Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey---Transactionalism Bad

Transactionalism exacerbates future disputes.

Coşkun 22 [Alper Coşkun; senior fellow within the Europe Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. His research focuses on Turkish foreign policy, especially in relation to the United States and Europe; 5-12-2022; "Making the New U.S.-Turkey Strategic Mechanism Meaningful"; Carnegie Endowment for International Peace; https://carnegieendowment.org/2022/05/12/making-new-u.s.-turkey-strategic-mechanism-meaningful-pub-87117; KL]

Second, while it is wise to spare the Strategic Mechanism of the burden of pointedly focusing on bilateral disagreements, assuming these matters can simply be set aside would be a mistake. The poisonous seeping effects of the problems weighing down the relationship do not afford the luxury of time. That is the underlying risk associated with seemingly practical solutions like embracing transactionalism, attempting compartmentalization, and focusing on low-hanging fruit while leaving problems on the back burner. Such an attempt would mean sleepwalking toward a future in which current problems will probably become more ossified and solutions will be harder to find. Despite such risks, Washington seems more inclined to wait things out, mostly because of its reluctance to engage in a process that is limited to rehashing arguments that have already been made to no effect. Turkey, on the other hand, seems ready to continue the debate, no matter what. The gap that needs to be bridged here involves identifying new common ground to move on. That is the incentive both sides need, and in Washington’s case, it is seen as a prerequisite. But the onus to create these conditions cannot fall on one side alone. It must be a mutual endeavor.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey---Mediation Turn

Turkey mediates peace. However, by influencing Turkey and bolstering Ukraine, Russia says no. Nuclear war.

Çuhadar 22 [Esra Çuhadar, Ph.D., senior expert for dialogue and peace processes at the U.S. Institute of Peace; Juan Diaz-Prinz, Ph.D., Acting Director, Inclusive Peace Processes and Reconciliation; 4-28-2022; "To Sustain Hopes for Peace in Ukraine, Keep an Eye on Turkey"; U.S. Institute of Peace; https://www.usip.org/publications/2022/04/sustain-hopes-peace-ukraine-keep-eye-turkey; KL]

Russia’s atrocities against Ukrainian civilians and its escalated warfare in southeastern Ukraine have swept aside last month’s public discussion of peace options as the countries briefly held talks in Turkey. Yet even in the darkest moments, all sides in this war, including the United States and Europe, have strong interests in maintaining channels for negotiation that can be used when opportunity re-emerges. Protecting that interest means understanding and maintaining Turkey’s role in facilitating talks—and its potential to serve more actively as a mediator.

By at least some norms of peace processes, Turkey is an atypical mediator—but policymakers would do well to note strengths, not widely recognized, that it can bring to this role. While analysts have suggested China, Israel, India and others as possible mediators—and while no options should be ignored—Turkey has emerged as the most immediately useful go-between. It is no accident that Turkey was Kyiv’s and Moscow’s preferred choice for their brief attempts at negotiations in March. By design, Turkey’s role in those talks was limited to facilitation, providing a secure space and even-handed treatment of Russian and Ukrainian negotiators, but without injecting Turkish observations or proposals.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey

Russian-Turkish relations are inevitable.

Kara 22 [Mehtap Kara, PhD in International Relations from Eastern Mediterranean University, assistant professor at the Department of Political Science and International Relations, Bahçeşehir Cyprus University; 6-13-2022; "Turkish-American strategic partnership: is Turkey still a faithful ally?"; Southeast European and Black Sea Studies; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14683857.2022.2088081?journalCode=fbss20; KL]

Turkish-Russian rapprochement and future of the transatlantic alliance

Turkish-Russian relations deteriorated after Turkey’s shot down of a Russian jet over Turkish territory in November 2015. However, the failed coup attempt marked a new beginning between the two. Both countries have reached agreements on several issues, including the maintaining territorial integrity of Syria despite their differences of opinion about the future of the Assad regime. Along with individual leaders’ common frustration with the Western countries, both countries also have been driven by pragmatism (Ibryamova and Kara 2017). In Turkey and Russia, the decision-making mechanism is centralized around one person. Both leaders, Erdoğan and Putin, have strong leadership characteristics and have been in power for a long time, which evidences that, further to the strategic interest, Turkish-Russian reconciliation is also the result of the overlapping ideologies of both political leaders on several issues, including being sceptical about the Western countries’ intentions, restricting media freedom, oppressing oppositions, and using nationalist narration and religious values in policy making (Nougayrède 2014). Erdoğan’s growing personal domination has turned into an authoritarian populism, especially after the Gezi Park protests and transition from parliamentary to a new presidential system, which allowed him to further consolidate his executive powers (Özpek and Tanriverdi 2018; Castaldo 2018; Özen 2020; Cilliler 2021). The new presidential system enabled Erdoğan to have a monopoly over the country’s foreign policy and national security matters. His populist rhetoric has been characterized by nationalism and anti-Western discourse where the West, particularly the US, is resituated as the ‘other’ (Kaliber and Kaliber 2019). Erdoğan seized disproportionate power to shape the country’s response to external stimuli and the AKP’s unofficial coalition partner, the far-right Nationalist Movement Party (Milliyetçi Hareket Partisi – MHP) leader Devlet Bahçeli. Both leaders’ images and threat perceptions have been based on an enemy image of Western countries.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey

Greece war draws in great powers.

Özgür 22 [Ozan Özgür; World Socialist writer; 6-14-2022; "NATO-Russia war inflames conflict between Turkey and Greece"; World Socialist Web Site; https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/06/14/xxxd-j14.html; KL]

Amid the ongoing US-NATO war against Russia in Ukraine, tensions are rising dangerously between NATO member states Turkey and Greece in the Aegean Sea. The two countries are holding war games aimed at each other, trading accusations of disregarding international treaties, and violating each other’s borders with jet fighters and warships.

