Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Job Guarantee Links

Policies emphasizing jobs for income inequality trap women in abusive situations because they increase dependence on income from the job.

Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]

Similarly, it is important for policy makers to attend to issues of economic abuse and its associated economic effects when making policy decisions in a number of areas, such as welfare to-work, public housing, credit, debt, divorce, property ownership, bankruptcy, and taxes. Policies governing these areas have significant consequences for DV survivors. They could serve to further trap women in abusive relationships and put them in harm’s way, or provide an avenue toward safety and financial security. For example, policies that consider the joint income of married individuals in the eligibility criteria for services create barriers for married women trying to access services; to remove this barrier, policies should instead consider women’s independent income. Also, current policies relating to personal debt do not consider the possibility that the debt may have been generated through coercion, fraud, or threat of harm. Survivors’ short-term safety and long-term financial well-being would be enhanced by policies that take into account how personal debts were generated and that create avenues for debt forgiveness or restructuring. In sum, to promote the safety and security of DV survivors, it would be advantageous to systematically measure and track these phenomena in order to have empirical data on which to base and evaluate policy decisions. Notes 1 For information

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Job Guarantee Links

The concept of “living wage” relies on the “male breadwinner” model of the family—the argument is NOT that the wage system is patriarchal – it is that evaluating how much money is necessary for a Living Wage requires determining how much a family needs to live on, which Presumes that the wife stays home and turns the wage into food, clothes and housing.

Grover, 2005- Professor at Lancaster University [CHRIS GROVER, Lancaster University, “Living wages and the ‘making work pay’ strategy,” Critical Social Policy Vol. 25(1): 5–27, 2005, http://csp.sagepub.com/content/25/1/5.short]

Second, the idea of need is problematic in living wages because of its close association with the concept of the family wage. This issue is recognized in sections of the living wage movement (Brenner, 2002), but has yet to be overcome. This means that living wages are premised upon an androcentric view of wage structures: that a male breadwinner should be able to earn the majority of income for his spouse and dependent children. This is the case in living wages, because, as we have seen, there is an expectation that there will be a full time worker in households. While there is care in living wage literature not to assign this role to men, it is difficult to see how the assumptions of living wages will break from the male breadwinner model. What this means in practice is that living wages can only meet the needs of workers and their families if they conform to the male breadwinner model. Hence, the difficulties demonstrated in Table 1 with delivering higher than the ‘making work pay’ strategy incomes to lone-mother-headed households. If wages were related as closely to need as it is sometimes portrayed in arguments for living wages, those people with dependent children, those working part time and those in families with only one earner would be paid a higher hourly wage compared to those families without dependent children, those with full time earners and those with multiple earners. In other words, those workers who do not conform to the male breadwinner model have potentially the most to gain financially from living wages, but under current proposals they would actually gain the least.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC – Jobs Guarantee Link

A FJG would reinforce women’s oppression by incorporating them into gendered workplaces, denying them caregiving roles, and maintaining the “work ethic” behind the stigmatization of “Women’s Work”

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

Like UBI, implementing FJG would undermine women’s oppression by providing them with the financial security necessary for escaping exploitative household environments. However, it is unclear that this option is accessible for many women. The caregiving work that many women are expected to perform at home could present substantial barriers that make it harder for women to use a full-time job as an exit option. As many scholars have noted when considering workplace inequality, direct and indirect financial penalties exist when women attempt to combine paid work with caregiving responsibilities.127 A woman-friendly jobs guarantee would need to account for this fact and accommodate women’s life patterns, not just men’s, possibly by basing their workplace design on Nancy Fraser’s description of a universal caregiver model. Instead of making women more like men, this model induces “men to become more like most women are now” by “dismantling the gendered opposition between breadwinning and caregiving” and encouraging men and women to embrace both paid, formal and unpaid, caregiving labor.128 A jobs guarantee like this may undermine exploitation, but a guarantee that resembles New Deal work programs would not. The potential for FJG to undermine exploitation, then, largely depends on the type of jobs guarantee implemented. Unlike UBI, FJG would not necessarily help those facing exploitation in the workplace. Instead, it risks establishing an alternative, state-run sphere where workers are exploited. The potential for FJG merely to duplicate an exploitative work environment depends upon the type of FJG implemented. If the jobs that workers perform does not produce a profit, then no capitalist is extracting “benefits from workers” and thus no structural relations “between social groups” that involve power and inequality are enacted.129 However, it is possible that those who would most benefit from a jobs guarantee—former felons, young workers, poor women, and racial minorities—might replace the exploited workers and the broader White- and male-dominated society might replace the capitalists. Although the latter would not be receiving a profit from the former’s labor, it would receive benefits in forms such as community services and improved infrastructure. These benefits do not present an exact parallel to profit since they presumably would help everyone but they may still constitute a benefit extracted from workers which implies their exploitation. Although a jobs guarantee which enables workers to give back to their communities may provide an escape from exploitation, the logic that underpins FJG may reinforce the work ethic which renders caregiving labor invisible. FJG “asserts that, if individuals bear a moral duty to work, then society and employers bear a reciprocal moral duty to provide good dignified work for all[.]”130 But his assertion assumes that individuals bear a moral duty to work, and most versions of a jobs guarantee assumes this work should occur under within a traditional workplace environment. These assumptions normalize exploitation and ignore the enormous amount of labor that women perform within their homes. Unless the version of FJG implemented rejects these assumptions, the policy may mirror 1990s welfare reform which urged mothers to work outside the home rather than enabling them to care for their families if they so choose. Although many feminists have spent their careers arguing against the assumption that women’s primary role should be as caregivers, women should still retain the right to follow this life path without being exploited. Affirming women’s right not to work in formal, paid employment that follows traditionally masculine life patterns is especially important considering the experiences of women of color, who have been prevented from caregiving for their families. Offering women a job but not the option to stay home without suffering from exploitation would not help many women. A jobs guarantee which accounts for women’s needs, however, may avoid these pitfalls. Still, FJG risks reinforcing the work ethic which legitimizes exploitation and has rendered women’s caregiving labor invisible. This reinforcement would perpetuate the stigmatization of women, erase their contributions, and thereby make it difficult to point out the exploitation they face. Therefore, FJG risks reinforcing the causes of women’s exploitation and would do a poor job at undermining it .

