Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 UTNIF Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Debating Nuclear Risk Good

Debating nuclear risk is good.

Bernstein ’18 [Aron; September 21st; Emeritus Professor of Physics at MIT; The Bulletin, “Reducing the risk of nuclear war begins in the classroom,” https://thebulletin.org/2018/09/reducing-the-risk-of-nuclear-war-begins-in-the-classroom/]

The need for education on nuclear weapons. When it comes to nuclear weapons, the students of today have less lived experience to draw on than older generations. Today’s typical college student was born after the end of the Cold War and has no memory of a time when most Americans were deeply afraid of nuclear war (excluding, to an extent, the fiery exchange of threats between President Trump and Kim Jong-un last year). Perhaps as a result, these students also have very limited knowledge about nuclear weapons. The majority do not have a strong understanding of what nuclear weapons are, their destructive power, or their role in the international order, and even fewer have a sense of how many nuclear weapons exist. They are not aware of the $1.2 trillion nuclear modernization program, in which the majority of costs come from modernizing and improving delivery systems rather than performing the technically necessary maintenance of the nuclear warheads. History education on the Cold War often addresses the US-Soviet arms race of that time, but nuclear weapons issues in other regions—such as the tense situation between India and Pakistan—are rarely ever mentioned. The distant, but persistent, possibility of an unintentional nuclear launch due to unauthorized access, technical failure, or a cyberattack on warning systems, is also overlooked, as is general information about which states possess nuclear weapons today.

In short, students in the United States (and likely elsewhere) typically graduate from high school having received almost no information on nuclear weapons. It is generally assumed that today’s American public simply doesn’t care about the complicated and somewhat abstract issues of nuclear weapons and deterrence because they rarely affect people’s lives directly. However, an alternative explanation exists: The American public doesn’t know enough about nuclear weapons to have much political opinion on them, but if they had more knowledge, that could change. If so, educating students on nuclear weapons on a large scale could have the long-term effect of creating an American public that is politically engaged on the nuclear issue and motivated to hold its elected leaders accountable for implementing nuclear policy that reduces the risk of nuclear war.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Fiat Good

Fiat is good -- foreign policy simulations teach students how allies and adversaries respond to U.S. policy -- fosters ideological reflexivity, accurate policy prediction, and argumentative agency.

Esberg and Sagan ’12 [Jane and Scott; 2012; Special assistant to the Director at New York University’s Center on International Cooperation; Professor of Political Science and Director of Stanford's Center for International Security and Cooperation; The Nonproliferation Review, “NEGOTIATING NONPROLIFERATION: Scholarship, Pedagogy, and Nuclear Weapons Policy,” p. 95-96]

These government or quasi-government think tank simulations often provide very similar lessons for high-level players as are learned by students in educational simulations. Government participants learn about the importance of understanding foreign perspectives, the need to practice internal coordination, and the necessity to compromise and coordinate with other governments in negotiations and crises. During the Cold War, political scientist Robert Mandel noted how crisis exercises and war games forced government officials to overcome ‘‘bureaucratic myopia,’’ moving beyond their normal organizational roles and thinking more creatively about how others might react in a crisis or conflict. The skills of imagination and the subsequent ability to predict foreign interests and reactions remain critical for real-world foreign policy makers. For example, simulations of the Iranian nuclear crisis*held in 2009 and 2010 at the Brookings Institution’s Saban Center and at Harvard University’s Belfer Center, and involving former US senior officials and regional experts*highlighted the dangers of misunderstanding foreign governments’ preferences and misinterpreting their subsequent behavior. In both simulations, the primary criticism of the US negotiating team lay in a failure to predict accurately how other states, both allies and adversaries, would behave in response to US policy initiatives.

By university age, students often have a pre-defined view of international affairs, and the literature on simulations in education has long emphasized how such exercises force students to challenge their assumptions about how other governments behave and how their own government works. Since simulations became more common as a teaching tool in the late 1950s, educational literature has expounded on their benefits, from encouraging engagement by breaking from the typical lecture format, to improving communication skills, to promoting teamwork. More broadly, simulations can deepen understanding by asking students to link fact and theory, providing a context for facts while bringing theory into the realm of practice. These exercises are particularly valuable in teaching international affairs for many of the same reasons they are useful for policy makers: they force participants to ‘‘grapple with the issues arising from a world in flux. Simulations have been used successfully to teach students about such disparate topics as European politics, the Kashmir crisis, and US response to the mass killings in Darfur. Role-playing exercises certainly encourage students to learn political and technical facts* but they learn them in a more active style. Rather than sitting in a classroom and merely receiving knowledge, students actively research ‘‘their’’ government’s positions and actively argue, brief, and negotiate with others. Acts can change quickly; simulations teach students how to contextualize and act on information.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Extinction Reps Good

Priming of existential risk focuses on compassion which results in progressivism

Vail et al, 9 (Kenneth E. Vail III, University of Missouri Department of Psychological Sciences researcher, Jamie Arndt, University of Missouri psychology professor, Matt Motyl, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs Masters in Experimental Psychology, and Tom Pyszczynski, University of COlorado at Colorado Springs professor and co-developer of terror management theory; "Compassionate Values and Presidential Politics: Mortality Salience, Compassionate Values, and Support for Barack Obama and John McCain in the 2008 Presidential Election," Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, Vol. 9, No. 1, p. 263-266, IC)

The present findings extend those of Rothschild et al. (2009). Rothschild et al. showed that priming religious fundamentalists with compassionate values that were clearly tied to their religious foundations in either Christianity or Islam led to lower level of support for the use of violence against Iran among Americans and to less hostile attitudes toward the United States (including less support of martyrdom attacks) among Iranians; in the absence of priming these compassionate values, death reminders led to increased support for violence among both groups. The present study goes beyond a religious context to show that in the absence of being faced with compassionate values, death reminders increased support for John McCain; but when oriented toward compassionate values, MS increased support for Barack Obama. This study also provides convergent support for a growing number of findings that existential threat is capable of motivating defense of progressive, prosocial values like tolerance, egalitarianism, and empathy (Gailliot et al., 2008; Greenberg et al., 1992; Rothschild et al., 2009; Schimel et al., 2006). Because people possess a variety of resources for buffering existential fear, terror management trajectories can be quite malleable. Thus, increasing the salience of a particular aspect of one’s cultural worldview, such as the prosocial value of compassion, can motivate increased adherence to this value after reminders of death. As such, examining the effects of MS in light of individual differences in progressive value orientation might be a useful direction for the future research on the psychology of politics and/or intergroup relations. For example, emerging research suggests that compassion might be found in the perception of interdependence among diverse groups of people, helping to reduce or eliminate reactionary, hostile forms of worldview defense. Motyl et al. (2009) report that priming a perception of a common humanity attenuated an increase in anti-Arab prejudice and hostile immigration policy among Americans reminded of death. This compassionate perception of a common humanity can also be observed, rather ominously, in universal dangers (i.e., global warming) that threaten humanity as a whole. In research conducted with both Americans and Palestinians living in Israel, Pyszczynski et al. (2009) demonstrated that the perception of such global threat bolsters support for peaceful coexistence in the face of increased death awareness. Future research on these values and concerns might provide useful directions for those seeking peace and political harmony among groups embroiled in long-standing conflicts. The present analysis of compassion also offers potential insights into understanding reactions to other political figures. Weise et al. (2008) found that MS motivated securely attached adults to support John Kerry instead of Bush. Given that secure attachment is linked to compassion and empathy (e.g., Mikulincer et al., 2005), the existentially motivated activation of secure adult attachment systems may have increased support for Kerry to the extent that he was perceived as the more compassionate candidate. However, comparing the current study with Weise et al. suggests a crucial distinction between the ability of Obama and Kerry to capitalize on the MS-induced need to achieve psychological equanimity by rigorously defending culturally cherished values. Whereas both men might very well have been harbingers of compassion, for Kerry, this may have been obscured by his relatively dry speaking style and meeker presence; Obama, on the other hand, wore compassion on his sleeve (Steinhauser, 2008). Thus, it may have been that Obama’s frequent, eloquent outbursts of compassion boosted his support by priming thecultural defense of this value amid frequent discussion of issues involving reminders of mortality (e.g., healthcare, Iraqi occupation, Russian invasion of Georgia, etc.). It is important to note, however, that the present analysis does not imply that compassionate associations are limited only to Democratic candidates. Indeed, as the quote which opens this paper illustrates, then-President George W. Bush co-opted the term “compassionate conservative” during his second campaign, a move that may have helped garner support, assuming both that he was perceived as the more compassionate candidate and that such values were made salient. The present research also contributes to understanding the nature and specificity of responses to thoughts of death (cf, Pyszczynski, Greenberg, Solomon, & Maxfield, 2006). Like a number of other studies, here we tested the impact of MS against that of personal uncertainty. Proponents of the uncertainty management model claim that MS effects are actually a result of increased personal uncertainty, which motivates efforts to regain a sense of certainty by defending the validity of one’s cultural worldview and confidently adhering to its norms and values (e.g., Van Den Bos, Poortvliet, Marjolein, Miedema, & Van den Ham, 2005). The present study demonstrates that uncertainty concerns did not impact political preferences, or produce reactions to cultural values (e.g., compassion) similar to those triggered by MS. The recently proposed uncertainty-threat model (e.g., Jost, Glaser, Kruglanski, & Sulloway, 2003) claims that uncertainty and mortality threat both produce a shift toward political conservatism. Critics of this model (e.g., Anson et al., in press; Greenberg & Jonas, 2003), on the other hand, have argued that the motivated social-cognitive foundations (i.e., dogmatism; intolerance of ambiguity; personal need for closure, structure, or order; etc.) of political ideology are not limited to a conservative shift, but can readily trigger support for progressive change. The present study provides clear and direct evidence for the latter contention: MS-induced threat is indeed capable of motivating support for either conservative or progressive politicians, depending on the values that are salient at the time. This idea, however, does raise an interesting possibility with regard to interpreting the present effects. The compassionate value statements were designed for this study to directly emphasize the value of compassion. While the comparison statements were designed to lack such references, it is possible that these statements might have been construed as priming wisdom. Previous research (e.g., Landau et al., 2004; Cohen et al., 2004, 2005) demonstrated that MS motivated increased support for authoritarian candidates, and for Bush specifically, without moderating factors such as a wisdom induction. This is consistent with the notion that Republican candidates tend to enjoy increased support from those reminded of mortality because these candidates tend to emphasize American superiority. However, McCain was considerably older than Obama and held his Senate seat for much longer; thus, he may have been seen as “wise” relative to Obama’s “na¨ıvete.” If this were the case, and if the neutral value condition’s statements did ´ prime wisdom, this may have motivated increased support for McCain after death reminders. While the participants in this study were by no means representative of the diverse American electorate, they provided crucial insight into the psychological impact of each candidate’s campaign and even of the candidates themselves. Embedded within a social climate boiling over with death reminders (e.g., war, terrorism, fear-mongering rhetoric, etc.), people may latch onto certain political leaders in an effort to affirm their faith in the permanence and validity of their particular culture. However, it would seem that the individual can achieve this leader-based worldview defense in several different ways. Depending on the salience of particular cultural values, a person might be motivated to follow a conservative leader who rigorously asserts the fundamental superiority of one’s culture and aggressively “defends” it from the clutches of evil, or they might be motivated to support progressive prototypes of their more compassionate social values. As Ernest Becker (1973, p. 139) concluded, “[The human] is a trembling animal who pulls the world down around his shoulders as he clutches for protection and support and tries to affirm in a cowardly way his feeble powers. The qualities of the leader, then, and the problems of people fit together in a natural symbiosis.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Extinction Reps Good

Preventing existential risk and framing it as a “we” claim is good.

Coles and Susen 18—Research Professor at the Institute for Social Justice at Australian Catholic University AND Reader in Sociology at the School of Arts and Social Sciences of City, University of London (Romand and Simon, “The Pragmatic Vision of Visionary Pragmatism: The Challenge of Radical Democracy in a Neoliberal World Order,” Contemporary Political Theory May 2018, Volume 17, Issue 2, pp 250–262)

Visionary pragmatism is driven by a political ethos that accents radical receptivity and a sense that a greater degree of wildness in our efforts is indispensable for transformative democratic movements. While some of my earlier works accented the ethical character of receptive generosity in political life, Visionary Pragmatism argues that receptivity is indispensable for generating democratic power – precisely because receptivity involves vulnerability, relationship formation, capacities to modulate, and learning in unexpected ways amidst difficult differences. Drawing on my engagements with the movement for democratic action research in Northern Arizona, I argue that receptive practices engender remarkable capacities for fostering grassroots critique and alternatives, powerful political assemblages across differences, and transformative dynamics in the face of what otherwise appear to be intractable problems. Our best and most powerful possibilities for co-creating urgent democratic change almost always advance along pathways engendered partly through relationships of careful attentiveness to what we initially took to be oblique, unintelligible – or, perhaps, even odious.