The Turkish Armed Forces (TSK) Ephesus 2022 exercise, held in the Aegean Sea and attended by more than 10,000 military personnel, ended last week. Thirty-seven countries, including the United States and Italy, participated in air, sea and land drills. Held in Seferihisar, only 1.5 kilometers from the nearby Greek island of Samos in the Aegean Sea, the exercise was based on the scenario of a “military landing on an island.” It was widely treated in Turkish capitalist media as a threat against Greece.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey

Greece says no and despises the plan. Or it escalates. This is their prime minister’s speech.

Mitsotakis 22 [Kyriakos Mitsotakis, Prime Minister of Greece; 6-7-2022; "Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis’ address to the Joint Session of the US Congress"; ekathimerini.com; https://www.ekathimerini.com/news/1184653/prime-minister-kyriakos-mitsotakis-address-to-the-joint-session-of-the-us-congress/; KL]

And speaking of open acts of aggression, I ask you, esteemed members of Congress, not to forget an open wound that has caused Hellenism unending pain over the past 48 years. I am referring to the invasion and subsequent division of Cyprus. This issue has to be resolved in accordance with international law and in line with the relevant decisions of the United Nations Security Council. As I told President Biden yesterday, nobody can and nobody will accept a two- state solution in Cyprus.

The same is true for all other regional disputes. Greece is a peace seeking democracy that always extends a hand of friendship to our neighbors. We are always open to dialogue. But there is only one framework we can use to resolve our differences: international law and the unwritten principles of good neighborly relations.

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey

Sales have significant implications for the Greek-Turkish security balance.

Zanotti 22 [Jim Zanotti, Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs; Clayton Thomas, Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs; 6-7-2022; "Turkey: Background and U.S. Relations In Brief"; Congressional Research Service; https://sgp.fas.org/crs/mideast/R44000.pdf; KL]

With U.S. officials already having notified a possible upgrade of F-16s for Greece to Congress in 2021,104 U.S. willingness to upgrade Turkish F-16s could have significant implications for the security balance between Turkey and Greece, and for relations involving the three countries.105 Erdogan announced in May 2022 that he would no longer deal with Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis, after Mitsotakis appeared to raise concern about U.S.-Turkey arms transactions while addressing a May 17 joint session of Congress.106 Turkey and Greece have long-standing disputes over maritime and airspace boundaries, energy exploration, and the status of Cyprus (see text box). A recent 2019-2020 spike in tensions has somewhat subsided, but during that time Greece strengthened its relations with the United States and a number of regional countries such as France, Israel, and Egypt.107

2022 Michigan Negative
Neg – PGMs 2 – BFHR › PGMs NEG › 1NC---AT: Turkey

Appeasement fails.

Aktar 22 [Cengiz Aktar; professor of political science at the University of Athens; 5-23-2022; "Appease and enable: The West’s disastrous Russia and Turkey policies"; POLITICO; https://www.politico.eu/article/appease-enable-west-disastrous-russi-turkey-policies/; KL]

Despite how odd Turkey’s strategic choices as a NATO member may be, the West continues to do business as usual with Ankara.

Western powers once again make excuses for President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, understanding Turkey’s mysterious “legitimate security concerns,” which often equates to a license to kill. But by appeasing him for the sake of “keeping” the country within NATO, they miss the point that the Turkish leader is not so different from Russian President Vladimir Putin — and that once again, a policy of appeasement simply won’t work.

2022 Michigan Kritik

Cap Good

Markets solve sustainability and are the only way to solve warming

Adler 22, Jonathan H. Adler is the Johan Verheij Memorial Professor of Law and Director of the Coleman Burke Center for Environmental Law at the Case Western Reserve University School of Law; "How Markets Make Economic Growth Sustainable," Reason, 3-30-2022, https://reason.com/volokh/2022/03/30/how-markets-make-economic-growth-sustainable/, Accessed 7-4-2022, LASA-SC