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --K Turns Solvency - UBI

Our framework is key – prioritizing implementation concerns over our values distorts the discussion

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]

It might be objected that the level of basic income has more to do with practical feasibility than why the proposal should be supported. The objection always raised when basic income or stakeholding is mentioned is that both schemes would cost far too much, but political imagination is required here.5 Besides, before turning to problems of implementation and cost we need to know why a basic income or stakeholding should be introduced at all, and what level of income or grant is entailed, given those reasons. If interest in a basic income is, say, as a means to relieve poverty—a goal that I certainly share—then the level of income will differ from the level required when a basic income is advocated as part of a wider strategy for democratization. Van Parijs remarks that the fight for a basic income “is no game for purists.” But if we are going to be “tinkerers and opportunists”6 in attempts to get a basic income squarely on the political agenda, we need to understand what we are being opportunistic about, including wider goals and the level of the income. What is it that we shall be sacrificing if, as no doubt will be the case, compromises are necessary in practice? Perhaps my notion of a level of basic income sufficient for a modest but decent standard of life makes me a “purist,” but this is necessary to appreciate the differences between arguing for basic income as an element in a democratic social transformation or advocating it as a means of improving existing systems of income support. The latter is no doubt more politically feasible, but a great deal of democratic value in the idea of a basic income is lost if immediate political feasibility dominates the academic discussion.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --K Turns Solvency - UBI

A standard UBI would not address gender-based hardships— a UBI must be tailored to women’s needs for it to promote gender equality.

Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]

Feminists have also expressed doubt about how far UBI truly challenges ongoing gender- and race-based inequalities in unpaid care and paid employment. They have cautioned that, rather than shifting gender norms on care, UBI in higher income contexts and heterosexual partnerships may mean that women cut back on paid work while men continue in full-time employment and receive additional income on top. UBI would therefore be little more than a “housewives wage”, reinforcing gender inequalities. The impacts of this potential reshuffling of household labor on migrant domestic workers remains unknown. Given the enormous fiscal implications, most UBI schemes will likely not be generous enough to cover basic living costs, meaning that recipients will require additional sources of income, particularly from paid work. In this regard, UBI cannot make up for lack of fulfillment of worker’s rights or access to decent work, especially for women and transgender and gender-diverse people experiencing multiple and intersecting inequalities in access to employment. Trade unionists have rightly warned that UBI does not solve issues of low pay, precarious work or lack of negotiating power in the workplace and could potentially detract from the need to tackle exploitative labour conditions and strengthen workers’ rights, including through living wages, universal job guarantees, affirmative action, unionization and collective bargaining. In this case, UBI would merely act as a band aid for a broken economic system and divert attention from more radical, transformative change needed to address structural inequalities. Finally, UBI raises important questions around who is included in a purportedly ‘universal’ scheme. For example, if receipt were attached to narrow notions of citizenship, incarcerated or formerly-incarcerated persons (a group often including disproportionately high numbers of people of colour and people living in poverty), migrants and their children (particularly those who are undocumented), unhoused people and those without government-issued IDs that reflect their identity (including many transgender and intersex individuals) might all experience exclusionary treatment. Box 2 further discusses the extent to which UBI could address structural inequalities. The design features necessary for a feminist universal basic income Debates remain largely hypothetical given that there are so few full-fledged UBI schemes, and because where they do exist they are usually not evaluated for gender impacts. It is clear that the extent to which UBI’s potential for reducing gender and other inequalities will be realized depends critically on its specific design features, including the level of benefit provided, its financing mechanism and its interaction with existing tax and social security systems. Without parallel investments in quality public services and strengthened support for workers’ rights, UBI could have detrimental effects for gender equality and social justice. However, well-designed UBI that is integrated into a comprehensive system of social protection, public services and labour market regulations could strengthen women’s and transgender and gender diverse people’s income security, lower poverty rates and go some way to redressing inequalities in wealth and income.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Basic Income Links