For these reasons, my political, theoretical, and pedagogical engagements move across many different configurations and a wider range of situations, ideologies, modes, and commitments than most. Eschewing a single subject position, in Visionary Pragmatism, I experiment with first-person plurals in which the ‘we’ morphs in relation to the different loci of initiative that animate my reflections. Sometimes ‘we’ refers to proponents of radical and ecological democracy very broadly, sometimes to scholars in higher education, sometimes to political theorists, sometimes to the action research movement that formed among people at Northern Arizona University and its community partners, sometimes to a specific action research team, sometimes to all people facing the possibility of planetary ecological collapse. Among the many things I find compelling about the writing of James Baldwin is how he shifts his pronouns without notice – for example, sometimes using ‘we’ to represent black people, sometimes as an uncanny member of the white-majority United States. This rhetorical shiftiness encroaches upon and pulls his readers – especially white readers – beyond the ‘innocence that constitutes the crime’ of their assumed individual and collective white subjectivities in ways that work in visceral, relational, and conceptual registers (Baldwin, 1992, p. 6). Such uncertainty has significant capacity to erode habits and defences, as one finds oneself unexpectedly drawn into perspectives, locations, energies, and tendencies that unsettle and reorient one’s own subjectivity. Much of my work has theorized ‘moving democracy’, and my rhetorical shifting of the first-person plural is a textual practice that aims to enhance this in ways that facilitate reflection.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
AFF Answers › 2AC – Extinction First

Extinction outweighs.

Seth D. Baum & Anthony M. Barrett 18. Global Catastrophic Risk Institute. 2018. “Global Catastrophes: The Most Extreme Risks.” Risk in Extreme Environments: Preparing, Avoiding, Mitigating, and Managing, edited by Vicki Bier, Routledge, pp. 174–184.

2. What Is GCR And Why Is It Important? Taken literally, a global catastrophe can be any event that is in some way catastrophic across the globe. This suggests a rather low threshold for what counts as a global catastrophe. An event causing just one death on each continent (say, from a jet-setting assassin) could rate as a global catastrophe, because surely these deaths would be catastrophic for the deceased and their loved ones. However, in common usage, a global catastrophe would be catastrophic for a significant portion of the globe. Minimum thresholds have variously been set around ten thousand to ten million deaths or $10 billion to $10 trillion in damages (Bostrom and Ćirković 2008), or death of one quarter of the human population (Atkinson 1999; Hempsell 2004). Others have emphasized catastrophes that cause long-term declines in the trajectory of human civilization (Beckstead 2013), that human civilization does not recover from (Maher and Baum 2013), that drastically reduce humanity’s potential for future achievements (Bostrom 2002, using the term “existential risk”), or that result in human extinction (Matheny 2007; Posner 2004). A common theme across all these treatments of GCR is that some catastrophes are vastly more important than others. Carl Sagan was perhaps the first to recognize this, in his commentary on nuclear winter (Sagan 1983). Without nuclear winter, a global nuclear war might kill several hundred million people. This is obviously a major catastrophe, but humanity would presumably carry on. However, with nuclear winter, per Sagan, humanity could go extinct. The loss would be not just an additional four billion or so deaths, but the loss of all future generations. To paraphrase Sagan, the loss would be billions and billions of lives, or even more. Sagan estimated 500 trillion lives, assuming humanity would continue for ten million more years, which he cited as typical for a successful species. Sagan’s 500 trillion number may even be an underestimate. The analysis here takes an adventurous turn, hinging on the evolution of the human species and the long-term fate of the universe. On these long time scales, the descendants of contemporary humans may no longer be recognizably “human”. The issue then is whether the descendants are still worth caring about, whatever they are. If they are, then it begs the question of how many of them there will be. Barring major global catastrophe, Earth will remain habitable for about one billion more years 2 until the Sun gets too warm and large. The rest of the Solar System, Milky Way galaxy, universe, and (if it exists) the multiverse will remain habitable for a lot longer than that (Adams and Laughlin 1997), should our descendants gain the capacity to migrate there. An open question in astronomy is whether it is possible for the descendants of humanity to continue living for an infinite length of time or instead merely an astronomically large but finite length of time (see e.g. Ćirković 2002; Kaku 2005). Either way, the stakes with global catastrophes could be much larger than the loss of 500 trillion lives. Debates about the infinite vs. the merely astronomical are of theoretical interest (Ng 1991; Bossert et al. 2007), but they have limited practical significance. This can be seen when evaluating GCRs from a standard risk-equals-probability-times-magnitude framework. Using Sagan’s 500 trillion lives estimate, it follows that reducing the probability of global catastrophe by a mere one-in-500-trillion chance is of the same significance as saving one human life. Phrased differently, society should try 500 trillion times harder to prevent a global catastrophe than it should to save a person’s life. Or, preventing one million deaths is equivalent to a one-in500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. This suggests society should make extremely large investment in GCR reduction, at the expense of virtually all other objectives. Judge and legal scholar Richard Posner made a similar point in monetary terms (Posner 2004). Posner used $50,000 as the value of a statistical human life (VSL) and 12 billion humans as the total loss of life (double the 2004 world population); he describes both figures as significant underestimates. Multiplying them gives $600 trillion as an underestimate of the value of preventing global catastrophe. For comparison, the United States government typically uses a VSL of around one to ten million dollars (Robinson 2007). Multiplying a $10 million VSL with 500 trillion lives gives $5x1021 as the value of preventing global catastrophe. But even using “just" $600 trillion, society should be willing to spend at least that much to prevent a global catastrophe, which converts to being willing to spend at least $1 million for a one-in-500-million reduction in the probability of global catastrophe. Thus while reasonable disagreement exists on how large of a VSL to use and how much to count future generations, even low-end positions suggest vast resource allocations should be redirected to reducing GCR. This conclusion is only strengthened when considering the astronomical size of the stakes, but the same point holds either way. The bottom line is that, as long as something along the lines of the standard riskequals-probability-times-magnitude framework is being used, then even tiny GCR reductions merit significant effort. This point holds especially strongly for risks of catastrophes that would cause permanent harm to global human civilization. The discussion thus far has assumed that all human lives are valued equally. This assumption is not universally held. People often value some people more than others, favoring themselves, their family and friends, their compatriots, their generation, or others whom they identify with. Great debates rage on across moral philosophy, economics, and other fields about how much people should value others who are distant in space, time, or social relation, as well as the unborn members of future generations. This debate is crucial for all valuations of risk, including GCR. Indeed, if each of us only cares about our immediate selves, then global catastrophes may not be especially important, and we probably have better things to do with our time than worry about them. While everyone has the right to their own views and feelings, we find that the strongest arguments are for the widely held position that all human lives should be valued equally. This position is succinctly stated in the United States Declaration of Independence, updated in the 1848 Declaration of Sentiments: “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men and 3 women are created equal”. Philosophers speak of an agent-neutral, objective “view from nowhere” (Nagel 1986) or a “veil of ignorance” (Rawls 1971) in which each person considers what is best for society irrespective of which member of society they happen to be. Such a perspective suggests valuing everyone equally, regardless of who they are or where or when they live. This in turn suggests a very high value for reducing GCR, or a high degree of priority for GCR reduction efforts.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Scenario Planning

Scenario planning is hijacked and militarized which makes global war inevitable

Carr 10. Matt Carr is a writer and journalist living in Derbyshire. His latest book is Blood and Faith: the purging of Muslim Spain 1492–1614 [“Slouching towards dystopia: the new military futurism,” 2010, URL: http://www.thecyberhood.net/documents/papers/carr10.pdf]//vikas 

