Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › China Not a Threat

Despite Advantages on both sides, US-China relations could solve AI MAD

Allison ‘20 (Graham Allison, Douglas Dillon Professor of Government, Harvard Kennedy School Member of the Board, Belfer Center Former Director, Belfer Center Faculty Affiliate, Future of Diplomacy Project,August 2020, )Roho

Clues for a Winning Strategy Is AI a race China is destined to win? With a population four times the size of the United States, there is no question that China will have the largest domestic market for AI applications. With many multiples of the United States in data, substantially larger numbers of computer scientists and a government for which there is a first-order priority, we can understand colleagues who are pessimistic. Indeed, it is our best judgment that on the current trajectory, while the United States will maintain a narrow lead over the next five years, China will then catch up and pass us quickly thereafter. Nonetheless, we believe that this is an arena in which the United States can compete—and win. Congress recently established the “National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence,” with Eric Schmidt as its chair, and Bob Work, who served as Deputy Secretary of Defense under both Obama and Trump, as Vice Chair. Its mission is to develop that strategy “to ensure America’s national security enterprise has the tools it needs to maintain U.S. global leadership.”55 In the hope of being helpful to that effort, we conclude with five pointers toward a winning strategy. First, Americans must wake up to the challenge. Recognition that that the United States faces a serious competitor in a contest in which the outcome will be decisive for our future is necessary to get our competitive juices flowing. The Olympics offers an instructive analogy for thinking about a competitive strategy for AI. It also reminds us that competition is inherently a good thing. Competition produces superior performance. Participants in a marathon run faster than they do when running alone. Indeed, competition is a core American value. Free markets organize a competitive process that produces better products at cheaper prices. Science and its applications advance as research teams compete to better understand the world.56 Second, in this competition, the United States cannot hope to be the biggest—in that category, China wins by default due to the size of its population. However, what the United States can be is the smartest. In the seeking to improve and advance the most advanced of technologies, the brightest 0.0001 percent of individuals make the difference. The United States can succeed by recruiting talent from all 7.7 billion people on Earth and enabling these individuals to realize their full potential.57 In fact, U.S. companies have now recruited more than half of the top 100 recognized AI geniuses. In sharp contrast, China is a closed society—limited essentially to 1.4 billion Chinese speakers. Just 1000 foreign born individuals became Chinese citizens last year. So while the United States will not win competitions in which bulk numbers are the dominant factor, where brilliance, creativity and innovation matter most, the United States has a decisive advantage.58 Third, platforms matter. Here the United States begins with a huge sustainable competitive advantage: English is the universal language for science, business and the web. Chinese face the choice of either speaking English, or simply talking to themselves. Not only do the Chinese, but also the French and others often complain that this is unfair—and it may be. But it is a fact. To transform Singapore from a third-world city into one of the world’s most successful and prosperous global trading hubs, Lee Kuan Yew insisted on making English its first language. (Indeed, at one point in counseling Chinese leaders, he suggested that China make English its first language.) Today, more than half of the 7.5 billion people on Earth speak English—and another billion are seeking to learn. Fourth, American companies have a significant first mover advantage in the establishment of the major platforms in AI, including operating systems (Android and Apple), design of advanced semiconductors (arm), and killer apps—including Instagram, YouTube and Facebook. Instagram has 1 billion monthly active users; Facebook more than 2.4 billion. While Chinese competitors will certainly attempt to displace the current leaders in both platforms and applications, if American companies are smart enough to continue enlarging their users’ opportunities, improving their experiences, and expanding the number of people using their platforms and applications, Chinese and others who want to speak to the world could have to continue relying on U.S.-dominated platforms. Fifth, while competing vigorously with the intention of sustaining U.S. leadership, we must recognize at the same time the necessity of cooperation in areas where neither the United States nor China can secure its own minimum vital national interests without the help of the other. The consequences of human energy consumption on the climate offers a vivid illustration. If either the United States or China keeps emitting greenhouse gases at the current rate, in one hundred years, this could produce a biosphere in which neither nation can survive. Thus there is no viable alternative to cooperation. The same is true in other realms including preventing third party provocations—for example, in North Korea or Taiwan—from dragging the United States and China into a catastrophic war; and cooperation to prevent recurring financial crises like the Great Recession of 2008 from cascading into another Great Depression. We suspect there may be an analog in limiting the unconstrained advance of AI. The possibility that nations could simultaneously compete ruthlessly, on the one hand, while cooperating intensely, on the other, sounds to diplomats like a contradiction. In the world of business, however, it is called life. While no one has yet developed a felicitous term for what is sometimes called “coopetition,” Apple and Samsung offer a powerful example. The two are ruthless rivals in the global market for smartphones (where, in fact, over the past five years Samsung has become number one). But who is Apple’s largest supplier of components for smartphones? Samsung. Managing a relationship that is simultaneously competitive and cooperative requires vigilance, judgment and agility in adapting. But if, as we believe the evidence shows, technologies on a small globe have left the United States and China with two—and only two—options, we believe they can find ways to coexist, however uncomfortably, if their only alternative is mutual destruction.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › China Not a Threat

AI collaboration between US-China are vital, and a translated Chinese report confirms development is NOT zero-sum.

Sullivan 21 (Lieutenant Colonel Sullivan is an Army pilot by trade, who lived and studied at the prestigious Fudan University in Shanghai, China, as an Olmsted Scholar. He was one of just five Army officers selected that year. Ryan has taken his experience in and knowledge of China and combined that with graduate-level work in the field of Artificial Intelligence to deliver an in-depth study of the critical elements of U.S.-China competition in Artificial Intelligence.) “The U.S., China, and Artificial Intelligence Competition Factors” 2021-10-04 // ZX