Fifty years ago, researchers at MIT produced The Limits to Growth, a report on how existing economic trends foretold environmental ruin. Left unchecked, the authors predicted, expanding populations and economic growth would exhaust global resources and ultimately prompt civilizational collapse. The models upon which Limits was based suggested that global reserves of copper, silver, lead, tin, zinc, and petroleum would have all run out by now, and the world would be struggling to find enough arable land to feed a population of over 7 billion people. Without governmental efforts to change global trends, "[t]he most probable result will be a rather sudden and uncontrollable decline in both population and industrial capacity," the authors warned. As should be obvious, the predictions offered in The Limits to Growth (and other contemporary doomsayers) were wildly off the mark. Among other things, they failed to account for how markets respond to scarcity, producing incentives for efficiency and innovation, so that we may do more with less. In short, the authors failed to understand why markets encourage sustainability. Those predicting imminent depletion of global resources and exhaustion of the earth's carrying capacity also failed to predict what is arguably the most important -- and under-appreciated -- positive environmental trend of the 21st century: Dematerialization of modern economies. The same economic incentives which forestalled resource exhaustion have actually enabled people to do more with less throughout the developed world. This dramatic development is chronicled in Andrew McAfee's book, More from Less: The Surprising Story of How We Learned to Prosper Using Fewer Resources — and What Happens Next, which I reviewed for Regulation. Here is an excerpt from my review: Dematerialization may be the most important, yet unsung, example of environmental progress in the 21st century. It is commonplace to observe that the relentless drive to do more with less has led to more efficient resource use, so that a soda can today is made with a fraction of the metal required 50 years ago. But dematerialization is not merely a story about increased efficiency or per‐​capita reductions. What is now being observed represents a fundamental decoupling of resource consumption from economic growth, such that as mature economies grow, they not only use fewer resources per unit of output, but they also consume fewer resources overall. In short, economic growth in the most developed nations increasingly coincides with a net reduction in resource consumption. Let that sink in. It is not merely that we are using resources more efficiently in countries like the United States. It's also that we are actually using fewer total resources year-over-year. The United States uses less gold, steel, aluminum, copper, stone, cement, and even paper than it did at the start of this century, despite the continued increase in gross domestic product. Annual consumption of all but six of the 72 resources tracked by the U.S. Geological Service are "post peak." We also use less fertilizer and water while growing more crops. Plastic consumption is up, as is energy use, but these two appear to have been decoupled from population and economic growth as well. How does this dematerialization occur? Some examples may be useful. The dematerialization of soda cans is relatively easy to grasp, particularly for those of us who can remember the heavier cans of the 20th century. Aluminum cans weighed 85 grams when introduced in the 1950s. By 2011, the average can was under 13 grams. Cans today are not only thinner and lighter, they are produced more efficiently, with fewer separate sheets of metal. Substitution can be an even more powerful source of dematerialization. Consider telecommunications. A single fiber optic cable made from less than 150 pounds of silica can carry the same volume of information as multiple 1‑ton copper cables. And were that not enough, satellite and wireless technologies enable us to bypass the use of physical cables altogether. We can communicate more and yet use vastly less material to do so. This not only saves copper, but other resources too. Think of all the paper saved by e‑mail, e‑banking, and e‑readers. Not only did neo-Malthusians not predict these developments, they failed to recognize that such trends would be driven by private markets, and not governmental regulation. We do more with less not because of government regulation or administrative direction, but because of capitalism and technology. These are the dominant forces driving dematerialization in the most developed countries and they could unleash similar gains in the rest of the world. We "want more all the time, but not more resources," McAfee notes. We want more of what resources can provide, and one way to get more is to do more with less. Market capitalism both facilitates and enhances the underlying incentives that drive efficiency gains and technological advance. This not only leads to dematerialization but also promotes "critical aspects of well‐​being," including health and prosperity. Unfortunately, these trends are not universal. While we consume fewer resources in developed nations, these trends have not (yet) taken hold in many developing countries, which often lack well-functioning market economies. We have also not observed equivalent trends in many forms of pollution, largely because emissions are not priced the way consumption is. An entrepreneur who figures out how to produce widgets while using less copper gains an economic advantage, as the copper must be paid for. An entrepreneur who figures out how to emit fewer particulates or nitrogen oxides does not, as emitting such pollutants is not meaningfully priced and contemporary regulations rarely create meaningful incentives for emission reductions on the margin. Understanding what has encouraged and allowed for dematerialization at the same time that populations have expanded and economies have grown is essential if these trends are to be replicated in developing countries and if we are to meet contemporary environmental challenges, including climate change. A suite of policies designed to replicate the same market dynamics that have led dematerialization could spur meaningful decarbonization. Ill-conceived policies, on the other hand, could actually do more harm than good. This is but one more reason policymakers should be more interested in fiscal instruments than regulatory mandates to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Another article in the same issue of Regulation as my More from Less review notes that greenhouse gas emissions in the United States may have peaked in 2005, and that GHG emissions appear to initially increase, but then decline, with economic growth. Such trends are not observed, however, in less-developed and less-market-oriented economies, such as China. The authors, Bruce Yandle and Jody Lipford, think this indicates that domestic GHGs could continue to decline going forward, even without new government policies. This may be so, but the reductions are nowhere near what would be achieved if carbon emissions were priced and there were more powerful market incentives for market decarbonization. Greater market incentives for decarbonization could also lead to the development and deployment of low-carbon technologies that could facilitate emission reductions in other countries as well, and given that climate change is a global concern, such measures will be necessary if atmospheric stabilization is to be achieved. The bottom line is that competitive markets create powerful incentives for efficient and sustainable resource use. Market-driven innovation has made it possible to provide for more people using fewer resources. Such environmental successes are often ignored because there is no policymaker or program than can take credit for them. They are the result of market processes, not governmental direction or design.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2ac left melancholy turn

The negative’s nostalgia for an anti-capitalism before post structuralism is left melancholy -- causes more political inaction

Dean 14 [Contemporary Political Theory, 4 November 2014, “Radicalism restored? Communism and the end of left melancholia,” Jonathan, School of Politics and International Studies, University of Leeds]

- The left likes to blame capitalism on everything and then we don’t know how to come up with effective resistances outside of cap (fem, queer, etc.) leads to clogging because we can only think in terms of capitalism

2022 Michigan Kritik

2ac anti-blackness turns

The freedom of the anti-capitalist worker is premised upon a denial of blackness because it remains on the terrain of beings. Their claim to produce freedom for blackness relies on a vicious ruse of analogy that re-elaborates on the conditions of slavery.

Barber (Daniel Colucciello, Department Member ICI Berlin Institute for Cultural Inquiry) 2016 (The Creation of Non-Being, Rhizome, Issue 29, , C.A.)