Abstract: In recent years, the military establishments of the US and the UK have produced a series of reports that attempt to ‘think the unthinkable’ in imagining future threats to the security of the West. A new genre of military futurology has emerged which owes as much to apocalyptic Hollywood movies as it does to the cold war tradition of ‘scenario planning’. Often outlandish and bizarre in its prophecies, and always dystopian, this new military futurism sees threats to the western way of life emanating not only from rogue states, weapons of mass destruction and terrorism but also from resurgent nationalism, conflicts over dwindling resources, migration, disease, organised crime, abrupt climate change and the emergence of ‘failed cities’ where social disorder is rife. This article provides a survey of the genre, showing how the grim predictions of the military futurists provide a justification for endless global war against enemies that may never exist. Reports that say that something hasn’t happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns – the ones we don’t know we don’t know. Donald Rumsfeld1 Downloaded from  at SUNY AT BUFFALO on March 1, 2010 14 Race & Class 51(3) There was a time when the future was considered a subject for prophecy and science fiction rather than empirical analysis. From Jules Verne and H. G. Wells onwards, science writers have combined fantasy with a serious examination of what the future might contain. But it was not until the last decades of the twentieth century that futuristic speculation began to transcend the category of entertainment, with the emergence of the discipline variously known as futurology, futuristics or future studies. Defined by the Encarta Dictionary as ‘the study and forecasting of the future, with predictions based on the likely outcomes of current trends’, futurology first emerged as a popular non-fiction genre in the early 1970s, with Alvin Toffler’s best-selling Future Shock and the Club of Rome’s environmental wake-up call Limits to Growth. In 1972, the University of Houston established the first graduate programme in futurism and today a plethora of university departments, thinktanks and research centres across the world are dedicated to ‘foresight’ and the study of ‘probable and preferable futures’, such as the Copenhagen Institute for Futures Studies, the UK Horizon Scanning Centre, Foresight International and the World Future Society. The military has also shown a keen interest in the study of the ‘possible future’ in the early twenty-first century, particularly in the United States. In 1997, the US National Intelligence Council (NIC) published Global Trends 2010, the first of three reports in its ambitious 2020 Project that aims to predict the ‘forces that will shape our world’ over a two-decade period. In 2001, the prestigious US Air Force thinktank, the RAND Corporation, established the Frederick S. Pardee Center for Longer Range Global Policy and the Future Human Condition. Since 2000, the US Joint Forces Command has published two studies of the international military and security environment over the next two decades and its implications for the military. Military and national security research institutions such as the US Army’s Strategic Studies Institute (SSI) regularly stage conferences and symposia on ‘Long Range Planning and Forecasting’, ‘Scenario Planning’ and ‘Projecting Future Battlespaces and Scenarios’. These studies are not limited to purely military concerns. Military futurists also devote considerable attention to more mainstream futurological subjects, such as social and economic transformation, demographics, urbanism, cultural trends and climate change. What explains the military’s interest in the future and what does this fascination tell us about the present? Military futurism is not a historical novelty in itself. Armies have routinely engaged in contingency planning ever since the German armed forces pioneered ‘long range planning’ in the late nineteenth century. Military futurism really came into its own during the cold war, when the RAND Corporation began conducting regular war games and simulations to predict the likely outcomes of nuclear and conventional military confrontations with the Soviet Union. In the 1950s and 1960s, RAND luminaries such as Herman Kahn, Leo Roster and Albert Wohlstetter built illustrious careers around ‘scenario planning’ and ‘systems thinking’, which attempted to provide US policymakers with the conceptual tools to anticipate ‘alternate’ or ‘surprising’ military futures by ‘thinking the unthinkable’. By the 1980s, forecasting, war-gaming and scenario planning had become routinely integrated into US military practice. While studies such as Innovation Task Force 2025 (1988) and AirLand Battle 2000 (1982) considered the transformation of the armed forces or rehearsed NATO war plans against the Warsaw Pact, others continued to explore the outer limits of the unthinkable future. One report published by the Department of Defense in the early years of the Reagan presidency imagined a nuclear war in which the White House, the Pentagon and much of civilisation were destroyed, but computers continued in the aftermath ‘to run a war no human mind can control’, directing space satellites, nuclear weapons and armies of robots ‘that can gallop like horses and walk like men, carrying out computerised orders as they roam the radioactive battlefield’.2 Cold war military futurism also spilled over into the private sector. In 1961, Herman Kahn founded the Hudson Institute, a conservative thinktank and research centre which aspires to provide ‘global leaders in government and business’ with the tools to ‘manage strategic transitions to the future’.3 In the 1970s, Royal Dutch Shell pioneered the corporate use of scenario planning in the oil industry in response to what was perceived as a new climate of uncertainty and unpredictability following the OPEC oil embargo. This overlapping nexus between the military and corporate futurism has continued ever since. Not only do the US military and the private sector share the same concern with geopolitical and international developments pertaining to US national security and the future of the capitalist world economy, but private companies and institutions specialising in scenario planning and risk management also work closely with the military in developing futuristic analyses. The Hudson Institute’s Center for Political-Military Analysis produces regular studies for the military on the ‘critical variables’ and ‘nonlinear forces’ affecting international politics.4 Both the Pentagon and the Department of Homeland Security have also commissioned futuristic studies from scenario planning specialists such as the Global Business Network (GBN) and the giant management consultancy firm Booz Allen Hamilton. In 2006, Booz Allen won a $32 million contract to provide the Pentagon’s Training and Doctrine Command (TRADOC) with war-gaming materials and simulations, whose aim, according to the company spokesman, was to ‘write the history of the future’ and provide the Pentagon with a ‘picture of the world between 2001 and 2025’.5 All this is in keeping with the tradition developed by Kahn and his RAND colleagues but the new military futurism is also strikingly different from its predecessors. Where the cold war futurists were primarily concerned with the Soviet Union and scenario planning for nuclear war, twenty-first century futurists are concerned with very different ‘threats’ and ‘challenges’. One of the most prolific producers of futurological studies is the Pentagon’s Office of Net Assessment (ONA), an obscure but influential thinktank run by the veteran RAND intellectual and military futurist Andrew Marshall. Each year, the ONA commissions dozens of studies from academics and thinktanks like the Hudson Institute and private consulting companies. Most of these reports are classified but the  website recently used the Freedom of Information Act to obtain an index of ONA publications. These include titles such as Pandora’s Boxes: the mind of jihad (June 2007), Why they Won’t Know What Hit Them: are Arabs thinking about the consequences of another 9/11 (July 2006), Europe 2025: mounting security challenges amidst declining competitiveness (September 2008), Role of High Power Microwave Weapons in Future Intercontinental War (July 2007) and even German Liberals and the Integration of Muslim Minorities in Germany (December 2006).6 These titles are an indication of the new concerns of contemporary military futurism. The new military futurists also differ from their predecessors in their generally grim perspective on the future. In Rethinking the Unthinkable (1963), Herman Kahn attempted to demonstrate that a nuclear war might not be survivable and therefore ‘thinkable’. This scenario was intended to be positive – albeit from a hawkish foreign policy perspective – but contemporary military futurism is often extremely pessimistic in its depictions of the twenty-first century ‘security environment’. Such pessimism is partly a reflection of the prevailing mood in the US national security establishment. Ever since the end of the cold war, US security analysts have argued that the US was vulnerable to attack by elusive and unpredictable enemies that were potentially more dangerous than the former Soviet Union. Such predictions appeared to be confirmed by the catastrophic events of September 11. On the one hand, the 9/11 attacks were ‘predictable’, in the sense that an attack of some kind had been expected. At the same time, the attacks constituted what futurologists call ‘wild cards’, ‘discontinuities’ or ‘surprising events with huge consequences’, which force a new set of expectations about what the future might contain. Some US security analysts have since added the Iraq insurgency to the category of ‘strategic shocks’ and attributed the failure to predict it to the same ‘failure of imagination’ that helped make the 9/11 attacks possible. The result is a new willingness amongst the US national security establishment to consider further ‘strategic shocks’ by ‘imagining the unimaginable’ – a tendency which has generated imaginative scenarios that sometimes owe more to apocalyptic Hollywood movies, manga comics and science fiction than they do to sober analysis. Faced with a future that seems fraught with unpleasant surprises, the Pentagon has embarked on some outlandish and even bizarre attempts to try to reduce the element of uncertainty and unpredictability. One ongoing project aims to recruit social scientists to compile a computerised database of cultural, religious and political beliefs in every country in the world that will supposedly enable the military to predict which countries are most likely to succumb to unrest, insurgency or terrorism. In 2002, the Pentagon’s cutting edge Defense and Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) came close to introducing a ‘terrorism futures market’ based on the financial futures market, which invited bets on when and where terrorist events were likely to occur in order to predict them beforehand. This scheme was abandoned when it was pointed out that some organisations might deliberately carry out attacks in order to profit from them. In 2007, DARPA awarded Lockheed Martin a contract to develop an ‘Integrated Crises Early Warning System’ (ICEWS) that its designers claimed will ‘anticipate and respond to worldwide political crises and predict events of interest and stability of countries of interest with greater than 80 percent accuracy’ in the same way that meteorologists predict the weather.7 These initiatives cannot be attributed simply to an overzealous desire to protect the US ‘homeland’ from ‘another 9/11’. The broad scope of contemporary military futurism is partly a consequence of changing concepts of warfare in the early twenty-first century, with its new emphasis on ‘asymmetric’ warfare, terrorism and insurgency across the global ‘battlespace’ rather than conventional wars between states. The commitment to ‘fourth generation warfare’ is fuelled by a new sense of the fragility and instability of the international state system, coupled with the belief that the nation-state in the early twenty-first century is increasingly vulnerable to global economic turbulence, civil and ethnic conflict and the violent activities of ‘non-state actors’ – all of which are perceived to pose threats to global security and even the future of globalisation itself. The ‘uncertainty’, instability and risk that military futurists project onto the future not only emanates from nuclear-armed ‘rogue states’ or ‘non-state actors’, however. A recurring theme in military futurist scenarios concerns the possibility that the emergence of China, India and Brazil as major economic powers may be accompanied by a decline in US – and western – global hegemony and that the ‘unipolar world’ of the post-cold war era may be drawing to an end. With the demise of the Soviet Union, US military thinking has been dominated by the concept of the ‘Revolution in Military Affairs’ (RMA) – a term used to describe periods of history in which one particular military power or group of powers outstrips all potential rivals. The display of US technological firepower in the first Gulf War convinced many military planners that this position is now occupied by the US. But this belief is often accompanied by a realisation of the limitations of US military power and anxiety that the RMA may not be permanent. The notion of the US RMA is often attributed to the Pentagon’s ‘futurist-in-chief’ Andrew Marshall at the ONA. Celebrated as a visionary genius by his admirers and denounced as a paranoiac by his enemies, Marshall is a long-time associate of Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz, and was given a major role by Rumsfeld in the preparation of the 2002 Quadrennial Defense Review, which the US Armed Forces use as a medium-range planning guide to justify its budget requests to Congress. That same year, Marshall commissioned an 85-page monograph for the ONA from Booz Allen Hamilton entitled Military Advantage in History, which studied some of the most successful military conquerors of the past for lessons on how the United States ‘should think about maintaining military advantage in the twenty-first century’.8 Though the study identified the United States as the ‘dominant military power in the world’, it nevertheless warned that such dominance might not be permanent and that ‘barring a more innovative approach the process leading to its substantial erosion has already been set in motion’. To contribute to this process of innovation, the report sought inspiration from imperial conquerors such as Alexander the Great, Genghis Khan and particularly from Rome, whose 600-year dominance, the authors argued, ‘suggests that it is possible for the United States to maintain its military advantage for centuries if it remains capable of transforming its forces before an opponent can develop counter-capabilities’.9 Stripped of its anachronistic application of contemporary military jargon, its shallow scholarship and its unproblematic comparisons between the United States and previous empires, this document was essentially a variant on ONA futuristic studies such as Preserving American Primacy (January 2006) and Preserving US Military Supremacy (August 2001). The same objectives are shared by the neoconservative thinktank Project for the New American Century (PNAC) in its 2000 call for US military transformation, Rebuilding America’s Defenses. The PNAC couples a boyish fascination with sci-fi weaponry with a strident insistence on the need to preserve US ‘primacy’, ‘geo-political pre-eminence’, ‘dominance’ and a ‘global security order that is uniquely friendly to American principles and prosperity’.10 This determination to shape, control and ‘dominate’ the turbulent and conflict-prone twenty-first century in the foreseeable (and unforeseeable) future is a key component of the new military futurism. On the one hand, military futurism is a by-product of the megalomaniac military doctrine of ‘full spectrum dominance’. At the same time, its predictions about the future express very real fears amongst the US ruling elite that the United States is inextricably connected to a world that may be slipping out of its control. Perhaps not surprisingly, therefore, the new military futurists are often considerably more pessimistic than their predecessors and tend to paint a very bleak future of an unsafe and unstable world that demands a constant military presence to hold it together. From Yevgeny Zemyatin’s We to Brave New World and Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four, twentieth-century writers have used dystopian visions of the future as a warning or as a satirical commentary on the often lethal consequences of twentieth-century utopianism. The dystopias of the new military futurists have a very different purpose. The US military often tends to perceive itself as the last bastion of civilisation against encroaching chaos and disorder. The worse the future is perceived to be, the more these dark visions of chaos and disorder serve to justify limitless military ‘interventions’, techno-warfare, techno-surveillance and weapons procurement programmes, and the predictions of the military futurists are often very grim indeed.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Russia

The 1ACs reading of Russia as aggressive expands a cartography of violence – Ukraine isn’t an isolated or uniquely horrific war zone but instead an extension of decades of imperial bloodshed waged by Whiteness

Cockburn 3/25 – author of War in the Age of Trump, prominent and award-winning war journalist [Patrick, “Ukraine Could Turn Into Another Endless War, Especially if NATO Decides More Than Just Peace is Needed,” 3/25/2022, , DKP]

People look at a map of Europe and express horror that a large part of it is once more in flames. Pundits point out with alarm that for the first time since 1945, one European country has invaded another and we are witnessing the first big military conflict on the continent since the Balkan wars in the 1990s, aside from some earlier fighting in the Ukraine itself.

But if we look at a larger map that includes not only Europe but the Middle East and North Africa, we get an entirely different impression because Ukraine is no longer a blood-soaked exception in a zone of peace. It is, on contrary, the new northern extension of a giant zone of war that has extended over the last twenty years east-west from Afghanistan to north-east Nigeria and north-south from Turkey to Somalia and Yemen.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Russia

Their framing of conflict in Ukraine is the Starwarsification of violence – voting aff obviously does nothing, but endorsing the 1ACs feeds into the fantasy of war machine

Eid 3/5 – [Hanna, “Russia, Ukraine, and the Desert of the Real,” 3/5/2022, KP]

According to Baudrillard: "We are all hostages of media intoxication, induced to believe in the war just as we were once led to believe in the revolution in Romania, and confined to the simulacrum of war as though confined to quarters"(1). This is so visible in this case: immediately after the Russian operation, we saw all of the signs of a manufactured narrative in something which felt quicker than real-time. Infographics, the 'Ghost of Kiev', Zelensky as 'war bae', quippy one-liners from Zelensky that read as if they are from the latest Call Of Duty installation: "I don't need a ride, I need ammunition". In a much darker vein, Pornhub's number one search is ‘Ukrainian women’, the 'refugees are welcome here' discourse from the liberals, 'anti-war' protests being staged (in reality they are pro-war and pro-sanctions). One person went as far as to create a list of fascist flags for people to avoid at pro-Ukraine rallies across the USA. All of this created the conditions for more sanctions on Russia in less than a week. It’s not sanctions just on "The Oligarchy", but on Russian cinema and sport as Russia was suspended from F1 and FIFA. The ruble crashed and is now worth less than one cent. Interesting to note is that the US' own oligarchs (Bezos, Musk, Zuckerburg, Branson, etc) are not called as such. Oligarch is a term the US reserves for the likes of Putin who belong to the "oriental despotism" that seeks to undermine American freedom and democracy.

Baudrillard continues: "our virtual has definitively overtaken the actual and we must be content with its extreme virtuality which, unlike the Aristotelian, deters any passage to action"(2). By this, he means that the event exists primarily in the media (even though real bombs drop). We can see this through the use of the same images to signify different things for either side. Videos of wounded soldiers claimed to be Russian and Ukrainian at the same time show us that.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Links – NATO

NATO and the US construct threats that pave the way to justify invasions

CAMPBELL 19 – Professor of African American Studies and Political Science, Syracuse University [Horace, “,” 4/9/2019, , DKP]