The purpose of this research is to examine the critical elements of U.S.-China competition over Artificial Intelligence (AI) norms and determine if the resulting contest is inherently zero-sum. The paper explores SinoAmerican AI competition through the lenses of values, cohesion, influence, and legitimacy to better understand each nation’s positional advantages and identify possibilities for cooperation in bilateral or multilateral engagements. Those engagements will be part of the overall Sino-American struggle for influence within international institutions and standard-setting organizations (SSO) over technical standards and, more importantly, values, norms and ethics guiding AI applications.In the new world order, competition over the establishment of AI norms is not zero-sum; however, the continued deterioration in mutual trust and bilateral relations will test both the U.S. and China to avoid transactional engagements or challenges to core interests which could escalate AI competition into AI conflict. Hal Brands and Zack Cooper argue that “many American conceptions of the competition with China rest on the false premise that this contest will be neatly bipolar – a replay of the East-West standoff in Europe during the Cold War. A much messier world is taking shape.”2 This messiness stems from 21st-century competition, which a report from RAND views as mixed sum, as shared interest and objectives converge in an international system that currently displays elements of unipolarity, bipolarity, and multipolarity.3 AI will play an instrumental role in reshaping the world order and the degrees to which each polarity element exists. Neither the U.S. or China can achieve its objectives alone, and both must seek support from other nations to achieve their desired ends. AI and other emerging technology will empower developing nations and middle powers to play a more prominent role in constructing a world order. Those middle powers, or “third countries, such as India, Indonesia and Turkey,” no longer feel the need “to align entirely with the United States, nor with China, when they can gain by playing Washington and Beijing against each other to produce a “multipolar competition, not a bipolar one.”4 This paper assumes that the liberal framework remains intact, and that AI competition will occur in an increasingly multipolar world order. Despite breakdowns in bilateral relations, zero-sum conflict is not predestined, as Shanghai scholar Wu Xinbo notes, “promoting pragmatic cooperation and constructive competition, effective management, control of risks, and prevention of major conflicts between China and the United States remains the basic direction of China’s diplomacy with the United States.”11 Several U.S. scholars and leaders such as Elizabeth Economy and Graham Allison also advocate cooperative approaches to competition by promoting coopetition, coevolution, or rivalry partnerships.12 Such strategies are hard to imagine in a period of increasingly strained bilateral relations and diverging values, and are likely to fail if the leaders of both nations maintain a binary approach to engagement. This paper explores competition through the lens of values, cohesion, influence, and legitimacy to better understand each nation’s positional advantages and identify possibilities for cooperation in bilateral or multilateral engagements. The U.S. and China remain the two nations best positioned to benefit from the increasing adoption of AI across society. Competition over AI is not zero-sum, in that both nations will derive value from AI growth, but the benefits are not shared equally. China’s substantial advantages in data and the size of its market lead experts to predict that China will account for nearly half of the estimated $15.7 trillion that AI will add to the global gross domestic product (GDP) by 2030, and almost double the expected growth in North America. Values competition is not zero-sum, but diverging AI values represent the most significant challenge to cooperation and limits the extent to which Sino-American collaboration on AI can continue in some areas. The synergy of economic, political, and technological challenges that AI competition creates demands action. Our nation’s gravest risk is to remain on the sidelines of global leadership and allow the CCP to promote a values system that prioritizes the Party over the nation and its people as a viable alternative to democracy. Failure to address federal data privacy and consumer rights concerns leaves China and Europe as the only two models offering “guardrails against invasive data collection.”106 Challenges and opportunities in forming alliances and relying on the collective to balance other nations’ interests and needs present opportunities and risks. Regarding China, Graham Allison offers that “while U.S. planners must consider all reasonable contingencies, basing our strategy to meet the China challenge on the expectation that the Chinese economy or political system fails would be a mistake.”107 Finding ways to cooperate or collaborate would prove beneficial to the collective, but such choices on a state-to-state basis could very well lead to conflict. Attempting to challenge or contain China without allies seems unlikely to succeed in the long term.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › China Not a Threat

China and the US will collaborate on AI research even through strategic tensions

Andrews 3/16 (Edmund L. Andrews is a former economics reporter for The New York Times who served as a technology reporter in Washington, European economics correspondent and Washington economics correspondent, “China and the United States: Unlikely Partners in AI,” Stanford University Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence, 3/16/2022, ) – MP

Despite both rivalry and rising tensions between the United States and China, the two nations have become the world’s leading collaborators in research on artificial intelligence. The newly released AI Index Report, which tracks AI trends on a host of fronts and is published by the Stanford Institute for Human-Centered Artificial Intelligence, finds that U.S. and Chinese AI researchers teamed up on far more published articles than collaborators between any other two nations. Overall, U.S.-China collaborations on AI research have quintupled since 2010 and totaled 9,660 papers in 2021—much faster than the increase in collaborations between any other two nations. Collaborations between the United States and United Kingdom, the second most prolific source of cross-border research, increased almost threefold to 3,560 papers. Read the 2022 AI Index The startling trend highlights a paradox. Even as China and the U.S. race for leadership in what they view as a strategically important technology, researchers on both sides appear to see benefits in sharing expertise and working together. “What’s clear is that the amount of collaboration between the United States and China has gone up dramatically, and it has gone up much more than collaborations between any two other countries,” says Raymond Perrault, Distinguished Computer Scientist at SRI International in Menlo Park and co-chair of the AI Index Steering Committee. To some extent, the surge in U.S.-China research simply reflects the fact that both nations have poured vast resources into artificial intelligence and produce huge amounts of research. On top of that, many Chinese researchers were trained in the United States and retain close professional ties to their American colleagues. But the practice is consistent with patterns observed during previous technological revolutions in textiles, steel, and chemical engineering. Research by Jeffrey Ding, a postdoctoral fellow at Stanford HAI, has shown that the full economic impact of historic tech advances stemmed less from which nation pioneered a technology than from which ones were best at applying it across a broad range of industries. That dispersion of technology requires sharing information across industries as well as borders, much as the United States catapulted applied British advances in steel machinery to develop manufacturing approaches that catapulted it to economic dominance. That said, the collaboration in AI comes at a time of growing friction between the United States and China over trade, human rights, and strategic power in the Pacific Rim. Former President Donald Trump villainized China over its trade practices, and President Joe Biden imposed a diplomatic boycott of the Beijing Olympics over China's human rights abuses. Indeed, the volume of published U.S.-China collaborations in AI has declined slightly from its peak in 2019. Perrault says it’s unclear whether the recent dip reflects a lag in data, a temporary disruption, or a more fundamental change. Collaborations have also declined slightly between most other nations, such as those between researchers in the United States, Canada, and Europe. Globally, AI research has soared over the past decade. The volume of peer-reviewed AI journal articles has more than doubled since 2015, hitting a new record of 172,000 papers in 2021. On top of that, researchers posted 56,000 pre-print articles in repositories specializing in AI. Chinese researchers have been the most prolific for the past several years, publishing 27.5% of all AI journal articles worldwide. American researchers accounted for 12%. Chinese journal articles also led those of every other nation in citations, an indicator of their scientific importance. And although the United States continues to receive more AI patents than any other nation, China is now filing more than half of all the world’s patent applications in the field. Image Graph showing increase in patent filings in China (51.69% of total) while patent filings in the U.S. fall (16.92%) AI research has also intensified in most other parts of the world, notably in the European Union, Canada, and Japan. The one notable exception is Russia, which has largely gone its own way. “Russia is way, way smaller in this area,’’ says Perrault. In the United States, 1,200 institutions published roughly 3,000 cross-border AI collaborations in 2021. In China, 500 institutions published 2,000 cross-border projects. By contrast only 60 Russian institutions teamed up on 600 AI projects.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › China Not a Threat

US-China AI competition is not zero-sum – collaboration with clear goals solves.

Sullivan 21 (Lieutenant Colonel Ryan Sullivan is an Army pilot by trade, who lived and studied at the prestigious Fudan University in Shanghai, China, as an Olmsted Scholar. He was one of just five Army officers selected that year. Ryan has taken his experience in and knowledge of China and combined that with graduate-level work in the field of Artificial Intelligence to deliver an in-depth study of the critical elements of U.S.-China competition in Artificial Intelligence. “US China AI Competition Factors,” 10/04/21 , p9)ZK

The U.S. and China remain the two nations best positioned to benefit from the increasing adoption of AI across society. Competition over AI is not zero-sum, in that both nations will derive value from AI growth, but the benefits are not shared equally. China’s substantial advantages in data and the size of its market lead experts to predict that China will account for nearly half of the estimated $15.7 trillion that AI will add to the global gross domestic product (GDP) by 2030, and almost double the expected growth in North America.23 AI’s economic benefits are undeniable, but AI competition with China goes beyond GDP growth and centers on the global diffusion of Chinese values, norms, and standards for AI utilization. That environment is very much undecided, as the international community struggles with challenges over data privacy, the role of AI-empowered multinational companies, and critical choke points in supply chains that impact the AI industry and threaten national security interests. This paper seeks to recognize that collaboration occurs between the U.S. and China and identifies efforts to address security concerns, collaborations, and even cooperation in areas of trans-national challenges that benefit all of humankind. The deteriorating bilateral relationships and mistrust likely prohibit bilateral cooperation in many areas. However, in working with like-minded nations with shared values, the U.S. can promote multilateral collaboration and cooperation opportunities for AI. Such engagements should not exclude China by design. However, the criteria for engagement must clarify that the values shared by democratic nations will help address the ethical concerns over AI and the adoption of technical standards. The current political environment and U.S. actions taken against universities and companies with ties to the PLA leave very little room for military-to-military (mil-to-mil) collaboration on AI, nor did research for this paper discover any indications from Chinese sources of a desire for mil-to-mil engagements. Nevertheless, in focusing on our allies and promoting interoperability, the Department of Defense (DoD) entities must remain aware that collaboration opportunities might arise in various areas of responsibility (AOR) and prepare appropriate guidance and safeguards for units based on current policies.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › US Winning/Can’t Lose

US leading AI now.