[28] This is to name the essential limit of Lazzarato's account as the failure to analyze the ways in which the domination of capitalism is constituted by the domination of anti-blackness. In making this claim, I am following Wilderson's argument that "the privileged subject of Marxist discourse is a subaltern who is approached by variable capital—a wage. In other words, Marxism assumes a subaltern structured by capital, not by white supremacy" (Wilderson 2003: 225). The essential limit of Marxism, he argues, is its theorization of capitalism in terms of "exploitation (rather than accumulation and death)" (Wilderson 2003: 234). Marxism thus begins from and stays within the being of whiteness, a being whose coherence is premised on the denial of the fact that capital "was kick-started by approaching a particular body (a Black body) with direct relations of force, not by approaching a White body with variable capital" (Wilderson 2003: 230). [29] The position of the worker, in virtue of its raced difference from the position of the slave, asserts a capacity for analogical relation—even amidst exploitation—with the exploiter. The exploited and the exploiter, despite their asymmetry, share a being that is made through the denial of blackness, which is positioned as the slave; the worker possesses an analogical relation to the owner that the slave does not. To presume that the slave position can be analogized with the worker position is thus to attribute the latter's analogical capacity to the former, which is without analogy. It is to presume an analogy between what is capable of being analogous with what is not: "the ruse of analogy" (Wilderson 2010: 37). [30] This means, as well, that there can be no question of an intersection between separate but equal spheres of class and anti-black racism, much less of an account that takes up anti-blackness as a means of proceeding toward a supposedly essential antagonism of class. Against such accounts, Wilderson remarks that, within them, "racism is read off the base, as it were, as being derivative of political economy" (Wilderson 2003: 225). On the contrary, what is essential is anti-black racism, or the incommensurability between non-being and being: class division concerns relations between analogizable terms (owner and worker) that, however conflictual or exploitative, presume a common being, a being whose making—and being made coherent—is premised on (the denial of) the real non-being of the slave. [31] All this is to say that anti-black racial ontology is the condition of possibility for the Marxist demand—central to Lazzarato's own version of autonomist Marxism—for being free from exploitation. As Christina Sharpe remarks: "The legal captivity of Africans and their descendants was central to the codification of rights and freedoms for those legally constituted as white and their legally white descendants. That is, freedoms for those people constituted as white were and are produced through an other's body legally and otherwise being made to wear unfreedom and to serve as a placeholder for access to the freedoms that are denied the black subject" (Sharpe 2010: 15). The being of freedom, or the articulation of a free being – that is, the very link between being and freedom—is premised upon a denial of blackness, or non-being. This is the case even (or especially) when freedom is expressed as a possibility, for such possibility—pertaining only to that which has already emerged as being—cannot articulate that which this emergence denies. As Saidiya V. Hartman remarks, the "language of freedom no longer becomes that which rescues the slave from his or her former condition, but the site of the re-elaboration of that condition" (Hartman and Wilderson 2003: 185). [32] Freedom names the modulative, mutational possibilities of being(s). Marxist discourse, however innovative, addresses free beings, or the being of freedom. It leaves unthought non-being, the reality of which is logically prior to all being, and thus to all possibilities of being. It is for this reason that Lazzarato's account of capitalism in terms of debt, while an extremely innovative form of contemporary Marxism, still fails to articulate the essential antagonism of non-being. When Lazzarato speaks of the indebted man, of the "we" of debt inheritance, he is speaking of the position that Marxism ascribes to the worker—instead of a capital-work relation we have, in Lazzarato, a credit-debt relation. Debt innovatively re-defines the meaning of work, but it does not change the positionality of the worker, which remains as the position of the debtor. His critique proceeds in virtue of a link—foreclosed by debt—between being and freedom, without ever articulating that the very possibility of this link is premised on the denial of non-being, on the making of blackness as that which is without the possibility of being free. Lazzarato thereby fails to address how the being of the worker, now the indebted man, is rendered visible by standing out against the background of (black) flesh.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2ac marxism fails

The worker has disappeared --- the lack of spatial proximity and continuity between workers denies the possibility of class solidarity fomenting meaningful resistance. Moreover, Marx’s economic theory understands labor as divisible into discrete units of time, but the floating, arbitrary value of money combined with the depersonalization of time means today’s cognitive worker no longer has no discrete surplus-value to be stolen

Bifo 15 [Francesco ‘Bifo’ Berardi, Professor of Social History of Communication at the Accademia di Belle Arti of Milan, Heroes: Mass Murder and Suicide, Verso: Brooklyn, NY, 2015, p. 138-42]

The recombinant alliance of cognitive work and financial capital was over. The young army of free agents, selfexploiters and virtual prosumers was transformed into modernity’s horde of precarious cognitive workers: cognitarians, cognitive proletarians and internet-slaves who invest nervous energy in exchange for a precarious revenue.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2ac perm

Permutation do both – undertaking an intercommunal perspective incorporates the useful political programs of the alternative with the orientation and planning of the affirmative

Narayan 17 -- John Narayan (2017) Department of Sociology, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK The wages of whiteness in the absence of wages: racial capitalism, reactionary intercommunalism and the rise of Trumpism, Third World Quarterly, 38:11, 2482-2500, DOI: 10.1080/01436597.2017.1368012