[15] Britain, France, Belgium and Portugal deepened their links to NATO but in 1956, Dwight Eisenhower halted the planned offensive of the British and the French in the Suez war. After this war, both the currencies of Britain and France suffered sharp declines with France seeking cover inside the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC), while the British pound accepted its place as a prop to the US dollar in the global economy. Within a year after the Suez debacle, France had pushed for the Treaty of Rome that paved the way for the European Economic Community to be a competitive force with US capitalists. Within the context of the competition between European capitalists and US capitalists, Charles De Gaulle exhibited pique at the organization of NATO that supported the armaments culture of US capital. Charles De Gaulle partially pulled France out of this alliance in 1966 after it became clear that this military organization was dominated by the United States and Britain (supporting their military industries). De Gaulle argued for an independent nuclear arsenal while remaining a signatory to North Atlantic Treaty and participating in the North Atlantic Council. Nicholas Sarkozy ended the farce when France returned to the fold of the NATO military structures in 2009. The duplicitous actions on the part of the French leadership were always based on calculations meant to preserve the dominance of French capital in Africa. When the US devalued the dollar in 1971 and broke the agreements of the Bretton Woods Treaty, it was the French who complained about the Exorbitant Privilege of the Dollar. For a short period, both the President of France and the Chancellor of West Germany had chafed under the privilege and had worked hard to bring into being the Maastricht Treaty and the Europe Union to end the dominance of the dollar in the international capitalist system. It was known than the one necessary aspect of this emerging common currency in Europe would be the dismantling of the military occupation of Europe by US military personnel. Hence, both Giscard de Estaing and Helmut Schmidt had linked the common currency, the European Central Bank and common foreign and security policy (CFSP), with the expectation that ultimately Europe will break from the traditions of NATO. It was in the face of this threat and the fall of the centrally planned economy that the forward planners expanded NATO. Emergence of Global NATO and the myth of ‘humanitarian intervention’ Usually, when an alliance is formed for a specific purpose such as halting the spread of communism, that alliance is folded when the mission is complete. Hence, after the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, it was expected by those seeking the ‘peace dividend’ that the mission of NATO would be scaled down. Instead, NATO expanded, seeking to encircle Russia by extending its membership to include former members of the Warsaw Pact countries. Progressive scholars have documented the cynicism of the US military planners who orchestrated the ‘humanitarian intervention’ in the Balkans in order to advance the hegemony of US capitalism after the fall of the Soviet Union. The scholarship on this manipulation of the European working peoples to entrench NATO is rich and needs to be revisited at this moment of the celebration of the 70thanniversary of the founding of NATO. Richard Aldrich in the book, The Hidden Hand: Britain, America and Cold War Secret Intelligence’ brought out evidence to expose how the massacres in the Balkans, helped give a new impetus to US hegemony.’ [16] David Gibbs had argued, “How the Srebrenica Massacre Redefined US Foreign Policy.” It is worth quoting at length how the Balkans war was used to manipulate public opinion in Europe, “Perhaps most importantly, the massacre helped give a new impetus to US hegemony, contributing to its post-Cold War legitimacy. In bolstering America’s hegemonic position, the significance of the Srebrenica massacre cannot be overstated: The massacre helped trigger a NATO bombing campaign that is widely credited with ending the Bosnian war, along with the associated atrocities, and this campaign gave NATO a new purpose for the post-Soviet era. Since that time, the Srebrenica precedent has been continuously invoked as a justification for military force. The perceived need to prevent massacres and oppression helped justify later interventions in Kosovo, Afghanistan, Iraq, and Libya, as well as the ongoing fight against ISIS. The recent UN doctrine of Responsibility to Protect, which contains a strongly interventionist tone, was inspired in part by the memory of Srebrenica.” [17] The more nefarious aspect of this manipulation of humanitarianism was the ways in which elements such as Bernard Kouchner used their credentials as former members of the left and progressive forces to give cover to US imperialism. Since the war in the Balkans it is now accepted by the military planners that humanitarian intervention acts as a force multiplier. [18] This position was explicitly stated by General Colin Powell who noted, “Just as surely as our diplomats and military, American NGOs are out there serving and sacrificing on the front lines of freedom NGOs are such a force multiplier for us, such an important part of our combat team.” These observations can shed light on the relationship between NGOs such as Doctors without Borders and the International Rescue Committee in global militarism. The fiction of collective western security was effectively broken while after the Asian economic crisis, US capital mobilized NATO to defend Wall Street. In this defense of Wall Street, NATO incessantly bombed Kosovo for 79 days in 1999 as it gave itself a new mission to enlarge US military power right up to the doorstep of Moscow. Gingerly, NATO expanded under US President Bill Clinton from 12 members to 16, then to 19, then to 26 by 2004 and by 2009 to 28 members. Despite vocal opposition from Russia, the discussion of expanding NATO now proceeded to develop the idea of Global NATO. In 2019 there were 29 members of NATO. In his presentation before the US Congress Stoltenberg advocated for a further expansion of NATO and boasted of the high state of readiness of the NATO Response Force (NRF) which had been created in 2002. NATO and the Weaponization of finance Global NATO was the preeminent force to orchestrate the weaponization of everything. Michael Hudson has outlined finance as warfare and the weaponization of finance in the current phase of imperialism. It will be important to grasp the present sanctions regime of the USA as a form of warfare. In the current literature on imperialism, the term weaponization of finance refers to the foreign policy strategy of using incentives (access to capital markets) and penalties (varied types of sanctions) as tools of coercive diplomacy. The multiple wars agains Iran represent a model example of the weaponization of finance, the weaponization of information and the weaponization of trade. Under the Presidency of Barack Obama,Treasury Secretary Jack Lew, noted that the weaponization of finance offers to the US “a new battlefield…one that enables [the US] to go after those who wish [the US] harm without putting [US] troops in harm’s way or using lethal force.” Instead of fighting countries militarily, the US can now “cripple them financially. The Obama administration had retreated from a full scale weaponization of finance with Iran by signing the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA ) with Iran in 2015. Under the terms of this agreement in Vienna on 14 July 2015 between Iran, the P5+1 (the five permanent members of the United Nations Security Council—China, France, Russia, United Kingdom, United States—plus Germany),[a] and the European Union, it was agreed that Iran would accept the P5+1 would ensure that Iran did not develop nuclear weapons. Both Saudi Arabia and Israel had opposed this agreement. When Donald Tromp became President of the United States, his administration renounced the JCPOA in 2018 and then signed an executive order reimposing sanctions on any foreign company that continues to do business with Iran. The order gave companies 90-day or 180-day grace periods to extract themselves from existing Iranian contacts or face punitive US measures. Those NATO partners of the USA who signed the JCPOA refused to accept the sanctions imposed on Iran and in 2019 agreed to create a special purpose vehicle to manage their trade with Iran. Britain, Germany and France rolled out INSTEX in February 2019 as one way to break the weaponization of Finance by the USA but in the cat and mouse game of economic warfare, the Foreign Ministers of Europe have not yet been transparent on the full mandate of the special purpose vehicle. These developments mirror the weaponization of trade [19] and finance within NATO and the problems of inter imperialist rivalry in West Asia. The threats against the countries that created a special purpose vehicle (SPV) to help facilitate trade with Iran must be taken very seriously, especially in the context of the political insecurity generated by BREXIT. This period reminds the world that of the depression when trade wars and currency wars eventually fueled open fighting in World War II. Finance as warfare Since the global financial crisis of 2008-2009, there have been efforts by countries holding US debt to limit their exposure to the dollar. In 2009, the Russians and the Chinese worked to establish an alternative international institution involving Brazil, Russia, India and China, later including South Africa and called BRICS. Within the context of BRICS, the Chinese set about a slow process to internationalize its currency, the RMB and undertook currency swaps to avoid the US dollar. After failing to negotiate successfully within the Bretton Woods institution for an increase of its drawing rights commensurate with its volume of international trade, the Chinese embarked on major economic and financial ventures under the banner of One Belt One Road and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank. When the AIIB was launched in 2015 with 57 countries, the former Treasury Secretary of the US, Lawrence Summers noted that the launch of the AIIB was a turning point and ‘the creation of the AIIB will undermine the leadership role the U.S. has long enjoyed in global finance.’ Both Russia and China intensified their swap trading efforts and Russia settled its crude sales to China. “In March 2018 news broke that Beijing is planning a pilot project for the second half of the year to pay for imported crude oil with renminbi instead of dollars. The two countries allegedly selected for the pilot are Russia and Angola, with rumors that Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates may become involved. If this venture is successful, it will act as a spur to similar schemes for other imports and primary products.” China was joining the leaders of Europe and the countries in Asia and West Asia who were calling for a multi-currency financial system. Many progressive economists noted that it was not a matter if more countries would flee the dollar, but when. One economist writing from Singapore wrote, “the emergence of a multicurrency or multi-asset international payments system will take time. It doesn’t portend a collapse of the global payments system, but does point to a redistribution of global wealth. The seigniorage harvested by the US as the world’s banker will gradually fall, narrowing the room for maneuver in US economic policy, which for the last 70 years has had the greatest influence on markets globally. As the power of the dollar wanes, the US will be pressured to adjust to a world economy vastly changed since 1945.” [20] The German financial leaders along with France were maneuvering to speed this change with the establishment of the special purpose vehicle to continue trading with Iran. At this time of writing the specific details of the specific purpose vehicle called the Instrument in Support of Trade Exchanges (INSTEX) is still being worked out, but the statements of former Ambassador Nicholas Burns before Congress on March 26 made it clear that the Foreign Policy establishment in the USA will not retreat from the weaponization of Finance, especially since INSTEX allows members of NATO to continue trading and financial arrangements with Iran, China and Russia. In so far as Global NATO is serving the task of defending the dollar, the extent to which China has created an alternative clearing system in the Cross-Border Interbank Payment System (CIPS) will be seen as another blow to US financial hegemony. Although in its first rollout of the CIPS system, the Chinese went to great length that it would cooperate with the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT) system, the current US intelligence war against the Chinese telecom firm Huawei point to the integration between Finance, information warfare and cyberwarfare. [21] In the book, The Perfect Weapon, David Sanger discussed the debates within this highest levels of US intelligence and the Federal Reserve of whether the USA should use its Federal Reserve and cyber warfare to backdoor into the Russian Central Bank to make money disappear. It is in this context where one can note in the planning of NATO strengthening the cyber capabilities is at the top of the Agenda. The Harvard study emphasized the importance of winning the Technology Battle in the Digital Age. The convergence of cyberwarfare, economic warfare and information warfare is being taken to new levels under the current administration with its wide ranging sanctions against countries in Europe, Asia, Africa and the Caribbean. Traditional books on NATO had surveyed the integration of diplomacy, sanctions and weapons procurement, but the new push of the USA in formulating its position of unrivalled dominance is turning out to be another front for defending the dollar. In a world where the USA had imposed sanctions on Cuba, Russia, China, Iran, Venezuela, Turkey, North Korea, Syria, Sudan along with individual sanctions against individuals in Somalia, South Sudan, Libya, Ukraine and Zimbabwe, the logic of these sanctions enforced by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) of the US Treasury has now clarified to the allies of the USA in NATO the importance finance was warfare. It was the former Treasury Secretary, Jack Lew, who had warned that the over use of sanctions could dull their effectiveness. His logic was simple: Sanctions work because they cut targets off from dealing with U.S. citizens and American financial institutions—a complete severance from the world’s largest economy and its most important financial center. If Washington used this power idly, Lew suggested, it could encourage countries to find partners outside of the United States, and undermine sanctions’ deterrent effect. What Lew did not acknowledge was the relationship between the Treasury, Global NATO and the financial wars. Much of the scholarship on the printing of dollars miss the way in which the infusion of capital in emerging economies further enmesh these societies into the instability of the system. Ultimately, the export of the oscillation of the US economy deepens social and political challenges on the world and reinforces the militarization of the international political economy. Michael Hudson outlined three ways in which flooding of dollars through debt leverage and QE supported the military: (1) the surplus dollars pouring into the rest of the world for yet further financial speculation and corporate takeovers; (2) the fact that central banks are obliged to recycle these dollar inflows to buy U.S. Treasury bonds to finance the federal U.S. budget deficit; and most important (but most suppressed in the U.S. media, (3) the military character of the U.S. payments deficit and the domestic federal budget deficit. He continued, “Strange as it may seem and irrational as it would be in a more logical system of world diplomacy the “dollar glut” is what finances America’s global military build-up. It forces foreign central banks to bear the costs of America’s expanding military empire effective “taxation without representation.” Keeping international reserves in “dollars” means recycling their dollar inflows to buy U.S. Treasury bills U.S. government debt issued largely to finance the military.” After the financial crisis in Europe, Quantitative Easing was extended to the Eurozone and Japan, but in the continuing re alignment, of global capitalism, US capital is working hard to decapitate Russia and China as opponents of Global NATO. The currency wars and weaponization of finance is now accompanied by the weaponization of trade and the weaponization of information. Sanger’s The Perfect Weapon War, Sabotage, and Fear in the Cyber Agehas opened one window into how full spectrum dominance and the militarization of space is now linked to the weaponization of information and cognitive hacking. We now have new terms of warfare, terms such as “fake news”, “disinformation,” “weaponized information,” “post-truth” and “alternative facts.” Weaponized information (WI) defines a new method messaging and dissemination of content that contains falsehoods, facts taken out of context and pieces of truth strategically released, in an attempt to manipulate knowledge and beliefs. The NATO destruction of Libya was one clear example of how falsehoods were refined to lull workers in Europe to support the destruction of Libya The weaponization of Finance and the Destruction of Libya Not enough is being done to expose the real role of Global NATO and the role of so called humanitarian operatives in ensuring that humanitarian interventions become a force multiplier. Currently, many countries of the EU collaborate with France in the North African region in the fabrication of terror to ensure the deployment of the US Africa Command and French forces in Africa. In Western Europe, NATO has been very successful in ensuring confusion, demoralization, paralysis, and apathy in relation to western imperialism in Africa. African scholars and progressives are very clear that while calling for the dismantling of NATO there must be a call for the EURO to break from the CFA franc zone. Nicolas Sarkozy was very clear that the intervention in Libya was to save the Euro. Africans cannot have a Newtonian view of the struggle against imperialism to assure those from the European left who want solidarity with Africans while supporting French imperialism in Africa. Global NATO and French machinations are involved in a delicate dance and there is silence from the left in the EU when it comes to Europe’s 4000 km strategic radius that covers the entire area of West Africa, North Africa and down through East Africa to Somalia. It is beyond this commentary to delineate the ways in which German scholars, religious organizations, German foundations and non-governmental organizations are now implicated in the criminal acts of France in Africa, especially the war on terror. It is the task of the progressive movement to penetrate the areas of cooperation and conflict between European capitalists and Wall Street so that European workers do not continue to complicity support ‘humanitarian interventions.’ When 200 African scholars wrote the open letter on the impending crime against the peoples of Libya, there has been and continue to be silence on the part of the left in Europe and the United States. Barack Obama had described the intervention in Libya as a mistake and the British Parliamentary Committee outlined how the Libyan intervention had been based on lies. Obama may have considered the intervention a mistake, but his understanding of the process did not reveal how Goldman Sachs was thoroughly implicated the destruction of Libya. The case in the London High Court of the Libyan Investment Authority vs Goldman Sachs brought out revealing evidence of how firms such as Goldman Sachs and others involved in the financialization of the energy markets sought to mobilize the resources of oil rich states with Sovereign Wealth Funds to keep alive the private equity, hedge funds and structured derivatives markets of the global capitalist economy. Most societies and peoples in the world want these banks to be brought under control. But Goldman Sachs benefitted in the ruling because in 2014, two and a half years after the case was brought before the High Court, there was a war in Libya and there was no government therefore one could not represent the Libyan Investment Authority in this arena. We see therefore that the financial institutions are direct beneficiaries of the warfare that is going on in Libya. When the United Nations passed Resolution 1970 and resolution 1973 in 2011, those who had signed these resolutions did not understand then that the resolution was for regime in Libya.[22] The current fighting in Libya remains one of the most inglorious aspects of the 70 year history of NATO but there is silence among those celebrating 70 years of NATO. [23] Since the writings on Finance capital over a century ago by Rudolph Hilferding, Vladimir Lenin, Rosa Luxemburg, and Nikolai Bukharin the role of finance in the international system has grown beyond the parameters outlined by those who linked finance capital to modern imperialism.[24] After the collapse of the dollar/gold system of 1944 the financial industry of the West has become the axis on which international capitalism spins.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Links – NATO

NATO is founded on the maintenance of global white terror – the construction of threats justifies policing, surveillance and coercive foreign policy that produces psychological warfare