NIST 22 (National Institute of Standards and Technology, agency of the United States Department of Commerce, April 5, 2022, https://www.nist.gov/artificial-intelligence/ai-standards-federal-engagement)

Federal agencies engaged in developing standards for artificial intelligence (AI) either because these activities are part of their assigned responsibilities or because AI is essential to their current or evolving missions. Executive Order (EO) 13859 directed agencies to ensure that "technical standards minimize vulnerability to attacks from malicious actors and reflect federal priorities for innovation, public trust, and public confidence in systems that use AI technologies" and to "develop international standards to promote and protect those priorities." NIST involved stakeholders from the private and public sectors in developing the U.S. Leadership in AI: A Plan for Federal Engagement in Developing Technical Standards and Related Tool, which was released in August 2019. The Plan provided guidance regarding priorities and appropriate levels of engagement in AI-standards-related matters. It also recommended that the "Federal Government should commit to deeper, consistent, long-term engagement in AI standards development activities to help the United States to speed the pace of reliable, robust, and trustworthy AI technology development." Since then, agencies which develop or use AI have made progress in bolstering AI standards-related knowledge, leadership, and coordination; promoted focused research on the trustworthiness of AI systems; supported and expanded public-private partnerships; and engaged internationally. Notable steps by agencies include: Established the role of Federal AI Standards Coordinator with responsibility to gather and share AI standards-related needs, strategics, roadmaps, terminology, use cases, and best practices in support of reliable, robust, and trustworthy AI in government operations. This responsibility resides with NIST. Created the AI Standards Coordination Working Group (AISCWG) to facilitate agency activities related to development and use of AI standards. Working under the charter of the Interagency Committee on Standards Policy (ICSP), and aligning its activities with the Federal AI Standards Coordinator, the AISCWG is responsible for promoting effective and consistent federal policies leveraging AI standards cited in the AI Standards Plan Multiple agencies are reviewing options to better position the Federal Government to gain access to new employees and to develop current employees to meet rapidly growing AI-capable workforce needs. That includes aiming to develop and provide a clear career development and promotion path that values and encourages participation in and expertise in AI standards and standards development. The National Defense Authorization Action of 2021 (NDAA) explicitly authorized NIST to carry out a wide range of AI standards-related functions. Over the past two years, NIST has expanded and made noteworthy progress in carrying out research that specifically addresses standards-oriented research recommendations in the AI Standards Plan. The National Science Foundation (NSF) is supporting several grant programs related to AI trustworthiness. Among them is the National AI Research Institutes program, which includes a growing number of partnerships with federal agencies and private companies. Strategic engagement in international AI standards was the focus of the U.S. Department of State's submission to Congress of "A Plan to Establish Exchanges and Partnerships between the United States and Its Allies to Create Standards for Artificial Intelligence Technologies." The US championed development of the first international principles for the responsible use of AI at the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). Also, the US became a founding member of the Global Partnership on AI (GPAI). Through engagement in GPAI, the United States seeks to complement the more policy-oriented work of the OECD by increasing coordination on research and development and scaling up practical projects for implementing trustworthy AI.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Competition Advantage Answers › US Winning/Can’t Lose

US winning – China’s authoritarian ascendence will cause its downfall – the US will outcompete

Kroenig 20 (Matthew Kroenig is a professor of government and foreign service at Georgetown University, and the deputy director of the Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security at the Atlantic Council, “Why the U.S. Will Outcompete China,” The Atlantic, 4/3/2020, MP

National-security analysts see China as one of the greatest threats facing the United States and its allies. According to an emerging conventional wisdom, China has the leg up on the U.S. in part because its authoritarian government can strategically plan for the long term, unencumbered by competing branches of government, regular elections, and public opinion. Yet this faith in autocratic ascendance and democratic decline is contrary to historical fact. China may be able to put forth big, bold plans—the kinds of projects that analysts think of as long term—but the visionary projects of autocrats don’t usually pan out. Yes, democratic governments are obligated to answer to their citizens on regular intervals and are sensitive to public opinion—that’s actually democracies’ greatest source of strength. Democratic leaders have a harder time advancing big, bold agendas, but the upside of that difficulty is that the plans that do make it through the system have been carefully considered and enjoy domestic support. Historically speaking, once a democracy comes up with a successful strategy, it sticks with the plan, even through a succession of leadership. Washington has arguably followed the same basic, three-step geopolitical plan since 1945. First, the the current, rules-based international system by providing security in important geopolitical regions, constructing international institutions, and promoting free markets and democratic politics within its sphere of influence. Second, it welcomed into the club any country that played by the rules, even former adversaries, like Germany and Japan. And, third, the U.S. worked with its allies to defend the system from those countries or groups that would challenge it, including competitors such as Russia and China, rogue states such as Iran and North Korea, and terrorist networks. America can pursue long-term strategy in part because it enjoys domestic political stability. While new politicians seek to improve on their predecessor’s policies, the United States is unlikely to see the drastic shifts in strategy that come from the fall of one political system and the rise of another. Democratic elections may be messy, but they’re not as messy as coups or civil wars. Open societies have many other advantages as well. They facilitate innovation, trust in financial markets, and economic growth. Because democracies tend to be more reliable partners, they are typically skillful alliance builders, and they can accumulate resources without frightening their neighbors. They tend to make thoughtful, informed decisions on matters of war and peace, and to focus their security forces on external enemies, not their own populations. Autocratic systems simply cannot match this impressive array of economic, diplomatic, and military attributes. David Leonhardt in The New York Times, “Chinese leaders stretching back to Deng Xiaoping have often thought in terms of decades.” Commonly cited examples of that long-term thinking include the Belt and Road Initiative, a program that invests in infrastructure overseas; Made in China 2025, an effort to subsidize China’s giant tech companies to become world leaders in 21st-century technologies, such as artificial intelligence; and Beijing’s promise to be a global superpower by 2049. Since putting in place sound economic reforms in the 1970s, China has seen its economy expand at eye-popping rates, to become the world’s second largest. Many that China could even surpass the United States within the decade, and that China’s model of state-led capitalism will prove more successful, in terms of economic growth, than the U.S. template of free markets and open politics. I doubt these predictions. Because autocratic leaders are unconstrained and do not have to contend with a legislature or courts, they have an easier time taking their countries in new and radically different directions. Then, when the dictator changes his mind, he can do it again. Mao’s autocratic China ricocheted from one failed policy to another: the Great Leap Forward, then the Hundred Flowers Campaign, then the Cultural Revolution. Mao only to nearly with Moscow in the next decade. Beginning in the time of Deng Xiaoping, China pursued a fairly constant strategy of liberalizing its economy at home and abroad. But President Xi Jinping abandoned these dictums when he took over. As the most powerful leader since Mao—he has changed China’s constitution to set himself up as dictator for life—he could once again jerk China in several new directions, according to his whims, and back again. , he has stalled or reversed course on eight of 10 categories of economic reform promised by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) itself. Moreover, Xi is baring China’s teeth militarily, from neighbors in the South China Sea and with Russia in Europe. The problem for Beijing is that stalled reforms will stymie its economic potential and its confrontational policies are provoking an international coalition to contain them. The declared great-power competition with China the foremost security threat to the U.S.; the European Union labeled China a “systemic rival”; and Japan, Australia, India, and the United States have formed a new “quad” of powers to balance China in the Pacific. Furthermore, the plans often cited as evidence of China’s farsighted vision, the Belt and Road Initiative and Made in China 2025, were announced by Xi only in 2013 and 2015, respectively. Both are way too recent to be celebrated as brilliant examples of successful, long-term strategic planning. A certain level of domestic political stability is a prerequisite for charting a steady strategic course in foreign and domestic affairs. But autocratic regimes are notoriously brittle. While institutionalized political successions in democracies typically lead to changes of policy, political successions in autocracies are likely to result in regime collapse and war. China’s “5,000” were pockmarked by rebellion, revolution, and new dynasties. Fearing internal threats to domestic political stability—consider the and Xinjiang—the CCP than on its national defense. If you follow the money, the CCP is demonstrating that the government is more afraid of its own people than of the Pentagon. This domestic fragility will frustrate China’s efforts to design and execute farsighted plans. If threats to Chinese domestic stability were to materialize and the CCP were to collapse tomorrow, for example, Chinese grand strategy could undergo another seismic shift, including possibly opting out of competition with the United States altogether. Autocracies have other vulnerabilities as well. State-led planning has never produced high rates of economic growth over the long term. Autocrats are poor alliance builders who fight with their supposed allies more than with their enemies. And the highest priority of autocratic security forces is repressing their own people, not defending the country. The world has undergone drastic changes in just the past few years, but these enduring patterns of international affairs have not. Some fear that Trump’s nationalist tendencies will erode the U.S. position, but the momentum of America’s successful grand strategy has kept the country on a fairly steady course. Despite Trump’s criticism of NATO, for example, two new countries have joined the alliance on his watch, including . The coronavirus has upended a sense of security in the U.S., leading many people into the familiar trap of in contrast to the halting and patchwork measures in the United States. But there is good reason to believe that this assessment will be updated in America’s favor with the benefit of hindsight. Already we are seeing evidence that conditions are much worse in China than CCP officials are letting on and that China’s attempts at international “disaster diplomacy” are backfiring. It has been revealed that the CCP has continually the numbers of COVID-19 infections and in China, and European nations have and returned faulty Chinese coronavirus testing kits. The great political theorist Niccolò Machiavelli considered a similar line of thinking in the 16th century, about whether republics or dictators charted a more stable course. He wrote, “I, therefore, disagree with the common opinion that a populace in power is unstable [and] changeable … The prince … unchecked by laws, will be more … unstable, and imprudent than a populace.” The U.S. political system certainly has problems. But democracy is the best machine ever invented for generating enormous power, wealth, and prestige on the international stage.

2022 CNDI Negative
AI Projects Neg › Inherency Answers › SQ Solves

US and NATO tech already counters malicious AI

Sanur Sharma May 30, 2022 [ Associate Fellow at Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses.; NATO’s AI Push And Military Implications – Analysis; EurasiaReview]

The technological advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI), machine learning, big data analytics, robotics, quantum computing and virtual reality have led to the rise in use of autonomous systems in military applications. This is changing the face of the battlefield by enabling new forms of military functions, over and above the conventional systems, thus enabling the execution of higher coercive actions. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) countries are also adopting such emerging technologies to maintain their strategic advantage and to mitigate transnational threats. Russia’s offensive cyber hostilities and China’s military adoption of AI for augmenting its high-tech warfare mechanisms have emerged as the contributing factors for NATO to upscale its technological efforts in Emerging and Disruptive Technologies (EDTs). NATO is making ambitious investments in EDTs to ensure interoperability and standardisation among member states. This Issue Brief takes stock of the current strategic surge by NATO in AI adoption and its ongoing efforts to exploit EDTs for defence innovation and adoption. It discusses the role of AI in contemporary conflicts, specifically NATO’s response to the Russia–Ukraine conflict, and explores the vulnerabilities in the AI systems as well as the challenges and limitations in AI adoption by NATO. The US National Security Commission Report of 2021 states that China is leapfrogging to new technologies by investing in intelligentised warfare like swarm drones and using AI for reconnaissance, electromagnetic countermeasures and coordinated firepower strikes.1 The US is jointly working with its allies on the policy implications of such new technology. It is also partnering with countries like Canada, Denmark, Estonia, the UK, France and Norway, to work on military standards on AI.2 In October 2021, NATO formally adopted the first AI strategy on the responsible military use of AI with three core tasks: collective defence, crisis management and cooperative security.3 NATO’s strategy aims to accelerate the uptake of AI for military systems.4 The six principles of the NATO’s AI strategy include: Lawfulness, Responsibility and Accountability, Explainability and Traceability, Reliability, Governability and Bias Mitigation.5 This strategy aims to protect, monitor and innovate AI and related disruptive technologies in a phased manner to establish political support for AI military projects. The strategic surge in EDTs is driven by the accelerated investment towards the military adoption and innovation of EDTs and maintaining a sustainable innovation ecosystem that can be achieved through civil–military collaboration. In 2021, NATO endorsed the strategy on EDTs that included AI and machine learning among the seven identified key technologies (Data, AI, Autonomy, Quantum, Space, Biotechnology, and Hypersonic).6 The strategy plans to invest US$ 1 billion in building test centres across Europe and North America, focusing on emerging technologies like AI, Quantum and hypersonics.7 In the NATO Summit held at Brussels in 2021, as a part of the NATO 2030 Agenda, NATO’s new Defence Innovation Accelerator for the North Atlantic (DIANA) was launched. It aims to maintain NATO’s technological edge compared to nations like China and Russia, which are challenging the West with their accelerated investments to build technological capacity and use offensive subversive measures. DIANA has been assigned to manage the NATO Innovation Fund, receiving a funding of US$ 82.6 million a year for 15 years.8 It will explore the future roadmap of implementation of advanced technologies and competition to foster transatlantic cooperation.9 At present, there are 10 accelerator sites with more than 50 test centres in technological hubs across the states.10 The NATO advisory group on EDTs is an external body that advises NATO on the optimisation of its innovation efforts. This group provides recommendations on improving collaboration and partnerships with the private sector, industry, and academia. In addition, there are other bodies like the NATO Advisory board, Allied Command Transformation (ACT), NATO’s Science and Technology Organisation (STO), and NATO Communication and Information Agency (NCIA) that support the alliance’s adoption of deep technologies and EDTs. AI has been a contributing agent in weaponising cyberspace and augmenting cyberwarfare to the next level in modern battlefield scenarios. While some of its uses such as in scaling of data analytics, data fusion, deep fakes, cyber defence have matured, its use in autonomous weapon systems and other complex operational applications are at a nascent stage. AI has been aggressively used to spread disinformation in the Russia–Ukraine War. Machine learning algorithms have been used to amplify misleading and fake content on social media platforms, like doctored videos of invading forces and fake live streams. On the other hand, it has also been used for anomaly detection, identification of disinformation and for cybersecurity. AI uses natural language processing algorithms, machine learning and deep learning to identify anomalies in the text data, images and videos. Russia is said to have used AI-enabled systems not only on the battlefield but also in cyberspace, targeting the critical infrastructures of Ukraine.11 Russian troll farms have been alleged to have used AI-enabled systems to generate human faces for fake propagandist personas on social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram and Facebook.12 NATO countries have also used AI to help Ukraine counter such AI-based attacks. Private companies are also playing a role in the unfolding AI battlespace. US-based companies like Snorkel AI, a data science platform, has made its services accessible to federal authorities for the detection of anomalous signals and adversary communications in order to access high-value information for better decision-making.13 Similarly, Ukraine has been given free access to Clearview AI facial recognition software, which has a database of 2 billion photos crawled from Russian social media platforms. This software is being used for the detection of Russian forces and to identify the dead and gauge the spread of disinformation in cyberspace.14 AI’s analytical potential has been tapped by companies even before the Russia–Ukraine war started. In December 2021, a geospatial data firm, SpaceKnow, claimed to have detected a military presence in Yelna, a Russian town. The Russia–Ukraine conflict has become a test case for AI adoption in modern warfare. The US is using the conflict as a test-bed for many of its AI projects with the Pentagon’s ‘Maven’ project having contributed to the detection and classification of objects of interest from various drone footage through AI and Machine Learning (ML) algorithms. It has been reported that the Pentagon has been using AI and ML tools to collect a vast amount of data on the Russia–Ukraine war and analyse it to learn and generate battlefield intelligence about the Russian command and control strategies.15 The advanced AI-enabled systems with the US Department of Defense (DoD) are said to have been used for overseeing the battlefield and collecting and archiving signals intelligence. It was stated at the Defense One’s Genius AI Summit in April 2022 that all this information will be fed into systems for training of machine learning algorithms to support future decision-making processes.16 It is believed that the US and NATO allies have already built such AI-enabled cyber weapons and defences, information about which is said to be highly classified.17 The US DoD and its allies have taken advantage of these advanced tools to gather critical information from the publically available image data to thwart Russian attacks in Ukraine. This war data will also help NATO allies anticipate adversary attacks, their behaviour, and the use of advanced technologies in the real world by countries like China and Russia. This intelligence will also augment multifactor analysis and modelling changes dynamically by integrating different technological platforms. Due to the sanctions imposed on Russia as a result of the Russia–Ukraine war, its AI development is expected to slow down. The ongoing conflict highlights the constraints around the use of AI. Despite AI-enabled cyber-attacks and misinformation campaign by Russia, Ukraine has mounted effective counter-cyber operations.18 Russia’s limited use of AI in the conflict can be explained through the existing vulnerabilities in the AI systems that can be exploited in many ways. One hypothesis for Russia’s limited use of AI could be the trust in such systems where it is a matter of lives and military objectives at stake.19 The vulnerabilities in the AI systems can include data poisoning and input attacks, attacking the supply pipelines by simply crafting data and feeding it to public resources, white-box and black-box attacks.20 There is always a chance of orchestrated and conflicting data in the face of AI models to derail them and to exploit the vulnerabilities in the algorithms, and active manipulation by the adversaries can be induced. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) has launched a Guaranteeing AI Robustness against Deception (GARD) programme. Under this programme, development efforts are being made to establish a theoretical foundation for defensible ML and the creation and testing of such systems.21 The Army Research Laboratory (ARL) is working with the Internet of Battlefield Things Collaborative Research Alliance (IoBT-CRA) to explore the use of ML and intelligent technology on the battlefield and strengthen the collaboration between autonomous actors and human soldiers in combat. They are also working on methods to understand the challenges of AI-enabled systems employed on the battlefield and to make them less susceptible to attacks.22 AI technology in modern warfare will be an intractable weapon in future conflicts beyond Ukraine. Countries trying to achieve a technological edge over others have started considerable investments in AI technology to strengthen their militaries. NATO has invested US$ 1 billion to develop new AI defence technologies. The US DoD has also planned to invest US$ 874 million in AI-related technologies as a part of their army research and development budget (federal fiscal year 2022 DoD budget).23 The UK DoD is funding suppliers to work with Defence Science & Technology Lab (Dstl) on AI projects which were £7million for the year 2021/22 and is supposed to increase to £29 million in the next year.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Depth/Breadth/Limits

