse. 4. A politically acceptable UBI would be insanely expensive. Libertarian economist and UBI advocate Ed Dolan has a detailed, fiscally viable plan to provide a UBI of $4452 per person per year. But every non-libertarian I’ve queried thinks it should be at least $10,000 per person per year. Even with a one-third flat tax, that implies that a family of four would have to make $120,000 a year before it paid $1 of taxes. This is pie in the sky. But doesn’t the UBI give people their freedom? In some socialist sense, sure. But libertarianism isn’t about the freedom to be coercively supported by strangers. It’s about the freedom to be left alone by strangers. If abolition of the welfare state is extremely unlikely and the UBI is worse than the status quo, does this mean libertarians should accept the welfare state as it is? Not at all. There’s a straightforward moderate path to a freer world: AUSTERITY. Cut benefits. Restrict eligibility. Remind the world of the great Forgotten Man: the taxpayer. We probably can’t convince the majority to end the welfare state. But “Welfare should be limited to genuinely poor people who can’t help themselves” has broad appeal – and unlike the UBI, it’s a clear step in the libertarian direction.