CAMPBELL 19 – Professor of African American Studies and Political Science, Syracuse University [Horace, “,” 4/9/2019, , DKP]

The celebration of NATO’s 70 years of existence provides another opportunity to unearth the real history of the ideas, practices and destruction wrought by this military alliance. Even with the clear exposure of the cooperation between NATO, the CIA and the British MI6 to spread terror and psychological warfare in Europe immediately after the formation of this military alliance, the mainstream media, academics and policy makers remain silent on activities of the ‘stay behind armies’ and ‘false flag’ operations that distorted the real causes of insecurity in the world after 1945. The evidence of the manipulations of the peoples of the world to ensure the continued survival of NATO has been well documented in the fraudulent interventions and bombings in the Balkans right up the present multiple wars against the peoples of Iran. Vijay Prashad had identified NATO as the prime defender of the Atlantic project. This Atlantic project, he noted was, “a fairly straightforward campaign by the propertied classes to maintain or restore their position of dominance.” This Atlantic Project was anchored in the military alliance called NATO with its principal work, that of reversing the South Project; the struggles for peace bread and justice by the poorer citizens of the planet, especially those who had emerged on the world stage after the decolonization of Africa, Asia, and the Caribbean. The ostensive reason for the founding of NATO was to ‘thwart’ Soviet aggression, but in practice the organization was a prop for western capital and after the fall of the Berlin Wall, became the core prop for Wall Street. In this year, there will be many commentaries on the fact that the existence of NATO reflects a Cold War relic, that NATO is obsolete and lost its mandate, but very few will link the expansion of NATO to the military management of the international system. Prior to 1991, the planners of NATO could justify the existence of NATO on ideological and political grounds, but with the threat of a multi polar world and the diminution of the dollar, NATO expanded to the point where this author joined with others in labelling this organization Global NATO to reflect its current imperial mandate. The Global thrust of NATO now comprises 29 members from Europe and North America along with 41 ‘partners’ that had started off under the banner of the North Atlantic Cooperation Council (NACC) in 1991. Since that time, NATO has launched a lengthy war without end in Afghanistan, colluded in the destruction of Iraq and conspired with militarists to forge ‘Partnership for Peace’ (with most members of the former Warsaw Pact states). The core 29 members are now enmeshed with treaties and undertakings from states involved in the Mediterranean Dialog and Istanbul Cooperation Initiative: Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, and United Arab Emirates. There are also the ‘partners’ from across the globe: Afghanistan, Australia, Colombia, Iraq, Japan, Republic of Korea, Mongolia, New Zealand and Pakistan. This enlargement served the military purposes of encircling China and Russia who military planners in the West targeted. There is no shortage of literature on NATO and its milestones, but very few have documented the real crimes of this global network of anticommunist operatives who precipitated real terror and psychological warfare against the citizens of Europe and North America while supporting mass atrocities from Algeria to Indonesia, and South Africa. Books such as that of NATO’s Secret Armies: Operation GLADIO and Terrorism in Western Europe by Danielle Ganser and The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and Their Secret World War, by Stephen Kinzer used rigorous research techniques to uncover the dark history of NATO. These two books can be distinguished from the bland international relations texts that discusses NATO inside the old calculations of ‘strategy,’ ‘concert of democracies’, ‘security cooperation’ and the balance of power,’ and spheres of influence. Most recently, this IR rendering of the history of NATO has been served up in a document entitled, NATO at Seventy: An Alliance in Crisis. Published by Harvard University with one of the coauthors being a former US ambassador to NATO. This document spelt out ten challenges.[1] However, in a testimony before Congress, Nicolas Burns boiled down the challenge of NATO to one objective; that the current role of NATO must be to contain Russia and China.[2] On the day before the actual 70thanniversary, on April 3, the Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg delivered an address to a joint session of the US Congress advocating an expansion of the alliance while promoting a military buildup against Russia. [3] European progressives will have to reflect deeply on whether the current sanctions regime and the special propose vehicle called the Instrument in Support of Trade Exchanges (INSTEX), is ushering in another round of inter imperialist rivalry reminiscent of the currency wars of 1929-1939. Then, the shifting alliances yielded confusion among working peoples who ultimately went to fight against each other in Europe, spreading barbarism throughout the world, from Auschwitz to Hiroshima. The continued struggles for bread, peace and justice ensure that it is only the authoritarian leaders from the Global South who are compromised on the real meaning of the existence of NATO. In the present era, there is a new capitalist competition while North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) serves as an integral part of the Pentagon’s world command structure. Recent experiences have demonstrated in Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya that the moguls of Wall Street are willing to wage as many wars, to destroy as many countries and to kill as many people as necessary to achieve the dominance of US capitalism. The destruction of Libya was a classic example of the convergence of finance as warfare, the weaponization of information and incessant bombing to destroy a society. Where at the start of NATO the war scare was the propaganda method, In the current digital age, brain hacking and the engineering of smart phones have placed the giant technology firms of Apple , Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Facebook at the forefront of the new weapons platform of NATO and Wall Street. This analysis is in three parts spelling out the rationale for the call for all progressive forces to join together to concentrate their energies in the dismantling of NATO. NATO at Birth: Stay behind armies, directed terrorist organizations and psychological warfare against Europeans. In the period after the fall of the Berlin Wall there were major press reports on the role of NATO’s stay behind armies that had been operating inside Western Europe since 1949.Ten years earlier, when the kidnapping and killing of the former Italian Prime Minister, Aldo Moro rocked western Europe, it emerged that his demise had been authored by clandestine paramilitary network code-named “Operation Gladio” that was a false flag operation of NATO. Danielle Ganser’s book, NATO’s Secret Armies: Operation GLADIO and Terrorism in Western Europe had meticulously documented how NATO funded and often even directed terrorist organizations throughout Europe in what was termed a “strategy of tension” with the aim of preventing a rise of the left in Western European politics. NATO’s “secret armies” engaged in subversive and criminal activities in several countries. In the specific case of Italy, Aldo Moro had committed the unforgivable crime of contemplating a government that included Italians who belonged to the Italian Communist Party Right from the start of the Cold war, the CIA and MI6 had worked closely with former fascists to oppose citizens and organizations in Western Europe that were anti-capitalists. Under the leadership of US planners such as Allen Dulles, William Colby, Frank Wisner and later James Angleton, these operatives weaned and nursed a network of agents and secret arms dumps across Europe, a network that would remain secret but active throughout the Cold War. [4] Ganser elaborated on the extensive operations of Operation Gladio all across Europe with the explicit aim of subverting the democratic wishes of European citizens who were opposed to oppression. It is worth quoting at length the role of the secret armies. “NATO’s “secret armies” engaged in subversive and criminal activities in several countries. In Turkey in 1960, the stay behind army, working with the army, staged a coup d’état and killed Prime Minister Adnan Menderes; in Algeria in 1961, the French stay-behind army staged a coup with the CIA against the French government of Algiers, which ultimately failed; in 1967, the Greek stay-behind army staged a coup and imposed a military dictatorship; in 1971 in Turkey, after a military coup, the stay-behind army engaged in “domestic terror” and killed hundreds; in 1977 in Spain, the stay behind army carried out a massacre in Madrid; in 1980 in Turkey, the head of the stay behind army staged a coup and took power; in 1985 in Belgium, the stay behind attacked and shot shoppers randomly in supermarkets, killing 28; in Switzerland in 1990, the former head of the Swiss stay behind wrote the US Defense Department he would reveal “the whole truth,” and was found the next day stabbed to death with his own bayonet; and in 1995, England revealed that the MI6 and SAS helped set up stay behind armies across Western Europe.”[5] The mainstream media and University commentaries have not been able to confront this history in so far as the manipulation and deception that gave rise to the birth of NATO is still at work against the citizens of Europe and the United States. War Scare, NATO and psychological warfare against the citizens of Europe and North America. At the end of World War II, the defense Industries in the USA had been faced with the choice of conversion and retooling the factories that made weapons or continue the massive subsidies for the industries vested in military and armaments production. The choice was eventually made to embark on a propaganda war scare to justify the need for an expanded army and it was in this context when NATO was conceived. To sustain the WW II armaments enterprise, there needed to be a cycle of war scare and the fabrication and inflation of threats and enemies. It was in this context that Lawrence D. Bell, President of Bell Aircraft Corporation, in a statement to the U.S. Air Policy Commission Finletter Commission) on September 29, 1947, stated that “as soon as there is a war scare, there is a lot of money available.” [6] According to Andrew Cockburn, “The aircraft corporations that had garnered enormous profits during the war on the back of government contracts had discovered by 1947 that peace was ruinous. Despite initial high hopes, the commercial marketplace was proving a far harsher and less accommodating environment than that of wartime, especially as there were far more companies than required by the peacetime economy. Orders from the civilian airline industry never lived up to expectations, while efforts to diversify into other products, including dishwashers and stainless steel coffins, proved disappointing and costly.” [7] In the spring of 1948, the U.S. Secretary of Defense James Forrestal and top officials of the Harry Truman administration began to sound alarm about a looming Soviet attack against Western Europe. It is now known, from declassified documents, that the officials were aware that there was no credible evidence to back up their war scare. Some analysts have argued that the war scare of 1948 was devised to save the aircraft manufacturing industry from plunging into bankruptcy. And this goal was achieved. In the book Harry S. Truman and the War Scare of 1948, Frank Kofsky states thatwithin 2 months of the emergence of the scare, the Trumanadministration revamped the aircraft industry by embarking on a 57% increase in purchase of military aircraft, and the total budget of the Pentagon was increased by 30%. NATO was born on April 4, 1949 out of this propaganda war to deceive the US citizens about a pending attack of the Soviet Union on Western Europe. The task of organizing the deception of the citizens of the West was assigned to the Central Intelligence Agency. There are now so many books and articles on the role of the CIA in deception, propaganda and psychological warfare that we will not spend a great deal of time on the role of the Covert agencies in giving legitimacy to the idea of a Soviet threat. Stephen Kinzer and David Talbot are two writers who have documented extensively how the Dulles brothers ensnared every major profession in the USA in this deception. [8] It was especially chilling how Universities were suborned to be surrogates for this psychological warfare. Noam Chomsky has dealt with this aspect of the period of the birth of NATO in the work on the Universities and the Cold War.[9] Racists and anticommunists in the propaganda war It was not by accident that the thinkers and planners of these secret operations were known racists and Nazi sympathizers. Frank Wisner who hailed from Mississippi in the USA was a good example of the upright US citizen who was an architect of the false flag operations and the deception associated with NATO and western intelligence agencies. After the War, in 1948 Frank Wisner was appointed director of the Office of Special Projects. Soon afterwards under the direction of Allen Dulles, this Office of Special Projects was renamed the Office of Policy Coordination (OPC). This became the espionage and counter-intelligence branch of the Central Intelligence Agency. Later James Jesus Angleton was to take this brand of counter intelligence work to the highest levels of state assassinations. Wisner had been mandated told to create an organization that concentrated on “propaganda, economic warfare; preventive direct action, including sabotage, anti-sabotage, demolition and evacuation measures; subversion against hostile states, including assistance to underground resistance groups, and support of indigenous anti-Communist elements in threatened countries of the free world.” It was from this opaque sounding name of Office of Policy Coordination where the brainwashing and virulent anti-communism of the Cold War era was refined. Evan Thomas reported in The Very Best Men: the Daring Early Days of the CIA, the OPC’s charter gave it responsibility for “propaganda, economic warfare; preventative direct action, including sabotage, antisabotage, demolition and evacuation measures; subversion against hostile states, including assistance to underground resistance groups, and support of indigenous anti-Communist elements in threatened countries of the free world.” NATO as the principal prop for international capitalism today.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Hegemony

US hegemony is an inherently unstable a global project of white supremacy – the foreign echoes the domestic – military brutality abroad and police brutality at home cannot be separated from massive violence against black and brown people cloaked in a language of “security” and “stability”

Kizer 20 - MA in Democracy & Governance from Georgetown University, BA in Middle Eastern & North African Studies from UCLA [Kate, “US HEGEMONY RELIES ON DEHUMANIZATION AND WHITE SUPREMACY,” 6/10/2020, , DKP]

When I began writing this column, Black Hawk helicopters were still circling over Washington, DC, flying low to intimidate and disperse protestors demanding justice for yet another murder of an unarmed Black person, this time George Floyd by Minneapolis police.