Tax and Transfer policies reinforce the patriarchy because they re-entrench the male, white bread winner model

Lu, 2021 - professor of Law at NYU [Lynn “From Stigma to Dignity? Transforming Workfare with Universal Basic Income and a Federal Job Guarantee,” UP]

At the same time, national tax and spending policies have consistently— both in intent and impact—favored the breadwinning-white-male-headed household over that of the unmarried single mother of color. Such incentives encourage patriarchal patterns of economic dependency that exacerbate disparate racial and gender impacts in income inequality, wealth building, and economic mobility. Even if not explicitly supporting disparate treatment by race, sociologists suggest that “perceptions of rising minority power, declines in whites’ relative socioeconomic status, or other perceived macro-level threats to whites’ racial status may provoke adoption of more restrictive welfare regimes.” As a result, cash assistance programs associated with greater uptake by people of color carry the harshest and most punitive or onerous requirements.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Basic Income Links

A minimum income is used by the right wing to prevent changes that may address racism and sexism – empirically proven.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

In 1964, Congress passed the Economic Opportunity Act and created the Office of Economic Opportunity (OEO) and corresponding Community Action Agencies that provided resources for local civil rights efforts. Unfortunately, following backlash to his efforts, Johnson retreated from these programs.47 President Nixon abolished the OEO in 1973.48 His administration attributed the nation’s ongoing problems with poverty to cultural failings. This notion was increasingly popular among conservative thinkers at this time who were convinced that poor people’s cultural environment fostered self-defeating attitudes and behaviors which perpetuated economic inequality.49 Despite these racist ideas, which were commonplace among those in the Nixon Administration, Nixon’s proposed Family Assistance Plan (FAP) constituted a “revolutionary” attempt to replace AFDC.50 Instead of penalizing work like AFDC had, a household receiving FAP benefits could earn up to $720 annually while retaining their benefits. This bill would have helped many poor Americans. Why would a conservative president endorse this measure?51 Despite the help that FAP would offer many Americans, FAP was ultimately based on unjust ideas about race and gender. The administration favored FAP because, instead of directly helping Black Americans, it was designed to provide a minimum income for all of the working poor and to calm rebellions led by welfare and civil rights activists. Conservatives believed these patriarchal, White family norms were the prerequisite to social and familial stability. These beliefs motivated FAP’s incentives for Black men to be breadwinners and for Black women to stay at home with their children.52 Democratic Senator and presidential advisor Daniel Patrick Moynihan’s report that laid the groundwork for FAP argued that, although there was “plenty of evidence tying social unrest to high unemployment, the underlying cause” was the disintegration of the Black family, which led to increased welfare dependency.53 Moynihan’s report emphasized the need to establish male dominance in the Black family, specifically through reinstating Black men “as household heads by reducing the labor-force participation” of Black women.54

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Basic Income Links

Framework is critical to evaluating solvency – examining a UBI through a gendered lens is crucial to avoid negative consequences for women

Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]

Recently, basic income has been articulated as a human rights issue, notably by Professor Philip Alston in his capacity as then UN Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights.14 In his 2017 report to the UN Human Rights Council, he observed that there is a growing sense of economic insecurity to which the human rights system has done little to respond.15 He argued that discussion of a basic income provides an opportunity to explore the form of social protection that can best secure human rights at a global level.16 While basic income and international human rights had little intersection prior to this report, there has been even less consideration of women’s rights and how they relate to considerations of gender equality within basic income debates. Alston’s report noted that economic insecurity has negative implications for gender inequality and suggested that ‘proponents of women’s human rights need to become more involved in debates over social protection and basic income’.17 An International Labour Organization (ILO) report similarly suggested the need for ‘a careful and comprehensive analysis of the various implications of a UBI (Universal Basic Income) for women’s rights and their empowerment’.18 This article responds to these suggestions by exploring the intersections between basic income, gender and human rights. Basic income has long been the subject of disagreement amongst feminists, some of whom see it advancing gender equality in the workforce and society while others are more skeptical or even fearful of its potential negative impact on women’s lives.19 However these debates, occurring in fields such as politics and economics, have remained largely outside of the human rights law space. This article considers how a gender rights lens might deepen the debate about a basic income and contribute to the development of social policies that address gendered poverty and inequality. A human rights approach that is attentive to gender suggests that a basic income is likely to assist women who are disproportionately poor and vulnerable in all societies. But on its own it will not address the complex and structural inequality that they face. A basic income will need to be accompanied by measures such as the provision of childcare and support for sole parents, alongside changes to the labour market and tax system. It will also have to be of adequate size to make a real difference to inequality. The form of a basic income, its likely impact and its desirability as a policy solution is contingent on the political and economic conditions of the particular country in which it is being considered and should be subject to democratic deliberation. Human rights principles informed by gender will help to ensure that any basic income proposal is carefully evaluated within the context of that country to advance rather than impede substantive gender equality.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Basic Income Links

