2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Afro-Pessimism › Ballot Turn
Hartman 1997. (Saidiya, Associate prof of English at Cal Berk. Scenes of Subjection p. 25-6)
Rankin was not alone in his desire to slip into blackness and experience the¶ suffering of slavery "firsthand," so to speak. On the contrary, the popularity of¶ Uncle Tom's Cabin and The Octoroon indicates the willingness of others to suffer,¶ too. The elasticity of blackness and its capacious affects enabled such flights and¶ becomings. Moreover, in this case, the figurative capacities of blackness and the¶ fungibility of the commodity are directly linked. The fungibility of the commodity,¶ specifically its abstractness and immateriality, enabled the black body or blackface¶ mask to serve as the vehicle of white self-exploration, renunciation, and enjoyment.¶ 22 Therefore, the ability to put on blackness must be considered in the context¶ of chattel slavery and the economy of enjoyment founded thereupon. Antebellum ·¶ formations of pleasure, even those of the North, need to be considered in relation to¶ the affective dimensions of chattel slavery since enjoyment is virtually unimaginable¶ without recourse to the black body and the subjection of the captive, the diversions¶ engendered by the dispossession of the enslaved, or the fantasies launched by the¶ myriad uses of the black body. For this reason the formal features of this economy of¶ pleasure and the politics of enjoyment are considered in regard to the literal and¶ figurative occupation and possession of the body. This reading attempts to elucidate¶ the means by which the wanton use of and the violence directed toward the black¶ body come to be identified as its pleasure and dangers-that is, the expectations of¶ slave property are ontologized as the innate capacities and inner feelings of the¶ enslaved, and moreover, the ascription of excess and enjoyment to the African¶ effaces the violence perpetrated against the enslaved. In light of these issues, the¶ schematic analysis of minstrelsy and melodrama that follows focuses on the convergence¶ of violence and pleasure, which is identified as one of the primary attributes of¶ this economy of enjoyment, rather than providing a close reading of the texts of¶ minstrelsy and melodrama. Scant attention is paid to the white spectator's identification¶ with blackface characters. Instead, the major issue explored is the relation¶ between pleasure and violence-that is, the facility of blackness in the other's self-fashioning¶ and the role of pleasure in securing the mechanisms of racial subjection.¶ In other words, this economy of enjoyment is interrogated through a consideration¶ of the dynamics of possession and close scrutiny of the object of property and its¶ uses.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Afro-Pessimism › Turn – Indebtedness
Hartman 1997. (Saidiya, Associate prof of English at Cal Berk. Scenes of Subjection p. 125-6)
Emancipation announced the end of chattel slavery; however, it by no¶ means marked the end of bondage. The free(d) individual was nothing if not burdened,¶ responsible, and obligated. Responsibility entailed accounting for one's¶ actions, dutiful suppliance, contractual obligation, and calculated reciprocity. Fundamentally,¶ to be responsible was to be blameworthy. In this respect, the exercise of¶ free will, quite literally, was inextricable from guilty infractions, criminal misdeeds,¶ punishable transgressions, and an elaborate micropenality of everyday life. Responsibility¶ made man an end in himself, and as such, the autonomous and intending agent¶ was above all else culpable. As Friedrich Nietzsche observed: "The proud realization¶ of the extraordinary privilege of responsibility, the awareness of this rare¶ freedom and power over himself and his destiny, has penetrated him to the depths and¶ become an instinct, his dominant instinct: what will he call his dominant instinct,¶ assuming that he needs a word for it? No doubt about the answer: this sovereign man¶ calls it his conscience.'' 1 In this regard, the burden of conscience attendant to the¶ formation of the sovereign individual was decisive not only in the ways that it¶ facilitated self-disciplining but also in its ability to engender resentment toward and¶ justify the punishment of those who fell below "the threshold of responsibility" or¶ failed to achieve the requisite degree of self-control. 2 The onus of accountability that¶ rested upon the shoulders of the self-responsible individual-the task of proving¶ oneself worthy of freedom-combined with the undue hardships of emancipation¶ engendered an anomalous condition betwixt and between slavery and freedom, for in¶ this case the individual was not only tethered by the bonds of conscience and duty and¶ obliged by the ascetic imperatives of restraint and self-reliance but also literally¶ constrained within a mixed-labor system in which contract was the vehicle of servitude¶ and accountability was inseparable from peonage. Moreover, the guilty volition¶ enjoyed by the free agent bore an uncanny resemblance to the only form of agency¶ legally exercised by the enslaved-that is, criminal liability.¶ Responsibility and restraint all too easily yielded to a condition of involuntary¶ servitude, and culpability. inevitably gave way to indebtedness. The emergence¶ of what I term "indebted servitude" is the subject of this chapter. 1 use the¶ term "indebted servitude" to amplify the constraints of conscience (discipline internalized¶ and lauded as a virtue), the coercion and compulsion of the free labor¶ system, and the ''grafting of morality onto economics'' in the making of the dutiful¶ free laborer and similarly lo illuminate the elasticity of debt in effecting peonage and¶ other forms of involuntary servitude.' According to Nietzsche, the feelings of guilt,¶ obligation, and responsibility originated in the relations~ip of creditor and debtor;¶ moreover, debt as the measure of morality sanctions the 'imposition of punishment;¶ debt serves to reinscribe both servitude and the pained constitution of blackness. 4 A¶ telling example of this calculation of conscience or the entanglement of debt and¶ duty can be found in Jared Bell Waterbury's Advice to a Young Christian. Here the¶ duty of self-examination is compared to bookkeeping: "Let the duty [of selfexamination]¶ be duly and thoroughly performed, and we rise to the standard of the¶ skilful fsicJ and prudent merchant, who duly records every ilem of business; who¶ never closes his counting-house until his balance sheet is made up~ and who, by a¶ single reference, can tell the true state of his accounts, and form a correct esti1nate of¶ his co1nmercial standing. "5 In the case of the freed, the cultivation of conscience¶ operated in the whip's stead as an overseer of the soul, although the use of compulsion¶ was routinely employed against those seemingly remiss in their duties. As it¶ turned out, the encumbrance of freedom made one not only blameworthy and vulnerable¶ to hardship and affliction in the name of interest but also, surprisingly, no¶ less susceptible to the correctives of coercion and constraint.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Afro-Pessimism › Alt double bind
Hartman 1997. (Saidiya, Associate prof of English at Cal Berk. Scenes of Subjection p. 12-14)