Limits destroy creative thinking – innovation results from breaking rules and challenging dominate modes of thought.

Clark 07

[(Brian, CEO and founder of Coppyblogger Media) “Do You Recognize These 10 Mental Blocks to Creative Thinking?”, Coppyblogger, 9/18/07]

Whether you’re trying to solve a tough problem, start a business, get attention for that business or write an interesting article, creative thinking is crucial. The process boils down to changing your perspective and seeing things differently than you currently do. People like to call this “thinking outside of the box,” which is the wrong way to look at it. Just like Neo needed to understand that “” in the film The Matrix, you need to realize “there is no box” to step outside of. You create your own imaginary boxes simply by living life and accepting certain things as “real” when they are just as illusory as the beliefs of a paranoid delusional. The difference is, enough people agree that certain man-made concepts are “real,” so you’re viewed as “normal.” This is good for society overall, but it’s that sort of unquestioning consensus that inhibits your natural creative abilities. So, rather than looking for ways to inspire creativity, you should just realize the truth. You’re already capable of creative thinking at all times, but you have to strip away the imaginary mental blocks (or boxes) that you’ve picked up along the way to wherever you are today. I like to keep this list of 10 common ways we suppress our natural creative abilities nearby when I get stuck. It helps me realize that the barriers to a good idea are truly all in my head. 1. Trying to Find the “Right” Answer One of the worst aspects of formal education is the focus on the correct answer to a particular question or problem. While this approach helps us function in society, it hurts creative thinking because real-life issues are ambiguous. There’s often more than one “correct” answer, and the second one you come up with might be better than the first. Many of the following mental blocks can be turned around to reveal ways to find more than one answer to any given problem. Try reframing the issue in several different ways in order to prompt different answers, and embrace answering inherently ambiguous questions in several different ways. 2. Logical Thinking Not only is real life ambiguous, it’s often illogical to the point of madness. While critical thinking skills based on logic are one of our main strengths in evaluating the feasibility of a creative idea, it’s often the enemy of truly innovative thoughts in the first place. One of the best ways to escape the constraints of your own logical mind is to think . One of the reasons why metaphors work so well in communications is that we accept them as true without thinking about it. When you realize that “truth” is often symbolic, you’ll often find that you are actually free to come up with alternatives. 3. Following Rules One way to view creative thinking is to look at it as a destructive force. You’re tearing away the often arbitrary rules that others have set for you, and asking either “why” or “why not” whenever confronted with the way “everyone” does things. This is easier said than done, since people will often defend the rules they follow even in the face of evidence that the rule doesn’t work. People love to celebrate rebels like Richard Branson, but few seem brave enough to emulate him. Quit worshipping rule breakers and start breaking some rules. 4. Being Practical Like logic, practicality is hugely important when it comes to execution, but often stifles innovative ideas before they can properly blossom. Don’t allow into the same room with your inner artist. Try not to evaluate the actual feasibility of an approach until you’ve allowed it to exist on its own for a bit. Spend time asking “what if” as often as possible, and simply allow your imagination to go where it wants. You might just find yourself discovering a crazy idea that’s so insanely practical that no one’s thought of it before. 5. Play is Not Work Allowing your mind to be at play is perhaps the most effective way to stimulate creative thinking, and yet many people disassociate play from work. These days, the people who can come up with great ideas and solutions are the most economically rewarded, while worker bees are often employed for the benefit of the creative thinkers. You’ve heard the expression “work hard and play hard.” All you have to realize is that they’re the same thing to a creative thinker. 6. That’s Not My Job In an era of hyper-specialization, it’s those who happily explore completely unrelated areas of life and knowledge who best see that everything is related. This goes back to what ad man said about creative persons—they want to be know-it-alls. Sure, you’ve got to know the specialized stuff in your field, but if you view yourself as an explorer rather than a highly-specialized cog in the machine, you’ll run circles around the technical master in the success department. 7. Being a “Serious” Person Most of what keeps us civilized boils down to conformity, consistency, shared values, and yes, thinking about things the same way everyone else does. There’s nothing wrong with that necessarily, but if you can mentally accept that it’s actually nothing more than groupthink that helps a society function, you can then give yourself permission to turn everything that’s accepted upside down and shake out the illusions. Leaders from Egyptian pharaohs to Chinese emperors and European royalty have consulted with fools, or court jesters, when faced with tough problems. The persona of the fool allowed the truth to be told, without the usual ramifications that might come with speaking blasphemy or challenging ingrained social conventions. Give yourself permission to be a fool and see things for what they really are. 8. Avoiding Ambiguity We rationally realize that most every situation is ambiguous to some degree. And although dividing complex situations into black and white boxes can lead to disaster, we still do it. It’s an innate characteristic of human psychology to desire certainty, but it’s the creative thinker who rejects the false comfort of clarity when it’s not really appropriate. Ambiguity is your friend if you’re looking to innovate. The fact that most people are uncomfortable exploring uncertainty gives you an advantage, as long as you can embrace ambiguity rather than run from it.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Depth/Breadth/Limits