Discussing a basic income without considering gender reinforces patriarchy – a UBI can provide women with economic independence if we Rethink our framework first

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]

Now is the time to ask the second question. The conditions under which the institution of employment and the Anglo-American social insurance system were constructed have now crumbled. “Old economy” male breadwinner jobs are being swept away in global economic restructuring and “downsizing.” New jobs have been created but many are low paid, lacking benefits, and temporary, and economic insecurity is widespread. Views about femininity, masculinity, and marriage are changing too, but since we are still in the midst of all these changes it is hard to know what the eventual outcome will be. Still, times of rapid change provide opportunities to investigate new ideas and look critically at old arrangements—including the moral hazard of institutions that give incentives to men to avoid their fair share of the unpaid work of caring for others. It has now become possible to rethink the connections between income and paid employment; between marriage, employment, and citizenship; between the private and public division of labor; and between caring work and other work—and to reconsider the meaning of “work.” But such rethinking requires a different approach from that taken by many participants in the debate about stakeholding and basic income. This is crucial if proper account is to be taken of women’s freedom, which has received rather short shrift in discussions of a basic income. As early as 1792, Mary Wollstonecraft argued in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman that rights, citizenship, and full standing for women required economic independence, whether a woman was married or single.33 As Ackerman and Alstott emphasize, a capital grant would be a step in this direction, but a basic income would for the first time provide all women with lifelong economic independence. Thus feminists might be expected strongly to support the introduction of a basic income.34

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Basic Income Link

Debating about a Basic Income without accounting for the gendered nature of work and the family reinforces the patriarchy. It subordinates women by encouraging them to leave the labor market, reinforcing the public/private dichotomy, and relegating women to the Private.

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, 2004. ]

Now is the time to ask the second question. The conditions under which the institution of employment and the Anglo-American social insurance system were constructed have now crumbled. “Old economy” male breadwinner jobs are being swept away in global economic restructuring and “downsizing.” New jobs have been created but many are low paid, lacking benefits, and temporary, and economic insecurity is widespread. Views about femininity, masculinity, and marriage are changing too, but since we are still in the midst of all these changes it is hard to know what the eventual outcome will be. Still, times of rapid change provide opportunities to investigate new ideas and look critically at old arrangements—including the moral hazard of institutions that give incentives to men to avoid their fair share of the unpaid work of caring for others. It has now become possible to rethink the connections between income and paid employment; between marriage, employment, and citizenship; between the private and public division of labor; and between caring work and other work—and to reconsider the meaning of “work.” But such rethinking requires a different approach from that taken by many participants in the debate about stakeholding and basic income. This is crucial if proper account is to be taken of women’s freedom, which has received rather short shrift in discussions of a basic income. As early as 1792, Mary Wollstonecraft argued in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman that rights, citizenship, and full standing for women required economic independence, whether a woman was married or single.33 As Ackerman and Alstott emphasize, a capital grant would be a step in this direction, but a basic income would for the first time provide all women with lifelong economic independence. Thus feminists might be expected strongly to support the introduction of a basic income.34 Yet this is not the case. Some feminists are critical of the idea because they fear a basic income would reinforce the existing sexual division of labor and women’s lesser citizenship. They argue that the provision of an income without having to engage in paid employment would, in light of women’s position in the labor market combined with lingering beliefs about the proper place and tasks of women and men, give women an even greater incentive to undertake more unpaid caring work in the household, and, conversely, men would have another incentive to freeride. A basic income, that is, would reinforce existing limitations on women’s freedom.35 This objection illustrates the importance of the reasons advanced for supporting a basic income. The probability of feminist fears being borne out is higher, for example, when the argument is made that to avoid weakening the “incentive to work” a basic income should be below subsistence level. This “incentive” is promoted with men and paid employment in mind. A basic income at this level provides no incentive for wives to “work” (i.e., enter paid employment); rather, it would encourage them to do more unpaid caring work. Again, to support basic income on the grounds that it would improve the living standards of the poorest sectors of the population does not promote consideration of the structural connections between marriage, employment, and citizenship, and the private and public sexual division of labor. Without the debates about basic income being informed by feminist arguments, and a concern for democratization (and genuine democratization necessarily includes women’s freedom and standing as citizens), the discussion will revolve around ways of tinkering with the existing system rather than encouraging thinking about how it might be made more democratic. Putting democratization at the center requires attention to institutional structures, especially the institutions of marriage and employment. For instance, Ackerman and Alstott remark in The Stakeholder Society that the “case for stakeholding does not ultimately rest on its effects on employment, marriage, or crime. It rests on each American’s claim to respect as a free and equal citizen.”36 However (leaving crime aside), the respect accorded to women and men as free and equal citizens has a great deal to do with the institutions of marriage and employment. It is not possible to understand women’s lesser citizenship, as Ackerman and Alstott show in their discussion of social security, without understanding the relationship between their position as wives and men’s position as workers.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Framework

Framework is essential to avoid oppressive welfare policies – if you ignore race and gender when examining the plan, you cannot solve for discrimination, empirically.