The effort to examine the event of emancipation is no less riddled by inescapable¶ ironies, the foremost of these being the discontinuity between -substantial freedom¶ and legal emancipation. Inevitably one is forced to confront the discrepant legacy of¶ emancipation and the decidedly circumscribed possibilities available to the freed. In¶ short, how does one adequately render the double bind of emancipation-that is,¶ acknowledge the illusory freedom and travestied liberation that succeeded chattel¶ slavery without gainsaying the small triumphs of Jubilee? Certainly one must contend¶ with the enormity of emancipation as both a breach with slavery and a point of¶ transition to what looks more like the reorganization of the plantation system than¶ self-possession, citizenship, or liberty for the "freed." In the place of the grand¶ narrative of freedom, with its decisive events and incontrovertible advances, I offer¶ an account that focuses on the ambivalent legacy of emancipation and the undeniably¶ truncated opportunities available to the freed. Lacking the certitude of a definitive¶ partition between slavery and freedom, and in the absence of a consummate¶ breach through which freedom might unambivalently announce itself, there is at best¶ a transient and fleeting expression of possibility that cannot ensconce itself as a¶ durable temporal marker. If periodization is a barrier imposed from above that¶ obscures the involuntary servitude and legal subjection that followed in the wake of¶ slavery, then attempts to assert absolutist distinctions between slavery and freedom¶ are untenable. Fundamentally, such assertions involve distinctions between the transient¶ and the epochal, underestimate the contradictory inheritance of emancipation¶ and the forms of involuntary servitude that followed in the wake of slavery, and¶ diminish the reign of terror that accompanied the advent of freedom. Put differently,¶ does the momentousness of emancipation as an event ultimately efface the continuities¶ between slavery and freedom and the dispossession inseparable from becoming¶ a "propertied person"? If one dares to "abandon the absurd catalogue of official¶ history," as Edouard Glissant encourages, then the violence and domination perpetuated¶ in the name of slavery's reversal come to the fore. 1• From this vantage¶ point, emancipation seems a double-edged and perhaps obfuscating label. It discloses¶ as well as obscures since involuntary servitude and emancipation were synonymous¶ for a good many of the formerly enslaved. This is evidenced in "commonsense"¶ observations that black lives were more valuable under slavery than under¶ freedom, that blacks were worse off under freedom than during slavery, and that the¶ gift of freedom was a Hhard deaL" I use the tenn "'common sense" purposely to¶ underline what Antonio Gramsci described as the "chaotic aggregate of disparate¶ conceptions" that conform with "the social and cultural position of those masses¶ whose philosophy it is." It is a conception of world and life "implicit to a large¶ extent in determinate strata of society" and "in opposition to 'official' conceptions¶ of the world. " 20 In this case, common sense challenges the official accounts of¶ freedom and stresses the similarities and correspondencies of slavery and freedom.¶ At a minimum, these observations disclose the disavowed transactions between¶ slavery and freedom as modes of production and subjection.¶ The abolition of chattel slavery and the emergence of man, however laudable,¶ long awaited, and cherished, fail to yield such absolute distinctions; instead fleeting,¶ disabled, and short-lived practices stand for freedom and its failure. Everyday practices,¶ rather than traditional political activity like the abolition movement, black¶ conventions, the struggle for suffrage, electoral activities, et cetera, are the focus of¶ my examination because I believe that these pedestrian practices illuminate inchoate¶ and utopian expressions of freedom that are not and perhaps cannot be actualized¶ elsewhere. The desires and longings that exceed the frame of civil rights and¶ political emancipation find expression in quotidian acts labeled "fanciful," "exorbitant,"¶ and "excessive" primarily because they express an understanding or¶ imagination of freedom quite at odds with bourgeois expectations. Paul Gilroy, after¶ Seyla Benhabib, refers to these utopian invocations and the incipient modes of¶ friendship and solidarity they conjure up as "the politics of transfiguration. "21 He¶ notes that in contrast to the politics of fulfillment that operate within the framework¶ of bourgeois civil society and occidental rationality, "the politics of transfiguration¶ strives in pursuit of the sublime, struggling to repeat the unrepeatable, to present the¶ unpresentable. Its rather different hermeneutic focus pushes towards the mimetic,¶ dramatic and performative." From this perspective, stealing away, the breakdown,¶ moving about, pilfering, and other everyday practices that occur below the threshold¶ of formal equality and rights gesture toward an unrealized freedom and emphasize¶ the stranglehold of slavery and the limits of emancipation. In this and in other ways,¶ these practices reveal much about the infrapolitics of the dominated and the contestations¶ over the meaning of abolition and emancipation.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Afro-Pessimism › Vulnerability DA
Harvester and Blenkinsop 11 Harvester, Lara, and Sean Blenkinsop. "Environmental education and ecofeminist pedagogy: Bridging the environmental and the social." Canadian Journal of Environmental Education (CJEE) 15 (2011): 120-134. rishi
Those advocating for ecofeminist pedagogy emphasize the role of dialogue in enacting new relationships between humans, and between humans and morethan- human nature (Gardner & Riley, 2007; Houde & Bullis, 1999; Li, 2007). Genuine dialogue, according to Buber (1965), is like an embrace, a moment when two come together and, without loss of self, are able to hold each other simultaneously with an open heart and mind. It is built on respect and a deep sense of the intrinsic value of the other being. This is a relation of the both/and, an acknowledgment of the immediate presence of both deep interdependence and the unique autonomy of each being. This is a relationship held together by humility. Blenkinsop (2005) proposes that a teacher who is prepared to engage in dialogue with students will push, support, and challenge students in whatever direction he/she feels will be most helpful for the student, while at the same time acknowledging that students respond out of their own free will. When ecofeminists speak of transformed relationships, they are presupposing that these relationships are based on an acknowledgement of human interdependence with each other and the rest of nature (Merchant, 2005; Warren, 2000). Kheel (1993) suggests that disengaging from patriarchal discourse allows us to hear fuller stories as we listen to nature, hearing voices that have been muted under patriarchy. Ecofeminists seek, in Buber’s language, for authentic dialogue based on respect for, and communion with, other beings. Clearly an ecofeminist pedagogy calls for a radical relational shift in education: a shift towards something that is more dialogical, where the human (teacher and student), the community, and the more-than-human come together and engage with each other in more robust and equitable ways than is currently the norm. This is a pedagogy where learning takes place in a more expanded, including outdoor, environment in which students can experience relationship and build community between themselves, their locale, and the rest of nature. This shift in both the place of education and the definition of and relationship between teacher and learner allows the natural world space to play the more prominent role of active dialoguer, even co-teacher, in an educational practice that is in, for, and through relationship. This notion of authentic dialogue, along with both a growing implicit thread of experiential education, and a critical philosophical stance, are three key components of an ecofeminist pedagogy.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › Perm
Griffin, 2015. (Penny, Senior Lecturer in International Relations at the University of New South Wales, Australia. “crisis, austerity and gendered governance: a feminist perspective,” in feminist review 109: 49-72, spp)
Adding to this extensive body of feminist literature, this paper interrogates crisis governance as discursively gendered, and the effects of this. A discursive approach is significant because it does not assume, as per liberal approaches, a foundational economic rationality to economic strategy, or, as per Marxism, the central truth of class struggle as universal. A discursive approach that centralises gender in understanding the reproduction of crisis governance discourses under- stands governance and its outcomes as a complex amalgamation of meaning and practice, founded by and reproduced through culturally produced and pervasively gendered ideas, assumptions and values about the world. A commitment to non- essentialism challenges, at fundamental and unsettling levels, some of the core categories of conventional forms of analysis. This contrasts with mainstream (international political economy) scholarship’s framing of human behaviour in terms of faceless, desocialised units of analysis and its reproduction of a model of society as a self-regulating machine explainable by scientific laws adapted from modern philosophy and Newtonian science. It also contrasts with critical scholar- ship’s preference for the Marxist view of economic relations as (pre)determined by the nature of class struggle. While some materialist (feminist) approaches articulate women’s disprivilege as a historical constant and something of a cultural given, discourse analysis of gendered governance, instead, understands privilege, discrimination and inequality as socially, and culturally, produced and variable across time and place, resisting the rooting of economic relations in class relations and showing a greater interest in the gendered cultural practices (including gendered recruitment and promotion practices, discriminatory forms of lending, gendered assessments of credit worthiness and so on) that enable the reproduction of gendered power in the global political economy. A discursive approach to gender and governance necessitates the analysis of norms and standards in the global political economy that many hold to be true, essential and universal, but a committed critique of which reveals as power-laden, regulatory and highly restrictive identity categories (Griffin, 2009: 1). Rather than positing the primacy of ‘the economic’, which swallows whole concepts such as culture, gender, race, production, consumption and representation, this paper looks to the cultural conditions of embodiments of capitalism, specifically neo- liberal global governance and the discourses of governance that neo-liberalism reproduces. To be sure, these discourses emanate from various and diverse actors, institutions, organisations and initiatives, including individual (state) governments and groupings of these (such as the G7 and G10); supra-national bureaucracies such as the European Union (EU); intergovernmental organisations such as the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and the UN; non-governmental organisations such as the World Economic Forum (WEF); and private financial governance initiatives (which are not available for public scrutiny) such as those instituted by the Bank for International Settlements and the International Organization of Securities Commissions. By asking us to confront in quite radical and imaginative ways how we know what we think we know and thus what we exclude from our analyses, a discursive research strategy is always strongly political.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › Perm
Griffin, 2015. (Penny, Senior Lecturer in International Relations at the University of New South Wales, Australia. “crisis, austerity and gendered governance: a feminist perspective,” in feminist review 109: 49-72, spp)
This paper draws upon, and seeks to extend, existing feminist analyses of the causes, constitution and effects of financial crisis to argue that crisis, governance and austerity are best understood by interpreting the discursive reproduction of crisis governance discourses and their feminist Frankenstein creation, what this paper refers to as ‘crisis governance feminism’. Existing feminist scholarship has, at length, detailed how capitalism, in all its forms and at macro, micro, local, regional and global levels, is gendered. Feminists have contested the seductively clean and unified agenda of ‘one world’ future prosperity lovingly perpetuated by neo-liberalism and its advocates and have highlighted instead ‘the messy, contradictory and disjointed processes of global restructuring that have monopolised the politics of development in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries’ (Griffin, 2010a: 91). Feminists have analysed and campaigned on economic crises extensively, interrogating the gendered impacts of the 1980s debt crisis (see, e.g., Sen and Grown, 1987; Benería, 2003), the East Asian crisis (Truong, 1999; Ling, 2004; Floro et al., 2009; Seguino, 2009) and the Argentine crisis (Chrabolowsky, 2003; De Cicco, 2011). Feminist discussions of global finance and crisis have displayed in stark relief the gendered injustices and inequalities created and sustained by various crises, the ‘retrogression of individual capabilities’ (Fukuda- Parr et al., 2013: 24), particularly those of women, created by financial crises, the social costs to women of austerity and the organisational manipulations of gender rhetoric that reaffirm existent and unequal economic policies and power relations (see, e.g., Montgomerie and Young, 2010; Roberts and Soederberg, 2012; Fukuda- Parr et al., 2013). As feminist analyses have so convincingly argued, ignorance of the local and social constitution of global processes leads only to flawed scholarship and ignorant policy-making that further exacerbate, or even create, hierarchies and inequalities of labour, class, gender and sexual relations. For feminists, regimes of capitalist production and consumption are always gendered. The reproduction of assumptions of individualism, market economics and democracy, perpetuated by neo-liberal governance mechanisms as pre-given and beyond question, mean, in particular, that neo-liberalism and its advocates have often failed to recognise that ‘the commercialisation of everyday life and of all sectors of the economy generates social dynamics that many individuals and cultures across the globe might find repulsive’ (Benería, 2003: 73).
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › AT: Root Cause - Offense
Burke 2002. (Anthony, School of Political Science and International Studies, University of Queensland, Alternatives: Global, Local, Political 27.1, InfoTrac OneFile)
These insights have direct relevance to the international conduct of states. Christine Sylvester has argued that there is a pernicious "normativity of sex" structuring international relations, while Tickner argues that statecraft is dominated by an image of "hegemonic masculinity" that is "sustained through its opposition to various subordinated and devalued masculinities such as homosexuality . . . and through its relation to various devalued feminities." In international policy, the characteristics of hegemonic masculinity "are projected onto the behaviour of states whose success as international actors is measured in terms of their power capabilities and capacity for self-help and autonomy." (53) What this achieves is a whole series of exclusions (and norms of action) based on the dichotomy between masculine and feminine. This generates a chain of analogous oppositions that align maleness with reason, activity, objective truth, and the mind, and woman with passion, passivity, subjective truth, and the body--realms and values constructed as perpetually threatening, backward, and disruptive. By then aligning these with two other crucial dichotomies--between savage and civilized, and the commonwealth and the state of nature--this chain of oppositions gives life to the progressive movement of being central to a post-Enlightenment politics of security. In the liberal chain that links subjectivity, economy, and geopolitics, gender is simultaneously a work on the self, a principle for the participation of individuals in society, and one for the conduct of the state in managing subject populations and constructing geopolitical space. Hegemonic masculinity has also been crucial to universalizing the liberal mode of economic subjectivity based around the subjugation, control, and exploitation of nature--with the implicit exclusion of other possible modes of economic life. (54) A pivotal figure here is Descartes, whose philosophical account of method and the division between mind and body has underpinned many characteristics of the modern liberal order: its obsession with political and epistemological certitude (stability and equilibrium), the vision of nature implicit in modern economics, and the control and production of international space. Genevieve Lloyd emphasizes how the separation of mind and body was essential to his vision of a "unitary pure thought" t hat secured the foundations of modern science, yet simultaneously separated it from the rest of life. Lloyd also draws out the links between Cartesian method and Hegel's association of male attainments with universality. Maleness becomes a technical attribute achieved by breaking away from the nature associated with woman, and thus analogous to modern theories of technological, political, and economic progress based on the manipulation and control of nature. (55)
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › AT: Root Cause - Defense
Rubin 1975 (Gayle, Professor of Sociology at the University of Michigan, one of the foundational figures in modern gender theory and well-honed reader of Marx, “The Traffic in Women…”)
Given the individual, the production of labour-power consists in his reproduction of himself or his maintenance. For his main-tenance he requires a given quantity of the means of subsistence.... Labour-power sets itself in action only by working. But thereby a definite quantity of human muscle, brain, nerve, etc., is wasted, and these require to be restored.... (Ibid.:171) The amount of the difference between the reproduction of labor power and its products depends, therefore, on the de-termination of what it takes to reproduce that labor power. Marx tends to make that determination on the basis of the quantity of commodities—food, clothing, housing, fuel—which would be necessary to maintain the health, life, and strength of a worker. But these commodities must be con-sumed before they can be sustenance, and they are not imme-diately in consumable form when they are purchased by the wage. Additional labor must be performed upon these things before they can be turned into people. Food must be cooked, clothes cleaned, beds made, wood chopped, etc. Housework is therefore a key element in the process of the reproduction of the laborer from whom surplus value is taken. Since it is usually women who do housework, it has been observed that it is through the reproduction of labor power that women are articulated into the surplus value nexus which is the sine qua non of capitalism. But to explain women's usefulness to capi-talism is one thing. To argue that this usefulness explains the genesis of the oppression of women is quite another. It is precisely at this point that the analysis of capitalism ceases to explain very much about women and the oppression of women. Women are oppressed in societies which can by no stretch of the imagination be described as capitalist. In the Amazon valley and the New Guinea highlands, women are frequently kept in their place by gang rape when the ordinary mecha-nisms of masculine intimidation prove insufficient. "We tame our women with the banana," said one Mundurucu man (Murphy, 1959:195). The ethnographic record is littered with practices whose effect is to keep women "in their place" —men's cults, secret initiations, arcane male knowledge, etc. And pre-capitalist, feudal Europe was hardly a society in which there was no sexism. Capitalism has taken over, and rewired, notions of male and female which predate it by centuries. No analysis of the reproduction of labor power under capitalism can explain foot-binding, chastity belts, or any of the incredible array of Byzantine, fetishized indignities, let alone the more ordinary ones, which have been inflicted upon women in various times and places. The analysis of the reproduction of labor power does not even explain why it is usually women who do domestic work in the home, rather than men.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › Marxism Fails
Oksala 15 Johanna Oksala is currently Academy of Finland Research Fellow (2012-2017) in the Department of Philosophy, History, Culture and Art Studies at the University of Helsinki, and a Visiting Professor in the Department of Philosophy at the New School for Social Research, USA (2013-2015). Her books include Foucault on Freedom (2005), How to Read Foucault (2007) and Foucault, Politics & Violence(2012). “Johanna Oksala on Foucault, Marx and Neoliberal Subjects”, Theory Culture and Society, February 16th 2015 rishi
It is my contention that Foucault’s “post-Marxist” insights about the intrinsic link between productive practices of power and forms of the subject must remain central in our critical analyses of the neoliberal turn. While in many Marxist accounts neoliberalism is understood simply as an intensification of capitalist exploitation, which is heightening the fundamental class antagonism between capitalists and laborers, from a Foucauldian perspective it must be understood as a new configuration of power relations that produces new forms of the subject. We have to recognize the historically specific ways that the instability and the persistent crises of capitalism have been negotiated in recent decades through neoliberal forms of governmentality – new political technologies of power and social regulation. Many socialist writers have lamented that the retreat from class analysis in the academy in the eighties and nineties was one of neoliberalism’s most effective weapons because it prevented class-consciousness from developing as the appropriate response to the rise of neoliberalism. While the spread of neoliberalism is clearly inseparable from the structural logic of capitalist accumulation, to view the subjects it produces simply as class subjects who lack the appropriate consciousness of their situation is nevertheless problematic in my view. While it is important to acknowledge that in his lectures on neoliberalism, The Birth of Biopolitics(2008), Foucault describes technologies and rationalities rather than their actual empirical outcomes, empirical and experiential evidence gives weight to the theoretical claim that the neoliberal reorganization of Western societies has resulted in new forms of the subject – a new understanding of ourselves. Social volatility and economic risks have become increasingly central for profit making and the financialization of everyday life requires new kinds of subjects and social networks (Floyd 2009, 196). Neoliberal governmentality has dramatically extended the reach of the markets and market rationality and thereby produced the corresponding subjects who are compelled to behave as market actors – consumers, individual investors and entrepreneurs – across several dimensions of their lives. As Foucault shows, neoliberal techniques scramble the traditional opposition between capitalists and workers in the sense that subjects are increasingly conceived and conceive themselves as entrepreneurs of the self, who attempt to maximize their “human capital”. Whether we focus on the reforms of pension plans and healthcare, revisions of copyright laws or the restructuring of universities, we are increasingly required to view ourselves as market-actors and to behave accordingly. These new forms of governmentality and social regulation are misrecognized insofar as they are identified as “merely” cultural or superstructural. The historically specific practices of power in which we must engage daily in order to go about our lives are not just symbolic, cultural or discursive practices as Foucault’s Marxist critics sometimes claim. They are essentially material, social and economic practices that are organized through neoliberal rationality and embedded in law and political institutions, but also in everyday social relationships. Hence, we are not confronted merely with ideological fiction that could be dispelled through the development of appropriate class-consciousness; we are confronted with a new kind of social reality. What the Foucauldian analysis of neoliberalism downplays in my view, however, is the necessary “failures” of neoliberal governmentality to constitute entrepreneurial subjects – the neoliberal constitution of “others”. The obstacles in the way of developing class consciousness are also “objective” in the second sense that we are witnessing other, radically new forms of subjectivation that are brought about by the global, neoliberal turn: the unemployed and the undocumented subjects, as well as the neocolonial, disposable subjects of the global South. It is widely acknowledged by numerous socialist writers that the composition of the workforce has dramatically changed in the last decades due to the globalization and neoliberalization of our economies. The industrial working class has been shrinking in all Western countries at a rapid rate, and has been largely replaced by post-industrial, service-sector workers, who are largely female and in part-time or precarious employment. Instead of social relations based on relatively stable forms of wage-labor, the growth of insecurity and negative flexibilization have come to increasingly characterize all work. Moreover, the majority of the poorest and the most oppressed people in the world today are not wage-laborers. They are people who have to eke out a precarious existence in the informal economy because capitalism appears to have no use for them at all. In other words, the forms of exploitation have not only assumed radically new forms, but it has become increasingly unclear what the class relations are and how we are situated in their intersections. It is imperative to also theorize these new forms of the subject and the political potential they hold for radical social transformation. That requires acknowledging the limits of both Foucault’s analysis of neoliberalism, as well as traditional Marxist class analysis, and moving beyond them.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › Marxism = Sex-Blind
Hartmann, 2006 - Heidi Hartmann is a feminist economist and the founder of the Institute for Women's Policy Research, a scientific research organization formed to meet the need for women-centered, public policy research, The Unhappy Marriage of Marxism and Feminism: Towards a More Progressive Union, HEIDI I. HARTMANN, United States 1945- . Economist. Founding Director of the Institute for Women's Policy Research (1987). Capitalism and Women's Work in the Home, 1900-1930 (1976), Women's Work, Aden's Work: Sex Segregation on the Job (1981), Comparable Worth: New Directions for Research (1985), Women, Work, and Poverty: Woman-Centered Research for Policy Change (2006).
The "marriage" of marxism and feminism has been like the marriage husband and wife depicted in English common law: marxism and feminism are one, and that one is Marxism. Recent attempts to integrate marxism and feminism are unsatisfactory to us as feminists because they subsume the feminist struggle into the "larger" struggle against capital. To continue our simile further, either we need a healthier marriage or we need a divorce. The inequalities in this marriage, like most social phenomena, are no accident. Many marxists typically argue that feminism is at best less important than class conflict and at worst divisive of the working class. This political stance produces an analysis that absorbs feminism into the class struggle. Moreover, the analytic power of marxism with respect to capital has obscured its limitations with respect to sexism. We will argue here that while marxist analysis provides essential insight into the laws of historical development, and those of capital in particular, the categories of marxism are sex-blind. Only a specifically feminist analysis reveals the systemic character of relations between men and women. Yet feminist analysis by itself is inadequate because it has been blind to history and insufficiency materialist. Both Marxist analysis, particularly its historical and materialist method, and feminist analysis, especially the identification of patriarchy as a social and historical structure, must be drawn upon if we are to understand the development of western capitalist societies and the predicament of women within them. In this essay we suggest a new direction for marxist feminist analysis. I MARXISM AND THE WOMAN QUESTION The woman question has never been the "feminist question." The feminist question is directed at the causes of sexual inequality between women and men, of male dominance over women. Most marxist analyses of women's position take as their question the relationship of women to the economic system, rather than that of women to men, apparently assuming the latter will be explained in their discussion of the former. Marxist analysis of the woman question has taken three main forms. All see women's oppression .in our connection (or lack of it) to production, Defining women as part of the working class, these analyses consistently subsume women's relation to men under worker's relation to capital. First, early marxists, including Marx, Engels, Kautsky, and Lenin, saw capitalism drawing, all women into the wage labor force, and saw this process destroying the sexual division, of labor. Second, contemporary marxists have incorporated, women into an analysis of evervdav life in capitalism. In this view, all aspects of our lives are seen to reproduce the capitalist system and we are all workers in the system. And third,, marxist feminists have focused on housework and its relation to capital, some arguing that housework produces surplus value and that houseworkers work directly for capitalists. . . . While the approach of the early marxists ignored housework and stressed women's labor force participation, the two more recent approaches emphasize housework to such an extent they ignore women's current role in the labor market. Nevertheless, all three attempt to include women in the category working class and to understand women's oppression as another aspect of class oppression. In doing so all give short shrift to the object of feminist analysis, the relations between women and men. While our "problems" have been elegantly analyzed, they have been misunderstood. The focus of Marxist analysis has been class relations; the object of marxist analysis has been understanding the laws of motion of capitalist society. While we believe marxist methodology can be used to formulate feminist strategy, these marxist feminist approaches discussed above clearly do not do so; their marxism clearly dominates their feminism. Marxism enables us to understand many aspects of capitalist societies: the structure of production, the generation of a particular occupational structure, and the nature of the dominant ideology. Marx's theory of the development of capitalism is a theory of the development of "empty places." Marx predicted, for example, the growth of the proletariat and the demise of the petit bourgeoisie. More precisely and in more detail, Braverman among others has explained the creation of the "places" clerical worker and service worker in advanced capitalist societies.2 Just as capital creates these places indifferent to the individuals who fill them, the categories of marxist analysis, class, reserve army of labor, wage laborer, do not explain why particular people, fill particular places. They give no clues about why women are subordinate to men inside and outside the family and why it is not the other way around. Marxist categories, like capital itself, are sex-blind. The categories of Marxism cannot tell us who will fill the empty places. Marxist analysis of the woman question has suffered from this basic problem.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
AT: Marxism › Alt d/n solve – Genderless
Wadley, 2010. (Jonathan, PhD in IR from Florida and currently professor of IR and sexual politics at San Diego. “Gendering the State: Performativity and Protection in International Security,” in Gender and International Security edited by Laura Sjoberg, pp. 40-41 - spp)
The analysis presented here challenges the discipline’s tendency to treat states as genderless persons by exploring the role of gender in the security performances of states. In doing so, it draws upon the concept of performativity – the idea that, in the words of Judith Butler, “identity is performatively constituted by the very ‘expression’ that are said to be its results.” It argues that performances within the field of security, much like performances within the daily lives of people, carry no intrinsic meaning, but must be made sense of through “a system of symbolic meaning” that cannot be but gendered. Through such performances, identities become salient, and masculine and feminine subjects are created. While this process is less palpable for states than it is for humans, it is nonetheless observable in broad patterns. States can be observed reifying themselves through performances of security, particularly through those which establish them as stable and masculine protectors. Recent work on the politics of protection, particularly that done by Didier Bigo, suggests the constitutive effects that protection has upon both providers and recipients. It stops short, however, of recognizing that these effects may be enabled by the gendered meaning that different forms of protection carry. When such meanings are considered, it becomes evident that by “being” masculine protectors, states can position themselves favorably in relation to other international actors and gain legitimacy from their domestic audiences. This means that states are gendered, and are gendered in much the same way as people are: through repeated performances. When state identity is viewed in this light, the anthropomorphic assumption, as it is commonly used, appears woefully inadequate. To be clear, it is not being suggested that drawing parallels between human subjects and state subjects is bad in-and-of-itself. Indeed, useful parallels can be drawn, despite (or, perhaps, because of) the notion that “both states and persons are fuzzy sets.” The trouble lies in assuming that states, or people, are constituted outside processes of interaction, and that either can be made sense of without considering the relational identities they take on through the systems of symbolic meaning through which they operate. Anthropomorphic assumptions tend to treat the state as a genderless, unitary actor – often, one that is ontologically primitive to its interactions – while neglecting the ways that the “actor-ness” and “unity” of the state are an effect of iterated, gendered performances, particularly in the realm of security. By viewing security performances with an eye toward their constitutive effects, and by moving gender to the center of that analysis, one gains not only a richer understanding of how states reproduce themselves (i.e. where their person-like “identities” come from), but a clearer picture of the hierarchical relations that exist among states and between states and domestic populations. This chapter begins with a consideration of how the state has been conceived of a person throughout the discipline, arguing that such practices almost always import an inadequate understanding of how people are constituted. In both cases, conceptualizing states and conceptualizing humans – this is a result, largely, of substance-oriented, as opposed to process-oriented, approaches. It argues that by making processes, rather than substances, the core of research, scholars will be able to more fully explain how states reproduce themselves as actors in world politics, how they garner power for themselves (in relation to other international actors, particularly states), and how they gain legitimacy from their subjects. Following that, the chapter argues that a theory of performativity can fill this need, especially in the realm of Security Studies. Moreover, such a theory would facilitate the study of gender within these processes and shed light on the incentives states have to behave as masculine actors. The final section of the chapter offers, tentatively, a way for empirical research to bear on the theoretical sketches presented here. It submits that “the rational protector model” may be examined as a type of dominant masculinity for states, one which allows them to “do” security ways that cast them as unitary, masculine actors.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
FEM IR AFF › NATO = Imperialistic
Martinez & Lolito 22 (Josefina Martinez, historian from Madrid and an editor of IzquierdaDiario.es, National Distance Education University, UNED Department of Contemporary History. Diego Lotito, journalist from Madrid, member of the Revolutionary Workers Current (CRT) and an editor of IzquierdaDiario.es. eg)
This political and military organization hegemonized by the United States in an alliance with European imperialism has experienced significant internal tensions throughout its 73-year history.3 However, after what was perhaps the period of greatest internal decline, during Donald Trump’s presidency, it has been unexpectedly revitalized by the war in Ukraine. Several member states have committed to increasing their military budgets to 2% of their GDP, thus fulfilling a NATO requirement with which, until now, few states had complied. The summit will be marked by the militaristic escalation and the rearmament of all imperialist states under the guise of “defending democracy.”
In this article we review part of its recent history to debate against the idea that it is possible for NATO to play a “democratic” or “progressive” role internationally, which has been widely repeated in Western media. But not only there. On several occasions, but especially now in the context of the war in Ukraine, we have seen “progressive” groups or sectors of the left embellish the role played by NATO, as if it were a progressive camp fighting against Putin’s reactionary regime.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › AT: Turkey
Cook 12 (Stephen A. Cook - Eni Enrico Mattei senior fellow for Middle East and Africa studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, “Don’t Fear a Nuclear Arms Race in the Middle East”, Foreign Policy, 2 April 2012, , MG)
Most important to understanding why the Middle East will not be a zone of unrestrained proliferation is the significant difference between desiring nukes and the actual capacity to acquire them. Of all three states that Shavit mentioned, the one on virtually everyone’s list for possible nuclear proliferation in response to Iran is Turkey. But the Turkish Republic is already under a nuclear umbrella: Ankara safeguards roughly 90 of the United States’ finest B61 gravity bombs at Incirlik airbase, near the city of Adana. These weapons are there because Turkey is a NATO member, and Washington’s extended deterrence can be expected to at least partially mitigate Turkey’s incentives for proliferation.
But even if the Turks wanted their own bomb, they have almost no capacity to develop nuclear weapons technology. Indeed, Turkey does not even possess the capability to deliver the 40 B61 bombs at Incirlik that are allocated to Turkish forces in the event of an attack, according to a report released by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › AT: Turkey
Ülgen 12 (Sinan Ülgen - visiting scholar at Carnegie Europe in Brussels where he researches the implications of Turkish foreign policy for Europe and the United States, “TURKEY AND THE BOMB”, The Carnegie Papers, February 2012, , MG)
Turkey has a stellar history of nonproliferation and has signed on to every relevant IAEA and international instrument governing the spread of nuclear technology. Moreover, it is a member of NATO and an EU candidate country. It is unlikely, absent a rupture in relations with its NATO allies, a significant change in its security environment, or a drastic reevaluation of Ankara’s immediate interests by the civilian leadership, that Turkey would consider developing nuclear weapons illicitly.
A Turkish decision to proliferate would seriously complicate its international standing, undermine its economic resurgence, and seriously damage relations with the United States and its other NATO allies. Moreover, any Turkish move toward weaponization would draw a harsh rebuke from the United States and would likely be met by an American proposal to strengthen security guarantees, as well as the threat of sanctions if Turkey were to continue its weapons efforts. Given Turkey’s nonnuclear history and its long-standing reliance on the NATO security guarantee, it is hard to imagine a scenario where Turkey would simply cast aside its policy in favor of an independent weapons capability.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › AT: Turkey
Eldridge 11 (William G. Eldridge – United States Air Force Commander, “The Credibility of America’s Extended Nuclear Deterrent The Case of the Republic of Turkey”, Air University Press, September 2011, , MG)
Turkey likely will “tip” if Middle East nuclear proliferation becomes widespread and NATO is perceived as ineffective and if US-Turkish relationships collapse. According to one Turkish diplomat, “things would have to get really bad” for Turkey to pursue its own nuclear weapons. Despite a rocky history, current NATO-Turkish and US-Turkish relations remain fundamentally sound, but leadership or regional security changes could strain those relationships. Factors working against Turkish nuclear weapons proliferation include the lack of support by senior Turkish leaders, the high value Turkey places on alliance relationships, the lack of funding for civilian or military nuclear programs, and Turkish treaty agreements forswearing nuclear weapons.