Limits are k2 clash and in depth discussion.

Hardy 10

(Aaron T. Hardy, Coach at Whitman College, “CONDITIONALITY, CHEATING COUNTERPLANS, AND CRITIQUES: TOPIC CONSTRUCTION AND THE RISE OF THE “NEGATIVE CASE””, Contemporary Argumentation & Debate, 2010, pg. 44-45, )

First, narrow topics are more likely to encourage substantive clash. One of the primary motivations for negative teams running away from engagement with the specifics of the affirmative is fear of “falling behind” in the necessary research effort. On a topic with 200 topical affirmative plan mechanisms, it is extremely unlikely that all but the most precocious of negative teams will be prepared to debate each one, and much more likely that they will turn instead to as generic of an approach as possible. Despite sentiments from some corners that the topic writing process is already too narrow and specialized, I would submit that the debate community has not yet truly experimented with what a radically narrower topic might entail. Even the smallest topics in recent memory have afforded the affirmative an incredible amount of flexibility, usually as a compromise to the “broad topics good” camp. A quick perusal of any of the archived case lists from the past decade reveals that even the narrowest topics the community has debated have entailed dozens (if not hundreds) of discrete affirmatives. Instead, envision as a potentially hyperbolic example, a topic with truly only to prepare a truly in-depth take on each one. Chosen in concert with the right literature base, perhaps the word “stale” could be replaced with “nuanced,” even if debates superficially resemble each other as the year progresses.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Depth/Breadth/Limits

Depth outweighs breadth.

Tai et al ‘8

Tai et al 08 [(Robert) Curriculum, Instruction, and Special Education Department, Curry School of Education) “Depth Versus Breadth: How Content Coverage in High School Science Courses Relates to Later Success in College Science Course work” 2008]

The baseline model reveals a direct and compelling outcome: teaching for depth is associated with improvements in later performance. Of course, there is much to consider in evaluating the implications of such an analysis. There are a number of questions about this simple conclusion that naturally emerge. For example, ho w much depth works best? What is the optimal manner to operationalize the impact of depth-based learning? Do specific contexts (such as type of student, teacher, or school) moderate the impact of depth? The answers to these questions certainly suggest that a more nuanced view should be sought. Nonetheless, this analysis appears to indicate that a robust positive association exists between high school science teaching that pro v ides depth in at least one topic and better performances in introductory postsecondary science courses. Our results also clearly suggest that breadth-based learning, as commonly applied in high school classrooms, does not appear to offer students any advantage when they enroll in introductory college science courses, although it may contribute to higher scores on standardized tests. However, the intuitive appeal of broadly surveying a discipline in an introductory high school course cannot be overlooked. There might be benefits to such a pedagogy that become apparent when using measures that we did not explore. The results regarding breadth were less compelling because in only one of the three disciplines were the results significant in our full model. On the other hand, we observed no positive effects at all. As it stands, our findings at least suggest that aiming for breadth in content coverage should be avoided, as we found no evidence to support such an approach.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Reasonability/Competing Interps

Reasonability collapses into competing interpretations, if we win our interp creates a better topic than theirs should be considered unreasonable.

Mancuso ‘82

(Steve Manusco, Debater for University of Kentucky, Wake Forest University, 1982, Topicality: In Search of Reason. The Debaters’ Research Guide, groups.wfu.edu/debate)

In recognition of the many possible definitions of a word, the debate community has adopted (original mother and father unknown) the convention that the affirmative definition only needs to be "reasonable." This burden traditionally stands opposed to the notion that the affirmative must have the best definition of a word, or even necessarily a better definition than the negative. While the initial theoretical underpinnings for such a convention are far from clear, it must certainly he justified on the grounds that it promotes the objective of quality debating. Such a convention recognizes that a definition is not right or wrong, but merely acceptable or unacceptable in a given situation. In situations where broad interpretations of a topic are desirable, a broader-than usual definition may be reasonable, and where a narrow interpretation is desirable, narrow definitions may be reasonable. Such a simplified view of reasonability is not justified in the face of the recent uses and abuses of such a convention. The relevant question is: What does it mean to be reasonable? Again, courts and legislators may have their own definitions of "reasonable," but they may not be at all useful for the functioning of the term in debate. To state that a court has been unable to define the word "reasonable" only means that in that particular context it was difficult, not that such a finding should be accepted as proof that we cannot come up with a workable concept of reasonability for our purposes. Of course, someone who has listened to a few debates concerning "reasonability" may find great sympathy with such a court the concept has taken on very diverse forms, to say the least, in its varied uses. On one extreme, teams have argued that as long as they were not "absurd" in defining their terms, they were reasonable, and some teams have argued that because their definition exists they are some how reasonable. On the other end of the definitional continuum, some interpretations of reasonability have been very restrictive. Some teams have argued that only the best definition is reasonable--that it shows little reason to accept an inferior definition. Clearly there has been quite a bit of disagreement as to what is entailed by a "reasonable" definition. Some debate critics have responded to this dispute by throwing up their arms and calling for the abandonment of the concept of reasonability as a topicality convention altogether. While it is very easy to respect and have empathy with such sentiment, it seems prudent to attempt a less radical solution by constructing a more useful and practical convention of reasonability without ""piffing" the concept in its entirety. I would suggest two steps in construction of a workable reasonability convention. First, we must agree upon what makes a definition acceptable. Keeping in mind the goal of high quality debating, two criteria necessary for an acceptable definition should be (1) Does it tend toward focusing debates on timely and relevant policy advocacy? and (2) does it allow the negative sufficient ability to be prepared in both analysis and research? A definition which failed to meet either of these goals would not seem to he an acceptable approach to interpretation. Secondly, the actual debate over topicality should center on the question of whether or not the affirmative interpretation actually did meet both of these criteria. In this sense, the "threshold" for when a definition became "reasonable" would be raised well above the currently less rigorous approaches, yet not overly restrict the affirmative initial and presumptive right to define its terms. The burden would be on the affirmative to explain, wren challenged, the implications of its definition, thus reviving the concept of an affirmative burden on topicality, without making the burden prohibitively heavy by making them refute any conceivable negative alternative definition. In an effort to supplement the convention of "reasonability," "standards" of definition have been offered which the affirmative should meet in order to be considered reasonable. These standards could potentially be used to discern whether or not the affirmative approach met the above two criteria.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Switching Sides Good

Switch Side Debate builds critical thinking skills which are key to foster democratic values and prevent extinction.

Harrigan 08 [(Casey, Master of Arts in the Department of Communications at Wake Forest University) “A Defense of Switch Side Debate”, 2008, ]

While such pragmatic justifications for SSD are persuasive, they are admittedly secondary to the greater consideration of pedagogy. Although it is certainly true that debate is a game and that its competitive elements are indispensable sources of motivation for students who are otherwise apathetic about academic endeavors, the overwhelming benefits of contest debating are the knowledge and skills taught through participation. The wins and losses (and marginally-cheesy trophies), by and large, are quickly forgotten with the passage of time. However, the educational values of debate are so fundamental that they eventually become ingrained in the decision-making and thought processes of debaters, giving them a uniquely valuable durability. To this end, SSD is essential. The benef its of debating both sides have been noted by many authors over the past fifty years. To name but a few, SSD has been lauded for fostering tolerance and undermining bigotry and dogmatism (M uir, 1993), creating stronger and more knowledgeable advocates (Dybvig and Iversion, 2000) , and fortifying the social forces of democracy by guaranteeing the expression of minority viewpoints (Day, 1966). Switching sides is a crucial element of debate’s pedagogical benefit; it forms the gears that drive debate’s intellectual motor. Additionally, there are social benefits to the practice of requiring students to debate both sides of controversial issues. Dating back to th e Greek rhetorical tradition, great value has been placed on the benefit of testing each argument relative to all others in the marketplace of ideas. Like those who argue on behalf of the efficiency-maximizing benefits of free market competition, it is believed that arguments are most rigorously tested (and conceivably refined and improved) when compared to all available alternatives. Even for beliefs that have seem ingly been ingrained in consensus opinion or 7 in cases where the public at-large is unlikely to accept a particular position, it has been argued that they should remain open for public discussion and deliberation (Mill, 1975). Along these lines, the greatest benefit of switching sides, which goes to the heart of contemporary debate, is its inducement of critical thinking. Defined as “reasonable reflective thinking that is focused on decidi ng what to believe or do” (Ennis, 1987, p. 10), critical thinking learned through debate teaches students not just how to advocate and argue, but how to decide as well. Each and every student, whether in debate or (more likely) at some later point in life, will be placed in the position of the decision-maker. Faced with competing options whose costs and benefits are initially unclear, critical thinking is necessary to assess all the possible outcomes of each choice, compare their relative merits, and arrive at some final decision about which is preferable. In some instances, such as choosing whether to eat Chinese or Indian food for dinner, the im portance of making the correct decision is minor. For many other de cisions, however, the implications of choosing an imprudent course of action are pot entially grave. As Robert Crawford notes, there are “issues of unsurpassed importance in the daily lives of millions upon millions of people...being decided to a considerable extent by the power of pub lic speaking” (2003). Although the days of the Cold War are over, and the risk that “the next Pearl Harbor could be ‘compounded by hydrogen’” (Ehninger and Brockriede, 1978, p. 3) is greatly reduced, the manipulation of public support before the invasion of Iraq in 2003 points to the continuing necessity of training a well-in formed and critically-aware public (Zarefsky, 2007). In the absence of debate-trained critical thinking, ignorant but ambitious politicians and persuasive but nefarious leaders would be much more likely to draw the country, and possibly the world, in to conflicts with incalculable losses in terms of human 8 well-being. Given the myriad threats of global proportions th at will require incisive solutions, including global warming, the spread of pandemic diseases, and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, cultivating a robust and effective society of critical decision-makers is essential. As Louis Rene Beres writes, “with such learning, we Americans could prepare...not as immobilized objects of false contentment, but as authentic citizens of an endangered planet” (2003 ). Thus, it is not surprising that critical thinking has been called “the highest edu cational goal of the ac tivity” (Parcher, 1998). While arguing from conviction can foster limited critical thinking skills, the element of switching sides is necessary to sharpen debate’s critical edge and ensure that decisions are made in a reasoned manner instead of being driven by ideology. Debaters trained in SSD are more likely to evaluate both sides of an argument before arriving at a conclusion and are less likely to dismiss potential arguments based on his or her prior beliefs (Muir 1993). In addition, debating both sides teaches “conceptual flexibility,” where decision-makers are more likely to refl ect upon the beliefs that are held before coming to a final opinion (Muir, 1993, p. 290) . Exposed to many arguments on each side of an issue, debaters learn that public policy is characteri zed by extraordinary complexity that requires careful consideration before action. Finally, these arguments are confirmed by the preponderance of empirical research demonstrating a link between competitive SSD and critical thinking (Allen, Berkow itz, Hunt and Louden, 1999; Colbert, 2002, p. 82). The theory and practice of SSD has value beyond the limited realm of competitive debate as well. For the practitioners a nd students of rhetoric, understanding how individuals come to form opini ons about subjects and then a ttempt to persuade others is 9 of utmost importance. Although the field of communication has established models that attempt to explain human decision-making, such as the Rational Argumentation Theory and others (Cragen and Shields, 1998, p. 66) , the practice of SSD within competitive debate rounds is a real-world laboratory wh ere argumentative experiments are carried out thousands of times over during the course of a single year-long season. The theory of SSD has profound implications for those who study how individuals are persuaded, as well as how advocates should go about the process of forming their own personal beliefs and attempting to persuade others.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Topic Education

Standard – Clarity

Myshak 2018 Elena. "DEFINITION OF THE TERM “BIOTECHNOLOGY”." Cogito-Multidisciplinary research Journal 4 (2018): 142-149.

As we can see from a small number of examples, the term biotechnology is by no means unambiguous, and the reason lies not only in the difference in the wording and its prevalence, but also in the selection of the relevant features of the concept when creating the definition. In most of the definitions, the definition is based on the use of living organisms or their components for the production of products designed to improve the quality of life of people. Other definitions emphasize that biotechnology is a technology that combines biology and technology that uses biological systems, living organisms or their fragments to develop or create various products. In almost all definitions, the idea of the benefits of biotechnology is expressed, namely: biotechnology is used to obtain useful products for society with the help of biological agents of microorganisms, viruses, animal and plant cells; creating useful products (from drugs to industrial enzymes); to improve plants or animals; to solve engineering and industrial problems, etc. It should be noted that almost all definitions have a different nuclear seme or genus and species trait: science (science); technology; manipulation; techniques; use; area. Such differences in the definition of the key term of the biotechnology sphere confirm the proposition that the definitions of concepts in any science are temporary and, depending on the development of the latter, can be transformed. So, in the presented examples of the definition of one term “biotechnology”, we tried to demonstrate the diversity of definitional variations of the term in its static (vocabulary) manifestation at the initial stage of the formation of terminology, i.e. on the way to the formation of the term system. This fact indicates the dynamic structure of the term, the development of the denotation, the concept and signification. The terminology of biotechnology is not fully formed and needs to be standardized in order to provide the recipient with information about the concept reflected in the definition.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Topicality Impacts › Topic Education

Simulating international agents is key to topic education. Literature consensus shows.

Shellman and Turan 2006 [Stephen M., and Kürşad Turan. "Do simulations enhance student learning? An empirical evaluation of an IR simulation." Journal of Political Science Education 2, no. 1 (2006): 19-32.]

Our simulation includes many international organizations such as the World Bank, the UN Security Council, the Arab League, NATO, the European Union, Amnesty International, etc. Most students are involved in or connected to an inter- 285 national organization in some way or another, whether it is indirectly through a mutual group international organization representative or directly as the Secretary General of NATO. By the end of the simulation we feel and the results infer that students can identify with the problems international organizations address, the processes that govern at least one of the organizations included, and the constraints that 290 are placed on countries’ sovereignty. We find that students also feel that the simulation enhances knowledge of international organizations and their processes. In contrast, the modal value is equal to four for theoretical enhancement. These results convey that while the simulation enhances knowledge in all three areas, it does a better job enhancing the knowledge of concepts and organizations and their 295 processes than IR theories. Perhaps assigning discussion papers and asking more theoretically based questions during the debriefing could bring this number up. Moreover, some of the theories we cover in class have a domestic basis like Fearon’s (1994) audience cost model and Milner’s (1997) domestic institutions and interest groups based theoretical framework. The simulation, at the present time, unfortu- 300 nately lacks proper mechanisms to apply such theories to decisions, processes, and outcomes and to analyze their utility. Thus, the simulation constraints may explain why the modal value for theories is four and not five. That said, overall, we find support that the simulation enhances knowledge of substantive course material. The results fit with Brown and King (2000) who find 305 that students’ knowledge of international relations increases as a result of participating in the International Communications and Negotiations Simulations (ICONS).12 Also relevant are the results from Kumza and Haney (2001). They show that the use of film in a U.S. Foreign Policy summer course to stimulate active learning works. Using self-assessment surveys, Kumza and Haney (2001) show that students’ 310 increase their knowledge of U.S. foreign policy through films, discussions, and written exercises. Our results are consistent with those discussed above in that they support the hypothesis that active learning exercises enhance learning. Both the modal and median values calculated for country=organization enhancement are equal to five. More than 90% of the students stated that the simu- 315 lation enhanced knowledge of their assigned country or organization at a level four or above on the five-point intensity scale. This finding is consistent with Brown and King (2000) who found that participation in ICONS enhanced knowledge of the country assigned and U.S. foreign policy. In a typical introductory international relations course, professors rarely expose students to characteristics of particular 320 countries and or their current foreign policies. Our simulation forces students to research a particular country’s foreign policy or a particular international organization’s rules, history, and structure. In order to actively engage in the exercise, one needs to know what to talk about, who to talk to, and what to offer and not to offer in order to get what one wants. The research assignment can be eye-opening to many 325 students who are unfamiliar with international relations, particular countries, their foreign policies, and their regional affairs. We infer from our data that the simulation enhances students’ knowledge of particular countries and=or organizations. In terms of critical and analytical thinking skills, over 74% reported enhancement levels at four or above for question 6. This supports the hypothesis that our 330 simulation aids in the development of critical and analytical thinking skills. Our simulation compels students to make their own decisions and anticipate and=or react to the consequences. For example, students in the past have created fake Yahoo e-mail accounts using the instructor’s name and have used it to gather information from other groups. Another individual used her friendship with the head terrorist’s 335 roommate to acquire information about the terrorists operations. These are some of the more intelligent and sneaky tactics students innovate and implement during the simulation. The students ultimately create solutions to resolve international problems given constraints placed on their countries and organizations. These are skills that are difficult to teach by reading and lecturing. Rather, we argue that simulation 340 is the best method for teaching such skills, because students are confronted with novel problems and they are forced to experiment with strategies and tactics to accomplish them. Then, they are able to learn from their successes as well as their failures. Our finding is consistent with Leonard and Leonard (1995) who found that business school graduates believed courses involving simulation exercises prepared 345 them better for their future jobs than courses that only used case methods. We want to produce professionals in all fields who can analyze and solve novel problems, and the survey results suggest that our simulation develops these skills.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Its

Its is possessive and requires ownership

Glossary of English Grammar Terms, 2005

(http://www.usingenglish.com/glossary/possessive-pronoun.html)

Mine, yours, his, hers, its, ours, theirs are the possessive pronouns used to substitute a noun and to show possession or ownership. EG. This is your disk and that's mine. (Mine substitutes the word disk and shows that it belongs to me.)

2022 CNDI Topicality
Should › Should – Desirable

“Should” doesn’t require certainty

Black’s Law 79 (Black’s Law Dictionary – Fifth Edition, p. 1237)

Should. The past tense of shall; ordinarily implying duty or obligation; although usually no more than an obligation of propriety or expediency, or a moral obligation, thereby distinguishing it from “ought.” It is not normally synonymous with “may,” and although often interchangeable with the word “would,” it does not ordinarily express certainty as “will” sometimes does. 

2022 CNDI Topicality
Should › Should – Not immediate

Should doesn’t mean immediate

Dictionary.com – Copyright © 2010 – http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/should

should    /ʃʊd/ Show Spelled[shood] Show IPA –auxiliary verb 1. pt. of shall. 2. (used to express condition): Were he to arrive, I should be pleased. 3. must; ought (used to indicate duty, propriety, or expediency): You should not do that. 4. would (used to make a statement less direct or blunt): I should think you would apologize. Use should in a Sentence See images of should Search should on the Web Origin: ME sholde, OE sc ( e ) olde; see shall —Can be confused:  could, should, would (see usage note at this entry ). —Synonyms 3. See must1 . —Usage note Rules similar to those for choosing between shall and will have long been advanced for should and would, but again the rules have had little effect on usage. In most constructions, would is the auxiliary chosen regardless of the person of the subject: If our allies would support the move, we would abandon any claim to sovereignty. You would be surprised at the complexity of the directions. Because the main function of should in modern American English is to express duty, necessity, etc. ( You should get your flu shot before winter comes ), its use for other purposes, as to form a subjunctive, can produce ambiguity, at least initially: I should get my flu shot if I were you. Furthermore, should seems an affectation to many Americans when used in certain constructions quite common in British English: Had I been informed, I should (American would ) have called immediately. I should (American would ) really prefer a different arrangement. As with shall and will, most educated native speakers of American English do not follow the textbook rule in making a choice between should and would. See also shall. Shall –auxiliary verb, present singular 1st person shall, 2nd shall or ( Archaic ) shalt, 3rd shall, present plural shall; past singular 1st person should, 2nd should or ( Archaic ) shouldst or should·est, 3rd should, past plural should; imperative, infinitive, and participles lacking. 1. plan to, intend to, or expect to: I shall go later.

2022 CNDI Topicality
Should › Should – Immediate

“Should” means “must” and requires immediate legal effect

Summers 94 (Justice – Oklahoma Supreme Court, “Kelsey v. Dollarsaver Food Warehouse of Durant”, 1994 OK 123, 11-8, http://www.oscn.net/applications/oscn/DeliverDocument.asp?CiteID=20287#marker3fn13)

¶4 The legal question to be resolved by the court is whether the word "should"13 in the May 18 order connotes futurity or may be deemed a ruling in praesenti.14 The answer to this query is not to be divined from rules of grammar;15 it must be governed by the age-old practice culture of legal professionals and its immemorial language usage. To determine if the omission (from the critical May 18 entry) of the turgid phrase, "and the same hereby is", (1) makes it an in futuro ruling - i.e., an expression of what the judge will or would do at a later stage - or (2) constitutes an in in praesenti resolution of a disputed law issue, the trial judge's intent must be garnered from the four corners of the entire record.16

[CONTINUES – TO FOOTNOTE]

2022 CNDI Topicality
Should › Should – Not mandatory

Desirable or recommended

Words and Phrases 2 (Vol. 39, p. 372-373)

Or. 1952. Where safety regulation for sawmill industry providing that a two by two inch guard rail should be installed at extreme outer edge of walkways adjacent to sorting tables was immediately preceded by other regulations in which word “shall” instead of “should” was used, and word “should” did not appear to be result of inadvertent use in particular regulation, use of word “should” was intended to convey idea that particular precaution involved was desirable and recommended, but not mandatory. ORS 654.005 et seq.----Baldassarre v. West Oregon Lumber Co., 239 P.2d 839, 193 Or. 556.---Labor & Emp. 2857