While the spread of popular uprisings against police brutality across the United States feels like an unprecedented tipping point, the impunity with which police and military forces operate is not new. Nor is it isolated to domestic policing. The willingness to weaponize state power against those expressing their discontent and calls for change has long been a part of both US domestic and foreign policy.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Disease/Bioterror

This has been super-charged by COVID – their rhetoric has a one-to-one correlation with Anti-Asian violence

Siu and Chun 20 – * Associate Professor Asian American and Asian Diaspora Studies Chinese Diaspora, Cultural Citizenship, Cultural Politics of Food, Diaspora / Transnationalism; Asians in the Americas, Ethnography PhD, Anthropology, Stanford University, MA, Anthropology, Stanford University, BA, Anthropology, minor in Ethnic Studies, University of California, Berkeley **Ph.D. student at the University of California, Berkeley in the Department of Ethnic Studies, 19-2020 recipient of The Catherine and William L. Magistretti Graduate Fellowship, B.A. in Politics and Social and Cultural Analysis from New York University. [Lok, Claire, Yellow Peril and Techno-orientalism in the Time of Covid-19: Racialized Contagion, Scientific Espionage, and Techno-Economic Warfare, Journal of Asian American Studies, Volume 23, Number 3, October 2020, pp. 421-440 (Article), DKP]

In the early weeks of the COVID-19 outbreak in the United States, President Trump put out many mixed messages, but he remained consistent with one—that China was to blame for the spread of the virus. Repeatedly, he insisted on calling the novel coronavirus “the Chinese virus,” despite mounting public criticism against the racialization of the deadly pathogen. Many noted the inflammatory nature of this anti-Asian rhetoric. During this same period, reports ranging from verbal abuse to intimidation to physical assault against people of Asian descent documented the sudden rise of anti-Asian hate crimes in the United States and globally. According to Human Rights Watch, an Asian woman in Brooklyn, New York, suffered a racially motivated acid attack, and in Texas, a Burmese American man and his two children were stabbed by a man who claimed he thought the family was “Chinese and infecting people with the coronavirus.”1 The Asian Pacific Policy and Planning Council in the United States reported over one thousand cases of anti-Asian incidents in a two-week period in March 2020.2 Outside the United States, a Singaporean student in the United Kingdom was violently kicked and punched by an angry group of men after they uttered, “we don’t want your coronavirus in our country” (my emphasis).3 In Australia, a survey taken by the community group Asian Australian Alliance recorded a total of 178 reports of anti-Asian incidents in two weeks, ranging from racial slurs to physical assault.4 Though President Trump has dropped the “Chinese virus” for “kung flu” and tweeted on March 23 that “It is very important that we totally protect our Asian American community . . . the spreading of the virus is NOT their fault,” it seems that Sinophobia and racial violence against Asian Americans have been unleashed.

Make no mistake, as long as President Trump continues to take a confrontational stance, using the rhetoric of blame against China with the intention to punish it with new sanctions, tariffs, and even the cancellation of U.S. debt obligations,5 the racial aggressions against Asian Americans will continue to rise, if not intensify. By now, it is widely accepted that the novel coronavirus emerged first in Wuhan, and scientists believe that the zoonotic disease might have jumped from animals to humans at Wuhan’s Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market, a wet market where vegetables, seafood, meat, and a small number of exotic wildlife were sold. Despite this, on April 30, President Trump casually offered a new theory, which Secretary of State Mike Pompeo tweeted: that COVID had originated in the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which houses a biosafety level-4 lab, and that the virus might have “leaked” from that lab. The implicit suggestion is that China had either intentionally bioengineered the novel coronavirus to cause massive destruction, thereby attributing malice, or carelessly leaked the virus due to scientific negligence, thereby attributing incompetence. In either case, these kinds of unsubstantiated speculations work to further stoke anger and disdain against the Chinese state. More disturbingly, they traffic in the idea of China as a biotechnology threat, resonating with pre-existing filmic representations of futuristic dystopian worlds.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Disease/Bioterror

The invocation of disease as a threat to security paves the way for permanent warfare waged via global networks of surveillance, sanctions, and violence that constitutes a necropolitical destruction of Otherness – this is operationalized through a legacy of bio-orientalism that constantly views Others as bio-weapon – an unhygienic threat to the cleanliness of Westphalian democracy

Kong 19 – John F. and Dorothy H. Magee Associate Professor of Asian Studies and English at Bowdoin College, PhD, English Language and Literature, University of Michigan [Belinda, “Pandemic as Method,” October 2019, Prism 16(2):368-389 DOI:10.1215/25783491-7978531, DKP]

The most proximate scene of biosecurity's solidification is the post-9/11 US security state's War on Terror. The extent to which the American government came to coopt the language of disease emergence was illustrated by Donald Rumsfeld's oft-cited speech from a 2002 Department of Defense news briefing in which he observed: "There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don't know. But there are also unknown unknowns. These are things we don't know we don't know."24 As Bruce Braun points out, Rumsfeld's logic mimed the contemporary perception of the "virtuality of molecular life": just as biology increasingly gets articulated in terms of virtual networks of unknown and dangerous viruses that "circulate and recombine in novel ways, threatening our bodies and identities," so national security came to be couched in terms of hidden networks of sleeper cells and emerging threats.25 Melinda Cooper calls this the "biological turn" in US foreign policy after 9/11, but more than a simple rhetorical resonance, she argues that this turn reflected a fundamental phi-osophical reconceptualization of warfare by the Bush administration. Moving away from the previous geopolitical doctrine of mutual deterrence, the US government strategically "conflate[d] public health, biomedicine, and war" so as to make operative a security agenda of "full-spectrum dominance, counterproliferation, and preemption."26 The epidemiological tenets of microbial emergence, resistance and counterresistance, and humans' permanent warfare against germs were transferred over and made central to defense policy. Within this new security framework, war became integral to the very conceptualization of life, or as Cooper puts it, "as if permanent war were simply a fact of life''27 In the reverse direction, national security now propels biological research— including the creation of new infectious diseases. In anticipation of potential bio- terrorist attacks, the US government's agency for developing cutting-edge military technology, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), has been actively inventing antibiotics and vaccines for not only known pathogens but also ones that do not yet exist. In the name of biodefense, "DARPA finds itself in the paradoxical situation of having first to create novel infectious agents or more virulent forms of existing pathogens in order to then engineer a cure," thus "blurring the difference between defensive and offensive research."28 For Cooper, this ideological convergence between biomedicine and biosecurity represents the culmination of neoliberalism's politics of life, which entrenches ideas of speculative preemption and catastrophe risk so as to disable a counterpolitics. What we can further emphasize is the real geography that underlies the post-9/11 bios- ecurity imagination. Despite rather postmodern descriptions of Al-Qaeda as a fluid organization of dispersed and fluctuating networks, the actual targets of US antiterrorism measures remain fixed in Asia and Africa. As in the case of the 2003 Iraq War, Rumsfeld's invocation of "unknown unknowns" served to justify American military invasion of Iraq in the absence of evidence that it was stockpiling weapons of mass destruction. Concurrently, the formulation of a prototerritory of infectious disease emergence took place against the backdrop of this geopolitical theater of war.

Yet the consoll dat ion of the biosecurity posit ion predates 9/11 and can be traced back to the late 1980s and 1990s, as part of the US response to post-Cold War geopolitics after the dissolution of the USSR. As Susan Wright details, up until the 1980s, the American government mostly regarded terrorism as a "sec¬ond- or third-tier security problem—a problem that happened elsewhere," so that proponents of biological defense remained marginal in national security discus- sions.29 With the end of the Cold War, however, the former template of the Soviet threat was replaced by the discourse of hostile third-world "rogue states," and the prospect of nuclear warfare was superseded by the menace of biological and chemical weapons of mass destruction. Before 9/11 gave a concrete context to this logic, the 1995 Aum Shinrikyo attack on the Tokyo subway provided biosecurity advocates within the US government with an early platform. This attack, they warned, represented the "index case" for contemporary acts of bioterrorism: a vital "threshold" had been crossed, a taboo lifted, and henceforth, terrorists of all stripes would follow suit by employing bioweapons on civilians.30 Bioterrorism, they argued, was "no longer the stuff of science fiction or adventure movies" but "a reality which has already come to pass, and one which, if we do not take appro¬priate measures, will increasingly threaten us in the future."31 As Wright recounts, this "alarmist" stance overtook Washington during the 1990s, and the congressio¬nal budget for counterterrorism defense soared.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Deterrence

Effective deterrence strategies require a silent war against racialized threats -- their every 2AC claim that “threats are real” is a performative gesture of sly civility that renders America the policeman of international politics

Mathur 16. Rita Mathur is a Professor in Political Science and Geography at UTSA and has a PhD in polisci from York. "Sly civility and the paradox of equality/inequality in the nuclear order: a post-colonial critique." 2016. Nuclear Politics: Beyond Positivism.