Conclusion: dealing with the end of the wages of whiteness This article has attempted to retrieve Huey P. Newton’s seemingly forgotten theorisation of imperialism’s transition to reactionary intercommunalism, not only to achieve some form of epistemic justice, but also because Newton’s thought speaks urgently to our present. It has taken over 40 years for the contours of a truly global capitalism to match up with Newton’s proto-theorisation of neo-liberal globalisation. But Newton’s theoretical prescience also centres on his appreciation of how such changes would be refracted through issues of race and whiteness that underpin the US state and its economy. In conclusion, I want to reflect on Newton’s thought and why we should return to his ideas to understand the era of Trumpism. It is my contention that Newton’s reflection on what the future may hold under reactionary intercommunalism may in fact be words about our present. In a 1972 discussion with sociologists Franz Schurmann and Alberto Martinelli, Newton outlined his theory of intercommunalism and the future’s likely political trajectory. Newton’s main point to Schurmann and Martinelli was that the changes associated with reactionary intercommunalism, chiefly its technological displacement of jobs and the global spread of capitalist social relations, meant that Western imperialism’s wages of whiteness, where imperial conquest led to a bargain between capital and the white working and middle classes in the metropole, were effectively over. Indeed, as Newton told an audience at Yale in 1971, he hoped white America would unite with ‘those people who are already unemployable’, but whether this did or didn’t happen that ‘material existence will have changed. The proletarian will become the lumpen proletarian’.60 Newton’s interview with Schurmann and Martinelli saw him declare that either the white US population would come to terms with this reality, and embrace the objective class relations between themselves and the vast array of humanity, or they would start on a path towards world war three: The people here have to realize that they live at the expense of the world, and this includes the workers. Either the people will oppose the reactionary circle for survival, for peace, or else they will go into the third world war. So our basic problem is educating and organizing.61 Returning to Newton’s ruminations on the impossibly of resupplying the wages of whiteness highlights how dangerous the death of the wages of whiteness may actually be for us all today. Trumpism’s attempt to resupply the wages of whiteness through racism, nationalism and xenophobia, places humanity on a likely path towards war. Despite Trump’s claim that ‘jobs will return, incomes will rise and new factories will come rushing back to our shores’,62 Trumpism is unlikely to supply any jobs and material wages to its supporters because it is not designed or capable of doing so. Just as Du Bois highlighted at the start of the twentieth century that the wages of whiteness were designed by the elite to split class unity along racial lines, Trumpism’s wages of whiteness appear designed to split class unity for elite ends at the start of the twenty-first century. Trump’s economic plans, dubbed ‘Trumponomics’, essentially repackage neo-liberal ‘trickle-down’ policies with the promise of Keynesian stimulus. Trump has proposed massive infrastructure spending combined with huge tax cuts for the rich and corporations and further deregulation in the hope of generating investment and jobs. The 30-year track record of neo-liberalism has shown that these policies are unlikely to illicit investment in the economy and such a strategy seems incapable of addressing how technology, as Newton realised, will eliminate ever more jobs.63 As such, Trumpism will likely continue the processes of enriching elites and corporations at the expense of all members of the working and middle classes.64 This failure to supply the economic wages of whiteness will in turn likely be supplemented with the overtures to trade protectionism (Border Tax), racist and xenophobic polices such as (Muslim) travel bans, illegal migrant deportations, border wall building and military actions that aim to supply the psychological aspects of the wages of whiteness. This will simply be the supplying of the wages of whiteness in the absence of wages. There thus appears more chance that we shall see a race war in the US than any potential class struggle. However, the changes brought about by reactionary intercommunalism have also changed the nature of geo-politics and made such resurgent nationalism a more likely conduit for war on the international stage. The quest to remake the world in the American image, or rather in its interests, has enriched non-Western elites and empowered nations in the Global South in ways even Newton could not have foreseen. Although the ‘neo-liberalism with southern characteristics’ of the BRICS bloc does not yet mark an ideological and geo-political alternative to US and wider Western power, it does mark a world of increasing multi-polarity.65 What chance that a trade war or imperial proxy war induced by Trumpism could lead to what Newton called the third world war? Yet, Newton’s thought also offers us a vision of an alternative approach to dealing with the end of the wages of whiteness and perhaps herein lays the true value of returning to Newton in the age of Trumpism. Newton’s discussion with Schurmann and Martinelli revealed his frustration with the Western left’s fixation with the ‘factory as a phase that does not go through transformation’.66 In Newton’s eyes the left couldn’t simply repeat the fantasy of returning to the post-war settlement between labour and capital. Not only was such a position unachievable due to the changes induced by reactionary intercommunalism, but also because such a position failed to see how the post-war era of embedded liberalism was itself a racialised imperial formation. Newton argued against nostalgic pleas for national forms of socialism, which had been used to imperially split humanity across the colour-line, and for a transnational politics he called ‘Revolutionary intercommunalism’.67 Revolutionary intercommunalism functioned off the recognition of the interconnected nature of the global economy and the need to deliver equality and justice for the entirety of the world’s communities. Above all else, revolutionary intercommunalism rejected the idea that nationalist settlements, whether Black, white or socialist, were the pathways towards liberation. In light of reactionary intercommunalism’s global dimensions, Newton argued that only a global form of justice that would equally share the productivity and resource gains of technology would now suffice: In order for a revolution to occur in the United States you would have to have a redistribution of wealth not on a national or international level, but on an intercommunal level. Because how can we say that we have accomplished revolution if we redistribute the wealth just to people here in North America when the ruling circle itself is guilty of trespass de bonis asportatis. That is, they have taken away the goods of the people of the world, transported them to America and used them as their very own.68 Revolutionary intercommunalism saw the BPP create alliances with a plethora of social movements both within and beyond the US. These included the student-led anti-Vietnam War and Peace movements, Latino groups like the Young Lords Organisation and poor white American groups like the Young Patriots Organisation and ‘peoples of world’ pursuing nationhood, such the National Liberation Front in South Vietnam (NLF), the Mozambique Liberation Front (FRELIMO) and Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO). 69 The aim of revolutionary intercommunalism was not only to create a united front of oppressed peoples against global capitalism, but also to create alternative forms of life to the capitalist way of life. This ethos was exemplified in the BBP’s ‘survival programmes’, community-based programmes that were set-up and run by the Panthers and wider community to provide services such as free healthcare, free breakfasts for school children and free clothing for the Black community and other communities who had been excluded from the spoils of US capitalism. As Singh has suggested, the practices of the BPP’s survival programmes not only filled these gaps in welfare but also provided a ‘projection of sovereignty’ that rivalled the ‘reality principle’ of the US state.70 This entailed a practical deconstruction of the idea of state power (policing, education, welfare) that reimagined spaces and practices along new intercommunal lines of self-determination and democracy. Through attempting to disrupt class relations, racial segregation and gender roles, the BPP’s survival programmes also attempted to offer alternative ways of life, both institutionally and ideologically, to the racially divisive, class exploitative and gendered structures of capitalist society.71 The value of returning to Newton’s thought today thus lays not only with his appreciation of how reactionary intercommunalism would be refracted through issues of race and whiteness, but also with how Newton’s vision of revolutionary intercommunalism demands us to link the project of anti-imperialist solidarity with the creation of alternative intercommunal ways of life to capitalist society. This especially pertinent given that Trumpism’s critique of neo-liberal globalisation ironically shares elements of the left’s own social democratic critique of neo-liberal globalisation.72 Although violently disagreeing on the means, both Trumpism and social democracy aim towards the end of taming global capitalism through reasserting national controls (whether this is through racist approaches to immigration or raising taxes) and alleviating economic insecurity through job creation (whether this is through deregulation and tax cuts or increased regulation and government spending). Newton’s work on intercommunalism leads us to question the very categories of labour, nation, capital and democracy that underpin both Trumpism and contemporary social democratic politics. For example, Newton’s theory of intercommunalism makes it clear that we must question the linking of wage labour and income in an environment where technology eliminates vast sways of jobs and labour markets are racially discriminatory. Moreover, we must ask this question with a global rather than solely a national inflexion. Newton’s thought thus demands that we consider a new politics that would create new institutions and ideologies that could serve and liberate communities both within and beyond the boundaries of nation states. Returning to Newton’s theorisation of reactionary intercommunalism, and his conclusion that both white supremacy and nationally bounded socialism were incapable of dealing with the contradictions of global capital, thus implores us to pursue a politics of intercommunal revolution rather than mere national reform. This may sound idealistic as we encounter the re-emergence of racist populism in the US and wider Western world.73 However, Newton’s work reminds us that the contradictions of racial capitalism under the machinations of reactionary intercommunalism also offer the possibilities of hope as well as horror. Newton saw a chance for intercommunal solidarity and the creation of alternative forms of life because he believed the effects of the dwindling wages of whiteness now meant that the white populaces in the US were ‘more ready to fight’ than ever before. The key was to answer the questions ‘who shall he fight? Who is your enemy? Who is your friend?’ Newton challenged the left in the West ‘to show [that] the other unemployables are not the enemy’.74 In our contemporary moment these words, and the anti-racist and anti-imperialist politics they commit us to, seem as urgent as the time they were first spoken.