Despite these proliferation disincentives, Turkey will probably hedge against falling behind a potential Middle East nuclear energy (or nuclear arms) race by developing a civilian nuclear power program. As Iran continues pursuing nuclear enrichment and possibly a nuclear weapon, Turkey will likely begin to develop a nuclear power program beyond its current research stage. Turkish leaders do not fear an attack from Iran, but instead they are concerned with the shift in the regional balance of power that may result from a nuclear-armed Iran. Hedging with civilian nuclear power provides scientific and engineering expertise needed for an aggressive Turkish nuclear program if Iran’s regional influence increases or a broader Middle East nuclear arms race begins. Therefore, the United States should continue its involvement in Turkey’s emerging civilian nuclear programs utilizing the existing 2008 US-Turkish nuclear cooperation agreement (123 Agreement), develop additional cooperation agreements that encourage Turkey to forgo nuclear and spent fuel processing, encourage scientific exchanges, and consider financially supporting Turkey’s civilian nuclear energy program. The credibility of US extended nuclear deterrence for Turkey is best signaled not through US nuclear inventory types or numbers, but by demonstrations of US political, economic, and security relationships with Turkey. Turkey’s most important political and security concerns include
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › AT Funding Tradeoff
Fred Kaplan, author and journalist. His weekly "War Stories" column for Slate magazine covers international relations and U.S. foreign policy, April 23, 2021
“We Don’t Need a Better Nuclear Arsenal to Take on China,” Slate, , (accessed 5-17-2022)
Richard and other senior officers know this, which is why they’re pulling out all the stops in making the case for new nukes. This week’s hearings marked the first public roll-out of the arguments, but they’ve been rehearsed in trade journals and conferences for some time now. Last fall, the Trump administration awarded Northrop Grumman a $13.3 billion sole-source contract to start developing the new ICBM, in an attempt to lock in the project and make it harder for anyone to kill it outright. Northrop Grumman had lined up more than a dozen subcontractors—including Lockheed Martin and General Dynamics, which are normally its chief competitors—in order to widen support in Congress. There will be fierce resistance to any slowdown of the strategic juggernaut. Most members of the congressional armed services committees regard the Nuclear Triad with the same veneration that Catholics bestow to the Holy Trinity. When they ask a witness if he believes in the Triad, they do so with a quivering tone, as if they were priests asking a supplicant if he believes in God.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › AT Funding Tradeoff
William Hartung, director of the Arms and Security Project at the Center for International Policy, April 21, 2020
“Now isn’t the time to push for nuclear modernization,” Army Times, , (accessed 5-17-2022)
Eliminating ICBMs and reducing the size of the U.S. arsenal will face strong opposition in Washington, both from strategists who maintain that the nuclear triad should be sacrosanct, and from special interests that benefit from excess spending on nuclear weapons. The Senate ICBM Coalition, composed of senators from states with ICBM bases or substantial ICBM development and maintenance work, has been particularly effective in fending any changes in ICBM policy, from reducing the size of the force to merely studying alternatives, whether those alternatives are implemented or not. Meanwhile, Northrop Grumman — currently the sole bidder for the new ICBM program — has announced that it expects to have hundreds of subcontractors spread throughout the United States for its work on the new system, known formally as the Ground-Based Strategic Deterrent. The company also claims that the next phase of the work could create 10,000 jobs. That’s a tiny fraction of national employment but will pack a political punch among members of Congress whose states or districts benefit from ICBM-related employment.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › U – Allies Won’t Prolif
Korb and Cimbala 4/17 (Lawrence J. Korb - senior fellow at the Center for American Progress and a former Assistant Secretary of Defense, Stephen J. Cimbala - Distinguished Professor of Political Science at Penn State University, “Nuclear Proliferation Is Not the Answer to the War in Ukraine”, National Interest, 17 April 2021, , MG)
States may not gain much from going nuclear, even if they live in a dangerous regional neighborhood and fear aggression or coercion from one or more of their neighbors. The threshold for the use of nuclear weapons is quite high, and most military coercion takes place at lower levels. Advanced conventional weapons, including smart drones, long-range precision strike missiles, and network-centric battle management may be as important in deterring prospective attackers as is a small nuclear arsenal. For countries such as Japan, South Korea, or Australia, for example, building and deploying next-generation conventional weapons, along with regional cooperation and U.S. support, could pay greater dividends in deterrence than joining the growing list of nuclear weapons states. Conventional weapons often deter because they can actually win a war at an acceptable cost, whereas nuclear weapons only deter if the threat of use—and prospect of mutual annihilation—is credible.
Considering the downside costs of regional nuclear arms races—including massive financial costs, increased risks of proliferation or accidents, and potential sanctions—it is doubtful that any state in the Middle East or the Indo-Pacific will improve their security by developing nuclear weapons. Instead, a growing number of states with small- or medium-sized nuclear arsenals will create more anxieties about the first-strike vulnerability of those forces. Few of these prospective nuclear weapons states can afford a fleet of ballistic missile submarines, currently the most survivable platforms among operationally deployed launch systems. These countries will therefore depend almost exclusively on aircraft or missiles that are less survivable and require their commanders to preempt their opponents. More states will deploy more forces, fears of a surprise attack will multiply, and the need for survivable counter-strike capabilities will lead to more nuclear weapons deployed on a “hair trigger.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › U – Nuke Prolif Now
Maire 6/19 (Tania Gemma Maire - final year bachelor’s student in Asian Studies & Management at the University of Applied Sciences in Konstanz, “The New Nuclear Arms Race”, Modern Diplomacy, 19 June 2022, , MG)
For decades, the world has been focusing on disarmament and reducing the number of nuclear weapons in circulation. Especially the main actors mentioned above were dedicated to promoting different treaties to avoid the spread. However, these public announcements, coming from wealthy, powerful nations in possession of such arms are contradictory to the current trend in nuclear proliferation (Al Jazeera 2022).
Even more surprising is the fact that the idea of disarmament has suddenly disappeared after the Russian attack on Ukraine. In fact, in a matter of months, actors in possession of nuclear weapons have announced to invest in nuclear arms in order to increase, modernize and optimize their arsenal. Countries that wanted to get rid of nuclear arms are now putting strong importance on the capability of their weapons. Russia’s threat of using nuclear weapons against Ukraine has provoked a common global reaction to get ready for potential danger (Al Jazeera 2022).
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
NUCLEAR CREDIBILITY DA › Aff › U – No US Cred Now
Kluth 6/20 (Andreas Kluth - Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering European politics, “Europe Needs a Better Nuclear Deterrent Against Putin”, The Washington Post, 20 June 2022, , MG)
During most of the Cold War and the years since, that question seemed settled. The European NATO members are meant to shelter under America’s nuclear “umbrella.” As part of the transatlantic alliance’s “nuclear sharing,” five partner countries — Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany, Italy and Turkey — host an estimated 100 American nukes on their soil. To retaliate against a Russian strike, the allies would be able to drop these US bombs from their own planes.
Aside from those American weapons, France and the UK also have their own arsenals. But France has always kept its nukes outside the joint strategizing of the Western alliance — it’s the only nation among NATO’s 30 member states not to participate in the alliance’s Nuclear Planning Group.