Sly civility can be understood as a concept encompassing practices of racial etiquette and strategic orientalism as discussed below. The practices of racial etiquette came into play with such speed in the establishment of the nuclear order that ‘the previous longevity of anti-egalitarian and racist sentiment can and was easily lost sight’ (Furedi 1998, 15). The practices of racial etiquette are conscious of the formal principles of equality among sovereign states, induce an epistemological silence against any overt statements on racial inequality but stubbornly refuse to give up on the idea of political mastery. Frank Furedi argues that practices of racial etiquette represent a ‘second form of colonization’ that does not have any serious commitment to anti-racism but seeks to indulge in a ‘silent war’ to ‘produce over time, social formations and even world orders that were macrostructural systems of inclusion and exclusion’ (5). These practices of racial etiquette are further reinforced by contemporary practices of strategic orientalism. Edward Said articulated the concept of ‘Orientalism’ to demonstrate how the West constitutes its own identity on the premise of its differences with others often seen as a source of threat (Said 2001). In these iterative practices of representation the cultural differences are effectively deployed to differentiate the West and discipline the others in the international order. Keith Krause and Andrew Latham suggest that the continued exercise of this disciplinary power necessitates maintenance of military superiority in the post-Cold War period. The West then deploys ‘strategic orientalism’ as a ‘new conceptual template’ that enables the West to impute ‘politicostrategic objectives and purposes’ to Third World countries in a manner that is ‘informed more by Western fears and prejudices than by the realities of politics in these states’ (Krause and Latham 1998, 38). It transforms ‘essentially contestable interpretations of danger’ into ‘“objective” and incontestable facts regarding the sources of threat and insecurity in the international system’ (38). An effort to map these intersecting practices of racial etiquette, orientalism and strategic orientalism on a continuum reveals practices of sly civility. A grasp of these practices of sly civility facilitates an understanding of the nuclear order with its practices of inclusion and exclusion and the West’s efforts to control the narrative of nuclear arms control and disarmament. In this narrative there is an assumption that the Western practices of arms control and disarmament are ‘rational’, ‘benign’ and provide for the global ‘public good’ (Krause and Latham 1998, 23). The control of the narrative and its representation of these standards is a prerequisite in the exercise of power over others. Any resistance to this narrative is through practices of racial etiquette and strategic orientalism to be marginalized as peripheral and a source of instability and chaos. These practices of strategic orientalism or sly civility are not sensitive to the ‘ethnocentricity’ of their underlying assumptions and exhibit a ‘distinct matrix of beliefs and dispositions’ towards others in the field of arms control and disarmament (23). It is, therefore, imperative that practices of sly civility be ‘caught in the irredeemable act of writing’ (Bhabha 1994, 133). Homi K. Bhabha suggests that the ‘practice of writing’ is a ‘strategy of colonialist regulation’ (134). This writing ‘puts on trial the very discourse of civility within which representative government claims its liberty and empire its ethics’ (136). The writing makes visible the ‘nationalist, authoritarian tone’ that polices the ‘culturally and racially differentiated colonial space’ of arms control and disarmament (134). This authoritarian tone is embedded in a narrative that is narcisstic in its insistence that the other recognize its authority. In its insistence for this recognition it is willing to calculate and deploy tactical measures such as ‘skeptical conceits’ that dismiss any efforts of the others that seek to challenge its authority (141). Any resistance unleashes acute anxiety and a ‘paranoia of power’ that generates ‘political and psychic’ contestations on authority to regulate the borders of arms control and disarmament (141–2). Despite this anxiety, it is important to scrutinize arms control and disarmament texts as ‘despatches of hyprocrisy’ that seek to ‘moralize’ but exhibit a specific ‘discursive doubleness’ that exists between the lines as an ‘effect of the ambivalent, deferred address of colonialist governance’ (Bhabha 1994, 136). It is in this space ‘between the civil address and its colonial signification’ with ‘each axis displaying a problem of recognition and repetition’ that there ‘shuttles the signifier of authority in search of a strategy of surveillance, subjection, and inscription’ (136). The signifier of authority traverses through time and through its repetition deepens the crisis of authority experienced in practices of arms control and disarmament. This crisis of authority encourages ‘projections’ compelling the ‘native to address the master’ and reproducing the native as ‘partially aligned or reformed’ in discourse ‘endangering the boundaries of truth itself’ (142). Any effort to address this crisis necessitates an exposure of practices of sly civility to encourage a confrontation with the ‘colonialist governmentality’ in the field of arms control and disarmament. This confrontation will make it increasingly difficult for the West to ‘normalize its own history’ and ‘inscribe the history of the other in a fixed hierarchy of civil progress’ (136). These confrontations have been initiated and are now generating a momentum towards disavowal of the strategies of sly civility demanding redressal against the experiences of ‘institutionalized humiliation’ (Parek 2009, 31). The practices of sly civility often fail to grasp that humiliation is not simply an affect but ‘a claim or claims of certain kinds’ and it is important to ‘explore the structure of these claims, their logical or conceptual conditions, and their role in the reproduction of relations of power’ (Palshikar 2009, 81). Bhikhu Parekh locates organized or institutionalized humiliation in an ‘unequal society in which some enjoy considerable power over others and exercise it with relative impunity’ and these powers are vested in ‘social institutions and practices’ that ‘embody disrespect for, and systematically violate the self-respect of groups of individuals’ (Parek 2009, 31). The pathos of this experience of humiliation among the subalterns became acutely visible at a time when the use of nuclear weapons in Japan reinforced the message that: locations in the hierarchy of states are marked off in part by specific weapons, so the possession of certain weapons is considered the sine qua non for claiming places higher up the international order. Perhaps of central importance in this regard are nuclear arms. (Mutimer 2000, 137) This particular experience of humiliation has been compounded with repetitive threats to use nuclear weapons, specifically by the USA, in wars of intervention in the Third World (Petras and Morley 1988, 151). It is against these experiences of vulnerability, suffering and humiliation that discourses on sly civility have to contend with to address the paradox of equality/inequality in the nuclear order. A clear conceptualization of practices of sly civility above encourages us to now survey the system of recordation of the paradox of equality/inequality in the texts on arms control and disarmament. For the purpose of this paper we will limit this exercise to three representative samples of writing that traverse through time vacillating between ‘what is always “in place”, already known and something that must be anxiously repeated’ (Bhabha 1994, 95). These texts display a liberal willingness to entertain the problem of equality/inequality in arms control and disarmament in some measure. The willingness to question the assumptions informing ‘a desirable and feasible’ nuclear order is constrained by the desire to rationalize and make it appear natural that the inequalities should persist in the existing nuclear order (Bull 1987, 191). The treatment meted out to the equality/inequality paradox deserves careful consideration as they make visible the practices of sly civility that are responsible for the hierarchical international nuclear order. In the initial period of the Cold War, Hedley Bull, a representative figure of arms control and disarmament acknowledges the hegemonic control that exists in the nuclear order (1987, 191). He concedes that ‘the vision of the world order that is projected by our arms control arrangements is one against which the majority of states are in revolt’ and that ‘one finds different degrees of opposition to these arrangements, deep mutual divisions’ (191). However he insists on the need for maintaining this nuclear order because those that ‘wish’ to break down this hegemony ‘have nothing in mind with which to replace it’ (191, emphasis added). Bull specifically cites countries such as China, India, Iran, Indonesia, Egypt, Libya, Saudi Arabia, Brazil, Argentina, Nigeria and argues that ‘the objection of the third world countries is not to the quality of order in the present international arrangements; it is rather to the way in which these arrangements discriminate against them’ (191, emphasis added). Thus, Bull not only specifically identifies the countries that are opposed to the inequality in the nuclear order but is also insistent in making a division between those that have a mind and others that are mindless in their quest for change in the nuclear order. He further argues that states located on the third rung of the hierarchical nuclear order harbour grievances not to the quality of order but the arrangements within this order that are discriminatory against them. This split discourse on quality of nuclear order and responsibility for the arrangements within the nuclear order is further buttressed by the suggestion that ‘those who have special interests recognize the special responsibilities that go with them, and conduct themselves in such a way as to engage general support for the system whose custodians and guarantors they are’ (Bull 1968, 1987, 143–50, 214, emphasis added). The racial etiquette practiced by Hedley Bull becomes more pronounced in his statement that the ‘Third World’s lack of power, including military power – its sense of impotence and vulnerability in relation to the Western countries’ makes it rail against the existing international nuclear order (1987, 201–2, emphasis added). It is with an inquisitorial insistence that he demands they articulate an ‘alternative conception of world order’ to be taken seriously (191). A similar tone of authority persists in the text of Joseph S. Nye as he writes in the last decade of the Cold War. Nye undertakes a purposeful investigation of the ‘logic of inequality’ in the nuclear order (1985, 123). The sincerity of his undertaking is belied by attributing theatrics to those claiming to harbour grievances against the existing nuclear order prior to the investigation being completed. At the very outset of this investigation, he describes the allegations of discrimination, hypocrisy and failure to live up to commitments levied by the diplomats of non-nuclear weapons states against the superpowers as a ‘drama’ (123). Nye then suggests that there is a ‘basic intuitive compact underlying the NPT’ and describes the nuclear nonproliferation treaty (NPT) itself as an ‘imaginary compact’ (1985, 124, 129) He then stipulates that ‘under certain conditions’ and ‘other things remaining equal’ nuclear inequality is acceptable (124–126). This reluctance to engage with historical circumstances and insert ceteris paribus clauses to advance abstract conditions of arguments is a questionable exercise. According to Akeel Bigrami and Priya Chacko this reluctance exhibits a ‘technological mindset’ that ‘fosters an abstract view of the world and relies on an understanding of truth as cognitive rather than as lived moral experience’ (Bilgrami 2003, 4164; Chacko 2011, 191). Nye deliberately insists on investigating the logic of inequality only as a technical problem susceptible to failure and denounces any investigation of the problem as embedded in racial roots. He emphatically insists that, ‘nuclear inequality has nothing to do with racism on the part of weapons states or with the irrationality that some claim to see in Third World leaders’ (Nye 1985, 126). This impatience to denounce charges of racism is coupled with fearful portents that questioning the logic of inequality could lead to the possibility that ‘deterrence will fail’ (126). The failure of deterrence it is argued ‘is likely to be much higher in most regional situations because of the shaky political conditions found in most states seeking nuclear weapons as well as their limited experience with nuclear command and control systems’ (126). The existing inequality is further justified on grounds that with ‘new proliferators’ the threat of breaking ‘nuclear taboo becomes that much more likely’ (127). The reference to ‘shaky political conditions’ belies an element of suspicion and uncertainty of a stabilized and legitimate influence in these regions that fuels the need for assertion of hegemony in the nuclear order. There is little effort to balance these observations with acknowledgement of the risks that the possession of nuclear arms by Western powers has exposed to the world (Sagan 1995). The maintenance of inequality is further proposed in the following terms, ‘under many circumstances the introduction of a single bomb in some non-nuclear states may be more likely to lead to nuclear use than the addition of a thousand more warheads to the US and Soviet stockpiles’ (Nye 1985, 128, emphasis added). This particular statement reveals the entrenched psyche of fearful discrimination and reignites the racial trauma of colonization in the subaltern that is to be severely penalized should even a single, rusty weapon be discovered in its possession by the colonizer (Memmi 1967, 93–4). Nye is confident in his assertion that, ‘nonproliferation is not an inconsistent or hypocritical policy if it is based on impartial and realistic estimation of relative risks’ (Nye 1985, 127). But he is oblivious to the consideration that the power to make calculations pertaining to risk of failure of deterrence are all vested in the West and violation of taboo are all sourced to ‘new proliferators’ that need to be policed (Nye 1985, 131). Nye does not problematize the task of policing as a shared responsibility of all countries but reiterates that the task of policing is ‘traditionally the domain of great powers in international politics’ (131). Any resistance to this policing function perceived as ‘the domain of great powers’ is further circumscribed by polarized choices between ‘some ordered inequality in weaponry’ or ‘anarchic inequality’ an oxymoron that is described by Nye to be ‘more dangerous’ (Nye 1985, 130). Nye casually entertains the possibility that ‘third countries may hold the superpowers similarly accountable’ but fails to provide any account of how this might be undertaken as he only insists on ‘alliance guarantees’ to stem proliferation and readily concludes that the NPT’s ‘Article VI obligations cannot be interpreted as simple disarmament’ (128). The transfer of nuclear technology even for energy programmes is also to be grounded in an ‘evolutionary approach’ and susceptible to additional deliberation on a ‘region’s stability and of the susceptibility of the technology to safeguards’ (130). It is this entrenched mindset of political master and paranoia of displacement of power that is displayed by Nye four decades into the Cold War. Nye displays little desire to question the legacy of attitudes that he has inherited from those that have been revered and are woven into the traditional discourse on arms control and disarmament.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Cybersecurity

Cybernetic regimes of control which justifies global conflicts

Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19. Nick Dyer-Witheford is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at University of Western Ontario and Svitlana Matviyenko is an Assistant Professor of Critical Media Analysis in the School of Communication. “Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism.” March 2019.

This is not the place for a detailed examination of the political economy of "postsocialist" nations (Lane 2014). In the USSR, the orgy of privatization and the chaos of shocktherapy marketization after 1991 have been followed under Putin by a new period of nationalization, in which oligarchic capitalists operate under supervision of, and overlap with, state elites in a context of market exchange (Worth 2005; Pirani 2010; Dzarasov 2014; Sakwa 2014). In the more complex case of the People's Republic of China, the party apparatus has maintained control of some "commanding heights" of the economy, even as other domains are handed over to private ownership, including both foreign and domestic investors. Some commentators see China's arrangements as tantamount to full subsumption with the world market (Li 2009; HartLandsberg 2013); others consider that a "left turn" from within the party apparatus could reestablish a socialist project (Amin 2013). At the moment, the latter possibility seems remote. In Russia, China, and other postsocialist countries, the wage organizes production, the responsibilities of the state for provision of public services have typically been diminished, and there are vast income gulfs between workers in and owners of the means of production. Corruption is often rife. Political elites are either identical with, entangled in, or dependent on capital ownership, and although these elites must in various ways manage, mobilize, and hegemonize public opinion, their fractions define the agenda of policy decisions, and perhaps especially foreign policy decisions. Thus discussions of international relations in terms of the intentions or desires of "China" or "Russia" - as, of course, of the "United States," "Canada," "Ukraine," "Saudi Arabia," or any other capitalist nation - must be understood as shorthand metonymic mystification of ruling-class power. Cyberwar has therefore emerged as a topic of global concern at a moment when the teleological certainties of Marxism seem broken or reduced to cruel caricature. This is not a coincidence. As we will argue, the emergence of cybernetics from the military-industrial complex of the United States at the end of the Second Word War was an important part of that nation's ascent as a new imperial leader for the capitalist system. Computers and networks, both in their military and economic applications, played an important role in eventual U.S. victory over the USSR in the Cold War. And their extension into electronic commodities, industrial automation, supply-chain logistics, and financial trading was a crucial part of the globalization in which a reinvigorated capitalism from 1989 on disseminated itself around the planet, under the shelter of the global hegemon's cruise missiles, smart weapons, and satellite intelligence. This armed pacification of a world market has, however, not had the finality many expected. Rather, it has generated new wars, of two major types, both misnamed and ill defined but each a consequence of capital's global triumph over its socialist opponents. The "war on terror" is, of course, the conventional and ideologically laden name for the protracted sequence of conflicts set in motion when mujahideen, armed and financed by the United States and its Saudi Arabian ally to fight the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, turned on its imperial patron with the destruction of the World Trade Center in 2001. These conflicts, centered on the Middle East but radiating across the planet, include the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan; world-distributed terrorist attacks; and counterterrorist operations across Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Nigeria, the Philippines, Mali, Libya, and many other theaters. If the "war on terror" is sometimes colloquially used to include the U.S. invasion of Iraq, this craven acceptance of the spurious rationalizations offered by the Bush administration could be only retroactively justified, as U.S. occupation generated first both Sunni and Shia insurgency and later, in its aftermath, the rise of ISIS. This so-called war on terror interpenetrates other regional conflicts, such as those in Kashmir between India and Pakistan, Russian actions in Chechnya, and Saudi Arabia's intensifying clashes with Iran in Yemen and elsewhere, and also overlaps with Israel's constant operations against Palestinians, wars with neighbors, and determination to maintain its regional monopoly of nuclear weapons. It is not our aim here to map the noxious vectors of the "war on terror," only to highlight how its mutating fronts have been a bleeding edge for the development and use of cyberweaponry, in counterinsurgency operations, domestic surveillance, and digital strikes and sabotage against nuclear weapons facilities.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Cybersecurity

That has an external impact of cybereugenics and nanocellular racism as the perfection of previous techniques elaborated during counterinsurgency wars, increasingly armed with racial technologies of control

Mbembe 17. Joseph-Achille Mbembe, known as Achille Mbembe, is a Cameroonian philosopher, political theorist, and public intellectual. “Critique of Black Reason.” 3-10-2017. Duke University Press. cut by vikas bbyyy