2022 Michigan Kritik

2ac alt fails

Capitalism is not bounded by the exploitation of labor but extends itself through a productive imperative and the expropriation of land from the Native and the body of the slave. Their appeal to a transition state established by a worker’s party [insert their alternative] strengthens systems of state-based theft, racial accumulation and policing because the state requires these formations in order to function.

Wang 18 [Jackie, writer, poet, musician, and academic whose writing has been published by Lies Journal, HTML Giant, and BOMBlog, PhD African-American Studies @ Harvard, p. 112-25//AK47]

Racial Capitalism and Settler Colonialism Given the dual character of capitalist accumulation identified by both Rosa Luxemburg and David Harvey, what new understanding of capitalism would be generated by focusing on dispossession and expropriation over .work and production? Contemporary political theorists as well as critical ethnic studies, black studies, and Native studies scholars and activists analyze how racial slavery and seeder colonialism provide the material and territorial foundation for U.S. and Canadian sovereignty. Rather than casting slavery and Native genocide as temporally circumscribed events chat inaugurated the birth of capitalism in the New World ("primitive accumulation"), they show how the racial logics produced by these processes persist to this day: In order to recuperate the frame of political economy, a focus on the dialectic of racial slavery and settler colonialism leads to important revisions of Karl Marx's theory of primitive accumulation. In particular, Marx designates the transition from feudal to capitalist social relations as a violent process of primitive accumulation whereby "conquest, enslavement, robbery, murder, in short, force, play the greatest part." For Marx, chis results in the expropriation of the worker, the proletariat, who becomes the privileged subject of capitalist revolution. [f we consider primitive accumulation 35 a persistent structure rather than event, both Afro-pessimism and settler colonial studies destabilize normative conceptions of capitalism through the conceptual displacements of the proletariat. As Coulthard demonstrates, in considering Indigenous peoples in relation to primitive accumulation, "it appears that the history and experience of dispossession, not proletarianization, has been the dominant background structure shaping the character of the historical relationship between Indigenous peoples and the Canadian state." It is thus dispossession of land through genocidal elimination, relocation, and theft that animates Indigenous resistance and anticapitalism and "less around our emergent status 35 'rightless proletarians.'" If we extend the frame of primitive accumulation to the question of slavery, it is the dispossession of the slave's body rather than the proletarianization of labor that both precedes and exceeds the frame of settler colonial and global modernity. 13 As lyko Day notes, Native dispossession occurs through the expropriation of land, while black dis􀄅 possession is characterized by enslavement and bodily dispossession. Although both racial logics buttress white accumulation and are defined by a "genocidal limit concept" that constitutes these subjects as disposable, Day notes that "the racial content of Indigenous peoples is the mirror opposite of blackness. From the beginning, an eliminatory project was driven to reduce Native populations through genocidal wars and later through statistical elimination through blood quantum and assimilationist policies. For slaves, an opposite logic of exclusion was driven to increase, not eliminate, the population of slaves."14 A debate has ensued in critical ethnic studies about which axis of dispossession is capitalism's condition of possibility: the expropriation of Native land or chattel slavery? Was the U.S. made possible primarily by unbridled access to black labor, or through territorial conquest? Is the global racial order defined-as Day writes-primarily by the indigenous-settler binary or the black-nonblack binary? At stake in this debate is the question of which axis of dispossession is the "base" from which the "superstructures" of economy, national sovereignty, or even subjectivity itself emerge. Those who argue that settler colonialism is central have sometimes made the claim that even black Americans participate in settler colonialism and indigenous displacement by continuing to live on stolen land, while those who center slavery and antiblackness have sometimes viewed Native Americans as perpetrators of anriblackness insofar as some uibes have historically owned slaves and seek state recognition by making land-based claims to sovereignty-a claim that relies on a political grammar that black Americans do not have access to, as slaves were rem from their native lands when they were transported co the Americas (see Jared Sexton's "The Vel of Slavery"). Although weighing in on this debate is beyond rhe scope of this essay, I generally agree with Day's assertion that to treat this set of issues as a zero-sum game obfuscates the complexity of these processes. With that said, it is important to note that this book deals primarily with the antiblack dimensions of prisons, police, and racial capitalism, though I acknowledge that analyses of settler colonialism are equally vital to understanding the operations of racial capitalism and how race is produced through multiple expropriative logics. Gendered Expropriation Though this book focuses primarily on black racialization in a contemporary context, it is worth noting that expropriation reproduces multiple categories of difference--including the man-woman gender binary. Although categories of difference were not invented by capitalism, expropriative processes assign particular meanings to categories of difference. "Woman" is reproduced as inferior through the unwaged theft of her labor, while the esteem of the category of "man" is propped up by the valorization of his labor. Even when women are in the professional workforce, they are still vulnerable to expropriation when they are given or take on work beyond their formal duties-whether it's washing the dishes at the office, mentoring students, or doing thankless administrative work while male colleagues gee the "dysfunctional genius" pass. But above all, gendered expropriation occurs through the extraction of care labor, emotional labor, as well as domestic and reproductive labor all of which is enabled by the enforcement of a rigid gender binary. This system is propped up by gender socialization, which compels women to psychologically internalize a feeling of responsibility for others. Although, at a glance, ic might seem that the expropriation of women's labor happens primarily through housewifeitization, the marriage contract, and the assignment of child-care duties to women, in the current epoch-characterized by an aging baby boomer population and a shortage of geriatric health-care workers-women are increasingly filling this void by taking care of sick parents, family members, and loved ones. It is hardly surprising that two-thirds of those who care for chose with Alzheimer's disease are women, even as women are the primary victims of this disease. Given thac women's lives are often interrupted by both childcare duties and caring for ailing family members, it's also hardly surprising that women accumulate many fewer assets and arc more likely to retire into poverty than their male counterparts. A recent report found that the European Union gender pension gap was 40 percent, which far exceeds the gender pay gap of 16 percent. Overall, gender is a material relation that, among other things, bilks women of their futures. The aged woman who has toiled by caring for others is left with little by the end of her life. Though gender distinctions are maintained through expropriative processes, they also have consequences beyond the economic and material realm. While it could be said that disposability is the logic that corresponds to racialized expropriation, gendered subjectivation has as its corollary rapeability. It also goes without saying that these expropriative logics are not mutually exclusive, as nonwhite women and gender-nonconforming people may be subject to a different set of expropriative logics than white women. Racalized Expropriation Although I do not claim that expropriation should be defined exclusively as racialization (again, because different expropriative logics reproduce multiple categories of difference), this book deals primarily with the antiblack racial order that is produced by late-capitalist accumulation. Michael C. Dawson and Nancy Fraser are two contemporary political theorists who have defined expropriation as a racializing process in capitalist societies. In "Hidden in Plain Sight," Dawson takes Fraser to task for not acknowledging racialized expropriation as one of the "background domains" of capitalist society. Understanding the logic of expropriation, in his view, is necessary for understanding which modes of resistance are needed at this historical juncture. His article begins with a meditation on the question: Should activists and movements such as Black Lives Matter focus on racialized state violence (police shootings, mass incarceration, and so forth), or should they focus on racialized inequality cawed by expropriation and exploitation? What is the relationship between the first logic-characterized by disposability-and the second logic-characterized by exploitability and expropriability? Rather than describing these logics as distinct forms of antiblack racism, he analyzes them as two dimensions of a dynamic process whereby capitalist expropriation generates the racial order by fracturing the population into superior and inferior humans: Understanding the foundation of capitalism requires a consideration of "the hidden abode of race": the ontological distinction between superior and inferior humans-codified as race-that was necessary for slavery, colonialism, the theft of lands in the Americas, and genocide. This racial separation is manifested in the division between full humans who possess the right to sell their labor and compete within markets, and chose that are disposable, discriminated against, and ultimately either eliminated or superexploited.15 Black racialization, then, is the mark that renders subjects as suitable for-on the one hand-hyperexploitation and expropriation, and, on the other hand, annihilation. Before the neoliberal era, the racial order was propped up by the state, and racial distinctions were enforced through legal codification, Jim Crow segregation, and other formal arrangements. In a contemporary context, though the legal regime undergirding the racial order has been dismantled, race has maintained its dual character, which consists of "not only a probabilistic assignment of relative economic value but also an index of differential vulnerability to state violence." 16 In other words, vulnerability to hyperexploitation and expropriation in the economic domain and vulnerability to premature death in the political and social domains. My essay on the Ferguson Police Department and the city's program of municipal plunder is an attempt to make visible the hidden backdrop of Mike Brown's execution: the widespread racialized expropriation of black residents carried out by the criminal justice arm of the state. It is not just that Mike Brown's murder happened alongside the looting of residents at the behest of the police and the city's financial manager, but that racial legacies that have marked black residents as lootable are intimately tied to police officers' treatment of black people as killable. The two logics reinforce and are bound up with each other. In her response co Dawson's analysis of racialization as expropriation, Fraser develops Dawson's claims by looking at the interplay between economic expropriation and "politically enforced status distinctions." 17 Not only does accumulation in a capitalist society occur along the two axes of exploitation and expropriation, but one makes the other possible in that the "racialized subjection of those whom capital expropriates is a condition of possibility for the freedom of those whom it exploits." 18 In other words, the "front story" of free workers who are contracted by capitalists to sell their labor-power for a wage is enabled by, and depends on, expropriation that takes place outside this contractual arrangement.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Politics › 2AC – Competitiveness – Thumpers

Antitrust bills are at the top of the agenda – Schumer is distracted

Kelly 7/22 (Makena, reporter at The Verge where she writes about the politics of the internet and a wide array of tech policy issues, 7-22-2022, "Progressives pressure Schumer to call a vote on tech antitrust bills," Verge, https://www.theverge.com/2022/7/22/23273924/progressives-antitrust-reform-bills-klobuchar-chuck-schumer-aico, DOA: 7-22-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

With a months-long recess on the horizon, House progressives are urging Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to act fast on two competition bills that would better equip antitrust enforcers to take on major tech firms.

In a letter sent to Schumer on Friday, more than a dozen Congressional Progressive Caucus leaders urged the Senate majority leader to schedule a vote on two bills in the coming weeks.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Politics › 2AC – Competitiveness – Fails

The bill is too little too late

Desiderio 7/20 (Andrew Desiderio, a congressional reporter for POLITICO, covering the Senate, national security and foreign policy, 7-20-2022, "How Congress' dream of a China confrontation got gutted," POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/20/congress-china-bill-gutted-00046842, DOA: 7-21-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

Congress’ big swing at China’s economic and geopolitical ambitions turned out to be mostly a whiff.

The Senate is poised to abandon months of work on legislation overhauling U.S. policy toward Beijing when, as soon as this week, it approves a drastically slimmed-down bill to boost domestic semiconductor manufacturing. It will do so without a firm guarantee that those tough-on-China provisions left on the cutting-room floor will ever become law.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Politics › 2AC – Competitiveness – Bad

The bill sabotages US competitiveness

The Editors 7/25 (The Editors, comprise the senior editorial staff of the National Review magazine and website.7-25-2022, "Semiconductor Bill: CHIPS Legislation Leaves U.S. at Disadvantage vs. China, "National Review, https://www.nationalreview.com/2022/07/semiconductor-bill-leaves-u-s-at-disadvantage-against-china/, DOA: 7-25-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

The CHIPS legislation advancing rapidly through the Senate is many things. It is an industrial-policy bill and a handout to the higher-education industry. It’s a bill intended to further entrench progressive pieties on diversity and equity within the federal bureaucracy. And it is expensive. What it is not, however, is a tool for improving Washington’s lot in the competition with the Chinese Communist Party.

After over a year of back-and-forth, lawmakers seem poised to converge on a final version of the so-called U.S. Innovation and Competition Act this week. At first, it seemed that the final package would contain about $52 billion in subsidies for semiconductor manufacturing and some miscellaneous other provisions. But, as lawmakers realized that a larger version of the package remained politically feasible, the package ballooned. The most recent version, put forward by Chuck Schumer, strongly resembles the original, disappointing version that the Senate passed last year. That’s the main problem. Sixty-four senators, including 16 Republicans, voted to advance the bill last Tuesday.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Politics › 2AC – Competitiveness – Bad

The Bill is Net-Worse for competitiveness – budgetary confusion, tax reform, subsidizing China, economic conflict, leverage, lobbying,

Brady & Riley 7/22 (Demian Brady, Vice President of Research for the National Taxpayers Union Foundation. His responsibilities include producing commentaries and studies on fiscal issues, as well as managing NTUF's BillTally program, State of the Union analysis, and more, Bryan Riley, background includes years of research on the impact trade has on people in the United States. He has led grassroots campaigns in support of initiatives like the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), 7-22-2022, "Congress Should Reject the Increasingly Costly CHIPS-Plus Act," National Taxpayers Union, https://www.ntu.org/publications/detail/congress-should-reject-the-increasingly-costly-chips-plus-act, DOA: 7-23-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

Legislation called the CHIPS-Plus Act is barrelling through Congress. Although the legislation is supposed to boost U.S. competitiveness and counter China, there are several ways the CHIPS-Plus Act, if enacted, would have the opposite effect. For example:

Increasing the federal budget deficit: In a matter of days, the possible cost of the bill exploded from $52 billion to $279 billion. According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the base 10-year deficit impact would be $79.344 billion, though, as described below, that number will be much higher if Congress decides to appropriate the funding that is authorized in the bill.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
AT: Politics › 2AC – BBB – No Impact

Slimmed down BBB killed by Manchin – At best it’s a health care bill which doesn’t solve the DA’s impacts

Zhou 7/18 [Li Zhou, Politics and Policy Reporter Vox, BA – Economics, English from Harvard University, "Build Back Better may end up a health care bill, thanks to Joe Manchin", 7-18-2022, accessed 7-20-2022, https://www.vox.com/2022/7/6/23197398/build-back-better-prescription-drug-prices] Lex IT

Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV), a longtime holdout on the Build Back Better Act, has once again up-ended talks on the bill.

Democrats had hoped to put together a slimmed down version of the original $2 trillion package, narrowly focused on health care, climate, and tax reforms. Manchin, however, has expressed opposition to additional climate and tax policies at this time, and it now seems the party will have to settle for a smaller bill than leaders wanted.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Politics › 2NC – AT: Thumpers

Voting to pass the bill can happen by this week

Shepardson 7/20 (David Shepardson, Correspondent at Thomson Reuters, 7-20-2022, "Pelosi Backs Chips Bill, Says House Could Vote on Measure Next Week," US News & World Report, https://www.usnews.com/news/top-news/articles/2022-07-20/pelosi-backs-chips-bill-says-house-could-vote-on-measure-next-week, DOA: 7-21-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. House plans to vote as early as next week on a slimmed-down version of legislation to provide tens of billions of dollars in subsidies and tax credits for the semiconductor industry, Speaker Nancy Pelosi said.

On Tuesday, the Senate backed by 64 to 34 a procedural measure to set the stage for potential votes to pass the legislation in the Senate as soon as this week.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Politics › 2NC – Floor time?

Urgency frames this debate – Congress want to get something passed before August to revive our national security and competitiveness, procedural vote proves momentum

Tasolides 7/20 (Justin Tasolides, Executive Producer overseeing national editorial content for Spectrum News stations nationwide, focusing on national and international news, breaking news and politics, 7-20-2022, "Domestic semiconductor manufacturing bill clears key Senate vote," No Publication, https://spectrumnews1.com/ky/louisville/news/2022/07/20/senate-chips-semiconductor-bill-biden-schumer, DOA: 7-21-2022//Smarx Ahsan)

After months and months of start-and-stop negotiations, the Senate on Tuesday voted to advance a $52 billion bill aimed at boosting domestic semiconductor production which lawmakers say is crucial to ease supply chain disruptions, bolster national security and increase competitiveness with China.

What You Need To Know