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? AC]

Racism, sexism, and classism embedded in welfare policies reinforce women’s subordination. To implement welfare policies that do not stigmatize, degrade, or generally mistreat recipients we will need to consider how race, gender, and class interact to make economically disadvantaged populations vulnerable to public policy decisions that neglect their needs. This requires that we be mindful of why and how we implement certain policies. Mothers’ pensions were designed to benefit White women at the expense of non-White women, New Deal programs and FAP aimed to benefit White men and reinforce traditional family structures, and PRWORA reformed policies in response to their increasing stigmatization once they had finally become more inclusive of those women most in need of assistance. Going forward, we need to implement public policies that do not neglect already vulnerable groups and actively reject the biases and exclusiveness that characterized these policy choices. Pursuing Social Justice: Undermining the Faces of Oppression We need a framework to evaluate UBI and a FJG that accounts for vulnerable groups’ needs and rejects their oppression. The existing frameworks which most authors use to evaluate UBI and FJG prioritize the need to combat poverty, expand freedom, or ensure equality among democratic citizens. The framework that focuses on equality among democratic citizens is most relevant to this paper. This is not because combating poverty and securing freedom are unimportant for women, but because social movements historically have relied on the rhetoric of equal rights associated with citizenship to democratize America. Feminist issues such as suffrage and For example abortion are generally discussed in terms of women’s lack of equal rights within a nation that claims to be a democracy under which all citizens are equal. Due to our particular concern with women as a group being subject to inequality on the grounds of race, class, and gender, among other factors, it makes sense to use a democratic citizenship framework to analyze UBI and FJG. Instead, however, I argue that democratic citizenship does not offer an ideal framework with which to evaluate public policy. U.S. history shows that this model does not offer a secure or inclusive basis to evaluate policies and therefore is incapable of guaranteeing democratic citizenship rights for all. Historically, the category of citizen in which a person was placed, or their exclusion from this category altogether, depended on one’s race, gender, and class. In Civic Ideals: Conflicting Visions of Citizenship in U.S. History , Rogers Smith points out that American lawmakers have “unapologetically structured U.S. citizenship in terms” of “racial, ethnic, and gendered hierarchies,” and restricted citizenship based on “passionate beliefs that America was [...] a white nation, a Protestant nation, a nation in which true americans were native-born men with Anglo-Saxon ancestors.”84 So many Americans throughout our history have lacked equal political rights that courts and executive officials have been rendered incapable of clearly deciding who was a citizen. They have divided Americans into categories that include birthright citizens, naturalized citizens, non-voting citizens, jurisdictional citizens, commercial citizens, citizens subject to incarceration or deportation without due process, U.S. nationals, and colonial subjects. These distinctions have made American citizenship “an intellectually puzzling, legally confused, and politically charged and contested status.”85

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › --Extend – Framework

Prioritizing a Gendered Justice framework is necessary to ensure that a UBI is designed and implemented in a way that reduces oppression and stigma

Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? ] EP

Conclusion Sexism, racism, and classism embedded within our welfare policies have privileged some Americans while stigmatizing and oppressing others. We need new policies that account for these problems and actively combat the damage that previous welfare policies have inflicted. This requires us to evaluate potential policies not just based on their economic consequences, but also on how effectively they undermine the injustices that harm their intended beneficiaries. Due to women’s unique experiences under our past welfare policies, we need different policies which undermine the oppression they experience in the form of exploitation, marginalization, powerlessness, cultural imperialism, and violence. The justice-based framework employed above to evaluate two potential policies, UBI and FJG, demonstrates how advocates and policymakers can center vulnerable groups’ needs when discussing the potential benefits and consequences of public policies. My analysis shows that UBI more effectively challenges the root causes of women’s oppression via marginalization and cultural imperialism. That said, not all UBI or FJG policies are created equal. Although theoretical analysis reveals that UBI is the best option for women in principle, the intentions behind and the particular type of UBI or FJG implemented will have varying implications for women. We should not, in the interest of theoretical purity, favor any form of UBI over a justice-oriented and woman-friendly form of FJG. Labeling a potential policy as a jobs guarantee or a basic income matters less than the intention behind the policy and whose needs are considered before it is implemented. Based on this paper, one cannot conclude that UBI or FJG is inherently preferable to the other. Instead, whether those crafting policy center or neglect vulnerable populations’ needs will determine if a policy helps these groups. Still, due to its potential to further the cause of women’s liberation, UBI should remain a long-term goal as we transition toward a more just society. Although analyzing past and possible future welfare policies does not lend itself to a black-and-white conclusion, this paper shows why it is important to prioritize justice concerns when evaluating and advocating for public policies and demonstrates how this can be done. Justice-oriented frameworks and specific heuristics like those Young offers may not clarify all issues surrounding a particular policy, but they offer guidance and raise important concerns which advocates and policymakers should not neglect when they consider how their actions will harm or help oppressed groups and women specifically. If we want to challenge the racial, economic, and gender oppression that remain pervasive in the U.S., we need to prioritize social justice consistently and unapologetically.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Gender K

In an academic setting we must break down the public/ private dichotomy through a feminist pedagogy. Only through a feminist pedagogy can we create a liberation and emancipation of gender.

Scering, 1997 – Thorton Elementary School [Grace, journal of teacher education, themes of a critical feminist pedagogy, ]

As a guide for a curriculum correlating democracy with critical/ feminist pedagogy, connected knowing emphasizes an expanded base for school knowledge and the development or students’ responsibilities to themselves, their peers, children and adults. Critical knowing needs to be at the core of issues and practices related to the power dynamics within schools… Young people also need clear instructions to help them visualize democratic values with a broader societal and global context (Goodman 1992). Emphasis on caring and responsibility linked to democracy may develop values and attitudes undergirding production of critical and connected knowledge. The dominant white male epistemology emphasizing dichtomization of social life apart from private values and the distancing of individual from others causes the failure to relate caring and responsibility to democracy in traditional schooling. Maher (1987) maintains that gendered (feminist) and liberation (critical) models of pedagogy complement one another because the gendered models tend to ignore the personal domain Leck (1987) acknowledges that a heightened awareness of gender is insufficient for changing the masculine paradigm of schooling but that liberation theory is a model for praxis, the intersection of theory, practice and action (Giroux, 1988). Yet critical/ feminist pedagogy is more than an extended liberation theory or a part of liberation theory (Giroux, 1988). It has the potential to affect the top-down educational stance of liberationist theorists. Feminist pedagogy may be able to move liberationist theorists to a full recognition of their own risk as they work in interrelationships within the limits of his dualistic, hierarchal and patriarchal paradigm. And paradoxically, without such systematic consciousness-raising among liberation theorists who are not primarily defined as doing feminist pedagogy, it would be unlikely that educators would recognize the role of patriarchy as an educational paradigm

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Gender K

4. Framework - A feminist framework identifies masculinist biases in our discourse about welfare – this is key to ending gender inequality

Mckay and Vanevery, 2002 – prof of economics at Glascow Univ. and Independent Writer [Ailsa and Jo “Social Politics, Gender, Gender, Family, and Income Maintenance: A Feminist Case for Citizens Basic Income,” Summer TA]

Developing a feminist perspective on the nature of state supported income maintenance policies facilitates the identification of androcentric bias inherent within the current basic income debate. Social security mechanisms, which are intrinsically linked to the labor market, are criticized for generating and sustaining gender inequalities. This is due in part to the invisibility of various forms of work, particularly care work, provided outside of the labor market. The family is a key institution providing care in contemporary societies. The family is also a deeply gendered institution, often criticized for its inequalities. In addition, radical changes in family forms have occurred which contribute to the "welfare crisis." It is argued that although a basic income provides an opportunity to redefine the basis of citizenship beyond the productivist ethic focused on labor market participation, and is thus an ideal policy for the "postfamilial" society, the current literature does not do this in any sustained way. By examining the relationship between gender, family, and the state, we draw attention to the potential a citizens basic income has for providing the foundations of a new gender-neutral conceptualization of social justice.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Gender K

Adopting the feminist lens can break down the public/private dichotomy by recognizing that the personal is political

MacKinnon, 1989 - Professor of Law at University of Michigan [Catherine, Toward a Feminist Theory of State]

In private, consent tends to be presumed. Showing coercion is supposed to avoid this presumption. But the problem is getting anything private to be perceived as coercive. This is an epistemic problem of major dimensions and explains why privacy doctrine is most at home at home, the place women experience the most force, in the family, and why it centers on sex. Why a person would “allow” force in the private (the “why doesn't she leave” question raised to battered women) is a question given its insult by the social meaning of the private as a sphere of choice. For women the measure of intimacy has been the measure of oppression. This is why feminism has seen the personal as the political. The private is public for those for whom the person is political. In this sense, for women there is no private, either normatively or empirically. Feminism confronts the fact that women have no privacy to lose or to guarantee. Women are not inviolable. Women’s sexuality is not only violable, it is—hence, women are--seen in and as their violation. To confront the fact that women have no privacy is to confront the intimate degradation of women as the public order.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Gender K

3. Alternative – We should reject the gendered assumptions in the affirmative’s discourse of welfare, breaking down the public private dichotomy.

Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, 2004. ]

Now is the time to ask the second question. The conditions under which the institution of employment and the Anglo-American social insurance system were constructed have now crumbled. “Old economy” male breadwinner jobs are being swept away in global economic restructuring and “downsizing.” New jobs have been created but many are low paid, lacking benefits, and temporary, and economic insecurity is widespread. Views about femininity, masculinity, and marriage are changing too, but since we are still in the midst of all these changes it is hard to know what the eventual outcome will be. Still, times of rapid change provide opportunities to investigate new ideas and look critically at old arrangements—including the moral hazard of institutions that give incentives to men to avoid their fair share of the unpaid work of caring for others. It has now become possible to rethink the connections between income and paid employment; between marriage, employment, and citizenship; between the private and public division of labor; and between caring work and other work—and to reconsider the meaning of “work.” But such rethinking requires a different approach from that taken by many participants in the debate about stakeholding and basic income. This is crucial if proper account is to be taken of women’s freedom, which has received rather short shrift in discussions of a basic income. As early as 1792, Mary Wollstonecraft argued in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman that rights, citizenship, and full standing for women required economic independence, whether a woman was married or single.33 As Ackerman and Alstott emphasize, a capital grant would be a step in this direction, but a basic income would for the first time provide all women with lifelong economic independence

2023 MNDI Negative
Gender Kritik › 1NC - Gender K

2. Impacts - Patriarchal Domination is the root cause of all forms of domination. Systemic dehumanization, famine, ecological devastation and nuclear warfare are all inevitable in a world of patriarchy.

hooks, 1989 - professor of english at city college in ny [bell talking back: thinking feminist – thinking black. p19-20]

We live in a world in crisis – a world governed by politics of domination, one in which the belief in a notion of superior and inferior, and its concomitant ideology - that the superior should rule over the inferior – effects the lives of all people everywhere, whether poor or privileged, literate or illiterate. Systemic dehumanization, worldwide famine, ecological devastation, industrial contamination, and the possibility of nuclear destruction are realities which remind us daily that we are in crisis. Contemporary feminist thinkers often cite sexual politics as the origin of this crisis. They point to the insistence on difference as that factor which becomes the occasion for separation and domination and suggest that differentiation of domination of the planet is the root of the problem. Such an assumption has fostered the notion that elimination of sexist oppression would necessarily lead to the eradication of all forms of domination. It is an argument that has led influential Western white women to feel that feminist movement should be the central political agenda for females globally. Ideologically, thinking in this direction enables Western women, especially privileged white women, to suggest that racism and class exploitation are merely the offspring of the parent system: patriarchy. Within feminist movement in the West, this has led to the assumption that resisting patriarchal domination is a more legitimate feminist action than resisting racism and other forms of domination. Such thinking prevails despite radical critiques made by black women and other women of color who question this proposition. To speculate that an oppositional division between men and women existed in early human communities is to impose on the past, on these non-white groups, a world view that fits all too neatly within contemporary feminist paradigms that name man as the enemy and woman as the victim. Clearly, differentiation between strong and weak, powerful and powerless, has been a central defining aspect of gender globally, carrying with it the assumption that men should have greater authority than women, and should rule over them. As significant and important as this fact is, it should not obscure the reality that women can and do participate in politics of domination, as perpetrators as well as victims – that we dominate, that we are dominated. If focus on patriarchal domination masks this reality or becomes the means by which women deflect attention from the real conditions and circumstances of our lives, then women cooperate in suppressing and promoting false consciousness, inhibiting our capacity to assume responsibility for transforming ourselves and society.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › UBI definition

Four criteria for a UBI

Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]

For the purposes of this brief, UBI is defined as a cash transfer that is (a) individual, in that it goes directly to each person rather than to a household; (b) continuous, in that it is provided on an ongoing basis; (c) unconditional, in that it does not depend on labour market participation or the fulfilment of conditions; and (d) universal, in that it is paid to all. These features distinguish UBI from most existing protection systems, although the relationship between UBI and social protection continues to be debated. UBI is noncontributory, meaning eligibility and benefit levels do not depend upon prior contributions. This makes it different to (contributory) social insurance systems, which tend to benefit those who are employed in the formal economy across their lifetime, and which feminists have long critiqued for being entrenched in male-breadwinner models and heteronormative bias, as well as for providing lesser protection to those who do not participate in full-time formal employment due to employment discrimination or caregiving responsibilities. UBI is also different to the majority of non-contributory social protection programmes, including cash transfers, which are often narrowly targeted to poor households and have been criticized by feminists for imposing cumbersome conditionalities on women recipients (such as ensuring children’s attendance at school or health clinics) and excluding families with lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex or queer (LGBTIQ+) members. UBI is distinct from a social protection floor, which refers to nationally defined access to essential health care and income security for all across the life course. However, some argue that UBI could form an essential part of a social protection floor.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › Capitalism Turns the Case

Neoliberal work roles and fiscal austerity are the root cause of gender inequality – capitalism only sees male labor as productive

Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, . AC]

With the rise of modern capitalism, be pro‐worker legislation in the West have kept children and seniors out of the factories, centering adult male workers at the core of the labour force. This 'productivist' setting solidified progressive political projects around the working class, but also implied a gendered division of labour within and outside the household. In particular, women were expected to support the family's 'social reproduction' at home by being responsible for food preparation, cleaning, childcare, elderly care, and so on. However, in the postwar period, the feminist movements—with the support of social democratic parties—promoted and were successful in ensuring that as the welfare state developed, public services provision for childcare, elderly care, and pensions were established. As a result, women were partially relieved from reproductive work, and their increased participation in the formal labour market enabled the fulfilment of women's intellectual, economic and social aspirations. Yet, such progressive trends did not last. Tithi Bhattacharya hanged social relations in ways that eroded women's material and sociopolitical emancipation. Women's engagement in paid work soon became less of a choice and more of a necessity, because male wages were no longer sufficient to maintain decent household living standards. Yet, women are often the first to be fired, and are subject to precarious contracts and part‐time work.[ ] Also, women with low socioeconomic status, from minority backgrounds, or in non‐heteronormative relationships, are often the most exposed victims of the costs of austerity paying with less work, the worst working conditions, low incomes or, worse, no job at all.[ ] The neoliberal model also dismantled social protection and benefits in favour of privatisation of care services and means‐tested social security.[ ] The shrinking of the welfare state has contributed to the transfer of care responsibilities back into the household, or in the form of commodified services in the market. For those who can afford it, the commodification of social reproduction has changed in various ways: from the multiplication of private nursery and elderly care agencies to the proliferation in the use of ready‐meals and take‐away food. Furthermore, an increasing amount of reproductive labour is performed largely by migrants and women of colour. The inability by some to pay for such goods and services has exacerbated exclusion and social inequality. Women who cannot afford these services engage in creative forms of 'care sharing economy' such as home‐based childminders and shared nannies. Hence, yet again, the most vulnerable poor are women, who have faced increasing pressure to cope with the 'double burden' of productive labour and reproductive work. They are not only poor in a strict economic sense, but they also suffer from time poverty, which hampers their socio‐economic mobility, wellbeing and, political participation. These worsening conditions in the three areas of care, work and welfare reflect the gendered crisis of neoliberalism and it is not a coincidence that atomistic and monetised policy solutions have become popular across the whole political spectrum. One of the solutions proposed is UBI—the focus of this article, in which I examine the arguments advocating for the positive effects of UBI on women and social reproductive work. I then discuss the limitations of those arguments and reflect on the under‐investigated tensions these have missed. Finally, the conclusion will ask relevant questions which untangle the case for a deep transformation of the socio‐economic structure of the economy.

2023 MNDI Negative
Gendered UBI Neg › UBS Counterplan – Cap K Net Benefit

A UBI would not solve women’s exploitation within a capitalist society – its individualistic approach ignores the root causes of sexism, and it depoliticizes the division of labor. A Universal Basic Services solves better and avoids the market based solutions based on income.

Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, . AC]

This is not to downplay the urgency in addressing social and economic injustice, but rather to recognise the need to focus our attention on equally probable risks that the implementation of the UBI might entail in terms of de‐politicisation of the causes and consequences of everlasting poverty. Last, but not least, the implementation of a UBI will not automatically eliminate the sexist attitudes and norms that created gender conflicts in the first place.[18] In this sense, UBI could worsen the wellbeing of poorer women by making them vulnerable to new ways of financial expropriation, that is, some men could manage to divert the funds allocated to women under UBI. This has happened already in situations where women start engaging with income earning opportunities and yet do not have full control of their spending decisions. By replacing universal provision of social services with commoditised needs and services, the neoliberal state has relinquished its responsibility for the social reproduction of the family and society at large. In this context, UBI might also reinforce the political trends towards the monetisation and individualisation of the provision of such needs and services. As a result, while inequality and social injustice increase, a gendered crisis of care would remain, because women would be stuck within the same set of patriarchal inspired duties of domestic labour and care at precisely the point when they have the least time and security in which to perform them. Unemployed women who sit at home will not only struggle to pay utility bills and risk feeling disenfranchised from the potentially dignifying experience of having a job, but will also stand to suffer a rise in social exclusion. In the context of these conditions, proponents for a UBI claim that the measure will help delegitimise the inquisitorial system currently used for determining eligibility for social benefits. However, the focus should be on the structure and processes through which the eligibility criteria are assessed rather than identifying UBI as the way out. Many are studying possible policy alternatives. Barbara R. Bergmann claims that the provision of free childcare highlights the different impacts of a UBI and the welfare state on gender inequality.[19] She says that whereas a UBI expands the opportunities for leisure, free childcare increases the options for paid employment. Bergmann continues by arguing that greater employment opportunities are likely to be more important for reducing gender inequality than UBI. Many employers have come to see women as long‐term participants in the workplace and, therefore, people worth training, putting into jobs leading to promotion, and then being considered for promotion. This kind of progress would be reversed if a higher proportion of women withdrew from the labour force when their first child was born because of a lack of affordable childcare. Universal Basic Services is also an appealing scheme.[20] Proposed in 2017 as a revival of the objective of redistribution and collective responsibilities and cohesion of the 'old fashioned' welfare state, it proposes a set of public, free, basic, and quasi‐universal services to address material needs such as shelters, sustenance, healthcare, education, legal support, transport and communication. Although in its original forms it lacked the much needed publicly funded provision of care, its recent version includes childcare and adult social care, which could reduce both gendered poverty and inequality. This approach goes in the right direction in two ways: it decouples the provision of societal wellbeing from market‐oriented, individualistic and 'productivistic' mechanisms, and it avoids the blurring of the line between citizens and consumers.