The same is true of the different ways in which living things can be manipulated, including the hybridization of organic, animal, and artificial elements. In fact, there is good reason to believe that in a more or less distant future genetic techniques will be used to manage the characteristics of populations to eliminate races judged "undesirable" through the selection of trisomic embryos, or through theriomorphism (hybridization with animal elements) or "cyborgization" (hybridization with artificial elements). Nor is it impossible to believe that we will arrive at a point where the fundamental role of medicine will be not only to bring a sick organism back to health but to use medical techniques of molecular engineering to refashion life itself along lines defined by racial determinism. Race and racism, then, do not only have a past. They also have a future, particularly in a context where the possibility of transforming life and creating mutant species no longer belongs to the realm of fiction. Taken on their own, the transformations of the capitalist mode of production during the second half of the twentieth century cannot explain the reappearance and various metamorphoses of the Beast. But they- along with major discoveries in technology, biology, and genetics-do undeniably constitute its background. 42 A new political economy of life is emerging, one irrigated by international flows of knowledge about cells, tissues, organs, pathologies, and therapies as well as about intellectual property.43 The reactivation of the logic of race also goes hand in hand with the increasing power of the ideology of security and the installation of mechanisms aimed at calculating and minimizing risk and turning protection into the currency of citizenship. This is notably the case in regard to the management of migration and mobility in a context in which terrorist threats are believed to increasingly emanate from individuals organized in cells and networks that span the surface of the planet. In such conditions the protection and policing of territory becomes a structural condition for securing the population. To be effective, such protection requires that everyone remain at home, that those living and moving within a given national territory be capable of proving their identities at any given moment, that the most exhaustive information possible be gathered on each individual, and that the control of foreigners' mobility be carried out not only along borders but also from a distance, preferably within their countries of departure. The massive expansion of digitization under way nearly everywhere in the world partly adheres to this logic, with the idea that optimal forms of securitizationnecessarily require the creation of global systems of control over individuals conceived of as biological bodies that are both multiple and in motion. Protection itself is no longer based solely on the legal order. It has become a question of biopolitics. The new systems of security build on various elements of prior regimes (the forms of punishment used within slavery, aspects of the colonial wars of conquest and occupation, legal- juridical techniques used in the creation of states of exception) and incorporate them, on a nanocellular level, into the techniques of the age of genomics and the war on terror. But they also draw on techniques elaborated during the counterinsurgency wars of the period of decolonization and the "dirty wars" of the Cold War (in Algeria, Vietnam, Southern Africa, Burma, and Nicaragua), as well as the experiences of predatory dictatorships put into power throughout the world with the direct encouragement, or at least complicity, of the intelligence agencies of the West. The increasing power of the security state in the contemporary context is, furthermore, accompanied by a remodeling of the world through technology and an exacerbation of forms of racial categorization. Facing the transformation of the economy of violence throughout the world, liberal democratic regimes now consider themselves to be in a nearly constant state of war against new enemies who are in flight, both mobile and reticular. The theater of this new form of war is both external and internal. It requires a "total" conception of defense, along with greater tolerance for legal exceptions and special dispensations. The conduct of this type of war depends on the creation of tight, panoptic systems that enable increasing control of individuals, preferably from a distance, via the traces they leave behind.46 In place of the classic paradigm of war, in which opposing sides meet on a well-defined battlefield and the risk of death is reciprocal, the logic is now vertical. There are two protagonists: prey and predator.47 The predator, with nearly complete control of the airspace, selects the targets, locations, times, and nature of the strikes.48 The increasingly vertical character of war and the more frequent use of unpiloted drones means that killing the enemy looks more and more like a video game, an experience of sadism, spectacle, and entertainment.49 And, even more important, these new forms of warfare carried out from a distance require an unprecedented merging of the civil, police, and military spheres with those of surveillance. The spheres of surveillance, meanwhile, are also being reconfigured. No longer mere state structures, and operating as chains linked in formonly, they function by cultivating private-sector influence, by expanding into those corporate entities responsible for gathering the data necessary for mass surveillance. As a result, the objects of surveillance become daily life, the space of relationships, communication (notably through electronic technologies), and transactions. There is not, of course, a total concatenation of the mechanisms of the market and those of the state. But in our contemporary world the liberal state is transformed into a war power at a time when, we now realize, capital not only remains fixed in a phase of primitive accumulation but also still leverages racial subsidies in its pursuit of profit. In this context the citizen is redefined as both the subject and the beneficiary of surveillance, which now privileges the transcription of biological, genetic, and behavioral characteristics through digital imprints. In a new technetronic regime characterized by miniaturization, dematerialization, and the fluid administration of state violence, imprints (fingerprints, scans of the iris and retina, forms of vocal and facial recognition) make it possible to measure and archive the uniqueness of individuals. The distinguishing parts of the human body become the foundations for new systems of identification, surveillance, and repression. The security state conceives of identity and the movement of individuals (including its own citizens) as sources of danger and risk. But the generalized use of biometric data as a source of identification and for the automation of facial recognition constitutes a new type of populace, one predisposed toward distancing and imprisonment. 51 So it is that, in the context of the anti-immigration push in Europe, entire categories of the population are indexed and subjected to various forms of racial categorization that transform the immigrant (legal or illegal) into an essential category of difference.52 This difference can be perceived as cultural or religious or linguistic. It is seen as inscribed in the very body of the migrant subject, visible on somatic, physiognomic, and even genetic levels.53 War and race have meanwhile become resurgent problems at the heart of the international order. The same is true of torture and the phenomenon of mass incarceration. It is not only that the line between war and peace has been blurred. War has become a "gigantic process of labor," while the military regime seeks to impose its own model on the "public order of the peace state."54 While some citadels have collapsed, other walls have been strengthened.55 As has long been the case, the contemporary world is deeply shaped and conditioned by the ancestral forms of religious, legal, and political life built around fences, enclosures, walls, camps, circles,and, above all, borders. 56 Procedures of differentiation, classification, and hierarchization aimed at exclusion, expulsion, and even eradication have been reinvigorated everywhere. New voices have emerged proclaiming, on the one hand, that there is no such thing as a universal human being or, on the other, that the universal is common to some human beings but not to all. Others emphasize the necessity for all to guarantee the safety of their own lives and homes by devoting themselves-and their ancestors and their memories, in one way or another-to the divine, a process that only subtracts them from historical interrogation and secures them completely and permanently within the walls of theology. Like the beginning of the nineteenth century, the beginning of the twenty-first constitutes, from this perspective, a significant moment of division, universal differentiation, and identity seeking.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – Cybersecurity

Cyber warfare is a product of racial capitalisms unconscious – the root cause is violence shaped by inter-capitalist rivalries that make war inevitable – but it also is a source for revolutionary disruptions through a “cyber war on cyber war” that short-circuits capitals monopoly on violence

Dyer-Witherford and Mtviyenko 17 – Nick Dyer-Witheford is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at University of Western Ontario and Svitlana Matviyenko is an Assistant Professor of Critical Media Analysis in the School of Communication [Nick, Svitlana, “Cyber-War and Contemporary Marxism,” 2017, DKP]

Cyber-war could, in theory be part of a contemporary revolutionary war position which might include development militant hacking to sabotage and paralyse corporate operations, recovering the worker power lost by the (cybernetic) diminishment of the power of the mass strike, etc, or disrupting the financial sector. More loosely, as we have already mentioned the last decades of seen some successes in cyber-organizing of occupations, demonstrations and riots, and one could imagine this process intensifying in future crises. However, there are problems in particular to applying cyber-war to revolutionary ends. As Hassan (2013), Dyer-Witheford (2015) and others have argued, there is a misfit between the speed and secrecy of cyber-war practices and the slower and social logic that, in the long term, form radically emancipatory subjects and movements: reliance on cyber-organizing probably account for some of the "up like a rocket, down like a stick" aspect of the 2011 occupations. Moreover, despite hacker romanticism, there is a persisting imbalance of power between state and no-state forces even in the digital realm (Healey 2013), and the new vulnerability of social movements to surveillance cyber-crackdowns seriously jeopardises all sorts of cyber-organizing hacktivism. To assess the future possibilities of revolutionary cyber-war therefore requires an overall assessment of the diverse factors at play in the emergence of cyber-war as a feature of contemporary capitalism, a task to which we now turn.

3. Cyber-War and the capitalist unconscious

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – China

Their attempt to model China’s desires is connected to a global process of control through modulating China’s tech development coalesces imperial violence

Dyer-Witheford and Matviyenko 19. Nick Dyer-Witheford is an Associate Professor in the Faculty of Information and Media Studies at University of Western Ontario and Svitlana Matviyenko is an Assistant Professor of Critical Media Analysis in the School of Communication. “Cyberwar and Revolution: Digital Subterfuge in Global Capitalism.” March 2019.

This is not the place for a detailed examination of the political economy of "postsocialist" nations (Lane 2014). In the USSR, the orgy of privatization and the chaos of shocktherapy marketization after 1991 have been followed under Putin by a new period of nationalization, in which oligarchic capitalists operate under supervision of, and overlap with, state elites in a context of market exchange (Worth 2005; Pirani 2010; Dzarasov 2014; Sakwa 2014). In the more complex case of the People's Republic of China, the party apparatus has maintained control of some "commanding heights" of the economy, even as other domains are handed over to private ownership, including both foreign and domestic investors. Some commentators see China's arrangements as tantamount to full subsumption with the world market (Li 2009; HartLandsberg 2013); others consider that a "left turn" from within the party apparatus could reestablish a socialist project (Amin 2013). At the moment, the latter possibility seems remote. In Russia, China, and other postsocialist countries, the wage organizes production, the responsibilities of the state for provision of public services have typically been diminished, and there are vast income gulfs between workers in and owners of the means of production. Corruption is often rife. Political elites are either identical with, entangled in, or dependent on capital ownership, and although these elites must in various ways manage, mobilize, and hegemonize public opinion, their fractions define the agenda of policy decisions, and perhaps especially foreign policy decisions. Thus discussions of international relations in terms of the intentions or desires of "China" or "Russia" - as, of course, of the "United States," "Canada," "Ukraine," "Saudi Arabia," or any other capitalist nation - must be understood as shorthand metonymic mystification of ruling-class power. Cyberwar has therefore emerged as a topic of global concern at a moment when the teleological certainties of Marxism seem broken or reduced to cruel caricature. This is not a coincidence. As we will argue, the emergence of cybernetics from the military-industrial complex of the United States at the end of the Second Word War was an important part of that nation's ascent as a new imperial leader for the capitalist system. Computers and networks, both in their military and economic applications, played an important role in eventual U.S. victory over the USSR in the Cold War. And their extension into electronic commodities, industrial automation, supply-chain logistics, and financial trading was a crucial part of the globalization in which a reinvigorated capitalism from 1989 on disseminated itself around the planet, under the shelter of the global hegemon's cruise missiles, smart weapons, and satellite intelligence. This armed pacification of a world market has, however, not had the finality many expected. Rather, it has generated new wars, of two major types, both misnamed and ill defined but each a consequence of capital's global triumph over its socialist opponents. The "war on terror" is, of course, the conventional and ideologically laden name for the protracted sequence of conflicts set in motion when mujahideen, armed and financed by the United States and its Saudi Arabian ally to fight the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, turned on its imperial patron with the destruction of the World Trade Center in 2001. These conflicts, centered on the Middle East but radiating across the planet, include the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan; world-distributed terrorist attacks; and counterterrorist operations across Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Nigeria, the Philippines, Mali, Libya, and many other theaters. If the "war on terror" is sometimes colloquially used to include the U.S. invasion of Iraq, this craven acceptance of the spurious rationalizations offered by the Bush administration could be only retroactively justified, as U.S. occupation generated first both Sunni and Shia insurgency and later, in its aftermath, the rise of ISIS. This so-called war on terror interpenetrates other regional conflicts, such as those in Kashmir between India and Pakistan, Russian actions in Chechnya, and Saudi Arabia's intensifying clashes with Iran in Yemen and elsewhere, and also overlaps with Israel's constant operations against Palestinians, wars with neighbors, and determination to maintain its regional monopoly of nuclear weapons. It is not our aim here to map the noxious vectors of the "war on terror," only to highlight how its mutating fronts have been a bleeding edge for the development and use of cyberweaponry, in counterinsurgency operations, domestic surveillance, and digital strikes and sabotage against nuclear weapons facilities.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – AI

Global solidarity that converges around AI and the Internet of Things is a symbiotic end of humanism that reifies neoliberal individualism and causes mass industrialized eugenics.

Armand 20 – Charles University, Prague, Centre for Critical and Cultural Theory, Director [Louis, “The posthuman: AI, dronology, and “becoming alien”,” AI & SOCIETY (2020) 35:257–262 , DKP]

Insofar as humanity dreams of life after death, the “drone” is the as-yet primitive technological image of that afterlife. Like the Panopticon, the drone is a metaphor (Bentham 1995). It is the prototype of an ideal proxy by which the “human condition” transcends its worldly embodiment into a cosmic internet-of-things: a distributed architecture of autopoietic, kinetic agency. Thought that moves itself. Yet, it is precisely for this reason that what calls itself posthuman masks the return of an ever-more-apocalyptic Humanism, wherein the prestige of what is conserved as species unique is equated with the prestige of species transcendence: the (supposed) “uniquely human” capacity to manufacture universalities—artificial intelligence, cybernetic machines, synthetic DNA, etc. The capacity, in other words, to project, by way of abstraction, an all-too Humanistic teleology upon the domain of evolution itself—and thus secure a future against human obsolescence.

This, at least, is the type of paradoxical science fiction narrative that has prepared the way, in the West, for the evocation of “species solidarity” in the face of catastrophic imminence: from Global Warming to Technological Singularity to Human Extinction Event. A pseudo-solidarity bound, on one hand, to the advance of neo-liberal individualism and, on the other, to a ceaseless erosion of the collective “social contract”. It does not matter that the logics of such catastrophes broadly contradict one another: what is essential is that the ultimate promise of business-as-usual both mitigates and masks a whole intervening process of un-becoming.

2022 UTNIF Kritik
Links › Link – AI

The integration of AI into Military logistics results unchecked racialized necropolitics as a value that informs politics and replaces human governance with AI that kill with impunity and result in endemic warfare

Grove 20 – Associate Professor of Political Science and Director of the Hawai’i Research Center for Future Studies at the University of Hawai’I at Mānoa, PhD in International Relations at Johns Hopkins University [Jairus, “From geopolitics to geotechnics: global futures in the shadow of automation, cunning machines, and human speciation,” International Relations 2020, Vol. 34(3) 432 –455, DKP]

The automation of war and the reduction of human troop sizes has a similar effect. Wars aided by drones and as a result significantly smaller numbers of soldier casualties continue on for decades in a kind of sustainable warfare.28 The political and material cost of casualties like the material cost of striking are being removed from the political equation making states less and less accountable in the case of social justice and the pursuit of violence outside their borders.

The feedback between these two trends is potentially catastrophic. At the same time that war becomes easier, governments become less accountable to their people, and people are deprived of the means to support themselves, it is also the case that people will matter less to their governments as they will not possess the labor power to cause pain to the economic productivity of the country by means of striking nor the capacity to refuse to fight. Zygmunt Bauman has spoken of disposable populations, a kind of human waste or surplus where the value of one’s existence is meaningless for the state.29 However, we ought to go further down this path by way of Achille Mbembe’s creeping necropolitics.30 It is not merely that chronically or even intergenerational unemployed people have no value; it is that the marginalization and even murder of people can now generate value. In what Mbembe refers to as the ‘enclave economies’ of war machines: